Latest / Politics with Paul / The US Senate: Abolish, Keep the Same, or Reform? | Politics with Paul #109
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about the US senate.
- 0:12Specifically, should we eliminate the US senate, or should we keep it the same, or
- 0:17should we just reform it?
- 0:19Because there's an idea that has been cropping up more in the news lately, and it's this
- 0:24proposal to abolish the US senate and leave congress as a one chamber body that just has
- 0:29the US house.
- 0:31The US senate has been around since the establishment of the US constitution or the
- 0:36ratification of the US constitution.
- 0:38And the biggest change that it has seen apart from, obviously, expansion of its membership
- 0:43due to more states being admitted to the union is the seventeenth amendment in 1913, which
- 0:49made US senators directly elected by the voters instead of by the state legislatures like it
- 0:54originally was.
- 0:56And then, of course, states have handled how to elect their US senators all sorts of various
- 1:01ways.
- 1:02But the support for abolishing the US senate outright isn't considerable support by any
- 1:08stretch, but it does appear to be gaining some traction, and it's most prominently associated
- 1:14with the democratic socialists of America or the DSA and other members of the far left.
- 1:19And so the idea may become more popular as time goes on, But regardless, it goes to the heart
- 1:25of several of our most recurring debates and arguments about democracy and the structure and
- 1:32function of our government.
- 1:35So is the US senate an outdated institution that needs scrapping, or is it just fine the
- 1:41way it is?
- 1:42Or are there major reforms that are needed that don't go as far as eliminating the entity
- 1:46entirely?
- 1:47What are the arguments made each way, and what does it all mean for the most essential aspects
- 1:53of our political system?
- 1:56That is what we are here to talk about today.
- 1:58So let's get into it.
- 2:00I think it makes sense to first talk about why do we have a US Senate in the first place.
- 2:06And the reason why is obviously just to start off this whole thing, but it's goes to this
- 2:12general idea whenever you talk about removing something in politics or really anything, but
- 2:17especially in politics.
- 2:18It goes to this idea of what's called Chesterton's fence.
- 2:22It's not an actual fence, but it comes from this parable by an English writer, GK
- 2:28Chesterton, that most succinctly boils down to this idea that you should understand or at
- 2:33least consider why something was put in place before you go about trying to remove or change
- 2:40it, whether it's a law, a tradition, a structure, a rule, does not mean that the
- 2:47reason for this rule or thing was a good reason.
- 2:50It's it doesn't mean that there was even any real reason at all.
- 2:54Sometimes people put things in place without really thinking much about it.
- 2:57Does not mean that the reason for the rule or thing that we're talking about hasn't become
- 3:02outdated or that you must uncritically accept this thing if you don't understand its origins.
- 3:10However, it is a good rule of thumb for political debates because you should know why
- 3:16something is there because it helps you to assess and make sure that that thing really is
- 3:22the source of the problem, that you can more effectively counter arguments made to keep
- 3:28something in place.
- 3:29Or if you do support that thing, it helps your case for why we need to keep that thing in
- 3:34place instead of just saying, well, it's what we've always had.
- 3:37It but if you are somebody who votes for getting rid of whatever policy or or thing it
- 3:44is, you can also better inform your own arguments for removing or changing that thing.
- 3:50Because if you don't know why you wanna get rid of that thing or excuse me.
- 3:53If you if you don't know why that thing was there in the first place, somebody's argument
- 3:58for keeping it might be better than yours because you don't know how to counter that.
- 4:03And also, you can try to eliminate as many unforeseen consequences as possible.
- 4:09Maybe this policy or thing that's in place needs to be removed or go away.
- 4:16But if you don't have the right idea to replace it, you can make matters worse.
- 4:21If you wanna remove anything, any sort of policy or rule, you should always at least try
- 4:27to figure out why it was there in the first place.
- 4:32And so the same thing applies to what we're talking about here, the US senate.
- 4:36We should know why we have a US senate in the first place before we even if we do think that
- 4:43it's bad and we should get rid of it, we should know why it's there in the first place.
- 4:47And so the main reasons for having a US senate is because congress is bicameral, which means
- 4:53it has two chambers because the framers, especially James Madison and Alexander
- 4:57Hamilton, as they argued in the Federalist papers, they argued that the legislative
- 5:02chamber is inherently the most powerful of the three branches.
