Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ken Ziffren: 2024 Trends and Transitions for Media and Entertainment Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this audio edition of Beverly Hills Bar Association's 2024 Trends and Transitions
- 0:05for Media and Entertainment Lawyers. This presentation was recorded on August 23, 2024,
- 0:11during the first annual Entertainment Law Summit. In just a moment, you'll hear Ken Zifrin present
- 0:16his annual review and assessment of key developments that are shaping the practice of
- 0:20entertainment law. He will discuss recent changes emerging trends and their impact on the rights
- 0:24and responsibilities of various parties within the entertainment industry. You may be eligible for
- 0:30CLE credit in your state. After finishing this episode, visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more
- 0:37information and to claim your CLE certificate. As usual, but in a different order, I'm going to
- 0:48start with Wall Street, then go to Collective Bargaining, then to Theatrical and then to
- 0:58TV, Slant, Espat, A-Bot, and so on. If I start on Wall Street with the current state of play
- 1:12on the Paramount Global situation, I think the only thing I can say that makes any sense is that this
- 1:23is a saga. So I'll move on. Recording in progress.
- 1:29Other thing that I want to remind you of is that three, four years ago, under the Trump administration,
- 1:38the Paramount Consent Decree was erased. And in a weird way, a few months ago,
- 1:56one of the companies that might have been affected by that, Sony, purchased a or is about to
- 2:07purchase, I don't think it's closed yet, Alamo Draft House, which has 35 venues in 25 markets.
- 2:21And we are now therefore looking at one of the, quote, major studios
- 2:32purchasing, forgive me, more than a Oscar event movie theater, which is where a bunch of the others
- 2:50have gone. And what more vertical integration do we get than where we are? So we'll just see how
- 3:01that plays on the international front. Because of some, I'll call it financial, I don't want to
- 3:15say manipulations, but some financial playing. The Vendi is likely to be parting from the Cano
- 3:27Plus, one of the major pay services, albeit linear, in France. And who may end up controlling that
- 3:42may also affect what happens in the French, if not Italian and other community.
- 3:50The other kind of Wall Street type fund issue that's out before us is waiting for the neutral
- 4:03arbitrator in the matter of Disney versus Comcast on the valuation of Hulu to go this way or that way
- 4:18with the Delta, that is Disney at what I'll call zero and Comcast at way more than zero. The Delta
- 4:32there is $5 billion. I don't know whether that matters to either company, but I'm sure they're
- 4:44fighting hard either to get it or to avoid it. And then finally, there is as usual a
- 4:56crisscross of interest from all concerned in India, now the most populous country in the world.
- 5:07And at the same time that there's M&A, there's the vestiture, there is reorganization,
- 5:21and it's just wonderful and almost impossible to follow, so I'm not going to try.
- 5:28On the front of the agencies in town, endeavor after a three to four year attempt at trying
- 5:43to attract Wall Street interest, their parent company is pulling endeavor in as a public unit
- 6:01so that endeavor will still be around in spades, WME, but not with a public presence except as a
- 6:1651% holder of a company called of course TKO. For those of you who do boxing, you know what I mean.
- 6:27And that's a $21 billion valuation and with a more than $7 billion market cap.
- 6:46And so that's what's developed this year as opposed to in the past. In the case of
- 6:55CAA, we have a new majority owner that wasn't around before and what we're told without knowing,
- 7:08one way or the other is that CAA was valued in that transaction where the majority moved from a
- 7:20basically a venture capital firm over to a, I don't want to call it fragrance firm, but a
- 7:34fashion firm, at least owner of fashion firm with a valuation of over $7 billion.
