Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 221:5-9. Vows: Parameters of Benefit, Property, and Avoiding the Vow

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 221:5-9. Vows: Parameters of Benefit, Property, and Avoiding the Vow · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning, we are in some rich Khalfaalov adarim sifhe
• 0:07
  Reuven sha. Also Hana.
• 0:09
  Also Shimen Reuven made a nether again.
• 0:12
  Shimen Yoko Lishan Ivo bimita Cortana.
• 0:16
  He is allowed to go ahead and to sleep in the same bed if it's a
• 0:21
  small bed together because he makes them all hot and
• 0:25
  uncomfortable. There's no Hana over there and a
• 0:28
  little bit most of Shamim and not, but not in the winter Meshu
• 0:31
  Humahano because if it's cold, body heat helps make them feel
• 0:35
  better, make you know, it warms them up.
• 0:38
  So that's giving him Hana little big day, though, but in a large
• 0:42
  bed, most are if they're not lying right next to each other,
• 0:47
  then a little bit of heat. Maybe he's mostly for that.
• 0:49
  Whatever that's not considered Hana and therefore they can
• 0:53
  sleep together on the same on the same bed and he can take a
• 1:00
  bath in a large, you know, a large bath, you know, take a
• 1:05
  bath, a bath, you know, wash together in a large bath of a
• 1:08
  little bit Tana and Shiva Hana should make be all of a maim,
• 1:12
  but not in a small a small bath because because he helps raise
• 1:17
  the water level and it's easier for the guy to wash right now.
• 1:21
  We're not talking about a mikvah because number one, Mrs. Slava
• 1:24
  and is didn't know and #2 I guess maybe rising the water so
• 1:29
  you can be tabled better. Maybe it's easier.
• 1:31
  I don't know. But the light submits us all the
• 1:33
  Henderson there anything in the water is going to raise the
• 1:36
  level, right? No, but he is being he is doing
• 1:40
  that though. No, no, not not to the same.
• 1:45
  It's not nicker. A big one's a big is a swimming
• 1:48
  pool. I don't know whatever, it's not
• 1:50
  something nicker. I mean Zia emo.
• 1:52
  He could take a schvitz with him, right, He can he can even
• 1:58
  in a small well, here's how in the bath, you know, whatever
• 2:01
  that you know, we can in the sauna.
• 2:04
  I guess if it's a small sauna, I don't know.
• 2:05
  I don't know if it's I don't know if he's doing most of the
• 2:08
  IT could be the if you start, if he if he's if he's sweating, the
• 2:12
  the question is maybe it would add a little extra heat.
• 2:16
  But if he's passking that no, that's not the Zia is not the
• 2:20
  adding Hana invasive e-mail the Mita and he can if they're, you
• 2:27
  know, if he's in the same couch, like for eating and he can eat
• 2:32
  on the same table of a low Bakara ahas because but he can't
• 2:38
  eat. If there's one serving bowl, he
• 2:44
  can't, he can't he can't eat from it.
• 2:46
  I mean, we we don't it's not common for us now, but it used
• 2:49
  to be that it could be that people would just, you know, eat
• 2:54
  from the they had one big serving bowl and they take a
• 2:56
  spoon and eat from it a big plate, whatever, or they had a
• 3:02
  big plate. Everyone, just everyone just
• 3:03
  took everyone just took from the, you know, their portion
• 3:06
  from the thing. Because the problem is maybe the
• 3:12
  mother Hana would eat, would eat from this guy's Khelik in the
• 3:16
  beginning, Hana from his from his from his Khelik Veem Derek
• 3:23
  Shabalabais Khawiza. And if they're you know, the
• 3:28
  let's say you know, the waiter or the Balbais comes out and
• 3:30
  keeps on refilling the plate coma Shahiabo motor, anything
• 3:37
  inside the motor, because then it's not you know, it's not
• 3:40
  you're not like, OK, every you know, everyone has a specific
• 3:43
  calic. You know, it's like it's like,
• 3:45
  but we'll see my short film, right.
• 3:47
  But if if like he'll do a short film in it.
• 3:51
  And the question is, you know, when 1 is a person that is
• 3:54
  everything mixed together, you know, and the guy takes it out.
