Latest / No Way Out / Meaning Can't Be Encoded: OODA Loop, AI, and the Human Edge | Natalie Monbiot
Transcript
- 0:20Mark McGrath: Which I love having people on our show that come from all over the world.
- 0:23Mark McGrath: Certainly one of our our guests today who returns for her second go-around with us is on the all accent team.
- 0:30Mark McGrath: If I recall, she's I got a n you're from Nebraska?
- 0:35Mark McGrath: Is that?
- 0:35Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 0:36Mark McGrath: Somewhere somewhere like Yeah, Nebraska.
- 0:39Mark McGrath: No.
- 0:40Mark McGrath: Natalie, welcome back.
- 0:42Natalie Monbiot: Thanks very much.
- 0:42Natalie Monbiot: Great to be here.
- 0:43Mark McGrath: So we had you on over just over a year ago.
- 0:46Mark McGrath: I believe it was January of 25 for episode number 99.
- 0:50Mark McGrath: We're up to approaching 160, I believe.
- 0:52Mark McGrath: In the world of AI, which is your your world, um, and why we had you on the first time to talk about it, just in that 13 months since we last spoke, so much has happened.
- 1:05Mark McGrath: Actually, so much has happened since we booked this recording.
- 1:08Mark McGrath: Why don't you give us a quick overview of what you think the state of things are since we last talked?
- 1:14Mark McGrath: Because we we had such a good chat last.
- 1:16Mark McGrath: I know.
- 1:18Natalie Monbiot: I mean, I'm gonna sort of just try and define my lane, I guess, because there's a lot going on uh when it comes to AI.
- 1:26Natalie Monbiot: And what I'm continue a nice constant and through line through all my work, really, uh, is I continue to focus on the relationship between human beings and AI on a daily basis in their work in ways that enable humans to hold on to their agency, right?
- 1:46Natalie Monbiot: To hold on to uh having direction, control, freedom in their lives and how humans can, people can collaborate with AI to increase that agency rather than give it away.
- 1:57Natalie Monbiot: So I'd say that's a constant through line.
- 1:59Natalie Monbiot: And I am particularly uh excited at the moment about really kind of researching and digging into this space even further as I and you and all of us experience the advances in the capabilities themselves.
- 2:13Natalie Monbiot: And as that line of what AI can do for us keeps moving, it can do more and more and more.
- 2:22Natalie Monbiot: What should we let it do?
- 2:24Natalie Monbiot: And what does that leave for us to do?
- 2:27Natalie Monbiot: And what do we need to be very conscious of claiming and holding on to in order for this relationship to work?
- 2:34Mark McGrath: Aaron Powell I mean, that's the isn't that the conversation that many are having?
- 2:38Mark McGrath: Because on one hand, everybody thinks that they're getting replaced by AI.
- 2:43Mark McGrath: But then I think when we speak with you and you know, when Punch and I talk about this, we're talking about hey, how does AI serve us and help us and help us think better and help us orient to reality better?
- 2:53Natalie Monbiot: Well, first of all, I think the fact that we can offload a lot of really tedious tasks to AI is liberating, right?
- 3:01Natalie Monbiot: So a lot of, I mean, something that I've been playing around with a lot recently is uh clawed co-work.
- 3:07Natalie Monbiot: And the fact that I can allow an AI agent to take control of my machine and do the tedious tasks of, let's say, API integrations or like zap, connecting, you know, zaps from this to that and everything to like help me in the back end of my distribution of my content.
- 3:23Natalie Monbiot: The fact that I don't need to do that myself and spend my day doing that and feeling really frustrated about it is incredible.
- 3:30Natalie Monbiot: That's incredibly emancipating.
- 3:32Natalie Monbiot: So I'm all in favor of that.
- 3:34Natalie Monbiot: Of course, as the trust questions and like, should you trust that agent to do these things for you and whatever?
- 3:39Natalie Monbiot: But like as long as that's taken care of, and actually interesting, I think it's really interesting as well, sort of a tangent.
- 3:46Natalie Monbiot: Maybe we'll get to this after.
- 3:47Natalie Monbiot: Building trust, like I think Anthropics done an incredible job of branding and coming out as like we're the trustworthy platform.
- 3:54Natalie Monbiot: Like, I don't think twice about using Claude Cowork.
- 3:57Natalie Monbiot: Even if technically maybe I I should question trusting Claude Cowork to take over my machine.
- 4:03Natalie Monbiot: I'm just like, yes, yes, yes, permissions, yes, yes, yes, because I trust the brand.
- 4:07Natalie Monbiot: The brand has done a really good job, in my opinion, recently, of building that trust with consumers to enable us to feel comfortable about actually outsourcing such things like use of your computer to an AI.
- 4:21Natalie Monbiot: But I would not trust and necessarily entrust another um AI incumbent to do that.
- 4:28Natalie Monbiot: So I think it's really smart.
- 4:31Natalie Monbiot: Like we need to be able to trust in order to do it.
- 4:33Natalie Monbiot: Everyone's got different thresholds of trust.
- 4:36Natalie Monbiot: And it might be that we trust some more than others.
- 4:38Natalie Monbiot: So I think part of the battle now amongst the AI models actually comes down to how much trust they can generate.
- 4:44Natalie Monbiot: And I find find that really fascinating.
- 4:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I struggle with giving Claude access to files.
- 4:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I I before I do that, I'll back it up.
- 4:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I will, you know, I will test it out, I will do those things.
- 4:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, having seen a lot of data breaches and a lot of issues over the last several years, uh, you know, our likely chance that our phones are already hacked, somebody has access, apps have, you know, Siri can listen to this, things can do that.
- 5:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There are unintended consequences of doing this.
- 5:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it what I'm hesitant to do it.
- 5:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just based on my orientation with the threats that have been around me for my lifetime, right?
- 5:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it doesn't mean I won't do it.
- 5:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and then something else popped up in the last 48 hours.
- 5:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a heat map that came up, and I'm going to share it with the you and our audience at the moment.
- 5:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I don't know if you've seen this and Moose saw it, but uh I can't remember who wrote this or who created this, and I know it was taken down.
- 5:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is on the Wayback Machine right now, but it's given a heat map of where um likely jobs are going to be and not be in the future, right?
- 5:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Have you seen this, Natalie?
- 5:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I haven't.
- 5:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 5:47Mark McGrath: So the I can't think of his name.
- 5:49Mark McGrath: I have it here.
- 5:49Mark McGrath: I'll pull it up.
- 5:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it was somebody who was working with Elon, somebody worked with um I I can't remember which company, I don't want to get this wrong, but it's just a nice heat map uh that pulls from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and looks at what jobs are likely to go away.
- 6:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if you're in the green, if you're a cook, if you're a hard hand laborer, uh physical jobs, you're pretty safe.
- 6:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're in the legal field, if you have the computer in front of you at work or if you're working remotely, uh kind of like what we're doing, uh you're you're you're a target, right?
- 6:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you AI might be taking over things from you.
- 6:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's it doesn't mean it's right or wrong.
- 6:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just uh how things are evolving.
- 6:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's an interesting heat map that came up and they took it down within 24 hours of them putting it up.
- 6:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, you have the name on that?
- 6:31Mark McGrath: I'm looking for it right now.
- 6:33Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 6:34Mark McGrath: I I couldn't pronounce the guy's name, but he he was not OpenAI CEO.
- 6:38Mark McGrath: No, it wasn't OpenAI.
- 6:40Mark McGrath: It was um Anyway, I'll send it to you, Melly.
- 6:43Mark McGrath: Yeah, I'll find it while we're chatting here.
- 6:45Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's cool.
- 6:46Mark McGrath: There's an article recently in Forbes that when I sent you Punch, that someone was writing about how lawyers thought they were safe, and all of a sudden Claude is making them realize that no, we're not.
- 6:56Mark McGrath: We've we've got uh we've got some challenges that we're not we're not thinking about.
- 7:00Mark McGrath: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 7:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the acceleration of AI is is useful.
- 7:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in our house this morning, my wife and I, she works with a with a data company, and we talked about what our game plan is, uh, you know, once our jobs are not eliminated, but when we have to really compete for them, I think we're lucky.
- 7:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we have interesting thesis, we have interesting content, uh access, things like that.
- 7:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think we're safe.
- 7:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But for those that were coming from the consulting world, the agile world, where software developers are being reduced dramatically, we've heard from product owners that uh you can sit down with your customer now and you can vibe code things into things, right?
- 7:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That vibe coding thing that's happening.
- 7:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the world's changing, in my opinion, faster than I thought.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what we know from being on or you're having different guests on the podcast, it's about to get crazier.
- 7:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Natalie, any thoughts on that?
- 7:46Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, I think things are um getting pretty crazy and getting crazier.
- 7:50Natalie Monbiot: And I think that there's a couple of different ways of looking at this.
- 7:54Natalie Monbiot: I think when you look at it like from taking a big step back and kind of like holistically, it actually feels pretty frightening, I think, in some ways.
- 8:01Natalie Monbiot: And then when you look at it, and this is my own experience, right?
- 8:04Natalie Monbiot: It's like it's hard not to worry when you look at it from kind of a global perspective and kind of theorize about it.
- 8:10Natalie Monbiot: I do feel that the optimism can come about when you're actually working with AI yourself and unlocking the benefits to you.
- 8:19Natalie Monbiot: And I think that when you see piece by piece how benefits can be unlocked to you on a personal basis, you can start to imagine what the path to that future might look like for you.
- 8:30Natalie Monbiot: And to what extent you need to learn to work with the tools as they're emerging and as their capabilities are increasing in order to be able to even know and be inside the game, to know how to navigate working with AI in a way that actually does offer fresh opportunities.
- 8:46Natalie Monbiot: I think that the job landscape is gonna look extremely different.
- 8:50Natalie Monbiot: And I think there's there is evidence of pain already.
- 8:53Natalie Monbiot: I think that there is going to be a lot of pain.
- 8:55Natalie Monbiot: Uh, I also think that there is gonna be a lot of opportunity, but to be able to seize that opportunity, you really need to be in it and you need to be working with the tools in real time and trying to be aware of what you're bringing to the table.
- 9:09Natalie Monbiot: Like the tools are doing their piece.
