Latest / Ed & Red! / Ed & Red! - Epi 135 - Separating Facts from Fiction about the Israel/Hamas War, & Why Ed Hates the Radical Left
Transcript
- 0:00The views expressed in the following program are those of the participants and do not
- 0:04necessarily reflect the views of Saga nine sixty AM or its management. Well,
- 0:16hello, Leanna, Hello, it's ah wow. World seems to be going
- 0:23to hell in a handbasket. It's gone to this hell in this handbasket before,
- 0:28but every time it does it, we seem to think it's the first
- 0:31time it's happened. Nonetheless, it's still hell in a handbasket. Yeah.
- 0:37People like to show what good people they are by going I keep thinking about
- 0:44you know that line from the first season of Loki on Disney Plus, Yes,
- 0:48very sad anyway. What was the line? They just told him that
- 0:55some people had gotten killed, and he took a moment to just say the
- 0:58perfunctory yes, sad anyway. And that is just how I feel about so
- 1:06many of these people who are screaming and crying and rending garments and using inflammatory
- 1:14language, and then the minute something closer to home happens, they're they're distracted.
- 1:19Squirrel Well, yeah, I mean, okay, America does have a
- 1:26unique mass shooting problem. They do, there's no there's no denying that.
- 1:32But the fact that it pivoted so fast, just surprised even me and I
- 1:40am very cynical. Well, I uh yeah, I have to say that
- 1:47I am completely done with the far left completely. You weren't done before this
- 1:55that I'm I'm more done than before when I was done. I'm done done.
- 2:01But well, let's let's be clear though, people are you know,
- 2:07political extremes are just that extremes, except they're the loudest to get the most
- 2:12attention. No, I I don't. I don't think. Well, oh,
- 2:15you mean the both extremes do. Yes, Well, that's because that's
- 2:20because the media loves all say Gong show, and I didn't want to say
- 2:23gong the uh okay, yeah. Left. The thing about the left is
- 2:31the left is every far left is every bit as hateful as the far right.
- 2:38They just think that if they cry performative tears, it makes them nice
- 2:43people. They their compassion and their principles are flexible. They don't apply universally
- 2:51to all people, all victims, for example. No, it's some people
- 2:55are worthy of their compassion and other people are worthy, are not worthy.
- 3:00So some civilians in the world, innocent civilians are worthy of their compassion.
- 3:07Other civilians they do backflips to try to talk about why these people who are
- 3:13victims are victims of their own actions, and they don't deserve any love,
- 3:20any compassion. They're just horrible people who are trying to convince themselves that they
- 3:25are good people. It's all over the place, horrible people who try to
- 3:31hook themselves up to what they think is a virtuous cause, and in service
- 3:37of that virtuous cause, they will do everything that is absolutely not virtuous because
- 3:43they think they have justification because they're virtuous. They are so full of crap
- 3:49and their heads are so far up their own butts's just and they're loud,
- 3:53and I just I mean, I the far right at least, you know
- 3:58how disgusting they are. But the far left people think, well they care
- 4:00about this. They know they don't, No, they don't. They don't
- 4:03care about anything except themselves. It's the Peacemaker thing, you know, he's
- 4:09so committed to world peace that he doesn't care how many people he has to
- 4:12kill to get it. That's right, the TV show Peacemaker, That's right.
- 4:15Yeah, I mean, let's face it, these extremes appeal to two
- 4:20types of people. Horrible people, narcissists, people with dark triad personality trade
- 4:27so dark tetrad as some people say, but or very very broken people who
- 4:35have such low self esteem that they just want to know what right things to
- 4:40say so that that will be protected by the biggest bully, and you know,
- 4:46they don't. The thing that I've found, and obviously I'm talking about
- 4:51what's going on in the Middle East, is that there are so many lies
- 4:58that are baked in the that people without requisite knowledge in the area think are
- 5:03givens, think are just well, everybody knows this is true. And this
- 5:08is why it's very difficult to have a discussion with somebody about the Middle East,
- 5:13because they're starting from a position of believing things that are complete bs.
- 5:16Like, for example, they freak out when you say, well, you
- 5:20know, there actually has never been a self governed Palestinian state in Palestine.
