Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / So You Want to be a Space Lawyer? Don't Forget the Duct Tape and Other Lessons Learned
Transcript
- 0:02Hello everyone. Welcome to today's program. So
- 0:06you want to be a space lawyer? Don't forget the
- 0:09duct tape and other lessons learned. I'm Olive
- 0:12Poli Castro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:15Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:18And today I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:20Randy Siegel and George John. Randy is a partner
- 0:24in the corporate and finance practice at Hogan
- 0:27-Lubles -Cudwallader, where she counsels satellites,
- 0:30space, telecommunications, and technology clients
- 0:33on a wide range of complex and first of a kind
- 0:36transactions, including financing, M &A, joint
- 0:39ventures, and commercial deals. Drawing on 18
- 0:42years of experience at a startup general counsel,
- 0:45she serves as a trusted end -to -end advisor
- 0:47for clients navigating regulatory and business
- 0:50challenges across areas such as data privacy,
- 0:53spectrum licensing, export control, and communications
- 0:56and aviation regulatory matters. Randy has represented
- 1:00notable clients, including Columbia Capital,
- 1:03Next Nav, Neo Space Group, and international
- 1:05satellite procurement efforts for agencies and
- 1:08companies in Mexico, Brazil, Bangladesh, Indonesia,
- 1:11Oman, and the UAE. George is also a partner at
- 1:15Hogan Levels Cudwallader in their global regulatory
- 1:20group where he helps establish companies, startups,
- 1:24and trade associations, and investors navigate
- 1:26the complex regulatory landscape governing the
- 1:29communications and space industries. Drawing
- 1:32on prior experience at a pioneering nanosatellite
- 1:35company and at both the FCC and the FAA, he advises
- 1:39clients on spectrum orbital debris remote sensing,
- 1:43licensing, and related matters before the US
- 1:46and international bodies. We can't wait to hear
- 1:49what they have to share with us today, so I'm
- 1:51going to turn it over to them. Thank you so much,
- 1:55Ala. And so you'll hear from me first, George
- 1:57in the middle, and then me and George at the
- 2:00end. And I'll tell you, there is really, at this
- 2:04point in life, in history, no more exciting place
- 2:09to be than to be a space lawyer. George may have
- 2:12consciously found his path to be a space lawyer.
- 2:17I accidentally became one and I haven't regretted
- 2:22a minute since. So for those of you who are either
- 2:27interested in space law or interested in finding
- 2:30out about it as one of the more interesting areas
- 2:34of CLE, I couldn't question that decision. Space
- 2:39is an amazing place to be right now. And so I'm
- 2:46going to do a little bit of background for those
- 2:49of you who don't know that much about the space
- 2:53economy and industry either. So we'll weave in
- 2:56some practical perspectives there too to give
- 3:00you a little bit of a foundation. The global
- 3:04space economy's value goes up astronomically
- 3:11on a year -to -year basis. I think if we had
- 3:13this year's George with a SpaceX IPO, I think
- 3:18that that alone would catapult it into a factor,
- 3:22a multiple of what the space economy was before.
- 3:28A lot of growth in the industry is being propelled
- 3:33as well by decreases in the cost of launch. It's
- 3:38becoming more democratized, where space can be
- 3:42reached by universities that are creating satellites
- 3:47that they're launching by smaller companies that
- 3:52are startups. It's not just the Boeing and Lockheed
- 3:56and Airbus of the world anymore. What you'll
- 3:59see here also is, you know, how it divides up
- 4:06into U .S. government and non -U .S. and what
- 4:11we've seen as spacefaring nations go is that
- 4:17the United States has done an amazing job in
- 4:25keeping the economy going and a lot of the Chinese,
- 4:31which we do not have as much insight about as
- 4:34we'd like given geopolitical issues. The Chinese
- 4:38have also perhaps the second largest grouping
- 4:44of satellites and launches. But again, we don't
- 4:47have that much visibility and Europe is trying
- 4:51its best to catch up. and a lot of countries
- 4:55in Europe are really moving forward. This is
- 4:59a concept piece for you, this circle of the types
- 5:03of players in the space industry that you can
- 5:06represent, the type of legal issues and what
- 5:10side of the table you're on. So for example,
- 5:14You could be investing in space. There are a
- 5:17number of VC and PE players who we see continuously
- 5:22investing in space. You could be a sovereign,
- 5:28a government investor in space who come with
- 5:33different issues that they're looking to... achieve
- 5:37and different goals for their country. You can
- 5:41be the operator, that is the company that is
- 5:44operating a system, providing services, or you
- 5:48could be financing. an export -import bank, JP
- 5:54Morgan. Other bankers, you could be doing the
- 5:58financing for satellite companies or a SPAC or
- 6:01a DSPAC or an IPO. All of the concepts that you
- 6:05know about come together in the satellite industry.
- 6:10Then you have the regulatory and legal and contracting
- 6:15end. You can be like us. you can be service providers
- 6:19into the industry. This is an extremely, extremely
- 6:25highly regulated industry. And we'll get into
- 6:29that today in terms of what is, when we talk
- 6:34about what is space law, what is a space lawyer.
- 6:39So let's start here with what is space law? And
- 6:45hinted is rocket science. So when, when you are
- 6:51a space lawyer, it's a little bit like doing
- 6:58a law school exam question. Every single area
- 7:02of the law is begged. So you have to know everything
- 7:06that every lawyer knows. You have to know employment
- 7:10law, executive compensation, IP, everything.