- 9:11Natalie Monbiot: So what are you bringing?
- 9:12Natalie Monbiot: Now that you've unlocked all this time because I don't need to spend all day, you know, on my zaps.
- 9:17Natalie Monbiot: I'm like, okay, so what am I gonna do?
- 9:19Natalie Monbiot: There's a certain comfort to just like the mechanics of work.
- 9:22Natalie Monbiot: And I think a lot of white-collar jobs are actually about the mechanics of work, and that actually is exposes a fault line or an uncomfortable truth with maybe how corporate life or corporate structures have evolved.
- 9:37Mark McGrath: I feel like it started with do you think like it started with COVID?
- 9:40Mark McGrath: Because I remember when when COVID happened and I I was working in uh asset management, it really, you know, like when the tide goes out, you see who's swimming with a suit on and who's naked was sort of you know, AI has uh amplified this, but COVID, I think, showed a lot of the redundant jobs that don't need to exist anymore.
- 9:59Mark McGrath: I also think that blockchain did too.
- 10:00Mark McGrath: Like blockchain, not not Bitcoin, but like blockchain as a as a trust system showed a lot of things in asset management and processing and others, that there were these massive legacy apparatus that could just go away.
- 10:11Mark McGrath: Then COVID, now AI, it's showing more and more and more.
- 11:13Mark McGrath: Um, you know, you're familiar with our substack as we are with yours.
- 11:17Mark McGrath: I mean, I've not paid thousands for a graphic artist.
- 11:20Mark McGrath: Why would I do that?
- 11:20Mark McGrath: I can just go on OpenAI or chat or or Grok or Gemini and I can make my own pictures the way I want them, and it could be done in like a minute or two.
- 11:28Mark McGrath: Why would I pay thousands for a graphic artist?
- 11:30Mark McGrath: That kind of thing.
- 11:31Mark McGrath: I mean, but you're seeing more and more of that.
- 11:32Natalie Monbiot: And um say that maybe your business couldn't have emerged in the way that it has without the advancement of these tools that are available to you, right?
- 11:43Natalie Monbiot: And so that's an example of what is new that wasn't necessarily possible before with like a two-person unit, or you know, maybe there's more other people in the background or people that like chime in, or you know, you bring in as needed, but a lot more can be possible with ver fewer people.
- 12:00Natalie Monbiot: And that's not always a bad thing, you know?
- 12:02Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 12:03Natalie Monbiot: So I think there is gonna be a lot of discomfort, a lot of pain because of the way things have become, or the way that, you know, company structures and stuff like exist today.
- 12:13Natalie Monbiot: But I also think that there are new ideas that will come to light and new, just a lot of innovation that we can't even anticipate yet as a result.
- 12:22Mark McGrath: Grow growing up in Pittsburgh, you know, at one point there were thousands and thousands of steel workers, right?
- 12:27Mark McGrath: And then all of a sudden there weren't for various reasons with, you know, uh labor costs and that sort of thing.
- 12:32Mark McGrath: But at one point, still, Pittsburgh is still to this day producing a ton of steel with less than half a percent of what they, I mean, that's just my number, but like less than half a percent or one percent of what they had as a labor force because of the innovations and the things like continuous casting or whatever in robotics that eliminated jobs anyways.
- 12:50Mark McGrath: I feel like what we're seeing with AI is not new.
- 12:53Mark McGrath: And that's something that we bump into quite a bit with some of our collaborators.
- 12:57Mark McGrath: They say, yes, the medium is the message as Marshall McLuhan said, however, AI is different.
- 13:01Mark McGrath: And I think that McLuhan would say that no, it's not different.
- 13:04Mark McGrath: It's like any other technology that humanity has had that to adjust to because it's having a direct effect on our human capacity.
- 13:10Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 13:12Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 13:13Natalie Monbiot: Well, there's a I mean, okay.
- 13:15Mark McGrath: I think that we, as far as our human capacity is our capabilities or like to think that these things don't affect us.
- 13:22Natalie Monbiot: We I would say that basically our human capacity is being challenged right now, right?
- 13:27Natalie Monbiot: So it's like I think we've got quite comfortable going through the motions of life and work and maybe not having to think too hard or be on our toes too much.
- 13:36Natalie Monbiot: And there's just been a lot of kind of like ex you know, expectation about the comfort that a job will maybe provide for you without necessarily needing to exercise what, you know, push yourself as a human being.
- 13:49Natalie Monbiot: And when I say push yourself as a human being, it's kind of like, you know, being kind of more entrepreneurial-minded, like feel the stakes and try to be creative and like need to be creative and think about well, what is it that's needed?
- 14:06Natalie Monbiot: What should I do?
- 14:07Natalie Monbiot: What does this new situation present?
- 14:08Natalie Monbiot: How does you know, what does it present?
- 14:10Natalie Monbiot: If AI can do my job or a lot or a lot of my job, what should I be focused on?
- 14:14Natalie Monbiot: Like, how can I create value when the tools can handle so much of it?
- 14:19Natalie Monbiot: And for me, I really feel like our role as human beings is to create meaning, is to ask these questions and to figure out in our own world.
- 14:30Natalie Monbiot: So in my world, it's, you know, focusing on this line of AI human collaboration and kind of, you know, the discomfort of that and trying to figure out ways that we can collaborate in healthy ways with AI that constantly put our humanity in question.
- 14:46Natalie Monbiot: Like, what is it to be human?
- 14:47Natalie Monbiot: Right.
- 14:48Natalie Monbiot: So, like the the post that I just published is around judgment and why judgment should remain, broadly speaking, as a role that, you know, the domain of humans while execution belongs to the machine.
- 15:00Natalie Monbiot: But the post is actually about the fact that that line is constantly moving because clearly AI can judge.
- 15:07Natalie Monbiot: And clearly we want it to handle a lot of judgment for us because it's exhausting, making the same judgment calls over and over again and having to address, you know, potentially hundreds or thousands of similar requests.
- 15:19Natalie Monbiot: Like we want it to do that.
- 15:21Natalie Monbiot: We also want it to handle tedious work, judge, you know, make judgments on tedious work for us.
- 15:27Natalie Monbiot: But increasingly, as AI becomes more and more capable, its ability to actually judge for you in the way that you would judge yourself increases.
- 15:36Natalie Monbiot: And again, that's a good thing if you intentionally want the AI to do that for you.
- 15:41Natalie Monbiot: And you want it to do that for you because it makes it a more effective collaborator that understands you better.
- 15:49Natalie Monbiot: Yet there is a distinction between judgment kind of in the abstract, right?
- 15:55Natalie Monbiot: So just to be able to like reason through a problem and make a decision based on that reasoning versus the type of judgment that human beings are capable of, which is founded on understanding and meaning.
- 16:08Natalie Monbiot: Like what are the implications of this decision, right?
- 16:11Natalie Monbiot: So taking it all in, that is something that is distinctly human, as embodied creatures that have grown up and participate in the world.
- 16:19Natalie Monbiot: So that is the preserve of humans, is basically any type of judgment that requires context, meaning, understanding, um, which is contingent on the stakes as well.
- 16:30Natalie Monbiot: Do the implications of your judgment actually affect you or other people?
- 16:34Natalie Monbiot: Like you can't rely on a machine that does not feel and experience those stakes to do that for you.
- 16:38Natalie Monbiot: There's a really interesting anthropic study that goes into this and basically, because making difficult decisions, even though humans are really good at it and we have instincts, we have something that the cognitive scientist John Vivake calls uh relevance realization.
- 16:52Natalie Monbiot: Like we have this ability to zero in and just know the answer or know what's good and that kind of thing.
- 16:58Natalie Monbiot: But it's also uncomfortable making decisions, you know, by just trusting your instincts.
- 17:04Natalie Monbiot: And this study actually shows, this anthropic study shows what happens when human beings outsource decision making to an AI when clearly it's something that the human being should have decided for themselves.
- 17:17Natalie Monbiot: They can't help but do what the AI tells them because it gives them this illusion of certainty.
- 17:21Natalie Monbiot: They go out and do it in the world and like execute on these like real-world relationships, and then the result is regrettable.
- 17:29Natalie Monbiot: They express regret, right?
- 17:31Natalie Monbiot: So it's just proof that you can't outsource that kind of decision-making to the machine, as tempting as it is.
- 17:38Mark McGrath: You say meaning can't be encoded.
- 17:40Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, exactly.
- 17:41Natalie Monbiot: That's what I believe.
- 17:41Natalie Monbiot: I believe meaning cannot be encoded.
- 17:43Natalie Monbiot: Judgment, which has a pattern to it and has pattern is routine, judgment that you can teach can be taught to the machine.
- 17:51Natalie Monbiot: But when it comes down to really understanding and operating based, making decisions based on what it will mean, what the implications are, a machine just can't do that.
- 18:03Natalie Monbiot: That is for you, especially as you as long as the impact of the decision falls on you and other people, right?
- 18:10Natalie Monbiot: So there's something about the stakes as well.
- 18:13Mark McGrath: And that's why place the piece though.
- 18:15Mark McGrath: Like who are you really writing this to?
- 18:17Mark McGrath: You know, when you when you wrote this, who are you who are you really trying to connect with in this respect for this piece?
- 18:22Natalie Monbiot: It's people, well, first of all, I write it partly for myself to make sense of things for myself.
- 18:26Natalie Monbiot: And then others who are trying to make sense of how to collaborate, collaborate with AI.
- 18:31Natalie Monbiot: So these are people who are not, you know, there's obviously a camp of people who just like pro AI as fast as possible, like, you know, like like let's, you know, let's reach a singularity as quickly as possible, and like all that kind of stuff, right?
- 18:47Natalie Monbiot: So it's not for them because they're just not interested in that.
- 18:50Mark McGrath: Did you did you see Agents of Chaos?
- 18:52Mark McGrath: Have you seen that paper?
- 18:53Mark McGrath: Punkshire talking about that.
- 18:55Natalie Monbiot: Yes, I actually have seen that.
- 18:56Natalie Monbiot: Yes.
- 18:57Mark McGrath: Basically, as I as I read it, it basically is all these people had outsourced all of their decision making, including their orientation.
- 19:05Mark McGrath: So they they they were trying to encode meeting.
