Latest / No Way Out / Skill Adaptation Beats Skill Acquisition: Ecological Dynamics & the OODA Loop | Keith Davids, PhD
Transcript
- 0:00Keith Davids, PhD: So if you were a soccer coach, Rivera, and you were successful, they would talk about your methodology as reverable.
- 0:08Keith Davids, PhD: Reverable.
- 0:09Keith Davids, PhD: You know, it's dominating the English league and that sort of thing.
- 0:14Keith Davids, PhD: Now, that for me is not a good sign because it kind of says, you know, this coach has got all the answers, etc.
- 0:21Keith Davids, PhD: But all the time, your methods, your plan, your approach, tactical approach, strategic approach, is being analyzed by data.
- 0:31Keith Davids, PhD: So coaches now and the opposition know what you're doing.
- 0:35Keith Davids, PhD: So you, if you stick too rigidly to your plan, your you know, reverable, for example, um, you're gonna get found out.
- 0:44Keith Davids, PhD: And people will be working on literally within a few weeks, a month maybe, they'll be working on solutions, antidotes to the impact of reverable in in competition.
- 0:55John Boyd: You have max entropy of max white disorder, which is that is called whack chaos.
- 0:59John Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:02John Boyd: The underlying method is very simple, and there is no way out.
- 1:05John Boyd: What if we can eliminate the feature just site?
- 1:07John Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.
- 1:10John Boyd: We want to get a map between our action and our situation to do it.
- 1:15John Boyd: We have a mixed message in hope, right?
- 1:17John Boyd: There is no way out.
- 1:19John Boyd: All right, our next guest, I've been looking forward to this for quite a while, since about 2019, actually.
- 1:24John Boyd: He is a professor of perceptual motor learning at Sheffield Holland University and one of the architects of ecological dynamics and the constraint slot approach.
- 1:33John Boyd: Uh, right now I understand he's working part-time and he's doing a lot of work on talking performance, and he has some other things going on in the background as well.
- 1:40John Boyd: So, Keith, hey, Professor David, let me say that first.
- 1:43John Boyd: Welcome to the No Way Out.
- 1:46John Boyd: Been very excited about this.
- 1:48John Boyd: We've had uh Andrew Sheaf, Rob Gray, George Voss on, uh John Flack, and just recently we had Alex Rem on.
- 1:55John Boyd: So uh the timing is uh is perfect to get a little bit deeper in the in the woods with you, if you don't mind me saying that.
- 2:01John Boyd: Uh but welcome to the show.
- 2:03John Boyd: Yeah, fine.
- 2:04Keith Davids, PhD: I mean, there's a stellar cast of uh speakers you've had this, hopefully I can uh live up to the say the quality level that they've produced.
- 2:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh I I I have no doubt.
- 2:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to give you a little background on how I came across your work, built some context up.
- 2:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so my background is fighter aviation.
- 2:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Back in 2017, 2018, the Navy had a couple of mishaps.
- 2:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And my job was to go learn how to build a high-performing culture.
- 2:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep this as short as possible.
- 2:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I got to talk to anybody I wanted to, right?
- 2:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then in 2019, a year or so after all that, your book came across my desk or across my path when I was doing a complexity conference with Yunir Bar Yam and uh Dr.
- 2:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: David Woods uh for the Navy.
- 2:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I was running a workshop, speaking with them.
- 2:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and then of course I met some folks through the Kinevin uh community, Kinevin framework community, who had your book in 2019, The Constraints Led Approach.
- 2:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we were all talking about it.
- 2:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it made so much sense to me that we started to started applying it towards teamwork development interventions, teamwork training.
- 3:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and it just it it resonated with me because in fighter aviation, we always have an enemy or an opponent.
- 3:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, that's how we train.
- 3:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it just gave me the theory and and underpinning principles to make sense of what we did in the military, or at least in fighter aviation, and uh taking that towards what we call uh the flow system now.
- 3:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so in that we're doing some team development intervention, teamwork skills development, non-technical skills development.
- 3:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And my assumption was that all coaches knew how to do this in sport.
- 3:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And boy, was I wrong.
- 3:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so I'm a parent of two girls that play basketball, and and somebody that has my background and understands a little bit about coaching and CLA, I couldn't see that they weren't being trained properly or or they weren't uh coaches didn't know how to do this.
- 3:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It took several years for me to go, wait a minute, there's something wrong here.
- 3:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so that's that's uh that's really uh what fascinates me about CLA.
- 4:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, my view is when you look at John Boyd's Real Observe Orient Decide Act Loop, it actually shows a performer and environment.
- 4:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so you can look at constraints and orientation, you can look at constraints in the environment, and you can see that performer, that agent operating in an environment.
- 4:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's my background on this.
- 4:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But recently you wrote to me and said that uh you you kind of want to move away from skill acquisition to skill adaptation.
- 4:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 4:29Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, that's a that's a really good uh question to ask at a good point uh to start our discussion, Brian.
- 4:35Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, I mean, uh if you look at a history of um our area, perceptual motor, whatever you want to call it, perceptual motor learning.
- 4:43Keith Davids, PhD: I've it's been called sensory motor learning and control, depending on which um area you approach the the practical issues, the theoretical issues from.
- 4:54Keith Davids, PhD: And one of the universals is that um there's the term skill acquisition, and that harks back to a time when the theory and the philosophy that supported the term skill acquisition was all about people acquiring an internal representation, a model of the world which guided them in their interactions, and then a model, and and in that um particular internal repository that they have, they can store models of movements as well.
- 5:26Keith Davids, PhD: That was the kind of um the uh the theoretical framework that supported it.
- 5:31Keith Davids, PhD: And that goes back a long way.
- 5:32Keith Davids, PhD: That goes back to the Second World War.
- 5:35Keith Davids, PhD: So there is a military connection there, yeah, and the relationship between engineers, ergonomists, and psychologists in solving issues to do with training, military combatants, or selecting them, certain aptitudes and skills and things like that.
- 5:51Keith Davids, PhD: And so the terminology really is pretty much seems to be entrenched and located, and has a sort of almost like a bias towards thinking that that's what you do, that's what this whole process is about.
- 6:05Keith Davids, PhD: And any practice, any training, any educational approach is about acquiring something and developing some internal model of the world.
- 6:15Keith Davids, PhD: But there are different models of learning, and there are different models of learning processes, and the the and that's what the ecological dynamics is focused on from a practical perspective.
- 6:27Keith Davids, PhD: And really lately, it's been when I say lately, that past five years or so, it's become clear that what we're talking about really is skill adaptation.
- 6:36Keith Davids, PhD: So, yes, you you know head towards gaining a bit of experience, a bit of knowledge um of a particular performance environment and um implementing your skills, but most of the time it's about adapting um your skills uh and your performance in relation to the performance environment.
- 6:58Keith Davids, PhD: Because in your introduction, I noticed that you kept mentioning that sort of person environment relationship, and that's the level of analysis that eco dynamics approaches things from, whether it's education, training, sports practice, therapy, you know, a wide variety of things, it's pretty much scaled to the person environment relationship.
- 7:19Keith Davids, PhD: And you know what?
- 7:20Keith Davids, PhD: What I've discovered over the years, and I've been working in this area for a long time, it's actually hard to keep that in mind all the time because you can keep relaxing into focusing just on the individual or just on the environment, but that person environment relationship, getting that right, it's quite hard to do.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, it it kind of resonates with the idea of mental models and a repertoire, those things that we build in our in our the way we used to talk about things, muscle memory.
- 7:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes, and then going back to, and I think this is a big challenge for talking about the the observer-oriented side act loop, but the real one, getting people away from looking at it as a four-stage thing, four steps.
- 7:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's actually bigger than that because it contains the environment.
- 8:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It it it is the environment.
- 8:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you go back to the 70s when John Boyd was talking about, he said, I'm your environment, you're my environment.
- 8:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think that is a hard transition to, you know, I do a lot of discussions in the free energy principle active inference community, and reflecting back on that, to me, that's kind of like an internal view of how they see the world, right?
- 8:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're not, and they do talk about the environment, you know, I'm not saying they don't, but it's it's hard to conceptualize that.
- 8:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when we're training folks and talking about how important the environment is, I want to point out one thing that that we learned from the Toyota production system, as well as from John Boyd.
