Latest / Politics with Paul / Connecting Historical Thinkers to the Present w/ Crom Carmichael | Politics with Paul #65
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Racking up another guest episode today, and for those who are new to the show, I always lead
- 0:14guest episodes regardless of who it is with a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:18against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:22Although it sounds cliche, it is true that those who do not know history are condemned to
- 0:29repeat the mistakes of the past.
- 0:31But it's not just about the errors and faults of the past.
- 0:34We sometimes forget to look at the positives of history and how we can apply them to today,
- 0:39especially in the face of daunting challenges in politics.
- 0:42So what positive historical lessons and thinkers can we look to for guidance in trying
- 0:48political times?
- 0:50How do we apply those lessons?
- 0:52Well, that's what my guest Kram Carmichael is here to talk about today.
- 0:56Krom is an entrepreneur, investor, and the cohost of the From Our Generation podcast.
- 1:02His experience includes co owning a multi state sporting goods enterprise, investing in over 60
- 1:07startups, and being a talk show panelist.
- 1:09But more relevantly for this interview, he co founded Knowledge Products, which produces
- 1:14audio programs on some of the most influential thinkers in history, including the company's
- 1:19Giants of Political Thought series, GOPT.
- 1:22So let's talk about these giants of political thought and what they can teach us about
- 1:27today's challenges.
- 1:28Please welcome Crom Carmichael to the show.
- 1:30Thank you for being on, Crom.
- 1:32How are you?
- 1:32Paul, I'm doing fine, and thanks for that nice introduction.
- 1:37Yeah.
- 1:37Absolutely.
- 1:38And I really appreciate you being here.
- 1:40So I like to start with guests by going back in time a bit.
- 1:44It's not maybe not quite the beginning, but sort of the the genesis of a lot of what we're
- 1:49talking about today.
- 1:50So what got you into making content like giants of political thought, and why make GOPT
- 1:56specifically?
- 1:57Okay.
- 1:58Well, that's a great question.
- 1:59And I'm gonna I'm gonna tell you a little story about myself.
- 2:03In 1979, we we did as you mentioned in the introduction, we were in the sporting goods
- 2:10distribution business, and we had a good business.
- 2:14We were Converse athletic shoe distributors.
- 2:17So Converse would sell Us shoes at a wholesale price.
- 2:21We would warehouse them in Columbus and we would sell them to retailers, in an 11 state,
- 2:27territory.
- 2:28And this was in the late seventies, and throughout the, 1980s.
- 2:32And it was a good business.
- 2:33Converse was a very, very popular brand.
- 2:36And, so so it was a good run for us.
- 2:39But in 1979, and you and I can look at you and I can tell you're too young to remember 1979,
- 2:46but in 1979, interest rates were 20 And we were borrowing $4,000,000 at the bank.
- 2:52And in 1979, dollars 4,000,000 would be the equivalent of about 12 to $14,000,000 today.
- 2:59And we were paying 20% in interest.
- 3:02But Converse would increase the price of their shoes every 90, three to 4%, which meant that
- 3:10the value of our inventory every ninety days went up three or 4%.
- 3:15The shoes that we had on order at the previous price went up in value even before we got them.
- 3:22And so the price increases, that, that that passed through our inventory more than covered
- 3:29the the very high interest rates we were paying at the bank.
- 3:32But it still seemed like a very, very strange period to me.
- 3:36And I didn't think it was sustainable.
- 3:38I was 31.
- 3:39And I read a brochure about a conference in New Orleans called the International Conference on
- 3:44Monetary Reform.
- 3:46And I read about all these things I would learn if I attended that conference.
- 3:50And it was all about here we are having this tumultuous economy, all these fears about
- 3:55hyperinflation and massive deflation and all these different things.
- 3:58And if I'd just come to this conference, I would hear I would learn, about what was going
- 4:04to happen, and I could then use that.
- 4:06So I said, well, that's it's in New Orleans.
- 4:08That's a neat city.
- 4:10The the, speakers, the list of speakers, it it lasted four days.
- 4:14There were 30 to 40 speakers, and I listened every one of them.
- 4:18And, and the first one got up and said something like, we we're gonna have
- 4:22hyperinflation.
- 4:23Here's why, and here's what you should do.
- 4:25And after that speaker sat down, I said, boy, that is a compelling argument.
- 4:30I better prepare.
- 4:31The very next speaker got up and said, we're gonna have massive deflation.
- 4:34Here's why, and here's what you should do.
- 4:37And after that speaker sat down, I said, man, that's a compelling argument.
- 4:40I better prepare.
- 4:42The third one would get up and say, we're not gonna have this.
- 4:44We're not gonna have that.
- 4:45We're going to return to the norm.
- 4:48Here's why and here's what you should do.
- 4:50And I said, man, that's a compelling argument.
- 4:52I better prepare.
- 4:53Well, at the end of all that, the lady that I eventually married and is still my wife of
- 4:58thirty seven years, She said, well, baby doll Congrats.
- 5:02Well, thank you.
- 5:02She said, well, baby doll, what'd you learn from all those speakers?
- 5:05I said, I learned that I am profoundly ignorant.
- 5:08And she says, oh, no, you're smart.
- 5:10And I said, well, that's debatable.
- 5:12But whether I'm ignorant or not is not debatable.
- 5:15And she said she said, well, why do you say that?
- 5:17I said, well, I've heard three different predictions of the future that and and all
- 5:23three are very different than the other two.
- 5:26Logic tells me that one of those three is gonna be closer to the truth than the other two, and
- 5:31I do not have a clue which one that is.
- 5:35That is the definition of ignorance.
- 5:38And so I became a student at that moment, that weekend.
- 5:41If I hadn't had that happen in a three day period, I don't think I mean, it was a life
- 5:45changing experience for me.
- 5:47And so for the next five years, I became a student, self taught student of economics, and
- 5:53by reading a lot of their newsletters and then also building a worldview on what creates
- 5:58inflation, what creates prosperity, what creates all kinds of different things in the
- 6:04economic world, but you cannot separate you cannot separate those things from politics.
- 6:10You can't separate them, frankly, from religion and philosophy.
- 6:14And so and so from all this, I said, you know, there's a lot of things I wish I had learned in
- 6:19college, but I was too immature when I was in college to really to really want to learn learn
- 6:25about them.
- 6:26So I'm gonna create a series of audio programs on history's most influential thinkers because
- 6:32because now now time, their ideas have been tested by time.
- 6:37Not that they're necessarily good, but that they are influential.
- 6:41And that's key.
- 6:43So in the giants of political thought, we cover we cover John Locke.
- 6:47We cover the Federalist Papers.
- 6:49We cover the Declaration of Independence, but we also cover the communist manifesto.
- 6:53We cover the social contract.
- 6:56We cover Leviathan.
- 6:58And so we cover a whole range.
- 7:00We cover Machiavelli, the prince, Common Sense by Thomas Paine, Adam Smith, The Wealth of
- 7:06Nations.
- 7:08So these are audio programs that now are, if you go to thegiantspoliticalthought.com, you
- 7:15can see them.
- 7:15They're all listed there.
- 7:16If you buy them and then download the app so that they're available to you and up to four
- 7:22other devices.
- 7:23So if you want to share them with family members, can, but you also have access to the
- 7:28transcripts and you have access to questions so that you can then review the questions to see
- 7:34if you can't answer them.
- 7:36You probably ought to listen to the program again.
- 7:38But that's what started me on building that.
- 7:42And then we ended up building a number of other series.
- 7:45We ended up with 130 programs, but we've launched the first one that we've relaunched on
- 7:53our own streaming platform is the Giants of Political Thought.
- 7:57And so you kind of led into in the introduction our politics today.
- 8:03And our politics today are not well, they're different in some regard, but when we had the
- 8:10revolutionary war, the public was essentially divided into three categories.
- 8:16You had those people, you had about a third of them who wanted to have a sovereign country.
- 8:21They would be the hardcore revolutionaries.
- 8:24You had about a third who did not want to separate from Great Britain, from England.
- 8:30And and you had about a third who didn't know which way they leaned because it was a very
- 8:35serious, very serious question.
- 8:38But but the revolutionaries carried the day in the sense that they signed the declaration of
- 8:44independence.
- 8:45It got passed by Congress.
- 8:46And so at that point, we had formally declared our independence from Britain.
- 8:52And now the people who wanted to stick with Britain, they had to either side with Britain
- 8:58or they had to kind of run away and wait until the wait until the dust settled as it were.
- 9:05But then the revolutionary war was over.
- 9:08We won the war.
- 9:10We won our independence.
- 9:12And so the first thing that happened after that was we well, 13 colonies came together and
- 9:19drafted the articles of confederation.
