Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Flirtation Walk (1934)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17your Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we are celebrating movies
- 0:23that were released in a normal calendar window.
- 0:28Why would you say that, Kyle? Because it's true.
- 0:31Well, and it's true for this year moving forward
- 0:35and not previously. This is correct. Up to a
- 0:39point. I'm looking at you, COVID. That's right.
- 0:41That changes things a little bit. That's going
- 0:43to be like 10 years from now, so we're okay.
- 0:45COVID's 10 years from now. Good Lord, I hope
- 0:48not. A clip that you'd like to put on the internet,
- 0:51huh? Yeah. Anyway, the good news is, is that
- 0:54we don't have to talk anymore about, well, this
- 0:56technically came out in 1933, 1934, but then
- 0:59here's the Academy Award nominees for this. Nope.
- 1:01This is just moving forward. We are talking about
- 1:04one specific year, which rocks. It's so cool.
- 1:07Very excited about that. And it's also interesting
- 1:09because we have talked about movies that have
- 1:12three Best Picture nominees. We've talked about
- 1:15movies that have 10 Best Picture nominees. You
- 1:18mean years? Yeah. I don't know what I'm doing.
- 1:20I get you. Only a third through my coffee. I'm
- 1:24getting there. We have talked about years where
- 1:27there have been, at least Academy Award years,
- 1:30where there have been three Best Picture nominees,
- 1:3210 Best Picture nominees. This year, we have
- 1:36our largest count yet, which is 13. Yeah. And
- 1:40this is something that will happen twice, this
- 1:43year and next year that we cover. That's it.
- 1:46After that, the highest. Nominee count is 10.
- 1:50Can I say something controversial? Sure. Thank
- 1:51God. Yeah, I'll thank him. 13 nominations is
- 1:55a lot. It's a ton. You have even been a loud
- 1:59advocate for not even seeing 10 sometimes. I
- 2:03agree. I think it should be 5 to 10. Yep. Doesn't
- 2:08have to be 10. But here we are with 13. And I
- 2:10think it's crazy that we've had like, I believe
- 2:13prior to this year, it was like a 17 month window.
- 2:17Yeah. But then when we reduce it down to the
- 2:1912 months, we're like, yeah, but let's do 13
- 2:21nominations. That's more than a movie a month.
- 2:23That's crazy. Yeah, it's interesting, too, because
- 2:26not so much in terms of time we'll look back
- 2:29and remember all these movies so fondly, but
- 2:31there's some heavy hitters in this year. Totally.
- 2:33So it's not even like there isn't an F1, so to
- 2:37speak, of why did they throw this in here? You
- 2:41can make sense on most of these. Yeah. I haven't
- 2:44seen all of them. There might be an F1. You know
- 2:46what's really funny? At the end of this, in the
- 2:48ceremony episode for this year, let's go back
- 2:50and we'll do the F1. We should do that. Every
- 2:53year on a ceremony, we should have an F1 award
- 2:55of like, what are you doing here, man? I like
- 2:57that idea. Which is funny because I actually
- 2:59support F1 being nominated for Best Picture in
- 3:02that sense. But I can acknowledge that there's
- 3:05a like, hey, Sinners in One Battle came out.
- 3:07And there's F1. Sure. So that's okay. And that
- 3:11being said, you know, this is an interesting
- 3:13year because this is a pretty monumental year
- 3:15when it comes to how movies can win awards and
- 3:19what that looks like. So we'll talk about that
- 3:21moving forward. Yeah. Not to give anything away.
- 3:23But today we're talking specifically about Flirtation
- 3:27Walk. We are. Kyle, have you ever taken a Flirtation
- 3:29Walk? Probably, actually. Yeah. I think so. So
- 3:34let's see. There's the Flirtation Walk and then
- 3:36the Kissing Rock. Okay, yeah. So have you found
- 3:40yourself on a flirtation walk? Sure. Near a kissing
- 3:44rock? Probably. I think I have too. I feel like
- 3:48we're revealing a lot about ourselves this episode.
- 3:50Well, you know, you're supposed to. Pulling up
- 3:52my collar. Some respect these days. Yeah, we're
- 3:55talking about Flirtation Walk. This is the Frank
- 3:58Borzegi feature. He's back, baby. Someone we've
- 4:01talked about a good bit, you know, just in the
- 4:03films that we've covered of his, Seventh Heaven,
- 4:05Bad Girl, Farewell to Arms. Yeah. It is a return
- 4:08for... borzegi and not just a return to the academy
- 4:13awards for borzegi but for me it's a return to
- 4:16a style of his because farewell to arms was not
- 4:20the style that i had expected from seventh heaven
- 4:22and bad girl oh interesting i think we are continuing
- 4:27his style here. See, the only thing that I'll
- 4:30agree slash disagree with on that is that I think
- 4:33there is a lot of Seventh Heaven in Farewell
- 4:35to Arms. Yeah. And I think there's a bit of Bad
- 4:38Girl in Flirtation Walk. So here's the thing
- 4:41with Borzegi. He writes the same story over and
- 4:44over, and it works if you put it in the right
- 4:48setting. And I think... He does that for half
- 4:51of this movie. Yeah. Yeah. That's exactly it.
- 4:54I think that this is a case of... Okay, you're
- 4:57teetering on good here. Yeah. So, yeah, let's
- 5:02talk about nominees. Teetering on good would
- 5:04be such a good autobiography name for Frank Borsicki.
- 5:07That'd be a good autobiography for me. I would
- 5:09take that. Honestly, that'd be such a compliment
- 5:11if I was teetering on good. Yeah. I'll take that.
- 5:14Let's talk about some nominations. So, Flirtation
- 5:16Walk was nominated for two. That was best sound
- 5:20recording for Nathan Levinson. An outstanding
- 5:23production. I want to talk about this. First
- 5:25National slash Warner Brothers. Yeah. So technically
- 5:29separate at the time or were they? I'm not sure.
- 5:31I'm not leading the witness. I'm asking. No,
- 5:33I think it was one of those things where First
- 5:34National produced it and Warner Brothers distributed
- 5:38it. Perfect. It got picked up ultimately by Warner
- 5:41Brothers. So ultimately, would that be Warner
- 5:43Brothers that's honored for outstanding production?
- 5:46I have it written. According to all my research,
- 5:49that First National was the awarded, or would
- 5:52have been the awarded if it won. Spoiler. Spoiler.
- 5:55Okay, cool. Good to know. I want to make sure,
- 5:57because I saw First National all over the posters,
- 5:59but in my research, Warner Brothers was talked
- 6:01about. Yeah, yeah. Makes sense. All right, let's
- 6:04talk about some cast. So the exciting thing about
- 6:06this movie, I think, is the return of so many
- 6:08names. Of course, Frank Borzaghi, which I think
- 6:12we're reaching a point, both of us, where we're
- 6:13like, this could go great or not so great. As
- 6:18far as the cast goes, though, last year we talked
- 6:20about 42nd Street and the way the musical exploded.
- 6:24Stars there included Dick Powell, Ruby Keeler.
- 6:27They're both in this. Dick Powell plays Dick
- 6:30Canary Dorsey, and Ruby Keeler is Kit Fitz, which
- 6:34is like the coolest name ever. Yeah, so her name's
- 6:36Kathleen, right? Yeah, but... Who cares? It's
- 6:40Kit Fitz, baby. I think she might be referred
- 6:42to Kathleen once, if even. Yeah. But credited
- 6:46it shows as Kathleen, but otherwise she's called
- 6:48Kit. Yeah, she is. And it's interesting because
- 6:49you're like, why are you called Kit? And the
- 6:51minute you find out her name is Kathleen Fitz
- 6:53and it's Kay Fitz and that's Kits or Kit. Yeah.
- 6:57Cool. I got it. But up until then, I was like,
- 6:59why do they call you Kit? But great name. I'll
- 7:01tell you why they call her Kit. One day she's
- 7:04coming out with sneakers. Like that. The Kit
- 7:06Kits. is a sneaker name. K -Fitz Kicks. Oh, man.
- 7:12Here's a side project we might want to work.
- 7:15Once upon a time at the Oscars merchandise, we
- 7:17come out with some sweet kicks. You don't have
- 7:22to look at my foot when I point to it. It's fine.
- 7:24Well, you're wearing Mario? No. Rodan. Rodan
- 7:27socks. Ooh. The king of fashion. That's me, baby.
- 7:32It's fine. I'm wearing fruit socks, I think,
- 7:33right now. Oh, yeah, you are. I love a banana.
- 7:36Pat Bryant is also in this movie as Scrapper
- 7:39Tom Hill. Uh -huh. Sure is. I'm leaving that
- 7:42alone. Off the rails so far. Honestly, we're
- 7:45starting the year off hot. Totally. So, Ross
- 7:48Alexander as Oski was the only other individual
- 7:52that I had listed down here. Oski was Canary's
- 7:55best friend, or at least confidant, in West Point.
