Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Labour on the brink, Trump hates more windfarms, and women of geothermal unite!
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to this latest episode of Energy Voice Out
- 0:05Loud. I'm Erika Ascalan, the news
- 0:07editor for Energy Voice. And coming up on this exciting
- 0:12episode, we will discuss labor energy policy on the brink.
- 0:17As they meet in Liverpool, Michael Baer is going to be
- 0:21talking about Trump and how he hates wind farms again, and then
- 0:25Matthew has been out and about meeting the women of Geothermal,
- 0:29so stay tuned. Hi, Matt and Mike, how are you
- 0:33today? I'm going well, thanks Erica.
- 0:34It's good to be back on the show while Ryan is off sunning
- 0:37himself in Tenerife this week. Sadly not the same level of
- 0:41sunshine in in Glasgow. I feel like every time I come on
- 0:44this podcast, I start talking about the the weather.
- 0:46But there. So never present.
- 0:49It's, it's a fine, you know, kind of British pastime, isn't
- 0:53it? Observe observations on the
- 0:54weather. So where?
- 0:55Where I come from, you know, we're too busy shovelling snow.
- 0:59Yeah. So at least I'm not having to
- 1:00put up with that at the moment, but otherwise doing well.
- 1:02How are you, Michael? I'm doing well.
- 1:04I've got, I've got things to talk about that's let's not
- 1:07instead of the weather, we've got stories that we're raring to
- 1:10talk about today. 100% Well, so we'll start by talking about
- 1:15energy policy, the Labour government, Um, it just so
- 1:19happens that they've got their, uh, party conference, uh, coming
- 1:23up in Liverpool, uh, after, uh, this, uh, podcast, uh, goes.
- 1:27So, hey, do you think maybe they'll be tuning in and
- 1:30listening? If you're listening, Ed
- 1:32Miliband, stay tuned. We've got some interesting
- 1:34things to highlight to you, particularly actually that it
- 1:39looks like the energy profits levy is failing to bring in the
- 1:45money that Chancellor Rachel Reeves needs in order to bail
- 1:49the UK out of whatever fiscal black hole they're facing.
- 1:53So the latest comes from well HMR CS own you know figures
- 2:00revenues from oil and gas fell 1.6 billion in the 202425 year,
- 2:09which is about 1/4 now. That's just kind of general
- 2:12revenues. So that reflects a number of
- 2:15things that reflects that oil and gas prices are lower, but it
- 2:18also and that production has declined, which of course we
- 2:21know is a bit of a natural thing.
- 2:24North Sea production has been in decline for a long time.
- 2:27We call that the Geo, the geology, the basin.
- 2:31But of course, you know, pretty much it's very clear that, you
- 2:35know, this decline has also been because operators are not
- 2:39investing, they're not drilling, uh, they're not spudding.
- 2:43Umm, you know, pretty much. There's been everything on hold
- 2:47and the reason for that is anyone care to guess why we
- 2:52think that that's the case? Anyone.
- 2:53Possibly have something to do with the Energy profits levy,
- 2:56also known as the windfall tax. Do.
- 2:58I get a Gold Star. You sure do.
- 3:00You sure do. You were going to say what?
- 3:04Ghosts. North Sea's gotten a bit
- 3:06haunted. Well, you know what?
- 3:08Actually, I feel haunted by the North Sea.
- 3:10I don't know about you guys. I'm pretty sure.
- 3:12I'm pretty sure Ed Miliband feels a bit haunted by the North
- 3:15Sea, you know, let alone Michael Shanks.
- 3:18Oh my goodness, you know, GB Energy, you know, they're all,
- 3:20you know, kind of like facing the same screaming banshees, you
- 3:23know, that, you know, whatever kind of anyone talks about the
- 3:26tax. But of course, what we also
- 3:30found is that, you know, the receipts that the government is
- 3:34expecting from the energy profits leverly level are also
- 3:38down 20% over the same period. Which kind of makes you think,
- 3:41well, if you're trying to tax stuff to raise money, because
- 3:46remember, you know, the the reason why the UK government
- 3:49wants to tax the North Sea is because they have a number of
- 3:54ways to spend that money. You know, not only is it
- 3:57supposed to fund the development of the net 0, whatever, you
- 4:04know, I mean, there's an expensive, you know, AR 7 coming
- 4:08up in order to try to kind of make sure that offshore wind
- 4:11farm developers have enough, uh, price, uh, to work on in order
- 4:16to kind of build that stuff out there.
