Latest / Raising Men / The Psychology of Raising Emotionally Healthy Boys with Dr. Daniel Singley
Transcript
- 0:00totally to me uncontroversial statement
- 0:02that there's science
- 0:04about why boys and men struggle and suffer
- 0:06there is science about gender
- 0:09sensitive
- 0:09and informed ways to work with those men and boys
- 0:12and I have an ethical obligation to go get on that
- 0:14and that's what I'm doing here
- 0:15it doesn't have to be everybody else's frame
- 0:17but I'm I'm not looking to make converts
- 0:28welcome back to raising men
- 0:29when we talk about raising boys today
- 0:33it's easy to get lost between extremes
- 0:35about talking about toughness on one side
- 0:37and emotional suppression on the other
- 0:40but
- 0:40we don't have to choose between cultivating strength
- 0:44and sensitivity my guest today
- 0:47might show us how
- 0:48emotional resilience is one of the greatest gifts
- 0:51a parent could pass down to their son
- 0:55Dr Dan Singley is a psychologist
- 0:57researcher
- 0:58and the founder of the center for Men's Excellence
- 1:02his work
- 1:03helps men navigate the transition into fatherhood
- 1:07strengthen their relationships
- 1:09and build emotional tools for life
- 1:12he's also the force behind
- 1:14behind Men Excel a movement
- 1:16empowering men to show up
- 1:19with courage and authenticity in every area of life
- 1:23among many other things Doctor Dan
- 1:26thank you so much for joining us here today
- 1:28you're a busy man thanks
- 1:30yeah I appreciate you having me out
- 1:31I'm like well
- 1:32now I gotta teach everybody how to
- 1:33you know have emotional resilience and
- 1:36and get their kids straight
- 1:37we're we got a lot to cover
- 1:38here today in about in about 20 minutes
- 1:39it's a it's a tall order
- 1:41but I think you're ready for it
- 1:43ha ha no
- 1:44thanks for having me on now
- 1:45you've dedicated your career
- 1:47to something that barely existed as a specialty
- 1:51when you went to grad school
- 1:53which is the psychology of men and fatherhood
- 1:56now that turned out to be a surprisingly brave choice
- 1:59didn't it what drew you to this work
- 2:02and what were some of the challenges you faced
- 2:04so there's an old saying you know
- 2:07research is me search and I ended up
- 2:10I was in grad school I was doing like whiteness
- 2:12like white racial identity development work
- 2:14um and really
- 2:15no one in grad school ever even talked about male
- 2:17gender we talked about every femininity and
- 2:20and trans
- 2:21and gender non conforming and queer identities
- 2:23and so forth
- 2:24but sis masculinity was just completely off radar
- 2:28and embarrassingly it I didn't even occur to me
- 2:30and it was when I got out here to
- 2:32to UC San Diego
- 2:33that a now very good friend and mentor of mine
- 2:36talked about early fatherhood
- 2:38and the psychology of men
- 2:39and that it was an existing area of specialty
- 2:43I had a three week old at that time and was like
- 2:46how the hell did I not think about like my
- 2:48my fatherhood identity and like really what that means
- 2:52and then from there I got and joined
- 2:54you know joined the San Diego Psych
- 2:56Association at the local level to do
- 2:58they have a men's issue
- 2:58we have a men's issues committee
- 3:00and then I ended up getting involved with the
- 3:02American Psychological Association and
- 3:05and the division that focuses on the
- 3:06on the psychology of men and
- 3:08and just through the years
- 3:10I have increasingly focused on the science
- 3:14you know the psychological science of men and
- 3:17and my research is on early fatherhood
- 3:19so paternal perinatal and reproductive mental health
- 3:22or just the due to dad transition
- 3:24um and so we end up doing a lot of that
- 3:28yeah you know
- 3:29you you just mentioned that
- 3:30how in your doctoral gender class
- 3:32you covered everything under the sun
- 3:35except cisgender masculinity
- 3:38why do you suppose that is
- 3:39and what are the consequences of that
- 3:41so um
- 3:44I work to stay the hell out of
- 3:46of culture wars and politics and all of that
- 3:49that's not my book my friend
- 3:51my focus is on how do I take the information
- 3:55the science the evidence based
- 3:56the research and turn it into actionable work
- 4:00and at the same time
- 4:02like you're asking a fairly straightforward question
- 4:04and the short version of it comes down to
- 4:08because in many if not most areas of US life
- 4:15men and boys hold unearned power of privilege as a
- 4:21as a function of their gender
- 4:23then institutions like the APA
- 4:27which has has rightly focused heavily on
- 4:30you know over the past 30 years
- 4:32elevating girls and women
- 4:34in the field uh
- 4:35you know people of color
- 4:37people with different sorts of disabilities
- 4:38marginalized backgrounds
- 4:40but it's never really been on the Apas
- 4:44radar to focus specifically on men and boys
- 4:47if you're talking about trans men
- 4:48yes if you're talking about black men
- 4:50yes but if you're just talking about like
- 4:52boys and men writ large that's gotten very
- 4:55very little attention over the years
- 4:57and it's the APA who sets the training standards for
- 5:01if you're gonna get a master's
- 5:02or you're gonna get a PhD um
- 5:04and a colleague of mine right now in
- 5:07in the division on the psych of men
- 5:09is actively working to get that added however
- 5:14she's running up against a lot of
- 5:16of blocks because wow
- 5:18the same folks that tend to lose their minds
- 5:20when they feel like the other side is taking
- 5:22an all or nothing
- 5:23zero sum frame themselves usually come from a place of
- 5:29wait wait
- 5:29you're trying to empower boys and men
- 5:31that means you're pro patriarchy
- 5:32and a men's rights advocate
- 5:35and by doing that you're
- 5:36you're holding women and girls down
- 5:38and that's just not true like
- 5:39like Jim Crow didn't hurt white people
- 5:41no legalizing gay marriage didn't hurt straight people
- 5:44supporting men and boys
- 5:46does not hurt people of other genders
- 5:47in fact the research generally says
- 5:49the rising tide floats all boats
- 5:51and so I just keep coming back to that
- 5:53yeah and I mean
- 5:55that feels true also it's
- 5:57it's more than just the research it it uh
- 6:01it's empirically
- 6:02kind of obvious that the better everyone does
- 6:04the better everyone does
- 6:06yeah I'm like
- 6:07do you are are you a father
- 6:08no do you have one
- 6:10OK so this is relevant to you right
- 6:12like right
- 6:12or or do you have men you care about in your life
- 6:16or do you have boys that you want to turn into men
- 6:19all of those things I mean
- 6:20this is 95% of the population
- 6:23and you're just ignoring it
- 6:25yeah and it's one of the things that
- 6:26particularly these days when
- 6:28and we can back into this if you'd like
- 6:30but um
- 6:32young people but in particular young boys
- 6:34have a much rougher go
- 6:36in terms of what it means to be a man and a boy
- 6:39and how to navigate that
- 6:41then I would say a lot of previous
- 6:43previous generations did
- 6:45like the lines are getting blurred and
- 6:48and what it means to be tough and a man and a boy and
- 6:52and just just to your intro
- 6:54I would say a lot of those aspects of what we call
- 6:56like being sensitive or being emotionally intelligent
- 6:58and then acting on that behaviorally
- 7:01I would
- 7:02I would submit that in many ways taking that risk to
