Latest / FE exam in the car / PROFESSOR WILSON DISCUSSES HIS BOOK ON THE ATHLETES GUT
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Welcome to Celebrity Exercise and Diet Secrets. We discuss how
- 0:05celebrities stay in shape and more. So let's get started.
- 0:31Speaker 2: Welcome back everybody. We'll get another great guest, doctor Patrick B. Wilson.
- 0:34He's a PhD in r Deeds also Associate Professor of
- 0:37Exercise Science, Assistant Chair of Human Movement Science. Is an
- 0:41old Dominion university over in Virginia, and today we're going
- 0:44to be talking about the athlete's guts. Also, he's the
- 0:47author of the book called The Athletes Gut as well.
- 0:50We're going to find out a lot about nutrition and athletes.
- 0:52Is it different than the general population? Well, I think
- 0:55if you don't know, it is, and if you do know,
- 0:58then you're going to be really excited about this. Us
- 1:00to listen more about how do athletes need to eat
- 1:03and how different is it? We'll find out before we
- 1:05get started. You know what to do, Share, subscribe, hit
- 1:07that I like button. You know we like it and
- 1:09that's not waste any more time. Welcome to the show,
- 1:10Doctor Wilson.
- 1:11Speaker 3: Welcome, Hey, thanks for inviting me on. It's be great
- 1:15to talk about some of these issues with athletes and
- 1:17feeling and nutrition. It's a big area of interest for
- 1:20at a lot of folks, from recreational people to the
- 1:23elite level.
- 1:24Speaker 2: Absolutely. I guess that's one of the things that people
- 1:28sometimes there is, well, let me see, how do I
- 1:30phrase this? There is a distinction, I guess we'll start
- 1:34off with that question. There's somewhat of a distinction between
- 1:36untrained and trained individuals. But even then the trained maybe
- 1:40the people who work out three to four days a
- 1:41week doing weights, maybe some cardio, but then athletes like
- 1:47baseball players, football players, and I also explore that with
- 1:50you too, is are the differences in sports? But what
- 1:52are the differences between those three groups, the untrained, the
- 1:56fitness enthusiasm and the athlete. Is there a difference? Yeah?
- 2:00Speaker 3: Nutritionally, definitely. The largest difference is going to be between
- 2:03your your sedentary individual and then the higher highly trained
- 2:08or higher trained individual. Into a large extent, it comes
- 2:11down to duration intensity of activity in terms of your
- 2:17training volume. So if you're spending you know, one to
- 2:21two to three hours per day, especially at moderate to
- 2:24high intensities, in terms of your activity, the metabolog demands
- 2:28for that are going to be pretty large, and the
- 2:30fueling requirements for that are going to be more substantial
- 2:33than if you're working out maybe three four times a
- 2:36week for thirty to sixty minutes. Not to say that
- 2:40nutrition doesn't make a difference, because of course it can,
- 2:42but it becomes probably more critical for individuals who are
- 2:47partaking in training volumes and intensities that really put stress
- 2:52on you know, the fuel reserves that you use from
- 2:57day to day put stress on your build to adapt
- 3:01to training in terms of making sure you've got enough
- 3:04protein other nutrients to ensure you're metabolically ready to go
- 3:10again if you're spending lots of time, especially in those
- 3:14moderate to high intensity zones. Now, if you're doing activity
- 3:17and it's lower intensity for a few hours per day,
- 3:19that's you know, there may be some nutritional considerations there.
- 3:23But when I teach this stuff in my classes in
- 3:27our university, a lot of the discussions around the needs
- 3:30are based on intensity and duration the combination of those factors.
- 3:35Speaker 2: Now, I don't know how specific person has to get.
- 3:39Maybe an athlete does, because obviously a tenth of a
- 3:41second can make a huge difference for the athlete. But
- 3:45how about bioavailability of protein? You mentioned protein, is that
- 3:48going to be something that really matters, in other words,
- 3:50than egg compared to some of their form protein, like
- 3:53a peanut butter.
- 3:55Speaker 3: The biability becomes perhaps a little bit more important when
- 3:58you're at lower to moderate doses protein. There's been a
- 4:01few studies that have fed higher doses comparing like vegetarian
- 4:06sources versus animal based sources, and muscle growth and strength
- 4:12gains have been pretty similar. Like if let's say you
- 4:14feed individuals a total of one and a half grams
- 4:19for every kilogram or their body mass, if it's all
- 4:23from vegetarian sources, including maybe like a soy supplement or
- 4:27something like that, or some other vegetarian source, and then
- 4:32you compare that to an omnivore diet at those higher
- 4:35protein intakes, At least in the studies that have been done,
- 4:38it doesn't seem like it makes a whole lot of
- 4:39difference on muscle strength and muscle hypertrophe if someone was
- 4:44consuming a lower amount of protein. I think it's put
- 4:47you know, there's a potential that source in terms of
- 4:50animal versus plants, could make some difference with muscle growth,
- 4:54but direct evidence for that is, you know, not super clear.
- 5:00When people say that, let's say an animal product or
- 5:02protein is better. It's almost exclusively based on just short
- 5:06term feeding studies where they give people let's say, in
- 5:09a way protein versus soy protein or some other plant
- 5:13based protein and look at the acute muscle protein synthesis
- 5:17response within let's say eight hours or something, and that
- 5:21can only tell you so much. So I think largely
- 5:25as long as if someone's a vegetarian or they eating
- 5:28a lot of plant based sources or protein, as long
- 5:30as they as long as they're total protein intake is sufficient.
- 5:34And on the higher side, I don't really think you
- 5:36need to get too bogged down in terms of this
- 5:38source of protein as much as what sometimes people may convey.