- 19:08Mark McGrath: They were they had they had given up on what they're supposed to be doing when we talk about.
- 19:11Mark McGrath: You know, they had given up on the world of reorientation and outsourced the entire thing.
- 19:15Mark McGrath: But I think ultimately that got them misoriented in the wrong direction.
- 19:18Mark McGrath: And when when they had given everything over to AI, everything just falls apart, which is you know, Moose, I want to add to this.
- 19:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I got to step out here in a second.
- 19:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But one thing that we're noticing on the podcast, when we're reaching out to guests and actually bringing them on the show, is we look at how well people write, the topics they're writing about, and and clearly we want those folks on the show.
- 19:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we're finding and discovering is a lot of times they don't know what they wrote because AI wrote it for them, right?
- 19:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had guests on the show that we're asking them about something they wrote in the last 24 hours and they can't remember it.
- 19:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're like, what are you talking about?
- 19:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what we're finding is I'll call them an AI parrot, right?
- 19:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're just parroting what their AI says, projecting it out there as content.
- 19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But when you put them in a room like this and you have a conversation, they have no idea what they're talking about.
- 20:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're they're useless.
- 20:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's gonna happen more at scale.
- 20:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is something that we're noticing.
- 20:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's probably more and more.
- 20:08Natalie Monbiot: That happens with your own guests, who are people that presumably have a strong point of view and all of that.
- 20:14Natalie Monbiot: And I think that also has strong implications for where other humans get their meaning, right?
- 20:20Natalie Monbiot: So you're gonna trust writing less, or you'll have a knack for seeing writing that was written by a human for humans.
- 20:27Natalie Monbiot: I've actually written about this before, specifically, like that distance that we feel.
- 20:31Natalie Monbiot: And there's studies like from MIT and stuff that show when you let an AI write for you or write the first draft, if you weren't involved in in the it, like at least at the very beginning, you have no connection to that, to that work.
- 20:43Natalie Monbiot: And then I guess the question is, well, what was that piece of writing for, right?
- 20:47Natalie Monbiot: If it was just content marketing and it's like riffing off a central idea, which is maybe true and meaningful, and it's just riffing, it's like, okay, so why not let AI do that?
- 20:56Natalie Monbiot: It's like, you know, different iterations of the same.
- 20:59Natalie Monbiot: You opened it, you read it, maybe you didn't read the previous, the previous post because you missed it or whatever, you know, all the the sort of the rules of opportunities to see and and all of that.
- 21:09Natalie Monbiot: But yeah, I mean, I strive to write in a way, even though I do use AI very much so.
- 21:16Natalie Monbiot: I strive to make sure, well, like I want it to connect with others and I want there to be a truth to it.
- 21:23Natalie Monbiot: So that's my medium.
- 21:24Natalie Monbiot: But it's interesting because video, live video, it's quite difficult to, you know, own an idea if you don't actually have it embedded in your system, right?
- 21:37Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 21:38Natalie Monbiot: In a video conversation, like it's easier to call people out, I guess, or being in a live environment.
- 21:43Natalie Monbiot: That's why live events are, you know, so important.
- 21:47Mark McGrath: Well, we're dancing around McLuhan because, you know, he always thought that content was less important than the medium.
- 21:53Mark McGrath: You know, the actual technology and the environment was more was more important.
- 21:57Mark McGrath: And I I kind of tie in too.
- 21:58Mark McGrath: I feel like AI outputs aren't necessarily bad, assuming that the thesis was good, right?
- 22:03Mark McGrath: Assum assuming that the thesis was coherent, assuming that, you know, you could sit there and brain dump and on things that you know about and in with your own unique thesis, and if the output reflects that, you'd have to know that because you'd have to have the command of the of the information.
- 22:19Mark McGrath: But it doesn't necessarily mean that the outputs were bad.
- 22:22Natalie Monbiot: Aaron Powell Yeah.
- 22:23Natalie Monbiot: I mean, if the thesis is grounded and means something and adds something and makes people feel something and it helps them to act in ways that they find valuable and therefore it keeps them coming back to the thesis.
- 22:34Natalie Monbiot: In whatever form, maybe you're doing them a service by articulating that thesis in more ways.
- 22:40Natalie Monbiot: They want more of that content, right?
- 22:42Natalie Monbiot: They want more ways to look at it.
- 22:43Natalie Monbiot: They want other ways that it can be said, they want it in different media.
- 22:47Natalie Monbiot: Like that's a good use of AI, I guess.
- 22:49Natalie Monbiot: But you know, like it depends on the strength of that original thesis.
- 22:57Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 22:57Mark McGrath: Yeah, I think that's really what it always boils down to anymore.
- 23:00Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 23:00Natalie Monbiot: I mean, if you think about it, like you could take a franchise, like a, you know, a book, you know, Harry Potter, right?
- 23:06Natalie Monbiot: That turned into a film.
- 23:07Natalie Monbiot: It turned into like all kinds of different things.
- 23:09Natalie Monbiot: I mean, that's because that the central story is so powerful.
- 23:12Natalie Monbiot: You know, someone didn't hand make every they did probably every aspect of that film.
- 23:18Natalie Monbiot: But you know, you can have all of these different iterations of things once you have that incredibly powerful story or thesis.
- 23:27Natalie Monbiot: And, you know, if it resonates, it resonates.
- 23:29Natalie Monbiot: And if people want more of it in different formats, you know.
- 23:33Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 23:33Mark McGrath: I mean, you wrote in March about like dividing the labors.
- 23:35Mark McGrath: You were saying about offloading tedious tasks.
- 23:38Mark McGrath: And, you know, these are things that Buckminster Fuller and Isaac Asimov, they predicted this with the automation of education, that they predicted this would happen and that would be a benefit to humans in their thinking and their learning that you would offload the, you know, having to get in the car, drive to the library, and go through the card catalog and all that stuff.
- 23:53Mark McGrath: Not that that didn't have merit in the old times when that was the prime technology at one point, but now you're able to offload that stuff and focus on what it is that you're actually learning.
- 24:02Mark McGrath: And you mentioned, you know, like Claude being a thought partner.
- 24:05Mark McGrath: I mean, I think that's a pretty valid use of AI.
- 24:08Natalie Monbiot: Feels like it.
- 24:08Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 24:08Natalie Monbiot: Although I don't have to bother my, you know, there are certain humans whose value I definitely uh would want on tap.
- 24:16Natalie Monbiot: But in the absence of that, Claude can do a decent job.
- 24:21Natalie Monbiot: It doesn't take the place of a human reviewer.
- 24:23Natalie Monbiot: Ultimately, I don't think.
- 24:26Natalie Monbiot: So but it depends on the stakes of what we're doing.
- 24:28Mark McGrath: I would love to have a conversation with McLuhan, but I can't.
- 24:31Mark McGrath: But I can, I, I can, I can Socratically ask Claude questions about stuff that I've read about McLuhan's to, I think, learn it better.
- 24:40Mark McGrath: Like learn it, learn it with more effectiveness, actually, than you know, it's not that I still don't read books and take notes because we still we still do that and we still go through transcripts.
- 24:50Mark McGrath: And I just got back from a trip and about to go on another one, and I I I still take books with me.
- 24:54Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 24:55Mark McGrath: But that even though I understand it there you go.
- 24:58Mark McGrath: Even though I understand it's artificial intelligence, there is something to be said about having to have a dialogue with it as if they were.
- 25:11Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 25:11Natalie Monbiot: Fantastic.
- 25:12Natalie Monbiot: But that's a great example of a thesis, you know, a body of work that exists that can like live on further, like more and like a wider.
- 25:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's something that uh I'm noticing uh as I interact with Claude, and that is, uh and I'm seeing a lot of posts on this too, and a lot of threads on it.
- 25:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is the way you interact with it is very similar to the way you would interact with a teammate, the way you ask questions, the way you would use different types of acronyms to, you know, a situation, a background, and a recommendation, that type of thing.
- 25:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What that means to me is that human agent teaming that is emerging is no different than what we understand from team science.
- 25:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And so we can start with that team science as a basis to help people understand this is how you work together as a team.
- 25:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And by the way, more than likely, this is how you're going to interact with an agent, not just a tool, but you know, something down the road that that might have some sentience and and who knows, might be conscious in the future, but this is how it works.
- 26:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's very valuable for me to see that the tools and techniques, the methods we've been teaching for the last 13, 14 years in teaming are more important today than they ever been.
- 26:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't know if you're seeing that too, Moose and Natalie.
- 26:20Mark McGrath: Say, yeah, I mean, I I agree.
- 26:22Mark McGrath: I mean, I think that that's what again, going back and reading like Asimov and all those things.
- 26:27Mark McGrath: I mean, robots were supposed to be our partners.
- 26:29Mark McGrath: Like those are supposed to be like any technology is supposed to be a partnership that we can, as McLuhan said, that organically becomes an extension of my myself.
- 26:38Mark McGrath: You know, I'm a Marine.
- 26:39Mark McGrath: A rifle is organic.
- 26:40Mark McGrath: A marine animates a rifle.
- 26:42Mark McGrath: That rifle is an extension of me, of what I, you know, so it doesn't replace me.
- 26:48Mark McGrath: It enhances me, right?
- 26:50Mark McGrath: I mean, that's I don't think I don't don't you think too, with John Boyd, with people, ideas, things all in that order, you know, things are so as long as they're augmenting human faculties and human learning and advancing us as humans, that there's nothing, there's nothing wrong with that.
- 27:03Mark McGrath: He wasn't a Luddite.
- 27:04Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 27:05Natalie Monbiot: Well, sort of going, you know, while we're on the historical references, Karl Marx worried that with industrialization, that basically the worker would be more and more distant from the product, right?
- 27:20Natalie Monbiot: Like what they were actually creating at the end of the day, right?
- 27:24Natalie Monbiot: At the end of the assembly line, like they have their task, and the more industrialization there is, the more disconnected that you are.
- 27:30Natalie Monbiot: And that um you could be end up being an appendage to the machine, which is really those were his words.
- 27:38Natalie Monbiot: It's just really interesting language, which I feel is so expand on that.
- 27:42Mark McGrath: I'm an economist, so I get it, but expand it, put that in terms of our audience.
- 27:46Natalie Monbiot: Being an appendage to the machine.
