Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Sunday School Remix: Did We Misread the Sheep and Goats?
Transcript
- 0:00Are sheep and goats really that different?
- 0:03I'm Pastor Nate, and this is another Sunday School remix.
- 0:06Let's go. Welcome to the Sunday School
- 0:09Remix, the show where we take Bible stories you learned as a
- 0:12kid and look at them with fresh eyes.
- 0:14Each week we dig into the context and the overlooked
- 0:17details, and we often discover interpretations we never heard
- 0:21growing up. This isn't about winning
- 0:24arguments, but simply hearing God's living word speak to our
- 0:28lives again today. So grab your Bible and put aside
- 0:31your assumptions and let's dive into another episode of the
- 0:35Sunday School remix. I want to look today at the
- 0:38parable of the sheep and the goats.
- 0:41It's found in Matthew 25, and there's some more pieces around
- 0:44it. And actually even calling this a
- 0:46parable might not be exactly correct because what Jesus says
- 0:51in Matthew chapter 25 is the Kingdom of heaven is like, And
- 0:55then he goes on to talk about some sheep and some goats.
- 0:58And in this passage, why you might be familiar or remember
- 1:01this from Sunday school. This is the famous passage where
- 1:04Jesus says, you know, when I was thirsty, you gave me something
- 1:08to drink. When I was hungry, you fed me.
- 1:11When I was naked, you clothed me.
- 1:12When I was imprisoned, you visited me.
- 1:15And the story is set up the parable, and again, might not
- 1:19actually be a classic parable is with Jesus then saying that the
- 1:24the people will be like, wait, like when did we see you like
- 1:27this? And Jesus says, whenever you did
- 1:29it to one of the least of these, you did this to me.
- 1:34And the way that the whole story is framed is that the sheep are
- 1:38the good ones. They're the ones who don't even
- 1:41realize that they've been feeding and, and giving water to
- 1:45those who are thirsty and, and helping those who are in prison.
- 1:47They don't even realize the good deeds that they're doing.
- 1:50And the goats are the bad ones. And they're the ones who, when
- 1:54they saw the need, they turned their back and completely
- 1:57ignored the need that was right in front of them.
- 2:02And so often this parable, this, these words from Jesus get
- 2:07interpreted in a very moralistic way.
- 2:10Well, the sheep are the good ones and the goats are the bad
- 2:15ones. And that means that sheep go to
- 2:18heaven and goats go to hell. And if you were listening to the
- 2:23radio in 1998, you know that that's an awesome song by the
- 2:27band Cake. Sheep go to heaven, goats go to
- 2:29hell. You should look it up.
- 2:30It's awesome. But it also illustrates how this
- 2:37story so often gets interpreted. It's a moralistic tale.
- 2:42And Jesus is telling us we got to be nice to the hungry people
- 2:46or we're going to go to hell. Actually, though, there's a lot
- 2:51more going on in this entire passage than meets the eye or
- 2:56then maybe that we learned about in Sunday school.
- 3:00Jesus. The the way that this story is
- 3:02framed in the context of it is that these are words that are
- 3:05directed at the Pharisees and the Sadducees.
- 3:09You see, the Pharisees and the Sadducees were these two groups
- 3:12of Jewish elites at that point in time, and they had specific
- 3:16roles within the religious structure.
- 3:19It's slightly different. We don't need to get into the
- 3:21nuance here. And the beliefs of these two
- 3:24groups were different, but both of them were often at odds with
- 3:28Jesus and his teaching and his ministry.
- 3:31The Pharisees in particular were people who really paid attention
- 3:35to the rules, and they wanted to make sure that you were doing
- 3:40your Jewish religion correctly. And so they focused so much on
- 3:46the rules just for the sake of rules.
- 3:50They're the ones who knew all of 631 of the Jewish laws, and they
- 3:53made sure that people were following them.
- 3:56And they used this knowledge that they had also as a way
- 4:00often to oppress, whether directly or indirectly, those
- 4:05who were in need around them. They're the ones who would get
- 4:08upset when Jesus healed on the Sabbath because there's a rule
- 4:12that says you shouldn't do work on the Sabbath, but that
- 4:15illustrates the greater point and why Jesus was always at odds
- 4:18with them. They were turning religion just
- 4:22into A to do list, just into rules to follow.
- 4:26And in so doing, they were missing out on the compassion
- 4:32that lived behind all of these rules in the beginning anyways.