- 8:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he said this, and maybe you can expand on a little bit.
- 8:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He said that uh, according to Ono and Shingo, who came up with the Toyota production system, that control is outside in bottom up.
- 8:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's from the outside.
- 8:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that I think connects back to the constraints in the environment that that you talk about.
- 8:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you expand on that a little bit if that's if that's accurate, or how you would have discussed that?
- 8:58Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, I'm not too familiar with those models, but the principle I recognize in ecological dynamics, the focus is on away from the traditional approach, which is hierarchical, which is pretty much top-down.
- 9:12Keith Davids, PhD: The brain and mind, that's what you're focusing on in any educational, any learning activity, whether it's a sports skill or some sort of concept in maths or science or English literature, for example, is pretty much top-down.
- 9:27Keith Davids, PhD: It's focused on the brain making sense of the environment, perceiving the environment, making decisions, problem solving, etc., and then sending commands.
- 9:37Keith Davids, PhD: Um, in essentially the process of skill, acquiring skill, is about enriching this process of the commands and the internal model, as I said, the model of the world, and that regulates everything.
- 9:50Keith Davids, PhD: So that's a hierarchical approach.
- 9:52Keith Davids, PhD: But in ecological dynamics, and it sounds like the other two approaches that you mentioned as well, it's more what's called heterarchical, where you get this self-organization approach where different parts of a complex adaptive system that's a system with multiple components, there's no kind of preferencing a system, parts of the system de facto.
- 10:18Keith Davids, PhD: That doesn't mean that parts of the system don't take a lead and others adapt, but that changes.
- 10:24Keith Davids, PhD: And a heterarchical system is one where control is distributed around the system, and at any time parts of the system can become more influential and shape the way that we behave.
- 10:37Keith Davids, PhD: Um, and and that is quite it's quite hard to understand, but it it's it's happened, it's happening all the time, it's around us all the time.
- 10:46Keith Davids, PhD: I don't know if you're aware, but politically at the moment, the government of Serbia has just changed hands.
- 10:53Keith Davids, PhD: So there has been a and an incumbent there in power for 12 years, had and had a particular way of doing things.
- 10:59Keith Davids, PhD: And I'm not gonna get into the politics of what is right or wrong here.
- 11:03Keith Davids, PhD: I'm just explaining this to show that it illustrates how old this hetero heterological approach is um all over the place.
- 11:12Keith Davids, PhD: There were recent elections and a group called the student list.
- 11:16Keith Davids, PhD: So basically, there are a list of people with particular skills and propensities, and they formed the party to challenge the government, and they'd won the election.
- 11:28Keith Davids, PhD: They now lead the country, but they don't have a leader.
- 11:31Keith Davids, PhD: There's no literally a heterarchical system of, I think, around about 150 or so individuals with different skills and talents and propensities, and now they've got to work out how they're going to govern a country using a self-organization adaptation to constraints type of approach, which is heterarchical rather than the traditional hierarchical system that most people are used to.
- 11:57Keith Davids, PhD: Most countries operate that way.
- 11:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 12:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I think talking about complex adaptive systems is important because it's it almost underpins ecological dynamics and system dynamics.
- 12:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And there are some nuances between some of the different ways we look at systems and complex adaptive systems that depending who you ask.
- 12:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think it's important to make sure our listeners understand that.
- 12:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I, you know, I have Alex uh Saramma's new book, which I think you you looked at and reviewed, uh, but it goes into complex adaptive systems.
- 12:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in that, it's the interactions, the quality of the interactions that matter more so than the quality of the agents.
- 12:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um that's that to me is an environment thing.
- 12:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's these things are interacting with other agents, and it's the quality of interactions.
- 12:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In our book, we talked about distributed leadership, right?
- 12:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that that's kind of like um kind of what you just uh uh shared with us and how that works.
- 12:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's never one thing.
- 12:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And when in fighter aviation, we use mission command, which is there is one, we'll call it a mission commander that has 51% of the vote, but it doesn't mean the others can't lead at different times.
- 12:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what happens in in sports, is we're starting to see evolve in basketball is is like a leaderless uh approach on the court.
- 13:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's more principles and understanding this.
- 13:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I do want to talk a little bit more about the um complex adaptive systems for a moment or so.
- 13:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because you know, most people try to reduce things down to their constituent parts, reductionism, things like that.
- 13:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But a team, by definition, and this is going into the world we talk about, is a complex adaptive systems, right?
- 13:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where the whole is greater than some of the parts.
- 13:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you can you build on that anymore and how you brought that in through uh uh ecological dynamics and CLA?
- 13:35Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, I mean it's from basically these ideas are not something I've invented.
- 13:39Keith Davids, PhD: Um it's quite important to understand that, you know, if I've made a contribution, what I've done is um taken these ideas from psychology, natural sciences, biological sciences, where they're more prevalent, those ideas, where there's you know, work, uh more work done at the systems level, looking at um populations, for example, and how parts of a population shape the behaviour or health of a whole population and that sort of thing.
- 14:06Keith Davids, PhD: And I've applied it, the ideas, to sport.
- 14:10Keith Davids, PhD: That's what I was passionate about.
- 14:11Keith Davids, PhD: I've always been interested in the practical side of things, etc.
- 14:15Keith Davids, PhD: And sometimes when I read papers, and I it's flattering to see that people have uh referenced me or my parts of my team as well, related to particular concepts, but they've been um this is where we've taken the ideas that have uh been developed in at a much more sort of philosophical scientific level and then applied them to issues and concepts and problems and challenges at a particular level of analysis, and that's human performance.
- 14:46Keith Davids, PhD: To go back to your point there, complexity is really important because it essentially complexity means it's a system with many, many interacting parts, it's not a sort of a passive system, it's an active system.
- 14:59Keith Davids, PhD: And the parts, the way that they behave, they can influence each other or different parts of the system and lead the system in different directions.
- 15:08Keith Davids, PhD: And so there needs to be a little bit of intentionality there in psychology, in philosophy, and that basically means where an individual intends achieving particular goals, achieving particular specific aims, rather than just it doesn't mean that essentially an athlete or team go um into performance and they're just randomly reacting to an environment.
- 15:32Keith Davids, PhD: That's not at all the case.
- 15:34Keith Davids, PhD: It's about them shaping the environment, the environment shaping them, and they're and there's this constant adaptation going on.
- 15:41Keith Davids, PhD: And that's why one of the main reasons why I think skill adaptation is a much better concept for us to be focusing on, because it captures that complexity, adaptive nature of human behavior.
- 15:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think it also resonates with folks that were in the agile software development community because that's what we were trying to do with the organization's creed, an agile adaptive organization.
- 16:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think the way we went about it is they we they used, we used a lot of pseudoscience, not a lot of sound science and team science and what you have uh with CLA and ecological dynamics.
- 16:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you brought up intention.
- 16:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You talk about attention, excuse me, intention, attention, and calibration.
- 16:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let me give you some background on this.
- 16:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh listeners here are familiar with Ensley's situational awareness, the three levels, perception being one, uh, the next level being the way I describe it is what's happening now, and the third level being anticipatory sense making or what comes next.
- 16:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do I expect to happen?
- 16:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit more about attunement and attention and how that is developed in ecological dynamics?
- 16:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 16:45Keith Davids, PhD: It certainly wouldn't be considered from the point of view of levels because that implies hierarchical in nature.
- 16:52Keith Davids, PhD: So that's from a different theoretical framework.
- 16:55Keith Davids, PhD: Attunement, attentionality, and uh attention as well are fundamentals of skill adaptation.
- 17:02Keith Davids, PhD: Without it, it's you're just focusing on actions emerging, but they don't just emerge randomly and they don't just emerge in a vacuum.
- 17:10Keith Davids, PhD: Attunement to information is the basis of skill adaptation.
- 17:14Keith Davids, PhD: It's a fundamental property of it where you are working out, learning what are the important information sources that surround you.
- 17:24Keith Davids, PhD: And some of these you're aware of, some of them you're not aware of, and that's what makes it so powerful.
- 17:29Keith Davids, PhD: And I'd like to um get to talk about the the way that we use information to support our actions, our behaviors, and we're not even aware of the a lot of them, and that comes from Nikolai Bernstein.
