Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP175: Mommy Dearest
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia, and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi Talia, Hi Tania. How are you
- 0:38doing? Oh? Today's great day. How are you? Yeah, it's
- 0:41a great day, fucking great day. Welcome everyone to another exciting episode of
- 0:46Crimes and Consequences. And before I get into today's story, I would just
- 0:51like to remind everyone to hit the subscribe or follow button. So before I
- 0:55tell the story today, I just have to warn everyone. It's a horrible,
- 0:59horrible, graphic case of child abuse. Girl. Didn't we already go
- 1:04down this plan with baby lollipops? We did? Yeah? I'm sorry?
- 1:08What is going out here? I got another one? And I'm really sorry,
- 1:12man, this one I literally walked out last time depressed. This one's
- 1:19bad. This one was bad, and I'm not gonna give it away.
- 1:23But anyway, I was pissed. I was pissed. Okay, I don't
- 1:26need all the details now, Okay, Anyway, by just looking at her,
- 1:32you would think Lois Jurgens was the picture perfect housewife in the time of
- 1:37nineteen fifties suburban America. At the very least, that image was exactly what
- 1:42she constantly strived for. This is like the I Love Lucy era. Yes,
- 1:48she strived for this, and that's the expectation that she set for herself.
- 1:53Lois grew up in an impoverished family with sixteen siblings. Holy Catholic,
- 2:00Damn, I'm guessing, so she knew exactly what kind of life she wanted
- 2:05when she eventually left home. She used her marriage to former bandleader turned electrician
- 2:10Harold Jerkins as a means to improve her social standing. At least with Harold,
- 2:15she was considered middle class, which was far better than what she grew
- 2:19up in. Lewis and Harold lived in white Bear Lake, Minnesota, which
- 2:23is a suburb of Saint Paul, and Lewis took pride in the home that
- 2:27they made together. Lewis had a pathological need to control her environment like she
- 2:32was obsessive. She cleaned, and she tended to her home both inside and
- 2:38out, like she just wanted to have this appearance of everything's perfect. She
- 2:43was all about the image. Her house was spotless, her garden was always
- 2:47tended to, and her life was seen as nothing short of perfectly manicured.
- 2:53Lewis herself was prem and proper, and both her and Harold were devout Catholics.
- 3:00You knew it. The only thing that left their perfect image tainted was
- 3:04the fact that Lois could not have children, and they desperately wanted kids.
- 3:09To add insult to injury, the couple also couldn't adopt, since while the
- 3:15authorities had barred Lois from pursuing this path to motherhood. The reason for this
- 3:21sanction was due to Lois's struggle with her mental health over the past decade.
- 3:24She had suffered bouts of depression and psychosis, which included an extended state at
- 3:30a psychiatric institution as a quote unquote mental patient. Lois was subjected to a
- 3:38variety of therapy during her stay oh Man in the fifties, and it included
- 3:43electroshock therapy. She was diagnosed as having psychonaurosis, which is a functional personality
- 3:50disorder characterized by disturbing emotional symptoms such as morbid fears, obsessive thoughts, or
- 3:58depressive states, but with out delusions or hallucinations. Yet, despite her history
- 4:03as well as those who would label her as unfit to raise a child.
- 4:08Lois yearned for motherhood, but it wasn't so much that she felt a super
- 4:12strong maternal drive to procreate, but more like an obsessive compulsion that had everything
- 4:17to do with the image she wanted to put out in the world. After
- 4:20all, a child would complete the ideal picture that she had in her mind
- 4:26of having a perfect family. Not being able to bring a child into the
- 4:30world drove her further into madness. Oh it's shid. She was determined to
- 4:34rectify the situation, and Lois was an extremely determined woman. When she wanted
- 4:41something, she always got it, and she felt as though this situation would
- 4:44be no different. Using the official channels close to her, Lois managed to
- 4:48arrange for the private adoption of a baby boy named Robert. He was born
- 4:54on June twenty second, nineteen sixty and four days later, on June twenty
- 4:58sixth, he was delivered to the Jurgen's home. Robert was the perfect addition
- 5:02and fitted well at the Jurgen's household. It definitely helped that he learned from
- 5:08a young age not to get in his mother's way or cause any undue mess
- 5:13that would most likely send her into a fit of rage. Despite what the
- 5:16authorities had originally thought of Lois, she appeared to be a devout mom.
- 5:23Robert grew to be an intelligent, general and obedient child, and his adoption
- 5:29with the Jurgons seemed to be successful in the eyes of authorities. As time
- 5:33passed, Lois had managed to change their minds. Now, they began to
- 5:38read. Lois had managed to change their minds. Yeah, I remember they
- 5:41said that they didn't want her to adopt, ok, gotcha. Now they
- 5:45began to rethink the ideas on her capabilities as a parent and reconsidered a next
- 5:50adoption. Now she's okay to adopt because she's been doing a good job right.
- 5:56As such, when Lois applied for adoption once again nineteen sixty two,
- 6:00the authorities were far more lenient this second time around. The second child to
- 6:05be adopted by Lois and Harold was one year old peddler named Dennis. The
- 6:11little boy had been born to a seventeen year old teenage mom named Jerry Sherwood.
