Latest / Stacking The Box, a Football Podcast / College Football EXPLODED in Week 7… Is the 24-Team CFP a HUGE Mistake?
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome to another edition of Stacking the Box College Football Podcast.
- 0:04[SPEAKER_01]: That's Cody Williams.
- 0:06[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Josh Yorish and we have to talk about one of the wildest college football Saturdays.
- 0:13[SPEAKER_01]: I can possibly remember week seven in college football.
- 0:17[SPEAKER_01]: had half the AP top 10 go down, including the number one and number two teams, a ton of wild upsets were going to do our best to sort through everything, hit on all the big games, because they were a ton of big games outside of that top 10 as well.
- 0:33[SPEAKER_01]: Cody, I just want to open with this.
- 0:38[SPEAKER_01]: The SEC coaches,
- 0:41[SPEAKER_01]: are some of the most interesting exciting figures and in college sports obviously but they can also be maybe the most annoying sometimes always talking about it's just so different down here you don't understand every week so war the big ten has weeks off and they get perdu and maybe that's not a good example Maryland and Rutgers and
- 1:04[SPEAKER_01]: This, you know, we have so many teams in the SEC, anyone can beat any given Saturday and for a long time, it's mostly been not true, at least the gap that they like to portray between the big ten and the other conferences.
- 1:28[SPEAKER_01]: limping to rivalry games a week after and get got and it looks like it is just kind of different down there every Saturday.
- 1:38[SPEAKER_00]: No 100% I think that there is a lot of hot air that has been expended on in terms of the SEC being quote unquote different.
- 1:47[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think this is like
- 1:49[SPEAKER_00]: It's different this year and that I think this is the deepest, like power conference we've seen in like many years.
- 1:55[SPEAKER_00]: It's, I think, top to bottom, like, well, not to bottom because I, you know, shots out to Vanderbilt and Arkansas play in this week, which I know I'm really cared about because I do think that is the bottom of the conference, but you have so much depth in the sleek.
- 2:09[SPEAKER_00]: I think the difference that really sets this apart, that'll be on the depth is I'm not sure that there's a clear separator at the top because we thought that was Georgia after the Alabama game,
- 2:18[SPEAKER_00]: but potentially not because they also look just as susceptible as anyone if you can lose the Auburn, you can probably lose to anyone in this conference and so it is one of those things where I think the depth like far exceeds whatever the big tin has to offer.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_00]: But I also don't know if any of these teams are better than Ohio State on a neutral field if we're talking power rating style.
- 2:37[SPEAKER_00]: So like it's one of those things where the more I look at the SEC, yes, I do think that the depth, like the argument that the coaches make it about this being a war every week, it's trueer than it's ever been.
- 2:49[SPEAKER_00]: But at the same time, if you go to war in the cultural playoff with the top of another conference, I'm not sure the SEC necessarily stacks up.
- 2:56[SPEAKER_01]: This is where I think I'm contractually obligated to say that Ohio State did lose to Texas, not on neutral field.
- 3:04[SPEAKER_01]: I think I agree, I watched that we came out of that Georgia and Alabama game and I felt like that should maybe be the National Championship game, like I felt like you could make a really convincing argument that those are the two best teams in the country.
- 3:18[SPEAKER_01]: I'm willing to give them both a little bit of a Mulligan on the fact that that was just a violent war at both teams came into this week with very significant injuries and a huge letdown spot.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_01]: not unlike how Ole Miss lost to Florida in a massive let down spot after their battle with LSU.
- 3:37[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, we can get to the big 10 and obviously that was supposed to be the game of the week in Indiana, Ohio State.
- 3:43[SPEAKER_01]: And it kind of delivered in a rockfighting, big 10 rematch, big 10 championship game rematch fashion.
- 3:50[SPEAKER_01]: But
- 3:52[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know that I necessarily feel that Indiana or Ohio State, whoever you want to put is the number one team, and maybe that changes with Julian Sand, is like better, is meaningfully better than the teams in the SEC.
- 4:06[SPEAKER_01]: I think the top of the SEC is,
- 4:09[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, the top of college football, it has flattened out.
- 4:13[SPEAKER_01]: And this is kind of the point that maybe I won't jump into it because I want to talk about some of these games, and I think it's worth giving them their due before we talk about the 2014 playoff.
- 4:24[SPEAKER_01]: But a lot of the premise I want to talk about today is,
- 4:28[SPEAKER_01]: This kind of, in my eyes, that was the perfect weekend to justify expansion of the playoff because there are so many teams that can actually jump up and get the top teams, the flattening of the sport, all the spending, Auburn has according to the athletics estimates, spent more money on its roster this year than Georgia is spending on its roster this year.
- 4:46[SPEAKER_01]: So it's not completely unreasonable or unfalemable that they would be able to hang on the same field with Georgia.
- 4:54[SPEAKER_01]: What is, I'll, I'll hyper focus on that game because it's the number one team in the country.
- 4:58[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 5:00[SPEAKER_01]: What is your concern level with Georgia after that loss to Auburn?
- 5:04[SPEAKER_01]: Are you giving them a full mull again?
- 5:06[SPEAKER_01]: Or are you saying you're not that good that Gunner Stockton could mess around with a bunch of turnovers and a week ago, you put the ball in the floor four times and didn't lose any of them this week.
- 5:18[SPEAKER_01]: You lost them.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think it really does come down to what you're talking about with the flattening of the sport at the top of the top of the, you know, the top of the sport and I guess that's what I was trying to say with the depth of the SEC because I think they just simply have more teams that are in that like plateau of great of a potential national championship winners.
- 5:38[SPEAKER_00]: I think that what I'm coming down to is I think my criteria for who can win a national championship this year is widening because I think there's not a perfect team there's not a team that's going to run away with it.
- 5:57[SPEAKER_00]: we saw that, it also looked like Georgia did not take that game seriously.
- 6:02[SPEAKER_00]: And is that a problem?
- 6:03[SPEAKER_00]: Are they susceptible if you don't take a game seriously?
- 6:05[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, because of the fighting at the sport of the top, at the top, you're not going to be able to go into every week, no matter if the opponent has a number next to their name or not, and not take a game seriously because there is depth that can jump up and bite you at any given point.
- 6:20[SPEAKER_00]: Aztecs is how that's going for him, you know what I mean?
- 6:22[SPEAKER_00]: And so like there's there's no weeks off in this league and like that if there's any concern for Georgia, it's that they took their foot off the gas in that moment in a game in a rivalry game, which is not something you typically see.
- 6:34[SPEAKER_00]: Having said that, I still think I fall more toward this is still one of the better teams in the country.
- 6:39[SPEAKER_00]: This is still a team that can win a national championship.
- 6:41[SPEAKER_00]: And so like
- 6:42[SPEAKER_00]: I'm maybe like pumping the brakes on how much, you know, gas we were giving to Georgia after last week, but I'm still not going to like look at Georgia and be like, oh, well, this team must offer and they definitely can't win a national championship.
- 6:55[SPEAKER_01]: I think the specific construction of this team is makes it
- 7:03[SPEAKER_01]: more vulnerable to the bad gunner stocked in game than maybe some other teams are to a bad quarterback game and the ceiling with gunner stocked in isn't quite as high as it is with a killing also a turner dot chamblas so you're not necessarily getting the upside and you're still getting a decent bit of the downside but I think that is probably too reductive for this team because the offensive line is so good they can run the ball so well I'm not like
- 7:31[SPEAKER_01]: I am willing to chalk it up.
- 7:32[SPEAKER_01]: It usually that isn't the case with a Kirby smart team.
- 7:35[SPEAKER_01]: Like Kirby smart teams are gonna be ready.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_01]: You can trust them.
- 7:39[SPEAKER_01]: They're bankable.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_01]: Very unlike a Texas Steve Sarkesian coach team.
- 7:43[SPEAKER_01]: That is not bankable at all.
- 7:46[SPEAKER_01]: But I just think it happens, right?
- 7:50[SPEAKER_01]: And Auburn got him.
- 7:53[SPEAKER_01]: Alabama.
- 7:56[SPEAKER_01]: I think there's maybe more reason, I mean, there's more reason to be concerned the fact that they now have two losses because somebody had to lose that Alabama Georgia game.
- 8:06[SPEAKER_01]: I think it was a defensive master class from Jim Knowles.
- 8:11[SPEAKER_01]: fantastic stuff like all the stunts, all the sim pressures.
