Latest / Kentuckiana's Morning News Early Edition w/Scott Fitzgerald / Dr. Charles Pemberton on Conversion Therapy
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 2: Good morning.
- 0:00Speaker 1: I'm Tony Cruz News Radio eight forty WHJS well House
- 0:04Billed four ninety five that has been brought to the
- 0:07forefront with the Representative David Hale, Republican from Wellington, is
- 0:12a primary sponsor of this bill that wants to protect
- 0:15what's called conversion therapy. It's been controversial for a while,
- 0:19or you could say conversion or reparative therapy. So doctor
- 0:23Charles Pemmerton is going to join us today because he
- 0:26is a counselor in his own right with the dimension
- 0:29Family Therapy, Louisville DFT dot com. And you know, Charles,
- 0:33this is a religious issue for many people. It's a
- 0:35social issue for many people. It's a scientific issue for
- 0:40some other people. I mean, you know, name name, whatever.
- 0:45The different levels of life are. And this has been
- 0:50a controversial disagreement by a lot of people on both
- 0:54sides of the fence here.
- 0:57Speaker 2: You're right, you're right. And I thought about, you know
- 0:59that this topic today, and I thought, what could be
- 1:01worse than talking about tariffs. Hey, let's talk about conversion therapy.
- 1:06That's about some more people up so, you know, so
- 1:11let let's talk a little bit about the House bill
- 1:13and so everyone needs to know that for all of
- 1:17the major therapy groups, marriage and family, social work, clinical counselors,
- 1:26all of them have a licensing board in the state
- 1:29of Kentucky, so that if something happens to you or
- 1:33a loved one through therapy and someone does something wrong,
- 1:38you can contact this board and say, hey, I think
- 1:40they did something wrong, and the board will is there
- 1:43to protect the public. Those boards aren't there to protect us.
- 1:47My licensing board doesn't protect me. My licensing board is
- 1:51really there for the to protect everyone else from me
- 1:55and therapist. So the first thing that's concerning about this
- 2:00this house bill is now they're saying, well, this type
- 2:04of therapy or this topic, now, this area that you
- 2:09might be working with, we're taking it out of the
- 2:11hands of all the licensing boards. The licensing boards will
- 2:15not have a say or have any authority over that. Well,
- 2:19that's concerning because if you go to someone and they
- 2:23do something wrong and it is in this area gender
- 2:28and sexual identity and identity possibly in general, there is
- 2:35no authority to protect you as part of the public.
- 2:39That always concerns me. I'm not saying the boards get
- 2:42it all right, but they serve as that protection from
- 2:45the public, and now there's not that that entity to
- 2:50protect you. Go on, So that's go ahead. I'm sorry,
- 2:53I was gonna say. So, that's one issue of this
- 2:56bill that is, like, you know, this should concern the
- 2:58public because there's not we're taking away that protection from you.
- 3:02Speaker 1: All right, Describe what conversion therapy means as you've seen it.
- 3:08Speaker 2: Okay, So conversion therapy has a lot of different aspects,
- 3:13but the basic principle is any type of therapy talk therapy,
- 3:20medical therapy, surgical therapy that works to alter a person's identity,
- 3:28more specifically their gender identity or their sexual identity, meaning
- 3:35whether they see themselves as more male or female or
- 3:39a combination gender, or whether they see themselves as being
- 3:44attracted to someone of the same sex, different sex, both sexes.
- 3:49Those are the in broad strokes here. Those are the
- 3:53identities that conversion therapy works with, and it looks to
- 3:56bring those into more of what we call a cist gender,
- 4:00which is identifying with your birth sex, and then more
- 4:05of a heterosexual sexuality, meaning attraction to the opposite sex.
- 4:12All conversion therapies work on that premise, whether it's surgery
- 4:17or drugs or hypnosis, all of them work to make
- 4:21that change.
- 4:22Speaker 1: There are people saying, right now, I'm the parent, I
- 4:25should have my rights to send my child to the
- 4:28therapist that I want. What do you.
- 4:30Speaker 2: Say, Well, and I agree with that. I go back
- 4:34to all that that therapist still needs to have someone
- 4:37guiding them and have authority over them. But I also
- 4:40say that, well, we need to respect where a lot
- 4:45of the science goes, and we go back to for sexuality,
- 4:51homosexuality was taken off the table as a disorder back
- 4:58in nineteen seventy three. So seventy three is when the
- 5:04organizations said, yeah, that's not a that's not a that's
- 5:08not something that someone's broke on, and these are these
- 5:13have continued for that long and now we've put gender
- 5:17in it. But I think we have to be respectful
- 5:20of those people that for the experts in this field,
- 5:25and it's not just one we're not saying it's just
- 5:27the Psychological Association. Every organization has said this doesn't work.