- 7:06to step out of the traditional guy box
- 7:08is one of the most courageous and manly things
- 7:10ironically that some of these people can do
- 7:13I would agree
- 7:15do you think that
- 7:16there is a problem with masculinity today
- 7:21hahaha okay
- 7:22so let me let me tease that one out a little bit
- 7:26absolutely I
- 7:27I know you
- 7:27how you like to avoid culturally sensitive issues
- 7:30so let me ask you that question no
- 7:31it's actually not that I'm a psychologist
- 7:33if I answer a direct question
- 7:34they'll pull my license like I'm not allowed
- 7:36so I love it no
- 7:38I what I would say is that um
- 7:41what it means to be a man continues to evolve
- 7:45and while some folks see
- 7:47the evolving nature of masculinity
- 7:50as masculinity being under attack
- 7:53I see masculinity as being under construction
- 7:57in such a way that allows
- 7:59look also tobacco um
- 8:01a lot of times when I'm training
- 8:03I'll do a quick word association and say okay
- 8:05just what comes to mind when I say
- 8:07you know
- 8:07like masculinity and it's 50% of the time it's toxic
- 8:11yeah right
- 8:12and
- 8:13and there have been some pretty unfortunate messaging
- 8:15in the past that equate masculinity
- 8:19with being bad and with being toxic
- 8:21but again I'm just very
- 8:23very briefly the research in this area is
- 8:25is is unequivocal
- 8:27it is not being male it is not masculinity per se
- 8:30which is which is problematic
- 8:32it is being rigidly only willing to be that traditional
- 8:38stoic aggressive independent
- 8:41you know successful aggressive
- 8:43like all this um
- 8:44in all contexts so
- 8:46it's the rigidity about only doing the Marlboro Man
- 8:50routine yeah
- 8:51even when the situation calls for empathy compassion
- 8:57emotional intelligence
- 8:58receiving influence from someone else
- 9:01being able to have productive conflict
- 9:03instead of talk first talk louder
- 9:05stack the data and all that
- 9:07and when when men and
- 9:10and you know
- 9:11beginning with boys
- 9:12learn to have that kind of flexibility
- 9:14or I can be super aggressive in a contract negotiation
- 9:17over here or as a
- 9:19as a warrior right
- 9:21but on the other side I go home and I try to
- 9:24you know tell my wife like
- 9:25you better ask how high on the way up
- 9:27like that's not gonna work
- 9:28and I have yeah
- 9:29I have had many opportunities with a front row seat
- 9:32with my patients that doesn't work
- 9:35but when you have that flexibility to enact that
- 9:38that what a lot of what we have traditionally called
- 9:42like feminized traits which they're not
- 9:44they're just human but when you can do both
- 9:47you live five to six years longer
- 9:49divorce rates plummet
- 9:51depression rates and anxiety rates plummet
- 9:55deaths of despair drug use
- 9:57like problematic covid like
- 9:58all these things that we want for the boys and men
- 10:01that we know
- 10:03generally
- 10:03come from being able to operate within the guy box
- 10:08and do that traditional thing
- 10:09when that's what's called for
- 10:10but to also then
- 10:11have the maturity to recognize
- 10:13that isn't what's called for in this other area
- 10:16and to take the risk and as I said before
- 10:18that courageous risk to show up in a different way
- 10:22cause you're running the risk of being shamed and
- 10:24and being called a wuss
- 10:26and when you look at the psyche of men
- 10:27shame and vulnerability are two of the thorniest
- 10:29most difficult psychological issues that we deal with
- 10:32yeah that's so amazing
- 10:33I think if if you marketed a pill on the internet
- 10:37that you could take
- 10:37that would have all of those benefits
- 10:39that you just talked about
- 10:40about the the depression rates and and um
- 10:45and the feeling of belonging and divorce
- 10:47and all of those things you'd buy it in a heartbeat
- 10:50but for
- 10:51there is this cognitive dissonance associated with
- 10:56evolving away from or
- 10:58or rising above this traditional masculine role
- 11:04it protects you from shame
- 11:05yeah that's what it is
- 11:06and yeah and
- 11:07and that shame you know
- 11:09if if I were gonna push back on that
- 11:10what I would say is that well
- 11:12aren't you just trying to turn men into wusses
- 11:15what what do you think about that
- 11:17what what is
- 11:18what is the answer to that push back
- 11:20I don't I
- 11:21I'm not sure how this fits
- 11:22with the demographic of your listeners
- 11:24but this is what George Carlin used to always call
- 11:26the pacification of the American male yeah
- 11:29and I bring that point up because this is not new
- 11:32like the the historical records
- 11:34going back hundreds and hundreds of years to um
- 11:38you know England in the 17th century
- 11:40had kings worried that the introduction of tea was
- 11:43going to cause lethargy in boys
- 11:45and you know
- 11:45the Boy Scouts were founded early 20th century
- 11:48because of fears that boys were becoming soft
- 11:50and they didn't have a like
- 11:52so this thing about
- 11:54we're losing traditional masculinity is not in any way
- 11:58new nor is it necessarily even true
- 12:03what keeps happening is generation after generation
- 12:06has to evolve and adapt to different circumstances
- 12:11technological social
- 12:13academic like financial certainly um
- 12:16and we have to do the downstream figuring out well wait
- 12:20who does this make and it's particularly different
- 12:21like one of one of the very
- 12:22very top issues when you look at the reports that
- 12:26look at the state of men these days
- 12:27is this sense of I don't have the financial
- 12:33power that previous generations did
- 12:36I followed the American dream
- 12:38I went to school I went to work
- 12:39I worked hard I'm supposed to be upwardly mobile
- 12:42but the current generation
- 12:44they're the first one in recorded history
- 12:46in our country where they're not gonna do as well
- 12:48as their parents did
- 12:50even if you follow all of these things
- 12:52now if you take that
- 12:54that hit that a lot of these men are now experiencing
- 12:57post 2,008 subprime mortgage crisis
- 13:00post covid and into now and
- 13:05and then you stand hard on the traditional
- 13:09you're a dude so protector provider
- 13:11mm hmm well
- 13:12if I feel emasculated with respect to my job
- 13:16let's say
- 13:17my partner makes significantly more money than I do
- 13:20then how do I square that with I have to be a protector
- 13:23I have to be a provider and that's just one like
- 13:25you get further away from that with like
- 13:27mental health issues like if you're gonna be a guy guy
- 13:29like a hardcore guy guy do you get to be depressed
- 13:32hell no you get to have anxiety
- 13:34that's for wusses right
- 13:35actually
- 13:35we've done research on this and generally speaking
- 13:38depression is a feminized
- 13:39mental health issues in general is a
- 13:40is a feminized concept wow
- 13:42which of course we all made up right
- 13:44it's just socialized
- 13:45but when you wanna understand some of the major
- 13:48major issues that boys and men are facing these days
- 13:50there's usually a broader
- 13:52like societal context you gotta understand
- 13:55and then
- 13:56how that's coming into conflict with these Learned
- 13:59male roles that are very old
- 14:01it goes back to what you were talking about
- 14:03the flexibility there
- 14:04it's the inflexibility that is causing that distress
- 14:09and and so what is what is the right vision of