- 5:42Speaker 2: And I don't know if this is too broad up
- 5:44a question, but macronutrient differences among different sport athletes in
- 5:50other words, like baseball and football and basketball, they're similar,
- 5:54but at the same time, like baseball, if you're an outfielder,
- 5:57it's kind of a peculiar position because you're just sitting
- 5:59there for who knows how long and then whom you
- 6:01got to go. And basketball you're not really ever sitting
- 6:03there as you're on the bench. But is there a
- 6:06differences for maquid nutrients there.
- 6:09Speaker 3: Yeah, I would say the biggest difference tends to be
- 6:10the amount of carbohydrate that you might be consuming from
- 6:14day to day, dependent on sport. So example, you know,
- 6:18on a day where you're competing, you know, in a
- 6:21half marathon or a marathonor has a lot higher chance
- 6:25of depleting their carbohydrate stores and running into problems with
- 6:29sustaining higher intensity activity. Usually with competition and the intensities
- 6:36you're you're going at, let's say for half marathon or marathon,
- 6:39you might run out of glycogen stored carbohydrate in some
- 6:43cases within an hour to an hour and a half.
- 6:46So yeah, there is a real risk of running low.
- 6:50Whereas with you know, a baseball player especially or even
- 6:53a basketball player. The amount of distance that a professional
- 6:57basketball player covers in the game is not all that much. Now,
- 7:00they do have some periods where they're doing high intensity
- 7:02stuff sprinting, obviously jumping, but for those athletes it's not
- 7:08quite as critical to have such high carbohydrate intakes. So
- 7:12it's depending a lot on the sport. Soccer is an
- 7:17interesting team sport where it's kind of like it's a
- 7:19combination of both the aerobic high intensity, and they actually do
- 7:22cover a phair amount of distance in a soccer professional
- 7:25soccer game. Also, if you like play the whole soccer game,
- 7:29you're there for ninety minutes at a minimum, whereas the
- 7:31basketball player is going to have some time on the bench.
- 7:34They might play for you know, on average, thirty to
- 7:36thirty five minutes a game. So there's differences even among
- 7:40team sports potentially in the requirement for especially carbohydrate. So
- 7:45not every single athlete needs to be, you know, crushing
- 7:48carbohydrate every single day. It depends on the metabolic needs
- 7:52that sport, and there's some sports where it's more critical
- 7:55than others to regularly consume a higher amount of car carbohydrate.
- 8:01Would even within sports like a marathon or there's there's
- 8:04gonna be periods of time where it's less critical to
- 8:07be consuming lots of carbohydrate. So I think that's been
- 8:11an evolution and a lot of the sport nutrition recommendations
- 8:14of the last couple of decades is to recognize some
- 8:16of the nuance there and just realize that just because
- 8:19somebody is an athlete doesn't necessarily mean they need to
- 8:21be eating a ton of carbohydrate all the time.
- 8:24Speaker 2: Boys, that's so true. The evolution in the world of
- 8:27sports exercise and the sports nutrition is amazing in the
- 8:31last twenty years. Those are great points, and I guess
- 8:35by other I had two questions that spawned from that.
- 8:38But the first one would be any research on carbohydrate
- 8:41loading two or three days prior. I keep hearing about
- 8:43this a.
- 8:44Speaker 3: Lot now or certain sports. Yeah, and it tends to
- 8:47be things that last more than sixty minutes. And I
- 8:51should clarify carbohydrate loading means different things to different people.
- 8:54But studies that I've actually done, like a carbohydrate loading protocol,
- 8:58usually we're talking about a minimum of something like eight
- 9:02grams for every kilogram in your body mass. Upwards of
- 9:05ten is more common. So I just did something like
- 9:08that for a half marathon that I ran about a
- 9:11month ago and didn't I didn't get to ten, but
- 9:14I got to I think it was eight grams for
- 9:16every kilogram of my mass, and that was roughly around
- 9:19six hundred grams of carbohydrate per day about a day
- 9:23and a half is what at the time frame that
- 9:25I did it for. And it's not necessarily easy to
- 9:28eat that amount, and I wouldn't do that. I wouldn't
- 9:32do that regularly because I'm not. I'm not doing a
- 9:35half marathon regularly at maximell intensity on a daily basis,
- 9:39So it's something I reserve for doing, you know, once
- 9:42every couple of months or a few months, when there's
- 9:45a longer effort that I know is going to be
- 9:47done at a maximell intensity. We'll actually actually count out
- 9:52the amount of carbohydrate that I'm meeting and trying target
- 9:55a fairly high amount. So carbohydrate loading. Yeah, usually it's
- 9:59the find around kind of that, you know, ten milligram
- 10:03or me ten gram per kilogram of body masks maybe
- 10:05a little bit lower, but it's it's more than just
- 10:09pasta or something like the night beforehand, or a carbohydrate
- 10:13rich breakfast. It's concerted carbohydrate rich foods pretty much at
- 10:18every meal, along with eating carbohydrate sources in between, including
- 10:22beverages or other sort of dense things like candies or
- 10:27you know, dried fruit, things like that. But it's only
- 10:30really necessary if whatever you're doing is probably more than
- 10:32at least sixty minutes. If it's less than that, generally
- 10:37you've got enough store carbohydrate to make it through those
- 10:39activities without running out. So it's not something I would
- 10:43do normally but it is potentially helpful in situations where
- 10:48you might anticipate you're going to be running low on
- 10:51your internal stores of carbohydrate.
- 10:54Speaker 2: So maybe a soccer player who plays the whole ninety.
