Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Dealer Confidence Dips, Mazda Levels Up, Shoppers Trust Each Other
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Thursday, December 4th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. This is Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:06Today we're talking about dealer confidence dipping, Mazda leveling up, and shoppers trusting one another. Shoppers- Where I go. The people really wanna know. Who I am... they, they trust one another.
- 0:17I mean, that's how reviews are based, right? Instead of wanting to know who you be. So wild. We're like, "We don't trust anyone, unless it's a review." Unless it's a total stra- We'll talk about that in a moment...
- 0:24unless it's a total stranger on the internet. Unless it's a total stranger on the internet. [laughs] That's it. That's it. Same principle of Uber, right? Okay. Like, oh, yeah. That's fair. Let, let's get, let's...
- 0:33Yeah, honey, why don't you get in a- Yeah, but no, I've trusted a couple, like, uh, you know, I did... why don't you get in a car with a total stranger and have them drive you somewhere? You know- Yeah...
- 0:41U- UberX and Lyft low level is, it's a little- Oh, boy... you know. There's question marks there... you and I, you and I have some stories. There's question marks there...
- 0:48from missing flights to almost dying several times to, uh, smelling like a certain type of plant when we get out of the car. Oh. [laughs] Plant-based, you know, plant-based driving... plant-based Uber ride.
- 0:58Yeah, had one of those. One or two. [laughs] That's the best. Oh, well- They should make a new version called Plant-Based. Oh. Oh, it'd be amazing. There's a few things going on.
- 1:07Tomorrow morning we have Ed Roberts of Bosard Ford Lincoln on the show. Big, uh, position change for him. And, uh, we're gonna have him on the show to share tomorrow night.
- 1:17Um, we have a little photo to share of the White House. We're gonna put, throw that up in a second.
- 1:21But first we wanna make sure you're checking out all the new content we're putting out from our interviews at LA Automobility, at the Auto- LA Auto Show. Um, they're, they're nowhere else.
- 1:30You can't actually get these people talking about these topics anywhere but these interviews. No. We were able to snag them at the LA Auto Show. So you can search Auto Collabs.
- 1:38Uh, we just released our friends at Kirby helped us sponsor this, uh, the programming. Joe Castellino, if you don't know him, you should know him because he's a, he's a G. You should definitely know him. Yes.
- 1:46Uh, Efrain Barcelo and Cody Collins, so we're talking about mobile service. Two amazing dealers, uh, one amazing Ford rep, and, uh, you can get that, go to autocollabs.com.
- 1:56We also have a webinar we talked about last few days with our friends at Uber for Business. We'll talk about that more tomorrow. But you can go to asotu.com and get that. Let's throw this picture up.
- 2:04We need to talk about this picture. Oh. All right, here's the picture from yesterday in the White House when the president signed in the new legislation that, you know, we'd, we've talked about, we'll talk about more.
- 2:14But we just thought it was ironic that three of the people surrounding the president are people that we're kind of friends with [laughs] and that we've talked to in the last day. We have Tom Castriota,
- 2:25chairman of NADA, standing right at, at the president's left. And behind him- In the middle... Senator Bernie Moreno.
- 2:31Also behind him, uh, Congresswoman Debbie Dingell, who we just met and had a fantastic time with- Fantastic conversation... just a couple days ago. So we just thought it was fun to put this picture up.
- 2:40We caught it on LinkedIn. We're like, you know what? Automotive is kind of at the center of the conversation, and it's fun to be friends with the folks. So much fun... who are legit.
- 2:48You know what else was super encouraging? I've been talking a lot, but super encouraging. That's fair. Debbie Dingell, Democrat representative. Bernie Moreno, Republican senator.
- 2:59They are both pushing the same sled forward, and if you don't think automotive is an industry that brings the country together, you're just wrong. Watch the interviews. Isn't that wild? We'll release them soon.
- 3:09Isn't that great? So good. Like, pe- people that, that seemingly on the different, different sides of the, uh, of the sled, like, here we go. Yep. You know? All working together. So that's pretty awesome.
- 3:19We have some news today. And then we have a lot to do today. We got news. There's a lot to do today. Let's get into the news. I like it. Okay.
- 3:25Dealer confidence slid hard to close out 2025 as rising costs, shaking consumer confidence, and slowing demand pushed the Cox Automotive Dealer Sentiment Index well below the positive threshold.
- 3:36Current market sentiment fell to 38, down from 43- What?... in Q3, with franchise dealers holding slightly stronger at 47, they're always a little higher, and independent dealers lower at 35.
- 3:47Future outlook declined from 46 to 42. Uh, basically customer traffic hit record lows, especially for franchise dealers, with both in-person and digital traffic declining. Profit pressure continuing.
- 3:58Uh, sentiment dropping to 36 overall, with independents feeling the tightest squeeze, as they always do. Uh, EV outlook deteriorating sho- sharply. We've been talking about this nonstop.
