Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Cybersecurity and AI: What Attorneys Should Know About Protecting Information from Breaches and Social Engineering
Transcript
- 0:03Thank you, everybody, for joining us. I'm Christina
- 0:05Toussaint. I'm the chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:07Bar Association Privacy and Cybersecurity Law
- 0:10Section. We have a great panel ahead of us today,
- 0:13and I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:15Mark Evans and Tracy Wilkerson. Tracy Wilkerson
- 0:18is a senior managing director at FTI Consulting,
- 0:21and she has more than 20 years of experience
- 0:23spanning cybersecurity, national security, litigation,
- 0:26and complex investigations. As a former federal
- 0:29prosecutor, she previously served as a U .S.
- 0:32attorney for the Central District of California
- 0:33after more than two decades as an assistant U
- 0:36.S. attorney, where she oversaw some of the nation's
- 0:39most significant cybercrime, fraud, and public
- 0:41corruption matters. At FTI Consulting, she advises
- 0:44clients on high -stakes cybersecurity challenges,
- 0:46regulatory matters, and complex forensic investigations
- 0:49worldwide. We also have Mark Evans, who is a
- 0:53cyber crimes and fraud detective, a certified
- 0:55fraud examiner, and the founder of Fraud Hero,
- 0:57where he provides training and education to financial
- 1:00institutions, businesses, law enforcement, and
- 1:03senior communities. He has investigated cyber
- 1:06and fraud related crimes and has been in law
- 1:08enforcement for over 13 years. These investigations
- 1:11have included social engineering, ransomware,
- 1:14credit card fraud, money laundering, identity
- 1:16theft, among various other forms of fraud crimes.
- 1:19His investigations have uncovered multiple methodologies
- 1:22used by criminals, as well as many arrests, convictions,
- 1:25and recovery of millions in lost funds and assets.
- 1:28Now let's get started. So I'm going to open up
- 1:33the panel and introduce our panelists who we're
- 1:35really excited to have here. And we're really
- 1:38I mean, I think this is really an extremely important
- 1:41topic that is really on the minds of so many
- 1:45consumers and businesses these days. I mean,
- 1:47recent reports are showing identity theft losses
- 1:51topping as much as $12 .7 billion in 2024. The
- 1:55FTC has talked about having over 1 .1 million
- 1:59reports of identity theft, and that's for people
- 2:01who know to report to the FTC's identity theft.
- 2:05resource center. And of course, with the advent
- 2:08of AI, there's lots of opportunity for new and
- 2:12more creative and more sophisticated scams. So
- 2:16I think let's just sort of start out by kind
- 2:19of directing the questions to Mark in this space.
- 2:23You've been working in the fraud and social engineering
- 2:25space for some time. Can you talk to us about
- 2:28what you do in your current position and the
- 2:30types of matters you work on in your role, as
- 2:32well as what you're doing in your role with Fraud
- 2:34Hero? No, absolutely. Thank you. Thanks for the
- 2:37introduction, too. I'm glad to be here. I want
- 2:39to thank the Barely Hills Bar Association for
- 2:41having me and inviting me. This is really awesome.
- 2:45But thank you to my career, my intro. I've done
- 2:47more than half my career. as a detective in financial
- 2:50crimes and fraud and cybercrimes. I'm based out
- 2:52of Las Vegas, so I've seen in probably every
- 2:55type of fraud and cybercrime fraud you can think
- 2:58of. Whatever happens here stays here. That's
- 3:01not true. Not when it comes to fraud. But so
- 3:09I spent more than half my career dealing with
- 3:11just financial crimes and fraud. So I investigated
- 3:13money laundering and bezel mints. Identity theft,
- 3:18credit card fraud, check fraud, you name it,
- 3:19I dealt with it. I did that for six years. Through
- 3:22the six years I did training. So I trained casinos,
- 3:25I trained businesses, hotels, you name it. And
- 3:27then I switched over to cyber crimes about a
- 3:29year ago, which is a very good segue because
- 3:33fraud and cyber crimes kind of go hand in hand.
- 3:36And so now what I do with cyber crimes is I investigate
- 3:38things more along the line of cryptocurrency
- 3:40and network intrusions, ransomware. these malware
- 3:46attacks that you're seeing in a lot, a lot of
- 3:48social engineering. So I would say the majority
- 3:51of the cases I get involve some form of social
- 3:54engineering. And so that's on the forefront of
- 3:56my mind all the time. Fantastic. Tracy, we'll
- 4:00turn it to you. You were a formerly US attorney.
- 4:03And can you talk to us about the issues you saw
- 4:05in your role there related to cyber crimes, those
- 4:10types of issues, and then talk about where you
- 4:11are in your current position? Yeah, absolutely.
- 4:14And again, I also echo Mark's thanks for having
- 4:18us. I'm really excited to be here. So while I
- 4:21was in the U .S. Attorney's Office, I was in
- 4:22the cyber crime section for many years starting
- 4:24in 2011. And we saw a real evolution of cyber
- 4:30crime into something that was incredibly sophisticated
- 4:32and harder to fight. We saw the beginning of
- 4:36the business email compromise where, you know,
- 4:39you're either being hacked or your emails are
- 4:41being spoofed and it's being used to transfer
- 4:43money. We saw the evolution of ransomware and
- 4:47the rise of cybercrime as a means for nation
- 4:50states to steal money, to steal business information
- 4:55and to, you know, influence elections. And so
- 4:59one of our messages to businesses when I was
- 5:01in the cybercrime section was we needed to be
- 5:04a community sharing information like this and
- 5:07protecting each other. Now that I'm at FTI, I
- 5:11consult with companies and attorneys on a wide
- 5:14variety of cyber and privacy matters, anything
- 5:17from how to develop an incident response plan
- 5:20to how to implement privacy plans and response
- 5:24to various regulations like the CCPA and the
- 5:27bulk data role. Fantastic. And you know, I've
- 5:32been seeing some really terrible and sophisticated
- 5:36new sort of identity theft issues that are out
- 5:38there, which I'll talk about in a bit, but including
- 5:43those related to sort of SIM swapping and phone
- 5:45usage. But Mark, I wanna turn to you. What are
- 5:48you seeing in terms of social engineering threats
- 5:50and cyber threats? What are the latest? What
- 5:54are the latest trends you're seeing amongst criminals?
- 5:56I hate to put criminals in a, you know, what
- 5:59is their newest innovation, but I think we all
- 6:01know there are iterations and innovations that
- 6:04they come up with. What are you seeing on your
- 6:06end in terms of what's new and whole? A lot.
- 6:12I didn't answer the second part of your question
- 6:15from the first one, so I'm going to get to both
- 6:16of them. And that was with Fraud Hero. So I founded
- 6:20Fraud Hero. while I'm still working as a detective.
- 6:23And one of the main reasons I founded Fraud Hero
- 6:25was because as a detective, I would get a crime
- 6:28or get a scam. And by the time someone reported
- 6:30to me, it was too late. And so I got to a point
- 6:33to where I wanted to do something before the
- 6:36scam happened or before the crime happened. So
- 6:38I founded Fraud Hero with the goal of educating
- 6:40and training businesses, banks, law enforcement,
- 6:43and senior communities based on what I'm seeing,
- 6:45because I get to see. the entirety of a scam.
- 6:48I get to see it from beginning to end. So I talk
- 6:50to the victim. I talk to the criminals lots of
- 6:53times. I get to talk to the banks and the businesses.
- 6:56So I get to see kind of a full worldview of how
- 6:59that works. So with Fraud Hero, I definitely
- 7:02wanted to be able to put that education out to
- 7:04stop the scam before they start. But to answer
- 7:07your question about what am I seeing, it's very
- 7:11interesting because the tactics of The underlying
- 7:14tactic that criminals use to commit these crimes
- 7:17haven't changed. So think of it the sense we
- 7:19all know about the Nigerian Prince scam, right?
- 7:22Back in the day, you get the email, hey, I have
- 7:23a bunch of money and gold. I need you to help
- 7:25me out. That scam under the underlying scam hasn't
- 7:28changed. It's just evolved into more of a technological
- 7:32version of it. So now instead of it being a Nigerian
- 7:35Prince scam, now you have the romance scam or
- 7:37you have the investment scam where someone's
- 7:39saying, hey, I made a bunch of money. And, you
- 7:41know, I can teach you how to invest in these
- 7:43funds and all you have to do is send, you know,
- 7:46$50 ,000 worth of crypto to me and I'll show
- 7:48you how to do this. And the person sends the
- 7:51money and then all of a sudden they're on a fake
- 7:53platform that this criminal guided them to and
- 7:56they're depositing more funds just to try to
- 7:58get their money out. And before they realize
- 8:01they've actually deposited, you know, their life
- 8:03savings. and given it to this criminal, they've
- 8:07lost, you know, $500 ,000 million at a time.
