Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / PDD Business Deep Value Investing Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever found yourself wondering about the sheer scale
- 0:03and just the ingenuity behind apps like Pinduo Duo and Timu?
- 0:07You know, the ones lighting up your phone?
- 0:09Today we're diving deep into the engine driving them PDD Holdings
- 0:13Inc. We'll be dissecting their latest
- 0:16financial research report. And this isn't just, you know,
- 0:18about another e-commerce giant. It's really about understanding
- 0:21a company that's fundamentally reshaping online shopping from
- 0:25group buying at home to, well, global marketplaces.
- 0:28Yeah, exactly. And our mission for you today is
- 0:32pretty clear cut through the noise, give you a concise but
- 0:35still comprehensive understanding of PDD holdings.
- 0:38We'll explore their unique social shopping model, unpack
- 0:40their recent Q22025 performance, look at the big challenges they
- 0:44face in, let's face it, a fiercely competitive market.
- 0:47And we'll even run them through a kind of Buffett style
- 0:49checklist. The goal is just to pull out the
- 0:51key insights quickly so you can really grasp what's driving this
- 0:54fascinating player and maybe what his future holds.
- 0:58Right, so you're going to get a shortcut to being genuinely well
- 1:00informed on a company that's not just making waves or kind of
- 1:03charting a new course from farms in China straight to your
- 1:07shopping cart. Let's dig in.
- 1:08So what exactly is PD DS secret sauce?
- 1:10I mean, you might know their platforms, pin duo duo Timu, but
- 1:14the core business model, it feels genuinely revolutionary in
- 1:17e-commerce. It's not just what they sell,
- 1:19but how they get people buying. It's fascinating, isn't it?
- 1:22The model is built around social shopping and group buying.
- 1:28Think of it like turning shopping into this collective
- 1:30treasure hunt. You don't just see a deal, you
- 1:32actively recruit friends, maybe even strangers through apps like
- 1:35WeChat to unlock an even better deal.
- 1:38This whole viral loop uses existing social networks, right?
- 1:41So customer acquisition becomes incredibly efficient.
- 1:44Every user is basically a potential marketer.
- 1:46Peneua Duo for instance, connects millions of active
- 1:49buyers. I think it was around
- 1:50882,000,000 back in Q12022 directly with merchants, often
- 1:55agricultural producers, small vendors, this direct consumer
- 1:58thing powered by social interaction and you know, those
- 2:01juicy coupons. It completely reshapes the
- 2:03traditional supply chain. It's high volume, community
- 2:06driven and really engaging. Wow.
- 2:07OK, so it's like a massive digital bazaar, all powered by
- 2:11community interaction. But with this huge network, this
- 2:13unique model, how does PD actually make money?
- 2:15What are their main revenue streams?
- 2:17Good question. They have two primary sources
- 2:19and it's almost all earned from the merchants, not really the
- 2:22end consumers. First, online marketing
- 2:25services, basically advertising fees, priority placement for
- 2:29merchants trying to get seen recently, that was about 54% of
- 2:33their revenue. Second is transaction services.
- 2:35These are the commissions PDD earns on sales made through
- 2:38their platforms. That accounts for roughly the
- 2:40other 46%. Tmoot does have a minor third
- 2:43source from direct merchandise sales, but yeah, those two main
- 2:46categories, that's where pretty much all the income comes from.
- 2:48OK, let's shift gears. Let's pull back the curtain on
- 2:50their latest performance. PDD just announced Q22025
- 2:54results. They actually beat revenue
- 2:56forecasts hitting R&D 103,985 million, that's what about
- 3:00$14.52 billion and it's up 7% year over year.
- 3:04So decent top line growth there. Indeed, the top line revenue was
- 3:07solid, especially online marketing services that jumped
- 3:1013% to R&B 55,703 million. But and this is where the nuance
- 3:15comes in, profitability that faced considerable pressure.
- 3:18Their cost of revenue surged a lot of 36% to RMB 45,859
- 3:23million. This was mostly higher
- 3:25fulfillment, logistics, server costs, all scaling up with that
- 3:27volume, right? So this big jump in operating
- 3:29expenses meant their operating profit actually fell 21% year
- 3:32over year down to RMB 25,793 million.
