Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 242:30-36. Honoring Rabbis: Overruling Rulings, Forgiving, Respect of the Student, Father Vs Rabbi, Denigration, Ruling Vested Interest

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 242:30-36. Honoring Rabbis: Overruling Rulings, Forgiving, Respect of the Student, Father Vs Rabbi, Denigration, Ruling Vested Interest · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning, we are in Sune Richmond bays safe in the
• 0:05
  Ramallah. In the middle of the Ramallah,
• 0:09
  it starts ha, ha, ha, ha. All Star in which which after
• 0:19
  something a different Rd. cannot matter it Ishiko Hadas from his
• 0:25
  own Chico Ladas. That's all.
• 0:28
  That's all, that's all. But if he has some sort of
• 0:35
  masayra, you know from his Robani that this is the tack.
• 0:41
  Yeah, that this, that what he did understood was a mistake or
• 0:47
  it's clear that he said the wrong thing.
• 0:51
  It's clear that he was talking about Varmishna, that there's a,
• 0:54
  you know, there's a clear Shahonara, you know, not even a
• 0:57
  password in the Mishna, but clear Shahonara, clear, you
• 1:02
  know, and say, you know, that everyone, which is such a thing
• 1:07
  that everyone goes by, there's no like no focus on it.
• 1:11
  You hold a hat here. He can go ahead and be Matt
• 1:14
  here. So the Ramon Baskins that it's
• 1:17
  clear that it that generally, if a person, a person asked for
• 1:25
  Shiloh and then he let's say he feels that now the Rabba
• 1:29
  austered it, but he feels that I don't know.
• 1:31
  He feels there's something the Rob didn't understand him or the
• 1:36
  Rob or he he knows a bit feels the rub was wrong, mistaken,
• 1:39
  whatever it was. He can go to a different rob and
• 1:41
  ask for Shiloh. There's no, there's no there's
• 1:43
  no problem with that. You know and says I say the
• 1:46
  Kharov, it doesn't mean you have to recover everything.
• 1:48
  He says, you know, whatever if a person you know where you did
• 1:54
  and if a person if a person feels and that you know that it
• 1:58
  was he asked her located in or something, he can go to a
• 2:02
  different roof that other roof can't.
• 2:07
  He can't be mad to it from Stan Shiko Ladakh.
• 2:11
  Well, he's some Ahmed Maple, not like that It has to be that
• 2:16
  there's that he has some sort of clear Masayra clear.
• 2:20
  You know something clear. So why he made a mistake of a
• 2:25
  filu in tab Ishiko Hadas and even if and on that the shock,
• 2:31
  the shock is holic and he holds that that appear only it's only
• 2:35
  told with varmish and not in some sort of cabala.
• 2:38
  The shock says he can only be mapped here if it's if it's
• 2:41
  clearly told with varmish now, not if it's just just what's it
• 2:47
  called a cabala because he says there are there are play scheme,
• 2:51
  there are there are. It's not because this is not
• 2:55
  because of of the DNA of cover of the first row.
• 2:59
  The second Rep has to give cover to the first row or it's not
• 3:01
  cover to go to a second row. It's mitam shavi khatikudi Surah
• 3:08
  that when the first Rev asers this the past and doser so then
• 3:15
  there's a police isser. It's like this idea of Shavi
• 3:18
  Anashi khatikudi Surah and a person, let's say a person
• 3:21
  himself feels that it's something is ulcer.
• 3:24
  So then it's we'd say it's Shavia nashe khati Khatis or
• 3:28
  whether it's a nether could be whether somebody showing say
• 3:32
  it's with Tom nether famous. So it's a Hoshan who says that
• 3:36
  it's because of, you know, a person has name on himself.
• 3:40
  He that he is a whole dust ball. They I'm not going to anything.
• 3:43
  All the wonders he holds that it's a it's an idea of a person
• 3:48
  who's just it's like an Amadeus. OK, you have to understand what
• 3:51
  he means. But Uncle Pani, Mr. Rav, Mr. Rav
• 3:57
  Paskins. So the ulcers.
• 3:59
  So then there is some sort of color is is there over here.
• 4:02
  So unless it's so you I thought the shots as well, unless it's a
• 4:06
  total of our Mishnah like you like to say by nether, you have
• 4:08
  to be ogre at me Cara. It's clear that he made a
• 4:10
  mistake. So then then it's not going to
• 4:13
  work where other other post game the shock.
