Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Minister Grace Lore: Should the BC Legislature reform Question Period?
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is van color. Welcome back to This is van color.
- 0:24Even for those of us who intently follow BC politics, Question Period in
- 0:28the BC Legislature is not something that most British Columbians are actually watching. And
- 0:34yet the theatrics of Question Period can be at times embarrassing, the heckling and
- 0:40the cheering, often devolving into personal attacks and what can charitably be called as
- 0:46childish behavior. But is this just part of the Westminster tradition or is it
- 0:51a toxic work environment that may require a modern update? Here to discuss.
- 0:56As BC's Minister of State for Childcare and the MLA for Victor Torreya beacon Hill,
- 1:00she is Minister Grace Laure and this conversation is supported by shelter Point single
- 1:06malt whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter point. Minister Laura, thanks
- 1:11so much for being on the show tonight. Thanks for having me well so
- 1:15for the political nerds that may not know this, what exactly is question period
- 1:22in the BC Legislature? So Question Period happens every day the House is sitting
- 1:26for thirty minutes and MLA's from all parties are in the House and it's a
- 1:30chance for the opposition to ask questions of the government, and as a political
- 1:37scientist, it's a very important part of the political process. You know.
- 1:46Excuse me, sorry for erupting. It just seems to be a lot of
- 1:49flexing, a lot of theatrics to an audience of like no one, Like
- 1:55it's maybe the press gallery is watching, but like British Columbians aren't actually watching
- 1:59this debate right. The questions part of question period, I do think is
- 2:04an important part of the political process. It's part of our Westminster system.
- 2:07But you know, to your point about theater, I'd say when I was
- 2:10first elected, I'm a newly elected MLA just from twenty twenty, but early
- 2:15on I would say it was almost exclusively theatrics, a loud and voisterous but
- 2:22I would see my colleagues motion across the way to let folks know any question
- 2:27was coming their way or they wanted to connect outside. You know. But
- 2:32that feeling has changed for me quite a bit in the last little bit.
- 2:37So how so like explain it to me. Well, I moved from the
- 2:40kind of backdeep corner up front when I became a minister, and I would
- 2:46say that what we have now is nastier. I've seen a rise in the
- 2:52personal attacks, in the interruptions. I felt a change in question period,
- 2:57and I think, you know, there's work for all of us us to
- 3:00do in this political system and in how we engage with each other. But
- 3:04I've seen a bit of a change in tone since Kevin Falcon became leader and
- 3:08came in the House. And you know, it does matter. Maybe not
- 3:14everybody's watching question period, maybe nobody's watching question period, but it is the
- 3:19part of our political process that people see most often. It's what makes news
- 3:23clips, for example. And you know who is watching every day. There
- 3:28are school groups of kids that come through and I look up at them and
- 3:30they're kind of wide eyed because there we are on the ground of the legislature,
- 3:37banging our desks and yelling and interrupting things that would never fly in classrooms
- 3:42or on the play guard. Yeah never, And so like, I understand
- 3:45your complaints. And obviously the opposition I think will naturally have a proclivity towards
- 3:50being aggressive because they're the ones asking the questions. But then at the same
- 3:53time, I've seen opposition MLAs also say you know what, it's also kind
- 3:57of nasty on this end, and sometimes they feel like they're treated unfairly.
- 4:00So I see, you know, an opportunity for bipartisanship to maybe make things
- 4:05more productive. And so why isn't there a push to say, okay,
- 4:10maybe we'll change some rules, maybe you can't bang on the desk, maybe
- 4:13you can't I don't know, interrupt a minister when they're giving an answer,
- 4:16like why isn't there a push to make it better? You know? I
- 4:19think question prood can be better, can be more productive, and when questions
- 4:24are asked in a meaningful, well intentioned way, I do think we see
- 4:28answers that are meaningful and well intentioned. You know. There was an example
- 4:31this session where a member of the bcup asked a question about ICBC driver test
- 4:39being made available in Ukrainian, letting the House know that his constituents and others
- 4:44around the province from Ukraine, we're taking a test in Russian, of all
- 4:48languages, right, And when that question was asked, it got a serious
- 4:53answer from the Minister of Public Safety and the issue got solved. So there
- 4:57are spaces that it happens. Why I think there's not a more concerted effort
- 5:03in that direction, I think is it. You know, it's part of
- 5:08how that place runs, and we've all just kind of accepted it as part
- 5:14of it. And there's name calling and yelling, and I do think,
- 5:17you know, political leadership is really important in tone setting, you know,
- 5:20and me raising one particular example of it is how we started having this conversation
- 5:26and when to call it out when it goes from spirited debate to unproductive and
- 5:30across the line. You know, I think we have to call it out.
- 5:33But Minister Laura, I think you're absolutely right. But you know that
- 5:36there's going to be people at home watching this being being like you're in government
- 5:40you can actually change things and maybe reach out to the other side, or
- 5:45don't reach out to the other side and say, hey, you know what,
- 5:46we're going to do things differently. Now, why aren't you doing that?
- 5:49Then? For me personally, it's a conversation I'm having all the time
- 5:54with my colleagues. I do think we have a you know, a new
- 5:57generation of MLA's, especially in our caucus. This is a chance to look
- 6:00at this challenge and think about doing it differently. And you know, I
- 6:05know that opposition parties are more likely to you know, you know, be
- 6:13in those spaces using the tools available to them, let's say, in question
- 6:15period is a tool, sure, you know. But I'm a at heart
- 6:18a nerdy political scientist, former university instructor, and the numbers and the evidence
- 6:25of this, I think matter. And so I looked at it, and
- 6:29there they interrupted three hundred and seventy one times in the last session, enough
- 6:33to get captured by handsward five times as much. There's room as on our
- 6:40side. There's room and need for all of us to do it. And
- 6:42I really hope that this conversation is part of how we start moving towards thinking
- 6:47what is acceptable and what isn't absolutely really quickly is part of the allure getting
- 6:54in that great rhetorical dunk. And I think anyone who's certainly being on Twitter,
- 6:59I can only imagine what it's like being in that battle rap environment of
- 7:01question period. I feel like maybe that thrill is almost too much for me,
- 7:08not I think. I think yes, And there's an energy at the
- 7:15time of question period. The rest of the day doesn't look like that.
- 7:19I think there's an energy to it. There's some commandery, commandery to it
- 7:25um. But for me, you know, especially when we think about a
- 7:29place that is productive and inclusive, it doesn't hit them. Mark Absolutely,
- 7:33Grace, thank you so much for your time. I really do appreciate it
- 7:35and keep up the good work in the BC Ledge and in Question period.
- 7:40Thanks so much, absolutely, folks. She is BC's Minister of State for
- 7:44Childcare, Grace Lore big thank you to Shelter Points, Single Malt Whiskey for
- 7:47supporting local conversations and local content. Now up next, a new poll says
- 7:53that young Canadian adults want socialism, but is that what they actually want?
- 7:57And even if it is, can we fault them? In twenty twenty three,
- 8:01We'll take a moment Up next,