- 8:15[SPEAKER_01]: He was making it really tough for killing Russell.
- 8:18[SPEAKER_01]: I also think the fact that Ryan Coleman Williams was not out there on the outside, made it a lot easier to cloud middle of the field zones and like tackle everything aggressively and play downhill than if you are worried about him beating you over the top.
- 8:31[SPEAKER_01]: Racing Delgado also not there.
- 8:33[SPEAKER_01]: The center for Alabama has been very good and he was missed as well.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_01]: Are you worried about it because I Alabama fans are ready to be done with Ryan Grub after they go scorelist in the second half for the second straight week.
- 8:49[SPEAKER_01]: And I kind of understand that a little bit, but I'm also probably just going to talk it up.
- 8:57[SPEAKER_01]: And I think killing Russell's awesome.
- 8:59[SPEAKER_01]: So I think you can still do everything.
- 9:01[SPEAKER_01]: You could still accomplish every goal you laid out before the season.
- 9:05[SPEAKER_00]: I think my concern level for Alabama is slightly higher, but it's not like we're not sounding the alarm or anything here.
- 9:11[SPEAKER_00]: We're not panicking by any stretch of the imagination.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_00]: But the last two weeks, I've kind of looked a little bit more when I like what I expected from Alabama coming into this season.
- 9:21[SPEAKER_00]: I think that this is a roster that does have holes.
- 9:24[SPEAKER_00]: Like you talk about missing Ryan Coleman wins.
- 9:26[SPEAKER_00]: The wide receiver that's on this team is pretty suspect at this point.
- 9:30[SPEAKER_00]: And like that's a problem, especially when you have a young quarterback who's going to have ups and downs as a 19 year old.
- 9:36[SPEAKER_00]: Like that's just the natural progression of point.
- 9:38[SPEAKER_00]: Like you're playing against guys three years or senior who have been doing this for a lot longer than you have been.
- 9:43[SPEAKER_00]: Like that's going to show up.
- 9:45[SPEAKER_00]: And especially when you're going out to your point, I get the coordinator like Jim Knowles
- 9:50[SPEAKER_00]: poke at every weakness and every pressure point that he possibly can having said that my favorite my biggest takeaway from this game is Tennessee like I'm taking more away from this game for Tennessee than I am for Alabama because again I'm giving Alabama the same the same grace that I am Georgia in terms of coming off of that game in Tuscaloosa for Tennessee like I think that this Tennessee team.
- 10:11[SPEAKER_00]: Has a ceiling that is still quite defined because the level of quarterback play like phase on Brandon is clearly not the right guy for this roster and George McIntyre gives them a high baseline But I don't think he really moves the needle in terms of what that passing often is gonna do But he does open up the run game for the Sean Bishop who I think is a really special player in that backfield and then you have a defense which
- 10:32[SPEAKER_00]: Typically Jim knows his defenses take about a year to really take and like really get underway.
- 10:37[SPEAKER_00]: Doesn't seem like we're getting that, we need that buffer period for the walls right now.
- 10:40[SPEAKER_00]: And if that's the case, that's like, that's a unit that can really level the playing field in an SEC to our point that is so deep, but deep in a way that everyone has flaws that can be exploited.
- 10:52[SPEAKER_00]: And so I think Tennessee, I think what this really does is moves Tennessee up into a tier closer to Alabama and Georgia than I previously had.
- 11:01[SPEAKER_01]: I definitely didn't have Tennessee in that tier.
- 11:03[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not willing to take them seriously for like a SEC championship or a national championship because of the, like, you define ceiling.
- 11:12[SPEAKER_01]: I think to the nose point, that's something he talked about pretty openly.
- 11:15[SPEAKER_01]: This offseason actually that, like,
- 11:18[SPEAKER_01]: it's he he doesn't have that buffer that maybe he used to have to integrate his his defense and didn't work at Penn State so he brought three Penn State guys with him wanted each level in Xavier Gilliam who's just a wrecking ball at nose tackle in defense of tackle.
- 11:34[SPEAKER_01]: Amari Campbell at linebacker and then to Jean Lane.
- 11:38[SPEAKER_01]: at safety.
- 11:39[SPEAKER_01]: So you have one at each level and he was kind of talked about how they helped to integrate this thing.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_01]: He also simplified some of this stuff on the back end.
- 11:47[SPEAKER_01]: I thought when I was going to watch the film of this game, it was going to be like classic Jim Null's coverage rotations and he's just confusing in 19-year-old.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_01]: And it was a lot of stuff up front because he can trust Arian Carter, his veteran linebacker and Gilliam is a machine down there.
- 12:03[SPEAKER_01]: So they did a ton of stunts and they stunted really well where they contained Russell and knew where the weakness was going to be in the pocket.
- 12:12[SPEAKER_01]: So that's where he's going to rush and then they had somebody right there.
- 12:14[SPEAKER_01]: Like it was it was complicated but it was kind of simple.
- 12:18[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and that's an evolution for Nulls that I didn't know that I would get.
- 12:22[SPEAKER_01]: I thought Nulls was best served with Caleb Downs and all the veterans at Ohio State.
- 12:28[SPEAKER_01]: And you do all the funky stuff on the back end because you can trust them to do all of that.
- 12:33[SPEAKER_01]: And he's getting it done without that at Tennessee.
- 12:37[SPEAKER_01]: I think that defense is like legit.
- 12:40[SPEAKER_01]: Very legit.
- 12:41[SPEAKER_01]: We came out of the Texas game going, what's wrong with Texas offense?
- 12:44[SPEAKER_01]: We're still doing that.
- 12:48[SPEAKER_01]: now doing this to Alabama.
- 12:49[SPEAKER_01]: Even though I don't think it was killing Russell's best game, I'm worried about those injuries on offense.
- 12:54[SPEAKER_01]: Like there are reasons, but they put up 10 points.
- 12:58[SPEAKER_01]: So even if you hold this Alabama offense to 20, I think you're doing a damn good job, right?
- 13:03[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_01]: And they were able to hold them with those injuries to 10.
- 13:06[SPEAKER_01]: So I, I agree with you.
- 13:08[SPEAKER_01]: The Sean Bishop is,
- 13:10[SPEAKER_01]: awesome in the backfield.
- 13:12[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to, if you give him what 25 carries, he's going to get you a buck 50 in two scores, probably.
- 13:20[SPEAKER_01]: I
- 13:22[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you can kind of win that way in the SEC right now, because it is like weirdly the sport is as it's evolving, it flattened so you think, oh, you need a lead quarterback play because that's going to be the differentiator and maybe that's still true, like we can have an Ole Miss conversation, but
- 13:41[SPEAKER_01]: Also, if everybody's coming back down a little bit and you can be elite defensively, you run the ball and you can not make mistakes, which George McIntyre hasn't really made a ton of mistakes.
- 13:50[SPEAKER_01]: You can win a lot of ballgame.
- 13:51[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I think the framing on Tennessee is worthwhile because I was very Alabama-pilled the way I watched this game and the way I've digested it afterwards.
- 14:01[SPEAKER_00]: No, 100%.
- 14:02[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean, as is natural to do, because I still think Alabama.
- 14:08[SPEAKER_00]: win healthy.
- 14:10[SPEAKER_00]: If we played this game again with that with Alabama fully healthy, I'm probably still picking out Alabama.
- 14:14[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't want to get that twisted like I think this was until your point about Jim Knows like he didn't confuse him with coverage, but he confused Q and Russell with what he was doing up front.
- 14:23[SPEAKER_00]: And Mike making him navigate the pocket, which to Jim Knows and Tennessee's credit, we saw that a little bit against Georgia with some of the pressure that they generated in some of the ways that they screamed up pressure against him in.
- 14:34[SPEAKER_00]: especially in that first half like key and Russell moving to his left a little bit like just looked on comfortable and getting him uncomfortable in those pressure point.
- 14:40[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, I mean full credit to Tennessee again, I I'm right there with you.
- 14:44[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think this is a team that's going to win a national championship, but I do think it's a team that like they did on Saturday can cause a lot of trouble for the teams that can potentially do that.
- 15:04[SPEAKER_01]: The Texas long horns Steve Syracuse in after that loss and the offense just sputtering again after once again a scripted first drive where they marched down the field 75 yard touchdown drive and you go it's going to be all right the Florida defense is what they need to fix this passing game it's all going to be good and then it spins its wheels for the next three quarters.
