Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Unpacking the Landmark 2026 Social Media Addiction Decisions: The Appellate Perspective
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:06unpacking the landmark 2026 social media addiction
- 0:10decisions, the appellate perspective. I'm all
- 0:13a poly Castro, director of education and professional
- 0:15development. And today I am delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker. Ari Stiller. Ari is the founder
- 0:21of Stiller Law Firm and a California State Bar
- 0:24Certified Specialist in Appellate Law. He has
- 0:26handled cases before the California Court of
- 0:28Appeals, the California Supreme Court, and the
- 0:31Ninth Circuit and served as a judicial fellow
- 0:33to Judge Paul Watford of the U .S. Court of Appeals
- 0:35for the Ninth Circuit. He has been recognized
- 0:38as a super lawyer rising star in multiple years.
- 0:42Ari teaches at USC Gould School of Law and serves
- 0:44on both the Los Angeles County Bar Association
- 0:47State Appellate Judicial Evaluations Committee
- 0:50and the California Lawyers Associations Committee
- 0:52on Appellate Courts. We're so excited to hear
- 0:54what he has to share with us today, so I'm gonna
- 0:56now turn it over to him. All right, thank you,
- 0:59Ala, for that introduction. We are going to talk
- 1:03about the social media addiction landscape What's
- 1:06been going on around the country with these cases
- 1:09and then mainly about the KGM versus meta platforms
- 1:13case which is the the case that just went to
- 1:16verdict in Los Angeles Superior Court and that
- 1:19is Going up on appeal likely any day now. So
- 1:23Jose you can go on to the next slide Okay, so
- 1:27yeah what we'll cover we're gonna cover what
- 1:29happened at the trial what the testimony showed
- 1:32what the jury actually found and also where it's
- 1:38headed on appeal and what I expect the likely
- 1:42appellate issues to be. And then my prediction
- 1:47of where this all is headed in the Court of Appeal,
- 1:50ultimately. Jose, you can go on. All right. So
- 1:55here's what's been happening on a nationwide
- 1:59scale. All of a sudden, although social media
- 2:03has existed for a long time, we have an onslaught
- 2:09of social media addiction cases around the country.
- 2:13And this isn't even all of it here. This is part
- 2:17of what's going on. But it's almost too much
- 2:19to really cover. And I don't know all of the
- 2:23details of every single case around the country.
- 2:25But here are kind of some of the big consolidated
- 2:29cases or cases that have gone to to jury recently
- 2:34and what's happening. So you have the federal
- 2:38multi -district litigation and that in that's
- 2:43in the Northern District of California. It involves
- 2:46over 2600 cases, many school districts that similar
- 2:52to the California consolidated cases in the federal
- 2:57MDL. they're going to have a number of bellwethers.
- 3:01But when this first bellwether was set to start,
- 3:04the case settled. And that was going to be on
- 3:07behalf of a school district in Kentucky, I think.
- 3:10And the remaining defendant, most of them settled.
- 3:15Metta was left standing. And then recently, Metta
- 3:17settled with that plaintiff. So there were no
- 3:20claims left to go to that first bellwether trial.
- 3:24We'll see what happens with the next federal
- 3:28MDL bellwether But that's scheduled for August
- 3:316th on behalf of another school district. I don't
- 3:34know You know what metas metas settle with the
- 3:38first school district I don't know whether that
- 3:39was because of something unique that the company
- 3:43saw in that case and they'd rather have the second
- 3:47the you know, the second school districts case
- 3:50go first, but or maybe they kind of plan to focus
- 3:55their energies in other courts and keep settling
- 3:57these federal MDL cases, I don't know. But they
- 4:02cover a lot of the same issues as in the KGM
- 4:05case and in the California Judicial Council coordinated
- 4:08proceeding, which we'll cover as the main focus
- 4:12of this presentation. And then you have the New
- 4:15Mexico litigation. That was brought by the New
- 4:19Mexico attorney general. we've probably all read
- 4:23about that. It was a pretty significant jury
- 4:25verdict. It was not exactly coextensive with
- 4:29the KGM trial that we're going to focus on today.
- 4:32It was about misleading safety information, and
- 4:37there was an issue about sexual exploitation
- 4:40of minors. As far as procedurally, the New Mexico
- 4:47case did involve some of the same arguments made
- 4:52by the social media companies as we have in California.
- 4:57And so that case may lead to similar appellate
- 5:02issues, even though the liability claims were
- 5:06not coextensive with what we saw in California.
- 5:11But our California case might actually beat the
- 5:15New Mexico case to an appeal because That case
- 5:18is still ongoing. What happened so far in New
- 5:21Mexico is that there was a jury verdict for part
- 5:23of the case, but then there's also a bench trial
- 5:26happening right now. As of when I last checked
- 5:29a week ago, there were some, I think, post trial
- 5:32briefs that were filed in that case. And I don't
- 5:37think we have a verdict yet on or a ruling yet
- 5:41from the judge on the bench trial aspect of the
- 5:43New Mexico litigation. But this is evolving so
- 5:47quickly that every day I'm kind of reading new
- 5:50headlines. And so if it hasn't happened yet,
- 5:52we'll get more information about what the judge
- 5:55does there any day now. And then we have the
- 5:58California Judicial Council coordinated proceeding.
- 6:03And that I have some of the statistics up there.
- 6:06There will be nine bellwether trials altogether.
- 6:10The first one the KGM versus meta platforms,
- 6:14that is the trial that happened ended March 25.
- 6:18And that is what is going to lead to an appeal
- 6:22in the California Court of Appeal. And because
- 6:24I'm a California certified appellate specialist,
- 6:27that's going to be the main focus of our talk
- 6:31today. The the if you're wondering, well, why
- 6:36isn't there an appeal yet? Because the verdict
- 6:39came down March 25th, and it's already June,
- 6:43there were post trial motions. That's pretty
- 6:46typical in in most cases that that go to a trial.
- 6:50But definitely it was expected here. And I'm
- 6:52glad that that happened because the post trial
- 6:56motions usually provide a good glimpse of the
- 6:59arguments that we can expect on appeal. And Judge
- 7:03Cool, the judge overseeing the KGM trial, denied
- 7:08the post -trial motions, but that order denying
- 7:10them came down on June 9th. So just recently.
- 7:16And the way the California deadlines to appeal
- 7:19work, normally you have 60 days from notice of
- 7:23entry of a judgment or an appealable order, that's
- 7:28your timeline to appeal. But there's a different
- 7:31timeline when post -trial motions are filed.
