Latest / Film And Whiskey / Once Upon a Time...in Hollywood (2019) / Eagle Rare 17-Year Bourbon (2024) ft. Noah Gittell
Transcript
- 0:00In 2019, director Quentin Tarantino and stars Brad Pitt
- 0:05and Leonardo DiCaprio gave the world a sprawling reflection on
- 0:09the death of the golden age of Hollywood.
- 0:13In 2025, we just couldn't stay away from this brand for more
- 0:17than a season. The film is Once Upon a Time in
- 0:21Hollywood. The whiskey is Eagle Rare 17
- 0:25and. We'll review them both.
- 0:27This is the The Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:49Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:52review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:55I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 0:57And this week we are looking at Quentin Tarantino's 2019 film
- 1:02Once Upon a Time Ellipses in Hollywood.
- 1:07I I expect you to hold that ellipses with respect to Bob.
- 1:10I know you do. We need, we need to pause for
- 1:13reflection as we say the title of this film.
- 1:16You know, Bob, I never knew when we watched The Assassination of
- 1:20Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford that there would be so many
- 1:24titles that I could use to just be annoying.
- 1:28Yeah, and you have really paid dividends on that bit, man.
- 1:32It's been 6 years here on film and Whiskey Brad, this is an
- 1:35interesting movie for me to record today because it's one of
- 1:39the first films that came out after we started this podcast
- 1:43that I remember doing like a video review for using our
- 1:47podcast social media channels. And this is back in the day
- 1:50where we were only reviewing movies from like the 40s.
- 1:53So it is it's just very strange that we're all the way up to
- 1:572019 now. We're talking about a movie that
- 2:00I have not seen since that first time in the theater in 2019.
- 2:05And I'll give a huge spoiler here, Brad, because the first
- 2:08time I saw this movie, I was not a big fan of it.
- 2:11Bob, Robert, what? What is wrong with you?
- 2:16I listen. Believe me, I have.
- 2:19I have searched high and low for answers to that question, Brad
- 2:22not not just as it pertains to this movie.
- 2:24I need to talk to your therapist.
- 2:27Well, we have somebody here that could maybe play the role of
- 2:30therapist today for us because we've brought back one of our
- 2:33favorite people to guest on this episode today.
- 2:35It's our friend, critic and author Noah Getell.
- 2:38Noah, how are you tonight, man? Guys I've had 8W sours and I'm
- 2:42ready to go. The best point about that scene
- 2:46is he's like you couldn't have just had 4W sours.
- 2:53Oh man. What a great scene.
- 2:55It's so it's so good, man. Brad, I have so many thoughts on
- 2:58this movie. I don't want to dive in too
- 3:00quickly. So let's set the stage here.
- 3:02Let's let's tease our audience just a bit.
- 3:04Folks. If you're new to film and
- 3:06whiskey, welcome in the title's pretty self-explanatory.
- 3:09We talk about movies, we talk about whiskey this season of the
- 3:12podcast. What we're doing is going back
- 3:14through the last 20 years of cinema history, and we're asking
- 3:17the question, does this movie deserve to be considered a
- 3:21modern masterpiece? We're trying to build the 21st
- 3:24century Canon here, Brad, and we have an interesting artifact
- 3:28here of the 21st century. This is a movie that I'm pretty
- 3:32sure you have not seen until this watch.
- 3:34Is that correct? That is absolutely correct Bob
- 3:37and I have done my best to stay as spoiler free as possible.
- 3:42I, I think the most I knew was that Brad Pitt is a stuntman and
- 3:48Bruce Lee, well, there is a cameo.
- 3:53How, how do you say it? Bruce Lee is not in the movie,
- 3:56but Bruce Lee is in the movie. Yeah, sure.
- 3:59You would say an actor plays Bruce Lee in the room.
- 4:01There we go. Thanks, Noah.
- 4:04I believe that's the technical terminology is is.
- 4:07Portrayed in the film. I I think that's what I was
- 4:10trying to say. There you go.
- 4:12All right. So that's that's the extent of
- 4:13Brad's knowledge on the movie. And I think that provides us the
- 4:16most natural segue into our first segment of the day, which
- 4:20we call, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 4:22movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 4:26ahead and do your take with this little segment that Brad
- 4:30explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 4:32show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 4:36just seen, often for the first time.
- 4:39Brad, this is very much true today and given given what you
- 4:44said you knew about the movie, I'm very excited to see you dive
- 4:47into explaining the entire plot here, folks.
- 4:50What we do in this segment is allow Brad free rein.
- 4:54He will spoil the hell out of this movie.
- 4:56So if you have not yet seen Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, it is
- 4:59bananas. So you should probably go watch
- 5:02it and then come back and listen to the rest of the episode.
- 5:05Brad, you have 60 seconds to spoil the film and go.
- 5:09Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is a film that follows Rick Dalton
- 5:15and his stunt double Cliff Booth, played by Lena Leonardo
- 5:20DiCaprio and Brad Pitt as they wander about Hollywood,
- 5:26pondering their futures, trying to figure out if what they are
- 5:29currently doing is right for them or if they need to take a
- 5:33new pathway for their careers. It also follows Sharon Tate,
- 5:39played by Margot Robbie, as she lives just an idyllic few days
- 5:44in Hollywood. It all culminates in a few
- 5:48months spent in Italy by Cliff and Rick.
- 5:53They come back and have a very Tarantino just incredibly
- 6:00peaceful, beautiful, philosophical ending.
- 6:05Yeah, very much so. By this is by.
- 6:08Philosophical You mean aortic spray then yes, we we have
- 6:12achieved that for. Sure dude, when Brad Pitt just
- 6:15like slams that girl's head into like 8 different objects across
- 6:20the house, it's. Incredible.
- 6:24Let me tell you something before we do anything else here.
- 6:26And I want to get to Noah. Watching that scene in the movie
- 6:29theater with the sound design of that scene, I have never been in
- 6:35such intense discomfort as as listening to the noises that
- 6:39were being made by flesh hitting objects in that scene.
- 6:42Unbelievable. It's absolutely brutal and it
- 6:46and it definitely is a discordant tone to end the movie
- 6:51on compared to everything that has LED up to it.
- 6:56I think that is a wonderful setup for where I'm going to go
- 6:59today. Brad.
- 7:00Noah, I want to throw to you, though.
- 7:02You know, we gave you the option to choose any movie on our list
- 7:05this season, and you immediately jumped at Once Upon a Time in
- 7:08Hollywood. You did throw in the caveat that
- 7:10you didn't want to talk about baseball movies, and that is
- 7:13understandable at this point. But why this movie?
- 7:15What What attracted you to this one on our list this year?
- 7:19Well, I was really excited to hear Brad do the Plot Summary.
- 7:22In fact, I've been looking forward to it all day because
- 7:26I've watched this movie 5 or 6 times and I'm not sure what the
- 7:29plot is. I would say, were you satisfied
- 7:32with me skipping over pretty much all of it?
- 7:34You actually did really well. You did.
- 7:37You did better than I would have done.
- 7:39I would have said something like an actor and a stuntman hang out
- 7:43and watch TV and then this other actress that goes to a
- 7:47bookstore. And then there are these cult
- 7:50members who almost kill someone at the end, but then they.
- 7:53Get killed. I did forget to mention the
- 7:55cult, which is a somewhat major part of the film.
- 8:00It is somewhat major and also like not at all important in a
- 8:04way. Like that's kind of the whole
- 8:05movie to me. And that's it's kind of what I
- 8:08love about it and why I will always come back to it to try to
- 8:11understand more of what Tarantino is doing.
- 8:15And I've come to the conclusion that I don't think he knows
- 8:17exactly what he's doing. I think this is in some ways
- 8:20like his most out of control movie.
- 8:23He has said it's his most personal movie, which is odd
- 8:27considering he was only 6 when the events of this film took
- 8:30place. I mean, I know he was in LA, but
- 8:33I don't think he was super conscious of all this.
- 8:35Maybe some of it. So I don't know exactly what
- 8:39he's thinking and what he's doing.
- 8:40I have a few ideas, but my my guess is that he started making
- 8:45this movie and he just fell in love with these characters.
- 8:48You know, because this is a movie.
- 8:50I think it's his his most tender movie outside of maybe Jackie
- 8:54Brown. And I think it's it's his only
- 8:57movie that would be like qualify as a true hangout movie like
- 9:00from beginning to end. And I think he got Leo and Brad
- 9:05and Margot in this movie. And he was like, I just want to
- 9:09watch these people play these characters and live their lives.
- 9:14And it's an immensely pleasurable experience to me,
- 9:17despite the fact that two of those 3 characters are probably
- 9:21terrible human beings. But that's the genius of the
- 9:24movie. That's the genius of these
- 9:26actors. And in some ways I think that's
- 9:28the point. But we can maybe unpack that a
- 9:30little bit more as we go. I actually think I, I don't want
- 9:34to speak for Brad, but I will speak for myself.
- 9:36I think you've actually nailed it.
- 9:37I think that is everything you said, I completely agree with.
- 9:42And yet I feel like I fall on the complete opposite side of
- 9:44the fence on this movie. It is by far his most unfocused
- 9:48movie. And I, I said this to Brad
- 9:50earlier, it's my least favorite Tarantino by a considerable
- 9:53margin. Like I'm not counting Death
- 9:56proof. I don't really, I know people
- 9:57love to count that one. I don't really count that one of
- 9:59his, you know, own unique works. I think it's my least favorite
- 10:03Tarantino. And this was only my second
- 10:05watch. So I gave it a good, you know,
- 10:07five years in between to make sure that I really understood
- 10:10what I was doing here. And I'm still landing in the
- 10:12same spot. And Noah, you said that you had
- 10:15a few ideas behind why the movie shook out the way it did.
- 10:19I'm wondering, Brad, if it's OK with you.
- 10:21Maybe we just kind of let Noah give us the outline for the
- 10:24episode here. Let's let's listen to his
- 10:26theories and debunk them one by one as we go.
- 10:29Well, these are the things the movie makes me think about while
- 10:32I watch them. And I don't know how much of
- 10:33this is intentional because I did read the novelization Once
- 10:38Upon a Time in Hollywood, and he makes things explicit in the
- 10:40book that are ambiguous in the movie.
- 10:43And I'm less interested the more explicit he makes them.
- 10:46For example, I don't really want to know that Cliff Booth, like,
- 10:49was part of a dog fighting ring and that's how he got Brandy.
- 10:53Like, that makes it less good to me to know that Cliff Booth was
- 10:56out there. Like letting dogs murder each
- 10:58other for money. Somehow that's worse than him
- 11:01killing his wife. I'm not exactly sure why, but
- 11:04that's another thing that is unambiguous in the book.
- 11:06Not a big Michael Vick fan, no. Hardly.
- 11:10No, I I was the owner of two pit bulls.
- 11:12So Brandy is a special, special dog for me.
- 11:16So again, I don't know how much of this is, is intentional, but
- 11:19what it makes me think about is he's making a movie about a
- 11:23transitional time in Hollywood history.
- 11:26So he's probably also thinking about the current era and the
- 11:30transitional moment we're in now.
- 11:32And, you know, one of the things that is has been much written
- 11:38about, much discussed of this era is that we are losing movie
- 11:41stars. We just don't have them anymore.
- 11:42We don't have people who can carry movies the way they used
- 11:45to. We have characters, superheroes
- 11:48and comic book characters who are more important than the
- 11:51actor playing them. And, and how this is really bad
- 11:54for the business. And, you know, in some ways, I
- 11:56think this movie is him showing us the power of a movie star.
- 12:01It is him lamenting, maybe even call it an elegy for an era that
- 12:07is going away, just like Rick Dalton is is represents an era
- 12:12that's going away in the film. And the scene that made me
- 12:15realize this was the scene when Brad Pitt is on the roof and he
- 12:21takes his shirt off because that is a a moment that Harkins back
- 12:26to how Brad Pitt got his start taking his shirt off in Thelma
- 12:30and Louise. And like, it's his trademark.
- 12:32His chest outside of his face is probably his biggest trademark.
- 12:36He's got a lot of trademarks. And I feel like in that moment
- 12:40he was saying, look at Brad Pitt.
- 12:42He's still got it. And once you do that, we're in
- 12:45in meta text, you know, we're now talking about the actors as
- 12:48much as the characters. And when I spoke earlier about
- 12:51how terrible these these characters are, you know, Cliff
- 12:54Booth in particular, this is a man who killed his wife.