- 9:22And in drafting the articles of confederation, it took them about about two or three months to
- 9:28draft the articles of confederation, and then it took two to three years to get them ratified
- 9:34by all 13 states, and then they lasted for five years and collapsed.
- 9:39And and so that's really it's I'm not sure.
- 9:42I would encourage any of your listeners who are interested in politics to go back and read
- 9:48Common Sense.
- 9:49It's not very long.
- 9:51If they don't want to read it, they can listen to our program on it, which covers almost the
- 9:54whole thing because it's a brochure.
- 9:57Read carefully the Declaration of Independence.
- 10:00I would even go read Thomas Jefferson's first draft of the Declaration of Independence, which
- 10:05is not what what was finally signed.
- 10:08And, and then I would read carefully the articles of confederation because when they
- 10:13were drafted, the people who drafted the articles of confederation thought that the
- 10:18articles of confederation would last for for a hundred years, and they collapsed in five
- 10:23years.
- 10:24And so there were so there were some serious, serious flaws in the articles of confederation.
- 10:30And and this gets into the seeds of what I think you probably spend a lot of your time
- 10:35thinking about in your course and whatnot, and that is what is the definition of how do you
- 10:40get to what people would generally would generally agree to is is good government?
- 10:46What is a good government?
- 10:48And, how get do to a good government?
- 10:51And the Federalist Papers go a long way toward, arguing all of the different points about how
- 10:58to organize a government and what are the risks of organizing a government in one particular
- 11:03way or organizing the government in another particular way.
- 11:07And what it really got down to is what is your belief in human nature?
- 11:14As Madison said, if all humans were angels, even need government.
- 11:21But since all humans are not angels, then you have to ask yourself, okay, well, if humans are
- 11:30not angels, then what are they?
- 11:34The answer to that is they vary.
- 11:37And some people lust for power.
- 11:40It does not take a very large number of people who lust for power to acquire power.
- 11:46So when our constitution was drafted, it was drafted with that notion in mind that we do not
- 11:56want it to make it easy.
- 11:58In fact, we want to make it as difficult as possible for a few people to acquire great
- 12:04power.
- 12:05And so that's why our constitution was drafted where you have, you have three branches of the
- 12:11federal government, but the constitution was drafted to greatly limit the powers of the
- 12:17government that is in Washington DC, whether it was the whether it's the congress, it's the
- 12:23president, or frankly, it's even the supreme court.
- 12:27The original constitution gave a great deal of power to the states and reserved a great deal
- 12:34of power to the states.
- 12:35And the reason for that was that if power was dispersed across a whole bunch of states, if
- 12:43somebody became a terrible, terrible governor, or if a small group of people took over a
- 12:49particular state, then the citizens of the state could simply move to another state.
- 12:55And so that would act as a check on bad government at the state level.
- 13:00And in fact now where do you live, Paul?
- 13:04I live in Florida, but hang on.
- 13:06Before we get more into this, it's kind of actually getting into the next question I
- 13:10want get into.
- 13:11I kind of want to set it up here.
- 13:13But no, no, you're good.
- 13:14You're good.
- 13:14But I mean, you do make obviously really great points.
- 13:18Even the articles of Confederation, even though we've obviously been it's been long since we've
- 13:23had those.
- 13:25When you look at the articles of Confederation, you can see why the founders did that.
- 13:30It was a very weak central government.
- 13:32All the power was in the states, but it went a little bit too much that way.
- 13:37Then that's why you have the US constitution.
- 13:39A lot of people who, despite the Articles flaws, Patrick Henry, still wanted to stick
- 13:43with the articles of confederation.
- 13:45It's really just a fascinating look.
- 13:46And even though that debate has been long settled, does really bring up a lot of
- 13:52questions we should be
- 13:53talking It has been long settled, but it's well worth discussing.
- 13:57Mean, so your point is your point is a great one.
- 14:02Yeah.
- 14:03And and speaking of that, I think for much of the public, historical figures, these debates
- 14:08that we're talking about, like The US founding fathers or the thinkers that influenced the
- 14:12founding fathers, like a Montesquieu or a Rousseau, their thinking seems to be esoteric
- 14:18for a lot of people and hard to learn.
- 14:20Now, some of it may be just people just aren't interested in it.
- 14:24Some of it is the way we teach it.
- 14:25So how do you make their philosophies accessible and approachable for regular people?
- 14:30I know you talked about how you have the CDs and the transcripts and everything, but how do
- 14:34you exactly break down what they believe for people to understand?
- 14:38Well, what we, what we do, and that's, I appreciate you asking me the question the way
- 14:41that you did.
- 14:42What we, what we did was we, we start with every thinker, every person like, like John
- 14:47Locke, for example, he wrote two treatises of government.
- 14:52And so we start by describing the times that he lived in.
- 14:59And it's very important for each of these thinkers to understand the circumstances that
- 15:06existed when they wrote the influential work that they wrote.
- 15:14Because at the time they were writing it, they had no idea that it would be as influential as
- 15:19it was.
- 15:20And and so for example, John Locke, when he wrote second the second treatise of government,
- 15:28when he did that, he actually wrote that under a false name because he believed, and I think
- 15:35it was other people at that time who were of his political and intellectual ilk.
- 15:42They were arrested and tried, and generally they were hung because of their because of
- 15:49their their arguments of of divine the the divine right of kings is a doctrine that is
- 15:55that is false.
- 15:57That that there is a direct in in case of John Locke, he argued there was a direct
- 16:02relationship between God and individuals.
- 16:05And when individuals are born and his, some of his language got into the declaration of
- 16:10independence that we are endowed by our creator with certain unalienable rights.
- 16:15Among those are life, liberty, and in case of Locke, he said property.
- 16:19Well, the idea that God would grant people property rights was an anathema to the king.
- 16:26Because the king had all the rights and didn't like it when somebody said they didn't,
- 16:31especially if they invoke the name of God to take away the king's rights to control all the
- 16:39property and all the people, and usually did so in conjunction with the church.
- 16:44And so this threatened both the church and the government.
- 16:48And John Locke, and we talk about all of the different little codes in the audio program.
- 16:57Listen to all these little codes and a lot of the things that he said would be sent to
- 17:03somebody in some funny little code about the baby been birthed and these different kinds of
- 17:09things.
- 17:10And the nurse has arrived and that the nurse was somebody with a particular person.
- 17:16It's actually quite strange, but, but you could get killed for advocating for individual for
- 17:24for liberty.
- 17:25You could get killed in those days.
- 17:27And so so John Locke's writings that did that then have now stood the test of time, they
- 17:33argue in favor of liberty and individual rights and property rights and, and limited
- 17:40government.
- 17:40Now at that same time was another person named Thomas Hobbs.
- 17:45And Thomas Hobbs was a political figure of great stature, and he wrote Leviathan.
- 17:51And, and and and his his argument was that if human beings are left to their own devices,
- 17:58it'll be, all against all.
- 18:00It'll be a state of what he what he called a state of nature, which which was a state of of
- 18:05sheer violence.
- 18:06And so it required government, and it might even require an extremely strong and powerful
- 18:12and oppressive government to keep people from killing each other.
- 18:15And so you had two people who existed at the same time who both were, well, in the case of
- 18:22Hobbes, he was a very powerful statesman.
- 18:26In the case of John Locke, he was a very powerful philosopher, one who had to keep his
- 18:31head down.
- 18:33And so we cover all this in our programs.
- 18:36We cover their lives.
- 18:37We cover what was going on at the time so that you get a context.
- 18:40It's very important when somebody has an idea to understand the context in which for their
- 18:47idea.
- 18:49And Machiavelli is another one because everybody thinks that he was this conniving
- 18:55kind of guy and he really wasn't.
- 18:57What he was concerned about was that Italy, during his lifetime, Italy was a bunch of city
- 19:03states.
- 19:04And there were these large, very powerful tribes from the North that he was convinced
- 19:09that if Italy didn't unite and become a nation, that, that the hordes from the North would
- 19:15descend and, destroy Italy.
- 19:18And so he wrote the prince hoping that the Di Medici family, which was, was the most powerful
- 19:24family in Italy and controlled a large area, that the Di Medici family would read the prints
- 19:33and then say, gee whiz, we need to have a strong nation.
- 19:37But it turned out that that didn't happen.
- 19:39And a few a couple of decades later, Rome was sacked.
- 19:43And, and what took a thousand years to build was destroyed in about ninety days.
- 19:50So it was so, Machiavelli was right, but the book, the Prince didn't come out.
- 19:56It wasn't published until after that.
- 19:59And so, so his theories on how to acquire political power were really designed in his
- 20:07mind for the Domenicius to acquire political power to protect the country or the area that
- 20:12was Italy.
- 20:14And so and but it's a very it's very devious.
