Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #226 - Garth Mullins & Jen St. Denis
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. We're dedicating tonight's entire
- 0:25show to British Columbia's longest and still ongoing public health emergency, BC's toxic drug
- 0:31supply crisis. Since April twenty sixteen, when our province first declared this public
- 0:35health emergency, more than fourteen thousand people throughout BC have died due to illicit
- 0:41street drugs whose supply is so toxic and lethal it kills users nearly instantly,
- 0:47with even the lock zone, a life saving medication that can reverse opioid overdose,
- 0:51being ineffective at times. Sadly, the death toll of people in our
- 0:55communities keeps rising, with twenty twenty three being the worst year of the crisis
- 0:59in accounting for over twenty five hundred debts. But is our province actually treating
- 1:04this crisis as the emergency that it declared eight years ago? A stunning piece
- 1:08in The Taiee this month revealed that the BC Corner's Service conducts autopsies in just
- 1:15fifteen percent of suspected overdose cases, leaving many families with painful questions that will
- 1:21never be answered. The journalist behind the story, Tayee reporter Jen Sa Dennis,
- 1:26returns to the show to talk about it, and she's joined by another
- 1:29returning guest, a co founder of DELF, the Drug User Liberation Front and
- 1:33the host of the Crackdown podcast, Garth Mullins. Garth, Jen, nice
- 1:37to see you. Nice to see you again. So, Jen, I
- 1:40want to start with you. When someone dies because of a suspected drug overdose
- 1:44or drug poisoning, what is the procedure at the coroner's service, because I
- 1:49imagine they have to do a toxicology report, right, Yeah, obviously the
- 1:52toxicology report is like a key part of the death investigation. So what happens
- 1:57in BC is we have a lay corner system, which means that we have
- 2:00a you know, a bunch of corners who do have special training, but
- 2:04they don't have a medical background. So they go to the scene of the
- 2:07death. They will sometimes do an examination at the scene, or they'll they'll
- 2:12do an examination maybe at a morgue. They'll also interview the family and and
- 2:15you know, the person's family doctor to establish, you know, did this
- 2:19person have a history of drug use, you know, was there drug perfectly
- 2:23at the scene, and then they will do a toxicology test, and but
- 2:28on that basis alone is sort of NBC how they determine like, yes,
- 2:31this was a drug overdose, and that's not actually how other provinces do it.
- 2:37So is the autopsy then like the next level of that, So beyond
- 2:40the toxicology report, the autopsy can actually teach us more about these deaths.
- 2:45Yeah, that's right. The autopsy is considered, you know, by forensic
- 2:47pathologists it's like the most accurate way to determine how someone has died. And
- 2:53so what forensic pathologists say is that in most other jurisdictions in North America,
- 2:58in fact, I think some of them have said in a whole jurisdictions except
- 3:00for BC, the practice is to do quite a high number of autopsies for
- 3:06suspected drug overdoses and also alcohol deaths in some cases too. So it ranges,
- 3:12you know, it's from sixty percent in Newfoundland to one hundred percent in
- 3:15Ontario of doing like an autopsy for everything, and then just fifteen percent in
- 3:21BC. So it's sort of shocking to realize this that the BC corner service
- 3:25is doing this practice that's not really in line with what other corner and medical
- 3:30examiners do, and their explanation is just kind of like, well, we
- 3:35think toxicology is good enough. We think that we do a good enough job.
- 3:38We have you know, expedited testing, they do do two rounds of
- 3:40it. But forensic pathologists sort of are like, well, we we beg
- 3:46to differ. Garth, you're on the front lines of this crisis when you
- 3:49hear this news and you saw the piece that GEN produced, what are your
- 3:53thoughts that BC only conducts autopsies and fifteen percent of these drug overdose cases.