- 12:57And yet I maybe Bob doesn't feel the same way.
- 13:00I still really like these guys and I still want to hang out
- 13:03with these guys. And I think that the only thing
- 13:06I can say for certain is that that's part of the statement
- 13:09Tarantino is making here is he's saying, look what a movie star
- 13:12can still do. If we give them the chance, they
- 13:14can make these despicable people likable, relatable and somebody
- 13:19you want to drink whiskey sours with.
- 13:21So that's one, that's one idea. Should I move on or do we want
- 13:24to talk about that one? No, let's talk about that for a
- 13:27second. And, and I hope I don't throw
- 13:29you too far off track, but you, you are falling victim to a
- 13:33classic blunder here. And I, I feel like I need to
- 13:35address it. It's it's a thing that Brad and
- 13:38I have interrogated a lot, especially with well established
- 13:41directors who have some amount of cache due to making really
- 13:45good movies. And it's like, once you've
- 13:47achieved master status, can you still misfire or, or are you
- 13:54given such a benefit of the doubt that, you know, for me, I
- 13:57think this is a a very poorly plotted movie.
- 13:59I don't, I look at the way that it's set up and it's, it is a
- 14:03hangout movie and it is very shaggy.
- 14:05But then there's also a lot of questions I have about like, why
- 14:07is the scene filmed this way? Why is it structured in a two or
- 14:10three day stretch for most of the movie?
- 14:12And then there's a jump forward in time.
- 14:13Six months. What is the Sharon Tate
- 14:15character even doing in this movie?
- 14:17Should we have just kept her behind a fence the whole movie?
- 14:20And then him being allowed behind the fence is like, it it,
- 14:23it's almost more impactful that way if we don't really see her
- 14:26throughout the movie. I, I say all this because I
- 14:29think that you're already talking about meta textual
- 14:32stuff. And we're giving Tarantino a lot
- 14:33of credit in saying that, like, he's leaving behind the plot of
- 14:38his own movie to take you into Meadaville and like an
- 14:42interrogation and an examination of stardom.
- 14:45And I'm not saying he's not doing that, but I, I feel like
- 14:48people so easily dismiss the weirdness of this movie in
- 14:54Tarantino's like Uvra because they just want to give him so
- 14:58much the benefit of the doubt and say he must be doing
- 15:01something more. And I just want to pause it like
- 15:03maybe this is just not his best effort.
- 15:06I do wonder why with a lot of directors we kind of skip over
- 15:10that part of the thought process.
- 15:12Well, I would say first of all, I'm not a Tarantino fanboy.
- 15:17Like there's several of his films I don't love at all.
- 15:20And in fact, as a person, I find him very, very great in and
- 15:25maybe even worse than that, maybe worse than that, I'm not
- 15:28sure I would want to ever have a conversation with him in real
- 15:30life. So I didn't necessarily go into
- 15:32this movie like expecting to love it or wanting to be him in
- 15:34a masterpiece. Although I agree with you if
- 15:36that happens, you know, and this is where we differ.
- 15:38But like, my retort would be like, this is an immensely
- 15:42pleasurable movie. When I watch this movie, I am
- 15:45smiling the whole time. I even took a picture of myself
- 15:49watching it 'cause I was like, I want to remember how my face
- 15:52looks when I'm this happy. That's what I did the other
- 15:55night when I watched it. And, you know, obviously our
- 15:59your mileage will vary, unlike whether this is an enjoyable
- 16:02experience for you. But like, there's only so many
- 16:05times as a film critic, I can just say this movie slaps.
- 16:08You know, like without getting into the ideas behind it.
- 16:12And I will acknowledge, and I have acknowledged, and in this
- 16:14case, I'm not sure all that I'm reading into it is intentional.
- 16:17But that's never stopped a film critic before, and it's
- 16:20certainly not going to stop me. Yeah, I mean, I listen to you
- 16:25guys and I, I feel like I watched a different movie
- 16:28because for me, yeah, I don't feel like this movie is shaggy
- 16:34in the sense of, like, lacking direction and focus to, to me,
- 16:39like, even like the character of Sharon Tate feels like the
- 16:44optimistic view on what Hollywood can be even as it
- 16:50passes away. Like I, I feel like she
- 16:53represents a very important role in the movie of like, regardless
- 16:58of the old guard of Hollywood, there's always something new
- 17:03coming on the horizon, Somebody who still enjoys watching
- 17:07themselves in a movie. And, and there's just something
- 17:10beautiful about that character. And you, I don't know, I found
- 17:14myself utterly entranced by every single character, by so
- 17:19many shots there. There are so many incredible,
- 17:22beautiful shots in this movie. And I like as I think about
- 17:26Tarantino pointing out the transition of one era to the
- 17:32next, I find it fascinating that this movie came out in 2019
- 17:36because like, obviously there's no way he knows what's coming
- 17:40the next year in 2020. But he and other film makers
- 17:44have gone on record of saying, like, ever since 2020, like
- 17:48cinema just has completely been altered.
- 17:51Like the, the whole deal between was it HBO and WB where they
- 17:58were streaming all their movies right away for the year and now
- 18:01they're back to the cinematic releases.
- 18:02But like so much happened in COVID that it really feels like
- 18:072019 to 2020 was a 1969 to 1970 type of transition.
- 18:14And so I, I don't know, I just, I was thinking about all of
- 18:16these things as I was watching it.
- 18:19I did not for a moment feel like this movie was really shaggy.
- 18:23Interesting. Yeah, I I do think that even if
- 18:26you don't find it Shaggy, what what I noticed reading reviews
- 18:30of it and you sent me a couple reviews as well as that everyone
- 18:32sort of acknowledged that the general vibe of the film.
- 18:37Maybe it's the pacing, maybe it's something else was totally
- 18:40new for a Tarantino film. And he's like a master at
- 18:44hangout level dialogue, right? Like the the opening restaurant
- 18:48scene in Reservoir Dogs and the opening scene in the car in Pulp
- 18:51Fiction. Like he's always just been a guy
- 18:53that really cleverly writes 2 dudes hanging out talking about
- 18:59stuff. And yet I feel like formally,
- 19:02functionally, this movie is just very different and he's trying
- 19:06something new. And Brad, you actually brought
- 19:08up earlier when I told you that I wasn't a huge fan of this
- 19:11movie. Like, how could you not be a fan
- 19:13of this movie? This is his licorice pizza.
- 19:16And you know how much I love licorice pizza.
- 19:19And I would actually posit something different.
- 19:21And you can't argue with me, Brad, because you haven't seen
- 19:23the movie I'm going to reference.
- 19:24But Noah can argue. I love licorice pizza and I
- 19:29understand like it's a California set hangout movie.
- 19:32So yes, there's definitely some parallels there.
- 19:34This actually reminds me a lot more of a movie from PTA that I
- 19:38didn't like either. And I'm in the small minority on
- 19:40that one. And that's a movie called
- 19:41Phantom Thread, which I found to be his most indulgent movie.
- 19:48It's a movie that is essentially built to one final scene at the
- 19:53at the very end of the movie that's kind of a rug pull and
- 19:56kind of a really funny, really dirty joke.
- 19:58And it made the whole movie for me feel like.
- 20:01You you undermined what you've been building with the end of
- 20:04the movie and this just felt like a really self indulgent
- 20:07joke upon the audience. I don't think Tarantino like
- 20:11committed the level of sin to me that PTA did with Phantom
- 20:15Thread. But I always just found that
- 20:17like, it's really clear that he wanted to write a story about
- 20:21the Sharon Tate murders and do his revisionist history thing
- 20:24with them. And so much of this movie feels
- 20:27like I I need to cobble together some stuff to get us to this
- 20:31point. And I think that's why it
- 20:34ultimately reminds me more of Phantom Thread than Licorice
- 20:36Pizza. Noah, I can see you by by your
- 20:39hands obscuring your face over here that you are in utter
- 20:42disagreement with me. So, So please take me down.
- 20:45But that's kind of where I land on this one.
- 20:46Only I only disagree with you on everything you said.
- 20:52No, no, not exactly. Phantom Threat is my favorite
- 20:55Paul Thomas Anderson movie, so we'll get that out of the way.
- 20:59And. Get him Noah.
- 21:01I, I, I agree, I agree with you in theory that I mean, I agree
- 21:07with what you're saying. I think I just disagree with
- 21:08like how it worked out. This movie was compared to
- 21:14Inglourious Basterds and Django Unchained when it came out as
- 21:16like another film in which some of history's most famous
- 21:21monsters are revenged upon by Quentin Tarantino.
- 21:25And yet this film does not feel at all like those movies.
- 21:29I'm not entirely sure those movies feel exactly like each
- 21:31other, but this one feels more different than either of them do
- 21:35to each other. And there are even scenes in
- 21:38this movie that feel like they're supposed to be like the
- 21:42scenes have long drawn out tension in those films.
- 21:45You know, Inglourious Basterds has like 3 or 4 of these
- 21:47incredible long scenes of tension.
- 21:50The opening scene for example, I think the Strudel scene and the
- 21:54the Tavern scene and Django and Chain has a couple of them as
- 21:57well. This movie you have the Spawn
- 21:59ranch scene, which I think is supposed to be as tense as
- 22:02those, but it just isn't. And I don't feel that that is a
- 22:08failing of the movie. I don't think I wanted it to be
- 22:12that. I do think it got away from him
- 22:13a little bit. But as I said earlier, I think
- 22:15it got away from him because he he loves these characters so
- 22:19much. I think this is his softest
- 22:21movie. I think it's a movie that shows
- 22:23Quentin Tarantino is not the hard ass that he used to be.
- 22:27There's a tenderness towards the characters.
- 22:28There's a love towards the characters.
- 22:30I almost feel like he doesn't want to put them through what he
- 22:34put through his characters in his other films.
- 22:37And I'm a sentimental person. I like sentimental movies and
- 22:39maybe that's why I like this movie more than you do.
- 22:42But I will just on the Licorice Pizza comparison, I do feel
- 22:45compelled to point out both Once Upon a Time in Hollywood and
- 22:50Licorice Pizza. You know, in addition to both
- 22:53being hanging out film set in LA, they have something else
- 22:55really weird in common. And I don't know what to say
- 22:57about it except it's a really weird coincidence, which is that
- 23:01they both are littered with actors who are the children of
- 23:05famous Hollywood figures. You know, and Once Upon a time
- 23:09in Hollywood, all of those Manson women are like, it's it's
- 23:13it's Margaret Quali, it's my Hawk, it's Rumor Willis.
- 23:16There's a bunch of other ones. And Licorice Pizza has, you
- 23:20know, Cooper Hoffman, it has Leonardo Dicaprio's father is in
- 23:24Licorice Pizza. So not children, but family
- 23:26member Paul Thomas Anderson and my Rudolph's kids are in the
- 23:30movie. 2 of Steven Spielberg's daughters are in the movie.
- 23:33I don't know how these two directors who are friends ended
- 23:36up doing this in both of their movies at the same time, but it
- 23:41that's just one of many things about this movie that I don't
- 23:44totally understand but continues to fascinate me.
- 23:47Crucially, only one of the films, though, features a line
- 23:50about enjoying peanut butter sandwiches.
- 23:53I was literally about to say, Bob, if Pussycat got into the
- 23:57car with Brad Pitt and Brad Pitt just immediately said, do you
- 24:02like peanut butter sandwiches? Would would that have like
- 24:06notched it up a half point for? You immediate 9.5 out of 10 for
- 24:09me if we'd gone. There, I told you off camera
- 24:13that I'm single again. I've been trying.
- 24:14That line does. Doesn't work.
- 24:17No, not so much man. Not that was a very 1973 line,
- 24:21you know they. Haven't tried the line on Bob.
- 24:24You you do that line on Bob and man, he is ready to go.
- 24:28Good to know man, buy all that away.
- 24:31Yeah, please do. No, I'm with you, though, in
- 24:33that I, I do agree that this has Tarantino's kind of tender
- 24:37streak all through it in a way that Jackie Brown did.
- 24:40It's actually what I love most about Django Unchained.
- 24:42And I, I found that critics have really diverged on their
- 24:47opinions in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood and Django, Django
- 24:51seems to get crapped on a lot on film Twitter.