- 5:27It's never there, never has been one. So you're taking away their ability
- 5:31to argue both sides of the issue. Well, the idea. See,
- 5:35they've got this idea that there was this existing state for a long time called
- 5:40Palestine, and then Israel was given half of an existing or a portion of
- 5:46an existing country, and that that isn't what happened at all. There was
- 5:51no. There was a district basically a region called Palestine. It was a
- 5:58British minister area by by England, and they did divide it. They did
- 6:02partition it the same way they did India and Pakistan. And it went about
- 6:08as well, yeah, the so people are like, the Jews don't belong
- 6:12there. They took the land. It's like no, no, no,
- 6:15they didn't take the land. In nineteen forty eight, the UN Partition Plan
- 6:18gave a portion of the area which was not a country called Palestine, and
- 6:25they said, this half's going to be for the Jews called Israel. This
- 6:28half will be They weren't called Palestinians there then, they were just called Arabs,
- 6:33but this would be for them. And the Arab nations said no,
- 6:39well, we don't have the time to get into what happened in the Goal
- 6:43and Heights and how some of it was part of Jordan and some of it
- 6:46was part of Syria and some of it was part of Egypt. And you
- 6:50know, there were multiple wars that Israel was not the primary aggressor in,
- 6:58and they used in sixty seven and technically Israel attacked first. But it's the
- 7:02same way as you know, Ukraine fired first in a few battles against Russia.
- 7:09But that's because Russia was surrounding the area. It's it's complicated. The
- 7:15area has gone back and forth. You know. The what frustrates me is
- 7:19people are using a bunch of words designed to have an emotional charge without understanding
- 7:26the concepts they're applying, like genocide and ethnic cleansing and apartheid. Well,
- 7:31okay, are we gonna go there, because this is gonna take some time
- 7:35on its own. Then it will take some time because here's let me tell
- 7:40you what I think and then let you'll give me the which term, Which
- 7:44term do you want to start with? Well, let me start with an
- 7:46overall thing, which is that the uh, the establishment of the State of
- 7:53Israel was because the world felt bad because once again they'd allow Jews to be
- 8:00slaughtered in epic fashion. Okay, that's not completely true, because part of
- 8:07it was they started it started with the Balfour Declaration, and then it was
- 8:13supposed to be relocating a bunch of Jewish people while the British still controlled the
- 8:18area. That started in nineteen forty seven, after some very very bloody Arab
- 8:26uprisings in the thirties, followed by some very very bloody Jewish terrorist group uprisings.
- 8:33They have an extreme de in the forties, and it got so bad
- 8:39that only a year after they started the transition process, the British went,
- 8:46we're out, We're not doing this anymore, with the expectation that Israel would
- 8:50last maybe three months. So it wasn't just oh, the poor Holocaust survivors,
- 8:56it was they wanted out of the area. They didn't actually care about
- 9:01the fate of the one year old, you know area called Israel, all
- 9:09right, true, that's very important for people to understand. There was no
- 9:16big colonial plot to give the area a Jewish character at the expense of then
- 9:24the Arabs now known as Palestinians. The Arab surrounding Arab countries did not treat
- 9:31Palestinians well, no matter where they went. You know, tens of thousands
- 9:35of them just disappeared in places like Syria and Jordan, other places we know
- 9:41there were uprisings and they were killed. The Arab countries that have had to
- 9:46deal with the Palestinians were no kinder to them than Israel was possibly quite the
- 9:52opposite. This is all important, This all matters. They they were into
- 9:58They were into Jordan, the Palestinians and tried to overthrow the government of Jordan.
- 10:03Well, they tried to set up their own state and they were trying
- 10:07to over they were trying to push out the monarchy. They were trying to
- 10:11push out King Hossein. Well, they were trying to collect their own taxes,
- 10:15and the Jordanians went ant no, and they that was that was the
- 10:20Black September. They slaughtered. The Jordanians went in there and said no,
- 10:26and they went into refugee camps, they went everywhere. They just they killed.
- 10:28They can't tend thousands of people change the thousands of people, far far
- 10:33more than we've seen in Gaza right now, where people are saying it's the
- 10:39worst thing ever, it's not. It's just not. It's terrible, but
- 10:43we have to keep our heads. It's not the worst humanitarian disaster or crisis.
- 10:50There are at least five more that I can think of that are worst
- 10:54right now, Yemen, Syria, t Gray, Ukraine, and the pick
- 11:00your fifth, you know, some of the stuff China's doing North Korea,
- 11:03pick one, you know. So, but there are a lot of popular
- 11:09sentiment supporting Israel was because oh, the Holocaust happened, and it was,
- 11:16and the Holocaust slaughtered six million Jews. It was, it was, It
- 11:20was horriforic and plus plus Romani people, plus gay people, oh yes,
- 11:28plus you know, but that they weren't part of the equation for uh,
- 11:31for Israel. So if you go and if that is the underpinning that people
- 11:37have had in their head of why Israel exists because they were victims of genocide.