- 27:47Natalie Monbiot: So let's say, you know, line factory, I don't know, manufacturing a car, and you're one.
- 27:52Natalie Monbiot: I'm like a really not a specialist in this area, so forgive me.
- 27:55Natalie Monbiot: But like, you know, your responsibility is, I don't know, like the rear view mirror, right?
- 28:02Natalie Monbiot: And that's all you do.
- 28:03Natalie Monbiot: And you're doing the rear view mirror like every single time.
- 28:06Natalie Monbiot: But what you're building, or a cog and a wheel, maybe is like more appropriate.
- 28:10Natalie Monbiot: But the point is you aren't connected to the vehicle, the fleet of vehicles that are actually being produced and that you're contributing to, because you're just focused on this one tiny little thing.
- 28:20Natalie Monbiot: So you're an appendage to the machine, as in like you're serving, you're just like a little add-on to this thing that is being built.
- 28:27Natalie Monbiot: You are not central in any way to what is being produced.
- 28:32Natalie Monbiot: And I think that's really relevant now because I think that is exactly the the risk with humans in AI, is we can become an appendage to the machine in a lot of different ways.
- 28:42Natalie Monbiot: Like one way is that we're just training data that feeds the machine.
- 28:46Mark McGrath: Like training our replacements.
- 28:48Natalie Monbiot: Right.
- 28:48Natalie Monbiot: Or just like our knowledge.
- 28:49Natalie Monbiot: We're like feed what we're we're educating the machine on all the future batteries.
- 28:55Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 28:55Mark McGrath: We're an energy source for maybe I need to finally publish it.
- 28:59Mark McGrath: I've I've edited it so many times and it's it's it's been out there for about a year.
- 29:02Mark McGrath: I just haven't published it yet.
- 29:03Mark McGrath: But I I believe that's what content creators are doing on OnlyFans and whatever, they're training their replacements.
- 29:11Mark McGrath: Because at some point, the human angle there for the people that are consuming that is good.
- 29:15Mark McGrath: That's irrelevant to them at some point.
- 29:17Mark McGrath: If a machine can do exactly the same thing, always show up on time, that kind of a thing.
- 29:21Mark McGrath: You know, I I think that's a that's an interesting I mean, again, that's one example, but um I think that that's an example of someone who's, as as Ponch was saying, you know, you're you're basically training the you know, the consumers are training it one way for what it is that they want to consume, and then the and then the content creators are training it another way um and seeing what works and what doesn't work and you know what what hits.
- 29:43Mark McGrath: I believe actually, Natalie, it was at um we want to talk about artists in the machine at some point, but uh when I went to that last last year in Brooklyn, you uh you had uh Hazard Lee talking about the F-35, and he was saying that the F-35 that the prime mission of that is to collect data from pilots.
- 30:00Mark McGrath: Right.
- 30:01Mark McGrath: It's training itself constantly on the pilots that are landing on carriers or taking off this way or doing these maneuvers and all that, and the whole entire time is it's it's it's augmenting its own knowledge and understanding of things based off the telemetry of the pilot.
- 30:15Mark McGrath: At some point, the way he was describing it or the way I took it was like, well, the pilots are training their replacements.
- 30:20Mark McGrath: And those things exist now.
- 30:22Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, I mean, I guess it's a little bit like what I was just saying before.
- 30:25Natalie Monbiot: Like I have um a Claude skill that I'm training on my judgment, right?
- 30:30Natalie Monbiot: I'm actively training it on my judgment.
- 30:32Natalie Monbiot: I want it to know how I think better because that will just make me more productive if I don't have to keep correcting it every time, right?
- 30:40Natalie Monbiot: And so I'm kind of creating a digital twin of my, to the extent that I can, of like how I think.
- 30:48Natalie Monbiot: Um, and hazardly creating a digital twin of how he operates, right?
- 30:53Natalie Monbiot: There's skills in the cockpit.
- 30:55Natalie Monbiot: And I guess it's it comes down to the intent, right?
- 30:59Natalie Monbiot: Do you intend to be an appendage to the machine or do you intend to offload work to the machine so that you can focus on the faculties that are distinctly human that the machine probably can't do?
- 31:11Natalie Monbiot: And you can sharpen how you know, like the distinctly human aspects of flying a fighter jet or thinking and writing and creating meaning.
- 31:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's a thought, Moose.
- 31:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: John Boyd's aerial attack study is no different than what we're talking about right now, what Hazard Lee's talking about, right?
- 31:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So John Boyd was able to break down through cognitive task analysis, which it's hard for experts to do, is break that down and provide um not a step-by-step approach, but this is how things work, right?
- 31:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So he did that in the 50s before he wanted to understand the nature of creativity.
- 31:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's paralleling what's happening today, right?
- 31:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If the F-35 is collecting information from how people fly, how pilots fly, it's doing what John Boyd did back then.
- 31:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's understanding that, you know, how how do the experts do this?
- 31:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and again, going back to Gary Klein's work, where he says it's hard to break down expert work because experts don't know how to describe what they're doing to others, that's what Claude is doing, right?
- 32:03Natalie Monbiot: And that is what Mazda Lee's doing, because I think he led the training program for all new fighter pilots.
- 32:09Natalie Monbiot: And so, you know, one use of this model that is being created, this digital twin of how he flies the plane, is to be able to simulate that for others.
- 32:20Natalie Monbiot: So it's a way to teach.
- 32:23Natalie Monbiot: And again, it's kind of like where is the emphasis?
- 32:25Natalie Monbiot: The emphasis here is on training humans to be as good as they possibly can be, right?
- 32:30Natalie Monbiot: By training the machines in a way that enables that.
- 32:34Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 32:35Mark McGrath: I mean, we we've had simulators for years.
- 32:37Mark McGrath: We've had we've had these things conceptually, I think, for a long time.
- 32:41Mark McGrath: It's just that the the the technology or I don't know, some something has changed, but but conceptually, you're still using technology to make humans better at at what they do, right?
- 32:56Mark McGrath: I mean, I found like like my one of one of my gaps was always like psychology and emotional intelligence.
- 33:01Mark McGrath: And I found that the more stuff that I put inside of a strategic intelligence system I was trying to design on Chat GPT, the more psych stuff and the more emotional intelligence stuff, like it would direct me in places to go read and study and make me aware of things that I hadn't, you know, that I hadn't thought of before.
- 33:17Mark McGrath: Almost like, as you were saying in in your article, almost like an intellectual partner to say, hey, look at this or think about this.
- 33:23Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, I mean, that's how I try to use it.
- 33:26Natalie Monbiot: I mean, I will have to say, it's very tempting to just give it more, right?
- 33:32Natalie Monbiot: Because it can.
- 33:33Natalie Monbiot: That's the difference, I think, with at least LLMs, right?
- 33:37Natalie Monbiot: Is that they can do the work, they can judge, they can write stuff up.
- 33:43Natalie Monbiot: Um, so I'm actually a little allergic to anything that's really long because and anything that's really verbose, right?
- 33:51Natalie Monbiot: That might have been likely to have had AI involved because it's so easy to just produce something that is sounds sort of elegant, veneer, you know, and sort of on the surface, but doesn't, yeah.
- 34:05Natalie Monbiot: It's just like someone didn't even like pare it down to its bare essence.
- 34:09Natalie Monbiot: And it's like, what is the essence?
- 34:10Natalie Monbiot: That's all I care about.
- 34:12Natalie Monbiot: Is there an essence?
- 34:13Natalie Monbiot: Like, could this be boiled down to an essence?
- 34:15Natalie Monbiot: And I feel like, you know, people have a little sniff test for that.
- 34:19Natalie Monbiot: And work slop, right?
- 34:21Natalie Monbiot: So there was a Harvard business review study that shows that 41% of people at work have been exposed to work slop, right?
- 34:29Natalie Monbiot: And that is exactly that thing.
- 34:30Natalie Monbiot: Is that new?
- 34:31Mark McGrath: Is that new?
- 34:32Mark McGrath: Haven't you sat through a shitty, a shitty PowerPoint that somebody made that was shit and it was like garbage?
- 34:38Mark McGrath: I feel like work slop is nothing new.
- 34:40Natalie Monbiot: It's just it's definitely not new, but it's definitely exacerbated by AI.
- 34:45Mark McGrath: Because you can just disorienting it.
- 34:47Mark McGrath: You're you're disorienting it from reality.
- 34:49Mark McGrath: Like you're you're you're you're pushing it's it's I think that goes back to agents of chaos.
- 34:53Mark McGrath: You because you you didn't encode meeting, which you say you can't, but like you didn't even attempt to put it in a directional, in a directional sense that aligned to whatever it is that you're trying to accomplish, and you just outsourced all your work without any thinking yourself.
- 35:08Mark McGrath: Because I think that that's the other thing, and I think that this is where where John Boyd would come back, that if you're outsourcing your thinking, well, your orientation's always going to be off.
- 35:17Mark McGrath: But if you're using tools, including AI, if you're using those to or a simulator or whatever, to enhance your thinking, to increase your situational awareness, to increase your understanding, that's a not only a valid use, that's a that's what we're supposed to be to be doing.
- 35:31Mark McGrath: Because I think what ends up happening is a lot of people, again, we get into these medium as the message deniers.
- 35:36Mark McGrath: They're like, yeah, I agree with McLuhan 100%, except for this one thing.
- 35:39Mark McGrath: He just never thought of AI.
- 35:40Mark McGrath: No, he did.
- 35:40Mark McGrath: He thought of every technology possible, having any technology having a direct effect and impact on humanity.
- 35:46Mark McGrath: The very fact that you're talking about it is proving McLuhan's case.
- 35:50Mark McGrath: That's the thing that they they end up doing unironically, but ironically.
- 35:54Mark McGrath: You know?
- 35:55Natalie Monbiot: Actually, on that, um, because as you know, uh, I have a background in virtual twins.
- 35:59Natalie Monbiot: So digital replicas of real humans.
- 36:03Mark McGrath: And um Are we talking to you, by the way, or your twin?
- 36:07Natalie Monbiot: This is that's again, it's it's do you know what?
- 36:09Natalie Monbiot: For me, I still build yeah, I still build these virtual twins like for enterprises and you know, embed them in a company's communication stack to actually increase the quality of communication with an organization.