- 24:53It's actually my personal favorite Tarantino film and it's
- 24:56for all of the reasons that you just said about this movie.
- 24:59I, I find it to be his most humanist movie.
- 25:02I find that he's not trying to, like, bludgeon the audience with
- 25:07violence in in a way that's like almost insulting to the people
- 25:12that it's pretending to champion.
- 25:15Which is like, there's a lot more gunshots.
- 25:17In that than there is not so much bludgeoning.
- 25:19Yeah, but but yeah, I'm with you.
- 25:22And, and what I really noticed was at the very, very end of the
- 25:25movie that that great scene with Emile Hirsch and Leo DiCaprio.
- 25:29And then like the the fairy tale kind of music at the end, it's
- 25:33that all three of these sort of revisionist history films that
- 25:37he made, they ended in very different ways.
- 25:40And Inglourious Basterds ends, you know, with them carving the
- 25:43swastika into Christopher Waltz's head.
- 25:45And it's a very kind of sick joke at the end, but it's like
- 25:47one more chance to screw the Nazi, so why not?
- 25:50And Django ends on a very triumphant note, you know, with
- 25:53them kind of riding away together after the house blows
- 25:55up. This one actually really lingers
- 25:58after the comeuppance. Like, he clearly wrote it to set
- 26:03things right. And I found that to be, like,
- 26:06for me, the most profound and impactful part of the whole
- 26:09movie because it's so quiet and so sweet.
- 26:12And I think that, like, I'm going to be honest with you,
- 26:14Brad, the last 20 minutes of this movie really boosted my
- 26:18overall score of the whole film. Dude, I I think that the end of
- 26:23this film, you said it earlier, Noah, it is the softest, most
- 26:29tender Tarantino that we have ever gotten.
- 26:32That the film's ray of light, that Sharon Tate, this bright
- 26:39bit of sunshine, little piece of joy that just wanders around LA,
- 26:45she survives. And I think that's this whole
- 26:49movie for me kind of came down to Tarantino loves movies.
- 26:55He loves old television and he loves the magic that it can
- 27:00bring into people's lives. And if it's up to him, he is
- 27:05going to guard that magic, even if it means making a movie to
- 27:10revise history to keep that magic true.
- 27:14Like, like that for me felt like the point of this movie.
- 27:18And, you know, it kind of comes back to a debate that we've
- 27:20talked about before, Bob, like, do you go to movies to be
- 27:23entertained or to like think more deeply about the world?
- 27:27And I think Tarantino does a little bit of both here, But he
- 27:31he does the let's think deeply about the world in order to
- 27:35protect and preserve what is beautiful and good.
- 27:39Well said. And yet here I am, still by far
- 27:42the lowest score of the three of us.
- 27:44Unmoved. Unmoved by your persuasive
- 27:47skills, man. No, let me, let me ask you this.
- 27:49I want you to introduce your theory #2 to us here.
- 27:54But you said something that stuck with me a bit ago that
- 27:59like you do think this movie got away from Tarantino a little
- 28:03bit. And yet it's still a a, a
- 28:05resounding success to you. Yeah.
- 28:07I mean, is it fair to say that this is in some way like an
- 28:09accidental success, then like it, despite Tarantino being LED
- 28:14astray, it still somehow works. I.
- 28:18Absolutely think it is. And part of me thinks that a lot
- 28:22of Tarantino's movies are accidental masterpieces because
- 28:25when I listen to him talk, I don't think I've ever heard him
- 28:28say a self reflective thing in his entire life.
- 28:32You know, he is, he is not an introspective person as far as
- 28:36we know, unless there's this whole other side of him that
- 28:38we've never seen. But given how much, how many
- 28:40words this man has spoken, you'd think some truth would come out
- 28:43from time to time. And yet I find his movies so
- 28:47intellectually engaging. And honestly, watching this
- 28:52movie and reading the novelization was very
- 28:55illuminating for me because I thought the novelization was
- 28:58terrible. Like I, and I've read his other
- 29:00book too, and I don't, I don't, I don't think he's a good writer
- 29:02of prose. And it's bizarre because he's a
- 29:06brilliant screenwriter and a brilliant image maker.
- 29:09I mean, I think that's actually his his bigger talent.
- 29:11I know he gets a lot of credit for his dialogue, but I think
- 29:14he's even a better director than he is a a screenwriter.
- 29:17So part of me thinks that once he starts making the movie,
- 29:20that's like things start happening on an instinctive
- 29:23level, you know, and because this movie, he says, is his most
- 29:27personal, and I don't know exactly what that means except
- 29:29he grew up, He was in LA at when this was happening and, and
- 29:33maybe it made an impact on him. I wonder if that's why it got
- 29:36away from him a little bit, you know, and the movie he wanted to
- 29:38make ended up becoming something different.
- 29:41I mean, he talks about this movie almost like it's a memoir
- 29:43piece, you know, and that is just so vastly different from
- 29:46anything else he's ever done, which is always playing with
- 29:49with genre. So But I I think that's the kind
- 29:53of movie I like the older I get, to be honest with you.
- 29:55I like movies that are a little bit wild, you know, like my
- 29:59favorite Wes Anderson movie is is Rushmore, which I think of as
- 30:02as a little bit out of control as well.
- 30:04Like there's, there's, there's a psychology in that movie that he
- 30:08hasn't quite, he doesn't quite know exactly what he's doing.
- 30:12And it's obviously very personal to him.
- 30:14And that's what I like about it. I, I like the rest of his movies
- 30:16too, but they're obviously much more controlled.
- 30:20So I think that that is a bit of personal taste for me.
- 30:23I'm really curious to hear, so if this is like Tarantino's,
- 30:28like personal childhood love letter to Hollywood memoir, how,
- 30:35how would you compare it to something like Meet the
- 30:37Fablemen's then? Because I, I feel similarly that
- 30:40like, you know, Spielberg is one of the greatest of the greats.
- 30:44But like, for me, that movie felt a little bit Shaggy, like
- 30:47it got away from him a little bit.
- 30:50Where do you think we're at with director?
- 30:53And, you know, maybe this isn't a question about Fablemen's as
- 30:55much as it is. Why is it so hard for directors
- 31:00to keep memoir type films from getting away from them?
- 31:05Well, I feel compelled to point out I don't want to sound like a
- 31:07broken record, but The Fable Men's was my favorite film of
- 31:09that year as well. So all the movies you guys think
- 31:15are just OK or worse are my favorite films.
- 31:17I I like the fable men. 'S I like it too.
- 31:20Yeah, I was going to say I enjoyed it.
- 31:22Maybe not my favorite of the year, but.
- 31:24Well, you know, I, we should point out that like, this was a
- 31:27thing that's happening around this time where a lot of film
- 31:29makers were making their memoir pieces and there was a lot
- 31:32written on it at the time. And people were saying it's
- 31:35because the kind like it won't be possible to make movies like
- 31:39this at this scale for much longer.
- 31:42So film makers like Alfonso Cuaron and Spielberg and
- 31:45Tarantino, and I'm sure there were a couple others, I guess
- 31:48Paul Thomas Anderson as well. On some level they're kind of
- 31:50doing it now and they all were sort of getting it out in in the
- 31:54late twenty 10s. So I think this movie totally
- 31:58slots, you know, right alongside all of those others as a memoir
- 32:01piece. And I don't know if these movies
- 32:05are like better than these film makers other films, but I like
- 32:11them more. I like seeing a director who is
- 32:15very controlling and like someone like Spielberg, who
- 32:20really, you know, explores the the breadth, the depth of the
- 32:24cinematic possibilities. I like seeing him get a little
- 32:27loose and a little weird, talking about his own childhood.
- 32:32I found The Fablemans to be as affecting as as any of his
- 32:37movies. And he did it without any of the
- 32:40narrative crutches that he usually uses, without spectacle
- 32:43and without fantasy and without visual effects.
- 32:46And it's one of my favorite Spielberg movies because of
- 32:49that. I'm, I'm, I'm moved by his
- 32:53courage in doing it, in going to this place.
- 32:56It's so late in his life, looking back at this painful
- 32:58time in his history. And I'm moved by his ability to
- 33:01bring the same ingenuity and skill to it that he does to
- 33:04these massive productions. So maybe I'm just a sucker for
- 33:07this kind of movie, but for me they work almost better even
- 33:10when they're not totally in control, because that's more in
- 33:13keeping with the spirit of the of the film, what the film
- 33:15makers going through. Absolutely, man.
- 33:18I, I think every single human knows on an innate level that we
- 33:25are weaving a story with our lives that, that we are meaning
- 33:29making machines. And when film makers take the
- 33:33time to reflect on the meaning that they have made of their
- 33:36stories, I, I'm with you, man. I, I think it's a fascinating
- 33:40endeavor. I think it's why people are
- 33:42fascinated by autobiographies. The fascinating thing for me is
- 33:47I don't know if necessarily I did not know enough about
- 33:51Tarantino to necessarily know that this would be a memoir like
- 33:56film. So that makes it even more
- 33:58meaningful in a sense. Yeah, I mean, you're you're
- 34:02right in that people want to be able to narrativize their lives
- 34:06and put their lives into stories.
- 34:07And it's worth noting that Tarantino's version of telling
- 34:11his story revolves around the central question of what if I
- 34:14could burn a hippie with a flamethrower?
- 34:17That, you know, that that seems to be the question that he's
- 34:20been sorting out in his own psyche for all these years.
- 34:22So and. Can I also say his his version
- 34:25of his own history is the story of an actor whose career gets
- 34:31revived, which is what he has done to so many actors over the
- 34:35course of the It's not a story about himself, it's a story
- 34:38about an actor who he does texturally in the film.
- 34:41What he did for many actors like often.
- 34:43That's actually a good point. Once again, not an introspective
- 34:46man. He's just championing his own
- 34:48abilities through this story. Noah, you brought up Wes
- 34:51Anderson a bit ago. And I think what I'm ultimately
- 34:54doing with this episode is just trying to figure out if we have
- 34:56the same taste in movies or not. But I do kind of think that
- 35:00you're you guys really pinpointed this, this trend in
- 35:03Hollywood that some of our more established film makers are
- 35:06getting their own personal pieces out while they still can.
- 35:09Wes Anderson's an interesting one because I feel like his
- 35:13early films were very personal in a much more raw type of way.
- 35:18And what you're seeing now is him kind of playing with form.
- 35:20He's, he's figuring out how much of a labyrinthine Rubik's Cube
- 35:25can I make my scripts into Brad, he made a movie a few years ago
- 35:29called The French Dispatch and it, it's such an interesting
- 35:32movie from a narrative standpoint.
- 35:35What I'm, what I do think, though, is that as interesting
- 35:39as it is to like, read the text with Wes Anderson, now, I, I'm
- 35:43detached from his movies in a way that I never have been
- 35:46before. And I'm kind of getting the same
- 35:48vibes with Tarantino in this movie.
- 35:50It feels like he started this movie from a novelist or a
- 35:55memoirist standpoint. And he really wanted to be able
- 35:58to demonstrate his encyclopedic knowledge of movie history of
- 36:031960s California. And there are so many scenes in
- 36:08this movie where it's like, did I really need Kurt Russell to
- 36:12narrate a dinner held at some random restaurant that is not in
- 36:17any way pertinent to this story? And so I think he kind of falls
- 36:20in the same trap that that Wes Anderson does.
- 36:22Whereas Wes Anderson is, like, really focused on this, the art
- 36:26form of the screenplay. Tarantino seems to be like, how
- 36:28can I make this a novel? Well, you know, it started as a
- 36:32novel. He wrote the novel first,
- 36:33actually, and then interesting. Yeah.
- 36:35As he was writing, he was like, I think this would make a better
- 36:37movie. And then he made the movie and
- 36:39decided to finish the novel and and put it out there for
- 36:42whatever reason. So I think you're I think you're
- 36:44on to something there. I just think when you talk about
- 36:48this movie, like what is necessary is like it's a tough
- 36:51that's a tough conversation to have because there's almost
- 36:55nothing that's necessary because I don't there's not a plot,
- 36:59right, Correct. Yes, there is no plot.
- 37:02So I don't think any of it is necessary.
- 37:04It's a question of whether it's enjoyable or not.
- 37:06I honestly think this is a movie.
- 37:08This is a movie that you either enjoy or you don't enjoy and
- 37:11there's there's nothing that can be done if you fall into that.