- 14:15of a balanced masculinity
- 14:17as opposed to this kind of rigid view that
- 14:20that we that we have by default
- 14:25there is no one size fits all like who am I
- 14:28who am I to come into your home and tell you hey
- 14:30the way that you
- 14:31and your partner are enacting your gender roles
- 14:33is wrong like yeah
- 14:35I that's that's totally up to you
- 14:37like so like when you every curve
- 14:38has two tails every normal standardized curve
- 14:42and so there are gonna be people that are
- 14:43you know hardcore in one way or the other
- 14:46generally speaking for the men my message is
- 14:52sit back and ask yourself
- 14:53what parts of doing the traditional
- 14:55like Marlboro Man guy thing
- 14:57what parts of those are truly serving you
- 15:01versus what parts of those are holding you back
- 15:06but in in a given household
- 15:08there's
- 15:08there's just no there's no right or wrong way to do it
- 15:11but so case example would be um
- 15:13look at Covid like during Covid yeah
- 15:16so my research is on early fatherhood right
- 15:18so I focus a lot on dads but broadly speaking
- 15:20men did way more of the domestic duties and child care
- 15:25and care giving than they had previously
- 15:28cause now they were at home yeah
- 15:30but if they didn't work outside the home before
- 15:32they were there and the dishes
- 15:33he's standing right next to him
- 15:34the kid that needs the diaper change
- 15:36he's standing right next to it
- 15:37and so it's not like oh
- 15:38I gotta go to the office and set up my email
- 15:40it's like boom
- 15:41let's do this right
- 15:42and so there was a spike in that
- 15:44now plenty of other stuff was going on in covid
- 15:46people lost their jobs women lost their jobs
- 15:48workforce still hasn't recovered in that way and so on
- 15:50but as we move on now we're like
- 15:53you know five years past it's
- 15:57regressing back to the me yeah
- 15:59men are doing less and
- 16:01and that's okay for any given family
- 16:03but to be thoughtful and intentional about it
- 16:06instead of that's man's work
- 16:08that's woman's work you can do that if you choose
- 16:10and that's the values of your household
- 16:12but you're also setting up a greater likelihood that
- 16:16actually
- 16:17there's a lot of gray in terms of what's man's work and
- 16:20and what's woman's work
- 16:21now people respond to this differently
- 16:22like people have different political takes um
- 16:25certainly um
- 16:26religious theological frames
- 16:28draw the bear
- 16:29about what's the identity of men and fathers
- 16:31and so forth
- 16:32and if that you take cool like incorporate that however
- 16:36if you're having some difficulty with this
- 16:39consider some ways to work in empathy compassion
- 16:44emotional intelligence
- 16:46doing a sort of communication
- 16:48to have more productive conflict
- 16:50like this isn't just made up hocus pocus
- 16:52this stuff is very well researched
- 16:54and pretty straightforward to learn how to do
- 16:57so
- 16:57what does the research actually show about men who can
- 17:02like go outside the house and go to the workplace
- 17:05and be a hardcore badass in business and all of that
- 17:08but then be empathetic
- 17:10and be vulnerable with their family
- 17:13and their kids and their friends
- 17:15well one thing that I would say is
- 17:17that dude that has that kind of flexibility
- 17:19is also much more likely to rise higher at work
- 17:25right like where I am in San Diego
- 17:27we're surrounded by tech and biotech
- 17:30and engineers and computer science
- 17:32and executives and so forth
- 17:34and just because you're a great coder or scientist
- 17:37does not make you a great administrator
- 17:39a lot of what makes people really solid beyond
- 17:42you know the political you know
- 17:43brinkmanship and
- 17:44and the resource acquisition and so forth
- 17:46is you can work with people
- 17:48and you can do that well
- 17:49not just the like people will take advantage of you
- 17:52if you don't step on their neck like
- 17:54I mean sure
- 17:55some contexts will be like that
- 17:56but I guess the thing I want to say is
- 17:57there are benefits at work to this more
- 18:01more balanced flexible like those folk
- 18:03a friend of mine's writing a book
- 18:04has written a book called strengths with Heart
- 18:06and it's all about heartful strength and leadership
- 18:09in the work context some of that research very
- 18:12very clearly shows
- 18:14followers will follow leaders more
- 18:16when the leaders
- 18:17make the followers feel seen and understood
- 18:20it doesn't mean the leaders gonna do what they say
- 18:22it means they help them see that
- 18:23and then in the other areas of life
- 18:27looking to you know directly cultivate
- 18:30you know how
- 18:30how am I gonna do one of the
- 18:32one of the resources that I really
- 18:33really like um
- 18:35Eve Rodski has done a really cool work with fair play
- 18:39now that came up out of the me too and um
- 18:42times up and so on
- 18:44um and the work that
- 18:46she's done
- 18:46one of the things she developed was this card sort
- 18:49I'm familiar with it people sit down
- 18:51so I have people do this all the time
- 18:53and when a couple does it
- 18:55I'll ask them be like OK
- 18:56bring your cards in to next session
- 18:58and then we'll talk about which of this stuff is manly
- 19:01which of this stuff is just for girls or what not
- 19:04and just that one conversation tends to start shifting
- 19:07the yeah
- 19:08it turns out particularly the parenting end of things
- 19:11this is more like this is
- 19:12there's a lot more gray here
- 19:14I would say that's that's one example
- 19:17that then translates to they live longer
- 19:20they have less depression
- 19:21they you know
- 19:21like you don't do as much fentanyl
- 19:23you know all that yeah
- 19:26yeah I
- 19:27I uh
- 19:27so I've gone through that card exercise
- 19:30uh with my wife and and
- 19:33and I've seen other people go through that exercise
- 19:35and it it was a
- 19:37it was very healthy experience for me and my wife
- 19:39um but I've witnessed
- 19:41some other people that really had a tough time with it
- 19:44the um
- 19:46both parties became very defensive about
- 19:48you know what they brought to the table and all of that
- 19:51and it just absolutely descended into a
- 19:54a a melee
- 19:55and I mean I've seen it ruin relationships too
- 19:58or maybe it maybe it didn't ruin the relationship
- 20:00the relationship was already ruined
- 20:01and what it did is just shine
- 20:03the light on the fissure there
- 20:06right so again
- 20:07when I'm when I'm working to do this
- 20:10before having a couple do that
- 20:12or an individual of mine go back and do it
- 20:14we do some solid work on the guy himself
- 20:17learning about his own emotional dysregulation
- 20:20like some cognitive behavioral work around
- 20:22here's the meaning that I'm ascribing to that
- 20:24and how to manage that
- 20:26and then how to do some productive conflict
- 20:29like how to how to lead assertively
- 20:31not aggressively because you're right
- 20:33that can stir why do you have so many cards
- 20:35and I don't have enough cards
- 20:36or you have the right ones
- 20:36or I just can't back off and
- 20:38and all this stuff yeah
- 20:40you don't have cards for the stuff that I do
- 20:42but only the stuff that you do
- 20:44yeah yeah yeah
- 20:46let's tease out I wanna
- 20:47I wanna drill down a little bit into this dude to dad