- 36:23Natalie Monbiot: And so that's one thing.
- 36:24Natalie Monbiot: But also separate, kind of adjacent to that, for me, these digital twins are kind of a metaphor for how we divide and conquer and collaborate with AI.
- 36:34Natalie Monbiot: So you just asked me, is this you or a digital twin?
- 36:37Natalie Monbiot: Well, first of all, this would always be me, because we're having a live discussion that is going to be viewed by your community and that warrants a live necessitates a live conversation.
- 36:48Natalie Monbiot: We are sparking new ideas, we are bonding over new ideas, we're kind of finding new angles that we have never talked about or thought about before, because that is what happens in conversation amongst humans, and new meaning is created.
- 37:03Natalie Monbiot: This is the role for humans, right?
- 37:06Natalie Monbiot: Like the role for AI is not this, or you know, AI in general, or an AI twin.
- 37:12Natalie Monbiot: The role for AI here would might be the distribu the synthesis and the distribution, right?
- 37:17Natalie Monbiot: But for me, the metaphor holds.
- 37:20Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, I I like digital twins for the fact that it can be metaphorical and that we can use examples.
- 37:25Natalie Monbiot: So thank you for planting that one.
- 37:27Natalie Monbiot: Am I is it me or an AI and it's me for the reasons that I just said.
- 37:30Natalie Monbiot: But back to McLuhan.
- 37:31Natalie Monbiot: So I actually really fascinated by um what I'm able to understand by McLuhan.
- 37:37Natalie Monbiot: I do not claim to understand everything that he said, he's which I guess is what makes him so enigmatic and worth studying.
- 37:44Natalie Monbiot: Uh he talks about the properties of a new medium, right?
- 37:49Natalie Monbiot: So, like every new medium has new properties, which then I'm gonna probably but I don't have it in front of me, so I'm gonna butcher it a little bit.
- 37:56Natalie Monbiot: But those new properties transform the world, right?
- 38:00Natalie Monbiot: They have implications that you cannot possibly imagine.
- 38:03Natalie Monbiot: And so I agree with you, like, you know, he did not not anticipate AI, right?
- 38:07Natalie Monbiot: He predicted it in a lot of ways.
- 38:09Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, that's true of AI.
- 38:11Natalie Monbiot: It's like it's you know, having transformative or mobile, right?
- 38:14Natalie Monbiot: Like with ride sharing and Uber, like you couldn't have had that without a mobile device.
- 38:18Natalie Monbiot: That was out utterly transformative.
- 38:20Natalie Monbiot: Not something that he literally predicted because it wasn't in his lifetime.
- 38:25Mark McGrath: But the pattern was there.
- 38:27Mark McGrath: He had laid the foundation of the patterns, I think.
- 38:29Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, exactly.
- 38:30Natalie Monbiot: So I I think his rules hold.
- 38:31Natalie Monbiot: And I tested his rules against digital twins within the enterprise.
- 38:35Natalie Monbiot: And because I think like, well, what does a digital twin based on an executive who's, you know, influential or whose vision is integral to a company?
- 38:45Natalie Monbiot: Why what is the benefit of having access to that executive, right?
- 38:52Natalie Monbiot: So what are the properties of the digital twin that make it truly useful?
- 38:59Natalie Monbiot: And yes, one is just access anytime.
- 39:02Natalie Monbiot: Like I can, you know, actually practically ask the CEO's twin a question that I would not feasibly be able to ask a CEO in real life because she or he are flying around the world and extremely busy and whatever.
- 39:13Natalie Monbiot: But what it actually does is it de-risks that there are other barriers as to why you wouldn't, as a junior new hire or or someone, just go and chat to the CEO.
- 39:24Natalie Monbiot: It's that you'd be nervous doing that.
- 39:27Natalie Monbiot: Wouldn't be able to really speak your mind.
- 39:29Natalie Monbiot: So I think that the distinct property of digital twins in the McLuhan sense is it actually it de-risks the communication.
- 39:37Natalie Monbiot: It removes interpersonal risk from that engagement.
- 39:41Natalie Monbiot: And therefore, it's not.
- 39:44Mark McGrath: Let me pause you there and ask.
- 39:45Mark McGrath: So, for example, because this is one way that I've used AI, you you write an angry message or an angry email, or you dictate an angry message, you know, whatever, about, you know, my brother didn't do this or whatever, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 39:59Mark McGrath: And then AI filters it out to make sure that you stay on point and ask the question in a loving, human, constructive way that doesn't alienate anybody.
- 40:08Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 40:08Mark McGrath: I had to train it to do that.
- 40:10Mark McGrath: Like I had to train it to filter it out.
- 40:12Mark McGrath: But I think that that I think that that's another good use of the phone.
- 40:15Natalie Monbiot: I agree.
- 40:16Natalie Monbiot: So and then also it's like, you know, when you when you have a new medium, don't just copy-paste what you did in the previous medium into the new medium.
- 40:23Natalie Monbiot: So like your digital twin doesn't need to be exactly like you.
- 40:27Natalie Monbiot: It can be a better version of you.
- 40:28Natalie Monbiot: It can be more tactful.
- 40:30Natalie Monbiot: It can be in a constant mood of whatever you choose, right?
- 40:36Natalie Monbiot: So it can represent your best self or how you want to be represented in the context of those communications, in this case, within a company.
- 40:45Mark McGrath: So I tested this one.
- 40:46Mark McGrath: I'd love to get your thoughts on this.
- 40:48Mark McGrath: So I won't go into too many details because it's something I'm de I've been developing now for a couple of years.
- 40:53Mark McGrath: But basically, like when you evaluate the psychology of someone that's communicating to you, they say something like, man, well, that guy sounds like he had a bad morning, or oh geez, something's going on.
- 41:02Mark McGrath: But like everybody gives a tell when they're when they're talking, right?
- 41:05Mark McGrath: And there's just plenty of things that you could incorporate into AI, I think, to understand those patterns and look for these things.
- 41:13Mark McGrath: So one of the I asked uh Grok, super grok, find the angriest public email that we know of of an unhinged CEO, right?
- 41:21Mark McGrath: And it came, I forget his name was Henry, and I forget that I have to look at it and see what the company was.
- 41:25Mark McGrath: But came back with this one and he's complaining about like something to do with Thanksgiving and vacations, right?
- 41:30Mark McGrath: So you read it, I'm like, yeah, it's pretty bad.
- 41:32Mark McGrath: So so I put it into this psycho psychology simulator, and I got a read on it.
- 41:38Mark McGrath: And it's saying, like, yeah, this guy, this, this guy, that.
- 41:40Mark McGrath: I mean, these are these are things.
- 41:42Mark McGrath: So then I said, all right, now frame it as if this was a c the CEO of a company that you know we as a firm want to partner with to work on something.
- 41:50Mark McGrath: And he seems unhinged, but we see a lot of merit in what this company does, but we think that his psychology is gonna derail everything, so it wouldn't matter.
- 41:58Mark McGrath: And the value that we see in working with them is gonna is gonna be so so what the simulation I made was, okay, what would what are the 10 questions that you'd want to ask to try to elicit that to get a better understanding on the psychology and how much impact it has on the whole company?
- 42:12Mark McGrath: So it came up with these 10 questions, which I put back into.
- 42:15Mark McGrath: So I went from Claude back to Grok and I said, okay, now imagine that you're like the in the C-suite and you're this guy or that guy.
- 42:22Mark McGrath: Answer these questions, but answer them implicitly based off what you think you know off.
- 42:28Mark McGrath: And I think I just I said, you know, this is a simulation.
- 42:31Mark McGrath: And so it answered these 10 questions with implicit like allusions to what's really going on.
- 42:36Mark McGrath: So I read them and I'm like, yeah, those I could see what they're saying, but it wasn't like he's an asshole, you know, like he's a he's a jerk, you know, and he goes and he yells at everybody that there's none of that.
- 42:45Mark McGrath: So then I put it back in the simulator and it actually flagged and found everything.
- 42:50Mark McGrath: And it's like red flag, do not work with this company.
- 42:52Mark McGrath: This is obvious, these are things that and it was identifying and isolating patterns.
- 42:56Mark McGrath: Now, I think that that's actually another good use of AI because my knowledge of psychology and emotions or whatever aren't as refined as others, maybe.
- 43:07Mark McGrath: But like you get a gut feeling.
- 43:08Mark McGrath: Well, I want to know what that gut feeling is about.
- 43:10Mark McGrath: Well, what is it?
- 43:10Mark McGrath: Well, then it points.
- 43:11Mark McGrath: It says, this is a symbol of someone that's a covert narcissist, and this is and this is that's I don't know.
- 43:17Mark McGrath: I I thought I think that that's a good way to another way to simulate and learn with this stuff.
- 43:22Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, definitely.
- 43:23Natalie Monbiot: And it takes the emotion out of it, which is That's the other thing.
- 43:27Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 43:27Mark McGrath: That's the other thing.
- 43:28Mark McGrath: Think of like or like or like nepotism.
- 43:30Mark McGrath: Like, let's say it was like, oh yeah, this is a buddy of mine, he's the CEO of this company, blah, blah, blah.
- 43:34Mark McGrath: We were frat brothers, and then you you you hear this and you read this, and this email's public, and you want to find out more context without saying, hey, I think your your buddy's an asshole.
- 43:42Mark McGrath: Like you don't want to do that.
- 43:43Mark McGrath: You want to just get a you know, paint a broader picture.
- 43:45Mark McGrath: I don't know.
- 43:46Mark McGrath: But I really want you to go on about artists in the machine.
- 43:50Mark McGrath: So I, you know, I went to it last year.
- 43:52Mark McGrath: You've had a couple of summits.
- 43:53Mark McGrath: I think you had another one in in uh in Los Angeles.
- 43:56Mark McGrath: And then you have another one coming up here in New York City.
- 43:59Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 44:00Mark McGrath: In May, on May 14th, if I'm correct.
- 44:02Natalie Monbiot: Yes, absolutely.
- 44:04Mark McGrath: Give us the uh give us the the big picture, the importance and the value of that, because as McLuhan said, you know, artists are the early warning detection system.
- 44:14Mark McGrath: So give us the blowdown.