- 15:27[SPEAKER_01]: Sark said everything is up for evaluation after the game, and he was asked if that includes like playcalling and archmaning, and he said everything is everything, basically.
- 15:37[SPEAKER_01]: And last week we talked about you're ready for Sark to give up the reigns.
- 15:43[SPEAKER_01]: I did a video yesterday posted it on my Twitter and Instagram wherever you want to look.
- 15:48[SPEAKER_01]: Arch left a ton of meat on the bone in that game.
- 15:51[SPEAKER_01]: There were a lot of throws.
- 15:52[SPEAKER_01]: He just was turning down and I can't really understand why.
- 15:56[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe that's a sarc thing of him, the way he develops quarterbacks in and offense.
- 16:00[SPEAKER_01]: That's very screens and shots.
- 16:02[SPEAKER_01]: He wants them to read it out very high low and try to take the shots when you can.
- 16:08[SPEAKER_01]: And then if they're not there, I can get why that would bog you down and maybe not be great developmentally.
- 16:13[SPEAKER_01]: I can get that Sark has done this with a couple of really talented quarterbacks and not develop them, but I also think, man, archmaning is is a big problem for this offense right now.
- 16:26[SPEAKER_01]: He's an average quarterback who's playing a little bit worse.
- 16:31[SPEAKER_01]: His talent levels really high, but I'm there apparently going to be giving Redshirt freshman KJ Lacey more reps this week that report came
- 16:42[SPEAKER_01]: if you have to if you can only you can change both right you can change the play color and you can change the quarterback you can do whatever you want everything's under evaluation but what decision would you make if you had to go soccer or are right now for this offense I feel like we're going to differ on this but I would definitely I would I would still lean sort because I think so like to be clear you're one hundred percent correct this was I think the worst performance I've seen on tape
- 17:12[SPEAKER_00]: I think a lot of it stems from he's lost every bit of confidence that he ever had himself.
- 17:16[SPEAKER_00]: The confidence that he had coming in this 26 and I still think the root of that issue is Sark and is play calling and how he's trying to develop this offense around archmaning.
- 17:26[SPEAKER_00]: Do I think that that's the likely assumption?
- 17:29[SPEAKER_00]: I do not.
- 17:29[SPEAKER_00]: I think that we're more likely to see archmaning bench and we're likely to see Steve Sarkese and give up the reins, which might be the Sark's detriment in the end because if this Texas team doesn't make the
- 17:41[SPEAKER_00]: That's a lot of years of unmet expectations that we're talking about at that point, whether you're talking about Quinn viewers, whether you're talking about archmitting.
- 17:48[SPEAKER_00]: And so, but I still come down to this offense, it's not just that Sark has a problem developing quarterbacks.
- 17:56[SPEAKER_00]: I also think the offense has lost a little bit of its teeth.
- 17:59[SPEAKER_00]: I think that it hasn't necessarily developed.
- 18:02[SPEAKER_00]: You talk a lot about the designer stuff that Sark likes to run.
- 18:05[SPEAKER_00]: Well, that designer stuff is like two seasons ago, the designer stuff.
- 18:11[SPEAKER_00]: right now is where the designer's stopping his offense is coming from in.
- 18:14[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's the that's the root cause of everything that we're seeing with this offense.
- 18:19[SPEAKER_01]: I actually agree with you.
- 18:21[SPEAKER_01]: As big of a problem as I think archmaning has been and was against Florida, I would I think one I think it's easier to change the play collar with the everything that archmaning is, but I also think it'd probably be the right decision because he's still insanely talented, like how many
- 18:39[SPEAKER_01]: can make that throw he made on the 62 yard completion, like getting out of pressure, but like I end his face, just rips it down the sideline.
- 18:48[SPEAKER_01]: That's a ridiculous play.
- 18:50[SPEAKER_01]: And that's in there.
- 18:51[SPEAKER_01]: And this is not he's not like a 99th percentile tools quarterback.
- 18:56[SPEAKER_01]: I think maybe that is clouding some of the discussion where people were talking about him as the number one pick.
- 19:02[SPEAKER_01]: He's very toolsy, but you need the other stuff to work with it.
- 19:04[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 19:05[SPEAKER_01]: But I agree with you.
- 19:06[SPEAKER_01]: Like
- 19:07[SPEAKER_01]: deserves absolutely no leash on this right now.
- 19:11[SPEAKER_01]: He did similar stuff with yours developmentally.
- 19:14[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe yours was never going to get there.
- 19:17[SPEAKER_01]: I really think this stuff I saw the second half from arch last season.
- 19:21[SPEAKER_01]: He was getting there and now we're set back because
- 19:26[SPEAKER_01]: Like you said, defenses had an offense or an off season to look at that offense and see, okay, this is looks a lot of the similar stuff that Sark has been doing for five years and they figured out answers for it.
- 19:39[SPEAKER_01]: I would, yeah, I think Sark should give up play calling and I agree with you if this team doesn't make the college for all play off, so I shouldn't have a job like.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_01]: he not any job, but the Texas job.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_01]: He just isn't a reliable head coach.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_01]: This isn't a reliable team.
- 19:55[SPEAKER_01]: It's the most talented roster in the country for my money.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_01]: Colin Simmons has been an absolute monster.
- 20:01[SPEAKER_01]: I think we'll must champ while Buster Faulkner got him a couple times yesterday or Saturday.
- 20:06[SPEAKER_01]: he's still, you know, been the correct higher for this defense and improved it in the ways that it's a championship defense and the offense, which is Sark's baby and he got all the weapons.
- 20:18[SPEAKER_01]: He got Hollywood's brothers.
- 20:19[SPEAKER_01]: He got Cam Coleman.
- 20:20[SPEAKER_01]: He got offensive linemen and it's falling apart.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_01]: So I agree with you.
- 20:25[SPEAKER_01]: I think it falls on Sark more than Arch, even if Arch was worse Saturday than maybe Sark's play calling to my eye.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_00]: no 100% it's the totality of the issue because like yeah like you said this isn't this isn't a isolated incident for Texas for archmaning for sarkesian this is a pattern that dates back more so than just the beginning of this season it dates back to the beginning of last season it dates back to Quinnewer's like you mentioned and so yeah it's it really just comes down at the feet of sarkesian and there's a lot of evidence not just at
- 21:00[SPEAKER_00]: the University of Texas to suggest that this is a salt problem.
- 21:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 21:05[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 21:06[SPEAKER_01]: I agree with you there.
- 21:07[SPEAKER_01]: Another team that keeps winning in the other side of the Red River rivalry on Saturday can talk you keeps winning Oklahoma back in the lost column, John Meteer, what three interceptions of critical pick six at the end.
- 21:21[SPEAKER_01]: Man, it was so sad that Material goes out there with the drive a chance to drive it down, pick six, and then he's got to go out there again.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: Man, this is just so rough.
- 21:34[SPEAKER_01]: You actually, I like kind of filled out from at this point.
- 21:39[SPEAKER_01]: But what do you make of Kentucky?
- 21:40[SPEAKER_01]: Because Oklahoma, we can discard of them.
- 21:44[SPEAKER_01]: What do you make of this Kentucky team that will Stein, just, I mean, I'm not to bring this to my team, but I wanted Penn State to hire him so bad.
- 21:53[SPEAKER_01]: Like he's such a good play, call or man.
- 21:55[SPEAKER_01]: He's so good.
- 21:56[SPEAKER_01]: And he has this team playing really well.
- 21:57[SPEAKER_01]: The offensive lines get in push, like, can this team actually enter the 12 team conversation?
- 22:06[SPEAKER_00]: I think so, I like in this year's Kentucky team to Vanderbilt of last year.
- 22:11[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, and it's obviously different because I think a lot of that had to do with just scheming around Pavia whereas this is just the scheming totality when it comes to Kentucky and what Willstahn's capable of doing Kenny Minchi I don't think is as unique or special of a college on as Diego Pavia was But he runs the offense very smartly.
- 22:29[SPEAKER_00]: He just he he'd done it, you know It's kind it's an interesting contrast after talking about Sark and arch to talk about Kenny Minchi
- 22:42[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not discrediting the fact that you, you played Oklahoma on the road in Norman.
- 22:47[SPEAKER_00]: Oklahoma's defense is still one of the best in the country.
- 22:51[SPEAKER_00]: And you went toe to toe with them and said, we don't, we don't care.