- 10:57Speaker 3: Yeah, I would say, you know, do they need to
- 10:59go to ten grams per kilogram? Probably not, but at
- 11:03least you know there's some studies. One interesting one I
- 11:08know of that was kind of a field study where
- 11:10they used GPS monitors to look at how much soccer
- 11:13players ran in one condition. I think it was eight
- 11:16grams per kilogram. In the other condition it was three,
- 11:18which is pretty low. It's not I wouldn't define that
- 11:22necessarily as low carbohydrate, but it's it's quite low for
- 11:25an athlete, and pretty much every soccer player in that
- 11:29study ran farther and did more high intensity work when
- 11:31they were on the higher carbohydrate condition. So yeah, it's
- 11:35certainly a higher amounts before a game. I don't know
- 11:38know that a soccer player would need to go as
- 11:39high as ten, but maybe the six to eight range
- 11:43grams per kilogram of body mass is a reasonable recommendation
- 11:47for a soccer player.
- 11:48Speaker 2: You're reminder me when you said about Boston, I'm thinking
- 11:51about my college days, thinking all you can eat posta places.
- 11:55It's a good idea for those days.
- 11:57Speaker 3: Yeah, it's pretty much what I did. The last time
- 11:59I did this is I just made an entire box
- 12:02of shell noodles and ate half of it at lunch
- 12:05and then half of that dinner. I think the next
- 12:07time I'm going to switch to rice, just because I
- 12:09think it's a little bit easier to get down the
- 12:11quantities required. And then beverages, you know, sugar beverages, sweetened beverages.
- 12:16I don't drink regularly, but on those days that you're
- 12:19eating a lot of carb, it's easier to get down
- 12:21a simple form of sugar like that, you know.
- 12:24Speaker 2: I asked a dietician yesterday that you bring that up,
- 12:26because it's really surprising to me. It's been shoot, I
- 12:30don't know, thirty years now, maybe forty years at least,
- 12:32maybe forty. I'm so old I can't remember fifty one.
- 12:35But I'm trying to think Gatorade's been around forever. And
- 12:39when I read the sports nutrition books and textbooks, I'm
- 12:41kind of geeked that way. I like to read textbooks.
- 12:43And I was reading the textbook and I was thinking
- 12:45Gatorad's still up there is the number one, number.
- 12:47Speaker 3: Two marketing all and wonders for you is it that.
- 12:52Speaker 2: Good or are there other options that are better?
- 12:54Speaker 3: It's there's nothing, to be completely honest, there's nothing unique
- 12:57about Gatoray in terms of the composition. It's sugar water
- 13:00with some electrolytes. There is really nothing I would say
- 13:04unique about Gatoray as a product in terms of what's
- 13:07in there. I mean, it's unique because it was really
- 13:09the first sports beverage that was marketed and sold and
- 13:13it's had a huge share of the market for many,
- 13:15many years. So obviously they've got a leg up, I think,
- 13:18on a lot of competitors from that respect. But basically
- 13:22all sports beverages are is just you know a little
- 13:25bit of variation in the carbohydrate content in terms of
- 13:27the percentage of you know, rams of carbohydrate relative to
- 13:31the leaders of fluid. Most are around six percent carbohydrate,
- 13:36very sometimes a little bit below that, sometimes a bit
- 13:39above that. But for the most part, they're all the same.
- 13:43They're sugar water with some differences in the composition of sugars,
- 13:48but there's really to For the most part, there's not
- 13:50real huge differences between most spore strinks, although all of
- 13:55them would like you to think it think there are
- 13:56major differences because they're selling product. Stand you want to
- 14:00create and market something that seems unique. But you know,
- 14:04it's it comes down to kind of I guess individual
- 14:06preference and maybe a few other factors in terms of
- 14:08deciding if you want to use one product versus another.
- 14:11But they're all sugar water.
- 14:13Speaker 2: And for the people who get more intense about this,
- 14:16I'm still there. So I'm sure there's some students out
- 14:18there said, what about the isotonic compound? Is that really
- 14:21something that's relative or is it kind of a.
- 14:23Speaker 3: Yeah, that's an interesting It's one of those things that
- 14:26you can show in very super geeky physiological studies that
- 14:31you know, isotonic beverage, the fluid will get absorbed usually
- 14:35maybe a bit quicker in the end. You know, that's
- 14:39not the only consideration I would make though, when I'm
- 14:41picking a beverage, like think about an elite marathon or
- 14:45some of them are consuming ninety you do one hundred
- 14:47grams of carbohydrate per hour. If you wanted to do
- 14:50that from an isotonic beverage, you would have to drink
- 14:54a leader and a half per hour of gatorade, which
- 14:57is not you know that that would be disaster in
- 15:00terms of your stomach stomach comfort. So they consume beverages
- 15:04that are denser in carbohydrates, and by definition they're more hypertonic.
- 15:10Now they train themselves to kind of be able to
- 15:11deal with that. So I think the idea that in
- 15:16isotonic beverage is always better, it's not necessarily the case.
- 15:20It depends kind of on your objectives. If your main
- 15:22objective is to eat a lot of carbohydrate during exercise,
- 15:25then no, an isotonic beverage isn't going to be the
- 15:27best choice for some people if they're looking for more
- 15:31of a moderate carbohydrate consumption rate than in isotonic beverage
- 15:36is perfectly fine. It might might be a little bit
- 15:40easier on the stomach. But there are other considerations beyond
- 15:45you know, whether it's hypertonic or isotonic that really I
- 15:48would factor in before I really pick a beverage, And
- 15:52that's not the main one that I would really probably
- 15:53focus on in most cases.