- 11:43If you want to delegitimize the state of Israel, you accuse Israel of
- 11:50committing genocide. It then takes away the power of what was done to the
- 11:56Jews and makes it like, well, you guys are no better, So
- 12:00it delegitimizes in the back of people's head. It starts to delegitimize the existence
- 12:05of the state of Israel. The same with ethnic cleansing, which, by
- 12:09the way, I think is the most offensive term cleansing. You know something,
- 12:15Do you know where that term came from? No, that was a
- 12:18weasel word adopted when Yugoslavia fell apart, and they couldn't actually use the term
- 12:28genocide, so they came up with this not a thing, you know,
- 12:31the way Paul did for for gay relationships, in the Testament. He just
- 12:37made up a word. They came up with that because they were trying to
- 12:43find something that sounded less bad, and at that time, the euphemisms were
- 12:50everywhere because the time, the belief was you had to appeal to the aggressor's
- 12:56better nature. So you know, you're not going to get anybody to do
- 13:01what you want if you say you're the worst person in the world. So
- 13:03they came up with this nothing term of ethnic cleansing, and now it's being
- 13:13used for the complete opposite purpose that it was created to do. Now,
- 13:16there was a lot of controversy about the use of the term at the time.
- 13:20A lot of these definitions that people are using have not been accepted.
- 13:26You know, there is a lot more agreement on climate change being a man
- 13:31made phenomenon than there is for some of these terms, and people throwing them
- 13:35around don't factor in that. Even some people on the left say there's a
- 13:43problem with the International Criminal Courts definition of apartheid, there's a problem with the
- 13:50definition of genocide according to the International Criminal Courts. And a big problem besides
- 13:56those is that neither the US nor Israel are signatories of the ICC. Canada
- 14:03is but you can't hold people to laws. They didn't join the ICC because
- 14:11they were afraid that it was it was a bit of a setup that I'm
- 14:15not saying it's true. I'm just saying that that was the justification that America's
- 14:20enemies would just accuse them of everything in the book. Because America is often
- 14:24called to be the world's policemen, and so their soldiers are at greater risk
- 14:30of being accused frivolously of war crimes. All of this matters. All of
- 14:35this matters. All of it matters. And as the problem for me with
- 14:39the term ethnic cleansing is these nobody's being cleaned. This isn't a massive bath
- 14:43for people. This is like like I said, it was designed to be
- 14:48an artificially gentle terminology. The warlord's feelings weren't warlord's feelings weren't hurt. It's
- 14:58that was the whole point of the term. People should not be using it.
- 15:01Nobody's being cleaned. They are being murdered. The idea of ethnic lensing
- 15:07is murder. It's not meaning, and that's not what's going on they do
- 15:09you not remember that when that term came in, I actually do as you
- 15:15were talking yeah, yeah, oh yeah, yeah yeah. It was a
- 15:20big bag nonsense right from the beginning, like just absolute, give me a
- 15:26break. People have come to believe that genocide just means a military situation where
- 15:35many people are killed. That is not well, they they in this case
- 15:39that it's that's not quite that simple. In this case, they're saying that
- 15:45the denial of food and water is is genocidal. Now, that's that's taking
- 15:54one piece of the law and inaccurately apply it. The people saying that are
- 16:00right that one way. If the intent is to starve or dehydrate a people
- 16:08because they are a particular ethnic or religious background, then it is it's that
- 16:15intent thing. And you really can't argue with a straight face that the issue
- 16:22here is just that Israel wants to you know, it would be it would
- 16:26be the dumbest move in history to think that you can wipe out the Palestinian
- 16:32people just in Gaza. They're not doing that. They were attacked. The
- 16:37idea that you can argue that it's somehow just oh, they want these people
- 16:41out of there so that they can be replaced, is missing the fact that
- 16:45fourteen hundred people were killed or kidnapped, and I do think that there is
- 16:52a certain glee in the minds of some all of these left wing people who
- 17:03just enjoy tormenting people, and they assume that they they're doing it because they
- 17:11just hate because they think everybody thinks like them. Again, not all.
- 17:17But you really have to stretch a long way to get the to get the
- 17:25outcome from the facts we have that have been verified, and facts that have
- 17:30been verified very important in this case, but you really have to stretch to
- 17:36get that intent based on what we have. And I want to talk about
- 17:41that more, but first I want to say that genocide, as you pointed
- 17:45out, is a deliberate intent to wipe out a people. Yeah, And
- 17:53the fact is that since nineteen forty eight, the population of Dalestinians in the
- 18:00West Bank in Gaza has grown from about one point two million to over five
- 18:06million. Now genocide would go from one point two million to zero, all
- 18:11right, The idea or you'd see numbers like you have of Jewish populations in
- 18:17Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Aaran, Syria, Lebanon and so on and so
- 18:21forth, you see them going from over one hundred thousand people and down to
- 18:27two or four or a few thousand. That's what you expect to see if
- 18:36there's a deliberate attempt which has happened. You know this, It's happened all
- 18:40over the world. The minute Israel was founded, they started putting in discriminatory
- 18:45laws and starting programs and a whole bunch of other things. People were forced
- 18:51to leave with nothing. And that was going on all through the fifties and
- 18:56sixties. And the people who are anti Israel have used that fact to label
- 19:03the Israelis colonists. That's one of the things that which is why I say,
- 19:10if we're gonna talk about definitions, we've got to talk about what definitions
- 19:12means. Colonialism. Colonists mean you're not from there South Africa. The Dutch
- 19:22when incolonized South Africa, they weren't from there. They weren't one historically indigenous
- 19:30population doing bad stuff to another historically indigenous population. They were from Holland.
