Latest / Film And Whiskey / Oscar Nominations 2026: Reactions and Breakdown ft. Daniel Joyaux
Transcript
- 0:00Well, hey everybody, welcome into film and whiskey.
- 0:02I am Bob Book and I would say that I'm flying solo today
- 0:05because my Co host Brad is not here with me.
- 0:08But I did not come empty handed. I brought along a special guest
- 0:12because today the Oscar nominations for the 2026 Oscars
- 0:17were announced. Thank goodness we are on the
- 0:19East Coast and I didn't have to wake up at 5:30 AM to see what
- 0:23these Oscar nominations looked like.
- 0:25But as with every year it seems now we have a long standing
- 0:28tradition of inviting our friend Daniel Zweio to come in and talk
- 0:32about the Oscars with us. This is one of probably 2
- 0:34episodes Daniel will be on as we get closer and closer to the
- 0:38Oscars. Here, he's very rapidly becoming
- 0:41our official Oscars prognosticator and
- 0:43correspondent. Daniel's joining us from his
- 0:45house tonight. Daniel, how's it going, man?
- 0:47I'm good. I'm good.
- 0:49You know what? I look over this list of Oscar
- 0:50nominees and I don't see a ton of surprises here.
- 0:54I think there's still quite a bit of storylines that we can go
- 0:56through that are exciting and that get me excited for this
- 1:00Oscar ceremony. But overall, like this looks
- 1:04like the list I expected. Daniel, how about you?
- 1:07Yeah, I for the most part it is. I got I think 38 out of 45
- 1:12predictions right for the major categories.
- 1:14There were a few curveballs and a few things I'm disappointed
- 1:17by, but for the most part, I think this is a really good
- 1:21nomination list and basically the expected nomination list.
- 1:25You know, some people might think it sounds bad when you say
- 1:28expected like that. It's disappointing that they
- 1:29aren't surprised, but ultimately when the best stuff is expected
- 1:32to get nominated and then does. That's that's a good thing.
- 1:36Absolutely. You know, and I've always gone
- 1:38back and forth on using the Oscars as a gauge for the
- 1:42quality of a movie year. The Oscars are known to get it
- 1:44wrong quite often. But there is something about,
- 1:47especially as you look back 30-40 years at what was deemed
- 1:52important at the time, I think it really is a window into what
- 1:56was going on culturally at that moment.
- 1:58You know, and we've talked about, Brad and I have talked
- 2:00about 1994 so often on this podcast cause we've done pretty
- 2:04much every movie, every major movie from that year now.
- 2:07And Forrest Gump wins best picture.
- 2:09And you know, it like we look back on it now and it's like, I
- 2:12can't believe Forrest Gump won best picture, but America was
- 2:15really behind that movie at that moment.
- 2:18So it's not necessarily a good gauge of what's considered the
- 2:22movie with the most artistic merit.
- 2:24But at least in the 1990's, the Oscars were a really good
- 2:27indicator of where the movie going public was and what they
- 2:31wanted to kind of throw their cachet behind.
- 2:34And I look at the movies in 2026, I guess, you know, 2025
- 2:38films that are getting nominated.
- 2:40And we've talked a lot, Daniel, about what the role of the
- 2:43Oscars is culturally now in the 20 twenties.
- 2:47But looking through this year in this list in particular, do you
- 2:50think that the Oscars are are siding a little bit more on the
- 2:54side of artistic merit or critical favorability?
- 2:58Or are they kind of swimming back towards maybe a little bit
- 3:01more of a populist award the way it was in the 90s?
- 3:05I think there's no question that they swing more artistically
- 3:08now. I think the last few years the
- 3:11Academy's exhibited probably the best taste it ever has.
- 3:14I mean, I think it was 2023 that it that had, you know, maybe the
- 3:17best, the greatest, best picture lineup ever, I think.
- 3:20But you know, this year is an interesting, it's an interesting
- 3:24case because you look at the best picture lineup and
- 3:27certainly most of it I think falls into that realm of
- 3:31choosing artistry. But then you have something like
- 3:34F1 getting in over it was just an accident, which I to me was
- 3:38the surprise of the day. Absolutely.
- 3:41Actually, let's let's. Pause here.
- 3:42Let me just read the we'll get through a lot of these
- 3:44categories, but let's do best picture here because I think
- 3:47this really sets the stage for a conversation.
- 3:50I I've talked to a few people about these nominees today and
- 3:53it rains ranges from people who have seen most of these movies
- 3:56to like your average movie goer. And I'm asking them, how many of
- 3:59these have you heard of? And so here's the 10 nominees
- 4:02that we got today. Begonia F1 Frankenstein Hamnet
- 4:09Marty Supreme 1 battle after another, the secret agent,
- 4:14sentimental value sinners and train dreams.
- 4:19Now, Daniel, I didn't mean to interrupt you there, but I do
- 4:21think that you are you're you're in the middle of a pretty
- 4:23interesting point here, because this is a this is a year that
- 4:27feels I hate to use the word schizophrenic.
