Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Episode One-Is There A Board Game Community
Transcript
- 0:02This is hashtag channel, a podcast about discord with Ben and Steve. Well.
- 0:09Actually a hashtag means it's a channel. So Ben say it along with
- 0:16me. Now, okay, very special day in May sixth, twenty twenty
- 0:19three, I will start. I swear that I will pay go ahead,
- 0:23true allegiance to your majesty and to your errors. Come on and successors.
- 0:29You know this isn't according to law, so help me. Do you know
- 0:34what? Do you know? I didn't do it. I didn't finish it,
- 0:38I didn't letish it. It doesn't count. I love the way that
- 0:40you didn't mention that at all when I was setting up. I bet all
- 0:44day you've just been sitting there work for the Well this doesn't get released on
- 0:48May the sixth, Steve, let me let me hurt you even more.
- 0:51I thought of it just now. That's the razor sharp wit that I bring
- 0:56to this exactly. So. So did you watch the coronations day? No?
- 1:00I don't even know what time it was on. It was on this
- 1:03morning at some point. Did you watch it? No? I imagine has
- 1:06some like historical interest. I mean, so it's kitch, right, so
- 1:08on this before, everything about your country is kitch It's incredible, isn't it.
- 1:12But oh but it's like there are more food banks than McDonald's in Britain.
- 1:18But we can have a bloody coronation, you know what I mean.
- 1:19Well, I guess it's a bit cheaper than the last one I've heard.
- 1:22It's only like fifty gazillion dollars, right exactly. Anyway, So Steve,
- 1:26here we are new show, brand new show called Hashtag Channel. Steve.
- 1:32This is where we interact with the people on what Steven Discord. That's right,
- 1:38don't don't ask me, Come on, don't ask you. Come on.
- 1:41I know you had a couple of drinkie poos last night. Oh man,
- 1:44you can tell the audience how they get in on this shabang. I'm
- 1:49gonna guess you're listening to this episode in a future that's been taken over by
- 1:53AI. Right, So just like hold your phone out in front of your
- 1:57face and say, take me to the five Games for Doomsday discord. Yeah,
- 2:01of course, Instead you will be taken to the factory that converts people
- 2:05into soil and green. But tell you what, though, iron line to
- 2:08here, I bet it's good in it. Yeah, that's all right,
- 2:12that's all right. Why do you think that. Well, if you add
- 2:15like those protein bars and that great, and I bet it just tastes like
- 2:16that. I think you get some kind of disease if you eat a person
- 2:20though, right, Yeah, you get like a shivering disease, whatever it
- 2:22is. But you know they'll salt it out, they'll sort it out in
- 2:24the in the making of it. Yeah, they probably like remove or filter
- 2:29out the disease causing agents exactly. And the point is right, I mean
- 2:32there's lots of paper. I eat delicious food, which means I should taste
- 2:36like the delicious food that I eat. Well, this is it, right,
- 2:38corn fed chicken or whatever, chicken, pizza, Hamberger, Torito's beer
- 2:46wine. Have you heard that whiskey? Have you heard that witty meme that
- 2:49everyone's a vegetarian? No, because you are what you eat and animals vegetables.
- 2:55Yeah before technically animals vegetables, so technically your vegetarian. Oh the Internet
- 3:02what what? What? What? Japs you? And all those japes?
- 3:10All right, Steve, so can you so for the listeners, we hammered
- 3:15out what this show was going to be in the last weekend. Well,
- 3:20yeah, I mean we basically came up with a very rough outline that you
- 3:23kind of actually hammered into a proper shape. But you know the general idea
- 3:28of the show, Steve, I just sit there and I shoot out ideas
- 3:31and then you refine them. Tell the audience what this show is. Um,
- 3:37it's you and me on yet another occasion for no particular reason, just
- 3:40bullshitting around. Yeah, but this time it's different, isn't it. Well,
- 3:44this time we're involving the members of the discord exactly. This time we're
- 3:47involving you. I'm not pointing at Ben, I'm pointing at the listener.
- 3:53Listeners. They are sitting out there. So five games from doomsday dot Com.
- 3:59Yeah, and there's a pinned post yap the page that's right with an
- 4:01invite to the day permanent invite. You can join us now. Well,
- 4:05you can't really join us now because by the time you're listening recording this,
- 4:09it's not live. Yeah. Well, because I've got I've got to edit
- 4:11all the really horrendous things you say. So what do you think we're doing
- 4:15right now? Like as the listeners listening to this. So I release this
- 4:17on Friday at six am. Okay, I'm gonna be just waking up in
- 4:23my tent because I'm going on a cycle trip online. It will be the
- 4:27last day of my cycle trip. Wait Friday, Yeah, Friday morning.
- 4:30Oh, you're gonna be back in rollin Friday night. Exactly. Nice?
- 4:32Yea, we have the weekend, So we have the weekend together because we
- 4:36didn't spend the weekend together because you're busy doing birthday things with your wife,
- 4:40an't you. Well, we're gonna hang out tomorrow, right, that's right.
- 4:42We're gonna have schnitz That's right, schnitzler or something. Shall I?
- 4:46Shall I break my vegetarianism just for a day because it's your birthday. Is
- 4:50a special enough occasion you don't need my permission, and you will anyway.
- 4:54Yeah, now, it definitely will anyway. So this is the show where
- 4:57we have an exclusive hashtag channel channel yep. On the discord, we pose
- 5:03a monthly topic, you comment, We read out your comments, and then
- 5:09we talk about them. Steve. Yeah, and all you have to do
- 5:11to participate is joined the channel. Yeah, exactly. The channel the channel
- 5:15channel, the channel channel, hashtag channel, join the channel and before we
- 5:19go on, before we inter channel, it's hashtag channel. Yeah, which
- 5:23channel hashtag channel now that they're all channels, Ben, Yeah, yeah,
- 5:27hashtag channel. Yeah, but which channel? Hashtag channel? Yeah? But
- 5:32okay, so hashtag yeah, Like that's what they put in front of the
- 5:35channel, is it? Yeah, never mind anywhere, let's just get on
- 5:40with it. So I just want to thank and I think I think you
- 5:42should do it. You're good at speeches, so you you will have heard
- 5:46the bumper to this show that features someone that is not me and or Steve
- 5:53that is one of the regular contributors. And we didn't pick him out to
- 5:57do the bumper because of his contentious well actually nature on the discord. No,
- 6:02not at all, and it's Cede Hunter. Steve. Will you tell
- 6:06Cede Hunter how happy we are that he contributed to the bumper? So are
- 6:12we going to refer to him by his gnome the discord at Cede Hunter?