- 5:05You have the executive branch, which is where the presidency is, and the executive agencies,
- 5:11the legislative branch, which is congress, and the judicial branch was the courts.
- 5:15And at least in their view, the legislative branch was inherently the most powerful because
- 5:22it's the one that writes the laws in the first place.
- 5:25The president does not.
- 5:27And then that get now that can sort of get into this territory about our executive orders
- 5:31basically usurping congress's powers and duties, but that's beside the point here right
- 5:37now.
- 5:38So the idea for the legislative chamber was, well, if it's inherently the most powerful, we
- 5:44need to find some way to put it on a more level playing field with the other two branches.
- 5:50So why don't we split it into two chambers?
- 5:52So now its power is more on par with the executive and judicial branches, and it makes
- 5:58congress have to be more deliberative.
- 6:00And so the senate was created to also give smaller states equal power to the bigger
- 6:07states, and bigger states have more power in the US house because when the framers were
- 6:13debating how to create the US constitution, smaller states and bigger states were at odds
- 6:18about the representation in congress because, obviously, bigger states thought they should
- 6:23have more power because they had bigger population.
- 6:26State smaller states did not want to be completely dwarfed by larger states and have
- 6:34little power just because they were smaller states.
- 6:36So congress is basically one big compromise.
- 6:40The actual establishment of congress is one big compromise.
- 6:46So the house is more democratic and has two year terms to allow some level of quick
- 6:51turnaround if voters decided they wanted some change.
- 6:56And the senate would be less democratic, and there'd be six year terms to insulate it more
- 7:01from immediate electoral pressures and, quote, unquote, passions of the people.
- 7:07And at the time, The US Senate was actually chosen by the state legislature.
- 7:13So if you were a US senator from Maryland, the Maryland state legislature would actually
- 7:18choose you instead.
- 7:20And so the house and the senate making congress a bicameral legislature, that was one of the
- 7:28things that was needed to make as many of the framers of the constitution or as many of the
- 7:33attendees of that constitutional convention back in 1787 agreed to this framework for the
- 7:43then new US government or US federal government, at least.
- 7:50And so I said at the top that US senate has, for the most part, not seen a whole lot of
- 7:57change in its structure, save for the seventeenth amendment in 1913 being ratified
- 8:03that made the US senate directly elected.
- 8:08And the US senate has been around since the ratification of the US constitution, but there
- 8:13is at least one major historical example of trying to abolish the US senate back in 1911.
- 8:20And there are some echoes of the arguments that you see today and who some of those that are
- 8:28making the argument for abolishing the senate are.
- 8:31Victor Berger of Wisconsin, who was one of the first socialists to ever be elected to the US
- 8:36house.
- 8:37This was at a time where a handful give or take of socialists were winning seats in congress.
- 8:42There was a about a ten, twenty, or so so year period where a handful of socialists were
- 8:50getting into the US house, but that would eventually dissipate.
- 8:56But this is at that time where a few of them were winning office, and Victor Berger of
- 9:02Wisconsin, one of the first socialists, was the guy to push this idea in congress, proposed a
- 9:11constitutional amendment in the US house because he's a house representative to
- 9:16eliminate the US senate.
- 9:18And some of those arguments that he gave echo some of those that you hear from today's
- 9:23proponents for abolishing the US senate.
- 9:26And I'll take a quote from the beginning of his resolution.
- 9:31He says, whereas the senate in particular has become an obstructive and useless body, a
- 9:36menace to the liberties of the people and an obstacle to social growth, a body many of the
- 9:41members of which are representatives neither of a state nor of its people, but solely of
- 9:45certain predatory combinations and a body which by reason of the corruption often attending the
- 9:50election of its members has furnished the gravest public scandals in the history of the
- 9:54nation, and so on and so forth.
- 9:57Pretty scathing remarks, and you can see some of those arguments that proponents of
- 10:03abolishing the US senate make today.
- 10:06Maybe not the necessarily the exact same arguments, but you see some similar ones.
- 10:10Now, of course, the proposal didn't go anywhere.
- 10:12It died in committee.
- 10:14So even the rest of his US house associates weren't really interested in helping out that
- 10:22bill.
- 10:23But only a couple months later, The US Senate finally approved its long delayed resolution
- 10:28that would eventually become that seventeenth amendment to the US constitution that would
- 10:33make US senators directly elected by voters instead of through state legislatures.
