Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP122: Ecommerce Analytics Tracking In A Cookie-Less World: New Best Practices with Elevar's Owner Brad Redding
Transcript
- 0:02Hello and welcome back to the re-platform podcast today.
- 0:05It's just me. Paul James is in a meeting but
- 0:08I'm delighted to be joined by Brad.
- 0:10I'll let him introduce himself in a second just to introduce
- 0:13our sponsors. So we sponsored by a lien switch
- 0:15is a market-leading headless EMS solution and claim a which is a
- 0:19vastly popular SMS and email marketing platform.
- 0:23So to get started Brad if you can maybe give us a bit of an
- 0:26introduction to yourself and also Alaba Yeah, thanks Paul.
- 0:31I'm my name is Brad, like Paul mentioned the founder and CEO of
- 0:34L of our. And we do two things primarily
- 0:37for Shopify Brands. Number one, we ensure that each
- 0:40one of their analytics and marketing channel platforms
- 0:43received nearly 100% of their conversion data.
- 0:46And number two, we ensure that each conversion or events across
- 0:49your site has a maximum amount of user Associated data that can
- 0:53be used in attribution and audience management Etc.
- 0:56So that's a little bit on the love our and I'm sure we'll get
- 1:00a little bit more into the weeds today on conversion tracking in
- 1:02general, lovely. And I've known Brad for a number
- 1:05of years and can definitely recommend all of our reviews,
- 1:08demos, the project. And also I realized I didn't
- 1:11introduce the topic. So today's topic is basically
- 1:14just looking at modern day tracking new best practices and
- 1:17Brad. And I are just going to talk
- 1:18about all of the changes to privacy cookies go4 and
- 1:23everything else. So first question Brad.
- 1:27So can you maybe? That's not really a question but
- 1:29can you You summarize everything that's happening around cookie
- 1:32based tracking initially. So, just to kind of set the
- 1:35scene, there's obviously been loads of changes a so, can you
- 1:38maybe just give us a bit of an overview?
- 1:39I'm kind of what's happening in the industry at the moment.
- 1:44Summarizing and the succinct manner will be difficult,
- 1:46everything that's going on. But yeah, I mean in general
- 1:49there's a couple there's many things happening.
- 1:51Number one is you have the different app provider so think
- 1:56this is the easy one iOS where apple is restricted sharing
- 1:59device data. So when it comes to if just talk
- 2:02about Facebook or Tick-Tock or SnapChat any other app that's on
- 2:05iOS or Android devices generally the when it when a user is
- 2:10browsing a brand site A brand and ultimately Facebook is
- 2:14helping connect the session to the user through your standard
- 2:18pixel data. So things that you would go to
- 2:20your pixel Helper and view different events and the
- 2:23different data that's sent with that event, what that activity
- 2:26back to Facebook, but then it was a device data.
- 2:28So, it'd be the essentially trying to really get down to.
- 2:33I know that there's some video, so it's like the data is
- 2:35associated to that device, ensuring that back to Facebook,
- 2:38that way Facebook or just do a better job of ultimately
- 2:40matching that activity and the click to the Conversion.
- 2:43So that's a big one. I again, I think that one's
- 2:45probably been talked. That horses has been beaten to
- 2:49death over the last couple of years or last year with that
- 2:52when it comes to cookies and just tracking in general.
- 2:55So the I'll just do a little bit of a history and how trackers
- 2:59have worked. So if you go back to like the
- 3:01web one web to as we transition web two days, the way that
- 3:05tracking essentially worked is Again, all of these marketing
- 3:09platforms, they would give you a script like, hey, Paul you, if
- 3:12you want to implement tracking for Facebook or Tick Tock,
- 3:15here's a piece of JavaScript and installed on your site.
- 3:18And essentially what that script is doing it is ultimately
- 3:22enabling an image. So there's little image that's
- 3:25loading on your site and then that image is actually help.
- 3:28It's part of that process as grabbing information within your
- 3:32browser. So it's grabbing your IP
- 3:33address, your device, your user agent, all this, Chronicle
- 3:38hidden information, that can help the ultimate platform.
- 3:42Identify Paul, your family household by doing that,
- 3:46geo-targeting type of matching of, again IP addresses user 8,
- 3:50user agents, trying to ultimately geofence you.
- 3:52So, there's a lot of hidden data that's implicit that you don't
- 3:54necessarily see coming through the piece of JavaScript or the
- 3:59pixel helpers, Etc. You're not seeing that, you
- 4:02know, IP address that's coming through and then with the
- 4:05cookies. So generally what a cookie is
- 4:06going to do and and these scripts when you install them on
- 4:10your site. Again, they are trying to do
- 4:12that work of identifying you but they're also setting and storing
- 4:16data within your browser. So for example, thing about
- 4:20Facebook, they have to cookies that they're generally setting
- 4:23and that cookie is going to help identify who you are the ad,
- 4:26they clicked on and then ultimately start tracking your
- 4:29behavior on the site you're visiting but also other sites
- 4:33that you visit throughout the web and that's where you can
- 4:36start getting into. You got to weather.com or you go
- 4:39to some of these other other sites where they might have
- 4:42data. Sharing is you'll start to see
- 4:44that more personalized, remarketing activity, that's
- 4:46happening because they're these different platforms are sharing
- 4:49data. So I'll just pause there to see
- 4:51if that again that's kind of like three different pieces of
- 4:54it. You have the cookie.