- 8:11So the underlying social engineering isn't changing.
- 8:13You're still seeing phishing. You're seeing a
- 8:15lot of more phishing now, which is voice phishing
- 8:17with the phone calls. And when we think about
- 8:21phishing, a lot of people think about AI. I can
- 8:24tell you right now, AI, when it comes to phishing
- 8:26is not, they aren't going hand in hand that often.
- 8:29They do happen, but they're just generally calling
- 8:32and pretending to be someone of authority. They're
- 8:34pretending to be a lawyer, the detective, a firefighter,
- 8:38an IT expert, the CEO. They're just taking these
- 8:42positions of authority, and they're using that
- 8:44to then make the person believe that, hey, you
- 8:48can trust me, go along with what I'm going to
- 8:50say, and I'm going to show you the way. And that's
- 8:54one of the more detrimental tactics that I'm
- 8:56seeing nowadays. And I've seen the AI piece to
- 9:01go along with that. I've seen where they do the
- 9:03calls, but then they come up with AI. related
- 9:06documents to make it seem like it's from a government
- 9:08official. So I saw someone who put together a
- 9:12fake stars report, suspicious activity report,
- 9:14and told a business person, you're in trouble.
- 9:17We have this report where you're moving all this
- 9:20money around that you're not supposed to be.
- 9:22And here's our document from the US Attorney's
- 9:24Office. And we're in a confidentiality agreement
- 9:26because we're the government. And so I have seen
- 9:29some of the AI. piece of it on the back end of
- 9:32it right where they're generating documents that
- 9:34may look more more real than they than they would
- 9:37have before but it's interesting you're saying
- 9:39it's sort of the same the same kind of scam and
- 9:42and and the phone calls and of course the text
- 9:44too right where it's you know you know you get
- 9:46a text and oh sorry i accidentally texted you
- 9:49and then next thing you know they confirm you're
- 9:51a real person and and go through with the with
- 9:54that process so that's that's really um you know
- 9:57yeah i how was it ai's not causing the scams,
- 10:02it's enhancing the scams. Like you said, the
- 10:05fake document fraud and things like that, they
- 10:07were doing that before with Photoshop and Microsoft
- 10:09Word. Now they can just do it at scale. So they
- 10:13can create a lot more documents faster. They
- 10:15can make a lot more phone calls faster. They
- 10:17can do a mass amount of text messages in a short
- 10:20amount of time due to using AI and AI agents.
- 10:23So it's just enhanced their ability to commit
- 10:26the scams they were already committing before.
- 10:28and improve their grammar, right? I mean, you
- 10:30know, we used to see the old, right? The old
- 10:32scams. It's like, this isn't a really well -written,
- 10:35you know, romance letter. We'd be able to tell
- 10:37victims, like, really, this doesn't really make
- 10:40sense that you're, you know, this person you
- 10:42think is from the U .S. is writing with this
- 10:45kind of grammar or writing in this way. And now,
- 10:48right, they can fix that and make it sound more
- 10:51believable or create a variety of letters, right?
- 10:53It used to be we'd say, oh, look, this letter
- 10:55is going out to 10 people. you'd find it online
- 10:58and now you can just have AI write another version.
- 11:00So yeah, that's this interesting point. Just
- 11:03to level set, Mark, in terms of what we mean
- 11:07by social engineering. I mean, I think of it
- 11:09as essentially a fraudulent way that one person,
- 11:13that the bad guy tries to convince somebody else
- 11:16to do something. So like you can commit a crime
- 11:18with a gun in your hand or you can try to fraudulently
- 11:22convince them to do something. Is that basically
- 11:25it? Or how would you define social engineering?
- 11:29I typically define it as manipulating someone
- 11:32to commit an act that they wouldn't normally
- 11:34do or to give over confidential information that
- 11:36they wouldn't normally turn over. And just like
- 11:39you said, if someone using fraud to some degree,
- 11:41they're trying to either gather information or
- 11:44gather money. Those are two means of two things
- 11:47that they're going after, because information
- 11:48is gold nowadays. And if they can just Use that
- 11:52information maybe later against someone maybe
- 11:54against a business. Maybe like in a data breach
- 11:56or a ransomware attack That works, but if they
- 11:59get your personal information or somebody else's
- 12:01personal information They can use it for themselves
- 12:03or to target somebody else as well So those two
- 12:08factors are what they're actually going after
- 12:11Tracy, I'll turn it to you. We've talked a bit
- 12:14about individuals, but what are the threats that
- 12:16you think businesses are seeing? I mean, of course,
- 12:18we've got traditional schemes that we'll have
- 12:20you talk about as well, but what kinds of things
- 12:22should businesses really be aware of, including
- 12:25people from their own law firms or their clients
- 12:27that may be listening here? What should people
- 12:29be on the lookout for? So one of the biggest
- 12:32things right now is mobile malware. which is
- 12:36malicious software that's specifically designed
- 12:38to target smartphones. And it's usually disguised
- 12:42as legitimate apps or links and texts. There
- 12:45even can be sort of walking past you and sending
- 12:48it to your phone. And this is a sort of insidious...
- 12:56attack on these phones, because when you think
- 12:58about all of the information that you share on
- 13:00your phones, it gets at all of the things that
- 13:04Mark was talking about them wanting. And they're
- 13:07using it specifically to target businesses and
- 13:09CEOs, particularly in this time when there have
- 13:14been attacks on CEOs, they're going after these
- 13:16people. And frankly, even nation states are using
- 13:20it. to find out more about what businesses are
- 13:23doing here in the United States. Maybe they don't
- 13:26do anything. They're not stealing your bank account.
- 13:28They're just watching your business emails and
- 13:30learning about how things are done in the United
- 13:32States. And so that is one of the biggest things
- 13:35that we're seeing. We're seeing issues with respect
- 13:39to BYOD or bring your own device policies or
- 13:43lack thereof where businesses are allowing their
- 13:46employees to access um their network or or anything
- 13:53but basically bring your own device to work and
- 13:56use it to access things and the issue is that
- 13:59people are not always careful when it comes to
- 14:03clicking on links or what they're surfing on
- 14:05their own computers. And so there's a much greater
- 14:07likelihood of malware making it through to the
- 14:12system. And then just, I guess, a little bit
- 14:15of the same, which is sort of not planning enough
- 14:17for cyber events. And obviously, as you guys
- 14:20have been talking about, the weaponization of
- 14:22AI to increase the sophistication and an ability
- 14:28to attack, right? I think that, you know, in
- 14:31a long, far away universe, you could only commit
- 14:35cyber attacks if you were a fairly technical
- 14:38person who could write code. And then we had,
- 14:42you know, what they call the script kiddies who
- 14:44would sort of get these little packages of scripts
- 14:47and be able to write it. And then we had you
- 14:50can go on the dark web and hire yourself a hacker
- 14:53to do these things. And now AI makes it even
- 14:56more widely available for people to be able to
- 15:00do these attacks. And then in terms of sort of
- 15:04the more traditional things, what are the, I
- 15:05mean, to me, I think the human factor is a constant.
- 15:10The need for businesses to train their employees.
- 15:13to not click the link, to report when they do.
- 15:17I had a case where there was a woman who worked
- 15:21at a company. She clicked on the link. Fine.
- 15:25These things happen. And then her computer started
- 15:27to go all wonky. And she just closed her computer
- 15:31and went home for the day. I think this is fine.
- 15:37And so the bad actors had a lot more time to
- 15:40get into the system. then they otherwise would.
- 15:44And so that training factor, that human factor
- 15:46is, I think, just a concept that's always going
- 15:48to be there. Right. And I think it's really important
- 15:51to be really aware of that. I mean, you may see
- 15:54a bounce back of, you know, oh, your email didn't
- 15:57go through to an email address you've never seen.