- 6:15Isn't it like? What is his actual name? I'm not bloody idea,
- 6:17Hey Cede Hunter. Um, I want to tell you how much Ben and
- 6:21I appreciate. Yes, your your pompous, overwrought philosophy undergraduate minor comments in
- 6:31the discord um, But I don't really have the words that would impress you
- 6:36enough to do so, so I'll just say thanks, thanks for being there
- 6:41for us. So, Steve, right, you've got a ranking, right,
- 6:45Zero means crapper the rapper, Yeah, ten means supery, dupery.
- 6:49Yeah. Where would you rate the word qua? You really don't like the
- 6:55word quas. I don't know what. I don't no issue with the word
- 6:57quash. She don't know what it means. And it's like Latin. I
- 7:00look it up and I go, oh, I still don't know what it
- 7:02means. Yeah, it's just it's like a relative pronoun in the ablative case.
- 7:06I suppose, right, Okay, so come on on the on the
- 7:10scale. So wait, I'm reading this word. What is this? Sorry,
- 7:14I don't get zero. Yeah, crappy, crap craps, ten,
- 7:17supero, dupero. I think we could do a lot. We could do
- 7:21a lot. We could do a lot better than qua. Though. I
- 7:25want to see Ceedie Hunter work in like a peri passu or a mutatas mutandas
- 7:30and all that kind of stuff. We don't know either of those words mean,
- 7:32just like drop them into so, Ceedie Hunter, if you're listening,
- 7:35and I know you are, please start littering your discord messages with all these
- 7:40obnoxious, abstruse latinisms. Just to wind up Ben and these words that Steve
- 7:45just said, if you know what they are, get in the discord,
- 7:48tell me what they mean. Because I'm not very bright. You can just
- 7:51look them up in a dictionary. Yeah, real fucking lazy, though,
- 7:55Steve. You can like literally select them with your finger and a dictionary will
- 7:59pop up. Tell you I started watching twenty four again. I started rewatching
- 8:03twenty four. I ain't got time for that fucking nerd shit once again.
- 8:05I was saving the world once again. Ben makes a comment that is apropos
- 8:11of nothing. I know what apropo means. A good word. Though,
- 8:13After altogether too much thoughts and consultation with the greatest mind in the world of
- 8:18topics, we present to you this month's topic. All right, Steve,
- 8:26So for this inaugural episode of Hashtag Channel, the episode that we are going
- 8:33to God damn it, I can't turn coronation into a verb, you know,
- 8:37coronate? Do you exactly we're having this? This is the coronation of
- 8:43the of the show. So as it were, do you maybe seed the
- 8:48hunter coronates? So can you read that out again? The oath whole.
- 8:52I think all the listeners should read that, except they should pledge their allegiance
- 8:56to us. So listeners repeat after us, I swear that I will pay
- 9:01true allegiance to Ben and Steve we Go and to your heirs and successors according
- 9:09So you're all right, You're off the hook for my heirs. That's fine,
- 9:11So help me guard at the end, I mean should be like,
- 9:13maybe if the penalty definition atheist that up a little bit, yes, so
- 9:16help me great atheism O. Yeah, there you go. Anyway, So
- 9:20we chose as the inaugural topic something one of your bugbears that you go on
- 9:26about all the time. Yep. I thought this was a good topic to
- 9:28start with because so the listeners love hearing us argue exactly, So what is
- 9:35the topic? Is there such a thing as a board game community? So,
- 9:39as far as I can see, it's completely bloody obvious that there is,
- 9:45and it's it's it's it's more obvious than the nose upon your face.
- 9:50And yet you vehemently claim that this doesn't exist. Would you care? How
- 9:56do I? How do I compete with someone who so clearly was like master
- 10:00in their debating society? The forensic talent. You think you think my school
- 10:05in Timbury wells how to debate takes your Your argument is simply to be emphatic
- 10:09and to insult me. I didn't insult you, device said something well the
- 10:13nose on my favor. I wasn't calling you big nose. No, No,
- 10:16well you implied it. I know, I dare you, But are
- 10:20you I assume that everything that you're saying is like somehow taking the piss.
- 10:22Are you be sensitive about you know? No, I don't think it's not
- 10:26big no romanesque exactly like the salad. So what do we mean by community?
- 10:31Just like the dickheads on Twitter who have opinions about things, Okay,
- 10:35it means that what we mean because we refer that, we refer to the
- 10:37community like, oh, what is the community going to think? Or the
- 10:39community is saying this about that? And I think it's just very abstract.
- 10:45I mean, we can't even really say who's part of this community and who
- 10:48isn't Like, we all have our communities where we live in our different places.
