Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🚨Bubble Watch: Buffett Indicator above 224% ⚠️ Schiller PE above 40! Investor strategies 💪
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today, we're really taking a
- 0:03scalpel to the market, looking at a specific snapshot in time,
- 0:07October 31st, 2025. Yeah, it's a fascinating moment
- 0:11because the data, well, it throws up this kind of stark
- 0:14contradiction. Exactly so our mission today is
- 0:17to unpack 2 key dashboards for you.
- 0:19That's right. One looks at the short term
- 0:21stuff, sentiment, risk, that immediate market vibe, any other
- 0:25The other gets into the the big picture macro valuation,
- 0:30basically what price are we paying so we need.
- 0:31To figure out how things can feel so calm, almost quiet, when
- 0:35the underlying prices look historically well stretched.
- 0:39Precisely, it's about connecting those dots, low volatility beta
- 0:42day versus potentially dangerous price levels underneath.
- 0:46OK, let's start unpacking the immediate risk environment
- 0:49first. We've got these three
- 0:50indicators, right? Designed to flag immediate
- 0:53stress. Or you know, maybe too much
- 0:54excitement. Yep.
- 0:56And the picture they paint right now, it's remarkably benign
- 1:00calm. Really benign, Like no warnings
- 1:02at all. Not a single alert triggered
- 1:04across these three. If you only looked at these, you
- 1:06might think everything is just perfect Goldilocks.
- 1:08Kind of. OK.
- 1:09So what's the first one? How are individual investors
- 1:12feeling? So first up is the AAII bull
- 1:15bear spread measures, individual investor sentiment.
- 1:18It's sitting at -5.80%, so slightly more bears than bulls,
- 1:23but only just meaning. Meaning sentiment is pretty
- 1:27subdued. You know, it's definitely not
- 1:29euphoric. We're not seeing that kind of
- 1:31retail FOMO, the fear of missing out that often precedes a sharp
- 1:35drope. Right.
- 1:36So no wild retail party, but individuals can be a bit slow to
- 1:40react sometimes. What about the pros options
- 1:43market? It moves faster, doesn't it?
- 1:45It does. And that brings us to the equity
- 1:47put call ratio, currently reading around .69.
- 1:51OK, .69, what does that tell us puts versus calls?
- 1:53Right. It measures protection buying
- 1:55that's puts versus speculation. The calls below 1 suggests well
- 2:00a slight bullish lean. More calls being bought.
- 2:02They're not extreme. No, not at all.
- 2:04The danger zone where confidence gets maybe excessive is usually
- 2:07below .5. At .69 it's just moderate.
- 2:10No panic buying of puts. No crazy call buying either.
- 2:13OK. And the third piece, volatility,
- 2:16you often say stress shows up in bonds first.
- 2:19That's often true. So we look at the bond markets
- 2:21version of the VIX, the ICE, Spofa Move Index, fixed income
- 2:26volatility. And the reading there.
- 2:27Very low, about 76.66. 76 And why should say an equity
- 2:33investor care so much about bond Vol being low?
- 2:35Because a bond market is really the bedrock, you know when the
- 2:38move is this low, it tells you there's basically no significant
- 2:42stress in the core credit system.
- 2:44And the alert level for the movie is much higher.
- 2:46Oh yeah, much higher. We need to see it above 150 for
- 2:48a real red flag. So 76, That's quiet.
- 2:51The message from all three short term indicators is unanimous.
- 2:55No immediate fear. That's a disconnect then, isn't
- 2:57it? All these immediate fear gauges
- 2:58are green calm waters. But we know high prices
- 3:03historically don't usually coexist with 0 fear for long.
- 3:07So let's look underneath. Let's shift from that immediate
- 3:10feeling to the long term valuation.
- 3:11Exactly. Short term is noise, long term
- 3:15valuation. That's the signal.
- 3:16That's what really dictates your compensation over time.
- 3:19OK. Let's start with the big one,
- 3:20the the Buffett indicator, total market cap to GDP.
- 3:25How big is the market relative to the economy?