- 6:15At the time, Jerry was in a bit of trouble, and when
- 6:17she gave birth to Dennis, she was still residing in a home for troubled
- 6:21girls. Because of this, she was convinced by those in charge to put
- 6:27her baby up for adoption. She didn't want to give up her baby,
- 6:31but Jerry did as she was told. She was promised that Dennis would go
- 6:34to a good home. They would take good care of him. Dennis spent
- 6:40his first year of life in the foster care of an elderly woman who had
- 6:46adored him with endless amounts of love and the right kind of affection. Now
- 6:51things would be different, as he would have a family and an older brother.
- 6:57What could be bad about that? Tanya? I know, I already
- 7:01know. I mean, I don't know, But what could go wrong?
- 7:04You're gonna tell me? And I'm just really seriously not going to be able
- 7:09to handle this. Fucking Everything goes wrong. Almost from the moment Dennis arrived,
- 7:14there were problems that arose. That is, in Lois's eyes, and
- 7:17her eyes alone. She took an immediate dislike to the little boy who was
- 7:23so different from her precious little Robert. After all, Robert had been trained,
- 7:28whipped into submission, and ultimately molded into Lois's perfect vision of an obedient,
- 7:33respectful child. She wanted the nuclear family, and she got that with
- 7:38Robert. Dennis, though not so much. He was quite the opposite,
- 7:42which she despised. Dennis was spirited, energetic, and a reimbunctious toddler.
- 7:47Okay, that's normal, yeah exactly. In other words, like, yeah,
- 7:50he's perfectly normal. I mean, he's a baby. Apparently, this
- 7:56was just too much for Lois to handle. She was used to the regiment,
- 8:00had ways of her household and the structure that came along with tidiness and
- 8:03obedience. In fact, she disliked Dennis so intensely that Harold actually suggested that
- 8:09maybe they shouldn't go through with the adoption, but Lois disagreed for two reasons.
- 8:15The first was she was concerned that it would discourage agencies and whatnot for
- 8:20future adoption, exactly for future adoptions. And her second reason was she decided
- 8:26to make Dennis her little project. She was going to make him conform.
- 8:30Plus, it would look bad if she was taking in a kid and then
- 8:33giving him having a failed adoption. She was just gonna make him into the
- 8:39perfect child, like just like Robert. As a result, the adoption went,
- 8:45I had is planned and Dennis was delivered to his new home in December
- 8:50nineteen sixty two, when he was fourteen months old. He didn't know it
- 8:52at the time, but he was being introduced to the family that would end
- 8:56up being responsible for his terrible and faithful demise. It only took a couple
- 9:01of months after moving into the Jurgen's home before Dennis had to be rushed to
- 9:05the hospital for first and second degree burns on his lower abdomen, genitalia,
- 9:11and buttocks. Even though the hospital visit was reported, Lois had somehow managed
- 9:16to convince the doctors that this was just an accident. She blamed the incident
- 9:20on Dennis. She claimed that while she was washing him in the scene,
- 9:24he had turned on the hot water while she left the room only momentarily,
- 9:30and by some fucked up miracle, they actually believed her, like really sixty
- 9:35two, yeah, I know. Somehow, the incident was officially deemed accidental
- 9:39and the world went on per usual. This was just the beginning of what
- 9:45was going to be a most horrific two and a half year descent into pure
- 9:50hell. I know, it's bad. Unfortunately, the process of adopting Dennis
- 9:58was complete, so he was the Organ's son over time, Dennis went from
- 10:01being a free spirited and outgoing little boy to one who was quit withdrawn and
- 10:07beaten down. He was frequently seen with bruises which were the direct result of
- 10:11daily beatings delivered at the hands of Lois herself, like Harold doing during this
- 10:18Harold's doing jack shit just to let you know he was afraid of Lois too.
- 10:22So later family members would speak to how the little boy was forced to
- 10:26wear sunglasses in order to hide black eyes. Imagine a two year old being
- 10:31made to wear sunglasses. Yeah, mine would never wear them right or pull
- 10:35them off their face. Right. Robert had been taught to recite the Rosary
- 10:39at the age of two, and he did it with ease. But when
- 10:41Dennis struggled to achieve this feat, and he didn't do it so easily,
- 10:48he was forced to kneel on a broomstick handle for extended periods of time,
- 10:52leaving him in so much pain that he barely was able to stand. How
- 10:56I supposed to get a two year old to do the Rosary? I know,
- 10:58dude, I don't even know of the Rosary. I do, but
- 11:01I mean, at two, I'm just hoping they don't poop their pants right
- 11:05exactly like, come on, well, Robert could do it. In her
- 11:11effort to make Dennis right in her eyes, Lois embarked on a series of
- 11:16sadistic and corporal punishments. She never made a single excuse for her mistreatment of
- 11:22him. If anything, she seemed proud of it, claiming she was doing
- 11:24God's work and making him perfect in the eyes of the Lord. When Dennis
- 11:30would wet is diaper or wet is bad, Lois's remedy was to place a
- 11:33spring action clothes pin upon the head of his penis all right, Tanya.