- 4:56So the cookie that's being set to help you cross like cross
- 4:59script or cross-site track. You have the invisible data,
- 5:01which comes from that little image pixel on the site and then
- 5:04ultimately have more of that explicit data.
- 5:07Great. I think you're done well to keep
- 5:09it that succinctly. And not kind of going to some of
- 5:12the other areas. I think that's already done and
- 5:15and I guess moving on to the solutions or kind of what people
- 5:18are doing to get around this kind of demise of cookies.
- 5:21So, can you maybe just give us an introduction to server-side
- 5:24tracking? And also kind of we're tracking
- 5:27is going and what some of their kind of, yes, Solutions are
- 5:30around some of this. Yeah.
- 5:33So the big thing is you see where you have the death of the
- 5:38third-party cookie which most browsers except Chrome have gone
- 5:42that way, but Chrome is going that way as well.
- 5:44And essentially a difference if there has been a first-party
- 5:47cookie and a third party, cookie is a third party.
- 5:49Cookie would be set if you're on, I don't know.
- 5:52Roth he's.com. And you look at a cookie.
- 5:55If that cookie is set to Snapchat.com or facebook.com,
- 5:58that would be considered a third party cookie.
- 6:00If that if a cookie, you know, It's set by one of these
- 6:03trackers but it's set on Roth he's.com.
- 6:05Then that would be considered a first-party cookie but it's
- 6:10ultimately created by a third party which that has limitations
- 6:13as well. So that was essentially a first
- 6:15thing. The first quote unquote fact
- 6:17that some platforms are doing a couple years ago to try to get
- 6:20ahead of this, especially as the initial ITP.
- 6:23So the intelligent tracking prevention, the Apple rolled out
- 6:25on Safari but trying to get around that.
- 6:28So just essentially moving a third party to the primary
- 6:30domain and They're starting to do things like hacking around
- 6:35your domain. So doing what's called cloaking,
- 6:39which again is too technical to get into, but people are trying
- 6:42these different hacks. And essentially, they all have
- 6:44all the hacks. They were being patched, is
- 6:47almost faster than what they let.
- 6:49The different platforms can come up to.
- 6:50So whether it's ad blockers or the actual different privacy,
- 6:55the folks pushing privacies that.
- 6:57So, obviously, Safari and apple are one of the big ones, they're
- 6:59essentially just patching all these hacks that are putting Put
- 7:02out there. So the next fall back, where if
- 7:06you think about this is big in Affiliates, which we see with a
- 7:09lot of our customers is okay? If the you if it's cookie
- 7:13essentially can't be trusted then they're going to fall back
- 7:17on the, in quote, unquote invisible data.
- 7:20So again, this goes back to. Here's a script and stalled on
- 7:24your site because we are going to collect a bunch of data that
- 7:28we're not going to tell you what, we're going to collect.
- 7:29It's in our magical fingerprinting.
- 7:31IE the like, IP address user agent, other aspects that are
- 7:35automatically captured in the browser.
- 7:37They're going to send that data back to the platform and then a
- 7:40platform is going to do their own magic again, without getting
- 7:44into too many specifics, but they're gonna do their own magic
- 7:47to try to map that activity Back To You, Paul versus relying on a
- 7:51cookie. So that's where that's
- 7:53essentially what a lot of platforms are doing now.
- 7:56And as we've seen with iOS 15, you would just look at what
- 8:00Apple's done where Now their office skating IP addresses.
- 8:04So if you are going to opt it out and there's certain
- 8:07conditions within your device, when you were, when you go to a
- 8:11website, they're no longer going to see your IP address.
- 8:14It's going to be essentially a masked IP address that Apple
- 8:17automatically creates, and that is going to start limiting the
- 8:21ability to again Target and match back by by IP address.
- 8:26And same thing the emails to so the hide my email, where if you
- 8:28are logging into a or opting into an email newsletter, And
- 8:32said of the brand getting your Paul email, it's going to be
- 8:36some random Apple Mail string. So with I'll just pause there
- 8:41before. So I start getting into service
- 8:43eye tracking and where we're seeing some platforms, start to
- 8:46transition to this, because frankly they have to so I'll
- 8:49pause there. Just to see if you have any
- 8:50questions. Know if that's five hit maybe.
- 8:52Yeah. If you just start, maybe to
- 8:53start by introducing server-side tracking as a principle that
- 8:57maybe move on to kind of power. Some of the platforms and
- 8:59networks are starting to adapt to Yeah, so a server-side
- 9:04tracking when we so Facebook used to have a technical
- 9:08marketing partner program which they've Sunset last year, but we
- 9:11were in that program. What they started telling us a
- 9:14couple years ago was hey we we know based on the pixel data
- 9:19that we have we are only getting 80% of signal and signal to them
- 9:24when they say signal that's essentially activity on the site
- 9:28and ultimately some of that advanced matching data to a
- 9:31user. So They can essentially apply
- 9:34that back and into their ads manager reporting and start
- 9:37calculating in their role as Etc.
- 9:39So if they knew and they saw this was with just their trans
- 9:44and you probably saw those with some your customers, but just a
- 9:46year-over-year analysis, forgive me with a covid years.
