Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Howard Marks on why your instincts fail
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. We've got a really fascinating
- 0:03one for you today. Yeah, we are setting the stage
- 0:05for a truly counterintuitive exploration.
- 0:08We really are. We're talking about money, about
- 0:11human psychology, and and honestly, why our most deeply
- 0:15ingrained natural instincts actually make us terrible
- 0:18investors. It is a fascinating look in the
- 0:20mirror to be honest. It is, but before we get into
- 0:23the psychology of it all, a quick reminder for you to access
- 0:26more advanced researches, applications and the latest
- 0:28published Personal Intelligent Multi Agent Deep Value
- 0:31Intelligence. Welcome to subscribe on Deep
- 0:33Values dot AI and research dot deep values dot AI and.
- 0:37Since we'll be talking a lot about market temperature today.
- 0:39Oh, right, yeah, to track total market temperature.
- 0:41Welcome to search and download the iOS app The Buffett
- 0:43Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 0:45Definitely a good tool to have handy.
- 0:46For sure. And of course our standard
- 0:48disclaimer. All analysis is based on
- 0:51publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 0:55differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 0:58are for educational and research purposes only and do not
- 1:02constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 1:05before making investment decisions.
- 1:07And, you know, that kind of rigorous due diligence is
- 1:10exactly what today's source material is built on.
- 1:12We're unpacking A genuinely remarkable conversation from the
- 1:15Brookfield Perspectives video series.
- 1:17It features the legendary investor Howard Marks speaking
- 1:20with Albert Daglio Glue. And what makes this specific
- 1:23dialogue so compelling, I think, is that it steps completely away
- 1:26from the daily noise. Totally.
- 1:28You are not going to hear them arguing about what a specific
- 1:31tech stock is going to do next Tuesday.
- 1:33Yeah, thankfully. Instead, they examine the
- 1:35fundamental balance between offense and defense in a
- 1:37portfolio and how understanding market cycles is well, it's
- 1:41almost entirely dependent on mastering your own psychological
- 1:44responses. I want to start with how they
- 1:45open this conversation because it completely flips the script
- 1:49on how most people approach finance.
- 1:51I mean, we all want a crystal ball, right?
- 1:53Yes. You turn on the financial news
- 1:56and every single pundit is trying to predict where the
- 1:59economy will be in six months or or what the Federal Reserve will
- 2:02do next year. But Howard Marks lays down a
- 2:05hard truth here. Predicting the future is
- 2:08impossible. Period.
- 2:10Right. If you take actions based on
- 2:11what you think will happen a year from now, you are usually
- 2:14going to be wrong. But he says, understanding
- 2:16exactly where we are right now, the current market temperature,
- 2:19that is the real cheat code. It's a vital distinction, but it
- 2:22really all comes down to your time horizon, doesn't it?
- 2:25It does. Marks notes that if you are
- 2:27genuinely investing for 20 or 30 years, you can honestly ignore a
- 2:31lot of this temperature checking.
- 2:32Just set it and forget. It exactly, if you have 3
- 2:35decades you just buy good assets and hold them through the chaos.
- 2:38But let's be realistic, human nature makes that incredibly
- 2:40difficult. Oh, nearly impossible for most
- 2:43people. If you care about the next one
- 2:45to five years, which almost everyone does, whether for their
- 2:48portfolios, performance or just their own Peace of Mind, you
- 2:51absolutely must understand the current balance between optimism
- 2:55and pessimism in the room. Which kind of begs the question
- 2:58of where we stand today. Well, the conversation points
- 3:00out that right now, optimism is absolutely dominating the
- 3:03market. We have had a massive.
- 3:05Run. There's a staggering statistic
- 3:06they bring up in the video that really puts this current era
- 3:09into perspective. Yeah, it's quite a statistic.
- 3:11They highlight that the recent 39 month period, so roughly
- 3:14spanning from late 2022 into early 2025, ranks as the 7th
- 3:19best three-year period for the S&P 500 out of the entire last
- 3:23100 years. 7th out of. Century.
- 3:25Let that sink in. 7th out of 100 years.
- 3:28That is a monumental surge in asset prices and it's entirely
- 3:31driven by a profound wave of market optimism.
- 3:34So true. Okay, let's think about what
- 3:36that actually means for you, the listener, because my first
- 3:39instinct and I think a lot of people's instinct is to look at
- 3:42that and think well market is doing great, I should be
- 3:45throwing more money in right the.
