Latest / Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano / The 1619 Project Strikes Again—This Time, It’s Education
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Old School,
- 0:06New School, Next School with Dom Giordano,
- 0:08a podcast devoted to shedding light on issues pertaining to making America smart again.
- 0:15These include, among many topics,
- 0:17school choice and parental rights.
- 0:19This podcast is dedicated to reversing the deeply disturbing trend known as the dumbing down of America.
- 0:27And now,
- 0:28here's your host,
- 0:29educator.
- 0:30and noted talk media commentator,
- 0:32Dom Giordano.
- 0:35Hey, everyone.
- 0:36Welcome in to this week's edition of Old School,
- 0:39New School, Next School with Dom Giordano.
- 0:42And boy, do we have a cause célèbre this week.
- 0:45Let me identify for you a little bit more fully than you might know.
- 0:50If you've never heard of the 1619 Project,
- 0:54the 1619 Project in a nutshell is a concoction of the New York Times.
- 1:00and a woman named Nikole Hannah-Jones.
- 1:04The 1619 Project alleges that we had the Revolutionary War,
- 1:10that America revolted against Great Britain because we were invested in slavery.
- 1:16We were not going to give it up.
- 1:18And the Brits had determined at that point in history,
- 1:21think about this, you didn't learn this in school, I hope, that they were going to give up on slavery.
- 1:27Now, none of this is factual.
- 1:29It's concocted.
- 1:30There's not a shred of evidence to it.
- 1:33But as a result of this and the push of the New York Times,
- 1:37this woman,
- 1:38Nikole Hannah-Jones,
- 1:39has become not only incredibly wealthy, but an authority, celebrated all over the place.
- 1:45And the book,
- 1:46The 1619 Project,
- 1:48in fact, I billed this week's Old School, New School, Next School, that The 1619 Project strikes again.
- 1:55It has struck once with all this misinformation trying to diminish the great
- 2:00revolutionary war, the foundation of this country,
- 2:03along with Howard Zinn's book, The People's History of the United States.
- 2:07These two are as big as fake news as you're going to find anywhere.
- 2:11But she's in the news because at the height of this celebrity, as it was gaining for her,
- 2:17she argued with her husband and she talks about it in a long article,
- 2:22where else this past week in the New York Times.
- 2:24Her headline was,
- 2:27in fighting for every black child,
- 2:29did I betray my own?
- 2:31So Nikole Hannah-Jones decided she was going to,
- 2:36at least she's not a liar,
- 2:38and let me make,
- 2:39this is one of the big points each week on old school,
- 2:42new school,
- 2:42next school,
- 2:43when it comes to progress on school choice.
- 2:47And let me just give you a nugget that's come out this week before I move forward with celebrities
- 2:53and people on the left and progressives and teachers and teachers unions.
- 2:58Many,
- 2:59many of them.
- 3:00It's hard to get an exact percentage,
- 3:02but somewhere in the 75 to 80 percent,
- 3:04they're not sending their kids to these bad public schools.
- 3:07They either go to a magnet school or they go to a top flight charter school,
- 3:13probably not so much a charter or a private school.
- 3:16She did the very same thing.
- 3:19So it came out this week.
- 3:21We're starting to get an analysis.
- 3:23of the numbers,
- 3:24of that money coming from the big, beautiful bill.
- 3:28And the number that is startling this week,
- 3:31and it depends on if your governor,
- 3:33wherever that governor might be, my governor,
- 3:35Josh Shapiro, has not signed it yet. He's weaseling all over the place.
- 3:39It could be $20 billion injected into school choice in one year.
- 3:46You know how it works.
- 3:48You can take up to $1,700 off your federal income tax.
- 3:53by contributing the 1700 to nonprofits that will be dispensing then the school
- 4:00choice money in the states thus we're not taking away money for the public schools in fact
- 4:05they're probably going to get some of this it is revolutionary that 20 billion dollars
- 4:12around there is about 25 percent of what the federal government spends every year on k-12 education in
- 4:20America.
- 4:21Think of that nugget for a moment.
- 4:23In one fell swoop,
- 4:25we are freeing up.
- 4:28You know, this is not a piddling sum,
- 4:29the $20 billion to be dispensed.
- 4:32How many people will this liberate? We always want more, but it's a start.
- 4:37So as that number came down this week,
- 4:40I'm thinking of Nikole Hannah-Jones.
- 4:43She put her child in what she said she thought was part of it was it was overwhelmingly minority black.
- 4:51She's black.
- 4:52But it was also substandard.