- 9:50But I think if you were to look at like 20, 20, 20 verses 2019,
- 9:55you would see, essentially the business is doing better
- 9:58conversion rates, higher Revenue, per visitors higher,
- 10:02Sure, but my reported row as and there were some other metric
- 10:05used in Facebook is lower even though everything else is
- 10:08higher. So, what Facebook explain to us
- 10:11was essentially that's just because we're not getting, we're
- 10:14missing 20% of the data, so we can't attribute back to the
- 10:17click. So, that's where they were
- 10:20really big into starting to push the conversion API, so much so
- 10:24where they were paying. So if you were a brand spending
- 10:28enough, Facebook would pay and some of our other Other
- 10:32technology providers to implement the conversion API for
- 10:35you because people were pulling budget so less signal.
- 10:40So the reporting lower performance and brand thinks
- 10:44shit, I need to move this money, go spend it somewhere else.
- 10:47So they Facebook was trying to head that on and they're really
- 10:50the biggest pot for the largest platform doing that first.
- 10:53So the conversion API or service eye-tracking, essentially what
- 10:57that is. Again, it's sound.
- 11:00I don't, I don't want to make it sound.
- 11:02Too simple but it's instead of sending data from the browser to
- 11:05Facebook through the pixel API you're sending data from a
- 11:09server. So this could be a Shopify admin
- 11:12like a sharp-eyed. Webhook sending data directly to
- 11:15Facebook through their conversion API.
- 11:18So essentially, you're moving that activity out of the
- 11:20browser. So, the activity is not
- 11:23constrained by ad blockers JavaScript, breaking on the
- 11:27front end people. Not lit waiting for the
- 11:30confirmation page to finish. Ding which used to be an old
- 11:33thing that you would see in best practices.
- 11:35So while they're all these little things that can happen in
- 11:37the browser that ultimately add up to that twenty percent.
- 11:41So service eye tracking is just saying we don't care about the
- 11:43browser, we're just going to send that data directly from
- 11:46server a, to Facebook, which that type of connection is, it's
- 11:52it's almost foolproof. I mean, because the, when
- 11:55Facebook receives that request, they essentially have to give
- 11:59you a thumbs-up or a thumbs-down that they receive.
- 12:02That event and it was successful or if there are errors or
- 12:06Warnings. So it's a forced response from
- 12:09Facebook so you really know what's going on.
- 12:12If all of your tracking is been sent successfully, so that's the
- 12:16that's a general overview. Overview on server-side
- 12:18tracking, I'll just give one one more little tidbit on it.
- 12:22Is if I use the pixel installed on a browser that's picking up
- 12:27IP address and all these other magical fingerprinting things
- 12:31about you. Will server-side tracking you
- 12:34have to be explicit. So you have to when the request
- 12:39that you're sending to Facebook or the purchase you're sending
- 12:41to Facebook, you have to send and Define, you know, whatever
- 12:46user data you want to send if you want to send IP address, if
- 12:49you want to send location Etc, you have to actually get that
- 12:53data and Define it in that request that you're sending to
- 12:57Facebook. So it's explicit versus implicit
- 13:00in the implicit is what the whole track.
- 13:02Industry has been forever. That's why it was pretty easy.
- 13:05We're just like copy and paste and we'll do all them all the
- 13:07fingerprinting for you. That makes sense.
- 13:09And I guess a lot of people talk about optimizing that
- 13:13conversions API like what can be done to get more from it and
- 13:17kind of what other kind of events and different things.
- 13:21Can you do to get more insight alongside your conversion API?
- 13:26Yeah, there's two things that we've seen.
- 13:28Number one is ensuring that. It's the conversion API is
- 13:32getting the maximum number of user with Facebook calls
- 13:36Advanced matching parameters. So this is your first name last
- 13:40name, email phone number address, the fbp cookie the FPC.
- 13:47Cookie the external ID, there's a there's a couple others but
- 13:53that's that number. That's the the magical number.
- 13:56You go to events manager and you see eight point six out of ten
- 13:58or six point seven out of ten or 3.3 know, the world's ending
- 14:02what's going on. So that that, that is number
- 14:06one. So with purchases it.
- 14:09You especially if you are using a server-side setup, you can
- 14:13essentially have access to all of that.
- 14:16Customer data in the order, what is a little bit tricky as
- 14:18getting the fbp and FBC cookie or any other data that generally
- 14:23lives in the browser. So attaching that to the order
- 14:25sets Something that we've built out over the last year or so is
- 14:29getting some of that. I don't want to use the word
- 14:32fingerprinting. That's essentially, that's the
- 14:33word. We use is getting some of that
- 14:35fingerprinting data that Facebook uses for their
- 14:38attribution. Getting that attach those
- 14:40server-side integration can in theory perform a little bit
- 14:42better than the conversion API that might be running through
- 14:45the browser. So that's number one and that's
- 14:48something that we see we've seen that perform well.
- 14:51So people had if they were missing the external ID or
- 14:54missing phone number or missing. F PP, or FPC cookie which in
- 14:57love I have never have 100% but you want to have as much as you
- 15:01can. But when we've seen brands that
- 15:03did not have that and then they started receiving Facebook
- 15:05started, receiving that through our integration.
- 15:08And we would see their performance increase.
- 15:11This second part of where we see improving the output of Cappy is
- 15:19The world of shopping is moving outside of just an online store.
- 15:24So you have the Facebook shop, which is embedded in the
- 15:27Facebook app, you have the tick tock shop.
