Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 254-Hollywood and the Movies of the Fifties with Foster Hirsch
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is doug Hess and if you're tuning into Forgotten Hollywood for the first time,
- 0:30what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey back in
- 0:32time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not know
- 0:37about. In this episode, we have a very special guest with us today,
- 0:42author Foster Hirsch, and we are here to talk about his book Hollywood
- 0:48in the Movies of the fifties, the collapse of the studio system, the
- 0:53thrill of Cinerama, and the invasion of the Ultimate Body Snatcher television. I
- 0:59think I mess up Foxter. I apologize for that. But welcome you got
- 1:03in Hollywood. You got it right, I got it right. Thank you.
- 1:08Good to be here. Yeah, well, thank you, and thank
- 1:11you for spending just a few minutes with us today to talk about your book.
- 1:15Oh sure. And one of the first questions we always ask any author
- 1:19that comes on is to allow them a chance to kind of give a quick
- 1:23overview of what their books about. Yes, my book is about. As
- 1:27the title says, Hollywood in the fifties. I because I'm old enough I
- 1:33admit it to have grown up in the fifties. So the films that I'm
- 1:37writing about now are films that I saw as a kid in my first decade
- 1:46of becoming a serious moviegoer. ZO It was very much a nostalgic visit,
- 1:52a revisit if you will, in the past. But it was also I
- 1:57also wanted to defend the fifties from people who have a very superficial idea of
- 2:02the fifties as a dull, bland, consumer oriented, conformity ridden era.
- 2:08It was that it was so sexless compared to the sexties sixties. My idea
- 2:15was, of course, the sixties are sizzling, but the sixties became the
- 2:17sixties because of a lot of things that were happening in the fifties. So
- 2:22I sort of wanted to defend my decade against I think an unfair reputation too
- 2:30much more complicated and various and challenging period that it's usually been given credit for.
- 2:38Plus, and here's the main point, I think there are more great
- 2:42movies from the fifties than any other decade in American film history. In my
- 2:47opinion, sure, sure, well, And as your subtitle says about the
- 2:53fifties, there's a lot going on in the fifties. I mean, yeah,
- 2:59you've got the almost the collapse of the studios. You said that,
- 3:05Doug, you said the important word almost. Yes, by the end of
- 3:08the decade, they were struggling. They didn't completely die until the part two
- 3:15of my book, which is Hollywood in the sixties. Then they die,
- 3:19right, That was a key word, almost. Yeah, they almost die.
- 3:22And then you really have them. You have the Blacklist going on during
- 3:27the fifties. You also have the birth of like you talk about the birth
- 3:31of television. And I think, and this is just my opinion, is
- 3:37a lot of people in the studios really had them separated. And I think
- 3:42that was probably true in the fifties, unlike today in twenty twenty four,
- 3:46where movie stars are jumping back and forth between television the big screen, and
- 3:53in the fifties that was kind of a death sentence, wasn't it. Television
- 3:58Television was considered your career on the way out right, A list actors were
- 4:03in movies. But remember the studios roomed stars and in many ways developed them
- 4:11and protected them in many ways that the actors became stars because of the star
- 4:16system, because of the contract system. Yes, it allowed for the development
- 4:21of protection and the survival of stars. The star system operates in a different
- 4:27way today than it did during the studio era, you know. And I
- 4:31think you brought up a good point there, because I think a lot of
- 4:34times the studio heads are portrayed as villain money hungary, and I'm not saying
- 4:42that's not true. To agree, but they also developed, like you said,
- 4:48careers and really took care of their stars that probably wouldn't have developed had
- 4:57they not have had the tight control from the studio heads. That's absolutely true.
- 5:02And you make a point that some reviews of the book pointed out,
- 5:08and I'm proud of this point. They say, I give an unusually even
- 5:13handed treatment to the old style movie moguls, but I give them credit for
- 5:21developing a huge and important business. They had wonderful instincts about movies and popular
- 5:30taste. They were sure or shrewd businessmen, sometimes avaricious. Were they at
- 5:35times predatory? Yes they were, But you give them credit for what they
- 5:40did accomplish. And as I say, I was, I've been The book
- 5:45has been noted for being unusually fair handed. I don't. I don't.
- 5:48I'm not out to trash them. I give Darryl's Anik, Jack Warner,
- 5:53Harry Cone, Louis Mayer, all all the big famous mobuls. I give
- 5:58the book credit for what they come. Yeah. Because, uh, because,
- 6:01like we said, there was a balancing act that they had to do.