- 10:52But is there one single unitary board game community that you can refer to
- 10:56as such a community? Qua community if you will, Yeah, I still
- 11:00don't know what carmings. But to the point is I think it's self evident
- 11:03that there is. Right, No, it's not self evident. Otherwise why
- 11:07would we be talking like this for forty five minutes. Well, well,
- 11:09the point is right. It seems to me that board gaming, especially is
- 11:15not so fractionated as to be fractionated. Word, I'm trying to keep up
- 11:20with you. Fractionated like that's how you do petrol, right, yeah,
- 11:24and you have like oil and then pace and then donkeys pace and then so
- 11:33board gaming is not so fractionated that you the people just aren't aware of kind
- 11:39of every niche of the hobby, right, I think that the dickheads that
- 11:43we hang out with, No, I take it back, even the dickheads
- 11:46we hang out with are not that aware. We are like in a very
- 11:50sort of I want to say elite group, but I don't mean it in
- 11:54an obnoxious in a qualitative sense. Yeah, like we are. We are
- 11:58like self professed board game enthusiasts, but we play games with people all the
- 12:03time who don't keep up with the hobby as it were. That's true,
- 12:05right, They don't go to Essen, they don't know what the trends are
- 12:07what's coming out and they don't care. And I think by and large most
- 12:11people are like this, and they're not even and they're not even like us.
- 12:13They're not even like us or the dickheads we hang out with, especially
- 12:18in Germany. It's a family pastime. So these people they just they go
- 12:20out and buy games, they play them with their family, and they could
- 12:22give a fuck about any community. So the point is communities right by their
- 12:26very nature, and Cede Hunter loves a definition, so by their very nature
- 12:31there in group at group, right, I guess. I mean there are
- 12:35definitely clicks within the board game world and so and so a broad board game
- 12:39community can encompass. So I guess I guess what I'm trying to say is
- 12:45there are lots of people who dip their toe in occasionally playing at Christmas,
- 12:50and I wouldn't say they're part of the board game community. They have no
- 12:54kind of vested interest in the art form, particularly apart from doing it,
- 13:00you know, once or twice a year. Yeah, I mean, I
- 13:01think it's just hard to come up with a solid definition for this, Like,
- 13:05look, I'm not part of the opera community, right, but I
- 13:07go to the opera. Maybe once a year. But I certainly don't have
- 13:11enough interest in the development of the art form or any desire to keep up
- 13:15with, you know, to keep up with who's big and who's not within
- 13:18the art form bonds. I think there are people within board games. Most
- 13:26of the people we play with have an interest in that night. I mean,
- 13:31I don't know even if they did, I don't know that that means
- 13:33that there is such a thing as a larger community that everybody somehow participates in.
- 13:37Our friend Teresa once I was talking to her about this is going to
- 13:41be really really on the nose. We're talking about plants. How should you
- 13:48keep your plants directly in a pot or you keep them in the plastic container
- 13:52that they came in and put that inside of a different pot. And I
- 13:54asked her about this because I've heard different opinions, and she told me,
- 13:58yeah, the planting community is divided on this one, Okay, like the
- 14:01community of people who have house plants, or like this self selected group of
- 14:07really super hardcore plant people who actually go on online forums and debate it and
- 14:13talk about it on Reddit and cancel each other on Twitter if they actually fucking
- 14:18put the plant directly in the pot. Okay, so I'm going to I'm
- 14:20going to pull back and talk about first principles of this. Right, it's
- 14:26very silent of the lambs. So we live in an age in which the
- 14:33primary forms of media, they're sort of modus operandi is too there you go.
- 14:39Is to atomize us, right, is to pull us apart, is
- 14:43to put us into our literal cocoons with our significant other or our small family
- 14:48group. So we give our full attention to those things, right, and
- 14:54this is just against our hardwiring. Right, we are a Gregari species.
- 15:00And so what you have seen with the onset of the Internet is people really
- 15:07getting into shit. And then I think what you dip your toe into something
- 15:13and you see a community forum, a community post to YouTube channel, and
- 15:20you really get into it, and not only do you get into it,
- 15:22but you seek others who are into it as much as you are. Right,
- 15:28that's a community. I don't know, I mean is it a community?
- 15:33Like? How is it functionally a community? I mean you seek out
- 15:35others, but we seek out others in person, locally at our local game
- 15:39night. Sure, And occasionally you go to a board game geek dot com
- 15:43and read a forum or make a post or something like that. Is that
- 15:46Is that a strong enough premise for a community? All right, So I'm
- 15:50going to read out seed Hunter here. He's featured quite a lot in this
- 15:52first episode. He gets to go first, so he says, I can't
- 15:56do the accent we had are Geese? The quist is whether the community is
- 16:02from South Africa. Yeah, that's right, our Geese. The Christian is
- 16:04where the community and the sense of people are live near and interact within the
- 16:08real life. I'm reading out the type of it in the because I cop
- 16:12it and pasted it from the discord, So I didn't write this, ain't
- 16:15ye. Christian is where the community would use the Latin word seek thus to
- 16:21indicate that you are transcribing something as it was originally rendered exactly. Thus,
- 16:27Christians with the community and the sense of people are live near and interact in
- 16:32the real life, is equivalent to an online grouping of people with similar interests.
- 16:37So I want to I want to be clear that I'm not making an
- 16:40argument about like online communities being legitimate communities or not. I don't think I
- 16:45would go that far to argue against you, to argue argue against it.
- 16:48Yeah, yeah, I this is not the point I'm trying to make.
- 16:51Um. The last time I remember when we really got into this argument.
- 16:55I think we were talking to Uli, who, by the way, has
- 16:56the strongest point in the entire that's right, we'll get to that. And
- 17:02I said that it seemed to me that there was a community among the publishers,
- 17:06because there aren't that many by and large, and they all seem to
- 17:08know each other. Sure, And I thought, well, maybe that could
- 17:11qualify as a community like the publishing community, but as far as like a
- 17:15larger board gaming community, it just it just seems to me like very hard
- 17:18to define, like what that is, who's part of it? And and
- 17:22how do you even like define it without coming across as elite in the bad
- 17:25sense, right, the people who are like self selected masters of the board
- 17:30game media sphere, like yourself. Right. Well, I want to ask
- 17:32you a question here again sort of going back to sort of first principles.
- 17:37I think I know my answer, and I assume you will agree with me.