- 7:40And UTA, separate and apart from fighting with Michael Kazin, which is a whole different story
- 7:51that I'm not going to get into, is expanding rapidly in the sports area with Rich Paul and also
- 8:01has a new financial investor which is more or less the first time at least to the size of the
- 8:09investment that it's had. Continuing in this vein, sports on Wall Street, you may, I know,
- 8:24now, you know that the NBA has just, I'll say, technically closed an 11-year deal with three
- 8:39different outlets. The 11 years totaling a little more than $76 billion of guarantee
- 8:49and there's now a lawsuit brought by the fourth entity, a company that you may be familiar with,
- 9:00it's called Warner Brothers Discovery and they're suing the NBA for matching rights that they believe
- 9:11they have against the Amazon deal, therefore not against what I'll call them either of the linear
- 9:28deals or either of the hybrid deals that the NBA made with Disney and with now Comcast,
- 9:42but with the so-called pure deal with Amazon and believing that the language in its former deal
- 9:58with NBA entitles them to match the terms of the deal that the NBA make with Amazon. So that is
- 10:11pending and unclear how long or how short that might last. There's also a pending deal non-deal
- 10:23which I can't follow between the PGA and the LIV respectively, the golf issues and that's with the
- 10:39with the government on the one hand and an unclosed merger deal on the other, whatever, I just want
- 10:47to bring it to your attention. And finally on that front there's a entity called Venue without
- 10:59the second E, P-E-N-U, where Fubo, primarily sports related outlet, got an injunction last week,
- 11:20preliminary injunction from the U.S. District Court to prevent the venue from being started.
- 11:34That's either a blow to or even conceivably a blessing to the three entities who were going to
- 11:48team up and here's the fun part of this one. The three entities, Disney Warner and Fox,
- 12:04yes there's still a fox around, formed an entity that was limited to sports,
- 12:15live and related sports activities. And that's what the district court found to be
- 12:28potentially illegal under the antitrust laws. Now why? Let me take you backwards.
- 12:39Every major entity in our film TV world, formerly a B2B world, wanted to expand.
- 12:58And so as part of their expansion, they go to the outlets, this is B2B time now, and they say,
- 13:13you want our channel, the big one, for example, it used to be ABC or it may have been ESPN.
- 13:23But if you take ESPN, we also want you to take the following and then there's this long list
- 13:29of other channels. So individually, Disney on its part, Warner's on its part, and Fox on its part,
- 13:42Fox in the case of Fox News, if you want Fox News, you got to take X, Y and Z.
- 13:50Individually, that's the way the world worked for the last 20 years.
- 14:02But when the three of them join up and say we are limiting ourselves only to sports programming,
- 14:11the district court found that that could lead to an illegal concentration would affect or raise
- 14:25consumer pricing and therefore stopped it from happening. That's being appealed. I'm not sure
- 14:36what good the appeal will do because the whole intent of venue was to start next week so that
- 14:50they could in effect cover what I'll call
- 14:55two of the four or five legs of the NFL, meaning I'll give you the days of the week,
- 15:11Sunday, Monday, and used to be Thursday, but not anymore, for Disney and Fox.
- 15:21Warner isn't a NFL signatory, but anyway, it's kind of a mute least to me that what each individual
- 15:38studio was doing on its own regularly with outlets when three of them keep it together is no longer
- 15:49legal. So we'll see. On to collective bargaining. A year ago, we're in the middle of two strikes.
- 16:01In fact, I look back at my notes and I just saw that this was a year ago yesterday that
- 16:10the parties that is in that case, the Writers Guild had met and got nowhere with the AMPTP.
- 16:20Eventually, of course, my goodness, that was resolved. WGA and the AMPTP signed and subsequently
- 16:33SAG signed. So and originally, TGA had signed. So the guilds were all, as of November of last year,
- 16:47all signed up for collective bargaining, respectively. This year,
- 16:54not the guild, but the unions. So let me just oversimplify matters by saying that last year
- 17:09was white collar bargaining and this year was blue collar bargaining.
- 17:14The IA, IATC, achieved some notable advances, primarily to shoring up their health plan,
- 17:33as well as some life kind of stuff so that below the line, workers arguably aren't going to have
- 17:47to work more than 15 hours a day and have breaks that are suitable on the weekend.
- 17:56They achieved that, believe it or not, weeks before the deadline for their contract was up.
- 18:09The basic crafts, slant teamsters, came in and were days before the
- 18:20expiration of their contract, July 31st, and they signed.