- 6:05They knew they had to make money. And that's why you go into
- 6:09business, right, is to make money. And they were. They were
- 6:13shrewd businessmen, but they loved their product. Yeah, like many of the
- 6:17people who run studios today are sort of faceless and interchangeable money people. They
- 6:24love movies and they were very protective of their studios, protective of their contact
- 6:29players, where they sometimes dictatorial and even fair. Yeah. Yes, were
- 6:35they deep died villains. I don't think so. I think they were American
- 6:41heroes of a kind. I give you full credit. Well, fus,
- 6:45I think you also bring up a great point there today and kind of picking
- 6:48on today's movie studio heads, they don't have the same love or hands on
- 6:57approach with movies as some of the old old time They don't. They don't.
- 7:05It's all about the bottom line. It's the bottom line. It's about
- 7:09it the bottom line. It's about product placement. It's about product, but
- 7:15it's not about making films that in some ways for the old time, old
- 7:21time moguls address their own feelings and desires. Louis B. Mayors MGM presented
- 7:30Mayor's idea of what America could be. Yes, follow what I'm saying.
- 7:35Absolutely. His idea of America. Was it documentary like? Was it realistic?
- 7:41No? He said, we make beautiful films about beautiful people. Aesthetic
- 7:46and he had an idealized version of an American Arcadia out of the perfect American
- 7:51Family. I like to tell people that the quintessential Louie B. Mayor movie
- 7:57is Meet Me in Saint Louis. Yes, that represents his aesthetic, what
- 8:03he would have hoped American could be like what it never was, only in
- 8:09his dreams, right, as an idealized vision. But in a way that
- 8:15kind of fits into the movie studio image of having a dream. And even
- 8:20though yes it's not really true and probably never going to be true, that
- 8:26wasn't who never will be true. He's an ideal to aspire to, and
- 8:30it's entertainment. Correct Mabe. Mayor never directed a film, he never wrote
- 8:35a script. What the MGM films made during his regime represented that man's point
- 8:43of view, Yes, yes, and that was true for most of the
- 8:46Mobiles. There were strong personalities and their imprint is seen on their films.
- 8:52Darryl Zannik was a writer in fashions himself a producer and filmmaker. Mayor was
- 8:56not, but his influence was equal to Aarrosatics. Yeah, and you can't
- 9:01argue with their success either. Absolutely, No, Hollywood's never been the same
- 9:07in the ghost studio era. Yes, a different business, it's a different
- 9:13model. It was doomed, it couldn't last forever. But I'm celebrating in
- 9:16this book the studio era near the end. It's golden age absolutely, you
- 9:24know, and kind of shifting gears just a little bit. Something that we
- 9:28also want to talk about is the Blacklist that was going on in the fifess
- 9:33and how the you had government in Hollywood at times in my opinion, holding
- 9:41hands and at times fighting one another and depending on who the star was,
- 9:46and it was just a mixed bag in my opinion. Well, the Blacklist
- 9:52was not the Moguls in their finest hour they agreed to a blacklist. They
- 9:58institute a blacklist. People say, now, well, they didn't really have
- 10:03to. At the time, they felt they did. A mogul like Mayor,
- 10:09who was King of MGM, felt inferior to the president's when we got
- 10:16to know personally. In other words, they thought Washington was a bigger arena
- 10:20than Hollywood, and they wanted to appease the Washington power players. And they
- 10:26were afraid if they did not accede to the blacklist, that Washington might interfere
- 10:31in the content of their films and interfere in their business. There were many
- 10:37complex reasons why the moguls instituted a blacklist. That they did is not their
- 10:45finest hour, right, and we understood. But you're vulnerable for having done
- 10:50it. Oh absolutely. And I think it's so easy to be in twenty
- 10:54twenty four and playing hindsight and looking back and being able to say, well,
- 10:58you should done this, you didn't need to do this in that So
- 11:01isn't that easy? Yeah? Yeah, everybody, what's so easy to say?
- 11:05Had I been there, I would never be to a blacklist. I
- 11:09would never have agreed to appear before Congressional committee and answer questions they have no
- 11:13business asking. Of course, I wouldn't. You don't know unless you were
- 11:18there. Absolutely, they had pressure too, and it's easier said than done.