- 15:30You have post-purchase upsells, you have, you know, embedded,
- 15:36social embedded shopping, and different blogs, or platforms
- 15:39and just a host of different ways that customers can can
- 15:43purchase Brands products. And this is easily seen.
- 15:46You can just go to your Shopify Analytics.
- 15:49Word. Go to the sales by Channel
- 15:52report and more than likely. You won't see.
- 15:55Just one channel, you're not just going to see the online
- 15:57store Channel. You're going to see a host of
- 16:00other channels that are there. It's very possible that if
- 16:03someone purchased something on one of these other channels that
- 16:07they were influenced by some sort of advertising and
- 16:10marketing. So getting that data to Facebook
- 16:13or any other channel is also pretty critical piece that
- 16:17standard tracking that Has been in setup in the past, would not
- 16:21catch. So that is another benefit of
- 16:24moving to a server-side. Tracking type is even if it's a
- 16:28small percentage, but getting that percentage of orders to not
- 16:32just Facebook, but other channels will ultimately help
- 16:34them. Not only with attribution of how
- 16:37you are performing but think about your marketing audiences
- 16:40or any look-alike. So you want to, you want to try
- 16:42to boost that as much as you can especially if those activities
- 16:45aren't happening in iOS devices except sin I guess in the
- 16:48context of elevator. So how are people using?
- 16:52Like I think from my understand your anywhere can shop but
- 16:55moment. So in terms of Shopify Brands,
- 16:58how are people getting the most out of conversions API?
- 17:02Where does that LaBarre come into this?
- 17:08Yeah, I mean basically where brands are coming out of our is
- 17:12they don't trust their data, whether it's in Google analytics
- 17:16or the data that Facebook Google ads, Etc.
- 17:19Are receiving number two, is they have some of those known
- 17:23issues or they know that they, some of the platforms are
- 17:28potentially not performing as well as they think they should.
- 17:31And number three, is they whether it's from their
- 17:35marketing team, or Potentially just edged himself education is
- 17:39realizing that moving eventually whether it's now or a year.
- 17:44From now, two years from now, all tracking will eventually
- 17:48have to move server side. Just because you whether it's
- 17:52privacy and able to get explicit in what you're tracking or just
- 17:55to ensure accuracy, ultimately just getting a head start on
- 18:00getting their tracking so they are tracking close to 100% for
- 18:03each Channel and that's to help with their own analysis to make
- 18:05sure to take decisions from It's the help, they're just in the
- 18:09platform analysis. So, again, doing their analysis,
- 18:13in Google ads, Facebook, Etc, and also just making sure that
- 18:16they're maximizing Their audience, audience capabilities
- 18:19within each platform. And I guess this might be a bit
- 18:22of a stupid question that. So I obviously run a company and
- 18:24half of that is paid media, but I'm very disconnected from that
- 18:28side. And I'm not particularly great
- 18:30with the tracking side of things, but we obviously use
- 18:33Alibi a lot of g.i. and kind of building out the data layer.
- 18:37We shot the thigh technically, how does a lava kind of improve
- 18:43upon this kind of stuff like, yeah.
- 18:44How, how is it that Alabama? Is actually kind of optimizing.
- 18:48The conversion a July and then equally, same point around gar
- 18:52zar. Yeah, so the two years ago, it
- 18:57was okay. There is a big maybe three years
- 19:01ago. I'm aging myself with again, the
- 19:03covid your, I kind of forget but three, three or four years ago,
- 19:08the valley propyl is. Okay, you want to, you have a
- 19:11mess of tracking, some are hard-coded in a theme, some are
- 19:14injected through different manners and it's become somewhat
- 19:18somewhat of a pain in the butt to even know what's going on
- 19:20with tracking. And it was impacting, your site
- 19:22performance. So it's moving things too.
- 19:24With tag manager, where you could simplify that, process,
- 19:27just have one data layer, they can map everything to.
- 19:30So that's still a big part of what all of our offers and the
- 19:34core of we're just your base client-side.
- 19:37Try tracking can be configured, where we've seen and started to
- 19:42push ourselves and our customers over.
- 19:44The last couple of years is okay.
- 19:46We if we know that tracking needs to go server side and we
- 19:50know that if we just talk Google analytics, there's just an
- 19:53increase in Direct traffic or just junk channels like organic
- 19:57referral coupon sites Etc. What what can we do to try to
- 20:01combat that? As we know that there's going to
- 20:04be an increase need and Brands to use analytics to just
- 20:07understand a from a broad broad stroke of what's happening with
- 20:10a business. So where we really made a push
- 20:13is capturing all of that attribution data, storing it in
- 20:18our data, layer setting it on the Shopify session or Shopify
- 20:22object. So when I say, Attribution data
- 20:25talking things like all over utm's your Facebook click ID is
- 20:28your G, click IDs, the impact radius click ID, Tick-Tock click
- 20:32IDs, anything that these platforms need for attribution
- 20:36is storing all of that setting it on the order.
- 20:39So all of these all these purchase or conversion
- 20:42Integrations, can move server-side, and they won't miss
- 20:45out on have and being able to ultimately connect back to that
- 20:48session. So, with Google analytics,
- 20:50specifically something that if you were to just go into our App
- 20:54today, is we even have a toggle to use.
- 20:58We use the term first touch of versus last touch when you want
- 21:00to send an order to GA, but the a little bit of a Nuance with
- 21:05Shopify is they they do a pretty good job of storing different
- 21:10activities. So if you go to your Shopify
- 21:12order, you'll see the little widget on the right side.