- 18:32What I'm now going to focus on is what's the kind of global look at what's happened with
- 18:45those five guilds and unions having closed their deals. The simple answer is that every
- 19:00union-related entertainment project will cost more than it did. I'm not saying that's bad, because
- 19:16whether it's the writers, actors, directors, or below the line personnel, all needed a major
- 19:34lift in their minimums and in other areas as well. But I pose to you, and this partially explains,
- 19:50partially not completely, why we're looking at decreased production post-strikes,
- 20:06or I could say looking at decreased production post-guild and union contracts.
- 20:18It's going to cost more. I know there are a dozen or more production companies and studios
- 20:35trying to pencil it out for their shows, whether those are movies, documentaries, scripted shows,
- 20:48the few that are non-union, non-scripted shows, and so on. It's totally financially reasonable for
- 21:07them if they've set their budgets for the year to say this is going to cost more than it did
- 21:17before. I can't bust my budget, so I'm going to have to decrease the number of shows that I do
- 21:28produce. I'm oversimplifying what was a very complex and hard-fought situation, but I'm also
- 21:43trying to give you a look, and I'll cover that later when I come down, talk about the TV and
- 21:54situation as it now exists. Moving on to theatrical, start with what I teach at UCLA.
- 22:09I teach a course that's basically theatrical sequential distribution, aka Windows.
- 22:20So how are the Windows going? The good news for the industry and I hope for the public
- 22:30is that none of the major studios at most of the production companies
- 22:44are committed, if they are going to go theatrical, to have a theatrical as exclusive
- 22:53with no digital day-in-day mess. So the issue will then be frontal.
- 23:11Am I better off a production company distributor will say to itself, am I better off going theatrical
- 23:21and spending in the case of a wide release if it's international as well, which most of those
- 23:32wide releases are? I'm going to be putting up an extra 75 to 125 million dollars in marketing costs
- 23:46to launch the film around the world. Am I going to get that 125 million dollars back either out
- 23:57of theatrical or downstream? The downstream aspect of this lovingly, it's demonstrable and I hope
- 24:16all of you have read this to a fairly well over the last few months. It's demonstrable that a
- 24:26project that goes theatrical wide becomes more valuable, not less valuable downstream.
- 24:39Does that overcome the cost element, my so-called 75 to 125 million dollars?
- 24:53Well, that's the it-on-depends. So we now have to look at what genres of films or what particular
- 25:13films are the studios looking at when they decide to go theatrical as opposed to digital at the outset.
- 25:27And what we also are going to be looking at is how long is the theatrical exclusive?
- 25:36Is it, I'll call it, the first three weekends, 17 days?
- 25:48Longer 31 days, longer 45 days, or, forgive me, God willing, 110 days or more.
- 26:00Each studio will determine that on its own for each picture involved. I don't think you can
- 26:14generalize, even though there are patterns that are out there, that each studio has chosen for
- 26:22benefit with attention paid to its own situation in the digital world, which differs
- 26:35from major to major to major to studio to studio. All different. So it's all over the place. So
- 26:42my fun class at UCLA, I have two charts that I show the students on the first day of class,
- 26:58and it's here's what happens sequential distribution prior to the pandemic.
- 27:07And I can put that on two charts, on two pages, and it was pretty simple to do. And today I can't
- 27:17even come close, because as I just said, it all depends on the studio and it all depends on the
- 27:25picture. And there's essentially no rules involved. Having said that, I can take you through the
- 27:37windowing that is mostly done in the world today, and I mean world, not just US.
- 27:48The first downstream window in most cases, certainly in most cases with the wide release,
- 28:04is what I'm calling PEST or PVOD. The P in both cases stands for premium.
- 28:14The S is for electronic cell through or VOD for VOD.
- 28:26That seems to kick in first again when depends on the film that on the studio involved.
- 28:37And you have three issues that you ought to know about. One is what's the price?
- 28:47How much does it cost the consumer to get access either to the PEST or the PVOD?
- 28:56And the way that's playing out right now is mostly a $20 fee, which is uniform in quotes
- 29:15for PVOD, that is the rental part, or $3 for what we'll call their tent pole that is bigger
- 29:30and therefore can charge a higher price. So we have the retail price issues. We also,
- 29:41there's a hidden antitrust issue there because the retailer outlet is supposed to determine the price
- 29:53rather than the studio determining the price. The second is for the studio, do you go in-house
- 30:05or do you go third party or a combination? So for example, Disney seems to watch in doing its,
- 30:18I'll call it PEST PVOD, to go only in-house on its features. So it's on both sides.