- 17:42Keith Davids, PhD: He talked, he had, he had a uh, you know, his work theorizing was in the 1930s, and he wasn't really aware of the dynamical systems approach, complex systems theory.
- 17:54Keith Davids, PhD: So he was um he was focused on a more of a hierarchical approach uh to movement organization, but that was really trying to build a um counter-argument against the behaviorist approach, you know, the stimulus response conditioning type of approach to learning that was dominant at that time.
- 18:16Keith Davids, PhD: And he was trying to get the humanistic aspect into it, decision making, taking responsibility and things like that.
- 18:24Keith Davids, PhD: So attunement to information is um a key property of skill, and that is uh essentially working out what the important source of information that you can use in order to problem solve, in order to act, in order to perceive further, and that sort of thing.
- 18:40Keith Davids, PhD: And at the same time, intentionality that frames your work, your ability, the the way that you interact or engage in transactions with the environment.
- 18:51Keith Davids, PhD: And in practice, this should always be an intention because coaches and trainers and educators, it is about educating the intentions of an individual.
- 19:01Keith Davids, PhD: In this situation, what is really important, and that is working with the individual to work out, well, in I'm trying to, you know, I think I'll try to do this, and we should be looking at that, and that sort of thing.
- 19:12Keith Davids, PhD: So there are intentions, and it's not just otherwise you'd just be reacting to information that emerges, challenges that emerges, problems that emerges.
- 19:21Keith Davids, PhD: There is a bit of a little bit of that that's needed, a tiny bit, but most of the time the idea is an individual self-regulates and they show autonomy in um in a particular performance environment.
- 19:33Keith Davids, PhD: And educating attention is part of a tuning.
- 19:36Keith Davids, PhD: So you what you attend to, what you should be focusing on at a particular moment, and how that might might change over time.
- 19:43Keith Davids, PhD: So all of those are important aspects underlying the relationship between cognition, perception, and action, which are deeply entwined and deeply integrated.
- 19:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to build up a little bit more on maybe some practical points on how you build that or how do you how you build that attunement or how do you how do you get people to see what's in the environment?
- 20:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let me give you some background here again.
- 20:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So reflecting back in my time in fighter aviation as an instructor, that's really what debriefing or after action reviews do, is they allow the instructor to ask the right questions.
- 20:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this goes into coaching too.
- 20:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are you asking the right questions?
- 20:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And just some basic things we would do when we're learning how to do basic fighter maneuvers is what altitude were we at?
- 20:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What was our heading?
- 20:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What was our airspeed?
- 20:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, what side were we on?
- 20:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where was the sun?
- 20:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, and it's just and and you think about going back to that time frame, how important that is, because that's that's what that is, is that's what I need to pay attention to, or you know, the next time I go out there.
- 20:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's how we accelerate learning is is we're doing two things, maybe more, in the debrief.
- 20:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's the what what did you notice?
- 20:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's in the environment?
- 20:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are you seeing?
- 20:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because we need to help the students see more.
- 20:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, uh, maybe in a complex environment, that might change a little bit because we won't be able we won't have all the access or or we won't comprehend all the information that's in our environment.
- 21:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that that debriefing, can you talk a little bit about that, how the coaches, uh how that fits into uh ecological dynamics and CLA?
- 21:14Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, I mean that would probably come mundane.
- 21:17Keith Davids, PhD: So there's different sources of knowledge that you can use in order to um enhance skill adaptation.
- 21:25Keith Davids, PhD: And James Gibson really provided some fascinating insights onto that.
- 21:29Keith Davids, PhD: So he talked about knowledge about the environment to start with, and knowledge about the environment is pretty much related to instructions, feedback.
- 21:37Keith Davids, PhD: So the debriefing might touch on a lot of knowledge about the performance environment.
- 21:43Keith Davids, PhD: So learning can emerge through that, but it's not the most important source of knowledge used.
- 21:49Keith Davids, PhD: It is supportive, but it's overrated in traditional methods.
- 21:55Keith Davids, PhD: Okay instructions and verbal information.
- 21:59Keith Davids, PhD: That the coach or trainer gives, pretty prescriptive, pretty uh linear, uh focused on technique, focused on intrinsic body movements and things like that.
- 22:10Keith Davids, PhD: That's not the best source of information.
- 22:12Keith Davids, PhD: And alternatively, Gibson talked about knowledge of the performance environment, and that is gained through when you are actively engaged in attunement, in intentionality, in educating your own in attention, perceiving, thinking, problem solving, acting, all of that.
- 22:33Keith Davids, PhD: So it's what Tim Ingold, the social anthropologist, calls that attentive dwelling.
- 22:38Keith Davids, PhD: Okay.
- 22:39Keith Davids, PhD: When you are in the lived experience of the here and now in the environment, that is far more important, but it unfortunately is underplayed.
- 22:47Keith Davids, PhD: Knowledge about is pretty much focused on skill acquisition, if you like, traditional approaches to skill acquisition, which is about this is an optimum technique.
- 22:58Keith Davids, PhD: I'm going to instruct you in it.
- 22:59Keith Davids, PhD: It's a template for this movement, and we're going to acquire it.
- 23:03Keith Davids, PhD: If uh part of the learning process is that I give you instructions, you try and perform the movement, I look at your actions as you're trying to perform that movement, and then I decide what is error.
- 23:16Keith Davids, PhD: And error means it doesn't fit this template that the coach or teacher or trainer has in their mind.
- 23:22Keith Davids, PhD: This is what I'm expecting of you now.
- 23:26Keith Davids, PhD: And as you say, it kind of ignores what people actually perceived at a particular moment, not just what they saw, you mentioned about seeing, but also what they felt, what they heard, basically the information that they got from their body, which is so-called haptic information, touch, feel, proprioceptive information, that sort of thing.
- 23:48Keith Davids, PhD: All of that is deeply integrated, and that forms part of knowledge of the performance environment.
- 23:55Keith Davids, PhD: That in many ways, some of this is subconscious, it's not brought to the fore because even Bernstein's levels of movement organization, levels three and four, um, are subconscious and people are engaged in it, and there um it has been called background corrections that goes on.
- 24:15Keith Davids, PhD: So, in other words, when when you actually engage with the environment, the way you interact with it, there may be all sorts of small, subtle, nuanced adaptations, postural adaptations, and they're not just meaningless because if the if an individual, a learner, is deeply engaged in the task of trying to work out, you know, get information, work out uh to solve problems, work out what they've got to do next, etc., what they're doing is they're learning to what I call um in ecological dynamics, address the performance environment, and that changes.
- 24:49Keith Davids, PhD: So when you in skill adaptation, addressing the performance environment is highly important in terms of orienting your body in space, the styles that you adapt, the posture, the way you regulate posture in order to pick up information to regulate action.
- 25:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that orient is critical in perception, information, and action, right?
- 25:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 25:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I I got a couple paths that we go down, and I hope we can uh there's so much I want to unpack on what you just shared.
- 25:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, namely on the uh attunement dwelling, uh, I think I'm saying that correctly.
- 25:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that similar to being present?
- 25:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then I want to go into intuition and interoception because we kind of hit on some of the the things that are going inside of our body.
- 25:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, first question is um that dwelling that we you brought up, is that like being present?
- 25:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there a similarity there and getting into flow?
- 25:39Keith Davids, PhD: It's part of it.
- 25:40Keith Davids, PhD: It's part of it, obviously to be present, but it's also uh attentive dwelling is about where you are learning by doing through practical experience.
- 25:48Keith Davids, PhD: So, for example, if you think about it, how did people learn important skills in the past when there were no there were no formal schools, no formal education programs, no training programs?
- 25:59Keith Davids, PhD: People they had to grow plants at certain times, crops at certain times, uh decide when to put seeds in, when to pick, harvest, etc.
- 26:09Keith Davids, PhD: Fish, hunt, all these are important skills for survival at that time, work in the team, um, maybe combat against people who wanted to take their lands, etc.
- 26:21Keith Davids, PhD: And the the open there was no formal schools that uh people went to that they went and they learned as they that as they were engaged.
- 26:30Keith Davids, PhD: And and that they they were actually the term that Tim Ingold and Carl Woodson ourselves use in ecological dynamics is enskillment, when it's an active process of inskilling yourself, and there are several concepts that are important.
