Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1123: Inside Maine’s Rural Birth Crisis
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Monday, May
- 0:0311th, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:06the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:09Today, inside Maine's Rural Birth Crisis, Doctor Dora Ann
- 0:14Mills, a senior advisor for public health at Maine Health
- 0:17and a former state health official and Asto's Alumni
- 0:20Society representative, tells us about the rapidly escalating
- 0:23rural maternity crisis and why it's more than just hospital
- 0:27closures. After celebrating Mother's Day
- 0:29this past weekend, it's a sobering reminder that Maine has
- 0:32lost nearly half of its maternity units, creating vast
- 0:36maternity deserts. And compounding the crisis is
- 0:39worsening maternal health, driven by chronic disease,
- 0:42mental health challenges and substance use, especially among
- 0:45rural and underserved populations.
- 0:48We hear a lot about the rural maternity crisis and
- 0:51particularly around hospital closures.
- 0:54And one thing I've learned is that it's really two crises in
- 0:58one. So first is the widespread
- 1:01closures of hospital maternity units across the country.
- 1:04There are over 50%, over half of rural hospitals have closed
- 1:11maternity units and that's true in Maine as well.
- 1:15In fact, we've had seventeen of our 36 hospitals have closed
- 1:19their units and over half of our about 54% of our rural hospitals
- 1:25have closed their labor and delivery units, 11 of them in
- 1:28the last decade alone. So it's, it's created these vast
- 1:33maternity deserts where the drive times for people not just
- 1:38for labor and delivery, but for perinatal care, prenatal visits,
- 1:43which average about 13 that are recommended and as well as
- 1:46postpartum care are very long in Maine.
- 1:49It's in rural Maine, the average drive time is 45 minutes.
- 1:54So you can imagine in about 60% of our rural maternity patients
- 1:59have Medicare aid. So they often do not have very
- 2:03reliable transportation. We don't have public
- 2:05transportation significantly in rural areas in this country.
- 2:09So you're talking about people who don't have reliable
- 2:11transportation and large proportion of them anyway and
- 2:15then having to drive 45 minutes each way for 13 prenatal care
- 2:21and postpartum care and labor and delivery.
- 2:23It's a huge crisis now. But the second one that's
- 2:26related to it is that we have worsening maternal health and of
- 2:32itself. So rural pregnant women in the
- 2:37US carry disproportionately high burdens of chronic disease such
- 2:42as diabetes, substance use disorders, and mental health
- 2:45conditions. A couple of examples, one in
- 2:48five rural pregnant women in Maine used nicotine during
- 2:51pregnancy. That's three times the urban
- 2:54rate. A neonatal abstinence syndrome
- 2:56also effects as much higher in rural areas.
- 3:00And when you look in a lot of parts of the country too, the
- 3:04rates are very disproportionately high amongst
- 3:07racial and ethnic minorities. So our black rural populations,
- 3:11our tribal populations as examples, have much higher
- 3:14burdens of these chronic diseases.
- 3:17And you've described this as a slow moving crises or crises.
- 3:24At what point did things tip too far?
- 3:27Well, I think, you know, in the last decade things have gotten
- 3:30worse across the country. I know we've seen that in Maine,
- 3:33but I know this is really a national trend for us in Maine.
- 3:38I would say 1 tipping point was the 160 mile stretch between the
- 3:44city of Bangor and Presque Isle, which are in from central to
- 3:49northern Maine. You drive by three hospitals and
- 3:53they have now all closed their maternity units.
- 3:57So we're talking about a very large part of the state where a
- 4:01woman who goes into labour in that region faces a very long
- 4:06journey, particularly in winter, winter roads where that drive
- 4:10can easily be a couple of hours. So that's not just a theoretical
- 4:14risk, it's really a public health emergency hiding in plain
- 4:18sight. Absolutely.
- 4:20And you know, talk a little bit more about some of the immediate
- 4:24impacts on on health systems when those when those maternity
- 4:31wards close. So one thing that's very
- 4:34striking is we know that when a maternity unit closes, that
- 4:41infant mortality rates in that area double.
