Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #43: Recall Elections - When Voters Kick Elected Officials Out Early
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:04I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about recall elections.
- 0:10But do you recall?
- 0:13In 2025, we have a lot of current or recently ceased campaigns for recall elections to be
- 0:20held against various elected officials at the state and local levels.
- 0:24We have yet another one against California governor Gavin Newsom that is trying to get on
- 0:29the ballot.
- 0:30There are two efforts against Michigan secretary of state Jocelyn Benson.
- 0:35A lot of Minnesota state house representatives in particular are also subject to recall
- 0:41attempts, and many city councilors, mayors, school board members, and more also potentially
- 0:47face recall elections.
- 0:49A recall election is an election where voters can remove an elected official before their
- 0:54term is normally over.
- 0:56So in that way, it can be argued as a type of special election because it's inherently
- 1:01irregularly timed.
- 1:03But not every elected official can be potentially recalled, however.
- 1:09The process of recall elections also isn't the same everywhere that they are used nor is the
- 1:15process for getting a recall election on the ballot in the first place.
- 1:19And recall elections, some have argued, are being increasingly used as partisan and or
- 1:26ideological tools simply because of dislike or even hatred of the elected official being
- 1:32recalled.
- 1:34So what exactly do recall elections entail?
- 1:38How do we even invent recall elections in the first place?
- 1:41How do they get on the ballot?
- 1:43What are some of the most prominent cases for recalls that we have seen in recent and not so
- 1:49recent memory?
- 1:51What are some of the debates we see about when, where, why, and how we should hold recall
- 1:56elections?
- 1:57All that is on tab for today's podcast.
- 2:01So let's begin.
- 2:03First of all, what is a recall election?
- 2:08A recall is an election where citizens call for an election for an elected official before
- 2:14their term is up as to whether to kick that official out early.
- 2:18Get out of here.
- 2:19Don't let the door hit you on your way out.
- 2:22It's inherently regularly timed, sort of like your normal special election that is meant to
- 2:28fill a vacancy.
- 2:29And sometimes, but not always, there's two parts to it on a ballot.
- 2:33It's do you wanna recall this elected official?
- 2:37And if they are recalled, which of these candidates do you want to succeed them?
- 2:43And in some cases, if a recall is is successful, the successor is appointed by
- 2:48somebody, probably the governor, but we're gonna get more into that.
- 2:52And not too far from now.
- 2:55There are some similar scenarios that you might have heard, like a recall election, but are not
- 3:00quite the same as a recall.
- 3:02So in a bunch of other countries, you may have heard the term snap elections, where their
- 3:08chief executive, like the prime minister, calls for a new federal election to try to come up
- 3:14with a new federal, or an attempt to either create a majority or to, increase their
- 3:24majority before their regularly scheduled elections.
- 3:27I'm I'm not super I'm not particularly well versed in snap elections.
- 3:32There's also retention elections in The US for some US Judges, elections where voters say yes
- 3:40or no to keeping a judge for another term.
- 3:43But those are regularly scheduled elections.
- 3:46Those are meant to happen every six, eight, ten, however many years.
- 3:52And, 20 states use those for state supreme court judges, and 19 states use them for their
- 3:58intermediate appellate and general jurisdiction courts.
- 4:01So retention elections are probably the most similar analog because they ask a similar
- 4:07question of, do you wanna keep this judge?
- 4:10But they're not quite the same as a recall election.
- 4:13So how did we even get recall elections in The US in the first place?
- 4:17Well, it goes way, way, way back, in fact, to pre US history.
- 4:22Early on, it was rarely used, but it can be traced all the way back to colonial times.
- 4:28And the first instance coming from the laws of the general court of the Massachusetts Bay
- 4:33Colony in 1631, and it also appears in the Massachusetts charter in 1691.
- 4:42Recall provisions were also included in the articles of confederation that those were the
- 4:47predecessor to the US constitution, what the US constitution would eventually replace, but
- 4:54recalls were never used while we were under the articles of confederation.
- 4:58And they actually almost did make it to the US constitution.
- 5:05During the constitutional convention, a Virginia delegate by the name of Edmund
- 5:09Randolph, he included recall elections as part of his Virginia plan.
- 5:15And the Virginia plan would become one of the major bases along with the New Jersey plan to
- 5:22become what we know as the US constitution.
- 5:26But the recall provision was not ultimately included in that because those or the provision
- 5:33for the recall election was ultimately struck down by a motion in the convention from Charles
- 5:41Pinckney to strike out that recall.
- 5:43So it never actually fully made it into the final US constitution.
- 5:48And the concept of recall elections came up a few more times in the decades after the US
- 5:53constitution was ratified, but they wouldn't really become popularized until their, what
- 6:00somebody might say, their modern day iteration that spawned from the progressive era, which
- 6:05was roughly 1890 to 1920.