- 19:36They were not from Africa. The Israelis, it was called Israel for reason
- 19:45and the alaxamaz Is on top of the side of the Second Temple. How
- 19:49do you claim they're colonists? Like I keep thinking of the Princess Bride.
- 19:56You know that line you keep using this word. I do not think it
- 19:59means what you think it means. And they keep using the term genocide even
- 20:03though, like listen, let's talk specifically about that. Okay, okay,
- 20:07Israel's military has the power to if they wanted to, over the last seventy
- 20:15five years, they could have easily militarily killed every everybody. I think they
- 20:23let me finish. Please, Yeah, but that argument is just refuted.
- 20:26I've had people refute this argument. How do you refute the fact they have
- 20:32the military strength to go in and if they wanted to, they could do
- 20:36what Jordan did to the Palestinians that went there. They could go in and
- 20:40just wipe them out, and they haven't. Ed. You are not factoring
- 20:44in that both sides of this conflict believe God wants them to be there.
- 20:49So in the minds of people, Israel is is Thanos. Okay, it
- 20:56has the Infinity gauntlet, it has all the power, and the only reason
- 21:02they haven't been able to do good genocide is because of God. Because God
- 21:10wants the Palestinians to win. And that's the problem. Groups like Hezbolo,
- 21:15groups like Hamas very Iran have promised their people that they are they are promised
- 21:22victory by God. I'm not gonna say the name they use because it upsets
- 21:26people, and I have restraint, ironically, but they've been promised by God.
- 21:33So if they stop fighting, there is going to be internal conflict like
- 21:38you have never seen before in your life, because all people have there because
- 21:44they have been kept poor and desperate and ignorant for so long. All they
- 21:49have is that belief. And so if they don't get that, it's it's
- 21:55gonna be ugly. Well it's good, It's gonna be ugly no matter what.
- 22:00Okay, just my final the point I'm trying to make is that genus.
- 22:04If Israel had wanted to commit genocide, it wouldn't be a few thousand
- 22:10people. I don't want to diminish it, but it wouldn't be a few
- 22:12thousand Palestinians killed when as mass casualty events, it would be they would be
- 22:21targeted. And when you go from a little over a million to over five
- 22:25million, that indicates genocide has not been committed against you by the very definition
- 22:30of genocide. So Israel is not committing genocide. It has no interest in
- 22:36committing genocide. What Israel wants is can you leave us and stop trying to
- 22:41wipe us out. And because of that, you can't argue that it's genocide
- 22:48when it's a response true, And it's not about the numbers. It's not
- 22:53about whether they were good genocide or bad genocide. It's if you know,
- 23:00so nine to eleven happened, right, And so the US went into Afghanistan
- 23:07and ended up with tens of thousands of civilian casualties. Now that wasn't an
- 23:15attempt to wipe out any group. You know, people in that region were
- 23:21trying to wipe out the Kords, which is why the Kurdish joined the other
- 23:26side. But it's just the whole thing. It's about intent, and the
- 23:34rhetoric in this whole thing has just been, well, you hate us,
- 23:38but you're less mighty warriors than we are. We hate you just as much,
- 23:41but we're better because we're stronger. It is that that rudimentary, It
- 23:48is that baby steps well anybody. It is impossible to have a rational conversation
- 23:56with somebody who believes that Israel took over land that was a Palestinian state and
- 24:04it's not it's not true, ed, and that Israel's trying to commit genocide,
- 24:11which the facts show they're not. When people believe these things as a
- 24:15given, it's very difficult to have any conversation about what's going on now because
- 24:21their idea of what the foundation is is completely skewed. Okay, but ed,
- 24:26you're assuming that anybody wants a rational, reasonable argument. Quite the opposite.