- 20:18In other words, Machiavelli said, this is how you acquire power, and it's well worth reading
- 20:23for people who are interested in politics today because his ideas of how to acquire power and
- 20:29how to keep power are, you know, they're, they're still very much a topic of discussion
- 20:34today.
- 20:35So what we do in every one of our programs is we provide a lot of historical context as well
- 20:41as the important passages from the programs.
- 20:45And then, as I said, for somebody who wants to be a real student, they can then read the
- 20:50transcripts because they're right there and they're part of it.
- 20:55Yeah.
- 20:56That that whole part about context is always so I mean, context in general is always such a
- 21:01critical part of of setting up anything, even if you're talking about I think it kind of also
- 21:05goes back to the whole difference between justifying something and understanding
- 21:12something.
- 21:12Like, if we talk about the founding fathers, for example, a lot of obviously tremendous
- 21:18contributions they've made to our political thought of today and a lot of ideas that we
- 21:24should take from them.
- 21:26Sometimes, though, it is kind of counterintuitive or hypocritical to the fact
- 21:31that some of them were slave owners, for example.
- 21:33Sure.
- 21:33You're not justifying that, but you are also understanding why they thought the way they
- 21:39did.
- 21:39It was a very common thing at that time.
- 21:41But it's it's also the same thing with you talk about Machiavelli, for example, and John Locke
- 21:47and and Hobbs.
- 21:49And so, it is such a great point to make about that because sometimes we kind of pick and
- 21:55choose when we want to know the context if we're trying to criticize somebody or not.
- 22:00You can apply the same thing to today when you know, you need to look at the context of why
- 22:05people are saying the things they do.
- 22:07So I I think that's that's that's a great point to make, and it really does help people
- 22:12understand more.
- 22:13So with that being said, that's how you guys make it more approachable and accessible.
- 22:19So I imagine that part of why you made GOPT was that you have some concerns or gripes about how
- 22:26these thinkers and their philosophers are taught.
- 22:29Correct me if I'm wrong on that.
- 22:30But if that's the case and regardless of whether that's the case, what are two to three
- 22:35things that we could do to teach these things better in schools and for continuing education
- 22:40for adults who may have not had a robust education in schools?
- 22:44Well, first of all, you have to, at least in my case, it wasn't until I literally had that
- 22:52weekend in, in New Orleans that I realized how ignorant I was.
- 22:57And when I say, when I say I was ignorant, that was that hit me like a, like a thunderbolt,
- 23:03that I said, my gosh, I've just heard three different scenarios of the future.
- 23:07And I don't have a clue which one's right.
- 23:09And one of them is more right than the other two.
- 23:11And that's when you, and when you, when you, when you, when you come to that conclusion so
- 23:16quickly, it's a scary moment.
- 23:19It really was.
- 23:20And then I started realizing that when I was in college and I'm sure there's some many college
- 23:26students who don't waste their time in college.
- 23:29But I think there are also a lot of college students who who decide that a liberal the
- 23:33liberal arts part of college is not necessary anymore because a lot of people say, well, it's
- 23:38it's old timey.
- 23:39Most of them, you know, some of them were wrote during the times of slavery, so therefore their
- 23:44ideas aren't valuable, aren't even worth knowing.
- 23:47And so I don't think that our constitution, don't think that federalist papers, I don't
- 23:59think that I think there are many, many things that are no longer even taught.
- 24:03So so and and if they are taught, I'm not sure that they're taught in a way that is inspires
- 24:10people to understand how our constitutional republic, first of all, was designed to work.
- 24:18And it doesn't work the way it was designed to work.
- 24:20And that was well after slavery was over that the period of time for me that when I look back
- 24:29and say, when did it change?
- 24:30It would be during Franklin Roosevelt during the depression.
- 24:35Because most people think because it's been told over and over again that Franklin
- 24:38Roosevelt got us out of the depression, and that's false.
- 24:42He didn't get us out of the depression.
- 24:44World War II got us out of the depression.
- 24:46He prolonged the depression for ten years.
- 24:49From 1932 to 1942, we stayed in a depression.
- 24:53And in fact, in 1937 to '39, we had a serious relapse.
- 25:01And that's because his policies that he adopted in 1933 after he was elected in '32, he
- 25:11dramatically increased the size and power of the federal government, and he increased the
- 25:16top marginal tax rate from 25% to 94%.
- 25:21The average person's taxes went from 10% to 40%.
- 25:25Well, I will promise you no country in the history of the world has ever taxed its way to
- 25:30prosperity.
- 25:32And, but Roosevelt wanted to, he wanted to create a jobs program and he and he wanted to
- 25:38try to he wanted to try at least to balance the budget.
- 25:42So the only way he could create a massive federal jobs program was to dramatically raise
- 25:47taxes.
- 25:49And after six years of that, went back into another depression.
- 25:54It was the depression of 'thirty seven through 'thirty nine.
- 25:59World War II did two things.
- 26:03One is we borrowed a great deal of money to build out, to take our industrial base and turn
- 26:10it into a war making machine.
- 26:13And then the second world war destroyed Germany, Britain, destroyed Japan.
- 26:22So so all of the manufacturing facilities essentially in the in the in the world except
- 26:29in The United States were destroyed by the war.
- 26:32And so if anybody wanted capital goods to rebuild their factories, they had to buy the
- 26:37capital goods from The US, which right after the war, exploded.
- 26:42But the other thing, and this, I don't want to get too far off top so you can rein me in here.
- 26:47The the one thing that Roosevelt did that that affects us today is that at the towards the end
- 26:53of his life before the war was completely over, he had put in wage and price controls and
- 27:00business people went to Roosevelt and said, Mr.
- 27:02President, if you want to keep price controls on, that's okay, but we're making very nice
- 27:08profits and we'd like to give our employees a pay raise.
- 27:11Will you take off wage controls?
- 27:14And Roosevelt said, no, the wage controls will remain, but I will allow you to pay for their
- 27:21healthcare and I will let you deduct it.
- 27:25And that was the birth of the third party payment system.
- 27:29And the third party payment system is now grown to be a $5,000,000,000,000 a year system that
- 27:34has all kinds of special interests who want to maintain that system.
- 27:41We spend $15,000 per person now on healthcare per year.
- 27:48So for a family of four, that means we're spending an average of $60,000 Well, where's
- 27:53that money going?
- 27:55It's going to the third party payment system, not the providers.
- 27:5960% of the cost of that 5,000,000,000,000, 60% is the payment system.
- 28:05It's the insurance companies.
- 28:07It's the it's the price fixers.
- 28:10It's the it's the drug.
- 28:11It's not the pharmaceutical companies per se.
- 28:14It's the it's the the benefits managers, the pharmacy benefits managers, the PBMs.
- 28:21And that's a whole another topic, but but our our health care system as is as it is today
- 28:29started with a with a with a mandate from Roosevelt that that he would keep his wage
- 28:36controls, but he let he let companies pay for insurance and deduct it.
- 28:41And it's because, see, a company cannot buy your homeowners insurance and deduct it, so
- 28:46they don't.
- 28:49Your company can't buy your car insurance and deduct it unless it's a company owned car,
- 28:54which are rare compared to the non company owned cars.
- 28:58And so consequently, we pay for almost everything with our cars except we insure a
- 29:07wreck, but we pay for gasoline.
- 29:10We pay for tires.
- 29:11We pay for mufflers, transmissions.
- 29:13We even we even pay for the car with no insurance.
- 29:17We only insure a wreck.
- 29:19Homeowner's insurance.
- 29:21If we need a plumber, we pay for the plumber.
- 29:22If we need electrician, we pay for the electrician.
- 29:25If we our washer dryer needs to be replaced, we have to buy those.
- 29:29You don't get in you know, your homeowner's insurance doesn't cover that.
- 29:33So consequently, all the prices of those goods and services have remained very competitive
- 29:38without a great deal of inflation over the past fifty years.
- 29:43Health insurance is a whole another whole another thing.
- 29:46Prices and inflation have taken over because nobody knows what the price is.
- 29:51And, and the only people who control the price are the insurance companies.
- 29:55And they now have, they're now so huge that they're so politically powerful that it's very,
- 30:01very hard to even have the discussion.
- 30:05So I'm gonna have
- 30:06Yeah.
- 30:06I think that that really Oh, sorry.
- 30:09Go ahead.
- 30:10I was gonna say so.
- 30:11Now that I've had the discussion, I have to go run and hide.
- 30:15Yeah.
- 30:16I know some people would have I mean, FDR is kinda like Reagan where a lot of people have it
- 30:23it could be a very I thought he was Maybe not controversial figure, but polarizing figure.
- 30:29Yeah.
- 30:29Well, was But I I bet was a great wartime president.
- 30:35That that is one thing that people, regardless of their political persuasion, he was a he was
- 30:41a great wartime president.