- 30:30Universal by contrast is completely third party.
- 30:43What's similar or almost identical is the deal that's between the outlet and the distributor
- 30:56is an 80-20 split in favor of the distributor. So at a $20 pricing, for example,
- 31:11the studio keeps $16 and pays residuals. There's the fun one. They should be paying on
- 31:23$16. Some of them may be trying to pay on a 20% bid royalty, but we'll deal with that another day.
- 31:36Profit participants want that $16 in the pot and people at Disney working on a Disney picture may
- 31:47want $20 on the pot in order to disregard the fact that it's inside. Anyway, that's one of the fun
- 31:56ones there. Good news in the PEST PVOD world is it didn't really exist until four years ago.
- 32:06So that's the one that is zero and now a plus. I'm now going to get into the reverse.
- 32:17So following the PEST PVOD window is the, I'll call it home entertainment window.
- 32:24The physical DVD or Blu-ray is going.
- 32:40Yes, you can still do some collector stuff and they are still in quotes publishing
- 32:52or promoting films that are able to be bought physically transactional, whether Blu-ray,
- 33:04DVD or 4K and so on. Physical home video used to be 120 to 150% of its office.
- 33:25It now basically doesn't exist for all intents and purposes.
- 33:39And unfortunately, at least the way we're looking at numbers, digital either PEST PVOD or
- 33:49downstream hasn't made up for that loss.
- 34:01Anyway, sorry, we do have a more arguably robust
- 34:08digital outlet downstream past PEST and PVOD on a either a subscription model or
- 34:30to a much lesser extent a transaction model. But it isn't as good as it was.
- 34:41Following that, we're looking at what used to be called premium pay
- 34:49popularized in the US, obviously by HBO, which is now
- 34:56emerged into maps and that kicks in six to eight months post the act of release.
- 35:12The studios who do this and all do it in-house, I'm not talking about Sony because they go to
- 35:20third parties, but the in-house studios, the four of them, are not as transparent with their rate
- 35:30cards as they used to be when they were in a B2B world. And so that's causing some problems,
- 35:39both for participants and for guilds. And there's a bunch of lawsuits and arbitrations
- 35:47that have been brought in that regard. Same thing downstream further with ad-supported television,
- 36:00whether that's linear, i.e. ABC, NBC, CBS, Fox, networks playing pictures or digital.
- 36:19And what used to be the kind of guidepost before the pandemic was anywhere from a 10 to 12.5%
- 36:36of box office license fee. So if I needed $100 million at the box office, I wouldn't be looking
- 36:48to do $10, $12, $15 million for that window of roughly six years, seven years of linear.
- 37:04And the issue is, are the participants and or the guilds and unions getting the benefit of that,
- 37:15or are they going to have to fight with the studios to get back up to where that should be?
- 37:28Looking next at the atropical results 2023, first and most important, at least to me,
- 37:39is how many wide releases are out there. The reason I say that is because I'm quite concerned that if
- 37:57the downward trend in releasing theatrical continues, we're going to lose theaters because they won't have
- 38:10stuff to attract consumers. So in last year, there were 83 wide releases in the US up from 79 in 2022
- 38:29and up from 81 in 2021. But free pandemic according to S&P Capital IQ Standards and Court Division,
- 38:48the majors released 113 wide releases from 2009 to 2019. And theaters stayed around and were happy
- 39:08with that. But going down into the 80s or 70s, it gets a little shaky here. Just for your fun,
- 39:22I'll give you the rankings from last year. First place was Universal, actually second year in a row.
- 39:33Universal had a little over $5 billion of revenue. This is wholesale. It's too universal. I'm not
- 39:43talking box office. $5 billion little over and roughly based on the S&P calculations,
- 39:56in one and a half billion dollar profit from its theatrical releases.
- 40:09Warners was second, a little under a billion dollars in profit, mainly due to Barbie.