- 7:38when there's a judgment followed by post trial
- 7:41motions, the deadline is extended to 30 days
- 7:45after notice of entry of the ruling on the post
- 7:49trial motions. And because the court ruled on
- 7:53the post trial motions on June 9th, the social
- 7:56media companies will have until July 9th to file
- 7:59their appeal. Technically, if they're not served
- 8:02with notice of entry of that June 9th order,
- 8:05right away, then they might actually have until
- 8:07longer than June 9th, but knowing what's at stake,
- 8:11I don't think they're going to take any chances
- 8:12with filing a late notice of appeal. So I would
- 8:15expect that to be filed any day now. I checked
- 8:19the docket before this presentation and I haven't
- 8:21seen the notice of appeal filed, but I would
- 8:26expect it before July 9th and probably even sooner
- 8:29than that. And then I'll just add there is one
- 8:34more bellwether. So we talked about the federal
- 8:36bellwether coming up on August 6th. There's also
- 8:40a state bellwether in the same coordinated proceeding,
- 8:44but on behalf of a different plaintiff coming
- 8:46up on July 27th, as of when I last checked. But
- 8:50as I said, these... Cases are developing quickly.
- 8:55Sometimes there are settlement discussions and
- 8:58things could change. But as of now, that's the
- 9:00status. Jose, you can go to the next slide if
- 9:03you don't mind. OK, so what happened in the KGM
- 9:09case that went to trial? There was a lot of motion
- 9:13practice leading up to the trial. And the case
- 9:17originally involved a number of claims that the
- 9:21court narrowed down. The court actually, although
- 9:26two claims went to trial, the negligence and
- 9:29failure to warn claims, the court sustained a
- 9:32demurrer brought by the social media companies
- 9:35that got rid of most of the claims. And it also,
- 9:40the demurrer was sustained as to a product defect
- 9:47claim, which I found kind of interesting because
- 9:49the The trial involved a theory of negligent
- 9:54product design, but the court earlier in the
- 9:57case had sustained a demur to a product defect
- 10:02cause of action. And there's a legal distinction
- 10:06between the two because what the court sustained
- 10:09the demur to was a basically a product defect
- 10:16claim would involve strict liability and different
- 10:18elements. And usually those types of claims arise
- 10:22from a physical product where you can see by
- 10:27virtue of this product breaking or not functioning
- 10:31or harming people, the idea behind having strict
- 10:37liability and product defect is to Hold the man
- 10:40if you're gonna compare the manufacturer with
- 10:43the person who was harmed by a product you would
- 10:45hold the manufacturer liable and so there are
- 10:48more easier standards to meet for a typical product
- 10:51defect claim the court said that that mold of
- 10:55product defect liability. Doesn't really fit
- 10:58here because the interaction that the social
- 11:01media platforms had with their users is very
- 11:06complex compared to. a transaction that the manufacturer
- 11:11of a humidifier might have with someone who uses
- 11:13a humidifier. So the court didn't like a product
- 11:17defect theory, but ultimately, the negligence
- 11:21claim involved a theory of defective design of
- 11:25these platforms in a way that would addict youth.
- 11:34So the two claims that survived were negligence
- 11:37and failure to warn. Do I think that the plaintiffs
- 11:41will file their own appeal as to the claims to
- 11:45which a demurrer was sustained? Probably not,
- 11:48because you have to show prejudice for an appeal.
- 11:51I think probably if their whole case had been
- 11:54thrown out, they would have appealed at that
- 11:56point. And there are actually some pending appeals
- 11:58of other members of this JCCP involving different
- 12:02issues. And because there were some, for example,
- 12:07school districts who were involved in the same
- 12:09coordinated proceeding, and Judge Cool sustained
- 12:12those demurs without leave to amend. And so those
- 12:16school districts appealed. I think those appeals
- 12:19have to do with their standing and not the kind
- 12:23of substantive issues that I expect from the
- 12:26KGM appeal. But do I think that that KGM might
- 12:32appeal from the demur, you know, the aspects
- 12:35of the demur that she lost, probably not because
- 12:37she was still allowed to go to trial and was
- 12:38successful in claims where the damages would
- 12:42overlap. So she would probably have a difficult
- 12:45time showing prejudice from the earlier order
- 12:48sustaining the demur. Okay, we can go to the
- 12:52next slide if you don't mind. All right, so what
- 12:56was the result? The damages were $3 million in
- 13:00compensatory damages, excuse me, 2 .1 impunitives
- 13:05to Meta, 900 ,000 impunitives to YouTube. So
- 13:09about a $6 million total exposure from the verdict.
- 13:14But of course, the reason why this case is getting
- 13:18so much attention Is not because of the six million
- 13:22dollars. I think I was I was just looking up
- 13:26this morning what? What metas revenue was for
- 13:30the last year. It's around two hundred billion
- 13:33dollars. So six million dollars is not really
- 13:36making a dent in their bottom line. But this
- 13:40is why the liability issues are so much more
- 13:44important because the liability questions really
- 13:48are. a business model. They really will affect
- 13:52the business model and would potentially open
- 13:56the floodgates to a lot of social media litigation.
- 13:59There's already a lot of advertisement by firms
- 14:02for clients to bring social media addiction cases.
- 14:06And so that's really why this is so important
- 14:11and why the legal issues on appeal are so important.
- 14:15They're not, I mean, they're basically like I
- 14:17wouldn't say bet the company issues because they
- 14:20involve a portion of the company's users and
- 14:23not all of them. But still, the implications
- 14:26are very significant for how these companies
- 14:29will be allowed to operate. and design their
- 14:33algorithms and test for potential addiction issues
- 14:37and all of that. So these were the monetary damages.
- 14:40There were also settlements by other social media
- 14:43companies involved before this case got to trial.
- 14:46So the overall recovery by the plaintiff is likely
- 14:50higher than this. But really, where the rubber
- 14:54meets the road here is in the legal issues that
- 14:57could lead to business model changes. for the
- 15:00social media companies. We can go to the next
- 15:06slide. OK, so now we're going to talk about what
- 15:11was on trial, what some of the evidence showed.
- 15:16So on appeal, the Court of Appeal is going to
- 15:19take a plaintiff -friendly or I should say a
- 15:22respondent -friendly view toward the evidence
- 15:26because The court of appeal does not second guess
- 15:31the jury's findings on an appeal. On an appeal,
- 15:34you don't get to retry the case in front of the
- 15:37court of appeal. It really focuses on whether
- 15:40there was a legal error in the trial court. And
- 15:42so a lot of the facts that we're going to talk
- 15:46about are facts that I think the court of appeal
- 15:50will assume are true for purposes of its analysis.