- 4:08Franchise dealers, EV outlook 24%. Here's a quote from Mark Strand, deputy chief economist at Cox Automotive.
- 4:15He said, quote, "Compared to the rest of the year, the current market feels like running, it's running out of gas." Whoa. [laughs] That's kinda wild. Yeah. Compared to the rest of the year, the current market. Yeah.
- 4:25I mean, the rest of the year's been, like, jamming. It, I, I mean, first half of the year was jamming.
- 4:28And, you know, I, it's so funny because I think over the last three days I've seen the most posts about, like, "Yo, November ripped," than I have in four or five months. Hm.
- 4:43So I, you know, it is kind of interesting to get the Q3 results and know that there was some sentiment down, there was some traffic down, especially at the end of Q3 when you think about September, um, waning on so much of the EV stuff.
- 4:58You know, that, that conversation was definitely gonna happen. I'm- Of course... interested to see what happens in Q4.
- 5:03The few people that I've talked to all already kicking off, uh, December one, it seems like an aggressive month.
- 5:10Um, but, you know, the, the, the, the fact that I, I'm seeing a lot of digital traffic declining across all of GA4 accounts that I have access to, uh, across multiple companies, um, shows that shopper demand is, has, has definitely changed.
- 5:26And that could be aligned with EVs. Um, but the, the, this is the problem for me. When we take sentiment reports and start to, like, believe them- Mm...
- 5:36that, oh, everyone feels, that's when your store, that's when your company, that's when everybody starts to trend toward, uh, a perceived norm. Negativity. Yeah. Oh, yeah. You can, you can trend against this so quickly.
- 5:48All right.
- 5:49First thing that came to mind, because you and I get to talk to dealers nonstop, day in, day out, um, the dealers we talk about are reflecting what you said you're seeing on social media, people talking about things ripping.
- 6:01Dealers- Yep... saying this is the best quarter ever, having a great month, the store is doing great. Go, fill in the blank.
- 6:07Could it be-That the dealers who are listening, watching, participating in content, who are on LinkedIn and other social media platforms participating in the conversation- Oh, could it be?...
- 6:21are the ones that are just doing better because they're the ones just going with the change, rolling with the punches, as they say. Could it be that? I have a feeling- Could it be?... that's pretty strong.
- 6:31Could it be the ones that are paying attention are the ones that are staying? Doing better, not the ones just filling out the consumer sentiment in, like alone in their office. Ooh.
- 6:39So look, if you know those people or, uh, you know someone- Bring them along... send them over here. Bring them along. Have them sign up for the daily email at asoto.com.
- 6:47Sh- turn them onto the show, because the more people that are talking this way actually is better for the industry. I, I- there's no study that we can do that does that. I mean, we probably could.
- 6:55We're not going to, right? Like along with the sentiment index. Can you imagine if they- I think-... they put a... We should talk to our friends at Cox, because putting something in there about do you consume, right?
- 7:06Regular media across X, Y, Z sources. Regular media, modern media, right? I think, I think there's some correlation. We should talk to our friends there.
- 7:12That'd be an interesting one, and they got the power to pull it off. Yeah. Just saying. Speaking of the power to pull it off. [upbeat music] That's right. Segway.
- 7:19I love talking about Mazda because of your pedigree, so you always have a lot to think about and say about- I love that you call it my pedigree. It is your pedigree. I'm so happy about that. [laughs] It's your pedigree.
- 7:26In a recent interview with Automotive News, Mazda CEO, uh, Masahiro Moro breaks down how the brand quietly climbed up market, uh, growing dealer throughput, elevating brand value, and pushing their margins higher, even with the tariffs, um, and the profitability challenges.
- 7:40US market share climbed from 1.7 to 2.6 since 2017. Um, the ATPs jumping from 24,000 to 34,000, and dealer throughput nearly doubling at, uh, retail evolution stores.
- 7:54Basically, tariff pressures, tariff pressures giving a temporary lo- loss, but they're saying they're gonna return to profitability in the back half of the year as the CX-30 production is adjusting, uh, and large vehicle margins are still holding.
- 8:06Their strategy still centered on low inventory, high mix, and prepping for a big lift from the all-new 2026 CX-5, which is dope. Uh, [laughs] Moro calls the Mazda- Yeah...
- 8:16a, quote, "Inten- intentional follower on EVs," projecting 25% are on, or lower EV mix by 2030 while keeping 2027 development on track. So he said, quote, "2027 marks, marks the 50th anniversary of our rotary engines.
- 8:31What do you want to see?" Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. Everybody's been calling for this for a while.
- 8:36I don't know if it's gonna happen, but that little nod at the end of a big, uh, at the end of a big interview has me thinking, like, that rotary engine might come back.
- 8:44And I'm telling you, if they pull it off the way that they've been talking about it for the last seven to eight years, that thing's gonna run 50 miles to the gallon, and people are gonna race toward it. Oh, yeah.