- 30:42And, but but some of his other policies I think are are worth discussing.
- 30:48And and if somebody agree if somebody thinks that they're good, then you still have to be
- 30:53able to debate these things without without, wanting to kill each other because we still
- 30:59have a giant deficit that's unsustainable.
- 31:04As I've said earlier, you're not going to tax your way into prosperity.
- 31:10That is a nonstarter from a not from a not from a political standpoint, from economic
- 31:15standpoint.
- 31:19Well, I I think in any case, that really does speak to I was actually gonna ask this question
- 31:24a little bit later, but I think it it makes sense to bring up now, and you you you touched
- 31:27on it with the it really does go to show how much this stuff that's hundred, one hundred
- 31:34fifty, 200, 250, 300 years old is still just as relevant today just because of the reverber the
- 31:41reverberation effects that we've seen through history, whether it's FDR or the the founding
- 31:48fathers or the who have whoever influenced the founding fathers.
- 31:52But like you also talked about early on in that answer, there is unfortunately a misconception
- 31:58amongst many people tend to be younger, tend to be either around my age or younger, but it's
- 32:04there's also older people that feel the same way, that they feel that this history is boring
- 32:09or irrelevant or it's illegitimate even like you talked about before.
- 32:15Yeah.
- 32:15And that extends to many of these influential thinkers.
- 32:18So what do you say to people who feel that way, and how can we convince more people that
- 32:24history and its thinkers actually are interesting and relevant to today?
- 32:29Well, if if if somebody is concerned about where we are today, and I'm I'm going to try to
- 32:38set aside the political differences and just talk sheer completely about the economic
- 32:44situation.
- 32:45People are concerned about inflation and justifiably so.
- 32:49People are concerned about what causes inflation, and and that's that's an interesting
- 32:55question.
- 32:56I have some thoughts on that.
- 32:58But but, but nobody likes inflation.
- 33:00And, and only a and only a relatively small number of people benefit from inflation.
- 33:08But but there are some people who benefit.
- 33:10Now that doesn't mean that they that they want it.
- 33:12It just means that they happen to have a 3% interest rate on their home when the inflation
- 33:17started.
- 33:18So they're paying a 3% interest rate and inflation is 8% or 9%.
- 33:22Their home is going up at 10%.
- 33:25They're benefiting from that.
- 33:26But in many other ways, they're not benefiting.
- 33:29So there are a lot of questions, it's interesting.
- 33:34It wasn't long ago when Reagan was president, the federal deficit was $200,000,000,000 and
- 33:42that was considered to be excessive.
- 33:47It was, well, how are we going to survive on $200,000,000,000 increases the amount of
- 33:53federal debt a year?
- 33:55Well, in the last ten years, the amount of debt has gone up 20,000,000,000,000,
- 34:0120,000,000,000,000 in ten years.
- 34:04That is an unsustainable amount.
- 34:10And so then you have to say, okay, well, if we can agree that it is not sustainable, what do
- 34:17we do about it?
- 34:18And therein lies, Paul, the questions that go back to these questions, these historical
- 34:24questions.
- 34:26Because if government, which the United States government has the authority under the
- 34:32constitution to borrow as much money as lenders will loan it.
- 34:37Once once lenders decide I'm not gonna loan you any more money, then that's that spigot gets
- 34:43turned off because the value of the dollar collapses at that point in time.
- 34:49But as long as the public debt can be increased to satisfy whatever somebody's interests are,
- 35:00as long as that can be done, then the parties are not forced to sit in a room and agree with
- 35:04each other.
- 35:06I live in Tennessee.
- 35:07You live in Florida.
- 35:09Now in Tennessee, we have to balance our budget.
- 35:14And like Florida, we have no income tax of any kind.
- 35:18So our state government lives lives almost exclusively on the sales tax.
- 35:23Our local governments live on the property tax live on property taxes.
- 35:28Well, sales taxes are a very broad based tax.
- 35:32And so raising taxes on everybody at once carries political risk.
- 35:36And so Tennessee right now right now, Tennessee is governed by, it's it's pretty much a red
- 35:43state.
- 35:44And so our government debt is very low.
- 35:47Our government spending increases only very slowly and and business businesses government
- 35:56has a very light very light touch on business.
- 35:59I think that's probably very true in the state of Florida also.
- 36:02And consequently, the state of Florida's economy is doing quite well.
- 36:07That doesn't mean everybody in Florida is doing quite well, but it means that the majority of
- 36:11people and maybe even a large majority of people's standard of living is on the incline.
- 36:16Whereas if you lived in New York or New Jersey or California, and you're the average person,
- 36:23you're probably struggling quite a bit because government just keeps getting bigger and bigger
- 36:30and bigger and bigger in those states.
- 36:32And that's because the interests that control the elections in those states, I don't mean
- 36:38control them in the sense of of actually controlling the actual elections, but the the
- 36:44powers that be in those states are so powerful that that defeating them to try to rein in the
- 36:52size of government is almost impossible.
- 36:54So as I so as I look at it as an investor, there are certain states that I just simply I'm
- 37:01uninterested in investing in because the the risks are so inherent are so great that the
- 37:07laws will be changed to, to really negatively impact, those investments.
- 37:14That doesn't mean there aren't people who do invest in California.
- 37:16There's obviously lots to invest in in California, but California has got a set of
- 37:21circumstances.
- 37:22A lot of people, live in Nashville who three or four years ago lived in California.
- 37:27Probably a number of people live in Florida now.
- 37:30The out migration, there are not many people leaving, not nearly as many people leaving
- 37:34Florida as there are coming in.
- 37:37And that's because they look at Florida as a state that has friendly taxes and generally for
- 37:47a lot of people, lot of a lot of freedom to do what they wanna do.
- 37:50And and so now this gets back to this question that you were bringing up earlier.
- 37:56And I like to I like to ask people, because politics is is is really about what are the
- 38:01rules?
- 38:02What are the rules?
- 38:04And so I ask people who, if I'm teaching a class or something like this, I'll say, you
- 38:09have a board game and the board game is for four people to play And there are four people
- 38:16and nobody's ever played it.
- 38:17In fact, somebody went and bought it from the store.
- 38:19What's the first thing that the people do?
- 38:24They read the rules because you have to know what the rules of the game are to play the
- 38:29game.
- 38:30And then everybody when that game starts, everybody who's playing that game knows that at
- 38:36the end of the game, there's gonna be one winner and there'll be three losers, but they
- 38:40still agree to play by the rules of the game.
- 38:44But what happens if they if if they say, no.
- 38:47No.
- 38:47No.
- 38:48Want to be so if three people ever wanna change the rules of the game while the game's in
- 38:53progress, three people will have the right to change the rules of the game.
- 38:58Well, then they'll never be a winner because if somebody's getting close to winning, the other
- 39:02three people will change the rules.
- 39:06And then why why play the game?
- 39:08It'd be like having a football game where you don't keep score And so how many people would
- 39:13wanna watch that?
- 39:14How many people would wanna play that game?
- 39:16And so and so here's the key point here.
- 39:19In order to have a contest, that's a good a really good worthy contest, There has to be
- 39:26everybody has to be playing under the same rules.
- 39:28And that's the big difference today to me in in looking at politics.
- 39:34I'm a seven I'm 77 years old.
- 39:36I've never seen such a big difference in the way in how people see the role of government in
- 39:43their lives and what they think the proper amount of power that government ought to have.
- 39:51Everybody says nobody's above the law.
- 39:54Well, we we now know that some people who who thinks that some people aren't above the law
- 40:00now thinks that other people are above the law, so you go back and forth.
- 40:03But but the the if I had to pick one book, by the way, because you yeah.
- 40:09At one point, you asked, if I pick one book of an kind of a relatively unknown person that I
- 40:15would encourage people to read, it would be the law by Fredrik Bastiat.
- 40:20It has it has there are two great things about it.
- 40:22One is it's it's very it's very thin.
- 40:25It's only about 60 maybe 60 or 70 pages.
- 40:30But every page is just is just chock full of of great thinking.
- 40:35So it's not a book that you're gonna sit down and read in an hour.
- 40:38If you do, you won't you won't understand it.
- 40:42But Bastiat talked about what is the law and and, and, and, how, how, how should we think
- 40:52about the law?
- 40:53How, and this gets back to our constitution.
- 40:57Constitution was designed recognizing that that there's always a tendency for for a relatively
- 41:05small group of people to want to, to want to attain power, not by producing a great product
- 41:11and selling it to as many people as possible, by using politics to, to feather their own
- 41:18nest.
- 41:19And then so our constitution was designed to separate powers to make that more difficult.
- 41:25And, and and we're we're now to the point where the federal government is much more powerful.