- 4:54People were not doing well. She hoped to revolutionize that by seeing school change there by other people following her model.
- 5:04Yes, she did betray her child.
- 5:06And again, as I said, the credit is she's not a phony.
- 5:10She'd at least sent her kid to.
- 5:11She's a big anti-school choice person.
- 5:15So you would think,
- 5:16after going through this, here's what happened with her child, who apparently is very bright.
- 5:21She was getting all A's in math.
- 5:24But when the child started to balk at how bad this school was, as far as fights,
- 5:32as far as teachers and principals almost never showing up, all those things. By the way, this is one of the best funded elementary
- 5:41schools in the world.
- 5:44We'll get to the funding debate coming up.
- 5:47That teachers there,
- 5:50Teachers Union in New York,
- 5:51the scale reaches $140,000 for a 180-day work year.
- 5:56Yeah,
- 5:57you do the math.
- 5:58That's not $1,000 a day, but we're getting pretty close,
- 6:01right?
- 6:03It spent this PS 307,
- 6:06where her child was sent,
- 6:08spent over $50,000 per
- 6:11student per year,
- 6:13an amount equivalent to private school tuition in some of the priciest, even in New York or in the country.
- 6:20They were spending that,
- 6:22but they are a failure across the board.
- 6:25And what happened to her daughter, who was bright and was being told she had A’s, she was doing well in math,
- 6:30when they asked to see the homework corrected and all that, they didn't do any of that.
- 6:38And the daughter then balked at all this, seeing what she saw every day.
- 6:43And ultimately,
- 6:44when they moved her to a better school,
- 6:46which they could have done in the beginning,
- 6:48she learned she didn't even know algebra,
- 6:52let alone anything else.
- 6:53So she moved to higher grade. She had no knowledge of any of this. It wasn't ever taught.
- 6:58So what would you say? This is a cautionary tale,
- 7:02a tale being told that's a grabber.
- 7:05What do we learn from this? Well, let's talk first about what did Nikole Hannah-Jones,
- 7:13what did she learn from it?
- 7:16Or what didn't she learn from it?
- 7:18The only question she seems to have is,
- 7:21was she lost in her own ideology?
- 7:24Yes.
- 7:25That she was trying to save so many black children.
- 7:29She betrayed her own. The answer is yes.
- 7:32But the lesson she didn't learn.
- 7:35Think about it.
- 7:35just for a moment here in old school, new school, next school.
- 7:38What about these thousands and thousands of parents who don't have the means and don't have the connections?
- 7:46And she's supposed to be an authority of all these things with the 1619 Project and all of her hookups.
- 7:53What are they supposed to do?
- 7:55Yet she adamantly is still anti-school choice,
- 8:00still wants to not give the choice.
- 8:03So has she been asked
- 8:05No,
- 8:06she doesn't do interviews on this.
- 8:07The question I would ask, you know what I would ask, you've listened to the podcast and maybe you heard me on radio.
- 8:12All right, what is your remedy?
- 8:14What is your remedy,
- 8:16Nikole Hannah-Jones, for this?
- 8:18And her answer,
- 8:20people like The View and others just skip right past this, of course, is more resources.
- 8:26She knows, or she should know, and some in the media not reporting,
- 8:31$50,000 a year is not enough.
- 8:34That's one of the highest
- 8:37in the world.
- 8:39So this fraudulent notion,
- 8:41the public schools will get so much better if they just have more money.
- 8:45How do we make that stand up with the experience of Nikole Hannah-Jones’s child?
- 8:51And the answer is, it doesn't.
- 8:54So she learned nothing from this as far as the lesson of maybe,
- 9:01maybe you're not going to reform these public schools.
- 9:05as easily as you think.
- 9:07There's not going to be this groundswell, these injection of people or whatever,
- 9:10sacrificing your child on this altar.
- 9:14As I said,
- 9:16it's not phony,
- 9:17but it's narcissistic.
- 9:19In other words,
- 9:20so wedded to her ideology,
- 9:23her belief system, as far left as it is, that she would throw the child into this,
- 9:30blinded, if you will,
- 9:32by how disastrous this was.
- 9:34any kind of cursory check would have told you that with this school.
- 9:39The lesson should be that we are seeing with the teachers unions covering for people like the teachers and principals in this school. They had enough resources.
- 9:51And then people this week started to do a breakdown about what happens with teachers in New York who are substandard even by these New York Post reporting.
- 10:04Removing a teacher requires a just-cause hearing, a process that routinely drags on for years and costs the city hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- 10:14Ratings, evaluations,
- 10:16and discipline are all governed by a contract negotiated with, wait for it, the teachers union,
- 10:22whose entire purpose is to make sure no one is fired no matter what.
