Latest / The Film Hobbyist / My Mom Jayne (2025): An Exercise in Humanization
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in my attic room. Outside,
- 0:36the weather has turned cold, that bitter, bone
- 0:39-deep cold when the chill seems to seep through
- 0:42your clothes. Because the attic isn't very well
- 0:47insulated, we're not exactly out of the cold
- 0:50up here. But you have access to the granny square
- 0:54blanket if you need it, and in your hands is
- 0:57a mug of tea, just as much to warm you up as
- 1:01to give you a beverage to enjoy. Today we're
- 1:06going to be talking about a documentary, a first
- 1:09for us. Documentaries can be quite artful and
- 1:13important, but because they're not exactly as
- 1:16profitable as narrative filmmaking, they're often
- 1:19less available than other films, less likely
- 1:22to receive a theatrical release or one on physical
- 1:25media. The film we're talking about today got
- 1:29a small theatrical release in a couple of theaters
- 1:32before heading to HBO Max. It's the most expensive
- 1:36streaming service out there, and not everybody
- 1:40shells out for that sort of thing. But even though
- 1:43I know you probably haven't seen this film, and
- 1:47probably won't have access to it, I'd like to
- 1:50talk about it anyway. It impacted me quite a
- 1:53bit, more than I was expecting to. And that film
- 1:58is My Mom Jane, directed by Mariska Hargitay,
- 2:02released early this summer. The titular Jane
- 2:06is none other than Jane Mansfield, a 1950s Hollywood
- 2:10star, a blonde bombshell who was once known as
- 2:14the most photographed woman in America. If you
- 2:17haven't seen any of her films, the best way to
- 2:20describe her is a sort of knockoff Marilyn Monroe,
- 2:25known for her blonde hair, her big boobs, and
- 2:28her girlish voice. And I mean that about being
- 2:32a knockoff. She went up for a lot of the same
- 2:36roles and was often sought out if Marilyn passed
- 2:39on a movie. Her big breakout performance was
- 2:42on Broadway in a play called Will Success Spoil
- 2:46Rock Hunter, in which she played a Marilyn Monroe
- 2:49-type Hollywood star. Mansfield also reprised
- 2:54the role on film. And when Monroe's life got
- 2:58more complicated, Mansfield got more work. though
- 3:01she never had quite the same success or reputation
- 3:04as Marilyn. If you aren't familiar with Mansfield
- 3:09through her acting work, you're probably familiar
- 3:12with her other legacy, the Mansfield Bar, that
- 3:17metal bar that hangs down on the back of semi
- 3:19-trucks meant to keep cars from sliding under
- 3:22the wheels in the event of a rear -end collision.
- 3:27Because that's how Jane Mansfield died. It's
- 3:31a grisly story, the sort you'll hear repeated,
- 3:34almost as an urban legend, many of the details
- 3:37exaggerated. But it's part of how she's remembered,
- 3:41too. Not just a blonde bombshell, but a dead
- 3:46blonde bombshell. Mariska Hargitay was her youngest
- 3:52daughter. If that's not a name you recognize...
- 3:56That might be because it's not how you would
- 3:59pronounce it if you saw it written down. You
- 4:02might be more inclined to assume it was Mariska
- 4:06Hargerty or Mariska Haggerty. And if that sounds
- 4:10more familiar, it's because she's been the star
- 4:13of Law & Order SVU for 27 seasons. Law & Order
- 4:18is a television institution. I once watched an
- 4:22interview where a famous actor jokingly referred
- 4:25to it as acting school for how valuable it is
- 4:28for up -and -coming actors. Every couple of months,
- 4:32YouTube's algorithm recommends clips of some
- 4:35current star's early work, whether Timothee Chalamet
- 4:38or Elle Fanning or Pedro Pascal. SVU carries
- 4:43on that tradition of television comfort food.