- 26:45Keith Davids, PhD: Attentive dwelling is one where you're right in the here and now learning by doing as you're going along, learning when to be quiet on a hunt, how to track prey, that sort of things, how to operate weapons, all that sort of thing.
- 26:58Keith Davids, PhD: But then there's also there's uh wayfaring that is you learn as you go along, and there's the perception, action, coupling, the active engagement in tasks, engagement with the environment that's important, and that is clearly skill adaptation because the way you look for information, the the feel, you know, in terms of your posture, your body posture, whether you can operate a weapon like a bow and arrow or a uh some sort of a uh a killing weapon, uh, but from different uh stances, because sometimes if you stand upright, prey might observe you.
- 27:35Keith Davids, PhD: So you're hidden away and you've got to operate in a crowd stance or lying down or that sort of thing.
- 27:42Keith Davids, PhD: And you can see the translations to military combat as well.
- 27:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think uh in the business world, a lot of folks use PowerPoints, they do a didactic, uh dominant approach.
- 27:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh they don't want to do experiential learning.
- 27:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All the things that I think uh coaches and in that are using CLA are experiencing, we're experiencing organizations as well.
- 28:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 28:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that we most people learn by uh what's the tr transactional approaches, right?
- 28:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where they're on top of it.
- 28:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 28:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's but we want transformational.
- 28:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's the right term that you're you're using.
- 28:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But to do that, you have to have some type of I'm gonna I I can't remember who said this, but do the thing.
- 28:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's either uh uh Sean Mishko or Pete Blair.
- 28:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I heard it from somebody recently that you and you just said it yourself, you have to do the thing in order to learn.
- 28:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 28:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So okay, so experiential learning activities.
- 28:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you can't do the thing, you have to have a simulation that shows you those things.
- 28:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would you agree?
- 28:34John Boyd: Yeah.
- 28:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 28:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, like if I can't teach teamwork over a period of five months because the team, you know, I just can't be there for five months and it's just a waste of time.
- 28:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have to do it in a shorter amount of time.
- 28:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have to use what some people refer to as anthro simulation, human and machine manipulation of the environment.
- 28:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Manipulation of the environment is I don't know if you use that term at all, but that's what constraints are.
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would you agree?
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 28:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 28:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 28:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or informational constraints, yeah.
- 29:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So and then when I talk to folks about what this is like, and you you brought up uh gardening earlier, uh, leading like a gardener, growing things, right?
- 29:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That is a that is like a metaphor or analogy to think about what is you're trying to do as a leader.
- 29:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're not there to tell them how to do all the movement.
- 29:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're it's all about the uh conditions of the environment.
- 29:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we talk a little bit more about uh constraints on the individual?
- 29:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think you call them uh task constraints or their, or excuse me, individual constraints, things like effectivities, their their genetics, uh, when they get tired.
- 29:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we talk a little bit about how a coach can use how they identify that and how they can start using that to their advantage to make sure we get some skill adaptation?
- 29:48Keith Davids, PhD: Yes, that that's a good topic to pick up on.
- 29:51Keith Davids, PhD: Carl Newell said a constraints model for the for listeners who are not aware of the constraints model.
- 29:57Keith Davids, PhD: I'm sure there aren't many of them there.
- 29:58Keith Davids, PhD: But um essentially Carl Newell in 1986 proposed um a model of interacting constraints.
- 30:05Keith Davids, PhD: So um I think um when we uh talk about constraints, sometimes it gets lost.
- 30:12Keith Davids, PhD: But interacting constraints is fundamental.
- 30:15Keith Davids, PhD: The idea of uh the constraints are either, according to Newell's model, personal, related to each individual, and that relates to what you or I or any other person brings to a performance environment, brings to a behavioral task, brings to a learning context.
- 30:33Keith Davids, PhD: And that could be physical constraints, it could be psychological, emotional, it could be related to uh personal uh capacities like intelligence and uh quickness of learning and that sort of thing.
- 30:48Keith Davids, PhD: And then you've got task constraints, and these are related to the specific task that you're learning.
- 30:54Keith Davids, PhD: It could be a military task, it could be a sport-related task in sport, that could be an individual task like running um a marathon, it could be um archery, it could be trampolining, or it could be a team-based task.
- 31:10Keith Davids, PhD: This is the collective task, you know, basketball, soccer, football, volleyball, all these sorts of things.
- 31:16Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, and then finally there's environmental constraints.
- 31:18Keith Davids, PhD: Environmental constraints refer to physical properties of the environment.
- 31:24Keith Davids, PhD: So, for example, altitude, gravity, ambient lighting, in dark conditions, in light conditions.
- 31:31Keith Davids, PhD: And I suppose this refers to relates to military combat, for example, ambient temperatures, fighting in the frozen Arctic conditions, fighting in um uh you know the really hot desert conditions, etc.
- 31:44Keith Davids, PhD: etc.
- 31:45Keith Davids, PhD: And those constraints interact.
- 31:47Keith Davids, PhD: So each individual we should expect what that means is that we should expect individual differences because what you or I or anyone else brings to a learning environment in terms of genetics, in terms of capacities, in terms of education, training, experience, skill, all differs and is constantly changing.
- 32:08Keith Davids, PhD: It's dynamic.
- 32:09Keith Davids, PhD: Um, task constraints are dynamic as well.
- 32:12Keith Davids, PhD: And so essentially you've got this interacting relationship between the different constraints, and from that emerges learning, emerges performance, emerge, emerges development over different timescales.
- 32:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So interacting constraints goes back to the complex adaptive systems discussion we had earlier.
- 32:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the quality of the interactions that something will emerge from that, and that's uh where we get self-organization from as well.
- 32:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 32:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I have a question about uh strong and weak anticipation.
- 32:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it goes like this.
- 32:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I could see the floor, if I could see the sport I'm playing, if I'm in situ and I can see it, I think I can have what is known as strong anticipation.
- 32:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Maybe, maybe I'm gonna say that wrong, or I'm not sure if I'm I'm getting that.
- 32:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think, yeah.
- 32:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But in a business, because I can't see the landscape, I don't have it.
- 33:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have to build a I'll say a map for lack of a better term for for a moment.
- 33:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That map reflects the environment.
- 33:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that map that I'm putting on a board or whatever, that that mission statement, that vision statement, that gives me weak anticipation because I'm not really engaging with the environment.
- 33:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 33:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is that I'm I'm and the reason I'm bringing this up is because in my mind, when we're working with organizations, they can't see the playing field.
- 33:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have to but in sport, you can.
- 33:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you talk and again that's my opinion.
- 33:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know what your what your thoughts are on that, but can you talk a little bit more about strong and weak anticipation?
- 33:35Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, it's related to how much heavy lifting a model of performance does, um, a model of the environment.
- 33:44Keith Davids, PhD: So if you're going into a particular competitive context, and it could be to do with uh just say sport example, I'm you know, my my familiarity is with sport, but it could also be in um a military environment.
- 33:57Keith Davids, PhD: It's absolutely fine and natural to have some sort of expectations, some sort of prediction, inference that you that you might make.
- 34:08Keith Davids, PhD: But the error that people make is that that is how we operate, how we best operate.
- 34:15Keith Davids, PhD: And that's the the strong, sorry, that's the weak anticipation in terms of you know, you have this model prediction, but there could be errors.
- 34:22Keith Davids, PhD: There could be you might have got it wrong.
- 34:24Keith Davids, PhD: You you know, the number of times in um elite's fought performance with all the data analytics that are that are there to support, you look at some performance and the coaches got it completely wrong.
- 34:36Keith Davids, PhD: Made uh you know, pick the wrong team, tactically got it wrong, not really understood the opposition's strengths and weaknesses.
- 34:45Keith Davids, PhD: It is it is rare, it's getting rarer, but it especially in coaching in teams, but sometimes that does happen.
- 34:51Keith Davids, PhD: But strong anticipation is where players and athletes and um uh members in a group in whatever performing context are taught to adapt, taught to read what's going on, take a look at the information, um, and uh perceive information, really enhance their skills in perceiving what the environment is offering, the affordances, called invitations and opportunities that a particular environment um is providing at this particular moment, whether it's expected or not, and becoming good at that, becoming good at basing their performance on that.