- 3:59I mean, I mean, I don't really know how all of this stuff
- 4:01works, Like, I don't know how conclusive at toxicology is at proving that
- 4:06someone's fatally overdosed. But what I wonder, and what lots of people in
- 4:12the community wonder, is you know, obviously, the vast majority of overdose
- 4:17deaths are exactly what you see happening, people using drugs and dying because the
- 4:24drug supply is toxic and unregulated. But occasionally we'll worry, did somebody get
- 4:30hot capped, which means was someone intentionally overdosed by someone else, Okay,
- 4:38and we just maybe you miss that if you only do the tox screen and
- 4:44not the autopsy. But I don't know, and I'm not trying to create
- 4:48this idea that this is like a huge problem, but occasionally you see it.
- 4:55And then sometimes we have people like I've had a friend who you know,
- 4:59was they ruled her death a fatal overdose, but she also had other
- 5:03medical conditions. We could never, you know, especially her partner, could
- 5:08never be entirely sure that that was what was happening. It strikes me as
- 5:13interesting that, again, in a quote unquote emergency, we're not doing autopsies
- 5:17on one hundred percent of cases of people that are suspected to have died from
- 5:21drug poisonings drug overdoses. Does that sort of surprise both of you as well?
- 5:27Yeah, I mean this is the you know, biggest health crisis in
- 5:30our province right now. It's the highest death toll. And like like Garth
- 5:34just said, you know, aside from the concerns that I hear those all
- 5:38the time too, the concerns about actual homicides being missed, just the public
- 5:42health element. Often people who use drugs have other things going on with them,
- 5:46other chronic health conditions. You know. I talked to Karen Ward,
- 5:48another drug policy advocate, who said, well, what about the guy who
- 5:51might have had a stroke, what about the guy who had right might have
- 5:55had lung cancer? You know where you're not going inside the body and looking
- 5:59inside, not seeing those things that are important for public health. I talked
- 6:01to a forensic pathologist in Ontario who said, you know, we want to
- 6:05know if somebody died of diabetes, even if they were also using ventional because
- 6:10we're tracking that. We're tracking how many diabetes cases we have. You also
- 6:14talked to some people in the BC government and you brought this to them and
- 6:16asked them why we were only doing fifteen percent of autopsies in these cases.
- 6:20What was their response? Yes, I did chase after Mark Farnworth in a
- 6:24parking lot and really put it to him. You know. His stance is
- 6:29like, we want to leave this to the coroner. We trust the chief
- 6:32corner, who, as I emphasize, is not a doctor. In BC,
- 6:36We've had like a series of police officers and then Lisall a pointer.
- 6:40Our most recent corner was the lawyer, and he's like, you know,
- 6:43we're going to leave it to the corner. They're the experts. But he
- 6:46never really explained to me why that was acceptable to have this practice in place
- 6:48that is not the same as what other jurisdictions do. So that's something I'm
- 6:54still really have outstanding, Arth. I want your response on that, a
- 6:57minister, I call bs on that we we trust the coroner, the chief
- 7:01corner, Lisa. The point has come out with our program at the Vancouver
- 7:06Area Network of Drug Users almost one hundred percent but completely independent of us,
- 7:13just based on the evidence. She's calling for safe supply and even non medical
- 7:17safe supply rolled out quickly and urgently. She was even sort of in a
- 7:23coded way, sympathetic to Dolff's struggle. So for mister Farnwerk to say,
- 7:30oh, he just trusts the coroner to do what's right. No, they
- 7:33have not been taking up their recommendations of the coroner. So for this one
- 7:38thing where it happens to save the governments some money, for him to selectively
- 7:42say, oh, on this one place, we're going to trust the coroner,
- 7:45I don't know, Jen, Do you think that's what it is?
- 7:46Is that autopsies cost money and the government either just doesn't have the funding or
- 7:51doesn't seem to have the will to put the money towards it. You know,
- 7:55I don't know if that's the answer. I think that's the one thing
- 7:58we always look to. I've done kind of back of the napkin per capita
- 8:01cost of like across Canada, how much we spend like a dollar per dollar
- 8:07on each resident, So a per capita breakdown, BC isn't really that much
- 8:11of an outlier in terms of like less or more. We're kind of in
- 8:13the middle. So I'm not sure if it's maybe just I know that I've
- 8:16heard from forensic pathologists that they feel kind of sidelined by the BC Corners Service,
- 8:24that their advice is not really being listened to the way it should.