- 16:00That's a real red flag. Has someone gotten onto
- 16:03your website? Are they on your, are they on your
- 16:05form? You know, where you're, you have an inquiry
- 16:07form. Do you have a proper capture there? So,
- 16:09you know, they can't have bots that are sending
- 16:11out all kinds of emails. Do you have your security
- 16:14on your website set up properly so that people
- 16:16aren't able to get in and maneuver through your
- 16:19website? I mean, it's not something everybody
- 16:20thinks of, right? In terms of, it's like, oh,
- 16:22I have a contact from my website. That should
- 16:24be fine. And there are ways in which. people
- 16:27can then be sending out malware pretending to
- 16:29be you, right? And I think that becomes a real
- 16:32issue is, you know, I have someone whose account
- 16:35must have been compromised a long time ago and
- 16:37I still get, you know, I mean, it's been years,
- 16:40I continue to get, you know, spam emails from
- 16:43all different permutations of that. So I think
- 16:46that's really important. And I think the other
- 16:48point you touched upon is, you know, when they're
- 16:51watching businesses, one of the things I've seen
- 16:53before is through the business email compromise,
- 16:56Now they're in now they're in the CEO's email
- 16:59system. I've seen them send an email saying,
- 17:01you know, oh, we need to transfer, you know,
- 17:04$100 ,000 to You know client access they need
- 17:08a refund and i'm gonna be and it's when the person's
- 17:12on a plane cuz they know when the ceo's cat what
- 17:14the calendar is and it's gotta be done urgently
- 17:17while i'm gone and next thing you know you know
- 17:19somebody like well the ceo wants me to wear this
- 17:21money out. And the money gets wired out and then
- 17:25with wires obviously very difficult to undo those
- 17:28because banks are supposed to honor those within
- 17:30the twenty four to forty eight hour period so
- 17:32their job is to send the money out and there's
- 17:35a real. I think challenge that I've seen with
- 17:37that where also where banks aren't necessarily
- 17:40requiring the name on the wire to match the account
- 17:43number. So it's like, you think you're sending
- 17:45it to ABC escrow or to your client and it's not,
- 17:50it's somebody else's, some fraudsters account
- 17:51number. So I think those are really important
- 17:54things to think about. I totally agree. And it's
- 17:57leading to increasing amounts of litigation.
- 17:59Because when that happens, there are two aggrieved
- 18:02parties who are out money, both the person sending
- 18:07it and the person that's supposed to be receiving
- 18:09it. And so now there's going to be litigation
- 18:10as to who is it that was hacked? Was it you that
- 18:15was hacked? Was it me that was hacked? Where
- 18:18is this coming from? And it becomes quite costly
- 18:22beyond just the cost of the lost money. And I'll
- 18:26touch on that too about the who and where. And
- 18:29I'll tell you right now, I'll probably deal with
- 18:30a fraudulent wire transfer or BEC at least once
- 18:33a week. And a lot of times it's not, and you
- 18:37mentioned earlier with the human factor, the
- 18:38way people are getting in, these criminals are
- 18:40getting in, is because hacking a human, which
- 18:44is what I define as social engineering, hacking
- 18:46a human is a lot easier than hacking a computer.
- 18:48So these... these threat actors or bad actors
- 18:51are sitting inside someone's email whether it
- 18:53be the CEO the accountant or whoever is in charge
- 18:56of the funds or maybe the clients email and they're
- 18:59just waiting to see when that invoice is supposed
- 19:01to come through and Now they know like okay.
- 19:04Here's the invoice number. I'm gonna send it.
- 19:06I'm gonna replicate it I'm gonna put change the
- 19:08account number on it and then it's gonna go whoever
- 19:10whether the CEO are the Businesses on the hook
- 19:13for it of the clients in the hook for it and
- 19:15like you say with litigation you're gonna have
- 19:18both sides fighting over who was the one who
- 19:19got compromised. So the business is gonna wonder,
- 19:23is the client who's the one who was compromised,
- 19:25and did we send the wrong information or money
- 19:26to the wrong person because the client was compromised?
- 19:29And the client's wondering, well, I checked my
- 19:31stuff, is the business compromised? And now are
- 19:35they at a loss because the business didn't handle
- 19:37their cybersecurity or take it seriously, and
- 19:40now someone's at a loss of a lot of money. I've
- 19:42seen money go out the window very quickly. But
- 19:46obviously I'm going to come back to, I will say
- 19:48that depending on how fast someone reports it,
- 19:50that's where reporting is very important. Money
- 19:53can be brought back as well within that 24 to
- 19:5648 hour period that you were talking about, Christina.
- 19:59So it's very important that people understand
- 20:02both sides of those. And like I said, I'm not
- 20:03an attorney, but I have seen the lawsuits come
- 20:05out and how bad it gets between client and business.
- 20:11And Mark, you talked about reporting. I think
- 20:14it's a really important thing. I think most people
- 20:16don't know who the right people are to report
- 20:18to, right? I mean, there's reports like submitting
- 20:20something to the FTC that's not going to get
- 20:22you an immediate response, important. But what
- 20:26would you recommend in terms of all of the agencies
- 20:30that one might want to reach out to? And who
- 20:32should they call first? And what would you recommend
- 20:35if someone's got one of those terrible wires
- 20:38that goes out, then they realize, should it?
- 20:41I always have three that you just report to right
- 20:44away as soon as you find out. The first one is
- 20:46your bank. If you have money go out, I use the
- 20:49analogy, if you had a busted pipe in your house
- 20:53and the water is just shooting everywhere, what's
- 20:55the first thing you're gonna do? And I've had
- 20:57people go, oh, I'm gonna call the plumber. No,
- 20:59you're going to shut the water off to the house.
- 21:01So you want to call the bank is the water to
- 21:03your house. Call them and say, look, stop the
- 21:06money from flowing out. Shut down the account,
- 21:08freeze it, lock it, make sure I don't lose any
- 21:09more money. Then you want to contact your law
- 21:11enforcement. And that's going to be your plumber,
- 21:13right? So you want to contact the FBI IC3 .gov.
- 21:17Especially if it's a wire transfer, IC3 .gov
- 21:19is the first place you should go to because they're
- 21:22going to get it immediately. I have seen those
- 21:24reports myself. I've gotten those reports within
- 21:26a matter of 10, 15 minutes. I've actually recovered
- 21:30$400 ,000 for somebody in a matter of 20 minutes
- 21:32of them losing it. So the faster somebody reports
- 21:36it, the quicker or the better it is for us to
- 21:39try to get that money back. And then you also
- 21:41want to report it to your local law enforcement.
- 21:43Those are the big three because sometimes you
- 21:45may have an insurance claim. that you have coming
- 21:47down the line. And some insurance companies want
- 21:50you to have both the IC3 report, because that's
- 21:52self -reporting, but they want you to have the
- 21:54local police report to show that you actually
- 21:55went in, filed a legitimate report, and it's
- 21:58going to get looked at. So I'll be honest, not
- 22:00every report you file to the FBI is going to
- 22:02be looked at, depending on different circumstances,
- 22:04depending on how much manpower they have to look
- 22:07at the cases, what the amount is, what their
- 22:09threshold is. But local law enforcement, at least
- 22:12you can say, hey, someone's going to look at
- 22:13it at a minimum, at least. And you have two different
- 22:16report numbers to say, look, this is very serious.
- 22:19I filed a report with both these. And you can
- 22:20give those to the bank to let them know you're
- 22:22serious about, hey, this is not first party fraud.
- 22:25You know, I'm actually a victim of fraud. I'm
- 22:27trying to do what I can to try to get my money
- 22:29back and report it properly. So those three are
- 22:31the first ones I always say. Everything else
- 22:33afterwards, you can kind of take time with those
- 22:36first three within those first 24 hours are very
- 22:38important. Yeah, and I'll say that here in LA,
- 22:41the FBI has a great task force with a great kill
- 22:46chain for these kinds of BC matters. And so reaching
- 22:50out to them and the local law enforcement will
- 22:53activate this group. And they've been really
- 22:56pretty successful at stopping when they get it
- 22:59in time. I'll send those kill chains myself.
- 23:02So I completely understand. It's very quick.
- 23:06it take all you have to do as long as we have
- 23:07the account information. If you were a victim,
- 23:10send the account where your account, where it
- 23:11came from, the account that it went to, that's
- 23:14an email that goes out, the FBI has their kill
- 23:16chain processed, that they do it, and you can
- 23:18give money back in a matter of 15, 20 minutes
- 23:20at times. So if the phones are still there, you
- 23:22can get that money back. And you can also call
- 23:25them if you're feeling really desperate too.
- 23:27In addition to IC3, in LA at least, somebody
- 23:30tends to answer the phone typically. Yeah, just
- 23:34to capture just to capture a question. It just
- 23:36came in. What we're saying is I letter I three.
- 23:42Dot com. I see dot com. Yeah, that's the that
- 23:47go that go or that go. Sorry, you're right. I
- 23:49see three. I'll put it in the chat. I think we
- 23:52have a link to it too in our materials, Mark.