- 10:26The proof is less than a mile away from the daughter's school.
- 10:31Community Roots Charter School sits at the edge of another
- 10:34Public Housing Project services mostly low-income Black and Hispanic students like the school that Nikole Hannah-Jones sent her daughter to.
- 10:43Its students post proficiency rates above 80% on state tests.
- 10:4991% of kids attend at least 90% of the time.
- 10:54But it spends roughly half of what PS 307 spends per student.
- 11:00No wonder admission must be managed via random lottery.
- 11:04due to overwhelming demand.
- 11:07Beautiful job by the New York Post. So here we have the school,
- 11:11public school. Why not send your daughter to a charter school? That's still a public school. Oh, no, no,
- 11:16no.
- 11:16That's a purity test.
- 11:17I'm not sending my kids to one of those charter schools.
- 11:20It's a mile away,
- 11:22maybe,
- 11:23from this completely failing school.
- 11:26It only remains open if parents want to go there.
- 11:29Overwhelming demand.
- 11:30You heard the test scores that I told you.
- 11:32This is warfare.
- 11:34that's going on with these teachers unions.
- 11:37That's where we are.
- 11:39And the lesson here to make America smart again,
- 11:42MASA—Make America Smart Again,
- 11:44and school choice,
- 11:45they go hand in hand.
- 11:47So she's not a hypocrite.
- 11:50This story blew up because the 1619 project is so toxic,
- 11:56the damage that it's done.
- 11:58And this woman is so insufferable,
- 12:00her success around this fraud,
- 12:03that people then really started to investigate.
- 12:06So there's a silver lining.
- 12:08The silver lining,
- 12:10it brought into sharp contrast.
- 12:12How in the world are we allowing this nonsense?
- 12:15And why wouldn't this influential person go,
- 12:18hmm,
- 12:19you know what?
- 12:20Thought I was doing the right thing.
- 12:22Okay.
- 12:22What about I met these parents and others who can't come anywhere near the resources?
- 12:31What are they supposed to do?
- 12:33Well,
- 12:34if you write the 1619 Project,
- 12:37you're not interested in that.
- 12:38You know what the answer is deep down. Any rational person knows what it is, and we're going to succeed at that, and we're going to succeed big time in January.
- 12:46That's freeing up as many kids as quickly they and their parents from these rotten public schools.
- 12:52They're rotten not because of poverty or not spending enough on whatever.
- 12:57They're rotten because of things like the teachers'
- 13:00union scandal that went on here.
- 13:01Now,
- 13:02one other part of this week for me, Dom Giordano with you on Old School, New School, Next School,
- 13:07that you might find intriguing,
- 13:10and I'll give you some of them off the top of my head, and particularly the third one,
- 13:14because it's an addendum to last week's show, and then I have a little bit of sound here at the end to play you.
- 13:21Well, let me play it right now so I don't forget.
- 13:23This Regents test,
- 13:24standardized test you had to pass to get out of high school,
- 13:28essentially,
- 13:29in New York.
- 13:30Here's the three people I'm talking about. I'm sure they think they're well-meaning people.
- 13:35There's a hint,
- 13:36too,
- 13:36here.
- 13:37Well,
- 13:38the one commentator that sits on the Regents board,
- 13:41that may be minority children,
- 13:43black and Latino.
- 13:44This is not their natural thing to take standardized tests.
- 13:48Here's how it sounded.
- 13:49New York inspires.
- 13:51It's extremely inspiring.
- 13:54I am so thrilled that all New York State students will now be able to demonstrate their competency,
- 14:00which I know is the expectation in a manner that showcases their strengths.
- 14:04Yes.
- 14:05And I think that it's very important for people to understand because there have been certain comments that have been made that I completely disagree with that are we dumbing down the ability for students?
- 14:13Quite the opposite.
- 14:15Absolutely.
- 14:15It's giving the,
- 14:17I know maybe you've seen the cartoon where you have a fish climb a tree,
- 14:20where you don't assess a fish on climb a tree because fish can't climb trees,
- 14:24right?
- 14:25That's right.
- 14:25So I am so thrilled about this.
- 14:27I just want to put it out there and say my question is answered and I will give my time back.
- 14:31you. Thank you.
- 14:32I'm going to remember that one.
- 14:36All right. As I said,
- 14:38imagine a fish in a tree and going, oh,
- 14:40that's a good one.
- 14:41I'll have to write that down.
- 14:43These are the people in charge in New York.
- 14:45What hope do these kids have?
