Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Recapping True Journalism and Future Forecasting
Transcript
- 0:01Wednesday, December 27th. Well on the way to our last week of the year. Mm-hmm. But today, we're bringing you a segment, Jamie Butters, Steve Greenfield, Daniel Govier. We hope you're ready for this one.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be.
- 0:17They stop and- Segments on point I'm pretty, I'm pretty sure none of these people were together until we had them on this segment at last week's year-end extravaganza. That would be...
- 0:26You know, that would be an interesting study, like how many net new panels can we create that have never sat on panels together? Ooh. Probably a lot.
- 0:34I mean, you started way back in the day, like, having competing, uh- Jim Fitzpatrick and Jason Stein. [laughs] That's the one that definitely got the most buzz. Right. And they were like, "Wait, who? What?"
- 0:47[laughs] But we were all locked down. Everybody had to get along. Yeah, exactly. I mean, they're both professionals- No doubt... and we did have a great conversation. Yeah. But yeah, no, that's...
- 0:53I mean, isn't that the magic, right? Ugh, it is the magic. Putting together new ingredients and be like, "Oh, these two things. That's why a charcuterie board is so great." [laughs] Yep.
- 1:02You know, I used to, like, we both have historically done podcasts and done events where, like, it's a single person talking and where it's, like, a single interview- Mm-hmm... which are great, right?
- 1:13Because you get that one person's perspective.
- 1:15But it's always more fun, whether it's AutoCollabs or whether it's an ASOTU CON stage or the year-end extravaganza, when you have these different voices kind of, like, speaking in on a similar topic.
- 1:26Because a lot of times you get alignment, but sometimes you get a different angle, right? Like- All the time... you get a different perspective way to see it.
- 1:32And I think that broadens the horizon for us instead of just, like, expecting that the person on the other side of the audio is just the right one, right?
- 1:40Well, I mean, I can't tell you how many times we've seen where you wa- literally watch or hear one guest say, like, "I- Move the attention"... I'm gonna call you about that because- Yeah...
- 1:50we're trying to do the same thing." I'm, I- And then we know, in the back channel, that actually happened and actually got deployed, which is like- Yeah. At ASOTU CON first year, you had Brian Binstock changing his mind.
- 2:00I had, I had, uh, Rick Reichert thinking about what Dan Bannister was doing this year on, on, on, on- No doubt... your stage. And so- Well, it's hard to do that when your-... you see that all the time...
- 2:08service retention rate's, like, 90%. [laughs] Right. I think everyone was like, "Yeah, what are you doing?" [laughs] "What are you doing over there?" Yeah. Counting out $100 bills? I don't know.
- 2:19But, uh, today, so we're gonna share this with you from our year-end extravaganza.
- 2:22If you haven't seen the whole thing, you can go to our YouTube channel and see it, A-S-O-T-U dot B-E, ASOtube, for those of you keeping track. And, uh, here it is. Here's, uh, Jamie, Steve, and Daniel.
- 2:34Oh, this is so much fun. Daniel, Jamie, Steve, thank you for, uh, giving us some time this week before Christmas. Glad to be here. Glad to be here. Glad to be here, guys. I knew.
- 2:41I was hoping I could get everybody to say something at right at the time. Right at the same time. [laughs] Um, okay.
- 2:45So this year, obviously, we've had so many things go on, but it is hard to avoid all of the drama and all of the conversation and uncertainty around the UAW strike. Jamie, I remember a conversation.
- 2:58It was, I think, one of the first conversations we ever had was at, uh, David Kane's event much earlier in the year.
- 3:04And, uh, one of the questions that came from the audience after your, after your talk was, "What should we be thinking about that we're not thinking about right now?"
- 3:12And you, uh, aptly said, "I don't hear anybody talking about a strike, but it's likely there's gonna be some fanfare a, around that."
- 3:19So, um, you were watching this way far in advance, then you've kind of, like, navigated us all through it. Everybody was, you know, tied to automotive news every morning. "What's the update?"
- 3:29Um, on this side of it, how did it play out based on how you thought it was gonna play out? Well, certainly, Shawn Fain has, was, been a, a very unpredictable character, right?
- 3:41And it was sort of fundamental to his strategy, was to be unpredictable to the automakers. So I can't claim that I, I saw this all playing out exactly as it did.