- 10:39Now that's some background on this idea of abolishing the US senate.
- 10:44But before we get to the actual arguments, there is something else we need to talk about
- 10:49here.
- 10:50And it's whether this idea is an extreme position.
- 10:54And I say that this is something we should talk about because it really goes to this general
- 11:00idea about how often this word extreme gets used to describe political beliefs in this
- 11:08country, and it's used by left, right, and middle.
- 11:13It it extremism is a label that gets thrown around a lot, and it usually just boils down
- 11:18to, well, this person said something I don't like.
- 11:21And a lot of times, the people who say that something's extreme are just very polarized and
- 11:26think anything that's not them is a polarized take.
- 11:31And so the word is more of a political tool that is rooted in political biases rather than
- 11:37something that's earnestly an earnest description.
- 11:41And you see it from people on the left, on the right, and in the middle.
- 11:45And it's also very intellectually lazy because if you call something extreme, that insinuates
- 11:50it's not even worth thinking about.
- 11:51So you don't have to engage with the possible merits and demerits of a position.
- 11:56We don't have to use our brainpower and and possibly challenge our own beliefs because we
- 12:01already figured everything out.
- 12:03But as much as we've seen people describe this idea of abolishing the US senate as an extreme
- 12:10position, especially because of some of the most common proponents of it being socialist
- 12:16and the far left, We've also seen some people make the argument that it is not extreme, and
- 12:21they also have political incentives to do that too.
- 12:24Because like with those hurling the extremist accusations, those insisting isn't extreme,
- 12:31maybe a little bit less than genuine about that.
- 12:34Because the label extremist inherently has a negative connotation.
- 12:39Almost nobody is going to consider themselves an extremist.
- 12:42Even actual extremists are not gonna consider themselves extremists.
- 12:45And I don't want this to sound like I'm trying to say that extremism is completely subjective.
- 12:50It's not completely subject subjective.
- 12:52There's obviously some people there are obviously some people who are out and out
- 12:59extremists.
- 12:59People who think that it is okay for them to murder in the name of their political or
- 13:05religious creed, or people who think it is okay for them to forcefully suppress differing
- 13:11views.
- 13:12That's extremism, of course.
- 13:14I'm not somebody who is a complete moral I'm not a moral relativist here.
- 13:19I'm just saying that a lot of times, the label though is used just as a political tool.
- 13:25Even in cases worse, you can argue that a political position is still extreme, it's still
- 13:31used more as a way to try to not actually have to engage with that argument.
- 13:38So if you support something, you're probably not gonna call it extreme, especially if you
- 13:42wanna convince other people about your position.
- 13:45And if you oppose this thing, you have the incentive to say that it is extreme because you
- 13:51wanna try to bring people to your side, and nobody wants to support something that's super
- 13:56extreme.
- 13:58So I'm not trying to say that abolishing the US senate is or is not an extreme position just
- 14:04because it's a useless argument to have, and it's too rooted in emotion and biases rather
- 14:09than trying to be logical.
- 14:12But you can argue that abolishing the US senate is a radical position, but let me explain that
- 14:18for a moment because now you might be thinking, you just said it's not extreme.
- 14:21Radical is not the same thing as extreme.
- 14:25They can be the same thing, but they're not actually.
- 14:28Radical can still have a negative connotation, but it's not exactly the same as extreme.
- 14:33And that's because my usage of radical here is a reference to one specific spectrum that is
- 14:39used in political science.
- 14:40It characterizes beliefs across a continuous line based on whether or not somebody wants to
- 14:48alter or revert a current system and how much they want to do so.
- 14:53So let me make sure I've Okay.
- 14:55Yes.
- 14:55So this is based on your the way you can see my hands.
- 15:00You have reactionary, then you have conservative, then you have moderate, then you
- 15:06have liberal, and then you have radical.
- 15:09So a reactionary is somebody who wants to revert back to a previous state of society that
- 15:15they think is more positive.
- 15:17They are more than conservative.
- 15:18Conservatives wanna maintain a status quo, and they're generally hesitant hesitant, excuse me,
- 15:24to change.
- 15:25Reactionaries wanna actually go back to a specific or a previous state of society.
- 15:32Then you have liberal, which is a somebody who advocates for gradual change through existing
- 15:41systems.
- 15:41And then, of course, moderate is between conservative and liberal.