- 23:54I think we may we may have one. Yeah, I think
- 23:56I saw it in there. So it is in there. Yeah, it
- 23:58should it should be in the materials as well.
- 23:59But yeah, that's the FBI's online resource for
- 24:02reporting. for crime. And then of course, there's
- 24:05the FTC as well. But but again, for a wire sort
- 24:08of quick moving, you know, I see three, I let
- 24:12her I see I don't know what it stands for actually
- 24:14internet crime. It's a it's internet crimes complaint
- 24:18center. So I and C is like there's no internet
- 24:19crimes complaint center. So I see three. Yeah,
- 24:24the three for the receipts. Okay, great. No,
- 24:26that's really helpful. And then, Tracy, do you
- 24:29have other things with respect to businesses
- 24:30when they're looking at a breach in terms of
- 24:32reporting what you suggest people do, or is it
- 24:36sort of the standard protocol? Call someone like
- 24:39you if it's a data breach type thing, or what
- 24:42would you suggest in that way? Yeah, I mean,
- 24:45Mark's got it spot on in terms of the order of
- 24:47things. Fourth and the fifth calls usually are
- 24:55to your insurance company, if you've got cyber
- 24:58insurance, and then to a remediator. And so FTI
- 25:02has an incident response team. There are many
- 25:05others, but someone who you were hired, obviously
- 25:10you report the crime, you want the law enforcement
- 25:12to look into it, but they're gonna make their
- 25:14own decisions about what they want to investigate
- 25:16and what they think is appropriate. You can also
- 25:19hire a remediator who can come in, find out what's
- 25:22going on, investigate your systems, get the bad
- 25:25guys out, and make sure that you're clean, and
- 25:28then work with you to develop your system so
- 25:30that they're a little bit more hearty in the
- 25:32going forward way. That's great. That's really
- 25:35helpful. And in talking about the mobile scam,
- 25:40you know, it's come to my attention lately, and
- 25:43something that I was not as familiar with, but
- 25:45I'd heard about it from my FBI contacts before,
- 25:48but the SIM swapping and the porting issues.
- 25:52I've recently come to learn about pretty serious
- 25:57SIM swapping and porting issues that people may
- 25:59not be as aware of in terms of things they can
- 26:02do. SIM swapping is basically somebody Taking
- 26:05essentially taking over your phone and transferring
- 26:08your number and information to a new phone and
- 26:11so it's what you do if you want to go get a new
- 26:14phone at your at your local mobile provider right
- 26:16you say oh change the SIM to this great new phone
- 26:20I'm getting but the problem is if a criminal
- 26:22gets your information and they're able to to
- 26:24use that data to pretend to be you. Sim swap
- 26:28your phone number to another number now they
- 26:30have your data for two -factor authentication
- 26:32I've seen them get into people's credit reports
- 26:35being able to pretend to be them So much so that
- 26:39the people themselves are very difficult for
- 26:41them to undo it The other thing that's done is
- 26:44porting illegal porting where they take your
- 26:46number not just within your own carrier But they
- 26:49take it to yet another carrier so you're at a
- 26:51Verizon or T -Mobile and they switch you to an
- 26:53AT &T or somebody else and the next thing you
- 26:56know Your phone number is not even with your
- 26:58carrier anymore. It's now in some other mysterious
- 27:01location that you don't know about And they may
- 27:04buy some other equipment while they're at it
- 27:06while they're pretending to be you and that puts
- 27:09people in a really tough position and what I've
- 27:14Recently learned and want to share with the audience
- 27:16is that you can do things now to protect that
- 27:19from happening You can on your phone itself lock
- 27:22your sim on your settings and you can also call
- 27:25your carrier and lock all of your phones from
- 27:27being ported without either a special password
- 27:30or use of your um use of a website or something
- 27:34else an app that they have to do it so just wanted
- 27:38to pass that along um just as something that
- 27:40i think is a real issue because what flows from
- 27:44the theft of your cell phone is so many other
- 27:46things right because they've got your data point
- 27:48now they've got your two factor and now when
- 27:50you try to reach out and prove who you are to
- 27:52lock your credit they're saying well you don't
- 27:55have the number for two factor authentication
- 27:57and so we're not going to give it to you and
- 27:59i've even seen the criminals put fraud blocks
- 28:02on themselves with their own passcode so that
- 28:04the person can then they unlock it when they
- 28:06want to steal more things that the person can't
- 28:09do anything with it right so i don't know mark
- 28:11have you got comments on that in terms of what
- 28:13what you've seen but but this the sim swapping
- 28:16and the phone theft I think is a pretty serious
- 28:19issue, especially since some people rely so much
- 28:22on their phone these days and the idea that you
- 28:24can lock those things and the SIM lock also keeps
- 28:28someone from putting a new SIM onto your phone,
- 28:31which is a thing they can also do, right? They
- 28:32can connect a number to your phone that kind
- 28:35of Tracy was talking about. But Mark, do you
- 28:36have thoughts on kind of some of the mobile fraud
- 28:39and things that you're seeing? How much time
- 28:41we got? So I think you're touching on, I'm going
- 28:50to touch on my sense swaps, but I think you're
- 28:52touching on a much bigger underlying issue is
- 28:54protecting your personal information and your
- 28:56devices not only protects you, but it also protects
- 28:59your business. Because if I can get access to
- 29:02you, if I'm a bad actor and I can get your information
- 29:04and I can not pretend to be you, if you're a
- 29:07CEO or some high ranking executive or not even
- 29:10high ranking, just if you work at a business
- 29:12and now I can pretend to get your device, I can
- 29:15take your personal information, your name, date
- 29:17of birth, social address, and then go into a
- 29:20phone's company store, Verizon T -Mobile, AT
- 29:23&T. and swap your phone and now I have access
- 29:27to your two -factor authentication. Now, if I
- 29:30know enough about you, which our information
- 29:33is everywhere, data broker websites, LinkedIn,
- 29:35all these other things, I now know you probably
- 29:37access certain systems when you work. So now
- 29:40I can reset your information, whether you're
- 29:42working for a major corporation or a smaller
- 29:44law firm. It could be. Now I know how to get
- 29:48into that system. I can pretend to be you, depending
- 29:50on the privileges that you have within that system.
- 29:53I can escalate those privileges. Maybe now I
- 29:55use that for ransomware. Maybe I take all your
- 29:58information, I lock it, and now I'm saying, well,
- 30:00if you want the information back and you don't
- 30:02want me to leak it, you got to pay me this much
- 30:04money. That's what the threat actors are doing.
- 30:07So protecting your personal information is super
- 30:10important. And I'll give you a story about a
- 30:12SIM swap that actually caught, like, as it was
- 30:14happening. And there was an individual who didn't
- 30:17even live within where I worked at. He lived
- 30:19in Florida. And he was out on a boat that day.
- 30:23But when he got back off the boat, he wasn't,
- 30:26he was on the boat and he wasn't getting any
- 30:27phone calls or text messages. So he just thought,
- 30:28maybe I don't have a signal because I'm not on
- 30:30the water. So when he got back, his phone still
- 30:33wasn't ringing, wasn't getting messages. And
- 30:34he goes, well, this is kind of not normal. And
- 30:37so he tries to make a phone call and realizes
- 30:39his phone's not working. So then he calls a phone
- 30:42company and says, oh no, your phone number was,
- 30:44was switched. And he goes, what do you mean?
- 30:46And they tell him where it was happening. And
- 30:47it's always happening in Las Vegas. So we actually
- 30:50were able to get a hold of the phone company
- 30:52and let us know what's going on. As he's doing
- 30:55this, he tries to access his bank account. He
- 30:57realizes someone is actively trying to withdraw
- 31:00funds at a physical branch. So we were able to
- 31:04go out there to the physical branch and catch
- 31:06this guy in person who had done the swim swap
- 31:09and was actively trying to get funds out of his
- 31:11account. That was a nice run we had that day
- 31:15through a parking lot, but that importance of
- 31:21protecting his information and putting those
- 31:22security plans in place as far as protecting
- 31:26his SIEM would have stopped someone from trying
- 31:29to access his account. It would have stopped
- 31:31someone from accessing his email account if he
- 31:33has two -factor authentication for his email
- 31:35accounts. So SIEM swaps can be... Very dangerous,
- 31:39but that information that they get to even do
- 31:41the sim stop in the first place is openly available
- 31:43on data broker websites And there's hundreds
- 31:46of data broker websites and now people can go
- 31:49on there and remove their information themselves
- 31:50It's tedious or those companies that do it, but
- 31:53there is this overarching thing that that's just
- 31:57umbrella you're talking about you're saying like
- 31:59hey look protecting yourself protects more than
- 32:02just yourself and That's that's I'll leave it
- 32:05at that. I think that's the best way to put it
- 32:07Well, and for people who don't realize how much
- 32:11information is out there, you know, and not everybody
- 32:13loves to Google themselves, but it's a good idea
- 32:15to see when you type in your name, is your home
- 32:19address, all of your personal data, your family
- 32:22information, is all that, are all those things
- 32:24coming up because those are things criminals
- 32:26would use or, you know, your mother's maiden
- 32:29name, people think that's such a great thing.