- 4:19Uh, but there's all sorts. Oh, like, you know, the list of,
- 4:22umm, things, uh, that, you know, the government needs to pledge
- 4:26in order to, umm, develop, uh, net 0 is incredible.
- 4:31And in fact, actually, I'm going to just take a little bit of a
- 4:33swerve and I, I hope, you know, you're prepared for this one,
- 4:37Matt, but you were just looking at, uh, the cap and floor
- 4:40projects that are going to be going through for, for long
- 4:43duration energy storage. And that's a big long list,
- 4:46maybe not as big as we thought it was, but these are the
- 4:49projects that looks like the government are going to be
- 4:51backing, you know, kind of with strike prices.
- 4:55And, you know, that's just kind of one thing that they're going
- 4:59to have to promote instead of, you know, or in replacing fossil
- 5:05fuels because it's less dirtier. So tell us about what's going on
- 5:09with long duration energy storage.
- 5:11Again, just update us. Yeah.
- 5:12So the UK regulator Ofgem has revealed 77 long duration energy
- 5:17storage projects which are going through to the next phase of its
- 5:20cap and floor revenue support mechanism.
- 5:22So this operates a bit similar to the Contracts for Differences
- 5:26scheme that supports renewable energy projects like offshore
- 5:29wind and solar. So basically for these long
- 5:32duration of your storage developers, if their revenue
- 5:34drops below a certain period below the floor, they get paid
- 5:37by the government to top that up.
- 5:39If it goes above the cap, they pay the government back so that
- 5:42the bills don't get too high for the British consumer.
- 5:46So basically this was put in because most battery storage
- 5:49projects only go to about two, maybe 4 hours at this stage with
- 5:53the current predominantly lithium ion technologies.
- 5:56So that's quite short duration. And you know, as we've all come
- 5:59become familiar with the term dunkle flout in recent years,
- 6:02when we get long periods in the winter where there's not much
- 6:05wind. So we really need this long
- 6:07duration energy storage. We can go for 8/10/20 hours plus
- 6:11depending on the technology. So this is things like I guess
- 6:14basically much bigger and and more advanced within my
- 6:17batteries to vanadium flow batteries, zinc flow batteries.
- 6:22There's other technologies like pump storage, hydro that's.
- 6:26My favorite? Liquid air energy storage and
- 6:29compressed air, compressed air energy storage where the other
- 6:33technologies that made the cut and a few that missed out.
- 6:37But yeah, so that's that's where I guess one area where, you
- 6:41know, Ed Miliband might be having a bit more joy than he is
- 6:43in, in oil and gas policy is that there does seem to be some
- 6:46movement going because, you know, with 77 projects going to
- 6:49the next phase, there were, I don't recall the exact number
- 6:53that that didn't make it, but they were quite a few projects
- 6:56that didn't make it through to the next round of the cap and
- 6:59floor mechanism. So there's clearly a lot of
- 7:01appetite from investors for at least for, for this aspect of
- 7:03the UK energy sector. But currently, as we were
- 7:06talking about, not so much the the oil and gas sector.
- 7:09Well, see, going back to the oil and gas sector, you know, the,
- 7:14the, it kind of looked like the Labour government was rethinking
- 7:18maybe what they're going to be doing.
- 7:20And I'm wondering now actually kind of with all of this
- 7:22speculation and all of this pressure kind of coming, you
- 7:25know, from various other politicians on Labour government
- 7:29to just change their policy when it comes to the North Sea.
- 7:33You know, there's been this very interesting proposal by John
- 7:37Underhill, who's a professor over at Aberdeen University.