- 15:56Speaker 2: By the way, folks, again we're talking to doctor Patrick Wilson,
- 15:59and he is the author of the book called It's
- 16:01Like lost it. I had it there. It is the
- 16:03athletes gut the inside science and it's cutting me off
- 16:07here inside science of digestion, nutrition and stomach distress. We're
- 16:12going to be talking a little bit about that too,
- 16:13because there are some foods and we'll see doctor Wilson
- 16:16agrees that you probably shouldn't have or sports day or
- 16:20game day because they may not help you. But we'll
- 16:23get to that in a little bit. Let me ask
- 16:25you about this. Then this was going to originally ask you,
- 16:28but then isotonic thing popped in my head? Uh, do
- 16:33you have to get really specific per individual? I know,
- 16:36as you mentioned earlier, you're getting more nuanced on you,
- 16:38but the industry itself is getting more nuanced realizing that
- 16:41we got different sports. How about athletes themselves? Are they
- 16:45processing food differently? Did some athletes require more sugar, less sugar,
- 16:49more carbs, less carbs, anything like that? Is that too much? Yeah?
- 16:53Speaker 3: I mean, and day to day there's differences and requirements
- 16:56for carbohydrate based on the things that kind of mentioned
- 16:58earlier with you know them, and intensity of stuff you're
- 17:01doing during exercise itself, like how much should you consume
- 17:06during exercise or some individual differences, and a lot of
- 17:08that would be dependent on again duration and intensity, but
- 17:12also just the caliber of athlete. And they're individual feeding tolerance.
- 17:19So you know, you can look at the best marathoners
- 17:22in the world and they may be again consuming sixty
- 17:25to ninety grams per hour for every hour that they're running,
- 17:28which is a very very high, aggressive rate of carbohydrate consumption.
- 17:32Again during competition, that's not necessary for somebody who's an
- 17:37average marathon or they're not burning carbohydrate as fast. They're
- 17:42not expending his energy at equivalent rate, so they don't
- 17:46you know, generally, you would not advise a middle of
- 17:49the road marathon or to be consuming you know, eighty
- 17:52grams of carbohydrate per hour. It's really for higher level
- 17:55athletes that are burning carbohydrate at a high rate and
- 17:59they're trying to stay in that high rate to burn
- 18:01and that's why they're eating so much during some of
- 18:04these races. So it's caliber of athlete, it's the event
- 18:08and duration. Shorter events in games like a basketball game
- 18:14other types of sports where it's less than an hour
- 18:17during the actual activity, in most cases you don't need anything.
- 18:20You know, it's not long enough for many athletes to
- 18:23really justify much consumption. So if you're running a ten
- 18:28k race and you're finishing in forty minutes or something
- 18:31like that or forty five minutes, you really don't need
- 18:34anything in most cases in terms of performance for something
- 18:37that short. It's when you get beyond an hour where
- 18:40it becomes usually more beneficial to think about that. So, yeah,
- 18:45it comes down to the athletes sports or event. They're caliber.
- 18:51Higher level athletes generally require probably more aggressive approaches, and
- 18:56then individual tolerance. Some people, like we will do studies
- 19:00in the lab and some people have got an iron gut.
- 19:02You can give them anything and they seem fine. And
- 19:05then you give somebody else even a moderate amount of
- 19:07fluid or carbohydrate and they've got you know, ratings four
- 19:12or five, six out of ten for fullness and bloating
- 19:15and reflux. So some people just for whatever reason, don't
- 19:19tolerate those types of aggressive approaches. So you've got to
- 19:23kind of individualize based on the person as well as
- 19:26the other factors that I mentioned.
- 19:29Speaker 2: Yeah, that's where it gets complicated because I know I
- 19:31was speaking to a dietitian the other day. It is
- 19:33a sports dietitian. What she was saying is it's always
- 19:38nice in the books they give you the recommendations and stuff,
- 19:41and then when you get to real life, like, wait
- 19:43a minute, that didn't work out at all.
- 19:45Speaker 3: Yeah, And that's something I try and impress on my
- 19:47students is that these are starting recommendations you can look
- 19:50at and textbooks or like position stands on nutrition and
- 19:54athletic performance. It's a good starting point. But then you
- 19:57get to try and consider the individual sport. You have
- 20:00to consider the individual athletes, what their goals are and
- 20:03what they're you know, what their tolerance is, and those
- 20:06are all things that are difficult to sometimes balance and
- 20:10figure out. But yeah, it's the art of being a
- 20:14practitioner is trying to take into consideration those individualized things
- 20:18that you don't get with generalized recommendations.
- 20:22Speaker 2: Have you noticed tcy I would frame this one for
- 20:25you because I know when we've talked about it, it was
- 20:26interesting to hear the cultural challenges that they can arise
- 20:29with athletes because certain cultures are like, well I don't
- 20:32want to eat that, or I want to eat this,
- 20:35and I want it can be incorporate some of my
- 20:36own food. So if you're looking like people from Mexico,
- 20:39maybe or my family background's Cuban, so we might try
- 20:43to get more rice in there than other cultures. Anything
- 20:46like that ever come across where you're like, well this
- 20:48is you know.
- 20:49Speaker 3: I mean, I would just say, usually you try and
- 20:51work with an athlete, you know, if you're coming up
- 20:52for example, it's like an example menu plan. I mean,
- 20:55you want to work within their preferences. Is as much
- 20:58as you can recognize that, you know, food is not
- 21:01just feel, It's also a source of enjoyment and culture
- 21:05for people. And I think sometimes practitioners can make mistakes
- 21:11if they just think about it purely and kind of
- 21:13the feeling perspective and forget that people eat for a
- 21:17lot of different reasons. They eat different foods for different
- 21:19reasons from social to cultural to ethical. So yeah, as
- 21:24much as you can work within those parameters in terms of,
- 21:30you know, what they're willing to eat, what they're interested
- 21:32in eating, and try and make adjustments based off the person.