- 24:33They want people to get inflamed. They want people to stop thinking and
- 24:38just start reacting. They just want to make people feel so bad that they
- 24:44just want the whole thing to go away. Because what happens when that happens,
- 24:48everybody gangs up on the side they see as quote unquote more reasonable or
- 24:55should be more resonable, and they try to get them to shut up to
- 25:00appease the bully. That's exactly what's happening here. All Right, we're gonna
- 25:04take a break and come back and continue. All right, Okay, all
- 25:07right, Stream us Live at SAGA nine to six am dot C. All
- 25:22right, continuing our conversation about I mean, there's an old statement that the
- 25:29first casualty of war is truth, and that's true, and yeah, people
- 25:37say Israel lives. It's like, yeah, you know what, There's no
- 25:41question that governments put out statements which at times are intended to mislead. The
- 25:48thing about Israel is they have such a very vocal and active free press right
- 25:52loves exposing when the government lies. That's what they're there for. They love
- 25:57it like I can't imagine the other place where the free press loves I mean,
- 26:03you think they love it in England, You think they love it in
- 26:06the States. No, in Israel, they love exposing the government when they've
- 26:11done something wrong. And you know what, there's the opposition. The strength
- 26:17of the opposition to the president government in Israel is substantial. Yes, you
- 26:22know. Oh, that's something people need to realize about Israel is that only
- 26:26twelve and a bit percent of the population voted for Lakut, the party of
- 26:32President met Yahoo, Prime Minister, President Prime Minister. I thought that sounded
- 26:37wrong. Yeah, but only twelve percent of the population voted for Netsan Yahoo.
- 26:45Israel has this baffling system where you can hobble together a coalition of parties
- 26:55that have two seats, three seats, one seat. And there has been
- 27:00this back and forth in Israeli politics where everybody wants nt Yahoo out, but
- 27:06nobody can get along well enough to get a working coalition. He was out.
- 27:12They had a coalition government of both center right Jewish parties and Arab parties,
- 27:21the thing everybody claims to want. They had. They couldn't get along,
- 27:26so the government fell and nets in Yahoo because he had the party with
- 27:32the most seats, they went back to the polls. It was a stalemate.
- 27:36He was allowed to try again, and the coalition he managed to put
- 27:40together has been increasingly right wing and increasingly religious. Sell its well, it's
- 27:47not some arcane system unique to Israel. In a sense, it's proportional representation,
- 27:52and people in Canada want that here. It's like, you don't understand
- 27:56proportional representation is leannas said. You know, it doles out votes in small
- 28:03drips and drabs. So these parties that on their own have practically infinitismal support
- 28:10because they're they're on the fringes. They come together and they become components voltrons
- 28:17of the government, and they have the ability like if they pull out,
- 28:21the government falls. So the government to keep things together, the coalition has
- 28:25to bend to these lunatics like they're like and and Netanya, who has no
- 28:30principles, so he doesn't care that he's bending to the demands of a of
- 28:37radical religious and political right wingers who the majority of Israel can't stand. So
- 28:45it's a it's their political system that has that has got this to got them
- 28:49there. People say they elected bet Nyah who will Yeah, but no,
- 28:53uh, they didn't. I don't believe that as much as people who say
- 28:57that the Palestinians elected Hama. That arguments used at both sides, and it's
- 29:02wrong on both sides. The average population of the Gaza strip, the average
- 29:04age is like eighteen. Half the population is under the age of eighteen,
- 29:11meaning they weren't even alive to vote in Hamas the Palestinian territories have not had
- 29:18an election in seventeen years. Yeah, no, it's no side can be
- 29:26held responsible for the government they currently have. Yeah, you've got two groups
- 29:30of people who are you know, this is a bad pun with this but
- 29:37held hostage. That this is a hostage situation on many many levels, and
- 29:44neither side can do very much. They're trying, they're trying very, very
- 29:48very hard, mostly within Israel, but that's because of you know, some
- 29:53of the people who go back and forth from the West Bank. There are
- 30:00attempts this belief that it's just this cartoonish, you know, Elves versus orcs,
- 30:06or you know the way the dwarfs in the Elves don't like each other
- 30:08and the lord of the rings. It's it's not like that. It's very
- 30:12complex. And the minute you start flinging things like you know, say genocide
- 30:21or things like apartheid that require basically a very tyrannical system with the power to
- 30:30be a for a minority to inflict its will on the majority, it it
- 30:37I mean places like Russia, places like China. Oh you can't say that.
- 30:41No, No, that'll upset, that'll cause an international incident. Right,
- 30:45that's what you say when you say similar things about China or Russia.
- 30:49Right, Yeah, why are the rules so different? I want people to
- 30:56ask themselves, why are the rules so different? That's the core of this.
- 31:00That's let me, let me just finish this point. Yeah, it's
- 31:03not whether Israel has done bad things, whatever you want to call them.
- 31:10I don't care about the words, because the problem is is that a political
- 31:17tactic is make the debate a sole discussion about whether your opponent is bad or
- 31:25good, because an opponent will lose that fight every single time. All people
- 31:30have to find is one thing that they did wrong, and that's it.