- 7:41So he's come up and said that one of the things that the
- 7:45government could do to, you know, kind of make the North Sea
- 7:48start to work again and, you know, maybe underpin a little
- 7:52bit of, you know, energy security to kind of slow that
- 7:55decline, increase receipts. Everyone likes, you know, kind
- 8:00of money coming in the door and I'm sure the Chancellor of the
- 8:02Exchequer would too. He's looking at, or he's
- 8:07proposed basically changing permitting to enable existing
- 8:14fields to be tied to existing discoveries and undrilled
- 8:19prospects. So, you know, he reckons that,
- 8:24you know, this will enable critical infrastructure to be
- 8:28extended a little bit and, uh, will, uh, you know, speed things
- 8:32up and, you know, will ensure that there are some fields, uh,
- 8:36that get, umm, produced. Uh, you know, he actually has a
- 8:40list of them. So there's, you know, gas, uh,
- 8:43projects in the southern north North Sea that could go, uh,
- 8:47there's, uh, ones, uh, uh, that, you know, were, uh, affected
- 8:51when the Thettlethorpe gas terminal was closed.
- 8:55See there's lots of gas too that uh, could be uh produced rather
- 8:59than stranded or brought in on a ship, uh, as LNG, uh, or, you
- 9:06know, kind of brought in from, you know, any other, umm, you
- 9:09know, kind of uh, maybe less savory government, you know,
- 9:12that is uh, still producing oil and gas because they're not
- 9:15afraid to do so. Umm, it's exciting times.
- 9:18So uh, we hope that umm, the, uh, everyone has a lovely time.
- 9:23Went there at, uh, Labour Party conference, umm, but that's
- 9:27enough. Listening to me on and on and
- 9:31on. We'll have a short break, and
- 9:34coming up we will be talking about everyone's favorite
- 9:39president of the United States and what he really thinks about
- 9:42wind farms. Welcome back.
- 10:31We're going to ask Michael Baer. So you've been writing about the
- 10:37latest salvo that President Trump has taken against the
- 10:42offshore wind sector in the US but it feels like it's having an
- 10:46effect here. Tell us more about that,
- 10:47Michael. We're glad we get to talk about
- 10:49Trump because I'd say that I am the second most enjoying person
- 10:54talking about Trump. That's a real Trumpian way of
- 10:56putting it. After Trump himself, I mean.
- 10:58Sure. Yeah, a double plus.
- 11:00Good way to say it for sure. I think like you, obviously we
- 11:04saw him talking at the UN this this week and he was basically
- 11:09repeating a lot of what he was saying about, he said during his
- 11:12state visit. The North Sea oil is, you know,
- 11:16we're neglecting this, this basin.
- 11:18You know, I'm not, I'm not a guy to to agree with Trump, but I'd
- 11:22say that maybe there's a few good points in there.
- 11:25Certainly I don't know why he had to say it as part of his
- 11:27hour long speech to the UN. But Trump's opinion, he's not
- 11:33someone who is shy about telling us how he feels.
- 11:37And his opinion on offshore wind is pretty set.
- 11:41And obviously, this has come manifested, shall we say, in a
- 11:46real vendetta against offshore wind in the US And this is part
- 11:50of a longer ongoing story as he basically just seems to be
- 11:54lining up offshore wind farms and taking shots at them.
- 11:59So latest on the chopping block? Chopping block or on?
- 12:04I'm messing up my metaphor on this.
- 12:06One, the firing line, definitely, I'd say it's
- 12:08definitely a firing line that he's got, you know, on these
- 12:10poor offshore wind farms, you know, that people are trying to
- 12:13build off the shores of the USA. So South Coast winds is an ocean
- 12:18winds development. Now if you're based in Scotland,
- 12:21you'll probably know ocean winds.
- 12:22I believe that they are currently the biggest operator
- 12:26of offshore wind in Scotland because they've got the Moray E
- 12:29wind farm, they've got the Moray W, they've got Caledonia coming.
- 12:33They're all kind of neighboring each other in the Moray first.
- 12:35So they're, you know, one of the one of the biggest developers in
- 12:40the world, certainly one of the most experienced and they were
- 12:42building this pretty substantial 2.4 GW S South Coast wind
- 12:48project. It's going to be off the coast
- 12:50of Massachusetts and they've got all their approvals in place.
- 12:55Like they've gone through the very long process.
