Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Volkswagen's Electric Compacts: A Winning Hand
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep dive. Today we're looking at something
- 0:14really interesting. That whole idea of getting the
- 0:16best of both worlds in your next family car.
- 0:19You mean like electric power for the school run but still having
- 0:22petrol for the long haul? Exactly that.
- 0:24You get the clean, quiet, efficiency day-to-day, you know,
- 0:27nipping around town, but then crucially you've got that petrol
- 0:31engine reassurance for the big family Rd. trips.
- 0:34No range anxiety. Sounds pretty ideal on paper,
- 0:37doesn't it? It really does.
- 0:39OK, so let's untag this. Today we're diving into the
- 0:41world of plug in hybrid SUVSPHEVS as they're usually
- 0:46called. We've gone through a whole stack
- 0:48of sources, detailed car reviews, market analysis, you
- 0:50name it, to pull out the key insights for you.
- 0:53Our mission today? Well, first we're pitting 3
- 0:55popular family PHEVS against each other head to head.
- 0:59We've got the BYDCOUDMI, the Omoto 9 and the Volkswagen
- 1:03Terran. But then, as it's important,
- 1:06we're going to zoom out, way out.
- 1:08We need to understand the huge shifts happening in the global
- 1:10EV market, particularly what's going on in China.
- 1:13What does all this mean for the big established car makers?
- 1:16And maybe more importantly, what does it mean for you if you're
- 1:19thinking about your next family car?
- 1:21It sounds like quite a journey and honestly, probably a few
- 1:24surprises along the way. A really crucial look at where
- 1:27things are heading. Are you ready to dive in with
- 1:29us? Absolutely.
- 1:30Let's get started with the contenders.
- 1:32These three PHEVSUVS, 1st up from China, we have the
- 1:38BYDCLUDMIBYD. They're an incredibly affordable
- 1:43brand that's, well, really making waves globally right now.
- 1:46Their DMI system is pretty unique.
- 1:48It mostly uses the petrol engine, like a generator you
- 1:50see, to charge the battery. It only directly drives the
- 1:53wheel sometimes, like under heavy loads.
- 1:55So it behaves more like an electric car more of the time,
- 1:58even when the engines running. Exactly, that generator first
- 2:00approach gives you that smoother, quieter electric feel
- 2:03for longer stretches. The key difference really.
- 2:06Then there's another Chinese challenge with the Emoto 9.
- 2:08This was getting attention for it's pretty impressive electric
- 2:11range. And finally, the German
- 2:13contender, the Volkswagen Tehran, the established player,
- 2:16you know, known for quality, comfort, solid engineering.
- 2:19Just quickly for anyone new to this, APHED combines a battery
- 2:22and electric motor, great for short 0 emission trips like the
- 2:26school run or pop into the shops, but it also has a petrol
- 2:28engine that kicks in for longer drives so no worries are running
- 2:31out of charge on a long journey. OK, so we have two ambitious
- 2:35newcomers from China looking to disrupt things and then the
- 2:39German heavyweight, the familiar name, three very different
- 2:42approaches to the family plug in hybrid.
- 2:44It's quite a lineup, isn't it? What jumps out at you first?
- 2:47It really is a fascinating mix. And yeah, what immediately leaps
- 2:50out from the reviews is the price, especially from the new
- 2:53players. Let's look at the BYDCLUDMI.
- 2:57It starts from just 33,205 Bowers.
- 3:01Wow. Yeah, reviewers are literally
- 3:03calling it Britain's best value new car.
- 3:06And it's not like it's basic spec either.
- 3:07It comes quote, fully loaded standard kit includes things
- 3:11like a panoramic sunroof, heated and cooled seats, even a head of
- 3:14display. All standard.
- 3:16Heated and cooled seats. A standard on the base model.
- 3:18Yep. Now compare that to the
- 3:20Volkswagen Terrace. It starts quite a bit higher,
- 3:2243,905. It's definitely positioned as
- 3:24premium, delivers on that VW quality and space promise, but
- 3:28well, that's a £10,000 difference over the DYD.
- 3:30That's significant. £10,000. It is and the O Mota 9 it's
- 3:34actually priced slightly higher again, 44,990 lbs so top end of
- 3:39this group. It has impressive standard kit
- 3:41too apparently, but that price makes it feel quite expensive in
- 3:44this company. A £10,000 price gap?
- 3:48I mean, that buys a lot of family holidays, doesn't it?
- 3:50Or maybe just a very fancy set of alloy wheels.