- 15:53even if Metta and YouTube had contrary facts
- 15:59or disputed experts and those types of things,
- 16:02the Court of Appeal is going to operate with
- 16:05the understanding that the jury believed the
- 16:08evidence favorable to the verdict. So KGM and
- 16:11her mother, Jose, you can, yeah, there you go.
- 16:16KGM and her mother both testified. KGM herself,
- 16:21testified that she started using Instagram when
- 16:23she was nine years old, and that she had compulsive
- 16:27use of Instagram where she would be on the platform
- 16:30for like 16 hours a day. And the her testimony
- 16:38really was about her addiction. And she spoke
- 16:42about her interactions with meta and YouTube,
- 16:46the same way as you might expect someone who's
- 16:49addicted to a drug. To talk about their interactions
- 16:53with the drug. She said she would have withdrawal
- 16:56like reactions when her phone was taken away
- 16:59and That she didn't really feel like she had
- 17:02a choice of whether to be on these platforms
- 17:04and she really couldn't pull herself away her
- 17:07mother Karen testified that she didn't know about
- 17:11the safety risks from the from the social media
- 17:15platforms and that she wouldn't have given KGM
- 17:20a phone if she were aware and that she tried
- 17:23to limit KGM's use. But it was a little bit like
- 17:27how you might expect a drug addict to react if
- 17:29their parent takes away their stash or something.
- 17:32She couldn't keep her daughter off the phone.
- 17:36And so it was it that's kind of the from the
- 17:40from the daughter and her mother, Karen. And
- 17:45I think some of the failure to warn liability,
- 17:49you know, it also part of that arose from Karen's
- 17:53testimony because she said that if she had been
- 17:57given a warning and knew the risks, then she
- 17:59would have acted differently or maybe not given
- 18:02her a phone in the first place. So you also had
- 18:07testimony from KGM's treating treating doctors,
- 18:13her therapist and her counselor, and They testified
- 18:18that they diagnosed her with general anxiety
- 18:22disorder, social phobia, and body dysmorphia.
- 18:26And both the therapist and the counselor tied
- 18:29those diagnoses to her social media use. They
- 18:33were asked, did you diagnose her with social
- 18:39media addiction? And they testified no, because
- 18:44There is no recognized diagnosis code for social
- 18:49media addiction, but they were clear that they
- 18:53thought that her diagnosable conditions were
- 18:58connected to her use of social media. And then
- 19:02the plaintiffs also called an expert, Dr. Anna
- 19:06Lemke. She was a Stanford psychiatrist, and she
- 19:11testified to some of the the addictive qualities
- 19:17of the design features that were at issue in
- 19:22the trial. And we're going to, in a later slide,
- 19:25we'll talk about specifically what those features
- 19:27were. But Dr. Lemke's testimony was that kind
- 19:31of the combination of some of these features,
- 19:34like, for example, notifications and... infinite
- 19:39scroll where the screen just keeps showing additional
- 19:43content and you can't kind of make it stop. And
- 19:47some of these social validation features, like
- 19:50you're constantly seeing if you're getting likes
- 19:52and that type of thing, that these features provide
- 19:58intermittent variable rewards. And her testimony
- 20:03was that That's a very addictive type of reward.
- 20:10You might think, well, if every time you do a
- 20:18certain behavior, then you're going to get a
- 20:21positive reaction, then you'd really want to
- 20:26do that behavior more. But what Dr. Lemke testified
- 20:30to is that you actually want to do the behavior
- 20:34more if you're not given a reward every single
- 20:37time that you do it, but if you're given that
- 20:40reward intermittently. And she compared it to
- 20:43pulling the lever on slot machines. So if you
- 20:46pull the slot machine and every single time you
- 20:48do that, you get sevens or I don't know what
- 20:51you're supposed to get on a slot machine because
- 20:53I don't do that. But say seven is the best possible
- 20:58outcome. you might really enjoy pulling the lever
- 21:02if you get sevens every time, but you could become
- 21:05addicted to pulling the lever if you get sevens
- 21:08like one -tenth of the time and you don't know
- 21:11which time you're going to get the sevens because
- 21:14then you just constantly want to keep constantly
- 21:17pulling and pulling and pulling the lever to
- 21:19see if you're going to get that reward the next
- 21:22time. And that is kind of the more addictive
- 21:27quality of of these platforms according to her
- 21:31testimony. And she also testified that youth
- 21:35like KGM are more susceptible to forming addictions
- 21:40from that type of input because of their developing
- 21:48brains. Meta did have a counter expert, Dr. Krishna,
- 21:54who tried to disconnect the causal link between
- 21:58KGM's harm and her social media use. And Dr.
- 22:04Krishna evaluated KGM and spoke about some of
- 22:08the other issues that she was facing in her life
- 22:11that could have led to some of her diagnoses.
- 22:20it appeared that the jury gave more credit to
- 22:23the plaintiff's experts and drew a connection
- 22:27between her social media use and her anxiety,
- 22:32social phobia, et cetera. We can go on to the
- 22:38next slide, please. Okay, so what were the features
- 22:46and what was the... what was the testimony about
- 22:52how these platforms were designed to cause addiction?
- 22:57The plaintiff's called a whistleblower, who was
- 23:01formerly Metta's senior engineering and product
- 23:04leader at Facebook. And his name was Arturo Bejar.