- 11:22Absolutely they're under enormous pressure. And that's part of the challenge of the
- 11:28fifties. It was. It was a period of enormous political division. Sound
- 11:35familiar to what's quite Yeah, very polarized country. Well, and a lot
- 11:41of people don't realize that. You know, there was regulations and whether or
- 11:46not a film was going to be allowed to be shown, and you're trying
- 11:50to make money and protect your stars, and so there was a lot more
- 11:54going on behind the scenes. And I think the public gives these studio heads
- 12:01credit for, like you said, not their finest hour, and I'm sure
- 12:05they wish they could have done some things different hindsight being twenty twenty. But
- 12:09at the moment, they thought they were doing the best they could. At
- 12:13the moment, they think with the cards they were handed and that was a
- 12:16difficult deck, they thought they were doing the best they could, right,
- 12:22And it was a period you touch on this. It was also a period
- 12:26when the production code was still in effect, so there were things that could
- 12:30not be said or shown in movies. But that's interesting too because that creates
- 12:35a climate of repression but also of subtext. So sometimes there were creative strategies
- 12:43for getting around what you couldn't say or show. You could imply an implication,
- 12:48an allegoria, metaphor can be more interesting than direct statement. I'm not
- 12:54saying censorship is good, but sometimes censorship is a kind of broad to creativity.
- 13:00Yes, absolutely, I couldn't agree with you more. And I know
- 13:03we're running closer on time. But a couple of other quick hits I want
- 13:07to get to. We were also coming out of World War Two with the
- 13:09fifties, and in terms of that, and then I also want to try
- 13:13to get to the birth of television, if I can say it that way,
- 13:16and how that was affecting. But first, maybe you just kind of
- 13:20touch a little bit on World War two and how that number. America came
- 13:24out of World War Two as the new world power right ndition of preeminent power,
- 13:31economic security, and success. It looks in hindsight like an absolutely great
- 13:35time and it was great for many businesses, but not for the movies because
- 13:41of television. Television cut in on daily attendance and the tendance figures for movie
- 13:50going in the war period was at an all time high. It will never
- 13:54be the same. And so if studios had to accommodate to a reduced clientele.
- 14:01But how do you get even those people back into the theater. You
- 14:03offer them new technologies three D CinemaScope, todd Ao, cinerama, this division,
- 14:11and you offer them new content. You have to find ways of enticing
- 14:16the people away from their free television sense they could stay at home and watch
- 14:22movies for free. Sounds like the tension now between streaming. I was not
- 14:26theater. I was just going to bring that up that not only think it's
- 14:31the same dynamic. Yeah, what television did to the movies in the fifties,
- 14:37if you will, streaming is doing to TV today. And streaming is
- 14:43having an effect on movie exhibition absolutely absolutely. Eaters are worried about. Oh
- 14:50yeah, another historian will have to write about the chaos of the twenty twenties,
- 14:56not me, another historian. I said in the book that until twenty
- 15:01twenty, the fifties was the most turbulent period in Hollywood history. I would
- 15:07say the prestent moment is now the most turbulent period. But as I say,
- 15:11that's worth another historian at a future day. That's for somebody else.
- 15:16Well, fom so, I know we're getting close to on time. But
- 15:18did anything surprise you during the research and the writing of this book. That's
- 15:24a good question. I was worried that I would be revisiting films that I
- 15:31would not like, Films that I had seen and liked when I was a
- 15:35kid, that be revisiting them from an adult perspective, all these many decades
- 15:41later, that they would look different or diminished. Yet in almost every case,
- 15:46I was surprised that films I had liked them I still liked, and
- 15:50films I hadn't liked I still didn't. What does that say? No growth,
- 15:56No intellectual or emotional growth. I didn't change so many decades, But
- 16:02I was surprised how consistent my own opinions were. Interesting. But we should
- 16:08not end. We shouldn't end ug before listing some titles. Then listen absolutely,
- 16:15because I'm making this broad claim of fifties being a great time. Well,
- 16:18how about naming some films, mister burst, Well, what about all
- 16:22the great Hitchcock films and the fifties Strangers on a Train, the Wrong Man?
- 16:27Where to Goo? Rear window or a start? What about melodramas the
- 16:33greatest of all? Imitation of life? What about epics? Afore my love
- 16:37ben her don't laugh? The Ten Commandments, the Rogue Band of the Pharaohs.
- 16:41These are good and exciting and visually resplendent films. What about the Great
- 16:47Westerns, Broken Arrow, Shane, the Searchers I knew? What about war
- 16:52films? Is there a better war film than Bridge on the River Kway?
- 16:55I don't know that there is, Rightie. The only genre that doesn't thrive
- 17:00in the fifties is comedy because it was such a dark period. I don't
- 17:04think it was a good period for comedy. If you like Martin Lewis,
- 17:08be my guest. If you like Avenan Costello, be my guest, right.
- 17:12If you like Francis the Talking Mule, be my guest. Right.