• 4:19
  And he says that the acres like the Rama that if he has a clear
• 4:24
  Kabbalah, if he has a clear Kabbalah, that also is that also
• 4:30
  will be acre. Even even even if he's mandar
• 4:33
  should be Shavia Fatika the Surah, it's still going to be
• 4:36
  acre the the den and still that shall heal the first the first
• 4:40
  one made a mistake Philo in back to the Rama Philo in Tov Ishikul
• 4:45
  Hadas. Even if the first one made a
• 4:47
  mistake in Shikul Hadas Yahoo Lisa vilitae nima Moira
• 4:51
  Achyakzavoy the I mean the second rough could call it the
• 4:54
  first Rob and and you know, argue with him until until he's
• 5:00
  Kreiser the Hain Ain is Sir Leshoya Alisha Leshaney.
• 5:05
  There is no it's up here in cover the Rav Nokia.
• 5:10
  If if if if a Shilo want it will go to a second row and after
• 5:14
  Shiloh Ubil Vajji Odiya Ali, sorry Shikharaya Harisha Lancer
• 5:19
  as long as he's Modiya to the second row of that the first one
• 5:23
  was Moira Isser. Now again, yeah, let's get this
• 5:30
  takes the this, I think takes a little bit of it's be a little
• 5:33
  personal, be a little bit careful because fortunately
• 5:36
  things get a bit political. It can get political or cannot
• 5:40
  you know, you have to know like the like the mice in the in the
• 5:43
  Gemara by Warren Brothels, it says that the for Gomliel.
• 5:48
  Are you sure that this is shown by your high went and and went
• 5:51
  to Gomliel and said I think it was Mario, so don't remember
• 5:54
  exactly. And he said he he answered one
• 5:57
  way. So I'll be sure.
• 5:58
  So different and it caused the Homococcus.
• 6:00
  So first that has to be does have to be a little bit Nissar
• 6:06
  in this, but upon him, if you feel if he goes to a bigger of
• 6:10
  obviously, you know, he there's there's room to ask, you know,
• 6:14
  to ask the filo in Hita Hari showing, even if it's the
• 6:18
  opposite. Let's say the first one was Matt
• 6:20
  here Kvar Khala Hara also, and his Hara was Kao, meaning he
• 6:25
  said that the pots motor right, That's pots on trace the pots
• 6:29
  motor and he used the pot Amish any less or because Shiko Ladas
• 6:35
  the second one can't awesome because Shiko Ladas, we won't we
• 6:38
  don't just say, Oh, well, what's what's going to just be Makhmir?
• 6:41
  Well, it's it's very easy to be awesome, awesome, awesome,
• 6:43
  awesome. They don't do that.
• 6:45
  Even if it didn't like no, even finally he has said Mammon.
• 6:48
  He can't just he he can't just go ahead and and besides the
• 6:52
  head there because of Shiko Ladas that that you should I
• 6:55
  should be Makhmir. Well, we're calls about Isa
• 6:58
  Haira asthma, and this is all talking about this this high raw
• 7:02
  itself about the Maesa Akhar shiita Shiahala Hairais
• 7:08
  machinery love, but in some other, but in a slightly
• 7:11
  different Maesa, which is which is domer than obviously, the
• 7:14
  that second row can can be murdered however he wants.
• 7:18
  The shack does bring that the same person.
• 7:21
  Yeah, right, right. And they asked me this exact
• 7:26
  this exact Mesa, even though there's something that's exactly
• 7:29
  the same thing but different Mesa.
• 7:30
  Let's say it's exactly the same thing happened, but it's a
• 7:33
  separate Mesa. It's still OK for him to to ask
• 7:38
  the shock does point out if the if the first rub asked her not
• 7:41
  because of not because of actual dim, but because of a you know,
• 7:47
  home air or together that he he asked him as because of a some
• 7:52
  sort of gather. Then then he can't, you know,
• 7:56
  for this, for this guy or for this, you know, then the guy can
• 8:00
  then the other one shouldn't be matter, because that's not
• 8:02
  that's like that already is to be covered a personal thing, or
• 8:06
  it could be a Claudius thinking thing or something that he then
• 8:09
  he shouldn't. He shouldn't be matter.
• 8:11
  You know, like someone told someone told me a story that saw
• 8:17
  that he he knew a Robin that wasn't in New York or something.