- 32:32Well, that's pretty commonly available, right?
- 32:35So it's like, you know, For all the criminals
- 32:38out there, my mother's maiden name is not my
- 32:40mother's maiden name on any of my stuff. It's
- 32:42something else, right? People feel like you have
- 32:45to answer that question. The answer is the answer
- 32:48you will remember. It can be whatever you want
- 32:51it to be, you know, it's like, what's the color
- 32:53of your first car? Well, you know, there's only
- 32:56so many colors. So baby, don't pick one of those
- 32:59colors, pick something else. So I mean, I think
- 33:01people sometimes are just, you know, sort of
- 33:03following along thinking this is not something
- 33:06people can find. But, you know, you could spend
- 33:08just a few minutes and you know, even go to AI
- 33:12and see what comes up about you, right? I mean,
- 33:14there's a lot of information out there, right?
- 33:16That is easy for criminals to get and pretend
- 33:18to be you and to go into the bank and figure
- 33:22that out. I agree. In that case, had they already
- 33:29put together an ID for the person that they had
- 33:32hacked the phone for? Do they have it? Oh, yeah.
- 33:34And it's not just like it happens quickly. They
- 33:36plan it out. So I've seen them. They'll make
- 33:38the fake ID. They'll make the fake documents
- 33:40before they execute the plan. So it's not, hey,
- 33:44I got your information right now. I'm going to
- 33:45go use it right away. It's like, OK, I got the
- 33:47information. I'm going to sit and wait. I'm going
- 33:48to make a fake ID with your address on it. Oh,
- 33:50you live in Florida. I'm going to make a Florida
- 33:52ID. Oh, I went to a data broker website. Now
- 33:54I have your name, date of birth, address, all
- 33:57that information. I can put all that on there.
- 33:59They're going to study it so they remember it.
- 34:01And so when they get questioned on it, they're
- 34:03going to go, oh, no, this is me. I live at this
- 34:05address. And I've lived here before. And yeah,
- 34:07my birthday is this day. And I've seen some really
- 34:10good fake IDs. I've seen some to the point where
- 34:13I questioned whether how good I was. I'm like,
- 34:16this guy is making some really good fake IDs.
- 34:21But I've seen, like, really scammers are getting
- 34:24better. Like I said, AI enhances it. So they're
- 34:27getting better with the use of utilizing tools.
- 34:30Now, we can use those same tools to help us get
- 34:32better at stopping them as well. So at the same
- 34:36time, while they're like, hey, you know, I'm
- 34:37going to use ChatGBT and Gemini to create all
- 34:39this stuff. I was like, OK, great. I can use
- 34:41the same tools to find you too. So it's a give
- 34:46and take with both, but it's just protecting
- 34:49your information is very important. Absolutely.
- 34:53Tracy, do you have thoughts on that from a business
- 34:55perspective just sort of generally or steps you
- 34:56think businesses could look at taking to help
- 34:59protect themselves other than what we've been
- 35:01talking about? Yeah, absolutely. I think it is
- 35:04so critical for businesses and law firms and
- 35:07anybody who has data to make sure that their
- 35:11plans for when a cybersecurity event happens
- 35:14are regularly updated and tested. You can't just
- 35:18have the policy and never try it out. You've
- 35:20got to test it. Tabletops can be, which are sort
- 35:23of exercises where you work with, you can either
- 35:26do it internally, or you can hire someone like
- 35:28FTI to help you put it together, where we come
- 35:31up with a scenario, maybe it's ransomware, maybe
- 35:33it's an insider threat, whatever, and then run
- 35:36through what's the plan says happening? What
- 35:37do we do this? And then what happens next? And
- 35:40what if this other thing happens? It can be so
- 35:42enormously helpful because, as has been often
- 35:45said, no plan survives first contact with the
- 35:48enemy. And you don't want to find that out when
- 35:52the real thing is happening. And there's so many
- 35:55decisions that have to be thought through. Like,
- 35:59who is in charge? Who is the decision maker?
- 36:01There's a lot of people that think it's them.
- 36:03And if you don't, make sure that you have it.
- 36:05And then what if that person's not around? Or
- 36:09if there's someone in our system, what are we
- 36:11going to do in terms of off -channel communications
- 36:14so that we're not communicating in a way that
- 36:16the bad guy can see? Or will we pay ransomware?
- 36:22Will we pay ransom, right? These are not the
- 36:25kinds of decisions that can be made in the moment
- 36:30at the time of the actual bad thing. Do we have
- 36:33the logging capabilities on our systems so that
- 36:37we will know whether or not our data has been
- 36:39exfiltrated? There are so many regulators that
- 36:42require you to report if... things have been
- 36:47taken, but not if they haven't. And if you don't
- 36:49have the ability to know, you're going to be
- 36:51stuck reporting. And so having this ability to
- 36:55know what's going on with your systems. And frankly,
- 37:00now with the rise of so many regulations about
- 37:04cybersecurity and privacy and advocating for
- 37:07consumers as they should, if these things aren't
- 37:10in place, you're not only going to suffer the
- 37:13harm of the incident to your company, but there's
- 37:16going to be even more consequences because you're
- 37:18going to be liable under these regulations to
- 37:21these regulators and frankly to your consumers
- 37:23who are going to come along or your clients who
- 37:25are going to come along and file litigation against
- 37:27you for not having the security that you need
- 37:29it. And so it can seem really expensive to plan
- 37:35for these events and to get these policies in
- 37:37place and do that. But it is. It is nothing that
- 37:42compares to what the costs are when the event
- 37:44actually happens. And so that is my foot stomping
- 37:49encouragement of people to take the time to look
- 37:52at their plans and make sure that they are up
- 37:54to date and tested. That's great. And one of
- 37:58the things we used to also say when I was at
- 37:59the FTC was we would encourage businesses to
- 38:03not keep more data. Then they need right in addition
- 38:06to having good backup plan you know just because
- 38:09you had it doesn't mean you should be keeping
- 38:11it forever you know I mean I got a data breach
- 38:14notice from a company that I probably haven't
- 38:16interacted with for 20 years. Why do they still
- 38:20have my data right there's no reason why they
- 38:22would keep that and it's not something where
- 38:24I had an active account or anything and but it's
- 38:27like now I'm getting a notice that you have data
- 38:29from 20 years ago and so you know I mean I think
- 38:32if you. whether you agree, but it's important
- 38:35to just make sure that the companies are, as
- 38:37you said, you've got to report what went out.
- 38:39So first of all, you have to know what you have,
- 38:41and then you have to know what went out, and
- 38:43then you have to know whose data went out, right?
- 38:45And all of those things being having a good sense
- 38:48of what your data flow is and having policies
- 38:51about not keeping things longer than you need
- 38:54to, or not taking extra stuff you don't need
- 38:56to take in in the first place, right? You don't
- 38:58need certain data. Companies probably shouldn't
- 39:01bring it in. And again, there's not only the
- 39:05real world cost of having lost the data, there's
- 39:08the cost of having to fix the problem. So we
- 39:11get brought in a lot when a lot of data has been
- 39:14taken. And now you're paying me to go into your
- 39:18systems, pull out all the stuff that was taken,
- 39:21run it through programs to figure out what countries
- 39:25do we need to report to? What regulators do we
- 39:27need to report to? cannot believe the number
- 39:31of times that so much of the data never needed
- 39:33to be kept. And so now there's this huge tranche
- 39:36of data that you're paying me to go through that
- 39:39you didn't need to keep in the first place. And
- 39:41so it just, I, I underscore that. Right. I've
- 39:45always seen that people don't care about fraud
- 39:48and scams. So they're a victim of fraud and scams.