- 40:17And then followed Sony, Paramount, and believe it or not, Lions Gay. And in, well, in quotes,
- 40:28last place is a little company called Disney, which last year had $56 million, approximately,
- 40:39$56 million of profit, the least of all the majors. The average domestic box office was a little over
- 40:53$88 million. So as you're looking at your Monday or Wednesday trade paper and looking at the tune
- 41:04for each picture, bear that in mind, that at least last year it was 88. And internationally last year
- 41:15was 119, a total of 207.6 of box. So if you're now backing up to what I was talking about before,
- 41:36when I said there's $75 to $125 million of marketing and related costs to release a picture,
- 41:50the theatrical average, things around cover, around cover, which does show you that
- 42:02those pictures, in essence, the profits on average from the studio point of view are downstream,
- 42:16that of a street. I keep getting, I can last mention and I'll say it again,
- 42:26the theater count is crucial, I think, to the, obviously, to the theatrical.
- 42:41If we keep running down into the 70s or below, I'm very concerned, not only in the U.S.,
- 42:54but internationally as well, there's going to be shutdowns and or consolidation.
- 43:09But now even take a look at what's happening here in the U.S. on cinemas. The top three,
- 43:18the top three theater chains who basically do close to 50, 50 percent of total box office,
- 43:33those three entities, and the other 600 entities in the theatrical business do the other, that's two percent.
- 43:48The top one, AMC, is still struggling mightily with its death mode. The number two entity who was
- 44:03is just about coming out of chapter 11. And the third cinema is doing reasonably well,
- 44:22mainly because they're in a more, I'll call it monopolistic position in most of their venues,
- 44:36because unlike the top two, they aren't strong theater presence in the top 10 markets in the
- 44:48United States. They aren't LA, New York, Chicago, blah, blah, blah. So if those three are teetering
- 44:59in one form or another, I'm not trying to scare you, I'm just trying to inform you.
- 45:06Okay. Finally, we get to TV and streaming. The viewing and revenue, I've sent you
- 45:22an article from Odea, a respected research company, that original productions last year are
- 45:42way down from the year before and pointing further downward. To make matters worse, because of the
- 45:57strike, which essentially paralyzed scripted programming for linear and digital, the only
- 46:09survivors during that period were essentially non-scripted and or documentary sports, non-union
- 46:22international, and some news or live action stuff. And the reduction affected not only the studios,
- 46:37but also what I'll call the pure streamers, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, and in a weird way, affected
- 46:56the social media entities, the YouTube's, Instagram's, and TikTok's of the world.
- 47:05And they are around the world. Indeed, the rise of social media and social media-related viewing
- 47:20is on the one hand a testament to the evolving nature of viewer engagement worldwide, and in fact,
- 47:33one or more research companies maintain that today as we look at it, 25% of the viewing that we do
- 47:49is on social, meaning that in effect, the consumer is not paying additional money to see our product.
- 48:11And that takes me to the linear TV subject. The other handout that I sent you on linear TV
- 48:25advertising, I think the title was, It is Entering a Terminal Underline, Terminal Declined.
- 48:34Linear TV has crumbled. It used to be over 50% of video global advertising,
- 48:47or if you just considered freemium, meaning professionally May, last year it was 80%.
- 48:56But over the next five years, it's totally inevitable, I think, as scary as it may be,
- 49:08that on the soon, the combination of online and social media viewing on the revenue front,
- 49:27it will not increase consumer spend. Now, I'm going to come back to that
- 49:36in what I'll call my closing remarks. How did all this happen? Where have we been? What are we looking at?
- 49:47As late as 10 years ago, the media industry had a programming offer in the form of a singular cable bundle.
