Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Oaktree and Bridgewater Lost China Bets Exposed
Transcript
- 0:00For decades, the the foundational belief in global
- 0:03finance was rooted in what everyone called the convergence
- 0:07species, right? This wasn't just some casual
- 0:10optimism. It was, I mean, it was almost an
- 0:11article of faith. The gospel was that China's
- 0:14financial system would inevitably mature, that it would
- 0:17align with global standards and, crucially, that it would protect
- 0:21foreign capital. Exactly.
- 0:23And for fund managers, you know, being underweight in Chinese
- 0:26assets, that started to look irresponsible, like you were
- 0:30making a bet against history itself.
- 0:32It basically became a fiduciary imperative to be there.
- 0:36But history, as it so often does, had a different script.
- 0:39The period from 2020 to 2026 didn't just challenge that
- 0:42thesis, it, well, it systematically and pretty
- 0:45brutally dismantled it. And that led to what we're now
- 0:48calling the Great Recalibration. It was a.
- 0:50Huge structural regime shift and today we're going to unpack it
- 0:53by looking at two financial Titans who, let's say they paid
- 0:56some very steep tuition fees to learn the new rules.
- 0:59We're talking about Oak Tree Capital Management and
- 1:00Bridgewater Associates. Yeah, and they came at China
- 1:03from completely opposite ends of the investment spectrum, and
- 1:06both failed in really spectacular but very different
- 1:09ways. So let's set the stage first.
- 1:12You've got Oak Tree Capital. These are the giants of
- 1:15distressed debt. They're known for their
- 1:17aggressive, almost mechanical loan to own playbook.
- 1:21They bet on pure enforceability, on the idea that a contract is a
- 1:25contract and that tangible collateral building piece of
- 1:29land that's real. And on the other side, you have
- 1:32Bridgewater Associates, the macro powerhouse Ray Dalio's
- 1:35firm. They don't bet on contracts.
- 1:37They bet on an ideology A. Big one.
- 1:38The Rising Empire thesis They saw China's rise as inevitable
- 1:43as this powerful historical cycle.
- 1:45So Chinese assets weren't just a growth play, they were a
- 1:48critical hedge against stagnation in the West.
- 1:50So our mission in this deep dive is to really reconstruct this
- 1:52failure. We're going to analyze how Oak
- 1:54True just walked straight into an operational quicksand,
- 1:56seizing assets they legally controlled but you know,
- 1:59couldn't actually sell. And then we'll look at how
- 2:01Bridgewater, after years of this deep conviction, executed a
- 2:05total strategic liquidation of its portfolio.
- 2:09It was the moment that decoupling went from just
- 2:11political talk to portfolio reality.
- 2:14This is a story about where policy, debt and ideology
- 2:17collide, and really, what happens when the state decides
- 2:21to just rewrite the rule book in the middle of the game.
- 2:23And, you know, tracking these kinds of systemic risks requires
- 2:26a good sense of the overall market temperature.
- 2:29Absolutely. And for anyone listening who's
- 2:30interested in that, we've actually developed an app for
- 2:33it. Just search for the Buffett
- 2:34Indicator on the Apple App Store.
- 2:36It's a great tool for just that. OK, so to understand the
- 2:39carnage, you have to go back to the beginning, the single policy
- 2:43decision that started this whole chain reaction.
- 2:45You're talking about the three red lines policy.
- 2:48August 2020. This was the moment the ground
- 2:51just fell out from under the investment castles.
- 2:53That's it. It was the genesis of the
- 2:55crisis. For years, developers like China
- 2:58Evergrande Group were operating on this massive, just
- 3:01unbelievable leverage. They were essentially acting
- 3:04like shadow banks. Using land speculation to fund
- 3:07everything and the three red lines policy just slammed the
- 3:10brace on all of that, right? What were the limits?
- 3:13Why did it shut off the liquidity so fast?
- 3:15Well, the limits were incredibly strict.