- 20:51um transition and a lot of the focus of
- 20:55of your work specifically now
- 20:56you've called father uh
- 20:58early fatherhood
- 20:59the tip of the spear for contemporary masculinity um
- 21:04what do you what do you mean by that
- 21:07yeah so what I mean by that is that fatherhood
- 21:13in a particular more so now than ever
- 21:16any cohort of of um
- 21:19new dads in in history in our country
- 21:23they're expected to be involved with pregnancy
- 21:27with the birth in in the immediate postpartum
- 21:30now there are all kinds of caveats we
- 21:31can make here about different cultural groups
- 21:33and geographically and so forth
- 21:34but just generally speaking writ large
- 21:37most people including the fathers themselves
- 21:39expect to be more involved than statistically
- 21:43their own father would have been
- 21:46and to be involved not just in
- 21:51you know keeping the saber tooth tigers away
- 21:53and food on the table yes
- 21:55that but now there's more of an expectation of well
- 22:00can they make it to a well baby visit
- 22:03can they go you know visit
- 22:05you know
- 22:06when they're gonna image their babies in utero heart
- 22:10you know there
- 22:11they can be part of the actual birth planning
- 22:13for the experience and this is all brand new
- 22:16and in part why I say this about the tip of the spear
- 22:20is
- 22:21men are being encouraged to be caring and caregiving
- 22:27and in particular with their children
- 22:31to a lesser extent with their partners
- 22:33but it all kind of goes together
- 22:34and so where I'm coming from is
- 22:38this whole thing about balance and flexibility
- 22:40and being a hardcore guy guy over here
- 22:42and being able to be more
- 22:44more flexible
- 22:45and work the room in a more strategic way
- 22:48with empathy and compassion and so forth
- 22:51that can really begin in early fatherhood
- 22:55when we as a society
- 22:58give the dad permission to be caring and a caregiver
- 23:03and to do some of these things that are a bit
- 23:04in violation of like
- 23:05you know traditional guy guy like who's gonna stand
- 23:08up and be like dude
- 23:09it's cool to be like an absentee father
- 23:11like that's not the most popular opinion
- 23:16you know these days now
- 23:17what that looks like and how you're gonna be involved
- 23:19there's no right or wrong way to do it
- 23:22but that's that's one element of it
- 23:24and and what I'm looking for a lot of like
- 23:26you know policy and
- 23:27and advocacy level work is now
- 23:30let's look at some
- 23:31ways to take the research around gender sensitive work
- 23:36like like
- 23:37uh programmatic development and work to continue that
- 23:41like to stoke that spark of caring and caregiving
- 23:45that starts in fatherhood
- 23:47and then keep it going to romantic relationships
- 23:51to friendships to extended family of theirs
- 23:56not just a high like it's
- 23:58it's kind of safe for a dad in some ways
- 24:00to be very caregiving in a hierarchical relationship
- 24:02like with an infant yeah
- 24:05right that infant
- 24:05and you can use that to help build that muscle
- 24:08in other relationships yeah
- 24:10that's it that so that's that's to me
- 24:12that's the tip of the spear in the
- 24:15in the evolution of what it means to be a man
- 24:17because the evolution of what it means to be a father
- 24:20is more of a yes
- 24:21and than a you have to you have to be this or that
- 24:25yeah I I think that formulation is really
- 24:28really really helpful
- 24:29and if you think about that as an opportunity
- 24:33to cultivate this side that you
- 24:36might not have had an opportunity to cultivate before
- 24:38because of societal pressures or that sort of thing
- 24:41it it really feels like wow
- 24:43this is something I really wanna
- 24:44you know it's something I wanna get stronger at
- 24:46I mean especially if you think about our culture
- 24:51you know it
- 24:52it tries to put men in a box and
- 24:54and tries to turn them into the
- 24:57the marble man
- 24:57but think about the way that our culture views a man
- 25:01who is both strong and a caregiver
- 25:04it's I mean
- 25:06it's laudatory wouldn't you say
- 25:09yeah haha
- 25:10I'm right there with you I mean
- 25:12I think I think there's
- 25:13there's very little that is
- 25:14that is as praised in our culture as a man who can
- 25:18who can be that flexible and yet
- 25:20it's not something that we're really taught to do
- 25:23or it's
- 25:23it's not something that we feel comfortable with
- 25:27yeah yes
- 25:28I guess that that scarcity is what makes it valuable
- 25:31it can be very upsetting and scary
- 25:36two people who for a variety of reasons
- 25:39have come to count on that traditional guy
- 25:42guy way of being when you start saying yeah yeah
- 25:45that's okay and this other thing
- 25:48because the other thing can seem very
- 25:50very threatening uh huh
- 25:52in that way
- 25:53now some of your research focuses on this
- 25:57paternal involvement with infants
- 25:59and helping men make that dude to dad transition
- 26:03as healthy as possible
- 26:05so what are the key psychological shifts
- 26:07that happen during that and
- 26:09and what separates fathers
- 26:11who really thrive
- 26:11from those who end up struggling with that
- 26:14so um
- 26:17there are several factors
- 26:19which best predict
- 26:20the father's involvement with his infant
- 26:23um factor 1 is his involvement during the pregnancy
- 26:27right with the
- 26:28it's very clear that
- 26:29fathers that are more engaged during pregnancy
- 26:31are also more present and engaged during the birth
- 26:34and then are also more present and engaged
- 26:36during the postpartum so
- 26:37there's a strong argument to help
- 26:39get their head in the game early
- 26:41to start developing
- 26:42what's called paternal role salience
- 26:44or just the extent to which
- 26:45I have an identity of being a dad
- 26:49and the dads that have a higher paternal role salience
- 26:51are more likely to be then involved and engaged
- 26:56um another really key factor
- 26:58is the extent to which the father perceives
- 27:02that his
- 27:03that that
- 27:04that the relationship with his co parent is supportive
- 27:09that's that
- 27:09that across not just my research
- 27:11like across across the whole field
- 27:13typically one of the strongest
- 27:15strongest factors
- 27:17that predicts the father being highly engaged
- 27:20with his infant is
- 27:21he feels
- 27:22a supportive and solid relationship with his co parent
- 27:26when it's the opposite
- 27:27and he feels really negatively about it
- 27:29and his perception is this isn't going well oftentimes
- 27:32um that translates to worse mental health
- 27:35both for him and for his partner
- 27:37and oftentimes
- 27:39causes his partner to go into a gatekeeping
- 27:42or gate closing mode
- 27:44that controls the extent to which he has
- 27:47access to the kid and so he can't be as involved
- 27:50or involved in the ways that he wants to
- 27:53this is by no means universal
- 27:55but it's a fairly common dynamic that most of us
- 27:58so it's either a virtuous cycle or a vicious cycle
- 28:00and you sort of get to pick which one you're gonna
- 28:03you're gonna fall into yeah
- 28:06and so there are other factors like
- 28:07you know you know trauma history depression lessons
- 28:12certain kinds of involvement
- 28:13part of what my team
- 28:14did was to work to expand the concept of
- 28:17father's involvement it used to just be
- 28:19does he live there and does he contribute money