- 22:54[SPEAKER_00]: And I think ultimately Kentucky has a problem where Kenny mentioned he's going to be asked to win a football game for them at some point and not just run the scheme.
- 23:03[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's going to catch them.
- 23:05[SPEAKER_00]: Much like it did Vanderbilt Lysher.
- 23:07[SPEAKER_00]: That's why I came up with that comparison.
- 23:08[SPEAKER_00]: His Vanderbilt was obviously a team that could clip.
- 23:10[SPEAKER_00]: Clip, anyone on any given week, but you get them in the right situation.
- 23:13[SPEAKER_00]: It's going to be a little bit too much of an uphill climb just because of the wreck was at talent on the roster.
- 23:18[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's where we're going to see Kentucky end up.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_00]: That doesn't mean you can't win nine games, which for year one at Kentucky for Will Stein is a tremendous and massive success.
- 23:28[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I completely agree.
- 23:29[SPEAKER_01]: And I think,
- 23:31[SPEAKER_01]: I agree with you about your point that they're going to run up against somebody where, I mean, they already did against Alabama, right?
- 23:36[SPEAKER_01]: It was a situation where you just can't match it.
- 23:39[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if that's on mincey or if that's on like the receivers on the outside, because Stalin is doing so much tight end, 12, have you 12, 13, have you personnel stuff, that I love?
- 23:49[SPEAKER_01]: It's just keeping defenses off balance.
- 23:51[SPEAKER_01]: It's such a different pitch than most offences out there throwing each week.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, I,
- 23:59[SPEAKER_01]: But we have to take them seriously.
- 24:01[SPEAKER_01]: It's two overtime wins and a lot of will signs, scheming it up, fine in the answers.
- 24:10[SPEAKER_01]: But eventually, the win total just gets so high where you go, all right, we have to have a real conversation about this team.
- 24:15[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that's going to happen with Kentucky.
- 24:17[SPEAKER_01]: But I don't know that they belong in the best team in the SEC conversation, which is where I feel like maybe we have to bring up Ole Miss.
- 24:27[SPEAKER_01]: After pounding Missouri, maybe if you just play the transit of property game, you're going to get lost in
- 24:35[SPEAKER_01]: I don't even know you it's impossible in the SEC right now.
- 24:39[SPEAKER_00]: It's absolutely impossible.
- 24:41[SPEAKER_01]: It's impossible to play the transit of property in.
- 24:44[SPEAKER_01]: So
- 24:45[SPEAKER_01]: This Missouri team that looked really good, couldn't run the ball at all against Mississippi.
- 24:50[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that was the biggest thing for me was the defense for Ole Miss.
- 24:54[SPEAKER_01]: I thought Simmons would get them in the secondary enough that this game, everyone wanted this game to be like Houston, Oklahoma State.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_01]: Those were going to be the two shootouts we got this week.
- 25:04[SPEAKER_01]: And one of them lived up to it, we can talk about that later.
- 25:07[SPEAKER_01]: Ole Miss though, just shut everything down, shut Jamal Roberts' water off after, like, him emerging as kind of this SEC star.
- 25:16[SPEAKER_01]: Do you take more out of this for Ole Miss?
- 25:19[SPEAKER_01]: Are you just done with Missouri?
- 25:22[SPEAKER_01]: Where do you fall on on that conversation and then Ole Miss in the best team in the SEC conversation?
- 25:29[SPEAKER_00]: So I definitely think this is more about Ole Miss.
- 25:31[SPEAKER_00]: I think this is still a better Missouri team than we saw a year ago.
- 25:34[SPEAKER_00]: Like I don't think this is the obligatory random SEC team at the end of the top 25.
- 25:39[SPEAKER_00]: Like I think this is probably the top 20 team in the country.
- 25:41[SPEAKER_00]: Based on what I've seen, you just ran into like up until your point, like Austin Simmons did move the ball in this game.
- 25:48[SPEAKER_00]: Like he threw for almost 340 yards in this game.
- 25:51[SPEAKER_00]: So like I still trust this Missouri offense to be able to move the ball against most units.
- 25:55[SPEAKER_00]: And I still do have some concerns about the Ole Miss defense.
- 25:59[SPEAKER_00]: But I definitely think you have to consider them as the top of the SEC because they're one loss came to your point.
- 26:04[SPEAKER_00]: Like if we're going to talk about Georgian, the Leitdon's white Alabama, and the Leitdon's white, and like give them the benefit of the doubt, we have to do the same for Ole Miss.
- 26:12[SPEAKER_00]: You came out of a war where you didn't just exhaust a bunch of physical energy against a really talented and really physical, LSU team.
- 26:19[SPEAKER_00]: You also exhausted a ton of mental energy in that game based up because of the way in kiffin of it all.
- 26:24[SPEAKER_00]: So like,
- 26:25[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's an excusable loss, as much as there is that in college football.
- 26:29[SPEAKER_00]: And when you have Trinidad Chambers and specifically Cawang, Lacey back in the backfield with him, and now you add McCoy in the backfield as well.
- 26:37[SPEAKER_00]: Like this is
- 26:39[SPEAKER_00]: This is an offense that I don't think many defenses are going to have a ton of answers to the caveat to that being you mentioned earlier and I knew we were going to talk about Ole Miss so I didn't bring it up at that time about Georgia being maybe more susceptible to bad court like a bad quarterback game than any other team of the country Ole Miss is that team that's the I think is more so good Georgia because of if traded at Chambers which to his credit we haven't really seen one from them and I think he's a far higher upside proposition than gunner stocked in his
- 27:08[SPEAKER_00]: But if he has a stinker, this team's going to be in trouble.
- 27:11[SPEAKER_00]: And that's kind of where I got coming to it.
- 27:12[SPEAKER_00]: But again, this is an SEC where Alabama has its flaws.
- 27:17[SPEAKER_00]: Georgia has its flaws.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_00]: Ole Miss has its flaws.
- 27:19[SPEAKER_00]: Like I think they are very much still in that same conversation because there isn't a perfect team in the conference and in the country.
- 27:28[SPEAKER_01]: I just haven't seen Trinidad have the stinker in a long time.
- 27:31[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly, man.
- 27:32[SPEAKER_01]: So even against Florida, he was really good.
- 27:34[SPEAKER_01]: So I think that's why I exclude them there.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_01]: But I understand the their range of outcomes hinges on the quarterback may be more than most.
- 27:45[SPEAKER_01]: You didn't have Ole Miss in a potential could win the national championship list a week ago.
- 27:50[SPEAKER_01]: You said you needed to reframe that a little bit this week.
- 27:53[SPEAKER_01]: Do they now enter that list and how how big is that list growing before we start to talk about like the 2014 playoff and and everything there.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_00]: I would certainly have them in that list because like the defense still does worry me, especially in the playoff format because you, you know,
- 28:09[SPEAKER_00]: You can put up 35, and if that defense hasn't all day, they can give up 42.
- 28:14[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm still very concerned about that.
- 28:18[SPEAKER_00]: Having said that, we saw what Trinidad Chambers and this offense were capable of in the college while playing a year ago.
- 28:24[SPEAKER_00]: And you know, there was turmoil going on there.
- 28:27[SPEAKER_00]: It's a lot more stable than it is than it was then.
- 28:29[SPEAKER_00]: So like I don't know how you could not include them that conversation into your point.
- 28:34[SPEAKER_00]: That this is probably about 12 teams right now.
- 28:36[SPEAKER_00]: After, okay, I'll just pass week.
- 28:37[SPEAKER_00]: Like I mean, I'm at a point where I'm like,
- 28:40[SPEAKER_00]: Do I trust you tall yet?
- 28:41[SPEAKER_00]: No, but like, can I roll them out as a national championship container now?
- 28:46[SPEAKER_00]: You know, like, we're in a spot where I think we've seen enough volatility and again, using this term flattening at the top of the sport that I don't think we're at a point where we can rule some of these teams out that haven't proven that they should be ruled out yet.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_01]: So,
- 29:04[SPEAKER_01]: I want like it's such a great week of college football to divert from talking about the games feels almost wrong, but it's it's pretty necessary because I do think it's a good framing of the conversation about the 2014 playoff and we'll get back to like the games, but I think this is the perfect segue and way to talk about it.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_01]: Is that weak of chaos of everything that we got?
- 29:27[SPEAKER_01]: Because the 12 team playoff, it opens access, right?