- 37:14This does not make me smile, camp.
- 37:16Yeah, it's absolutely a Are you along for the ride?
- 37:21Like when Brad Pitt takes a drag on the acid cigarette and goes,
- 37:26all right, here we go. Like, like that could have been
- 37:29at the very start of the movie because that's the essence of
- 37:32the film. It's like, here we go.
- 37:34Are you are you with me or are you not?
- 37:36I think part of it is the way it's edited too, like so for a
- 37:39long time, Tarantino worked with this editor, Sally Menke.
- 37:42They had a great relationship. She passes away and then I think
- 37:45from Inglourious Basterds on or maybe Inglourious Basterds was
- 37:49their last collaboration. But it's it's worth noting that
- 37:52his movies continually get longer since that point too.
- 37:55I think he probably has more input in the edit.
- 37:57This is edited differently than any Tarantino movie.
- 38:00It has almost, forgive me for this, Noah, but it has like
- 38:04Family Guy style cutaways at at points in ways that are like
- 38:09anathema to what I'm used to seeing in Tarantino.
- 38:12You know, somebody at one point he pulls out the acid cigarette
- 38:15and he goes, where'd you get that?
- 38:16And he goes, oh, I got it from some hippie.
- 38:17And then they just show him buying it from the hippie and
- 38:20they cut right back to the scene again.
- 38:22It's a completely, once again, it's an unnecessary cutaway.
- 38:26I'm with you guys in that it's a vibes movie.
- 38:29But I think what I'm bucking up against is that for all of his
- 38:33really Florida writing, sometimes, especially with his
- 38:36dialogue, there's always been like an economy to a Tarantino
- 38:39movie. Like, Reservoir Dogs is an hour
- 38:41and a half long and this, this is by far his least economic
- 38:47writing. And I think that that's like it.
- 38:49It really sticks out like a sore thumb among his filmography for
- 38:52me. Brad.
- 38:54Dude, I, I just, I never once thought to myself, man, it, it
- 39:00when's this movie going to be over?
- 39:02Which like. I thought, could this please go
- 39:04on forever? That's what I think.
- 39:06Yeah, I wanted to spend so much time with Cliff and Rick that
- 39:11like even when Rick I I don't know how he manages this when he
- 39:17is talking to Jay Sebring about about what happened and he and
- 39:23he's. Like and the.
- 39:24And the last one, I, well, I, I don't know how to say this, but
- 39:27I, he's a flamethrower, Jay. I don't know how.
- 39:33He's like, I roasted her or something and he's like, you
- 39:36roasted her? He's like, yeah, I got that
- 39:37flame thriller and. Then he just looks at me.
- 39:40He goes, yeah, the 14 cliffs of what?
- 39:42What should we call it? There's a great like the facial
- 39:47expression on Leo. It is so earnest.
- 39:50There's a cut to him when Sharon Tate is talking to him through
- 39:54the teleprompter, the teleprompter through the like
- 39:56the PA system and just says, well, is everybody OK?
- 40:00And he goes. Well, can hit these aren't, I
- 40:03could tell you that much. Oh, it's so good, guys.
- 40:08I think this is probably a good place for us to hit pause.
- 40:10We've been stepping all over Noah's list of theories here, so
- 40:14we'll come back. We'll listen to theory #2 after
- 40:16the break. Brad, it's time for us to drink
- 40:18some whiskey. What do you say?
- 40:20Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 40:28checking out for the second time this season Brad Eagle Rare 17
- 40:33year that. Might be the craziest sentence
- 40:38that has ever been uttered in this podcast history.
- 40:40It took us like, what, nine seasons to even try it?
- 40:43And then we got it twice in one season.
- 40:44We we've apparently gotten inside the good graces of
- 40:48Buffalo Trace, despite all the things Brad has said about them
- 40:51over the years. I I don't know what you're
- 40:53talking about, Bob. And they've sent us a sample of
- 40:56Eagle Rare 17. I think back in like January, it
- 40:59came in and we were way down the distribution list.
- 41:01So we got it kind of after that initial rush, we've been sitting
- 41:04on it for a while because at first it was like, do we want to
- 41:07do the same whiskey twice in one season?
- 41:10We typically don't do the same whiskey twice ever.
- 41:12But again, folks, this is B.Tech.
- 41:14This is some of the most sought after whiskey in the world.
- 41:17I kind of feel like, Brad, if we're going to be like do our
- 41:20due diligence here, then we have to go all in and and try this
- 41:24whiskey. And this is a service that we do
- 41:26for you folks. It's it's hard work, but
- 41:28someone's got to do it. Yeah, we, we take our task very
- 41:33seriously and and we will sacrifice on your behalf.
- 41:39Now the 2023 batch. So what?
- 41:42Let me say this, this is the 2024 batch.
- 41:44It just came out in the fall. We tried 2023 earlier this
- 41:48season and that proved to be one of the best whiskey's Brad has
- 41:51ever drank. On this podcast.
- 41:53I'm looking at your scores, Brad.
- 41:55You gave it a 45.5 out of 50, so a 91 out of 100.
- 42:01This one has some big shoes to fill, a lot to live up to here.
- 42:05It does of course clock in at 17 years, this one specifically 17
- 42:10years, four months. There's some really cool things
- 42:13that Buffalo Trace does with the fact sheets they send out with B
- 42:16Tac it like including the evaporation loss on every one of
- 42:21the B tacs because they're so well aged.
- 42:23This batch had an evaporation loss of 86%, so only 14% of the
- 42:29whiskey that went into the barrels that made this blend up
- 42:32was remaining when they actually blended it together.
- 42:34That's insane dude. I can't imagine a world where
- 42:40you put liquid in at 100% full, the barrels completely full, and
- 42:46there's only 14% left. That's like.
- 42:52That is mind boggling to me. How frustrating that has to be
- 42:58as a distiller. Yeah, like that's insane, dude.
- 43:01I can't imagine how hazmat this was in the barrel before they
- 43:04proved. It down.
- 43:05Oh my. 201 proof, like it had to be in the one 40s at least,
- 43:10dude, minimum. All right, let's dive in.
- 43:13Brad, I am picking up on the nose here and I'm drinking this
- 43:16live. Brad's already tried it.
- 43:18I don't know if it's this Glencairn I've been using, but
- 43:20I've been using a Glencairn from our friends at Doc Swinson's
- 43:23that they branded and sent to us a long time ago.
- 43:26And it's got a like a, a, just a little bit of a wider kind of
- 43:30bell curve to it than the one that I had been using for the
- 43:33last season or so. One of them curvy Glens.
- 43:36Oh. Dude it is thick with two CS
- 43:38daddy and listen it. It really adds a perfumey note
- 43:42to most of what I've been drinking.
- 43:44It's like almost a Cologne type note.
- 43:47So like I, I wasn't expecting to stick my nose in this and get
- 43:50notes of Old Spice, but there's there, there's something going
- 43:53on here that is both like perfumey floral and a little bit
- 43:57Old Spice, like Old Man Cologne and it is really throwing me
- 44:00off. That's the first thing I
- 44:02noticed. I'm going to dive in.
- 44:03Brad, why don't you keep giving your nosing notes while I figure
- 44:06out what's going on over here? Are you sure you didn't like
- 44:09accidentally spray that glencairn with Cologne and then
- 44:13like like bake it in somehow? That's actually how I test all
- 44:16my colognes is I'm like, I'm going to spray the inside of
- 44:18this glass first before I put it on my body.
- 44:20Yeah, yeah. Yeah, give it a nice Kentucky
- 44:22chew. Oh yeah.
- 44:26Bob, the nose on this Eagle Rear 17 is wild and complex.
- 44:33There is cranberry there. It's got a really nice bready
- 44:39flavor to it that there's a bit of like a chocolate cacao nibs.
- 44:45There's caramel. I I think that this has a lot of
- 44:49really nice fresh notes about it.
- 44:52I'm going to give it an 8 1/2 out of 10 here.
- 44:54I'm going to give it a nine. I I can't get past these
- 44:56perfumey notes, Brad, but they are like kind of dancing above
- 45:01all of the notes that you had here.
- 45:02It's a classic bourbon with a little bit of that kind of dusty
- 45:06floral. Noah's Mill, you know, will it
- 45:10funk a bit? It does have some really tart
- 45:13Berry notes as well. I like this a lot.
- 45:15And I think that I'm already on board with this to the extent
- 45:18that I can remember the 2023 version.
- 45:21I'm on board with this more than that already just because this
- 45:24seems like it's going to go to some interesting places.
- 45:26Yeah. Yeah, I, I mean, I think for me,
- 45:28the palate has a lot of really nice things going on.
- 45:32It's got a bit of like a a Baker's chocolate.
- 45:35There's cinnamon, it's got Graham cracker there.
- 45:39There's a bit of like a mixed Berry tart light.
- 45:43Like you get a little bit of that pastry flakiness along with
- 45:48like a really nice tart mixed Berry.
- 45:51I'm going to give it a nine out of 10 on the palate, Bob, this
- 45:53is delicious. Yeah, I agree.
- 45:55And Eagle Rare has always been in that kind of like spicy range
- 46:00where I prefer my weeded bourbons.
- 46:02I prefer my bourbons a little more mellow.
- 46:05Eagle Rare is definitely it packs that peppery punch, and
- 46:08this one does too. I'm you can tell how much my
- 46:11mouth is watering. I think it's really prickly on
- 46:14the palate. It it drinks hotter than 101
- 46:16proof, but that doesn't mean that it's unpleasant by any
- 46:18stretch. For me, the note that I'm
- 46:20getting on top of all this is a really fresh ripe Peach, like
- 46:26it's it's got Peaches for days. It tastes like a summertime
- 46:30whiskey to me. I am really digging this man.
- 46:32It's it's the classic eagle rare notes with just a little bit
- 46:36more of an oak punch, but not over oaked and not char and not
- 46:41ashy. And then you get this great
- 46:44summer stone fruit thing going on top of it.
- 46:46I'm going to give it a nine once again.
- 46:48I think the finish is where this one really stands out.
- 46:51The the oakiness stands in and gives it like a firm foundation.
- 46:56It gets into those really nice pepper places.
- 46:59The cranberry really comes through on the finish.
- 47:03It reminds me of like a baked oatmeal with like a mixed Berry
- 47:09yogurt on top of it. I really like the finish a ton.
- 47:14I'm going to give it a nine and a half.
- 47:16Yeah, I'm going to come down just a little bit to an 8 1/2.
- 47:18I actually really love the flavors here, but it's just not
- 47:20quite as long lasting. And when you said yogurt, I
- 47:24think what's actually lacking for me here is like a sense of
- 47:27creaminess or oiliness or anything that kind of gives that
- 47:30lasting like coat your tongue impression.
- 47:34This one gets a little bit thin. And I mean thin in that like the
- 47:38ethanol kind of lingers a little bit and it makes the finish
- 47:41dissipate more quickly. It's still a really good finish,
- 47:45but I think for me, I do wish it had a little bit more like
- 47:48creaminess, flabbiness to it here.
- 47:50So it's an 8 1/2 for me. You know you like them, flabby
- 47:54baby. How many times do I have to tell
- 47:56you? Yes, we all know that.
- 48:00Proudly. Oh my goodness.
- 48:03Moving on from that, I think, I think balance wise this is a
- 48:07nine out of 10. Like there is complexity of
- 48:10flavor. There is all sorts of really
- 48:13interesting notes that work incredibly well together.
- 48:17It's a nine out of 10 for me on balance.
- 48:19I think I'm going to be in the same spot, Brad.
- 48:20I, I actually feel like I like this whiskey more than a nine in
- 48:25almost all these categories. But being objective about it,
- 48:29it's, it's not quite to the level of the like transcendent B
- 48:33tax we've had, but I do think this is probably better than any
- 48:37of the 2023 B tax. Like we went through that entire
- 48:41line up and I was in the 39 to 44 range and I feel like this is
- 48:47something that feels more special than any of those ones
- 48:51did to me. I, I think I'm not quite with
- 48:54you, Bob, that this one has amazing flavors.
- 48:58It is complex. It's deserving of the title of B
- 49:00Tac. I think that the 19 year Eagle
- 49:04rear 17 from last year just had more of a punch, more
- 49:08complexity, a little. It was a little more interesting
- 49:11of an experience and like deserving of the B Tac moniker.