- 35:30Keith Davids, PhD: So it's okay to have some sort of intention, some plans, some expectations, but it's it's uh much more unskilling of the individual for them to be thinking, well, this is what I expected a bit.
- 35:44Keith Davids, PhD: But actually, things are not quite what I expect, you know, uh things might be going a bit pear-shaped here, and then they can adapt.
- 35:53Keith Davids, PhD: They have that confidence, they had that level of awareness of the environment that surrounds and uh focus in order to be able to adapt to what's emerging in front of them.
- 36:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I want to kind of bucket a few things together and see if they they work.
- 36:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so it's intentions, intent uh from a coach, and then heuristics principles of play, because we're moving away from scripted approaches.
- 36:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't want set things in in certain situations, we want to uh create the adaptive adaptiveness of the individuals and the team to the changing environment to recognize that.
- 36:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we talk about a few things?
- 36:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The importance of heuristics principles in in working with complex adaptive systems and ecological dynamics and how that resonates with and what the difference is between intentions and intent from a coach, if there is a difference.
- 36:43Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, well uh I mean basically that that's the essence of skill adaptation.
- 36:47Keith Davids, PhD: What you captured there is this focus of this need on heuristics, the problem solving, dealing with the uncertainty, the ambiguity.
- 36:55Keith Davids, PhD: And when I talk about that, I don't mean you look at it and go the ambiguity is in the individual, or the uncertainty is in the individual.
- 37:02Keith Davids, PhD: It's not, it's in the individual environment relationship.
- 37:07Keith Davids, PhD: That's what's ambiguous at a particular time, or that's what's uncertain at the time.
- 37:12Keith Davids, PhD: That's that's a more ecological approach.
- 37:14Keith Davids, PhD: And it's really that's what skill adaptation is focused on.
- 37:17Keith Davids, PhD: So training and practice and preparing for performance using skill adaptation sets that up.
- 37:25Keith Davids, PhD: So it provides you with the basis, um, the wherewithal in order to engage with the heuristics, not go overwhelmed with it, but embrace it and to problem solve, to come up with a solution that is good enough rather than looking for the to achieve some sort of perfect optimal solution that a coach or a plan had in mind.
- 37:48Keith Davids, PhD: But under the circumstances, this is the reality of the situation, and this is why it's it's it's kind of working out what uh what a particular decision is, what a state of affairs is, and going with that rather than actually um uh striving for some optimal uh situation of state of affairs, whether it's a technique that you're working on or um uh a sort of context environment and striving for that.
- 38:18Keith Davids, PhD: It may never happen.
- 38:19Keith Davids, PhD: Uh and so that would be futile, and that's where a lot of the energy will be wasted.
- 38:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 38:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Actually, uh this is interesting.
- 38:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In in the military, we had something known as effects-based operations.
- 38:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You start with the end of mind and work backwards.
- 38:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can define a great future state.
- 38:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In a complex system, you can't do that, right?
- 38:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we get a direction of travel.
- 38:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's why intent is so important.
- 38:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think what happens today is a lot of folks take what we learned in fighter aviation and go, every organization has to define a future, you know, high-definition destination.
- 38:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have to know exactly where they're gonna be, but you can't do that in a complex system.
- 38:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So where I'm going with this now, and I'm uh I I I don't know how to do this yet, but how does how do you advise coaches, researchers, anybody that's asking, how does a leader talk about intent?
- 39:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How does a coach talk about it with their team?
- 39:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Given that context we just talked about.
- 39:11Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, there's lots of ways that you can approach it, but one of the ways that we've approached it in ecological dynamics is to emphasize the role of co-design, co-designing.
- 39:23Keith Davids, PhD: So you work with your athletes, not in a hierarchical way, but more in a heterarchical way, where solutions can emerge from different parts of the team, parts of the group, or even in a one, you know, like an individual sport where there's another you're you're coaching an athlete just by themselves, that can still lead to co-design, the importance of co-design.
- 39:46Keith Davids, PhD: So you work together rather than in a top-down way the coach saying, This is what I want you to aim for, this is what I've got in my mind, these are my expectations, and I want you to fulfill it, which is such an old-fashioned way of doing it.
- 39:59Keith Davids, PhD: A good athlete acts like a scientist.
- 40:02Keith Davids, PhD: They're trying, they're experimenting with things, they're exploring, they're searching.
- 40:06Keith Davids, PhD: They've got no vested interest in exploring a movement, um, a skill beyond its functionality, beyond it being functional.
- 40:16Keith Davids, PhD: Is this useful?
- 40:17Keith Davids, PhD: Is this helpful?
- 40:18Keith Davids, PhD: Is this going to help me achieve my intention, my goals, uh performance goals, that sort of thing?
- 40:24Keith Davids, PhD: Beyond it, they're very rarely looking at things like etiquette, you know, beauty, aesthetics, you know, some sports might emphasize that as part of the scoring criteria, but that's that's a task constraint.
- 40:35Keith Davids, PhD: A lot of sports don't have that task constraint.
- 40:38Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, the rules and uh regulations in the scoring system, etc.
- 40:41Keith Davids, PhD: It's all about, for example, if you score a basket or if you score a goal or a touchdown, how you get that over.
- 40:48Keith Davids, PhD: There are certain um parameters, rules that you fulfill, but beyond that, it's pretty much it's quite open and adaptive there.
- 40:56Keith Davids, PhD: Um and an athlete will work, will know it, they're very um honest.
- 41:00Keith Davids, PhD: They know what they need to improve, they they know what they want to get better at, they know you know they can look at data, they've got no vested interest in being biased and providing some sort of rosy picture of their performance when the data tells otherwise.
- 41:15Keith Davids, PhD: You know, they're there to work with the coach.
- 41:17Keith Davids, PhD: And so often you can uh work closely with the other things, say, what do you think, what do you think is going wrong here?
- 41:22Keith Davids, PhD: What is and and they could tell you, you know, it could be some sort of social environmental constraint to do with um something emotionally going on uh socially in their lives or whatever, or it could be just that they want to try to become better at a particular aspect of performance.
- 41:38Keith Davids, PhD: And so this is where the coach acts as the mentor, the guide, the facilitator of learning and problem solving.
- 41:44Keith Davids, PhD: The coach isn't the problem solver on the field in uh in uh in the performance environment, performance concept, the performer is the problem solver.
- 41:54Keith Davids, PhD: So that's what uh the team, if you like, got to work towards supporting.
- 41:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I'm hearing you correctly, the the idea of co-design and intent.
- 42:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're a coach at the beginning of the season, uh you can't come in with a we you know you can't know exactly what the the full intent.
- 42:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's gonna evolve over time based off of what you learn from your players and the environment.
- 42:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Contrast that with what happens in a lot of sports.
- 42:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You hear a commentary that they're bringing a coach and he's gonna install this system into this place and they're gonna it's gonna work phenomenally.
- 42:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're like, but you're forgetting about something, the people in the team and the environment, right?
- 42:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is a shift in thinking.
- 42:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Am I incorrect in saying that the intent will co will evolve over time?
- 42:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're getting at the beginning of a basketball season, right?
- 42:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we're talking about on day one may not be what we're talking about on day 10.
- 42:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 42:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 42:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 42:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 42:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then intent isn't static.
- 42:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's another way to say it, right?
- 42:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 42:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 42:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it has to dynamic.
- 42:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the the the coach or the leader has to communicate that as it evolves and co-design it with the players.
- 42:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I'm hearing, right?
- 42:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 42:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 42:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 42:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That that makes makes a lot of sense.
- 43:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's messy.
- 43:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think that's why people struggle with this, is when when I run workshops for organizations and they go, hey, what are the outputs?
- 43:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, what what's the agenda look like for the day?
- 43:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, I really don't know.
- 43:15John Boyd: Yeah.
- 43:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can't know because I don't know what's going to happen here.
- 43:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 43:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have an idea.
- 43:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have tools and methods, and I have ways to change constraints.
- 43:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 43:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it's I don't know what it's going to look like at our four.
- 43:28Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah.
- 43:29unknown: Yeah.
- 43:30Keith Davids, PhD: And just take this conversation, for example.
- 43:33Keith Davids, PhD: We haven't predetermined this script.