- 3:17They put a cap on the debt to asset ratio, another on the debt
- 3:20to equity ratio, and a third on how much cash you had to cover
- 3:23short term debt. Yeah.
- 3:25And the moment Beijing said they were enforcing this, the signal
- 3:28of the banks was clear. Stop lending to anyone who
- 3:31crosses these lines. So the credit, the very
- 3:34lifeblood of their entire business model, it just stopped
- 3:38instantly. Gone overnight and investors
- 3:41like Oak Tree, they thought they were safe.
- 3:43They were making these high yield loans backed by what they
- 3:46thought was tangible land. But the policy exposed the fatal
- 3:50flaw in that thinking, didn't it?
- 3:51The Land's value was completely dependent on that debt machine
- 3:54continuing to run. Exactly.
- 3:56When Beijing broke the machine, those assets, they didn't just
- 4:00get cheaper, they became structurally stranded.
- 4:03And that liquidity crisis didn't stay contained.
- 4:06It spiraled out and became a classic balance sheet recession.
- 4:09By 2024, this wasn't just a problem for developers anymore.
- 4:12No, it became a societal problem.
- 4:14A massive 1. And this is the part you really
- 4:16need to grasp. We know that something like 70%
- 4:19of Chinese household wealth was tied up in real estate, so when
- 4:23property prices just collapsed, we're talking drops of around
- 4:2640% in top tier cities, it created the staggering negative
- 4:31wealth effect. Which led directly to what
- 4:34analysts started calling consumer capitulation.
- 4:37I mean, when 70% of your net worth just vanishes on paper,
- 4:40you don't go out and buy a new car.
- 4:42You hoard cash, credit demand completely evaporates.
- 4:46And that destroyed the whole consumption upgrade story that
- 4:48so many growth investors like Bridgewater were betting on.
- 4:51Precisely so. The liquidity problem that
- 4:53stranded oak trees collateral also killed the consumer engine
- 4:57that Bridgewater's entire thesis depended on.
- 4:59One policy, two different victims.
- 5:00And as if that wasn't enough, you had the whole geopolitical
- 5:03mess layered on top of it. Oh.
- 5:04Yeah, by 2025, with the threat of renewed tariffs and
- 5:08restrictions, the so-called Trump trade that turned Chinese
- 5:10stocks from just growth assets into outright geopolitical
- 5:13liabilities. It's a fundamental change in how
- 5:16you calculate risk. Suddenly a company's earnings or
- 5:19its PE ratio become secondary. The main question is it's
- 5:23listing risk. Can it be delisted?
- 5:25Can capital be controlled? The market stopped pricing
- 5:28fundamentals. It started pricing political
- 5:31anxiety and that forced everyone's hand, starting with
- 5:34Oak Tree, who thought their legal documents were strong
- 5:37enough to withstand a political hurricane.
- 5:39OK, let's dig into oak tree. Then they walked onto this
- 5:42quicksand with their standard playbook loan to own.
- 5:45It's simple. Lend money, take high quality
- 5:48assets as collateral and if they default you seize them.
- 5:52They really thought they were making a defensive bet backing
- 5:55physical assets. You know, not just some
- 5:57unsecured corporate paper. Their strategy centered on 2
- 6:00huge pieces of collateral from Evergrand.
- 6:03The Venice on the Sea resort project and something called
- 6:05Project Castle in Hong Kong. Right.
- 6:08They assumed, look, even if the market completely falls apart,
- 6:11we can enforce our security, take control and just liquidate
- 6:14the assets to get our money back.
- 6:16So let's let's look at Project Venice.
- 6:18Oak Tree actually executed the seizure early 2022.
- 6:22On paper, legally, they had one. But economically, the war was
- 6:26already lost. The sources show.
- 6:28Oak Tree walk straight into what they call the illiquidity trap.