- 49:17I think for me when it comes to value.
- 49:20And obviously folks, if you've been around filming whiskey for
- 49:23long enough, you know that once we hit like $250 plus we're
- 49:28talking luxury whiskeys now, I know that this is technically
- 49:32$150.00 MSRP. We can call this a luxury
- 49:37whiskey, can we not? Very fairly, yes.
- 49:40Yes. So in the world of luxury
- 49:43whiskey, I'm going to give this a 7 out of 10 on value.
- 49:47I like I think it's really, really good.
- 49:50It's not quite at the level of other Eagle Rare seventeens that
- 49:54I've had. And I I found myself at the end
- 49:57of the day wishing that this was like 111 proof instead of 101.
- 50:04I do think we really like whiskeys that fall between that
- 50:07one O 7 Weller proof point and then like the 1:14 one sixteens.
- 50:12That really does seem to be the sweet spot for us.
- 50:14Brad, I'm going to do something before I give my value score.
- 50:17I just looked behind me on the shelf and I have literally 1 sip
- 50:21left of the 19 year from 2023 and I want to try it just to see
- 50:26which one I like better. If you will indulge me for just
- 50:28a minute. Yeah, have at it man.
- 50:30I, I love that 19 year. I think, I think this is like
- 50:35the fascinating element of B TAC, though, is like they've
- 50:40created this like elite culture where you, if you want to be in
- 50:47the know, you have to get every single year at least one of the
- 50:51five bottles. And I that's like what I hate
- 50:54about B TAC. But it does make for an
- 50:57interesting experience where you can compare and contrast the
- 51:00different years and releases of the whiskey.
- 51:03I mean, how many people who are huge sport fans don't spend time
- 51:08debating like which version of your favorite team would win
- 51:12the, you know, the 80s championship winning team or the
- 51:152000s team that almost won a championship?
- 51:18Like who would have won? Like, you know, I I think all
- 51:21the time about the 2019 Buckeyes and how they should have beaten
- 51:25Clemson and won the national championship, right?
- 51:29I appreciate you vamping so much for me to take this sip.
- 51:31Oh, I. I'm back.
- 51:32I'm ready to to dive in The the 2023 is definitely like 10 times
- 51:39more viscous and syrupy and it has almost like a a really dark
- 51:44wine grape character to it. But it tips way too bitter at
- 51:49the back end. It actually, I don't know if
- 51:50maybe just because of this sample bottle having so little
- 51:53in it, maybe it got a little oxidized.
- 51:55It was like unpleasantly bitter for me.
- 51:58I definitely prefer this new one, but I can see how people
- 52:02who enjoy the sort of thing I just drank in the 23 would like
- 52:06that one better because it does feel more like a it.
- 52:10It feels like a luxury bourbon on the tongue, where this one
- 52:13just feels like a really good bourbon.
- 52:15Feels like it has the elbow patches on its sports jacket.
- 52:20Very much so. All right, So I'm going to go
- 52:21ahead and give this a 7 1/2 on value, Brad.
- 52:25That's taking me to a very high 43 out of 50.
- 52:29Where are you falling on this one?
- 52:32I am at a 43 out of 50 Bob. After saying that it doesn't
- 52:37achieve the heights you know. Yeah, well, it doesn't.
- 52:40I, I, I would say for the level of notoriety that B.Tech has, it
- 52:47needs to hit 45 out of 50 for me to say, yeah, this is worth it.
- 52:53Yeah, You know what I mean. Like so you would call this just
- 52:56by that definition, a disappointing B.Tech?
- 53:00I think so. Interesting.
- 53:02Yeah, I like and that's that is all to say this is a 43 out of
- 53:0850 folks. It's an incredible whiskey
- 53:12compared to the heights of B Tac that you know, some of the stags
- 53:15that we've had the the like dude, the Thomas H Handy, like
- 53:22those are the peaks, the the beautiful mountain tops of AB
- 53:28Tac experience. And I hate to say this, Bob,
- 53:31because I like eagle rear 17 was my Unicorn for years and years
- 53:34and years. I think the eagle rear night,
- 53:38the 2023 edition, I think hits that level of wow factor to make
- 53:45it worth it. I don't think the 2024 edition
- 53:47does all right. Well, folks, there you have it.
- 53:50We're coming out to the exact same score, but for me it's an
- 53:53achievement and for Brad this is a let down.
- 53:56So take do it that what you will.
- 53:58It's still coming out to an 86 out of 100 or a 43 out of 50.
- 54:02Brad, would you recommend trying or buying B Tac Eagle Rare
- 54:0717/20/24? If you have a choice between
- 54:13this and other B tacs or even other Eagle Rare seventeens, I
- 54:18think I would say move elsewhere.
- 54:23If this is your only choice and you know, you're like, wow, do I
- 54:26want to spend 40 bucks on this? I do think it's a really good
- 54:30pour. Like, I don't know, I'm not
- 54:33going to tell you how to spend your money.
- 54:34You figure it out. All right, man, what do you say
- 54:37we rejoin our friend Noah Gatel and keep talking about Once Upon
- 54:40a Time in Hollywood? Let's get to it.
- 54:48All right, everybody, that was Eagle Rare 17, a whiskey that
- 54:52Bob and I ranked almost exactly the same.
- 54:55Oh, or exactly the same. Were we both at a 43?
- 54:58We, I think one of us was at a 43 and a half, one of us was at
- 55:01a 43. Beautiful.
- 55:03And you said only negative things about it, and I said only
- 55:06positive things. Somehow I don't think that's
- 55:12where we're going to end up today with the movie, though,
- 55:14Bob. Yeah, not so much, man.
- 55:16But it it, it might be where we end up with our next segment,
- 55:18which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 55:21Brad is going to try to stump your ball. 2 are right and what
- 55:28is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 55:32and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 55:34with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 55:38which is a complete lie and I need to figure out which one
- 55:41that is. Brad, I'm coming off of some
- 55:45some ups and downs these last few weeks.
- 55:48Luckily I have a guest here for the first time in a little
- 55:50while. Noah, the way this works is that
- 55:52if I tap you in to help me answer and we lose, I get
- 55:57credited with two losses on the week, but only one victory if we
- 56:01win. So Brad, this, this is his way
- 56:04of trying to like get back at me because I'm not going to just
- 56:06like not engage with you, not going to ignore you.
- 56:10So be prepared to take me down here and give me two losses.
- 56:14I really hope you know more about this movie than me, is
- 56:16what I'm saying. I believe the last two times I
- 56:19have helped you with this we have lost, so maybe the third
- 56:22time will be the charm. Noah.
- 56:24Come on man. Fact #1 Stuntman Cliff Booth was
- 56:30partially based on Jean LaBelle, a real stuntman, professional
- 56:34wrestler and two time national judo champion who came to work
- 56:38on the Green Hornet after complaints by other stunt
- 56:41performers that Bruce Lee was, quote, kicking the shit out of
- 56:45the stuntman. Like Booth, LaBelle was
- 56:48suspected of murder but never convicted.
- 56:52Fact #2 The controversial scene where Cliff Booth fights Bruce
- 56:56Lee was originally a 7 minute showdown, but test audiences
- 57:00thought it was too epic and it overshadowed the rest of the
- 57:02movie. Fact #3 When Sharon goes to a
- 57:06showing of her movie The Wrecking Crew from 1968, the
- 57:10film makers chose to use the actual film rather than
- 57:12recreating the scenes with Robbie.
- 57:14The real Sharon Tate briefly does appear on screen.
- 57:19All right, I I was typing something during fact #2 what
- 57:22was the showdown was what, 2 minutes long?
- 57:25Bob that, that. No, no, no, no, no problem.
- 57:27Hey, listen man, one of us has to take notes to make these
- 57:30episodes coherent. What's fact?
- 57:33#2 Brad The fight scene was originally like a 7 minute
- 57:37showdown. But it got the fight with Bruce
- 57:39Lee. Yes, sorry, the Cliff, Cliff and
- 57:42Bruce fight, OK. Noah I mean, I think it's got to
- 57:46either be one or two like that's.
- 57:49I think I've got. This one I'm.
- 57:50Sorry to say I'm really reticent to say, but I think I got this
- 57:54one. All right.
- 57:55Well, let me let me turn it over to you here.
- 57:56I think it's #2 and I'll tell you why.
- 57:59I mean, I know, I know the well, Brad just made a weird face.
- 58:02Now I'm not so sure. That's just his face, don't
- 58:06worry. I know the character is based on
- 58:11a real stuntman. I don't know the name of that
- 58:13stuntman, but it would not surprise me if it was some
- 58:17obscure person I've never heard of.
- 58:19How many stuntmen have I actually?
- 58:20Heard of? Are you also insinuating that
- 58:23stuntmen are just, you know, murderers that don't get
- 58:26convicted? Some of them, perhaps.
- 58:29Some of them, yes, and here's why #2 just strikes me as false.
- 58:37I just don't think Tarantino would trim down a scene that he
- 58:41loved because audiences felt it throughout the pace of the
- 58:44movie. Not a Bruce Lee Brad Pitt bites.
- 58:50I don't buy it. I mean, as we know, this movie
- 58:53is famous for its impeccable pacing anyway.
- 58:56So yeah, I think I'm going to be with you.
- 59:01Noah. Listen, if we're going to go
- 59:02down, we'll go down together. Brad.
- 59:04I will say with Noah that number 2 is the falsehood.
- 59:09Gentlemen, you are 100% correct. Yes, that is.
- 59:14The fault finally broke the street.
- 59:16As soon as I read the words test audiences, I was like, oh,
- 59:20Tarantino wouldn't give a shit about his audiences.
- 59:22Why did I write that? Come on, Brad.
- 59:25Yeah. That's great, man, honestly,
- 59:27Noah, I Bob said that he was typing and I was like, maybe he
- 59:31maybe he missed the test audiences thing.
- 59:33Not me, buddy. See, that's why we bring in a
- 59:37guest. All right, Noah, we have been
- 59:42stepping all over your list of theories here on why this movie
- 59:46is the way that it is. I'd love to hear theory #2 if
- 59:49you'd be so kind. All right, Well, look.
- 59:52Two or three, did we? Did we get OK?
- 59:57I'm going to sort of combine 2, which is this movie is
- 1:00:01regressive as like this this movie when I think about the
- 1:00:07politics of this movie. I like it less because so this
- 1:00:14is essentially a movie of Cowboys versus hippies, right?
- 1:00:17Like Dalton's a cowboy on screen.
- 1:00:20Cliff Booth is kind of a real cowboy.
- 1:00:22Like what that would really be like off screen.
- 1:00:23He's an actual hero and a murderer.
- 1:00:27And the cowboy versus hippie dialectic has been part of
- 1:00:31American politics for like 60 years.
- 1:00:34Like a really big part of American politics for 60 years
- 1:00:38is the reason Ronald Reagan wanted to be seen on his ranch
- 1:00:42all the time. I mean, he was an actual Western
- 1:00:44star, but he understood that the power of that image.
- 1:00:46And George W Bush, same thing, always off clear and brush on
- 1:00:50his ranch or whatever, whatever he was doing down there.
- 1:00:53And, you know, the cowboy is a traditional alpha male.
- 1:00:57And that's certainly those are some values that are associated
- 1:01:01with one side of the political divide.
- 1:01:04And then the hippies, you know, have been used as a scapegoat
- 1:01:07for, you know, so many things by the right towards the left.
- 1:01:11Even these days when they talk about, you know, crime in inner
- 1:01:15cities, like, or in how disgusting New York is, things
- 1:01:18like that, that it that Harkins back to the like, you know,
- 1:01:21liberals are hippies, hippies are an American hippies are
- 1:01:24criminals. Like this has been part, a huge
- 1:01:27part of the American discourse, political discourse for years.
- 1:01:31And in this movie, it plays out right.
- 1:01:33It is hippies versus Cowboys. And he picks this moment in time
- 1:01:39and he makes the hippies, he picks the worst possible hippies
- 1:01:43to represent hippiedum in this movie, the ones who were actual
- 1:01:48murderers. Like that is that is tipping the
- 1:01:52scales. That is putting your thumb on
- 1:01:53the scales in a major, major way.
- 1:01:56And on the other side, you've got Rick Dalton, who, you know,
- 1:01:59I think Tarantino's knowing about the fact that he's not a
- 1:02:02real cowboy. He's a fake cowboy.
