Latest / The Fourcast / Syria: how to rebuild a 'corrupted narco-state'
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the Forecast.
- 0:02I'm Christian Guru Murphy and we are in Damascus.
- 0:05I'm with our international editor Lindsay Hilson and with
- 0:09Fuad Saeed Issa, who is the director of the aid agency
- 0:13Violet, which has been operating in the north but has has now
- 0:17come to Damascus after the revolution.
- 0:20So we are now a few days into these jaw-dropping events in
- 0:26Syria, and we wanted to try and talk about where we are now and
- 0:30where we might be heading. I mean, in terms of what's going
- 0:33on in the country. Give us some sort of overview
- 0:36because there is still a lot of activity going on in the north.
- 0:39You know the war is not over everywhere.
- 0:41Absolutely not. And so you've got, I mean,
- 0:43you've got 2 outside players. You've got the Israelis who've
- 0:46been bombing certain facilities because they say they don't want
- 0:52weapons to fall into the hands of the extremists.
- 0:54Well, some people say that's the reason.
- 0:56And other people say it's because they want to make sure
- 0:58that Syria is always weak and they've taken a, what they're
- 1:02calling a temporary buffer zone to try and prevent trouble
- 1:06spilling over the border. And then you've got Turkey,
- 1:09which has a historic enmity with the Kurds who control NE Syria.
- 1:13And they have also been bombing. And my understanding is that
- 1:16there has been, you know, some people are being displaced in
- 1:18the northeast because of continued fighting.
- 1:22And we're hearing, you know, the town of Dera Zor has now fallen
- 1:25to what what we were calling, he's put Tahir al Sham, this
- 1:30rebel group, and now they're calling themselves the
- 1:33transitional government. So, you know, I'm not quite sure
- 1:36who we what we call it now. So there's that going on.
- 1:41And then the other thing that's going on is that you have all
- 1:45these fighters from Idlib, which is the area the HTS was
- 1:49controlling, who have now come into Damascus and into all the
- 1:53other cities. And, you know, they're country
- 1:56boys. They're country boys in uniform.
- 1:59And this is a big city. And it's very different from
- 2:02what they're they're used to. And as you said to us, they're
- 2:06friendly. And what I understand from
- 2:08people I've been speaking to is that they're friendly to
- 2:10everyone else. But there's a whole load of, but
- 2:12they are Islamists there. There's an awful lot of mixing
- 2:15of people in Syria who have never mixed before and the sense
- 2:19that yes, they are in control, but what are they going to do?
- 2:24There's also apprehension as well as joy.
- 2:27Also there is a big worries from our side as an organization
- 2:30about the services because you know now they are trying to run
- 2:34the services. But as we understand from the
- 2:37government, there is like no any resources now to run this
- 2:42government because all the resources mean the money, the
- 2:46dollar, the other things were stolen before arriving from
- 2:50Bashar al-Assad and the the old government and now there is no
- 2:55any resources. Because at the moment, I mean, I
- 2:57suppose the, the, the reasonably hopeful thing is that the civil
- 2:59servants, if you like, have stayed, They haven't been
- 3:02sacked, they haven't run away. So the, the government
- 3:05departments should still function if they can find a way
- 3:09of paying them and keeping them on the payroll.
- 3:10Now you you met one of the people now in charge of one of
- 3:13these ministries. Yeah.
- 3:15So just before I talk about that, let's just say one thing.
- 3:19But we've been talking about, you know, the present, which is
- 3:21the joy, and the future, which is the apprehension.
- 3:24Let's just quickly talk about the past, which is the
- 3:27prisoners, because I mean, this is obviously one of the the
- 3:29biggest things is that some people are full of joy, but
- 3:34there are a lot of people crying as well.
- 3:35The people who've been to the prisons and found out their
- 3:38their son, their husband, their sister was tortured, was
- 3:42murdered. And that you know, that goes
- 3:45through everything. It goes through everything
- 3:48because there's scarcity, a family that hasn't been touched
- 3:51by the utter cruelty of the Assad regime.