- 41:35John Kennedy became president, which I was 12 years old, when he became president, total
- 41:41federal spending, total federal spending was a $100,000,000,000.
- 41:48And most of that was on defense.
- 41:51So spending on non defense might've been $50,000,000,000.
- 41:57Well, now it's more than 5,000,000,000,000.
- 42:00It's it's it's a number that that humans I mean, we just can't even think about those
- 42:05those numbers.
- 42:06But and so that if I if I would encourage people to do anything, if the classics are
- 42:14great, Having a a fundamental understanding of it because the classics are really about human
- 42:19nature.
- 42:20For example, you mentioned we do the social contract.
- 42:24I don't agree with with what Rousseau said.
- 42:29I don't agree with him on almost anything, but his ideas were very eloquent.
- 42:34His ideas were very powerful.
- 42:37Robespierre said that Rousseau was the father of the French revolution.
- 42:43And his ideas are what caused the French revolution.
- 42:47Well, it's useful to go back and study the French revolution and why did it happen.
- 42:55You had two different legal systems in France.
- 43:00You had, if you were, if you were the king or associated with the king, there literally was a
- 43:04set of courts that you were tried in and you always found innocent.
- 43:08And then if you weren't associated with the king, then you were tried in another court,
- 43:12which was generally the result was whatever it should have justly been because you weren't
- 43:20protected.
- 43:21And this went on for a period of fifty or sixty years and got worse and worse and worse leading
- 43:27up to the fall of the Bastille.
- 43:32Then you had the Jacobins and they overthrew the government.
- 43:36They decapitated the king.
- 43:39And when they decapitated the king, they decapitated the executive branch of the French
- 43:44government, literally.
- 43:46So the executive branch ceased to exist at all, which meant that all of the power now was in
- 43:54the legislature.
- 43:55Well, you try to you get three or 400 people in a in a very tense situation and get them to try
- 44:00to agree on any path forward that makes sense.
- 44:03Good luck.
- 44:06And so you and so you you had the French it's a little bit like looking at our congress today.
- 44:13And that's why that's why we tried to anyway, but but keep it on the French revolution.
- 44:20And then so so you had the revolution and there was a doctor who had built a machine to kill
- 44:31people.
- 44:32And he built it to kill them quickly, so that they wouldn't be killed through torture, which
- 44:39was the way the king would have people killed who committed a capital crime was had them
- 44:47drawn and quartered, literally pulled apart by four horses.
- 44:51And so this doctor named guillotine built the guillotine so that so you would have your head
- 44:58severed quickly.
- 44:59And that was considered to be a very humane way to to to execute somebody.
- 45:06The populace hoisted up thousands of guillotines on the backs of wagons and took
- 45:14them out to the small towns.
- 45:15And they would try the magistrate at 10:00 in the morning and execute them at 02:00 in the
- 45:21afternoon.
- 45:22And over twenty thousand people were killed in that manner.
- 45:27The economy of France shrunk by 60% in fifteen years.
- 45:33Then once the people were completely exhausted, and that's really a key, the people were
- 45:38exhausted, the economy was in shambles, people were starving, and Napoleon Bonaparte rose to
- 45:46power.
- 45:47And so now the king was replaced by a dictator.
- 45:51And so it's this is why this is why it is important.
- 45:56And I I really appreciate what you do.
- 45:59You try to help people understand the importance of ideas so that they can then use
- 46:04those ideas to think clearly in solving social and personal, but more social and political,
- 46:15being able to think about and talk about political issues.
- 46:19Because it's tough.
- 46:22It's toughest I've ever seen it, and I'm a good bit older than you.
- 46:27Yeah, it's definitely tough.
- 46:29But even if you find an idea completely, totally objectionable, there may be some little
- 46:36aspect of it that you could say as, oh, well, you know what?
- 46:39That part actually makes sense.
- 46:40I could use that to refine my ideas.
- 46:42It's a lot of times we treat these things as completely binary, like it's an either or, and,
- 46:49you know, it's kind of this death of nuance that we've seen, especially in social media
- 46:53lately.
- 46:54But I want to go back to, you mentioned a Bastiat.
- 46:57I don't think I've actually heard of him before.
- 46:59So, hey, I I learn something new every day, especially when I have a guest on here.
- 47:03I'll have to look into him, but that will actually go a little bit into I was gonna ask
- 47:07who your favorite lesser known historical thinker was.
- 47:10So but a little bit different Are than there, besides Bastiat then, are there any more
- 47:18influential thinkers, let's say two to three influential thinkers on your giant stuff
- 47:23political thought series that you haven't had yet?
- 47:25Why do you want
- 47:26add that?
- 47:26Adam Smith and the wealth of nations.
- 47:31He was the first person to really explain economics in a formal way.
- 47:41And so I would encourage The Wealth of Nations is very hard to read, but we do a great job of
- 47:48explaining it.
- 47:49And if you don't want to listen to what we do, pulling up summaries of The Wealth of Nations
- 47:53is probably still useful just because and what he gets to is this.
- 47:59He's, you know, the the people who are against tariffs, for example, and and I'm not I'm I'm
- 48:05not either.
- 48:05I could I could argue in favor of tariffs.
- 48:07I can argue against tariffs.
- 48:09I can argue either side.
- 48:11But one thing that Adam Smith said, he was a great believer in free trade, but he said free
- 48:16trade only works as long as the participants in free trade are playing by the same rules.
- 48:22He said, doesn't work if one side gets to take advantage of the other.
- 48:27That's not that's not free trade.
- 48:29That's extortion.
- 48:31And and so that's that's an interesting part.
- 48:33So when you're looking at the world today and and taking a position on whether or not the
- 48:40tariffs that Trump is imposing today, whether they're good or bad, and listening to his
- 48:47reasoning, whether or not you agree with his reasoning, whether you think his reasoning is
- 48:51even accurate.
- 48:53But these are the issues of whether or not tariffs, they certainly generate revenue.
- 48:58So to that extent, they generate revenue, but whether or not they distort, certainly they
- 49:06distort in the short term, but whether or not tariffs in response to unfair trade practices
- 49:14by your trading partners, whether or not that's appropriate is fair question.
- 49:20And so Adam Smith would be a good one.
- 49:24I think two that are really that they're so polar opposite is Thomas Hobbes Leviathan and
- 49:33John Locke's two Treatises of Government.
- 49:36They are polar opposites in terms of what is the proper relationship between government and
- 49:44the individual.
- 49:45And Thomas Hobbes believed that the absence of government, a state of nature was the only
- 49:52alternative to a strong, powerful government.
- 49:56And his definition of a state of nature was all against all.
- 50:02And of course, nobody would want to live in all against all.
- 50:06And John Locke says, no, no, no.
- 50:08People will agree to give up some very specific rights in order to have the rest of their
- 50:14rights protected.
- 50:18And so that gets into an interesting and a deeper conversation about today.
- 50:24For example, I mentioned healthcare earlier.
- 50:30The people who generally support the current system either have very, very good insurance
- 50:38plans at their place of work.
- 50:42They're they're on a very significant government subsidy or I'm on Medicare.
- 50:48Now I'm 77.
- 50:50I have no choice.
- 50:52So I'm on Medicare and and people who are on Medicare do not want Medicare rules changed in
- 51:00any way that harms them.
- 51:03Now I can come up with as as a person who who believes that there's great savings to be had
- 51:11in the health care system.
- 51:13Here's a question, Paul.
- 51:15If I if if my if Medicare reimbursed my doctor for a doctor visit, reimbursed my doctor a
- 51:21$120, and that doctor made a $40 profit, let's say, on that, that he had $80 of expenses and
- 51:31made $40 If I devised a way to reduce that doctor's costs from $80 to $40 and then reduce
- 51:42the reimbursement from $1.20 to 80.
- 51:45So the doctor still made 40.
- 51:47If I if I reduce the reimbursement by 33%, am I cutting Medicare benefits?
- 51:57And some politicians would argue that I would be cutting benefits by finding something that's
- 52:04more efficient in delivering the exact same service.
- 52:09So that's the political problem is that nobody wants to try to find an efficient way.
- 52:15I have just a tiny bit personal, but no big deal.
- 52:19I recently had three very small melanomas found on my skin.
- 52:26The doctor who took them off would only take off one at a time.
- 52:31I don't know why, but I'm guessing because if he took off three at a time, three all in one
- 52:39visit, he'd get paid for one visit.
- 52:41But making me come back three times, he got paid three times.
- 52:45That's what my guess is.
- 52:51So there are ways
- 52:51And maybe or maybe there's some sort of stipulation that he had to follow that may that
- 52:56said, like, you can only take one at a time.
- 52:59I don't know.
- 52:59But I mean
- 53:00There's a whole lot of, of hoops to jump through.
