Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / The Crunch with JJ McCullough: Is B.C. a "conservative" province?
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to This is Van Color. We're gonna wrap things
- 0:10up tonight with my friend, a political commentator and YouTuber based right here in
- 0:14Vancouver with nearly a million subscribers. He is JJ McCullough and this is the
- 0:19Crunch. So, Jj, we just heard from BC Conservative leader John Rustad
- 0:29you sat in on that interview. I mean, he's clearly shaking things up
- 0:32when it comes to polling, or at least the BC Conservatives are. How
- 0:35palatable is the BC Conservative Party because I look at things like the carbon tax
- 0:40and SOGI and think that, you know, they're not really going to make
- 0:42a lot of headway in the cities. Yeah, I mean I was personally
- 0:45a little underwhelmed by that interview, I must say. I mean I think
- 0:48that he seems like a decent I take that personally, by the way,
- 0:51thank you, No not. He seems like an intelligent, sort of well
- 0:55informed guy. He actually seems like a real throwback politician to a sort of
- 0:58politician that you saw I think a lot in the nineties sort of critiquing the
- 1:02NDP government and has sort of adapted those criticisms to now, I guess to
- 1:06bring to the current DP government. I don't think calling anyone socialist has the
- 1:08same I know, but he did it. Yeah, that's true. But
- 1:11I think but anyway to get to your question, I do think that what
- 1:15we see from that interview suggests that the strength of the BC Party is not
- 1:18necessarily that John Rustad is sort of catching the province on fire. It's that
- 1:21I think that the strength of the BC Conservative brand has risen a lot,
- 1:26and I think there's a number of reasons for that. I think that you
- 1:27know, Peer Polyev has, you know, is very popular. I think
- 1:30a lot of people are excited within sort of the Conservative coalition to vote conservative,
- 1:34and I think they just want to vote for anything that's labeled conservative that
- 1:37comes in. Even though he said in the interview he's not conservative, which
- 1:41is a weird thing to say unto itself, and again like very sort of
- 1:44nineties, Well, you know, we have to have a big coalition,
- 1:46and the idea that he's you know, they say in the reporting and all
- 1:49that that he's open to, you know, perhaps merging with the VC United
- 1:53Party and this kind of stuff. So it's it's again like it's just it's
- 1:57not about him, and I think that he's not an overly careismatic person.
- 2:00I don't think that your average British Columbian has any idea who he is.
- 2:02But I do think that the fact that the media is talking about the BC
- 2:07Conservatives a lot more because I think that he is impressive in a way that
- 2:09appeals to people like you, Frankly, who know a lot of Yeah,
- 2:14those aren't the nerdy BC politics kind of type of person, right, And
- 2:17I think that makes people like you take him a bit more seriously in a
- 2:21way that previous heads of the BC Conservative Party have not been taken seriously.
- 2:24So I think that there's just and I think that Frankly, the decision for
- 2:28the BC Liberals to rebrand as BC United was a disastrous hurt. Well,
- 2:31let's actually result in votes for the BC Conservatives once we get to October.
- 2:36Oh yeah, I think so. I think that, you know, I
- 2:38think that at the end of the day, sort of BC political nerds like
- 2:42yourself and like the leader have a presumption that your average BC voter has like
- 2:47a very long understanding of BC political history. Well, I think that like
- 2:53increasingly, in the kind of the media climate that we exist in today,
- 2:55like everybody is pretty much coming in cold to these elections, right, I
- 3:00think that your average British Columbia can barely remember who likes, say, Christy
- 3:02Clark was like that is like a distant figure. So I think that they're
- 3:06coming to this election with a sort of a clean sort of frame of reference.
- 3:09They don't know who the current premirea is. They just know that we've
- 3:13got an MDP, we've got a Conservative, we've got something called BC United.