• 3:57
  They're like, it's bavar. This is my Calor, right Shiloh,
• 4:03
  you know Hoshimish brother, if a guy you know someone's house and
• 4:06
  you take he takes a Schnitzel, can he sell it?
• 4:08
  And he puts 4 bits in his mouth when he sell the Schnitzel or
• 4:11
  whatever one is to become his. But upon him he has a hey there.
• 4:14
  He has a hey like in the food on the plate, on the large plate
• 4:18
  and therefore maybe he'll take from his Kayla.
• 4:22
  But they keep on refilling it then not Hagar.
• 4:27
  Oh, Shahaim, it's already at the plate is very full and therefore
• 4:34
  we're not it's not going to run out.
• 4:36
  So therefore it's going to be Molter Eva use name Koiferin
• 4:41
  Bakarian Biajat. If both of them are are digging
• 4:44
  trenches irrigation whatever right in the Karen Biaja Loyako
• 4:48
  Bashura Pravello, he can't dig in the row right next.
• 4:52
  They can't dig in row adjacent rows.
• 4:55
  They should Mahanoy should Marapa Carpalifano, because if
• 4:58
  one guy's digging here, he might come to soften the the earth in
• 5:02
  front of the other guy and therefore they'll give him.
• 5:07
  But if it's further away, it's that's not a problem.
• 5:11
  But Loyim Carlo, you can't sell him anything or can you buy
• 5:16
  anything from him? Loyashi Leno, the loyal venue,
• 5:21
  he can't lend him, lend him something nor, you know, lend an
• 5:27
  object or lend the money. Well, you shovel, you know, nor
• 5:30
  can he borrow or, you know, borrow something or borrow money
• 5:34
  from him. The the Loyashi Leno is not a
• 5:39
  problem. Xavier, I'll do that.
• 5:41
  He's going to go ahead and borrow something from him.
• 5:43
  You know that That's the thing. Because maybe you'll go, oh, I'm
• 5:46
  not I'm not anybody come to make mistake.
• 5:49
  So therefore the humming word goes there an extra haka vav her
• 5:56
  mother Hana MI haviero ye Viejo meerkats someone who is mother
• 6:01
  Hana from someone they show you Meerkatsu Bassabad was storing
• 6:04
  the ear and he owns he owns something.
• 6:07
  He owns a bath house or Bassabad or or a store or a whatever,
• 6:16
  some sort of some sort of M&T or whatever something was.
• 6:20
  So the other guy could get hung off from imyesh lobahem srisis
• 6:24
  yad aser. So if he just if he just rents
• 6:28
  it out and he just gets serious. The one who made the netter
• 6:36
  against the other guy, the motor.
• 6:38
  Now the person who wants to go ahead and use this guy's bath
• 6:44
  house now, if he was, you know, you know, Reuven said that
• 6:49
  you're not getting Hana from me right to Shimon right now.
• 6:52
  Shimon want Ruben owns a bath house.
• 6:54
  So Shimon wants to use the bath house is a motor for him.
• 6:57
  So if it's, you know, if he's managing the bath house.
• 7:00
  So then of course, I thought that's also because he's getting
• 7:02
  Hana from this guy's the housing.
• 7:04
  But if it's rented out it, you know, renting out, but it's
• 7:07
  Memcarla, Yo, it's the people who are renting it.
• 7:09
  They it's they, you know, it's they're in their shows.
• 7:12
  So the question is that like you know, you said before, if he
• 7:15
  gives him a ton of and it's OK for the other guy to use it.
• 7:17
  What about skiers? If he pays, then no.
• 7:24
  If he pays, then. If he pays, then not.
• 7:27
  We'll see. We'll see in the like by the
• 7:28
  teaching and stuff. I mean, the the house before
• 7:49
  discussed with Lahim core. It depends if it's that it has
• 7:52
  to be that he's paying him cost price because if he gives it,
• 7:57
  you know, if they're both mother or whatever, that's, you know,
• 8:00
  thing. And but over here.