- 7:15Go down the whole list of areas that you need
- 7:19to know if you are a lawyer. But on top of that,
- 7:24it is highly regulated. So George does regulatory
- 7:31communications type of rules, which talk to every
- 7:41component of a satellite has to have regulation
- 7:45attached to it. And a satellite system, and this
- 7:48is in the slides in the back, a satellite system
- 7:51is something on the ground. something in the
- 7:55ground, the customers typically have some device
- 7:59too, some kind of dish typically talking to the
- 8:04satellite, and then something in the air, the
- 8:08satellite. Now that's not the same architecture
- 8:11for every innovation in space. So it pivots,
- 8:15it's different if you have a commercial space
- 8:17station, but it's similar ideas that you have
- 8:22on the ground. people and devices communicating
- 8:26with, leading, monitoring the commercial space
- 8:31station. And you have something in the sky, which
- 8:36is the commercial space station. And you have
- 8:40different devices, both in the commercial space
- 8:43station and on the ground, to be able to communicate,
- 8:46to communicate for the mission, as well as to
- 8:50communicate in order to navigate. the commercial
- 8:54space station. Same with lunar landers, Mars
- 8:58rovers, these all have elements that combined,
- 9:03at least at this point in history predominantly,
- 9:06something in the ground that talks to something
- 9:10in space and whether it is a space station level
- 9:17low Earth orbiting, very low Earth orbiting geostationary
- 9:24that is hovering over the same spot on Earth
- 9:28the whole time. But there are regulations that
- 9:33are out there as to how you have to act with
- 9:40different regulators with respect to each of
- 9:44those components. What approvals do you need?
- 9:53How are you going to communicate? Is it going
- 9:55to be radio frequencies? Is it going to be optical,
- 10:00synthetic aperture radar? Then in turn, how is
- 10:04that regulated further by export regulations?
- 10:10If you have a certain type of payload, where
- 10:14you have energy being emitted, you may have nuclear
- 10:20energy regulatory and other regulatory. If you're
- 10:24doing an experiment in space, it brings in as
- 10:29well the potential if it's a life sciences experiment
- 10:33of the Food and Drug Administration and other
- 10:36agencies that control the Food and drugs in space
- 10:44so you find yourself as a space lawyer and with
- 10:49each innovation that occurs in space law having
- 10:55to Think about what happens when I layer on another
- 10:59area of the law So when you talk about yes, George
- 11:04if I could just intervene real quickly just to
- 11:07take a step back to help folks conceptualize,
- 11:10but you just uh outlined some of the like the
- 11:14space technologies everybody's describing sound
- 11:17really out there but they are here we'll get
- 11:19into it but there are other space technologies
- 11:22which we've had to regulate we've had to do contracts
- 11:25for we've had to litigate and you're going to
- 11:27be very familiar with them like some of the most
- 11:29uh common satellites provide connectivity to
- 11:33the house to your car, to your airplane, to your
- 11:38ship. Others are now connecting these things,
- 11:41handsets or iPhones or any type of user device.
- 11:45And then moving outside of the communication
- 11:47sphere, we have what we call positioning navigation
- 11:51timing satellites. One you're all very familiar
- 11:53with is GPS. The Air Force and now the Space
- 11:57Force run that system and it provides all the
- 12:02utility that's possible for infrastructure and
- 12:06life as we know it. Another very helpful space
- 12:10service is what we call Earth exploration or
- 12:13Earth observation or remote sensing. And this
- 12:16is the technology that you put on board the satellite
- 12:21that will take images or it will sense or radar
- 12:24the Earth. And that's how you get derivative
- 12:28products such as Google Maps, for example, and
- 12:30the satellite imagery you see there. And so why
- 12:33you might not think about on your day -to -day
- 12:34basis, you actually are quite impacted by satellite
- 12:38technology today. And those are three common
- 12:41services. And then they have the commercial space
- 12:43stations, the replacements to the International
- 12:45Space Station, or you have lunar Mars rivers.
- 12:48Elon Musk would like to start colonizing outside
- 12:51of Earth. And there are other derivative space
- 12:55services and applications and concepts that we're
- 12:58constantly noodling over. But I just want folks
- 13:01to be aware that three that are very pervasive
- 13:04are communications, PNT, or positioning navigation
- 13:08timing, and remote sensing. And that's a good
- 13:11segue into a further division of what is the
- 13:15space law that affects these different. services
- 13:18that I mentioned. So that's great, George. Thank
- 13:22you. And so, you know, unlike other areas of
- 13:28the law, when you think about it, other areas
- 13:30of law, constitutional law, what we take in law
- 13:32school contracts, constitutional law, there's
- 13:36a book. and the book has cases about a series
- 13:43of laws created either in law or in cases that
- 13:50define what is constitutional law, what is contract
- 13:53law. Space was actually not the same. There are
- 14:00historically space treaties, and we'll talk about
- 14:04that very briefly. And until recently, space
- 14:10treaties really had very little to do with our
- 14:13practice. Our practice of law as a space lawyer
- 14:20with the traditional space areas that services,
- 14:26whether it is cruise ship communications, whether
- 14:29it is DirecTV or DISH, whether it is SiriusXM
- 14:35radio, Those you normally think about more, do
- 14:41I have my communications regulatory approvals
- 14:43just like you need it for your cell phone? You
- 14:47know, there has to be approvals for terrestrial
- 14:49and there has to be approvals for satellite.
- 14:55And we haven't, so the space treaties have generally
- 15:02been drafted and there are more We'll talk about
- 15:07them later after this slide. We'll talk about
- 15:11them. They really don't impact the day -to -day
- 15:16practice of a lawyer, generally, as a space lawyer.
- 15:20We'll talk about that shortly. The areas when
- 15:23you said to me, when you say to me, what is space
- 15:26law? I would say to you it's an amalgam of these
- 15:31other areas, a specialized, commercial, way that
- 15:38contracts are written, especially an understanding
- 15:41of an industry and how the normal rules that
- 15:47would apply if you were buying a pen or paper
- 15:50are different when you're putting something up
- 15:52in space. So for example, when you're buying
- 15:56a satellite or when you're launching a satellite,
- 16:01You can't have the same exact warranty that you
- 16:05might have if you were buying a desk. With a
- 16:10desk, you'll always be able to fix it if it collapses.
- 16:15With a terrestrial phone, you can always fix
- 16:19it if it breaks or give someone a new one. Once
- 16:22you launch a satellite into space, historically
- 16:26at least, it is not that easy to fix it. Also,
- 16:31the risks involved historically with launching
- 16:35a satellite into space were ones that could ruin
- 16:38a company if there was liability. So the way
- 16:42the industry has evolved is space insurance has
- 16:47evolved as a critical component to close the
- 16:51gap. So space law is really an amalgam of the
- 16:58types of regulations and commercial dealings
- 17:02that have grown up in the industry and that have
- 17:07morphed from what other industries have. Why
- 17:09is it different than an industry that sells pens
- 17:13and desks and paper? Because of the nature of
- 17:18what's being done and the risks. and the heavy
- 17:22duty regulation. So in addition to communications
- 17:27regulation, which is what George will talk to
- 17:31us shortly about, you also have heavy duty in
- 17:35the United States, at least launches are regulated.