- 39:51It's, it's like, okay, if you just prevent the
- 39:53preventive measure in the first place, you wouldn't
- 39:55have gotten scammed or defrauded. in the first
- 39:57place and you say yourself sometimes millions
- 39:59of dollars if you could just pay someone like
- 40:01fti to come in and go hey you know what we're
- 40:03here we can show you what you need or you pay
- 40:05someone to come in do education and training
- 40:08like i do and go hey look your employees the
- 40:11way they're getting into your system is not they
- 40:13hack your computer they have to hack your employee
- 40:15so it's just those mitigation tools that you
- 40:19have in place say hey look you know what maybe
- 40:20we should actually invest in stopping the scam
- 40:23or stopping the fraud or stopping the intrusion
- 40:25before we actually have an issue in your hand
- 40:27now you're dealing with litigation and and people
- 40:29leaving reputation damage is really huge so there's
- 40:34a lot of other factors that come into it after
- 40:35the fact right because once that data goes out
- 40:38you then now have a whole class of people who
- 40:40are now going to be potential new identity that
- 40:43victims who are going to come back to you and
- 40:44say I gave you my data for this particular limited
- 40:47use and now I'm being targeted for, you know,
- 40:50a variety of identity theft issues. And I would
- 40:54also add to sort of an old school piece of advice,
- 40:57you know, I've seen most recently as part of
- 41:01this sort of larger identity theft issue I mentioned
- 41:04earlier with the SIM swaps is the ordering of
- 41:06lots of merchandise to the person's home. And
- 41:09then the post office will allow you to get information
- 41:12sent to you about what mail's coming your way,
- 41:14like a scan of the front of your envelopes. And
- 41:18so I've actually seen the criminals set up a
- 41:20situation where they were getting the mail cover
- 41:23information. So they would know when the items
- 41:26they stole were going to the house so they could
- 41:29go and intercept it before it got to the actual
- 41:32consumer. And then it would look to the company
- 41:34like the consumer was part of the scam because
- 41:36the consumers ordered all these things to their
- 41:38house. And so, yes, you did buy these tens of
- 41:41thousands of dollars worth of equipment, but
- 41:45this person just knows what day the mail carrier
- 41:47is coming so they can just go and pick it up.
- 41:50So I would say the old school secure. secure
- 41:53mailboxes, locking down your credit, having fraud
- 41:58alerts, having all of those things, annualcreditreport
- 42:01.com. That's a government site. You can get your
- 42:05credit reports for free from all three agencies.
- 42:08And now, if you're a fraud victim, you can even
- 42:10check it more frequently. But being at the place
- 42:13where you know if somebody is opening new accounts
- 42:15in your personal or your business name. Because
- 42:18if you're not checking your credit and you don't
- 42:20have any alert system, people can be doing all
- 42:23kinds of things right and you won't find out
- 42:25until it's delinquent after a while or or something
- 42:29of that nature and you know when I've seen companies
- 42:31say well no we've decided that we think you are
- 42:34responsible it's like but this person didn't
- 42:37make the purchase and there was a recent case
- 42:39where a woman um challenged a fraud on her bank
- 42:43account and they said you took too long sorry
- 42:46and she didn't recognize that's a real thing
- 42:48yeah that happens too I've seen that And that
- 42:51was quite a bit. They say you don't usually report
- 42:52within 30 days. Usually it's 30 days, sometimes
- 42:5560, depending on what it is. But if you don't
- 42:57know, if you don't get the notifications every
- 42:59single day, which you can put in place for notifications
- 43:01of payments on your bank account or credit cards
- 43:03and debit cards and things like that. But if
- 43:05you're someone who send out like checks, like
- 43:09check fraud, it's really big. You were mentioning
- 43:10mail and people were doing mail covers. Having
- 43:13informed delivery is free. And it's very important
- 43:16that if you're still using checks, which I don't
- 43:18think you should be, that's just my personal
- 43:21opinion. I hate checks. But but if you're still
- 43:26using checks, you want to make sure that, hey,
- 43:27did it go to the right person? Did it actually
- 43:30make it to the mailbox, especially law firms?
- 43:32I've seen a lot of law firms who are getting
- 43:34their mailboxes still broken into every single
- 43:36day because they're getting checks. They were
- 43:39still receiving checks from clients from the.
- 43:42Cases that they've had and then the person goes
- 43:45to say I never received a check and like well
- 43:47we put the mailbox Well, it was stolen it was
- 43:49cash, but not by the person who intended to be
- 43:51cashed by so That's a whole nother story ours
- 43:56I mean that was you know, yeah back when I was
- 44:00in law school a hundred years ago That was one
- 44:01of the one of the criminal cases where someone
- 44:03was getting sentenced where she was literally
- 44:05Going around and taking the checks out of the
- 44:07mailboxes and you know washing them and putting
- 44:09another name on them and it's still it's still
- 44:12happening but and even people putting stuff in
- 44:14the post office boxes that are outside right
- 44:16that's not secure either i mean people can easily
- 44:19break into those i just saw something someone
- 44:22posting this was trying to actually steal the
- 44:24whole mailbox i mean these are i mean it's pretty
- 44:27bold what people do i've seen the whole mailbox
- 44:30i've actually gone to a bad actor's house and
- 44:33they had the mailbox on the wall like it was
- 44:35a trophy um so So yeah, it happens all the time.
- 44:40Like that one shocked me. But yeah, that one
- 44:41literally, they like, oh yeah, you know, well,
- 44:43I had a girl who was, she was addicted to stealing
- 44:46mail. She told me she had dreams about stealing
- 44:48mail every single day. So it's, it is pretty
- 44:51bad. But like I said, that's a whole nother webinar.
- 44:54Yeah, absolutely. So in terms of what you know
- 44:58what what what kinds of advice can we give people
- 45:01or even just just sort of a larger question is
- 45:03are there things we think that can be done in
- 45:05in a larger way to kind of help protect we've
- 45:08talked about a lot of things so far but are there
- 45:10other things we can think of um we want to sort
- 45:13of have people look out for I mean we've talked
- 45:15a lot about just being being aware being cautious
- 45:17doing trainings for for your staff um you know
- 45:21maybe mark what do you see as some of the kind
- 45:24of red alerts or things people might not might
- 45:26not be paying attention to or sort of your top
- 45:29tips for that maybe stuff we haven't talked about
- 45:30already about how to protect themselves or their
- 45:32businesses. I think of the big, especially since
- 45:35we're talking about social engineering for the
- 45:36most part in AI, I have a phrase that I use and
- 45:39I tell people to pause, think, and verify. And
- 45:42what is the three -step method for you to actually
- 45:44make sure that you're not being a victim or you're
- 45:47not being socially engineered? And I said, we're
- 45:49going to pause. So sometimes we get those random
- 45:52requests, that text message, that phone call,
- 45:54that email. And it's some kind of hook that they
- 45:58have in there. Hey, you have fraud in your account.
- 46:00Sorry, I missed your call. Hey, I have to send
- 46:03this invoice. Take a second and just breathe
- 46:06because they're trying to create urgency. They're
- 46:08going to say, hey, we want it right now. And
- 46:11so we take that second to pause and just think
- 46:13about. What is actually being requested of me
- 46:16right now? Why are they asking me to do this
- 46:17right now? My CEO has never asked me to do this
- 46:21this way before. Why now? When's the last time
- 46:24I talked to the CEO? Have I checked my bank account
- 46:28to see if there's actual fraud in the account
- 46:30without clicking the link that they send you?
- 46:33So think about all these different things that
- 46:35should normally run through your mind. Start
- 46:37training yourself to run those in your mind and
- 46:39then verify who you're talking to. Are you actually
- 46:42talking to your CEO? Maybe text them and call
- 46:44them and make sure that you should really send
- 46:45me this email requesting a $500 ,000 transfer.
- 46:48I'm pretty sure they're not gonna be upset that
- 46:51you verified before you sent off half a million
- 46:53dollars. Verify if you're talking to the bank.
- 46:56Like, is this actually a bank rep? Because you
- 46:58can spoof a phone number. That's part of social
- 47:00engineering. Technology is free. I can make whatever
- 47:03number I want show up on the phone. So... And
- 47:06criminals have used that technology to the fullest
- 47:09while we get spam calls all the time I've got
- 47:11a phone call from myself before that was the
- 47:14weirdest thing my own name popped up That was
- 47:17very interesting. That was some years ago, but
- 47:19in but I learned how to remove all my information
- 47:22from the internet now more Public -facing so
- 47:25my and my stuff's out there, but I know how to
- 47:26find people so they want to come after me let's
- 47:28have some fun, but But yeah, so verify that,
- 47:33but verify who you're talking to. Is it the bank?
- 47:35Is it the CEO? Is it your fellow employee? Is
- 47:37it your client? Verify who you're talking to.
- 47:39And then once you put all that into place, then
- 47:41make your decision and do what you're gonna do.
- 47:44Yeah. It's the know your customer, just more
- 47:46of it. Right. Yep. And I think it's really important.