- 15:45And then radical, which means you want rapid fundamental change in society towards something
- 15:51new.
- 15:52And depending on the level of new changes made in society, what is liberal or radical could
- 15:57eventually become conservative down the road.
- 16:01Some a lot of the things that you see in politics today, at one point, they were
- 16:07considered radical.
- 16:09Now they're much more commonplace.
- 16:13So in this context, eliminating the US senate is radical because it would be a rapid
- 16:18fundamental change completely different than anything we have seen, at least at the federal
- 16:24level, since the US constitution was ratified.
- 16:29But that does not mean that we don't have to engage with it.
- 16:33We don't have to think things over.
- 16:36It's don't get caught up too much in these labels here.
- 16:40So now with that out of the way, let's talk genuinely about this debate.
- 16:44What fundamental concepts and arguments are at issue here?
- 16:49I wanna talk about two of them.
- 16:51Two very basic things here.
- 16:54Is the US senate undemocratic, and does the US senate make congress and therefore overall
- 17:01government more deliberative and thoughtful, or does it just make it inefficient?
- 17:06And at the end, we'll briefly go over ideas for reforming the US senate instead of eliminating
- 17:12it completely.
- 17:13And we'll also assume for this exercise that all arguments for and against abolishing the US
- 17:20senate are made earnestly.
- 17:23That is necessary for genuinely debating this topic.
- 17:26In reality, though, many of those that are calling for the abolition of The US are just
- 17:31mad that they do not control the US senate.
- 17:33While a lot of those that are opposing the abolition of the US senate just don't wanna
- 17:38give up their power.
- 17:41There that's like many things in politics, there are ulterior motives.
- 17:46What what they're arguing for is a lot of times something that benefits them.
- 17:50I don't think that if if if more socialists were in the US senate, I don't think as many of
- 17:58them would be arguing to get rid of the entity.
- 18:01And a lot of those who oppose socialism, I think they would be a little bit more amenable
- 18:05to abolishing the US senate if more socialists were in the US senate.
- 18:11But I digress on that point.
- 18:13It is something that you have to keep in mind though when you hear a lot of these arguments
- 18:17is are some of these people being sincere about whether they really think this entity needs to
- 18:24be gotten rid of.
- 18:26But for this exercise, we're just assuming everybody is genuine in their intent here.
- 18:32So first, is the US senate undemocratic?
- 18:36And that's one of the main arguments about The US Senate.
- 18:39We treat democracy as a bedrock of the American political system even if it isn't a pure
- 18:44democracy and it wasn't fully intended to be.
- 18:48So is this accusation true?
- 18:51Well, yeah, it kinda is.
- 18:53But is that necessarily problematic?
- 18:56Hang on a second.
- 18:57I just said that democracy is a bedrock of American politics, or at least it's supposed to
- 19:03be.
- 19:03So how could I how could it be a good thing that the US senate is not a democratic
- 19:08institution?
- 19:09Because the US senate does not equally represent the will of the people.
- 19:13It is not one person, one vote as smaller states have the same number of US senators as
- 19:18bigger states.
- 19:19Wyoming gets the same number of senators as New York does.
- 19:24Hawaii gets the same number of US senators as Florida does.
- 19:28But here's the thing.
- 19:29Many of the framers of the constitution did not intend for the government to be fully
- 19:34democratic, and several of them worried about factual passions explicitly and potentially
- 19:42uninformed voters overtaken the system, what some would call mob rule, quote unquote.
- 19:49But how much they were wary of democracy wasn't necessarily a consensus because their views on
- 19:57how democratic the system should be differed to the point that they had to debate what parts of
- 20:01the system should be democratic and which one should not be democratic.
- 20:06Because The US constitution is an amalgamation of democratic and undemocratic ideals or or
- 20:12policies, I should say.
- 20:14And in fact, congress is the result of a compromise between smaller and bigger states
- 20:21because of this whole what should be democratic, what should not be.
- 20:25The house was a win for the bigger states because the power there is based on the state
- 20:29populations.
- 20:30The senate's a win for smaller states because it leveled the playing field regardless of the
- 20:34state's populations.
- 20:38An inherent in the arguments about democracy is what is considered fair.
- 20:44Sometimes, democracy and fair are terms that are used interchangeably or seen as one and the
- 20:50same, but they're not necessarily the same thing.
- 20:53What constitutes fair in the context of the US senate?