- 23:10And he testified that he personally told the
- 23:13head of Metta, as well as Mark Zuckerberg, about
- 23:16some of the mental health risks to kids from
- 23:20the design features that they were implementing
- 23:22on their platforms. He also testified that Metta
- 23:26told employees not to use the word addiction,
- 23:29so they could talk about what they were trying
- 23:31to accomplish with getting more hours and more
- 23:36viewership on their platforms, but they didn't
- 23:40want to use that word. I think that testimony
- 23:44might have created the impression that they knew
- 23:46something was potentially off and they didn't
- 23:49want to create a stir. And he also testified
- 23:54that Meta made safety features opt in instead
- 23:59of opt out. So you had to actually go in and
- 24:03change your settings in order to implement some
- 24:06of the safety features, even if you're a kid,
- 24:09as opposed to those being automatic and then
- 24:13you had needing to opt out. They also called
- 24:17YouTube's VP of Engineering, his name is Christos
- 24:21Goodrow, and he had to authenticate a lot of
- 24:25documents that probably made him uncomfortable
- 24:29to talk about because there were internal documents
- 24:33from YouTube where they talked about creating
- 24:37an attention casino. Some of these documents
- 24:42spoke about their goals to increase Watch hours
- 24:46and. That there there platforms rely on. Call
- 24:54rely on advertising. That happens while people
- 24:59are watching the platforms so they need each
- 25:02you know that they're going to get more advertising
- 25:05impressions. The more people watch the more watch
- 25:10hours they have so they had these goals about
- 25:12increasing watch hours. And one of the recommendations
- 25:18that YouTube employees were discussing internally
- 25:21that apparently got a lot of approval at YouTube
- 25:25was the idea of Kids Tube to get more kids to
- 25:30go onto the platform. And an internal memo said,
- 25:34we'll jump through the legal hoops to make it
- 25:36happen. potentially creating the impression to
- 25:39the jury that they knew or were negligent to
- 25:44the possibility that there was some harm that
- 25:47could arise from getting more kids on a platform,
- 25:50especially if they're working so hard to make
- 25:53the platform more attention grabbing and potentially
- 25:55more addictive. And then other documents that
- 26:00Mr. Goodrow authenticated spoke about nighttime
- 26:09autoplay and That YouTube opposed disabling nighttime
- 26:15autoplay. So, you know, if you have if you watch
- 26:18one YouTube video It's not just gonna stop and
- 26:20let you click on the next YouTube video It's
- 26:22gonna show you the next one right away and then
- 26:24the one after that and the one after that They
- 26:27had the ability to stop that at nighttime and
- 26:30the document showed that that could have restored
- 26:33kids asleep like given basically 9 ,000 hours
- 26:36of kids sleep back and made it so that kids would
- 26:40sleep better, but that YouTube kind of opposed
- 26:44changing its platform to disable that autoplay
- 26:50feature at nighttime. The testimony also showed
- 26:55that Meta knew that many users were under 13
- 26:57years old and that Meta was kind of too tracking.
- 27:01Basically, that Meta was Some of the testimony
- 27:07was that Meta was designing these features to
- 27:11become more addictive for everyone. And at the
- 27:14same time knew that a lot of its users were very
- 27:18young. And so the inferences that they should
- 27:22have known that some of these young users might
- 27:25be affected or even affected more adversely than
- 27:29older users by the features that they were working
- 27:33so hard to implement. OK, so go ahead. We can
- 27:36go ahead. What were the design features at issue?
- 27:42There were a lot of them. And I think this is
- 27:44a really important point legally for the appeal.
- 27:48And I'll get to that in a second. I was proud
- 27:51of my infinite scroll graphic here. I don't know
- 27:53if anyone has read Infinite Jest. But Infinite
- 27:57Jest was so prescient because it's about this
- 28:02exact issue. of basically the company's creation
- 28:07of a video that was just so compelling that you
- 28:12can't stop watching it. It was addictive to the
- 28:15extreme. And I thought it was so fitting that
- 28:18here, one of the features that's at issue is
- 28:20infinite scroll. So I had to kind of modify the
- 28:24infinite jest book cover and turn it into infinite
- 28:27scroll. So the design features, I've listed them
- 28:31here. The legal point that I'd like to make is
- 28:37that the argument was not that any one feature
- 28:42by itself was addictive, but that these features
- 28:46were designed in combination to work altogether
- 28:49to create addiction. And so it wasn't just the
- 28:53push notifications, it wasn't just the infinite
- 28:55scroll, but you might get a push notification
- 28:58on your phone that tells you to go on and see
- 29:03who's posted on your feed. And then once you
- 29:05get there, you have an infinite scroll feature
- 29:08that just keeps you looking, looking, looking.
- 29:11And probably most adults have experienced this
- 29:13for themselves that, you know, I know I have
- 29:17where you start looking at your LinkedIn or whatever.
- 29:20And even though it's professional content, you
- 29:23just are looking at the next clip and you're
- 29:25like, why am I doing this? So that's kind of
- 29:28the the argument was that these features combine
- 29:33to create liability. And I'll just mention on
- 29:38the push notification specifically, we're kind
- 29:40of one of these features where there was an intermittent
- 29:43variable response, where every push notification
- 29:47you get on your phone to log on to Instagram
- 29:52or whatever, it might not show you something
- 29:59it might not notify you of something you want
- 30:04to see the most every single time. But if it
- 30:08notifies you of something you find really compelling
- 30:10every 10 times, then you'll always want to look
- 30:14and see if it's giving you that kind of compelling
- 30:17notification. And the same for refreshes on the.
- 30:22on the pages. When you refresh, it's not necessarily
- 30:25giving you the thing that you will like the most
- 30:29every single time. But if you don't know when
- 30:32you're going to get the thing you like the most,
- 30:34then you will continually refresh and refresh
- 30:37and refresh to see if you get it. So we can go
- 30:41to the next slide. Where is this case headed?
- 30:45This is my prediction. I think I have it on pretty
- 30:48good. authority that this is where it's going
- 30:51to go. So, you know, the California Court of
- 30:54Appeal, it's in this case is coming up from the
- 30:57LA Superior Court. So it's going to go to the
- 30:59second appellate district. The second appellate
- 31:03district has eight divisions. How do we know
- 31:06it's going to go to division two? Well, as I
- 31:10mentioned, the there have been a couple of other
- 31:14appeals in the same coordinated proceeding. there
- 31:18were some school districts that got knocked out
- 31:21and they've appealed. And so I think there have
- 31:23actually been maybe five appeals in this coordinated
- 31:27judicial council coordinated proceeding. They've
- 31:29all gone to division two. And that's not an accident
- 31:33because the second district actually has internal
- 31:36operating procedures. that say that when one
- 31:41division within the second district is assigned
- 31:43to an appeal from a case, that generally that
- 31:47same division is assigned to subsequent appeals
- 31:50arising from the same case. So this case is unique.
- 31:55There are so many potential appeals arising from
- 31:58it that, you know, of course, if they all went
- 32:00to division two, that would overwhelm that division.
- 32:03But the fact that these other appeals have gone
- 32:06to Division 2 and that the court generally sends
- 32:09appeals from the same case to the same division
- 32:11makes me think it's very likely that this one
- 32:14will also go to Division 2. And it's kind of
- 32:20an interesting division for this to be going
- 32:23to because you have two justices, Louis and Chavez,
- 32:28who have been there for quite a while. who maybe
- 32:31have more of a track record where you can look
- 32:33up how they've ruled. You have two other justices,
- 32:37Richardson and Gorvich, who were appointed very
- 32:40recently. Gorvich, like very recently, within
- 32:44the last couple months, I think. So we don't
- 32:48have much of a track record to look up for him.