- 28:22and then it was does he play
- 28:25which all those are cool however
- 28:27that doesn't encapsulate really
- 28:28what's the modern frame on
- 28:29on fathers and involved fathers of infants
- 28:31and so we developed a scale that's multidimensional
- 28:35it's got five different aspects of involvement
- 28:37basically work and play and emotional involvement
- 28:40and kind of like a meta perspective and indirect care
- 28:43and that has changed the conversation from
- 28:46is he involved or not to well
- 28:49is he and what does that look like
- 28:52and what are the factors that
- 28:54support him being involved
- 28:55and when he's involved in those ways
- 28:57how is it helpful not just to his baby and partner
- 29:00but to him himself and so
- 29:02including fathers as a dependent variable in research
- 29:07meaning how is the father impacted
- 29:09by this that's fairly new
- 29:12wow yeah
- 29:14you know that you're
- 29:15when you mentioned about the partners
- 29:19um being supportive of each other it
- 29:21it brings to mind a story from my own journey when
- 29:25when my boy was first born um
- 29:29my wife and I I mean
- 29:31we thought we were prepared
- 29:32but we were we were not
- 29:35and we ended the first two weeks
- 29:37she and I were just at each other's throats constantly
- 29:41we were just it was like and
- 29:42and I remember thinking I can't do this
- 29:45like I cannot live my life this way
- 29:47and then the next thought that occurred to me was that
- 29:50I'm not gonna have to live my life this way
- 29:52well I mean
- 29:53it's gonna be so different in a year that it's
- 29:56this isn't I mean
- 29:57this is just a short term thing
- 29:58like just just let it go and
- 30:01and I remember sitting down with my wife and said
- 30:04alright we need to make a deal
- 30:06and our deal is we will not get divorced
- 30:08no matter what happens
- 30:09we will not get divorced before the baby turns
- 30:11at least one
- 30:12and so that actually gave us a time box where
- 30:16where it'll
- 30:17it actually freed us up to be supportive of each other
- 30:20because we didn't have to worry that any given pain
- 30:24or any given
- 30:26negative situation was gonna last for very long and
- 30:31and it enabled us to do that
- 30:33and that's that was our
- 30:34crazy little
- 30:35weird mechanism of cultivating that in each other
- 30:40I love that you did that as direct
- 30:42like that's stopping
- 30:43and really indexing on the fabric of the relationship
- 30:46and saying yeah
- 30:47things are changing
- 30:48we don't know what's gonna look like in a year
- 30:49we're not gonna make any rash decisions
- 30:51between now and then
- 30:52now let's figure this out together like good on you
- 30:55yeah and you know
- 30:56there's probably a positive way to to frame that like
- 30:59no matter what I'm here for you
- 31:02at least until this time
- 31:03I don't know it was it was a weird way to do it
- 31:05it worked for us and uh and um
- 31:08I I
- 31:09I don't know
- 31:09I don't know if I would recommend it to anyone else
- 31:11because actually there is a problem because when the
- 31:13when the when the boys started turning a year old um
- 31:16we had an issue where my wife actually
- 31:19she broke down at one point in time
- 31:20she's like oh
- 31:21and you're gonna divorce me after he turns 1
- 31:23I was like no man hahaha
- 31:25that wasn't the deal it's the anyway
- 31:28it was kind of a funny moment
- 31:31I'll tell you another story along
- 31:33along the lines of something you mentioned before
- 31:36and that is
- 31:38and I turn my cheek and my wife asked me she said
- 31:42why did you turn your cheek
- 31:43why didn't you just kiss him
- 31:44and I said and I and I said to her I
- 31:45said men don't kiss each other on the lips
- 31:49and I realized in that moment like that is messed up
- 31:55and I caught myself and I
- 31:57and I didn't catch myself until about the next day
- 32:00and I and I went back to my wife and I said listen
- 32:03you know actually
- 32:05that's really unhealthy and I'm gonna not do that
- 32:08and then I started kissing my boy on the lips
- 32:10and uh it was
- 32:12it was it was a weird thing for me to go through
- 32:17you know I love that because of the concreteness of it
- 32:20and frankly when you get down to it how arbitrary yeah
- 32:25it is and and I'll I'll I'll go you one for it's funny
- 32:28it was just like you know personal bit a singly family
- 32:31my grandfather kissed my dad on the lips
- 32:35my dad always kissed us
- 32:37I have two older brothers and like
- 32:39I didn't think anything of it
- 32:40until some kid in the second grade
- 32:41like shamed me for it at the um
- 32:44you know
- 32:44in carpool and I was like it didn't even occur to me
- 32:47I was like there's nothing like
- 32:48you know sexual happening there
- 32:50but I'll go you one further
- 32:52the same kind of direct equating of
- 32:57physicality and body parts
- 33:00exclusively with with sexuality
- 33:03has manifested in a series of fathers of
- 33:08of little girl babies
- 33:11who are terrified of their daughter's vaginas
- 33:16because to them
- 33:18their whole lives that was a sexual organ yeah
- 33:22and now they have a little girl
- 33:25and they can't rectify in their minds well
- 33:28turns out it's not just a sexual organ
- 33:31it's just part of your body that
- 33:33you know variety of thing
- 33:34but like and it
- 33:35and the dads don't articulate it that way
- 33:37they're just like
- 33:37they're just kind of like Tinky or I don't know
- 33:40but unfortunately they're
- 33:41they're trapped in the room with a psychologist
- 33:43and I'm like alright
- 33:43we're gonna get into this and in many ways it does
- 33:46it boils down to that like discomfort
- 33:47and it's I would
- 33:48I would say those are in the same basic arena of
- 33:52we've sexualized it given sure
- 33:53I mean kissing is physical intimacy no matter what
- 33:56but from there we say all physical intimacy is sexual
- 34:00and that is not true
- 34:03wow that is really
- 34:04and I'll tell you I mean
- 34:05just as I'm examining that myself
- 34:07I struggle with that too with my daughter
- 34:09I and
- 34:10and part of it is is discomfort
- 34:13and part of it is there's a social stigma about that
- 34:17and I I wouldn't want to go anywhere near being accused
- 34:21of things and and uh
- 34:24but yeah it's
- 34:25it it feels
- 34:26it feels risky at the same time
- 34:29somebody's got to clean that baby
- 34:31I mean you can't
- 34:32you know you can't let the poop be in there
- 34:34exactly right that's yeah yeah
- 34:38actually it's
- 34:38it's funny the other day um
- 34:41she had a dirty diaper and
- 34:43and literally
- 34:44we're walking into her room to go change her diaper and
- 34:47and uh
- 34:48and she says to me she says dad
- 34:50would you make sure to clean my vagina
- 34:53she's she's 3 years old
- 34:56yes baby
- 34:57I will I get discomfort around it
- 35:00my point isn't it shouldn't have discomfort
- 35:02my point is let's look at where that's coming from
- 35:05let's really look at where that's coming from
- 35:08and then make a mindful intentional decision
- 35:11about how I wanna show up as a parent
- 35:13instead of you know
- 35:14knee jerk reactivity
- 35:16I think that's the perfect way to put it and
- 35:18and just be thoughtful rather than just on autopilot
- 35:22work on what your unconscious mind is telling you to do
- 35:26bring it into your conscious mind
- 35:27and make an intentional decision