- 21:36Speaker 2: What are some of the biggest faux pause that you
- 21:38see athletes make when it courage to food. I know,
- 21:42one of the ones I always hear about is fiber.
- 21:44You gotta be careful with that before game day, that
- 21:47could be problematic.
- 21:49Speaker 3: Yeah, there's you know, I say faux pause. I mean
- 21:53sometimes it is. You can have in some cases for
- 21:57higher level athletes, you can have underfeeling, which is a
- 22:01concern for a significant chunk of athletes, especially weights where
- 22:04body composition or weight is a part of it. You know,
- 22:09where it might be distance running or gymnastics or something
- 22:12like that. You know, the idea is that, yeah, you're
- 22:15gonna restrict energy intake and you're gonna lose body fat,
- 22:18you're gonna you know, maintain your weight, and that's going
- 22:21to be good for performance. And that sometimes leads to
- 22:25situations where it's completely counterproductive and you under fuel to
- 22:28the point where it no longer is an advantage and
- 22:32it becomes actually a detriment to performance and then eventually
- 22:35to to your health. So I think that's especially among
- 22:38higher level athletes in certain sports, it's a very common issue.
- 22:42And then there's of course, you have the mistakes that
- 22:43people make before competition and things like that. It can
- 22:46be just eating the wrong thing or too much, or
- 22:49trying something out you know that they haven't really tested
- 22:53out in their training, and they kind of go overboard
- 22:56with it and figure out that you know it didn't well.
- 23:00Like an example sometimes is just doing too much caffeine.
- 23:03You know, before a gamer race, thinking now I've heard
- 23:06caffeines good for performance, and then you know, you just
- 23:11do it a little bit overkill and you don't account
- 23:16for the fact that a lot of athletes are already
- 23:19kind of hyped up for competition, and you might throw
- 23:22a little bit too much caffeine at the mix in
- 23:24that stress response is a little bit more than what
- 23:26you wanted.
- 23:28Speaker 2: It's a lot of juggling. It's a lot of juggling.
- 23:33I guess now we're talking about caffeine. How important is
- 23:36hydration is? This is something I see some people don't
- 23:40consider it very much, but even the climate can affect hydration,
- 23:44am I right? Yeah?
- 23:45Speaker 3: The biggest factors for fluid intake needs would be again activity, duration, intensity,
- 23:52because the biggest thing that dictates how much fluid do
- 23:55you need in a day is how much you're sweating.
- 23:57So what dictates sweat rates is environment. Obviously, hotter human
- 24:01conditions is gonna they're gonna increase sweat rates, but then
- 24:04work rate, so easy examples if you look at a
- 24:08running race or traflon or something like that, The people
- 24:11who have the largest fluid deficits are typically the winners
- 24:14or the people at the front of the run of
- 24:16the pack, because they're sweating the most. Heat production is
- 24:21directly related to sweat rates, So the higher intensity you're working,
- 24:25the longer you're working, the more you're sweating, and the
- 24:29more fluid you need to replace. Other factors secondary to
- 24:32that would be body size and shape. People who are
- 24:35bigger have to rely more unsweating is a mechanism to
- 24:39cool off as opposed to somebody who has smaller because
- 24:43a smaller person has more skin surface area relative to
- 24:46their body volume. As you make something bigger, the ratio
- 24:52between your surface area and your body volume becomes more
- 24:55unfavorable in terms of you're not able to get rid
- 24:58of heat through the kind of normal mechanisms you would
- 25:02and you have to align more on sweating, so offensive alignment.
- 25:05In football, for example, that's an example of an athlete.
- 25:10If you standardize everything else, you know, work rate and
- 25:15things like that environmental conditions, they will still typically sweat
- 25:18more than smaller football players. So there's a number of
- 25:21factors that dictate sweat rates, and ultimately it comes down
- 25:24to how much You're sweating is going to be the
- 25:27main thing that dictates how much fluid you should be
- 25:29consuming on a daily basis to maintain hydration status.
- 25:33Speaker 2: Are you sorry? Are you folks measuring swear sweat rates
- 25:36as well?
- 25:37Speaker 3: You can? I mean the time where maybe that could
- 25:41be advantageous is if you want to get an idea
- 25:45about how much fluid to drink during exercise, you can
- 25:49calculate sweat rates, and that would be simply taking your
- 25:52weight before and afterwards, and then accounting for if you
- 25:56drink anything during the exercise, like if you drink a
- 25:59leader of flu you'd also kind of need to consider
- 26:01that into the calculation. But you know, over the course
- 26:04of let's say three hours of exercise, when you experience
- 26:07weight change, almost all of that is due to fluid loss,
- 26:10So you can use weight change as a proxy for
- 26:14sweat rates. Now, is it worth it to know what
- 26:17your sweat rate is? I think for some for especially
- 26:19some endurance athletes that are maybe competing more than three
- 26:23hours or two hours, it can be helpful to know
- 26:25what your sweat rate might be if your training or
- 26:29your competition is less than an hour or two hours.