- 11:41If he couldn't go to the bathroom, he'd be chained to a drain pipe
- 11:45near the toilet until he could force a bow movement. Often, Dennis was
- 11:50force fed and made to swallow spicy foods. If he threw up during this
- 11:56cruel treatment, he'd be forced to eat his own vomit. Fucking hate people,
- 12:00I hate people. Lois obsessed about Dennis's weight, claiming he was too
- 12:07big, but according to his medical records at the time of adoption, doctors
- 12:11noted he was the appropriate weight for a child of his age, and bill
- 12:15it didn't matter. Though he was frequently starved to rid him of quote unquote
- 12:20sloppy fat, as Lois called it. She even used the name sloppy fat
- 12:24as a nickname due to the frequent amount of starvation he endured. Dennis gained
- 12:31only three pounds during the entire two and a half year period as he aged
- 12:37from one year old to three and a half years old. This has to
- 12:41be messing up Robert too, right, I mean Robert's there. When Dennis
- 12:46was permitted to eat, he would sometimes reject certain foods, just as any
- 12:50normal child. My kids reject all the food back and cheese and ramanules and
- 12:56chicken nuggets. Right. However, when this happened, it piste Lois off
- 13:01to high hell, and she responded by placing horse radish on the food and
- 13:05then force feeding it to him. According to reports from family members who would
- 13:09later testify at trial, one told the story of a time when Dennis turned
- 13:15purple from being force fed a bitter and spicy horse radish whatever and then having
- 13:20his oxygen supply cut off as Lois covered his mouth and nose. This treatment,
- 13:24coupled with the exertion as he struggled, made it Dennis sick to the
- 13:30point of vomiting. Obviously, this enraged her and you know what she did.
- 13:35I don't have to read, don't have to repeat it. All the
- 13:37reports claimed Lois would often strike Dennis with her hands, pull and lift him
- 13:41up by the ears, whip him with a belt or a cedar board,
- 13:45and frequently kept him tied to his crib. So, as you mentioned,
- 13:50what was Harold doing? Yeah? Where he was there? And I wondered
- 13:56about it while I was reading the story, like did he intervene? But
- 14:00no, The truth was Harold was intimidated by Lois. He was scared of
- 14:05her. Lois was an extremely disturbed woman who was prone to fly off the
- 14:11handle at the slightest annoyance, and Harold, just like the children, was
- 14:13whipped into submission. Well, okay, but he's a grown man. He
- 14:18did nothing to help curb the abuse. But he did note that he personally
- 14:22never mistreated Dennis. Okay, just allowed it, just allowed it. Certain
- 14:28neighbors and family members knew there were problems with Lois's treatment of Dennis, but
- 14:31they also did nothing to prevent it. They attempted to mind their own business
- 14:37and feared retribution from Lois, who wasn't above threatening them of their own lives,
- 14:43like threatening their lives. Yeah, Lois had quite the reputation amongst those
- 14:48of newer which was that she was an intense, angry woman with a very
- 14:52short and volatile temper. Clearly, in other words, you didn't want to
- 14:56get in her way when she was on a mission to rage. And whatever
- 14:58the reason was, Dennis's arrival in her home provoked sadistic rages that she would
- 15:03unleash on him. She was literally obsessed with abusing him, and she went
- 15:09out of her way to make sure he knew he was the bad child and
- 15:13Robert was the good child. Then one fateful day, Lois took her abuse
- 15:20a little too far. Oh boy, here it comes, here it comes.
- 15:22On the night of April tenth, nineteen sixty five, a great flood
- 15:28hit the Saint Paul area, with the Mississippi River waters rising to record levels
- 15:33and eventually bursting its banks, causing widespread destruction in the region. Places of
- 15:39businesses and homes were flooding rapidly, and the Jurgen's home was, unfortunately one
- 15:43of them. The water soon poured into the home and just flooded the basement.
- 15:50Lue stood by and watched as the elements started to destroy this home that
- 15:54she worked so hard to make perfect. The very thing that she was most
- 16:00proud of was being wiped away right in front of her eyes, and there
- 16:03was nothing she could do to stop it. So this sent her into a
- 16:07crazy fit of rage. And as always, it was Dennis who bore the
- 16:11brunt of her anger. The three year old was punched, slapped, and
- 16:17slammed against the walls. He would try to make this less sad. I
- 16:21know, I know. He was throttled, thrown down the stairs into the
- 16:25flooded basement, and then hurled back up again by his arm. Lois was
- 16:30on a rage rampage. In the early morning hours of the following day,
- 16:34April eleventh, which was Palm Sunday. Dennis's frail body couldn't take an ounce
- 16:40more of the punishment, and he tragically died. Harold and Lois told authorities
- 16:44pretty much the same story. Dennis had been suffering from a bad cold the
- 16:48morning before Saturday. He had slipped on the basement floor near the bathroom,
- 16:53damp from flooding all of that great stuff, and he struck his head on
- 16:56the tile. At nine am Sunday morning, Lois went into Dennis's bedroom,
- 17:02only to find him gasping for breath and gurgling. They said they immediately dialed
- 17:07the doctor and the police. However, by the time they called it was
- 17:11nine thirty and the police got their ten Dennis had already passed. Once brought
- 17:15to the morgue, Dennis was undressed and stripped of a pair of pajamas,
- 17:19an undershirt, rubber pants, and two diapers. I'm thinking they're the cloth
- 17:23diapers. Got those rubber pants in the arm and Facial bruises continued across virtually
- 17:30all of Dennis's body, radiating in every direction, varying from the size of
- 17:34a dime to a half dollar. During the autopsy, the pathologists counted from
- 17:41fifty to one hundred bruises running the length of Dennis's body. The exact number
- 17:47was hard to judge because so many of them overlapped. They were varied in
- 17:49color, so some were fresh, some were black and blue yellow. The
- 17:55various stages of bruising. They covered his legs, arms, hands, the
- 18:00front and back of his head, his shoulders, his buttocks, the small
- 18:04of his back, the middle of his back, everywhere there was I don't
- 18:07think there was a spot on this poor baby that didn't have a bruise.
