Latest / new renaissance capital / Mostro: Building Censorship-Resistant P2P Bitcoin Trading on Nostr w/ Francisco Calderón
Transcript
- 0:00All this stuff was really impressive for me and I decided to quit my job and started to study Bitcoin.
- 0:07And then I started to understand the Austrian economy.
- 0:11So I started to understand what happened in Venezuela, what happened here in Argentina in terms of inflation, all this money printing, all that stuff.
- 0:22Yes, I started to understand the technological part of Bitcoin and I was shocked.
- 0:29I was thinking like it's too good to be true.
- 0:38Welcome, everybody. Frank here. Francisco, joined by another Francisco today. Francisco Calderon, coming to us from Latin America.
- 0:48Super excited to have Francisco on the show.
- 0:51We had the Cuba Bitcoin team on the show a few episodes back, and I recently just did a piece on some of the work that's happening with the Bitcoin research team in Bolivia, and Francisco's name kept coming up in these conversations.
- 1:04So I wanted to reach out to him also because I personally have spent some time in Venezuela.
- 1:09Francisco is from there originally, so we'll touch a little bit on Venezuela, but I want to focus more on the work that Francisco is doing with P2P technology, particularly with Mostro these days.
- 1:20and yeah but let me stop it there for just a second Francisco let me hand the mic over to you
- 1:25could you give a brief introduction of yourself if you don't mind
- 1:28hey Frank everyone thank you for inviting me and well I'm just as I told you before I'm a
- 1:40software developer I have like more than 20 years working as a developer but some one day when I
- 1:47understood Bitcoin, I said I can't keep working as just a developer and I want to move to work
- 1:54on Bitcoin, on something related to Bitcoin.
- 1:59Because I'm from Venezuela, that shaped me.
- 2:02But this Venezuelan situation, political and economical situation, shaped me as who I am
- 2:09right now.
- 2:10And I decided to do something with my skills as a developer to help people that are happy, that can live situations like I lived before.
- 2:24I'm still living in Buenos Aires, so I like inflation and all this stuff.
- 2:30Yeah, things are maybe a little bit better than they were in Venezuela, but Argentina has its own inflation issues for sure.
- 2:37Can you take us a little bit through that journey?
- 2:39So you've been in the FOSS, the free and open source software space for, I think, like 20 years at this point.
- 2:45So doing things before Bitcoin.
- 2:47As you said, you were inspired to work on Bitcoin once you understood it.
- 2:51Did you come to understand Bitcoin while you were still in Venezuela?
- 2:56Yeah, I had a long time since more than 20 years, years working with open source.
- 3:03and we, a long time before in 2000, we were doing events showing to the people how important is
- 3:12open source for society. At that time, people didn't understand much because software was not
- 3:21that everyone had direct contact. But right now with mobiles and smartphones, it's easier to
- 3:29to explain how important is the open source.
- 3:33And I, of course, I'm linked to technology and open source and all this stuff.
- 3:40I knew about Bitcoin, but I was at that time in Venezuela, I was thinking like,
- 3:45this is too good to be true.
- 3:48So I ignored it.
- 3:52And when I came to Argentina in 2015, I had the need to send money to my family in Venezuela
- 3:58And I started to experiment with Bitcoin without understanding.
- 4:04I started to use it, but really without understanding, like in a philosophical way or technical way.
- 4:14But at the end of 2017 and 2017, yes, I started to understand the technological part of Bitcoin.
- 4:25and I was shocked all these electric code and digital signature, asymmetric,
- 4:34how they use asymmetric encryption to create the addresses and send Bitcoin.
- 4:43All this stuff was really impressive for me and I decided to quit my job
- 4:49and started to study Bitcoin.
- 4:51And then I started to understand the Austrian economics.
- 4:54So I started to understand what happened in Venezuela, what happened here in Argentina in terms of inflation or all this money printing, all that stuff.
- 5:07But the response is I, the first time and second time, third time, I didn't use Bitcoin.
- 5:15Just when I had the real need.
- 5:18Oh, I had the need in Venezuela because we had inflation, but I ignored it.
- 5:22I was thinking like it's too good to be true.
- 5:28Interesting.
- 5:28So too good to be true.
- 5:30You learn how to use it.