- 6:09The progressives of that era and the progressives of today, there's there's some
- 6:14similarities in the ethos, but they're not quite the same thing because they obviously had
- 6:19a lot different or some similar issues of that day, but there are also some that weren't a lot
- 6:26different.
- 6:26But Progressive Era was also responsible for the direct election of US Senators, whereas
- 6:34prior to that becoming US amendment, the state legislatures chose our US Senators.
- 6:41And then there was also the direct or the income tax.
- 6:44For recall elections in particular, the progenitor, if you will, that was particularly
- 6:50cited by multiple sources that I used for research was a man by the name of John Randolph
- 6:56Haynes, and he was a California political activist who was a major player in progressive
- 7:03era reforms, but in particular, the recall election.
- 7:09And Los Angeles actually became the first municipality to implement recalls in either
- 7:14nineteen o two or nineteen o three.
- 7:16I saw a little bit of disagreements with a couple of of resources.
- 7:21National Conference of State Legislatures said Los Angeles used it in nineteen o three, and I
- 7:27forget what the other source I just used was.
- 7:30I think it was history news network said nineteen o two was when it occurred.
- 7:35But in any case, Los Angeles was the first municipality to implement recalls.
- 7:41And then over time, more and more places would implement recall elections.
- 7:46And some examples of that being that Michigan and Oregon in nineteen o eight, they would be
- 7:51the first states to adopt recalls for state level officials because initially, it was just
- 7:55for local level officials, but then it started becoming more common for state level officials.
- 8:01So things like governor or attorney general or secretary of state at the state level.
- 8:09Those are many of those legislators or even or many more of those government officials or even
- 8:15state legislators or even judges would, in some of these states, become subject to recall
- 8:22elections.
- 8:23And most recently, New Jersey in 1993 and then Minnesota in 1996, they were the most recent
- 8:30states to adopt recalls for state level officials as well.
- 8:36Speaking of which, who exactly can be recalled?
- 8:39So local level officials were the first people to really be able to face recalls in at some
- 8:48point in somewhere in The United States, and then it started to become more common for state
- 8:52level officials.
- 8:53Federal officials, however, cannot be recalled.
- 8:56Remember that the US constitution did not ultimately incorporate a provision for federal
- 9:02recalls like Edmund Randolph would have included in his provision.
- 9:07Some states, though, have argued through their state constitutions and through other legal
- 9:12means that citizens have a right to recall members of congress.
- 9:16Now the US Supreme Court has yet to directly rule on this, but they have ruled in the past
- 9:23that, one, the right to remove a member of congress resides exclusively with congress.
- 9:28That's how they expel members of congress.
- 9:32And number two, individual states cannot unilaterally change the length and number of
- 9:38terms of office for federal officials, which complicates the quest for some people to
- 9:45implement term limits for members of Congress.
- 9:49So 39 states allow recalls for at least some or all local level officials, and then 19 of them
- 9:56allow it for state level officials as well.
- 9:59Possibly a twentieth state there, but it's a little unclear.
- 10:03I'll tell you about that in just a moment.
- 10:05But 19 states can definitely remove at least governors through recall.
- 10:12Illinois allows governor and only governor at the state level to be recalled, but the other
- 10:1818 states also allow all executive state level officials that are not governor to be recalled
- 10:25as well.
- 10:25So things like secretary of state, lieutenant governor, if that state has that.
- 10:32If they have a comptroller, attorney general, things like that.
- 10:39All those 18 states, except for Rhode Island, also allow recalls of state legislators, and
- 10:45then 10 of those states allow for recalls of state level judges.
- 10:51So now for that twentieth state, that really iffy one, Virginia is iffy about whether state
- 10:59level officials can be recalled.
- 11:02Why would it be unclear and ambiguous?
- 11:05Why wouldn't it be straightforward as to whether they could be removed?
- 11:10Code of Virginia, section 24.2 dash two three three.
- 11:15Upon petition, a circuit court may remove office from office any elected officer or
- 11:21officer who has been appointed to fill an elective office residing within the
- 11:25jurisdiction of the court.
- 11:28So why is that an issue?
- 11:29Well, problem is that the circuit courts only account for a portion of the states.
- 11:34They cover a circuit, while state level officials cover the whole state.
- 11:40So do circuit courts still have jurisdiction over state level officials?
- 11:45That's a little up in the air.
- 11:46Could all of the circuit courts then get involved in the recall of a governor?
- 11:52There's gonna need to be it's code of Virginia, perhaps the legislature can actually rewrite
- 11:57that law or voters I I'm not sure what the law is off the top of my head for Virginia when it
- 12:05comes to, citizen initiated ballot measures, but citizens might be able to push forward a
- 12:13ballot measure to to get that cleared up as well.
- 12:16So right now, there's there's no clear cut answer as to whether Virginia can remove state
- 12:22level officials in either the executive legislative or judicial branches through recall
- 12:27elections.