- 32:52For Justice Richardson, really the same. And
- 32:57also a lot of these issues the issues that we're
- 33:01gonna talk about more substantively in the next
- 33:04slides, they often arise in federal court. And
- 33:08so you have a lot of federal opinions that have
- 33:11come into play. There isn't a lot of track record
- 33:13to be considering these issues in state court.
- 33:16And so I think that kind of makes it interesting
- 33:18when you have state court judges ruling on these
- 33:22constitutional questions and federal law questions.
- 33:28We'll see what Division 2 has to say about all
- 33:32of this. In my experience, Division 2 usually
- 33:37does not issue a tentative ruling. So we're going
- 33:40to have to wait and see what they say. I think
- 33:42the argument itself will show a lot. Just from
- 33:47also from experience. it seems like in state
- 33:51court the oral arguments, the justices have a
- 33:54very good idea of how they're going to rule before
- 33:56the oral argument takes place. And so it's kind
- 33:59of maddening as an appellate advocate to get
- 34:03up there and you know pretty quickly, you usually
- 34:08know pretty quickly where they're headed because
- 34:11they've pretty much made up their minds. Can
- 34:15they be persuaded? Yes, they definitely can be,
- 34:20but especially part of in the state court system,
- 34:23there's a 90 day rule where just as in the trial
- 34:27courts, the courts of appeal have to issue their
- 34:29opinions within 90 days of the case being submitted.
- 34:33And so if the case is submitted at argument,
- 34:34they have to get that opinion out very quickly,
- 34:37which usually means that they have to work up
- 34:39the opinion before the argument in order to be
- 34:42able to meet that 90 day deadline. So as a result,
- 34:45often the opinions are pretty well thought through
- 34:49before the argument. So I think the argument
- 34:51here is going to be very telling. I'll just give
- 34:54you a quick idea of the timeline. In California,
- 34:58appeals can take easily one to two years. That's
- 35:03fairly typical, at least a year. I would assume
- 35:06that the parties are going to be proceeding quickly
- 35:09with this but then again there are other moving
- 35:12parts they're considering their national litigation
- 35:14strategy and so they if it seems like they might
- 35:18get a better ruling from a different court on
- 35:20the same issues perhaps they'll try to slow play
- 35:22this appeal to pursue their arguments in a different
- 35:26court and maybe try to build more precedent in
- 35:29the meantime that will help them with this appeal
- 35:31or maybe they'll try to fast track this appeal
- 35:35i don't i don't know but they the attorneys will
- 35:38be thinking about all of those big picture kind
- 35:41of strategic choices as they as they move forward.
- 35:46All right we can go on to the next slide. Okay
- 35:49so this is the we're going to get into some of
- 35:53the the legal issues and what the big picture
- 35:57question here the question that juries are going
- 35:59to be asked if if this case is is allowed to
- 36:03go forward legally then juries will be asked
- 36:07when does a design feature become so compelling
- 36:10that it's addictive? And that, if that's a fact
- 36:16question, so it goes to a jury to decide, well,
- 36:20you know, is this, was this just really good
- 36:25platform design so that people really wanted
- 36:29to go see what was on the platform or did it
- 36:34cross the threshold into addiction so that People
- 36:38really had no choice once they started on the
- 36:40platform. They just had to keep coming back You
- 36:43know, that's gonna involve that expert testimony
- 36:46and disputed factual Questions and so that's
- 36:50why the companies are trying so hard to turn
- 36:53this into a legal Dispute because if that's a
- 36:57fact question of well, you know Was it really
- 37:00addictive or did it fall below or beyond the
- 37:03addiction threshold? then These cases there's
- 37:07going to be a lot of these cases There will potentially
- 37:10be a lot of settlements the company's behavior
- 37:13might change Because they will I mean from the
- 37:18plaintiff's perspective. They'll be a lot more
- 37:20cautious, but from their perspective They might
- 37:22say well we have we have to make really You know
- 37:26we have to change how we are presenting information
- 37:29on our platforms to try to make them less compelling
- 37:35because of the risk that if we make them too
- 37:37good and make people want to go on too much,
- 37:40that we'll get sued for that. So that's kind
- 37:43of the complication and why it's so important
- 37:47for them to win on the legal issues and not let
- 37:50this become a factual issue, a factual kind of
- 37:54dispute that goes to jury. We can go on to the
- 38:01next slide, please. Okay, so these potential
- 38:05appellate issues, these are kind of the big picture
- 38:07issues that I pulled from the post trial briefing.
- 38:11Number one is kind of the most salient and the
- 38:16main focus for the social media companies. And
- 38:20that is, are these design features protected?
- 38:24And they've argued for protection under two sources
- 38:27of law. One is section 230, of the Communications
- 38:32Decency Act. And then the second is the First
- 38:35Amendment. And those are we're going to talk
- 38:39in more detail about both of those laws. But
- 38:43a lot of the other appellate issues are basically
- 38:48different ways of packaging the Section 230 and
- 38:52the First Amendment argument. So number three
- 38:56on here, overly generalized jury instructions
- 38:58in verdict form. that the issues about the jury
- 39:03instructions and verdict form derived from whether
- 39:07they appropriately instructed the jury about
- 39:10Section 230 on the First Amendment. So a lot
- 39:13of this is going to come down to those two legal
- 39:16issues. And the reason why it's important for
- 39:20the companies to focus on those is that if they
- 39:23win, then they accomplish the business model
- 39:26objectives that that I mentioned at the beginning
- 39:29are so important to them. Because if the design
- 39:33of these features can't be grounds for a lawsuit,
- 39:38then they have more discretion to design their
- 39:42platforms as they want. And so that's why, even
- 39:46though they raised other issues in their post
- 39:48-traumotions, like insufficient evidence to support
- 39:50the verdict, that's going to be, there are two
- 39:53reasons they probably won't want to pursue that
- 39:55on appeal. I don't think they'll pursue it at
- 39:58all. But if they do, it'll be a very minor point.