- 29:30[SPEAKER_01]: This is the word access, is the word that we're hearing about why the 2014 playoff needs to exist.
- 29:35[SPEAKER_01]: And I do understand that and I'll kind of go into some of the reasons why I can justify it and understand it a little bit.
- 29:44[SPEAKER_01]: But when you get a 12 team playoff, okay, this access opens up where there are a lot more games that matter.
- 29:50[SPEAKER_01]: and we found that's really fun down the stretch of a college football season.
- 29:54[SPEAKER_01]: I've loved the 12 team format to be honest with you.
- 29:56[SPEAKER_01]: I wish that was there.
- 29:57[SPEAKER_01]: Tinker with it and there are ways to make it even better and we stick there.
- 30:02[SPEAKER_01]: But
- 30:04[SPEAKER_01]: when you're opening that up a little bit, so many of these games are consequential.
- 30:10[SPEAKER_01]: George and Alabama can have their trip ups, and we don't have to write them off as a team.
- 30:13[SPEAKER_01]: We're not done with George and Alabama, and we're also not done with some of these two lost teams.
- 30:18[SPEAKER_01]: And so it culminates in this situation along with NIL and transfer portal and revenue sharing, where so many more teams are being serious contenders and belong in the conversation with one of the most fun days of college football that I think we've ever had.
- 30:34[SPEAKER_01]: Is that day better or worse with a 2014 playoff?
- 30:38[SPEAKER_01]: Because the argument against it is, well, now even Texas is lost to Florida, which feels like Texas isn't done, but it's red alert, it's anxiety time.
- 30:51[SPEAKER_01]: Now that's not really a problem, right?
- 30:52[SPEAKER_01]: Texas, they'll be fine, they'll get to, even if they get to eight wins, they're probably going to be in a 2014 format, right?
- 30:58[SPEAKER_01]: if we eliminate some of those stakes, we can go Notre Dame, losing to BYU, I mean, whatever, though Ironouts and Kings, BYU, Thuro Big Ponds, it's really not gonna matter.
- 31:10[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe that's still true in the 12th team, but that's the argument against it.
- 31:15[SPEAKER_01]: The argument for it is that, as you expand this access,
- 31:20[SPEAKER_01]: Even more games are now consequential.
- 31:22[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know that my brain could take that.
- 31:24[SPEAKER_01]: I certainly know my my table for twelve column cannot exist in a twenty four team because we will be up to 3 a.m. on Sunday.
- 31:36[SPEAKER_01]: Um, or 3 a.m. on Monday.
- 31:37[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, actually go a day further, but
- 31:42[SPEAKER_01]: I'm trying to reason whether it's better or worse that we're expanding to this.
- 31:48[SPEAKER_01]: I don't love the 2014 playoff, but I can see the argument is that day better or worse with it.
- 31:56[SPEAKER_00]: It's probably slightly worse, but I'm also a little bit of a nihilist when it comes to the 2014 playoff.
- 32:02[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:02[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:04[SPEAKER_00]: Is it what I would do, is it my ideal idealized version of a college football postseason?
- 32:09[SPEAKER_00]: No, I actually, to your point, think it is the 12 team playoff, because I too have been a huge fan of it.
- 32:14[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's the right number to set consequences for losses, but still give access to teams, like give access to teams that can trip up here and there.
- 32:22[SPEAKER_00]: Like I think that 12 team playoff is the right number for that, especially with the number of teams that in any given year, we believe can win a national championship.
- 32:32[SPEAKER_00]: I will say like to the devil's advocate argument of like why I think it's only slightly worse is because you still have games that have consequence because as of right now, basically what we saw and we're going to again, we'll talk about this game, but like Oklahoma State Houston is a game where that's talking about a team that right now, Oklahoma State is not in the 2014 playoff, Houston Houston played their way in there.
- 32:54[SPEAKER_00]: So there's still games that I really enjoyed from Saturday that have consequence and have
- 32:59[SPEAKER_01]: But is it better that our focus nationally is on Oklahoma and Houston and on Notre Dame BYU?
- 33:05[SPEAKER_00]: Well, to my next point, which is, I still think there are consequences.
- 33:10[SPEAKER_00]: They're just different sets of consequences, because one of the smart things I think they are doing with the 2014 playoff is the two rounds of home games, or on campus games, where now Notre Dame's thinking about, oh, we might be getting that first round game at home.
- 33:26[SPEAKER_00]: We're going on the road in week two and South Bend is a much different environment and so like there are still consequences that are being talked about here and to that point especially big and I think it does matter that we're also talking about week seven in college football because Yeah, I think Texas is a really good example in there because yes they would still be in a 2014 playoff and yes with the schedule they have
- 33:45[SPEAKER_00]: it probably would get in at eight and four, but your margin for errors slips up because yes, like that result matters for what happens in a week eight, what happens in week nine.
- 33:53[SPEAKER_00]: So like when we get this type of week, uh, this type of week in the middle of October, I don't think it lessons at that much because it still does raise the stakes for what's to calm down the line.
- 34:02[SPEAKER_00]: It still gives us
- 34:04[SPEAKER_00]: these consequences that are going to matter whether it's home games, whether it is even getting into the 2014 playoff.
- 34:09[SPEAKER_00]: Like, it makes the games that are forthcoming matter that much more.
- 34:13[SPEAKER_00]: And it makes the schedule moving forward that much more.
- 34:17[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I think it adds intrigue as you go further along because the results, the losses, the wins.
- 34:22[SPEAKER_00]: They still matter just in different ways.
- 34:24[SPEAKER_00]: And like, I say I'm a dialess because we're gonna get used to this just like we did the 12th playoff.
- 34:29[SPEAKER_00]: There were plenty of people who are pissed off about the 12th team playoff as well when we expanded there.
- 34:34[SPEAKER_00]: And like you like I wasn't like super in favor of it at the time.
- 34:37[SPEAKER_00]: I've changed my tune.
- 34:38[SPEAKER_00]: I thoroughly have enjoyed what we've seen in this era I'm sure I'll get there eventually with the 2014 playoff as well.
- 34:44[SPEAKER_00]: We just kind of have to adjust like what the consequences are not necessarily say that their art consequences because a team doesn't make the play.
- 34:50[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think that's necessarily the case Yeah, I think that's fair.
- 34:54[SPEAKER_01]: I I find I can make a lot of arguments for the 2014 playoff
- 35:01[SPEAKER_01]: in a macro sense, that I don't know if I can make the counter argument as well for the 12 team playoff, but I just like it better.
- 35:11[SPEAKER_01]: And I guess the main argument to me is that college football has,
- 35:16[SPEAKER_01]: always been a regular season sport.
- 35:18[SPEAKER_01]: And once you become a postseason sport, as we're seeing, you have to just keep expanding the postseason as every sport does college basketball, the MLB, everything because you become a postseason sport.
- 35:30[SPEAKER_01]: So then those are the games that matter.
- 35:32[SPEAKER_01]: Those are where the casual viewers flock to.
- 35:34[SPEAKER_01]: So then you need to maximize that revenue as much as possible.
- 35:37[SPEAKER_01]: And like that's the part that's annoying because I feel like there should be
- 35:42[SPEAKER_01]: that the only way we're going to prevent them from doing stuff like this, we being like the viewers and consumers is to stop watching.
- 35:50[SPEAKER_01]: But that's, to me, that's just such a frustrating answer because it's like, oh, I'm supposed to stop watching something that I love because they're making it materially worse at my expense.
- 36:01[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I don't, I get why that's the consequences, but shouldn't there be some social contract there where take care of the fans that really care about this to the
- 36:13[SPEAKER_01]: Tennessee's always going to care about beating Alabama.
- 36:16[SPEAKER_01]: Auburn's always going to care about beating Georgia.
- 36:18[SPEAKER_01]: That's always going to be a good day, regardless of anything.
- 36:21[SPEAKER_01]: Oklahoma's always going to care about beating Texas, right?
- 36:25[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know that you're going to zap that from Knoxville, from Auburn, from Aldead, from Norman.
- 36:34[SPEAKER_01]: because of playoff stakes.
- 36:37[SPEAKER_01]: Because in that moment, they want to beat their rival, and I think that's always going to exist.
- 36:41[SPEAKER_01]: I hope we don't get too far away from that root in the sport.
- 36:45[SPEAKER_01]: And then the more macro argument.