- 17:41But so, do you see a qualitative interest in the community of people
- 17:45you hang around with face to face and members of an online group? Do
- 17:52I see a quality? Qualitative interest? Is one interest sorry, I want
- 17:57to make a qualitative different difference. You know, is one more nourishing for
- 18:02you? Does one have a greater impact on your life? Is one just
- 18:07for the animal that we are better? Or no? Oh, I don't
- 18:10know. I think it's probably different. People will think different things. I
- 18:12don't participate that much in online boarder game communities. I'm not talking specifically board
- 18:18games. I'm talking about sort of online communities and face to face communities.
- 18:22Oh. Man, I think at different points in my life I probably got
- 18:25something from online versus offline communities when I was a teenager. Well, I
- 18:32guess I've always had both. Lately, I haven't had too much of an
- 18:34online community of you only only the discord Really. Well, no, it's
- 18:38not true. It's not true. So what's fascinating is running a podcast means
- 18:44that people interact with your work and they speak to you about it and through
- 18:49a similar interest. So we have a five games from five Games for Doomsday
- 18:55community, right, But that has come out of a broader board game community,
- 18:59right, And so what's what's fascinating with the whole board games thing.
- 19:03I think part of the reason I'm coming into sort of my eleventh year I'm
- 19:06sort of being really serious about this thing. And I've never really been into
- 19:11something as much as this that you would call a hobby ever in my life,
- 19:15right And I think part of the reason is the community. Is that
- 19:19through a mutual interest in something, I have found genuine friends. So I
- 19:27think of you, I think of Ulie, I think a Tony, I
- 19:33think of Isaac, I think of Johnny Pack, I think of Marry Us,
- 19:38I think of you know, this this group of people, some people
- 19:41that have come out come into my life and exited my life, but some
- 19:45people that have been consistent. Fuck no, I'm thinking of Marry Us and
- 19:49and and that this is your community, right sure, And you know everybody
- 19:56probably has their community. But it's like it's like walking into So if you
- 20:02think of it in terms of walking into a place where people have a similar
- 20:06interest and you're able just to pick up a conversation with them about something that
- 20:10isn't challenging or weird or awkward because you have that same interest, that's a
- 20:14community. Though I don't know. I mean, you could go to Washington
- 20:18Square Park in New York City right now and sit down and play chess with
- 20:21somebody. Sure, you know, if you know the rules, you can
- 20:22play chess anywhere in the world. I don't know if that makes it a
- 20:26chess community per se, although I think there really is a global online backgammon
- 20:30community. I've heard of this. I'm sure there is. I mean,
- 20:33there's a community for everything, you know. I think it's very hard for
- 20:34human beings to like really think in like a global sense, because community,
- 20:41to most people, naively speaking, probably means like the number of people I
- 20:45could conceivably have relationships with who live right next to me, you know,
- 20:51like the village, the town, the neighborhood, whatever, like my local
- 20:53community in my physical space. It's very hard to extend this first of all
- 21:00line, but we can, and we have done. But then further into
- 21:04like this sort of abstraction, like anyone who participates in a thing I participate
- 21:08in is now part of this community that doesn't really have any like functional meaning
- 21:14at that point. Okay, so tactor says, what do you think tactors
- 21:18from? Well, just what'd you say? I mean, all your fans
- 21:21are from the UK or Australia, right, So where's he from in Britain.
- 21:25Let's say he's from Britain, Wes he from I'm supposed to guess that
- 21:27by looking at the name is tactus? You know? Yes? And it
- 21:30wells oh lovely, Okay, get it. It's a group of people you
- 21:37choose to be a part of example online, less of a community than what
- 21:41you can't choose and are forced to a degree to interact with, example neighbors.
- 21:48Does a community need to have a goat keeper, which may be an
- 21:52in group that has to agree that you're part of the community, or can
- 21:56you just declare yourself to be part of it? Hey, interesting questions.
- 22:00So my my building, everyone who lives in the building, once a year,
- 22:04there's a meeting that's right for all of the people who live in the
- 22:07building. I have not attended this meeting yet myself, But this is kind
- 22:11of like it is a community, right, It's not a community that like
- 22:15is a lot of lulls for me, sure, and I have no choice
- 22:18but to be a part of it, even if I never even participate at
- 22:21all. Maybe this is the kind of community he's talking about. Yeah,
- 22:26I mean, and you certainly couldn't get in, Like you can't walk off
- 22:29the street and join that community, right, But it's a very specific community,
- 22:33right, So I guess our community is self policing in that way they
- 22:37can be I mean, does so to be? I guess I get still
- 22:41really difficult questions to work. Is being part of the board game community?
- 22:47So what makes someone part of it? Well, this is the point.
- 22:49The barrier to entry is very low. He asked the question here does a
- 22:52community need to have a gatekeeper which sort of stamps your pass as being part
- 22:56of community? Well? Can you just declare yourself to be a part I
- 23:00think it must depend on the community. I mean absolutely. There are loads
- 23:03of communities that are clearly exclusive. So we've seen today country clubs, academia,
- 23:08the Privy Council. I can't be part of the Privy council community.
- 23:12Dare to dream? Should we do the oath again? We've already done it?
- 23:15I shoot, all the listeners have already said it. Yep. And
- 23:18now did you know that that contractually obliges them to tithe me ten percent of
- 23:22their money? Ten percent? Yeah, you finally can hit the goal and
- 23:26and ceedee hunter yep, he's a lawyer that explains the quas and the Latin
- 23:33and yeah, yeah, superciliousness, So I reckon like he's fucking yeah,
- 23:37yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, but ten percent of that but like Kruger
- 23:41ends, right yeah, Australian black Yeah, they're not worth that much.
- 23:44So it's like he probably makes five hundred thousand. Yeah, that's probably three
- 23:48quids. Yeah, that's why he's never visited us in Berlin, that's true.
- 23:51Can't buy a plane ticket with that kind of money. Yeah. So
- 23:53so okay, I'm going to ask you something. Now, do you feel
- 24:00like within Bold Games you all pont of a community. I feel like this
- 24:07is a setup. It never really occurs to me. No, it's just
- 24:10it's just question. I have, um my local friends that I play games
- 24:17with. I've got Rudy's Rudy Is is technically a community center? Right?