- 18:11There was also a large, swollen abrasion on his forehead. There was a
- 18:17bluish mark on the right side of his head that started at the temple and
- 18:21extended to behind his right ear. There was also a deep ulcerous lesion on
- 18:26the base of his penis and dark bruises on the tip, which looked a
- 18:30lot like a human bite. I'm sorry. The coroner noted in his report
- 18:37that Dennis had almost zero subcutaneous fat, which put him at the level of
- 18:42a person who had died of starvation. Subcutaneous fat is the kind of fat
- 18:47that we call baby fat, and you can pinch I get a lot of
- 18:52that. It lies just below the first two layers of your skin. None
- 18:56of this, however, was what killed Dennis. During the intern autopsy,
- 19:00a quarter inch perforation in the boy's small bowl was found. The whole had
- 19:06allowed a fifth of a quart of infectious fecal matter to flow into his abdominal
- 19:12cavity. It was judged that the perforation had occurred one to two days before
- 19:18his death. During that time, the abdominal cavity's surface tissue normally shiny had
- 19:25turned all and the pus filled matter had solidified come on, man forming adhesions
- 19:33matting together pieces of the bowl, which were classic symptoms of period tonitis,
- 19:38which is a redness and swelling inflammation of the lining of your belly or abdomen.
- 19:44Dennis most likely had died after an extended period of agonizing pain and needlessly,
- 19:49as this could have been treated. At the time, it wasn't known
- 19:53specifically what caused the fatal blow, though the injury was later found to have
- 19:57been beyond a reasonable doubt inflicted by Lois and the evidence of her constant physical
- 20:03abuse. While there was some form of an investigation, it wasn't much.
- 20:08The case definitely didn't receive the attention it's so rightfully deserved when it came down
- 20:14to it, this was a different time. The society and law enforcement of
- 20:18the mid sixties didn't accept the concept that a child in a middle class home
- 20:22could be the target of abuse. It was simply something that just didn't happen.
- 20:29That being said, it would have been difficult at the time to prove
- 20:32that Lois had committed murder. I know, it's just it's crazy souls.
- 20:37In spite of extensive physical evidence pointing towards severe abuse. The medical examiner didn't
- 20:42classify the death under any of the standard classifications of accident, suicide, or
- 20:48murder. He simply marked it deferred. Okay, deferred. That's like,
- 20:55I don't want to say that's what. That's what. That's Yeah, well,
- 20:59we'll tell you later. There was also a great deal's suspicion surrounding Jerome
- 21:03Zuris, who was the brother of Lois Jurians. He was a police lieutenant
- 21:08in the town of White Bear Lake. Actually he was the number two of
- 21:12this case. Oh so he investigated. There was a common belief among witnesses,
- 21:18neighbors, and the investigators who eventually reopened the case that Jerome interfered with
- 21:23the investigation and destroyed incriminating evidence. Whether this was true or not, Lois
- 21:30managed to escape the brunt of any criminal charges. Instead, she would be
- 21:37faced with the authority's decision to remove Robert from her kids. That is punishment
- 21:41for her. Yeah, and he was placed in the custody of his paternal
- 21:45grandmother. As you just said, it drove her nuts. Robert would remain
- 21:52out of her grasp for five long years. During this time, the Jurgens
- 21:56spent a small fortune trying to regain custom through the courts. When that failed,
- 22:02Lois started spewing threats of arson. Whether these threats were held in any
- 22:07real weight isn't completely certain to the paternal grandparents, Is that who she threatening
- 22:11arson too? Yeah? Yeah? And one thing that did happen though,
- 22:15Robert's grandmother would end up dying in a house fire in nineteen seventy while Robert
- 22:21was in the hospital recovering from about of pneumonia. So coincidented coincidents, I
- 22:27think not for this reason, Robert, who was now ten, was returned
- 22:33to the monsters lair. I believe the only reason this was allowed to happen
- 22:37was because the Jurgens had hired a new lawyer who happened to be good friends
- 22:41with the judge who presided over the juvenile court custody hearing. Not to mention,
- 22:45the couple had finally agreed to be examined by a county appointed psychiatrist.
- 22:51A Ramsay County social worker her name was Marion Dinah. Nord later told police
- 22:56she had strongly opposed Robert's return. Certain Dennis had been killed, but she
- 23:02said she had been discouraged by her supervisors and the prosecutor from probing into the
- 23:07past. She totally. She was left with the impression that she wasn't to
- 23:11get involved in why Robert was taken in the first place. She was only
- 23:15to study the question of whether it was okay to return him now, really,
- 23:19really, really, because that sounds like a great idea. Come on,
- 23:25it's so ridiculous, I know. In the end, the doctors who
- 23:26checked out Lois both decided she was okay. Prosecutor in the welfare department were
- 23:33no longer opposed to Robert's return. Two years later, in nineteen seventy two,
- 23:37Robert was joined by four more school aged children, three brothers and a
- 23:42sister from Kentucky. They joined the home. Are you kidding me? You're
- 23:48what? No? I know. The state of Kentucky wanted to get these
- 23:52four children off of welfare and keep them together, and placed them in a
- 23:56Catholic home. The Jurgen's annual salary was now sixty thousand dollars a year.