- 3:54And so one of the first demands is justice.
- 3:58And if they don't have a functioning justice system,
- 4:03there will be revenge. There may be revenge anyway.
- 4:06There may be revenge, which is already happening that we don't
- 4:08know about that going on in in sort of.
- 4:10Corners, that's happened. Actually.
- 4:12We we heard some incidents happen.
- 4:14It's still small numbers, but as you said, like the people need
- 4:19the justice because you can imagine that someone killed your
- 4:24children and he's back living in the same building where you are
- 4:29and you cannot do anything because there is like no, no
- 4:33fighting decision and but you need your justice in the end.
- 4:36And then this is. There are some incidents.
- 4:40We we heard that people are not waiting because they need the.
- 4:43Justice, right? And that's what weapons, that's
- 4:45right. And this guy I met yesterday,
- 4:47he's the he's the deputy minister of administration.
- 4:50His name is Mohammed Yassa Khazal, very good English.
- 4:54He was an HTS fighter and then he was the administrator of
- 5:00Idlib. So he has a lot of experience
- 5:02because Idlib, you know, which was a rebel held enclave, about
- 5:054 million people. That's a small country, you
- 5:07know, it's not nothing, but we found him yesterday.
- 5:10It was extraordinary. We went into, it's the Damascus
- 5:12Governorate and you have this incredible scene where all the
- 5:14civil servants, as you were saying, have come back to see if
- 5:18they can get their job back. The answer at memories, yes, but
- 5:21some of them have. So how did you get a job in the
- 5:24Assad regime? Well, you got a job if you were
- 5:27a member of somebody's family or if you paid a bribe or whatever.
- 5:30And there's a lot of ridiculous jobs.
- 5:32And when I spoke to Mr. Hazal, he said it was interesting.
- 5:37We had the formal interview and at the end he he said, can I ask
- 5:40you a question? He said, let me tell you a few
- 5:42things. And one of the things was he
- 5:43said, look, the big people, they've fled, you know, they've
- 5:49fled. We're not going to get them.
- 5:50And what we're dealing with here are the are the middle level
- 5:52people. And he said, and there are some
- 5:54technocrats and people who, you know, could be said there's all
- 5:56these other people, what are we going to do with them?
- 5:59He said, well, some of them have potential and maybe we can
- 6:02retrain and so on. But an awful lot of them, they
- 6:05would just, you know, this. Wasn't really do anything, yes.
- 6:08Yeah, this was an old sort of make work communist system.
- 6:13And the other thing which was fascinating, I, he said to me,
- 6:17he said, So what should we do to try and get the recognition and
- 6:24the acknowledgement from the British government, the American
- 6:26government, sort of very practical man, very aware of
- 6:30exactly what you've been talking about, making the water work,
- 6:33making the electricity work so we don't have all these power
- 6:36cuts, you know, trying to do all the sensible normal things that
- 6:40people need. He said this place is like North
- 6:42Korea. He said we have to, we have to
- 6:44make it into a proper country again because they know
- 6:47perfectly well the money's gone, the money was stolen, the
- 6:52country is in. As he said, it's an absolute
- 6:55catastrophe. I mean, Fred, you've worked with
- 6:58these guys in the north with your organization, so you know
- 7:01them reasonably well. I mean, you know, there is,
- 7:03there is an obvious fear in, you know, in, in Europe and America
- 7:08that this is in some way like the Taliban, you know, that they
- 7:11want an Islamist state, that they are radicals, but they're
- 7:17not, are they? I mean, in, in that sense, it's
- 7:19not. They don't want that kind of
- 7:21country here today. I think to be honest, I think
- 7:24they are mostly from Islamic background as we are in Islamic
- 7:28country. But I think they are thinking in
- 7:30very big way, thinking to have a very great relation with
- 7:33international countries. That's what I mean, in terms of
- 7:37their ambition, their their ambition is not the same as the
- 7:41Taliban or ISIS. I didn't get that impression at
- 7:44all, but presumably there will be different strands of thought
- 7:48amongst the different groups who are now coming together in the
- 7:51salvation government and I'm sure there are some who are much
- 7:55more that way inclined than others.