• 8:03
  So if the the the question is this guy getting hung off and
• 8:05
  it's the Hussain. So he said if he has treats, if
• 8:10
  he just, you know, pays if the, if the people who manage the
• 8:15
  manage the store, manage the base of America, pay the pay the
• 8:19
  rent to the owner and he and he gets rent.
• 8:21
  So then, then they then the kilos, kilos in there is just,
• 8:25
  and they own it. So it's much different to get Oh
• 8:27
  no. But if he gets, if they pay like
• 8:30
  property tax, they pay extra stuff to the to the owner or he
• 8:36
  gets like maybe something to do, like maybe he gets like free
• 8:39
  entrance. Maybe.
• 8:40
  I don't know if that that applies, but if he if he you
• 8:45
  know, if he get if he gets something, he gets a part a bit
• 8:48
  of the profit, things like that. So then then it's going to be
• 8:52
  also for Sherman to use this bathhouse, but otherwise it's
• 8:59
  motor in ain't low. Behan treats this Yamoto right
• 9:01
  if he hasn't used Yamoto. Also a lot of the favorites
• 9:05
  Khalista Gama love. If he says you're not using my
• 9:07
  my bathhouse either, then that's and then he can do that.
• 9:12
  He can do that and that and then it would be awesome.
• 9:14
  Would I equate today to somebody saying you can't have a help?
• 9:17
  From me and and. You could use a parking spot,
• 9:23
  well, a parking spot well, that we had before about the crossing
• 9:26
  his, you know, crossing his land or what?
• 9:29
  What? Going through his property.
• 9:30
  If you park in a spot that's using his property, you know, so
• 9:34
  with her. So yeah, that would be an issue.
• 9:37
  Zion Hamas get bison Haviero someone who rents rents out his
• 9:42
  house, the Afrika. He there has Saiker in the House
• 9:46
  of the saiker here means the massacre means the owner of the
• 9:49
  house. You know, tells the tells the
• 9:55
  the renter not you can't I mean bother you right now.
• 10:02
  The massacre, the rent the, you know, the owner landlord, you
• 10:07
  could say has shebud to give to to to go ahead and to, you know,
• 10:16
  supply this house to the to the site here.
• 10:19
  And just because he made a nether, he can't be mafia.
• 10:22
  The shebud. Let's say, you know, there's a
• 10:25
  whole discussion. Can you kick renter?
• 10:27
  Can you kick renters out? One can you kick renters out?
• 10:29
  It's not so simple, especially here in this country.
• 10:33
  It's not no, no, no, he can't. It's it's no, he can't because
• 10:42
  it's, no, it's because he has a shebut and there's times when he
• 10:45
  can't, like in the winter. There's different times he
• 10:47
  can't, he can't go ahead and kick them out here in this
• 10:50
  country. It's almost impossible for many
• 10:53
  stories of, of tenants don't pay and they can't and they won't
• 10:56
  let them kick them out for years for stories about that.
• 11:00
  So, so the so maybe he had an idea.
• 11:04
  Mother, I'm going to make another against this.
• 11:06
  This guy, he's got to leave, right?
• 11:09
  So it doesn't work because it's not mafia, the Shibu, the
• 11:12
  imperious about his preferors. But if he says this house, he
• 11:16
  ain't showing me that might work, then I call him another.
• 11:23
  There's a din. There's a din in an error that
• 11:25
  if someone's maktish to the base maktish house or land that is
• 11:31
  not Kia the Shibu. The question is, is a Konam is a
• 11:35
  nether which is, you know, hatfasa in Kadusha is that mafia
• 11:39
  Shiva? So you're showing it is
• 11:41
  Instagram. I love and he can kick the guy
• 11:43
  out. The you're showing him Shafili
• 11:47
  and Piyushova feyrish Anna yahala osva bilasan kainam.
• 11:51
  He can't he can't kick him out Belushi and kainam.
• 11:56
  So she just remained Tom in low Belushi and hectish Mamish
• 11:59
  unless he's mamish Mack tissue and this and Todd says nowadays
• 12:02
  doesn't apply to the zombies and Mikdash the heck the heck the
• 12:06
  Ned should stop is not going to go ahead and muskia and muskia
• 12:09
  the house. I don't know we have to get into
• 12:13
  that, but I'm saying people don't do that nowadays.