- 6:32They seize control, yes, but then they were immediately
- 6:35forced to resume partial construction to deliver homes.
- 6:38Wait, wait, hold on. Why?
- 6:40If they legally own the equity, why couldn't they just sell off
- 6:43the land and get their cash back?
- 6:44Isn't that the whole point of secured lending?
- 6:47It is in a Western legal system, but in China, the state's number
- 6:51one priority is social stability.
- 6:54The local government stepped in and prevented a fire sale.
- 6:56Why would they do that? Because allowing Oak Tree to
- 6:59dump that land at a massive discount would have crashed all
- 7:02the other land values in the region, and more importantly,
- 7:05would have created huge social unrest among all the people who
- 7:08had already paid for apartments that weren't finished yet.
- 7:11So Oak Tree became what? An unpaid general contractor for
- 7:15the Chinese government, forced to spend more of its own money
- 7:17to finish the project, with no way to get out.
- 7:20That is the perfect way to put it.
- 7:21Their loan to own strategy turned into a loan to operate at
- 7:26a loss. They applied a cyclical
- 7:28framework, thinking the market would eventually bottom out to
- 7:31what was actually a structural political crisis.
- 7:34The state was actively blocking their exit.
- 7:37Even in Hong Kong with Project Castle, which is under common
- 7:40law, you could see the scale of the value destruction.
- 7:43Oak Tree's $520 million loan was against some undeveloped land
- 7:47for a mansion. And the receivers did eventually
- 7:50sell it right for about $637,000,000.
- 7:53So they got their principal back.
- 7:55They did, but that headline number is so misleading.
- 7:57That sale price was nearly $400 million less than whatever
- 8:00Granted tried to sell it for just a little while earlier.
- 8:03It forced Evergrand to book a staggering $770 million loss.
- 8:08And for a distressed fund, just getting your principal back
- 8:10after a long, expensive fight, that's a failure.
- 8:13Your time, your opportunity costs, it's all gone.
- 8:16It's a total disaster for that kind of mandate.
- 8:18And Oak Tree wasn't alone. You saw Carlisle sell an office
- 8:21tower in Shanghai for about $0.57 on the dollar.
- 8:24BlackRock just walked away from office buildings, a 100% equity
- 8:28wipeout. The lesson was brutal.
- 8:31Legal control did not equal economic control.
- 8:33OK, so let's pivot from that mechanical failure to the
- 8:36ideological capitulation of Bridgewater.
- 8:39If oak tree lost on the collateral, Bridgewater lost on
- 8:41the conviction. Bridgewater had built this
- 8:44enormous exposure based on Ray Dalio's whole Rising Empire
- 8:48thesis. They saw Chinese assets as this
- 8:51critical diversifier, totally non correlated to the West.
- 8:54And they poured capital into the darlings of the new
- 8:56economyalibabajd.com Neo. And they were buying the dip.
- 9:01All through 2021-2022, they kept doubling down.
- 9:04They believe the government crackdowns, the whole common
- 9:06prosperity thing, were just temporary hiccups.
- 9:09Their conviction was massive. But then came Q2 2025, and this
- 9:13wasn't just a rebalancing, this was a strategic forced exit.
- 9:16A total liquidation of their US listed Chinese stocks, A
- 9:20disposal of around $1.5 billion. They exited all 16 Chinese
- 9:24companies in that portfolio. We're talking 5.66 million
- 9:28shares of Alibaba, nearly 3 million of JDA, complete exit
- 9:32from PDD and Neo IT. Was a strategic retreat because
- 9:35we know they bought in when prices were higher.
- 9:37By selling Alibaba on 118, they locked in huge losses.
- 9:41They even missed a 20% rally later that year.
- 9:44And that timing tells you everything.
- 9:46It confirms the exit wasn't about fundamentals.
- 9:49It was driven by existential custody risk and just
- 9:51overwhelming client pressure. The political risk delivered
- 9:54permanent valuation compression. The growth story was over for
- 9:58Offshore Capital. But here's the thing that's so
- 10:00fascinating, the paradox that defines this whole story.