- 3:27And the readings here are frankly pretty startling.
- 3:31Depending on the exact model source you use, it's somewhere
- 3:33between 217% and maybe 223%. 270 to 223%.
- 3:38Wow. Yeah.
- 3:39And both our models immediately flag this.
- 3:42Level 1 says strongly overvalued, the other says
- 3:44significantly overvalued. So the market cap is more than
- 3:47double the country's annual economic output.
- 3:50That's what it means. Historically, anything over 200%
- 3:53has been a major warning sign. And just a quick note for
- 3:56listeners tracking this, if you want daily updates on this
- 3:58specific metric, we actually developed an app for that.
- 4:01It's called the Buffett Indicator App, available in the
- 4:04Apple App Store. It's pretty handy for keeping an
- 4:06eye on this stuff day-to-day. Yeah, that's useful context.
- 4:09Okay, so let's pair that really high Buffett indicator with the
- 4:13other big valuation measure, the Schiller KP.
- 4:16Right, the cyclically adjusted PE ratio, remind us why we look
- 4:20at that one, the smoothed out earnings version, why not just
- 4:23the current PE? Good question because current
- 4:25earnings jump around a lot, right?
- 4:27Business cycles, booms, busts. The KP smooths earnings over 10
- 4:32years. To get a sense of the underlying
- 4:34structural earnings power. Exactly, it gives you a truer
- 4:38picture less affected by short term noise and the current KP
- 4:42reading. It's hovering right around 40 to
- 4:4341, specifically 40.74 in our data. 40.74 That sounds
- 4:50incredibly high. What's the historical average
- 4:52for context? Well, the long run average, the
- 4:54mean is only about 17.3 and the median, the middle value, is
- 4:59even lower at 16.1. So we are more than double the
- 5:03historical norm right now. Way more than double.
- 5:05OK. So when we've seen CP this high
- 5:07before, I think 1929, maybe the.com bubble peak, are there
- 5:13structural reasons today why maybe this time is different or
- 5:17should we just default to history?
- 5:18Well, people always debate the different this time argument,
- 5:21you know, interest rates, tech dominance, stuff like that.
- 5:24But the historical data is just stark.
- 5:26So what's the big take away from having both these indicators so
- 5:29high? The combination is key, a
- 5:32Buffett indicator over 200% and AKP around 40.
- 5:36That puts current U.S. equity valuations squarely in the top
- 5:40top 10% of all historical readings.
- 5:42The top decile. And what usually happens next
- 5:44historically? Speaking historically, this
- 5:46combination has almost always preceded periods of much lower
- 5:50real returns for broad stock market indices over the next 5
- 5:53to 10 years and. When you say significantly
- 5:55lower, what does that mean practically for, you know, for
- 5:58our listeners, like flat returns or worse?
- 6:01It often means real returns. That's after inflation hovering
- 6:04near 0 or sometimes, yes, even outright negative over that 5 to
- 6:0710 year period. So you can't just rely on the
- 6:10index going up to make money. Not from these starting
- 6:12valuations, no. The high price itself becomes
- 6:15the biggest headwind you face, OK.
- 6:18So we've got this picture historically, price for trouble
- 6:21potentially, but acting day-to-day like everything's
- 6:24fine. Complacent maybe.
- 6:26What are the volatility metrics telling us about that
- 6:28complacency? Yeah, complacent is a good word.
- 6:30You can measure it directly. The VIX, the main equity
- 6:34volatility index. It's spot reading is only around
- 6:3617. 17 is pretty low right? Typical calm market reading.
- 6:39Very typical and pair that with credit spreads, we look at the
- 6:42high yield spread, the IC, BofA, OAS index, junk bond risk
- 6:47premium essentially. And that's low too.
- 6:49Very low, around 2.8%. So investors are demanding very
- 6:52little extra yield to hold risky corporate debt.
- 6:55So low Vics, tight credit spreads.
- 6:58What's a combined signal? The signal is a deeply
- 7:01complacent and benign regime, as the source material puts it.