- 1:02:04But you've got Cliff Booth, who is a wife killer.
- 1:02:08And yet we're rooting for him over the hill.
- 1:02:13OK. And that's another thing.
- 1:02:14That's another thing. I have another theory.
- 1:02:16I'm glad you said that. So we never see Cliff Booth kill
- 1:02:20his wife, right? I have had this whole theory at
- 1:02:23the time, I don't know how much I believe it anymore that that
- 1:02:25whole thing was meant to be Tarantino's comment on the ME.
- 1:02:28Too. Natalie Wood.
- 1:02:30Oh, I thought was Natalie Wood. OK, OK.
- 1:02:32No, it's definitely. Reference movement?
- 1:02:33Where? Where are you going with this
- 1:02:35man? Because this wasn't.
- 1:02:36I thought I had it pegged here. No, I think it's definitely
- 1:02:39referencing Natalie Wood. I think you're right about that.
- 1:02:40But you know, you got to remember this was 2019.
- 1:02:43He's writing it in 2017. He's shooting in 2018.
- 1:02:45This is right in the wake of the Me Too movement.
- 1:02:47Like, a lot of stuff is still coming out in this era.
- 1:02:49And here we've got a a figure in movies who is accused of a
- 1:02:56violence against a woman and his career is suffering as a result
- 1:03:00of it. And nobody knows what happened
- 1:03:03because nobody else was there. And Tarantino doesn't show it to
- 1:03:06us. He lets us see like everything
- 1:03:09up until the moment and lets us form our own own conclusions.
- 1:03:13And I thought that was an incredible provocation at the
- 1:03:16time, like, you know, trying to just touch on the the mood of of
- 1:03:20the moment and provoke us and make us think about this sort of
- 1:03:23thing until I read the book and I saw that don't know Cliff
- 1:03:26Booth totally, completely brutally killed his wife.
- 1:03:31But it ties into the overall theory, which is like he's
- 1:03:34totally he's stacking the deck for the heroes, but in which is
- 1:03:39normal in a movie. But in this case, in the in the
- 1:03:42context of the cowboy hippie dialectic, I think it's really
- 1:03:45kind of politically problematic. And I don't think that team is
- 1:03:49aware of any of this, but. A a couple things that I'll say
- 1:03:52on that. This most recent theory you just
- 1:03:54shared. I, I agree with you.
- 1:03:56And I think that looking at his movie prior to this, The Hateful
- 1:04:008, which is a movie we haven't even talked about, which I, I
- 1:04:02actually think might be his worst movie, if I'm being
- 1:04:04honest. Like, I'd like it less than this
- 1:04:08in that it's mediocre, but I've always viewed that movie and
- 1:04:13essentially as Tarantino's summation of his thoughts on
- 1:04:17race relations in the United States.
- 1:04:19There is like this central letter from Abraham Lincoln that
- 1:04:23is established very early on to be bullshit.
- 1:04:25And inside that letter is all of the platitudes that we
- 1:04:30consistently like parrot in the United States about how to get
- 1:04:34along and respect each other. And the way that movie ends is
- 1:04:38like, everyone's out for their own survival.
- 1:04:41We're all trying to screw each other over.
- 1:04:44And the only way that the main black character and the main
- 1:04:47white character actually end up working together is
- 1:04:50acknowledging the inherent hypocrisy in each other and in
- 1:04:55the system. Like, it's a really cynical read
- 1:04:58on race relations. Sounds like a Coen Brothers
- 1:05:01movie. Yeah, I mean it.
- 1:05:01It kind of is in the way that it ends.
- 1:05:04So I don't think you're far off here with this potentially being
- 1:05:07his comment on the Me Too movement because, you know,
- 1:05:09Hateful 8 comes out in the wake of so many, you know, police
- 1:05:13shootings and everything else in that political climate.
- 1:05:16I I really do think that there might be something there.
- 1:05:18And I think it's notable that he cast Emil Hersh in this movie,
- 1:05:20who was persona non grata at the time because he strangled a a a
- 1:05:25female executive, a movie executive.
- 1:05:27And he hasn't really worked since then in a mainstream
- 1:05:29movie. So it does seem like I don't
- 1:05:31know if Tarantino's commenting on me too movement or he's
- 1:05:34opposing cancel culture. I mean, I think that's all on
- 1:05:37the table for him based on what I see in the film and.
- 1:05:40I think you're caught you're Cowboys versus hippies comment
- 1:05:44too. It's interesting that you know
- 1:05:46Tarantino's favorite movie of all time is The Good, the Bad
- 1:05:49and the Ugly. He loves spaghetti westerns.
- 1:05:51He's on record saying this. So yes, it makes sense that he's
- 1:05:54going to send Rick Dalton to go be in a bunch of spaghetti
- 1:05:56westerns. It's interesting, though, that,
- 1:05:58like, he doesn't see the upheaval of the Western genre as
- 1:06:04part of the hippie part of on the hippie side of the equation.
- 1:06:07Like, at the end of the day, even though Rick is hesitant to
- 1:06:10be in these movies, he goes and does it.
- 1:06:12And then like, it is brought into the fold of Rick's side of
- 1:06:17things, which is like championing good classic
- 1:06:20Hollywood, the past, you know, not the future, not this
- 1:06:23ruination of this beautiful thing that we have.
- 1:06:26So yeah, I I think there's a lot to unpack there for sure do.
- 1:06:28You think is the good man, the ugly, supposed to exist in this
- 1:06:31world? Because Rick Dalton says very
- 1:06:34disparaging things about Italian westerns.
- 1:06:37But this is 1969. I mean, the whole Mam and No
- 1:06:39Name trilogy has come out already by this point.
- 1:06:42That always struck me as a little strange.
- 1:06:44All I know is that they say that the the director he's working
- 1:06:47with is acknowledged as the second best director of
- 1:06:49spaghetti westerns. So I assumed that like, it's got
- 1:06:52to be Leone, right? And it's possible that Dalton is
- 1:06:56just an idiot and doesn't know that.
- 1:06:57Like they're actually great spaghetti westerns.
- 1:07:01That 100% tracks. You know, the more I think about
- 1:07:04it, I don't know if I want to spoil my let's make it a double,
- 1:07:07but this would be such a weird let's make it a double that I, I
- 1:07:09think I'll say it now. You guys keep talking about the
- 1:07:12Sharon Tate character and I, you know, deep down, if I'm being
- 1:07:16honest, I think this is a waste of Margot Robbie.
- 1:07:18I'm I'm sorry, guys, She's barely in the movie.
- 1:07:20She does nothing. I love Margot Robbie to death.
- 1:07:22This character is a nothing burger.
- 1:07:24But I think it's really interesting how Tarantino is
- 1:07:28using Sharon Tate, the person as a symbol, a symbol for like, the
- 1:07:35lost innocence of Hollywood. Like, that her murder was a
- 1:07:39turning point in Hollywood, both as an industry and as like, a
- 1:07:43community, a real geographic community.
- 1:07:46And that by correcting the wrong of her murders that, you know,
- 1:07:50we we've now set Hollywood back on its idyllic course.
- 1:07:54And I think like, if there's something that that reminds me
- 1:07:56of, it's the song American Pie by Don McLean, where he, he
- 1:08:01pinpoints this, you know, the day the music died, where the
- 1:08:03plane crash happened and Rock'n'roll died as like the
- 1:08:07moment that a generation of people lost their innocence.
- 1:08:10I I find it really fascinating that like you said, 6 year old
- 1:08:14Tarantino would pinpoint this this thing that happened as like
- 1:08:18the turning point moment in Hollywood.
- 1:08:20Well, I do think historians have sort of cited this and the
- 1:08:25Zodiac killer as well as like the two the moment the hippie
- 1:08:29wave sort of turned dark, you know, when it when it crested as
- 1:08:33as Hunter Thompson said. So I don't think he came up with
- 1:08:36that on his own necessarily. I feel like that's been that's
- 1:08:39been discussed before, but on the on the, on the Sharon Tate
- 1:08:43point, you know, I don't see it as a waste of her.
- 1:08:46Like, I, I understand where you're coming from.
- 1:08:48Like it's not, there's no character there.
- 1:08:49Like she's just an Angel. It's completely one-dimensional.
- 1:08:53But there aren't that many actors who could do what she
- 1:08:55does in that movie theater scene, you know, where you
- 1:08:58could, she could sit there and be goofy and insecure and
- 1:09:02gorgeous and like have you be right there along with her.
- 1:09:04That is a it's a rare gift, I think.
- 1:09:07So I give her credit for that. And I do think the character has
- 1:09:10a purpose. I mean, Brad alluded to this
- 1:09:12earlier, but if there is an idea in the end of this movie, I
- 1:09:16think it's that as Rick's time was ending, there's two ways it
- 1:09:21could go. You know, there's the really
- 1:09:23dark way, which is the way it went.
- 1:09:26That's what could happen to Hollywood.
- 1:09:28The Manson Family could like that, could be the new character
- 1:09:31of this place that Tarantino loves, or there could be these
- 1:09:34young, hip, beautiful people like Sharon Tate who could be
- 1:09:37the next wave. And in this movie, Rick Dalton
- 1:09:42kills the bad way and saves the good way.
- 1:09:44And so I don't think the movie would make much sense if that
- 1:09:46character were not involved to that degree.
- 1:09:50Brad, it occurs to me that we are like almost at the one hour
- 1:09:53and 10 minute mark or whatever here.
- 1:09:54We really haven't talked about like the actors or the the if we
- 1:09:57thought they did a good job in the movie.
- 1:10:00Brad Pitt do so good. Listen, Brad Pitt wins an Oscar.
- 1:10:04Brad Pitt's phenomenal in this movie.
- 1:10:06No, I'd love to get your thoughts.
- 1:10:08We've had Brad Pitt on a couple times this season.
- 1:10:10This might actually be his third appearance.
- 1:10:13Yeah, he's guested on this show quite a few times.
- 1:10:17Brad Pitt has started doing, it's like the He's challenging
- 1:10:21himself to play every character more and more understated, which
- 1:10:25is like really rare for a MW star of his caliber.
- 1:10:31Moneyball, I think kind of being like the apex of that where it's
- 1:10:33just like, I don't know if he was just sleepy on set or if
- 1:10:36he's really doing an understated thing.
- 1:10:38He kind of does it here too. I I'm wondering what you think
- 1:10:41of like 21st century pit as opposed to 90s movie star pit.
- 1:10:47Well, let me of of Moneyball, of which I I know a few things.
- 1:10:50Let me say that people who know Billy Beane well say Brad Pitt's
- 1:10:55performance was uncanny. So I don't know how much of A,
- 1:11:00you know, low energy thing it was or if it was really him just
- 1:11:03kind of matching the tenor of that particular person.
- 1:11:05Got it, Got it. You know, when I think of his
- 1:11:08earlier performances, I mean, I all actors have more energy when
- 1:11:12they're younger, I think. So Thelma and Louise and 12
- 1:11:15Monkeys, which is like a very energetic performance, you know,
- 1:11:20that's that's a young actor really trying to make a name for
- 1:11:23himself. And it worked.
- 1:11:24You know, he became a star with one and he got Oscar nominated
- 1:11:27for the other. But, you know, Brad Pitt's 61
- 1:11:30years old now. I mean, he's older than Paul
- 1:11:34Newman when he did The Color of Money.
- 1:11:36And I don't think it's unusual for a movie star to settle down
- 1:11:40a little bit as they get older. And I don't know, Brad Pitt, I
- 1:11:43don't know if his personality has settled down or not.
- 1:11:45I've there've been some stories in the press that maybe, maybe
- 1:11:48not, but I don't I think it's, I think it's good and normal and
- 1:11:54natural for a movie star of his age to settle down.
- 1:11:56Frankly, I would I'd rather see him make doing more performances
- 1:11:59like this. And and if you were like,
- 1:12:01whatever Ferrari is or not Ferrari, the F1 movie that's
- 1:12:04coming out soon is going to be because that doesn't look at all
- 1:12:07interesting to me personally. But on the other hand, you know,
- 1:12:10I think it's worth noting that he also is doing more kind of
- 1:12:13action than he's done in a while.
- 1:12:15Like he did this movie, which has some actual action scenes in
- 1:12:19it, real physicality for him. And he did bullet train, you
- 1:12:22know, not around this time as well.