- 43:35Keith Davids, PhD: We haven't met several times over the past months or whatever, and said, no, we'll talk about this and then next, then you introduce this very in a very kind of scripted way.
- 43:45Keith Davids, PhD: It's kind of ecological in that respect, in that we, you know, the conversation is emerging, the ideas are emerging, and um, there's an interaction going on.
- 43:55Keith Davids, PhD: So, in a sense, we're co designing this particular podcast.
- 43:59Keith Davids, PhD: Uh the performance.
- 44:01Keith Davids, PhD: And it's the same with um a performance.
- 44:02Keith Davids, PhD: So don't forget, you know, you can say, oh, well, um, in sports, for example, and maybe in military combat, uh, there's a lot of data, information presence.
- 44:12Keith Davids, PhD: So you can actually try and script it, but the opposition have the data, they have access to um all the same information, etc.
- 44:21Keith Davids, PhD: You but when you go out, you don't know the uh strategical approach that the opposition is going to take in a particular context and performance context.
- 44:31Keith Davids, PhD: You think you can, you you can go with the intentions, but if they don't operate in that way, you could be completely flummoxed and find yourself in a really difficult situation very quickly because your athletes aren't used to adapting.
- 44:46Keith Davids, PhD: And uh, what do we do now?
- 44:47Keith Davids, PhD: Are we sticking to the plan?
- 44:49Keith Davids, PhD: Are we gonna uh bin the plan?
- 44:50Keith Davids, PhD: Am I gonna go and do this?
- 44:51Keith Davids, PhD: What are you gonna do?
- 44:52Keith Davids, PhD: That sort of thing.
- 44:53Keith Davids, PhD: So they have to learn um and be put into that context in practice environments, performance preparation environments, and that doesn't mean randomness and sheer chaos, which is that it's a term that has a very specific meaning in science, used in sport in a very applied way.
- 45:10Keith Davids, PhD: I'm not a big fan of the way it's used, actually.
- 45:13Keith Davids, PhD: But we're talking, you know, high levels of variability in practice, and that's why skill adaptation for me is a more functionally relevant terminology to capture the types of practice design and performance preparation approaches that can be used in a lot of context.
- 45:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna keep you a few more minutes if that's possible.
- 45:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know we're running over time.
- 45:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not a problem.
- 45:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's talk about, I'll call it orientation right now, but uh no one person on the team can have the full picture.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that same should be true for the coach.
- 45:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so how do we how do you talk about that from a an ecological dynamics perspective?
- 45:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How no one of us has all of the information or understand what's going on around us in a inner sport or an event?
- 45:57Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, and and I'd question whether you need that full detail of information.
- 46:02Keith Davids, PhD: I mean, you for me, uh what I love about dynamical systems theory is that intentionality.
- 46:09Keith Davids, PhD: Scott Kelso, wonderful psychologist, experimental scientist, movement scientist, Scott Kelso talked about intentionality being one of the most important sources of information that is used in the the way that a dynamical system emerges, behav how behaviour emerges from a dynamical system.
- 46:31Keith Davids, PhD: So that frames the way that you approach a task, that frames performance preparation, that frames learning, that frames the what the approach that you're going to take in a particular contest in a competitive environment.
- 46:46Keith Davids, PhD: And it is it is very, very important.
- 46:48Keith Davids, PhD: And that can change.
- 46:49Keith Davids, PhD: So it's not set in stone.
- 46:51Keith Davids, PhD: It's not a case of saying this is plan A, we've only got plan A, etc.
- 46:56Keith Davids, PhD: We shouldn't even talk about plan A, B, C.
- 46:58Keith Davids, PhD: There is a sort of intentionality, but there should be an understanding that you're in a complex adaptive system and your opponents are part of that.
- 47:08Keith Davids, PhD: So this thing is constantly changing.
- 47:10Keith Davids, PhD: This is why the term ecological dynamics, the ecological side emphasizes the transactions of an organism, an athlete or um a military combatant with their environments, those transactions.
- 47:24Keith Davids, PhD: And dynamics means constantly changing over different timescales.
- 47:28Keith Davids, PhD: And that for me captures exactly the way to approach performance preparation.
- 47:34Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, and it goes back to the first question that you you made at the beginning there, Brian, about skill skill acquisition, but why should we talk about skill adaptation?
- 47:43Keith Davids, PhD: It's because of those uh sort of um advances that we might move towards that.
- 47:49Keith Davids, PhD: In reality, if I if I just use skill adaptation all the time, people wouldn't know what I was talking about.
- 47:55Keith Davids, PhD: So I have to be careful about that.
- 47:57Keith Davids, PhD: But I'm I'm hoping it's a move towards that.
- 47:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It makes sense.
- 48:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can help you with that.
- 48:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I I want to start using that.
- 48:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I see that you brought up Scott Kelso.
- 48:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh he's been writing a lot about flow.
- 48:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You've written about flow, flow states, peak performance recently as well.
- 48:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and where this is going, we're starting to talk about attractor states and getting more into things like that.
- 48:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, can you talk a little bit more how you're using attractors and and uh how Scott's using that and what that means to I'm gonna say a word here that I'm not super familiar with, metastability and and we call it liminality.
- 48:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I understand that.
- 48:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we talk a little bit more about how those attractor dynamics, metastability, liminality all fit into this?
- 48:36Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, basically you talk about a dynamical system.
- 48:40Keith Davids, PhD: And one of the most influential, um, if we go back before Stock Kelso's wonderful work in coordination dynamics, so what main contribution was to do was to sort of say, well, these dynamics, we know about it in physics and chemistry and biology.
- 48:56Keith Davids, PhD: We can also apply it to the study of movement and the study of brain and behavior.
- 49:01Keith Davids, PhD: That's what he what he did.
- 49:03Keith Davids, PhD: But if you go back, Conrad Waddington, a biologist in the 1950s, wrote about the dynamical landscape and how that changes over time.
- 49:11Keith Davids, PhD: And he produced this wonderful um image of an attractor landscape.
- 49:15Keith Davids, PhD: I've seen it on t-shirts, I've seen it on people's.
- 49:17Keith Davids, PhD: I remember in a pub in England once, and there was a guy sitting there next to me, um, near us, and he had this dynamical landscape, and it was a gr a graphic that I put in um a book in 1999 on it.
- 49:31Keith Davids, PhD: And so basically the idea is that the relationship between an organism and the environment can be captured um as an attractor landscape, and that is essentially to do with the um amount of stability in their actions or insta.
- 49:47Keith Davids, PhD: And so you imagine uh you've got this landscape of the performance environment where you've got all the actions that you will need and may rely on at a particular time.
- 49:57Keith Davids, PhD: Some of them are less stable by that they're not as well learned.
- 50:01Keith Davids, PhD: They may be under pressure, they might be a little bit um weaker, and others are more stable.
- 50:07Keith Davids, PhD: These are more, uh these are, for example, patterns of behavior that that are well learned and reliable.
- 50:12Keith Davids, PhD: And they are deeper parts.
- 50:14Keith Davids, PhD: So they talk about wells.
- 50:15Keith Davids, PhD: You've got deeper parts.
- 50:16Keith Davids, PhD: So imagine there's a ball rolling around this landscape, and parts of it are deep, and other parts are not so deep.
- 50:22Keith Davids, PhD: And the peak of a hilly incline, for example, the ball could roll this way or that way.
- 50:28Keith Davids, PhD: That is not a stable part of the environment.
- 50:30Keith Davids, PhD: So as you learn, as you become more experienced, as you become more knowledgeable and you gain more expertise, the an attractor in that landscape becomes deeper.
- 50:40Keith Davids, PhD: But you don't want it to be too deep because the ball will get stuck there in the bottom of that.
- 50:46Keith Davids, PhD: It's like a well, and it will need a lot of energy and effort from you to move um from that part of the landscape to another part of the landscape because you will need to.
- 50:56Keith Davids, PhD: It's a dynamical landscape, and we are a dynamical movement system.
- 51:00Keith Davids, PhD: And so this is where the skill adaptation comes in, where you want the landscape a little bit um with uh places of stability, somewhat stable, and other places that are less stable because we there's no human that's got the whole repertoire of movements that they're ever going to need.