- 3:36And consequently, net income also dipped about 4% to RMB
- 3:3930,754 million. So yeah, revenue beat
- 3:42expectations, but the bottom line, a different story, a story
- 3:46of strategic trade-offs, So. Robust revenue, OK, but squeezed
- 3:49margins for a company like PDD with their scale and ambition,
- 3:52what does this actually mean? Is this a red flag or something
- 3:54else going on? Well, management was pretty
- 3:56explicit about it. They attributed this margin
- 3:59squeeze to aggressive ecosystem subsidies and big marketing
- 4:03investments. This isn't just, you know, a
- 4:05random dip. It's a calculated gamble by PDD.
- 4:08They're deliberately prioritizing long term growth
- 4:11market share, aiming for that kind of winner take all position
- 4:15in certain segments, even if it costs them profits right now by
- 4:18heavily reinvesting, think about all this Teemu deals you see
- 4:21everywhere. They're trying to solidify their
- 4:23position, pull in even more users and merchants.
- 4:26But it does raise that important question, when does market
- 4:29dominance turn into sustainable higher profit and what's the
- 4:32risk in the meantime? It's definitely a bold strategy.
- 4:36Right. And every company, especially
- 4:37one playing on this aggressive global scale faces headwinds.
- 4:41What specific challenges, what risks should we be watching out
- 4:44for with PDD as they navigate these, well, pretty complex
- 4:47waters? Yeah.
- 4:48Connecting this to the bigger picture, there are several big
- 4:50risks. Short term, they're super
- 4:53sensitive to China's macro cycle, a sluggish economy, a
- 4:57weak property sector that can really curb consumer spending
- 4:59and e-commerce trade tensions to US tariffs on Chinese goods that
- 5:04could raise costs for Teemu, their cross-border stuff and
- 5:07domestically fierce competition. You've got alibabajd.com, Bite
- 5:12Dance. They're all ramping up subsidies
- 5:14too, which pressures PD to keep spending heavily.
- 5:17Regulatory changes in China could also hit their unique
- 5:19model. Those are definitely substantial
- 5:21short term hurdles, but what about looking further out longer
- 5:24term perspective? Are there structural issues,
- 5:26broader trends that could affect PDD down the line?
- 5:29Oh, absolutely. Over the long haul, you've got
- 5:31different risks. Demographic shifts, tech shifts.
- 5:34China's slowing population growth and urbanization could
- 5:37eventually cap domestic e-commerce growth.
- 5:40That pushes companies like PDD to expand internationally,
- 5:43which, you know, has its own set of challenges.
- 5:45There's also the risk that maybe social commerce loses its
- 5:48novelty or user engagement drops off.
- 5:51That would hit their viral model directly.
- 5:53Politically, potential US bans on Chinese apps like TMU.
- 5:57That would obviously have a huge lasting impact on their
- 5:59international plans. And maybe their reliance on low
- 6:03price, high subsidy tactics just isn't sustainable forever.
- 6:06If they have to scale back those subsidies, revenue growth could
- 6:08slow down permanently. So yeah, structural risks from
- 6:12policy, market saturation, evolving global trade, lots to
- 6:16consider. That heavy spending you
- 6:18mentioned, the ecosystem, subsidies and marketing, how
- 6:21does that really show up in their cost structure?
- 6:22Where's all that money actually going?
- 6:24How much is it hitting the financials?
- 6:25OK. So PDD's cost base is mostly two
- 6:28big areas. The largest variable cost, the
- 6:30one that scales right with sales volume, is fulfillment and
- 6:33payments. That's everything from logistics
- 6:36shipping to payment processing fees.
- 6:38For every single transaction in Q22025, their cost of revenues,
- 6:44driven largely by these higher fulfillment cost per order,
- 6:46jumped that huge 36%, totaling RMB 45,859 million.
- 6:53So yeah, more sales literally mean higher fulfillment costs.