- 21:14It says this is the customer six session until they made an order
- 21:19and they can click into that and see, they first came to through
- 21:22this link and then I did these Things then they converted.
- 21:25So we try to do is we try to capture pull that data in merge,
- 21:32that with what we capture within our data layer and then present
- 21:36that as an option that Merchants can use.
- 21:37So they have more control over their essentially, their
- 21:41attribution and and Universal analytics or Google analytics.
- 21:45And that that was a pretty big push last year.
- 21:48As again, Facebook became a little bit of a not really,
- 21:51don't really know what's going on so that That I'll just pause
- 21:55there to see if I answer the question in terms of where we've
- 21:57been seeing that push of the transition from just a basic GTM
- 22:00data layer, get everything out of the theme for site speed, get
- 22:04everything in a GTM now it's into, okay, how can, how can L
- 22:08of our help with attribution without being attribution
- 22:11software, like the north beams and rocker Boxes Etc.
- 22:14But it's in our little world of conversion tracking and getting
- 22:18getting that data. That the platform's need that
- 22:20ultimately these different software providers.
- 22:23Also need because Our, they're ingesting that data, that's what
- 22:26made as a good analogy. We are pushing this data to the
- 22:29platforms. They're ingesting this different
- 22:32data to do their attribution magic to help, Merchants better
- 22:36understand where we're conversions are coming from.
- 22:38So it's almost like we're the you don't want to pull dirty
- 22:42data out. So that's why we're trying to
- 22:43really control that clean data going into each platform now
- 22:47that make that make sense. Yeah, that definitely answer the
- 22:49question. I think the only thing I'd add
- 22:50is turns a lot of things into configuration, which is always.
- 22:54Good. So next question.
- 22:57So you obviously see a lot of issues when it comes to tracking
- 23:02and a big Focus, your product is on different levels of tracking.
- 23:06What are the most common issues that you see what?
- 23:08I like? The most common things that you
- 23:10see break for clients Oh, most common issues that we see
- 23:19duplicate conversions. So that's one to duplicate
- 23:22tracking. So that could be as simple as
- 23:25just having tracking set up in GT M, and a native Shopify app.
- 23:27So that's that's one same thing with Google ads.
- 23:30So having a Google shopping app installed and also having the
- 23:33Google conversion hard-coded in the thank you page.
- 23:39Incorrect product, IDs cattle, got catalog ID.
- 23:41So that's another one where you it's again, it's kind of a pain
- 23:44in the butt. Just wit.
- 23:45This is set up for from the merchant perspective, but you
- 23:48have your catalog upload just our Google ads what same thing
- 23:51for any platform, but your catalog upload through merchant
- 23:53center and you have your primary identifier, you need to need to
- 23:56make sure that your tag that's ultimately triggering and
- 23:59sending the different events. The page page view.
- 24:01Add to cart events is sending that same product ID, so there's
- 24:05a match. So that's another big one.
- 24:08The missing conversions. So missing conversions is
- 24:12really, I wouldn't put that put that in the top two or three
- 24:16issues. It's generally that happens.
- 24:20But missing conversions is a, if you're let's say, you're just
- 24:24using using the native Shopify Integrations for GA Facebook,
- 24:28Google ads, Etc. And general does a pretty good
- 24:30job. You should be around 90 ish
- 24:33percent ninety. Some are 95% summer 85%.
- 24:36But in general, that's usually what we see.
- 24:38See in your decision-making. Depending if you're, maybe in
- 24:42that one to ten million dollar brand, your decision-making
- 24:47won't really change in Google analytics from going from 90 to
- 24:5199 percent and conversions. In my opinion, once your larger
- 24:55than that could potentially that could change but usually missing
- 25:00conversions is a big issue when we start talking about brands
- 25:03that are using recharge or any or post-purchase up cells, Etc.
- 25:08Not as plug-and-play. So that's that's usually one of
- 25:12the big things that we see in big, big issues won't come or
- 25:15big issue that we see when it comes to tracking.
- 25:17But otherwise yeah, I would say it's still many Brands to still
- 25:21have that combination of some tracking installed on the theme,
- 25:24some install and thank you page. Some that's coming through GTM.
- 25:27Some it's coming through apps and ends up being a mishmash
- 25:29everywhere and just causes a lot of pain pain for the marketer,
- 25:34really? Yeah.
- 25:40Experience, most MBM the recharge one's been.
- 25:43We've had various issues of like the external check out.
- 25:45So that's always been a bit of an annoying, one to dissect and
- 25:49and I guess you have any other tips for Brands when it comes to
- 25:53particularly Facebook. Also GA like in terms of kind of
- 25:56identifying these issues earlier putting anything in place.
- 25:59But is there anything people can do proactively to be more aware
- 26:02of tracking issues, but it does feel like, you know, in most
- 26:05cases identified based on Change them performance or changes in
- 26:10reporting. Is there anything people can do
- 26:13to be more proactive? Yeah, if we talk Google try to
- 26:19go, I try to give examples of DIY eyeing it and then other
- 26:23examples that are out there, so with Google analytics, there is
- 26:27a little-known feature called alerts and Universal analytics.
- 26:30I don't think this even exists in GA for, but you can set up
- 26:33custom alerts to just look at percentage changes of conversion
- 26:37rate, transactions, Etc. Inside a Facebook.