- 3:52Um, you know, certainly the reason I felt so confident that there would be a strike isn't because, um, because I have some, you know, divine power other than I have this great army of intelligence gatherers that work for me- [laughs]...
- 4:05and share, uh, their insights. So I was definitely leaning on Michael Martinez, uh, his reporting and his insight.
- 4:12You know, and, and it kind of did seem obvious and, and I think it did play out as we expected in that, you know, this union was really reeling and trying to get back on its feet. They'd had a- Mm-hmm...
- 4:25a really massive scandal. Shawn Fain won a very narrow and, uh, thinly attended election. Uh, he had no base. He had no machine. He had no mandate.
- 4:36And so he did all these sort of stunts and this public media, public relations campaign through, you know, Facebook Live and whatnot to build his own credibility, to try to rebuild some of the culture within the UAW and rally people around a, you know, the common effort.
- 4:55And then he did it the way he did it and, you know, it was costly to the industry, but arguably not as costly as it could've been. Mm-hmm. And, uh, and, uh, workers got really big raises. [laughs] Yeah.
- 5:10Now, Daniel, you obviously, uh, uh, as, as on the dealer side, you know, working with manufacturers that were directly, were not directly impacted.
- 5:20You know, there, there was a variance in, in dealers that were directly impacted because their manufacturers were a part of the negotiations and those that were not.
- 5:27And you've gotten the chance through, uh, the Wheelhouse podcast to kinda talk th- to a lot of people through that.
- 5:32What's been the sentiment of how it's actually impacted dealers on the ground and, and, uh, what are dealers experiencing as a result of the, the UAW strikes? Yeah, good question.
- 5:42I think the best thing was when, actually, I had, uh, Patrick Gabad on the show and I s- you know, and he runs a, a massive Toyota store, and I asked him the same question.
- 5:48Like, "This doesn't look like it's gonna directly affect you." And he said, "It's still an opportunity for me. I'll tell you exactly what I would say at our store, even if I was at a store that is directly affected.
- 5:56When I'm talking to the client, right, when I'm actually at the point of, at the, at the point of actual contact with the client, I'll tell them, 'This may affect us in some way or another, but I prom- my commitment to you is it will never affect you.'"And he, he probably said it better than, than that.
- 6:10And that was a good learning opportunity for a lot of people to adapt what they were thinking their client contact would be.
- 6:16And for a lot of us, too, it was a good opportunity to understand what the union was going through was essentially because they hadn't had any updates, right, in a decade or so.
- 6:24Like, there wasn't, you know, the way that they were compensating, the way that they were looking at their compensation hadn't changed.
- 6:30And so, then they had to do a whole lot all at once very, you know, somewhat violently rocking the boat.
- 6:35And so, had we, in, in a shorter period of time, in less than 10 years, have we had the opportunity to look at ourselves and change how we're compensating or how we're taking care of our people so that it's not necessarily a strike, but very much so in the sense where we could have that area of difficulty internally as well in our industry.
- 6:52What do we... Do we take this opportunity and look and see what things can we change? What things are we past due on looking at so we don't have to try and change so much all at once?
- 7:00Overall, from the rest of the dealer side, I, I really didn't run into really any, uh, any, any strong feelings of being disadvantaged by, uh, by the strike at all. Wow, that's impressive.
- 7:12Now, so that's kind of like boots on the ground, frontline. Steve, you get to play in a space that is always kind of looking over the horizon and tying it back to what the needs are.
- 7:21Did you see any conver- hear any conversation or see any motion at all in, um, like the tech space in the conversations that you have about what's over the horizon that considered the strike as, uh, anything more than a speed bump?
- 7:35Well, I think it, I mean, t- time will tell. I, I think, you know, this is gonna be the classic definition of a Pyrrhic victory, meaning that, you know, you, you win the battle, but you lose the war.
- 7:45And I don't know what Jamie's thought on this is, but as I thought it, thought it out, and, and there may be an ecosystem of startups that benefit from all this collateral damage that's caused.
- 7:52But, you know, the, the, the UAW seems to be continuing to want to now penetrate some of the import manufacturers. And I think that, um, you know, the dynamics, I would say, are, are three that, that I worry about.
- 8:03O- one being the legacy automakers that are trying to figure out the timing to make this transition to EVs are, are bleeding cash in their EV operations, and I think indefinitely will continue to do so.