- 7:05Investors are basically acting as if yeah, the Fed nailed the
- 7:08soft landing. No major risks on the horizon.
- 7:10But the source also warns this is, and I quote fine until they
- 7:15aren't. What usually breaks that kind of
- 7:18calm? What's the trigger historically?
- 7:21Often it's a sudden shock, usually related to credit or
- 7:24financial conditions. Maybe the Fed has to tighten
- 7:26unexpectedly, or some hidden credit problem blows up.
- 7:29Think commercial real estate or something else unforeseen.
- 7:32And because compensation is so low.
- 7:34Exactly because the risk premiums are so thin, any kind
- 7:37of hiccup, whether it's in earnings or liquidity, it just
- 7:40gets a magnified much faster. Right, that low compensation is
- 7:43crucial. Let's drill into that.
- 7:45The equity risk premium, the ERP.
- 7:48Are investors actually getting paid to take stock market risk
- 7:51compared to save bonds right now?
- 7:53This is maybe the most critical piece of the puzzle today,
- 7:56opportunity cost. So we look at ES and P500's
- 7:59forward PE ratio. It's high about 22.7 times.
- 8:02OK. And that implies an earnings
- 8:03yield of. Clip it over, you get an
- 8:05earnings yield of about 4.41%. That's the earnings you're
- 8:08getting relative to the price. 4.41% Now compare that to the
- 8:11risk free alternative, the 10 year Treasury. 10 year U.S.
- 8:14Treasury yield is currently around 4.08%.
- 8:18OK. So 4.41% earnings yield from
- 8:21stocks, 4.08% yield from safe Treasuries.
- 8:25The difference? That's the ERP.
- 8:26That's the ERP, the extra compensation for taking all the
- 8:29risk of owning stocks, and it's just 0.33%. 0.333 percent, 33
- 8:34basis points, yeah. Think about that.
- 8:36You get barely 1/3 of a percent more yield for taking on all the
- 8:40potential downside of equities versus locking in a government
- 8:43guaranteed return for 10 years. That is incredibly thin
- 8:46compensation. It's razor thin, especially at
- 8:49the broad index level. And the implication for you, the
- 8:52listener is pretty significant. Just buying the whole market,
- 8:56the index beta, it's not well compensated right now.
- 8:58Which really underscores the need for stock picking, finding
- 9:01specific value rather than just writing the index.
- 9:04Absolutely. It means you need to generate
- 9:06alpha, find specific opportunities because the market
- 9:08itself isn't offering much of A risk premium.
- 9:11It also means the index becomes more dependent on just a few big
- 9:13winners holding it up. Makes sense.
- 9:17OK, one last macro indicated before the playbook, the yield
- 9:19curve, specifically the 10 year -3 month spread, it's just
- 9:24barely positive now, right around plus .2% after being
- 9:28inverted for so long. Yeah, it's just crept back into
- 9:30positive territory. What does that very shallow
- 9:33positive slope tell us about the economy?
- 9:35Well, the fact that it's positive might suggest the worst
- 9:38recession fears are maybe fading.
- 9:40Supports that soft landing idea a bit.
- 9:42That it's very shallow. Extremely shallow.
- 9:44It's definitely not signaling strong accelerating growth
- 9:47ahead. So the message is still caution.
- 9:50You need to use conservative assumptions about the economy
- 9:53when you're valuing investors. You can't bet on a huge economic
- 9:57boom to bail out an expensive stock.
- 9:59OK. So we've arrived at this really
- 10:00interesting point, sky high valuations, paper thin risk
- 10:03premium, but zero current market stress.
- 10:07We definitely need a practical playbook for navigating this
- 10:10specific kind of weird environment.
- 10:11Absolutely. And the source material lays out
- 10:13four core strategies really derived directly from this
- 10:16conflict between the high price and the low current fear.
- 10:20OK. Strategy one, how do we deal
- 10:22with that super high KPE ratio? You have to demand clear cash
- 10:27economics because valuations are so high you simply cannot afford
- 10:30to buy stocks hoping their PE multiple will just keep going
- 10:33up. That game is risky now.