- 35:29to do whatever the thing is
- 35:31and that's that's fine
- 35:33going on autopilot is not fine
- 35:35because autopilot will steer you the wrong way
- 35:37sometimes it can sometimes it can be great
- 35:40right right
- 35:40it's just it's just stopping and
- 35:42and it's like there's a way to look at
- 35:44at plain old walking which is not just locomotion
- 35:47it's putting one foot in front of you
- 35:49to keep from falling uh huh
- 35:51which is an analogy for mindlessness
- 35:55I'm not being intentional about this
- 35:56I'm moving my foot so I don't fall however
- 35:59if I were to simply just stand in one spot
- 36:01look around scan and say
- 36:03now I'm gonna lift up my foot and
- 36:04go that way and my center of gravity is up and down
- 36:08and I'm not just keeping myself from falling
- 36:10it's a completely different journey
- 36:12and that's the way I like to think about
- 36:14about the fatherhood journey
- 36:16yeah yeah
- 36:18well so let's talk a little bit about practical tools
- 36:22now when fathers come to you
- 36:24and trying to figure out how to raise
- 36:26emotionally healthy sons what are some of the first
- 36:29concrete steps that you tell them
- 36:32first of all it's not really
- 36:33all that different from raising emotionally healthy
- 36:36girls sure
- 36:37you know daughters
- 36:38um but briefly
- 36:41it begins with a look at authenticity
- 36:44and then a kind of basically a visioning exercise
- 36:49when you think about 10 years from now
- 36:52how do you want your relationship with this child to be
- 36:56and what kind of
- 36:57other relationships are you hoping this child
- 37:00will have right
- 37:02and and one really important piece of that that's a
- 37:04that's a that's a critical mirror
- 37:06that I'll shine on some of these dads
- 37:08is to say for example
- 37:11um if you're partnered or married or whatever is
- 37:15is your relationship with your partner
- 37:18what you would hope your child will have
- 37:22is the way that you express love
- 37:24is the way that you express communication
- 37:26is the way that you handle conflict
- 37:28certainly if it's in front of those kids or that kid
- 37:32are you
- 37:33modeling the kind of relationship that you're hoping
- 37:37for that kid if so
- 37:39good on you if not
- 37:43don't be a wuss do the work like
- 37:45and lean into the relationship
- 37:47there's so much fear and stigma about it
- 37:49but like at the end of the day
- 37:50like that you
- 37:51you can do quite a lot with that
- 37:53the other is for these fathers
- 37:55um
- 37:55just being highly engaged with their infants during the
- 37:59just the first year of life predicts
- 38:03both for boys and for girls
- 38:05um really
- 38:07for the research I've seen is for kids of any gender
- 38:09um they have higher emotional intelligence
- 38:12they are more
- 38:14they have more words when they get to school
- 38:16they engage in more controlled risk taking
- 38:19less involvement with the juvenile justice system
- 38:21and this is just being around and being hands on
- 38:25now from there
- 38:26I would say that fathers can play a really
- 38:28really important role
- 38:29both for their children by when they when
- 38:34when we engage in a parenting fail
- 38:36which we all do to go own it to the kid
- 38:39hey when I did blank
- 38:42that was the wrong thing to do
- 38:45in the future going forward
- 38:47I am going to do blank
- 38:50and often times being able to name
- 38:52and when I did that I felt ashamed anxious
- 38:55worried right
- 38:56you don't tell this to a three year old developmentally
- 38:58they're not ready for it but what you can do is say hey
- 39:00daddy was upset daddy
- 39:01you know blah blah
- 39:03but what you're doing is setting a family culture and
- 39:07a relationship with the child that very
- 39:10very very clearly includes
- 39:13this man is talking about his own emotions
- 39:18and is showing attunement to his young child
- 39:22and trying to understand the child
- 39:26and you wash rinse repeat this over time
- 39:29and it's very likely to have the effect of simply
- 39:32normalizing
- 39:33being able to talk about feelings and emotions
- 39:35like when you get dysregulated
- 39:37that's one of the reasons why
- 39:38having a highly involved dad
- 39:40predicts children being much better emotional
- 39:43regulators when they get
- 39:45when they get further down that and
- 39:47you know different aspects of um
- 39:49kind of the
- 39:50the paternal activation relationship and risk taking
- 39:52and and so forth
- 39:54but having a dad that will say emotions
- 39:58good and bad are not emotions
- 39:59and sure angry yeah frustrated
- 40:01uh huh
- 40:02but that's all kind of the same secondary emotion
- 40:04but a dad that will go to a kid and say look
- 40:06I was feeling kind of helpless
- 40:08or feeling ashamed about this
- 40:10and you know I was anxious
- 40:12and so I know I looked angry
- 40:13and and you're giving them the gift of modeling
- 40:19emotions are not off the table here
- 40:21you have them I have them
- 40:22let's talk about what they mean
- 40:23and then
- 40:24they're likely to go through life with the expectation
- 40:26of if I'm in a relationship
- 40:28and we can't talk at that level
- 40:30it's probably not gonna work for me and sure
- 40:33the therapist thinks
- 40:34everybody needs to talk about feelings fine
- 40:36I walked into that one
- 40:37and just look at the evidence space
- 40:41right the guys that can't talk about their emotions
- 40:43the fathers who only have conflict by like
- 40:47being super confrontational and aggressive
- 40:49they get divorced more yeah
- 40:52they die sooner like all these things like
- 40:54like and so I'm sorry to keep coming back to this
- 40:56cause there's a whole contingent of
- 40:58of people in particular dudes
- 41:00that don't wanna hear be more emotionally available
- 41:03and learn how to interact with certain important
- 41:07close people in your life at that more affective
- 41:11emotional relational level
- 41:13and you're ultimately gonna be happier
- 41:15once you get past the awkwardness
- 41:17and your kids are gonna benefit hugely
- 41:20yeah I've heard you
- 41:21we haven't talked about this yet
- 41:23during this conversation but I've heard you refer
- 41:26to that kind of thing as upgrading your OS
- 41:29and I think that is such a perfect way to put it and
- 41:33and maybe in in terms of thinking about your job
- 41:36as you wanna make sure that your son or your daughter
- 41:40has a better OS than the one you have
- 41:44and in doing so
- 41:44you also wanna be able to upgrade your own OS
- 41:47to model that for them is that a good way to put it
- 41:50hundred percent yeah
- 41:52I love that that that image of upgrading your own OS is
- 41:56is a very powerful way to think about that
- 41:58I think and it's controversial right
- 42:01for folks who want to preserve a
- 42:05more traditional kind of masculinity and
- 42:07and fatherhood which they get to um
- 42:11the prospect of an upgrade is very unwelcome
- 42:15the problem is when you come back to
- 42:17when you really want to understand
- 42:19the most significant issues facing uh
- 42:21boys and men these days
- 42:23it is usually the results of the confluence of broader
- 42:27societal systemic factors
- 42:29and
- 42:31internally Learned lessons that don't feel flexible
- 42:35I have to be this kind of man why
- 42:37and then you ultimately dig down to it
- 42:38and you get to the existential stuff about
- 42:40you know unlovability