- 4:47I've only watched a couple of episodes, and that
- 4:50was only because I turned on a hotel TV during
- 4:53a high school trip just to see what was on. But
- 4:56it's the kind of show that thrives on being on
- 4:59hotel TV. Something to watch when you're in between
- 5:02things. And for the last 27 years, Mariska Hargitay
- 5:07has been the face of that comfort food, TV institution.
- 5:12But inevitably... If you want trivia about who
- 5:16she is, her life, and career, the first fact
- 5:19you learn about her is that she's Jane Mansfield's
- 5:23daughter. The second is that she was in the car
- 5:27when her mom died. How do you reckon with that
- 5:32as a person? How do you process that to come
- 5:36to any semblance of understanding? And how do
- 5:40you present that reality to other people? Unfortunately,
- 5:46Jane Mansfield isn't really a person. She's an
- 5:52image, a thing. She's that picture of Sophia
- 5:56Loren staring at her cleavage at the Oscars with
- 5:59a mixture of jealousy and revulsion. She's a
- 6:03playboy spread. She's a girlish voice on a film
- 6:07screen. Or she's the horrified whisper of a decapitated
- 6:11head sitting on the hood of a car, a character
- 6:14in a true crime screed. And the sad reality is
- 6:19she's not just those things to the public. She's
- 6:22those things to her youngest daughter. Mariska's
- 6:26memories of her mother are non -existent. But
- 6:30there are all those talk show clips and films
- 6:32to watch and magazines to read. And these artifacts
- 6:36painted her mother as a hyper -feminine product
- 6:39to sell. That, of course, was all kind of on
- 6:44purpose. The Hollywood studio system of the 1920s
- 6:49to the 1950s was built by producers to sell things.
- 6:55At the time, movies weren't looked on as art,
- 6:59but as entertainment products, like a roller
- 7:02coaster or a carnival ride. And it's not by coincidence
- 7:06that one of Hollywood's names in its golden era
- 7:08was the Dream Factory. Not the Dream Workshop,
- 7:13but the Dream Factory, mass -producing entertainment
- 7:17fantasies. A big part of mass production is consistent
- 7:22output. You want to guarantee that, as much as
- 7:26possible, Each product looks the same, so customers
- 7:30can get what they are expecting and be satisfied
- 7:33in that purchase. The best way to sell a picture
- 7:37is to have understandable ideas, which means
- 7:40understandable actors. Today, an actor's greatest
- 7:45attribute is their versatility. We want to see
- 7:49new layers to an actor and their performances.
- 7:52An actor who does too many of the same roles
- 7:55is someone we complain about. But in the golden
- 7:59age of Hollywood, an actor was a brand, and it
- 8:03meant you knew what kind of story you were about
- 8:05to watch. Starring Errol Flynn meant you were
- 8:09about to watch a romantic adventure. Starring
- 8:12Mae West meant you were in for a bawdy crime
- 8:15story with some humor and some intrigue. Jane
- 8:19Mansfield was a very intelligent, skilled young
- 8:23actress. But she struggled to book work. It took
- 8:27her years to break into Hollywood. She dyed her
- 8:30hair blonde for an audition for The Seven Year
- 8:33Itch, which went to Maryland, and shortly after
- 8:36did a spread for Playboy. Between the two, she
- 8:40had a way she could sell herself, a blonde bombshell.
- 8:44And that was very effective. She had a type.
- 8:47She could slot into the factory of films and
- 8:50be celebrated. That wasn't as good as it sounded.
- 8:55Mansfield viewed the blonde bombshell image as
- 8:58a way to get the foot in the door until she could
- 9:02reinvent herself as a bona fide actress. She
- 9:05thought especially after her role in The Wayward
- 9:08Bus, for which she won a Golden Globe, that she
- 9:11could easily make the pivot. But the Hollywood
- 9:14star image, the thing that was Jane Mansfield,
- 9:18could not be redefined, could not be conquered.