- 5:31Well, practically, you experience using Bitcoin to send money back to Venezuela come 2017.
- 5:36At that point in Venezuela, I'm sure there was a lot of need for that.
- 5:40I think that was around the peak of when things got really, really bad under the Maduro regime.
- 5:442017 was a really rough time.
- 5:47I'm actually going to come back to that, what's happening in Venezuela.
- 5:50I'd like to keep going with some of your work as a developer.
- 5:55So you leave your job working in broader open source or software tech.
- 5:59You start studying Bitcoin.
- 6:01And then what is your transition to working in Bitcoin?
- 6:03How long did you study it?
- 6:04And then what was your first job or your first task working in the Bitcoin space?
- 6:09Yes.
- 6:10When I quit my job, it was like January, January maybe in 2018.
- 6:16And I started to study.
- 6:18I just say to my partner, like, I'm going to be three months studying,
- 6:23and I have enough money to keep paying bills, and I'm going to find a job.
- 6:28But the main idea for me was take a, study Bitcoin and find a job on the space, Bitcoin space.
- 6:37And I created a Lightning Network website for Bet called Microbot.
- 6:45and you can do like small bets of 100 satoshis or maybe more on football basketball and baseball
- 6:56and people you you put the bet and someone and bet you put the prediction and people
- 7:03bet against or or in favor so it was like a like a game like an experiment
- 7:10and at that time was like 10 websites on lightning so we got a little bit famous in that
- 7:19micro space and i got a job to work in a startup from canada and exchange so i started to work with
- 7:29them on uh and working on their lightning part so that was really good because i kept
- 7:36learning about lightning and earning money, earning Bitcoin, and keep there and doing stuff at the same time doing open source stuff, ideas or experimental stuff.
- 7:52So that helped me to keep going and keep learning and keep doing stuff on Bitcoin.
- 8:01Yes. That's so something more for fun than anything. You weren't necessarily creating like a lightning wallet or something. You were doing something almost like a little bit of a game online with with the technology. That's very cool. And what year was that again, if you don't mind just reminding me?
- 8:16I don't know if that was in like maybe April of 2018.
- 8:21It was microbeck.
- 8:23Okay.
- 8:23Or yes, something like that.
- 8:25And yes, time happened and I started to work from one year with RGB.
- 8:35And, you know, these are the protocol.
- 8:39And then I started to work on LMP2B bot.
- 8:43I had people from Venezuela asking me, they told me we have the need of standing, because in 2017, 18 was a huge problem there in Venezuela.
- 8:59And then they were using local Bitcoin to send, people in Venezuela were using local Bitcoin, but local Bitcoin closed.
- 9:07so in 2020 they came to me asking me there is a way of do something like a local bitcoin on
- 9:16telegram because we have a telegram group where people started to say hey i want to buy
- 9:22100 no not much like 50 dollars 20 dollars and people in in venezuela wanted to get bitcoin
- 9:31people outside want to send bitcoin there because the people inside can send bolivarists to to their
- 9:39family so it was a small community and it was they can't trust because it was a small community but
- 9:47it started to grow and they say we need to have some kind of escrow because we're gonna get more
- 9:54people can get scammed and i started to do experimental stuff because because i had an
- 10:03idea of using holding voices as an escrow and and this then we have a call with people from
- 10:13Lightning Labs they were the first one who implemented implemented the holding voice
- 10:21which is a
- 10:22I don't know if you know technically
- 10:24but it's an invoice that
- 10:26when you pay
- 10:27the creator of the invoice
- 10:30don't show you the payment
- 10:31so the payment stays like
- 10:34in a waiting payment
- 10:36and so
- 10:38yes and see
- 10:40something happen you have to cancel
- 10:42it's like a failed payment
- 10:43you don't have to send the money and send it back
- 10:46so you
- 10:47you save the
- 10:50routing fees going and going back routing fees and you also it's good because you don't have
- 10:59the money in reality you have almost you have the money but you don't have it you need to settle
- 11:06the invoice so it was a good idea and we talked with them and they say oh yes it's a good idea
- 11:13you can try and i started to do it on the telegram bot and it worked and we started like organically
- 11:20like i say don't put much more money because this is dangerous experimental people started to put
- 11:27fifty dollars one hundred dollars and we started to fix bugs and working and grow a lot to that
- 11:37today we have like more than three 30 000 users and in monthly we have 1300 users active monthly
- 11:50and we have a lot of people using it and it's a good really good
- 11:58project but the problem is on telegram it's centralized but we don't know since some central
- 12:05telegram is going to close someday, closes someday.