- 3:46FOMO kicks in. Exactly.
- 3:48Fear of missing out. So why is that a dangerous
- 3:50assumption? Because of the seesaw fact
- 3:52between price and perspective returns.
- 3:54OK, unpack that seesaw for us. When optimism is high, prices
- 3:58soar way above a company's actual intrinsic value.
- 4:02People are happily paying a premium just to get in on the
- 4:05action because like you said, they have FOMO, right?
- 4:08But because you are paying such a massive premium today, your
- 4:11perspective returns for the future shrink considerably, and
- 4:14at the same time your risk of a sudden downturn grows.
- 4:17So you're basically buying high hoping it goes even higher.
- 4:20Exactly. You are relying on the greater
- 4:22fool theory. So if we are in this wildly
- 4:25optimistic top seven in the century market, the move isn't
- 4:29sheer aggression. No, Mark suggests it is actually
- 4:32actually time for what he calls an upgrading of defensiveness.
- 4:35Upgrading of defensiveness. I like that phrasing.
- 4:38And this defensive posture is compounded by a larger
- 4:41macroeconomic reality, right? Yes, the massive tailwinds that
- 4:44drove rapid growth in the late 20th century are fading.
- 4:48Think about the massive post World War 2 economic recovery.
- 4:52Or the initial explosion of the Internet and technological
- 4:54advances. Yeah, and the massive,
- 4:56unprecedented wave of global free trade and globalization.
- 4:59Those unique historical forces were massive engines for
- 5:02corporate profits. They really drove the market.
- 5:04Up, but they're likely going to be far less impactful in the
- 5:07decades ahead. Right.
- 5:08Suggesting we might be facing a future of much more moderate
- 5:11growth. So blind aggression in a highly
- 5:14optimistic market, especially without those historical
- 5:17tailwinds, is a very dangerous game.
- 5:19It's funny though, if we know high optimism means high risk
- 5:22and high prices mean lower future returns, why do we keep
- 5:25buying at the top? It makes no logical sense.
- 5:27None. We don't act like this anywhere
- 5:29else in our lives. There's a real life paradox
- 5:31Marks brings up here. The retail analogy.
- 5:33Yeah, if you go to the store and your favorite brand of coffee or
- 5:37or the shoes you've been eyeing or suddenly 40% off, you buy
- 5:40more of them. You literally text your friends
- 5:42about the great sale you suck up.
- 5:44Exactly. But in the financial markets,
- 5:47human beings do the exact opposite.
- 5:48When prices drop and the market goes on sale, people actively
- 5:52want to sell what they have and run away.
- 5:54It is a profound flaw in human psychology, and it is what makes
- 5:58good investing inherently uncomfortable.
- 6:00Because you're fighting your own brain.
- 6:01Truly attractive valuations. The real generational bargains.
- 6:06They only appear in environments marked by extreme fear, extreme
- 6:09uncertainty and forced selling. Marx actually brings up two
- 6:12historical examples where staring into the abyss was a
- 6:15requirement for success. Yes, September 19th, 2008, right
- 6:19after the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy, and March 2020, the
- 6:22low point of the global pandemic panic.
- 6:24Those were terrifying moments. I mean, I remember looking at my
- 6:26retirement accounts in March 2020 and just wanting to close
- 6:29my eyes and pretend it wasn't happening.
- 6:31Everyone did. The panic was palpable.
- 6:34And in both of those moments of absolute terror, Marks actually
- 6:38wrote memos to his clients with the exact same title.
- 6:41Nobody knows. Nobody knows I.
- 6:43Love that title. It is so brutally honest.
- 6:46He wasn't pretending he had the crystal ball we talked about
- 6:48earlier. Not at all.
- 6:49But during those terrifying moments, he points out a golden
- 6:52rule of risk that is incredibly counterintuitive.
- 6:55Let's think about what this actually means for a second, he
- 6:57says. The riskiest thing in the world
- 7:00is the belief that there's no risk.
- 7:02It sounds like a Riddle, but it is deeply pragmatic.
- 7:05How so? When everyone is happy, the
- 7:07economy is humming and everyone believes the market can only go
- 7:10up, they stop demanding a margin of safety.
- 7:12They buy at any price. Because they think it's a sure
- 7:15thing, right? And that is when you are in the
- 7:17most danger, because any slight piece of bad news will shatter
- 7:21that fragile perfection and send prices tumbling.
- 7:24So the inverse is equally true then.