- 24:00I think that's really good money for nineteen seventy two. So they hired a
- 24:04lawyer to press their case once more. Some of the social workers objected to
- 24:10the adoption, but they were again shut down by their superiors. Lois had
- 24:15gotten a glowing reference from her pastor father, Bernard Riser, and that seemed
- 24:19to be all she needed to set things in motion. So the children were
- 24:22delivered to their new home and introduced to their new evil stepmother will not quite
- 24:27a stepmother, but it sounded adopted mom. By this point, Lois's rage
- 24:33in Mania had gone beyond her ability to maintain an appearance of normalcy, and
- 24:37people were talking. It didn't take long for them to relocate to rule Stillwater,
- 24:42Minnesota, possibly in an effort to escape the gossip of their former neighborhood
- 24:48where Dennis was killed. Despite this, Lois pretty much picked up where she
- 24:52left off with Dennis, and she began dolling out savage beatings on the regular.
- 24:59Moreover, she had not lost her active imagination when it came to dreaming
- 25:02up the cruelest of punishments. One time, she grabbed one of the boys
- 25:06by his ears and slammed his forehead into a nail protruding from the wahop stop
- 25:11it I know. Another time, one of the kids was made to stand
- 25:15barefoot in the snow. On another occasion, and this is just fucked up.
- 25:19I don't want to say. Yeah. Lois rubbed a used sanitary napkin
- 25:25in one of the children's faces, like really, like I can't like disgusting,
- 25:30Like why would she do that? Lois awaked them in the middle of
- 25:33the night to inspect their rooms, beating them if she found dust or hangers
- 25:37crossed in the closet. Reminds me of mommy, dear. I was just
- 25:41gonna say that it reminded me a little bit of mommy, dearist Lois's bedroom
- 25:45door squeaked loudly when she opened it, and when they heard that noise,
- 25:48the children couldn't help but be consumed by fear. Coming home from school on
- 25:53the bus, they could see the Jurgens's driveway from a distance, like from
- 25:59the top of a hill, and if Lois's gold Buck Skylark was parked there,
- 26:03they would just be terrified to go home. And before I tell you
- 26:07more, we're going to take a break. Sometimes Lois would order Harold to
- 26:36beat the children. I thought he didn't do that. Well, he didn't.
- 26:38He would take them into the basement and tell them to cry loudly while
- 26:41he slapped his own leg During this period, Lois was once again placed in
- 26:45a psychiatric facility. Eventually, the four children couldn't take it any longer because
- 26:51Robert never got an either. He still didn't get any he still didn't get
- 26:53eye. They couldn't take it any longer, and they decided to run away,
- 26:57and they took Robert with that. They escaped the home and ended up
- 27:02getting help from concerned neighbors, who then got the police involved. Since the
- 27:07four Kentucky children were older, they were able to vividly recount two authorities the
- 27:12daily abuse that they suffered from at the hands of their foster mother. Adopted
- 27:18them, No, she didn't adapt them. They told their sad tale about
- 27:22their impossible living situation, coupled with their own version of a dictator who ran
- 27:27it. Their former foster mother and Kentucky visited them after they fled the Jurgenses
- 27:33home, and she was horrified. The children she had known as loving,
- 27:37affectionate, and happy were now distrustful and disoriented. One of the boys later
- 27:42would spend hours on a psychiatrist's couch trying to black out the pain. Afterward,
- 27:48the decision was quickly made by authorities to remove the children from Kentucky,
- 27:52but Robert was left to stay with Lois and Harold. Additionally, could that
- 27:59makes sense? I know? Additionally, Lewis and Harold were to never again
- 28:03be allowed to adopt or even foster children. Lewis of course lost her goddamn
- 28:08mine and raged against this to make sure that happened a while ago. Yeah,
- 28:14she threatened to take the matters to court, but Harold wisely persuaded her
- 28:18against this course of action. He didn't want to attract any more unnecessary attention.
- 28:23Where would it lead. Right, So, at this point, Lois
- 28:26had pretty much gotten off scot free with not only countless acts of cruelty against
- 28:30children, but also the horrendous murder of poor three year old Dennis. Lucky
- 28:37for us, karma was about to catch up with Lois armas a bitch yep,
- 28:41it doesn't forgive, and there was a little bit of justice served.
- 28:45Do you remember I told you about Dennis's birth mom, Jerry. Yes,
- 28:49Well, at this point in the story, it's now the early nineteen eighties,
- 28:53and Jerry wasn't a clueless teenager anymore, but a grown woman in her
- 28:56late thirties who had since married Dennis, his biological father, and had four
- 29:02more children by him, you know. But of course she never forgot about
- 29:07her firstborn. She assumed he would be a young adult by now, and
- 29:12she wondered if he might like to get to know her and his younger siblings.