- 8:54It'll be wild. So we'll see if that happens in 2027. They've obviously taken the trend of following, following Toyota in their footsteps.
- 9:01There's a big partnership between Toyota, Toyota, uh, Finance, um, as well as some manufacturing and production.
- 9:07And for brands that are leveraging hybrid at scale and have already won when it comes to gas mileage across the brand, um, that's why so many people are flocking.
- 9:20Not just that, but their Apple CarPlay integration and their tech integrations- Mm. They're always great... even though they don't have these, like, massive screens, are just so seamless. They're so easy to use.
- 9:30You've been raving about that forever. They're just so easy to use, and, and I think that that's a big reason for their jump. Um, not just that, but the design style is, is extremely savvy. I remember
- 9:42hearing, "Hey, we just went from 21,000 to 24,000 average transaction price," then the 24 to 27,000 average transaction price.
- 9:51Now you've got vehicles like the CX-90 competing with BMW's, Acura's, Acura's, um, high-market brands for a mid-market brand. It's really quite an incredible story over the last, like, seven, eight years.
- 10:04Ever since really, they really got out of the last legacy of the Ford relationship- Mm... Mazda has been challenging the market. To double your market share is quite insane. It is. With no trucks. With no trucks.
- 10:15And no large SUV. No. Period. Like the CX-9- what is it, CX-90? The biggest one? Yeah. That's their largest thing, yeah. That's the biggest thing. I mean, I'm a fan. It is still awesome.
- 10:26I mean, we've, we've, we've kind of had a front row seat to watching, uh, the new Beaver Mazda in Cumming, Georgia, go up from dirt to where it is now.
- 10:33And, uh, even seeing firsthand the reaction of some of the Mazda brass in how the brand is developing and how it kind of is playing out in that store specifically.
- 10:42And, um, man, I, I was never, like, really a Mazda follower or a Mazda fan just because lack of exposure really, but man, I am now. I am now. Come on now. Speaking of being a fan. [upbeat music] Segway.
- 10:57Yeah, it turns out the real power shoppers this year aren't actually influencers. They're everyday consumers dropping reviews at a record pace.
- 11:05Trustpilot, a massive review platform, reports a massive surge in review activity as buyers lean heavily on peer feedback before spending.
- 11:13Consumer reviews spiked 76% year over year, with nearly four million visitors participating in, uh, National Write a Review Week, uh, a big push on writing reviews across a bunch of products.
- 11:2586% of shoppers said they checked reviews before buying, and 40% waited specifically for others to post first. Hmm. So there's, like, a real desire to watch the early adopters give you a nod on, on what to do.
- 11:38Here's the top complaints, though. Delivery delays, meaning Amazon has changed our expectations there. Yeah, they have.
- 11:44Tech issues, meaning our software providers have changed our expectations, and weak customer service. Weak customer service. Holiday spending is tightening as well.
- 11:5328% of Americans plan to cut back on decorations, and 26% will spend less on gifts. Wild. I think that the increased participate- participation in reviews
- 12:05also goes along with the increase in, across social media in general of people wanting to get their opinion out there.
- 12:11I think those two things are actually correlated, and so it makes a lot of sense in that people are more, "Hey, I want you to know what I think." Isn't that the basis of social media? Yep.
- 12:21And so especially, I want you to know what I think about a good thing and especially a bad thing.
- 12:27I think when you get good reviews and you can overcome just the negative tendency of people to write negative things, I think it weighs heavy, and I know I can't think of one single person who shops online that doesn't rely heavily, heavily- Heavily on reviews...
- 12:41on reviews to make decisions. So, um, I think- Totally... this is just more par for the course. I think that cus- uh, companies making it easier and easier for people to leave reviews is, is an amazing thing.
- 12:50Like, I can't ima- Like, people are... Where did I go last where they're like, "Please leave us a review," and they, they, like, made it so easy? Um, there was a chiropractor that did it, and then there was one more.
- 13:02Ugh, I can't remember who it was. It, it... I mean, I'm, I, I like leaving reviews, especially when you get great customer service. Like, that for me is the one that if, if the customer service- A person, yes...
- 13:14everything else could, could, could wane, but great customer service, that will win my review every single time. Yeah, mentioning a person's name. It is kind of fun.
- 13:22If you do the Google Review thing and you add some photos, like, it's kind of fun, too, when you get the follow-up email like, "Hey, like, 1,000 people have seen your thing." Oh, man.
- 13:30Even though it doesn't really attract- Yeah... but it is, it's a little gamified, too. [upbeat music] Listen, it's Thursday. We got a lot. It's the 4th, December 4th, new month.
- 13:38We hope that your sentiment, wherever you are, your sentiment index is through the roof because it should be, because we're doing this thing together, caring about the people, selling some cars. We'll see you tomorrow.
- 13:47[upbeat music]