• 12:15
  People, people don't you know, it's it's it, it's I don't
• 12:20
  remember, but I guess if he damaged it, it could be, it
• 12:24
  would, but it's it's it could be whatever.
• 12:29
  It's not the I recommend it, but the general Hector should people
• 12:33
  say the Muktishit, some sort of, you know, fun stuff or whatever
• 12:37
  that the town says doesn't work? Can if he's renting the
• 12:44
  property, he can answer it on other people.
• 12:47
  He has the right to go ahead and to pay race of him because you
• 12:53
  know he's renting it and it's Hilo his payers and he can go
• 12:56
  ahead and answer it and and mother hand off from other
• 12:59
  people. Mamash gang and the and the and
• 13:03
  the someone who was we had in the in in in he was Rebus
• 13:08
  Mamashkanta that he he he he's he's has a lien on the property
• 13:13
  and he's using it or whatever. And you know, Dino can mask
• 13:17
  here. He didn't have a like a mask
• 13:18
  here. Baal Mashkuna Dino Kasaika and
• 13:21
  the and the owner of the owners stay again.
• 13:25
  The guy owes money to someone else, Baal Hove and they and he
• 13:29
  says, listen, I go I'm I'm going to make my property into into a
• 13:33
  mash gun and and the guy lets and lets the owner stay there.
• 13:37
  So in that case, the the mash game, even he doesn't own it,
• 13:41
  but he hasn't done a mask here. And the Baal Mashkuna, the guy
• 13:45
  who really owns the Carka, he has the dinner of a Saiker, Ha
• 13:50
  ha, Hamachi will buy some cover. Someone who lends his house out
• 13:53
  to someone else. And Yokola Osvarolov, Khuzvana
• 13:56
  Shayla, He can't be mad there enough.
• 13:58
  And the guy you know, the guy doesn't want to leave the house.
• 14:01
  He's squatty. I don't know makes makes makes
• 14:03
  another. If he you know, if you let him,
• 14:07
  if you let him, if you let him stay there, make her.
• 14:09
  He can't kick the guy. He can't after after the house
• 14:12
  like by skiers, Kosher came by Shayla because the Shayla is
• 14:15
  even more in his resource. I'll show you all the all story.
• 14:18
  I'll ask her calls on a Shayla to keep the kiddie day dummy.
• 14:22
  And also, like we said before that the show by cycle, the show
• 14:25
  can also can answer it on someone else, because it's while
• 14:29
  Shayla, it's Kilo, it's his, it's his, his, his property or
• 14:34
  so he's allowed to do that. Yes, I know you seen Tabla La
• 14:40
  Uman, the the marsh. Can't answer it.
• 14:44
  If you promised him a certain time, why can't he change his
• 14:49
  mind? Like which part is open if he
• 14:52
  never answer for? Him he can never answer for him.
• 14:55
  Listen, there's a there's a dim by Shayla that it says that if a
• 15:01
  person doesn't specify a time, then he then the guy doesn't
• 15:05
  have to give it back. But they get it's a surprising
• 15:11
  to him, but I have to get into the to get into.
• 15:15
  But I'll be dim if he doesn't. He doesn't specify a time.
• 15:20
  Technically the guy can just keep it for however long, you
• 15:24
  know, like I said, but there's a there is a there is a didn't
• 15:33
  like that. So that's what's referring to
• 15:35
  here. Also the close one that even if
• 15:38
  he does that at a time, right then then also he said you can
• 15:43
  borrow it for, for, for, you know, for for five days and he
• 15:47
  can't be mothered enough for those five days or whatever for
• 15:50
  Shabbos. That's a nice Intab of the Uman.
• 15:54
  The tire. He gave a canvas or something
• 15:57
  for the person to go ahead and to and to write on or to draw.
• 16:02
  So I paint on whatever make a picture, but also I'll buy law
• 16:05
  after Chitira. And then the guy the the painter
• 16:09
  is made, made a nether against the ball after he after he
• 16:14
  painted it. Koden Shapiro before, you know,
• 16:16
  before the guy paid him, after the guy paid him.
• 16:18
  There's something to talk about Muteris.
