Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Teaching Isn't a Checklist
Transcript
- Ilana: Have you ever walked out of a lesson thinking, I did everything I was supposed to do? I started with asking the students what they already knew. Then I front-loaded information, I modeled, I cold-called, I checked for understanding, I used mini whiteboards. I finished with an exit ticket. And somehow the lesson still totally flopped. If you've ever had that feeling, you are not alone. Today we're talking about something that's quietly happening in education. Teaching is becoming smaller because we're losing our professional autonomy. And through that, teachers are being asked to think less. To not use your professional judgment. Think about it. When you think about the resources that are in the schools right now, are scripted. To make it easier to use. Teachers are begin are being given more strategies, more routines, more frameworks, and sometimes that equals fewer opportunities to exercise the one thing that actually makes teaching the profession that it is, which is your professional judgment. Your admin will tell you what you're learning on your professional development day. And if you actually already have something in mind that you really wanted to learn about, that you were excited to learn about and bring into your classroom, sometimes the roadblocks to be able to do that on your own are just too great and you end up going along with it anyways, even though you're not as engaged and you're not getting as much out of it. You can have two teachers who do the exact same lesson using the similar strategies, but one class will have a completely different experience than the other class, which actually happened a few years back with myself and my buddy class. We were teaching about the Salish Sea because we had signed up to do the same field trip and they had put us together because we were already buddy classes. We were doing the similar lessons and we started noticing when we got both classes together, as you do to you know, create richer learning experiences and get diverse perspectives. My class was extremely enthusiastic about the learning and the opportunities and and engaged in what we were doing. And they were the ones that were answering most of the questions, even though both classes were learning the same things and doing the same lessons. The difference was that I knew when to use which strategy and I had the why behind it, backing it up. I made sure that the tools I had to create real curiosity engagement, which led to a lot of enthusiasm. And I started thinking about this because I read a TES article by Sam Gibbs that was titled How We Dumb Down Teaching and What We Must Do to Fix It. I don't know if you read the article, it is available online. I'll make sure to put the link to it in the description. And that article really did stop me in my tracks because it gave language to something that I had been noticing for quite a while. And kind of what Gibbs in the article is that they notice that over time teaching has gradually been reduced to something that looks much simpler than it really is, In the efforts to improve consistency, reduce workload, and support new teachers with fewer and fewer resources, as well as being able to respond to accountability pressures, you know, education has become very good at identifying the visible things that teachers do. You know, they've developed instructional frameworks, teaching playbooks, coaching models, and lists of high impact strategies. And you know, of course, none of those things are inherently problematic and pretty helpful in most cases. You know, new teachers do need models. Schools absolutely benefit from a shared language and 100% reach research should absolutely inform your practice. However, Gibbs is really interesting in how She challenges us to ask what happens when your focus shifts almost entirely to the observable behaviors of teaching, what you can actually see happening, which, as you know, is a very small aspect of teaching, of what you do all the time. what happens when we start evaluating teaching by whether certain strategies are present rather than think? Thinking about what led to the decisions to use those strategies in the first place. I think this is really this is exactly where the importance of teaching as a profession is lost. Because teaching isn't simply, you know, a succession of techniques, it's a process of constant interpretation and decision making. You are Continuously asking yourself, what are my students understanding? Where are they struggling? What do they need next? Which strategy fits in this moment? And you know, you are making those decisions hundreds of times a day in seconds. when professional learning focuses only on what to do without helping teachers understand the why behind a strategy working, understanding when it works and when it doesn't, there's a risk of treating teachers as technicians rather than professionals instead of developing judgment teachers end up developing compliance and when that doesn't work you feel like a failure even though you're not Her argument isn't that we should abandon evidence informed practice or shared approaches. Of course not. It's that it should strengthen your thinking as a teacher instead of replacing it. The goal of professional learning isn't to produce identical lessons. It should be to help teachers make increasingly sophisticated decisions in response to the students in front of you. As I was reading the article, I kept thinking back to one sentence. The strategy isn't the pedagogy. The decision is the pedagogy. Your decision in the moment. That is the pedagogy. You know, pedagogy is knowing why you're using the strategies and the tools you're using in different scenarios. The pedagogy is knowing when to use them and how to adapt them. Also, knowing when to not use them, right? Picking and choosing those strategies and tools that will enable the lesson to really have an impact. And All of that is the intellectual work of teaching. Pedagogy lives in professional judgment, not in the strategy itself. Okay? And what I mean by that is, you know, it the pedagogy is the decision, you know, whether, when, why, for whom, and how. Your pedagogy is knowing which tools to use for one student and which tools to use for a different student. Or which tools work for math and which tools and strategies work for teaching paragraph sequencing instructor, right? And so, you know, we can see those results in the classroom. if many of your students kind of bomb a question on a quiz, maybe the checklist tells you, well, you need to move to independent practice, but you As a professional, you ask, well, why did they miss it? Was the vocabulary unfamiliar? Did my explanation confuse them? Are they tired today? You know, has there been a heat wave? Was the track meet yesterday? And you know, then you take note of the room and you maybe ask the class how they're feeling, or the individual students. And then you know you create the plan. And that matters much more than a checklist you were given at a pro D or the next step the book is telling you to do because you know your students and you need to trust that knowing. You need to trust yourself. When I first started creating my own professional development workshops and I was going around facilitating, I once heard someone describe professional development as needing to be designed for the weakest teacher. And that phrase has stuck with me because it sounds so painful. you learn from good things and you learn from things that don't feel as great, right? And so it did make me realize that some teachers do view professional learning as equaling compliance, that they were getting told what to do, which as a pro professional development lover and a facilitator, it did it broke my heart. Because I don't think that's how professionals grow. You know, I'm sure you don't think that's how you grow. you know the moment that the lesson you're teaching isn't going according to your plan. Half the class understands, half the class doesn't, someone asks a brilliant question, someone else is upset, you have 30 seconds to decide what happens next. Nobody hands you a checklist for those real life moments. You have that knowledge. you know your students. Personally, I think evidence informed practice does scare a lot of teachers, but research it's not supposed to Eliminate your judgment, it helps you, it supports you in the decisions that you make and the paths that you take in the learning journey that you give your students. And you can also say, Hey, I'm doing this because this is the research, and it it supports what I'm doing in my classroom. I kind of like that because research then gives you the principles. And the facts that help you not only understands the decisions that you're making for your own students, but it also kinda helps other people understand. So for instance, when people ask, Well, what do you do for your literacy lessons as an inclusive education teacher? I talk about, you know, the Anita Archer method and I say that I follow I follow her method for teaching, you know, phonics for literacy. and I leave it there. If the other person wants to like research that, fantastic. But it's not up to me to kind of talk about that. I just say this is it, you know, obviously it's written in research, and I move on. I'm using my professional judgment to discern what will work for my students. Just like you do every day. Great teaching is about developing your judgment. It's about professional thinking you do every minute as a teacher that you are interpreting your students' learning. You're pivoting how you teach to better reach your students, And the more you are able to recognize how much knowledge you have and develop the judgment that you have, the better your students will learn. So when you do get back to the classroom. Don't think about if you use the strategy. Ask yourself, why did I choose the strategy? What evidence did I see that I was responding to? Would I make the same decision again? Because those questions, that reflection, that is absolutely how professional judgment grows. It's not by collecting more techniques, but it's about deeply understanding this techniques and strategies that you use. and having the why behind it. Thanks so much for watching. I'll see you next time.