- 17:39We have multiple agencies regulating space. So
- 17:42we have the Federal Communications Commission
- 17:46in the United States. We have NOAA. Earth observation,
- 17:51and we also have the FAA, which regulates launches
- 17:56into space. And we have other agencies that oversee
- 18:02it and look into because it's an important industry
- 18:06for the United States. We have the Committee
- 18:10of Foreign Investment into the U .S. CFIUS and
- 18:14foreign direct investment issues so that if someone
- 18:16wants to buy an interest in a US space company,
- 18:21there's a long regulatory perspective. You also
- 18:25have export and trade regulations. There are
- 18:28some extremely complicated rules, both EAR and
- 18:36ITAR for any of you who are export gurus that
- 18:40apply to satellite industry components. Launch
- 18:45vehicles by definition, are viewed as ITAR, State
- 18:50Department, regulated. And it's a very complex,
- 18:55crazy quilt, especially when you have an international
- 19:00industry where components are being bought and
- 19:04moved across border and launches are being done
- 19:08in one country of a satellite being built in
- 19:11another country. And every time there's a communication,
- 19:15with regard to that. It begs export and trade
- 19:19regulation issues. And so the space law is really
- 19:25a compendium of all these different areas of
- 19:28the law. Just to mention the space treaties.
- 19:34So we've had space treaties since 1967. They
- 19:41are, I view them as generally more aspirational,
- 19:45but they do, they have started to take on more
- 19:49practical implications. So the Outer Space Treaty,
- 19:54for example, may be the one that It's sort of
- 19:59the umbrella one that has all of these principles
- 20:03embedded in it that we that that space belongs
- 20:06to everyone. We should all play nicely in space.
- 20:09We shouldn't use space for war. We should also
- 20:12have rescue other astronauts and so the outer
- 20:18space treaty has a number of countries who have
- 20:22signed up, but another number of countries who
- 20:24haven't signed up to the treaty. The others,
- 20:31including the most recent one, the Artemis Accords,
- 20:34has only limited parties who are members. So
- 20:37you ask yourself at the end of the day, what
- 20:39happens with our geopolitical issues when some
- 20:44of these countries are not members of that treaty?
- 20:48What happens when you do asteroid mining? And
- 20:51what the rights are? What happens when someone
- 20:53puts down a flag on the moon or Mars and says,
- 20:59I own this segment. What happens when someone
- 21:03purports to own a segment? What happens on the
- 21:07choice of law on all of the planets and asteroids
- 21:10and what applies? The treaties do not answer
- 21:14these questions. One of the practical implications
- 21:19which George will talk about that the treaties
- 21:22do address is it makes each country that is responsible
- 21:28for a space -faring party to have responsibility
- 21:35for the parties that it licenses. So the United
- 21:41States is responsible for the parties in the
- 21:46United States that it licenses. There are issues
- 21:52that have arisen over time with flagging of satellites
- 21:57and with orbital debris and with respect to different
- 22:03kinds of space pollution as to how this is all
- 22:10protected. In some countries, they regulate more
- 22:16than others orbital debris. activities to prevent
- 22:20orbital debris. On launches, some countries require
- 22:25their flagged parties, for example, SpaceX, to
- 22:29obtain launch insurance against personal death
- 22:36injury property damage. Some countries don't
- 22:41require insurance, and they just articulate that
- 22:45their citizens are liable to them for any liability
- 22:52that the state may have to other states. So this
- 22:55is coming more into thought processes, the space
- 23:01treaties, especially as people start to have,
- 23:05launches start to have, reusable launches that
- 23:08land in other territories. that might have failures
- 23:13where debris is left in other jurisdictions and
- 23:20more and more countries are beginning to think
- 23:23about having their own spaceports. So these treaties
- 23:28don't necessarily offer The answers, because
- 23:32they are written very aspirationally, but I do
- 23:36believe in the upcoming years that there needs
- 23:39to be some sort of an evolution of the space
- 23:43treaties into more practical decision making.
- 23:47Can I add a few things here, Randy? So going
- 23:51back to that space trees slide, just running
- 23:55through a couple of the. important principles
- 23:58in some of these treaties would be helpful for
- 24:00the audience here. The Outer Space Treaty, Randy
- 24:03highlighted one of the main provisions, which
- 24:05says that if one of your citizens is going and
- 24:10conducting some type of space operation, you
- 24:13need to authorize and you need to supervise them.
- 24:17And so this has become very complicated as to
- 24:20which administration is actually going to be
- 24:23the launching state and the one responsible for
- 24:26this authorization and supervision. And we can
- 24:29use, let's say, this remote sensing, the Earth
- 24:33observation, picture -taking camera, the satellites
- 24:36manufactured in the United States, but... Components
- 24:41came from New Zealand, the launches from New
- 24:44Zealand, the company that holds the license is
- 24:47from France, and there are a number of other
- 24:50countries that there's a nexus tied to. And so
- 24:54it's not actually abundantly clear that it is
- 24:56the United States in this instance that is the
- 24:59launching state and therefore should be responsible.
- 25:01And so these countries that might be launching
- 25:05state, they have a consultation and they decide
- 25:09that this entity, this administration should
- 25:11be the one that goes and takes the liability.
- 25:14And so that's something that needs to be cleaned
- 25:16up over time. Another provision in the Outer
- 25:19Space Treaty that might be of interest to you
- 25:21all is regarding property rights. And you have
- 25:25probably heard in the past of folks that were
- 25:28trying to sell rocks from the moon or from any
- 25:31celestial body. And it makes you wonder who owns
- 25:34things out in space. And the answer is, it can't
- 25:38be like a national administration, a government.