- 31:34They've lost. What you have to look at is whether they are uniquely bad
- 31:41compared to other people in the same situation. And you cannot argue, based
- 31:47on the behavior of all of Israel's neighbors that they are uniquely bad in that
- 31:52region. You just can't. That's counterfactual. And now I don't remember what
- 31:57I was gonna say, but there's so much to say. I can just
- 32:00pick up from wherever. The fact is that what was I gonna say?
- 32:07Oh, the problem I have with people on the fire left who knee jerk
- 32:15support or oppose Israel is that they more oppose Israel than support Palestinians. For
- 32:21one thing. Wow, And they don't they don't realize they have adopted an
- 32:25anti Semitic worldview without even knowing it. And here's that's a whole lot.
- 32:30We've skipped over definitions of terms completely. But okay, here's here's the way
- 32:37I run I run it down. If you are pounding on Israel for their
- 32:44military response to the barbarity of what Hamas did to Israeli civilians, and if
- 32:52you're saying that, if you're criticizing Israel for going in and trying to route
- 32:57out Hama and the number of civilian Palestinian civilians killed. But you're not saying,
- 33:05hey, Hamas, you are using Palestinians as human sacrifices. No,
- 33:10ed, Now you're being racist. Now you're being racist. No, you're
- 33:15being racist at no, no, no, no not. You can insist
- 33:19that the Palestinians must condemn Hamas. Oh, that's racist. That's like what
- 33:22they did after nine to eleven, asking Muslims to That's what people do.
- 33:27That's what people do. You know as well as I do. Here's what
- 33:30I'm saying that Hamas. If Hamas really cared about the lives of Palestinian civilians,
- 33:38they'd surrender or they'd say we will not inhabit these particular areas. Hamas
- 33:45deliberately places their basis. And this isn't propaganda, it is documented fact.
- 33:50Yeah, hospitals that this isn't better known. I find this very strange.
- 33:54Yeah, they put it in hospitals, in schools, in a resident areas
- 34:00like homes. They do this on purpose because to them, every Palestinian civilian
- 34:07who is killed is a point in their favor to show how bad Israel is,
- 34:12how they are victims and they are. They're not victims. That they're
- 34:15not victims. The language matters here. They are martyrs. That means they
- 34:20died valiantly and will be rewarded in the next life. Victims is a very
- 34:25different mentality than martyr. So they're like, even though they didn't ask these
- 34:30individuals if they're willing to be martyred, as far as they're concerned, they
- 34:35are martyrs to the greater cause, which I'd like to get to you later,
- 34:38but they are martyrs. So as far as they don't wish to minimize,
- 34:43Hamas does not wish to minimize civilian casualties. They wish to maximize civilian
- 34:49casualties. And people say that's not true. All people are the same they
- 34:52want to protect. No, not all people. When you get into certain
- 34:55groups, they're not all the same. We don't all share the same worldview
- 35:00and values. So if you're not saying to Hamas, hey, Hamas,
- 35:05you don't want Palestinian civilian debts, get out of civilian areas. If you're
- 35:09not holding Hamas to the fire and say these people are being killed because you're
- 35:14hiding behind them and you're instead just criticizing Israel, you have adopted a passive
- 35:21anti Semitic point of view. See, I think it's actually anti Semitic and
- 35:25islamophobic because it's they expect that Muslims, well, brown people period are the
- 35:35only people who don't have a primary responsibility to protect their own people, to
- 35:39minimize casualties on their side, and unfortunately can't you can't turn away from the
- 35:46fact that the only way someone could believe that is that they believe that Arabs
- 35:52are just savages and can't be expected to be held by the same standard as
- 35:54actual humans. We experience this in a microcosm, and I what do you
- 36:01mean. Well, when we were at Much Music and on the music committee
- 36:06which selected videos, Much Music had specific rules about what could and could not
- 36:10be shown on videos that they air. But if a hip hop video came
- 36:17in for hip hop anything urban came in and it the video violated the rules
- 36:25that had been established, the very nice white liberal people would say, well,
- 36:31well, it's part of their culture. We have to let that in
- 36:35because it's part of their culture. As if you can't hold black people to
- 36:42the same rules that you hold everybody else, because it's like there they just
- 36:46can't help themselves. You know, they're over sexed and over like all these
- 36:52horrible, okay black stereotypes, and there was one black guy on the committee
- 36:55who just look over and rule. Well I remember member private conversations of what
- 37:05are they talking about? And no one knew what they were talking about as
- 37:10far as it's part of their culture. Yeah, because I mean, we
- 37:15did a documentary on this. Every every artist we talked to said they were
- 37:21just taking the imagery from hair band metal videos of the eighties of the eighties,
- 37:29and it's true, it was. It was appropriated culture. And that's
- 37:35the thing nobody asked. Nobody asked them. They just assumed because they were
- 37:42racist. Well they and these are people who thought they were being anti racist
- 37:47anyway. It's the idea that well that that term didn't wasn't quite popularized,
- 37:52you know, but these people thought that they were being progressive and supportive,
- 37:57when in fact, what they were saying is these are individuals who can't be
- 38:00held to normal standards because they can't help themselves. But it's absolutely undeniable that
- 38:07there is a dynamic there when it comes to any conflict involving brown people.