- 12:28Local officials can definitely be recalled, though, because they would be subject to those
- 12:33circuit court or the those circuit courts because the they're the they'll at least have a
- 12:39specific jurisdiction over those local level officials.
- 12:45And the way Virginia does it is that they actually have those circuit courts review
- 12:51whether they can recall those officials.
- 12:55Not really a recall election like you would see in other places.
- 13:00But as for states overall, when it comes to recalling local level officials, like we said
- 13:09earlier, 39 states allow for recall of local officials, but there are sometimes limits.
- 13:15There often are limits to that.
- 13:17Some states only allow some local level officials to be recalled.
- 13:23Some of those examples in Minnesota, they only allow it for countywide offices.
- 13:27So municipalities are not countywide, so they would not be subject to it.
- 13:32Missouri has a specific designation called a class three city, and then charter cities that
- 13:39also include recall provisions.
- 13:40Those can be those can see recalls as well.
- 13:44So some charter cities might not include recall provisions and then cities that are not
- 13:49specifically designated as class three.
- 13:51In Missouri, that's not necessarily a designation you see in most other states.
- 13:57And then West Virginia also allows for recalls in charter cities.
- 14:02And then recall may also be limited due to home rule provisions.
- 14:07A couple a few episodes ago, I had a actually, two episodes about home rule.
- 14:13So please go ahead and check that out for more about home rule.
- 14:16But home rule is basically the capacity that local governments have to administer their own
- 14:22affairs apart from the involvement of state governments.
- 14:29In such cases where home rule is applicable, states will allow cities and or counties to
- 14:35adopt their own charters that can then provide for a local recall.
- 14:38A charter is basically you can think of it as like a local government constitution.
- 14:44So a city that has a charter, it's a constitution specifically for that city.
- 14:50Now those are all the states where you see recall elections.
- 14:56How is the actual process of recall elections?
- 15:00Well, the process for getting recalls on their on that state's ballot, they differ greatly
- 15:09between states.
- 15:11But the general process is basically that citizens had to get a certain number of
- 15:16petition signatures from registered voters of the appropriate jurisdiction.
- 15:20So for example, if it's a city councilor, they're trying to get recalled.
- 15:26It's citizens that are in the jurisdiction of that city councilor.
- 15:30It can't just be anybody in the state.
- 15:33Whereas if it is a statewide official, like a governor, then anybody in the state could sign
- 15:39a petition for it.
- 15:40But citizen has to get enough petition signatures at a specific piece of paperwork
- 15:45that you have to fill out saying, yeah, I wanna see a recall election for this official.
- 15:50You get enough of those from registered voters in the appropriate jurisdiction, then you gotta
- 15:55get those signatures verified.
- 15:57And I've had to do that for not for a recall election, but I have had to get petition
- 16:03signatures for something before.
- 16:05And, boy, it's a pain because you have to get the actual signatures signed or the actual
- 16:12petition signed with real signatures, and then you have to get those signatures verified.
- 16:17And there could be any reason that that signature doesn't get verified.
- 16:22Not not necessarily that a lot of them don't get verified, but you can expect something like
- 16:26five to 10% of those signatures won't get verified for whatever reason.
- 16:31So enough petition signatures signed, signatures verified, and then the recall
- 16:37question gets put on the ballot.
- 16:39So you're it's not you get all those petitions and then they say, okay, that guy is at that
- 16:45that person that's in office right now, now they're now they're out of here.
- 16:48No.
- 16:48Then you get the recall question put on the ballot.
- 16:53Now beyond that, the ways that states can differ in getting a recall election on the
- 16:58ballot, one way is the petition signatures, the number that they have to get, and what exactly
- 17:04that number is based on.
- 17:06Typically, it can be based on a percentage of votes cast in the last election for that office
- 17:11or a percentage of registered voters at the time of that last election.
- 17:15So if it was Joe Schmo running for that one in, the governor's race in 2022, and it was based
- 17:23on the percentage of votes cast in that last election, let's say there was a million that
- 17:27were cast and then you needed at least 20% of that number of votes that were cast, that means
- 17:34you need 200,000 signatures to be signed and verified.
- 17:38If it's a percentage registered voters at the time of that last election, so maybe there was
- 17:42a million people that voted, but there were actually 2,000,000 people that were registered
- 17:48to vote at that election, but 50% of them didn't vote for whatever reason, then you need
- 17:5420% of that 2,000,000, which actually is 400,000.
- 17:59So petition signatures, the number that you need and what that number is based on, that can
- 18:05differ.
- 18:07The length of time the petitions to that the petitions can be circulated to call for a
- 18:12recall.
- 18:13So if you're running a campaign, maybe you get depending on what the office is, you might have
- 18:18several months to do it.
- 18:19Maybe you have something like a hundred and fifty days, two hundred days, Or if it's, like,
- 18:25a really local level office, then you probably have a lot shorter length of time.