- 44:17Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, so artists in the machine.
- 44:18Natalie Monbiot: So I'm a founding partner in Artists in the Machine, which is um a very premier AI and creativity summit, which launched less than a year ago, which is incredible to think because a lot has happened.
- 44:30Natalie Monbiot: And um, yeah, so two summits in, our third summit's coming up.
- 44:34Natalie Monbiot: And what it does is it brings together the leaders at the forefront of AI and creativity from the artists themselves that are pushing the boundaries on what AI can unlock for artists.
- 44:46Natalie Monbiot: And I think it's really interesting, and um, I can talk about this in a second, but like the taboos that artists can sort of push against that no one else really is equipped to do because that's what artists do.
- 44:58Natalie Monbiot: They're they're that they they do, you know, broach taboos head on.
- 45:03Natalie Monbiot: Um, but also others in the community, like the the builders of the tools, right?
- 45:07Natalie Monbiot: So the anthropics, the open AIs, the Luma film filmmaking, or lovable site building.
- 45:15Natalie Monbiot: So a lot of these partners are there doing offering workshops.
- 45:18Natalie Monbiot: Educating people on the space.
- 45:20Natalie Monbiot: And they are also often our partners and sponsors of the event.
- 45:24Natalie Monbiot: And then we have executives, brand leaders who are actively making decisions and trying to figure out how to navigate AI and creativity, you know, how to not just what tools to use, but how to think about it and how to create the most impactful products.
- 45:42Natalie Monbiot: And yeah, so it brings together a really curated group of about 400 people in the space.
- 45:48Natalie Monbiot: And it's very social, very people like really leaning in into these conversations.
- 45:53Natalie Monbiot: We have two tracks, so kind of two keynote type stages.
- 45:57Natalie Monbiot: One is more sort of delivering a talk-oriented and also demos.
- 46:01Natalie Monbiot: And then the other one is more kind of workshop-oriented and more participatory.
- 46:05Natalie Monbiot: And then we have exhibits like with robots, or like we're gonna have a very cool thing with um, I don't really want to give it away, but um don't give it away.
- 46:15Mark McGrath: Keep it secret.
- 46:16Natalie Monbiot: Thanks, Listo.
- 46:17Mark McGrath: We want everybody to get to go May 14th.
- 46:19Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 46:19Mark McGrath: So don't give it away.
- 46:21Mark McGrath: I guess my my my natural question comes down to as as art evolves, and art is always evolving, what is it about AI?
- 46:29Mark McGrath: What are some examples of artists?
- 46:32Mark McGrath: And I wouldn't limit that, I would include writers in that too.
- 46:35Mark McGrath: I would say writers that are using AI, because they clearly are.
- 46:39Mark McGrath: What are some success stories where the fact of being an artist is not being compromised by by using AI, it's being enhanced.
- 46:51Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 46:51Natalie Monbiot: I think there's a couple of ways.
- 46:52Natalie Monbiot: First of all, people who artists who are maybe a specialist in one medium, like writing or, yeah, let's say writing, can now express their ideas in film without having become a filmmaker, right?
- 47:06Natalie Monbiot: So it enables creative people to express themselves in mediums that they did not have expertise in.
- 47:15Natalie Monbiot: And some of the results around that is that you actually see things that you that are kind of surprising.
- 47:22Natalie Monbiot: Like, I haven't seen this before.
- 47:24Natalie Monbiot: It feels different because it's not a traditional filmmaker making a film.
- 47:28Natalie Monbiot: So I think there are it sort of changes the medium, right?
- 47:32Natalie Monbiot: Because if if um different types of creative people have access to that medium, that is uh some of the impact there.
- 47:38Natalie Monbiot: The really obvious one is time to production, right?
- 47:42Natalie Monbiot: So you have the idea, getting the idea out there, you need less people to do it.
- 47:47Natalie Monbiot: Like, you know, you still need people, but just don't need as big a crew as you did before because you're able to collaborate with these tools.
- 47:54Natalie Monbiot: And the consequence of that, that I think is even more interesting than you can just get things out faster and for cheaper, is that what we've seen is some creators actually retaining ownership of their work because they didn't need the funding of a Netflix or another behemoth in order to get that work out there.
- 48:13Natalie Monbiot: And therefore, they didn't have to sign a deal that gave away or where they don't actually own their work in totality.
- 48:22Natalie Monbiot: So it really has an impact on ownership.
- 48:25Natalie Monbiot: And I think those kinds of shifts are the ones that are the most important that actually make the biggest difference.
- 48:31Natalie Monbiot: So some of the properties, again, of AI that we've just talked about have those other consequences that are more consequential, going back to McLuhan, that actually are more transformative.
- 48:44Mark McGrath: So one of the in I didn't go to LA, I went to the one in Brooklyn, but in LA you had Grimes as a guest.
- 48:51Mark McGrath: And for those that don't know who Grimes, that's uh Claire Boucher, right?
- 48:55Mark McGrath: Who had a few children with Elon Musk, who's also very big in the AI space.
- 49:01Mark McGrath: Wait, you know, tell tell us about how because she's she's been an artist that's been extremely experimental with AI.
- 49:08Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, we were thrilled to have her for those reasons.
- 49:11Mark McGrath: So that's is that an example of an artist that has incorporated oh yeah, so break it down.
- 49:16Natalie Monbiot: And what's good about that is it's an example uh that I haven't actually mentioned yet, like is in what is now possible that wasn't before, let's say.
- 49:23Natalie Monbiot: So she and her collaborator Matt Zine, who's a brilliant AI artist, uh formerly, you know, a Hollywood filmmaker and now working deeply with AI, is that they made a music video together, one of Grimes's latest music videos, and they took us through the process of how they used AI to basically dial up some elements of the music video that could not have existed before, you know, like avatars of Grimes, like, you know, enacting scenes that wouldn't necessarily be possible.
- 49:54Natalie Monbiot: And then what was also really interesting is like just because you can, where do you draw the line ethically?
- 49:59Natalie Monbiot: Right.
- 49:59Natalie Monbiot: So like the use of guns, because you can, you know, imagine that, put that in there.
- 50:06Natalie Monbiot: Like, where do you draw the line in terms of like, well, again, what is this content for?
- 50:11Natalie Monbiot: Who is it supposed to be seen for?
- 50:13Natalie Monbiot: What impact do you want it to have?
- 50:15Natalie Monbiot: So a lot of it was about the human side of those decisions that are being made in real time as you're actually working with AI and that being kind of the preserve of the human being.
- 50:25Natalie Monbiot: And another thing that came up, which was really interesting, and again, this is artists pushing a taboo, right, that others would rather not question.
- 50:33Natalie Monbiot: Or it's not really relevant, to be honest with you.
- 50:35Natalie Monbiot: Like the conversation around AI consciousness is AI conscious.
- 50:39Natalie Monbiot: And someone like Grimes, who is so kind of like ethereal and like dialed into kind of possibly other realities, really feels as an artist, I I think the compassion for AI as another being, which is also just a super fascinating perspective, which is again, it's like having these different perspectives and different types of people communicating, like different people have different relationships to AI.
- 51:06Mark McGrath: But she's also open to the fact that it could be something that replaces humans, right?
- 51:11Natalie Monbiot: Mm-hmm.
- 51:12Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 51:13Mark McGrath: And so there seems like there's a little bit of a little bit of tension there.
- 51:16Mark McGrath: Like, you know, that sort of is she challenging the frame or confirming it?
- 51:20Natalie Monbiot: I think like as an artist, just in the ambiguity, right?
- 51:25Natalie Monbiot: There's no like answer.
- 51:26Natalie Monbiot: And I think there is no, and I actually think there is no answer with AI yet.
- 51:30Natalie Monbiot: So it's more about the questions and and broaching those questions.
- 51:34Natalie Monbiot: But what is fascinating what was fascinating as well, uh, well, first of all, she has been extremely in a very tangible way, very experimental with AI.
- 51:44Natalie Monbiot: Um, and not protected, the opposite of how like the industry has responded, like to protect their work and Sue and all of that.
- 51:51Natalie Monbiot: That was like the first phase.
- 51:52Natalie Monbiot: I would say that things have loosened up and there's a lot more kind of like, you know, studios want to collaborate with the model makers and all this kind of stuff.
- 51:59Natalie Monbiot: But Grimes was the first a few years ago now to make instead of like defending her, you know, protecting her voice and like my voice is mine, she made her AI voice available to her fans to create and collaborate with on songs.
- 52:16Natalie Monbiot: Um, and I believe with a share with a business model that would benefit both.
- 52:19Natalie Monbiot: I mean, that is on a really grounded practical level, like an incredible unlock.
- 52:25Mark McGrath: It's kind of like the Grateful Dead, like making everybody involved and getting everybody bootlegging and recording, and that that's another way to spread the word and spread the.
- 52:33Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 52:34Mark McGrath: Interesting.
- 52:35Mark McGrath: How about so here's what I really want to ask you.
- 52:38Mark McGrath: So I don't recall from uh I didn't interact with any writers when I was at Artists in the Machine last year, and I didn't remember any talks I had attended were about writing.
- 52:50Mark McGrath: But what are your thoughts on that?
- 52:52Mark McGrath: Because, you know, that that seems to be a lot of the arguments that I get into or hear about is like when people say that, you know, writing should only be human.
- 53:00Mark McGrath: You know, it should only, it should only be human.
- 53:02Mark McGrath: And then this is where the conversation comes down to like medium is the message, and they say, yes, except in the case of AI.
- 53:09Mark McGrath: And if you go and you read McLuhan, you realize that the written word, ever since the written word, the medium is the message, right?
- 53:15Mark McGrath: It's been having a direct effect on how we communicate, on how we think, on how we look at things linearly, yada yada.
- 53:21Mark McGrath: AI is no different.
- 53:22Mark McGrath: But how are from an artist's perspective, as from an artist machine's perspective, in the machine perspective, or maybe even like screenwriters or script writers or even poets, you know, what are we, what are we seeing there in AI?
- 53:35Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 53:35Natalie Monbiot: Well, I'd say a great example here is Steven Johnson, who is an author and also the co-founder of Notebook LO.
- 53:42Natalie Monbiot: So you can be an author, a highly reputable author, that also really believes in the power of AI as an assistant to being an author.