- 36:49[SPEAKER_01]: that I know the commissioners are making, and I do actually see the validity too.
- 36:54[SPEAKER_01]: Right now we have 20, I think it's 28 teams spending over 30 million at their high end estimate according to the athletics reporting, which I certainly am not really even taking with your in-to-sol.
- 37:07[SPEAKER_01]: I'll take that pretty clearly as fact.
- 37:10[SPEAKER_01]: So we have about maybe 30 teams spending about 30 million.
- 37:14[SPEAKER_01]: That's serious investment.
- 37:17[SPEAKER_01]: And you go to like 25 million, you're looking at 45ish teams, right, you're over 20 million, you're looking at most of the team, the power conference teams in the
- 37:35[SPEAKER_01]: reward only what 12 of those, or 11 of those teams, if say 45 or taking it seriously.
- 37:44[SPEAKER_01]: That's a really small chunk.
- 37:46[SPEAKER_01]: And how long until that number of 45 taking it seriously and spending it a real way, widdles down to 30.
- 37:55[SPEAKER_01]: And then your TV product on a weekly basis in the regular season is materially depleted.
- 38:04[SPEAKER_01]: because the gap between the serious vendors, the real contenders, and the rest of the power conference, widens to a level that we're now seeing between the power conferences and the group of six.
- 38:16[SPEAKER_01]: So then your further consolidating power in this sport that's always been so wide open in terms of
- 38:25[SPEAKER_01]: viewing interest, regionalities, all of these things on a given Sunday, any college football fan can have a selection of the things that they're interested in.
- 38:34[SPEAKER_01]: That narrows and all funnels up if we continue to do the 12th team thing, because eventually a...
- 38:41[SPEAKER_01]: Nebraska's the first team that jumps into my mind, probably not Nebraska because they'll always care, but a TCU maybe will say, what are we spending $28 million on this roster for what are we what are we getting out of it right all these mid tier programs even a
- 38:58[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, a Penn State's never going to stop.
- 39:00[SPEAKER_01]: I keep thinking of very, like, football schools, but a Kentucky.
- 39:03[SPEAKER_01]: If a Kentucky isn't able to get there, and they go, we're not doing this anymore.
- 39:08[SPEAKER_01]: We're a basketball school.
- 39:09[SPEAKER_01]: We're done trying to compete.
- 39:11[SPEAKER_01]: We'll take all the losses in this bloated SEC.
- 39:14[SPEAKER_01]: Not everybody can win every week.
- 39:16[SPEAKER_01]: Arkansas's already kind of doing that, right?
- 39:19[SPEAKER_01]: how long until you get more and more teams doing that that every week, you're looking at less competitive games on the field.
- 39:28[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's the argument that I'm most willing to latch on to with this 2014 thing and the access.
- 39:36[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe eventually those programs are going to say, okay, just getting into the playoff isn't really doing anything for us.
- 39:43[SPEAKER_01]: It's not
- 39:44[SPEAKER_01]: invigorating our fan base and our donor base in a way that we would like and that still happens.
- 39:49[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe the financial structure of the sport are so greatly overhauled by Congress or some other party that that doesn't even matter.
- 39:58[SPEAKER_01]: But I think that's the the argument that I'm seeing most clearly and understand the most about the 2014 playoff and the threat that I do think kind of this is side stepping.
- 40:11[SPEAKER_00]: No, I do think that, I mean, it's a fantastic point.
- 40:14[SPEAKER_00]: Like I'm looking at a Pittsburgh Pirates penit behind you.
- 40:18[SPEAKER_00]: And you know, talk about a team that just doesn't spin because what's the point?
- 40:23[SPEAKER_00]: You know what I mean?
- 40:24[SPEAKER_00]: It came compete with the Dodgers.
- 40:25[SPEAKER_00]: Can we compete with the Cubs in the division?
- 40:29[SPEAKER_00]: In baseball, I don't hold that argument because we're watching the brewers, the guardians, the rays and the css, but like I think in college football, it is a much more valid argument to make that at a certain point, if you limit it.
- 40:41[SPEAKER_01]: And in college football, not to jump you there and in college football, it is not a billionaire owner doing the spending in a lot of cases, it is the actual fans, sometimes it is billionaire donors, but it's not a billionaire owner.
- 40:55[SPEAKER_01]: donor and owner is a very kind of different thing.
- 40:57[SPEAKER_01]: I'm willing to take billionaires money and put it to something that I enjoy and any at any turn in society, but it is a different mechanism by which they are spending and I know Penn State fans right now are very upset about
- 41:12[SPEAKER_01]: the stadium renovations and rising ticket prices and a lot of fans fan bases are feeling that same pressure to the onus is on them to make the team good and that is something that's also unsustainable and a difference between pro sports and college sports that I think is is meaningful there not to not to jump your point on that no 100% but it's a phenomenal point and I'm glad that you made it because I'm I don't think Texas tech is holding all pretty time soon there obviously a college will play off contender in the 12 team era but
- 41:40[SPEAKER_00]: If you were to have Texas Tech like take like a slight step back and they're sitting in like that 16 range we stay at a 12 team play off play off how long is Cody Campbell going to keep you know donating the money that he is because to the point of ownership like ownership has a responsibility that is their asset that's something they bought Cody Campbell's doing this for love with the game brother yeah I'm sure he's getting some return some kick back from it but like at the same time like.
- 42:04[SPEAKER_00]: it's not like an obligation that he has because he's he's the owner of Texas tech football and it's a vanity project exactly one hundred percent and like at some point that false it's going to turn off a few limit the access which to your point is going to hurt the sport
- 42:22[SPEAKER_01]: To the football field because I think we hit that as well as we as well as we could and there was a lot of points that I wanted to talk through with you because I know you are a little bit of an analyst about this and I can I can be I don't muster up the the fury that some do and I respect them and appreciate that they're doing it right but I just I understand where some of it's coming from even if it can be frustrating and I and I love it.
- 42:47[SPEAKER_00]: No, I agree.
- 42:48[SPEAKER_01]: To a game that is consequential, whatever way you slice it, Indiana and Ohio State, Ohio State wins this game.
- 42:58[SPEAKER_01]: And I come out of it feeling so much better about Indiana than I do about Ohio State.
- 43:02[SPEAKER_01]: That is a quarterback injury, obviously to Julian Sane, but it is also how Julian Sane played before that injury happened.
- 43:10[SPEAKER_01]: It is...
- 43:14[SPEAKER_01]: Indiana was half of Nick Marsh's foot away from actually winning that game and Josh Hoover did not play well and they did not have a run game.
- 43:24[SPEAKER_01]: I loved their plan for Jeremiah Smith other than one jackpot heave to the end zone where he just big brothered everybody.
- 43:31[SPEAKER_00]: That's cool how it is Jeremiah Smith.
- 43:33[SPEAKER_01]: It's gonna happen man like that's gonna happen.
- 43:36[SPEAKER_01]: I come out of this game
- 43:41[SPEAKER_00]: I don't disagree, man.
- 43:43[SPEAKER_00]: And like honestly, to your point, that is pre-july and saying injury as well, too.
- 43:47[SPEAKER_00]: Like, especially with the saying injury, like I think that that's the way you have to look at it, because
- 43:53[SPEAKER_00]: We're getting a lot of vague timetables on Julian saying right now, which a bit concerning to say the least, but this Ohio State offense, I said it coming into this game and one of the things we talked about going into it about what's Brian Haynes going to have on deck, which turns out he had a lot of real fun stuff on deck for this Ohio State offense, but this Ohio State offense has been pretty one dimensional.
- 44:15[SPEAKER_00]: And that one dimension has been, hey, let me get Jeremiah Smith the football.
- 44:19[SPEAKER_00]: And we saw what happened when you put pressure on
- 44:23[SPEAKER_00]: One of my favorite things about Kurt Signetti is he tells you exactly, like he doesn't, he's not gonna play coy about things.
- 44:29[SPEAKER_00]: They asked him on the sidelines pre-game, how do you stop Jeremiah Smith essentially paraphrasing that?
- 44:34[SPEAKER_00]: And he said, we get to the court about him before he can get him the ball.
- 44:37[SPEAKER_00]: And love the whole, that's what they did.
- 44:39[SPEAKER_00]: And that's a recipe that a lot of teams, not just in the big 10, but in the national championship level can attack with Ohio State.