- 40:02And the reasons are that it's not going to help
- 40:07with their business model issues. And also, it's
- 40:12a more discretionary standard of review. The
- 40:16Section 230 and First Amendment questions are
- 40:18pure legal issues. And so those get an independent
- 40:21de novo standard of review, which is the most
- 40:24favorable standard for an appeal. versus the
- 40:28insufficient evidence to support the verdict,
- 40:29that's going to be reviewed under a substantial
- 40:33evidence standard. And as long as there was some
- 40:37quality evidence, it's not a matter of comparing
- 40:40who has more evidence than the other. Do you
- 40:42have more evidence than they do? It's a matter
- 40:45of, is there enough evidence that could lead
- 40:49the jury to come to the conclusion that it did?
- 40:52assuming that it believed KGM's version of that
- 40:55evidence. And so that's just a hard, that's going
- 40:58to be a hard argument for them to win. And they
- 41:00don't care as much about that as they do not
- 41:04having the follow on cases. It's, you know, in
- 41:06a typical appeal, you have, it's a lot about
- 41:09these parties and getting a reversal. You can
- 41:13get it, you want to get it however, however you
- 41:15can. But in this appeal, it's a lot more about
- 41:19the precedent from Section 230 in the First Amendment,
- 41:23if neither of those sources of law blocks lawsuits
- 41:27like this, then you have that kind of floodgates
- 41:30problem potentially for the companies. And then
- 41:37you have other evidentiary issues. That's number
- 41:41four here, inclusion of evidence that caused
- 41:44liability for protected conduct. That also comes
- 41:48down to Well, evidentiary issues are normally
- 41:52under evidentiary rulings are normally under
- 41:55an abuse of discretion standard because the trial
- 41:57court has a lot of discretion to to decide what
- 42:00evidence comes into the trial. But if it but
- 42:05then it could it could kind of brush up against
- 42:07legal issues that are reviewed independently.
- 42:09But again, those would be those would be issues
- 42:12arising from the Section 230 and First Amendment
- 42:14argument. So that's why those are so important.
- 42:17OK, we can go to the next slide. So I've kind
- 42:24of mentioned these are these are really where
- 42:26the rubber meets the road the section 230 and
- 42:28the First Amendment arguments I don't think we
- 42:31I kind of covered this on the last one So I say
- 42:33if you don't mind we can we can go on to the
- 42:35next one Okay, so this is important I mentioned
- 42:40before the general the verdict form The I'll
- 42:47say it this way the the plaintiff's argument
- 42:51was that these design features combined to create
- 42:55liability. As a result, the verdict form did
- 42:59not specify which feature caused the liability
- 43:04because the idea was the combination of the features
- 43:07caused the harm. That comes with risk for KGM
- 43:12because all the social media companies need to
- 43:17do is show that one of the features giving rise
- 43:22to liability qualifies for protection under section
- 43:26230 or the First Amendment and then the entire
- 43:29verdict crumbles because it was infected by the
- 43:35inclusion of some liability evidence or an issue
- 43:44that we know was part of the plaintiff's theory
- 43:47that really shouldn't have been because it qualifies
- 43:51for protection. And so I'm sure it was a balancing
- 43:56test because the plaintiff didn't want to, or
- 43:58rather a balance that they had to strike because
- 44:01although this type of verdict form creates some
- 44:04risk and helps out, in a sense, the social media
- 44:07companies, because all I need to show is that
- 44:10one design feature was unconstitutional or protected
- 44:14by Section 230. On the other hand, the plaintiff
- 44:19didn't want to get into every single design feature
- 44:22and ask the jury, well, does design feature A
- 44:25cause addiction? Does design feature B cause
- 44:27addiction? Because their theory was that it was
- 44:32an entire kind of landscape of features that
- 44:37work together to cause the harm. So we'll see.
- 44:41I think that that's going to be a major issue
- 44:44to watch legally for the appeal is whether, you
- 44:49know, whether this whether any one design feature
- 44:52and maybe because of this, we might even see
- 44:56meta and YouTube. arguing that, you know, kind
- 44:58of focusing on a couple of the design features
- 45:01to try to create a narrative that, like, look,
- 45:03the most compelling design feature for them,
- 45:05they might focus on that and not really talk
- 45:08about some of the other ones because all they
- 45:11need to show is one feature that's protected.
- 45:14OK, we can go to the next slide. All right. So
- 45:18we're going to talk about Section 230 in the
- 45:20First Amendment. I'll just caveat this by saying
- 45:25I'm an appellate specialist. I'm not an expert
- 45:28in Section 230 and the First Amendment. One thing
- 45:31I love about my job as an appellate specialist
- 45:33is that I'm a generalist, and I get to learn
- 45:36about all these different areas of the law. But
- 45:38I can't say that I'm an expert in Section 230
- 45:41and the First Amendment. So what I know, basically,
- 45:44is from reading the post trial briefing here,
- 45:49reading the earlier briefing in the case, the
- 45:51Demura order, and from reading some of the main
- 45:54cases. So I will walk you through some of the
- 45:56main cases and just generally what these areas
- 46:00of law stand for. So Section 230 was implemented
- 46:05by Congress around the time that the internet
- 46:08was starting. And the idea behind Section 230
- 46:13was to protect the development of the internet.
- 46:16by not making companies that host third party
- 46:21content or like internet platforms that host
- 46:23third party content liable as the publisher or
- 46:27speaker of the content. And that's the critical
- 46:29language in the statute that you're not liable
- 46:31as the publisher or speaker of the content. And
- 46:35so Meta and YouTube said, well, what is the substance
- 46:38of KGM's claim here? It's that She goes on meta
- 46:43and YouTube and watches third party content.