- 12:58I think if I remember correctly, they got their final approval
- 13:02for their COP, the construction operations plan, which is
- 13:05basically the final administrative hurdle they need
- 13:08to to get over before they can they can start construction.
- 13:13They got that under the Biden administration three days before
- 13:17Trump got into power. Now, obviously, I'd say if you
- 13:21had like the list of things, Trump.
- 13:22Pretty close to the line, right? Yeah, Yeah, I think if you have
- 13:25the the list of things Trump hates, then offshore wind is up
- 13:29there and Biden is up there. So going after offshore wind and
- 13:34destroying what was, you know, I'm pretty massive part of the
- 13:39the Biden administration's kind of clean energy plan was
- 13:41offshore wind that yeah, maybe there's the bit it was like you
- 13:45try to sneak that one in you, you tried to get one on or on
- 13:49me. So, you know, they went through
- 13:53the approval process. And look, I think we know the US
- 13:57is a lot like the UK in that regard.
- 13:59The approval process is not fast.
- 14:01So there's very much the feeling that, look, we went through the
- 14:04approval process. It's fairly rigorous.
- 14:08If we got approved, then, you know, it's there's a reason for
- 14:12that. And now he's coming in saying,
- 14:14not Trump specifically, but his new Bureau of Ocean Energy
- 14:17Management, that's the, the US sort of federal regulator has
- 14:21come in and said, no, we think there's something that may be
- 14:24missed and we're going to suspend the, the, the approval
- 14:31essentially to, to go over it. Now there's a big question of
- 14:35what they're going to find, because obviously this isn't the
- 14:37first wind farm that he's that Boehm has tried this on.
- 14:41Now that we had revolution wind that that was probably one of
- 14:45the most. I mean, look, I'm the renewables
- 14:48reporter. I, I think, you know, I'm, I'm
- 14:50OK to admit there's a bit of bias in favour of renewables on
- 14:53my part that this was probably one of the more egregious
- 14:56examples because revolution wind being developed by Orsted.
- 15:00It was midway through construction.
- 15:02It's it is currently midway through construction.
- 15:05It was set to come online next year and they put in a stop work
- 15:10order which as recently Orsted as you know, they put in,
- 15:14obviously they went fighting in court and the courts have ruled
- 15:19kind of in favor that they can keep going with construction
- 15:23whilst this is being settled. Definitely the, the, the judge
- 15:29kind of came in quite in favor because one of the things that,
- 15:32you know, the the federal government was saying was, look,
- 15:36you've not demonstrated that you've the, this injunction,
- 15:40this stop work order, it's going to have a negative effect on
- 15:43your, your project. And obviously they went no, no,
- 15:46that that's completely the opposite.
- 15:47And the, the judge came in and said, yeah, in like getting in
- 15:52the way of construction is definitely going to have an
- 15:55impact. Because I think, you know, we,
- 15:56we know enough about offshore wind to know that the schedules
- 16:00are tight. And on international scale, the
- 16:04there could be knock on effects from these delays.
- 16:06You know, if you've, you're spending, however, millions of
- 16:10dollars it costs to to hire a wind installation vessel that a,
- 16:16you don't want run ONS by even a day and they have to leave to,
- 16:20you know, travel across the Atlantic to go work in, in
- 16:23Europe or the US. Your delays impact other
- 16:27projects. So they very much come down on
- 16:30the side of revolution wind on this one.
- 16:33And, you know, I was speaking to some analysts and they said that
- 16:37this, this is a sign that Revolution Wind is probably
- 16:40going to win this this case. And with a bit of luck, that
- 16:44means that there is the legal case that, you know, look, I'm
- 16:48not a sooth Sayer, but I think we can say that these there's
- 16:53going to be more of these actions against offshore wind
- 16:55farms, but that this means that they're likely to to win.
- 16:59These are some of the biggest interestingly investors, I guess
- 17:03in offshore wind because you know, there's Ecuador and their
- 17:07empire wind development, orsteds, revolution wind and
- 17:12then, uh, ocean winds. Umm, you know, with their
- 17:17project on the brink now, Umm it, I mean, is it, uh, are
- 17:22these, does this, what do you think this means for investors?