- 9:22And as the Hollywood system shut down, she couldn't
- 9:25even rely on the blonde bombshell type to get
- 9:28work anymore. The definition of the bombshell
- 9:32changed drastically in the 1960s, and the child
- 9:36-voiced, tan, big -breasted Jane Mansfield was
- 9:39not it. So she remained stuck. in this reduced
- 9:44personhood role. Until she became a different
- 9:48kind of thing. An urban legend. I have complicated
- 9:54feelings for true crime. It existed for decades
- 9:58in print before radio became podcasts, but now
- 10:02that it's a genre connected most strongly with
- 10:04audio, it really is our current form of oral
- 10:08storytelling. It's fact reporting and gossip
- 10:12and cautionary tales all rolled into one, an
- 10:15ancient tradition that we almost crave. And it
- 10:19taking hold among women especially makes sense.
- 10:22It's our oral legendarium, the stories we tell
- 10:26each other to keep each other safe. Tales meant
- 10:30to enforce why you should be careful about the
- 10:33nice guy who tries to isolate you from your friends.
- 10:37or why you should look in your backseat before
- 10:39driving away in your car. But these stories we
- 10:43tell get warped in the telling, and the victims
- 10:46of crime and accidents stop being people and
- 10:50start being dark fairy tale characters, the victims
- 10:54of serial killers as real to us as Bluebeard's
- 10:57wives. A misunderstood police photo of one of
- 11:02Jane Mansfield's wigs thrown from her crashed
- 11:04car becomes remembered as her head, when that
- 11:08isn't how she died. And she becomes a horror
- 11:12story wrapped in reality, like your friend's
- 11:15cousin who claimed they saw an actual ghost.
- 11:19Again, she ceases to be a person. Mariska Hargitay
- 11:26does not remember the car accident. She was three.
- 11:30But she was there. It was a real thing that happened
- 11:34to her. And how odd must it be to hear it repeated
- 11:39as a ghost story around a campfire, a deeply
- 11:42sad event that changed your family forever. There
- 11:48is a version of this documentary that could have
- 11:51been this kind of thing, a true crime hunt. Or
- 11:56it could have been a deep dive into the Hollywood
- 11:58myth of Bombshell Jane. Or it could have been
- 12:03this other weird depersonalizing thing. Stars
- 12:06are just like us. One of the things that brought
- 12:10down the Hollywood system was a magazine called
- 12:13Confidential. There'd always been a gossip arm
- 12:17to the studios. Columnists Luella Parsons and
- 12:21Hedda Hopper had been a part of PR campaigns
- 12:24working with the studio systems to build mythologies
- 12:28around their stars, to help build this perception
- 12:32that the characters on screen were somehow the
- 12:34same as the actual actors. If there was bad press
- 12:38about an actor, the gossip columnists could build
- 12:42up a counter -narrative. What made Confidential
- 12:45so destructive to the Dream Factory was that
- 12:48it reported the actual salacious things that
- 12:51stars got up to, or at least the worst versions
- 12:55of the actual stories. So Hollywood stars weren't
- 12:59these legendary beings, they were warped, fallen
- 13:03humans. Eventually, with the advent of television
- 13:07talk shows, stars and studios countered this
- 13:11with broadcast, candid interviews. This way.
- 13:15The actors looked like real people, but the best
- 13:18version of real people. And these two arms of
- 13:22media, the tabloids and the talk shows, are still
- 13:25going strong. The tabloid could set up one false
- 13:29image of a person, and the talk show could set
- 13:31up another. And a biological documentary could
- 13:34set itself on one side or the other. It could
- 13:38be a tell -all kind of salacious deep dive, digging
- 13:42into all the dirty details. Or it could be a
- 13:46glossy portrait of someone covering their biggest
- 13:49flaws with excuses, where a person becomes an
- 13:53innocuous figure. The miracle of this film, what
- 13:58makes it stand out, why it's worth talking about,
- 14:01is that it is none of these things. All of these
- 14:05layers of dehumanization, these methods of flattening
- 14:09a person, this documentary not only avoids, but
- 14:13undoes. This is a film that humanizes Jane Mansfield,
- 14:18or rather, re -humanizes her. She's not a Hollywood
- 14:24star, or an urban legend, or a dirty little sinner,
- 14:27or a hallowed mother gone too soon. She's a person.