- 4:46And those are really striking statistics.
- 4:49And so we see this pretty immediate impact on maternal and
- 4:54infant health. I mean, we know when a maternity
- 4:57unit closes, people who are pregnant have to drive much
- 5:00farther for prenatal care, labor and delivery and postpartum
- 5:05care. Then the risks there we see are,
- 5:09for instance, significant increases in out of hospital
- 5:13births, women who don't make it to the hospital in time.
- 5:16There are significant decreases in prenatal and postpartum
- 5:20visits. I mean, 13 post prenatal visits
- 5:23are recommended, but if you don't have very reliable
- 5:26transportation and you have a hour or so each way to go for
- 5:30those visits, you're just not going to be able to make them.
- 5:33And the distance and cost become prohibitive.
- 5:36And there are impacts on perinatal mental health.
- 5:39So here's something that also people don't often think about
- 5:42is that when a maternity unit closes, often there's no one
- 5:46left in the emergency department who can safely manage an
- 5:51obstetrical emergency. So this is a life threatening
- 5:54gap, not just an inconvenience. And for those rural pregnant
- 6:00people who have a lot of stressors already and we know
- 6:04our young adult population across the country has high
- 6:07rates of disproportionately high rates of, of anxiety and
- 6:11depression. And you add pregnancy to it and
- 6:14then you add the stressors of rural maternity units closing
- 6:18and having longer drives. The mental health issues, as I
- 6:21mentioned, are also very, very striking.
- 6:23Yeah, and you know those outcomes for for mothers and
- 6:27babies is awful. But then, as you just
- 6:30illustrated, your compounding pressure on the health system at
- 6:33large. Exactly.
- 6:35So you know, maternal infant health indicators are they're
- 6:40really the Canary in the coal mine in many ways.
- 6:43They're really the indicator for communities overall health.
- 6:47So when you have those decline, when they deteriorate, it also
- 6:52shows you how much the health system is stressed.
- 6:56You've got emergency rooms and, and and EMS emergency medical
- 7:00services who are not used to obstetrical emergencies or
- 7:03having to handle them on their own.
- 7:07So it stresses the health system out and it also stresses the
- 7:11whole community. Well-being starts to go down,
- 7:15starts to deteriorate. Yeah, and you mentioned, you
- 7:19know, the need for real policy. And for a real.
- 7:22Change, and I'm wondering what that looks like and if the rural
- 7:26health Transformation program might be part of a solution.
- 7:29Absolutely. And I first just want to mention
- 7:32that, you know, we mentioned the health effects and on these on
- 7:36this issue as well as the stressors at the hospitals or
- 7:40and other healthcare are experiencing, but also there's
- 7:43the economic effects too. So we know that when counties,
- 7:48when communities have had to close and return to the units,
- 7:52there's also a downturn in economic activity.
- 7:56And hospital presidents and businesses have shared with me
- 7:59and others that when a maternity unit closes, they have a hard
- 8:03time recruiting workers to that area because what workers look
- 8:07at, particularly young workers and families, they say, well,
- 8:11can we deliver babies safely here 'cause we want to expand
- 8:14our family or have a family and can other schools, you know,
- 8:17they look at hospitals and school healthcare and schools.
- 8:19And so when the hospitals are closed for maternity, it, it, it
- 8:24then has a ripple effect into the economy.
- 8:27So, so there's a lot of ripple effects from closing rural
- 8:33maternity units overall. But the good news is, is we do
- 8:38have this rural health transformation program, which
- 8:42does I think provide some meaningful strategies that
- 8:46people that states can implement.
- 8:49So examples there are transformational dollars that
- 8:54are used are being used are proposed to being used to see
- 8:57things like regional care coordination systems.
- 9:01You know, for instance, we've got some regional care
- 9:03coordination that's just starting here in Maine and be
- 9:07some of that includes for instance, closed maternity
- 9:12hospitals, working with open maternity hospitals and figuring
- 9:16out other ways to provide perinatal care, coordinating
- 9:20things like that to try to cut down on the mileage that people
- 9:24have to to drive to just get prenatal care.