- 20:58If you support abolishing the US senate, you say that the US senate is an undemocratic
- 21:04institution, and it's unfair because it goes against the idea of one person, one vote, which
- 21:10is fair.
- 21:12If you are against the abolition of the US senate, abolition would actually be the unfair
- 21:18stance because it weakens smaller states' power and lets bigger states dictate policy in
- 21:24congress.
- 21:24Also fair.
- 21:27And when I say fair, I mean, those are fair points made by either side.
- 21:33And so the US senate isn't intended to be a democratic institution, but is it perhaps now
- 21:40too undemocratic?
- 21:42That is something for you who is listening to to decide here.
- 21:48And then the other fundamental concept to talk about here is does the US senate make the
- 21:54government too inefficient?
- 21:55Does it slow it down?
- 21:56Does it bog down government function?
- 21:59Because one of the most common complaints about government is that it is slow to respond.
- 22:03It's inefficient.
- 22:04It's gridlocked.
- 22:05They can't get anything done.
- 22:08Framers like Madison and Hamilton argued that the legislative branch was inherently the most
- 22:14powerful of the three branches, so the power had to be diluted by making it bicameral.
- 22:19Forces the government to be more deliberate, and you have to cut deals and compromise and
- 22:23hear different ideas from all over the place.
- 22:29So it's true that it requires more deal making with two branches than just one, and therefore,
- 22:35it inherently makes government slower to have two branches instead of one.
- 22:42Does that come at the expense of a reasonably responsive government though?
- 22:47Because at the heart of this issue is this particular issue is whether we want a
- 22:53deliberate government or an efficient government.
- 22:55And this is something I had covered much more extensively in a previous episode of this
- 23:01podcast.
- 23:02And I'm not the first person to come up with this concept.
- 23:05I don't know if they necessarily use the exact words that I use, but do you want a government
- 23:10that's more deliberate or do you want one that's more efficient?
- 23:14Because both sides have their pros and cons, and in some cases, a more deliberate government
- 23:18may be better, and in other cases, a more efficient government may be better.
- 23:24Because on one hand, a deliberative government is forced to take in consideration more views
- 23:31and not just be rash.
- 23:33More people are involved in the process inherently, but it can also make government too
- 23:39slow to respond to pressing needs and can be bogged down by political opportunists who see
- 23:44that I can try to just slow down things to get my point of view across.
- 23:48But on the other side, for efficient government, yes, government can then be swift
- 23:54to respond to critical issues and crises when they need a quick response, but it can also
- 24:00lead to more unintended consequences by failing to think policies through before we try to run
- 24:06it through the legislative process, and the majority can just simply run roughshod over
- 24:12detractors to a policy.
- 24:14So it's not a simple this this way is better, this way is not when you're talking about the
- 24:21speed of government.
- 24:24And there's also the fact that it tends to be the people who are currently in control.
- 24:30They want a more efficient government because they wanna get all their things done that they
- 24:33wanna get done.
- 24:34They wanna run through things through as quickly as possible and not and have as little
- 24:40opposition as possible.
- 24:41Whereas, if you're not in power, suddenly, deliberative government looks a whole lot
- 24:46better to you, and you think, you know what?
- 24:48Think government needs to take into account other people's views.
- 24:52It's funny how that works.
- 24:53Right?
- 24:54And so having a senate in addition to a house clearly sides with the case for a deliberate
- 25:00government.
- 25:01And giving US senators six year terms is another method of of deliberate government
- 25:06because US senators are, at least in theory, supposed to be elder statesmen and stateswomen
- 25:12who are much more seasoned.
- 25:14They have a lot more information.
- 25:16They're much more able to think things through and be generally insulated from political
- 25:22pressures.
- 25:23They're less subject to these, quote, unquote, temporary passions, these immediate electoral
- 25:27pressures of voters by making their terms longer.
- 25:31People think harder about who they choose for the US senate because of those term lengths.
- 25:36At least, that's the theory.
- 25:37So what about reforming the US senate instead of eliminating it?
- 25:42Like with lots of arguments in politics, what to do about the US senate is sometimes being
- 25:47treated like a binary choice.
- 25:49It's an either or, and it's not a binary choice.
- 25:52You'd find a lot of things in politics are more than just choice a and choice b.
- 25:58So what if instead we just change some major aspects of the chamber without getting rid of
- 26:03it altogether?