- 7:58So the people we're meeting at the moment are, you know, full
- 8:02of this that, you know, yes, women will be free to wear what
- 8:04they want. And no, we are not going to
- 8:07oppress the Alawites and the the Christians.
- 8:11But there's going to be some people in there who, who think
- 8:14differently. And I suppose, you know, now is
- 8:17this moment of unity. But how long, you know, I
- 8:20remember Libya, you know, it was all joy and happiness, you know,
- 8:26until someone lost an eye. You know, it's you get different
- 8:29people and you're going to get different groups who who will
- 8:32have a different vision for. The country and that the worries
- 8:34why the Syrian are trying to to be to do the unity to gather to
- 8:39not like, I mean losing the control or losing the message,
- 8:44the great message that they are spreading now.
- 8:47The message. I think it's good for the most
- 8:50of Syria now what they are saying how they are acting.
- 8:54That's important. But when we can, I mean, there
- 8:57is a moment we could lose all of that.
- 8:59And I think the big worries for for them is not the Syrian is
- 9:03the international world and how they can build a relation with
- 9:07this government. This is the.
- 9:10This is the great danger, though, it seems to me, Lindsay,
- 9:11isn't it the, the governments are, they're waiting to see what
- 9:16this is. And, and, and the truth is you
- 9:18don't really have time in deciding whether or not to
- 9:21engage with with this government because if you don't, then who
- 9:26knows what will happen. Well, it, it look, that's
- 9:29exactly true. But I you've got Gulf countries
- 9:32and I think this is what's really important because I
- 9:34suspect that the British, the Americans, the French are all
- 9:38going to dither because that's what they tend to do.
- 9:42Because they're all still, they're still banned at the
- 9:45moment. Yeah, all these people, you
- 9:46know, Gilani, who's no longer called Gilani, who is the head.
- 9:50Of the Al Sharana. Yes, right.
- 9:51The he's the head of this salvation government.
- 9:55He is a, he's on the terrorism list.
- 9:57I'm not actually quite sure how you get off the terrorism list.
- 10:01I don't really know what the mechanism for that is.
- 10:04And that's going to be an issue. But there's a lot of money in
- 10:08the Gulf, you know, the Saudis, the Qataris, the UAE.
- 10:11There is a way in which money can come into this country for
- 10:16paying the salaries and for reconstruction that doesn't have
- 10:20to, to go through Western countries.
- 10:23But then look, I don't want to be Cassandra, I hate that role.
- 10:29But. Sort of.
- 10:31Your job. It is my job to be Cassandra.
- 10:33Yes, Lindsay. Cassandra Hilson.
- 10:36My fear also is that if a lot of money comes in, that's when you
- 10:40get corruption, you know, and and it's very difficult.
- 10:44You know, you've got all these people who've been poor for so
- 10:47long. This country's been under
- 10:49sanctions, people. I was talking to a fighter
- 10:52yesterday when we were wandering around Bashar al Assad's palace,
- 10:56which has been picked clean, you know, looting, which is, you
- 11:01know, writing historical wrong. And he was saying, you know,
- 11:03they were living in luxury while we were being bombed in tents.
- 11:06Absolutely true. Money starts to come in.
- 11:10Your family is living in the most appalling conditions and
- 11:14you don't really have enough to eat, you know, or, and then you
- 11:18get a little bit more and you want a little bit more and you
- 11:20want it better. Like, you know, you, we've seen
- 11:23it in so many places. Reconstruction money breeds
- 11:27corruption. And I don't, I mean, it's
- 11:30inevitable you're going to have some of that, but how you keep a
- 11:33lid on that, I don't really. But if I can also, I mean speak
- 11:36about our experience with them, with this government before,
- 11:39because we work with them in the.
- 11:40Area, yeah, for 3-4 years 2 downbeat.
- 11:44We work with them for for long and we didn't hear any big
- 11:47corruption happened in the area from this government because
- 11:52they were focusing on their goals.