- 44:47[SPEAKER_00]: This is not a,
- 44:50[SPEAKER_00]: juggernaut no higher state team.
- 44:51[SPEAKER_00]: This is not the highest team we saw with Will Howard at the home.
- 44:54[SPEAKER_00]: This is not someone like Will Howard is not a perfect quarterback by any stretch of the imagination, especially if you're talking about through like the pro lens with your Steelers, but like I do think that Will Howard is a playmaker at the college level.
- 45:05[SPEAKER_00]: Will Howard was a playmaker who you could trust that he was going to make something happen with whether with his legs or with his arms when the moment was big.
- 45:13[SPEAKER_00]: I don't feel that way of a Julian Sand and I haven't since he
- 45:20[SPEAKER_00]: whether he's returns or doesn't that's a that's a problem for the book guys right now.
- 45:24[SPEAKER_01]: Your point about will Howard I absolutely love with his legs because it's just a numbers game sometimes.
- 45:31[SPEAKER_01]: Indiana was straight up double-teaming Jeremiah Smith like a lot of the game.
- 45:36[SPEAKER_01]: Not just brackets, not just clouding safeties like there were times they were putting two defensive backs in a line on top of him and straight double-teaming him.
- 45:51[SPEAKER_01]: it was also the right decision and Ohio State on plays that weren't Jeremiah Smith targets average four yards per play.
- 45:58[SPEAKER_01]: That's incredible by the Indiana defense one and a big problem for the Ohio State offense.
- 46:04[SPEAKER_01]: You should be able to run the ball.
- 46:05[SPEAKER_01]: You should be able to hit your other receivers.
- 46:07[SPEAKER_01]: I really did like two things.
- 46:10[SPEAKER_01]: I love the touchdown throw out of the to Jackson.
- 46:13[SPEAKER_01]: I think it was out of the backfield.
- 46:14[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 46:15[SPEAKER_01]: That was a really nice play call that used Jeremiah Smith, which why was he not on the field for the three plays prior to that?
- 46:21[SPEAKER_01]: Just Ryan Day once again, trying to prove he's a tough guy.
- 46:26[SPEAKER_01]: Just it worked so easily.
- 46:28[SPEAKER_01]: But
- 46:29[SPEAKER_01]: other than that before saying got hurt they started to go into like some bootleg stuff and saying got a nice like eight yard run out of it and you also completed a pass I really liked that because then it just forces saying into the fit somebody has to account for saying so you're not you're playing ten on nine basically with two guys are with Jeremiah Smith and you're taking them out of the equation
- 46:51[SPEAKER_01]: You force them into conflict in a way that Will Howard did.
- 46:55[SPEAKER_01]: Also, there were other great receivers on that team.
- 46:57[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know that this team has them.
- 46:59[SPEAKER_01]: But you force them into conflict that Will Howard in the run game could.
- 47:04[SPEAKER_01]: And say in the fact that he kind of waltz under pressure,
- 47:08[SPEAKER_01]: in my opinion, not pressure of the moment, like actual pressure and the fact that he's not a creator with his legs, I think puts a pretty clear defined ceiling on this offense, it's the reason they lost to Miami, it's the reason they lost Indiana, they've lost, it's largely one of the big reasons they lost the Texas and the offense couldn't get going in the second half,
- 47:29[SPEAKER_01]: I worry about that and I also worry about the Ohio State Pass rush because like where's it been, man.
- 47:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, you stopped the run.
- 47:36[SPEAKER_01]: You took Richard out of the game and BB out of the game.
- 47:40[SPEAKER_01]: Great.
- 47:41[SPEAKER_01]: But Hoover wasn't under a ton of arrests.
- 47:44[SPEAKER_01]: They got to him a little bit, but there's nobody on this scene that's really like, you didn't replace our Valreys, you didn't replace all these defensive line men, the way we thought like Ohio State will have more.
- 47:54[SPEAKER_01]: They don't really right now, so like you I have, I have real concerns with the buck guys.
- 48:02[SPEAKER_01]: I also have some concerns about Indiana, but they're significantly lessened due to health and due to just what I saw in that game.
- 48:11[SPEAKER_00]: No, and for me, it's also due to just coaching.
- 48:15[SPEAKER_00]: Like, yeah, I'll make shade ahead of Brian Haynes like I'll just end their battle.
- 48:19[SPEAKER_00]: So guys, they're very, very good at their jobs.
- 48:21[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think they're going to be implemented much longer, quite frankly.
- 48:25[SPEAKER_01]: Brian Haynes, like, somebody's got a higher hand, and he'll make you good.
- 48:29[SPEAKER_01]: regard like resources obviously are going to matter, but very much in a well-stined way.
- 48:35[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to make you so good on one side of the ball immediately that you're just going to get up to a level of confidence, competence that you didn't reach.
- 48:43[SPEAKER_01]: Like if Marilyn hired Brian Haines, he could vault them into that mess in the middle of the big ten so quickly.
- 48:50[SPEAKER_01]: No, he's what Purdue thought Ryan Walters was.
- 48:53[SPEAKER_00]: That's what I think about Ryan Haines.
- 48:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think that's a great point.
- 48:59[SPEAKER_01]: And I, I'm just going to trust Indiana.
- 49:02[SPEAKER_01]: I, until, yes, they're win streak ended, but I'm, I'm going to keep trusting them to the other big game, the other top 10 matchup, they were a ton of big games, but the other top 10 matchup, what does this do for you about BYU?
- 49:17[SPEAKER_01]: Because it was,
- 49:20[SPEAKER_01]: It was teamed up very well.
- 49:22[SPEAKER_01]: Everything was, there were like two, three options especially in the first half on every play.
- 49:27[SPEAKER_01]: They talk about playing to your quarterback's strengths.
- 49:31[SPEAKER_01]: Barbarque Meyer is showing more as a drawback pastor than I think most people thought he would.
- 49:35[SPEAKER_01]: And reminder, once again, leave room for players to improve.
- 49:40[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 49:42[SPEAKER_01]: the way they use his legs, and he's such a physical runner, they just created a really functional offense against Notre Dame.
- 49:51[SPEAKER_01]: Notre Dame down Boobacartary, they're best past Russia five plays in the game because of a targeting call, which was the correct decision, obviously.
- 49:59[SPEAKER_01]: Are you ready to take BYU seriously as like a national champion as the number two team in the country,
- 50:11[SPEAKER_00]: So as my national championship roster has expanded, yes, I will take BYU seriously as a team that could potentially do it.
- 50:19[SPEAKER_00]: Do I think that the second best team in the country?
- 50:21[SPEAKER_00]: No, I don't either.
- 50:22[SPEAKER_00]: I don't either.
- 50:23[SPEAKER_00]: But I do think they're a little better than I thought they were.
- 50:27[SPEAKER_00]: I do think that this game proved a hell of a lot for me.
- 50:29[SPEAKER_00]: Not just like,
- 50:32[SPEAKER_00]: like your point about their offense is well taken, they overcame a lot to still be able to win this game too.
- 50:37[SPEAKER_00]: Like you jumped out to me.
- 50:38[SPEAKER_00]: A fake punt that is like, what are you doing, Kalani?
- 50:42[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I'm like bad coaching decisions, blowing a lead at home to the number two team in the country at that time.
- 50:49[SPEAKER_00]: And then fighting back and still doing that and like,
- 50:52[SPEAKER_00]: I get to your point about bearbot matters well founded because that was obviously a criticism most people in the industry I do think had of this be while you team was.
- 51:01[SPEAKER_00]: We know they can run the ball.
- 51:02[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, same here.
- 51:03[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, same here and like we know they can run the ball, but would love to see bearbot matters, or throw it a little bit.
- 51:08[SPEAKER_00]: Legend, glass or certainly helps with that having a guy like that, but I also think that bearbot matters also.
- 51:15[SPEAKER_00]: So the point like honestly we just talked about Will Howard he's kind of all of that ilk is kind of what he's looking like right now someone who's just like an absolute gamer someone who is a Our colleague John Bueler, I see us this time a fox whole guy.
- 51:28[SPEAKER_00]: It's a guy that you want leading you into battle and In college football, I think more than any other sport that matters that matters a hell of a lot and especially when you get to play your home games at a place like program
- 51:40[SPEAKER_00]: Because when you have someone who can get that crowd who's just hopped up on dirty sodas and ready to go like when you get them fired up that is an immensely difficult place to like try to get your just get your bearings if you're the opposite.