- 3:16I never heard of that. So I think that you know, he
- 3:19benefits from, you know, a public that's not terribly plugged in and two
- 3:23very strong party brands NDP, which you know, a lot of people in
- 3:28this province like you know, like you said, you know, we have
- 3:30a very sort of Vancouver sort of centric population these days, over half the
- 3:34population is in the greater Vancouver area. And then you have the Conservative brand,
- 3:37which is a very strong brand as well, and a very strong brand
- 3:39with people that you know, they might not know a lot about politics,
- 3:43but they know that they don't like the NDP, they don't like the left,
- 3:46they don't like what they've seen the left doing in a kind of broad
- 3:49national or transnational sort of way. And so if they want to vote for
- 3:52something that's not NDP. They have a very clear and well understood alternative.
- 3:57When we think of British Columbia as a whole, our province lean one way
- 4:00or the other, because I've certainly heard us being called the left coast.
- 4:03We're a little more quote unquote liberal, small l liberal. But then you
- 4:08see this surge for the federal Conservatives here and certainly the provincial Conservatives. So
- 4:14where would you kind of put BC on the political spectrum. I mean,
- 4:16I think that we're probably more left wing than not. I mean, but
- 4:20you know, at the same time, when you look federally, a third
- 4:23of our seats in the Parliament do go to the Conservatives. The thing about
- 4:26this country is that our provinces are so gigantic right. So it's like if
- 4:30this was a if we were in the States, you know, British Columbia
- 4:31would be multiple states and there would be like some quite conservative states that would
- 4:36be a component part of that. And I think that once you get outside
- 4:40of you know, the greater Vancouver area and you get into sort of the
- 4:43north in the interior and more rural parts of the province, you do come
- 4:46into a completely different culture that people like you and me sort of downtown Vancouver
- 4:49hipsters just don't really think about it very much. And so I think that
- 4:54there is a degree to which, you know, the strength of the BC
- 4:58Conservatives comes from a kind of consistently rural right wing sort of voter block that
- 5:04votes conservative federally, and it was responsible for a lot of the Conservative members
- 5:08that we have in Ottawa, and you know, used to be the backbone
- 5:11of the of the of the Social Credit Party and then kept the BC Liberals,
- 5:15and frankly is like the backbone of the BC Liberal Party now because they're
- 5:17very much shut out of the greater Vancouver area. So but you're just making
- 5:21it sound like there's a ceiling to a party that's labeled exclusively as Conservatives.
- 5:26Yeah, I think that's true. Like I think that the Conservatives have a
- 5:29very particular base, you know, the Conservatives, I suppose we should say
- 5:31like the right of center sort of block of voters in BC. It has
- 5:36a base, it has a ceiling, And I think that the challenge for
- 5:41you know, guys like Jon Rastad and other sort of center right politicians in
- 5:45this province is like, do you have a strategy to kind of like expand
- 5:47that base, can you make arguments that are appealing to people that are not
- 5:50already inclined to vote for you. And frankly, I don't think that he's
- 5:54a politician that has those skills in the way that I think somebody like peer
- 5:58Polyev at the federal level, because he's a little bit you know, Pierre
- 6:01is more charismatic, more outgoing, and has more of an interest in trying
- 6:04to like make inroads in new communities. I could see John, you know,
- 6:10doing well with the sort of you know, taking away votes from BC
- 6:13Liberals and sort of unseating some BC Liberal MLAs. But in again, parts
- 6:17of the province where you do kind of have a more consistently right of center
- 6:21leaning population. So in the same way that they switch from Social Credit to
- 6:26BC Liberal, you can see them now switching from BC Liberal, from BC
- 6:29United to BC Conservative just because that's now what conservatives do. Fascinating. JJ,
- 6:32appreciate your time tonight. I'm not sure if mister Rustad will, but
- 6:35thank you so much. No problem, folks, that's our show. Thank
- 6:40you to JJ McCullough and BC Conservative leader John Rustad for their time tonight.
- 6:45We will be back next week for episode one hundred here on check. I
- 6:48promise it'll be full of surprises. In the meantime, please follow me on
- 6:53X or TikTok at van Keller. Of course, this is van Keller,
- 6:56and I'm mo oamir telling you that in a province where you can be a
- 7:00thing, be colorful paste