- 26:33Most of the time, I think you can just kind
- 26:34of drink the thirst and probably be fine. It's just
- 26:37not enough time to develop dehydration to the point where
- 26:40it's going to impact your performance. I think most athletes,
- 26:45at least during exercise, thirst in many cases is sufficient
- 26:49to maintain hydration. The exceptions, so that would be if
- 26:52you're going really really long then maybe especially in a
- 26:56hot environment, you might think about wanting to know what
- 26:59your sweat rate is is to try and anticipate how
- 27:02much do I need to drink, let's say, over the
- 27:04course of this you know, half iron Man, drathlon or something.
- 27:09Speaker 2: How about urine color with that player role at.
- 27:12Speaker 3: Ard, That's a good question. That's actually something that I've
- 27:15a couple of studies I've done recently, not on urine
- 27:17color specifically, but something that is directly related to it,
- 27:20which is specific gravity, so kind of the density of
- 27:24urine relative to pure water. And you will oftentimes read
- 27:29that if someone has this urine specific gravity of one
- 27:32point zero two or above, that's indication that they're dehydrated.
- 27:37And that may work reasonably well in some settings. The
- 27:41issue that I've found is that in studies we've done,
- 27:46bigger people just tend to have higher urine specific gravities
- 27:52at baseline, and probably the main reason for that is
- 27:57bigger people, especially bigger athletes, have or muscle mass and
- 28:01they're excreting things from muscle. In terms of metabolites, the
- 28:06main one is creatinine. So you know most of your
- 28:09creatine is in muscle, and you day to day you
- 28:13break down free etine into creatinine. So somebody who has
- 28:17more scaltal muscle mass is going to have to excrete
- 28:21more creatinine in their urine, and their urine is likely
- 28:24to be just denser, more concentrated in part because of that.
- 28:29So there's some studies. If you look at studies that
- 28:32try and estimate how common is dehydration prior to practice
- 28:37or prior to games, studies estimate that fifty to seventy
- 28:40five percent of athletes are dehydrated prior to even starting exercise,
- 28:44And I think that is a gross overestimate of how
- 28:48many actually are because those studies just simply use this
- 28:52urine specific gravity threshold to try and identify people who
- 28:57are dehydrated without really considering variations in size. Variations between
- 29:04men and women. Women tend to have lower year in
- 29:06specific gravity levels. And there's even differences between race ethnicity
- 29:10to some extent that may be partly explained by body composition,
- 29:13but not fully. So I think you can use it
- 29:18you're in color and you're in specific gravity, But if
- 29:21you were going to what I would recommend is trying
- 29:25to develop like an individual profile for your athlete. So like,
- 29:29if you're going to use your in specific gravity as
- 29:31an example, testing you're in specific gravity in the morning
- 29:36several times in a condition where you think they're likely
- 29:40to be kind of normally hydrated, to say, what is
- 29:43their baseline, and then if they spike above that, then
- 29:47you realize, Okay, they probably need to drink more because
- 29:50they've been under drinking relative to where their normal baseline is,
- 29:54as opposed to using kind of a universal threshold for everybody,
- 29:59which probably doesn't work because of differences in body size
- 30:02and body composition and some other factors. So sorry, long
- 30:05story shorts, you can't use them. You can't use things
- 30:10like you're in color and you're in specific gravity. But
- 30:14sometimes the way they're applied in the field is it
- 30:18makes the information not all that great.
- 30:20Speaker 2: I reminder that BMI, yes.
- 30:23Speaker 3: In a way, it is kind of like that.
- 30:25Speaker 2: M h Yeah, that's really fascinating. No, no, don't don't
- 30:29ever apologize for that. It's great. Stuff's got my brain
- 30:33rackings on. I'm thinking about all the different things here. Well,
- 30:39we live in and we have to be real at
- 30:41least I do right in this world. Because athletes drink,
- 30:44they drink alcohol, it's going to have an impact on hydration.
- 30:49What kind of an impact does alcohol have on an athlete,
- 30:52let's say before game day.
- 30:55Speaker 3: Yeah, that's a good question. Actually, a PHA student and
- 30:58I did a review paper on beer speci typically. We
- 31:01published a couple of years ago, a year or two ago.
- 31:04If anybody's interested in checking it out, It's Got Beer.
- 31:07Is the title kind of a play on the gold thing? Yeah? Surprisingly,
- 31:12you know, it's a little bit, you know, it's it's
- 31:16nuanced in terms of like recovery and hydration. For example,
- 31:19is drinking alcohol problem after exercise? It is probably dose dependent.
- 31:25So if you have one drink or let's say one
- 31:27beer that's five percent alcohol, it doesn't seem to have
- 31:31much of an impact on rehydration. Now, if you get
- 31:34into two, three, especially more than that drinks, the alcohol
- 31:40becomes sufficient to really stimulate your in production. Because it
- 31:45is alcohol is something that is a diuretic. You know,
- 31:50it will cause your body to produce urine. So if
- 31:53you're consuming lots of alcohol post exercise, it can be
- 31:57detrimental to rehydration attempts. Now that can be maybe offset
- 32:03by drinking more fluid in general, so pairing it with
- 32:06water or other beverages or there's some interesting studies that
- 32:09were done of Australia where they put extra sodium into
- 32:12beer and that helped a little bit. I mean, do
- 32:15you want to drink salty beer after exercise? I don't know,
- 32:19but I think largely it's dose dependent, so one or
- 32:23two drinks in most cases post exercise. I don't think
- 32:26you need to lose sleep over that. It becomes situations
- 32:28where you're heavy drinking where it's more problematic from any
- 32:33number of perspectives, from hydration to the balance of inflammation
- 32:39in recovery, to muscle function to muscle protein synthesis. With
- 32:43high levels of alcohol intake, you can negatively impact all
- 32:46those things.