- 7:58Okay. He was the guy who helped him put on the
- 8:01production and everything. We'll get ahead of
- 8:03it. So, let's talk about it. I want to start
- 8:06with this. When the movie starts, it has this
- 8:09rolling banner, a rolling introduction of the
- 8:12names. The title crawl. The title crawl. Thank
- 8:14you. Star Wars. I was just about to make a joke.
- 8:17Oh, oops. We go to West Point. No. So it says
- 8:22the cast naming here. And when you look at the
- 8:25cast, you see Dick Powell as Canary, Ruby Keeler
- 8:28as Kit, Pat O 'Brien as Scrapper, Ross Alexander
- 8:31as Oski. And they're all quoted. Right? It's
- 8:35all a quotation, like a nickname. Yeah. And I
- 8:37was like, is this a gangster movie? I know. Because
- 8:41the last time we saw this was like Lady for a
- 8:42Day. With Apple Annie and the dude. Apple Annie,
- 8:45the dude. I forget. No, Shakespeare. Yeah. So
- 8:50you had a lot of that. And I was like, I don't
- 8:52know anything about this movie going in. The
- 8:54only thing I know is that Kyle had posted an
- 8:56Instagram story about how he's watching a movie
- 8:57set in Hawaii with his surfboard in the background.
- 9:00Yeah. So unless this is a Hawaiian gangster film,
- 9:03I have no idea to expect. And the answer is just
- 9:06that everyone has cool nicknames in the army.
- 9:09It's true. Even the women who aren't in the army
- 9:12have cool nicknames. That's true. Is your dad
- 9:14a lieutenant? Here's a cool nickname. Are you
- 9:16going to come out with the hottest sneakers next
- 9:18year? Here's a cool nickname. Oh, my gosh. The
- 9:20Ruby Keeler kicks. Or the Ruby Keeler hears.
- 9:23This gets better and better. I'm writing this
- 9:24down. You know, there's such a market for 1930
- 9:28film actors and shoes. You joke. I think there
- 9:32is. Look at The Wizard of Oz. What are we doing?
- 9:35What are we waiting on? I'm trying to think of
- 9:37what I would do for Wallace Beery. High tops?
- 9:40No, I can't figure it out. We'll get there. Basketball?
- 9:43Well, it's fine. So the point of this podcast
- 9:48is I'm losing my mind. The synopsis behind Flirtation
- 9:51Walk is we're introduced to Dick Dorsey, whose
- 9:55nickname is Canary. And Canary is... A free -spirited
- 10:00man who is living in the military and trying
- 10:02to live his best life and finding more and more
- 10:04that he needs to be more responsible and accountable
- 10:06within the army. And he tries to take his role
- 10:10very seriously. And unfortunately, he does this
- 10:12at the exact time that he meets the lieutenant's
- 10:15daughter, Kit. And she is very... of course,
- 10:20played by Ruby Keillor. She is very domineering
- 10:23and playful and wants the full experience. And
- 10:27that results in him kind of going off script
- 10:29and not behaving like a officer or military cadet.
- 10:33And this is controversial because he takes her
- 10:36somewhere he's not supposed to. And they watch
- 10:38a luau and they make this, you know, genuine
- 10:41connection. But ultimately, this results in him
- 10:44being potentially barred from the military. And
- 10:48something needs to come out of it. And what comes
- 10:50out of it is him committing himself to West Point
- 10:52and separating himself from Ruby Keeler. Yeah.
- 10:56I think that's the best way to describe this
- 10:57without saying how it ends, too. Yeah. But that's
- 11:01the synopsis behind this. Would you describe
- 11:03it another way? Yeah, it's a musical, for one.
- 11:06Is it, though? I think in the sense of like the
- 11:09way musicals have made a comeback last year with
- 11:1242nd Street and Gold Diggers in 1933, a lot of
- 11:16that music is reserved for the back end. Yeah.
- 11:19But you also have like the luau scene where Dick
- 11:22Powell sings Aloha Hoy, which is honestly one
- 11:26of my favorite scenes in the movie. I didn't
- 11:29realize I like. like that song like genuinely
- 11:31like that song great little lullaby i think yeah
- 11:35oh yeah for sure and i agree with you in terms
- 11:37of scenes uh that's probably one of the better
- 11:39ones and you're right the the musical numbers
- 11:42really are saved for the end um almost to a point
- 11:45where the movie just feels almost unearned as
- 11:49a musical because it's the last 30 minutes or
- 11:51so and canary is just like you know the hundredth
- 11:55night thing that we do here at west point i'm
- 11:57gonna write a musical Yeah. A musical review.
- 11:59And you're like, what? What's happening? And
- 12:03it just kind of becomes a musical all of a sudden.
- 12:05Because you're right. Up until that point, the
- 12:07only musicals that we got were the Hawaiian natives
- 12:10were performing a song, and then they insist
- 12:13that Canary sing. Yeah. And then those are the
- 12:17only two musical aspects that you have. Well,
- 12:19I mean... Up until that point. Canary himself,
- 12:21like, he has that nickname Canary because he
- 12:23sings all the time. Sure. And people expect him
- 12:25to just... burst into song at any point right
- 12:27and that's like the the main point of his character
- 12:32he's kind of borderline lazy he doesn't pull
- 12:35his weight in the military right he's he doesn't
- 12:38take it seriously he's pretty much like the worst
- 12:40soldier ever to a degree and he finds himself
- 12:43you find him singing like all the time so that
- 12:46is a draw eventually for ruby keeler the kit
- 12:49falling in love with him is he takes her to this
- 12:53luau and and serenades her The story itself is
- 12:57kind of weird. It like threw me for a loop. One,
- 12:59I had no idea what flirtation walk meant. Right.
- 13:02Ultimately, we find that this is a real location
- 13:05outside of West Point in Washington, D .C. Right.
- 13:09Where soldiers would literally, they'd take their
- 13:13sweethearts out on a flirty walk. It's like the
- 13:16makeout point of the military. Right. To a degree.
- 13:19But the way this story plays out, like we're
- 13:23in Hawaii at first. And I was really excited.
- 13:27I was like, oh, this is cool. This is a location
- 13:29we haven't explored yet on the podcast. We haven't
- 13:33really explored just in cinema a whole lot up
- 13:36to this point. There are a few movies here and
- 13:38there. So I'm thinking we get to do a Hawaii
- 13:41movie and we leave pretty quickly. Like maybe
- 13:46the halfway point, maybe a little sooner. Yeah.
- 13:48Yeah. Bersaghi has his style, right? He has his
- 13:53stories that. constantly rely on a man and a
- 13:57woman who are, as the audience knows and believes,
- 14:02in love. But the two characters, for whatever
- 14:05reason, have a wedge between them. And we have
- 14:08seen that time and time again. When we first
- 14:11see these two characters together, they instantly
- 14:12fall in love. And through these very artificial
- 14:17obstacles placed between them, they're separated.
- 14:22And we talked about this with A Farewell to Arms,
- 14:24but I'm just kind of tired of this same story
- 14:28coming from Borzegi. And that's a bummer to me.
- 14:33I don't know about you, man. It's a bummer. No,
- 14:34it's a bummer. And, you know, I think it's okay
- 14:37to show our hand a little bit here. This did
- 14:40not hit me the way I think it was supposed to.
- 14:42Sure. I was not the intended audience, or at
- 14:44least this was not the intended film for me.
- 14:46I'm trying my best not to think of this as reactionary.
- 14:51Not my review, but the movie itself. But it's
- 14:54interesting watching Dick Powell and Ruby Keillor
- 14:57come from something like 42nd Street. And then
- 14:59even the, not formula, but the structure of like
- 15:03the three musical numbers at the end. We saw
- 15:06that in 42nd Street starring these two people.
- 15:08So when that happens in this, it just feels kind
- 15:10of like. I don't want to say derivative, but
- 15:13it just feels like, yeah, we've seen this happen
- 15:15before. And again, if you're taking an interesting
- 15:18approach to it, like, well, this one's set in
- 15:19Hawaii, and look at their relationship that they
- 15:22have, you're right to say that you're like, cool,
- 15:26it's a Hawaii movie. But not really, because
- 15:28then he goes to West Point, and when he goes
- 15:30to West Point, for the majority of his time there,
- 15:32we don't see Ruby Keeler or even hear from her.
- 15:34Sure, yeah. It's really just more his movie,
- 15:37Dick Powell's movie. a pacing issue was a clear
- 15:41problem that i had with this but also to your
- 15:44point we've seen you do this we've seen borzegi
- 15:47tackle this and it's not in like an interesting
- 15:49like different way if anything it was more canaries
- 15:54growth as an individual yeah not as a romantic
- 15:57partner and not even necessarily as a man but
- 15:59just more so like i'm going to be the best version
- 16:03of myself in this academy that I can be. Because
- 16:06he even thought, you know, he was asked to do
- 16:08too much when he was in Hawaii. But then he finds,
- 16:12well, you know what? Scrapper doesn't really
- 16:14believe in me and doesn't think I can do this,
- 16:16and I want to prove that I can. And he goes to
- 16:19High West Point to do this. Yeah. Finds it even
- 16:22more difficult, and it is more, like, strenuous,
- 16:25but he still commits himself to it. And it makes
- 16:27him hardened, kind of, in a way. So I thought,
- 16:30if anything, this might be an interesting, like,
- 16:31you know, when she sees him again, he's a different
- 16:33person. But that doesn't really change anything,
- 16:35because once they see each other, or not once
- 16:37they see each other, but once they work together
- 16:39again, he's kind of like... I'm just kidding,
- 16:41doll. I love you. Like, it's not interesting.