- 14:47If New York follows what Philadelphia did,
- 14:50you're going to see them say you can submit a portfolio or watch a video online.
- 14:56In Philadelphia,
- 14:57They gave kids credit who couldn't pass.
- 15:01They gave them credit,
- 15:02all in the state constitution are claiming now, the state laws,
- 15:06for ladder safety.
- 15:09In other words,
- 15:10how to be safe on a ladder, put a ladder away, a step ladder, an hour.
- 15:14They probably didn't even watch it, but as long as they sat in the room, I guess they gave them credit for that and a million other courses like that.
- 15:22How are those kids graduating?
- 15:24What are they going to do in the world?
- 15:26And the answer is not much.
- 15:29So with this situation in New York,
- 15:33this cries out for what's going to start to break in January.
- 15:38Well,
- 15:39Pennsylvania,
- 15:39where I am,
- 15:40if Governor Shapiro won't do this, I'm told it could be a billion dollars he's leaving on the table,
- 15:46a billion dollars to free up kids.
- 15:50Why is it even in doubt? Because he wants to be president and the teachers union is going to hold him to it.
- 15:55So last week on Old School, New School,
- 15:58we talked about an antidote to all this stuff,
- 16:01even happening in the public schools.
- 16:03And that antidote is what's called the Mississippi Miracle.
- 16:08By using phonics,
- 16:10by saying a kid has to read by the end of third grade or they're going to be left back,
- 16:14by having literacy coaches,
- 16:17by not having teachers unions, they have collective bargaining associations,
- 16:22but they don't have the power of the teachers unions to try to
- 16:25blunt learning.
- 16:26Mississippi has gone from worst to almost first in the entire country.
- 16:32But there's one fly in the ointment.
- 16:34This week,
- 16:35a website that puts out data points took a look at proficiency scores, things of that nature, raw data,
- 16:43about America's school districts.
- 16:46And they put up the 50 worst school districts in America.
- 16:51No surprise to me,
- 16:53Detroit,
- 16:53Michigan was number one.
- 16:55No surprise to me,
- 16:57Baltimore was number two.
- 16:59Philadelphia, where I am,
- 17:01fraudulent as they are,
- 17:02is number six.
- 17:04But we're right behind Cleveland.
- 17:07Well,
- 17:07we're ahead of Cleveland in that we're not as bad.
- 17:10In third place was Jackson,
- 17:13Mississippi.
- 17:14Whoa,
- 17:14whoa, whoa,
- 17:15Mississippi miracle.
- 17:17Jackson, Mississippi.
- 17:18So the Wall Street Journal is aware of this. They did a good job breaking it down.
- 17:23Here's their analysis and it's mine.
- 17:25We have the Mississippi miracle,
- 17:28but once you get past those early grades,
- 17:32they say maybe by fifth grade or something like that, Mississippi rejected school choice.
- 17:40And what happens is all the intensity and focus that's going on to get those kids to read and be proficient and all that,
- 17:48it dissipates.
- 17:49So the Wall Street Journal says we don't need just the Mississippi miracle.
- 17:53We now need the Mississippi
- 17:55Moonshot.
- 17:56Meaning even Mississippi,
- 17:58which I've been touting, wow,
- 18:01look at what they did here.
- 18:03Why in the world would they knock down school choice?
- 18:08Now,
- 18:09just an instinct. I think some of them are saying that,
- 18:12well, we knocked it down because we're already doing great. What more do you want, Giordano?
- 18:16Not so when you get into the later grades.
- 18:19I'll develop this more in the future.
- 18:21But the 50 worst school districts,
- 18:23Newark's in the top 10,
- 18:25Cleveland,
- 18:26as I said,
- 18:27Jackson,
- 18:28Mississippi,
- 18:28which according to news reports is incredibly dangerous also.
- 18:32It is very,
- 18:33very troubling how these things work.
- 18:38And it is amazing to me that this continues to go on.
- 18:45Just stunning.
- 18:47But help is coming.
- 18:48Help is around the corner.
- 18:50Make America smart again.
- 18:52School choice is exactly what we need.
- 18:55in addition to the good work they've done with the Mississippi Miracle.
- 18:58So as we close this week's edition,
- 19:00this Nikole Hannah-Jones,
- 19:04cautionary tale.
- 19:06The message is school choice is the only thing that's going to break through.
- 19:11You're not going to break through with these teachers unions,
- 19:13these schools.
- 19:14You're just not going to do it in a place like New York.
- 19:18Send me an email if you have a question or comment.
- 19:45domshow@aol.com.