- 47:50I mean, it's just, you know, in fact, I just
- 47:52got an email earlier today from someone I know.
- 47:54It's like, here's an Adobe document for you to
- 47:57open. This is not a person I normally... I know
- 47:59this person, they're another lawyer, but it's
- 48:02not somebody who normally sends me any documents.
- 48:05We don't have any reason to be sharing documents.
- 48:07And there was some incorrect grammar in the heading.
- 48:11But somebody else is like, oh, it's a document
- 48:14from an attorney I know. I should probably click
- 48:16on it. And I'm about to give him a call and tell
- 48:19him he better check his email to see if it's
- 48:22there, right? Because that's the other piece
- 48:23is you know, if you're compromised, look in your
- 48:27set box, look in your trash, see if you're finding
- 48:30things that somebody is sending out through your
- 48:32email that you don't know about, right? Read,
- 48:34you know, use, use two factor when you can and
- 48:37any other, you know, don't, don't have easy passwords.
- 48:40It's easy to It's easy to want to use the same
- 48:42password over and over again, but we used to
- 48:45say the longer passwords are stronger. And it
- 48:48can be a couple of sentences you put together,
- 48:51right? Or a full sentence, if you remember, that's
- 48:53got some letters and numbers and symbols mixed
- 48:56into it. But again, the brute force attacks,
- 49:00right? These days can try a lot of different
- 49:03combinations if you don't have a system that
- 49:05locks people out, which... But he should definitely
- 49:07do. That was a case back when I was the FTC where
- 49:10they didn't have that. And they let people try
- 49:13as many times as they want. And in that particular
- 49:15case, they got into one location. And then the
- 49:18other thing was that companies have multiple
- 49:20locations, we would always say, don't tie things
- 49:23together such that you're You know, your desk
- 49:26clerk at a hotel in, you know, in Ohio has access
- 49:30to the entirety of your whole nationwide system,
- 49:34right? I mean, that's a real problem. That person,
- 49:36people should only have access to the things
- 49:38that they actually need. And so I think another
- 49:41thing about making sure, you know, your data
- 49:43as Tracy was talking about is making sure people
- 49:45only have access to what they need. So if someone
- 49:48gets breached, you know, and somebody has to
- 49:50come in and look at it, they can say, oh, well,
- 49:52she got breached, but she only has access to
- 49:54this, one subfolder. It's unfortunate, but this
- 49:57is the level of what she has as opposed to, oh,
- 50:00this employee got breached and now our entire
- 50:02system of data that she really didn't need to
- 50:05be accessing anyway is entirely breached. So
- 50:08I think those are things for people to kind of
- 50:11think about as they're working with data and
- 50:15thinking that part of it through. So, sorry,
- 50:21Mark, you were giving advice. Other advice you
- 50:23have on that or Tracy in terms of protecting
- 50:26people and kind of what companies should think
- 50:28about or any other good war stories. Mark, I
- 50:31like the mailbox. I don't know if you have any
- 50:34other cautionary tale people about kind of all
- 50:38of these issues. We have lots of war stories
- 50:40about the Tracy going on. The one thing I wanted
- 50:44to talk about here is I think that there's been
- 50:47a real evolution of thought about regarding whose
- 50:52responsibility the cybersecurity of the business
- 50:55is. I think a lot of people, a lot of times lawyers
- 50:58like to say, I don't know anything about it.
- 51:01That's the IT guy's thing. That's the CSOS thing.
- 51:04That's over there. And I don't need to concern
- 51:06myself with whether or not it's good. And I think
- 51:10that there's been a real evolution of thought,
- 51:11appropriately so. that frankly everyone in the
- 51:14company has skin in the game. The CEO, the CFO,
- 51:18even small companies, there's a lot of skin in
- 51:20the game on this, whether it's because of the
- 51:24regulators saying that you do and you're going
- 51:26to be held responsible or whether it's because
- 51:28of the lawsuits from clients and customers and
- 51:33things like that. And so that... If you're not
- 51:37in that head space, I would say get to that head
- 51:39space. You do have skin in the game. Make sure
- 51:41that you're aware of what data you have and how
- 51:46it's being properly protected so that you know.
- 51:52Mark, you were going to say something. I was
- 51:54looking at somebody's questions on the side.
- 51:55I mean, I got a bunch of words. I see all these
- 51:57questions are coming in. Yeah, we can jump on
- 51:59the questions. One of the questions is, how do
- 52:01you deal with having a plethora of different
- 52:03emails for multiple accounts and remembering
- 52:05them when needed? Yeah, I mean if you really
- 52:09want something you can have mail you can have
- 52:10email forwarding So if you like if you have multiple
- 52:12count or use a password manager, so if you mean
- 52:14like logging As far as like using a bunch of
- 52:17different databases having a password manager
- 52:19is awesome. I use a password manager To to keep
- 52:23all my emails in place. I use a I'm a I'm a cybercrime
- 52:26detective So I'm probably more paranoid than
- 52:28the average person but I use a lot of email aliases
- 52:32because I know if something's breached, I can
- 52:34type that email to that specific company and
- 52:37I know exactly what happened. But that gets forwarded
- 52:39to my main email that I'm gonna be using. But
- 52:43having a password manager in case you wanna remember
- 52:46all the passwords, you can use it. There's a
- 52:49bunch of different companies out there that do
- 52:50that. I use Proton for myself, but there's Proton,
- 52:55there's I think LastPass, FirstPassword, there's
- 52:58a bunch of different ones that are out there.
- 53:00But I think that's a really good way to do it
- 53:02and use one master password that doesn't access
- 53:05anything else. Don't use Microsoft or Google's
- 53:09browser password manager, please, because that
- 53:13can be breached and someone can access your information.
- 53:15So if you have a third party one to use, I think
- 53:19that's really good for having all those different
- 53:20emails. Right. I hope I answered that. Yeah,
- 53:25I think you did. There's another comment. I delete
- 53:29all texts and emails if it has a link or attachment
- 53:31from someone I have no reason to receive. Do
- 53:35you see any problem with just deleting my thought?
- 53:37If it's legitimate, they will get a hold of me
- 53:38another way. That seems fine. Right. And I think
- 53:43there are some. companies that also like like
- 53:46with cell phone companies, I think they will
- 53:48also allow you the option to forward it like
- 53:50a lot of companies will have an option to forward
- 53:52spam or market is phishing or to do it in that
- 53:55way. So I think if there's that option to market
- 53:58and then delete and when you market phishing
- 54:00they'll often delete it as well. So sometimes
- 54:03that can also just sort of help help others in
- 54:06the larger way of a company's identifying it.
- 54:08I always immediately block and I not only just
- 54:12delete I block stuff and so i don't want to jinx
- 54:16it but it does seem to uh i don't seem to be
- 54:19people's favorite target anymore because i'm
- 54:21pretty quickly in flagging their stuff and so
- 54:24i don't think they love that They have to get
- 54:26a new number because it keeps getting flagged.
- 54:29So I would say, you know, if you have a phishing
- 54:30option or an option to market a spam, that's
- 54:33always a good way to and then and then, yeah,
- 54:35delete it. People will people will typically
- 54:37find you if it's really if it's really important.
- 54:39I agree. Or if it's someone you know, like reach
- 54:41out to them like like the email I got, I'm about
- 54:4499 percent sure it's not accurate, but I'm going
- 54:46to reach out to the person. And if there really
- 54:48was something, then, you know, then he'll resend
- 54:51it to their father. You're talking to. For sure,
- 54:54for sure. And I got a war so I can give you if
- 54:56you want it. So I think it was to kind of sum
- 54:58this up. And this is a case that I had about
- 55:01about a year ago. And this involves a business
- 55:04email compromise, but it shows the importance
- 55:07of protecting your devices and your personal
- 55:08information. So there was a business who was
- 55:11doing he had a vendor or this business had a
- 55:14vendor that was out of state. They were doing
- 55:15a project out of state. And this vendor was in
- 55:19charge of all the invoicing for all the contracting,
- 55:21everything they were doing out there in the other
- 55:23state. But this vendor who was in charge of that
- 55:25connected to a public Wi -Fi. And he didn't use
- 55:28a VPN. He logged into his email address and what
- 55:31ended up happening was the bad act, he logged
- 55:33into a bad Wi -Fi that belonged to a criminal
- 55:37actor. And that person was just in his email.
- 55:40And what ended up happening was when it was time
- 55:42to send an invoice, this person sent a legitimate
- 55:46invoice from a legitimate email. because he was
- 55:49actually logged into the vendor's account. So
- 55:52when the email came through to the actual business,
- 55:55it came from a legitimate person. It looks real.