- 16:45Yeah, I mean, ultimately, I think a big phrase
- 16:47that this movie hinges on is the officer and
- 16:51a gentleman thing here. Because once we get to
- 16:55the point where Canary is in trouble for taking
- 16:58Kit out to this luau, he kind of has to shun
- 17:04her a little bit to protect his job. And that's
- 17:06when she says, you know, You'll never be an officer
- 17:10and a gentleman like you don't have that in you
- 17:12to be that personality. Right. And that's what
- 17:14kind of fuels him to be the officer. One, because
- 17:17he kind of has to to save his career. But now
- 17:21he also wants to prove her wrong as well as Scrapper
- 17:25and all of these other people who don't really
- 17:26believe in him. Then as the movie progresses
- 17:29and we see him succeed as an officer. When he
- 17:33does run into Kit again, now he's kind of standoffish
- 17:37to her. He's a little cruel. So now he's reached
- 17:40the rank of officer, but he doesn't have the
- 17:42gentleman part down. And, you know, he comes
- 17:46around on that eventually, too. I just think
- 17:48it's really interesting that the next episode
- 17:52we'll be talking about has a budding romance
- 17:55in it where I think the characters spend so much
- 18:00time together that you... really really believe
- 18:03in their romance yes borzegi does this thing
- 18:07where he either has the characters together for
- 18:10a large amount of the movie and then has like
- 18:12these these wedges and these reasons where they
- 18:14they can't be together sure or he has these wedges
- 18:18that physically keep these characters apart on
- 18:21the screen i think that seventh heaven and bad
- 18:24girl are the latter version of that and then
- 18:27a farewell to arms and this have these two characters
- 18:30who we see briefly together and we're like oh
- 18:32this is great they have great chemistry i'm invested
- 18:35in their relationship and he immediately separates
- 18:38them for a majority of the movie yeah and I want
- 18:43to see this romance. I want to see it happen.
- 18:46I want to see it develop. By the time they get
- 18:48back together, I'm not rooting for them in any
- 18:51way because I don't know if they're good together.
- 18:53Yeah, it's more like they walk in and they're
- 18:57like, hi, I'm the love interest. And that's kind
- 18:59of the expectation here. It's not, did I get
- 19:02to know you? Did I get to actually fall in love
- 19:05with you? And the only chance they have is this
- 19:08one night of... him driving her and her insisting
- 19:11like nope don't call me ma 'am like don't even
- 19:13call me miss like you can call me a real name
- 19:15kit drive me here show me this like go the opposite
- 19:18direction don't take bumps like you know trying
- 19:20to be like flirtatious but also like trying to
- 19:24commandeer the conversation and at no point did
- 19:26i feel like oh yeah this is like an earned love
- 19:29it was just more i can tell that this movie is
- 19:31trying to tell me this is a love interest yes
- 19:33but i don't feel that and honestly i have the
- 19:35same problem with this as i did with bad girl
- 19:37where it kind of comes down to miscommunication
- 19:40and a series of just we didn't talk about this
- 19:42properly yeah where the whole reason that he
- 19:44even has to do this is just well look i mean
- 19:47you did this and it's better for the uh military
- 19:50really if we just pretend that this didn't happen
- 19:53and you just didn't follow orders anything she
- 19:55told you she didn't tell you and then she has
- 19:57to push him away so he doesn't lose his job and
- 20:00so she can continue to live the life she wanted
- 20:02to live and all like the rest of this movie the
- 20:05latter half of this the back half really is just
- 20:08misunderstanding and just miscommunication yeah
- 20:11these two people feel the same way that they
- 20:13did before but they have grown differently And
- 20:16it just felt like we didn't have to do this.
- 20:18This movie didn't have to, or at least this plot
- 20:20point didn't have to exist if we just talked
- 20:22normally to each other. So that was the issue
- 20:24I had with it. But I agree with you. The relationship
- 20:27between Dick Powell and Ruby Keillor, where we've
- 20:29seen that they have chemistry. Yeah, totally.
- 20:31In this does not register. Not at all. And that's
- 20:34such a bummer. And we did it with the Farewell
- 20:38to Arms episode where we kind of really criticized
- 20:41Borzegi's style a lot. I think that even the
- 20:46way that Farewell to Arms was shot was a little
- 20:48more inventive here. I think this relies a lot
- 20:51on location to kind of wow the audience. The
- 20:55luau scene and like the Hawaiian setting at the
- 20:58beginning of the film is really cool to see and
- 21:00really exciting. And then when we move to West
- 21:03Point, that's a location that I'm sure audiences
- 21:05at the time were like, oh, wow, this is cool.
- 21:07I've heard about this and now I'm getting to
- 21:09see it myself. I really do feel like Borzegi,
- 21:15for the amount of times he's appeared on the
- 21:17podcast now, he is a director. I'm really excited
- 21:20for us to talk to him at the end of this episode.
- 21:22I know. He's going to be so bummed that we are
- 21:23just bashing him again. What do you mean you
- 21:26didn't like the romance? But I feel like you
- 21:28can take all of his films and place them in a
- 21:31Venn diagram, and there would be so many overlaps.
- 21:36And not enough variety in everything. And that's
- 21:39what kind of bums me out. Looking back now, I
- 21:42kind of feel like Bad Girl was the most unique
- 21:45of his movies that we've covered so far. Because
- 21:48at least you had the two characters, like, spend
- 21:51the full movie together. They were never really
- 21:53separated. That's true. So, as much as I like
- 21:57Chico and Diane in Seventh Heaven, like, they
- 22:00don't spend the whole movie together. I think
- 22:01their chemistry is probably the best of the Borzaghi
- 22:03films. But yeah, Bad Girl just, I don't know,
- 22:07it's what I want from these types of movies.
- 22:09You know, it's interesting. I feel like, I'm
- 22:11not sure if, how often we're talking about and
- 22:15covering these, I shouldn't say how often, how
- 22:17quickly we are, that's not even the right word
- 22:20either, how close together we're watching these
- 22:22movies. Sure. Right? 42nd Street came out in
- 22:261933, and this came out in 1934. So it's a year
- 22:31apart. But for us, it's only a couple weeks apart
- 22:33that we're watching them. Right. So it's difficult
- 22:36for me not to project some of my thoughts on
- 22:40this movie from what I felt about 42nd Street.
- 22:43And the reason I say that, the things that I
- 22:46like the most about this movie kind of stem from
- 22:4942nd Street. And I don't just mean like the chemistry
- 22:52between, not even chemistry, but the connection
- 22:54between Dick Powell and Ruby Keillor. Like we
- 22:57saw them in 42nd Street together. Again, we talked
- 22:59about on that episode, they've done like six
- 23:01other projects for Warner Brothers alone. Yeah.
- 23:03Moving forward. So we anticipate that's going
- 23:06to happen too. I like them, not so much together
- 23:09in this movie, but I like them. That's 42nd Street.
- 23:13I really like the musical aspects at the end
- 23:15of this movie, like the productions that are
- 23:17put on, even some of the songs, the Mr. and Mrs.
- 23:20song. Mr. and Mrs. is the name. Right. Great.
- 23:24But then that feels, again, derivative of 42nd
- 23:26Street. And the thing that I want to talk about
- 23:28right now, the Hawaii section of when they go
- 23:31to this luau, and they find the natives performing
- 23:34at the luau, and they're singing, which is fine.
- 23:38But then they get to this choreographed bit.
- 23:41where they're doing the Busby Berkeley kaleidoscopic
- 23:46choreography of people in the middle of a circle
- 23:49doing one thing and the outside of the circle
- 23:51doing a similar thing with their legs. But the
- 23:53camera isn't doing the same thing. It's kind
- 23:55of almost at an angle instead of being on top
- 23:57of. Sure. And to me, watching that, I was just
- 24:00like, this just, it doesn't feel like, oh, you
- 24:03know, kind of like that. It just felt so close
- 24:05to it that I was like, look. If you have one
- 24:08of those things, that's fine. But when you have
- 24:10three of these things that are with the two people
- 24:13from that movie, it's difficult for me to feel
- 24:16like it's anything but uninspired in that sense.