- 32:47Speaker 2: And I know this is a rare occurrence, but if
- 32:49you were to find an athlete who's using steroids, I'm
- 32:53being facetious, but if you find one who does it
- 32:55Does that impact the macronutrients or the hydration issue at all.
- 33:00Speaker 3: That's a good question, honestly, I don't I don't know.
- 33:03I don't know that there's much research on that question overall,
- 33:08you know. I yeah, I don't honestly have a good
- 33:10answer for that.
- 33:11Speaker 2: I'm not sure if it what or not, because I
- 33:13know there's a dearth and research on that. Yeah, obviously,
- 33:17well I guess you could. I don't know what about
- 33:19cannabis anything at all on that because that's another one
- 33:21obviously in today's world, seems to be increasing. I'm not
- 33:24sure if they've done anything on that one.
- 33:25Speaker 3: Yeah. We actually I'm teaching a class right now in
- 33:28the summer, an ergagenicates class, and we actually just talked
- 33:31about cannabis yesterday. So it's interesting timing. And you know,
- 33:36it's one of those where there is even less than alcohol.
- 33:39There's very, very very little research on cannabis with athletes
- 33:43in terms of experimental studies.
- 33:47Speaker 2: With ethical reasons you think, or is a liabilities.
- 33:50Speaker 3: Or legal largely legal historically, I think because of you know,
- 33:53the illegality of cannabis in many places, it's been difficult
- 33:57to do research. So there's another podcast that I had
- 34:02my students listen to. It's called the KUP Cast. He's
- 34:06an ultrarunner coach and he had a researcher on there,
- 34:10doctor Jamie burr Out of Canada, who they wrote a
- 34:14review paper on cannabis and exercise and they're doing some
- 34:17studies with cannabis and exercise. So it was an interesting,
- 34:21interesting interview just talking about some logistical issues of doing
- 34:24research with cannabis. For the most part, I mean, what
- 34:28we what I've seen and what they talked about in
- 34:31an interview is that with cannabis you do see some
- 34:36changes cardy vascularly, typically acutely, you might see an increase
- 34:40in heart rate, increasing blood pressure. How that would impact
- 34:45performance is still to be settled, but the suggestion is
- 34:49that it might not be favorable for you know, sort
- 34:53of cardi respiratory exercise.
- 34:54Speaker 2: Like VO two max issueser.
- 34:56Speaker 3: Yeah, theoretically, I mean, I mean, of course there's other
- 34:58effects too, I mean there's the the psychological effects, the
- 35:02mental effects that might also impact how somebody performs. But yeah,
- 35:07there's a suggestion if that you're you know, at rest,
- 35:10even you're seeing a fifteen you know, ten to fifteen
- 35:13beat increase in heart rate that that may not be
- 35:17all that great for especially sustained like cardi respiratory exercise.
- 35:22So they were doing doctor Burd was doing some studies
- 35:25on that, and they were in the interview they had
- 35:27talked about they were kind of actively doing data collections.
- 35:30So I don't think that they published the actual exercise
- 35:32studies yet, but I would think that maybe in the
- 35:35next year or two there'll be some data on that,
- 35:37because historically it's mostly been studies from the like eighties,
- 35:41seventies and eighties that took either untrained people or even
- 35:45people with like heart failure and COPD and administered on cannabis.
- 35:48And you can't really, you know, garner too much from
- 35:51those studies in terms of what impact it might have
- 35:53on athletes.
- 35:55Speaker 2: Interesting. I guess for me, maybe Tim Larry and Barba
- 35:58Ronda's had something look in their files later on, but
- 36:02I guess me, I was thinking about the munchies, you know,
- 36:04that's what you always hear about marijuana, and I thought
- 36:06one of the sort of altering their appetite, does it
- 36:09require a different macronutrient.
- 36:12Speaker 3: Yeah, that's a whole other question too, is like those
- 36:14effects on appetite and other other things, just you know,
- 36:18beyond the performance implications. Yeah, it's certainly being more commonly
- 36:23used among the general population and athletes, so it would
- 36:26be helpful to know, you know, what are what are
- 36:29some of the effects here.
- 36:31Speaker 2: And folks, and if you're wondering, you got to get
- 36:33them on the show. Yeah, we'll reach out to Doctor
- 36:34Burr ourselves as well and see what we can do.
- 36:36But the maytime, we can catch that other podcast and
- 36:38see what they're up to, and uh, you can give
- 36:41us other questions that maybe he would he didn't, they
- 36:43didn't ask, and we'll see what we can get on
- 36:45Doctor Burd see what they're up to. Over then on
- 36:48that side, this is going to be an unusual question,
- 36:52is a bit at Don's. It came to my mind
- 36:54just because of my background. Medications something people don't talk about.
- 36:59Some athletes will upper from anti depression or anti anxiety.
- 37:02Have you seen anything there at all? By chance?
- 37:06Speaker 3: You know, I certainly those medications can impact things like
- 37:09appetites and body weight in some cases in terms of
- 37:14athletes and research and how they interact with nutrition, I
- 37:16honestly haven't haven't seen much research on that, so I
- 37:20think largely would be kind of anecdote or extrapolating for
- 37:23them from studies of non athletes in terms of what,
- 37:26you know, what might be some implications there. So, yeah,
- 37:29it's an interesting question, but I don't I don't really
- 37:32have probably real clear answer for you in terms of
- 37:34what that impact might be.
- 37:36Speaker 2: I thought because it was kind of interesting. I'm just
- 37:38surprised the amount of physiological things that causes people. It's like, well, jeez,
- 37:43really it's interesting. I don't know, I don't know how
- 37:45many athletes are actually on that stuff. Yeah, it'd be
- 37:49a fascinating discussion. I know. We got a few minutes
- 37:51left before you have to go, and I really appreciate it.