- 4:29I don't want to say schizophrenic here, but it feels
- 4:31a little bit like I can't find a good through line to define
- 4:36where the Academy's thinking is. Because you're right, a lot of
- 4:40these are, as they have been in the past 10 or so years, really
- 4:43small. Either independent films or
- 4:45films with tiny, tiny release windows and distribution.
- 4:51But then you've got an F1 thrown in here and F1, I don't feel
- 4:55like was on anybody's radar until just a few weeks ago.
- 4:58And then all of a sudden there were these rumblings that like,
- 5:01hey, it's gonna it's gonna get in all the technical categories.
- 5:03And you should really watch out for Brad Pitt's F1 getting a
- 5:07Best Picture nomination. I was absolutely floored by that
- 5:11one. Well, I'd say the fact that you
- 5:14can't find a through line in these nominees would make
- 5:18Academy governors happy. I think that's.
- 5:21Probably true. I, you know, back when best
- 5:24picture was a field of five, you would often have years where the
- 5:29five nominees felt like 5 of the exact same kind of movie.
- 5:32It was 5, you know, sort of prestige, star driven, issue
- 5:36based dramas. And even in the last decade, as
- 5:41we've had 10 nominees, it's actually been 16 or 17 years
- 5:45now. I think there have been a lot of
- 5:48years where, you know, eight or nine of those 10 nominees feel
- 5:52like very similar art house drama type of films.
- 5:55This year I really think you have a mix that it was the
- 6:00Academy's goal when they expanded the field to 10.
- 6:03When they did that, the hope was that you would get big budget
- 6:07movies and crowd pleasers and foreign films and in in every
- 6:11kind of film. In this year you really have
- 6:13that. You've got 2 international
- 6:14films. You've got two of the year's top
- 6:16ten highest grocers. You've got several star-studded
- 6:18dramas it this is the type of Best Picture line up that I
- 6:22think The Academy Is always hoped to get.
- 6:25Absolutely. Wait, in terms of the size of
- 6:27the movies and the thematic elements of the movies, it's
- 6:30definitely a diverse crowd, but there's two at the top that I
- 6:34think it it really has become in a lot of ways A2 horse race here
- 6:37and that is 1 battle after another with 13 nominations and
- 6:41Sinners, Ryan Coogler Sinners breaking the Oscar nominations
- 6:45record with 16 nominations. Prior record was 14.
- 6:50This is a huge deal, Daniel. And again, it's one of those
- 6:53things that if you've been paying attention to some of the
- 6:55rumblings coming out of Hollywood, people were saying
- 6:57this could break the record. But to smash it by 2 is pretty
- 7:02extraordinary. And that goes all the way back
- 7:04to the acting nominations that it picked up, including one for
- 7:07Delroy Lindo, who gets his first Oscar nomination for supporting
- 7:12actor after years and years of incredible work.
- 7:15Just let's talk a little bit about Sinners, because I think
- 7:18that you know, it, you could say, oh, it, it positioned
- 7:21itself well in the technical categories and that's where the
- 7:24bulk of its nominations are. But that's not true.
- 7:26It's it's really spread out and that makes it a really strong
- 7:29contender here in the Best Picture race.
- 7:32Yeah, so a few things. First of all, I, I saw a few
- 7:34people on the line today say like, well, it only broke the
- 7:36record because the, you know, the casting category is new this
- 7:39year. That's wrong on 2 fronts.
- 7:41First of all, it broke, it broke the record by two.
- 7:43So even if the casting category didn't exist this year, it still
- 7:45would have broken the record. But second of all, the casting
- 7:49category took the place of what used to be a second sound
- 7:51category. There used to be two sound
- 7:53categories, best sound, best sound effects, editing.
- 7:56Now there's only one sound category.
- 7:59If we were still in the days of two sound categories, Sinners
- 8:01would have gotten nominated for both.
- 8:03So it would have still broken the record back then too.
- 8:07And the other part about the Sinners Hall today and you
- 8:12touched on this that it got nominated everywhere.
- 8:15Is it actually got nominated in every single possible category.
- 8:18There are 24 Oscar categories. The 8 categories that it did not
- 8:22get nominated are the three shorts categories, animated
- 8:25feature, which it's not animated International Film, it's not an
- 8:28International Film documentary feature.
- 8:30It's not a documentary feature. Adapted screenplay.
- 8:32It had an original screenplay. And then the last one is lead
- 8:35actress. Now you can make an argument
- 8:37that maybe Hailee Steinfeld was a lead in that film.
- 8:39I don't really think she was She was certainly campaigning in is
- 8:42a sporting role. So if you adopt the idea that
- 8:45the film had no female lead, then it literally got nominated
- 8:48in every single category that results.
- 8:51Yeah, which is, I mean, first of all, congratulations to Sinners.
- 8:54And it's a movie that I've been pretty vocal on this podcast
- 8:57about the fact that, like, it didn't work for me quite on the
- 8:59level that it has for other people.
- 9:01That does not mean that it is not a very rewarding experience
- 9:06and certainly deserving of the nominations that it got.