• 16:20
  It doesn't help for two reasons. 1 is a Mahogan.
• 16:23
  So Uman calling Bishwakhli. There's a discussion for Uman.
• 16:26
  If you give someone more, you know, raw materials to make into
• 16:30
  a let's say into a chair. So there's a Mahogan in the
• 16:32
  Gemara about whether the Uman can get some sort of king in in
• 16:39
  the object for building it. So according to the Manda Omar
• 16:44
  that Oman is in according to Shraklee.
• 16:46
  So of course he can't be mother and all.
• 16:48
  Even according to the Manda Omar Oman Koenen Bishwaklee by Seor,
• 16:54
  that's not considered doing anything.
• 16:56
  Painting is not is not Nekshav, it's Samani putting paint on is
• 17:02
  that's not Nekshav or dying something.
• 17:04
  That's not, that's not actual actually doing something.
• 17:10
  Paint, even paint even even even paint is napkins.
• 17:14
  Is is is considered aimbo Manish, even thick oil paint.
• 17:20
  Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's it's it's not, it's not
• 17:24
  considered anything. For example, the and Khoshimish
• 17:28
  brothers, a dinner. Someone, someone will come if
• 17:30
  your house needs painting and someone will come paint your
• 17:32
  house. It gets a complicated thing, but
• 17:34
  it's called your aid. You would have to come, you
• 17:37
  know, you would have to pay him certain amount of that.
• 17:41
  So so the Naseeva said Naseeva says that that you wouldn't that
• 17:47
  you wouldn't have to. He didn't actually do anything.
• 17:49
  The painting is not considered doing something based on this
• 17:52
  this idea. It's based on cameras that it
• 17:55
  it's considered an amble Manish. But obviously, if in a case
• 17:59
  where the Uman would do what even materials to make a chair,
• 18:03
  so then that could be he would that could be he would it would
• 18:08
  be in that situation the. Woman is not a biom while he's
• 18:14
  doing work, then he's a shower. He's a shower.
• 18:17
  The question is, it could be also he has some sort of, he
• 18:19
  also has some sort of Kenyon in it.
• 18:23
  Yeah, yeah, that's, that's my focus.
• 18:28
  So yeah, you know, on the whole of the same idea.
• 18:32
  It would be if I don't know with computers and stuff and I don't
• 18:36
  know the computer itself versus can answer.
• 18:39
  But programs and things is amble mommish.
• 18:41
  So he wouldn't be able to answer anything.
• 18:44
  I did graphics and whatever he wouldn't be able to answer it
• 18:48
  because that's also amble Mommish copyright is it doesn't
• 18:56
  give him give him owner. That doesn't give him make that
• 18:59
  doesn't that that's it's complicated, but it doesn't.
• 19:03
  There's this page, there's books about it's, but it's that
• 19:09
  doesn't that doesn't give him an ownership and the thing the guy
• 19:14
  pays him to go ahead and make a graphic for him.
• 19:16
  You know, he can't or whatever or program and things, whatever.
• 19:21
  That's not going to be common. Her mother, Hana MI Kaveri
• 19:26
  Yahalama de Lomar, the Hanveny Ploni mother Hanami.
• 19:31
  If any of the guy, you know, the guy's mother-in-law, he can't
• 19:35
  give an all to to, you know, to to to, you know, to this guy, to
• 19:40
  the other guy. The guy has no food.
• 19:42
  He wants to go ahead and give him stock or give him food.
• 19:44
  So what should he do? So he tells he can go to the
• 19:47
  company and say, listen, this guy, I'm mother Hun off of this
• 19:50
  guy, but I really want to help him out.
• 19:53
  You know how many recently the company can go ahead and give
• 20:01
  food to, you know, give food to this other guy?
• 20:05
  Because even though you tell me her mother and you can go ahead
• 20:08
  and take money from from the guy whose mother in years to her
• 20:13
  mother, the father, but only if the guy has an option.
• 20:18
  To pay the power he's not higher to power because if he was to
• 20:24
  pay, then it would be like A and they can't and doing is will be
• 20:30
  a problem right. It's a Remus the cane e-mail and
• 20:38
  the motor buy a sleep noise get a leak door saw the leaks or the
• 20:42
  guy the motor has has has to be built.