- 17:26I mean, these are, and they're all big major European
- 17:29investors, you know, does are they feeling a little bit left
- 17:33out in the cold, I presume from Trump, who, you know, was
- 17:37clearly, you know, thinks that he deserves a Nobel Peace Prize.
- 17:42Nobel Peace Prize against offshore wind that they'll
- 17:45they'll introduce that for him. I'm sure we're very much in a in
- 17:48stroking his ego mode these days.
- 17:51My assumption is that the right now if even if these projects go
- 17:58through, I think there's in the investment sentiment will be
- 18:01rattled. I know that I spoke to 1, you
- 18:04know, one person from one of the the services companies and it
- 18:07was very much the developer said we'll see you in four years that
- 18:13even if these projects go ahead, even if they win their court
- 18:16battles. And, you know, I think it's
- 18:18worth mentioning that there is bit of debate going on as to
- 18:23whether these actions are part of Trump's, you know, very well
- 18:27posted vendetta against offshore wind for spoiling the view from
- 18:30one of his golf courses so many years ago, or whether these are
- 18:33being used as essentially gambling tokens.
- 18:37Because Ecuador, we all pointed out that the the stop work order
- 18:43on their Empire Wind project aligned quite nicely with an oil
- 18:49and gas pipeline. I think the Constitution
- 18:50pipeline in New York getting re examined for approval.
- 18:55I'm not sure that anyone's been able to track down what oil and
- 18:59gas projects that Revolution wind and South Coast wind might
- 19:03be being used to push through. But that might be a fair
- 19:07assumption to to explore. But yeah, I think it is a case
- 19:12that investor sensible because a four year gap in the project
- 19:18pipeline we know is not a good thing from a work supply or your
- 19:23supply chain perspective that no one wants to go, OK, so there's
- 19:27going to be no US revenues for four years and that scares away
- 19:32work jobs, expertise, investment.
- 19:36Certainly, you know, I think there's probably plenty question
- 19:42marks about whether we will quite frankly even see a a
- 19:46unparalleled third Trump administration.
- 19:49So maybe four years might be. Oh, Yikes.
- 19:51OK, well, no. Optimistic crazy, isn't it?
- 19:55Absolutely. Well, he's he's selling those
- 19:57those Trump 2028 hats. Have you bought yours yet?
- 20:02Oh, I've got, I've got my Trump 2032 Charlie here.
- 20:05First renewables. Renewables report to Michael
- 20:08there. He's off the win.
- 20:09Can't stand it. Fabulous.
- 20:14Well, OK, on that cheerful note, we are maybe going to take a
- 20:19little bit of a different take here.
- 20:22Matt, you've been on your adventures.
- 20:25Tell us about what you're going to be, who we're going to be
- 20:28hearing from next. Yes, so I headed out to the
- 20:30British Geological Survey, a Geo energy observatory in Glasgow
- 20:35yesterday for a Women in Geothermal UK or Wing UK event
- 20:39to speak to a lot of very enthusiastic women about their
- 20:42love for and passion for geothermal energy.
- 20:45And during that visit, I spoke to Anne Morrell, who's the lead
- 20:48of Geothermal UK, and she is trying to set up an industry
- 20:51body to to push the geothermal sector and its benefits forward
- 20:56in the UK. So we'll be hearing from Ann and
- 20:58why geothermal has a lot more potential in the UK than you
- 21:01might think. Here in Glasgow at a mine water
- 21:58geothermal research site and I'm joined by Anne Morrell from
- 22:01Geothermal UK. And you're trying to set up
- 22:05Geothermal UK as a as a trade body.
- 22:07What are the reasons behind, I guess, why you think that would
- 22:10be beneficial for the geothermal sector in the UK?
- 22:14It's really important that we all come together to work
- 22:16together to speak with one voice.
- 22:19Every self respecting industry has an industry body and that's
- 22:23what we need for geothermal. To do all the classic stuff, to
- 22:26be the go to when people have questions, when policymakers
- 22:29want to know about the opportunities of geothermal and
- 22:33to have a go to website when people want to find out about
- 22:36geothermal. People like yourself and you
- 22:38have questions about geothermal and geothermal is so fantastic.