- 18:30You might have, like, thirty days to do it or forty five.
- 18:34What also differs is if it's a state official or local official.
- 18:39If if, if it's a local official, you have a lot fewer signatures that you need because the
- 18:44local official has a much smaller electorate than the state official.
- 18:48That governor who had a million people vote on him, that local official's probably gonna have
- 18:53something more like several thousand or maybe tens of thousands, unless it's like a bigger
- 18:57city, but it's still gonna be a lot less than in regards to that governor.
- 19:03And then also the reasons that are considered valid for a recall.
- 19:08Of the 39 states that allow for recalls to some extent, 12 of them have specific grounds that
- 19:14need to be met for that recall election to even be possible.
- 19:20So some grounds are a bit more specific and clear cut, while others are a little bit more
- 19:26ambiguous.
- 19:27There's more specific ones like misfeasance or malfeasance.
- 19:31Misfeasance means you did a lawful act or you were trying to do your duty, but you did it in
- 19:37the wrong way.
- 19:37You mishandled it.
- 19:40Malefeasance means you intentionally did something wrong.
- 19:44You were doing it with malice.
- 19:47So misfeasance, malefeasance.
- 19:50So those are a bit more clear cut as to what they are versus what some states include as a
- 19:58mental lack of fitness.
- 20:01That might sound obvious, but, I mean, if you look at Joe Biden and Donald Trump, for
- 20:08example, obviously, they their presidents, they can't be recalled, but largely depending on
- 20:16your partisan affiliation, people have considerably different opinions as to whether
- 20:23either one of them or both of them were are mentally fit for for the presidency.
- 20:29But you can apply that same kind of logic to local or state level officials that can be
- 20:36recalled.
- 20:37What exactly constitutes a mental lack of fitness?
- 20:41In any case, the grounds for recall among these 12 states, it's gonna differ, but they may or
- 20:46may not include lack of fitness, incompetence, neglect of duties, corruption, conviction of a
- 20:53felony, moral turpitude.
- 20:55I really enjoy that term.
- 20:57Basically means wickedness or depravity.
- 21:00So moral turpitude, drunkenness, oppression, gross partiality, misuse of funds, and then
- 21:07there are a bunch of other potential grounds for a recall election to happen.
- 21:13Now you won't see all those in each of those states, but they are it's in in those 12 states
- 21:19that require specific grounds to be met.
- 21:22You're gonna at least see some of those.
- 21:24Now what happens if that official is successfully recalled?
- 21:27So you had that official that was being recalled.
- 21:30You got that election on the ballot, and people say, yeah.
- 21:33We're tired of this person.
- 21:34He's out of here.
- 21:35She's out of here.
- 21:36They're out of here.
- 21:37Whoever it is.
- 21:38What happens if that official is successfully recalled?
- 21:44So there are four general methods that you see for getting that one unique method of Virginia
- 21:50where circuit courts handle it.
- 21:52There's four general methods that you see where a what what happens after that official is
- 22:00successfully recalled.
- 22:02Sometimes you'll see a simultaneous election where the same ballot asks, do you want this
- 22:08official recalled?
- 22:09And then if this official is recalled, who do you want to take their place?
- 22:13So even if you don't want that official to be recalled, it says, well, just in case that
- 22:19person gets recalled, who do you want to replace them?
- 22:22Other cut cases, there's a separate special election.
- 22:25So those two questions are spaced out.
- 22:27So you have the actual recall election happens, and you say you do or you don't want that
- 22:33person to be recalled.
- 22:35Then if they are recalled at a later date, you have that special election that says, okay.
- 22:40Now who are we gonna replace that person with?
- 22:43Other times, there's an appointment where the successor is chosen by a different governmental
- 22:48official, or I don't know why I said governmental.
- 22:51Government official.
- 22:53Most likely, it's gonna be the governor, but if it's a local level official, might actually be
- 22:58somebody else.
- 22:59And then there's also automatic replacements.
- 23:01So the succession is chosen by a legal line of succession.
- 23:06So if the governor is removed, it's probably gonna be the lieutenant governor that goes in.
- 23:11Unless that state doesn't have a lieutenant governor, then it might be somebody like the
- 23:14secretary of state.
- 23:16And then some states are gonna use multiple methods depending on which elected official is
- 23:20removed.
- 23:21So in Alaska, for example, if the state legislature or the state legislator is the one
- 23:27that's recalled, the then it's an appointment by the governor.
- 23:31And if it was the governor that was recalled, then it's an automatic replacement.
- 23:37And I'm pretty sure it's just a lieutenant governor that goes in that.
- 23:41California, if it's a state level official, it's a simultaneous election, sorta like what
- 23:46you saw with Gavin Newsom in 2021.