- 25:42There is a provision of outer space treaty that
- 25:44specifically forbids that. But the work around
- 25:48that countries have implemented, such as the
- 25:51United States, Luxembourg, Japan, and others,
- 25:55is the concept that private actors are not necessarily
- 26:00subject to the outer space treaty and they could
- 26:04be able to potentially take moon rocks and bring
- 26:08them back to earth. And so this is something
- 26:10that's gonna be tested over time and there's
- 26:13something we'll have to follow. The other two
- 26:16treaties I want to just quickly note, liability
- 26:19convention and the registration convention. The
- 26:21liability convention is important because this
- 26:24is what assigns risk. after something has actually
- 26:28gone wrong. And so if the property damage occurs
- 26:32in space, then it's fault -based liability that
- 26:35applies. If, however, the property damage occurs
- 26:38on Earth, then you have absolute liability. And
- 26:43so the administration that I had mentioned before
- 26:45that authorized and supervised is then on the
- 26:48hook in either case under the liability convention.
- 26:51And the registration convention is the one that
- 26:54ties this all together. And it actually says
- 26:57that if you're going to have a space object for
- 27:01a particular country, you need to go register
- 27:02it at the United Nations in the space object
- 27:05registry. And you also will need to have a national
- 27:08registry of all of your own space objects. So
- 27:12bullets one through five, there are the treaties.
- 27:17If you could go back, Randy. Bullets 1 through
- 27:205 are treaties. Bullets 1 through 4 are treaties
- 27:23that most of the world have signed onto. Bullet
- 27:265, the Moon Agreement, is one that a lot of the
- 27:30world has not signed onto. In fact, the United
- 27:32States is not a member to the Moon Agreement,
- 27:35and it actually is interested because it leads
- 27:37into the final bullet there, the Artemis Accords.
- 27:40This is not a treaty. The Artemis Accords are,
- 27:45let's say, a collection of countries, it's up
- 27:48to about 60 or 70 countries that have used a
- 27:52lot of the principles that we've described here
- 27:54under the Outer Space Treaty Liability Convention
- 27:56and Registration Convention to allow activities
- 27:59on the Moon and in cislunar space. And this was
- 28:05something that the US started because they wanted
- 28:08to build some type of consensus, but they recognized
- 28:10that a treaty would be hard to overcome given
- 28:13today's geopolitical context. And so it's been
- 28:17pretty impressive that just in about five, six
- 28:20years they've been able to get close to 70 countries
- 28:23to sign on to these non -binding, let's say,
- 28:26principles or guidelines. Okay, so a different
- 28:35summary of the core principles of all of these
- 28:38accords and treaties is peaceful purpose, no
- 28:42national claims, international cooperation, state
- 28:47Responsibility for their own space liabilities
- 28:50and astronaut safety. To help out other astronauts.
- 28:58George, do you want to? Well, yeah, that's my
- 29:02bad. I didn't actually appreciate that that slide
- 29:04was still there. So still your thunder on the
- 29:07previous slide. But moving into. I guess one
- 29:12of the more specific topics that we thought it
- 29:14might be interesting to you all. All of the different
- 29:17satellite services that we mentioned, they have
- 29:20a communications aspect to them. And specifically,
- 29:24if you think about how cell phones work or how
- 29:27Bluetooth devices work or the Wi -Fi at your
- 29:30homework, there are invisible waves that allow
- 29:33those technologies to communicate. And the invisible
- 29:37waves are what we call spectrum or radio frequencies.
- 29:40And the main authorities that are going to be
- 29:44regulating that are two. One is the national
- 29:47administration, the country where you will have
- 29:51devices communicating to and or from the satellites.
- 29:55And the second will be an international body
- 29:58called the ITU, or the International Telecommunication
- 30:01Union. It's a specialized agency under the United
- 30:04Nations. And to my knowledge, I think it's actually
- 30:08the oldest agency under the United Nations. It
- 30:12started back in the 1860s. sometimes 1800s or
- 30:151900s, early 1900s. And so what they are trying
- 30:21to do is essentially recognize that spectrum
- 30:25is a finite resource. It's like oil. There's
- 30:28only so much of it. The moment too many people
- 30:31start dipping and trying to get access to the
- 30:33spectrum, it runs out. And you can think about
- 30:38this as in like years ago when you're driving
- 30:40the car and you had radio stations that you were
- 30:43flipping through. Some of them you could hear
- 30:45two different channels, two different stations,
- 30:48especially talking over each other. And that
- 30:50is what we call radio frequency interference.
- 30:53And that's because they're using the same spectrum
- 30:55to relay the same data. And in the radio context
- 30:59in the car, it's not the end of the world if
- 31:01two stations are talking to each other. But let
- 31:03me tell you. If they are GPS satellites, and
- 31:07there's somebody else that's talking on top of
- 31:09those GPS satellites, planes are going to crash,
- 31:12or other utilities, as we know them, just will
- 31:15not function. And so that's why Spectrum is a
- 31:18Halib resource, and it's one that's very closely
- 31:21regulated by these two authorities. Switching
- 31:25gears, satellite imaging, which talked about
- 31:27the Google Maps example there. This is something
- 31:31where there's typically only one authority that's
- 31:34going to apply, and it's at the national level,
- 31:37and there is no equivalent internationally to
- 31:40the United Nations or just internationally in
- 31:43general. But at the national level, the main
- 31:46regulator that folks have to deal with is called
- 31:49NOAA, or the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
- 31:52Administration. And NOAA has jurisdiction if
- 31:57you are a U .S. person or entity. or if you are
- 32:04operating the private remote sensing system or
- 32:08the cameras from the United States. So we're
- 32:11not going to bore you with the two prongs and
- 32:14what they actually mean, but what you end up
- 32:17learning is you start actually digging in into
- 32:22the United States more and more often. So although
- 32:24you might not think you are a US person or entity,
- 32:27you might have US employees that are outside
- 32:30the United States, and they might actually have
- 32:31control over the cameras in space. And all of
- 32:36a sudden, even though you might think you're
- 32:39completely removed, you actually are regulated
- 32:43by NOAA in that instance. For space objects here,
- 32:48This is what you can think about. You launch
- 32:51something into space and you want it to be safe
- 32:54and you want space to be sustainable for a long
- 32:58time. forever. And there are a number of mechanisms
- 33:02or guardrails in place to ensure that your satellites
- 33:06are only up there for a certain period of time
- 33:09when they're operational. And when they're done
- 33:11operating, they get moved to some other orbit
- 33:15or they come through the Earth's atmosphere.