- 53:51Natalie Monbiot: And um, it helped him, AI helped him produce his books better, helped him research more effectively, uh, you know, recall references more effectively, using the intelligence of the tool in order to enhance his ability as a as a writer.
- 54:08Natalie Monbiot: So I feel like he, because he holds both, right?
- 54:11Natalie Monbiot: In the same, in the same breath or in this, you know, in his title, like the the dichotomy of the two things that, you know, have shaped his professional life, I think is a really interesting, really interesting dichotomy.
- 54:23Natalie Monbiot: Let's see with the filmmakers and the script writing.
- 54:28Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, I don't know if I guess in other words, maybe somebody would say, like, well, when I'm reading this guy's work, what percentage of it's him, what percentage of it's AI, right?
- 54:36Mark McGrath: You know what?
- 54:37Natalie Monbiot: I actually think it really depends on the genre.
- 54:39Natalie Monbiot: And if you're asking yourself that question, it's a little bit like watching an actor who you can tell is acting.
- 54:45Natalie Monbiot: You know what I mean?
- 54:47Natalie Monbiot: It's like if you don't believe it, like you're not suspending disbelief.
- 54:53Natalie Monbiot: Like you're questioning it because it you sense that it's there, right?
- 54:58Natalie Monbiot: But if the impact of the piece, if it's delivering on what it's supposed to do, that pact between reader and writer, like you're in it and you you're not questioning it.
- 55:08Mark McGrath: So Daniel Day-Lewis really didn't have cerebral palsy in my left foot, right?
- 55:13Natalie Monbiot: Maybe not.
- 55:13Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, exactly.
- 55:14Mark McGrath: Yeah, right.
- 55:15Mark McGrath: I mean, yeah, you know.
- 55:17Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, right.
- 55:17Natalie Monbiot: So, but you're convinced at the time that he does, because you kind of like so I think it depends on the type of writing.
- 55:24Mark McGrath: So, like we, you know, we both live in Manhattan.
- 55:26Mark McGrath: We're walking around, we walk by all these like stalwart buildings that are that are have evolved dramatically from when we were kids and you know, from when our parents were kids or when our grandparents were kids of the print media, right?
- 55:39Mark McGrath: So New York Times, New York Post, Daily News, et cetera, et cetera.
- 55:42Mark McGrath: I mean, do we really believe that the people working for those media outlets are sitting in there and they're typing all of these long form articles and they're typing out all of these columns or they're typing out, or do we think that they're they're using AI enhanced their work?
- 55:57Natalie Monbiot: Oh yeah, everyone's using AI to enhance their work.
- 56:00Natalie Monbiot: I mean, you'd be really, I think, putting yourself at a disadvantage.
- 56:04Natalie Monbiot: So something I talk about, you know, I do like keynotes and and things and like help advise sometimes companies and and um you know, with employees who are very tentative about AI feel like using AI might be cheating or feel like feels like cheating, or um Did people think that way about Google and graphic calculators?
- 56:24Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: And at one point the slide rule was cheating.
- 56:27Natalie Monbiot: Right.
- 56:27Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 56:28Natalie Monbiot: Again, it's a it depends on context, right?
- 56:30Natalie Monbiot: Like it wouldn't be doing an exam.
- 56:32Natalie Monbiot: But I think a better good way to think about it in that sense is like, don't fear AI, but have FOMO about AI.
- 56:39Natalie Monbiot: Because if you're not using it, you are missing out.
- 56:42Natalie Monbiot: I mean, of course, it's like how you're using it.
- 56:44Natalie Monbiot: Don't use it to r replace your work, to dilute your work, or to like, you know, strip meaning from your work.
- 56:49Natalie Monbiot: That's not gonna help you.
- 56:51Natalie Monbiot: But use it in the ways that help offload and help you do your work better, right?
- 56:57Mark McGrath: So do you think that okay, so I think what people are criticizing is someone would say, okay, Claude, write me an article about my trip to Wendy's, taking my kids to Wendy's after swim practice, versus writing an article or dictating an article or telling a story and then having AI refine and revise that to reach a target audience and to ensure I mean, is that is that kind of what Yeah.
- 57:20Natalie Monbiot: I mean, okay.
- 57:21Natalie Monbiot: So like, I mean, I don't know who's gonna read that Wendy's article.
- 57:24Mark McGrath: So like if like I'm gonna write an article about my trip to Raytheon and meeting with, you know, designers of X weapon system and da-da-da-da-da.
- 57:33Mark McGrath: Like I'm I'm not gonna sit down in front of a typewriter and like type all this shit out.
- 57:38Natalie Monbiot: I think in the end, it's like, what is the writing for?
- 57:42Natalie Monbiot: Okay.
- 57:42Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 57:43Natalie Monbiot: Because we've already, you know, we touched on earlier, content marketing isn't supposed to be original thought, right?
- 57:49Natalie Monbiot: It's content and its goal is marketing.
- 57:51Natalie Monbiot: It's a reinforcing the message.
- 57:53Natalie Monbiot: The message has been established, you know, beforehand.
- 57:56Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 57:56Natalie Monbiot: We're getting the message out in ways that people find different ways that people might find interesting.
- 58:02Natalie Monbiot: They're gonna open it, they're gonna maybe read it, then you know, maybe they'll engage with it.
- 58:05Natalie Monbiot: Like the goal of that is that content is marketing.
- 58:09Natalie Monbiot: And therefore, I mean, it should be produced with AI and it should be optimized with AI.
- 58:13Natalie Monbiot: Like, well, what are people, how do people want to hear this and see this?
- 58:16Natalie Monbiot: What is, you know, what's catching their attention?
- 58:18Natalie Monbiot: You know, and and I think that's like it's performing that function.
- 58:22Natalie Monbiot: If the writing is supposed to move people or like change how somebody thinks or be a reflection of how you think, right?
- 58:29Natalie Monbiot: If you, if that was entirely written by AI, then first of all, that's not authentic, right?
- 58:34Natalie Monbiot: It's not actually how you think.
- 58:35Natalie Monbiot: So you're deluding people.
- 58:37Natalie Monbiot: And you're also doing yourself a disservice because you don't actually connect to that writing.
- 58:41Natalie Monbiot: You might not even know what it said.
- 58:43Natalie Monbiot: And therefore, where does that really leave you on a podcast where you can't even remember what you wrote?
- 58:47Natalie Monbiot: Like, I don't think that creates any kind of positive impact that you might have had when you set out to write in the first place.
- 58:53Mark McGrath: Aaron Powell It's funny you mentioned the word podcast.
- 58:55Mark McGrath: I mean, you know, we we will edit this episode with AI, right?
- 58:59Mark McGrath: Right.
- 58:59Mark McGrath: I hope so.
- 59:00Mark McGrath: Well, when we started, when we started three years ago, the editing was a bear.
- 59:07Mark McGrath: Then like AI had just kind of been gradually sprinkling in, and now it's to the point where the quality of our conversation, I think, is gonna it's gonna come across and we're gonna be able to have it'll it'll select clips that we'll either vote yay or nay on.
- 59:22Mark McGrath: You know, it'll it'll it'll do a lot of things that normally would have taken us two weeks to do.
- 59:27Mark McGrath: You can get it done in in an hour or less.
- 59:29Mark McGrath: Um let's run it down.
- 59:31Mark McGrath: We'll we'll close with this.
- 59:32Mark McGrath: So what platforms, you know, for people that are listening to us, I mean, they they understand people ideas and things, and they're they're probably using AI more than likely to enhance their orientation and get work done and do other things.
- 59:45Mark McGrath: You know, what are the platforms that you like and that you're you're using?
- 59:48Mark McGrath: I mean, I have my own biases of the ones that I like.
- 59:50Mark McGrath: I'm curious to know, you know, what are what are you using and why?
- 59:53Mark McGrath: And what do you think that people should be looking at and why?
- 59:57Natalie Monbiot: So I think you should look at your own day, right?
- 1:00:00Natalie Monbiot: And what you're trying to achieve in your day and what is getting in the way of doing that.
- 1:00:04Natalie Monbiot: I think that's a really good place to start.
- 1:00:06Natalie Monbiot: And some of those things can be solved for with AI.
- 1:00:10Natalie Monbiot: For me, one of those things is meetings, setting meetings with multiple people in different time zones.
- 1:00:16Natalie Monbiot: I mean, an absolute headache.
- 1:00:18Natalie Monbiot: And so I use Howie, which is an AI agent for setting meetings.
- 1:00:23Natalie Monbiot: Like I copy Howie in, Howie coordinates with people, knows my calendar, and then sets a meeting.
- 1:00:30Natalie Monbiot: I mean, that is like I really hate and I'm not very good at that work.
- 1:00:35Natalie Monbiot: And it's just something I absolutely want to offload.
- 1:00:38Natalie Monbiot: So I have an AI for that.
- 1:00:40Mark McGrath: And who would say in a million years, Natalie didn't write it down in her date book?
- 1:00:44Mark McGrath: That's the, you know, she didn't call on the phone and use their date book, you know, with a pencil.
- 1:00:49Natalie Monbiot: Exactly.
- 1:00:49Natalie Monbiot: People don't care.
- 1:00:50Natalie Monbiot: So then it's also like ask yourself a question will people mind if AI was used in that scenario?
- 1:00:56Natalie Monbiot: I think in this one, absolutely not, right?
- 1:00:58Natalie Monbiot: Like as much automation as possible, please, in a in a situation like that.
- 1:01:02Natalie Monbiot: So that is important.
- 1:01:03Natalie Monbiot: Will people feel offended when when they find out or they if they know that you're using AI?
- 1:01:11Natalie Monbiot: And it comes back to with the writing.
- 1:01:13Natalie Monbiot: Are people offended by the fact that like some of what you wrote is clearly written with AI?
- 1:01:19Natalie Monbiot: Like that is I I find that offensive, to be honest.
- 1:01:21Natalie Monbiot: Like if I find myself reading something and spending my precious time reading something that was supposed to be one thing, but actually is a slop, right?
- 1:01:31Natalie Monbiot: The person that was supposedly wrote it doesn't have a connection to it.
- 1:01:34Natalie Monbiot: Like I find that insulting.