- 5:35But more importantly, the studies have shown it makes it
- 5:40worse for people, So you could actually be making it
- 5:43worse for your child.
- 5:44Speaker 1: People say sexuality is a nature nurture situation. In your
- 5:48professional experience, what have you seen?
- 5:51Speaker 2: You know? I think, as always it's never an easy,
- 5:55you know, white or black, this or that type of answer.
- 5:58I think that there's a whole lot of things that
- 6:00go into developing our identity and gender and sexual is
- 6:06one of those identities. It is not only chemical, we
- 6:10know all sorts of neurochemicals go into that, but yes,
- 6:14life life experience can go into that trauma as well
- 6:19as good things can go into that. There's a lot
- 6:23of things that happen there. I think we want to
- 6:26have that easy answer of thing, well it is this,
- 6:30but rarely is it just one thing.
- 6:33Speaker 1: What's been your experience when you've talked to patients who
- 6:35come to you and they're concerned about their sexuality, how
- 6:39do you deal with that?
- 6:40Speaker 2: Yeah? You know, when I deal with that, I always
- 6:42back up and I look first of all at that
- 6:44general identity issue of well, who how do you see yourself?
- 6:48And are you happy with where you are? And if
- 6:52you're not satisfied with with who you see yourself as well,
- 6:58then what are the options that you have before you
- 7:01to make those changes. It's not a matter of me
- 7:05judging them. I look at it the same way as
- 7:07as somebody says, you know, I want to be a plumber.
- 7:09I'm like, well, that's a stupid job. Why would you
- 7:11want to be a plumber? And I try to divert
- 7:14them from being a plumber to being an electrician. I
- 7:16would never do that. So it becomes well, you if
- 7:20your father wants you to be a plumber and you
- 7:22don't want to be a plumber, well, what are your options?
- 7:25Can you talk about that? Are there other things that
- 7:28you can do? What is it about being a plumber
- 7:30that you don't like? Are there can you be a plumber?
- 7:33But change those things? It's the same way for me
- 7:36with any identity issue that someone comes to me with.
- 7:39Speaker 1: There has been a lot of talk and some other
- 7:44some others in your profession, particularly in England and others
- 7:47have changed their minds on kids and their sexual identity.
- 7:51What are your thoughts about the formation of that and
- 7:54when kids want surgery and their moms or dad want
- 7:57to or both, obviously we want to comply with what
- 8:00their children want at twelve or thirteen years old.
- 8:04Speaker 2: Well, and that is a situation where I think exploring
- 8:07some of those is definitely needed. Being open to listening
- 8:12to your child is definitely needed. But I think we
- 8:15have to be very careful when we start making changes
- 8:19in someone's life that are ultimately permanent or have permanent effects.
- 8:24Now I believe that not only with some of these therapies,
- 8:28but I believe that with some of you know, medications
- 8:31for ADHD and all sorts of other things as well.
- 8:35I'm not saying don't do it. I'm saying we have
- 8:38to be very careful with all of those. We also
- 8:42know that neurologically, a person's brain is not developed until
- 8:49they're in their mid sometimes late twenties. So we have
- 8:53to be cognizant of the fact that what a child wants,
- 8:57what an adolescent wants right now may not be what
- 9:03they ultimately want in life.
- 9:06Speaker 1: Whether that's a job or what, oh, your phone's breaking
- 9:09up here a little bit, Whether it's.
- 9:11Speaker 2: Whether that's whether it's you know, the job they want
- 9:14or a school or even a tattoo. We have to
- 9:17sometimes slow that down and let all of their bodies develop.
- 9:23The problem is is that with some of the gender
- 9:25blocking issues, we if we don't block them early, then
- 9:31it's even harder to make that change. We are seeing,
- 9:34unfortunately a lot of regret with people, meaning they've made
- 9:38those changes than they wish they didn't, and we have
- 9:41to weigh that in on that scientific outcome.
- 9:45Speaker 1: Appreciate your time, Charles, thanks as always for joining us,
- 9:48and we'll talk again a couple of weeks.
- 9:50Speaker 2: All right, Thank you very much, Dony all right
- 9:52Speaker 1: Charles Pemberton, Dimension Family Therapy, LOUISVILLEDFT dot com contact canasweren
- 9:56news more coming your way, sports with John Alden's next