- 53:03You never know what exactly is stopping them from what exactly they want to do and what is
- 53:09something
- 53:09they And think that's is because the decision is not made between the doctor and me.
- 53:15The decision is made between the doctor and Medicare.
- 53:21And so therein lies the rub on how to try to take a $5,000,000,000,000 We spend more money
- 53:30on healthcare now than anything else by far, by far.
- 53:35And so if we're going to rein in the federal budget of the deficits, we have to find more
- 53:44efficient ways of delivering the same level of service.
- 53:48I don't want to lower service, but our system is inherently costly.
- 53:57And that doesn't mean the doctor's costs are high.
- 54:01It means that the system makes the doctor's costs very high.
- 54:07And then the insurance companies are on the other side and they have all these people that
- 54:12they have to pay.
- 54:14And so that would be an interesting topic sometimes if you wanted to really delve into
- 54:18just one topic, that's a huge one.
- 54:21And and where I think that's the that's the one place where neither Republicans nor Democrats
- 54:27will will seem this government shutdown apparently is over Obamacare subsidies.
- 54:32Well, we we just finished the fiscal year.
- 54:36Federal deficit was 1,800,000,000,000.0, just like it was the prior year.
- 54:42According to the news reports that I see is that the Democrats want Republicans to agree to
- 54:49$1,500,000,000,000 more spending on various for various people on Obamacare.
- 54:56Where is that money gonna come from?
- 54:59It'll just get added to the debt.
- 55:01And what I said earlier was we'll keep borrowing money until people will not lend it.
- 55:06And that's when things you know, it's kinda like somebody go broke slowly, but then when
- 55:11they finally do go broke, life changes quickly.
- 55:16And just like in France and just like in the glorious revolution in England, a hundred years
- 55:22before the French revolution.
- 55:24So collapses are worth studying.
- 55:27Our depression, most people do not know what caused the depression.
- 55:31Most people say it was the Smoot Harley tariffs.
- 55:35They might've had something to do with it, but the biggest part of it was people were trading
- 55:40on margin accounts of 90%.
- 55:42And the stock market had exploded for about six or seven years.
- 55:47And then when those margins, when the stock market dropped and people were trading on these
- 55:52huge margins and all of a sudden margin calls happened, then the stock market that's what
- 55:57caused the actual crash of the stock market.
- 56:00The smooth Harley tariffs might have might have started the first 10%, but the rest of it was
- 56:07because of the, the amount of margin that people could have and the amount of risk people
- 56:12were taking.
- 56:13Because it's like any of these manias, the Tulip bulb mania and all these different
- 56:18things, they burst.
- 56:20The housing market burst in 2008 and 2009.
- 56:24The commercial real estate market burst in '87 through '90.
- 56:30So these are all interesting periods, but they were all every one of these every one of these
- 56:37these, bubbles, were precipitated by bad public policy.
- 56:44And so that's why that's why studying politics is so important is understanding the effect of
- 56:50public policy, and it's not instant.
- 56:52It always there's always a lag.
- 56:56Well, well, it would the point about the the depression, the great depression, I remember
- 57:01back in AP US history.
- 57:03So that was the twenty ten to twenty eleven school year for me.
- 57:08I I do remember specifically our our teacher.
- 57:12He because if we had a not a flowchart.
- 57:17Trying to think of the exact name for it, but he had the great depression, and he had bubbles
- 57:22out to show, like, all the causes of the great depression.
- 57:25There was that the tariffs were brought up.
- 57:28Obviously, the stock market crash.
- 57:29A lot of people say is, you know, just look at the stock market crash, but there's also
- 57:32overproduction of crops, bunch of other things I can't remember off the top of my head, but it
- 57:36kind of goes back to all that to say a lot of times we sometimes we kind of go in the wrong
- 57:44direction where we oversimplify political concepts.
- 57:47Now to some extent, you need to simplify it to bring people in like so that's why with my
- 57:52content on my podcast or what stuff I write, I try not to make it as accessible as possible,
- 57:58but also trying to lead people to start to understand things a little bit more from a
- 58:03little bit more of a complex, but a more complex look at things.
- 58:08And I I think sometimes we judge who impartially people have an incentive to
- 58:15oversimplify things like if it's their candidate, everything they do is great.
- 58:20There's nothing else to it.
- 58:21That's true.
- 58:21Or if it's somebody they don't like, they're a terrible candidate.
- 58:24There's nothing to it.
- 58:25There's no real nuance.
- 58:27And and and so we can all fall into that trap Sure.
- 58:30Absolutely.
- 58:30But I I I think we I think, unfortunately, for some people, that's a very chronic thing where
- 58:37they just Did make it too simplify when politics is just there's just too much going on
- 58:42for it to say, this is the exact thing, and there's nothing else to it.
- 58:47Did did your Did your teacher or your professor on the great depression, by the way, he covered
- 58:52a lot of good topics.
- 58:54Was one of the things that he said that caused the depression, especially caused it to last
- 58:59was when Roosevelt came into office, he raised the top marginal tax rate immediately from 25%
- 59:05to 68%.
- 59:06I
- 59:10can't remember if that was brought up.
- 59:12At the very least, was talking about the initial causes of the Great Depression.
- 59:16So it
- 59:16would have been right before Roosevelt got in.
- 59:19And that is dead.
- 59:21That part's a little bit hazy though.
- 59:23Yeah.
- 59:23So your professor's dead right on what caused it.
- 59:26But what kept it going is what is even started it is important to understand the nature of
- 59:35bubbles.
- 59:37But what caused it to remain for ten years was the public policy of the Roosevelt
- 59:43administration because he got everything he wanted economically and it lasted.
- 59:50And I have a dog in that fight because I wasn't around then.
- 59:54But anyone who thinks that you can tax your way into prosperity, I encourage them to go back
- 1:00:01and say, well, then why didn't Roosevelt create great prosperity in the 1930s?
- 1:00:07Because he sure increased taxes on everybody, not just the wealthy.
- 1:00:12The wealthy went from 25% to 94%, but the average person went from 7% to 40%.
- 1:00:20And that's a big increase.
- 1:00:22Well, I can't say whether I agree or disagree purely because my my disclaimer at the at the
- 1:00:29top of the episode.
- 1:00:30So I tried not to put forth specific opinions on people, but but I do try to give my guests
- 1:00:36some room to be able to say their piece as well.
- 1:00:38But it it is something to really think about.
- 1:00:41Is it a for some people that they the idea is that Roosevelt brought us out of the great
- 1:00:47depression.
- 1:00:48Well, some people say he didn't bring us out of the great depression.
- 1:00:51You could take it also to Reagan.
- 1:00:52Did Reagan's policies help expand the economy, or did it lead to a crash in the market towards
- 1:00:59the end of his tenure?
- 1:01:00It's just those kinds of things you wanna think about.
- 1:01:02And, unfortunately, I think a lot of people base it purely on their political views.
- 1:01:06Obviously, if you're for a lot of liberals, FDR is an angel, but for a conservatives, he's the
- 1:01:13devil.
- 1:01:13Opposite way for Reagan conservatives.
- 1:01:16He's a shining example of of a statesman.
- 1:01:19He's the devil if you're a liberal.
- 1:01:21So try to I try to present both of those viewpoints as much as as as as I possibly can
- 1:01:26in in in my work say, well, some people say this, some people say that.
- 1:01:30Obviously, I have my own opinions, but
- 1:01:32Yeah.
- 1:01:33Go ahead.
- 1:01:33Well, I mean, you do a really good job of that, and but it it is an interesting it's good
- 1:01:40discussion to have about the depression, what kept it going so long, there is an answer.
- 1:01:51We may not agree on the answer, and somebody else may have a different opinion that isn't
- 1:01:56the answer, but it's a different opinion.
- 1:01:58Because these things don't just happen by coincidence.
- 1:02:02It's interesting, you talked a little bit about, the political side and supporting.
- 1:02:07When George Bush the first ran for office in in his in his, his campaign, his campaign speech
- 1:02:16at the Republican convention was he made such a huge, huge deal over not raising taxes.
- 1:02:23Remember the read my lips, no new taxes.
- 1:02:26That was his
- 1:02:26No new taxes.
- 1:02:27Yeah.
- 1:02:27That was what he said.
- 1:02:28Read my lips, no new taxes.
- 1:02:30And sixty days later, gets into office, gets an office with first sixty days.
- 1:02:35He raised his taxes.
- 1:02:38Now I became a non George Bush fan the moment he did that.
- 1:02:43Not because he not because George Bush as a person changed, but his policies did.
- 1:02:49And for me, his honesty did.
- 1:02:52So as our we had a Republican governor here in Tennessee trying to pass a state income tax,
- 1:03:00and I was the most vocal person on radio opposing opposing the person that I had
- 1:03:07supported as a candidate.