- 46:47And yeah, we're maybe the design features are
- 46:49compelling her to go look at it. But the harm
- 46:52that she's experiencing arises from the third
- 46:55party content. If there was no content there,
- 46:57there would be nothing for her to go see. So
- 47:00the issue became, well, is it enough to get section
- 47:05230 protection if the third party content is
- 47:08a but for cause if it's somewhere in the chain
- 47:11of causation of the plaintiff's harm. And Judge
- 47:14Kuhl throughout the case many, many times said
- 47:17that third party content being in the chain of
- 47:21causation somewhere is not enough to protect
- 47:26the companies under section 230. So we can go
- 47:28to the next slide. Judge Kuhl drew more of a
- 47:35connection to, this is a case called Lemon versus
- 47:37Snap. And in this case, it involved this speed
- 47:41filter where Snapchat had this feature where
- 47:45you could superimpose the speed that you were
- 47:52moving at as an image on top of whatever you
- 47:57were posting or whatever you were snapped. snapping,
- 48:00whatever they call it. So the court in Lemon,
- 48:04the Ninth Circuit said, you know, the liability
- 48:06here doesn't, although third -party content plays
- 48:10a role, because this has to do with posts and
- 48:17communicating the images, the liability arises
- 48:21from imposing the miles per hour on top of the
- 48:24image. And what happened in Lemon is that uh
- 48:30it was either a kid or a teenager unfortunately
- 48:34died in a car accident because and the allegation
- 48:37was that the speed feature the speed filter feature
- 48:41um encouraged him to drive recklessly because
- 48:44he was trying to get over 100 miles an hour to
- 48:47post and show his friends that hey look you know
- 48:49like look at the the what the filter showed i
- 48:51was doing so here you know one of the claims
- 48:54is that there was a beauty filter and And so
- 49:00then Judge Kuhl basically said, look, a beauty
- 49:03filter that causes anxiety because it modifies
- 49:06your appearance is something that the platforms
- 49:08create. It's not third party content. It's coming
- 49:12from the platforms themselves. And so the court
- 49:15said no but for causation. That's not enough.
- 49:19And I think that's probably right. there was
- 49:22actually a case out of Massachusetts called Commonwealth
- 49:25versus Metta, where the court basically agreed
- 49:28with that, with that idea that but for causation
- 49:34isn't enough. So we'll see, but I think that
- 49:38the Commonwealth versus Metta case from Massachusetts,
- 49:40it's the Massachusetts Supreme Court will probably
- 49:43be an important template for the California courts
- 49:47to look at when they're deciding these issues.
- 49:50So we can go to the next slide. All right. So
- 49:53then the question becomes, if but for causation
- 49:56isn't enough, then how much connection with content
- 50:00is necessary? Because the Snapchat feature, that
- 50:05was clear that that was a feature being superimposed.
- 50:10And the harm, it seems to me, very clear in lemon
- 50:17that the harm was coming from the feature itself.
- 50:20But here, it's more complicated because the content
- 50:25is more connected. And so you have to in order
- 50:28for the plaintiff's theory to really work out
- 50:31the the case has to arise from the design feature
- 50:36like from the design features, and not from the
- 50:39content of the third of the third parties posted.
- 50:43And so So that that kind of raises a complicated
- 50:48question of, okay, if but for cause isn't enough,
- 50:53then what what is enough? How much content needs
- 50:56to be involved? And there are cases like, for
- 50:58example, in dough one versus meta platforms.
- 51:03They alleged harm from these Rohingya posts,
- 51:08basically that Metta was prioritizing these toxic
- 51:12posts that were discriminatory against the Rohingya
- 51:15people. And the court said no, the court dismissed
- 51:18that case because promoting some posts over others
- 51:23is publishing conduct and Section 230 protects
- 51:26publication. And the court distinguished lemon
- 51:29and said, you know, that had to do with the feature,
- 51:32but this has to do with promoting content. But
- 51:35sometimes, you know, if if here, the way the
- 51:38content is promoted causes addiction, then it
- 51:42kind of asks the question of, well, is it was
- 51:46the harm really? coming from the content that
- 51:49she saw or was it coming from the feature that
- 51:52made her need to keep coming back? And Wozniak
- 51:54versus YouTube is another case where the, and
- 51:57this is, this is, I guess, particularly pertinent
- 51:59because it's from the California Court of Appeal.
- 52:02And there the court said that the harm arose
- 52:06from allowing harmful third party videos. Steve
- 52:10Wozniak was like a founder of Microsoft and people
- 52:13were using his image and fake videos to try to
- 52:16scam people and to get to like handing over money
- 52:21and like a fake kind of investment scheme. And
- 52:25the court said, yeah, that's coming from those
- 52:28third party videos. That seems pretty clear that
- 52:30the harm is coming from the videos, but here
- 52:32it's a little bit more in a gray area. Some language
- 52:37is kind of helpful for the social media companies,
- 52:39though, from Wozniak, is that the lawsuit was
- 52:44seeking to hold them liable for exercising a
- 52:47publisher's traditional editorial functions,
- 52:50such as deciding whether to publish, withdraw,
- 52:52postpone, or alter content. That makes it seem
- 52:57like if what they're doing is publishing, maybe
- 52:59they're just really good at attention grabbing
- 53:02publication and not over the line. And we can't
- 53:06ask this question of whether they're over the
- 53:09line to the point where it's causing addiction.
- 53:12OK, we can go to the next slide. All right, so
- 53:16this is what I was basically saying. Judge Kuhl
- 53:18saw the features as features like in Lemon, the
- 53:22same as a as the speed feature versus Doe 1 might
- 53:28suggest that if what we're talking about is promoting
- 53:31attention -grabbing posts, that's not really
- 53:33a feature that is content publication, and that's
- 53:36protected by Section 230. But I do think that
- 53:38this Massachusetts case that basically says,
- 53:41no, no, it doesn't really matter what the content
- 53:44is. The point is they designed an algorithm that
- 53:47keeps you coming back no matter what you're looking
- 53:48at, then that starts to look a little bit more
- 53:51like a feature. OK, go ahead. Okay, so then we're
- 53:56getting into the First Amendment, which is the
- 53:58next big legal point. And Judge Kuehl said, look,
- 54:01this is not, the features are not their expression.
- 54:04They were saying, well, the features are a form
- 54:07of how we express ourselves. So they're protected
- 54:10by the First Amendment. And Judge Kuehl, in her
- 54:13order denying the demurrer, said, no, the features
- 54:17are more like the actual physical book that words
- 54:21are published in, not like the words themselves.
- 54:24So then it creates a question, OK, well, what
- 54:27if something that we see as, what if some content
- 54:32that is just traditional First Amendment -protected
- 54:36content like the New York Times comes in an addictive
- 54:39format, like if the New York Times came up with
- 54:42a way to deliver the news through newspapers
- 54:45laced with drugs or through a slot machine type
- 54:49of delivery mechanism, which I mean, the New
- 54:51York Times has its app, what if it adopts some
- 54:54of the same design features that have caused
- 54:58so many watch hours for these social media companies?
- 55:04Is that going to be getting closer to the addiction
- 55:07sphere? So Judge Kuehl said no. Judge Kuehl said
- 55:10this is really about the features, not about
- 55:12the content. Go ahead. Our likes speech, you
- 55:18know, one of the one of the arguments. I mean,
- 55:20if I were the social media companies, I might
- 55:22really focus on the likes issue because you have
- 55:24a Ninth Circuit case just recently that held
- 55:27that like counts are expressive. And so they
- 55:31are. They do qualify for the First Amendment.