• 8:20
  And and and I came to him and asked him said and said, do I
• 8:26
  you know, he's sitting here, Don't you just sit here on
• 8:27
  Chavez? And I said, yeah, you do.
• 8:31
  And and someone was there and said, oh, so he went to rotation
• 8:34
  and said, I understand. How could this Rob say it?
• 8:36
  Well, he should say Shiv on Chavez.
• 8:38
  Maybe he should say go back to him and ask that Rob don't ask
• 8:41
  me. So he asked him.
• 8:42
  He said, listen, I didn't tell this guy who said Shivan Chavez,
• 8:45
  he'd be, he'd be driving into work and and working.
• 8:49
  So I told him, said Shivan Chavez.
• 8:53
  So whatever you have to, sometimes you have to understand
• 8:56
  what's going on. I love the days I Rav I'll move
• 9:12
  out or one thing for any of his talmedium or the echo mayhem or
• 9:17
  for one of the talmedium because we say torrell so delay that his
• 9:22
  Torrell is his. He's allowed to be mithal on it.
• 9:26
  Mahal mitzvah Allah Talmud, the hydroid, and even though he's
• 9:34
  mithal is it it's still emits on the Talmud to do hit her right.
• 9:38
  So example, if he's mithal on chemo standing fall high, so
• 9:42
  then the he should still do hit her when the Ruff comes and
• 9:45
  passes by, they should still do so, you know, hit her also live,
• 9:49
  as they say, the Brussels Kochikane Kochikane kilo.
• 9:55
  That is also too embarrassing. And of course he he he might
• 9:58
  call his cover, but it doesn't mean that yet that he's he can
• 10:02
  be treated like a regular person.
• 10:03
  It just means you don't have to go ahead.
• 10:04
  And that's for standing and and he'll save and all these things.
• 10:10
  So us obviously also to him. Hello, I'm gimo he and the
• 10:22
  opposite is true as a mission and others like quote Tamitra
• 10:25
  should be hobby like show call the person a rebbe.
• 10:28
  Rob has to bahab his Talmud. He has to he has to bahab his
• 10:32
  Talmud. The yeah, unfortunately people
• 10:37
  sometimes I'm going to be stumbling all over.
• 10:40
  But the the the the piston tuber brings a public yard to ask them
• 10:43
  what about all the insults in the Gamora insults in the
• 10:47
  shining. You see that the, you know,
• 10:49
  calling, calling each other names this like, you know what,
• 10:53
  you don't have a brain. I'll just like, you know, look
• 10:56
  in the Mahamas, you know, they get the the bomb or yeah, very
• 11:00
  sharp, very whatever I think he was here said if it's with Tom
• 11:06
  Henno to make A to make a point, to make a that you want to make
• 11:10
  something clear. It's it's with Tom Henno.
• 11:13
  If you're allowed to go ahead and and do it.
• 11:14
  Obviously, if, if, if, if, if I don't remember if he sees his
• 11:19
  NIT car or something, yeah, then you shouldn't do that, you know,
• 11:23
  But Uncle Ponni, if it's to make a make a very sharp point, you
• 11:29
  know, and that's what it's sort of the minute, you know.
• 11:31
  But Caruso, they screaming at each other.
• 11:32
  Why, you know, you know, so you know, that's it's a it's a
• 11:37
  normal thing. The point is that they're that
• 11:38
  that they're getting to the Ms. not that he's just being Mevaz
• 11:41
  at him and you know, get out of here.
• 11:46
  Well, that's alright. They're learning and what kind
• 11:51
  of child is that? You know, it's fine, but there's
• 11:53
  time in the some on the street. Hey, bozo, you know it's not the
• 11:58
  it's not something that the there of.
• 12:00
  You know, unfortunately, there are cases of, you know, Ravana
• 12:02
  who will like pick names for this.
• 12:05
  Ravi is a pick name for the Tomita and it's not nice.
• 12:07
  Whatever Alphabanum llama Dalid Avedas Alvida Avedas rabbit.
• 12:16
  If their their father has an is an Aveda and Avedas rabbit and
• 12:20
  he can't get he can't get both of them, right.
• 12:24
  Let's say, you know, he can only get 1.
• 12:27
  So who should he get? Rabbuh Muvuk?
• 12:29
  Only Rabbi Muvuk Avedus Rabbuchodemis.
• 12:32
  The Aveda of his of of his rabbi is Titan the E if.
• 12:40
  Well, yeah, it's also if he if he could do both mine or if you
• 12:42
  can only do one. I mean, whatever.