- 6:56That's a core challenge. Then on the operating side,
- 6:58sales and marketing, that's their single biggest expense
- 7:00line item came in at RMB 27,200 and 10 million in Q2.
- 7:05This covers advertising, promotions, all those generous
- 7:07coupons they use basically their customer acquisition engine.
- 7:11And while it's somewhat discretionary, these costs tend
- 7:13to scale right alongside user growth and those market share
- 7:16battles. It clearly reflects that
- 7:18aggressive growth strategy we talked about.
- 7:19OK, shifting gears a bit. Now let's think about the people
- 7:22actually steering the ship through all this complexity.
- 7:24Who's at the helm and how does their leadership philosophy
- 7:27maybe influence PDD strategic choices?
- 7:29Leadership's always critical, right?
- 7:30Especially in such a fast moving industry, right?
- 7:33PDD is led by Lei Chen. He's a founding member, chairman
- 7:36and Co CEO alongside Jiaz and Zhao, who's also Co CEO.
- 7:40Historically, this team has really aggressively pursued
- 7:43growth, even, like we said, at the cost of short term profit.
- 7:47And they've been pretty transparent about these
- 7:49ecosystem investments. They talk openly about the
- 7:51margin impacts with analysts. They don't really sugarcoat it.
- 7:54What's really fascinating here is their incredibly strong value
- 7:57alignment. Chen and Zhao control a
- 8:00significant majority of the Chinese operating entity, the
- 8:03VIE, the variable interest entity.
- 8:05That's that common structure for foreign investment in certain
- 8:07Chinese sectors. This means they are heavily
- 8:10invested in the company's equity value.
- 8:11They stand to gain far more by growing the business than from
- 8:14salary alone. And there's no public record of
- 8:17them selling shares, insider selling.
- 8:19In fact, reports say they actually bought more into
- 8:21related payment ventures back in 2022.
- 8:24This deep personal investment, their long tenure, it really
- 8:27suggests a powerful commitment to the company's long term game.
- 8:30That kind of skin of the game is definitely compelling.
- 8:33It speaks to their long term vision.
- 8:34But, you know, sometimes intense personal investment can lead to
- 8:39maybe a resistance to change or doubling down on strategies that
- 8:43aren't quite working. Do we see any signs of that here
- 8:46or or has their strategy pretty much paid off?
- 8:49That's a fairpoint and it's always a potential risk with
- 8:51highly centralized leadership, isn't it?
- 8:53But PDD story, at least so far, has largely been one of success
- 8:57in executing that growth first strategy, their ability to adapt
- 9:01to expand globally with Teemu, that suggests a management team
- 9:05that isn't rigid. And the market, well, it has
- 9:08rewarded their aggressive expansion.
- 9:10So it indicates that up to now, they're bold bets have generally
- 9:13paid off. It's definitely a high stakes
- 9:14game but they've shown they can play it effectively.
- 9:17Excellent point. So with this leadership clearly
- 9:19focused on reinvestment, what about external shareholders and
- 9:23how does PDD manage its capital overall?
- 9:25Are they returning cash to investors or is it purely
- 9:27reinvestment? OK.
- 9:29Major shareholders include Tencent.
- 9:31They were an early investor, still a strategic partner and of
- 9:33course, the founding executive team through their PDD
- 9:35partnership. Tencent's been a key shareholder
- 9:38since way back in early 2017. They provide strategic help,
- 9:41especially with WeChat integration payments, that sort
- 9:44of thing. Now, unlike some competitors,
- 9:46PDD does not pay dividends and they've rarely bought back
- 9:50stock. They basically keep all cash for
- 9:52growth initiatives. It just reflects a super
- 9:54aggressive reinvestment strategy.
- 9:56One notable long term investor is Li Liu of of Himalaya
- 9:59Capital. He built up a large stake
- 10:01starting in late 2020 and interestingly, he actually
- 10:04increased his position in Q22025, adding about 4.6 million
- 10:08Adss. Those are the American
- 10:10depository shares traded in the US at an average price around
- 10:13$105. He's still a major holder, which
- 10:15suggests, you know, continued optimism from some pretty savvy
- 10:18investors about PDD's long term prospects.