- 9:08I do wonder a little bit, Daniel, And I don't want to say
- 9:11this points to a weak year in film because it seems to be
- 9:15unchallenged in a lot of ways and because of how many
- 9:18nominations it got. But I am wondering if the sort
- 9:21of technical craft of sinners is enjoying the fact that there
- 9:28were not a lot of competitors in terms of like, you know, if this
- 9:32would come out the year of like an Oppenheimer where other
- 9:34things are really, you know, being filmed in IMAX, the way
- 9:37that one battle after another was.
- 9:39It seems like both of these two films enjoyed the fact that,
- 9:42like, a lot of these technical categories, the ones that we
- 9:46thought were going to get nominated just did not show up.
- 9:48Like, you don't see Wicked for good showing up at all.
- 9:51It gets completely shut out today.
- 9:53Do you think that those two films just kind of separated
- 9:57themselves by the fact that they had a lot more technical craft
- 10:00than everything else this year? Well, as far as the craft
- 10:03categories go, the single biggest shock to me today was
- 10:07that Avatar, Fire and Ash didn't get nominated for best sound.
- 10:11Now, it, it didn't get shut out. It got nominated for visual
- 10:14effects and costume design. But for a James Cameron movie to
- 10:17miss best sound was just I, I mean, it's, it's basically never
- 10:22happened before all of his movies get nominated for best
- 10:24sound. So that was a huge surprise.
- 10:27And it did speak to the idea that since the best picture
- 10:33field expanded to 10, voters are now less likely to search
- 10:40essentially beyond the 10 best picture nominees.
- 10:43You know, once they sort of decide or once, you know, the,
- 10:46the punditry sort of decides like these are going to be the
- 10:4910 best picture nominees or, you know, might be 12 or 13 that are
- 10:51fighting for that. For those 10 spots, a lot of
- 10:53voters will kind of just watch those 12 or 13 movies.
- 10:56And no matter what branch they're in, whether they're
- 10:58costume designers or editors or visual effects supervisors, you
- 11:01know, what have you, they'll, they'll just kind of check boxes
- 11:05based on those 12 or 13 movies. And I think we saw maybe a
- 11:09little bit of that today in some of the craft branches that they
- 11:13just nominated the best picture contenders instead of, you know,
- 11:16looking for things outside the box.
- 11:17And I think it's a little unfortunate when that happens.
- 11:19I, I understand it to some degree.
- 11:20I mean, you know, you can't expect Oscar voters to just
- 11:23watch every movie that comes out in a year.
- 11:25That's not reasonable. They have to figure out, you
- 11:27know, somewhere where the line is and how many things they're
- 11:29going to watch to figure out to fill out the ballot.
- 11:33But it does feel a bit like the major contenders today picked up
- 11:37some extra nominations just by virtue of being the major
- 11:40contenders. I mean, I think one group of
- 11:44people that's not complaining about it at all is Warner
- 11:47Brothers, the studio that released both 1 Battle After
- 11:50Another and Sinners and Weapons, which picked up 1 nomination for
- 11:55Amy Madigan. Which means that Warner Brothers
- 11:58is currently sitting on top of 30 Oscar nominations this year,
- 12:03which is insane, especially given how embattled that studio
- 12:07has been in the past year. David Zasloff wanting to fire
- 12:11both of the heads of the film development branch and then
- 12:15deciding in like September that he's keeping them both on.
- 12:18So I, I think it's a great opportunity for them to take a
- 12:21bow here, but it. Never.
- 12:22I mean, it has always come. The lesson is that David Zasloff
- 12:25is an idiot who's done nothing but fail upper.
- 12:28Yes, and I, I didn't think that we would end this movie year
- 12:32with Warner Brothers taking a victory lap of this sort.
- 12:35But like, I'm kind of glad to see it because I have not been a
- 12:38fan of the direction of that studio the last couple years
- 12:40under Zaslob's leadership. And it's nice to see that the
- 12:43people at the studio that actually care about movies are
- 12:46being rewarded for that. I agree.
- 12:49All right, all right. Daniel, you published an article
- 12:53today on rogerebert.com and it featured a word in the headline
- 12:57that I am not used to seeing You use.
- 12:59Eight biggest snubs of the Oscars this year.
- 13:02I thought you were famously anti snub.
- 13:04Man, what's going on? I am, I am anti snub.
- 13:06I did not use the word snub in the article and sadly, headlines
- 13:10are not written by writers of the article.
- 13:13So whoever wrote that headline, you know, I, I don't begrudge it
- 13:15because look, writing is a quagmire.
- 13:20It's hard. I don't, I'm not going to shoot
- 13:25on anyone for trying to, you know, maximalize search engine
- 13:28optimization, you know, if using it, if using the word snub is
- 13:31going to. Get your writing.
- 13:33Scene then then go for it. Yeah, 100%.