- 7:26When people are terrified and believe risk is everywhere, that
- 7:29is actually when things are the safest.
- 7:31Wait wait, how is it safest when everyone is panicking?
- 7:34I think people struggle with that concept.
- 7:36It's because that absolute terror drives prices down to
- 7:40rock bottom, far below their intrinsic value.
- 7:43When prices are that depressed, the prospective returns are at
- 7:47their absolute highest. Furthermore, the actual downside
- 7:51risk is minimal because the absolute worst case scenario is
- 7:54already priced in. Everyone who wanted to panic
- 7:56sell has already sold. But doing that requires so much
- 8:00courage. You have to embrace the ache of
- 8:02doing what feels entirely wrong to your nervous system.
- 8:04You really do. If an investment feels
- 8:06incredibly easy, or if everyone at a dinner party agrees it is a
- 8:09genius move, you are probably buying at the absolute top of a
- 8:12bubble. Marx uses a quote from Warren
- 8:14Buffett to drive this home, which I think perfectly
- 8:17encapsulates this contrarian mindset.
- 8:19Oh, the. Prudence quote.
- 8:20Yeah, Buffett says. The less prudence with which
- 8:22others conduct their affairs, the greater the prudence with
- 8:25which we must conduct our own. It is the very essence of
- 8:28contrarianism. You cannot achieve better
- 8:31returns than the average investor if you behave exactly
- 8:34like the average investor. You have to diverge from the
- 8:36herd. OK, so that leads us to a
- 8:39massive question. If long term contrarian
- 8:42investing is so mathematically powerful, and buying when others
- 8:46are fearful is the proven way to build wealth, why do so few
- 8:50people actually do it? The conversation breaks this
- 8:53down into three major roadblocks, and the first one is
- 8:56bigs right into our biology. Yeah, in behavioral economics
- 8:59this is known as the non linear utility function.
- 9:02Wait. Let's put that in plain English.
- 9:03What does a non linear utility function actually look like in
- 9:06daily life? Think about it like this.
- 9:09Imagine you're walking down the street and you find a crisp $20
- 9:12bill on the sidewalk. You feel a little boost of
- 9:14happiness. It's a nice moment, right?
- 9:16For sure free money. Now imagine later that day you
- 9:19reach into your pocket and realize you lost a $20 bill.
- 9:22The psychological pain of losing that $20 feels much sharper and
- 9:25lasts much longer than the joy of finding it.
- 9:27Human beings are wired to care disproportionately about losing
- 9:31compared to gaining. Exactly so that warp psychology
- 9:34prevents us from viewing risk objectively.
- 9:37To make good returns, you have to expose yourself to the risk
- 9:40of loss. Not avoid risk entirely, but
- 9:43bear it intelligently. Right.
- 9:45Yet our brains are constantly screaming at us to run away at
- 9:48the first sign of a downturn because losing feels so bad.
- 9:52And that brings us to the second roadblock, which isn't about our
- 9:55brains. It is about the financial system
- 9:57itself. It is called the agent problem
- 10:00or institutional constraints. Let's create a scenario for this
- 10:03one because it's fascinating. Go for it.
- 10:05Imagine you are a professional managing a billion dollar
- 10:08pension fund. If you buy standard popular tech
- 10:11stocks in the market crashes, you don't get fired.
- 10:14You just shrug and say hey, the whole market crash wasn't my
- 10:16fault. You have safety in numbers.
- 10:17Right, but if you take a calculated risk on a deeply
- 10:20undervalued, unpopular, distressed asset and it dips
- 10:24further, you look like an idiot. You lose your job.
- 10:27So your entire incentive structure is just to avoid
- 10:29looking stupid rather than achieving massive gains for your
- 10:32clients. That is a crucial structural
- 10:35flaw in the financial industry. Your personal survival as a
- 10:39manager is detached from the client's optimal outcome.
- 10:42David Swenson, the legendary manager of the Yale Endowment,
- 10:46noted that good investing requires non institutional
- 10:49behavior from institutions. It's a massive conundrum.
- 10:52How do you get an employee of a massive financial firm to act as
- 10:56a true contrarian when their career survival, their mortgage,
- 11:01their bonus, all of it depends on blending in with the herd?
- 11:04It is very difficult. And the third Rd.
- 11:06Black might be the most controversial one they discuss.