- 3:53The BYD really seems to be shaking things up here.
- 3:56That kind of value proposition must be keeping competitors up
- 3:58at night, don't you think? How do they even do that?
- 4:01That's a really good question and it touches on their whole
- 4:03manufacturing approach, which maybe we can circle back to be a
- 4:07value wise, the BYD is making a statement.
- 4:09OK. Moving on from price though it's
- 4:11hard to ignore it. Let's get into the technical
- 4:12stuff, the battery range performance, the real power
- 4:17play. And here the Emoto 9 really
- 4:19stands out. Our sources call it the range
- 4:21champion. It packs a big battery, 34
- 4:24kilowatt hours. That gives it acclaimed 93 miles
- 4:26of electric only range. 93 miles just on electric.
- 4:29That's what they claim, yeah. Class leading for a PHEV.
- 4:32And combined with this petrol engine, the total range is
- 4:34apparently over 700 miles. It's also the most powerful
- 4:37here. 443 brake horsepower does zero to 62 in just 4.9 seconds.
- 4:44Whoa, OK, that's quick for a family, SUK.
- 4:46It is, and it has the fastest DC charging too, 80 kilowatts.
- 4:50Now the Volkswagen Terran. It has a 19.7 kWh battery, good
- 4:55for a very useful 75 miles electric range.
- 4:58Plenty for most daily driving I'd say.
- 5:00Combined range claimed near 600 miles though, or some reviews
- 5:03felt that might be a bit optimistic.
- 5:05In the real world, DC charging is 40 kilowatts.
- 5:08Oh, and interestingly, this 1.5 liter petrol engine was noted as
- 5:12being surprisingly vocal when it kicks in.
- 5:15Not quite as seamless then. Potentially not.
- 5:17Then there's the BYDCLUDMI. It offers 2 battery sizes, 18.3
- 5:21or a larger 26.6 kWh option. The bigger one gives you 78
- 5:25miles EV range. So right up there with the
- 5:26Terran. And remember that DMI system we
- 5:29mentioned? It's very efficient, combined
- 5:30range of seven and six miles. Basically neck and neck with the
- 5:32Emota. The downside?
- 5:34Slowest DC charging. Just 18 kilowatts.
- 5:36Only 18 kilowatts only. Yeah, but for a PHEV most people
- 5:40charge at home overnight anyway, right?
- 5:42So maybe not a deal breaker for everyone.
- 5:44That's true. OK.
- 5:45This is where it gets really interesting though. 93 miles
- 5:48electric on the Emota, that is a huge number for a plug in
- 5:52hybrid. For you listening now, how
- 5:55important is that maximum pure EV range versus the total
- 5:59combined range? I mean, you've still got the
- 6:01petrol engine backup. Does that massive EV range
- 6:04actually change the game, or is it maybe a bit overkill compared
- 6:08to, say, the Byd's overall efficiency?
- 6:10It's a real balancing act. It absolutely is.
- 6:13And that balance might also depend on how these cars
- 6:15actually feel on the road. So let's talk driving dynamics,
- 6:18ride comfort, handling. You know the comfort zone.
- 6:20Here the sources are pretty clear.
- 6:22The Volkswagen Terran is the most sophisticated Dr. I got
- 6:25praise for a really comfortable ride, helped by adaptive
- 6:27dampers. Apparently that's nicely
- 6:28reactive steering and composed handling.
- 6:30Just feels well engineered, refined.
- 6:33Classic VW then, solid and reassuring.
- 6:35Pretty much, yes. Now the BYD Seal UDMI, it's
- 6:40described as comfortable enough, but it just doesn't have that
- 6:44same level of Polish as the Terran.
- 6:46The ride was called a mixed bag, sometimes a bit floaty, other
- 6:50times a bit firm over bumps and potholes and the steering a bit
- 6:54lifeless. Was the word used not as
- 6:56engaging as the VW? OK, so competent, but not
- 6:59exactly thrilling. Right now, the O Moto 9, this is
- 7:02where things kind of fall apart. According to the reviews, ride
- 7:05quality was described as poor. Busily fidgeting and bumping
- 7:10over surfaces doesn't sound very relaxing.
- 7:12Ouch. Fidgeting and bumping.
- 7:14Not ideal for a family. Trip.
- 7:15Not really. And the brakes were called
- 7:17grabby and hard to modulate smoothly.
- 7:19That's quite a fundamental issue.
- 7:21Yeah, jerky brakes are never fun, so if you value a smooth,
- 7:24composed cruise, the VW sounds like the clear winner here.