- 24:19Yeah. And then the pacing issues happen of like,
- 24:22what do you like most about this? Well, I guess
- 24:24it's that it's Ruby Keeler and Dick Powell are
- 24:26on screen and they're in Hawaii. Well, what if
- 24:28we put them away from each other? We have Ruby
- 24:29Keeler not even on screen for the next 30 minutes
- 24:32and we leave Hawaii. Then am I interested in
- 24:36the movie? I don't think so. Yeah, that's not
- 24:38what I came to see. Exactly. It's a tough beat
- 24:40of a movie. And it's not like it's miserable
- 24:43or I had a horrible time with it. But certainly,
- 24:47it felt like it wasn't interested in what I wanted
- 24:50from the movie. And it wasn't interested in what
- 24:52the audience would want to see. It was just more
- 24:54so, well, this is the story, and if you're not
- 24:55into it, sorry. Yeah, and I think... Early on
- 24:59in the podcast, the movies we were covering,
- 25:02there was a lot of, okay, well, this is the first
- 25:03Western and this sets up a lot of what we're
- 25:05going to see in the future. And this is the first
- 25:07musical. And when we hit Busby Berkeley last
- 25:10year, this is what brought musicals back. Now
- 25:13we're reaching the point where we have what came
- 25:16directly after. So I think if you look at like
- 25:19the high points of certain genres and things,
- 25:23we've reached a point where we have something
- 25:25to compare to. We have the original that we can
- 25:29at least be like, okay, well, this was the first,
- 25:31so there's some praise due there. And then we
- 25:34have what comes, and we know is great, The Singing
- 25:37in the Rain, The American in Paris, those types
- 25:40of films. We're like, okay, well, I know what
- 25:42we evolve into and how great it can be. And then
- 25:46we've got the middle section here. And there's
- 25:49so much that you can compare this movie to with
- 25:51all of the Borzaghi we've covered before. And
- 25:54then with, of course, the Busby Berkeley musicals
- 25:57that have just exploded onto the scene already.
- 26:01And I think all of that is really working against
- 26:04this movie. Like you said, if I sat down in 1934
- 26:08and I was like, there's a Ruby Keeler, Dick Powell
- 26:11musical coming out. I love that last year. Yeah,
- 26:14yeah, totally. And then it really is kind of
- 26:16like a bait and switch. And then like moving
- 26:19on to the actual movie itself, when there's just
- 26:23a whole lot of nothing. A lot of this movie is
- 26:27Canary in his like officer training and kind
- 26:31of in boot camp again. Right. And there's some
- 26:33comedy there for sure. Like when he's trying
- 26:36to stick your neck in. Exactly. When he's marching
- 26:39and he's trying to be like the number one perfect
- 26:43posture guy. It's comical. He looks goofy. He's
- 26:46got like 13 chins because he's sucking it in.
- 26:48The only thing funnier than that is that everyone
- 26:51around him. or at least the majority of people
- 26:53around him, are walking normally. Right. So then
- 26:55the laugh line is that he's doing it. Funny thing
- 26:58to me is if you look at, there's one scene specifically
- 27:00where he's told to tuck his chin in even more,
- 27:03and he's walking with his chin tucked in. There's
- 27:05a guy behind him diagonal who's doing the same
- 27:08thing. Really? And you can see the quadruple
- 27:11chin underneath. He's trying to do it. And I
- 27:13was wondering, the laugh line here is that this
- 27:16guy, to your point, is trying to be the best.
- 27:18Yeah. So he's doing it. But then another guy's
- 27:20like, yeah, me too. I also want to be the best.
- 27:24Let me tell you, I know those guys in the background
- 27:28actor industry. There's always somebody. My guy's
- 27:33mom just died at home, so he wants to be the
- 27:35best, too. So you're Army Sergeant Number Five.
- 27:39Like, chill out. Hey, can we tuck that guy in
- 27:41the back? Yeah, you're doing too much, kid. Yeah,
- 27:44tuck him. Yeah, my chin. No, him. Yes. Tuck him.
- 27:46He's gone. Send him home. I do want to mention
- 27:49one quick thing before we get more into the story.
- 27:51The other thing that really makes me just feel
- 27:52like, God, man, you're just reminding me of a
- 27:55movie that's better than yours, is that you talked
- 27:58about that scene with Dick Powell where he's
- 28:00singing a lot, even to a point where after he
- 28:02gets knocked out by Scrapper, he's in the washroom
- 28:06and he's washing his face after he has a bloody
- 28:09nose. And when he's doing this, he's singing
- 28:11a song. And the song that he's singing is By
- 28:13a Waterfall, which is the same song that he sings.
- 28:17or is also sung at least, in Footlight Parade,
- 28:201933. So we have another reference to a Busby
- 28:24Berkeley production with Dick Powell. And it
- 28:26just, it feels like while it's also, you know,
- 28:29yeah, these are little like, you know, references
- 28:31and little callbacks. It just feels like a reminder
- 28:34where I'm like, I kind of want to watch that.
- 28:36Like the whole movie is like the studio selling
- 28:39tickets. Yes. In whatever way we'll put butts
- 28:43in seats. Correct. And man. I think this movie
- 28:47is where I feel it the most so far in the podcast.
- 28:50Yeah, no, I agree. And it sucks because I think
- 28:53it's much more fun to talk about movies like
- 28:57this where the movie is just inherently bad.
- 28:59Right. And this isn't like, you know, a terrible
- 29:02movie. It's just, it gets so much of it wrong
- 29:05and misreads what you would want from it that,
- 29:09and especially, you know, here's the other spoiler
- 29:11too. The movie we'll talk about next. is really
- 29:14the movie to talk about for this year, and we'll
- 29:16get there. And that's not to say, hey, you're
- 29:19not this movie, so you're not good, but you kind
- 29:21of expect, you at least hope the quality matches
- 29:24something like that. And this was just a misread
- 29:26on my part. Not my part, but on my end, I just
- 29:29felt like this was a complete, not a complete
- 29:32misfire, but majority was a misfire for me. Yeah.
- 29:36Let's talk about some of the good things in it.
- 29:38Sure. Right? So a highlight for me, one, Anytime
- 29:42Ruby Keeler and Dick Powell are on screen together,
- 29:45I'm in it. I'll tell you, I like Dick Powell
- 29:47a lot in this. I thought he was... In the beginning,
- 29:51he had so much character, and I really liked
- 29:53him a lot. I thought as he got a little bit more
- 29:57stiff upper lip in the army, I was less interested
- 30:01in his character. He gets a little misogynist.
- 30:04A bit. Misogynistic. To a point where when he
- 30:07sees Ruby Keeler, it doesn't come across as like...
- 30:10well, you harmed me and now I'm going to protect
- 30:12myself. It's just more like, I expect you to
- 30:15be on time like all the other men. Yes. Yeah.
- 30:17Yeah, there is a lot of misogyny. It doesn't
- 30:19feel playful. No. It feels like he resents her.
- 30:22Yeah. It's kind of gross. I don't like it. And
- 30:24she's really, wow. Well, that can't be true because
- 30:27of the musical number. But I mean, I don't know
- 30:29if many other women speak in this. There's a
- 30:31little girl at the end who's like, that guy's
- 30:32crying. But like, that's kind of it. Right. So.
- 30:36That's not to say that he's like that towards
- 30:38all women, but certainly Ruby Keillor, who is
- 30:40one of the only women who speak in this movie,
- 30:42he's that way towards her, so it's hard not to
- 30:44kind of see it that way. I agree with you. Totally.
- 30:47Another highlight of the movie for me is Pat
- 30:49O 'Brien's character, Scrapper. Oh, I love Pat
- 30:52O 'Brien. And I even think that this is a reoccurring
- 30:55thing in Borzaghi's movie. You have the rat in
- 30:58Seventh Heaven. You have... Say it. What's that?
- 31:01I'm waiting for you to say his name. Well, in
- 31:03Bad Girl, you have the... The roommate. Isn't
- 31:06it Runkles? No. No, the woman who's always giving,
- 31:11what's his name, a hard time. He's like, get
- 31:13out of my house. Yes. I love her specifically.
- 31:16I wish I remembered who that was. But then you
- 31:19have Adolph Manjoo in A Farewell to Arms. Baby.
- 31:22Baby. So, like, that's a reoccurring thing. You
- 31:25have this almost like sidekick character. Yeah.
- 31:27Who provides quite a bit of not only comedy,
- 31:31but like. a shoulder to lean on for our lead
- 31:35in, I'm going to say it again, almost a way that
- 31:38can be construed as minorly romantic. Right.
- 31:42And that might be, like, shifting this, like,
- 31:44you can have healthy male relationships without
- 31:46them immediately turning into, like, a queer
- 31:49relationship. But there are some moments in here
- 31:53that I think play out very similar to Farewell
- 31:55to Arms. Yeah, I mean, I'll be real with you,
- 31:58man. Like, I think... If you do one or the other,
- 32:01it's like, sure, maybe you mean more like a fatherly,
- 32:03like, you know, he wants the best for you. But
- 32:05when you do it in A Farewell to Arms and you
- 32:07do it in this, I think it's clearly romantic.
- 32:10Right. Because Scrapper, even more so than Ruby
- 32:12Keeler in this, is like, I just want the best
- 32:15for you, man. Yes. Like, I know you're capable
- 32:17of it. I just really want to see you come into
- 32:19your own. And he leaves. Like, he's like, I have
- 32:21to go. I can't be here anymore. And I really
- 32:24just want to see the best from you. And he leaves.