- 24:22Yeah? Like located in physical space for the people of that area more or
- 24:27less? Um, I don't. I don't think of it in terms of
- 24:30like being a community though over time I've met more people. It's like I
- 24:36know more people in the board game world. If I can use that word,
- 24:40Um, are they a community though? Because I think when you when
- 24:42you talk about a community and here here now I can like shift to your
- 24:47side of the argument a little bit. Um I mentioned on the discord the
- 24:51book Imagined Communities by Benedict Anderson, which is about the nation state and what
- 24:56makes a nation and nationalism right, And the idea presented in this book is
- 25:03something like, when I wake up in the morning and I read a newspaper
- 25:07about what's going on in the nation, I can imagine many other people who
- 25:11I don't know and never met and never will meet, doing the same thing,
- 25:15right. And I think modern journalism actually has a lot to do with
- 25:21the creation of the nation state as a meaningful political entity where you can actually
- 25:26feel like you have something in common with people you've never met. So if
- 25:30you look at a community in that sense, then I think that your arguments
- 25:36like there's more grist for your mill. However, I don't think in the
- 25:40case of the board game community so called, that there's a single narrative that
- 25:45everybody is aware of, whereas in the case of news media, I mean,
- 25:48this is the argument and imagine community, it was much less fractious back
- 25:52then. Everyone like today is a good example, everyone in the world knows
- 25:56that you're King Charles the Third being crowned right right, and everyone in the
- 26:02UK is aware of it, and like they know that other people are aware
- 26:06of it, and you're all supposed to watch it together and do the oath
- 26:07together, and definitely is and this is what makes you all wake up in
- 26:11the morning every day and realize that you are part of this thing called the
- 26:14United Kingdom. Right. I don't know if there is a comparable thing for
- 26:18board games to that, because we don't all know that. You know,
- 26:22oh, the next Rosenberg game is coming out. We're all aware of it.
- 26:25We all care. It's like no, but we don't know. We
- 26:26don't know certain events that happen within our nation either, right, Yeah,
- 26:30So the nation is a much stronger concept than community, and this I think.
- 26:36I think so nationhood is definitely a most more stronger concept, a more
- 26:40stronger concept. That's that's good. That's good. I mean it actually has
- 26:42like political valence. Yeah. Well, the point is it also seems to
- 26:47me to be unshakable, right, It's it's a permanent thing when the nation
- 26:52a feeling of being from a certain nation. So part of the reason I
- 26:56would say it's historically contingent, Ben, but I'll let you take this one
- 27:00up. But you know, so when Brexit happened, of course, there
- 27:03was the discussion about what do you do right. This is funny because what
- 27:07actually changed from one day to the next. Um, well, like lots
- 27:12of juridically speaking things changed, but like basically people's mentality change. Actually,
- 27:17lots of little things have changed in my life, but they'd be too long
- 27:22to listen. But you know what I mean. In reality, Yeah,
- 27:23we all woke up one day and we don't imagine the UK anymore as being
- 27:27part of the right. But what's fascinating is I was thinking about becoming German.
- 27:33So you're gonna like criticize people constantly. Yeah, yeah, lose your
- 27:37sense of humor. Yeah yeah, eat boring food. You can't have spacey
- 27:40food anymore, you like Spacey's true, that's true. But but the big
- 27:44thing was and until this changes sometime this year, people are promising I would
- 27:48have to relinquish my British citizenship, right, I mean, you can't vote
- 27:52anyway, so what good is it? I know, But and this is
- 27:55completely irrational, It's completely right. Oh but you feel an attachment, yeah,
- 27:59but the thought to dispensing my No matter where you go, you still
- 28:03believe yourself to be part of right. Yeah. So certainly the board game
- 28:07community is not that I can imagine a day where I no longer play board
- 28:11games, I no longer have board games, I no longer participate in community
- 28:15activities. Certainly the sense of nationhood is a stronger gives you wealth for me
- 28:22at least, and I would say majority of people a stronger sort of bond
- 28:26something you. It's it's not an opt in community in the same way that
- 28:33you know a hobby community is. I don't think that makes them any less
- 28:36of a community. Well, I want to refer to my comment and my
- 28:41argument. Can't do it. You're going to do it in some like funny
- 28:45fo American accent that's meant to take the piss. Aren't you know this is
- 28:48this is an impression to you. Why don't you Why don't you do your
- 28:51actual best? You're an actor, you're a professional performer. Why don't you
- 28:55put something, some of your talent into this for a change. Okay,
- 28:59go on, I'm going to read it now. My argument is against the
- 29:02idea of there being a general monolithic community to which people refer when they say
- 29:06the community. I don't think that exists. Man, See what did you
- 29:11think about I thought that was really good. I take it all back.
- 29:15I take it all back. I'm a bloody impression when you really want to.
- 29:18Yeah, so I was doing it for lulls before, but that you
- 29:21asked me to be serious now, then I'm sorry. I'm sorry, I'm
- 29:23sorry. I you know, I apologize from my previous statements. You are
- 29:27a consummate professional, so it's interesting that you say my arguments against that they're
- 29:33being an idea of a general monolithic community like the community. Right, Okay,
- 29:41But so I've been wanting to ask you this for about ten minutes.
- 29:45It's just got into my head and it hasn't disappeared out of my head a
- 29:47second. That you're a middle aged man, we better just do this now.
- 29:49Right when you go to Essen? Now, I know everyone doesn't go
- 29:53to Essen, but everyone who I would consider to be part of the board
- 29:56game community is aware of the existence of us, right when you walk in
- 30:03there, that sort of unalloyed mecca to the art form of board games.
- 30:11Do you not feel part of something that you could call monolithic? Great?
- 30:17Big? Do you know? Because I mean I certainly did. What like,
- 30:21what do I feel a part of when I when I go to Essen?