- 33:18There are other regulations that ensure that
- 33:21you aren't going to collide with other spacecraft
- 33:24or space objects. There are other regulations
- 33:27that say when you actually come through the Earth's
- 33:30atmosphere, the human casualty risk needs to
- 33:32be lower than a certain number. And so these
- 33:36space safety and sustainability type provisions
- 33:39are found internationally and nationally again.
- 33:43And so we already covered the outer space treaty
- 33:46and the things that might be most relevant for
- 33:49you all is at the national level. There's a thing
- 33:52called the launch authorization or mission authorization.
- 33:56And so the launch authorization, the way you
- 33:58can think about it, is SpaceX or Blue Origin.
- 34:03They have a launch vehicle or reentry vehicle.
- 34:08They have to actually go and get that authorized
- 34:10by the Federal Aviation Administration because
- 34:12they're launching from the United States. The
- 34:15mission authorization is slightly different.
- 34:17It's what happens after that launch vehicle has
- 34:20been launched into space. It releases the spacecraft,
- 34:23such as those communication satellites that we
- 34:25mentioned. And the communication satellites might
- 34:29have different activities that might do in space.
- 34:34One example is a company that's doing orbital
- 34:37transfer vehicles. And that means they will have
- 34:41little satellites inside of their spacecraft
- 34:43and they'll drop them off after SpaceX does at
- 34:46different little points in space. And so might
- 34:49they need a mission authorization to show that
- 34:51they will not collide with other space objects,
- 34:54that they will live up in space for a reasonable
- 34:56period of time and they will de -orbit from space
- 34:59in a responsible manner. And that's what mission
- 35:02authorization is. So if you want to flip to the
- 35:04next slide, Randy, all the different topics that
- 35:07I just covered on this prior slide, excuse me.
- 35:10They're outlined in greater detail here. We talked
- 35:13about the spectrum and the two authorities, internationally
- 35:16and nationally, for remote sensing, talked about
- 35:19NOAA, and NOAA is housed underneath the Department
- 35:22of Commerce. There are often discussions of Washington,
- 35:27D .C. about whether remote sensing and commercial
- 35:31space activities should be within NOAA or should
- 35:33be within a specific office of space commerce
- 35:36in the Department of Commerce. It hasn't been
- 35:40formalized, but probably I wouldn't be surprised
- 35:43if that actually comes about in the next five
- 35:46to six years or the next decade. Oops. Ready
- 35:52to go to the next page? Yeah, we talked about
- 35:55all the other things here in the previous slides.
- 35:57You can jump to the next one. So getting into
- 36:01the nitty gritty here, when you're actually going
- 36:04for an FCC satellite license application, The
- 36:08relevant rules appear in the Code of Federal
- 36:12Regulations, Title 47, and then Part 25. And
- 36:17I flag that because after we submitted this for
- 36:21the presentation here, the FCC actually adopted
- 36:25a new 47 CFR, Part 100. And I'll get into what
- 36:30that means in a second. But currently, what does
- 36:32actual application filing take? It's... hundreds
- 36:36of pages long, believe it or not. It's not just
- 36:39a simple administrative form. You are trying
- 36:42to convince the government what you're doing
- 36:44is safe from radio frequency perspective and
- 36:47from an orbital debris perspective. And so there
- 36:49are a number of legal and technical showings
- 36:51that you have to make. And we have a team of
- 36:54often engineers as well as lawyers that have
- 36:56to work on it together. And so not only does
- 36:59it take hundreds of pages of documentation, but
- 37:02you'll have multiple exchanges with the FCC.
- 37:05You might have multiple exchanges with third
- 37:06parties. And in the end, the process as it stands
- 37:10today could take anywhere from 12 to 18 plus
- 37:13months. Some instances might be shorter, some
- 37:15instances, and oftentimes it might actually be
- 37:17longer than that. And why is that relevant? It
- 37:21ties into FCC part 100 or space modernization
- 37:24proceeding. The FCC and the US government under
- 37:27this administration recognize that, hey, if the
- 37:29US -based industry is to succeed, the timelines
- 37:33can't be as exorbitant as they currently are.
- 37:35The documentation should not be as burdensome
- 37:38and as rigorous as it currently is. Every other
- 37:41country in the world has a much less stream,
- 37:43has a much easier process streamlined with very
- 37:45little regulation that they need to follow. And
- 37:48so that's why they adopted this part 100. And
- 37:52so In terms of the other things here, I'm not
- 37:57going to go into the details regarding the application
- 37:59materials, the information processing. We talked
- 38:02about how it would be easier now than it was
- 38:05before. And so going to the next slide here on
- 38:09spectrum, this is just for your background. discuss
- 38:13in the beginning about how invisible waves, and
- 38:17there's very limited a number of invisible waves
- 38:19available. And this very colorful chart here
- 38:22is what we call the spectrum allocation table
- 38:24in the United States. And the way you can think
- 38:27about it is, if you want to do a particular space
- 38:30or satellite service, what you are trying to
- 38:33do needs to fit within that color bucket that
- 38:35appears here. on the screen. And so if you were
- 38:39to take a much longer look at this later, you
- 38:44would see that certain services have a lot of
- 38:47spectrum, and certain services don't have a lot
- 38:49of spectrum. And historically, the satellite
- 38:51services, there has been some spectrum allocated
- 38:55for it, but it's been primarily for US government
- 38:58use. So the NASAs, the NOAs, the Department of
- 39:01Defense or Department of War, Those have been
- 39:04the historical strong incumbents, but what we've
- 39:07seen in the last 15, 20 years is the pendulum
- 39:10just totally shifts, excuse me, shift to the
- 39:13other end where we see commercial industry. being
- 39:16the ones that are launching things into space
- 39:19and operating massive constellations and all
- 39:21types of novel space activities. And so we see
- 39:25proceedings at the FCC, at the NTIA, which administers
- 39:30the US government spectrum. And we see conversations
- 39:32on Capitol Hill about allocating more satellite
- 39:36spectrum and more of it for commercial or non
- 39:39-federal entities. And this also, just to add,
- 39:43George, Selection of your spectrum also affects
- 39:48what you're building. And if you build it to
- 39:51the wrong spectrum, it is not a good thing. Similarly,
- 39:56there are different amount of spectrum you need.