- 23:48Now he was not recall he was not successfully recalled far from it, but on that same ballot,
- 23:55they had, do you want Gavin Newsom to re be recalled?
- 23:58And then the second question was, if Gavin Newsom is recalled, who do you want to replace
- 24:02him?
- 24:03And then if it's a local official in California, then an appointment is made
- 24:07instead.
- 24:09Now who are some of these prominent past and present targets of recall elections.
- 24:18So recalls are and they're inherently notable because voters were angry enough to kick out or
- 24:24almost kick out an elected official before their term was over.
- 24:29Now, obviously, some recall attempts don't even get close to being on the ballot, but for the
- 24:34ones that do get on the ballot and the ones that successfully do remove an official, that
- 24:41makes it inherently notable to some extent.
- 24:45But some recalls are obviously more impactful and or more prominent than others.
- 24:51Now historically, local level officials much more successfully recalled than state officials
- 24:58are because local level officials have a far lower threshold for petition signatures that
- 25:03need to be gathered to get that recall election on the ballot compared to a state level
- 25:07official.
- 25:09Local jurisdictions, only voters in that locality versus statewide where you have to go
- 25:13all across the state to get petition signatures.
- 25:16And then there's just the sheer number of local officials is much greater than the number of
- 25:22state officials.
- 25:23And there's been a bunch of attempts against governors statewide, though most of them don't
- 25:29get to the ballot.
- 25:31And only two governors have been successfully recalled in US history.
- 25:36Way back in 1921, we had Lynn Frazier of North Dakota.
- 25:41Though interestingly enough, only a couple years later, he'd make it to the US senate, and
- 25:45he'd served there from 1923 to 1940.
- 25:49So didn't really tank his career far from it.
- 25:53And then not too long ago I mean, it'll seem forever ago to some people, and I was only 10
- 25:59when this happened.
- 26:00But Gray Davis in California in 02/2003, he was blamed for a state electricity crisis and
- 26:06faltering economy, and that was actually what opened the door for the governor Arnold
- 26:11Schwarzenegger to become governor of California.
- 26:16But he funny enough, he was also the target of a recall campaign, but that failed to make the
- 26:21ballot.
- 26:21That didn't really get that far, but still kind of inter interesting anyways.
- 26:28But we just talked about him before multiple times against Gavin Newsom, including the one
- 26:34in 2021 that did get on the ballot, but Newsom easily won.
- 26:37But now there's another petition or recall campaign against Gavin Newsom going on right
- 26:45now.
- 26:47A different governor that was that actually did come fairly close to getting recalled, Scott
- 26:54Walker of Wisconsin.
- 26:56He also ran for the presidency for the Republican Party in 2012, whereas Gavin
- 27:02Newsom's Democrat, Scott Walker, Republican.
- 27:05He faced a recall in 2012 that did get to the ballot, but Walker ultimately won with 53.1% of
- 27:12the votes.
- 27:13And I believe that was during his first term.
- 27:15So I think he ran again in 2014 for a regular election for reelection.
- 27:22And then Evan Evan Meacham in Arizona in 1988, he would have been subjected to a recall, but
- 27:30he was impeached and convicted by the legislature before that happened.
- 27:34So that would have been in all likelihood well, he would have been the second governor to have
- 27:40been recalled more than likely because that was before Gray Davis did get recalled in 2003 for
- 27:46California.
- 27:47But, for state legislature, right now in 2025, we have at least 30 recall campaigns for
- 27:54Minnesota state house representatives.
- 27:56Right now in Minnesota, the the power division of power between the republican and democratic
- 28:03parties is incredibly tight.
- 28:05It's the thinnest it can be.
- 28:07Republicans have the majority right now.
- 28:11Whether any of those will go anywhere is up in the air, and I don't believe off the top of my
- 28:17head, I don't believe Minnesota requires a reason for a recall.
- 28:23But there's lots of local officials like mayor, city council, and school boards that have been
- 28:28subject to recalls over the years, especially in recent years.
- 28:33In recent and in recent years, common reasons for those recalls of those local officials have
- 28:40included COVID nineteen policies and general debates about how to educate pre k through 12
- 28:47students.
- 28:48Not always the case, but those are fairly common reasons that you see recalls recall
- 28:54campaigns be waged against them.
- 28:56Not necessarily that they actually get to the ballot, but they at least attempt to get recall
- 29:01elections on the ballot against those officials.
- 29:05And Ballipedia, to cite some data, Ballipedia from 2009 to 2024 said that there was an
- 29:13average of 35 recall efforts against an average of 81 school board members per year during that
- 29:19time.
- 29:20And 20% of school board members included in those efforts faced recall elections.
- 29:26So 80% of them, they saw recall attempts, but they didn't make it to the ballot.
- 29:30Some of them might have gotten close.
- 29:32Some of them might not have gotten even remotely close.