- 12:09Or we know that
- 12:11Pablo Duró has some
- 12:14contacts with Russian governments.
- 12:19Also, he was in jail by France
- 12:22and they've released him.
- 12:26And we suppose they have an agreement
- 12:28of sending information,
- 12:30having a chance, because they put him in jail
- 12:33because he didn't want to give information of the people, but now they've released him.
- 12:41So we think we know he have an agreement with them.
- 12:48So we don have information from the users but Telegram has information And we do this because we thinking about people in Venezuela in Argentina
- 13:01in Cuba, in Nicaragua, Iran, people who lives mostly or people who live in places
- 13:11where it's a life or death situation, moving money.
- 13:16so we started to do most that's it's amazing to hear and i'm happy that you shared those numbers
- 13:25i was curious as to how many people were using this so i'm curious also you've worked on rgb
- 13:31which was a pretty big project and now you're doing this very specific thing mostro it as i
- 13:35said it kept coming up or i didn't mention this specifically but i've been having a lot of
- 13:39conversations with people and more and more people seem to be using mostro and as you said it's a
- 13:45lifeline for people. It's a way for people to change money, to get money into a country where
- 13:49otherwise there are either currency controls or maybe the country is cut off from the SWIFT system,
- 13:55the international banking system. My question here is how do you sustain yourself? You don't
- 14:00have to get into all of the economics, but is it a way to make money? How do you monetize
- 14:06something like Mostro? I don't fully understand how it works. Yes. My dream,
- 14:12my um professional dream was working on open source but that's really difficult because
- 14:20you don't get money because most most of the time you don't get money so since i don't know maybe
- 14:272020 we started some people started to give donation and create organization to fund developers
- 14:37and I right now Monstruo is getting funds it's getting funds by Human Rights Foundations and
- 14:47OpenSight and we we keep the project because of that if we didn't have that support I was working
- 14:58on something else and doing like on my weekend Monstruo but it's a full-time job it's a lot of
- 15:06It's big, huge.
- 15:07We have like more than 20 repositories and like really important projects inside most organizations.
- 15:18We have like five, like we need full-time people working there.
- 15:22We're receiving some collaborations, but most of the people that are working full-time needs to get funded.
- 15:29and where it's like growing in a way that developers that have one or two years working on
- 15:39can pass their own grant or some organizations. So the project is on right now is on production.
- 15:53It was a big project and it was really difficult to do.
- 15:58Right now, we have the advantage of having AI
- 16:02because we're doing better things,
- 16:05but when we started, we didn't have it.
- 16:07So we did a lot of experimental and try and see that it doesn't work.
- 16:13We have to try again.
- 16:15We have to create a protocol again,
- 16:16experiment to create the server and the client.
- 16:19And all this stuff needs full time.
- 16:22So for now we have grants, but we have the idea of have a foundation in the future.
- 16:34And we're trying to have a foundation.
- 16:40Like we add a fee, a cut of the fee to send to most redevelopment fund.
- 16:49Right now, it's like, I don't know, 200 sacks.
- 16:52We're getting 200 sacks daily.
- 16:55But maybe in the future, we have a lot of projects working,
- 17:00a lot of nodes, most of them are working.
- 17:02We can have enough money to pay developers without asking to HR for open sacks.
- 17:09We think it's possible.
- 17:11Let's see.
- 17:13Okay.
- 17:14It's amazing how much it's grown.
- 17:16And I feel like it's this amazing story in Bitcoin that doesn't really get a lot of press and attention.
- 17:21That's one of the reasons that I reached out to you because I feel like it's really a lifeline.
- 17:25And I just want to double check.
- 17:26So people are using this now.
- 17:28I know in Bolivia, there's like a fork of Mostro, I think, specifically for the Bolivian context, if I'm not mistaken.
- 17:34And then there's Cuba, Venezuela, and then Spain, I think, as well.
- 17:38Or in Colombia, if I'm not mistaken.