- 10:35So focus on the actual business. Exactly.
- 10:37Focus intensely on tangible things, real cash flows.
- 10:41The business generates what we call owner's earnings.
- 10:44Does a company have room to reinvest profitably?
- 10:46Does it have pricing power? Look for earnings yields that
- 10:49can grow on their own, not just because the market feels like
- 10:52paying more. OK, solid advice that leads
- 10:54logically to the second point, right?
- 10:57If index investing isn't offering much premium.
- 11:00Then you need to focus on idiosyncratic value.
- 11:03Hunt outside the mainstream indices, meaning look in less
- 11:07obvious places. Special Situations, maybe
- 11:09complex spin offs, good companies having temporary
- 11:11problems the market hates solid businesses aggressively buying
- 11:15back their own cheap stock. Find value that's specific to
- 11:18the company, not just riding the overall market wave.
- 11:21Find the niche opportunities. Got it.
- 11:23The third strategy is about discipline, which, let's be
- 11:26honest, can be tough when everything seems calm and maybe
- 11:29going up. It's the hardest block
- 11:31sometimes. Stay valuation disciplined
- 11:34because that ERP is so skinny. Like we said .33% and the
- 11:38starting KP is so high. Your margin of safety needs to
- 11:41be wider than usual. So be tougher in your analysis.
- 11:44Yes, you need to underwrite potential investments using
- 11:47higher discount rates. Demand a higher rate of return
- 11:50and assume lower terminal multiples.
- 11:52Don't bet on selling it for a super high PE years down the
- 11:55road. Basically building conservatism
- 11:57because the starting point is expensive.
- 11:59Precisely. It forces you to only buy things
- 12:02where the potential return looks really compelling, even with
- 12:04conservative assumptions. Makes sense.
- 12:06And finally #4 since low volatility seems to be enabling
- 12:10this whole situation, how do we use volatility as a tool?
- 12:14Use credit and volatility as risk dials.
- 12:18The key is not to chase the market now while it's
- 12:20complacent. Instead, prepare.
- 12:22Prepare how? Have your watch list ready.
- 12:24Identify great companies you'd love to own, but only at
- 12:27specific lower prices. Define your buy levels in
- 12:30advance. So you're ready when things
- 12:32change. Exactly.
- 12:33Because when, not if, complacency breaks, things can
- 12:36change fast. If that high yield spread
- 12:39suddenly widens to say, from 2.8% to 5%, or the VIX jumps
- 12:43from 17 towards 30, that's when opportunity appears.
- 12:47Those who are prepared with cash and a plan can act decisively.
- 12:51That's a really clear framework O wrapping this U the big lesson
- 12:55for you. The listener seems to be
- 12:56acknowledging this split personality of the market right
- 12:59now. On the one hand, total surface
- 13:01calm, low VIX, tight spreads, no short term alerts flashing.
- 13:05But underneath historically stretched valuations top to
- 13:08style readings for the Buffett Indicator and the Schiller KPE.
- 13:11Priced for perfection, essentially.
- 13:13And the price being paid for this calm is that skinny
- 13:15compensation? Yeah, that tiny .33% equity risk
- 13:18premium, it really highlights the complacency.
- 13:21High prices are being sustained by low fear for now.
- 13:24OK, so let's leave our listeners with a final thought to chew on.
- 13:27We saw the AAII sentiment data. It's only moderately optimistic,
- 13:31right? Bulls around 44%, bears 37%.
- 13:35It's definitely not extreme fear or panic, no.
- 13:38Not washed out at all. So the question is, what kind of
- 13:42shock would it actually take to break this current benign yet
- 13:45very expensive regime? What event, maybe geopolitical,
- 13:48maybe inflationary, maybe accredited, that we don't see
- 13:51yet? What would be big enough to
- 13:52truly shake this complacency? Right.
- 13:54What would push fear gauges like the VIX and credit spread
- 13:57significantly wider, creating those broad bargain
- 14:00opportunities that value investors?
- 14:02Wait for something. To think about what breaks the
- 14:04calm, we'll leave you with that question.