- 11:08It is the myth of volatility. For the last 50 years, a concept
- 11:12out of the University of Chicago has basically ruled the
- 11:14financial world. The idea that volatility price
- 11:17is bouncing up and down day-to-day is the exact same
- 11:19thing as risk. But Marx argues that equating
- 11:21volatility with risk is fundamentally flawed for the
- 11:24long term investor. Wait, hang on, let me play
- 11:26devil's advocate here. If I check my retirement account
- 11:29on a Friday and it has dropped 20% in the week, that certainly
- 11:32feels like a massive risk to my future.
- 11:34Why is that 50 year old academic theory wrong?
- 11:37It feels like a risk, yes, but we have to define what risk
- 11:40truly is. Real risk is the permanent loss
- 11:43of capital. Like a company going bankrupt.
- 11:45Or buying an asset at such an inflated price that it never
- 11:48recovers its value. If you are well funded and you
- 11:52do not have to withdraw your money tomorrow to pay your rent.
- 11:54Price fluctuations are just a natural part of life.
- 11:57They are a temporary dip in a stock's daily quote, not a
- 12:01permanent loss. Exactly, if you don't sell
- 12:04during the dip, you haven't actually lost the capital.
- 12:06OK, that makes sense. If I don't need the money today,
- 12:08the daily price is just noise. To cement this, they share
- 12:11another incredible Buffett gym. I'd rather have a lumpy 15%
- 12:14return than a smooth 12%. If you are demanding a smooth
- 12:18ride with the numbers only ever go up a tiny bit everyday, you
- 12:21are sacrificing massive potential growth just to coddle
- 12:24your own emotions. You are paying a premium for
- 12:27comfort. Which transitions perfectly into
- 12:29how we should actually behave if we want to build wealth.
- 12:32The dialogue discusses a memo Marks wrote in October 2022
- 12:36called What Really Matters. At that time, if you recall, the
- 12:40entire financial media was obsessing over inflation and
- 12:44exactly which month the Federal Reserve would stop raising
- 12:46interest rate. All right, it was all anyone
- 12:48talked about. What's the Fed going to do?
- 12:50Marks pointed out that this fixation is entirely irrelevant
- 12:53to long term wealth creation. Deciding whether the Fed pauses
- 12:57in March or May does not change the fundamental value of a great
- 13:00business over the next decade. And here he reverses a piece of
- 13:04advice we are all giving his kids.
- 13:06Growing up you were always told don't just sit there, do
- 13:08something. If there is a problem, act.
- 13:10But in investing, you actually have to reverse that completely.
- 13:13You need to buy good pieces of companies and then just sit
- 13:16there do nothing. Stop checking the app every 5
- 13:18minutes. Stop trying to trade in and out
- 13:20based on the news cycle. But sitting there and doing
- 13:22nothing, especially when the market is temporarily moving
- 13:25against you, requires an immense amount of daring.
- 13:29The conversation elaborates on Mark's famous Dare to Be Great
- 13:32memos. To achieve superior performance,
- 13:35you must take what are called uncomfortably idiosyncratic
- 13:38positions. Uncomfortably idiosyncratic.
- 13:41You must dare to be different from the consensus.
- 13:43You must dare to be wrong. And perhaps most painfully, you
- 13:47must dare to look wrong to your peers for a long period before
- 13:51the market eventually proves you right.
- 13:52Daring to look wrong is so tough.
- 13:54Let's supply that to the hottest topic in the world right now,
- 13:57artificial intelligence. Everyone is rushing to throw
- 13:59money at anything with AI in the name.
- 14:02Now the discussion acknowledges that AI will change the world.
- 14:05That isn't the debate. The technology is revolutionary.
- 14:08Right, but the real issue for an investor isn't if a technology
- 14:12changes the world, but who actually benefits financially.
- 14:15Think back to the Internet boom of the late 1990's.
- 14:18The Internet absolutely changed the world, but thousands of
- 14:21early Internet companies went to zero and investors lost
- 14:24everything. Capitalizing on a massive
- 14:26technological shift requires superior investment selection.
- 14:30It requires aligning with specialized cycle tested
- 14:33managers who understand not just the upside of the technology,
- 14:36but the fundamental downside risks, the competitive moats and
- 14:40the valuations. You can't just throw darts at a
- 14:42board of AI stocks and expect to win.
- 14:44There is a great analogy from the discussion for this.
- 14:47The chicken should not be assigned to do daredevil feats.
- 14:50You have to play within yourself.