- 29:34And then 12% of those school board members were of the school board members that were subject
- 29:40to recall campaigns, not necessarily elections, but recall campaigns, 12% of them were
- 29:46successfully removed from office.
- 29:50So as a general overview of how these recall elections work.
- 29:59But now let's get more to the normative thoughts about the the philosophical reasonings
- 30:08behind recall elections and when, where, why, and how we should have recall elections or if
- 30:15we should even have them because many recent recall efforts have been criticized as couched
- 30:21primarily in partisanship and ideology as opposed to actual wrongdoing.
- 30:26So voters, especially in these polarized times that we have, a lot of these recall elections
- 30:33have been accused, not necessarily all of them and not everybody agrees, but some of them have
- 30:37been seen as, well, you're just doing it because this official is a Republican or this
- 30:41official is a Democrat.
- 30:42This person has conservative policies.
- 30:44This person has liberal policies.
- 30:46But how do you determine definitively which ones are partisan and which ones are
- 30:52ideological and which are, quote, unquote, justified?
- 30:56Such such determinations of those can also be biased.
- 31:00Maybe maybe those recall elections are biased in terms of partisanship or ideology, but the
- 31:06people who are criticizing them also have their own partisan or ideological bias against those
- 31:13recalls.
- 31:14But in it but even if they are overly partisan or ideological, does that mean that those
- 31:19recalls should not be used?
- 31:22I was reading you know, when I was doing research for this, I was reading it was
- 31:26Marquette Law Marquette University Law School, and they actually had two articles that weren't
- 31:37necessarily arguing completely different things, but one of them said that it was
- 31:43actually referring to the Scott Walker recall and saying basically that people in support of
- 31:52Scott Walker were saying that recalls were only designed for officials that were corrupt,
- 31:59whereas the person writing this article was saying that that was false, that recalled
- 32:03provisions were never intended to be limited in such fashion.
- 32:06But then there was a different author in mark for Market University that said many of the
- 32:11advocates of of the recall from the progressive era saw it as a useful tool against corruption.
- 32:17Not necessarily completely diametrically opposed viewpoints, but even in that one
- 32:27resource, it did seem to be at least a little bit of differing views at for what recall
- 32:33elections were attended for and what they should be intended for.
- 32:37Well, I guess they weren't necessarily arguing whether they should be used for just for
- 32:42corruption purposes or anything like that.
- 32:44But in any case, even if it is primarily partisan or ideological and it's not based on
- 32:53any criminal wrongdoing, does that mean that these recalls should not be allowed?
- 32:59Is it the organizers of the recall that are being partisan or ideological, or is it the
- 33:05target of the recall that has been partisan or ideological in how they've handled things?
- 33:11What if both sides are being partisan or ideological?
- 33:16And then even if we largely agree that an elected official is terrible and they need to
- 33:21get out of there as soon as possible, Should we just have to accept that we elected the wrong
- 33:27candidate and suck it up, so to speak?
- 33:29Do we get to have a do over before the term is up, or do we have to wait it out and basically
- 33:34say, we messed up?
- 33:36They they're just gonna have to finish out their term, and then we make a different
- 33:40decision when the next election happens.
- 33:45It's not necessarily a straightforward answer, and, obviously, there's gonna be a lot of
- 33:50different answers for each of those questions.
- 33:52There's also the fact that all elections cost money to administer, and local governments bear
- 33:57the brunt of those costs.
- 33:59It's actually not the states that primarily handle elections.
- 34:02They oversee things, but the ones that are actually administering the elections are the
- 34:07local governments.
- 34:08Now that doesn't mean that we should not have those recall elections, but you need to keep
- 34:16these costs in mind because elections can get very expensive, especially if you have a
- 34:20statewide one.
- 34:21I believe the one against Gavin Newsom in 2021, I wanna say I read that it cost $300,000,000.
- 34:28I can't remember for sure.
- 34:29Now California is also a massive state, the largest population in the country, but the
- 34:38costs of these elections are something that you have to consider as well.
- 34:43But in any case, even if we were all to agree that, okay, we should have recall elections to
- 34:49some extent, Ask ourselves the the where, what, where, when, what, why, and how.
- 34:58And the when.
- 34:58Did I say the when?
- 34:59Whatever.
- 35:00The five w's and the how.
- 35:03So when should we be able to have these recall elections?
- 35:06Is there such a thing as too close to a regularly scheduled election?
- 35:09What there was theoretically a recall election that happened four months before the regularly
- 35:17scheduled end of a term.
- 35:19So if the if an election was happening in November 2026, the regular election, but the
- 35:26recall happened in, see, four months before.
- 35:30So July 2026.
- 35:31Is that too close?
- 35:33Is that kind of a waste of time at that point?
- 35:36Or should it have to be, like, a year before at least before the regularly scheduled election
- 35:43happens.
- 35:43So instead of November 2026, it happens since November 2025.