- 1:12:25So I think he's still doing unusual, like varied things,
- 1:12:28which is sort of what he's always done in his career.
- 1:12:32I, I think Brad Pitt is perfect in this movie.
- 1:12:36I think that was like my main take away.
- 1:12:38I loved the, the juxtaposition of DiCaprio and Pit in this
- 1:12:44movie that they're both kind of the same person, but just like
- 1:12:48the yin and the Yang of each other.
- 1:12:51And I like, I think Tarantino just wrote two fascinating
- 1:12:55characters. The the thing I loved about the
- 1:12:57two of them together was that it wasn't until about halfway
- 1:13:01through the movie that I was like, oh, they actually just
- 1:13:04genuinely really like each other.
- 1:13:06Like their characters really like each other.
- 1:13:09Like, he does such a great job of setting them up as, you know,
- 1:13:14the movie star and the entourage of a fading movie star.
- 1:13:21And yet by the end of it, you realize you're like, oh, these
- 1:13:23guys just genuinely really love each other and they understand
- 1:13:28their roles in relation to each other and, and I think both of
- 1:13:32them like pull off that dynamic perfectly.
- 1:13:36You know, the scene that you're making me think of is when they
- 1:13:40get home and he says to him, do you want to come in and watch my
- 1:13:44FBI with me? And he goes, oh, I just figured
- 1:13:46we would. I got a six pack in the back and
- 1:13:49we're going to order a pizza. And then they sit there and do,
- 1:13:51like, a director's commentary of that episode.
- 1:13:54And I love the moment when when Rick Dalton appears on screen in
- 1:13:59the TV show and you just hear Cliff Booth say something like,
- 1:14:02oh, here comes trouble. And you just know these guys
- 1:14:06love each other. I've never seen anything like
- 1:14:08that in the Tarantino movie. Well, and then like again, you
- 1:14:11get a really sweet moment at the end where they're putting Brad
- 1:14:13Pitt into the ambulance and like through the closed door, Leo
- 1:14:17just says like, hey, you're a really good friend.
- 1:14:21And I was like, aw, I can't believe that.
- 1:14:23Like there's, there's no snark, there's no irony to it at all.
- 1:14:26It's a, it's a truly genuine earnest moment, which I don't
- 1:14:30think Tarantino is a supremely confident person.
- 1:14:33I think we've established that. I, I don't know if he would have
- 1:14:36had the self-confidence to put a moment like that in a movie in
- 1:14:39the 90s and, and just let it sit there without commentary.
- 1:14:42It's it's a really beautiful moment.
- 1:14:44Do you think that there's a bit of meta commentary there on Brad
- 1:14:47Pitt's career that he asks for bagels?
- 1:14:50He's like, hey, I haven't been seen eating food a single moment
- 1:14:55in this movie. I need you to bring me.
- 1:14:59Food I can't get out of here man without eating a carb.
- 1:15:03I need it. Well, you know, DiCaprio
- 1:15:07improvised the whole scene in the trailer and that's a very
- 1:15:09rare thing that people are allowed to improvise in
- 1:15:11Tarantino movies. So maybe Pitt improvised the the
- 1:15:14bagel line as well. All right, Noah, any outstanding
- 1:15:20theories on why the movie is the way it is?
- 1:15:23No, but I forgot to mention in the whole Me Too movement thing
- 1:15:27that like Roman, Polanski plays a significant role in this film
- 1:15:30as well. I I was, I didn't get around to
- 1:15:33saying it, but I was like, man, we're talking about me too.
- 1:15:36And Roman Polanski is a huge part of this film.
- 1:15:39Totally innocent in this movie does does nothing wrong.
- 1:15:42No commentary upon anything he's done.
- 1:15:44I mean, if Sharon Tate did doesn't die.
- 1:15:47Yeah, I mean. That's true that that's that's
- 1:15:49maybe he prevents the whole, you know, the history of sexual
- 1:15:53assault and harassment in Hollywood from happening with
- 1:15:55this film. Yikes.
- 1:15:56It it probably never happens. Man, guys, I, I, it occurs to me
- 1:16:00that we haven't really talked about Leo, once again, a fixture
- 1:16:04of this season. Brad Leonardo DiCaprio.
- 1:16:07I don't know if this movie will ultimately be on his Mount
- 1:16:12Rushmore the way like The Wolf of Wall Street was.
- 1:16:14That's a bigger, flashier, showier, more outsized
- 1:16:17performance. But I will say that between that
- 1:16:21movie a few weeks ago and this movie, he is such an underrated
- 1:16:25comedic actor. He doesn't necessarily have like
- 1:16:28what I would consider great comedic timing, but he does that
- 1:16:32thing that really good actors who are in comedies can do.
- 1:16:35And I've already alluded to it. It's like he's so perfectly
- 1:16:38plays the earnestness of that character and, and gives that
- 1:16:43kind of dimwitted character so much heart that everything he
- 1:16:46does is funny as a result of that.
- 1:16:49And I'm glad that he's not trying to go broad and he's not
- 1:16:51trying to be the funny guy on screen.
- 1:16:53It's very much like, you know, when you watch De Niro in a
- 1:16:56movie like Midnight Run, like De Niro's funny as hell, but he's
- 1:16:59not trying to be a comedian. He's just being Robert De Niro.
- 1:17:02And I I really appreciate that about DiCaprio here.
- 1:17:05And he gets the biggest laugh line in the movie when he says,
- 1:17:10in 15 years, you're going to be living it, which I still
- 1:17:13remember in the theater. Seen this movie like Pack House.
- 1:17:18It's almost out of character. It's like a little too clever
- 1:17:20for Rick Dalton. But DiCaprio totally nails it.
- 1:17:24And you're right, he's not he's not turned it into a punchline.
- 1:17:27He's speaking from his own place of despair and and his deep
- 1:17:32knowledge of the industry and his cynicism about the world.
- 1:17:36And that's what makes it so funny.
- 1:17:37So I think that that completely speaks to your point, Bob.
- 1:17:40I I think one of the funniest moments for the character of
- 1:17:43Rick Dalton is when a 8 year old child like compliments his
- 1:17:49performance and he like starts crying as he reflects on how
- 1:17:54great he was. And then like you, the audience
- 1:17:58think about like I and like to be clear, it was a great moment
- 1:18:03of acting very good. Yeah, very, very good.
- 1:18:06But then you the audience go, yeah, it was a great moment of
- 1:18:09acting on some like C level TV show.
- 1:18:14And it just, oh, it's such a beautiful moment that made me
- 1:18:19laugh so hard. All right, guys, we've
- 1:18:23established that Brad Pitt is great and Leonardo DiCaprio is
- 1:18:25great, so we broke new ground here on this podcast today.
- 1:18:29Can we can we say Mikey Madison is great in this movie?
- 1:18:32Yes, yeah, let's yeah, let's talk about the Tarantino to
- 1:18:36Oscar nomination pipeline going on down the cast list here
- 1:18:40'cause you've got your Austin Butler's, you've got your Mikey
- 1:18:43Madison's. Like you said, Maya Hawk is in
- 1:18:46this movie. There's there's so many young
- 1:18:48stars that were kind of Sydney Sweeney, thank you very much,
- 1:18:51that we're catapulted to fame after this film.
- 1:18:55Former young stars Dakota Fanning.
- 1:18:57Yeah, listen, so we're recording this the Sunday after the
- 1:19:01Oscars. Mikey Madison has just won the
- 1:19:03Academy Award for Best Actress. And it's it's interesting
- 1:19:07because I was certainly not opposed to her winning.
- 1:19:10She was not who I thought was going to win.
- 1:19:12But I will say, if you didn't want to see Mikey Madison win an
- 1:19:15Oscar, then watching what happens to her in this movie,
- 1:19:20it's very interesting. Next step in that process.
- 1:19:24My God, Brad, I can't. I've never seen anything happen
- 1:19:29to the human body so badly in a Tarantino film.
- 1:19:32Does she receive the worst treatment of any Tarantino
- 1:19:38character? Because I mean to be brutalized
- 1:19:42by a Pitbull to be? Does she get shot or just
- 1:19:47stabbed? Or does her fat?
- 1:19:49I can't fully remember, it was such a blur.
- 1:19:52I do know that she ends up getting torched.
- 1:19:55Yep, by a flamethrower. She sure does.
- 1:19:58It's it's rough, man. I mean, what happens to all
- 1:20:01three of those individuals? You could.
- 1:20:05I mean, you could power rank the deaths if you wanted to.
- 1:20:08They're they're all really brutal deaths.
- 1:20:10I think it's the most like, to me, it's the most violent
- 1:20:13sequence in any Tarantino movie. And then because.
- 1:20:16Of how soft the rest of the movie.
- 1:20:18Has been exactly. And it's not like, you know,
- 1:20:22shooting Hitler in the chest 1000 times or something like
- 1:20:25that. This is a gentle movie in so
- 1:20:28many ways, and these deaths are deeply felt like when he is
- 1:20:32slamming the redhead's face against the mantle.
- 1:20:36I mean, it's it's. I mean you do the inhale like.
- 1:20:40You. Know yeah, it's it's rough.
- 1:20:42And yet I'm laughing at the same time.
- 1:20:44That's the amazing thing. Yeah, well, you are a twisted
- 1:20:49individual when? Austin Butler says I am the
- 1:20:53devil and I'm about the devil's work.
- 1:20:56Like and he just. The most terribly dark humor
- 1:21:01funny line because. That's, I mean, that's like on
- 1:21:04record as something that was said and then to have him
- 1:21:07undercut it with like, Nah, I was Dumber than that.
- 1:21:11And he said, and the booth repeats it later, the cops, he
- 1:21:14said I'm the devil and I'm here to do some devil shit.
- 1:21:17And. Then he goes.
- 1:21:19I don't think that's verbatim. All right, guys.
- 1:21:24On that note, I think it's time for our last segment of the day,
- 1:21:27which we call let's make it a double.
- 1:21:29We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 1:21:33the film and Whiskey show. Let's have another film with
- 1:21:36this one, even if it's struggle. It's a final segment of the day.
- 1:21:38Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is
- 1:21:41presented by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 1:21:44It's the part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with
- 1:21:47this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:21:50Now, I already suggested a plethora of I think we've all
- 1:21:53suggested movies here. Licorice Pizza.
- 1:21:56Was it the master? No, it wasn't the master.
- 1:21:58What was it? Phantom Thread, American Pie.
- 1:22:00There's a there's a ton of stuff we could pair this up with.
- 1:22:03Noah, you are our honored guest today.
- 1:22:06I'll give you first pick in. Let's make it a double.
- 1:22:09You know, with the Tarantino movie, there's like an endless
- 1:22:11array of options because he wears his influences on his
- 1:22:14sleeve. Obviously you could pick any one
- 1:22:16of the other Once Upon a Time in movies to pair it with.
- 1:22:20But I'm such a huge fan of Westerns, particularly neo
- 1:22:22Westerns. I love movies about, you know,
- 1:22:26aging gunslingers, people who represent a different era.
- 1:22:30And there were quite a few of them that came out in the the 20
- 1:22:32tens. And the movie that I would pair
- 1:22:35this with is Logan, which is I'm not a big comic book guy.
- 1:22:40I'm not a big superhero guy, but I love Logan because it is so
- 1:22:44true to the conventions of the Western.
- 1:22:48You know, I mean, you can go back to Shane.
- 1:22:49I mean, that's probably where all this starts.
- 1:22:51You know, a guy who's from a different time, from a different
- 1:22:53place coming in to defend civilization.
- 1:22:57But that's what Logan Wolverine is doing in that movie, and
- 1:22:59that's what Rick Dalton is doing in this movie.
- 1:23:01And they're both just phenomenal movies, so I would love to watch
- 1:23:05them in succession. You know, no, I hate to disagree
- 1:23:09with you, but Logan does not have a flamethrower and there's
- 1:23:12no hippies to burn. So I will say it guys.
- 1:23:16I've only seen. So I watched Logan with a group
- 1:23:19of friends who had all seen it and they wanted to watch the
- 1:23:23black and white version and so I watched that.
- 1:23:26I really enjoyed it. Do you think it's worth going
- 1:23:28back to watch the actual full color edition?