- 4:37Jesus is wanting and constantly confronting the religious
- 4:40authorities of his days because he wants them to recognize that
- 4:43the way they're framing religion isn't actually helpful for the
- 4:49project that God is trying to undertake.
- 4:52The work of compassion and reconciliation, the ways of
- 4:57bringing greater human flourishing, caring for the most
- 5:00vulnerable among us. Yeah.
- 5:03There's a lot of rules that can get in the way if we let them,
- 5:07religious rules that prevent us from doing this good work.
- 5:12And so Jesus talks about the sheep and the goats and really
- 5:16what he's doing. And the reason why I say this
- 5:18maybe isn't a parable. This is more of an apocalyptic
- 5:22vision. Now let me unpack those scary
- 5:25words before we get too far ahead of ourselves, because
- 5:29apocalyptic isn't about the end of the world as we classically
- 5:34think of that. It's about a huge unveiling and
- 5:38changing that's taking place. And So what Jesus is trying to
- 5:42do is he's saying the Kingdom of God, the reality of God at work
- 5:47in the world, God getting what God wants.
- 5:50This is what that looks like. It looks like the thirsty being
- 5:55given water and the hungry being fed and the naked being clothed
- 6:00and the imprisoned being visited.
- 6:03That's Jesus's vision for a new reality.
- 6:07That's Jesus's mission in undertaking and all the ministry
- 6:11that he does. Side point on that front, we
- 6:14often debate like, why did Jesus come to earth what he's doing?
- 6:17Well, what Jesus tells us very clearly is that he came to
- 6:20proclaim the Kingdom of God, which when you know that detail,
- 6:24really reframes how you understand a lot of his
- 6:27ministry. Jesus was trying to unveil an
- 6:30apocalyptic vision for what the world could be like, and he was
- 6:34trying to bring people into that vision to realize it themselves
- 6:38so they can become the hands and feet of God, continuing this
- 6:43vision forward long after he has returned to heaven.
- 6:48This little story is Jesus's apocalyptic vision, and it's
- 6:52offered as an affront to the current vision that the
- 6:56Sadducees and the Pharisees are putting forward from their
- 7:01position of religious authority. I hope you're starting to
- 7:06connect the dots on all of this. What's so interesting about the
- 7:12sheep and the goats story is the way that Jesus frames all of
- 7:17this. The ones who are deemed
- 7:22righteous, the the sheep in this situation don't even realize the
- 7:28good that they are doing. That is very much flying in the
- 7:34face of the assumptions of the Pharisees and the Sadducees.
- 7:37No, no, I'll tell you how to do good.
- 7:39The Pharisee says you follow all 631 laws.
- 7:43She's saying no, no, no, like you, you care for people and it
- 7:48becomes such a part of your very existence in being that you
- 7:52don't even realize the good you're doing.
- 7:55And not only that, but Jesus is also telling us that he is the
- 8:00one who is with the poor. When did I see you naked or
- 8:05thirsty or hungry? Lord, truly, I tell you,
- 8:09whenever you did this to one of the least of these, Jesus says
- 8:12you did this to me. And so Jesus is also showing us
- 8:18that he is promising to show up and to be present in some of the
- 8:23most difficult situations, and that just by arriving ourselves
- 8:29with compassion, we are encountering the risen Christ in
- 8:35those moments through our kind, caring, humble actions.
- 8:44Conversely, the goats in this story are the ones who don't
- 8:50even realize that they've missed the opportunity to serve,
- 8:55worship their Lord. They are the ones who are so
- 8:59caught up in doing all the right things and doing all the rules
- 9:02that they miss the opportunity for care and compassion along
- 9:05the way. And so the way that this whole
- 9:08story is being framed, you know, as this judgement parable,
- 9:11that's why we often go to the eternal sense of heaven and
- 9:14hell. And there is judgement
- 9:16articulated in the story. I don't want to deny that, but
- 9:19the judgement is a here and now judgement, not an eternal 1.
- 9:25You are missing the opportunities.
- 9:27You see it, Sadducees and Pharisees.
- 9:30You are missing your chance to encounter God and to serve God
- 9:36because you're so preoccupied with your rules, with something
- 9:40else. And what you need to know Jesus
- 9:42is saying is that God is most present in the moments of
- 9:47vulnerability, in the moments of difficulty, in the moments where
- 9:52people are at their wits end, that's when God promises to show
- 9:57up. And so if we then, as followers
- 10:01of Jesus, decide to show up with care and compassion, in those
- 10:06moments, it's an encounter with God.