- 1:03:09I support him as the candidate because as the candidate, he promised that there would never
- 1:03:13be a state income tax as long as he was governor.
- 1:03:17So I believe I really believe strongly that our society will only work if if political
- 1:03:24candidates make makes make very serious promises and then keep them.
- 1:03:28I think it's very important that that they keep their promises.
- 1:03:33And and so so then then the the voters will then get what they ask for.
- 1:03:39And they ought to get what they ask for, not what they deserve.
- 1:03:43They ought to get what they have.
- 1:03:44Now that that might be the same thing.
- 1:03:47But if somebody runs and says, I will not, if you vote for me, I promise I will not raise
- 1:03:52anybody's taxes.
- 1:03:54If they break that promise, then there's nothing else that they're going to say or do
- 1:03:58that's going to resonate as a leader.
- 1:04:01Would you agree?
- 1:04:02I'm just interested if if you agree with that as
- 1:04:04a Well, yeah.
- 1:04:05That that you want your whoever you vote for, you want them to keep their promises.
- 1:04:11Yeah.
- 1:04:11Well, then then yeah.
- 1:04:13Unfortunately, for a lot of people, that's that's what what gets them elected as promises.
- 1:04:18I'd personal I mean, this is more and this is not a an opinion on one person or another.
- 1:04:22So I I feel like I can at least say this.
- 1:04:25I would per personally refer if politicians more instead of promise, and this is I mean,
- 1:04:32this is this might sound a little weasley to some, and they wanna say, no.
- 1:04:35You need to stand up for it.
- 1:04:37I'd rather they say something more along the lines of, I am going to try as hard as possible
- 1:04:42to not do this unless certain other circumstances arise.
- 1:04:47Because you never know what the future is gonna break up, and you never know if there is some
- 1:04:51sort of if there's some sort of information you don't know.
- 1:04:54You say, I don't believe that this is the way to do things.
- 1:04:58And I'd rather not hear somebody promise that because there I mean, we do have countless
- 1:05:03examples of politicians of all varying stripes say that they promise to do something and then
- 1:05:09they don't do it.
- 1:05:10And then it's like, well, were they never planning on doing that?
- 1:05:14Or did did some sort of circumstance arise that said, oh, jeez.
- 1:05:17I guess I gotta renege on my promise now.
- 1:05:20I'd personally prefer if they don't flat out promise things, but they say, this is what I
- 1:05:25believe.
- 1:05:25This is what I'm trying to fight for.
- 1:05:27But that doesn't work as well to get you elected, unfortunately.
- 1:05:32And there's
- 1:05:33a lot
- 1:05:33of incentives out there for people to do that that I I wish we didn't have those incentives
- 1:05:39for them to act on so that they would act a certain way.
- 1:05:42It's sort of like how en enraging people gets people elected.
- 1:05:47Unfor that's an unfortunate incentive that I wish we didn't see.
- 1:05:51Well, that that that unfortunately
- 1:05:53Sorry.
- 1:05:54You were going about to say something?
- 1:05:55Well, that that the the last thing you said is is now kind of part of part of the process
- 1:06:00today.
- 1:06:00But it's a great political question, Paul, as someone who has kind of seen politicians who
- 1:06:11weasel their way, almost all politicians weasel their way around.
- 1:06:14And voters only get one chance every so often to express themselves with their vote.
- 1:06:30If And businesses treated their customers the same way politicians treat the voter, most
- 1:06:36businesses would fail because they would lose the confidence of their customers.
- 1:06:40And so I really I'm gonna I I will push back a bit with you because I I think that I would
- 1:06:47rather have have candidates who who have very different opinions of what government should
- 1:06:54be.
- 1:06:55And then if the if the if the like, for example, ma'am Donnie has been very clear what
- 1:07:01he wants to do.
- 1:07:03I'm glad I don't live in New York because I don't think he will.
- 1:07:05I don't think that what he, if he does what he promises to do, I don't think it will inert to
- 1:07:11the benefit of most people in New York.
- 1:07:12I think it'll be very bad for the people who live in New York, but if he gets elected and he
- 1:07:17doesn't keep those promises, then what does that say to the people who voted for?
- 1:07:23And so, so for me, yeah, for me, if politicians are, if we are expect, if we expect them to,
- 1:07:36to, not be honest about what they will do.
- 1:07:39If we expect that I think voter turnout becomes lower and lower because it really your argument
- 1:07:45is, well, it really doesn't matter who wins because they're not going do it anyway.
- 1:07:51But I think a self governing society, I think it only works long term if if the voters will
- 1:08:02is is carried out by the elected people.
- 1:08:07And they that can only happen if the people who are elected and have power after the election
- 1:08:13do what they promised during the election.
- 1:08:16I don't know.
- 1:08:16That'd be a fun conversation, Paul, to have with the round table discussion type of thing.
- 1:08:23Politicians who I did politicians who wanted both ways.
- 1:08:31Go ahead.
- 1:08:32Politicians who wanted both ways.
- 1:08:37Don't think they generally I I think they generally don't they're not very effective.
- 1:08:44Sure.
- 1:08:44Well, it's it's more I think it's not that I'm not I'm not saying that they shouldn't promise
- 1:08:50anything.
- 1:08:52It's I'm more about the fact that unless you're absolutely certain that you're going to do
- 1:09:00something, and maybe they really were certain that they were gonna do something up until they
- 1:09:03got into office, I'd rather than just not say promise, but they say, this is what I believe.
- 1:09:10This is what I'm gonna fight for.
- 1:09:11But you know what?
- 1:09:11That's that's a whole other can of worms, and and and that that's a good point.
- 1:09:15And it's it's it's it's something to think about.
- 1:09:17I might have to write something on that.
- 1:09:18Think about it a little bit more.
- 1:09:20But there there can be a way where people talk about not promise anything, and then they
- 1:09:24they're still trying to be weasels about it just cause they don't wanna commit to anything.
- 1:09:28Now you can't just not commit to anything as a candidate.
- 1:09:31Not not asking for that.
- 1:09:32But I think I would like to see a little less outright promise just because of that break a
- 1:09:40potential breaking the promise.
- 1:09:42But it it but again, it is something to to think about harder, think about some more.
- 1:09:46Yeah.
- 1:09:47But we're we are running a little low on time, I want to hit the last couple of questions.
- 1:09:52So and this not not for any not necessarily for any particular issue like health care, for
- 1:09:58example, or or guns or anything like that.
- 1:10:01What are give me like one or two figures and their philosophies that you think are
- 1:10:07particularly relevant today in the face of this toxic polarization we see?
- 1:10:12Well, gosh.
- 1:10:14Now that's an interesting question because the thinkers that we cover the giants of political
- 1:10:24thought, like for example, the Communist Manifesto, may Carl Marx makes makes it very
- 1:10:33clear what he thinks what what government ought to do.
- 1:10:38He makes it very clear.
- 1:10:40And so he's not somebody who who you would go read to say, let's calm let's call let's try to
- 1:10:47get people to come together.
- 1:10:48And and most of the most of the most influential thinkers took very strong stands
- 1:10:54one way or the other.
- 1:10:55I mean, when I when I read when I listen to or read, our program on Leviathan, Thomas Hobbs
- 1:11:04was a was a statesman who I don't disagree with, but I believe his heart was in the right
- 1:11:10place.
- 1:11:10I do believe that he genuinely thought that if you didn't have a strong powerful government
- 1:11:17that controlled the population, I genuinely believe that he thought that it would be all
- 1:11:23against all in a state of nature, which would not end well.
- 1:11:28And I don't think that's true.
- 1:11:30But it's but it's a it's a school of thought that that ought to be studied and debated.
- 1:11:37And so then then and then so if you then decide it shouldn't be an all powerful oppressive
- 1:11:43government because humans aren't that bad.
- 1:11:46Okay.
- 1:11:47Well, then if they aren't that bad, then what what should the government what should it be?
- 1:11:52Because there are lot of people who say, well, I don't like our constitution.
- 1:11:56And I say, well, okay.
- 1:11:57What would you replace it with?
- 1:12:00And then when they start saying what they were replace it with, and I then I will then say,
- 1:12:05well, if you replace it with that, are you willing to have a government that then can
- 1:12:09control you the way that you would like the government to control your opponent?
- 1:12:15Well, their answer is no.
- 1:12:16I said, well, then what keeps the government from becoming the one that you don't like?
- 1:12:22The one that you do like today, you're at least free to express your differences.
- 1:12:25As you have one where where people who have the wrong opinion are not allowed to express it
- 1:12:35because it's wrong.
- 1:12:37And what happens when the other side gets power and imposes the exact same rule on you?
- 1:12:43And there there in lies the rub of what is circling back to the beginning of our
- 1:12:49conversation.