- 8:15Um, number two is that's gonna be compounded by the fact that, um, um, Elon Musk and Tesla are more profitable from a gross margin than any of the other automakers, and as a result of that, except maybe, like, Ferrari and Porsche.
- 8:27And as a result of that, he's gonna continue to squeeze their EV operations and continue to ensure that they bleed by dropping prices and continue to find, you know, efficiencies in production.
- 8:37And then the, the last thing that will compound things even more and make it more painful is that I, I think it's inevitable that the Chinese are gonna bring product into the US market.
- 8:47Um, you've, you've seen e- even this week some talk about sort of backdooring through the Mexican market. And I think, you know, the squeeze is on, uh, for the legacy automakers and their EV operations specifically.
- 8:57And having inflated, you know, uh, labor costs isn't gonna help that at all.
- 9:01So I think, you know, 5, 10 years from now we'll look back at this UAW, you know, um, uh, big victory as being maybe the first piece of the puzzle that's gonna bode very, very poorly, I think, for the economics and the industry ab- above the dealer level.
- 9:15I don't know, um, to Daniel's point, that it's ever gonna ki- kind of get down to the dealer level.
- 9:19But I think for the legacy OEMs, I'm looking at this and scratching my head and saying, "You know, what's our profitability gonna look like for the next few years?" Because all of these headwinds are mounting. Right.
- 9:28Yeah. Jamie, actually just this week, um, uh, you know, there was an article about the fact that the UAW is continuing to pursue relationships with the manufacturers that do not currently have unions in them.
- 9:43And, uh, particularly to, to Steve's point, like, this is not gonna be a dead conversation.
- 9:48We're gonna be continuing to talk about this as an industry and the impact that it might have on the dealer or the consumer or the legacy OEM's ability to compete in a new market.
- 9:58How do you see that playing out as we head into 2024? If you had your crystal ball like we all, we all thought you had- There we go [laughs]...
- 10:05back early 2023- [laughs] How do you see some of these conversations playing out?
- 10:09I'm still stuck on the idea of pursuing relations, uh, with these other automakers 'cause, uh, the, you know, uh, ask Ford how they feel about their relations with the UAW, right?
- 10:19[laughs] They used to, Ford, you know, Bill Ford especially, felt a real, you know, bond with UAW, uh, felt that they were, they were together to take on the Teslas and the Toyotas.
- 10:29And Shawn Fain is like, "I'm- we're not your partner, man. You're, you're the enemy." [laughs] "We're against you.
- 10:35You know, Toyota and Tesla are gonna be our next enemies, but their workers are, you know, are brothers and sisters of the, uh, of the factory." So
- 10:44yeah, they, uh, Shawn Fain just went down to Chattanooga, or I think he was in Chattanooga. He was, uh- Yeah, it was Chattanooga...
- 10:49you know, dealing with, uh, you know, to, to tell Volkswagen, you know, uh, "Stand down and let us, uh, organize these workers." And they're like, "Hey, we're not doing anything wrong."
- 10:58So it's a contentious relationship. Chattanooga has a chance. You know, that one was really close- Mm-hmm... even when the UAW was being, you know, rocked by scandal headlines on the regular. Mm-hmm.
- 11:09Uh, so they seem to have a chance there. I don't know. Toyota and Honda- Ooh... um, have had so many decades of relationships with their employees directly. Mm-hmm.
- 11:20Um, and you see the raises that are being given out by the non-union automakers. Right. They wanna keep the union out and make it- What are you fighting for, right? Well, yeah.
- 11:29Why do you wanna pay dues to somebody in Detroit who will tell you when you can and can't work? We'll just pay you what's fair, uh, get you close enough to that, and, and let's leave the union out of it. You know, I,
- 11:42I worry as w- like you said, Steve, about the, the cost of labor going up so much, you know.
- 11:47But one thing, I, back when the Harbor Report was still published, and I, I'm dating myself 'cause I don't think they've been making this public for a decade and a half probably, but we were seeing the average amount of, uh, labor hours per vehicle come down to about 30.
- 12:04So-Even at $100 an hour, you're talking about $3,000 of labor in a vehicle that now costs $50,000 on average. Mm-hmm.
- 12:16Um, you know, it's not inconsequential, and whether it's 3,000 or it's 2,500 makes a big difference for automaker profitability. Uh, but it's, it's not as devastating as the cost of a battery- Right. It's not outside-...