- 38:15It's just well, that's the way they are. They can't help themselves.
- 38:19We must pity them instead of respecting them as equals. Yeah, it's there's
- 38:24there's absolutely no way of getting around that. And this again is racism from
- 38:36the progressive left who think that they're they're being compassionate and sensitive, when in
- 38:42fact they're being racist. And we got to go a break. We'll come
- 38:45back. Okay, that's another thing I want to talk about. We come
- 38:47back because this is the part that just kills me. No radio, no
- 38:58problem. Stream is live on Saga C. All right, we're back.
- 39:07What part of kills you? Okay, so before the break we were talking
- 39:12about, you know, the whole we'll say benevolent racism, but it's not
- 39:16really benevolent on the left and the left for years. The reason I checked
- 39:22you a little bit on the anti racist thing is that that's a particular worldview,
- 39:28but short version. The left, especially the very left, has been
- 39:34pushing this idea that intense don't matter. If someone from the affected group believes
- 39:42that you are a bigot, you are a bigot, you don't get a
- 39:45say. Right, We've we've all encountered this, right, listen and learn
- 39:50right, this has gone out the window when it comes to Jewish people and
- 39:54anti Semitism on the left. You have to convince the number of people that
- 40:02I've said, you are basing your opinions on an anti on a piece of
- 40:07anti Semitic propaganda. No, I'm not. I have Jewish friends. I
- 40:12didn't mean to, I didn't know. You know what part of this is
- 40:16is there is this the notion has been just put into the bloodstream unconsciously that
- 40:24Jews are rich, powerful people, that all of them, we're all rich,
- 40:31powerful people. Do Anything Jews do can't be justified because they are in
- 40:36positions of power and they you know, they're using and abusing their power.
- 40:42And it's not true. Why which is why antifa jokes about getting checks from
- 40:47George Soros won't knock it off when Jewish people tell them you are not helping
- 40:54and don't see the problem, like if Jews control the media hyted to a
- 41:04meeting. None of this is true. And by the way, the reason
- 41:06I'm using Jewish people is it really confuses people about when the when the appropriate
- 41:13time to say Jews is. I feel bad for people on this one,
- 41:19all right, but anyway, Yeah, because there are some well meaning people
- 41:23have gotten yelled at for saying Jews instead of Jewish people because some people have
- 41:31turned the word jew. That's true, it's epithet, right, But it's
- 41:36one of those things like who gets to use the N word? And I
- 41:39personally don't use the N word, even with friends who say it's okay,
- 41:45you're not one of those people you can say THET I can't get it.
- 41:51It won't pass my mouth. I I won't say it unless it's a quote,
- 41:54and then even then I won't. But yeah, it's but just so
- 42:00people, because I've been asked that a lot that when I use the term,
- 42:05you know, the Jews, they're like, why can you say that?
- 42:08But I get in trouble and I'm like, it's there's a lot of
- 42:13complicated things surrounding it. Of is it just you know, you're either very
- 42:20in group or very out group, and so anybody kind of in the middle
- 42:24is left very confused. And I want to I want to give some some
- 42:29empathy to that, because it is very confusing if you don't. Well,
- 42:34yeah, because like I said, people anti Stomites have successfully turned Jew into
- 42:40an insult as opposed to an identifier. But because of that, and because
- 42:45self deprecating humor is a cope for many Jewish people, including me. It
- 42:53does confuse people and it is very challenging. And you know, I had
- 42:59this really nasty exchange with somebody who was applying the you know, the Jews
- 43:05just lie stereotype and didn't know it. And I completely believe them. They
- 43:10were them, they used they then pronouns. I completely believe them that they
- 43:16didn't know. The point is they spread it. And the point I made
- 43:22to them is that you won't give Jewish people the benefit of the doubt when
- 43:29it comes to these stories. You won't give them the benefit of the doubt
- 43:31for honesty and now you want it for yourself. How interesting? And they
- 43:38didn't get it, Yeah, you don't. People tend not to get what
- 43:43they choose not to get right. I just I just think a lot of
- 43:46people don't think deeply. And that's why some of the things you're saying that
- 43:52are absolutely right are really ineffective in terms of debates, because you're you're talking
- 43:59to people that don't don't think deeply enough to get to the level that you're
- 44:07at. Well, the other thing that as far as debates that I've found
- 44:13online is they people can't understand how you can both support Israel's right to defend
- 44:22itself and understand the principle of destroying Hamas, and at the same time be
- 44:29really sad and worried for Palestinian civilians. They think that if you are a
- 44:36supporter of Israel's right to exist, you are happy that there are Palestinian civilians
- 44:43that are killed. Like people have said this to me, Doesn't this make
- 44:45your penis hard? Don't Yeah? Yeah, showing me victim pictures like no,
- 44:52why can you not? Like some people cannot fathom that you can have
- 44:57sympathy and empathy for a civilian victims no matter which side of a conflict they're
- 45:02on, And that's because they themselves. Wait, have empathy. If you're
- 45:08on my side, I have empathy or sympathy. If you're on their side,
- 45:13I have none. Whereas I am sick about what's happening to Palestinian civilians.