- 14:51If you are inherently A defensive, cautious person, you
- 14:55shouldn't suddenly try to become a day trading tech speculator
- 14:58just because AI is in the news. You have to balance offense and
- 15:01defense based on your own natural temperament.
- 15:03And that search for balance is timeless.
- 15:06Reflecting on Marx's 57 year career, they know that despite
- 15:09massive technological shifts from mainframe computers to AI
- 15:12and massive economic shifts, the fundamental truths of investing
- 15:15haven't changed at all. Superior judgement remains
- 15:18intensely personal. It is not something you can just
- 15:20program into a machine. There are no silver bullets and
- 15:24there is absolutely no magic investment that offers high
- 15:27returns without bearing some form of risk.
- 15:30While human nature hasn't changed, the landscape is
- 15:32evolving, specifically with the massive rise of private assets.
- 15:35We are talking about investments that are not traded on a public
- 15:38Stock Exchange, like private equity, private credit or direct
- 15:42real estate. There has been a huge shift of
- 15:45capital into this space and there are some real trade-offs
- 15:48you have to consider here. Let's break those down, starting
- 15:51with the pros. The primary benefit of private
- 15:53assets is that you avoid the daily mark to market panic.
- 15:57Let's contextualize that. It's like buying a house versus
- 16:00buying a stock. If you want a house, you don't
- 16:02get a notification on your phone every morning telling you it
- 16:04dropped in value by 2%. Because you don't see that daily
- 16:07price fluctuation, you aren't tempted to panic sell your house
- 16:10on a random Tuesday just because the news was bad.
- 16:13That is the benefit of avoiding mark to market pricing.
- 16:16Plus you get access to unique assets and companies that the
- 16:19general public simply can't buy into.
- 16:21However, the cons are equally significant and directly related
- 16:25to that housing analogy. Private assets suffer from
- 16:28extreme illiquidity. Just like a house, you cannot
- 16:31simply liquidate your position and get your cash out on a
- 16:33Tuesday morning because you changed your mind or got
- 16:35nervous. Your money is locked up, often
- 16:38for years. Furthermore, because these
- 16:40assets aren't traded daily on an exchange, there is a distinct
- 16:44lack of reference points for fair pricing.
- 16:47You have to deeply trust that the manager truly understands
- 16:50the underlying intrinsic value of the asset, because the broad
- 16:53market isn't giving you a daily consensus price to check their
- 16:56own work against, which is. Exactly why the biggest players
- 16:59in the game, the massive institutional allocators, are
- 17:01changing how they operate. They are seeking a magic number
- 17:04of relationships. Instead of spreading their money
- 17:06across hundreds of different funds to achieve shallow
- 17:09diversification, they are looking for fewer but much
- 17:12deeper 5 to 10 strategic relationships with specific
- 17:15managers they implicitly trust. It is the ultimate balancing act
- 17:19in portfolio construction. As the dialogue summarizes, you
- 17:23concentrate your investment to take advantage of what you
- 17:25deeply know and understand, which is how you build wealth.
- 17:28But you diversify to protect against the vast universe of
- 17:31things you don't know, which is how you keep that well.
- 17:34Striking that perfect balance between concentration and
- 17:37diversification is where true financial expertise lies.
- 17:41So as we bring this all together, the big take away from
- 17:43this exploration into Howard Marks philosophy is that
- 17:46mastering the market has almost nothing to do with predicting
- 17:49the future. No one has a crystal ball.
- 17:51Mastering the market is entirely about mastering yourself.
- 17:54It is about understanding the current temperature of the room,
- 17:57whether people are irrationally exuberant or irrationally
- 18:00terrified, and having the iron discipline to manage your own
- 18:03psychology and fear so you can do the exact opposite of the
- 18:06herd. And that leads to a final
- 18:08thought for you to ponder as we wrap up.
- 18:09The central theme of this entire discussion is that comfort never
- 18:12coexists with good investing. True bargains only exist where
- 18:16extreme fear lives. So ask yourself, what is the
- 18:19most uncomfortable financial or professional decision you are
- 18:23avoiding right now simply because it goes against the
- 18:25consensus of the herd? A brilliant and slightly
- 18:28uncomfortable question to leave off on.
- 18:29We want to thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive
- 18:32into the psychology of risk and reward.
- 18:35Before we go, a quick reminder. If you like to access wider
- 18:38topics, including life and investing philosophy, please
- 18:40subscribe to our sister channel at Deep Values.
- 18:43Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.
- 18:45We will see you next time. None.