- 55:34But Judge Kuhl said, this is not about seeing
- 55:37the like count. It's about the design of the
- 55:40feature that caused, the design of the likes
- 55:43feature that caused the harm. But how can you
- 55:47design a likes feature that is disconnected from
- 55:51the likes count? And so there could be some,
- 55:55a needle to thread with the ninth circuit or
- 55:57else if there's an issue that's raised. If a
- 56:00dispute arises with the Ninth Circuit, then a
- 56:03higher court is going to need to review it. Okay,
- 56:06you can go ahead. And then there's this issue
- 56:09of content moderation. And that I think is probably
- 56:12a bigger, stronger argument for the social media
- 56:15companies. The Supreme Court recently held in
- 56:18this moody case that the social media companies
- 56:22do have discretion to choose content and order
- 56:26and organize it. So is what's happening here
- 56:29a way of organizing content or is it, or regardless
- 56:35of the content, is it an addictive feature? And
- 56:38so that, that is, that's going to be this first
- 56:42amendment question because it's, are they just
- 56:45really good at showing you stuff you want to
- 56:46see? Or when you're talking about intermittent
- 56:49variable rewards, they don't even care necessarily
- 56:52about showing you stuff you want to see every
- 56:54time. They're just trying to get your eyeballs
- 56:56on the screen. Is that is that a feature and
- 56:58not really the same as like making a content
- 57:01based choice about what to show you? Go ahead.
- 57:04Okay, so that this is basically the same, you
- 57:11know, this is a different case that stands for
- 57:13the same kind of proposition. Go ahead. So The
- 57:19one hurdle for Meta and YouTube is that they
- 57:22didn't actually put on evidence about how their
- 57:24algorithm works. So if they're going to make
- 57:26the argument that we were really just trying
- 57:29to display content and choosing how that content
- 57:31is displayed, so what? We use a machine to do
- 57:34it. We use an algorithm process to do it. But
- 57:37that just makes us better at displaying content
- 57:40than other companies. They didn't show how the
- 57:46algorithm works so that there's not that much
- 57:48evidence in the record for them to be able to
- 57:49make that argument. And the court admonished
- 57:53the jury not to consider content. And so that
- 57:56might have mitigated any harm from them potentially
- 58:01considering content as part of the liability
- 58:04determination. OK, go ahead. OK, and we only
- 58:10have a few minutes left. So I'm going to I'm
- 58:12going to just say quickly the the. The court
- 58:16in the Demer ruling did rely on this Rowan case
- 58:19about basically that you have the right as a
- 58:22homeowner to decide not to get certain mail,
- 58:26like to not get obscene mail delivered to your
- 58:28house. And so the court said that basically this
- 58:32if the plaintiffs were correct, then. Then it's
- 58:37similar to Rowan because the plaintiff didn't
- 58:39have a real choice to avoid the content. And
- 58:42the First Amendment allows consumers to avoid
- 58:46having content brought to them, harmful content.
- 58:49And so the court compared it to this Rowan case.
- 58:52OK, Jose. And then does the verdict burden adult
- 58:58access? There was a case recently, FSC versus
- 59:01Paxton, where the court kind of applied a different
- 59:06standard to minors and basically accepted the
- 59:11fact that that case involved content and maybe
- 59:15would burden adults. It had to do with obscene
- 59:18content online. And there was a law saying, look,
- 59:23if you have a website with that kind of content
- 59:26on it, then you need to make sure that people
- 59:28going into your website are over 18 years old.
- 59:31And the court said, yeah, that's burdensome on
- 59:33adults who are over 18 needing to click a button
- 59:36to say that they are allowed to enter the site.
- 59:40But it did a balancing test under intermediate
- 59:43scrutiny compared to the harm potentially from
- 59:47kids going into a site like that and said, we're
- 59:51going to allow this age -gating law. So the platforms
- 59:55here said age -gating. would burden adults access.
- 59:59In other words, if we had to put a kind of click
- 1:00:02here to confirm your over 18 thing before you
- 1:00:05go on to Instagram, that would make it harder
- 1:00:09for adults to go onto the site. But the fact
- 1:00:13that this FSC versus Paxton case said that, yeah,
- 1:00:16okay, maybe a little bit burdensome, but overall,
- 1:00:19because we're talking about kids, it will allow
- 1:00:22that type of burden. then maybe that will come
- 1:00:25into play here and then we might see a more favorable
- 1:00:27standard for kids. Okay, go ahead. So as I said
- 1:00:32before, if it goes to Division 2, we don't know
- 1:00:34much. I did some research about Division 2's
- 1:00:37track record on these issues and there's not
- 1:00:39much. They decided like one unpublished case
- 1:00:42applying Section 230, but it was very straightforward,
- 1:00:46had to do with content and didn't get into the
- 1:00:51complications that this case poses. And then
- 1:00:55I haven't seen any citations to some of the big
- 1:00:59recent First Amendment cases that will probably
- 1:01:03come into play. So we're kind of operating on
- 1:01:05a blank slate for Division 2, if that's where
- 1:01:08it goes, which makes it exciting to watch, but
- 1:01:11harder to predict. OK, go ahead. And as I mentioned
- 1:01:16before, and then we'll wrap it up, there's a
- 1:01:19This is what's at stake here. If KGM wins, you
- 1:01:23open the floodgates to addictive design litigation.
- 1:01:27You probably cause the platforms to become a
- 1:01:30lot more cautious about how they're designing
- 1:01:32their algorithms and maybe test them more to
- 1:01:35see if they're going to cause addiction in kids.
- 1:01:39On the other hand, if Meta and YouTube win, they
- 1:01:44will have immunity and maybe will even make their
- 1:01:47their platforms more addictive to kids because
- 1:01:50there's nothing we can do about it. And so, you
- 1:01:54know, I think the court of appeal cares a lot
- 1:01:55about the policy behind the rules that they adopt.
- 1:01:59And it seems to me the court's going to want
- 1:02:02to adopt a rule that balances these potential
- 1:02:07harms and doesn't just, you know, I think that
- 1:02:12it would be, if they just had blanket immunity
- 1:02:14to create addictive design features for kids,
- 1:02:17I think that that would probably be a hard policy
- 1:02:20for the Court of Appeal to swallow. But at the
- 1:02:23same time, they need to come up with a way to
- 1:02:25protect First Amendment rights and uphold Section
- 1:02:29230.