- 11:54They were focusing on having free Syria, but as you said,
- 11:58like it's could be different when the money.
- 12:00Came when you get. The control on the whole Syria,
- 12:04but because also that sometimes held because they have the
- 12:08values and they are believing in their and.
- 12:11That's the Islamism. That's the positive side.
- 12:13Exactly that that pushing them all the time to be aware from
- 12:17getting any money not in the in the good way or the right way.
- 12:22The other thing, you know, that where there are unrealistic
- 12:25expectations is the political process.
- 12:27Now, you know, at the moment they're a transitional
- 12:29government. They're, they're suggesting
- 12:30we'll just be a transitional government for a small number of
- 12:33months and then we'll create, you know, a process of
- 12:36institutions and the expectation of some sort of, you know,
- 12:39democratic process. It's going to take a long time.
- 12:42Look, it really is. And one of the things that sort
- 12:45of annoys me about Western governments in these kind of
- 12:48situations is they're saying, right, you have to have
- 12:50elections. What a lovely thing elections
- 12:52are. How can you have elections in
- 12:55the short term when you've got, I don't know, what is it,
- 12:5714,000,000 Syrians who are forced into into exile,
- 13:03refugees, what would be the mechanism for them to vote?
- 13:06Some are coming back, some aren't, and so on.
- 13:08And when and who do they vote for?
- 13:09There are no political. Parties there are no.
- 13:10Political parties and just to say something if I can, if you
- 13:13see the street, the people were today and yesterday printing the
- 13:17photo of El Giuliani, a sharer and having it not because they
- 13:21loving him, but this is the way how they learn that from Alassa
- 13:26where? You just back them, you back
- 13:27just. Got that.
- 13:29To say that we're protected somehow and we are the people
- 13:32who came from the Raffles area and from Midler.
- 13:35We're saying no one in Midler do that, no one having his photo.
- 13:39I mean, he did the work and. Interesting you know it.
- 13:42Really is. But they are they were acting
- 13:44like that with the lasted regime, with the lasted for 14
- 13:47years. And now they think that the only
- 13:50way to to be. Safe.
- 13:51And that's the that's the mentality.
- 13:53I mean, I'm sorry to be, you know, a boring old thought, but
- 13:57this just makes me think of something from 2003 where the
- 14:01day Saddam Hussein fell and the Americans came into town.
- 14:06I just remember the American tanks coming in, and there's a
- 14:08group of people. And what they had always done
- 14:13was they had jumped up and down and shouted in Arabic.
- 14:17Oh, Saddam, we redeem you with our blood and spirit.
- 14:21We redeem you. Oh, Saddam.
- 14:23And then they kind of. And then they saw the tank and
- 14:26they saw us. And and they go, oh George Bush,
- 14:29we redeem you with our blood and our spirit.
- 14:32I mean, that's, that's the reality.
- 14:35Thinking isn't. From the first hour we arrived
- 14:38to some cities in in Homs and the Moscow they were saying bro
- 14:42with them. DK Jolani yes, like in blood,
- 14:44we're. It's the same 1, isn't it?
- 14:46Yeah, I mean for Jolani, and they don't know him.
- 14:49Who's Jolani and what he's coming to do?
- 14:51What the things then? I mean, that's why it's not
- 14:55easy. It's like the message for the
- 14:58the UKUS and the other governments.
- 15:01It's not the way to just push for democracy in a very fast way
- 15:05without thinking about the reality here.
- 15:07The people, they didn't have any parties from 45 years and they
- 15:11didn't join any politicals out of El Bas party.
- 15:15They they didn't know how the the, the government, the people
- 15:19in in the world like acting and living.
- 15:22What the political choice may be, you know, you, you've got to
- 15:25build those arguments, those groups and.
- 15:27Those and those institutions, first of all, because what are
- 15:32people talking about? Justice and dignity.
- 15:35That's what people want justice and dignity.
- 15:37Oh and water and electricity. But I think it it's this issue
- 15:41because the Syrian, I think there's more state, you might
- 15:45more of a Syrian state than there was of a Libyan state.