- 7:28Nobody wants a messy ride, especially with kids in the
- 7:30back. Makes you think though, what are
- 7:32you willing to compromise on? Would you sacrifice some ride
- 7:34refinement for say that huge EV range or the BYDS price?
- 7:38Things about trade-offs, isn't it?
- 7:40OK, let's move inside the car interior space.
- 7:42Practicality. Family first, right?
- 7:45A family SUV needs to work for family life, and in this area
- 7:48the Volkswagen Terran is hailed as the undisputed king of space.
- 7:53It offers loads of rear leg room apparently, and a simply massive
- 7:56705 liter boot. 700 liters. Wow, it's huge.
- 8:01It is easily the most practical for families who regularly pack
- 8:04the car to the brim. The interior itself is described
- 8:07as typical VW. Well built, solid, easy to use,
- 8:11maybe nothing less exciting design, but functional and high
- 8:13quality. The BYDCLUDMI also does well
- 8:17here. It impresses with a spacious
- 8:19cabin, and reviewers noted the wide opening rear doors that's.
- 8:22Actually a really useful detail makes getting kids in and out so
- 8:25much. Easier, exactly, and the
- 8:27interior itself feels, well, surprisingly upmarket for the
- 8:29price. Nice materials, good design, but
- 8:32there's a trade off. Boot space is smaller, 425
- 8:36liters. Quite a bit less than the
- 8:37Terran. Considerably less, yeah.
- 8:39More passenger focus, less cargo focus.
- 8:40Perhaps the Emoto 9. It has an attractive high
- 8:44quality feeling interior too. And it's boot is pretty big, 660
- 8:48liters. So much closer to the Terran in
- 8:50that respect. OK, so good space there.
- 8:52Any drawbacks? Yes, a couple were mentioned.
- 8:55An oddly high set driving position was one comment.
- 8:58And also poor rear visibility, which you know isn't great for
- 9:02maneuvering a family car around town or in tight parking spots.
- 9:05Ah, the battle of the boot space.
- 9:07It's amazing how fast even a big car shrinks when you're trying
- 9:10to pack for a week away with the family, isn't it?
- 9:12So what does this mean for you? If you're constantly hauling
- 9:14pushchairs, Sports gear, maybe the dog?
- 9:18That Terran space is hard to beat, but maybe for city driving
- 9:20the BYD is easier access. A nice cabin even with a smaller
- 9:23boot could be the better fit. Depends on your life really.
- 9:25Absolutely. OK, Next up, technology and
- 9:28infotainment. The modern must have screens,
- 9:31connectivity, user interface. It's a huge part of the
- 9:33experience now and the BYD seal UDMI really scores highly here.
- 9:38The big talking point is it's fantastic 15.6 inch rotating
- 9:42touchscreen. Rotating like portrait and
- 9:45landscape. Exactly.
- 9:46Bit of a party trick maybe, but reviewers said the system itself
- 9:49is really good. Intuitive, supports wireless
- 9:52Apple CarPlay and Android Auto plus standard tech is excellent
- 9:56head up display, 10 speaker, Infinity audio system.
- 9:59All standard, even on the base model.
- 10:01All standard, every model gets the same high level of kit.
- 10:04No need to take expensive option boxes for the good tech.
- 10:07That's a massive plus for value the Volkswagen Terran it has an
- 10:11improved VW infotainment system, large screen and, crucially, the
- 10:15welcome return of physical steering wheel buttons.
- 10:18People definitely prefer actual buttons sometimes.
- 10:21They do easier to use without looking.
- 10:23It also has voice control with ChatGPT integration, which is
- 10:26nice modern touch, but some touch screen buttons for other
- 10:29controls are still described as fiddly.
- 10:31So not perfect but improved. And the Emoto 9, Well on paper
- 10:35it has an impressive kit list loads of features, but the
- 10:38usability reviewer said it was just lain poor.
- 10:41Oh. Dear, how so?
- 10:42Frustrations included things like difficulty getting back to
- 10:45the car's own menus once you're using ALE Carlay, and the driver
- 10:49assistance systems were apparently infuriatingly
- 10:52intrusive, just near constant binging and bonging of warnings.
- 10:57Yikes, that sounds incredibly annoying, like a recipe for a
- 11:00headache on a long journey and maybe even distracting.
- 11:03Exactly. It really undermines the premium
- 11:05feel they seem to be going for elsewhere.