- 42:41rejection isolation
- 42:43meaningless and
- 42:43and you get away from well
- 42:45because evolution says no
- 42:47it doesn't sorry yeah
- 42:50yeah you know it
- 42:51it I
- 42:52I feel like there's an interesting paradox at work
- 42:56there and
- 42:57and it's probably it
- 42:58it might even be a false paradox because
- 43:01you know a lot of the discourse out there
- 43:03all the loudest discourses
- 43:04at either ends of the spectrum
- 43:06but on one side you have this
- 43:07these like avid men's right types that are just
- 43:11you know
- 43:12absolutely completely resistant to even examining the
- 43:15the possible merit of anything you're saying
- 43:17and on the other side
- 43:18you have these well meaning progressives
- 43:20with what is essentially misandry
- 43:23and it's completely unexamined for them and
- 43:25and so how do you I mean
- 43:26how do you navigate I'm sure that
- 43:27you must see that all the time in your work and
- 43:31and so I'm interested to know how you deal
- 43:33with that and you know
- 43:33how are we
- 43:34muggles supposed to deal with that sort of thing
- 43:37but with what specifically
- 43:39well with this
- 43:39with this paradox where you know
- 43:42on on our culture seems to
- 43:46to to force people to be on either one side or another
- 43:49where where you have to
- 43:51you almost have to be kind of
- 43:52almost a men's rights types
- 43:54where you don't even want to examine um
- 43:57the the possibility of the truth of this or no
- 44:00you wanna be a progressive that is
- 44:02that is deeply feeling and
- 44:03and you don't you don't even realize that
- 44:06some of what you're espousing is just
- 44:09not even particularly well disguised
- 44:12not even particularly well disguised misandry
- 44:16right uh
- 44:17well I can tell you
- 44:18uh for me personally
- 44:19in the in the work that I do professionally
- 44:23I'm not in any way trying to convert or appease
- 44:29the more extremist types that are out in the tales yeah
- 44:33that's that's not that being said
- 44:35I'm in plenty of meetings with folks who do come a
- 44:38come from a you know
- 44:39significantly more conservative
- 44:41or significantly more Liberal frame and
- 44:43and we've got work to do and
- 44:44and while I'm not gonna get on board with
- 44:47with aspects
- 44:49that just are not in line with the research
- 44:51or the science and
- 44:52and don't don't add up to me
- 44:56generally speaking
- 44:58I'm a kill them with kindness kind of a person yeah
- 45:00like folks I mean
- 45:02I always look like an idiot to the people on the left
- 45:04cause I don't go far enough
- 45:05and I look like an idiot to the people on the right
- 45:07cause I don't go far enough
- 45:08and that's fine but my guess is
- 45:10the vast majority of people are probably
- 45:12pretty well aligned to that
- 45:14and they're not and even though they're the most vocal
- 45:17people are that way
- 45:18and the most online social media people are that way
- 45:21the vast majority of people are kind of
- 45:23run the gamut in the middle
- 45:24don't you think it's it it
- 45:26it is a profoundly uncontroversial statement that
- 45:30in some ways men and boys struggle and suffer
- 45:33and so let's figure out ways to help support them
- 45:36sure in the context of power and privilege and all that
- 45:40yeah but just as a test case right
- 45:44folks will want to say like all men and
- 45:46you know and patriarchy and and the so forth
- 45:49which which has its own interesting like you
- 45:51you talked about misandry
- 45:53like it has its own sort of interesting frame
- 45:56it's like well
- 45:56a lot of times
- 45:57the way that the misandry comes out is not
- 45:59people saying screw men and boys yeah
- 46:02it's they're not important
- 46:04it's benign neglect yeah
- 46:06cause this other thing is important
- 46:07it's a zero something this other thing's important
- 46:09right but half the population
- 46:11you know slut
- 46:11just under half the population
- 46:13is not really that important
- 46:16and so for me just coming
- 46:18back with the totally to me
- 46:21uncontroversial statement
- 46:22that there's science
- 46:24about why boys and men struggle and suffer
- 46:27there is science about gender
- 46:29sensitive
- 46:29and informed ways to work with those men and boys
- 46:32and I have an ethical obligation to go get on that
- 46:34and that's what I'm doing here
- 46:35it doesn't have to be everybody else's frame
- 46:38but I'm I'm not looking to make converts
- 46:41I'm looking for folks who honestly
- 46:43probably don't think about this stuff very much
- 46:45but they know a boy in their life who's struggling
- 46:47they know a man in their life who's struggling
- 46:50they themselves
- 46:51may be that boy or man who are struggling or suffering
- 46:54and they're open to they're
- 46:55they're open to expanding a bit
- 46:58that's who we're going for
- 47:00yeah I
- 47:01I think that's the perfect way to look at it
- 47:03now you have two sons right
- 47:05they're 21 and 18
- 47:07yes looking back on your journey as a father
- 47:10and now seeing them as young men
- 47:11what do you think the most important thing that you did
- 47:15right is
- 47:15and what do you think you would do differently
- 47:19I was around I had to travel
- 47:22you know I did did
- 47:23did did a lot of work and
- 47:25and certain jobs had me on the road quite a lot
- 47:27but no matter what I was
- 47:30I was present with them a lot of camping
- 47:34you know we would do trips and so forth
- 47:36but beyond that I was there
- 47:37most nights to make dinner and for us to be together
- 47:41just to just to kind of
- 47:43you know BS or
- 47:44you know snipe at each other or whatever the thing was
- 47:47but one of the aspects of it is I was there
- 47:51I was involved I was engaged
- 47:54far from perfect just as many
- 47:56you know regrets and guilt as
- 47:57as any other parent I know
- 48:00and I've talked with thousands of them
- 48:02yeah over the years but
- 48:04but that that
- 48:05and I've always I've always tried to follow and
- 48:10and I think done a fairly decent job of following
- 48:13the advice that I gave earlier
- 48:15which is to own my mistakes and own them to my children
- 48:20to go to the boys and say hey
- 48:22when I I got angry
- 48:23I talked with you snarkily
- 48:24I just said something that if somebody else said to you
- 48:27I would lose it
- 48:29and it's not okay for them and it's not okay for me
- 48:31and I feel embarrassed I know I looked angry
- 48:34but the reality was what you did was making me worried
- 48:37and that's
- 48:37and so going and having that conversation with them
- 48:40unfortunately repeatedly
- 48:42cause
- 48:42I would be enacting parent fails over and over again
- 48:45yeah um
- 48:46that's another element of
- 48:48of what I'm what I'm proud of in my
- 48:51in my fathering
- 48:52that seems to have really played out with
- 48:54with the two of them no
- 48:55I I owe my son one of those conversations
- 48:58uh today actually
- 48:59cause we we walked to school and we had a
- 49:01we had a problem and and uh
- 49:03and it was my fault and uh
- 49:06so I I will make you this commitment I'll
- 49:08I will have that conversation with him today
- 49:10I love it
- 49:12you you use emotion words when you do
- 49:14I double dog dare you
- 49:17I love it I
- 49:18I have two more questions
- 49:20so uh
- 49:21the first is a father is listening right now
- 49:25who wants to break the cycle
- 49:27wants to be emotionally available to his son