- 35:47And then you gotta turn around a year later and have the regularly scheduled election.
- 35:55But then not even just when the recall election should happen.
- 35:59How long should these recall petitions be able to be circulated to get a recall election on
- 36:04the ballot?
- 36:04Earlier, we mentioned that partially depending on whether it's a local level or state level
- 36:09official and how big the state is and several other factors, you might have more time to
- 36:16circulate petition signatures.
- 36:18So maybe one election has a hundred fifty days to or a hundred sixty days to circulate
- 36:24petitions, whereas another election is thirty to forty five to sixty.
- 36:29Which of those is appropriate, and how much does that change depending on what official
- 36:36we're talking about?
- 36:37Now, what about the question of where should we be able to have recall elections?
- 36:42Should we just have them at the local level?
- 36:45Or should we be able to have them at the state level as well?
- 36:49And if you do have it at the local level, do we get to have it with any local official?
- 36:54Remember, we have those home rule considerations to think about.
- 36:58What where where as to whether home rule cities get to decide, yes, we are gonna have recall
- 37:05elections where when you don't necessarily normally have recall elections in that state or
- 37:10the exact opposite way where a state normally allows recall elections, but this one place
- 37:16that has some level of home rule says, actually, we're not gonna have recall
- 37:20elections, which cities and counties get to differ from the rest of the state.
- 37:29So are there home rule exemptions in this regard?
- 37:32Because home rule is not necessarily a a a clear cut.
- 37:35This city has home rule.
- 37:37This city doesn't have home rule.
- 37:38There's a lot of factors into it, and we go into it more on that those couple of episodes.
- 37:43I talk about home rule where they might have more leeway as to how to structure their
- 37:50governments, these local governments.
- 37:52But typically speaking, more fiscal matters like tax rates, they tend to have a lot less
- 38:01the local governments tend to have a lot less say in what those tax rates are.
- 38:05They usually have to get state government permission.
- 38:08So where does the provision of recall elections fall in that regard?
- 38:13Because even in states that have some level of home rule, the level of home rule is going to
- 38:18differ from another state.
- 38:21And if we include recall elections at the state level, should we be able to have it for just
- 38:28the executive branch?
- 38:29Do we also include judicial branch?
- 38:31Do we also include the legislative branch?
- 38:33Is does recall apply to one, two, or all three of those branches of government?
- 38:39Not necessarily straightforward answer because some states don't or some states allow it for
- 38:45all three branches of government where some only allow it for two, and then some only allow
- 38:49it for one.
- 38:51So how about why?
- 38:53What reasons should we be able to have recall elections?
- 38:57Should they be for any reason at all, or would they start to become too frivolous?
- 39:02And even if they necessarily seem frivolous, those campaigns still have to get the requisite
- 39:08number of signatures to get that election on the ballot.
- 39:11So that also gets back to that question of how how many petition signatures should a recall
- 39:19campaign have to get to get a recall election on the ballot, and and how long should they be
- 39:23able to circulate those petitions.
- 39:26So should we have any reason whatsoever?
- 39:28Can it be just because we don't like this person's face?
- 39:33We we don't like the way they talk?
- 39:35Yeah.
- 39:36Should should there be specified reasons instead?
- 39:40Does there need to be an accusation of criminal or civil wrongdoing?
- 39:44So political corruption, misfeasance, malfeasance.
- 39:48Can we include specific policy issues and proposals that they've had?
- 39:54So we don't like how they've handled a city's crime rates or that they raised taxes or that
- 40:03we don't like how they handled COVID nineteen.
- 40:07Whole myriad of reasons.
- 40:08The the they're now these reasons are not necessarily gonna include a specific policy
- 40:15issue in the laws where, like, the laws say, okay.
- 40:18You can have if it's a state that that has a provision for, okay, you need to meet these
- 40:23specific grounds.
- 40:24It's not gonna say, like, oh, well, the the policies that you're allowed to address are
- 40:30these.
- 40:30No.
- 40:31But should we have restrictions on that?
- 40:36Are some issues more important than others in that regard?
- 40:41Is the economic record a justifiable reason?
- 40:45Because economics, a lot of people are involved.
- 40:49It's very easy for us to look at one person and say, they're the specifically the problem, but,
- 40:54again, that can be couched in partisan and ideological biases.
- 40:59Or is there a level of conduct unbecoming of an elected official that should be considered?
- 41:06So if they're generally just a jerk wad, is that good enough to to try to hold a recall
- 41:15against them or to circulate petitions to have a recall election against that person.
- 41:21Even if we do have specific reasons, are those really just cover for partisan and or
- 41:27ideological reasons?
- 41:29And even if it is a cover for those, does it matter?
- 41:33Is it like how I excited that Marquette University Law School couple two different
- 41:39articles.
- 41:40One said, oh, it no.
- 41:41It shouldn't be for recalls weren't intended for any specific reason.