- 22:42It's we have so many opportunities under the ground
- 22:45for heating, cooling. And these start with ground
- 22:48source heat pumps with very shallow geothermal and go all
- 22:51the way through mine water, geothermal to deep geothermal
- 22:54into aquifers to extraction of lithium with geothermal.
- 22:58And we as a body, we need to work together to represent all
- 23:03these opportunities to in a very coordinated way and present
- 23:06them. Because a lot of people may
- 23:08think that geothermal requires somewhere like Iceland, Italy,
- 23:11New Zealand that has a lot of volcanic resources, but that's
- 23:13that's not the case I guess. What are some of the unique or
- 23:17specific advantages that the UK has when it comes to to
- 23:19geothermal energy? Well, it's not particularly
- 23:22unique. We all have these advantages
- 23:25around basically every in the UK, approximately every
- 23:28kilometre you go down, the temperature of the ground
- 23:31increases by say 2728°C and so very quickly you come to
- 23:37temperatures that you can actually use on the surface to
- 23:40heat. Of course, if you don't drill
- 23:43down very deeply, it's not really hot enough, so you need a
- 23:45ground source heat pump to enhance that heat.
- 23:48But as soon as you get down to a couple of kilometers down, you
- 23:51may be getting sixty, 7080° and that's absolutely sufficient to
- 23:56be heating homes. The brilliant thing about
- 24:00geothermal is you can just flip the system around and we're here
- 24:03in Glasgow at an actual functioning geothermal system
- 24:07which can provide heat by extracting the heat from the
- 24:10earth and putting it into the, the the surface, or it can take
- 24:14the heat out of what's happening on the surface and store it in
- 24:16the ground. So you have all these different
- 24:19opportunities of using geothermal energy.
- 24:22We also in, we do have I suppose some unique opportunities
- 24:25through our industrial heritage. Approximately 25% of the built
- 24:31environment in the UK is over disused mines.
- 24:35And you can imagine that as soon as we stop pumping water from
- 24:38these mines, they fill with water and these mines are
- 24:40underground. I was just talking about the
- 24:42geothermal, the temperature of the underground.
- 24:44So that's warm water, warm water under homes and businesses that
- 24:48need heat. So we have this great
- 24:50opportunity of using the abandoned mines to access
- 24:54geothermal energy. So that is, I suppose that's
- 24:56quite a quite because of our industrial heritage.
- 24:58That's it. That's a good opportunity.
- 25:00And you were talking through earlier today about some of the
- 25:04experiences you've had in Germany working in, in
- 25:07geothermal and some of the, I guess this terminology might be
- 25:10the cascading uses of how you can make use of Germal.
- 25:12So can you run me through I guess some of the how that looks
- 25:15in practice in terms of if a community has a geothermal
- 25:17project set up, what are some of the the flowing the flow on
- 25:20benefits from that that the community can see?
- 25:23The brilliant thing about geothermal is it's place based
- 25:26and it will provide solutions where it is.
- 25:29It's underneath our feet. We keep talking about energy
- 25:31security, can't get more secure than what's happening under your
- 25:34feet. But there are examples in
- 25:36Germany, specific examples that I've seen that exactly as you
- 25:40say, you can use the energy underground for a cascade of
- 25:43uses. I think the example that really
- 25:47comes to mind is a community called Kirchweidak, which is
- 25:50east of east of Munich in the middle of Bavaria.
- 25:54And what they do, they actually access the energy a few
- 25:58kilometres under their town and the the energy is warm enough so
- 26:02they can actually produce electricity out of the
- 26:05geothermal energy. This is another use which is
- 26:07possible in certain parts of the UK.
- 26:09So first of all, they they access these geothermal
- 26:11resources, they produce power and they produce more power than
- 26:14their small town needs. Obviously it's fed into the
- 26:17grid, but effective if the effective amount of power is
- 26:20more than their small community needs.
- 26:22And then once you've extracted the energy from the water to
- 26:25produce that power, the water is still pretty warm and you can
- 26:28use use the remaining warmth in the geothermal water.