- 10:03While their actual equity portfolio is getting liquidated,
- 10:06Bridgewater's onshore Chinese funds were absolutely thriving.
- 10:09Thriving their all Other plus onshore fund posted a what was
- 10:13it, a + 35% return in 2024. It's an incredible contrast.
- 10:16How is that even possible? How can a firm get it so wrong
- 10:19on one side of the wall and so right on the other?
- 10:21It's all about what they were betting on.
- 10:23The offshore equity bet failed because it was a bet on
- 10:26capital's growth and corporate earnings.
- 10:29The onshore fund won because it was a bet on macroeconomic
- 10:32volatility and policy using. Ah, OK.
- 10:35So it was heavily invested in Chinese government bonds and
- 10:38commodities. Exactly.
- 10:39So as the economy was slowing down and facing deflation, what
- 10:43happens? The central bank tries to inject
- 10:45liquidity, which pushes down yields and that makes long term
- 10:49government bonds soar in value. So they won on the reality that
- 10:53China is a managed deflationary economy.
- 10:56Right. And they lost on the idea that
- 10:57China was a capitalist growth story.
- 10:59The state was deciding where value would be created and it
- 11:03wasn't in tech stock profits, it was in the fixed income market.
- 11:05And the whole era really came to a symbolic and when Ray Dalio
- 11:09himself sold his personal stake in 2025, leading to this big
- 11:13strategic overhaul away from the Founders China Bowl ideology.
- 11:18So if you put the two failure side by side, the lesson is
- 11:20clear. Oak Tree's failure was the
- 11:22illiquidity trap. Legal control didn't grant an
- 11:25economic exit. And Bridgewater's failure was
- 11:28valuation, compression, political risk, permanently re
- 11:31rated the multiples for stocks, Corporate profits were simply
- 11:34less important than sovereign policy goals.
- 11:36And the primary lesson for global finance is absolute.
- 11:40The era of just blindly passively allocating to China is
- 11:43over done. The assumption that corporate
- 11:46profits would keep growing even if GDP slowed?
- 11:50That's been shattered. So China is no longer a passive
- 11:52asset class. It's now very complex macro
- 11:55trade. The only way to win is to align
- 11:58with the state's goals. Treat the bond curves.
- 12:00Trade commodity volatility. You're betting on the state's
- 12:02reaction, not on corporate performance.
- 12:05And Bridgewater's complete liquidation of its US listed
- 12:07portfolio, that's the loudest signal you could possibly get
- 12:10that the great decoupling is no longer just a theory, it's a
- 12:14portfolio reality. So to bring it all home, what
- 12:17these losses really show is that in a state capitalist system
- 12:20that's facing a crisis, the state will not hesitate to
- 12:23transfer value away from foreign creditors to protect domestic
- 12:26homeowners and social stability. That's the core learning for
- 12:29global capital. Your legal rights are always
- 12:32going to be subservient to social stability, and your
- 12:34equities are always junior to sovereign policy.
- 12:37And the provocative question we want to leave you, the listener
- 12:39with is this what other markets in the world today have a
- 12:43similar structural risk where the rule of law is really just
- 12:47contingent on the rule of the party?
- 12:49That's the knowledge you have to carry forward.
- 12:51And if you do want to track total market temperature and
- 12:53systemic risk signals like these, we welcome you to search
- 12:57for and download our iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple
- 13:00App Store. You can get daily alerts.
- 13:03And for those who want to hear our full deep dive on this or
- 13:05access more advanced content, please join our Deep Value Club
- 13:08membership. You can also subscribe to the
- 13:10Deep Value Investing channel on Apple and Spotify podcasts or at
- 13:14luluvc.com. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 13:19on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 13:21or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 13:25purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 13:28Please conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 13:31investment decisions.