- 29:17So Jerry began making inquiries. She had called the Ramsey County Welfare Department
- 29:22trying to trace the whereabouts of her son. Six weeks later they had responded
- 29:26by letter, and that was how Jerry would make the heartbreaking discovery that Dennis
- 29:30had passed. Oh man, I know. All it said was quote,
- 29:34sorry to inform you that Dennis Craig died April eleventh, nineteen sixty five,
- 29:40of paria tenitas, sincerely, and it came from that county. It came
- 29:45as a shock to her, after all, he was only three Titus.
- 29:52Jerry began making calls and doing a ton of research on Dennis and what could
- 29:56have possibly happened to her precious baby boy. She just belt in her bones
- 30:00that something awful happened to him and she needed to know. From the yellowing
- 30:04newspaper notice of his death that she found during her search, she learned that
- 30:08the boy's body bore multiple injuries and bruises. From the death certificate, she
- 30:14learned that while Donnis had died of periatonitis due to a ruptured bowl, the
- 30:19coroner had never ruled whether the death was an accident, homicide, or natural
- 30:25causes. They just buried him and that was it. Jerry had somehow managed
- 30:30to get a telephone number for Lois Jergins, so she called her. Oh
- 30:33shit, right. While they were talking, Lois acted taken aback at the
- 30:37fact that no one ever informed a Jerry of the boy's death. She appeared
- 30:42very compassionate as she told tales of happy, healthy, cute Dennis. Lois
- 30:48was kind, polite, and even promised to send Jerry some mementos of Dennis's.
- 30:53However, the keepsakes never arrived, and when Jerry made a follow up
- 30:56call to the Jergins residence, she discuss heard that Lois had since switched to
- 31:02an unlisted phone number. Obviously, this immediately perked her suspicion, Right,
- 31:08you know, I'd be like m that seems a little weird. So Jerry
- 31:11took it upon herself and did her due diligence. With Dennis's death certificates still
- 31:17classified as deferred, the case was technically still open. This factor, grouped
- 31:22together with the lack of a statute of limitations for a murder charge, she
- 31:27pretty much paved the way toward the prosecution of Lois. Right then, she
- 31:33decided she was going to take up this matter with the White Bear Lake Police
- 31:37Department. She was convinced that her son had been beaten to death and demanded
- 31:41the case be reopened. She asked to see the police report, which read
- 31:45as follows quote. Dennis was lying on his back in the crib with his
- 31:49arms totly stretched alongside his body. The hands and forearms reaching upward lifted stiff
- 31:56eight inches off the mattress, bed covers pulled up mortis Yeah. Bed covers
- 32:00pulled up to below his armpits obscured the lower part of Dennis's body, but
- 32:06a good number of black and blue spots could still be seen all over the
- 32:09boy's face, head, in arms. There were at least a dozen bruises
- 32:13on the face alone, which ranged in size and shades of color. A
- 32:16big, harsh abrasion covered the center of his forehead. Dennis's nose was blood
- 32:22red and peeling, so red it looked like if you wiped it once the
- 32:25skin would pull away. It just didn't make sense to Jerry. There were
- 32:30also so many mishaps throughout the case as a whole. For starters, there
- 32:34were pieces of the case file that had gone missing, such as crime scene
- 32:37photos. That's where you were saying about the brother. Yeah, witness testimonies
- 32:43were missing, and there were reports of people coming forward to give their statement
- 32:46and then being threatened later because they didn't recount their birds man. Also,
- 32:52authority figures that had originally witnessed something amplified would later recount what they saw as
- 32:58nothing out of the ordinary. Oh no, it wasn't that big of a
- 33:00deal. Okay. There were a lot of pieces of the case. It
- 33:05seemed to be hush hushed or swiped under the rug without a second glance.
- 33:09No one wanted to get their hands dirty with something we as a society still
- 33:15didn't fully understand and definitely were not the least bit educated in children from middle
- 33:20class homes were just not routinely killed by their parents or by those who were
- 33:24supposed to have loved them the most. Jerry contacted the Medical Examiner's office in
- 33:30Ramsay County to see if she could get more information. Pathologists by the name
- 33:35of doctor Michael B. McGee met Jerry there. Doctor McGee found the autopsy
- 33:39report in Inside the file were pictures of Dennis as he appeared all those years
- 33:45ago, and doctor McGee wasn't prepared for what he saw. He said,
- 33:50quote that little boy laying on an autopsy table, completely nude, and he's
- 33:53just covered with bruises. His face is covered in them. He has a
- 33:58large bruise on his head, reason his abdomen is descended. I said,
- 34:02well, this is a homicide and we need to find out what happened.