- 40:00So, you are familiar with the phrase broadband
- 40:03and narrow band. There are certain technologies
- 40:08that require broadband, meaning more spectrum
- 40:11and cannot accomplish their mission in a narrow
- 40:15band allocation. Similarly, there is. interference
- 40:21that many of these services have in both inside
- 40:25of the band and neighboring bands. So we spend
- 40:29a tremendous amount of time coordinating both
- 40:33within the space industry and with other users,
- 40:37garage door openers, toll booth users, terrestrial
- 40:44users between all of these uses. And so the ones
- 40:47that you see that are extremely colorful with
- 40:51multiple boxes in one tiny little space, that
- 40:55represents a number of industry players that
- 41:00have to work together. Jumping into orbital debris,
- 41:11I already covered space safety and space sustainability
- 41:14and the different considerations when you're
- 41:17going for licensing and then operating the satellites
- 41:20thereafter. But if you're curious about how these
- 41:23rules have evolved over time, back in 2000s,
- 41:272004 specifically, like that's when the FCC first
- 41:31adopted a lot of its initial order of debris
- 41:36mitigation rules. And this was because no other
- 41:38government agency had taken on that role. And
- 41:40we recognized that commercial industry was taking
- 41:42off and someone needed to start authorizing and
- 41:46supervising these satellites. And nothing happened
- 41:49for about 15, 20 years. But you saw that there
- 41:52was a influx of new satellite applicants at the
- 41:56FCC. We talked about SpaceX, OneWeb, Telesat,
- 42:00Biasat, Amazon, and so forth. There were a number
- 42:04of companies that wanted to deploy large constellations.
- 42:07So the FCC decided in 2020 to revamp a lot of
- 42:10those rules that I was talking about earlier.
- 42:12And then in 2024, or excuse me, 2022, it further
- 42:17revamped it. And the most further revamp is the
- 42:20one that's most notable because there was never
- 42:22a rule saying how long after you finished your
- 42:28operation did you need to have that satellite
- 42:30deorb it completely from the Earth's atmosphere.
- 42:33It was just like a rough guideline of 24 years.
- 42:36And that just seemed like a super long time to
- 42:39leave something like a piece of trash in space
- 42:41and not have it pulled out. And so the FCC said,
- 42:45you actually need to have that spacecraft, after
- 42:48it's completed its mission, to deorbit within
- 42:50five years, not 25 years. It's caused a lot of
- 42:54change in how satellites are designed and they're
- 42:56manufactured and they're deorbited. You can jump
- 42:59to the next slide. So remote sensing, we flag
- 43:06that NOAA is the one that is supervising and
- 43:10authorizing. cameras and imagery from space for
- 43:14certain entities that fall within NOAA jurisdiction.
- 43:17If you're ever curious about what the relevant
- 43:18rules are, you can again go back to the Code
- 43:20of Federal Regulations, Title 15 and Part 960
- 43:23is where those rules are outlined. And here,
- 43:28I'm not going to go through all the nuances for
- 43:32the application, but what you need to be aware
- 43:34of is NOAA has a tiering system. Essentially,
- 43:39tier one means there are other operators in the
- 43:41world with the same camera capabilities. Tier
- 43:43two means they're only US operators with those
- 43:46same camera capabilities. Tier three means there's
- 43:49no one that has similar camera capabilities in
- 43:52the world, including the United States. And so
- 43:55depending on how sophisticated your camera is,
- 43:58talking about the resolution, for example, that's
- 44:01what's going to define how rigorous is your application
- 44:05going to be, how burdensome is the licensing
- 44:09compliance going to be thereafter. And so that's
- 44:13what Randy has pulled up on the screen here in
- 44:15terms of the tiering system. And I guess the
- 44:20caveat here is the rules were very bad up until
- 44:222020. and they were completely rewritten. But
- 44:26we're about six years now, and we've learned
- 44:28a lot from how the rules were rewritten. And
- 44:30so there is a lot of push on Capitol Hill and
- 44:34at NOAA, and it's been acknowledged by NOAA leadership
- 44:36that the rules do need a revamp. And so if we
- 44:39were to have this conversation again in another
- 44:42year or two, it's likely that we'd have a more
- 44:44substantive update and hopefully a more positive
- 44:46update on a streamlining and further modernization
- 44:49of the remote sensing regulation. And one of
- 44:53the dilemmas that we've seen in recent years
- 44:56is that so many companies are doing constellations.
- 44:59And constellations, by definition, leave your
- 45:03territory, and they go over other territories.
- 45:06And so when we, for example, with the NOAA licensing,
- 45:11in part in reaction to some attacks that occurred
- 45:16in the Middle East, recently in connection with
- 45:21some of the issues in Iran, the system has been
- 45:28evoked to require a mandatory hold with certain
- 45:35of the tiered. disclosures for a period of time,
- 45:40which in turn, if you're subject then to the
- 45:43U .S. regulation as opposed to having a system
- 45:46that is governed and flagged out of Spain, for
- 45:49example, it puts U .S. companies in a bad situation.
- 45:55It's hard for them to compete. So this is one
- 45:58of the, you know, back and forth that people
- 46:01who look at the policies here think about. On
- 46:04the one hand, you're trying to do the right thing
- 46:06for the world and deal with the geopolitical
- 46:10issues. On the other hand, when you regulate
- 46:12too much in the United States and put too much
- 46:15burden on U .S. system, it makes non -U .S. people
- 46:18in particular look to purchase systems from outside
- 46:22the United States. So, we're going to accelerate
- 46:29a little bit here as we have 13 minutes left.