- 15:48But we're still talking about a mafia family that run this, ran
- 15:53this country for 50 years and in recent years ran it on the drugs
- 15:58trade. Captigan.
- 15:59So basically this is a narco state.
- 16:02So it has no economy and totally corrupted institutions in as
- 16:09much as they were. So that has to be the priority.
- 16:14You're more or less starting from scratch.
- 16:15And it's going to be difficult for them to just close all of
- 16:18that down, isn't it, because it's a source of revenue?
- 16:21If, if I can say also the organization, when we came here,
- 16:24we don't have resources to work in this a huge city and we were
- 16:28trying to visit the big organization, Hunterian
- 16:31organization here and the whole big organization.
- 16:35The leaders were lifting because all of them were affiliated with
- 16:39Assad fully or also part of his family or something.
- 16:43Then this is the organization and the humanitarian sector.
- 16:47What about the ministers? What about the money, the
- 16:50businesses and other things? I think the focusing should be
- 16:54now in the 1st month IS and as I said, I mean is the services,
- 16:59the civil services, electric, water and humanitarian aids and
- 17:04what needed for the people. And then working on the
- 17:08political side just to do some awareness.
- 17:12The other way is just also having the Syrian Rapples and
- 17:16the Syrian opposition from outside of Syria, because we
- 17:19have like big, big, we can say the resources from the Syrian
- 17:26who was living in diaspora for for 45 years, they need to come
- 17:30back for 20. They should come back.
- 17:32They should be a important part from this government because
- 17:35they are acceptable. They are like welcomed and they
- 17:40need to put their resources now. It's the national time for all
- 17:44of us, for all of Syrian. Everyone have resources to be
- 17:47here in Damascus and to work either with government, either
- 17:51with establishing new political things or parties, but it's the
- 17:55time for all national people, Syrian people, to be here and to
- 17:59act hand in hand to build this country.
- 18:02But that there will be a natural caution, won't there, of people
- 18:04saying, well, is it is now the time to go back or do I need to
- 18:07wait? I think it's a catch 22.
- 18:10It yes, but I, most Syrians I know are desperate to come home.
- 18:15They really want to come home. And there has been a lot of work
- 18:17done with sort of government in exile and people trying to build
- 18:21up the skills and so on that they, they need.
- 18:24And for the last 13 years people have been thinking about this
- 18:28moment in the diaspora and they've been thinking about what
- 18:32they can contribute when they come home.
- 18:33So I do think, I do think that there are many Syrians of
- 18:37goodwill who want to come back and, and build their, their
- 18:40country. But I just hope that the Western
- 18:44countries don't push them into the political divisions too
- 18:48early on, because I think that could be very destructive.
- 18:52I was at the shrine yesterday to the the prophet's granddaughter.
- 18:55It was very interesting and, and a young man came up to me and
- 18:59wanted to chat and he said we were talking about why people
- 19:03were so afraid of, of, of the, the revolution in, in their
- 19:08community, the Shia community. And he said, he said, look, he
- 19:12was a student, he's currently a student at university.
- 19:15He says even at university in our first year, we had a course
- 19:19we had to take compulsory called National Culture.
- 19:23And in that we were taught that a revolution would be a
- 19:27disaster. These were terrorists.
- 19:29They would come and kill us and it would be the end of
- 19:31everything. And he was just having that
- 19:33awakening of saying, you know, it, it was all wrong.
- 19:37You know, and there's a lot to kind of shift in the way people
- 19:42are thinking he was. He was stepping into this shrine
- 19:45which was now being guarded by HTS fighters, you know, Sunni
- 19:49fighters guarding a Iranian built Shia shrine.
- 19:54That's right. I think that was like the system
- 19:57are just now we are trying to understand how they was
- 20:00controlling this country for 45 years.
- 20:04When I was 16 or 15. Also when the revolution started
- 20:08in 2011, I was in my school, the high school and then we was like
- 20:14when the Arab Spring started, we were discussing what could
- 20:18happen in Syria and how we can act.
- 20:20We were children's like in that day and I was arrested for two
- 20:24days because just we were discussing something.