- 13:36I do think that the way the article's written is that it's
- 13:39all about the big surprises of the day, you know, both good and
- 13:42bad. And I, I, I'd like to just turn
- 13:44it over to you, man. You got 8 of them in the article
- 13:46here. I don't need you to spoil the
- 13:48whole thing. I'd like people to go read it.
- 13:50But when you think about the major storylines and the most
- 13:52surprising storylines of the day, what really stands out to
- 13:55you? To me, the biggest surprise is
- 13:57it was just an accident which was the winner of the Palme Dor
- 14:01at the Cannes Film Festival. It's an Iranian film by Jafar
- 14:04Panahi. As soon as it won The Palm Door
- 14:07last May, it had been sort of presumed to be a major Oscar
- 14:11contender all season. I mean, it did get 2 nominations
- 14:14today. It was nominated for best
- 14:15International Film and for Best Original screenplay.
- 14:19I I think most people assumed it was also going to be safely in
- 14:22the best picture field and best director field.
- 14:23I was really surprised it didn't come through in those
- 14:26nominations, especially given everything happening in Iran.
- 14:31And Jafar Panahi's personal situation is he's there's a
- 14:35warrant for his arrest basically as soon as he goes when this
- 14:38Oscar campaign season is over and he goes back to Iran, he.
- 14:41Is. Probably facing a jail sentence.
- 14:45It's especially surprising that it wasn't nominated.
- 14:47I mean, you were talking at the beginning of the episode about
- 14:50the way the Oscars reflect the times.
- 14:53And something that's really amazing to me about it was just
- 14:55an accident is, you know, the movie premiered a year ago and
- 14:59it was, you know, in production for however long before that.
- 15:02But you could watch the film right now and believe it was
- 15:04written yesterday. It feels like it's a movie about
- 15:07ice, basically. And so I'm really surprised
- 15:12voters didn't respond to it. Yeah.
- 15:13I, it's something I said in my article is whenever you expect a
- 15:17movie to get nominated, it doesn't.
- 15:18There are basically three possible reasons.
- 15:20Either voters didn't watch it, voters watched it and didn't
- 15:23like it, or something went wrong with the campaign.
- 15:25And that's the interesting question to me is because the
- 15:30distributor is because the distributor Neon was somehow
- 15:36managed to pick up all five of the major contenders in for best
- 15:40International Film and they were juggling campaigns for all five
- 15:43of those movies. It was just an accident,
- 15:45Sentimental Value, The Secret Agent, Serrat and no other
- 15:47choice. And most of those movies didn't
- 15:50get as many nominations today as they hoped to.
- 15:53And so it makes you wonder if one distributor trying to
- 15:56monopolize this sort of entire strata of the International Film
- 16:01market is maybe not a great idea.
- 16:04Yeah, I mean, they're cannibalizing themselves at this
- 16:06point. And the the interesting thing is
- 16:08like, it's hard to accuse Neon of botching the campaign for it
- 16:15was just an accident because all the things that could go wrong
- 16:18with that, you see that it it worked in the case of
- 16:21sentimental value and the secret agent.
- 16:23Now the secret agent is Brazil's nominee for the year.
- 16:26And the Brazilian contingent has proven itself to be a really,
- 16:30really strong voting bloc and like a monolith when it comes to
- 16:33voting because last year they were able to get I'm Still here
- 16:37nominated for best Picture, which I will say ended up being
- 16:40my favorite movie of the year. So I was really glad to see it
- 16:43reflected there. But the Brazilians all seem to
- 16:46vote as a block. And sentimental value had gotten
- 16:49this kind of crossover appeal that everyone kind of assumed it
- 16:52was going to get nominated for best Picture.
- 16:54And so that leaves it was just an accident in this really weird
- 16:56spot because it was assumed, yeah, it'll probably get a best
- 17:00picture nomination, but it will probably win international
- 17:04feature. At least that's the reporting
- 17:05that I saw was like, it's much stronger in this category.
- 17:09It'll get a nod for best picture, but it's not really a
- 17:11player there. And now that it didn't get a
- 17:14best picture nomination and two other international films did,
- 17:18it might not even be in the lead to get the international feature
- 17:22Oscar. And I think that puts it in a
- 17:23really precarious position here. Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's it's
- 17:27probably going to go home empty handed an Oscar night.
- 17:30I mean, sentimental value got 9 nominations and it's up against
- 17:35the the two categories that it was just an accident didn't get
- 17:38nominated in. It's up against sentimental
- 17:39value in both of them. I think you have to assume
- 17:42sentimental value is probably the more likely front runner for
- 17:45international feature and original screenplay.
- 17:48So and look, I love sentimental value.
- 17:49It's certainly nothing. It's that film, but it's it's
- 17:51too bad that it was just an accident.
- 17:53Just something fell flat with voters.
- 17:54And it's, it's hard to say what because the film feels so timely
- 17:58and so potent about what's happening right now and the
- 18:01story behind his making. I mean, Jafar Panahi shot the
- 18:04film in secret, even on city streets in Tehran, but with
- 18:08hidden cameras. I mean, it's to to make
- 18:10literally any film under those circumstances, let alone a, you
- 18:13know, pseudo masterpiece. I'm just amazed that voters
- 18:17didn't respond to it. Yeah, man.