- 32:26To a point when he goes to West Point, to me
- 32:30it doesn't feel like, I gotta make sure that
- 32:32I make her proud. It feels like Scrapper's words
- 32:35really got to me, and I think I gotta be the
- 32:37best version of myself. And oh look, Ruby Keeler
- 32:39is back. I 100 % agree with you. Scrapper has
- 32:43my favorite line in the movie when he's getting
- 32:44on the boat to leave. He says, someday I'm gonna
- 32:47salute you and like it. Yeah. And that just feels
- 32:51like... Which is super inspiring. The final moment
- 32:53makes that feel a little bit more. But again,
- 32:55to your point, when the final moment of your
- 32:57movie, and I guess minor spoilers here, but when
- 33:00the final moment of your movie is more of a callback
- 33:03to Scrapper and Canary than it is for Kit and
- 33:08Canary, whose romance are we talking about? She
- 33:11cuts out of this movie so early for what it is,
- 33:15for this romance musical. Yeah. So I'm with you
- 33:18on that. I think Pat O 'Brien is like a major
- 33:22highlight of this movie. Yeah. And a huge selling
- 33:25point. Like, oh, you showed up for Ruby and Dick?
- 33:28Let me give you a little pat on the side to hold
- 33:31you over. Yeah, no, I think that's way more interesting.
- 33:35And maybe there's like a side thing that's being
- 33:37told there, but clearly they wrap it up a little
- 33:40more concretely than that, concretely than that.
- 33:43Yeah. With like the musical number and him being
- 33:45like, I love you. Yeah. And the movie there.
- 33:49I think, you know, if you're going for your romance,
- 33:52I don't know. We'll talk about the ending like
- 33:54in detail here in a second. Good, because I have
- 33:56some things to say. Yeah. I do think that the
- 33:59movie really starts to cook as we get to like
- 34:03the musical element of it. Which, at what point
- 34:06are you counting that? Are you saying like that's
- 34:09when the Aloha Oi happens or are you thinking
- 34:12more at the end? Well, yeah, I love that. The
- 34:15intro of it is great and I'm excited for something
- 34:18that, ultimately doesn't happen right so then
- 34:20when we get to the the musical performance at
- 34:22the end of the movie which i want to talk about
- 34:25a little bit does happen in the last 15 maybe
- 34:2720 minutes yeah but not only that other than
- 34:31ernst lubitsch musicals which are very different
- 34:33than than everything else we've covered as far
- 34:35as musicals go right every musical that we have
- 34:38covered on the show is a movie about how we're
- 34:43making a musical yes Like it's the Broadway or
- 34:47like the movie making side. Yes. Exactly. And
- 34:49when we covered 42nd Street, I read the term
- 34:53backstage musical where, you know, you're seeing
- 34:57the making of and the inner workings of everything
- 34:59going on behind the scenes. Right. And that's
- 35:01every musical. We did it with the Broadway melody.
- 35:04We did it with 42nd Street. We didn't cover Gold
- 35:07Diggers, but that also is the same exact thing.
- 35:10Right. And then we have it here, too. And this
- 35:13is less Broadway. And, of course, it's. put on
- 35:15by the military and the officers of West Point.
- 35:18But again, the movie hinges on this narrative
- 35:20of we're going to make a musical. When do we
- 35:23get to a musical that is just a musical? We will
- 35:27get there. Obviously, we know like the end destination,
- 35:30or not end destination, but like the highlight
- 35:32destination of where we're going with musicals.
- 35:35And we'll get there soon -ish. But yeah, that's
- 35:41not it right now. It's just so interesting to
- 35:43me. But see, that's why to me, with 42nd Street,
- 35:46when they're doing the backstage musicals, we're
- 35:48still finding our footing. And I kind of get
- 35:51that. But again, I intentionally didn't read
- 35:54the synopsis of this. And I'm trying not to do
- 35:56that moving forward with any movie. Totally.
- 35:58Because I feel like sometimes they just tell
- 36:00me the end of it. And I feel like I'm going to
- 36:03guess that I know the synopsis of this. And it
- 36:05does the same thing where it's like, well, it's
- 36:07a musical set in Hawaii. No, no. Don't you lie
- 36:10to me. Hardly a musical. And certainly the musical
- 36:13aspect is not set within Hawaii. Right. Right.
- 36:15It's set within Washington, D .C. And even then,
- 36:18it's the last like 15 minutes of this movie.
- 36:20And I know what you're probably saying at home.
- 36:22Ryan, that's 42nd Street. 42nd Street only has
- 36:26the musical numbers at the end of it. Sure. But
- 36:29we see rehearsals and the dance numbers and everything
- 36:31leading up to that point. To where the backstage
- 36:34element does lead to that musical. This just
- 36:38feels like we've tacked it on to the end. And,
- 36:40yeah, sure, Canary likes to sing and everything.
- 36:43But that doesn't mean that he's writing productions
- 36:45for people like this all the time. Right. And
- 36:48then we just hear about this 100th night thing
- 36:49all of a sudden. Yeah. And it just feels like,
- 36:51you know what? Why don't we make it a musical?
- 36:54And it's like, you had that chance with Aloha
- 36:56Oi, which was great. I agree with you. Yeah.
- 36:59Especially Dick Powell when they just let him
- 37:00loose. But up until then, it's just. Okay, cool.
- 37:04Yeah. We're just going to do it now, I guess.
- 37:06And it feels like an afterthought. I'm not saying
- 37:09it was, but the movie, as a result, feels like
- 37:14they just decided, what if we just do a musical
- 37:16now? Yes. To a point, and this is true. I don't
- 37:20just lie on here. But the ensemble director,
- 37:22Bobby Connolly, he shot the Hawaiian number,
- 37:27the Ala 'o 'oi that you're talking about, on
- 37:29the largest set constructed at Warner Brothers
- 37:31at the time. Okay. Do you want to know when they
- 37:34broke this record? When? A couple days later
- 37:37with the same movie. The military wedding number
- 37:40that's filmed in, well, it takes place in D .C.
- 37:43at the end of the movie. That had 400 professional
- 37:46dancers. Wow. So that was the largest set at
- 37:50the time. But it was only broken just days after
- 37:54when they did the largest set at the time for
- 37:57the Hawaiian number. Just constantly sweeping
- 37:58this movie under the rug. When the behind the
- 38:04scenes is more interesting than your on screen,
- 38:06there's something to be said about this. But
- 38:08interesting for two days. Yes, exactly. When
- 38:11he's like, we broke the record. And they're like,
- 38:13wow, that's amazing. Do it again. Okay. Yeah.
- 38:16But I mean, it's funny because when you go back
- 38:18and watch the Aloha Oe number, it doesn't look
- 38:22like it should be the largest production. Now,
- 38:24the backdrop does because it looks like you're
- 38:27supposed to sell that this was like on the beach,
- 38:29right? But then when you talk about just the
- 38:32number of people involved in that military wedding
- 38:34number, I mean, of course, 400 professional dancers.
- 38:37And that doesn't count like, you know, your Ruby
- 38:39Keeler, your Dick Powell, like your actors. That
- 38:42is the professional dancers. So that makes sense.
- 38:45But I can't say that I was blown away by either
- 38:47of these. I thought the Aloha Oe number, again,
- 38:50was fun. And I really liked the backdrop of this.
- 38:53But then the parts that should have stood out
- 38:55to me were just more like, yeah, you're... I
- 38:57just saw this in 42nd street where you're kind
- 38:59of doing with, with the Busby Berkeley specific
- 39:01style of choreography. Yes. Not just choreography.
- 39:05Cause he doesn't hold own real estate in that,
- 39:07but that specific style is very much him. Yeah.
- 39:10I mean, we talk about it now, like he's synonymous
- 39:12with that style. Correct. So it just so much
- 39:16of it felt kind of off to me, but you can't talk
- 39:20about something like this and not talk about
- 39:22like the, the features or not features, but the,
- 39:24The musical numbers? The musical numbers and
- 39:27also just what they achieved with this, right?
- 39:29And I'm not talking so much about the success,
- 39:31but just more so the size of when you try to
- 39:34make a number like this. Sure. So it shows that
- 39:37intentionality, but that's disconnected from
- 39:39the narrative for me. Right, right. It kind of
- 39:43becomes another advertising point of, you know,
- 39:46the largest number of performers on screen at
- 39:49one time. Yep. Come see it. The Hawaiian musical.
- 39:53Yes. It's not really either of those things.
- 39:56Marketing things. Exactly. Is what it is. Yeah.
- 39:58So I want to ask you, too, the other musicals
- 40:02we've covered, they're about musicals themselves
- 40:04and the making of musicals. But the other ones
- 40:07we've done have been Broadway musicals. Sure.
- 40:09Whereas this one is the military putting on a
- 40:12musical. Yeah. Now, how do you feel about movies
- 40:15that kind of follow this? Well, if you were asking
- 40:19me to put my foot in my mouth. I will gladly
- 40:21do so. Because I have told you, and I don't remember
- 40:24if it was on pod, but certainly off pod, I really
- 40:28like White Christmas. Okay. I'm a big White Christmas
- 40:31guy. I watch it every year around the holidays.