- 37:54Again your time. By the way, folks, again, this is
- 37:56doctor Patrick Wilson, and the book is The Athletes Got.
- 38:00I highly recommend you go check it out. So let
- 38:03me ask you this. We talked about hydration. We talked
- 38:07about somewhat macronutrients. Fat. This is another big one that
- 38:12people talk about sometimes in the circles with mega threes
- 38:15on mega sixes. What is it with fat saturated unsaturated?
- 38:19You've got all kinds of wars going out out there.
- 38:22What's your take on fat and.
- 38:23Speaker 3: For the athlete, Yeah, you know, fat is certainly something
- 38:28that can have an impact in different ways. You know,
- 38:32for performance, is fat something that is helpful. You know,
- 38:37a higher fat diet theoretically in some situations might have
- 38:41some advantages. And sometimes it's not necessarily the high fat component.
- 38:44It can also just be you know, if you're eating
- 38:47a lot of fat, that means you're not eating a
- 38:48lot of carbohydrate. So for example, if you have an
- 38:51athlete that maybe you could stand to lose a little
- 38:53bit of weight or body fat. There's certainly studies that
- 38:57have put active individuals, rational athletes on ketogenic diets or
- 39:02low carb high fat diets. They lose weight and they
- 39:05perform better. So you know, that's I think that's an
- 39:08aspect to consider for some athletes that if it allows
- 39:12you to manage your weight a little better, there can
- 39:13be some advantages there. Or ultra endurance athletes, you know,
- 39:19when they're competing, you know, they're largely exercising at less
- 39:22than sixty percent of their view to max or their
- 39:25maximal oxygen consumption. So that's a zone where you're already
- 39:29burning a lot of fat. And if any event where
- 39:34that makes sense to eat some more fat. I mean,
- 39:37that's one where at least I would say for a
- 39:39lot of athletes, a higher fat diet would be perhaps
- 39:42equivalent to a high carb diet. You know, in some
- 39:46cases some athletes might perform better on a high fat
- 39:48diet among those ultra endurance athletes. Really really difficult to
- 39:53do research in that area because if you can imagine
- 39:55trying to bring in volunteers, asking them to do different
- 39:59diets and then performing you know for five, six, seven,
- 40:02eight hours, you know, nine hours, ten hours on a
- 40:04treadmill or something like that, just logistically very very difficult
- 40:08studies to do. So there's not a lot of studies
- 40:10on that, even though that's the type of population that
- 40:13would I think be more likely to benefit from a
- 40:16high fat diet. A Mega threes there's some evidence for recovery,
- 40:22you know, helping to speed up recovery with muscle damaging exercise.
- 40:27There's some interesting evidence around head injury as well as
- 40:33some you know, some other effects around older individuals with
- 40:37muscle growth. If they had a higher Mega three intake
- 40:41and their protein intake with suboptimal, it might help with
- 40:45some of the muscle building going on. So there's some
- 40:48things there. I think with the Mega three's especially that's interesting.
- 40:52I wouldn't describe any of them as like game changers
- 40:55for most people, but there's some interesting data there where
- 40:59there may be some benefit it's to a hire Mega
- 41:01three intake with respect to some of those applications.
- 41:05Speaker 2: I guess my last question, it seems like a lot
- 41:08of this stuff is based on marketing. Really, am I
- 41:12off on that?
- 41:12Speaker 3: Like?
- 41:12Speaker 2: In other words, I see certain products and they'll pick
- 41:15one study that has sample size them to including the researcher,
- 41:19and they'll just say this is what you're got to use.
- 41:21And you're kind of like, you know, wow, okay, and
- 41:23I get it. General population doesn't do all this work
- 41:26to hunt this down, but they see a study and
- 41:28that's the right thing to do. I was studied, all right,
- 41:31let's do it.
- 41:32Speaker 3: Yeah, that's you. You're you're very much right about that.
- 41:35I mean there's a lot of products that will say
- 41:38that they've been tested or they've been proven to work
- 41:41in a study. I mean, if you go and look
- 41:43at the studies that they're referencing, I mean a lot
- 41:45of times if you actually read it in detail, it
- 41:48it wouldn't really support what they're actually claiming. Either the
- 41:52studies too small, or the types of tests they use
- 41:55are just not really relevant, or they're exaggerating how much
- 41:58benefit you're going to get. And that's just that's the
- 42:01small subset of companies and things that are actually saying
- 42:04they've done research. And then there's the other ninety five
- 42:06percent who haven't done any research on their products and
- 42:09just make claims in market. And you know, it's attractive
- 42:14for people, I think, and I understand. You know, it's
- 42:16attractive to think that you can take a pill or
- 42:19use a supplement or a device or whatever and it's
- 42:22going to be kind of a quick way to get
- 42:24where you want to get. But in many of those cases,
- 42:28the benefits are either non existent or way smaller than
- 42:33what people really think.
- 42:35Speaker 2: Yeah, that's a whole other conversation for another test. A
- 42:39lot of weeds going on that one. Well, thank you
- 42:42so much, doctor Wilson for taking the time to be
- 42:44with us.
- 42:44Speaker 3: Sure, thanks for the invite. It's been in an interesting conversation.
- 42:47Speaker 2: Absolutely, I learned a lot. By the way, Folks, Again,
- 42:50doctor Patrick Wilson, the Athlete's got the inside science Digestion
- 42:53nutrition and stomach distress. Go check it out and you
- 42:57know what to do, Share, subscribe, and hit that I like,
- 42:59but you know, we like it.