- 14:34So how does Hargitay accomplish this re -humanization?
- 14:39First, the film begins by contrasting Jane Mansfield,
- 14:44the star persona, with Jane, the person. The
- 14:48opening montage shows Hollywood glamour footage
- 14:51of Jane Mansfield walking through her grand mansion
- 14:55with current footage of Mariska walking through
- 14:59the demolished lot that she once called home.
- 15:02Then we are introduced to Mariska and her family
- 15:05via a talk show clip, where Mansfield brought
- 15:09on her four youngest kids, including two - or
- 15:12three -year -old Mariska, then called Maria.
- 15:15This clip really makes it clear how artificial
- 15:19that world is, so different from the actual Mariska
- 15:23in the current day. Next, we move into the interview
- 15:27subjects that make up the bulk of the film. Hargitay's
- 15:31Three Older Siblings. In a documentary, you can
- 15:35introduce your talking heads in two ways. Either
- 15:38they appear on the set in their chair like they
- 15:40only exist in one spot for all eternity, or you
- 15:44can set up some kind of introduction. Like, the
- 15:47host of the documentary will walk up to their
- 15:50house and knock on the door and the subject will
- 15:52welcome them in. The first is obviously artificial,
- 15:56but so is the second. It seems more news -like,
- 16:01but it's also been set up. That person already
- 16:05knows you're coming and has picked out clothes
- 16:08and has gotten makeup on, and the host has probably
- 16:11said hi to them earlier. Hargitay chooses to
- 16:15do something unique. She first shows us the spaces
- 16:19without the interview subjects, and then we see
- 16:23the setup for the interviews. We see her brother
- 16:26Zoltan making comments about the film slate looking
- 16:29nice. We watch her sister Jane Marie get makeup
- 16:32on. Hargitay strips away the artifice by reminding
- 16:36us that these talking head interviews aren't
- 16:39just one person talking to a camera, but one
- 16:42person talking to a room full of 10 to 20 people.
- 16:46And that makes them feel like real humans, not
- 16:49just objects on film. We are suddenly aware.
- 16:53that a documentary is an artificial construct.
- 16:58And for her opening question, Hargitay and her
- 17:01editor J .D. Marlowe make a very smart choice.
- 17:05They leave in Mariska's opening comments to her
- 17:08brother Mickey Jr., telling him that he doesn't
- 17:10have to talk about anything that makes him uncomfortable,
- 17:13but that she would like to talk about their childhood.
- 17:17These comments smoothly transition to her saying
- 17:20the same thing to her brother Zoltan, as she
- 17:22asks about his memories of their mother. And
- 17:25then, after some awkward silence where he struggles
- 17:29to speak, interspliced with candids and home
- 17:33footage of their mother and him as a child, he
- 17:36asks if they can turn the camera off. This does
- 17:41a couple of things. It communicates that we aren't
- 17:44going to hear. every tawdry detail. This family
- 17:48isn't going to make everything public. It also
- 17:52makes us painfully aware that these are real
- 17:54people and that we aren't owed anything. Their
- 18:00discomfort with the camera makes us self -conscious.