- 51:20Keith Davids, PhD: And where the the regions of metastability are regions where very easily, with very little energy, the system, i.e., the person, can transit to another one part of the environment or another part of the environment.
- 51:35Keith Davids, PhD: And that is a major part of skill adaptation for practice and training.
- 51:40Keith Davids, PhD: Designing, we talked about coaches, teachers, trainers being designers of practice tasks, and they design a practice task where there isn't just one solution.
- 51:52Keith Davids, PhD: We know repetition is important in training and practice, but repetition without repetition is much more important where an individual can move, go this way or that way on the performance environment, depending on the needs at that time.
- 52:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thank you so much for that description.
- 52:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I actually did a uh talk on Wall Street for uh PTSD using the same and similar analogies and uh using from ideas from uh Robin Carhart Harris to explain how we get in these attractor states and these deep valleys, and that's how we have trauma sometimes.
- 52:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And where this connects back to what you're talking about, in my view, is sometimes that ego gets in the way.
- 52:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sometimes we have to relax the ego if you're a coach to see that there are other ways to do things, right?
- 52:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And so that's this also applies to coaching.
- 52:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There are many coaches stuck in a deep valley right now on the dogmatic historical approach to doing things.
- 52:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then it takes energy to get them out of that valley into something else.
- 52:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's kind of what I think Alex has experienced in the NBA, or or maybe he doesn't have that resistance anymore.
- 52:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you're seeing other coaches work on this as well.
- 53:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're trying to get those egos, those other coaches' egos to relax a little bit to lower the energy required to move into another basin, if you will, right?
- 53:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 53:11John Boyd: Yeah.
- 53:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 53:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there is I again, thanks so much for that because uh the similarities, I I never put that together until just now that uh we can talk about the same approach in inside of coaching.
- 53:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Good.
- 53:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I tell you what, uh, this has been fantastic.
- 53:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, you know, I appreciate your time today.
- 53:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything you want to cover in the last few milk moments?
- 53:29Keith Davids, PhD: Anything you want to No, uh just that um, you know, it it the work goes on and um it's not a case of being evangelical or anything like that, but there's still a lot of education needed to prov to provide this alternative.
- 53:45Keith Davids, PhD: I'm not when I come across a coach or an athlete or trainer, uh, a scientist, an academic who doesn't agree with principles of ecological dynamics, and there's plenty of them around.
- 53:57Keith Davids, PhD: I don't see as my role to convert, if you I'm not that evangelical about it.
- 54:04Keith Davids, PhD: I see my role, I've got the easy role actually, as the applied scientist academic, is to put the ideas, communicate them, put them on the table, as it were, in written format, in presentations, in discussions like this.
- 54:16Keith Davids, PhD: And then people use them.
- 54:18Keith Davids, PhD: And I think the humility of you talked about egos getting involved.
- 54:24Keith Davids, PhD: It's it's important to be humble and recognize that we're all learning as we're going along and developing as individuals.
- 54:33Keith Davids, PhD: I've been working in this area for 40 years, probably more than that, to be honest, and I'm still learning.
- 54:38Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, um, I think it's quite important to it's better for you if your ego doesn't get in the way, would be my advice to a coach or a or an athlete, and keep humble.
- 54:48Keith Davids, PhD: And by that I mean just keep seeing yourself as adapting and learning because we're all changing.
- 54:54Keith Davids, PhD: We're all changing as we um get along.
- 54:56Keith Davids, PhD: Some of us are getting more experienced, some of us are uh, I don't know, aging and their the injuries and the conditions are sort of taking over.
- 55:05Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, but we've got to adapt and uh having that mindset to adapt, I think, helps us to carry on on our journeys.
- 55:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I tell you, I have about 40 more questions we can go over.
- 55:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep you on here as long as you can.
- 55:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh if you have another moment, data.
- 55:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, we get a lot of data from sports, and and data should inform into how we set up the constraints in the environment to get the things we want.
- 55:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, just looking at basketball right now, uh, the shot spectrum, uh, those things are pretty powerful.
- 55:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're looking at other sports too.
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But how important is data in driving what a coach does in the training?
- 55:43Keith Davids, PhD: It's it's very important.
- 55:44Keith Davids, PhD: I mean, it used to be the case that coaches' intuition, hunches, beliefs, feelings, you know, were more important because uh people didn't have access to the data that I I mean I uh cut my teeth as a young academic at Liverpool Polytechnic in the 1980s, and Liverpool Polytechnic, if the listeners are not aware of in the UK, this uh this small institution is the home of the first sports science course in the world.
- 56:13Keith Davids, PhD: That was the first place in 1975 the course started, that was the first place that anyone would go to to become a sports scientist, and then from there this whole movement has uh grown on.
- 56:25Keith Davids, PhD: And Liverpool Polytechnic in the 1980s, I got there about 10 years after the course started.
- 56:31Keith Davids, PhD: It was the home of performance analysis in a very rudimentary way.
- 56:37Keith Davids, PhD: A lot of it was hand notation, uh, because in dance, for example, uh, disciplines like dance, Rudolf Laban he created the hand notation to describe movements in dance, and so they took that inspiration and they applied it and up uh changed the the way that it was um uh approached in team sports, particularly soccer.
- 56:57Keith Davids, PhD: It started in the football clubs in Liverpool.
- 57:00Keith Davids, PhD: And it's just grown more and more important.
- 57:02Keith Davids, PhD: It gives coaches evidence to support their intuitions and beliefs.
- 57:07Keith Davids, PhD: So it's taken away um, if you like, tendency for coaches, sometimes it's taken away the tendency to become you know obsessive about a particular belief, idea, or model that they have.
- 57:22Keith Davids, PhD: You know, in uh soccer, which I'm most familiar with, the media like to call the latest take um if you were a soccer coach, Rivera, and you were successful, they would talk about your methodology as reverable, reverable.
- 57:38Keith Davids, PhD: Um, you know, it's dominating the English league and that sort of thing.
- 57:43Keith Davids, PhD: Now, that for me is not a good sign because it kind of says, you know, this coach has got all the answers, etc.
- 57:50Keith Davids, PhD: But all the time, your methods, your plan, your approach, tactical approach, strategical approach, is being analysed by data.
- 58:00Keith Davids, PhD: So coaches now and the opposition know what you're doing.
- 58:04Keith Davids, PhD: So you if you stick too rigidly to your a plan, your you know, reverable, for example, um, you're gonna get found out.
- 58:13Keith Davids, PhD: And people will be working on literally within a few weeks, a month maybe, they'll be working on solutions, antidotes to the impact of reverable in in competition.
- 58:24Keith Davids, PhD: So, really, for me, it's data are important, but equally, what's far more important is for coaches to take more of an adaptive approach to performance and coach, learn to coach, and this is really hard.
- 58:39Keith Davids, PhD: I'm not saying this is easy, but training, educating, teaching, coaching in an adaptive way is hard because it evolving, changing, looking at the needs, co-designing, that sort of thing.
- 58:53Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah.
- 58:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so you you brought up uh hints of of uh destruction and creation that the the coaches that are doing well and uh you know if they're gonna go with reverball, I'm gonna need to destroy that model or that that approach and then pick up something new.
- 59:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I said model there, I shouldn't have said that, but that's it's just I have to go through that cycle of destruction and creation.
- 59:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you share with me what the level of play that you've seen by organizations that have embraced ecological dynamics?
- 59:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you actually, over the last 40 years, have you seen the game get better, these teams get better?
- 59:31Keith Davids, PhD: Not only teams get better, um, but also individuals as well, because it's in a range of different sports.
- 59:38Keith Davids, PhD: And the really heartwarming thing for me, Brian, is that um it's not just uh confined to sport, it's confined, it's sorry, it's embraced in a lot of performance contexts.
- 59:52Keith Davids, PhD: Education, music, teaching children, infancy.
- 59:56Keith Davids, PhD: I've seen some stuff on um needlework, I've seen some stuff in law enforcement, the police, uh military combat, Jack Bale's work, uh military combat, etc.
- 1:00:06Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, you know, literally, I'd say there are there must be nearly 50 studies of people applying these ideas in ecological dynamics outside of sport.
- 1:00:15Keith Davids, PhD: In sport itself, a range of different sports.
- 1:00:18Keith Davids, PhD: And what I'm really absolutely wowed by is uh at quite elite levels.