- 34:07After seeing the pictures, it was decided that in order to find out what
- 34:12happened, Dennis would have to be exhumed. The body of Dennis Jurgens was
- 34:19dressed in a blue outfit with a long sleeved white shirt, and shockingly,
- 34:23his body was very well preserved, even though Dennis had been buried more than
- 34:28twenty years. At that point, doctor McGee wanted to find out his exact
- 34:31cause of death, and he worked hard until he found it. He didn't
- 34:36give up, and that's when he found out what killed him. And when
- 34:40he did, he was positive that it wasn't an accident, that he didn't
- 34:45pass away from an accident to teach use something ractali to him. No,
- 34:50thank god right, it was the period to nitis. That's why I thought
- 34:53it was something kid. He said that children do fall down and they get
- 35:00injured and they do hurt themselves. But the way that he was injured,
- 35:06there was no way it could be an accident. The force of his injuries
- 35:09just couldn't have happened just by him slipping and falling. So when Jerry found
- 35:15this out, she went to the local media with this information, and she
- 35:19wasn't going to stop until somebody really listened to her. On Sunday, October
- 35:22twelfth, the Saint Paul Pioneer Press ran a story on the investigation, praising
- 35:28Jerry for her tenacity and writing about the tragedy of her personal loss. As
- 35:34luck would have it, one of those who read the story was none other
- 35:37than Robert Robert Yeah, who as a five year old had been a witness
- 35:42to the murder. Now a twenty seven year old adult and police officer,
- 35:45he's a police officer, Robert decided it was time to come forward and tell
- 35:51what he knew. At his mother's trial, Robert recounted the events of that
- 35:55evening, including Lois's extensive beating of Dennis and his being thrown down the stairs
- 36:01by her. He said, quote, Dennis used to cry try to get
- 36:05away. Later on, Dennis didn't do as much crying, and he didn't
- 36:09do any running away. I would recall that he more or less submitted and
- 36:14would just kind of whimper and not get into that heavy crying. He gave
- 36:17up. Mmmm. I don't know exactly the reason why, but I cherished
- 36:22my mother. I did everything she said. I ate my food, I
- 36:24picked up my toys. I kept an eat and Dennis didn't, and as
- 36:29a result, Dennis received more traumatic rippermands. In the days preceding Dennis's death,
- 36:36he remembered Lois in the basement, dunking Dennis's head and a laundry tub
- 36:39full of water. She was holding his head there until Dennis was gasping and
- 36:45crying, trying to Breathe riding his tricycle in the basement. Soon after that,
- 36:50Robert remembered hearing several loud thuds, then seeing Dennis rolling very fast and
- 36:54landing hard at the base of the stairs on his stomach. Then his mother
- 36:59came down the stairs after him, hollering at Dennis picking him up, shaking
- 37:02him and hitting him. As for the night Dennis died, Robert remembered it
- 37:07well. He said, it was storming out, thundering and lightning. Remember
- 37:12the flood. Yeah, he was afraid to go to bed, but he
- 37:15did finally. The next thing he heard were screams coming from Dennis's room.
- 37:19The following morning, he said, quote, I remember waking up hearing loud
- 37:22screams. I went to Dennis's bedroom. I saw Lois picking Dennis up out
- 37:27of his crib. She kept yelling his name, Dennis, Dennis, Dennis.
- 37:30His arms were limp like a dish towel, and he was just swaggering
- 37:34his arms and his legs. Something was wrong and his head was moving back
- 37:37and forth uncontrollable due During the trial, when asked if he thought his mother
- 37:43was responsible for Dennis's death, Robert said yes. Doctor McGee testified also at
- 37:47the trial, and he went into detail about how hard he would have had
- 37:52to have fallen for it to injure him like it did. And I'm not
- 37:55going to describe it any further. Thank you, You're welcome. And nighteen
- 38:00eighty seven, Lois was convicted of third degree murder of third degree now,
- 38:06and she was sentenced to a maximum of twenty five years in prison. Okay.
- 38:10Unfortunately, she would serve only eight years of her sentence before she was
- 38:15released on good behavior and paroled in nineteen ninety five. It's just I'm just
- 38:21happy she got some time. She returned to Stillwater, Minnesota, where she
- 38:24lived with her husband, Harold until Harold Harold you son of a bitch,
- 38:30seriously, and Harold died in two thousand. At that time, Lois was
- 38:35initially suspected of poisoning him. Oh However, he was in failing health and
- 38:39his autopsy results didn't indicate poisoning, so there was really I wouldn't either.
- 38:45There was also talk years earlier of her having started the fire at her which
- 38:52killed her mother in law, and she really never got along with her mother
- 38:54in law, so people were like, m it would make sense. Lois
- 38:58would live for another thirteen year years. She died on May seventh, twenty
- 39:01thirteen, at the age of eighty seven. Wow. Until the end,
- 39:06she insisted she was innocent, of course, of all the accusations against her.
- 39:08I was a great mom. I was a great mom. I loved
- 39:12her. All those kids are just lying. Yeah, everybody's lying. During
- 39:15the years to follow, a much needed evolution unfolded in this country, the
- 39:19idea of child abuse. It was finally exposed and people do believe it now
- 39:23and it can happen to anybody. It wasn't until nineteen seventy five that Minnesota
- 39:28adopted legislation regarding the reporting and mail treatment of miners. In nineteen seventy one,
- 39:34the term battered child syndrome made its first appearance in a case that reached
- 39:37the Minnesota State Supreme Court. The investigation, trial, and conviction are considered
- 39:43landmarks in the history of child abuselaw. I didn't know that that concerning Lois
- 39:49And with that is my that's the end of my horrorfic story for a little
- 39:53Dennis. And you know, thanks for really putting me in a bad fucking
- 39:58I'm so sorry. I know this was just why even't I heard of this
- 40:02woman? But I'm kind of glad I didn't know about her. But you
- 40:05know what we should do to make it better? Review the review of the
- 40:08reviewer. Yes, that one that is necessary at this point. Okay,
- 40:14to Leah, are you going to read it to me? Read it to
- 40:16you? Do you want to hear the bad review or the good review first?