- 30:22I mean, this just could be a matter of enthusiasm, But you
- 30:26are begging the question, right, like, oh, absolutely, I don't
- 30:30know. I think Essen is like fucking mostly day trippers. True, there's
- 30:37definitely like a scattering of us, and it's funny we you know, we
- 30:40see each other, you know, passing in the halls. But I don't
- 30:42think by and large that's most people at Essen. This is the point I'm
- 30:45trying to make. Like board gaming is, it's a consumer product and it's
- 30:49an industry, and a lot of people just buy them and play them with
- 30:52their their families or even with their friends, and they don't participate in any
- 30:56larger thing. So I mean, it could be that there is a board
- 31:00game community and we are part of it, but most people who playboard games
- 31:03aren't and don't care. I never will. That's true most people. Then
- 31:07we're back to the kind of like elitist statement. Well, it's so elitist.
- 31:10I think it's just highly like disseminated, right, it's not a central
- 31:15thing like the nation. We're saying, Well, well that you're implying that
- 31:18there needs to be some sort of central governments, some sort of central authority
- 31:22that deems a community of community, and that's clearly not true. But you
- 31:26know you think of a town square, right, does board gaming have a
- 31:29town square? You might say board might I think it's absolutely the boardgaming time
- 31:33square. You might say that, and it's not Twitter because they're all no
- 31:37beds. But it's like it's it's arguable, right, I mean probably a
- 31:38lot of board gamers don't pay attention to board game geak that much, so
- 31:42I don't Yeah, I want yeah, please Ulie Blake. What does Ulie
- 31:45Blake say? He's got the closing argument in this whole conversation as far as
- 31:48I'm concerned, Uh, you're right. Boomer ellipsis Oh it is a boomers
- 31:56Yeah, they love him to lay boomers. Yeah, what is it with
- 31:59Boomer lips sees? And Uli? What is it with Is he going to
- 32:01hear this? I doubt you should just send him a link or something,
- 32:06Yeah, send What we should do is we should drive out to his house
- 32:08in the Tuderberg forest and get like a massive speaker and just like blare it
- 32:13at it. What we should do is download this podcast onto a C ninety
- 32:17and then mail it to him. He might actually listen to it, maybe
- 32:22an eight track anyways, So kind Fortress says and an kind Fortress. So
- 32:29he's from South Carolina, so I can do that accent. Do you remember
- 32:30when he explained to us where he came up with the name kind Fortress.
- 32:34Yeah, God, it was a very long explanation. It's some game he
- 32:37designed, I think be famed board game designers. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 32:42it's just I thought it was gonna be like a very quick answer,
- 32:45and he kind of like went on for a while, and I started,
- 32:46I stared into the distance and stopped listening. So I don't remember. I
- 32:50just remember something like at some point. So he says, so I can
- 32:54do the actual He's from South Carolina, so we definitely sounds like this,
- 32:58he's from South Carolina, even though even though he lives in North Carolina.
- 33:01That's right. The community exists, as do many others. When we refer
- 33:07to the community, we're largely talking about a visible subset of people who are
- 33:13active on social media. Begay, gay, and even in local gaming communities
- 33:19begay. Someone from South Carolina would say, okay, they we are the
- 33:24alpha gamers. They set and reinforced norms about gameplaying. It's social fabric quite
- 33:30successfully, such that participating in the gaming group or Revente is nearby the same
- 33:36experience in Portland, Oregon, Portland, he's to Portland, Oh, Portland,
- 33:42Oregon, Portland, Maine, or Porto, Portugal. I like how
- 33:46he worked in Porto there for us, So that's interesting. You're your friends
- 33:52in the board game snobs are going to be super offended by that. By
- 33:53the way, Hey, I hope they're not listening. I hope they honest
- 33:57things. So that's an interesting thing. So the point I think we should
- 34:00focus on here is do you so you've gained in Murker? Yeah? Germany
- 34:07yep, Portugal yep. The UK. You haven't been to the UK Games
- 34:12Expo. I haven't been to the I did live in London for a while,
- 34:15but I don't know that I played a board game when I was there.
- 34:16So, so do you think he's right? The essentially what the community
- 34:23has done is, in short, that you get a sort of consistent gaming
- 34:29experience wherever you go. Okay, I mean you're really setting me up here,
- 34:31because if I say that he's wrong, the next time we see him,
- 34:35I'm going to have to deal with him explaining to me the next three
- 34:38hours why he isn't um. But I mean, as usual in all seriousness,
- 34:44Isaac makes very cogent points. He does. He's a he's a trenchant
- 34:49thinker, ben Um. I don't know any of these ones. And I
- 34:54think this is more or less the point we were just making a moment ago.
- 34:57Right, If there is a community, it's this is about as much
- 35:00as it is right. It's not as if there's like major controversy in the
- 35:05board game community and like people in the community are saying this and have an
- 35:07opinion about that. It's more like, yeah, when you go to these
- 35:10events, it's the sort of same type of people that you see at all
- 35:15the other events, And like you were saying before, you can fit right
- 35:19in very easily because you speak the language, you understand the patois of games.
- 35:23But I don't know if it makes a community. I mean, at
- 35:27a certain point the word just loses meaning to me. So Nits So I
- 35:32thought her name was knits and mistress yep, but it's not. I actually
- 35:38read it when I was putting these notes together, and it's knits amid Trees
- 35:44amidst Trees, Nits amidst Trees. It's very I mean, she could have
- 35:49chosen a user name that's not so difficult to say. It must be on
- 35:52purpose. So I picked the sig nits amidst trees. What do you think
- 35:54she's from? Well, that's that's very Somerset, Probably ain't. I mean,
- 35:59it's a very like twee kind of names. It's definitely from your country.
- 36:01Yeah, so I like. I like the way she opens this bit.
- 36:07I would disagree with that kind fortress that being a consumer is enough.
- 36:12Go into Michaels and buying yarn does not make you a member of that community.