• 12:44
  Yeah, it's the same. It's the same thing.
• 12:48
  Avedus Rabbuchodemis passions here is he can't do both, but
• 12:51
  the question if he could do both which is called them there it
• 12:55
  could be the robbers still call them Kodamas IEM Haya Aviv
• 12:59
  because it says that the father only brings him to Adam Hazer
• 13:03
  and the the the his ready brings him to Adam Haba.
• 13:07
  So therefore he has to bahawa him more.
• 13:08
  But IEM haya Aviv shuffle connected Rabbi.
• 13:12
  If the father is also Tamil chaham, you know, equals or
• 13:15
  equally an equal Tamil chaham, Aveda Sajid Kodemis, because
• 13:19
  then not only does he have to keep it up, but he also has
• 13:22
  covenant toya to his father, to his father.
• 13:26
  And therefore that's going to you know, that's going to trump
• 13:30
  the no pun intended Trump the the, the the the, the, the they
• 13:38
  see mostly if they're both carrying carrying things or from
• 13:41
  the donkey, whatever in the rabbi first he should help
• 13:45
  unload his rabbi's and then help unload his fathers.
• 13:51
  The rabbi only the base of Chevy if they both were captured.
• 13:55
  Play this rabbi first. Yes, before he was rabbi and
• 13:59
  after his father if his father's Podis Aviv.
• 14:07
  Yeah, Podis rabbi again, then he didn't then because he has two
• 14:11
  things then keep it, keep it out.
• 14:13
  And is is is is dated the cover around.
• 14:20
  So I don't know. I don't think I don't think so.
• 14:26
  See the Rambo even if there's a lesser tomahawkum, but by Pedia,
• 14:30
  he does not have to be shuffle. By Veda, he has to be shuffle.
• 14:33
  By Pedia, he does not have to be shuffle as long as there's as
• 14:37
  long as there's there's a tomahawkum.
• 14:46
  Let's actually the sukana also involved.
• 14:52
  Well, if you look at the remote one second I'll go became the
• 14:55
  Farik must oh, call him the rabbi, the alpha piece.
• 14:58
  You ain't no shock over Hawker rabbi.
• 15:01
  The remote adds in that that even if he he can also he's also
• 15:07
  Mpharik the masa before his rabbi, even though even though
• 15:11
  he's not Shaka but aim master call them ache shuffle to naked
• 15:16
  robbery that it seems that the only the only time that that
• 15:22
  only did in the SP shuffle is by a by a Veda that because the
• 15:33
  second is Gufa, the second is Gufa.
• 15:34
  I mean, the the harvest seems to be his holic on this, because
• 15:37
  the harvest is it puts puts a Bafaric Massao in the same
• 15:42
  category as a Veda, but by Pignon Schwer in the second of
• 15:45
  school. So there he he's already the the
• 15:48
  Ramallah heard puts in that he that could be, you know, there's
• 15:53
  only there's hefsid mammal, but hefsid mammal.
• 15:56
  Then there his rough comes first.
• 15:57
  Depends on what year what the Icker Dakota is.
• 16:01
  You show me how the rabble called him.
• 16:02
  The obvi Hindi should learn it in my between him.
• 16:06
  But this is only if there is Rebbe is learning between him
• 16:08
  with him about him. Obviously.
• 16:10
  Hello Rebbe. Rolando obvi called him the
• 16:12
  whole doba. He nearly Icker.
• 16:15
  However, if the father's paying tuition, then then then the
• 16:22
  father comes comes first. I don't I'm not.
• 16:29
  I don't know, I don't see why he would argue.
• 16:33
  There's no, there's no reason why he would argue on that.
• 16:35
  There's no clash over here. So even if somebody else is
• 16:39
  staying in the, the village. Ah, that's interesting.
• 16:42
  So yeah, OK, that it's it's oh, so that and then there's remote
• 16:51
  the safe exceeding. So, so that's the sort of the
• 16:54
  safe exceeding as well. You have to look it up for Tom,
• 16:57
  but you know that that if he's not doing it between him, I
• 17:04
  guess it's it's a lower amount. He doesn't he doesn't get the
• 17:06
  the shame rather move on. That's something to think about.
• 17:10
  Ahmed. Hey, Aveda also called him the
• 17:13
  show. All the official rabbi is Aveda
• 17:15
  comes before Alvi Vilshaw rabbi because we say that's only you
• 17:21
  know, it's it's we say by by his father early.