- 20:27As a children, we were worried all the time how we can continue
- 20:31our studying. And they were saying that you're
- 20:34not able to get to the university if you're not part of
- 20:37Hizbul Bass Bass party. And yeah, I mean, as a children,
- 20:41we were shocked. Like, what is that?
- 20:43What's happening here? And when we got arrested, we
- 20:47understand that it's not a job. Like it's sensitive things also
- 20:51as a children. And it was crazy when I, I mean,
- 20:54I was, I, I born and also had all of my life in Syria.
- 20:59But then when I went out to, to the Western countries and to the
- 21:03whole countries, I feel that we were in, in just kind of series
- 21:09or something, film or something, how they control us and how they
- 21:13close our eyes in Syria for all of these years.
- 21:16And we saw that this is the right.
- 21:18The right is not talking about the political, the right is not
- 21:22being part of any like activity, also civil society things.
- 21:28And you should just get like a photo for Bashar Lassen and put
- 21:32it on ahead of your like. So, but so many Syrian families
- 21:37now have relatives overseas. And of course you have had the
- 21:41Internet. And so although you do still
- 21:44have that sort of mindset, there are lots of people who, you
- 21:48know, have had so many different experiences now within their
- 21:52families that I think that that, you know, that can change quite
- 21:56quickly. Do you think?
- 21:57I think so, but you know what, when when the revolution started
- 22:00in 2011, when as a as the children, we were joining this
- 22:05like marching the only one who's who's who was seeing from our
- 22:10families. I mean, my family were also part
- 22:14of like the revolution in the 18th and many of our like my
- 22:20uncles, they were arrested for 35 years.
- 22:23And those people were the only one who say to us, you're not
- 22:27allowed to do that, don't do any revolution.
- 22:30And we were like with the energy as a use to do something.
- 22:34And they were just, I mean, fighting us to not do anything.
- 22:38Because they were so afraid for you.
- 22:39Because they're afraid because they have their whole life in
- 22:42the presence and they were like just 10s of people.
- 22:46I mean, instead of us saying don't do anything, you don't
- 22:49know the reality, you don't know what's going on.
- 22:52And we were saying like you are the people who is affecting from
- 22:56that. You should push us to do that
- 22:58and. That's why.
- 23:00That's why it's, I mean, again, in, in this 13 years when the
- 23:05people under the asset control, the areas of asset control, they
- 23:09were worried of saying any single word.
- 23:12When you see your brother getting to the president to the
- 23:15president for having $100 in your pocket money or or so
- 23:20saying a word and then being without any news for 10 years in
- 23:25a in a like arrested for 10 years.
- 23:27Then what to do thinking about politicals or think something
- 23:31just stock on house and it water electric is the best what you're
- 23:37thinking about If you can get that.
- 23:39And till this day like now, no Assad, no country governments,
- 23:44no one. And then still the people are
- 23:47afraid from getting the dollar or also saying any word they
- 23:51saying when the incidents happened, they're not saying the
- 23:54revolution were till this day because they are afraid from
- 23:58saying the words of revolution. Then that's why I think it's a
- 24:02huge changing in the country. But it could take a time, it's
- 24:06not a quick changing and the services and the government
- 24:09think it will be very risky if especially the Western
- 24:13countries, they didn't decide to go and support the Syrian in
- 24:18this sensitive. Time.
- 24:20Well, it's just the beginning. It's fascinating and it's a it's
- 24:22an amazingly exciting thing to watch out to say.
- 24:25I mean, it's, it's a, it's a very, it's a, it's a privilege,
- 24:28I think to. We're very lucky to be here with
- 24:30you. We're lucky to be a part of this
- 24:33revolution. We're now building our future.
- 24:36We'll be building the new Syria, and it's the time to get the
- 24:40support from the whole countries, from the whole three
- 24:43people. Who's believing on us?
- 24:45And who's believing that the Syria worth it and could have a
- 24:51better future? Thank you very much indeed.
- 24:54That's the forecast for now. Until next time, bye bye.