- 36:15You have Michaels in the UK, No, what is Michael's. Michaels
- 36:19is like a craft store in America. Oh, she's definitely Americans. So
- 36:22you can go there and you can buy like yarn and paper and clay and
- 36:25whatever you want to do to like arts and crafts type things. Oh,
- 36:29change the accent then, Oh, you would disagree with that kind fortress that
- 36:32being a consumer is enough. Go into Michaels and buying yarn is that Oregon
- 36:38or something? Okay? Good? Going to Michaels and buying yarn does not
- 36:43make you a member of that community, and neither just going to Target and
- 36:45buying a game make you a member of the board game community laying down a
- 36:51gauntlet here. By the way, in America we pronounce it targe. Oh
- 36:52do you well, if we're trying to be funny, right, it's funny,
- 36:55right, it's hilarious. So because it's fancier than Walmart is the joke.
- 37:01So I completely agree with that the buying games does not make you.
- 37:06So she's referring to another post that Isaac made that is that we haven't read
- 37:08out. But I just like to think Shane's board game designer Isaac Shellev gets
- 37:13plenty of play on this podcast. Absolutely. So what's interesting though, is
- 37:20going to Target and buying a game does not make you part of the board
- 37:22game community. But if you're someone like lemon Cello, you could be part
- 37:25of the board game community and never buy a game at all like some people
- 37:29that we know, absolutely, but like lemon Cello, the way lemon Cello
- 37:31buys board games, yeah makes him yea an absolutely incredible holder you. I
- 37:37mean, it's the opposite also true. You could you just like collect the
- 37:40board games, never play them, never talk to anyone else who plays them,
- 37:44and still be part of the communities. So that's a great point.
- 37:47I would say, No, I think you can buy loads of games,
- 37:51hold them, never play them. But if you talk about games, you
- 37:55interact with others about games, whether that be digitally or face to face,
- 38:01I think that makes you part of the community. I think for me what
- 38:06the center of being part of the community is is the interchange of ideas.
- 38:13So I think, if so this sounds really reductive, and people can disagree
- 38:16with me on this, but so I think if like you and your misses
- 38:21just play games together and never really interact with anyone else in the board game
- 38:27world, even though you play very Rosenbergen Chef and Feil games and all of
- 38:30that sort of stuff, I don't think you're part of the community in that
- 38:32sense. But when do I become part of the community, Like the first
- 38:36time I go on Twitter and make some obnoxious remark, Well, I mean
- 38:40you can be a cubes in that. So yeah, I think that's what
- 38:46being a part of a community is, right, is interacting with others.
- 38:51Essentially, communities are So the reason Rude Is where we game is called a
- 38:57community center is because of the old sense of community. So what Dagda referred
- 39:01to this idea that you're just thrown into this geographical area with people and there
- 39:07your communities, and I think this is like an easier for us to grock.
- 39:09But what the internet has done is we create our we build our own
- 39:14little villages, right, we build our own little countries actually, and within
- 39:20that we have our own little villages that we dwell in. And I think
- 39:22I'm wondering if from the Middle Ages they had like a jousting community, but
- 39:25unfortunately they had no Twitter. Well I've been listening to I've been listening to,
- 39:30fucking sir. I've been listening to a podcast about the Plantagenets, and
- 39:34it seems to me they definitely had jousting nerds who really liked certain types of
- 39:40equipment and talked about which jousters were great. Did they travel around the continent
- 39:46going to various jousts? Yeah, well I don't know if if it was
- 39:50a spectator sport, but there were definitely groups of nights who did that,
- 39:53right, well, yeah, nights, perhaps, I don't know exactly.
- 39:59I mean, so I think it's the It's it's not like they had,
- 40:01you know, a league or something. No, but they definitely have to
- 40:06Yeah, they have tonam, But I think I think that's what makes a
- 40:08community. If you get out there and you talk and you dissect, and
- 40:13you take an active interest in the particular field that to me defines a community,
- 40:21and therefore I think board gaming most definitely has a community. I think
- 40:23the first time that this argument came up between the two of us, it
- 40:28was in the context of referring to the community as if it is this large
- 40:34body of interconnected people, right that that kind of has its own narrative or
- 40:37discourse or opinions, or like, I'm like, I keep saying, like
- 40:42hot topic in the community, and I just I don't think that exists.
- 40:45So I probably like fall somewhere um on the side of somewhere between what Isaac
- 40:52is saying and my point about this like imagined space where we we understand that
- 40:59there are other people who are into the thing that we're into and doing the
- 41:00thing that we're into. But now I'm wondering, is it is it useful
- 41:06to think of this or are we just like making way too much out of
- 41:08like a dumb conversation we had three years ago, So like it is it
- 41:14is it worthwhile to think of the think of a boardinging community as a thing
- 41:17and refer to it. I will explain to you why it's valuable for me.
- 41:22It always comes back to you. So the reason I say this is
- 41:25because it's very difficult as we've you know, we've been going for forty one
- 41:30minutes now, and it's clear generalizations will not suit, right. But that
- 41:37point you make, is it useful to think of a community for me?
- 41:43One hundred because it gives value to what I do workwise, because I feel
- 41:52I'm serving a community with the work that I produce. That's the community of
- 41:58people who listen. Yes. But also the hope is that people who are
- 42:00in the board game community will also be able to derive something from that because
- 42:05they have a connection to what I do. Also, in the dark tea
- 42:13time of the soul, at three o'clock in the morning, it's sometimes.
- 42:17So I've just moved into a new room and I'm surrounded now for the first
- 42:22time in two years by my game collection, and I kind of can't tell
- 42:28you how comforting that is to have all of my games out. How often
- 42:32do you smovel around and just stare at them? Yeah? I do.
- 42:36I do, And it's weird and it's nazi, right. But the reason
- 42:38is is because these shelves of games are potential to connect to other people.