- 46:33This is endless to talk about. There's so many
- 46:36interesting things to talk about, but we'll also
- 46:38let you know that in addition to the FCC NOAA
- 46:44ITU regulation, there's all sorts of regulation
- 46:49that occurs in connection with a launch. and
- 46:54in connection with the payload that's on the
- 46:57launch, are you launching into space on this
- 47:00rocket something that is dangerous, that could
- 47:03explode, that could do bad things? And those
- 47:05are regulated also quite a bit. And if it's a
- 47:10US FAA jurisdiction launch, it also will look
- 47:14at who's being launched on the launch vehicle,
- 47:18and is it safe? So the current regime does not
- 47:30fully address all of the types of cutting edge
- 47:35areas that we have, including in space servicing,
- 47:41manufacturing, lunar, Mars, asteroid mining,
- 47:45commercial space stations, commercial space flight.
- 47:48which is under a learning period. So just stay
- 47:53tuned. We could go through, which is a course
- 47:57unto itself, all of the status of all the issues
- 48:03on this, but suffice it to say it is an evolving
- 48:07place. Same on launch and human space flight,
- 48:14trying to not have red tape going on trying to
- 48:19rely on informed consent for the vehicle. You'll
- 48:24see also, by the way, in appendix two, you'll
- 48:28see that we gave a summary of some of the states
- 48:30in the United States that have. Protective legislation
- 48:36sort of think of it like a ski lift, but on on
- 48:39steroids where you wave, you understand and appreciate
- 48:43that it's a dangerous activity and you sign off
- 48:46on it. So, some states, those that have quite
- 48:49a few launch companies and space ports in them
- 48:55are more likely to have these types of provisions
- 48:58already in place. Here, we're going to just briefly
- 49:04highlight some of the other main areas that we
- 49:09space lawyers think about all the time. Export
- 49:12and trade regulations, almost everything in space
- 49:18is either EAR, Commerce Department, or ITAR,
- 49:24State Department controlled, requires a complex
- 49:29scheme of approvals, licenses, actions that are
- 49:34taken, and it's a full -time occupation for many
- 49:39people in space companies. We also have trade
- 49:43sanctions on certain countries. You cannot sell
- 49:49space articles to, for example, China, and currently
- 49:55also with Russia. And we've seen more activities
- 50:01this year also on tariffs, which is not new news
- 50:05to anyone in the United States. Tariffs are out
- 50:08there. You have to worry about them. But it is
- 50:10very complex when you have so many jurisdictions
- 50:13you're dealing with. You might have something
- 50:17being bought in Canada, something being launched
- 50:20in the US, part of it being purchased in Europe.
- 50:25tariff issues relating to that are tremendous.
- 50:29So export and trade regs are a full -time undertaking.
- 50:35Government contracts, national security, CFIUS,
- 50:41so much of the space business is either regulated
- 50:46by the government or the government as a customer
- 50:52has very significant issues that affect how you
- 50:57do business. You know, you may have heard of
- 51:00the federal acquisition regulations and the defense,
- 51:04DFARs and other contracting authority. And, you
- 51:10know, space is a... deep, deep interest of the
- 51:15government, whether it's as a customer, whether
- 51:18it's regulating it, whether it is regulating
- 51:21sales of the companies. If you sell any company
- 51:24in space to anyone who is a non -US person, even
- 51:28in part, it triggers CFIUS review. So these are
- 51:33things that we see all the time. Commercial transactions
- 51:37in space. There are many, many pieces of the
- 51:45puzzle that we deal with as commercial lawyers
- 51:49for space companies that are different than,
- 51:53as I said before, buying and selling a desk,
- 51:57buying and selling a pen, paper. Satellites and
- 52:01space transactions are unique, and the regulation
- 52:05relating to it is unique. Repairs, manufacturing,
- 52:10different ways that parties join together. For
- 52:16launches, it's very expensive. So lots of different
- 52:19commercial interests one has. Intellectual property,
- 52:26as in most industries, IP is a very big piece
- 52:32of space transactions. You really do focus a
- 52:38lot. just like most high tech industries on IP
- 52:44ownership and licensing, and very often relying
- 52:48on trade secret protection and to protect the
- 52:54innovations as to who's going to be the next
- 52:56generation SpaceX. Space insurance, as I said
- 53:05before, Space insurance is a major component
- 53:11of closing the contractual gap between to cover
- 53:19the risk of what's going on in space. Again,
- 53:22different than building a desk. You're building
- 53:25a satellite and you're putting it on a rocket
- 53:27that has a good possibility of exploding. And
- 53:33national space laws also foster having insurance.
- 53:44Very briefly, as we see different industries
- 53:49doing different things in space, these days we
- 53:52see a lot of space energy. We see data centers
- 54:00in space. We see nuclear Nuclear is one of the
- 54:08few ways that we're going to have for deep space
- 54:11travel. And what are the risks of nuclear facilities
- 54:15and batteries in space? And high power lasers
- 54:19to transmit energy to Earth. Life sciences, people
- 54:25have come up with some really important medical
- 54:28breakthroughs in zero gravity. that cannot be
- 54:32accomplished as well on the planet. And so with
- 54:37it, manufacturing pharmaceuticals in space and
- 54:43other body parts and the like become a risk and
- 54:50it intersects with the existing regulatory agencies
- 54:54for life sciences. AI, Privacy being able to
- 55:01see from space. Has generated some significant.
- 55:08Case law, so these are all issues that are right
- 55:11now evolving. Each of them is a course in and
- 55:16of itself. So space to summarize highly regulated.
- 55:23Compliance is difficult and costly to determine
- 55:28and ensure, and the laws are evolving and or
- 55:31have not yet been written. It's like playing
- 55:34a mystery multi -level chess game. Geopolitical
- 55:39shifts and issues come up as to who you can contract
- 55:43with to buy or sell. Just 10 years ago, Eight
- 55:48years ago, I had multiple clients who were buying
- 55:51Russian launches. And then the law just shifted.