- 11:07So a rotating screen is cool, definitely a conversation
- 11:10starter, but constant alerts? How much does that seamless, non
- 11:14annoying tech experience matter to you when you're driving?
- 11:18Is a flashy feature worth putting up with constant
- 11:20interruptions. It's a very personal
- 11:22calculation, isn't it? OK, so let's bring it all
- 11:24together. We've looked at price range,
- 11:26driving field, practicality, tech.
- 11:29The Volkswagen Terran great space, refined drive, but comes
- 11:32with that hefty premium price. The Omoda 9 incredible electric
- 11:37range, powerful but let down significantly by poor ride
- 11:40quality and frustrating tech. Plus it's expensive, which
- 11:43leaves the BYDCLUDMI, and based on our sources, it's the clear
- 11:48stand out here. It just, well, demolishes its
- 11:50rivals on price while still delivering A spacious, high
- 11:53quality cabin packed with user friendly tech.
- 11:56And that efficient DMI hybrid system is genuinely clever.
- 12:00For just over £33,000 you get a family SUV that does almost
- 12:04everything really well. The competition just can't match
- 12:07that overall package right now. It really feels like it sets a
- 12:09new benchmark for plug in hybrid family SUV's.
- 12:13So the BYDCLUDMI takes the win in our comparison today.
- 12:16But as you hinted earlier, this story is much bigger than just
- 12:19these three cars, isn't it? This head to head is really just
- 12:21a small snapshot of a massive transformation happening
- 12:24globally, especially in China. It shows how fast the game can
- 12:27change. Absolutely.
- 12:28It's a really fascinating dynamic situation.
- 12:30We're seeing this incredibly rapid switch to EVs in China and
- 12:33it's having a huge impact, particularly on the established
- 12:36traditional car makers, brands like Volkswagen, Toyota, Nissan,
- 12:41Hyundai, they're all looking at potentially their worst sales
- 12:45figures in China in years. Wow, worst in years.
- 12:49Why the sudden drop? It's primarily down to that
- 12:51rapid shift away from traditional petrol and diesel
- 12:54cars, ICEVS. Take VW for example.
- 12:57Their overall sales in China fell dramatically from around
- 13:004.1 million cars just a few years ago down to 2.9 million.
- 13:04That's a massive hit. So it's not just a small dip.
- 13:07What are Chinese buyers actually looking for now that's causing
- 13:10such a major shift away from these big, familiar brands?
- 13:13That's the crucial point. Our sources say Chinese
- 13:15consumers really care about in car technology and software like
- 13:18really care. And that's an area where
- 13:20traditional brands, including VW, have openly struggled.
- 13:23Some of their software issues even became Internet memes in
- 13:26China. Oh dear, memes about your
- 13:27software is never a good sign. Not really.
- 13:30And Chinese buyers also seem to value affordable, future packed
- 13:34cars over perhaps the historical prestige of some legacy brands.
- 13:39This shift in what consumers want has just opened the door
- 13:43wide for Chinese brands like BYD.
- 13:46They're dominating the EV market.
- 13:47They're now sometimes even out selling Tesla locally.
- 13:50That's incredible, a complete reordering of the market.
- 13:53So beyond just what buyers want and the new tech from local
- 13:56players, what else is driving this EV boom in China?
- 13:59It's been a combination of factors.
- 14:01A real perfect storm. Government policy has been huge
- 14:04heavy subsidies for EV manufacturers, a massive push to
- 14:07build charging infrastructure quickly, and unique incentives
- 14:11for buyers like those special green license plates.
- 14:13The ones that bypass lotteries and restrictions.
- 14:15Exactly. They make EVs incredibly
- 14:17attractive, especially in big cities where getting regular
- 14:19plates can be difficult and expensive and driving
- 14:21restrictions apply. Then there are the environmental
- 14:24benefits people are noticing. Clearer skies, less noise
- 14:27pollution in cities and of course the much lower running
- 14:30cost for consumers are a big draw.
- 14:31Cheaper to run, easier to buy and use in cities, better for
- 14:34the air, quite compelling. And strategically, the Chinese
- 14:38auto industry saw this whole EV transition as a massive
- 14:42opportunity, a chance to leapfrog the West and become
- 14:46world leaders rather than constantly playing catch up on
- 14:48traditional engine technology. Wow.
- 14:51What's fascinating here is how quickly an entire huge market
- 14:54can pivot when all those factors align.
- 14:57Government push, consumer pull, and industry ambition.
- 15:00It really is like a Wild West for innovation over there.