- 42:49Being part of this community, being into it and giving a shit about it
- 42:54is valuable. Why do you need a community for that? Because I'm a
- 42:59great, garious animal that needs other people. So for you, it's important
- 43:04that you can imagine there are others out there like you who share the same
- 43:08passion and enthusiasm. I mean, for sure, that's true. I think
- 43:12all I'm saying is I don't think there's a community. So then what we're
- 43:15trying to say is there are lots of people who share this hobby with us,
- 43:20and they all form somehow part of what a world a group of I
- 43:29don't know how to define it. So what is a great word for a
- 43:30sort of nebulous group of people come together that all have an interest in the
- 43:37same thing. What is a good word? What? What world walk words
- 43:42would you use? I walked right into that. Um, I just wouldn't
- 43:49call a community because I don't think there is a board game community. Like,
- 43:52there are people who play board games, there are people who enjoy the
- 43:54hobby, but like this, this is this is the point I want to
- 43:57close on. Unlike with the imagine community of the nation, there isn't this
- 44:01kind of single unitary narrative unless it's the unitary narrative that is dictated to us
- 44:07by the kickstarter campaigns and the publishing schedules of the board gaming companies. Um.
- 44:14You could say, though, that there is much more of a community
- 44:16than just that, because of all of the media that's being created by people
- 44:21like yourselves, like yourself, other podcasts, they're also a board game magazines.
- 44:27So I mean, there's there's there's something there. Um, maybe you
- 44:30could call it a community. It doesn't it doesn't feel right to me to
- 44:32call it a community because I don't like the idea that there is a board
- 44:37game community that has some set of opinions and like that we need to even
- 44:40like worry about it, right, Like what is the community going to think?
- 44:44Because there's also a dark side to the community, absolutely, you know,
- 44:46there was that there was an inherent conformity, Yeah, and a tyranny
- 44:51of the mall with community that we've seen. And also the problem of opting
- 44:55into a community. You never want to offend. You can be removed from
- 44:59the community. Yeah, exactly. So this, this is this is kind
- 45:01of why I pull back a little bit. So one thing I would say
- 45:06just to wrap this up is I'm very happy and proud to be part of
- 45:09this community. But if I don't win the Golden Gate next week, the
- 45:15lot of you can fuck off. In an act of willful competition, we
- 45:20present our all right, Steve. So, as it's the innormal episode,
- 45:28as it was your topic, I'm going to allow you to choose our poster
- 45:32of the month, Poster of the month. And this is not like to
- 45:36choose yourself. I wasn't going to good on this topic. On this topic
- 45:42from is there a board game community? Yes, from this topic from the
- 45:45hashtag channel channel. I mean, there is clearly only one obvious choice.
- 45:51Okay, whole discussion. He's the only one who made a clear, concise
- 45:55argument that we can all agree with. I know where this is. The
- 46:00poster of the month is the one, the only Lulie Blenniman. Julie Blenneman,
- 46:04you are this month poster of the months. That was our all right.
- 46:15So just to wrap up two minutes, Steve, I've got a bullet
- 46:20pointed list here and I want to go through it and then we could get
- 46:23out of this farrago. So how did you join the discord um? Oh
- 46:29god, this again is five spelled out right, Yeah, I f I
- 46:32ve five consistent with my branding. Yeah, except on Twitter use the number
- 46:37five. They have a limit. Maybe Elon must change that by now you
- 46:40should check. Maybe somebody might be squatting on the five spelled out that's true.
- 46:45I'm gonna pay for it. Jump on that before this episode goes out,
- 46:47right, someone's gonna claim it. Yeah. So you go to five
- 46:51Games for Doomsday spelled out dot com, not five games for Doomsday spelled out
- 46:55dot com. You spell out the numbers in the name, five games for
- 46:59dooms, and then you go to five Games for Doomsday dot com. Right,
- 47:01there's a pinned post at the top of the page using pinning post technology
- 47:07of some kind. Right, I don't understand to do it. I work
- 47:10friend Sanya told me how to do it. Yeah, I work in it,
- 47:13and I don't understand it at all. But you can follow the link
- 47:19or whatever and it's a permanent invite. Yeah, you can. Just you
- 47:21can just join join the party and then go to the channel which is hashtag
- 47:27channel. Yeah, well it just says channel. Yeah, because hashtags are
- 47:30don't it's it's not two hashtags and it's not the word hashtag spelled out.
- 47:35No, it's just it's channel anyway. So secondly, Stephen, how do
- 47:39you support the show if you've listened to this and thought, why these guys
- 47:43know their onions? Hugs? No, I don't. Firstly, I don't
- 47:46like hugs because I'm British. Secondly, I want coming that hard cold madula
- 47:51platts. I like plule its. Actually yeah, it's not as good as
- 47:54money, but plulled it to a close second. Yeah, well, if
- 47:58you want to give the if you want to give Ben something other than hugs
- 48:01and plotts, then you should go out this again. Why do you make
- 48:06me do this every time? Because you're great at it? Patreon dot com
- 48:09Yeah slash Hang on a second, is it spelled out? No? Okay
- 48:15the number five games number. No, it's not short version. It's the
- 48:20enough five five G for D. There we go, pat you have three
- 48:22different ways of doing this. It's very confusing, so confusing. So I
- 48:28lead a Brandon manager Patreon dot com forward slash five G for D, And
- 48:30I just want to say before we bow out, so to listen to this,
- 48:34you already have to be a Patriot. No, this is this is
- 48:36on the main Otherwise, why would we be telling them exactly. Yeah,
- 48:38good point five dollars a month. And you get to listen to the battle
- 48:43and other things. And you know what, you get to listen to what
- 48:45the last battle report where I had a little nervous breakdown. Stephen, it
- 48:52was great, You're great. So I just want to say thank you to
- 48:53everyone who contributed. And if you join the discord, you can contribute to
- 48:59and cha in the next episode of Hashtag Channel. And yeah, so Stephen,
- 49:06thank you, Thank you. Ben. You know, I don't really
- 49:08know for sure if there is there isn't a board game community, but for
- 49:12sure you are the only community that I need.