- 12:27in an electric vehicle... historical norms. Right. Absolutely. Yeah.
- 12:29Daniel, you are a, an extreme advocate for, um, employee health, uh, employee advocacy within any organization, specifically the dealers that you've been a part of.
- 12:39Um, how do you, uh, how would you encourage dealers and even the OEMs that you may be partnered with to, to look at this situation and approach employees in maybe a new light, understanding what the union has pushed these, uh, these OEMs to?
- 12:56Yeah, 'cause it's the part that I still don't understand. It's the reason that the, this particular strike was so contentious and so costly was because nothing had been done for such a period of time. That's by design.
- 13:06You sign a contract, and then you st- you stuck with it. Nothing changed. You didn't take any additional input. You saw things happening outside your proverbial windows.
- 13:14You could point to a balance sheet and say that there were, you know, "Look at all these profits that were made." The thing is, nobody was telling you you couldn't have been a part of that except for you.
- 13:22You were in a contract. Right. You decided that there weren't gonna be things that changed.
- 13:26And so if noth- I mean, I really do hope, it is the little drum that I'm beating on, that we do look at this and say that this is... We kind of have to inverse this pyramid of, you know, where the ideas come from.
- 13:35Mm-hmm. And it's not that it doesn't narrow at the top. It needs to actually have a very broad base to it. And then that's, in the, in the retail world, that's the things that we have to get used to.
- 13:45Uh, seeing that there are, if we are not making changes, if we are saying that, you know, it's...
- 13:50At the same time we say that we wanna stick to we know what's true and we know what's good, at the same time we also say, like, "Well, we don't wanna go back to what was." Right.
- 13:57And this is, you know, the, the what was is in great quotation marks, and everybody could paint a different picture of what that was.
- 14:03Um, but the number one thing is, is that we need to start giving the people who are doing the work the platform to how to put together an idea. You have a suggestion.
- 14:12You have something that you like and you want more of. You have something that you don't like and you want less of. You see something that could help us be more efficient. Very easy to put in.
- 14:21It takes m- not much more than effort.
- 14:23But there needs to be a platform for the people that are doing the work to put together their thoughtful expertise and raise that then up into the levels that use that as a guiding light, as the metric to how they stay truly at the tip of the spear and at the forefront of the changes that are gonna be continuing to come.
- 14:39And so that we don't have to continue to have such revolutions of how we take care of our people.
- 14:44And, and to give a great example, when these other manufacturers do those things, it's like how could anybody that works for a union manufacturer not think that that's an, a better way of going about it?
- 14:55Like, it's, it was fun, first of all, to be on the other side of the mix, 'cause Daniel Govier hosts, uh, the ASOTU Wheelhouse- Right... Show. And he does such a great job, and he's in full control of that show, right?
- 15:06He has commands, pres- And so in this, I was like, "Oh, I get to ask the questions now, Daniel." [laughs] Uh, it was an amazing. Great insights- Who's the captain?... from all three. Right. [laughs] You know it.
- 15:17It's great. I know it. No, and, and not just that, but the, the astuteness of Jamie Butters to just be real about the, what he was tracking, who was tracking it.
- 15:27You know, him understanding his team was all over the stories as they were developing. And then to see each of these have a different perspective on how it's impacted the industry, because it is.
- 15:39It's impacting the industry in a different way for everybody. Some, not at all. Some, massive impacts. There were people- Right... that were really struggling with parts for some time, and we're seeing that rebound.
- 15:49Um, but it's gonna have continued impacts. I was... Uh, the, the one I wasn't thinking about is where Steve Greenfield was talking about just the, the residual impact of the three, five, seven-year timeline- Right...
- 16:02as changes in technology, changes in these vehicles, all of that, and these manufacturers' ability to keep up. It'll be interesting. So true. And, and is it just me, or does Jamie Butters just have an amazing voice?
- 16:14We don't g- ever get to hear it through the microphone. Silky smooth. It's so good. Such a silky smooth voice. He's gonna, he's gonna be a professional, like, book reader in his retirement.
- 16:21[laughs] I need to sit and just read books, and I'm gonna listen to them all. Oh, man. Well, here we are. We hope you're having a great Wednesday.
- 16:27We hope we sent you on your way with something to think about, something to implement. But right now, we all know what everyone in the industry is doing: closing the year out strong. We will see you tomorrow morning.
- 16:39[upbeat music]