- 40:34So if you're asking me how I feel about the military
- 40:36putting on a musical number, pro. Okay. I'm a
- 40:39pro for that. So it's not even that. And it's
- 40:43not like, what's the military doing putting on
- 40:44a musical? But Dick Powell specifically being
- 40:47like, yeah, I write it. It just it feels so disconnected
- 40:50from the rest of it. Was the question how I feel
- 40:53about the military put on a musical or was there
- 40:54more to that? No, I think in the 40s, we're going
- 40:58to be covering more like military themed musicals.
- 41:01Sure. And I don't know this for a fact, but I'm
- 41:03sure somewhere in there we'll cover one that
- 41:06the story isn't, hey, the military is putting
- 41:09on a musical. It is a musical about the military.
- 41:13Sure. And I think that's kind of what I want
- 41:15more. Yes. Otherwise. There is a part of me that's
- 41:19like, guys, we're about to go to World War II.
- 41:22Like, this seems a little silly to me. And I
- 41:25don't know. Well, it's not like they know at
- 41:27the time, right? I don't know, man. I mean, Hitler's
- 41:30out there. I mean, that's true. He loves cavalcade.
- 41:34He does. That's true. But at the same time, like...
- 41:39Movies back then didn't have to exist as like,
- 41:42what's the word I'm looking for? A showcase of
- 41:43what's actually happening out there. We can disconnect
- 41:46it from reality in that sense. Now, don't get
- 41:49me wrong. I don't think they should be name dropping
- 41:50Hitler in this and being like, yeah, we're going
- 41:52off to war soon. Anyways, here's a number about
- 41:54girls. Sure. Like, certainly. But I think you
- 41:57can be disconnected from that reality, especially
- 41:59back then, because they weren't making like movies
- 42:01that were specifically, you know, they weren't
- 42:03all quite in the Western front or even a little
- 42:05bit of cavalcade. I've tried to be commentary
- 42:08on that. So I think you can be disconnected from
- 42:11that, but certainly, don't get me wrong, if Flirtation
- 42:15Walk came out in 1937, we have some questions.
- 42:18Yeah, it's a little different. It's a little
- 42:20different, yeah. Of like, hey, isn't the military
- 42:21great? It's a little different. And this might
- 42:24be me, like, showing... like a political opinion
- 42:28that maybe I shouldn't be revealing, you know,
- 42:30but I, I did think like the plot was a little
- 42:33silly. Oh, certainly. I'll give you that. Like,
- 42:36but the music, like the military doing the musical
- 42:38part of the plot. Yeah. That's silly. Oh, definitely.
- 42:42Yeah. Okay. Yeah. No, a hundred percent. Like,
- 42:43but that's what they did. Like, you know, even
- 42:46you go up to like the, the Bing Crosby segment,
- 42:49the whole movie is a segment, but the Bing Crosby
- 42:51in within a white Christmas of them putting on
- 42:55productions just to kind of pass the time. Like
- 42:57this is something they've been doing for a while.
- 42:59So I, I get that, that it happens and I'll allow
- 43:03it to be a little silly. I feel like a parent
- 43:06of, of like some school drama department. I'm
- 43:10just like, You guys are covering that? This is
- 43:12outright, like, I don't know. I feel, maybe I
- 43:15shouldn't have said anything. No, that's fine.
- 43:16It's just kind of silly to me. You know what?
- 43:18I think I hear what you're saying, and I want
- 43:19to make sure that I repeat it back properly,
- 43:22so let me know if I'm wrong. You're saying that
- 43:24there was too much singing in this military academy
- 43:27and not enough swine time. Is that right? The
- 43:29return of swine time. That's what you're trying
- 43:31to get at. Maybe. More swine time. Yeah. In every
- 43:35movie, really. Are you okay with the fact that
- 43:37we're really not going to get back into swine
- 43:38time until, like, night? 1990 whatever with babe
- 43:41you don't know that do i not know that i don't
- 43:45i thought we talked about that there might well
- 43:46that was my reference point there might be a
- 43:48movie that comes out next year where there's
- 43:50like a whole pig movie a whole pig movie yeah
- 43:54well now you're talking now we're back in hawaii
- 43:56can you i was about to say how did we have like
- 43:58a whole movie well not a whole movie half a movie
- 44:00in hawaii hello but uh how do we have half a
- 44:03movie how do we have half okay no i'm going back
- 44:07to that i love the idea of you doing like um
- 44:10a groucho marx like a hawaiian groucho marx is
- 44:12like aloha that's a good idea i'm gonna write
- 44:16that one down hello well aloha the podcast is
- 44:19gonna have all these side hustles dude i'm telling
- 44:21you i'm selling we got shoes yeah we got uh swine
- 44:24time kit fits shoes man we should open a barbecue
- 44:28restaurant called swine time And all of the posters
- 44:32are like, well, hang with me here, are all like
- 44:351930s, 40s, and 50s musicals, but we put pigs
- 44:38in it. Oh, okay. Right? So Swing Time is Swine
- 44:42Time. Yeah. Singing in the Rain is Singing in
- 44:44the Mud, of course. Right? That's pretty good.
- 44:47Pretty good. That's pretty good. White Christmas.
- 44:50Blue Boy. Sure. And then just State Fair. Yeah.
- 44:56That's the big one. But the remake. Okay. Because
- 44:59it's a musical. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The original
- 45:01wasn't. I'm down with this. Here's the problem.
- 45:03I'll write it down. We forget that we record
- 45:05this and put it into the world. Right. We need
- 45:08to copyright this. That's true. Because then
- 45:10someone else is going to make Swine Time as a
- 45:12barbecue restaurant themed for movie posters.
- 45:15I'll cut this. I think we've cut this whole episode
- 45:19now. We're just giving too many good ideas. Restart
- 45:20it. A couple things I want to point out. The
- 45:24majority of this cast did reunite with Borzegi.
- 45:27Of course they did. Right? Why not? But here's
- 45:30the thing that's even more interesting. Do you
- 45:32know this? Okay, you don't. Maybe you do. You
- 45:35don't. Do you? Because of the audience? So they
- 45:38reunited with Borzegi and the majority of the
- 45:39cast. Not only did they reunite, they reunited
- 45:43to make a similar film. And I know what you're
- 45:45going to say. Sure, Ryan. They made a musical,
- 45:48right? Not just a musical, a military -based
- 45:51musical called Shipmates Forever. My favorite.
- 45:54In 1935 about the U .S. Naval Academy. So they
- 45:58kind of did this again. And I'm not completely
- 46:01sure on the narrative, like the story aspect,
- 46:03but it was a musical based within the U .S. Naval,
- 46:06or, well, the Naval Academy. So even this feels
- 46:10kind of like, this is a derivative, but like
- 46:13Shipmates Forever, they just do this again. Yeah.
- 46:16So something about it just feels like, I don't
- 46:18know, man, I need you to do something a little
- 46:20different. I really think that I have just grown
- 46:24less attached to Borzegi over time. Which is
- 46:27unfortunate because, you know, Seventh Heaven,
- 46:29actually, that was the first episode we made.
- 46:32That was, yeah. To cover a movie, that is. We
- 46:34did episode zero. Sure, yeah. But that's the
- 46:36first movie we covered. Exactly. And that's what's
- 46:39so... And again, I love seeing the evolution
- 46:42of these directors or lack thereof. And I think
- 46:45that's what a lot of Borzegi is. I feel like
- 46:48he sees a lot of what is popular at the time
- 46:51and almost pulls from that, but just plugs in
- 46:54his formula. But it doesn't feel earned and it
- 46:57doesn't feel true to the story. Right. But it's
- 47:00wild because he keeps showing up here. You know,
- 47:02he's making movies that are nominated for Best
- 47:04Picture. It's working. And I think that there
- 47:06is a connection to. box office totals and Academy
- 47:11Awards in a way that isn't necessarily true today.
- 47:15Yes. So that's kind of an interesting take and
- 47:19look at these movies historically. But yeah,
- 47:22I mean, before we start to wrap up, let's talk
- 47:27about the music itself here. Sure. That is the
- 47:29highlight of the movie, I think. We've talked
- 47:32a lot about Aloah Hoy, and it is solid. We both
- 47:36like it. Beyond that, we have two big numbers
- 47:40towards the end of the movie. We have the very
- 47:43fun but weird no horse, no wife, no mustache.
- 47:48So weird. Yeah. Ruby Keeler kind of leads this
- 47:51one, which I was grateful for because we'd gone
- 47:53the entire movie without really getting Ruby
- 47:56Keeler singing. Yes. And that bummed me out quite
- 47:59a bit. Yeah. Thanks for the bait and switch.
- 48:01No dancing either. No. The dancing is very lackluster.