- 10:20All right, now for the ultimate test.
- 10:21Maybe. How does PDD hold up under the
- 10:23scrutiny of, say, Warren Buffett's principles?
- 10:26We're going to put PTD holdings through a kind of Buffett style
- 10:29checklist. See how it measures up against
- 10:32classic value investing ideas. You got to appreciate the
- 10:35numbers that tell a story, right?
- 10:37Especially through such a disciplined lens.
- 10:39And hey, Speaking of numbers and market insights, for those of
- 10:42you who really love getting into the weeds on market temperature,
- 10:44you can actually search and download our iOS app Buffett
- 10:47Indicator right from the Apple App Store.
- 10:49It gives you daily updates on market bubbles.
- 10:52Just a useful tool there. Absolutely.
- 10:54I'm looking at PD, DS, say 10 year key metrics.
- 10:57The story is just one of hyper growth.
- 10:59It's stunning. Revenue skyrocketed.
- 11:00I mean year over year growth rates hit what, 126% in 2019,
- 11:0584% in 2023? Just massive numbers.
- 11:08Net income. It went from losses back in
- 11:102019-2020 when they were scaling like crazy to an estimated $15.4
- 11:14billion by 2024. That's huge.
- 11:17Gross margins have consistently improved too, from around 31% in
- 11:202018 to an estimated 66% in 2024.
- 11:23And net margins went from deep negatives to over 28% in 2024,
- 11:27plus spectacular earnings per share growth since 2020.
- 11:30I mean, these are the kinds of numbers that just demand
- 11:31attention from any growth investor.
- 11:33OK. So on the surface, yeah, with
- 11:34those kinds of growth, those margins, it sounds like an
- 11:36absolutely phenomenal business. But Buffett's criteria, they're
- 11:38often quite strict, right, focusing on intrinsic value,
- 11:41margin of safety. How does PDD actually fare on
- 11:44the specific Buffett checklist items?
- 11:46Right. So PDD generally checks almost
- 11:48all of Buffett's boxes for business quality.
- 11:51Their gross margins have between 6067%, net margins 2528%
- 11:55recently, those are way above his typical 40% and 20%
- 12:00benchmarks. Return on equity averaged over
- 12:02the last three years, well, about 15%, another strong sign.
- 12:05They also have a very strong balance sheet, very little debt,
- 12:08easily passes his safety tests on debt to equity interest
- 12:11coverage and they've generated significant free cash flow since
- 12:14turning profitable. Their return on retained
- 12:16earnings extremely high, well above 2030% in recent years,
- 12:20which is just exceptional capital efficiency.
- 12:22Always a, but isn't there especially applying these, let's
- 12:24say, traditional value metrics to a high growth tech company
- 12:27that just operates so differently from, I don't know,
- 12:29a railroad or a candy company? Precisely the main, let's call
- 12:33it a red flag from a traditional Buffett perspective is valuation
- 12:37discipline, specifically the price to book ratio, the PB.
- 12:40Buffett often looks for companies with a low PB, usually
- 12:44under 1.5. It suggests the market value is
- 12:46well supported by tangible assets offering a clear margin
- 12:49of safety. Now for PDD, while they're
- 12:52priced earnings, their PE ratio has come way down as earnings
- 12:54boomed. It's estimated around 11 for
- 12:572024, which is comfortably under Buffett's typical 15 rule.
- 13:00Their PB, it remains high, generally between 2.4 and 3.4.
- 13:05That's well above is 1.5 rule. And it reflects the stocks rapid
- 13:08growth, sure, but also it's intangible heavy balance sheet.
- 13:11It's a software platform, not a company with lots of physical
- 13:13assets. So while the business quality
- 13:15looks exceptional, finding that obvious margin of safety at
- 13:18current PD levels, that's more challenging for a strict
- 13:20traditional value investor. This high PB, though, it isn't
- 13:24necessarily a red flag for a modern tech company like this,
- 13:27but it forces us, you know, to maybe rethink how we value
- 13:29assets for PDD. So much of its book value is
- 13:32intangible, right? It's massive user base, it's
- 13:34network effect, it's algorithms. A true deep dive means asking,
- 13:38are these intangibles defensible enough to justify that premium
- 13:42valuation? OK.