- 17:17Very few comedies of the fifties that I liked, Yes, well, and
- 17:22you know you mentioned, you know, being heard in the Ten Commandments.
- 17:26I still watch those films from from occasions. You think they're great, but
- 17:29they need to be seen in a huge yes, huge screen. A flat
- 17:33screen TV in your living room does not cut it does not do it right
- 17:37than nothing, but it doesn't do it. I saw the The Been Her
- 17:42on the reserved seats at the beautiful Egyptian Theater in Hollywood, on a huge
- 17:48screen. That's the way to see the way it was meant to be a
- 17:52scene. And you know the other thing is, you know, those were
- 17:55two films that were long in terms of film with films, you know,
- 18:00what about three hours for both films, pretty closer to four four Okay,
- 18:07I hadn't seen them in a while, but yes, I know they're very
- 18:10long, you know, with intermissions correct, you know, does today's audience
- 18:15have the patience that was going to be? My question is back then,
- 18:21in the fifties, was it more accepted? Is today we've got all our
- 18:27little gadgets, our cell phones and our laptops, and we're like, hey,
- 18:32this is this is running too long. I got to go do something
- 18:34else. We had a different sense of time in the fifties. We didn't
- 18:38have the distractions of all this technology. Young people don't believe. It was
- 18:44a time without cell phones and without that's about computers, right, So we
- 18:49had a different sense of time. So we could commit four hours to a
- 18:53long, good movie if we if we wanted to nowadays, we have to
- 18:57make a special case to do that. The attention span has changed. Yes,
- 19:03definitely. I don't want to leave without mentioning the great acting in the
- 19:07fifties, the method actor, James Den, Montgomery Clifton, the greatest of
- 19:11all, Marlon Brando. What is the greatest, single, greatest film of
- 19:15the fifties, mister Hirsch on the Waterfront? What is the best performance I
- 19:22have ever seen in an American movie? Marlon Brando and on the Waterfront.
- 19:26Yeah, that's great. I'm a little partial to The Godfather a few years
- 19:32later that he would do in the seventies with Marlon Brando, But he was
- 19:36a controversial actor. Amazing in The Godfather. That's an amazing performance. Yes,
- 19:44you look at what he did in her life on the Waterfront. That
- 19:48film is all about what's going on in the character's money. Yeah, and
- 19:53when the inner and outer come together, he can appear before the committee and
- 19:57tell what he knows. It's all about the progression of the inner life.
- 20:03It's an extraordinary performance. Yeah, he was. He was an amazing actor
- 20:08in general. Marlondo. Yeah, and don't laugh, but he's he makes
- 20:17a very good Napoleon in Desert, a film nobody sees or remembers, and
- 20:22if they do, they laugh at it. Randall said, this is my
- 20:25worst performance. I'm sorry, he's wrong. It's a very clever, sneaky,
- 20:30subversive performance. He does. He plays Napoleon with a clipped British accent.
- 20:37Well why not, right? Yeah? You know it's funny that you
- 20:40brought up Napoleon because last November my son and I went to the theater and
- 20:45saw the new Napoleon film that came out. It's three and hours or so.
- 20:52It was a fine film. I'm not here to bash any film in
- 20:55terms of but it's just maybe it's just me, but when you get the
- 21:00long films today, the quality was better. I think in the fifties with
- 21:06the ben Her and the Commandments. I'm going to say the writing was better
- 21:11for those films, oh much better. The act yes, and the acting
- 21:17as well. I can be less tactful than you. I went to see
- 21:22Napoleon first day because I love epics, and ridden Scott really is a director
- 21:26who wants to say epics. He has a taste for it. I don't
- 21:30think he's been successful so far. I thought the production detail of Napoleon brilliant,
- 21:37superb production design, poorly written, and very poorly acted. I thought
- 21:44the Walking Phoenix npole and it was just contemporary American. He didn't make any
- 21:51attempt to play a historical figure. I didn't think he had any idea about
- 21:55the character. Yeah, no, I thought that Joseph was very poorly I
- 22:00would agree with that as well, especially the writing. I thought it was
- 22:03like, I mean, I'm no writer, but I thought I could have
- 22:07written a better screenplay than that. Some of it was just lazy writing.
- 22:15I'll just crazy wright. Look, it's really hard to write dialogue for epics.