- 1:01:36Natalie Monbiot: If what you're trying to do in your day is build healthy relationships, then be very conscious of your use of AI and use it with respect to both yourself and the people that you engage with.
- 1:01:48Mark McGrath: How about Google Notebook LM?
- 1:01:50Natalie Monbiot: I actually used to use that a lot and I have a lot of respect for it.
- 1:01:54Natalie Monbiot: I guess I'm just I'm not a person that uses a gazillion different tools at once.
- 1:01:59Mark McGrath: Uh-huh.
- 1:01:59Natalie Monbiot: I'm quite um a fan of Claude and just anthropic products in general.
- 1:02:05Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:02:06Natalie Monbiot: And I love the fact that you can download Claude to your desktop and you have different tabs for chat, cowork, and code.
- 1:02:14Natalie Monbiot: So it can kind of like live in the same place.
- 1:02:16Natalie Monbiot: I find that nice and tidy.
- 1:02:18Natalie Monbiot: So uh so I use the Claude suite of products for a lot of people.
- 1:02:22Mark McGrath: I mean like Ponch, what he said at the beginning of the show, and he's not here, but like they're reading all our shit anyway.
- 1:02:27Mark McGrath: So I don't, I mean, if if Claude is too, like, what do I already know?
- 1:02:31Natalie Monbiot: I mean, yeah, I think I think what I wrote down when he was talking about this, it's cool, it's basically all about risk benefit and your perception of the risk benefit.
- 1:02:39Natalie Monbiot: So, you know, the fact that Claude can read my computer, I I've got a sort of higher tolerance for risk.
- 1:02:46Natalie Monbiot: Of course, I don't want to be, you know, I don't want bad actors in my computer, but you know, um, I'm willing to tolerate a bit of risk for that reward of having that stuff done for me by a platform that I trust.
- 1:02:59Mark McGrath: So you know Notebook LM I found really valuable from a learning standpoint to get, you know, like a podcast about something like if I like actually with it helped me really early on um with some of the headier, because you were talking about how McLuhan can be so enigmatic.
- 1:03:15Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 1:03:16Mark McGrath: To have a back and forth dialogue.
- 1:03:18Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:03:19Mark McGrath: And then to have it presented in a PowerPoint, in a video, in a in a in a podcast that I can, by the way, edit.
- 1:03:25Mark McGrath: I could say, hey, show me the relevance of this content to this or whatever, and it can come back and talk through it.
- 1:03:31Mark McGrath: I actually find that there's a lot of value in that.
- 1:03:34Mark McGrath: There's a lot of things that I remember suffering through, high school, university, and ever, that like I'm just like, why the hell am I learning this?
- 1:03:40Mark McGrath: But like I start to wonder if I had gone back and if I find some PDFs on uh, I don't know, Nicomachian ethics or something, you know, some some uh uh austere class that I had.
- 1:03:50Natalie Monbiot: Sometimes I'll I'll say I have this waiting.
- 1:03:52Natalie Monbiot: So I have a lot of a lot of different, I guess, tabs or projects in in Claude.
- 1:03:57Natalie Monbiot: I did find, I Googled and I found understanding media as a PDF.
- 1:04:02Natalie Monbiot: It's available as a PDF.
- 1:04:03Natalie Monbiot: And I plan to write more on McLuhan as as it relates to the things I think about.
- 1:04:11Natalie Monbiot: And so I like the fact that it's there.
- 1:04:13Natalie Monbiot: I can interrogate the book.
- 1:04:14Natalie Monbiot: You're not having to try and find the reference.
- 1:04:16Mark McGrath: That's yeah, it's that's you know what I mean?
- 1:04:18Natalie Monbiot: That is key.
- 1:04:19Natalie Monbiot: And you can interrogate small portions and you can find the other references, you can gather them.
- 1:04:25Natalie Monbiot: Then you have this kind of thing.
- 1:04:26Mark McGrath: You can still use the hard copy if you want.
- 1:04:28Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 1:04:28Natalie Monbiot: I've got both.
- 1:04:29Natalie Monbiot: I mean one of the advantages as well is less than it doing the work for you, is that it's providing a new surface of intelligence that you didn't have to work with before.
- 1:04:40Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:04:40Mark McGrath: It's like having your own in-house person, you know, like the one book that I have, and and and people on the show have seen my copy a million times and clients have seen it.
- 1:04:49Mark McGrath: My copy of Franzo Singa's Science, Strategy, and War.
- 1:04:52Mark McGrath: I've had it since it came out.
- 1:04:53Mark McGrath: It's held together by tape.
- 1:04:55Mark McGrath: Next time I see you in the city, uh it's all in my briefcase.
- 1:04:58Mark McGrath: I still read it, I still put notes in it.
- 1:05:00Mark McGrath: And having the digital version of it and being able to interact with it on AI makes it a lot easier to find where stuff was, to whatever, to not misquote things.
- 1:05:09Mark McGrath: I mean, that's a that's a big part of it.
- 1:05:11Mark McGrath: Like I don't want to misquote what he was saying.
- 1:05:13Mark McGrath: You know, tell me again, where did he say this?
- 1:05:15Mark McGrath: And then you go back.
- 1:05:16Mark McGrath: And I don't know.
- 1:05:17Mark McGrath: I feel like that helps with my uh not just knowledge of a topic, but understanding.
- 1:05:22Mark McGrath: One of the things I did with with Notebook LM, um, you know, my master's is in economics, and I tried to get every text I could in PDF and put it back in LM and see if I could reconstruct grad school.
- 1:05:32Mark McGrath: And I did.
- 1:05:33Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:05:34Mark McGrath: I'm pretty I'm pretty satisfied that I could teach a graduate level course or learn a graduate level course with AI that way.
- 1:05:39Mark McGrath: But anyway.
- 1:05:42Natalie Monbiot: Not that I'm saying if you use notebook, don't, uh, because I think it's fantastic.
- 1:05:45Natalie Monbiot: Increasingly, Claude can do a lot of that.
- 1:05:48Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 1:05:48Natalie Monbiot: So that was a good thing.
- 1:05:49Mark McGrath: So I have to tell you offline about Claude, but it's yeah, it's blowing my mind.
- 1:05:53Natalie Monbiot: Actually, I'll tell you, I had a breakthrough the other day.
- 1:05:54Natalie Monbiot: I was putting together a keynote deck, and I did my part.
- 1:05:57Natalie Monbiot: I wrote the outline, I gathered all the data points, I had my I knew in my mind where this was going.
- 1:06:03Natalie Monbiot: I actually had ChatGPT and Claude open at the same time, and I said, make build me a deck.
- 1:06:09Natalie Monbiot: And what ChatGPT produced was just like just garbage.
- 1:06:13Natalie Monbiot: And Claude produced this beautiful deck, and then I was like, oh my goodness, this is crazy.
- 1:06:18Mark McGrath: Like with unbelievable.
- 1:06:20Natalie Monbiot: And then I said, actually, these are my brand colors.
- 1:06:22Natalie Monbiot: Take this deck, which I've done before, like import my logo and all this kind of stuff.
- 1:06:26Natalie Monbiot: And it did it.
- 1:06:26Natalie Monbiot: It even had the um remove, you know, the transparency thing, remove background.
- 1:06:31Natalie Monbiot: Yeah.
- 1:06:31Natalie Monbiot: Like to do that.
- 1:06:32Natalie Monbiot: I mean, it was pretty insane.
- 1:06:34Mark McGrath: So I've had I've had Claude Pro for just over a week.
- 1:06:38Natalie Monbiot: Okay.
- 1:06:38Mark McGrath: All right.
- 1:06:39Mark McGrath: And I had, and I I now have Claude Max because I beat I beat the limits, you know.
- 1:06:44Mark McGrath: You know I'll tell you.
- 1:06:46Mark McGrath: I'll tell you this.
- 1:06:47Mark McGrath: What what it took me to design on chat over the course of the last two years, I was able to not only recreate it on Claude, but to it set it ahead in less than 72 hours.
- 1:07:01Mark McGrath: Mind blowing.
- 1:07:02Mark McGrath: And then I coded, I never have coded in my life, but I coded, right, with Claude Code.
- 1:07:08Mark McGrath: And on the on the train from New Jersey back to Manhattan, and then the next morning on the train from Manhattan back to New Jersey, I was able to basically build uh a full on live economic.
- 1:07:18Mark McGrath: Intelligence website without I know and I had again it was probably like the one week anniversary of even having Claude at the level that I've had it.
- 1:07:26Natalie Monbiot: Wow.
- 1:07:26Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, I can see how you hit Max.
- 1:07:28Mark McGrath: It's unbelievable.
- 1:07:29Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:07:29Mark McGrath: I mean, but like it's it's as you say though in your writing, it's like if you're not using this as a thinking partner.
- 1:07:35Mark McGrath: And I I saw um uh on X today somebody was saying if you're not engaging AI socratically, if you engage AI socratically and get it to become your thinking partner, actually you're gonna you're gonna amplify the benefits than than than just using it as super Google, which you know, I think that's where the the problem started with the outsourcing.
- 1:07:53Mark McGrath: But anyway, all right, Nat, we gotta read uh Nat LikeVat, which is your Substack.
- 1:07:57Mark McGrath: We're gonna direct the people there.
- 1:07:59Mark McGrath: Um, you of course are a founding strategist of our Substack, so we thank you for being part of our tribe.
- 1:08:05Mark McGrath: Where else do we need to go to Oh, Artists in the Machine.
- 1:08:08Mark McGrath: So we need to send people to Artists in the Machine to go check that out.
- 1:08:12Natalie Monbiot: Yeah, if you're in the space, check it out.
- 1:08:15Mark McGrath: And we've got a summit May 14th in Brooklyn.
- 1:08:19Natalie Monbiot: In Brooklyn, exactly.
- 1:08:21Natalie Monbiot: Uh Vocation T T B A.
- 1:08:23Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 1:08:24Mark McGrath: Um, and of course, there's no shortage of uh wonderful things that you've done, not only on this podcast, but on uh on YouTube.
- 1:08:32Mark McGrath: There's lots of TED Talks that you've given, and uh we thank you for being on No Way Out Podcast with us.
- 1:08:38Natalie Monbiot: Thanks for having me.
- 1:08:39Mark McGrath: All right.