- 17:40And when I talk about this, so it's open source technology.
- 17:44when we talk about each country having its own version of it,
- 17:48what does that really mean?
- 17:49If it's the same sort of technology that anybody can use,
- 17:52if they have access to the internet,
- 17:54what does it mean that there's sort of a different version of it for each country?
- 17:58Yes, the main goal is to remove the single point of failure.
- 18:04With a Telegram board, I can get like a judge.
- 18:07I live in Argentina.
- 18:08I can get a mail from a judge telling me you have to shut down.
- 18:14the telegram bone and i have to do it because i live here i can move to another country and get
- 18:19another letter there so the main idea is to have people that easily can create a note most of note
- 18:28and if they do it maybe if they are doing it in afghanistan and they don't want to say they are
- 18:38who they are they can run it and it's going to be really difficult to find it but it's going to give
- 18:46in a service for people there because it's on Nostro so if you are a node operator and you post
- 18:55post publish events Nostro events in your Afghanistan monster and you push it only in
- 19:05relays you trust maybe you have relays in another country so it's it's going to be impossible for
- 19:11for authorities there to know who you are so that is the idea could you talk about this interaction
- 19:20and i i'm asking this as someone who's not extremely technical so you're running a mostro
- 19:25node you have a mostro node and this is now intertwined with nostr and so you can publish
- 19:32what are you publishing to the relays via Noster?
- 19:35So you have the Maestro Node.
- 19:36What's getting published to the relays?
- 19:39Clients that are using, let's say, the mobile app,
- 19:43they create an order or take an order,
- 19:46and they send the message,
- 19:48a gift wrap event is an encrypted event,
- 19:51to the relay directed to the node, Maestro Node.
- 19:55The Maestro Node gets that message and publish the order.
- 20:02in Noster so someone if it is a create is a new order so someone can take the order but send an
- 20:09encrypted event to the monster so everything is encrypted and it's really difficult to
- 20:16to understand what is happening if you are observing the the the network on Noster
- 20:23and it's not possible that you have you know the IP address because you unless you have the relay
- 20:30we think it's gonna we think governments in the future are going to create their own
- 20:36release to to to watch people's movement but the main idea is to have um different people
- 20:48running the note so maybe in different in different geographical location and people
- 20:56in their geographical location using their own node. For example, it's going to be really difficult
- 21:01for me to, if I'm having a node here where I live, I speak Spanish and English, if I have someone
- 21:11taking an order or creating an order from Saudi Arabia and they only speak Arab.
- 21:18So how I'm going to solve a dispute.
- 21:22So the main idea is to remove this centralization of the Telegram bot
- 21:28and giving tools for the people to create their own infrastructure for free.
- 21:37It's open source. They can do whatever.
- 21:41Amazing. Right now, I feel like there is this affiliation with Mostro in Latin America,
- 21:47in Spanish-speaking countries?
- 21:48Is part of the issue that that's a linguistic challenge,
- 21:52that people who are just speaking Spanish are using this
- 21:54because, as you just said, the communication is in Spanish?
- 21:58And do you foresee people from other languages
- 22:01or people who speak other languages in other countries
- 22:04eventually adopting the technology as well?
- 22:07Yeah, probably it's because we have this Telegram room
- 22:10and many people speak Spanish.
- 22:14But we're having people in Africa.
- 22:16So I'm interested, to be honest, interested in Africa and Latin America because we need it most.
- 22:25But if this project works, if I have in mind to solve problems in places with slow internet and having difficulties,
- 22:41every kind of difficulties.
- 22:44If it works in those places, it's going to work in Europe and the United States.
- 22:50So my main goal is to keep hearing what they say, what they need,
- 22:56and fix the problem they are having.
- 22:59When it comes to these problems, what's an example of a problem?
- 23:02I don't know if that would be maybe too technical of a question to ask,
- 23:05but what's the sort of troubleshooting or development
- 23:08that you end up having to do on a regular basis?
- 23:11for example, slow internet.
- 23:14We have a big community in Cuba of the Telegram bot,
- 23:21and they are telling me that when internet is really slow,
- 23:27the Telegram is getting difficult, intermittent services.
- 23:38Understood.
- 23:38But they told me like they're testing Maestro without internet and no, without energy, without power and with one bar of mobile data.