- 8:26That it's that it's not a medically driven system, and so you know,
- 8:31I'll be doing some more stories looking into that angle as well, But I'm
- 8:35not really one hundred percent sure on what exactly is happening here. After your
- 8:39report, after your piece in the Taiee, did you have the feeling that
- 8:43Minister Mike Farnworth, this listener General, was actually aware that only fifteen percent
- 8:48of autopsies were conducted in suspected drug overdoses. I don't think this had ever
- 8:54been raised before the fact that BC is completely doing something completely different than other
- 9:01provinces, and it really is. You know, I think I talked to
- 9:03every single province except for Quebec and PI. We're the only ones who just
- 9:05didn't get back to me, and our numbers are really just so much lower.
- 9:11And so, you know, I kind of there's this thing that kind
- 9:13of goes on in BC sometimes where there's a bureaucratic inertia that I find where
- 9:18you can raise a problem again and again. So that's why we really tried
- 9:22to craft our story in a way that people would would take notice, and
- 9:24we had like real life examples too of how how this that affected families and
- 9:28just left them with these with these questions Garth really quickly, we got about
- 9:33thirty seconds here. Do you feel like there is a bureaucratic inertia? I
- 9:35mean you're on the front front lines. You are also doing your own reporting
- 9:39when you raise issues. Is that something that you run into one hundred percent.
- 9:43We've had extreme trouble moving things through the system, big things, small
- 9:48things. So yeah, for sure. When you hear about this idea of
- 9:50an oversight committee by the government, to look after safe supply and safe supply
- 9:56diversion. What are your thoughts Is this actually going to help in reducing drug
- 9:58det I mean, this is all just a sensationalism coming out of like the
- 10:05big drug bust that happened up in Prince George. You know, the RCMP
- 10:09seizes a bunch of drugs, puts them on the table, everyone freaks out
- 10:11in the media. Government says, oh, we got to have a committee
- 10:15to solve the problem. It sounds like the same old pattern to me.
- 10:18If you looked at those drugs, there's a bunch of different pills, you
- 10:20know, and they don't know even if they got a prescription bottle, they
- 10:24don't know whether those are safe supply pills or not. Right, you look
- 10:26at delatted most of those a lot of prescriptions, like something like eighty five
- 10:31thousand of them come from people who are getting them for pain, you know.
- 10:35So and those people also do sell and divert pills and they have forever
- 10:39and it's never been a big political problem. Second we're involved, then it
- 10:43becomes lightning. Right. So I used to buy Delauded way before, like
- 10:48in the nineties, and you know, you get it because little old Granny
- 10:52is selling her prescription for her hip pain, and she does that the same
- 10:56reason most people do it, because people are broke and I need to get
- 11:00food. So the idea of having a committee to oversee drug users who are
- 11:05getting safe supply prescriptions, that just I mean, that makes me think of
- 11:09like eight bureaucrats crowding into a room with me while I piss in a cup
- 11:13to make sure that I'm using them properly, and I really don't want that,
- 11:16you know. Yeah, I think that's an interesting point that diversion for
- 11:20pharmaceuticals has always happened, and when you look at these specific drugs is prescribed
- 11:26in far greater numbers when it comes to other things aside from safe supply,
- 11:30Jen, I want to ask you about the opposition parties here in British Columbia
- 11:33BC United and the BC Conservatives. They seem to really be focused on this
- 11:37idea of safe supply diversion and they almost seem to be ignoring the number of
- 11:41debts that still happens. Are they missing the plot here? Well? I
- 11:46think they found an issue that's a real political they think winner for them,
- 11:50So it's political, I know, yeah, I think so. I mean,
- 11:54they've really the way they hammer and hammer on safe Supply kind of up
- 12:00these fears also of like organized crime being involved. I don't know. Whenever
- 12:03I hear you know, eleanor Stirko is kind of the BC United MLI who
- 12:07has really taken the torch on this and really run with it, and she
- 12:11constantly brings up, you know, organized crime, organized crime with safe supply.