• 17:24
  We say, you know, parents, it's only me, Maman or whatever, not
• 17:28
  his own money. It's Rob also he's have to lose
• 17:30
  money to Mohave his his ready in the same way he's have to lose
• 17:35
  money LA evolve now Ivoro Amy Amy macabre in car in high.
• 17:42
  He's like a moisture. So I would never learn from you,
• 17:45
  even if you're like Moshe Raveno, even if you're a Moshe
• 17:49
  Raveno. I want to learn from you Malkin.
• 17:50
  So you shouldn't be Zion, Malcolm, because it's bizarre.
• 17:53
  What's the B Zion here? The B Zion is so the Bergolo
• 17:58
  explains that it's because of COVID, the Moshe Rabeno, but
• 18:01
  he's being evasive. He's been evasive because no one
• 18:03
  could be like Moshe Rabeno. So you say even if you're like
• 18:06
  Moshe Rabeno, but no low compromotions.
• 18:08
  And I get the puzzle. So therefore, so therefore it's
• 18:14
  Vivaza. He shouldn't it's Vivaza, Moshe
• 18:16
  Revenu anything. Orion is the Gamora which
• 18:19
  compares Amoris. Even if you were like you should
• 18:22
  have been known. Is that because it didn't the
• 18:25
  Gumora didn't say even like there's not going to be like
• 18:26
  mushroom. It shouldn't be none.
• 18:28
  OK, but you can't be like mushroom.
• 18:29
  It's a it's a bezoi Hagar Hagar. You know the time of Hokum
• 18:38
  shamar Dwahalaka, the dobra Hashaya for the day.
• 18:41
  Now what about the so Tom Hokum says says Allah was something
• 18:45
  which he's the gay of a dobra. So in amarcodim Maisa if he
• 18:51
  passed in the thing before Maisa happened, show me in love then
• 18:55
  well we can pass him. You say OK then the guy is that
• 18:59
  even though he's no gay or he can pass him.
• 19:01
  The in love ain't show me in law, but if it was after Maisa,
• 19:05
  then it could be he's trying to, you know, rationalize the Tirets
• 19:09
  to roots him as to why he did it and then whatever.
• 19:12
  And we shouldn't they shouldn't use that as a sock because he's
• 19:16
  not gave a daughter and it could be like his one, you know, maybe
• 19:19
  made a mistake, whatever. But Dafkasha Amar Kaki Balti,
• 19:23
  that's only if he said this is as a couple from Ira Bay and
• 19:27
  this is how you know whatever. So I understand well, but he
• 19:33
  says up Shah to Mara pony Ludvarov and he gives or brings
• 19:36
  her actual rise to it. Who Neera and and what he's
• 19:40
  saying makes sense. Show me low then even Akhar
• 19:42
  Maiser is show me low because we don't say his negi is, you know,
• 19:48
  ruin stuff. For example, like the Shah
• 19:50
  brings Mahila. I think the Shah says that a
• 19:53
  husband shouldn't pass in Vila shiles for his wife because he's
• 19:57
  very negative, though. I mean, it's a little bit
• 20:00
  different than this same idea. Of our ain't but however of our
• 20:03
  ain't show me in the day Dilma when we we shouldn't he
• 20:07
  shouldn't of our ain't show me in the day Dilma Madame Dorian
• 20:11
  Lahadi Shainam Dainim in who posture showing us.
• 20:15
  So what's this watching here is a bit is a bit right.
• 20:18
  And he said that if the if it's a if it's a meaning, the tales
• 20:22
  explained that if it's if it's Madame Milsa Lamilsa, if it's
• 20:27
  not just like straight riot, but if it he's making a he has to
• 20:30
  Madonna Milsul the Milsa and he has to make up sock and also
• 20:34
  like, you know, the sesh tickle terrorists.
• 20:37
  And then also we don't you know, we also the maybe we'll ask
• 20:40
  Arkham Isa. Maybe he's not.
• 20:42
  Maybe he like the Nagius is pushing him to say things, which
• 20:45
  are a little bit, you know, again, it's it's not it's it's
• 20:49
  not. It's asked me something which is
• 20:50
  pretty clear politically riots, not just, well, Mr. Burr says
• 20:59
  this and the ratio says this and this.
• 21:01
  In this case, it could be like this.
• 21:02
  And it would make sense that that doesn't work only if it's a
• 21:05
  clear if it's a clear riot.