- 13:43So PDD is kind of breaking some of Buffett's traditional
- 13:46valuation rules, particularly on PB.
- 13:49Does that mean his framework is maybe outdated for these new
- 13:52economy companies? Or does it just highlight that
- 13:54PDD needs a different kind of margin of safety calculation,
- 13:58one that accounts for these intangibles?
- 13:59I think it highlights the challenge and yeah, the need for
- 14:02adaptation. Buffett's principles always
- 14:04emphasize durable competitive advantages.
- 14:06Moats, right? For PDD, those moats aren't
- 14:09physical factories. They're powerful network
- 14:12effects, immense user data, that highly efficient, socially
- 14:15driven customer acquisition model.
- 14:18So while the PD ratio might look high traditionally, the question
- 14:21for a modern investor becomes how robust are these intangible
- 14:25modes and do they create enough future free cash flow to justify
- 14:28the current valuation? The core framework still
- 14:31applies, I think, but the interpretation of assets and
- 14:34value definitely needs to evolve with the underlying business.
- 14:37OK. Given all these metrics, this
- 14:39push and pull between aggressive growth and traditional
- 14:42valuation, what does it all mean for its intrinsic value?
- 14:45Can we actually put a number on it or try to?
- 14:47Well, we can try a simple discounted cash flow ADCF
- 14:50analysis. If we use 2024 net income as a
- 14:53rough proxy for free cash flow, say $15 billion, and use a 10%
- 14:58discount rate, it suggests varying intrinsic values based
- 15:02on what you assume for future growth.
- 15:04In a, let's say, conservative growth scenario, maybe 20%
- 15:07growth, the present value comes out around $180 billion For a
- 15:11nominal growth case, maybe 40%, it's about $250 billion and an
- 15:16optimistic scenario, say 60% growth, that puts it way up
- 15:19around $320 billion. Now with today's market cap
- 15:22hovering near $170 billion, PDD might be close to fair value in
- 15:26that conservative case or potentially undervalued if you
- 15:29believe in those more optimistic growth scenarios.
- 15:32Even that conservative DCF suggests a PE in the low teens
- 15:35is actually quite reasonable given the projected cash flow
- 15:37and growth. So there you have it.
- 15:38You've now gained, hopefully, a pretty sophisticated
- 15:40understanding of PDD Holdings from its social shopping engine
- 15:43and really impressive growth to the strategic choices impacting
- 15:47its profitability. It's a company that I think
- 15:48beautifully illustrates that tension between aggressive
- 15:50growth and traditional value metrics.
- 15:52A true disruptor. That's right.
- 15:54We've seen a business with just outstanding operational metrics,
- 15:57strong management alignment, yet a valuation that definitely asks
- 16:01you to look beyond typical book value metrics.
- 16:04You have to consider the immense intangible assets of a platform
- 16:07company like this. This deep dive, I hope, shows
- 16:10you that truly understanding a company means looking at its
- 16:13unique context, its forward potential, not just applying
- 16:16some rigid historical formula. So here's a final provocative
- 16:19thought for you to consider. In this era of rapid tech
- 16:23change, intense global competition, how do you balance
- 16:27the undeniable quality and immense growth potential of a
- 16:29company like PDD, driven by intangibles, network effects,
- 16:34with the valuation discipline that long term investors
- 16:36cherish? What aspects of their story
- 16:38stand out to you as most impactful for where they go
- 16:40next? Keep exploring, keep asking
- 16:42questions. That's how you'll keep
- 16:43uncovering those Nuggets of knowledge that truly deepen your
- 16:46understanding. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 16:49on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 16:52or different interpretations. The content is for educational
- 16:55purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 16:58Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 17:01decisions. If you want to learn more about
- 17:03this topic, subscribe us on Apple Spotify Podcasts Channel
- 17:07Deep Value Investing. Don't forget to take the book
- 17:09list of Value Investing from the episode description.