- 1:00:23Keith Davids, PhD: So it's across across all levels of sports.
- 1:00:25Keith Davids, PhD: So you've got the um you know, school level, the physical education side of things, and club sport, and amateur, recreational, adult, that sort of thing in women's sport, in men's sport, at elite level, lots of different sports.
- 1:00:40Keith Davids, PhD: And they're published.
- 1:00:41Keith Davids, PhD: A lot of these coaches are publishing their ideas, so they're they're not they have such a good understanding of it, they're not they're they're not taking a like a whimsical, uh capricious approach to saying, oh, you know, just manipulate constraints, just just do it.
- 1:00:57Keith Davids, PhD: You can just pick one and off you go, you know, like randomly picking it.
- 1:01:01Keith Davids, PhD: It's pretty much they've got a like a model, and the model is dynamic, so it's not just a sort of a model that confines them.
- 1:01:07Keith Davids, PhD: It's quite dynamic and evolving.
- 1:01:10Keith Davids, PhD: They embrace that and they got a way of coaching.
- 1:01:12Keith Davids, PhD: Some of the proponents, I mean, I'll I can I can drop a few names.
- 1:01:16Keith Davids, PhD: Fabianotte, goalkeeping coach, he's at Tottenham Hotster in the English Premier League.
- 1:01:22Keith Davids, PhD: He was actually the US men's national team goalkeeping coach a few years ago, before he went to Liverpool in the Premier League, and now he's at Tottenham.
- 1:01:32Keith Davids, PhD: He uses ecological dynamics ideas coaching goalkeepers.
- 1:01:36Keith Davids, PhD: So these are in like um there, you know, in in a professional football club organization, there may be three, four goalkeepers.
- 1:01:44Keith Davids, PhD: So he's immediately got a problem of trying to simulate, you know, you talked about simulating practice environments, and you've got goalkeepers.
- 1:01:52Keith Davids, PhD: So how do you do that?
- 1:01:54Keith Davids, PhD: You've got to also simulate the environment where may there may be lots of players around, distracting the goalkeeper, trying to put the goalkeeper off, physically interacting with them at times.
- 1:02:04Keith Davids, PhD: And he has learned to do that and manipulate the task constraints really well.
- 1:02:08Keith Davids, PhD: So he, for me, is right up there.
- 1:02:10Keith Davids, PhD: Alex Sarama's another one, basketball.
- 1:02:13Keith Davids, PhD: But it's not just um uh limited to team sports.
- 1:02:16Keith Davids, PhD: People, I've seen some real misconceptions where they say, Oh, yeah, ecological dynamics, you know, it's just limited to team sport.
- 1:02:22Keith Davids, PhD: It's not.
- 1:02:22Keith Davids, PhD: I've seen it in springboard diving, I've seen it in uh track and field, uh, cricket, bowling, um, run up in long jump, for example.
- 1:02:32Keith Davids, PhD: The idea is and climbing, you know, the individual on the vertical surface, swimming in a pool.
- 1:02:37Keith Davids, PhD: Yep.
- 1:02:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They've been applied all over.
- 1:02:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I want to talk about this, and I shared this with Alex and George and a few other folks, uh even Pete Blair.
- 1:02:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is my view is you know, 95% of the kids that are playing basketball here in the US are not gonna go to college to play basketball, right?
- 1:02:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But they are gonna face an environment where technology is accelerating, they have to be adaptive.
- 1:03:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't be, you know, you can't have a dominant approach, you can't be top-down in this environment.
- 1:03:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna be working in a complex environment, meaning, you know, what we talked about earlier, that's where humans are going to dominate or or still be valuable.
- 1:03:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Novelty seeking, creativity, that type of thing.
- 1:03:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what that's why CLA is important to me in sport right now, is I have two daughters that are doing this.
- 1:03:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't want them to go this is not about them going to play D1.
- 1:03:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is about creating great kids, teammates, leaders to adapt to a future environment that's going to be here right now.
- 1:03:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's changing so fast.
- 1:03:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't think people share that view or or they don't understand that.
- 1:03:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and I might be a uh you know in the minority here and saying something like that, that the things that you're learning in sport can be super valuable for working in at the age of 24, 25 when you go into an organization that's using this accelerated technology.
- 1:03:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any thoughts to that?
- 1:03:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any any connection there?
- 1:03:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely, spot on.
- 1:03:59Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, completely agree.
- 1:04:00Keith Davids, PhD: So the educational value is good for brain and behavior, um, it's it's good for social development, you know, the environmental interaction, um, engaging with other individuals, working as part of a team, learning how to work independently, uh, to be productive, to contribute to society.
- 1:04:16Keith Davids, PhD: The point about um ecological dynamics, which I like a lot, is that there is a health legacy to it.
- 1:04:24Keith Davids, PhD: So, yeah, you're right.
- 1:04:25Keith Davids, PhD: Nobody's claiming that use these methods and you'll produce world-class champion athletes.
- 1:04:30Keith Davids, PhD: It's not that's not the point.
- 1:04:32Keith Davids, PhD: It's about each individual reaching their own potential, achieving what they can do, satisfying the constraints on them to a level that they want.
- 1:04:43Keith Davids, PhD: The point that people, for example, let's just take the the I the idea about the role of genetic genetics genes, acting as a constraint.
- 1:04:52Keith Davids, PhD: Sure, it's an important constraint on you know your performance, etc.
- 1:04:56Keith Davids, PhD: But the point about genetics is that um unless you're going to an elite level, you're really trying to achieve, I don't know, perform a marathon in uh under two hours and break the you know the record, that sort of thing, etc.
- 1:05:11Keith Davids, PhD: It's not important.
- 1:05:13Keith Davids, PhD: It's far more important to focus on the value of sport and exercise, physical activity, playing games for health and well-being.
- 1:05:23Keith Davids, PhD: And if you're still playing and performing at a senior age, that's so important for your legacy.
- 1:05:30Keith Davids, PhD: And what can happen?
- 1:05:31Keith Davids, PhD: Uh, ecological dynamics can help you with that because um you can exploit variability and adaptation to adapt as your body changes, as your brain changes, etc., to still be functioning under particular constraints, performance constraints.
- 1:05:46Keith Davids, PhD: And we're not, and I'm not talking about going for world-class championships at a at a senior age.
- 1:05:51Keith Davids, PhD: I'm just talking about exercising, participating in sport, contributing to society.
- 1:05:57Keith Davids, PhD: So I applaud, I applaud your views on your daughters.
- 1:06:00Keith Davids, PhD: I've got four kids, uh, and all of them play sport and engage in activity and train still.
- 1:06:06Keith Davids, PhD: And for me, that's a win-win situation.
- 1:06:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's a fantastic place to wrap this up.
- 1:06:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, Keith, Professor Davids, can you tell us uh what you're working on, where they our guests can find you, our listeners can find you, uh, your podcast, your work, anything that uh you want to share?
- 1:06:21Keith Davids, PhD: Thanks for that.
- 1:06:22Keith Davids, PhD: Yeah, so um I've got a podcast with a really uh long-standing colleague, Ian Renshaw.
- 1:06:27Keith Davids, PhD: I I supervise, uh co-supervised Ian's PhD, wonderful collaborator, Martin Rothwell, is another one.
- 1:06:34Keith Davids, PhD: And the podcast is called The Constraints Collective.
- 1:06:38Keith Davids, PhD: And people can become members if they want, but there's a lot of free stuff on the website there.
- 1:06:43Keith Davids, PhD: And it really addresses all things ecological related to performance in different environments, different contexts, mostly sport, but other contexts too.
- 1:06:53Keith Davids, PhD: So people are very welcome to look for that.
- 1:06:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, awesome.
- 1:06:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna keep you on here for a moment and uh we'll we'll wrap it up right there.
- 1:06:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But thank you so much for joining me today.
- 1:07:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we'll get this airborne here soon and we'll package it up with uh uh Alex Arama's uh recent uh visit to us here on No Way Out.
- 1:07:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thanks again, Professor.
- 1:07:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you.
- 1:07:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Don't go anywhere, I'll keep you right here.
- 1:07:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What am I getting at?
- 1:07:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 1:07:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There is no layout.
- 1:07:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.