- 41:45They were just intended for anything, for any reason that voters thought that they should be
- 41:51recalled.
- 41:52Whereas another one said recall re, the people who originally the progressive reformers who
- 41:59originally popularized recall were doing it in regards to corrupt elected officials.
- 42:08So does it matter if any of those are actually just a cover for partisan or ideological
- 42:13reasons?
- 42:14And then lastly, how should we have recall elections?
- 42:18So we talked about the four general methods earlier.
- 42:22Should it be a simultaneous replacement where, excuse me, where on the same ballot, you say,
- 42:29like with the Gavin Newsom twenty twenty one recall election where you say, do you want this
- 42:34person recalled?
- 42:35Okay.
- 42:36If we do recall this person, do you who do you want to replace them with?
- 42:40Should we have that at the same time or should there be a separate special election?
- 42:46So one of the benefits of having a simultaneous election is that you're doing it all at once,
- 42:53so you don't have to have election costs for for holding two different elections.
- 42:59So you don't have the one for recalling the elected official and then having another one
- 43:05later that says, okay, who do you want them to who do you want to replace them with?
- 43:10Whereas if you're having that separate special election, you're having to pay for two
- 43:13different elections.
- 43:14But if you have that separate special election, you get to have a certain length of time to
- 43:19think your decision over, whereas the simultaneous selection, have to you have to
- 43:26take less time to really come to a decision of who you want to replace that person.
- 43:32Not necessarily that one being better than the other.
- 43:36It's just another consideration to consider.
- 43:39Or if we don't instead of a a an another election by the voters or the where the the
- 43:44voters get to decide the recall, but maybe they don't necessarily get to be the ones to decide
- 43:49the replacement.
- 43:49Maybe then we should appoint the replacement.
- 43:53Maybe it's the governor that doesn't, or if it's a local level official that gets recalled,
- 43:58maybe the mayor should do it, or maybe some county, the county commission should jointly
- 44:05decide who gets to replace that local elected official, or do we just have an automatic line
- 44:10of succession so voters don't get to decide, government officials don't get to decide.
- 44:16It's already set in stone in law who gets to replace that elected official if they get
- 44:23recalled.
- 44:25And then should courts be involved like in Virginia's recall system where the circuit
- 44:29courts basically decide if that person gets recalled.
- 44:36That's a very unique system.
- 44:38Should that be implemented in another state?
- 44:41Or should there be an entirely different system that somebody has not come up with yet?
- 44:46Maybe it should be a combination of all of these.
- 44:49I I don't know.
- 44:50Maybe maybe we say, oh, the, governor gets to appoint this person, but then the voters get
- 44:56to, say whether or not they approve of that governor's choice.
- 45:03Who knows?
- 45:04Just just a whole bunch of ideas being thrown out.
- 45:07So there's all these sorts of considerations where even if you agree that we should have
- 45:11recall elections, you need to think about whether or how exactly those are administered.
- 45:18And that and that's that's the way with a lot of different political issues.
- 45:22We know not necessarily just, okay, we should do it this way, but exactly how do you do it
- 45:28that way?
- 45:28Or you you generally fall on one side of the fence of, okay.
- 45:32I support this general thing, but how do we exactly implement it?
- 45:37Always more complicated than a lot of people like to make it out to be.
- 45:41So our recall elections, what we should we have get to have recall elections for everybody?
- 45:48Should they only be allowed for certain people?
- 45:52You know, that's that's obviously for you to decide.
- 45:55I'm not here to get involved as to whether or not I think that they should that somebody
- 46:01should be recalled.
- 46:03I'm just trying to give as the the as informative of tools as possible for you to
- 46:08decide what you think about recall elections, how they should be handled, and so on.
- 46:13So that's gonna do it for today's episode.
- 46:15So as always, thank you so much for listening to the podcast.
- 46:20Please like, comment, subscribe, share the podcast with your networks, with your friends,
- 46:26with your family, with people you don't like.
- 46:28May maybe you can reach out to somebody and have a truce and say, hey.
- 46:34This podcast is really nice.
- 46:35You should you should listen to it.
- 46:37I mean, obviously, that's wishful thinking.
- 46:39But in any case, please share the podcast with anybody you know and links in the show notes
- 46:47for my Facebook, LinkedIn, my educational email course about ways we unintentionally further
- 46:54polarize the political climate even when we're trying to depolarize it and how we can fix
- 46:58those mistakes.
- 46:59My book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections and how they can become more
- 47:04competitive, not arguing for or against independents, just saying a lot of the
- 47:08roadblocks that they face.
- 47:10And couple of other things in there too.
- 47:14My matchmaker FM profile, if you wanna be on this podcast or you want to have me as a guest
- 47:20on your podcast.
- 47:23I think that's going to do it.
- 47:26Always, thank you so much for listening.
- 47:28Until next time, take care.