- 22:21How did people in the old in old times speak? Howard Hawkson,
- 22:25who was making landon Pharaoh said, asked the question. His co writer was
- 22:30William Faulkner. He said, how do Pharaoh speak? And he's not sure
- 22:36they ever found a language to express the way Pharaoh would speak. I think
- 22:41they did better than they thought. It's William Faulkner, after all, it
- 22:45had some elevation. But it's really hard to write convincing dialogue for an epic,
- 22:52and he certainly didn't achieve that in Napoleon. You can't be just contemporary.
- 22:57Yes, it has to have somevation a little bit of depth in there.
- 23:02And so I say this with a little bit of hesitation, is that,
- 23:07you know, like you said, it's hard, so I'll give them
- 23:11a little bit of a soft landing from my standpoint on that. But I
- 23:15have to agree with you at the end of the day. I think at
- 23:18some points they thought, I don't know what else to say, and they
- 23:22just kind of got lazy and wrote whatever they wanted and so very very contemporary.
- 23:27Yes, yes, it has to have some hype to it, absolutely,
- 23:32and you listen to the dialogue and Ben hurt and it has to that.
- 23:36So for that matter, just the dialogue sometimes stiff. In the Ten
- 23:40Commandments, yes, they were trying for something in elevation well. And it's
- 23:45also kind of interesting is even though a lot of that was filmed in a
- 23:52studio, been Her and the Ten Commandments, there was just kind of a
- 23:56feel and a look that didn't make it seem that way in my opinion,
- 24:00even though you know the back in your mind, you're like, that's a
- 24:03studio somewhere in la that they're probably filming this, But they went to great
- 24:08links to to make it look different. And I don't think I'm really explaining
- 24:15myself. But it looks realistic within the conventions of that kind of filmmaking.
- 24:22Yes, yes, realistic pattern to it, which it needs also, Doug.
- 24:29Science fiction was born in the Yeah, they're great science fiction films.
- 24:33The thing then it came from outer space incredible Shrinking Man, Invasion of the
- 24:40Body, Snatcher's Five Winners that your listeners should be familiar. Oh. Absolutely.
- 24:45There were no science fiction films before nineteen fifty. It took the atomic
- 24:49bomb and the fear of atomic radiation to inspire a raft of science fiction film
- 24:56well in the fifties. And the other thing I wanted to talk about that
- 25:00just real quick, is that in twenty twenty four, we've got the green
- 25:04screen. We've got all these fancy computers and technology that makes things look real.
- 25:12Fifties they didn't have that, you know, And I could just think
- 25:15or see some individual going, I've got to do what you know, and
- 25:22have to be very creative in order to make things look real, and sometimes
- 25:26it looks fake. I'm sure we get that because of the times, you
- 25:30know, but it was amazing what they could do with not the technology that
- 25:37we have today. I think that's a fair assessment sometimes I show the old
- 25:42science fiction films to students fairly often because I really do want their responses,
- 25:48and I'm always a little nervous that they might start laughing. Right, most
- 25:52of the time, most of the time they say, you know what,
- 25:56was pretty good, They did a pretty good drunk for instance, the giant
- 26:00ants in them. Yeah, students find those that special effect still pretty effective.
- 26:08Despite that it was not very much pre CGI. I just saw a
- 26:14quiet place with these monsters that come down and stop on people. The monsters
- 26:18look terrific in that film. CGI is fantastic in a way that it could
- 26:22never have been in the fifties. Absolutely. Problem is in the fifties those
- 26:26science fiction films had subtext and meaning. The monsters in Why Place don't mean
- 26:33anything. Yeah, they're just good. They're communists or communists takeover or some
- 26:38kind of metaphor about American masculinity. There was some there was was loaded with
- 26:45meaning and implication in quiet places. Just CGI very well done, and the
- 26:49monster's scary and they're articulate. But that's it, right, Yeah, they
- 26:55don't represent anything. Yeah. Shoot, well, if they did, it
- 26:57eluded me. Foster, thank you so much for coming on and spending a
- 27:03few minutes with us today, and to our audience, please go out and
- 27:07get a copy of of Foster's book, Hollywood in the Movies of the Fifties.
- 27:11You're not going to be disappointed. We just touched on a little bit
- 27:15of the iceberg here today. Foster, Thank you again so much for coming
- 27:19on you so thank you for the pleasure, pleasure to talk to you.
- 27:23Thank you for reaching out to me. Oh well, it's our pleasure.
- 27:26And thank you for listening to this episode Forgotten Hollywood. Just search for Doug
- 27:30Caster Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me a Twitter and Instagram at hestog
- 27:33fourteen. If you listening to this podcast on iTunes or another podcast service,
- 27:37please subscribe to rate and review this episode. Tune in next time for a
- 27:41late US episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for listening and we will see you then