- 1:12:50What is good government?
- 1:12:55Yeah.
- 1:12:56I I think yeah.
- 1:13:00It's it's okay.
- 1:13:01It's I think it's okay to take strong stances for what you believe in.
- 1:13:06And when I I've talked about it before and and other stuff I've had and written and and talked
- 1:13:13about is, you know, there are several different kinds of polarization and the partisan and the
- 1:13:21ideological and the issue of polarization, those can bring their own problems, but those
- 1:13:24aren't inherent or those aren't a problem by themselves as long as you can still talk to
- 1:13:30people.
- 1:13:30It's this what we call affective polarization where the when you actually hate somebody
- 1:13:35simply because they have a different opinion.
- 1:13:38And I think that's that's kind of more what I was going about.
- 1:13:43Like you talked about with, you know, people like Thomas Jefferson and John Lacken actually
- 1:13:49being able to voice these opinions.
- 1:13:53Maybe maybe none none of these philosophers well, I guess, actually, you could talk about
- 1:13:56James Madison, for example, in the Federalist Papers talking about
- 1:14:00Sure.
- 1:14:00Oh, yes.
- 1:14:01Well, he didn't he actually used the word, but pluralism.
- 1:14:03Talks about pluralism and how no particular faction will become strong enough to supplant
- 1:14:10the others.
- 1:14:11Now Well, his rule of faction today, but that's a whole other can of worms.
- 1:14:16No.
- 1:14:17But his his his his rule of faction was a big was a very important, that very important to
- 1:14:26his foundation of how he thought about, by government.
- 1:14:29I will promise you Paul, that, that if you read, Bastiat, Frederick Bastiat's, law it will
- 1:14:40inform this part of the conversation because he was not a politician.
- 1:14:48He didn't have an axe to grind.
- 1:14:51I think you'll find that work.
- 1:14:52Okay.
- 1:14:53I think you'll find it fascinating and just very it's very deep.
- 1:14:58And then then I've read it three or four times.
- 1:15:04So if you read it and wanna have a discussion on that, it would be a very good discussion for
- 1:15:10for an hour.
- 1:15:14Okay.
- 1:15:14I'll I'll I'll have to to look into that when I when I get the chance.
- 1:15:18Fredrik Bastiat.
- 1:15:19Okay.
- 1:15:20I'll I'll have to remind myself of that.
- 1:15:22Maybe I'll remind myself when I'm editing this episode and I see the names like, oh, yes.
- 1:15:26I gotta I gotta look him up.
- 1:15:27But we are just about out of time, so I want to get to the random question of the day here.
- 1:15:36So for those of you who are new to this podcast, at the end of episodes, I like to end
- 1:15:41off with a random question of the day.
- 1:15:43It's fun.
- 1:15:44It's nonpolitical.
- 1:15:45I mean, not not that the other stuff isn't fun, but this is meant to be more nonpolitical, a
- 1:15:49little bit lighter content and just gives a little bit more of a well rounded look at our
- 1:15:54guests.
- 1:15:55So, Kram, today's random question of the day for you is, what is a food ingredient that many
- 1:16:02people love, but you just don't understand why?
- 1:16:06Anchovies.
- 1:16:10Okay.
- 1:16:11You know, I don't think I've ever actually had anchovies, but what don't you like about them?
- 1:16:14Just don't like the texture, taste, everything about them?
- 1:16:18Nothing.
- 1:16:19I like I like nothing about anchovies just but people who like anchovies love them.
- 1:16:26I mean, if that's that is Yeah.
- 1:16:29Yeah.
- 1:16:30And the the you know, there's still it's also a little Pizza.
- 1:16:32Bit I happen to like chicken liver, but a lot of people don't.
- 1:16:38But for me, anchovies anchovies would be the would be the one.
- 1:16:43Yes.
- 1:16:46Yeah.
- 1:16:46I've I've never actually tried anchovies.
- 1:16:49They they don't appeal to me, but but maybe I'll have to try it one time just to see.
- 1:16:54But
- 1:16:54Just to see.
- 1:16:55I'll tell you something.
- 1:16:56I absolutely hate.
- 1:16:57I I tried you, like, especially with the politics.
- 1:17:01I always try to find a way to understand why some people are where some people are coming
- 1:17:06from.
- 1:17:07I will not understand why people like mushrooms.
- 1:17:10I hate mushrooms.
- 1:17:11And they they don't even look edible.
- 1:17:14They don't look edible.
- 1:17:15Why I I who was the first person that looked at those and said, I'm gonna eat those?
- 1:17:19I'm sorry.
- 1:17:20I don't know.
- 1:17:20Do you like mushrooms?
- 1:17:21I do.
- 1:17:22I I like mushrooms.
- 1:17:23So so see, that would be that would be mushrooms.
- 1:17:26More for you.
- 1:17:27More for you.
- 1:17:28Mushrooms is for you like anchovies is for me.
- 1:17:32So, that's interesting.
- 1:17:34Hey, means more mushrooms for you.
- 1:17:36There there you go.
- 1:17:37Yeah.
- 1:17:37No.
- 1:17:37I I just I don't like the texture.
- 1:17:40I don't like the look.
- 1:17:41If if they didn't look so bad, I'm might mentally, I might be more okay with the now I
- 1:17:48can take if a sauce uses mushrooms to marinate a little bit, that I can actual that I can
- 1:17:55tolerate.
- 1:17:56But actually That's what I'm the mushrooms?
- 1:17:58No.
- 1:17:59Okay.
- 1:18:00Alright.
- 1:18:00Yeah.
- 1:18:00Well, interesting.
- 1:18:01Interesting.
- 1:18:02Yeah.
- 1:18:02That's yeah.
- 1:18:04But hey.
- 1:18:05I mean, we all we all got our things little food ingredients that you just just can't get
- 1:18:12behind.
- 1:18:12I mean, there there are some other crazy ones.
- 1:18:14Like, there's an Italian person I know who flat out does not like cheese, which I I mean, for
- 1:18:19one, I don't know how you don't like cheese, period.
- 1:18:22But, like, also as an Italian person, like, come on.
- 1:18:24How do you not like it?
- 1:18:25And then somebody who's from Wisconsin didn't understand have you ever been to Culver's?
- 1:18:32Yes.
- 1:18:32Oh, yes.
- 1:18:33Culver's is they're
- 1:18:35Okay.
- 1:18:35I I love
- 1:18:38I like that.
- 1:18:39I love Culver's.
- 1:18:40I like
- 1:18:40their chili.
- 1:18:41There's somebody
- 1:18:42I like their chili.
- 1:18:44Their chili?
- 1:18:45Okay.
- 1:18:45I never tried their chili, but love their burgers.
- 1:18:48They got great cheese curds, custard, obviously.
- 1:18:50But there's somebody else I know that's from Wisconsin.
- 1:18:54From Wisconsin, the heart, the home of Culver's, and he does not understand why they
- 1:18:58put butter on a burger.
- 1:19:00Wow.
- 1:19:01Wow.
- 1:19:02What are we talking about?
- 1:19:03Oh my god.
- 1:19:04How can you not like that?
- 1:19:05But No.
- 1:19:06Yeah.
- 1:19:07Right?
- 1:19:07That's that's
- 1:19:08that's that's what I'm
- 1:19:09I don't know how you can't like that, but he yeah.
- 1:19:11He he doesn't he doesn't understand why they do.
- 1:19:14But, I mean, I'm sure there's something very weird that I dislike and somebody's like, how
- 1:19:19can you not like that when you're a Floridian or something?
- 1:19:22I don't know.
- 1:19:23But, hey.
- 1:19:24We're we all we all got our things we love and don't love.
- 1:19:26But Yeah.
- 1:19:27In any case, though, that is gonna wrap things up for today's episode.
- 1:19:30So, Crom, thank you so much for coming on.
- 1:19:32Any other links you wanna share?
- 1:19:34I'm gonna share, of course, the Giants of Political Thought, your From Our Generation
- 1:19:37podcast, your website, anything else?
- 1:19:39Both of those would be fabulous.
- 1:19:41Giantsofpoliticalthought.com and From Our Generation would be great.
- 1:19:45Thank you so much, Paul, and I've had a great time today.
- 1:19:48Thank you.
- 1:19:49Absolutely.
- 1:19:51So we're gonna go ahead and wrap things up here and my links, my Facebook, Paul Raider author
- 1:19:57and speaker, my LinkedIn, mymedium.com profile, obviously this podcast on YouTube, Spotify and
- 1:20:03Apple podcasts, my five day educational email course about how we can better mitigate
- 1:20:09polarization in America, and my book on Amazon, it's ebook and paperback format.
- 1:20:16So we are going to end things here.
- 1:20:18So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.