- 26:05In this podcast, I I strive to keep my own opinions out as much as I possibly can.
- 26:11If I do put them forth, I try to be as balanced and level headed as possible.
- 26:15Try not to favor any one position too much.
- 26:19In this case, though, I'm going to be forthright.
- 26:21I think abolishing the US senate is a very bad idea.
- 26:25It is not going to work out the way you think it will, and you might wanna be careful what
- 26:29you wish for.
- 26:30But it's also ridiculous to act like everything's as as just fine and dandy as it
- 26:35is.
- 26:36I don't know how you can look at anything in politics just about and say, well, everything's
- 26:42just cool, and we don't need to do anything about it.
- 26:45But before we talk about those ideas for reform, we have to talk about something else.
- 26:50First of all, abolition of the US senate is never going to happen because they will require
- 26:55a constitutional amendment with super majority support because to propose a constitutional
- 27:00amendment or actually, first, why does it require a constitutional amendment?
- 27:04Because the US senate is embedded in the US constitution.
- 27:08And in order to change the US constitution, you need an amendment to do that.
- 27:12Just like how there was an amendment that was needed to change how we chose our US senators
- 27:18where it used to be state legislatures that chose them, and then it became a directly
- 27:23elected body just like the US house.
- 27:27And to propose a constitutional amendment, you need either two thirds of both chambers of
- 27:32congress or needs to be requested by two thirds of state legislatures.
- 27:37Now the US senate is not going to support eliminating itself, so you can just throw that
- 27:42out the window.
- 27:43You are not gonna have two thirds of both chambers of congress.
- 27:46US house is probably not gonna do it either because they don't want to start a fight with
- 27:51the US senate whether they are the same party or not.
- 27:55And then state legislatures are not gonna come even close to two thirds because many are not
- 28:02gonna support a system that does not benefit them for various reasons.
- 28:05A lot of those state legislators, they're gonna wanna run for US senate at some point Or with
- 28:12how much the parties are becoming more and more uniform in their policy views, a republican
- 28:20legislature is not gonna get rid of a system that gets rid of its republican US senators,
- 28:25and a democratic legislature is not gonna get rid of a system that gets rid of its democratic
- 28:30US senators.
- 28:31They're not gonna do it if it's going to hurt their party.
- 28:35And it's probably going to hurt their party because more and more of these states are
- 28:39pretty starkly red or starkly blue.
- 28:44But let's just say that the proposal process was successful.
- 28:48You did find two thirds of chambers in congress or or of both chambers in congress or you found
- 28:54two thirds of the state legislatures to say, yeah, we wanna get rid of the US senate.
- 29:01Even if that was going to be the case, you still need three quarters of state legislatures
- 29:07or three quarters of special conventions held by the states to ratify this constitutional
- 29:14amendment to remove the US senate.
- 29:17That's still not going to happen.
- 29:19But regardless of the possibility or lack thereof of abolishing the US senate, as flawed
- 29:28as the US senate is, as is any government institution, I do not believe it's gonna make
- 29:33the fixes that some people think it will.
- 29:35Yes.
- 29:36You make congress capable of acting faster with one house.
- 29:39And sometimes, the government is too inefficient and slow.
- 29:42But that doesn't mean you're going to get better policy.
- 29:44A lot of times, they don't thinks think things through because they are just focused on
- 29:49getting their interest pushed through and don't listen to other people when it's just gonna be
- 29:55one chamber.
- 29:57And as polarized and averse to working together as we can be, a bicameral legislature forces
- 30:03some level of deal making even when one party controls both chambers.
- 30:07Because there are some points where congress or certain state legislatures were a house and
- 30:14senate were at real odds with each other even though they were the same party.
- 30:20And while minority political groups can be purposefully obstinate to and purposely try to
- 30:29bog down a political process, like with the filibuster, for example, we also need to limit
- 30:35the capability of the majority to run over people who don't agree with them.
- 30:39And we already have a serious problem in this country of not listening to differing views
- 30:43already, regardless of whether or not we get rid of the US senate.
- 30:50So I'm going to be honest that I don't believe that this is a good idea, but I also wanna try
- 30:56to give as much of a balanced view of both abolishing and keeping the US senate as is
- 31:04because I want people to think these things through for themselves and to really understand
- 31:09these ideas that are at the heart of these debates, because I do not believe in echo
- 31:16chambers.