- 26:41There are also, there's a custom alerts or notifications, you
- 26:44probably know this better than I do, but nomenclature, but same
- 26:48thing you can set up rules to look for big spikes of
- 26:52activities of could be spikes in your CPI, CPAs or Os, or
- 26:58whatever. I mean, it's almost unlimited
- 26:59what you can do with with the Facebook alerts notifications.
- 27:02So that's another one that we've seen used in the past and try to
- 27:05encourage especially around the big holiday shopping season.
- 27:10There are me, it's also very manual.
- 27:13So it's digging into your events manager.
- 27:15May I know that we've seen that many marketers marketing
- 27:19agencies, do that over the years of part of their daily weekly
- 27:22processes to go through manually and test the site and see if
- 27:25there's duplicate track and going through the downside of
- 27:29that is to pixel helpers aren't really the source of Truth.
- 27:32So you everything could look right in a pixel Helper, but
- 27:34it's really not right. In the Diagnostics inside of
- 27:38each platform. So that's not always foolproof
- 27:41foolproof, per se. There is there are tools out
- 27:45there like pingdom. So something to do with pingdom
- 27:48is you can do synthetic, attesting.
- 27:51It is a little more technical, but you can create these rules
- 27:54to have a bot. Go through the site and validate
- 27:56different data or things that should happen.
- 27:59Maybe what we've done. So we in part of our quarterly
- 28:03reviews, I would take all the screenshots that would come in
- 28:06from customers. This is going back, 2018, 2019,
- 28:09but Where they would again be, they would send us emails.
- 28:12Like, hey, we noticed this event dropped off, or this started
- 28:16duplicating, and we didn't have a solve for back.
- 28:20Then we, we could solve for data layer errors, where, like
- 28:24revenue is undefined or things like that, that was in our data
- 28:27layer are monitoring. So what we ended up building in
- 28:31was what we call Channel accuracy monitoring.
- 28:34So that's that this wasn't really only enabled with the
- 28:37move to server-side tracking. So, essentially what we're
- 28:39doing, Is inside our dashboard is you have your channel and
- 28:45you'd have your we just look at Facebook and we can look at how
- 28:49many orders you had in the last 24 hours or hour by hour seven
- 28:53days 30 days. So let's say if we saw thousand
- 28:57orders and Shopify that you had yesterday or today and then
- 29:00we're looking at how many orders were sent to Facebook and
- 29:04successfully received without errors, and then that's where we
- 29:07quantify it. So that's really our value
- 29:09proposition to be gone. Our homepage, it's we guarantee
- 29:1195. Percent conversion of
- 29:12conversions, are sent each Channel and we can quantify it
- 29:15because we can again going back to how server-side tracking
- 29:18works. Is when you send a an event to
- 29:21the conversion API, these platforms have to give you a
- 29:24thumbs-up or a thumbs-down. So we log that, we log that
- 29:27thumbs up, thumbs down and simply compare.
- 29:29So, if you drop, so if you drop a go below 95% or go above 105
- 29:34percent then that triggers an alert and we'll say, hey, Paul,
- 29:37your Facebook conversion, tracking is at 50%.
- 29:41There's probably an issue there of some sort of duplicate
- 29:43tracking happening, but there is a, yeah, it's a, it's a great
- 29:48question. And something that there might
- 29:50be other Solutions out there. But for the most part, I know
- 29:53it's still a very manual process for most.
- 29:56What is amply INS in a word? It's Freedom, the freedom to
- 30:01build a digital experience as Limitless as your vision create
- 30:05preview schedule, and manage, all your content in one easy
- 30:08place. Find out more at a lien, start
- 30:12calm, and plants experience, Freedom, that makes sense.
- 30:18And it's interesting how much you've shifted into this space.
- 30:21Could obviously I've known you more for the ga side over the
- 30:24years and various things here written or even when we first
- 30:28met, but it is interesting that obviously people are willing to
- 30:31invest in the surrogate. Everyone's kind of increasing
- 30:34spend. And, you know, seeing challenges
- 30:36with these channels. Yeah, it's really interesting.
- 30:39Yeah. I can imagine has been a big
- 30:41area of, you just go back to the cookies piece and some of the
- 30:44changes that we see in there and with all the new kind of privacy
- 30:48issues. How do you see this impact in
- 30:51the CRM side? Because obviously, a lot of the
- 30:53CRM or kind of the SPs will be tracking behavior on site using
- 30:58cook. It is like, what's your view on
- 31:00this right? Is this something that you think
- 31:02you know, they're starting to look at the server side route
- 31:04but is it a case of actually over time it's going to really
- 31:08impact that side. We believe that Brands
- 31:15eventually are going to the responsibility will be on the
- 31:19brand to create their own identification and tracking
- 31:24that. And that goes It goes for GA or
- 31:28potentially serums Etc. If users if people are using
- 31:32klaviyo that obviously they're they're very aware cognizant of
- 31:36this issue as well. Especially with the conical hide
- 31:39my Else. But in general think that's are
- 31:42like getting too deep in the weeds, we believe that you won't
- 31:45be able to just rely on the quote-unquote.
- 31:49Cookie identifier that GA or other platforms create
- 31:51automatically for you. So there needs to be a fallback.
- 31:55Now whether you use a piece of software to help you manage that
- 31:59that user identification that's Anonymous and can initially be
- 32:02track to back to user depending your privacy requirements or you
- 32:06do it yourself, you build it in. House yourself.