• 20:44
  The guys have money. You'll follow the plotting motor
• 20:48
  and not maybe any any of the Mrs. I want to help the guy out.
• 20:51
  I don't know what to do. Hey, you see me MO they can go
• 20:54
  ahead and understand the hint and and build or do whatever do
• 20:57
  the work. We'll buy that in scar me.
• 20:59
  I'm out there and they could go take take scar from the from the
• 21:02
  mother. And here's a matter of the bar.
• 21:04
  If the mother wants to pay. He moved to Leimar call Hassan
• 21:09
  Leploni or is he Moreno Masid or he can announce ensure he's a
• 21:14
  clap. Anyone who wants to support
• 21:16
  Cloney, he won't be massive right?
• 21:21
  He's not going to lose out. Why isn't that shikas?
• 21:24
  So one shot that the shock brings the pre show.
• 21:26
  Who says that? It's because it's a Barabian.
• 21:29
  He says a Barabian. So he's not he's not making a he
• 21:32
  can't do Shikas on a general announcement to the rabbit.
• 21:35
  That's not called Shikas. Also Lamar call Shamaya coyly
• 21:39
  yells. Employee yells from sea boy that
• 21:42
  he says anyone listens to me should go ahead and he's the Rob
• 21:45
  and he says hi have to support the guy and he does whatever.
• 21:51
  OK Also Laura La Caveiro tells him Ploni will taps it Also if
• 21:56
  he says to his friend that if you specifically if you if you
• 22:01
  support Paloni, he won't lose out.
• 22:03
  Yeah, even even though he doesn't make him a schliach, he
• 22:09
  looks like a schliach and it's going to be it's going to be
• 22:13
  awesome. Let me just do test.
• 22:15
  Test is fairly easy I'm Hulkim Medeira and if they're going on
• 22:20
  a journey to travel to England and the mother guy, the guy
• 22:24
  who's his mother from has nothing to eat noise in the
• 22:27
  after the shame atana but he gives it to the other person the
• 22:31
  shame atana and the other guy can take it from the third
• 22:34
  party. He may need more.
• 22:36
  Harry is no one else. When he called seller Ray, who
• 22:39
  moved for the coal, he just masquerade Mishi hold Mishi.
• 22:44
  It said hello Nita. The other guy will take it and
• 22:47
  eat. That's where I give it to
• 22:52
  someone else's in Matano about emailing the pseudo.
• 22:56
  Listen, I'm going to pay for your, you know, for your
• 23:00
  function, for your pseudo. The yellow Ploni shoe, also
• 23:04
  vanilla saying Ploni's going to come.
• 23:06
  You got to invite. He's going to come.
• 23:07
  You got to invite Ploni to come, but Sudha raised the ulcer.
• 23:12
  That is also because he makes it a Shreya.
• 23:14
  The oil. I feel nice enough.
• 23:16
  Stan, even he just gives it to him.
• 23:18
  Gives about Sudah because of her armor love.
• 23:20
  It's not because you have a plony, you know.
• 23:22
  You should invite Plony if he'll come.
• 23:26
  Eat with you if it's clear that the from the end of what he what
• 23:34
  he mentioned also no El Aminashi of aplony.
• 23:37
  The whole point of giving him some massive right, You know it
• 23:41
  gets very clear. You call also that it's going to
• 23:44
  be ulcer. He going to he's making a
• 23:47
  hostile big Sudha. But who writes a Shiva of if
• 23:50
  this guy wants his father to come a rabbi or or his rabbi if
• 23:56
  he hates him, shame a Suri behind the outside.
• 23:58
  If some reason mother they reminded him they're called Mr.
• 24:03
  Dosa. They couldn't eat from the Suda
• 24:05
  Sherry SU dosa, but haka solov she'll gomer the hack noise, but
• 24:09
  he can clear tip is that it was clear that the only reason he
• 24:12
  gave the guy he gave this other guy the Suda was because he
• 24:15
  wanted his father to come and and to eat by the by the Suda.
• 24:20
  That would be that would be awesome for Chavez.