- 18:19Now I will offer a quick brief correction to you.
- 18:22Neon did not get that fifth international feature slot,
- 18:25which people thought was going to go to No Other Choice.
- 18:28No Other Choice did get legitimately snubbed because The
- 18:32Voice of Hindra Job, Tunisia's entry for this category did get
- 18:35in. Which I personally am very happy
- 18:39about because in Vulture's Movies Fantasy League I picked
- 18:42up The Voice of Hindra Job for like $2.00 and it is paying
- 18:46dividends for me right now. So I'm sorry part Chan Wook,
- 18:49that the Academy apparently hates you, but it worked out for
- 18:52Old Bob and his on his list. Here.
- 18:54So like I said, Neon had picked up for distribution the five the
- 18:59highest profile international films of the year.
- 19:01And one of the big questions was would one distributor really get
- 19:03all 5 slots in the best International Film race?
- 19:05As you said, no other choice didn't manage to get a
- 19:09nomination. And that also is a pretty big
- 19:10surprise for me. I mean, part Chan Wook, who's
- 19:13pretty lively regard is one of the the great masters of
- 19:17contemporary cinema. I mean, he this is the guy who's
- 19:19directed Old Boy, the Handmaiden and decision to lead.
- 19:22None of his films have ever gotten a single Oscar
- 19:24nomination, which is just, it's, it's astonishing.
- 19:27Yeah, man. Now, the nice thing that Neon
- 19:29can kind of rest its hat on is that it didn't botch things
- 19:32worse than Searchlight, because Searchlight has a movie coming
- 19:36out in wider distribution today, the day of Oscar nominations.
- 19:40And what that tells me is that they thought this movie was
- 19:43going to get some nominations and then they would open and it
- 19:46would do killer business in the small number of theaters.
- 19:49And it's a movie called The Testament of Anne Lee, which is
- 19:52a very tough sell to your average movie goer.
- 19:55It is a quasi musical about the Shaker movement starring Amanda
- 20:00Seyfried. And from all accounts, it's an
- 20:02incredible film. But nobody has seen this movie.
- 20:06And crucially, it's not just like John and Jane Doe in
- 20:09Nebraska that haven't seen this movie.
- 20:11I'm seeing movie critics. I'm seeing Academy voters that
- 20:13are saying, I couldn't find a Screener to this.
- 20:16I couldn't get the link to this. They just screwed it up so
- 20:19badly. That they basically tanked
- 20:22Amanda Seyfried's chances of getting the best actress
- 20:24nomination that most people had her penciled in for a couple
- 20:28months ago. I just, when you've got a movie
- 20:30like this where you know it's not going to do hundreds of
- 20:33millions of dollars at the box office, it, it's amazing to me
- 20:36how badly they fumble this campaign, man.
- 20:39Yeah, I like I said, I haven't seen that one yet either.
- 20:42It it opens where I live tomorrow, so and we'll probably
- 20:45see it this weekend. I'm looking forward to it.
- 20:47I I expect to like it. Yeah, for sure.
- 20:50Let's talk about a couple movies that your average moviegoer will
- 20:53have heard of. And you know, we've already
- 20:55talked about sinners. We've talked a little bit about
- 20:571 Battle after another. I want to go through the acting
- 21:00categories here because there are some major players and I
- 21:03guess at the top of the list, especially in lead actor, you've
- 21:06got Timothy Chalamet for Marty's Supreme, who I think at this
- 21:10point would have to do something really, really stupid to lose
- 21:15this race. It seems to be his Oscar to
- 21:17lose. Am I crazy?
- 21:19You're not crazy in the sense that that is definitely the
- 21:22conventional wisdom. I don't agree with it though.
- 21:25Oh. Who?
- 21:28Who's it going to? Well, it's a long time between
- 21:32now and Oscar night, and so I haven't.
- 21:33This is by no means a prediction.
- 21:35I don't know who I will ultimately end up predicting.
- 21:37But something I have been saying for the last few months is that
- 21:40if Ethan Hawke can get a nomination, and that to me felt
- 21:43like the big if whether voters would watch Blue Moon, whether
- 21:46Sony Pictures Classics could, could mount enough of a campaign
- 21:48for it. But I've long thought that if
- 21:51Ethan Locke could get a nomination, he's now sort of
- 21:54reached the point of his career where it feels like voters want
- 21:57to give him an Oscar. And now that he's officially in
- 22:01the field, I really think he could kind of become a contender
- 22:07similar to the way Demi Moore did last year.
- 22:09And then Demi Moore ultimately ended up losing, which was a
- 22:12huge surprise in Oscar night. But, you know, for the longest
- 22:15time it felt like, well, she's not going to get nominated for
- 22:17the substance because that's this sort of gross out body
- 22:19horror movie and the Academy won't watch that.