- 31:16I don't believe in pandering, and I'm not going to I don't want people to just accept
- 31:20everything that I tell them.
- 31:23I also wanna make clear, I do not think the US senate is great the way it is.
- 31:27It's clearly not.
- 31:30So what are some potential reforms that are more achievable?
- 31:33Because you're not gonna get rid of the US senate.
- 31:36It's just not going to happen.
- 31:37Even if it even if we agreed that it was needed, if it was objectively better, it's not
- 31:45gonna actually happen.
- 31:46So let's talk about some potential ideas.
- 31:49I'm not saying we need any of these ideas specifically, but it's it's to get the cogs
- 31:54turning about in our heads about, well, some maybe some of you listening are sympathetic to
- 32:04the idea of abolishing the US senate.
- 32:06Well, have you considered these ideas instead?
- 32:08Because some of these things may be something that is needed anyways.
- 32:12And then it might actually fix the US senate, at least in the ways that you think it needs to
- 32:17be fixed because a a lot of times we think we need to get rid of something when really it
- 32:23just needs to be fixed.
- 32:25And then, of course, there are some times where we think we need to fix something when you just
- 32:29need to get rid of it altogether.
- 32:30But you have to be really careful about just haphazardly removing a policy or an entity or
- 32:38anything.
- 32:38You gotta make sure that you have something better in place.
- 32:41But what are some potential reforms of the US senate that are more achievable than just
- 32:45getting rid of the body entirely?
- 32:48Well, you could talk talk about the filibuster, which is probably the most common complaint
- 32:53about the US senate.
- 32:55Should we get rid of the filibuster or at least lower the threshold for the vote for cloture,
- 33:01which is what can actually override the filibuster?
- 33:04Because the in a filibuster, you need 60 US senators to override the filibuster so that
- 33:12people stop yapping to try to stop a bill.
- 33:17And you've seen some notable instances over the years or have read about notable instances over
- 33:25the years of US senators using the filibuster for a very long time.
- 33:29A couple years ago, I believe it was Cory Booker over in from Colorado.
- 33:35The most famous example of a filibuster, though, probably is Strahm Thurmond back in
- 33:40nineteen nineteen fifty seven, but he spent just over twenty four hours arguing against the
- 33:49civil rights bill.
- 33:50Not a good look, but he he did go for twenty four hours.
- 33:53Funny enough, though, they passed the bill, like, shortly after he finished his spiel.
- 33:59But if we talk about the filibuster more generally, though, this is another way that you
- 34:07see a lot of people be insincere about whether they really support the filibuster or not
- 34:11because I can think of specific instances in both the Republican and Democratic parties
- 34:16where they have flip flopped on whether they support the filibuster based on whether their
- 34:22party was in charge at the time.
- 34:26Filibuster looks like an awful thing when you're in charge because you just wanna get
- 34:30your policies run through.
- 34:32And all the this minority party is trying to trying to be obstinate.
- 34:37They're trying to obstruct.
- 34:38They're trying to stop us from getting needed work done.
- 34:40And if you are the one that's out of power, the filibuster is needed to protect your ability to
- 34:45speak your mind and to have earnest debate and to make sure that government is thinking things
- 34:53through and you are representing your people.
- 34:55And all of a sudden, when the minority party becomes the majority party, sometimes people
- 35:02who supported the filibuster, all of a sudden, now the filibuster seems like a terrible thing.
- 35:06And when you thought the filibuster was a terrible thing before, now all of sudden, seems
- 35:10like a great thing.
- 35:12So you should be wary of people of of members of congress who have done that when they say
- 35:20that we should or shouldn't get rid of a filibuster because pretty much always a vested
- 35:25interest in that at that given point in time.
- 35:28But I digress on that point.
- 35:31Should we get rid of the filibuster?
- 35:33I believe the filibuster is necessary, but should we lower the threshold for cloture then?
- 35:39Should it be instead of 60 senators, should it be 55 US senators?
- 35:44Or doesn't need doesn't even need to be a multiple of five.
- 35:47Maybe it should be 57 US senators or 53, or it should be 60 US senators, but only for certain
- 35:55types of bills.
- 35:56So if it's a if it has to do with taxes, maybe it needs to be 60 US senators.
- 36:01Or maybe in in the case of taxes, it could be knocked down to 50.