- 26:32Then first of all they dry crops that extracts another couple of
- 26:35degrees out of the water. Then the water is I think 6070°,
- 26:40which is sufficient for their district heat network.
- 26:42So then that can go into district heating.
- 26:45And then after the the energy is extracted for the district heat
- 26:48network, the water is still warm.
- 26:50And So what they've done in the middle of the Bavarian
- 26:52countryside is built greenhouses, which obviously
- 26:56need a constant but relatively low temperature to use the
- 27:00excess or the remaining energy in that water to heat these
- 27:04greenhouses. In the middle of the Bavarian
- 27:06countries, that middle of the Bavarian winter, they're
- 27:09providing fresh fruit and vegetables for their local
- 27:11community. This is jobs, this is a new
- 27:13business, this is a new opportunity for the for the
- 27:16community. And then of course, when they're
- 27:18doing this, they're saving the flight of the tomatoes from
- 27:21Tenerife and the truck miles for the other vegetables that
- 27:26they're getting from the Netherlands, for example.
- 27:29And because the economics are so interesting because of these
- 27:34different uses of, of energy, the energy costs are very low.
- 27:39And this is the community is benefiting in lots of different
- 27:43ways, apart from having relatively economic heat, but
- 27:48business is growing, there are jobs in the area and they're
- 27:51able to offer these opportunities at a very, very
- 27:53low cost to the community. And the community gets this
- 27:55direct benefit. And then the brilliant thing.
- 27:57Can I just tell you the brilliant thing?
- 27:58So we've extracted geothermal water from the ground.
- 28:03We're taking out step by step through this cascade.
- 28:05We, we're using the energy for these different things.
- 28:08And when we, we've extracted all the energy from the water, what
- 28:11we do is we put it back down into the ground, it heats up
- 28:14again. And so you've got a constant
- 28:16system that just keeps on going. It's pretty remarkable, I think.
- 28:20You touched on some of the benefits there, some of the
- 28:22advantages around, you know, technological advantages, the
- 28:26environmental and social, but there's also a real energy
- 28:28security element of that. You know, you can't get more
- 28:30secure than just the ground, but beneath your feet, right?
- 28:33And so I guess what interest are you seeing from policy makers
- 28:37with all the discussions around energy security at the moment in
- 28:40the UK around geothermal? Are you seeing that level of
- 28:43interest increase? It is increasing slowly but
- 28:46surely. It's partly the job of the
- 28:48industry to make that story, but absolutely.
- 28:51And there are certain parts of government, for example the
- 28:53Ministry of Defence, where this really is a headline for them at
- 28:56the moment. So we it's a, it's seen as a
- 28:59great opportunity that we are slowly but surely unlocking.
- 29:04Obviously the other factor about energy security, not just that
- 29:08it's here, it's our domestic energy beneath our feet, the
- 29:11energy security in terms of constant flow of energy.
- 29:16It's brilliant that we have solar, it's brilliant that we
- 29:17have wind, but those are intermittent forms of energy.
- 29:20Geothermal 247365 that's another form of energy security that we
- 29:24can provide. And I guess what is holding
- 29:27geothermal back at the moment? What are some of the what are
- 29:29some of the barriers to seeing that more widely used in the UK?
- 29:33To a large extent, I think it's people aren't aware of this
- 29:37opportunity. As you mentioned, my background
- 29:41is in in geothermal in Germany and particularly in Bavaria
- 29:44where I was working. When when you ask people about
- 29:46renewable energy, it's wind, solar, geothermal.
- 29:49It's part of the landscape. I think Munich is going to be
- 29:53almost 100% geothermally heated very soon, by 2035 or something.
- 29:58In Paris, they've been using geothermal heating for decades.
- 30:01All the countries around us are using this geothermal heat.
- 30:03But for some reason we don't have that awareness.
- 30:07Perhaps the investors definitely government don't are not aware
- 30:12of this great opportunity and that's something that we have to
- 30:15change and we're working on now. And it seems especially strange
- 30:18because earlier today during your presentation, you were
- 30:20talking about the fact that in a lot of those projects that
- 30:22you've worked on, when someone had a problem, they had to call
- 30:25the office in Aberdeen. When someone had a technical
- 30:27question, they had to call the office in Aberdeen.