- 22:22But then as soon as she did actually get nominated, it felt
- 22:24like, oh, well, she might win. And that's how it feels to me,
- 22:27right? Well, and I think that's the
- 22:29thing that people don't realize still about Academy Awards
- 22:32voting is yes, this is a global body, but it is still highly
- 22:35localized. And all of these people have
- 22:38been doing their campaigns in and around Los Angeles and some
- 22:41New York appearances for months now.
- 22:44So you've got screenings that are hosted by the film makers.
- 22:46You've got, you know, the actors making appearances at
- 22:49screenings, at little get togethers on podcast, what have
- 22:53you. And so a movie like Blue Moon,
- 22:55which played for literally one week in one theater in the area
- 22:59that I was in and I still haven't seen it yet.
- 23:02And that like that should tell listeners of this show a lot
- 23:05about the distribution of Blue Moon.
- 23:06Like I have not seen this movie. And and I, you know, I want to
- 23:11be a purist about the Oscars, Daniel, and think that if if
- 23:15Ethan Hawke is to win, it's good for the Oscars.
- 23:18It's good for movies because I want the best performance to
- 23:20win. There is a part of me, though,
- 23:22that's like, you know, this is like a populist, if not a
- 23:26populist award. It's a populist awards
- 23:29presentation. It's it's broadcast on
- 23:31television. They want the biggest stars to
- 23:33be up there, especially for the future of this telecast.
- 23:37And I just wonder, like, if Ethan Hawke is able to kind of
- 23:40swoop in and and get the Oscar out from underneath Leo
- 23:44DiCaprio, Michael B Jordan or Timothy Chalamet, is that
- 23:47ultimately a bad thing for the Oscars future?
- 23:50Well, I, I, I don't know how to answer that question because I
- 23:53mean, look, Blue Moon is a movie is not going to have the
- 23:57lifespan that one battle after another or sinners are going to
- 24:00have. But something that people also
- 24:01hate about the Oscars is when they look back at a career like
- 24:04Ethan Hawks and say, what do you mean he never won an Oscar?
- 24:07Sure, sure. So it's it's a double edged
- 24:10sword. I'm really so as, yeah, I'm
- 24:14curious, as you were saying it about the the populism, who
- 24:17would you feel like if, if voters wanted to to, you know,
- 24:23have the populist winner, who even is that between Chalamet
- 24:26and Michael B Jordan, Leonardo DiCaprio?
- 24:28It's got to be Chalamet at this point, I think, especially when
- 24:31you're thinking about the next generation and the ability to
- 24:34pass on the Oscars and and hope that it's in good hands in terms
- 24:38of viewership. You know, Leo famously is like,
- 24:41I hate doing press. I hate doing interviews.
- 24:43And yes, he's still maybe the biggest movie star in the world,
- 24:46but you know, he doesn't resonate with Gen.
- 24:48Z the way he's resonating with me as a millennial.
- 24:50Michael B Jordan yes, but like Timmy's out there campaigning
- 24:54for this. Timmy's doing the rap videos and
- 24:56everything else. He really desperately wants this
- 24:59Oscar. And I think maybe that that that
- 25:01could be why he won't get it because they see him kind of
- 25:04begging for it in a Bradley Cooper.
- 25:05I was just going. To say Bradley Cooper, it's
- 25:08starting to feel thirsty. You know, the Academy has 10,000
- 25:13voters. I think it's actually more than
- 25:14that. I think it's close to 11 or
- 25:1512,000. Now.
- 25:17We don't know the breakdown of like, so, so a nominee appears
- 25:24too thirsty. OK, So what percentage of voters
- 25:27does that turn off in, in a voting body of 12,000 people,
- 25:31does appearing really thirsty? Is that going to turn off 500
- 25:35voters, 1000? Who knows?
- 25:37Also, who knows how many or how far ahead Chalonet might be.
- 25:41Like if he turns off 1000 voters, that still might not be
- 25:44enough to lose. On the other hand, maybe he
- 25:47turns off 500 voters and that is enough to lose.
- 25:49We, we just don't know how close these things are.
- 25:51So I, I, I, I agree that the degree to which he, it seems
- 26:00like he's begging for it, that that will cost him some votes.
- 26:03Whether or not it's enough votes matter, you know it's impossible
- 26:07to say. For sure now, as you said, we're
- 26:10still a couple months out from the ceremony itself, but it
- 26:14seems like most of the major categories, especially the big
- 26:18six here are kind of sewn up. And I, you know, I say the Big
- 26:226, I don't, I'm not talking about the screenplays, I'm
- 26:24talking about all four of the acting categories.
- 26:26Best Picture and Best Director seem to have clear front runners
- 26:31at this point. Do you see?
- 26:33Do you see them going 6 for six or do you see somebody losing in
- 26:36these races? I, I see multiple, multiple
- 26:39people losing. I, I agree that there are, there
- 26:44is the appearance of front runners.
- 26:46I think a lot of that could change.
- 26:48So I mean, let's, you know, quickly go front runner by
- 26:50category. OK, So best director front
- 26:52runner is obviously Paul Tom de Sanders, right?