- 18:03And that, in turn, makes us see their memories
- 18:08of Mansfield as something different. Real, human
- 18:13recollections. not just film trivia. And this
- 18:18isn't a tell -all. The third thing Hargitay does
- 18:23is to not talk about the most obvious sensationalized
- 18:27topics. Hargitay frequently refers to Mansfield
- 18:31as a sex symbol and shows several pinups, but
- 18:35she does not talk about the Playboy spread. She
- 18:39also doesn't talk about the specifics of how
- 18:41her mom died. There are no photos of her body
- 18:45or specifics of her injuries. She's given the
- 18:50dignity to brush away these most dehumanizing
- 18:53lenses. Instead, the accident is talked about
- 18:58from her brother's perspectives, their very real,
- 19:01final memories of their mother, devastating,
- 19:04awkwardly human pain. Zoltan just wishing his
- 19:09mom would stay with him in the backseat, the
- 19:12realist little boy thought, magnified by a terrible
- 19:16tragedy. This film honors his pain, rather than
- 19:22autopsying their mother. But it also doesn't
- 19:26stay away from Hargitay's mother's foolish choices
- 19:29or struggles. An important late reveal which
- 19:33I actually think was the original impetus for
- 19:36the film, is that Mariska Hargitay is actually
- 19:40the biological child of singer Nelson Sardelli,
- 19:43whom her mother had a fling with toward the end
- 19:46of her marriage to Mickey Hargitay, the man who
- 19:48raised Mariska as his own. Mariska has known
- 19:52this for over 30 years and has kept it completely
- 19:55secret. This film is her attempt to reclaim her
- 20:00life narrative. But it also wrestles with her
- 20:04frustrations at her mother for making the choices
- 20:07that led to this secret. For her biological father
- 20:11for removing himself from the picture entirely,
- 20:14leaving Mariska with complicated identity issues.
- 20:18Jane's choices led to a lot of pain in her family.
- 20:23Physical, emotional, psychological. And that
- 20:29is the real heart of this piece. processing that
- 20:33pain in a way that challenged me to be careful
- 20:37how I look at Hollywood stars and be cautious
- 20:40in how I think and talk about them. Around the
- 20:46time of this film's release, an actress named
- 20:49Sydney Sweeney received a lot of controversy
- 20:52over an ad for American Eagle. Sweeney is blonde
- 20:56with big boobs. She got her start on an HBO show
- 21:00called Euphoria, where she played a teenager
- 21:03with deep emotional wounds wearing very skimpy
- 21:06clothes. She's trying really hard to break out
- 21:10as a serious actress. She started a production
- 21:14company to ensure she could get interesting,
- 21:17meaty, dramatic roles. None of them have performed
- 21:21very well. She's been very candid in interviews
- 21:25about how she does advertising campaigns to pay
- 21:28the bills so she can keep trying to make it as
- 21:31a serious actress. This summer's ad caused quite
- 21:35a stir, first by referencing the horribly sexualizing
- 21:39Calvin Klein Jean ad starring young Brooke Shields,
- 21:43and second, by including a double entendre that
- 21:47could be interpreted as white supremacist messaging.
- 21:51This November, Sweeney's newest film, Christy,
- 21:54a boxing biopic, bombed at the box office. And
- 22:00film internet was filled with comments and videos
- 22:02and articles jeering that she can't actually
- 22:05act, she just has a nice rack. I don't know Sydney
- 22:11Sweeney. I don't know who she is as a person.
- 22:15I don't know her actual personal beliefs. But
- 22:21it was uncomfortably similar to hear a woman
- 22:25who really wants to be a serious actress, who
- 22:28is hustling hard to earn a living and break her
- 22:31way into an established career, be reduced to
- 22:34a blonde bombshell. She probably shouldn't have
- 22:38done the ad. But I don't know what offers are
- 22:44available to her. I don't know what's in her
- 22:47bank account. She's a person, not a thing. And
- 22:55I really, really hope that she has a long life
- 22:59to learn wisdom and to build a career and enjoy
- 23:04the company of a safe community that she lets
- 23:08take care of her. Jane Mansfield didn't really
- 23:13get that chance. And this documentary makes me
- 23:19ache. for that loss. May we all see the full
- 23:25dignity and value of every human we encounter
- 23:29in person or on screen. Thanks for coming.