- 40:22I don't care. Okay, then I'm gonna start with the bad review.
- 40:24Oh great, just kick me when I'm down. So we received an
- 40:28email just yesterday from Kim and this is what Kim had to say. Okay,
- 40:35ladies, I used to really like your podcast but had to stop.
- 40:38You don't need to go into all the gory details to get the story across.
- 40:44The constant oh my god from Tanya is the most annoying thing ever?
- 40:49Can you say that from me? Oh my god? I think that's beautiful.
- 40:52God, I don't know. She can fuck off? All that comes
- 40:57across as a joke with no respect to the victims. Is that it?
- 41:00And that's it? Well, I'm gonna give her a one motherfucking star because
- 41:06I love it when you say, oh my god, what should you say?
- 41:08What should I say? And my reactions are genuine, Yeah you know
- 41:14what, she can fuck off? Yeah she can fuck off and good riddance.
- 41:17And how did you like us before? But not like us now?
- 41:21Because you've been saying, oh my god, I know since day one and
- 41:25we've been going into the gory details since day one. Exactly. I don't
- 41:30understand her email. Yeah, so I have not responded, but I plan
- 41:35to. I just haven't decided what we can just respond this way. Yeah
- 41:37that's true with ah fuck off. You get a one star. I wanted
- 41:43to be like, Okay, well then go listen to your crime tongue.
- 41:46She rated crime. Go for it. I'm sorry you don't appreciate. Oh
- 41:52my god, god, but that's what bothers her, not like what the
- 41:55fuck? Yeah that doesn't Yeah, exactly what the fuck is? This ship
- 41:59doesn't bother her, but the Oh my god. So in the future,
- 42:01I'm gonna come up with some more some different reactions. Okay, and you're
- 42:05gonna laugh every single fucking time because they're gonna be stupid. She gets a
- 42:10one star. What do you think? One star? One star for Kim.
- 42:15Thank you, Kim for input. We really appreciate it. Go fuck
- 42:19yourself. Fuck yourself. I love you so much. Yeah, go fuck
- 42:27yourself. Where gonna that come from? Okay? So this is the good
- 42:32review and it kind of is like similar topics. That's why it's I'm gonna
- 42:37laugh right. Okay, So this person is Randy Text and they just left
- 42:42this review this past Tuesday, it's a five star review. Love These Ladies
- 42:46one of my favorite podcasts. They keep it real and allow their own disgust
- 42:52for the criminal of the week. Normally I would rather hear the story without
- 42:57slant by the host, but the timing of reactions is and doesn't feel scripted.
- 43:00Keep up the great work. That's because it's not scripted. Yeah,
- 43:04exactly, it's definitely definitely not scripted. Yeah, not never scripted. Nope.
- 43:10So you gets five stars. Yeah, and it's funny because like one
- 43:15person likes that, one person doesn't. You can't make everybody happy, No,
- 43:19you can't barely make anybody happy. That's why there's just tons of other
- 43:22podcasts you can listen to if you don't like it. Yeah, you can
- 43:24go go listen to those fuck off but Randy, that was very very nice
- 43:31of you, very nice of you. Thank you not scripted like some of
- 43:36the podcasts I may have just mentioned two minutes ago, exactly. So if
- 43:42you haven't already, please hit the subscriber follow button on whatever app you're listening
- 43:46to us on. It really helps us out. Thank you for tuning in
- 43:49this week. If you love us so much that you want extra episodes and
- 43:53you haven't subscribed to Patreon or through our Apple channel, you should. You
- 43:59should because there's just as many Patreon episodes as there are public episodes public,
- 44:04so check them out sometimes more because there's minis. Yeah, so there's there's
- 44:07morning yeah. And you can get our public episodes am free and early.
- 44:14It's released early yeah, yeah, Fridays instead of Monday. You can find
- 44:17out information about that on our website Crimes and Consequences dot com, or go
- 44:22to patreon dot com slash t nt crimes. Oh my god, oh my
- 44:28god, oh my god, I'm my god, oh my god. That's
- 44:34what you gotta dona change it up a little bit. Then it's gonna see
- 44:37it sound ridiculous. We're gonna laugh and we're gonna be laughing about child abuse.
- 44:42No, that's not funny. No it's not funny. No it's not
- 44:44and my, oh my gods, are not funny. No. I'm like
- 44:46shocked, genuinely shocked. I told you I'm gonna come up with some new
- 44:50ones. All right, we'll make a list, so everybody pay attention next
- 44:52time, Tully. It tells a story. Yes, I can't wait.
- 44:57I can't wait to see her list. Be like I Corumba. I don't
- 45:00know what. I don't know. I don't know, he gads, I
- 45:04don't know what is that? Is that a word? Yes, it's a
- 45:07word. Is it English? Yeah? Heads, Corumba is not English,
- 45:12but I understand that. I'm not stupid. I know, but what is
- 45:15it? Gads? I don't know, he gads. I know it sounds
- 45:19ridiculous, right, Hannah. That sounds like some Canadians would say, Oh,
- 45:24I know, everyone, don't kill each other. Bye,