- 26:54However, Sinners officially got more nominations than one battle
- 26:58after another. Another factor is that no black
- 27:01film makers ever won best director.
- 27:03I do think that will become a story over the next six weeks
- 27:07and that. Will get more likely though that
- 27:10that. See I'm at the point now where
- 27:12like if if PTA loses another one, it's going to be like he's
- 27:16getting into Diane Warren territory and I could see it
- 27:19more likely that Sinners takes best picture and PTA takes
- 27:23director. Then I see the opposite app.
- 27:25So that could happen. But again, there have been two
- 27:29films by black film makers that have won Best Picture. 12 Years
- 27:32a Slave in Moonlight. Neither won best Director.
- 27:34So I think that the narrative will be very specific about why.
- 27:38What does the black filmmaker have to do to win Best Picture
- 27:40or to win best Director? And if it's not for a film that
- 27:43gets 16 nominations, then what? What could it ever be for?
- 27:47What? What's it going to be?
- 27:49Yeah, that's fair. That's fair.
- 27:50And then to your Paul Thomas Anderson point, I mean, so he's
- 27:54obviously nominated for best director.
- 27:55He's also a producer on the film.
- 27:56So he's nominated for best picture and he's nominated for
- 27:58best adapted screenplay. He could win all three.
- 28:01He could win 2 out of three. He could win one of the three.
- 28:04He will certainly win something. I find it literally impossible
- 28:07to leave that. He won't leave Oscar night with
- 28:09an Oscar. Whether or not he goes one for
- 28:123/2 for three or three for three, That's a different
- 28:14conversation. And I do think Ryan Coogler will
- 28:17will turn into some serious competition that will almost be
- 28:20a toss up by the time we get to Oscar night.
- 28:23If I was. I was going to say, if I was a
- 28:26betting man, I think Jessie Buckley in Hamnet is maybe the
- 28:33most odds on favorite out of this entire list.
- 28:35And not because the competition is not good.
- 28:38I'm just looking at the other nominees here.
- 28:40You got Rose Byrne in. If I had legs, I'd kick you.
- 28:43Great win of the Golden Globes. I don't know if that movie is
- 28:46going to have like quite enough juice to carry her to victory
- 28:50there. Kate Hudson, a surprise nominee
- 28:52for Song Sung Blue. I think she's absolutely going
- 28:55to work that circuit and she could maybe, you know, get
- 28:58herself up into second position there.
- 29:00Renata Rainsby for sentimental value and then Emma Stone semi
- 29:06surprise. Not really for Begonia.
- 29:08I just don't see any of those four having what it takes to
- 29:12beat Jessie Buckley for this one.
- 29:14So you're right that Jessie Buckley is definitely the front
- 29:16runner. She is one of the safest Oscar
- 29:19bets on the board right now. I would not say it's sewn up of
- 29:23one factor that I've been thinking about.
- 29:26So I think her biggest competition is Rose Byrne.
- 29:28And I think Rose Byrne really could win when you compare those
- 29:32two movies. And so let's go with the
- 29:34stereotype that Oscar voters are lazy.
- 29:36They're not going to watch everything.
- 29:38They're going to, you know, watch 10 minutes of this movie,
- 29:4110 minutes of this other movie, etcetera.
- 29:44If that happens, think about Jessie Buckley's performance
- 29:47versus Rose Byrne's performance. Jessie Buckley's performance in
- 29:50hand, that's what sends it home, is the last 15 minutes of the
- 29:53movie. If you don't watch the last 15
- 29:55minutes of the movie, you will not think she deserves an Oscar.
- 29:58Now compare that to if I had legs, I'd kick you.
- 30:01To me, the 1st 30 seconds of that movie are when I wanted to
- 30:05give Rose Byrne an Oscar. Wow.
- 30:08You could literally watch 5 minutes that movie and think,
- 30:11well, I want to vote for her. I mean, the the opening shot of
- 30:14If I Had Legs, I'd Kick you is just a close up of Rose Byrne's
- 30:17eyes while she delivers a monologue and you don't even see
- 30:19her lips moving. It's just a close up on her
- 30:21eyes. And it's such a stunning intro
- 30:24to the movie. And look, if I had legs, I'd
- 30:28kick you. It's about the problems of
- 30:31parenthood. It's a it's depressing and it's
- 30:33also funny, but it's depressing and heavy in a lot of ways.
- 30:37So I would believe that some voters won't watch it or won't
- 30:39watch all of it, but if they just watched the 1st 5 minutes,
- 30:43that might be enough if they don't manage to finish all of
- 30:46them. All right, Daniel, as we wind
- 30:47down today, because I want to save some meat on the bone, I'd
- 30:50love to have you back on as we get closer to the ceremony
- 30:52itself, maybe to give some final predictions as you look across
- 30:57the board here at the Oscar nominees, is there any
- 31:00particular movie, you know, that we have or have not talked about
- 31:03today? We didn't end up doing a A10
- 31:06best of 2025. So I, you know, like I
- 31:08absolutely have movies that I want to suggest our audience
- 31:11sees if they haven't yet. But like what are the ones that
- 31:14stand out to you of I think if I could recommend this one or two
- 31:18movies that everybody watched before Oscar night, it should be
- 31:21these ones. Well.