- 45:17I support the idea that Israel needs to do something about Hamas, but
- 45:22I don't. I'm not happy at all about what's happening to Palestinian civilians.
- 45:28It's to me, they're I mean, as a Jew, no life is
- 45:30more precious than another, and so I know I am not. I'm not
- 45:37happy with what's happening to Palestinian civilians. But they can't grasp this, and
- 45:43that says something about them. I mean, the fact that they turned it
- 45:45into a sexual thing is well, these are idiots. Yeah, no,
- 45:51that that's beyond it. That's when people hit that point. It it really
- 45:57feels to me like reveling in it, and they are. And that's the
- 46:02part that I get really creeped out, because Okay, none of this is
- 46:13good. It's horrifying. That it's horrifying, and it's more horrifying because nobody
- 46:19can really do anything about it, and I don't. And that's the truth.
- 46:24All the protests, all of the nasty things, all of the chanting
- 46:29death to the Jews, all of the Free Palestine, even all of the
- 46:35I mean, they're doing some really really powerful installations. I don't know if
- 46:38you've seen in Tel Aviv with the table settings and the photos of the missing
- 46:45and the killed in the university on a time, they're really powerful. But
- 46:53let's face it, they're not gonna do anything because you've got a situation here
- 47:00where neither side can back down even if they want to. We're at an
- 47:05existential crisis point, all right, and at that point, we have to
- 47:09go to a break and come back and wrap up quickly. All right,
- 47:17stream us Live at SAGA nine six am dot CA. You know, it's
- 47:27a symptom of this topic that there were a few more really important points I
- 47:32wanted to make, but we haven't got any time. This is just that
- 47:36which points out this is not a situation that truly lends itself to black hats
- 47:43and white hats. Yeah. Also, Alan Wick two's out today, and
- 47:46I wanted to be talking about that, and I wanted to be downloading that,
- 47:51but I'm not. I'm talking about this nonsense, yeah, Ed,
- 47:54And I shouldn't say it's nonsense, but it is kind of nonsense. The
- 47:58fact that we didn't talk about the actual I guess we did, but we
- 48:00spent most time, most of the time refuting nonsense. That's very frustrating.
- 48:07And I know that you're using nonsense in place of a word that talks about
- 48:14bovine excrement. Oh, pretty much every third word I have used on this
- 48:19show today is not the word I actually wanted to use. Well, see,
- 48:24that's using diplomacy. I wish everybody involved in this would recognize that they're
- 48:30dealing with other human beings and try not to provoke, but to try to
- 48:35be a little more diplomatic. And I say that across the board right at
- 48:38that point, and that's what that's where we're going to stop on this topic
- 48:42because we've got to wrap it up. Okay. Leanna can be heard,
- 48:46as you know on It's not Therapy a podcast making a navigating the madness of
- 48:53mental health is the way that it's described. It's entertaining, but it's informative
- 48:59and it's touching on a human level. Check it out on all podcast platforms
- 49:02and serious XM app. Leanna also has videos on YouTube on the Leanna K
- 49:07Channel four nights, four days a week five. If you're a patron on
- 49:12Patreon, which you should be, check that out. I am on ninety
- 49:15four nine The Rock in the Greater Toronto area midnight to five am Eastern time,
- 49:22Monday to Friday, doing the all night show. We play music,
- 49:27and lately I've discovered that I actually know a little bit more about music than
- 49:30I thought. We're playing music. I take calls. It's a very interesting
- 49:35It's almost like an SCTV sketch, this cast of characters who are real people
- 49:39who call up regularly. You couldn't write this stuff. It just where it
- 49:44comes from is like whoa. It's very entertaining and fun, but also a
- 49:47sense of community and that can be found also on the Rock dot Fm and
- 49:52the rockapp. And if you go to the rock dot Fm or Rock app,
- 49:55look for on demand you will find the All Star All Night Show is
- 50:00collect weekly collections of the best stuff. All right, And at this point,
- 50:05uh, Leanna, I turn it over to you to take us to
- 50:08the finish line. Leanna, Bye bye bye. No Radio, No Problem.
- 50:24Stream is live on SAGA nine sixty am dot CA.