- 49:58Indeed, for the six major studios, the cable bundle was the highest or next to highest profitable
- 50:12division of each of the six. 40% margins plus an allucrative side business, as I mentioned before,
- 50:27that theatrical and physical home video were ascendant. But in 2019, it came to a weird reversal,
- 50:45or starting to reverse. In 19, Fox was sold to Disney, pay TV subscriptions started to go backwards,
- 51:04and that was then followed by, we all know, the pandemic, which basically shut down theatrical viewing
- 51:16and accelerated the shift to streaming. The media industry in the last four to five years,
- 51:27and this is where I'm starting to get more pessimistic, has basically shifted to lower margin
- 51:40product, like streaming, tech companies are encroaching with their phone product, and the box
- 51:58office is declining. So even with, if you will, S-FOD or AVOD growth, which doesn't exist,
- 52:14whether that's subscription for transactional. Oh, and here's my footnote. In 2013,
- 52:293% of consumer video spending was present then on S-FOD, AVOD, and pretty clearly going to reach
- 52:5340% in 2028. But it's doing so without growth in advertising as a whole, or consumer spending
- 53:10as a whole. Indeed, the projection is that inflation, at least here in the United States,
- 53:18and probably elsewhere, inflation will be higher than video growth for the next few years,
- 53:31and will be less video growth than discretionary spending or spending on recreational services
- 53:41outside of video. So we seem to be going in the wrong direction. First, streaming services,
- 53:54all under controlled by public companies, I'll say this, rightly paying obeisance to Wall Street,
- 54:04are shifting to some form of advertising element to their businesses. With the exception, for example,
- 54:19of Apple, who doesn't have advertising except as part of its sports offering,
- 54:28soccer, baseball. All of the others are basically giving the consumer a public four choices.
- 54:43We have a so-called fast channel that's free, it's usually branded, and it's usually old stuff,
- 55:02or news or weather. Then a step up from there is a low priced hybrid, SFOD with AVOT at a lower price,
- 55:19or third tier, a slightly higher mid-range price on a hybrid basis, or number four,
- 55:36SFOD with no transaction, which is today, of all things, the highest revenue producer of those four.
- 55:48But all of us will have a choice of one of those four from our seven or eight now
- 56:00companies that have aspirations worldwide. But in countries like India, China, Indonesia, etc.,
- 56:16where good looking color TV and all of that is not nearly as big, I don't have my
- 56:34cell phone here, but that's what people in those countries are going to be watching.
- 56:51And as I said before, the major studios and the pure streamers are shifting from scripted
- 57:11to non-stricted local language ad-supported tiers, sports and live-action programming,
- 57:22or even immersive programming to furnishies. So turning down to lower cost streaming
- 57:33through bundling partnerships and M&A, and to cap it off, the consumer spend as a whole
- 57:48isn't in a growth mode. Now for a fun one, will AI solve this problem?
- 57:58That's something that I want you to remember for five years from now. I don't know.
- 58:11So what I'm really saying is I don't know if we can reverse these trends. I don't know whether
- 58:25we can, in quotes, bring back the ancient, meaning pre-2020, ancient situation where we had
- 58:44consumer spend and entertainment spend on a growth greater than the CPI, both here and around the
- 58:58world, but that's kind of the way I have to leave their speech today. So happy to answer all your
- 59:15questions.
- 59:16That's wonderful.
- 59:26That's a good one. Well, it can take a couple of questions if they're not difficult.
- 59:35Easy questions only. Easy questions only. Easy questions, yes.
- 59:49Ken, if you go back to your first bucket of Wall Street and the expectations of bondholders,
- 59:58shareholders, and then look at the complete wipeout that has been announced over the last
- 1:00:04month or so, how will the market think about funding newer companies and what is the prognosis
- 1:00:17for the legacy firms that have downward slope? Next question. That's, it becomes a self-fulfilling
- 1:00:35prophecy, I think, that if we're caught in this downward slope, there's less and less interest
- 1:00:48on the part of Wall Street investors to feed the beast. Because obviously they like to feed
- 1:00:59growth, and if we're at a level that's sloping down, I'm not sure. Added to which, and this is a
- 1:01:15point I really do want to make, that the hesitance about transparency, and I'm almost compelled to
- 1:01:30say that Netflix is better than everyone else in that regard in terms of giving transparency.
- 1:01:39Not that they're as good as I would like them to be, but they're better than anybody else in that
- 1:01:45world. There isn't a VC or PE firm who's going to invest as they used to in features with no
- 1:02:09transparency downstream. So the only kinds of deals that get made in the absence of transparency
- 1:02:22downstream would be if you were betting solely on box office. Anyway.
- 1:02:33Okay. Other questions, anyone? Going once. Have I depressed you sufficiently? Going twice.
- 1:02:45No more difficult questions. Thank you everybody.