- 31:22That's a good question. I mean, in some ways my taste
- 31:25was really basic this year. I honestly believe that One
- 31:27Battle After Another and Sinners are the two best movies of the
- 31:31year. I really liked sentimental
- 31:32value. I really liked it was just an
- 31:34accident. I really liked Marty Supreme.
- 31:36I mean, so I'm not exactly hitting you with hot takes
- 31:39there. I would say watch if I had
- 31:45likes, I'd Kick You for Rose Burns performance and watch Blue
- 31:48Moon for Ethan Knox's performance.
- 31:49I think those are two smaller profile movies that, for what
- 31:54they're nominated for, really deliver.
- 31:57I was going to come in here today and talk about how my
- 32:00number one movie of last year was this small film called
- 32:04Sorry, Baby, which just happened to win a Golden Globe and got
- 32:09itself some really, really good screenplay juice going into
- 32:13Oscar nominations. And I was going to recommend
- 32:15everybody go see Sorry, Baby because it was my number one
- 32:17film and then it got shut out today.
- 32:19So if I can use the word snub one time on this podcast, I
- 32:24think sorry, baby got snubbed. And I'm going to break my own
- 32:26rule about the nominees and suggest that you go see that
- 32:29unnominated film so that you and I can share in our misery
- 32:33together about how good that movie was and from on the fact
- 32:36it didn't get nominated. I will completely cosign.
- 32:39Sorry Baby is a great movie. I believe it's streaming on HBO
- 32:42Max, so anyone listening, you should absolutely check it out.
- 32:45And it has the endorsement of Julia Roberts.
- 32:47She stood on the Golden Globe stage and implored people to
- 32:49watch. Sorry Baby.
- 32:51It was a beautiful moment. Because you want to believe that
- 32:53these artists are also discovering art themselves.
- 32:56And you know, Julia Roberts in that, in that moment, used her
- 32:59platform to recommend a piece of art, and I'm happy.
- 33:02Shit, Daniel, thank you so much for joining me today.
- 33:06Where can people find you for more Oscars coverage as we get
- 33:09closer to this ceremony? I'm on Blue Sky at Third Man
- 33:15Movies and like you said, I'd do some some awards writing for
- 33:18rogerebert.com. You can see me, I have my
- 33:21nominations predictions post there a few days ago and then I
- 33:25had my reaction to the nominations and the eight
- 33:27biggest surprises post there today.
- 33:29All right, this is going up in just a couple hours folks, so
- 33:32you can get all of your Oscar news here.
- 33:34We'll be back really really soon with another bonus episode
- 33:37talking about the re release of the Lord of the Rings trilogy.
- 33:40Can I interrupt real fast and and please make and say one more
- 33:44thing that I thought was fascinating about today is
- 33:48people love to talk about Oscar Bates and people love to talk
- 33:51about how these you know, you know, months in advance what's
- 33:54going to win and this all rubber stamps and etcetera, etcetera. 4
- 33:58movies came out in 2025 that I felt looked like they were
- 34:03genetically engineered in a lab solely for the purpose of
- 34:05getting best actor nominations and they were J Kelly
- 34:09Springsteen delivered me from nowhere.
- 34:12The smashing Machine and Nuremberg with Russell Crowe as
- 34:17a Nazi general. As Goering.
- 34:19Yeah, yeah, Goering. All four movies failed to get
- 34:22best actor nominations. None of them were probably even
- 34:25close. I mean, it did never seemed like
- 34:27they were serious in contention. The Smashing Machine got a best
- 34:31makeup nomination, but other than that all four movies were
- 34:34shut out. The Springsteen movie didn't
- 34:35even get a sound nomination, which is extremely rare for a
- 34:38music biopic to not even get its sound nomination.
- 34:40So I just, I really think if you look at those 4 movies, you can
- 34:43see that actually being good really doesn't matter.
- 34:48And voters aren't just rubber stamping bait created to sort of
- 34:53dazzle them. And I think that's a good thing
- 34:55to recognize. I will reluctantly admit that J
- 35:00Kelly worked on me and I don't know why because I went into
- 35:03that movie and I was like, I got 25 minutes in and I was like,
- 35:05this sucks, dude. And by the end of it, I was a
- 35:07weepy mess. So I am pro J Kelly.
- 35:10But but point taken. Daniel, thank you so much again
- 35:13for joining us. We'll be back with the Lord of
- 35:15the Rings episode just tomorrow. If you want to find film and
- 35:18whiskey, you can find us on all of our social media accounts,
- 35:21Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok and YouTube at Film
- 35:25Whiskey, where you can join our Patreon at three different
- 35:28levels of support. You'll be hearing from me and
- 35:31Brad tomorrow, but until then, I'm Bob Book and we'll see you
- 35:35next time.