- 23:57And they could do a whole operation on Maestro in that really difficult situation.
- 24:06situation so we have small events on mostro they are encrypted twice but still they are they are
- 24:16like 1k of bytes like 1 000 bytes and those are it is even if you have a slow internet 1 000 bytes
- 24:26are a good number good size of package we send on mostro so it is i think cuba was the
- 24:36the
- 24:37let's say
- 24:41the most difficult situation
- 24:44that you've had to deal with
- 24:46most challenging
- 24:47the most challenging
- 24:48situation so
- 24:51I keep focusing
- 24:54on Cuba
- 24:55places in Africa
- 24:58where you have really slow
- 25:00internet asking to them
- 25:02okay tell me what's happening
- 25:04in England, anyhow can fix it because it's like an extreme situation and we wanted to
- 25:13see it working there.
- 25:15Okay.
- 25:16So you're building this for the hardest places to have it function.
- 25:20My first question that comes to mind here, please excuse me if this is not a very smart
- 25:25question, but is there any way that you see like a potential integration with eCash, something
- 25:31that can work offline or is that something that's incompatible based on the technology
- 25:37you developed Am I not thinking along the right lines I guess is my question Or can eCache become a solution here as well Yes there is a discussion created in our repository But we have an open quiz to explore that proposal
- 26:00But we're waiting for some contribution for someone to start working on it.
- 26:07but we have like a milestone and a lot of issues to solve and that are priority
- 26:17because still we still are stabilizing the protocol and stabilizing and all this stuff
- 26:27But maybe if someone don't get that issue, but we're still getting some people asking, we can add it more high on this priority list.
- 26:45But yes, I think it's a good idea to have it like an option.
- 26:51Okay. Yeah, because I know that the team from Cuba Bitcoin, they built their own version of Cashew, I think they built Cahu, and it's easier for them to use, especially because you have these blackouts and the internet just completely gets shut off.
- 27:04We're seeing something comparable, not for the same reason, but seeing something comparable in Iran right now as well, where people are operating without Internet right now.
- 27:15So it seems like that's obviously the most difficult situation.
- 27:18But it's amazing to know that people are still thinking about ways to potentially handle a situation like this.
- 27:25Truly amazing.
- 27:27How big do you feel like something like Mostro could get?
- 27:31meaning is it something that only technical people
- 27:35or people who are technically inclined
- 27:37feel comfortable engaging with
- 27:40or do you look to make it easier
- 27:42so that it's something that the average person
- 27:44thinks to use frequently?
- 27:48Yes.
- 27:49I don't know how big it's going to be
- 27:52but I hope to be an option
- 27:56in some countries where they need it.
- 27:59But we have in mind
- 28:01constantly that
- 28:03our clients have to be
- 28:05for all
- 28:07people to use it.
- 28:09So it's more difficult for all
- 28:11people or people
- 28:13that have no
- 28:15technical
- 28:16skills. If you
- 28:19see, I don't know if
- 28:21you try our mobile app.
- 28:24I have
- 28:25not. So Mostro mobile app.
- 28:27Yeah. Yes. We have it
- 28:29We're still not going to put it on Google Play, but we have plans.
- 28:34We don't want, we want to, this grow organically because we're still,
- 28:40I want to improve some stuff.
- 28:44But yes, the mobile, I think we have a really good UX for mobile.
- 28:54Our main idea is to make it simple.
- 28:56For example, when you install the mobile app, we don't ask you anything.
- 29:03Just a seat is created for you.
- 29:06And you have like a notification that never goes away until you back up.
- 29:13That's it.
- 29:13But you can, since the beginning, just open the app the first time and take an order.
- 29:20And you can select your node.
- 29:24For example, the Polybia node or Columbia node or the default node.
- 29:31But after you do that, you just can take another and start working.
- 29:37And it's like just touching buttons.
- 29:40I think it's really intuitive.
- 29:42We can make it better and we will.
- 29:45And we're just working on it.
- 29:49Amazing.
- 29:50so in terms of having it grow organically and I can understand reasons why you wouldn't want to
- 29:56try to put it through like the proper app stores is it also are we just are we just in the early
- 30:01days of this technology and you just sort of maybe it's misunderstood and regulars don't
- 30:07I'm sorry regulators don't really understand it so is it better that it sort of serves the
- 30:12population it needs to serve right now like a population that really needs this as you said
- 30:17as a lifeline versus trying to reach more people?