- 10:09But when we're too preoccupied with our own agendas, with our
- 10:13own sense of right and wrong, with our own sense of the rules
- 10:18of it, all, the religious practices and rituals, yeah,
- 10:21even those can get in the way of a relationship with God.
- 10:26It's what this parable, this apocalyptic vision is pointing
- 10:32us towards. And here's where I think it
- 10:37really gets interesting. Sheep and goats are actually
- 10:45incredibly similar animals. It seems like if Jesus was
- 10:51really trying to make a point about who are the good ones and
- 10:53who are the bad ones, he would have chosen something a little
- 10:56more dramatic, You know? And it's like the the the hippo
- 10:59is the good one and the TTC fly is the bad one, right?
- 11:04Like just something vastly different.
- 11:06But I think she's a specifically chose to animals that are so
- 11:11similar because it's often hard to tell what the difference is
- 11:18right? It's a razor thin line in the
- 11:20way he's describing it of the ones who look like they're the
- 11:24religious people who are doing all the right things and saying
- 11:27all the right things and keeping all the right rules, and yet
- 11:30they can be so far from what God actually desires from us.
- 11:38And what's really neat is it, and I don't know if Jesus had
- 11:42some vast understanding of animal biology, maybe, but
- 11:48nowadays what we know is that goats and sheep are of similar
- 11:52size and the males both grow horns.
- 11:57It male sheep and male goats have horns.
- 12:00They both have 4 stomachs and they're both from the bovine
- 12:04family. There's a whole bunch of
- 12:07biological similarities between these two animals.
- 12:11But do you know the biggest difference between sheep and
- 12:14goats? Sheep have much bigger hearts,
- 12:24and maybe that's what the Lord requires of us to enter the
- 12:29world with big hearts, with a sense of compassion for the
- 12:35suffering of others. Not one of judgement or
- 12:39qualification. Not one where we're trying to
- 12:43explain away, but but to just notice the needs that are right
- 12:46in front of us. And to offer water to those who
- 12:49are thirsty, and to offer food to those who are hungry.
- 12:53And to visit those who are imprisoned.
- 12:56To give clothing to those who are cold or in need.
- 13:01Maybe it's just about showing up with big hearts and all the
- 13:05rules and rituals that we so often attach to our religion and
- 13:09our practice of faith. Maybe those are simply there to
- 13:14help us better connect with this big heart mindset, this big
- 13:20heart vision that Jesus is bringing to the world.
- 13:24It's a totally different way of looking at this.
- 13:27And what's so ironic is that when we take this parable and we
- 13:31start to say no, no, no, like some people are sheep and
- 13:35they're the ones who are good and some people are bad and
- 13:38they're the goats who are going to hell.
- 13:40When we read this passage that way, we're literally doing
- 13:44exactly what the Pharisees and the Sadducees were doing and
- 13:48saying themselves. We're trying to compartmentalize
- 13:53people and to put people in categories based on what they
- 13:59do. But Jesus is simply saying, hey,
- 14:03you're not even going to realize when you're doing good, but
- 14:07hopefully you can continue to show up with a big heart to care
- 14:11for the needs that are right in front of you.
- 14:14This is what I'm asking of you. Well, I'm Pastor Nate.
- 14:20This has been another Sunday school remix.
- 14:22I hope you learn something new, maybe some different
- 14:24perspectives. These are just some of the
- 14:26perspectives on this passage. That's what I love about the
- 14:29Bible is that it's the living Word of God.
- 14:31And so every time we read it, maybe there's something else
- 14:33that jumps out. I'm not trying to claim to be
- 14:36the authority on this text, but just to give us other angles of
- 14:40thinking about this story that we were told in Sunday school
- 14:44and we were given one vision there, and now we're looking at
- 14:47it a little differently. I hope you enjoyed it.
- 14:49As always. Remember, Sunday School was just
- 14:53the beginning. I'll see you next time.
- 14:56Thanks for listening to another episode of Sunday School Remix.
- 15:00If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, feel free to
- 15:03check out my church's website, bethanydenver.org.
- 15:07Or you can download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect
- 15:11in your phone's App Store.