- 12:15You know, safe supply is prescribing prescription drugs to a really really small
- 12:20number of drug users AE see. And you know, I personally, like,
- 12:24as someone who does report on the downtown east Side, I have frequently
- 12:28run into horrific stories of actual organized crime violence that's horrific, and it's connected
- 12:33to the illicit supply, not to safe supply. So I would just kind
- 12:37of question, like, where are priorities going? Is this really warranted this
- 12:41amount of laser like attention on this issue? Man, They're trying to solve
- 12:46a different problem than me. Okay, I'm trying to stop people, I
- 12:48know, me, everybody who's drug using this province from dying. Right,
- 12:52that's the problem that we're trying to solve. They're trying to solve a get
- 12:58elected problem or a MPEd people with fear to the right side of the voting
- 13:01spectrum problem or I don't make it so that a poor people are no longer
- 13:07visible in the neighborhood's problem. But they certainly don't seem very seized with the
- 13:13dying problem because they never have an answer for that, they never want to
- 13:16address it, and they're just way way more fentanyl around than there is anything
- 13:20else. With this comedian in particular, it seems like the government and some
- 13:24of the opposition parties they just want more accountability and Garth, you did mention
- 13:28this idea of a urine test. They're also talking about garanty chemical trip.
- 13:31Well they already do. Yes. I mean, my god, I'm on
- 13:35just on methodone and I have to have every time I go to the clinic.
- 13:39You're in test people are on hydromorphone getting urine tested all the time.
- 13:43This already happens. See these people on the right, they don't even have
- 13:46a clue how the system actually works. It sounds like this is all smoke
- 13:50and mirrors that at least in terms of how it's being discussed. There are
- 13:52people into voting for Eleanor Stirko and Kevin Falcon and Pierre Pouliev and whoever's next.
- 13:58Does it worry you that they're going to be a crackdown on harm reduction?
- 14:01Oh? Hell yeah. I mean, if we're going to see Pierre
- 14:03Pouliev win the next federal election in twenty twenty five or before then, and
- 14:09he's gonna win with a big, huge majority probably, and he's gonna go
- 14:15and wipe out harm reduction. And that's the same thing that really Eleanor Stirkle
- 14:18and these other people want to do in a slightly lesser, kind of more
- 14:22polite BC kind of way. Peer Pauliev, since you brought them up,
- 14:26has talked about no free drugs, but free treatment. I mean, I
- 14:31think that appeals to some voters who may not be that well versed in the
- 14:33issues. Why doesn't that work well? I think it appeals to voters you
- 14:37know who, you say, appeals to voters who are not well versed in
- 14:41the issues. I think it appeals to voters who have seen their loved ones
- 14:43struggle with addiction. I think there is, like you know a large number
- 14:46of people who are just like, listen, if my loved one could just
- 14:50stop taking the drugs, that would solve our problem. But The issue is
- 14:54with that is that it's just such a simplistic solution. We know that people
- 14:56struggle in treatment, they often relapse, they often have to do it again
- 15:01and again. Some people never successfully go through treatment. I think that's what
- 15:05we've seen over the years and why there are now these sort of like different
- 15:09ways of treating addiction that addiction doctors indoors like safe supply. I think it's
- 15:15because we have seen that model of treatment just not work. It's not a
- 15:18one size fits all model, and in this app this reality of the drugs
- 15:24being so dangerous every time someone relapses there at risk of dying. Garth,
- 15:30Jen, thank you so much for your time tonight. I think this is
- 15:31very illuminating and definitely shed some light on this hot button topic. So thank
- 15:35you so much. Thanks well, folks. That was Jen Saint Dennis and
- 15:39Garth Mullins. They're among the leading voices covering BC's longest public health emergency,
- 15:43as they both produce incredible eye opening work. Find Jen's work at the Tyee
- 15:48online and search for Crackdown Podcast wherever you listen to your podcasts for Garth's work.
- 15:54Now up next. You may have heard of the story about a major
- 15:56drug bust. In Prince George, we referred to it just now seizing safe
- 16:00supply drugs. Or perhaps you heard the reactions to that story from politicians both
- 16:07in this province and across the country. Well, I'm going to react to
- 16:11those reactions up next