- 32:08That that's likely. Going to be something that many
- 32:11Brands will start to undertake over the next couple years and
- 32:14they'll be they'll also have to work very closely with the their
- 32:19data science team not that everyone has a data science team
- 32:21per se so it could be if you are using an attribution solution.
- 32:26Like Again The Rocker boxes nor themes Etc.
- 32:30They'll and they're essentially your data warehouse where you're
- 32:33going in to do your analysis is just making sure that you have
- 32:36things lined up appropriately. So when they're doing their
- 32:39merger, And even NASA T2, that I know dasty does a lot of this of
- 32:43just blending data from different sources.
- 32:44Is making sure that you have the right identifiers that you can
- 32:48anchor off of. Make sense but yeah, clay clay
- 32:53view, I don't know if what they're or any plan email
- 32:58platform. And if we get to the world where
- 33:01there's no, you don't know, the actual email.
- 33:03So you don't know it's Paul or it's just a it's a knot on the
- 33:06string. Does it really matter?
- 33:08That's the other thing I would ask is, did I really need to
- 33:11know what's Paul? What do you think?
- 33:13Yeah, it's an interesting one. Is now I guess, as long as I'm
- 33:17able to tie the behavior together like does Mater desert.
- 33:22Now, where that would break is, if it doesn't matter to klaviyo
- 33:26because you use or your your CRM in general, but if you just want
- 33:30to see their lifetime activity and what products that this
- 33:35clinical users viewed and what they purchased and all that.
- 33:37That's probably fine and not a big issue.
- 33:40It'll it's an issue from probably user research and other
- 33:44things like that. We're like you said, that is an
- 33:48issue is for platforms, that want the email in order.
- 33:52Order to do the match back. Because if we're sending
- 33:55Facebook or SnapChat or Tick, Tock the random Apple Mail
- 33:59string, they're not going to be able to use that to try to match
- 34:03back to their campaign. That's where they're going to
- 34:05need some of their identifiers. So Tick-Tock has this TT, click
- 34:10ID. So it's we're almost going back
- 34:1215 years, 20 years, in the marketing space, we're ensuring
- 34:16that every session, every query parameter that is on an inbound
- 34:19Link at you. You can't.
- 34:22You literally can't lose that. And that, that has to be sent,
- 34:24has to be like a spiderweb sent to all of your different
- 34:28analytics and marketing platforms.
- 34:30I guess you lose the ability to cross device and all of that
- 34:33kind of stuff if there's no like because I guess most platforms
- 34:38at the moment, red tie the entry of an email back to combining
- 34:42different devices. So yeah, unless I'm being really
- 34:45stupid. I can't see a way of Yeah.
- 34:48Well, yeah, it go. Dump.
- 34:55The the cross-device, there's two two ways to look at it one.
- 34:59If if users logging in and you are quote, unquote work, we're
- 35:04requiring a login, you can start to do some that cross device,
- 35:07but there are platforms out there that they'll they'll embed
- 35:12links. So if they're driving whether
- 35:15it's through SMS or email and again they're setting their own
- 35:18query parameters on a links and that's how they're able to
- 35:21essentially. Stitch that activity back.
- 35:23So they can say, oh, well Paul. We know that we know the email
- 35:26that the email link that Paula clicked on last week and we know
- 35:30the emails that he clicked on since then and they can start to
- 35:33do some that stitching together where you don't have necessarily
- 35:36be logged in but again it all comes back to just link it comes
- 35:41back to Links. Yeah, just linking the links
- 35:43together. Yeah, that's definitely
- 35:46definitely some room to lose some day and still because I our
- 35:50average client definitely I wouldn't have a high percentage
- 35:53of users logging in our average kind of like premium fashion
- 35:57brand together and they would rely a lot on stitching people's
- 36:03behavior together across different devices based on email
- 36:05and true. So yeah I guess yeah.
- 36:07It's going to be an interesting one but I guess that takes time
- 36:10to the next Quest. I think that's going to change.
- 36:13I ever Lane was one. I don't know if you recall but
- 36:18five-ish 45s years ago, they were One of the brands of you,
- 36:23if you came into their product page, they presented their
- 36:26product pages, actually pretty slick where they were.
- 36:30It looked like you needed to login in order to add to cart.
- 36:33They don't, they don't do it anymore, but I do believe that
- 36:37is going to be something that will happen in the future and it
- 36:40could be simple as you add to cart and then you're prompted
- 36:44with a like, hey do you want to enter your email to get those
- 36:49coupon or proceed or whatever it might be?
- 36:51I don't it's not going to be as rigid as the old Magento days
- 36:54where it's oh yeah you hit the checkout and it's like create
- 36:57your account right now. I don't think it'll be as rigid
- 36:59as that. I think it'll be absolutely more
- 37:01seamless user experience, but that that's going to it's going
- 37:05to happen eventually, or even like a sold a single sign-on
- 37:08sessions that we think. I was just like, pushing.
- 37:10Yeah, some level of. Yeah, exactly.
- 37:13Now that makes sense. And then I guess we've touched
- 37:15on some of it though. I'd imagine that last question.
- 37:19How do you think? You know, all of this is going
- 37:21to change Did I know what is the future?
- 37:23Is it a case of Brands taking more ownership of this stuff?