- 49:30he wants to upgrade his own OS
- 49:32and he's starting from scratch
- 49:34he doesn't know where to go
- 49:35what is the one thing he should do right now
- 49:38this week today
- 49:40in order to start on that journey
- 49:43find other dads that you think are cool
- 49:45and begin to develop a community of like minded dads
- 49:50I think as men
- 49:51I think we under estimate the importance of community
- 49:57my wife has nine friends
- 49:58that she shares every detail of her life with
- 50:01and I have many fewer than that
- 50:04and it's yeah
- 50:05I mean it's not just you right like
- 50:07like the onset of parenthood
- 50:09certainly for men
- 50:10is a well documented inflection point
- 50:12where we become less healthy
- 50:14we sleep less we try to get all of our emotional
- 50:17support and intimacy needs met
- 50:18generally by our partner
- 50:20we start eating cold dino nuggets
- 50:23because that's what's on the counter
- 50:25when we get home from
- 50:26work instead of like a salad that I'd have to make
- 50:29and this
- 50:30this isolation piece and the letting friendships go
- 50:33I mean it's huge the I mean
- 50:35the the
- 50:36the Surgeon General of the US couple years back
- 50:38issued an entire report just on
- 50:41loneliness and social isolation
- 50:43and part of that finding was that
- 50:46being lonely
- 50:47and experiencing unwanted social isolation
- 50:51which is different than introvert recharge time
- 50:54overall health effects are in terms of morbidity
- 50:59mortality
- 50:59about the same as smoking a pack of cigarettes a day
- 51:03wow let let that sink in
- 51:06so my advice to the dad that's listening question 1 Dad
- 51:11are you fairly isolated sure you're around people a lot
- 51:15but are you actually connecting
- 51:17like do you have 2
- 51:183 other dads that that you can talk to him and be like
- 51:23dude I don't know how you do this work balance thing
- 51:25or like my relationships you know
- 51:26kind of a nightmare over here or what do you do with
- 51:29you know what's the best five point titanium reinforced
- 51:32dot endorsed
- 51:33you know car seat or or whatever the thing is
- 51:37but often times dads will take that um
- 51:42rugged individual like
- 51:44independence aspect of traditional masculinity
- 51:47and run with it and the problem is
- 51:49they'll use that to bolster the fact
- 51:51that bro dating is awkward right
- 51:54if if you're used to like dropping
- 51:56like you dropped your kid off today
- 51:58guaranteed you were walking by some other dads with
- 52:00their kids who might seem cool
- 52:03they had a snarky T-shirt that you were into
- 52:05or they kind of seem to have like a cool vibe going on
- 52:08or whatever it is
- 52:09and the prospect of going up and talking
- 52:11and pulling man digits is often times so awkward
- 52:16and so anxiety provoking but when you ask the dad
- 52:19it's like
- 52:20I just don't want to or I just don't have time for that
- 52:22it's like hmm
- 52:23you don't you sure you don't
- 52:25cause I've seen avoidance
- 52:28due to anxiety in pretty much all its forms
- 52:30at this point and that's a pretty straightforward one
- 52:33I invited a guy out to lunch not too long ago
- 52:36about a couple weeks ago now
- 52:38and I had a couple different reasons to do it
- 52:42one one of one of them was a businessy kind of reason
- 52:45but the other reason was
- 52:46I just like him and I wanted to be friends
- 52:49and I told him that I
- 52:51we were sitting across from each other at lunch
- 52:52I said you know
- 52:53I mean the reason I wanted and I know that you don't
- 52:55you and I don't know each other very well
- 52:56but the reason I wanted to invite you to lunch is No. 1
- 52:59I thought we might have some of these business things
- 53:01but more importantly man
- 53:02I think you're a cool guy and I want to be your friend
- 53:04and as I was saying this I felt so uncomfortable but
- 53:09then when it was done I felt great
- 53:11yeah I love that you did like
- 53:13it's sort of like like when I think about this
- 53:16I look like developmentally
- 53:17like I think about
- 53:18like a second grade boy or a third grade boy
- 53:20and he's on the playground and he
- 53:22like breathlessly runs up to some other
- 53:24some other kid and goes hey
- 53:26I like you let's play and be friends
- 53:28and they run off and like each other
- 53:30and they play and be friends
- 53:31but you know
- 53:31by the by the sixth grade
- 53:33it's like no
- 53:34no no
- 53:34no no
- 53:34that's not cool it's not cool to like things or care
- 53:37you know it is what it is and blow stuff off
- 53:40but I love that you had
- 53:41like a mandate where you were like bro
- 53:44I think you're cool let's play and hang out
- 53:46and like and I did
- 53:47I mean my son taught it to me
- 53:48my son does that all the time on the
- 53:51let's be best friends and then they go off together and
- 53:56and and I thought to myself
- 53:57well that's the way I should be too
- 53:59I mean and what a gift
- 54:02if I can keep my son from having to experience that
- 54:06sort of anxiety is
- 54:07so when he gets to 6th grade
- 54:09I want him to still feel that way
- 54:10about being able to go up to people and be vulnerable
- 54:13and and
- 54:13and ask him to be friends with him
- 54:16then I'm telling you
- 54:16you modeling that and talking with him about
- 54:19about what you're doing and yeah
- 54:21and the behavioral and what you're thinking and
- 54:25and and the emotional aspect of it
- 54:27like keep it up man
- 54:28I love that
- 54:30I appreciate that alright
- 54:32I like to close these discussions
- 54:34by asking everybody the same question
- 54:36and that's this what is one principle
- 54:40that you like to live your life by
- 54:42when it comes to raising powerful capable men
- 54:48be kind
- 54:50have the strength to be kind
- 54:55I don't think it's more complicated than that
- 54:57cause what's the opposite of that
- 54:59being cruel and what what gets people to cruelty
- 55:02usually they feel anxious and helpless and hopeless
- 55:06but the ones that can be kind
- 55:09even when it's a challenge
- 55:11are enacting a kind of strength
- 55:14that I would really like to see more of in the world
- 55:16particularly these days and you never regret being kind
- 55:20do you you regret being cruel a lot
- 55:24and you're never proud of being cruel
- 55:26no I mean
- 55:26you might be kind to someone who throws it in your face
- 55:28or or shames you
- 55:30and that's the risk you're running by being kind
- 55:32I'm gonna feel weak
- 55:33I'm gonna feel like I got taken advantage of
- 55:35there are risks to doing this
- 55:36which is why I see it as courageous
- 55:39and really called for for young boys to learn
- 55:44this is this is a kind of strength and power
- 55:48I think that is a beautiful place to end our discussion
- 55:51Doctor Daniel Singly
- 55:53is the founder of the center for Men's Excellence
- 55:55where he's dedicated his career
- 55:57to advancing men's mental health
- 55:59and father inclusive Psychology
- 56:01his work with Men Excel
- 56:03continues to empower men to lead with strength
- 56:06empathy and emotional intelligence
- 56:07helping fathers everywhere
- 56:09to raise the next generation of healthy
- 56:12resilient young men Doctor Singley
- 56:14it has been an honor to have you here today
- 56:16thank you so much for your valuable time
- 56:18thanks for having me
- 56:24raising men is produced by Phil Hernandez
- 56:28this episode was edited by Ralph Tolentino