- 9:29Also those rural to health transformation program funds are
- 9:33also being used to increase telehealth alternatives.
- 9:38So for instance, on telehealth networks between rural hospitals
- 9:42and referral centers, so that, you know, maybe family medicine
- 9:47OB obstetricians in family medicine OB's or family medicine
- 9:52physicians who've been had some extra training in OB so they can
- 9:54do C sections that they're out there in the rural area that
- 9:58they can call in easily to an obstetrician in a more regional
- 10:02office and have them see the patients with them through
- 10:06telehealth. So that's something that's being
- 10:08worked on. Also workforce pipelines.
- 10:11We know that diversifying the workforce, the OB workforce is a
- 10:15very important strategy. For instance, implementing
- 10:19programs that train family medicine physicians to do C
- 10:23sections so they can provide a full range of OB care.
- 10:28So those are the kinds of things that I think the rural health
- 10:31transformation program provides an opening to exploring and or
- 10:36implementing. Do you have any advice for other
- 10:39states? Other rural.
- 10:40States that are. Facing similar challenges.
- 10:43Yes, I would say first of all, don't treat the hospital
- 10:47closures and maternal health crises as separate problems.
- 10:51They really are intertwined. And I think you have to work
- 10:55with hospitals on the finance side of things, but you also
- 10:59have to work on the health side simultaneously, for instance,
- 11:03such on substance use, mental health and social drivers to
- 11:06health. Second, I would get the data
- 11:09systems in order now so that you need them to make the case.
- 11:15Vital records prams, briefest mortality, mortality review
- 11:19panels from producing timely and reliable data.
- 11:22So the as we know in public health, if you don't have data,
- 11:25you don't have a problem. You got to be able to prove that
- 11:28you got a problem. And 3rd, I would invest in
- 11:31regional planning early. Our experience in Maine,
- 11:36particularly around the trauma centers, we had a big planning
- 11:40process abound those several years ago.
- 11:42It was very successful, but just starting regional planning for
- 11:45maternal health and I believe likewise that regional planning
- 11:49with all the hospitals, health centers, other providers at the
- 11:54table and patients will be very successful in trying to assure
- 11:58coordination and a seamless system.
- 12:01And then finally, I think it's really we got to be honest with
- 12:05our communities about what's coming.
- 12:07The closures are likely to continue in the near term given
- 12:11the workforce shortages and birth declines in rural areas,
- 12:15and pretending otherwise doesn't serve anybody.
- 12:17But I think we can offer is some genuine plans, not just crisis
- 12:22management, and a vision of what safe and sustainable rural
- 12:27maternity systems can really look like and and be and get a
- 12:32credible path to being there. Doctor Dora Ann Mills is a
- 12:35senior advisor for public health at Maine Health and a former
- 12:38state health official. Read Doctor Mills policy review,
- 12:41titled Maine's Rural Maternity Crisis A Policy Agenda by
- 12:45clicking the link in the show notes.
- 12:48Masto, in collaboration with the Berkeley Media Studies Group,
- 12:51will host a virtual training designed to strengthen
- 12:54participants ability to communicate adverse childhood
- 12:56experiences, AC, ES, and other relevant public health issues in
- 13:01ways that resonate with target audiences and generate
- 13:03meaningful media coverage. The session will also build
- 13:07skills and crafting compelling narratives by leveraging expert
- 13:10voices, translating data through social math, and delivering
- 13:13clear, impactful messages. Find a link in the show notes.
- 13:18Join ASTO for a webinar May 20th to explore how to build
- 13:21resilient dialysis systems and teams.
- 13:24Understanding the structures, processes, and practices that
- 13:27influence patients safety during times of stress is essential to
- 13:30informing priorities and targeting interventions that
- 13:33strengthen resilience. This one hour session convenes
- 13:36frontline clinicians, workforce leaders and public health
- 13:39partners to examine practical evidence, informed strategies
- 13:43that enhance both system and worker resilience in the
- 13:46outpatient dialysis setting. The link to register is in the
- 13:49show notes. This has been public health
- 13:51review morning edition. I'm John Sheehan for the
- 13:53Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.