- 55:56First, the law shifted based on U .S. government
- 55:59policy. And then it changed because of the war
- 56:02in Ukraine. And I have, you know, things have
- 56:06just changed. And you have to keep up with when
- 56:10you have a very complex supply chain. You have
- 56:15to think through how do I draft my contract so
- 56:18that I can get out of the contract if there is
- 56:21a geopolitical shift? We're going to end here
- 56:27in the last couple of minutes and there are no
- 56:29open questions. Just for you to think about,
- 56:33because I know we can't converse here, but George
- 56:36and I are going to converse a little bit. commercial
- 56:39space stations. There are four or five different
- 56:42commercial space stations now that are being
- 56:44built that are supposed to substitute for the
- 56:48ISS, that are going to be launched with maybe
- 56:53somewhat different missions and are going to
- 56:55be available for both government missions and
- 56:58for commercial missions, whatever that may be.
- 57:02And, you know, so first, We're all used to satellites
- 57:08which could take five years to build, six years
- 57:11to build, but these commercial space stations
- 57:13not only will take that long to build, if not
- 57:16longer, but also will be up there in space for
- 57:2050 or more years in space. How do you come up
- 57:25with the different rights for everybody for a
- 57:2950 -year period of time where regulation is not
- 57:33defined yet? George, what are the major issues
- 57:36that you've seen in commercial space stations
- 57:40so far? So just running through the list. Okay,
- 57:46from a communications perspective, we might have
- 57:50Wi -Fi terminals on board so that you or I as
- 57:54private space flight participants can actually
- 57:57cruise the internet while we're up there. Talking
- 58:00externally to the space station, they might be
- 58:03communicating back down to Earth using optical
- 58:06or laser energy. And so now you're talking about
- 58:09potential FDA involvement given their regulation
- 58:11of lasers on board the space station. In addition
- 58:15to having humans on board, you might be having
- 58:18all types of experiments and actual like you
- 58:23know, manufacturing going on board the space
- 58:26station. So one of our clients is going to be
- 58:30developing knee cartilage for folks that have
- 58:34lost ACLs and so forth. And apparently it can
- 58:38be done much more cost effectively in space and
- 58:43a fraction of the time and their whole Pitch
- 58:47is we are going to be manufacturing things just
- 58:50are not possible to do on the Earth's surface.
- 58:53And so that's one example. Another one that might
- 58:55be neat for folks to understand is cancer research
- 58:58or just like any type of basic cell research
- 59:01in space. It can be done in a matter of days,
- 59:05weeks, even maybe in some months. On Earth, it
- 59:09takes years, if not decades for that same research
- 59:12to occur. And so not only do you have FDA, they
- 59:16have a number of other agencies that are trying
- 59:18to figure out, do we have a say in what's going
- 59:20on here? The actual energy on board the spacecraft,
- 59:24there are initiatives within the US government
- 59:26that maybe it should be nuclear. It should not
- 59:29be solar energy that actually is fueling and
- 59:32energizing these spacecraft. And so here you
- 59:35might have the Department of Energy or one of
- 59:38its subsidiary agencies such as the NSSA. they
- 59:43might have a part to play here. And so that's
- 59:46just like a sampling of a couple different aspects
- 59:49of this commercial space station operation and
- 59:51the different agencies, at least three or four
- 59:53right off the top of my head that I can name.
- 59:55If you were to consider the fact that they're
- 59:56humans coming to and from and living on board,
- 1:00:00there's FAA involved. And so there's like a litany
- 1:00:03of acronyms and agencies that you could list
- 1:00:05here as commercial space stations evolve. You
- 1:00:09know, we think about this, I thought about this
- 1:00:11also for clients that were thinking of doing
- 1:00:12entertainment in space and doing sports in space.
- 1:00:17And you say to yourself, well, you know, what
- 1:00:19happens if I'm doing this extremely expensive
- 1:00:23experiment in space also and the light bulb goes
- 1:00:27off and who has the liability there? Who has
- 1:00:31the risk there? What happens if I have, you know,
- 1:00:36I sell somebody a module on my space station?
- 1:00:39What if they're not a good neighbor? Can I buy
- 1:00:42back the module? You know, what are the responsibilities?
- 1:00:45What happens if I have a Korean company in module
- 1:00:49one and a Japanese company in module two and
- 1:00:51a German company in module three? And what happens
- 1:00:54with the shared facilities for the oxygen and
- 1:00:58the food and sleeping and everything else? And
- 1:01:01what law, what's the choice of law that also
- 1:01:04applies? And what is the intellectual property,
- 1:01:09which country applies. So there's a lot you need
- 1:01:13to think about from a commercial perspective,
- 1:01:17let alone what happens when you have different
- 1:01:19sovereigns in the commercial space station that
- 1:01:23may say, nope, if it's my space module, my piece
- 1:01:28of the station, US law applies because I'm the
- 1:01:30US government. What happens if someone commits
- 1:01:33a crime on a commercial space station, which
- 1:01:35law applies? And, you know, so you've got to
- 1:01:40think about what can go wrong and who's going
- 1:01:44to be commercially responsible for it. And the
- 1:01:48models we have today for ground activity do not
- 1:01:51necessarily apply. George, anything else you
- 1:01:56want to say? Because I see we've run out of time
- 1:01:59and we don't have any questions. No, I just want
- 1:02:03to appreciate everyone for their time on this
- 1:02:06very esoteric topic, and I just want to highlight
- 1:02:10this last example here. The bounds are limitless,
- 1:02:13but there need to be limits, because one of my
- 1:02:17former supervisors at the FA would ask, like,
- 1:02:20where do we stop at the regulation example being
- 1:02:22commercial space stations? If I want to brush
- 1:02:26my teeth. or play the cello on board the space
- 1:02:28station? Do I need to really go get a license?
- 1:02:30Or will that be permissible in space? And so
- 1:02:33that's an open question as to where those bounds
- 1:02:35are. And so there's going to be a refinement
- 1:02:37of those treaties that Randy flagged, a refinement
- 1:02:40of national law and how it's implemented. And
- 1:02:42so it'll be an exciting time not only to see
- 1:02:44the technology involved, but also the regulation
- 1:02:47as well as how we arrange these commercial agreements.
- 1:02:52George and I also have our contacts listed on
- 1:02:55the cover of the materials. Feel free to reach
- 1:02:59out to us and also we're both on LinkedIn. Thank
- 1:03:03you.