- 30:20Are you primarily just focused on making sure
- 30:22the people who need it most have access to it
- 30:24for the time being?
- 30:25Is that the correct way to maybe say what your focus is?
- 30:30Yes, I think I'm really not interested
- 30:33in most of being a big thing.
- 30:36Okay.
- 30:36Like in Europe, everyone will just be more.
- 30:39I don't care.
- 30:40Yeah, I understand.
- 30:42I don't want to, I think it's,
- 30:44But that is the way I don't want to run my own Maestro.
- 30:48We have the default Maestro node, but I don't want to run it.
- 30:53Because I already am running the Telegram bot, and everyone knows I'm running the Telegram bot.
- 31:00And it's good that I live in Argentina, which they are more relaxed with these authorities.
- 31:09but I know everyone in Europe don't want to do that.
- 31:15Or maybe if they run a most or not,
- 31:17they're going to do it like a pseudonymously.
- 31:25For example, this week I have a call with someone from London,
- 31:31a community there, a Bitcoin community,
- 31:32And they were asking me about if I know about the legal stuff or regulation on Europe.
- 31:43And I say, to be honest, I'm not.
- 31:46And I just wanted to work on the technology.
- 31:49That is because I'm doing this for people to create their own nodes.
- 31:55But I don't want to.
- 31:57I just want to focus on building the technology and not running a node.
- 32:01I have one node because I need to have a default node right now.
- 32:07Right.
- 32:07But when we have, like, most stable nodes, like, we know they're solid,
- 32:15I'm going to remove my default node and leave it.
- 32:20Like, you have to decide what node.
- 32:22We have, in the mobile app, we have a message telling to the people,
- 32:29like short message, like we're telling to the people, the operator is the one.
- 32:37When you are using this node, you are accepting you are under the rules of the operator.
- 32:44The code developers, the developers are not, we can't control that.
- 32:50We are creating the tools for people.
- 32:54The thing we are doing now is creating something called Monstro Community.
- 32:59where we are helping communities, established communities, Bitcoin communities,
- 33:05to create their own monster on all.
- 33:08But we started this because we want to talk with the community,
- 33:12hear them, see what people are in their community,
- 33:20and see that they are, like, find out if they are real people or scammers behind us.
- 33:29community because with monster you can create if you're a scammer we know the scammer are going
- 33:35to create their own monster to get people in scam so the thing is we have we created a mobile app
- 33:43and we are adding all these communities that we know there are no scammers but still we don't know
- 33:51yep it's hard right it's hard yes but i think it's there are more good things that we can get
- 34:02from this that one scanner one that one that i don't know that situation but i think uh we're
- 34:12helping more people than people that can get, I don't know,
- 34:18that's the situation.
- 34:20Yeah, I think that's a good way to look at it for sure.
- 34:25It's really, it's remarkably exciting stuff.
- 34:28For some of, you know, I'm sure that on some level,
- 34:31because you're interfacing with people who are living in very difficult scenarios,
- 34:37let's just say Cuba, for example,
- 34:39I'm curious how much you end up learning about the country and the people there.
- 34:44I mean, obviously you learn about what their needs are or whatnot,
- 34:47but I'm sure that it gives you a lot of information about what's actually happening on the ground in certain places
- 34:53versus maybe what we hear on the news.
- 34:56So for a place like Cuba, you're from a country that went through a similar sort of socialist takeover, communist takeover.
- 35:05what would you tell people
- 35:08for the average person who is maybe
- 35:11hearing a little bit about Cuba
- 35:12what are we missing?
- 35:14What's actually happening on the ground
- 35:15that information that the average person
- 35:18maybe isn't getting?