- 55:58And this is where following policies and having
- 56:01policies in place and following them make a lot
- 56:04of sense. And the reason is when that invoice
- 56:08came in, the accountant who was in charge for
- 56:11that part then sent it off to be verified. They
- 56:15didn't send it off for payments, nothing to verify.
- 56:17And then that person was supposed to verify it
- 56:19and then make the payment. They didn't verify
- 56:21that it came from him. They never contacted him
- 56:23and they just sent the payment off. And it was
- 56:25about $435 ,000. That money went out. Luckily,
- 56:30they call it very fast. Now, this is where we
- 56:33talked about reporting and the kill chain process
- 56:35and the whole harmless process. I don't think
- 56:38we mentioned that, but how to get that money
- 56:40back. And what happened was because they reported
- 56:42it so fast, I was able to send off the kill chain,
- 56:45able to contact the bank, and then they were
- 56:47able to send back the money that wasn't withdrawn
- 56:49yet, which was about 80 % of the money. So they
- 56:52still got back most of the money, but it goes
- 56:54to show the importance of protecting your personal
- 56:56information, protecting your devices, having
- 56:59policies and procedures in place, and following
- 57:01those policies and procedures and verify who
- 57:04you're speaking with before you send off any
- 57:06kind of transaction. And also never using public
- 57:09Wi -Fi. People do not use public Wi -Fi. It's
- 57:16ridiculous. I was actually at a hotel in Nevada,
- 57:19and I was like, where's the password? And they're
- 57:21like, well, you're going to have to talk to RIT
- 57:23people in order to get the password. I'm like,
- 57:26I am not using public Wi -Fi in this Nevada hotel.
- 57:32connected to a casino, like this is not happening.
- 57:35So I mean, I think, you know, being cautious,
- 57:38you know, if you have a situation like that,
- 57:40use your own personal hotspot if you need to
- 57:42on your phone, something that is not there. Make
- 57:44sure your personal hotspot has password protection.
- 57:47It's not just out there open. Don't name your
- 57:52Wi Fi with your full name. I've seen that before.
- 57:56Somebody told me a Prominent public official
- 57:59who shall remain nameless Was on the plane with
- 58:02others and his Wi -Fi was his full name. So like
- 58:06not a great plan. So, you know Don't think just
- 58:10because you can get on Wi -Fi and safe that is
- 58:13a criminal's You know dream is to have you on
- 58:16Wi -Fi that they've compromised and they can
- 58:17get access to to your data So that that's I think
- 58:20a really really important thing that people sort
- 58:23of are not cautious enough about I would say
- 58:26out there. All right, there's a question about
- 58:29what are the AI tools for individuals or companies
- 58:32to fight cyber crimes? Did anybody have any ideas
- 58:36about anything that's sort of out there yet?
- 58:37I'm not really aware of anything. It just depends
- 58:40on what you're trying to stop. Like if you're
- 58:43trying to stop something that's email based,
- 58:45you may have to look for a tool that focuses
- 58:47on phishing emails. If you're looking for something
- 58:50that stops text messages, you may have to find
- 58:52a tool that, so there's no one catch all tool.
- 58:55Like I've seen like the company like no before
- 58:57where they do the phishing emails to a lot of
- 58:59corporations. I've seen where they have there's
- 59:02various texting ones that are out there. I can't
- 59:05say the one that's for sure going to catch everything.
- 59:08I haven't gotten to that point yet because A
- 59:10.I. is still very nuanced when it comes to actually
- 59:12preventing the cyber crimes because they're looking
- 59:16more so for behavior analytics. I've seen AI
- 59:19be used a lot more towards investigating crimes
- 59:22or helping with investigations of crimes to kind
- 59:24of minimize the amount of data you have to go
- 59:25through. But it just depends on the type of tool.
- 59:28So like if you have fishing tools, like a fishing
- 59:30tool, that's good to have within your outlook
- 59:32system or whatever system that you're utilizing.
- 59:36But I'd like know before it was one, there was
- 59:38one for anti -money laundering was, I think it
- 59:40was nice, but like. Actimize, I think the company
- 59:45name is just bio catch. There's a bunch of different
- 59:47companies out there That do have various tools.
- 59:51It just depends on what type of cybercrime you're
- 59:54trying because cybercrime is an all -encompassing
- 59:56huge umbrella What are you talking? What are
- 59:59you trying to protect yourself from? So I wish
- 1:00:00I had a better answer for like just specific
- 1:00:02tools If you send me an email or a message, I'll
- 1:00:06look those tools up off those researchers. I
- 1:00:08think I was from Paula To really see what what
- 1:00:11we can do to help with that That's great. Yeah,
- 1:00:14and I know years ago the FTC had a competition
- 1:00:17and the company called no no mo robo for robocalls
- 1:00:21actually won that and and there They came up
- 1:00:24with a product to help block sort of the robo
- 1:00:26robocalling thing So I think there are you know,
- 1:00:28there are definitely things that are out there
- 1:00:30But but I agree, you know sort of having having
- 1:00:33the the anti -fraud AI tools is I hope where
- 1:00:36where a lot more companies are going to be going
- 1:00:38a lot sooner And then what third parties do you
- 1:00:44suggest to use to test security systems? I don't
- 1:00:49know if we have any thoughts on that. I think
- 1:00:52I said it depends on what you're testing. Are
- 1:00:54you testing social engineering? Are you testing
- 1:00:56the physical system? Because there's pen, I mean,
- 1:00:58there's pen testers that do that. And there's
- 1:01:01a lot of different pen testing teams out there.
- 1:01:04But you would have to find a pen tester that
- 1:01:07you trust to be able to look at your data and.
- 1:01:11be able to say, hey, you're vulnerable in these
- 1:01:13positions. So I think that's what you have to
- 1:01:18look at. But if you look at data, pen testing,
- 1:01:20you look at social engineering to test your actual
- 1:01:22employees, whether they would actually fall for
- 1:01:24social engineering tactic or not. That's a different
- 1:01:27type of pen testing. So research pen testing
- 1:01:29and then find a company that you found that's
- 1:01:31reputable and that you can trust. And then I
- 1:01:34would go from there. Great. I think our last
- 1:01:38question is, does a password manager work across
- 1:01:42all of your devices? How do I use it across a
- 1:01:45desktop, laptop, phone, iPad, et cetera? You
- 1:01:49would have to install the official app. So don't
- 1:01:51install the go to the official company. And you'd
- 1:01:54have to install the app on your web browser,
- 1:01:57your phone, your laptop, whatever device. Like
- 1:02:00I said, I use a password manager. I have it installed
- 1:02:02on my laptop. I have it installed on my phone.
- 1:02:06and I haven't installed it on my desktop. So,
- 1:02:09and I can access it anywhere, but it's password
- 1:02:11protected. So it's only I can get into it. Actually
- 1:02:14it's biometric. So you can't even get into it
- 1:02:18unless you have my biometrics. But yeah, so you
- 1:02:22can do it across all different platforms. There's
- 1:02:25a few companies out there, but you would just
- 1:02:28download the official app and it stays locked
- 1:02:30until you unlock it. And then you can scroll
- 1:02:32through, you can look up what your password was.
- 1:02:34Sometimes they have autofill. If you want that
- 1:02:37part of it, you don't have to have autofill to
- 1:02:39put in, but definitely you can store a ton of
- 1:02:42passwords. And I can tell you right now, my entire
- 1:02:44cyber team, all of us use password managers.
- 1:02:47So I can tell you, our passwords aren't normal.
- 1:02:48We have the most random, weird passwords you
- 1:02:51could think of that are crazy generated, 20 characters
- 1:02:54long when you can't get into them. So the longer
- 1:02:56the password, the better. And the more lowercase,
- 1:02:58uppercase, you know, symbols, numbers, the more
- 1:03:03complicated, the better. So if you are going
- 1:03:06to do a password manager, do more than eight
- 1:03:07characters. Try to do like 12 or 13 characters
- 1:03:09at least. I would say a minor 20. So they're
- 1:03:13long. As they should be. Mine too. Okay. Well,
- 1:03:17I think we are at a bit past our time. So I just
- 1:03:21want to thank our panelists, Tracy and Mark,
- 1:03:24for a great presentation. I hope that the audience
- 1:03:27enjoyed it. I think there's a lot of good tips
- 1:03:30for people to go away with and appreciate everybody's
- 1:03:35contributions. Thanks for being here. Thank you.
- 1:03:39Thank you. I appreciate it. Bye.