- 36:05But then if you're talking about elections bills, then maybe that still needs 60 US
- 36:12senators, or you can knock that to 50 US senators where the vote for cloture is needed.
- 36:18And these ideas about the filibuster and the vote for cloture, these ideas do not require an
- 36:25amendment to the US constitution because the filibuster is not part of the US constitution.
- 36:28It's part of the rules for the US senate.
- 36:31But that still has a process for how to change those rules as opposed to just simply just
- 36:36saying, we're not doing this anymore.
- 36:39But other ideas that would need a constitutional amendment, but would still be
- 36:44much more likely to happen than the than getting rid of the US senate entirely is what
- 36:52if instead of keeping the US senate completely equal, but also not just changing it to where
- 36:59it's basically just another US house where it's based on population proportionally, what if we
- 37:06just gave bigger states one to two extra US centers, but not too too much more that it
- 37:11becomes unbalanced and all of a sudden, smaller states are being left in the lurch again.
- 37:18So maybe states like California and New York and Texas and Florida get three US senators or
- 37:24four US senators, whereas all these other smaller states or California, New York,
- 37:31Florida, and Texas are the four most populous states in the union.
- 37:37What if they get four?
- 37:39And then states that are still pretty well populated, but not as much like a Virginia or
- 37:44an Illinois.
- 37:45Maybe they get three US senators, and then states like a Hawaii, a Wyoming, a Kansas, a
- 37:51Louisiana, they get two US senators.
- 37:54So now they are not they're not on the same exact or so a a state that has, like, 800,000
- 38:02people isn't getting two US senators or the same number of US senators as a state that has,
- 38:07like, fifteen, twenty million people, but it's still at least somewhat balanced in a way where
- 38:15these smaller states aren't being completely dwarfed.
- 38:18Maybe that's an idea that can be that can be done.
- 38:22Or what if we added at large national or regional US senators?
- 38:28Maybe we have a handful of senators that get elected across the country just like they do
- 38:33for the presidency, or you have them for a specific region.
- 38:39So like the Southeast gets one, then the Northeast, then the Midwest, or the North the
- 38:45Pacific Coast, or something along those lines.
- 38:49So instead of just each state having US senators, now you have senators that represent
- 38:55a whole region.
- 38:56Or what if we kept the number of US senators the same, but now you split it where one
- 39:01senator takes one half and then another senator takes the other half.
- 39:05So then you start to get into redistricting, which as a whole other can of worms that we've
- 39:11talked about before, of course, that has its own political issues.
- 39:15But could you make it where a US senator takes one half that takes up a lot of the West side
- 39:22of a state, and then the other senator takes the East side of it, or one takes the North
- 39:28side and one takes the South side.
- 39:29But you obviously try to make it balanced in terms of population.
- 39:35There those are just some starting points for ideas about how to reform the US senate.
- 39:42I'm not saying that I necessarily agree or disagree with any of them.
- 39:46I I don't the getting the rid of the filibuster is not gonna work out the way you think it
- 39:50will.
- 39:50That I will say.
- 39:51But I think that you can definitely talk about reforming how it's used or when it's used.
- 39:58So there's just some ideas there for what can possibly be done to reform the US senate.
- 40:06Because the US senate, just like pretty much everything else in politics, needs refinement,
- 40:11and it needs to be needs to be reformed over time.
- 40:17But, of course, what what what needs to be reformed is a is a a subjective thing, and
- 40:24there's no it's it's not an easy fix.
- 40:27But it's it's something that we need to talk about a lot more and be earnest in talking
- 40:32about it so that we can actually have the best policies we can possibly come up with.
- 40:37But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 40:40As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 40:42Please like, comment, and subscribe, and let everybody that you know know about this
- 40:50podcast.
- 40:50Spread the word so we can make politics more accessible for everybody.
- 40:55My links are in the show notes.
- 40:57The other works I have, my five day educational email course about how we can all more
- 41:02effectively detoxify and depolarize the politics in this country.
- 41:10My works that my writings on medium.com, and my book that I wrote about political independence
- 41:19is the Amazon link is is in the show notes as well.
- 41:24My other links, my Facebook, my linkedin.com profile, and my website, paul raider dot org,
- 41:32and my email, paulraiderwrites@gmail.com.
- 41:36So we're gonna leave things here.
- 41:38Again, thank you so much for listening and for watching, and we'll see you next time.