- 30:29Do you think that the UK is making enough use of that wealth
- 30:32of expertise that is sitting up in Aberdeen at the moment?
- 30:37Not yet, but it's a huge, it's I, as you mentioned when I was
- 30:41drilling in Germany, Aberdeen for me was this absolute
- 30:44paradise of drilling expertise. And we got crews out and we got
- 30:48equipment out from Aberdeen. And I'm very, very keen that we
- 30:52do leverage this and we do create or enable this transition
- 30:57of all the skills or the expertise or the knowledge from
- 31:01the traditional industries into this strangely enough new
- 31:05opportunity for the UK. But obviously it's been known
- 31:09for millennia the Romans were using geothermal heat.
- 31:12So this is a tried and test trusted technology.
- 31:15We have the great skill set in Aberdeen.
- 31:16We have all those opportunities, all that knowledge.
- 31:19We absolutely need to use that and have a huge opportunity not
- 31:23just for what we need to do in the UK, but to continue that
- 31:26huge export opportunity and the great reputation that that this
- 31:30skilled workforce in Aberdeen has across Europe and and I
- 31:34think across the world. And what would be your key
- 31:36message to policy makers if, say, Ed Miliband was listening
- 31:40to this podcast at the moment? What would you like to see the
- 31:41UK government doing to grow the geothermal sector in the UK?
- 31:46Understand the geothermal opportunity and talk about it.
- 31:49Geothermal needs to be in the energy strategy.
- 31:51We need a geothermal road map and when government sees that
- 31:55opportunity and recognises and speaks about that opportunity,
- 31:59it will open. Open up private investment,
- 32:02which is is obviously can follow government investment and make
- 32:07people more aware of this opportunity and open those
- 32:09doors. We do have the opportunity to
- 32:12drill deeply in the UK and produce power.
- 32:15And in fact the first geothermal power is going to go on grid I
- 32:19think in October in Cornwall with our United Downs, our
- 32:21colleagues from United Downs. But this will be a relatively
- 32:24small amount of power. But we do have opportunity
- 32:27through some very deep drilling. The Eden Project has drilled 5
- 32:30kilometers through this deep drilling, accessing these hot
- 32:34temperatures to produce power. But there's a really interesting
- 32:38other opportunity regarding power coming from geothermal.
- 32:43Of course, with the intermittent nature of our future renewable
- 32:47sources, we have to expand the grid and we know we have to
- 32:51expand the grid capacity. We have to make sure that we can
- 32:54bring all that power that's been generated offshore in the north,
- 32:57in the North Sea, across the country.
- 32:59And it's very challenging. Geothermal can provide power as
- 33:03a small part of that solution to have the base load in the grid.
- 33:08But if we think differently, a lot of our efforts at the moment
- 33:12are going on to electrifying heat.
- 33:14What happens and and actually heat is anticipated to be
- 33:18comprise 40% of the demand for power in the future.
- 33:24How about instead of working on the supply, we think about the
- 33:27demand and take that heat off the grid, take that 40% of
- 33:31demand out of the system and use the ground for our heat and use
- 33:34the ground for our cooling rather than electrifying it.
- 33:38This could have a significant impact on our energy systems of
- 33:42the future. It's a huge opportunity.
- 33:44It's a huge cost saving compared to the the grid expansion that
- 33:48we that we're planning. And I think these are the kind
- 33:51of messages that we need to get across to government.
- 33:53So the government realizes what a great resource we have simply
- 33:57under our feet. Well, thank you very much for
- 33:59joining us today. Anne And that was Matt speaking
- 34:02to Anne Morrell of the trade body Geothermal UK.
- 34:06You've been listening to Energy Voice and I just really like to
- 34:09thank Matt and Michael for sharing their thoughts.
- 34:14And I'd also like to thank you listeners for tuning in.
- 34:18We will be back again next week with more exciting energy
- 34:23industry news, so stay tuned. Dial in via your podcast channel
- 34:29of choice to make sure that you always hear what's going on with
- 34:33Energy Voice out loud.