- 51:58[SPEAKER_01]: That said, Notre Dame left points on this board or on the field before half with the weird spike C.J.
- 52:05[SPEAKER_01]: Carr, what do we do in there, man?
- 52:06[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it was the correct call and like a duty-cated, a duty-cated correctly.
- 52:11[SPEAKER_01]: And probably should have gotten another definitely, should have gotten another play at the end of the game.
- 52:16[SPEAKER_01]: We're doing one second talk again, that was PI, and there was one second left.
- 52:23[SPEAKER_01]: and BYU cached in all of its red zone trips with touchdowns, Notre Dame settled for a lot of field goals, and that is credit to BYU, and also had red zone turnovers, and that is not so much credit to BYU, because that's just to see your card mistake.
- 52:39[SPEAKER_01]: So if they played this game
- 52:51[SPEAKER_01]: the punch that be why you could throw was had that much pop behind it to your point.
- 52:57[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm not I'm not freaking out about Notre Dame either.
- 53:02[SPEAKER_01]: I actually saw a lot from CJ car in that game and I like you have been kind of not a believer in CJ car that much.
- 53:10[SPEAKER_01]: I've been just hesitant to buy all the way in.
- 53:12[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 53:14[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know that I'm completely there because there were some bad misses, including a touchdown in the first quarter that he just, I don't know what he was doing on that throw.
- 53:24[SPEAKER_01]: Mr. Bad, it was wide open, but he made a lot of good plays off movement, throwing on off platform like he was the type of creator that this offense that doesn't have a ton of explosiveness out of the backfield though they're coming along and doesn't have a clear number one receiver needs.
- 53:44[SPEAKER_01]: Like I'm not I'm not freaking out about Notre Dame.
- 53:47[SPEAKER_01]: I'm very excited for that Notre Dame Miami game because both of those teams look kind of flawed, but I think this is more of a BYU story than it is a Notre Dame story in my opinion.
- 53:57[SPEAKER_00]: I still do have some concerns about Notre Dame, but like it doesn't drastically change my opinion because they were the concerns I had about Notre Dame coming into the game.
- 54:04[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they averaged 3.8 yards per carry against the best defensive they've seen this year.
- 54:09[SPEAKER_00]: I think the run game might have been a little inflated.
- 54:11[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not sure this team can actually run the football against the highest level of competition.
- 54:16[SPEAKER_00]: That's something, and when you couple that with the questions that I still have about CJ, I'm right there with you, like overall an impressive performance from CJ Carr.
- 54:26[SPEAKER_00]: And he stepped up and with them not being able to run the ball the fact that they were in this game, even if you left me on the bone, like is a credit to what CJ Carr was in how he played in this game.
- 54:35[SPEAKER_00]: But,
- 54:36[SPEAKER_00]: When you get it, like, again, I don't think BYU is the number two team in the country.
- 54:39[SPEAKER_00]: And if you can look like that against them, what do you like?
- 54:41[SPEAKER_00]: We talked about Tennessee's defense.
- 54:42[SPEAKER_00]: What does CJ car in this run game with how you against Jim?
- 54:44[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 54:45[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's, that's a good question.
- 54:48[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and so like I still have those same questions that I've had again, that's not like a transformed opinion.
- 54:54[SPEAKER_00]: That's the opinion I had going into this game.
- 54:56[SPEAKER_00]: So like I still see Notre Dame the exact same way.
- 54:59[SPEAKER_00]: I see BYU a little bit higher in a little bit higher regard than I did coming into this game.
- 55:05[SPEAKER_00]: And specifically when you're looking at the big 12, I see BYU as a team that clearly looks like a cut above the rest of that conference in my opinion.
- 55:16[SPEAKER_01]: I think, I'm, oh, I don't know, I don't know that I think they're right in the tier with Texas Tech Utah and I'll even put Houston there like I think they're just in that mix.
- 55:28[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's a bit 12, so that's fair, you know, I think that mix is just better than it's been in the past, right?
- 55:34[SPEAKER_01]: Like I think that mix is better than it was last year when it was Texas Tech and then everybody else.
- 55:40[SPEAKER_01]: Before we go to the big 12th, which that was a good segue in that direction, I'm still gonna take in the direction I predetermined.
- 55:46[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, my amy, do you, are you worried?
- 55:51[SPEAKER_01]: Or was that just Deuce Robinson and some rivalry game nonsense?
- 55:56[SPEAKER_00]: I think Dus Robinson took advantage of what I am worried about Miami, and that's this secondary is beat to hell man.
- 56:04[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 56:04[SPEAKER_00]: And there aren't a ton of teams in the ACC that I'm like terribly worried about being able to take full advantage of that because the ACC is not a very good league at the moment.
- 56:16[SPEAKER_00]: So like Miami certainly benefits from that.
- 56:20[SPEAKER_00]: However, I would consider for a state to be one of the teams near the bottom of that category.
- 56:24[SPEAKER_00]: I and it it's part right rivalry game nonsense because I don't think you get that performance from for to say to get someone that's not by amy that was a team that look like it was on quit watch for a playing for Mike and reveal coming in that game so like I think that was the most shocking part to me was that they got up for it.
- 56:41[SPEAKER_00]: But it exposed the concerns that are there for Miami like.
- 56:44[SPEAKER_00]: If it was me doing the if if I was submitting an AP top 25 ballot there's no way and how I'd have my name in everyone how they got 60 first place votes this week I beyond me we're not going to get to the full rankings discourse, but that's a choice that's a decision that was made, but I do think that like Miami I don't have any concerns about the offense the office is still going to be able to put up 35 to 40 of most teams that they play.
- 57:08[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that probably includes their game.
- 57:09[SPEAKER_00]: I think they were names gonna have a score in the 30s to win against Miami, because I don't think that with Malacar Tony with the now multi-headed backfield that is dangerous with the way Mince's playing so efficiently.
- 57:21[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I don't think that we're going to see Miami's offense really slow down until we get to the college from all playoff.
- 57:27[SPEAKER_00]: But I do think that this is a team that is susceptible to offensively.
- 57:30[SPEAKER_00]: And I know he's,
- 57:33[SPEAKER_00]: He's bought himself a lot of goodwill for a Mario crystal ball coach team that still I still have an ink ring in the back of my head where Getting in close games that you shouldn't be in.
- 57:45[SPEAKER_00]: Where is me a little bit.
- 57:47[SPEAKER_01]: That seems like a Mario crystal ball thing to do.
- 57:51[SPEAKER_01]: Florida State of 35% success rate in this game.
- 57:54[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 57:56[SPEAKER_01]: 16% was a pass rate.
- 57:57[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of that is do's Robinson.
- 58:00[SPEAKER_01]: And a lot of that is the secondary that I'm worried about, but for the year those numbers aren't great.
- 58:05[SPEAKER_01]: The two teams, like you said in the ACC, that are going to test that Florida State just because of do's Robinson probably.
- 58:12[SPEAKER_01]: And then I would say Wake Forest with geolopas and Hernandez and Jake Baker.
- 58:16[SPEAKER_00]: Honestly.
- 58:17[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and Jake Baker, and they already beat Wake Forest.
- 58:22[SPEAKER_01]: So.
- 58:24[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not concerned that Miami isn't going to like make the playoff or anything they're going to win the ACC.
- 58:29[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have any opinion changed about that.
- 58:33[SPEAKER_01]: The game with Notre Dame is going to be fantastic.
- 58:36[SPEAKER_01]: I kind of am willing to give them a moment again in this game that for to state just really jumped on, right, but I don't know.
- 58:47[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know with all these injuries that you can accomplish your main goal, but we have a lot of times still to see what Miami can do.
- 58:56[SPEAKER_01]: Two games that I want to jump to pretty quickly because we have blown past our expected time, which is pretty classic.
- 59:04[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, actually Houston, Oklahoma and UCLA apologies to you.
- 59:10[SPEAKER_00]: We love you, but we gotta go.
- 59:13[SPEAKER_01]: We gotta go.
- 59:15[SPEAKER_01]: that's the show for this week.
- 59:16[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much.
- 59:17[SPEAKER_01]: We'll be back with another addition of stacking the box.
- 59:20[SPEAKER_01]: College football podcast.
- 59:22[SPEAKER_01]: Next Monday at 1 p.m., check us out with the live, subscribe to the channel.
- 59:27[SPEAKER_01]: We'll talk to you then.