- 48:05Kind of. The highlight of the musical numbers
- 48:09here is the chorus line, both with the singing
- 48:12and the dancing. Right. Our two stars don't get
- 48:15a whole lot to do, and certainly Dick Powell
- 48:18has way more than Ruby Keeler, and that just
- 48:21bummed me out overall. After that, we have, we
- 48:24mentioned before, Mr. and Mrs. is the name, and
- 48:27it's a very cute song. It is. Them walking down
- 48:29the aisle. Yes, but again, this is mostly performed
- 48:32by the chorus line. And without now the Busby
- 48:36Berkeley choreography, without the snappy lyrics
- 48:39that we had from 42nd Street, and the fact that,
- 48:43like, our stars aren't really the ones performing
- 48:46here. The music's just mostly going on around
- 48:49them. I like the music. It's fun. And it's very
- 48:52refreshing after this whole kind of lackluster
- 48:55movie. But even here, I'm like, well, this isn't
- 48:58what I was promised. No. It's weird because we
- 49:01know they're both capable. Yes. Right. We've
- 49:03seen it in multiple films that Dick Powell and
- 49:05Ruby Keillor can hold their own. So why aren't
- 49:07we letting them? And the only thing I can think
- 49:09of is that, well, hey, their character wouldn't
- 49:10do that. Yeah, that's a problem when you hire
- 49:13these two people and like you don't have their
- 49:14characters be capable of having this kind of
- 49:16performance. And then that, of course, leads
- 49:18to the third one, which is the aptly named flirtation
- 49:21walk. Yeah. Yeah. And I don't know. That's probably
- 49:25the least memorable one. For me, honestly. Yeah,
- 49:28you're probably right. I mean, I know they say
- 49:30flirtation walk, but I forget the name of it.
- 49:33Or not name of it, but the melody of it. Yes.
- 49:35I do want to go back to no wife, no horse, no
- 49:39mustache. Right. I thought this was very funny,
- 49:42and I felt like I was laughing more at it than
- 49:44with it. But you said that Ruby Keillor leads
- 49:48it, and that's mostly true. But there are a chorus
- 49:51of men standing around her in an office when
- 49:54she's like, tell me about what it's like to be
- 49:56in the military. And they're like, well, we have
- 49:57no wife, no horse, no mustache. And then three
- 50:00minutes later, it cuts to all three of them in
- 50:03a room being like, no mustache. Yes. Over and
- 50:07over. And I was like, this is hilarious. And
- 50:09I feel like I'm on an acid trip, but I'm completely
- 50:12sober. I did think that was funny, but again,
- 50:17it wasn't like, this is a great movie. It was
- 50:19more like, what are we doing? What is this? You
- 50:22know, and to wrap up the movie too, the huge
- 50:26bit of conflict here is once Canary starts to
- 50:28fall back in love and want to profess this love
- 50:31or confess this love to Kit, she's already gotten
- 50:35over him. She's moved on and she's engaged to
- 50:37another man. And like they have their little
- 50:40spat together where they're arguing about it.
- 50:43And then two minutes later, the man she's engaged
- 50:47to shows up and is like, hey, I've got news for
- 50:50you. We're not engaged anymore. Well, I'll do
- 50:54you one better. I'll extend on that just a little
- 50:56bit. He, he, who is it? Canary finds out that
- 51:00Kit is just going to move forward with the engagement.
- 51:03Right. Right. And he comes to her house begging,
- 51:06like, you can't let this happen. Like, we got
- 51:07to be together. To a point where when he is found
- 51:11out, he's found out by her fiance. He's like,
- 51:14you're lucky that it was me who found out, not
- 51:15the lieutenant. Because he would have just completely,
- 51:17like, you know, demolished you. So instead, resign.
- 51:21And if you resign, we'll just forget this whole
- 51:23thing happened. He's like, fine, I'll resign.
- 51:25And he tries to resign. And when he sends in
- 51:28his resignation, maybe 90 seconds later, maybe
- 51:31two minutes. the fiance comes back he's like
- 51:34so we don't accept a resignation and also uh
- 51:37she called it off and we're not engaged and you
- 51:40have my blessing shake my hand and he's like
- 51:41smiling yeah he's like i think you guys are gonna
- 51:44i think your kids are gonna be okay it is the
- 51:47smallest conflict in this movie possible and
- 51:50i think there's one other movie that we'll talk
- 51:52about this year and we'll get there that has
- 51:55the same problem for me where at the very end
- 51:57it feels so rushed when you want that like reunited
- 52:02scene you want the scene of them reunited and
- 52:04like finally we can be together and this is me
- 52:07professing my love for you and us getting to
- 52:08share that love together and it happens off screen
- 52:11and in the last 90 seconds of the movie right
- 52:14and it just feels kind of like and we're done
- 52:16you're like yeah but i want to see you guys embrace
- 52:19and like finally we get the climax of like you
- 52:22getting to be together and not just we here Yeah.
- 52:25It's the equivalent of the director, like the
- 52:27curtain comes down and he walks out and he's
- 52:29like, by the way, happily ever after. You're
- 52:31like, all right, would have liked to have seen
- 52:33that, but sure. This all takes place after the
- 52:36musical, right? Yes. So that's crazy. The last
- 52:39time you see Ruby Keeler is when they're arguing
- 52:41and he's professing his love or whatever. Correct.
- 52:43And then he hears that they get to be together
- 52:45and then she is just present at his graduation.
- 52:48Yes. But not on screen with him. Exactly. They
- 52:51don't have a final moment together. They don't.
- 52:53It's so crazy. And it's the same issue that I
- 52:55have with another movie that we'll talk about.
- 52:57It is wild. It's crazy. Only other thing I want
- 53:01to mention about this is Taylor walked in on
- 53:03the last 10, 15 minutes of this movie. And she
- 53:06was asking me about it. And I told her a fun
- 53:08little detail. And I was like, you like The Wedding
- 53:11Planner, right? With Matthew McConaughey and
- 53:12Jennifer Lopez. She was like, I love that movie.
- 53:14And I was like, this appears at the end of it.
- 53:17Oh. So Flirtation Walk, I almost call it The
- 53:19Footlight Parade. wishful thinking uh flirtation
- 53:23walk appears at the end of the wedding planner
- 53:25um there's a movie that they go see in the park
- 53:27at the end and the movie they're playing is flirtation
- 53:29walk um warner brothers did um i'll call the
- 53:33monster in law wedding planner uh as well so
- 53:36this makes sense cool but clearly time has remembered
- 53:39this kind of this movie sure and it's interesting
- 53:41how this has kind of survived over time you know
- 53:45of all the movie musicals for them to play uh
- 53:48in something like this uh in again 2001 crazy
- 53:52they picked flirtation walk maybe that was a
- 53:54favorite of someone who made it sure and it really
- 53:57boils down to the first borzaghi we ever saw
- 54:00was seventh heaven yep could you show somebody
- 54:02any one of the movies we've covered of his on
- 54:05the podcast as their first borzaghi and they'd
- 54:07be like okay that's my favorite because they
- 54:09all follow the same plot is it just a matter
- 54:12of which one you saw first i think it has to
- 54:15be Yeah. So I'm really curious. Maybe someone
- 54:17saw Flirtation Walk as their first Borzegin.
- 54:19They were like, wow, what a great story. Well,
- 54:21you know, and it could also just be like, you
- 54:23know, you're really involved in the military
- 54:25or you came from a military background family.
- 54:27Yeah, I guess it has that element. Military family
- 54:29background is what I mean to say. Maybe there's
- 54:31aspects like that where it's more catered to
- 54:33you specifically. But for me, it's just it was
- 54:35a misfire. It's just something we've seen before.
- 54:38Yeah. In so many different elements. And that
- 54:42is why I gave this film. Two stars. I did the
- 54:45same thing. Yeah. Two stars. I feel like if something
- 54:48is lower than two stars for me, this is like
- 54:50a how dare you type situation. Right. And right
- 54:53now, this isn't so much of a how dare you. It's
- 54:56just more like a come on, man. Like, I know that
- 54:59you're better than this. Like, I really do like
- 55:01Seventh Heaven a good bit. Bad Girl, I was a
- 55:04little baffled by a little bit, but still, like,
- 55:06fine. Nothing wrong with it. And then Farewell
- 55:09to Arms just felt like a complete misread of
- 55:11the source material to a point where Ernest Hemingway
- 55:13is, like, disavowing it. I mean, I told you what
- 55:16he called it. Like, that is the clear, like,
- 55:19a clear, like, shame that he has of, like, this
- 55:22movie. He's just denouncing it completely. So,
- 55:25it's a bad beat. to follow up something like
- 55:29that where it was a complete misread of the source
- 55:31material of like well this feels like 42nd street
- 55:34and not in a fun way it feels like you just kind
- 55:36of like well let's put this in there yeah and
- 55:38maybe even warner brothers is like hey we need
- 55:40something else like that and look what we did
- 55:42with them so why don't you do something similar
- 55:43because that kaleidoscopic choreography that
- 55:46we talked about in the hawaii number isn't present
- 55:49there's not really even like a dancing number
- 55:51later on it's just more there are people kind
- 55:53of staged around and singing uh than it is like
- 55:57them dancing and you know having choreography
- 55:58yeah so it just feels like even though they're
- 56:00building the largest sets it just feels uninspired
- 56:03totally i i think that this movie suffers a lot
- 56:06of 90 something years later we're watching it
- 56:11yep of us watching this many films back to back
- 56:14to back that are similar or Like an evolution
- 56:17of its director or some of its parts, really.