- 15:04If you're finding these insights into the global car market as
- 15:07electrifying as we are, do hit that like button and subscribe
- 15:10to the Deep dive. It helps us keep bringing you
- 15:12this kind of analysis. So faced with this incredible
- 15:15surge from local brands like BYD, what are the established
- 15:18players like Volkswagen doing? Are they just accepting defeat?
- 15:21No, not at all. They're fighting back hard.
- 15:24They've implemented what they're calling a China for China local
- 15:27development and procurement. Plan China for China, so
- 15:29designing and building cars specifically for that market,
- 15:33not just adapting global models. Precisely.
- 15:36It's a much deeper level of localization than before.
- 15:39The key part of this is significantly expanding their
- 15:42R&D center in Hefei, the Volkswagen China Technology
- 15:45Company, or VCTC. That's already their biggest
- 15:48development hub outside Germany. And this VCTC, what's its
- 15:53specific mission in this China for China strategy?
- 15:56More than just engineers in a building, presumably.
- 15:58Well, absolutely. VCTC is tasked with driving
- 16:01local innovation and drastically speeding things up.
- 16:04The goal is to cut the time it takes to develop new vehicles
- 16:07and components by 30%. 30% faster how?
- 16:11Through more efficient processes and new tech.
- 16:13For instance, they have something called an E4 poster
- 16:16system. It's a rig that can simulate an
- 16:18entire vehicle's life cycle of stress and endurance testing on
- 16:21the battery and chassis in just one month, instead of the three
- 16:24months it used to take doing it on test tracks.
- 16:26Oh, so compressing testing time dramatically.
- 16:29Exactly. High loads active battery
- 16:31testing. It replicates real world use
- 16:33much faster. They're also heavily using
- 16:36virtual reality in the design validation phase.
- 16:39They can quickly tweak ergonomics, controls, bodywork
- 16:42in VR, saving loads of time and money compared to building
- 16:45physical prototypes for every little change.
- 16:48Smart using tech to accelerate development?
- 16:51What about the cars themselves? Well, they're developing a brand
- 16:54new electric platform specifically for the entry level
- 16:57Chinese market. It's derived from their existing
- 16:59MEB platform that's the base for the ID .3, ID .4, etcetera, but
- 17:04tailored for Chinese tastes and cost structures.
- 17:07And they're aiming to develop cars on this new platform in
- 17:09just 36 months. It's about a third quicker than
- 17:12their usual time frame. Very ambitious.
- 17:14And they're not doing it all alone.
- 17:15They're forging key partnerships with local Chinese companies.
- 17:19They've got to deal with X Peng, another big Chinese EV player,
- 17:22to jointly develop 2 new electric cars, and they're
- 17:25partnering with JC Group to build a new plant specifically
- 17:28for making high voltage battery systems in China.
- 17:31OK. So this raises a really
- 17:33important question, doesn't it? We're seeing this incredible
- 17:36pace of change, innovation coming from everywhere,
- 17:39established giants like VW adapting aggressively with
- 17:42localized strategies. It really makes you wonder, will
- 17:46all this hyper competition, this intense focus on specific
- 17:50markets like China, ultimately lead to better, maybe more
- 17:53affordable cars for everyone all around the world, or will it
- 17:57lead to more regional divergence?
- 17:59That's the big questions. Let's recap.
- 18:00We've seen today how plug in hybrids like the ones we
- 18:03compared offer this really compelling mix of electric and
- 18:05petrol. We saw the BYDCLUDMI emerge as a
- 18:08benchmark for value challenging established players.
- 18:12And we've dived into how the whole global car market is being
- 18:14fundamentally reshaped, particularly by the EV
- 18:16revolution in China. It's forcing everyone, new
- 18:19players and old guard alike, to innovate and adapt faster than
- 18:21ever. Which leads us to a final
- 18:23thought to leave you with as these big automakers double down
- 18:27on local for local strategies, tailoring cars and tech for
- 18:31specific regions like China, will we end up with a future
- 18:35where cars are fundamentally different depending on where you
- 18:37buy them, truly custom built for regional tastes?
- 18:40Or will the market eventually consolidate again, perhaps
- 18:43around a few dominant global EV platforms, leading us back to a
- 18:47more universal world car? What do you think is the next
- 18:51big disruption? Let us know your thoughts and
- 18:54please don't forget to like this deep dive and subscribe for more
- 18:56insights that aim to cut through the noise.
- 18:59Thank you for joining us on the Deep Dive today.
- 19:01We look forward to sharing more fascinating discoveries with you
- 19:03next time.