- 1:23:32I actually haven't seen the black and white, so I couldn't
- 1:23:34tell you, but I will say he he captures the color of westerns
- 1:23:39really well. Of course, there are a lot of
- 1:23:40great black and white westerns too, so perhaps.
- 1:23:43He also captures the color of gratuitous blood and gore quite
- 1:23:47well. Yeah, you could.
- 1:23:48That's what I was like curious about because I'm like black and
- 1:23:51white does not capture blood and gore quite the same.
- 1:23:54I think it would feel much more vivid overall in color.
- 1:23:57I would do it. I mean, it's a great movie.
- 1:23:59If you have to watch it again, then it's just OK.
- 1:24:02I don't think you know that's not a problem.
- 1:24:04All right, Brad, what's your? Let's make it a double today.
- 1:24:07You know, I with all of Tarantino's references to films
- 1:24:12of the past, along with it being a buddy, just get along with it.
- 1:24:18Have fun movie. I am going to pair this with the
- 1:24:22nice guys because I for the life of me, I like I grew up with
- 1:24:29like six or seven VH s s of Abbott and Costello.
- 1:24:35And when Ryan Gosling is like pounding his chest, I literally
- 1:24:40I I pulled a Leonardo DiCaprio and I like pointed at the screen
- 1:24:46and was like Lou Costello. Lou Costello.
- 1:24:49I've seen that before. And it was like a beautiful
- 1:24:52moment and I felt like a film nerd and I felt proud of myself.
- 1:24:56And I'm going to pair it with the nice guys.
- 1:24:59Both great LA. Movies, too.
- 1:25:00Yeah, very much so. You know, it's amazing to me we
- 1:25:02haven't talked about Robert Redford and Paul Newman at all,
- 1:25:06which this this movie was kind of billed as like this is the
- 1:25:10Newman and Redford movie of our generation and Brad Pitt.
- 1:25:13I feel like it's such an interesting combination of both
- 1:25:16Paul Newman and his demeanor and Robert Redford and his looks
- 1:25:20that like we could have gone with the sting.
- 1:25:22Brad, that's a great movie. Butch and Sundance would have
- 1:25:24been a great movie to pair this way.
- 1:25:25What a. Great film.
- 1:25:27I dude, I was so surprised by the sting, it was incredible.
- 1:25:31Oh, it's so entertaining, man. I'm actually going to go a
- 1:25:33little bit farther back with my let's make it a double.
- 1:25:35I'm going to say that, yes, this is Tarantino's western, but it's
- 1:25:39also Tarantino's riff on another classic Hollywood movie, a movie
- 1:25:43about two guys hanging out in Hollywood, one of whom is a
- 1:25:47movie star, one of whom hangs out behind the camera.
- 1:25:49They hang out with a bright, upcoming young ingenue who's
- 1:25:53trying to become a star at a time when Hollywood is on the
- 1:25:56precipice of a huge change. That movie, that movie is
- 1:26:00called, That movie is called Singing in the Rain, Baby.
- 1:26:06I knew it. I mean, this is Tarantino's take
- 1:26:10on a Singing in the Rain story. That's a good cut, man.
- 1:26:14Love it. If Gene Kelly had murdered
- 1:26:17anyone with a flamethrower at the end of that film, it
- 1:26:20probably would have been even better.
- 1:26:23That's all I have to say, Brad. Bob, would you pay to watch that
- 1:26:25movie? Lena Lamont getting torched at
- 1:26:28the end of that film. Talk about a character who truly
- 1:26:31deserved it. Brad, come on.
- 1:26:34Gene Kelly does not kill anyone with a flame flamethrower, but
- 1:26:37Leonardo DiCaprio does dance briefly in this movie, so I
- 1:26:40think that's. True the the hullabaloo
- 1:26:41sequence, yes, he wins, I think. All right, so there are our
- 1:26:46picks for Let's Make it a double.
- 1:26:48But no matter what you choose to pair this movie up with, you can
- 1:26:51always make it a double with Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 1:26:55If you go to bourbonoutfitter.com/film
- 1:26:57Whiskey and use our code Film WHISKEY at checkout, you'll get
- 1:27:005% off your bottle of Blackwood as well.
- 1:27:04Guys, it's time to give this movie some final scores.
- 1:27:07I'll go first 'cause I'm the low man here.
- 1:27:10I was at when I first saw this movie, I was at like a
- 1:27:13legitimate 4 out of 10. I really truly disliked this
- 1:27:15film. I texted Brad with about 20
- 1:27:18minutes left in the movie and said I'm I'm up to about a six
- 1:27:20on this. And then the ending was so good
- 1:27:23that I think I'm going to come up to A7 out of 10 on this
- 1:27:25movie. It is still, I think my least
- 1:27:29favorite Tarantino film, if if not his worst.
- 1:27:33But it says a lot about Tarantino that a 7 out of 10 is
- 1:27:35like, this is his worst movie. So that's where I'm at, Brad.
- 1:27:40Bob, you're dumb. No, I want to hear what your
- 1:27:42score is. Well, last time I was on this
- 1:27:44show, guys, I believe I gave Armageddon a nine, so.
- 1:27:49And right, Lisa? So I'm going to also give this a
- 1:27:54nine. I can't possibly go lower than
- 1:27:57Armageddon and I don't, I don't think it's a 10.
- 1:28:01So I'm going to go that's. That is the incredibly difficult
- 1:28:04thing about having 8 1/2 seasons now of scores under my belt.
- 1:28:10It's like the inevitably there's going to be a movie that I gave
- 1:28:14like a nine and a half and Bob's going to be like, you gave this
- 1:28:17a nine and a half and then I'm like, yes, Bob, I I don't I
- 1:28:21don't keep it all in my head all at once.
- 1:28:23Well, it. Speaks to, you know, as a film
- 1:28:24critic, you look at a movie and you say how well did this do for
- 1:28:28what it is trying to be, you know, and I maintain that
- 1:28:30Armageddon got really, really close to what it was trying to
- 1:28:33do. And I I think this movie did
- 1:28:35too. I certainly prefer this movie
- 1:28:37over Armageddon, but for what they are, I think they are
- 1:28:40equally good. Yeah, what you're saying is not
- 1:28:43all nines are created equal. There you go.
- 1:28:45That is much more succinct than the way I put it, a. 100% man.
- 1:28:50No, I'm with you. This is a nine out of 10.
- 1:28:53I loved this movie. I like I had so much fun with
- 1:28:58it. It connected with me.
- 1:29:01I I thought it said a lot of interesting things, but more
- 1:29:05than that, it had great characters and I like I will
- 1:29:10come back to this movie. I do think that this movie is
- 1:29:14going to be divisive, like there's no way to walk away from
- 1:29:17this movie and not feel passionate about it.
- 1:29:21And so like to go back to what Bob said at the start of the
- 1:29:23episode, I had no doubt as to why you picked this movie, Noah.
- 1:29:29It's because this is a movie that draws passion out of
- 1:29:32people. It doesn't leave you standing in
- 1:29:37the middle ground. And I, and I think that could be
- 1:29:39said about all Tarantino films, but this one, because it feels
- 1:29:43so personal to him, feels like it has a little bit extra bite
- 1:29:48and edge to it in a really beautiful way.
- 1:29:52All right, So it's a nine from Noah and from Brad it's a 7 from
- 1:29:56me. So for me and Brad, that brings
- 1:29:58us out to an average of an 8.0 out of 10 guys, Any final
- 1:30:05thoughts on this? And I guess crucially, the
- 1:30:06question for us to answer is, is this a modern masterpiece?
- 1:30:11That honestly, that's a tough one for me.
- 1:30:15I because, and it's tough because it's reflecting on so
- 1:30:21much history of Hollywood. I like, I'm going to come out
- 1:30:26and say this. I, I think apart from me, this
- 1:30:29is considered 1 of Tarantino's best films.
- 1:30:31So I acknowledge that it probably will be considered a
- 1:30:34masterpiece. I think that I, I mean, I think
- 1:30:38Inglorious Basterds is better than this.
- 1:30:40I think Django is better than this.
- 1:30:43I I would put this on par with at least the Kill Bill movies.
- 1:30:46So I know we're not capping directors entries into our
- 1:30:49fictional like pantheon here, Brad, but for me it's a no.
- 1:30:54But it's just because we have so many other really good Tarantino
- 1:30:57films. For me, it's a yes and I put it
- 1:30:59in the top tier of Tarantino, which probably has for me has
- 1:31:04four films in it, this Jackie Brown, Pulp Fiction and
- 1:31:09Bastards. But I think it will be very
- 1:31:12interesting to see how this film ages because he's got one more
- 1:31:15in them, right? He says he's making 10 movies.
- 1:31:18This was his ninth. He almost started production on
- 1:31:20a new one last year and then pulled it at the last minute.
- 1:31:24I'm kind of not surprised after he got so open and vulnerable
- 1:31:27and tender with this movie. It's kind of like, where do you
- 1:31:29where does he go from here? And and with the pressure of it
- 1:31:31being his last one, I can see why it would it would cause him
- 1:31:35some, you know, hesitancy. But if his next movie is like
- 1:31:40Stone cold Tarantino masterpiece, I can see this
- 1:31:44movie sort of getting forgotten or considered a minor, a minor
- 1:31:47Tarantino. And that wouldn't necessarily be
- 1:31:50a bad thing. Some of my favorite films are
- 1:31:52minor films from acclaimed directors.
- 1:31:55But it might make us withhold the modern masterpiece
- 1:32:00designation. I think I'm going to say no.
- 1:32:06Like this is the hardest answer to that question that I've had
- 1:32:12this season. Because I think that quality
- 1:32:15wise, it's up there. It's just on the edge.
- 1:32:20Like if this is a 9 1/2 or 10 out of 10 for me, yes, then it's
- 1:32:25a modern masterpiece. I think there's just enough of
- 1:32:27this film that feels casual for me to keep it out of the
- 1:32:33pantheon of modern masterpiece, but man is it close.
- 1:32:38I don't know, I might change my mind after we stop recording.
- 1:32:41We could always just meet in the middle and put licorice pizza in
- 1:32:43the pantheon. Then you get the rest of both
- 1:32:46worlds. We have not reviewed that movie,
- 1:32:48Bob. Oh, fine.
- 1:32:49All right. Well, Noah, I can't thank you
- 1:32:52enough for being here tonight. Man, we.
- 1:32:53It's always a freaking pleasure when we have you on the show.
- 1:32:56Where can we find you? What are you up to these days?
- 1:32:58Well, you know, I'm not doing that much film criticism
- 1:33:00anymore, but I'm still apparently giving terrible takes
- 1:33:03on Twitter, so you can find me there and on Blue Sky at Noah
- 1:33:09Gitell GITTELL. And I don't know when this
- 1:33:13episode's coming out, but I will be appearing at the Music Box
- 1:33:16Theatre on the 23rd of March. Will it be?
- 1:33:21Yeah, will be up by then, introing a screening of Eight
- 1:33:23Men Out and selling copies of my book Baseball The Movie.
- 1:33:28That's awesome, man. Cannot recommend the book highly
- 1:33:30enough. Cannot recommend the guy highly
- 1:33:32enough. Folks, this has been Noah
- 1:33:33Gettel. Thanks so much for joining us
- 1:33:35today. Thank you guys.
- 1:33:36It was great as always if you. Want to learn a little bit more
- 1:33:39about film and whiskey? You can find us on any of our
- 1:33:41social media platforms, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:33:45Tiktok, or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:33:49Or if you want to join the conversation, we are on Discord
- 1:33:51every single day talking about movies, whiskey and most
- 1:33:55recently tariffs on Canada. It's it's a wild time on our
- 1:34:00Discord server. If you want to join the
- 1:34:03conversation, you can find a link at the end of every single
- 1:34:06one of our show notes. Next week we will be back with a
- 1:34:10frequent Twitter sparring partner of Noah Getell as our
- 1:34:14friend Daniels YO to talk about the movie Argo, the 2012 Best
- 1:34:19Picture winner. So join us for a healthy dose of
- 1:34:22Ben Affleck next week when we talk about that movie.
- 1:34:25Is Ben Affleck just like cheap Brad Pitt?
- 1:34:30It's it's a question that that echoes down throughout the
- 1:34:33annals of time. We will discuss it next week,
- 1:34:35Brad. But until then, I am Bob.
- 1:34:37Book I am Brad. G and we'll see you next time.