- 56:21So there's a lot working against it. And I can
- 56:23see why this was so popular and successful during
- 56:26its time. Because they're capitalizing on multiple
- 56:30different things here. Its director, its cast,
- 56:32its style, the musical element. And it's just
- 56:35not working 90 -something years later. It's not.
- 56:37And it didn't work for me. Me neither. How about
- 56:41your double feature? I was really happy with
- 56:43my double feature. And it's right down the line.
- 56:45This is not like, oh, how'd you get that one?
- 56:47I went with something that I did not know was
- 56:50directed by this man. And I'm interested if you
- 56:52know who directed. I went with a 1961 Blue Hawaii,
- 56:56Elvis Presley. I went with a musical set within
- 57:00Hawaii. What I wanted from something like Flirtation
- 57:04Walk, I went with what I thought I would have
- 57:07gotten. And that's more like a blue Hawaii type
- 57:09film. Do you know who directed it? I do. I was
- 57:13wondering, did you know before you just looked
- 57:15it up? No, I had to look it up. So it is directed
- 57:16by Norman Torog, who faithful listeners will
- 57:20remember was the director of Skippy. And I can
- 57:26only hope that Elvis didn't have a peanut butter
- 57:28sandwich he was very fond of and let Norman Torog
- 57:31know about it. Please don't shoot my peanut butter
- 57:33sandwich. I was going to say, please don't eat
- 57:36my peanut butter sandwich, but sure, yeah. He's
- 57:39just holding a gun to a sandwich. If you don't
- 57:42sing a whole lot of love right now. That's brutal.
- 57:46Yeah, that's crazy. Yeah, Blue Hawaii. And I
- 57:49have a really great story about Elvis Presley
- 57:52and Blue Christmas that I will tell anyone off
- 57:55pod because it is one of the funniest lore stories
- 57:58for me, and I'll tell you off pod, too. But I
- 58:00feel like if I tell you on pod, then that's the
- 58:01episode, and I don't want to do that, too. That
- 58:04is more interesting than Flirtation Walk, but
- 58:06I'm not going to do it to Flirtation Walk. Okay.
- 58:07Fair play. Blue Hawaii is my pick. I've never
- 58:10seen an Elvis movie. Did you see the Austin Butler
- 58:14movie, Elvis? Yes. I should say I've never seen
- 58:16a movie with Elvis. I don't mean to make you
- 58:18a liar on your podcast. Fair play. Fair play.
- 58:20Not an Elvis guy, personally. Really? Yeah. Not
- 58:23a big fan. Like, movie -wise, song -wise, across
- 58:25the board? He has some songs that I like, but
- 58:28typically I don't like his versions of those
- 58:30songs. You don't have a hunk -a -hunk -a -burnin'
- 58:32love for him? No. Can't say I do. It would be
- 58:35really funny if you didn't even understand that.
- 58:36You're like, what is that? That's, uh... In Pulp
- 58:40Fiction, John Travolta has the thing where he's
- 58:42like, you're either a Beatles man or you're an
- 58:44Elvis man. And I've kept that with me, and I'm
- 58:47definitely a Beatles man. That's so funny. I
- 58:49feel like I would go a different... Beatles are,
- 58:51like, maybe, like... stones or something like
- 58:55that i don't know anyways yeah point is uh good
- 58:58to know i i won't i'm so sorry for recommending
- 59:00all this movie i won't do that i mean i'll i
- 59:02see how upset you are i won't do it throw my
- 59:05book on the ground uh so you obviously didn't
- 59:08pick an elvis movie uh what did you do so again
- 59:11not my best choice i could not get this movie
- 59:14out of my head while i was watching flirtation
- 59:16walk though i don't know if the themes are there
- 59:19other than person is in some type of boot camp
- 59:23and kind of makes a fool of themselves for a
- 59:26little while until they take themselves seriously.
- 59:28And that is the Hilary Duff film, Cadet Kelly.
- 59:33Oh boy, Taylor's going to be so happy that you
- 59:36paired this with Cadet Kelly. This is an inspired
- 59:38pick. Yeah, you know. Well, I mean, look, the
- 59:41idea of her coming in and almost being a joke
- 59:43and then how she leaves. Yeah. I mean. If you
- 59:46want to talk about a scrapper to a canary, you
- 59:48got to talk about Christy Carlson Romano in this
- 59:50movie. Man. Did you see Cadet Kelly? Yeah. Okay.
- 59:53Wonderful. It was a long time ago. Okay. Yeah.
- 59:54I'm just making sure. I didn't want to be like
- 59:56talking game about it. You're like, oh, I've
- 59:58never seen it. No. Well, have you seen Christy
- 1:00:00Carlson Romano lately? I haven't run into her.
- 1:00:03I got to tell you, we're not in the same circles.
- 1:00:05Bummer. No, I've seen her like on TikTok. Oh,
- 1:00:08sure. Sometimes. Yeah. I'm just like, you have
- 1:00:10not aged today. What is going on? Yeah. You know
- 1:00:12what that is? It's not even Stevens. No. That
- 1:00:15is unfair, Claire's. Yes, it is. Sorry, Shia.
- 1:00:21But yeah, Cadet Kelly, you know, I couldn't get
- 1:00:25it out of my brain. Yeah. And that's my pick.
- 1:00:27That inspired pick. Honestly, I'm mad I didn't
- 1:00:30do something cooler like that. Well, you did
- 1:00:31Elvis, you know. Yeah, but more true to me would
- 1:00:36be a Disney, a DCOM, Disney Channel original
- 1:00:38movie than, you know what we should do? We should
- 1:00:41do double features and then a silly one. It's
- 1:00:44called The Silly One, and it has to be a DCOM.
- 1:00:47Yeah. And we have to find a DCOM that best fits
- 1:00:49that. Oh, boy. Yeah, that's tough. That's going
- 1:00:51to be a tough one. We'll save it for the next
- 1:00:52one. Hey, I do want to shout out. We have these
- 1:00:54double features listed over on our Letterboxd
- 1:00:56page. Sure do. So if you're interested in seeing
- 1:00:58those and really looking for something to double
- 1:01:02feature these movies with while you're watching
- 1:01:03along with us, you can head over to our Letterboxd.
- 1:01:06It is O -U -T -A -O Podcast. We don't have a
- 1:01:09ton of followers there, and I don't know if I
- 1:01:11promoted enough for people to really... engage
- 1:01:14with it we'll share more on the instagram yeah
- 1:01:16totally but if you have thoughts about flirtation
- 1:01:19walk you can shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 1:01:22at gmail .com we will read those responses on
- 1:01:26the show and if you want to support the show
- 1:01:29financially you can check out patreon .com slash
- 1:01:32O -U -T -A -O podcast. All of this information
- 1:01:34is in the show notes as well. So if you don't
- 1:01:37want to remember all of that, you can just click
- 1:01:39on the show notes. We've got the Patreon listed.
- 1:01:41We've got the letterbox listed. Everything is
- 1:01:44right there for you to make it nice and easy.
- 1:01:47But beyond that, next episode, I'm super excited
- 1:01:51because we're covering a Frank Capra film that
- 1:01:53I know I enjoy called It Happened One Night.
- 1:01:55It's rare these days. Yeah, it is. It is. It
- 1:01:57Happened One Night will be the next episode.
- 1:01:59Oh, and we didn't mention this, but this is a
- 1:02:01very interesting year for us. Since we are covering
- 1:02:0413 films, we didn't want to jam -pack that all
- 1:02:06into one month. Right. So this will be the only
- 1:02:09time the next couple of months here where we
- 1:02:11split up the Academy year across several months.
- 1:02:15Yeah, you know, we've been doing three episodes.
- 1:02:18three episodes a week for the past month um or
- 1:02:21the past year rather and that worked really well
- 1:02:24there is no way to cover 13 and do three episodes
- 1:02:27here along with the ceremony episode so yeah
- 1:02:29it makes sense to kind of spread it out a little
- 1:02:31bit for this month and the next month that we
- 1:02:32talk about next year this is getting confusing
- 1:02:34but yeah hang with us on that we have just a
- 1:02:37three more nominations than normal in the 10
- 1:02:40year and uh twice Twice, yeah. So we'll have
- 1:02:44a couple films to talk about. But next week is
- 1:02:46going to be, or next episode is going to be a
- 1:02:48very interesting one because it is Frank Capra.
- 1:02:51It's the return of Frank Capra after Lady for
- 1:02:53a Day. Yeah. And we will be talking about that
- 1:02:56because that is a monumental one to cover. Yeah,
- 1:02:58yeah. So again, these next two Academy years
- 1:03:01will be split up across the next three months.
- 1:03:04So by the end of August, we'll be through 1935,
- 1:03:08which is wild. Very exciting. Yeah. So stay tuned
- 1:03:11for that. Until then, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And
- 1:03:14we'll see you at the movies.