- 37:26Yeah. What do you think that the next
- 37:29maybe two or three years as install from a track and
- 37:32perspective and kind of data perspective?
- 37:37Yeah, Brands there will be an increased responsibility for
- 37:41Brands to own their just tracking infrastructure.
- 37:46Whether it's again that unique identifier and making sure
- 37:49that's that's try. That's actually set and tracked
- 37:53for all activity. Do I do believe that the login
- 37:59is going to be another one and part of that is especially if
- 38:03you are in Europe or potentially some of these states in the u.s.
- 38:08that are starting to roll out more strict privacy is if you
- 38:12can't, if I mean that's the other thing we talked about is
- 38:14privacy, is there is the if you if people don't opt in then
- 38:18there's no tracking whatsoever or it's very limited.
- 38:22So that is going to hit me if you look at newspapers.
- 38:25Hers. And some of the, the old media
- 38:27companies where they've they've had to go to this route of you
- 38:30need to create your calendar pay.
- 38:32I think we're not too far away from that happening with
- 38:34e-commerce as well. I don't necessarily think that's
- 38:37a bad thing because users are potentially used to doing that.
- 38:41Or many users are used to doing that on apps and phones and the
- 38:44like the oauth logins with hotels.com or whatever it might
- 38:47be. So as long as it's very seamless
- 38:50and potentially is tied to the value prop, so it could be
- 38:53instead of getting the welcome Banner as As you just land on a
- 38:56site, which most people it's going, people are numb to it now
- 38:59and they just closed it out anyways.
- 39:00But not everyone, but I think you can, you'll start to see
- 39:03just some user experiences change where you are encouraging
- 39:07users to quote, unquote log in to create their account because
- 39:11then you can you can run them through have them the whole
- 39:13privacy process enabled and and also unlock somebody's tracking
- 39:18tracking pain points. So those are those are probably
- 39:22the two biggest ones, the already mentioned the server
- 39:24side. Let's not just through Facebook
- 39:27was earliest and pushing conversion API because the
- 39:29signal loss was impacting them, the most as a big public company
- 39:33but the same the same constraints and friction they
- 39:35were experiencing every app experiences right now Tick Tock
- 39:39is on the they're just exploding with the organic and against
- 39:43Tick Tock is you don't need to have a ton of followers, you
- 39:46just need to have interest that you follow.
- 39:48So there's just different. There's different way to explore
- 39:50and discover as a user. But eventually once there's big
- 39:54dollars, Stood in to tick, tock, spend for Brands.
- 39:58Again, that, that spend will come under, whatever the word
- 40:04is, people are going to they'll want it.
- 40:05They'll be asking the same questions of tick-tock that they
- 40:08are with Facebook today. So again, they're going to
- 40:10they're gonna hit those privacy or the tracking constraints.
- 40:13Yeah. Yeah.
- 40:13Makes sense Superman. Chest out via interests and say
- 40:16hi whole kind of them followed and great.
- 40:20Yeah I mean I think that's a really good episode is my last
- 40:22question. Really appreciate you coming on
- 40:25some really Custom topics, 30, I need to get a lot better with
- 40:28some of these areas like people always tend to ask me about the
- 40:30Facebook stuff, but I always defer them to other people
- 40:33because I just not spent enough time looking at it but yeah,
- 40:36we're really interested in. Is there anything else that you
- 40:39want to add or how can people get get in touch with you, as
- 40:43well? If they've got any questions?
- 40:45Yeah, one thing I'd add is, don't sleep on ga4 and getting
- 40:50that set up so you have the year-over-year once that July
- 40:53date kicks in and I also don't don't get don't when you first
- 41:01log in a ga4 it's overwhelming because it looks nothing like
- 41:04what you're used to but there is a very hidden feature right now
- 41:09that we've only explored a little bit, I think as an
- 41:13industry. And that's the ability.
- 41:15D to modify your default attribution.
- 41:18So you no longer have to be tied to gaas.
- 41:21Last click. You can use their data driven
- 41:24attribution model, you can default all of your reports to a
- 41:27first touch and if you and power that with Google signals which
- 41:32is their way to help some of that magical cross device
- 41:37fingerprinting since everyone's logged in on the Google Device.
- 41:40There is, I think some of that some of the ga Or functionality
- 41:46that will start to hear more and more benefits as as more
- 41:49branches, spend more time in there, but I think that's
- 41:52probably one of the more interesting things about GA for
- 41:54that. I'm excited to see how Brands
- 41:56utilize that and potentially compare and contrast to, what
- 41:58they're they're seeing in some of their other two lengths that
- 42:01they utilize. So that's a ga for side just as
- 42:04a last thought. And if anyone has any questions,
- 42:07you can email me Brad at. Get all of our.com and that is
- 42:12GE. Tele2 be isn't There they are.
- 42:16Lovely. Great, thank you.
- 42:18And yeah, thanks everyone for listening.
- 42:20And as always, feel free to listen on the main channels and
- 42:24all you can watch on YouTube and yet give us a like or a pilot or
- 42:28a bit more information on this topic, head over to re-platform
- 42:38dot. F m, for our audio podcasts to
- 42:40discuss a project or if you like to chat about any of the topics
- 42:43covered in this episode in more. Ow, please.
- 42:45Reach out to myself, James guard.
- 42:46And my co-host pull Rogers, via LinkedIn, and Twitter.
- 42:49Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 42:51next episode.