- 35:20I think Venezuela and Cuba
- 35:22have a lot of things in common
- 35:25and
- 35:26people are really similar
- 35:28and
- 35:30we have
- 35:32I'm also
- 35:34know people from Bitcoin Cuba and I'm going to every year to Oslo Freedom Forum where I met
- 35:43Cuban activists and we talk about it and we keep the contact with people in Cuba or people outside
- 35:51Cuba wanting to connect in Cuba with LMP2P bot on Monstro. So I think we have good connection with
- 36:02Cuba and
- 36:04and
- 36:06what I think the real
- 36:08situation there is
- 36:10is really
- 36:11bad because
- 36:13I think everyone knows
- 36:16they are out of energy
- 36:18and it's
- 36:20not only because of the
- 36:22blockade that
- 36:24they're having right now because
- 36:26of Donald Trump
- 36:28but also because
- 36:30before that the
- 36:32And the dictatorship there started to blockade the users from doing commerce or speak freely.
- 36:42So now I see everyone, I follow Cuban news.
- 36:51And in the government, in Cuba, the dictatorship started to talk about, oh, we should see what we are doing bad.
- 37:00maybe where we
- 37:02must open a little bit
- 37:04the economy. So,
- 37:06after 50 years, I don't know,
- 37:0850, 60 years, you think
- 37:10right now you're going to open the economy.
- 37:13It's because they are,
- 37:14they know, they know that
- 37:16their ideas are,
- 37:20it doesn't
- 37:20work, that doesn't work.
- 37:23Their skill, they still
- 37:24need to
- 37:26keep talking about,
- 37:28like coal,
- 37:29like Cold War and all this stuff
- 37:32because they need the...
- 37:35Yeah.
- 37:36Do you, on a certain level,
- 37:39I mean, their argument,
- 37:40the argument of imperialism
- 37:42and what America did to Cuba,
- 37:44Latin America,
- 37:45I understand the argument.
- 37:47I do get it.
- 37:48But I think what a lot of people miss
- 37:50is that they might be right
- 37:52in their argument,
- 37:53but it doesn't mean that they're right
- 37:55in doing what they're doing
- 37:56on the ground to their people
- 37:58because people are suffering in a really sort of heavy way.
- 38:01And it's interesting.
- 38:02Here in New York, I went to the court when Nicolás Maduro was brought to Brooklyn.
- 38:08I went to the courtroom, and we had a lot of New Yorkers saying,
- 38:13no, no, no, free Venezuela, release Nicolás Maduro.
- 38:16And there's just this understanding.
- 38:18There's this, I think, people have this idea of what socialism is
- 38:21or what that authoritarian control is,
- 38:23and I think they think it's a lot nicer than it really is.
- 38:28And so it creates a difficult political situation where sure like even if you look at Venezuela they remove Maduro in a way that very unconventional That probably a nice word to put it And obviously certain Americans feel like we shouldn have done this
- 38:48And I understand that perspective.
- 38:50But then there's most Venezuelans who I speak would say, I don't care.
- 38:54I just want anything to essentially change.
- 38:57I'm curious, from your perspective as a Venezuelan, when you watch that, when you watch Maduro be captured,
- 39:02What was your initial reaction and maybe what is your reaction now after some time?
- 39:09Well, my initial reaction was to party.
- 39:16Okay.
- 39:19Think about this.
- 39:21Venezuela is dealing in a dictatorship, but two people that are responsible of a lot of torture, disappearing, and killing opposition, they are paying what they did.
- 39:36So I think maybe it's not the justice we wanted because we wanted to, like, Venezuelan court judge them.
- 39:52But still it's justice.
- 39:55Maybe it's because Donald Trump wants to buy oil from Venezuela.
- 40:01I don't care.
- 40:02I just want them to pay.
- 40:04So I'm happy because of this.
- 40:07And now we see, like, the Chavistas in Venezuela, they are mutating.
- 40:17They're removing photos of Chavez and Maduro.
- 40:22And they're removing the red color and putting blue.
- 40:27Is that right?
- 40:28Yes, I'm starting to hear like
- 40:31El Chavismo Azul
- 40:33The blue Chavismo
- 40:35I haven't heard of this
- 40:37Yeah, what is this? I don't know what this is
- 40:39It's like they're removing
- 40:41Symbols
- 40:43Of Chavismo
- 40:44What does the blue Chavismo symbolize?
- 40:47I know red symbolizes the socialist revolution
- 40:49Red usually is that
- 40:50There is no symbolism
- 40:52They are just trying to
- 40:54Like put a
- 40:56since January 3rd
- 40:59is like a bad
- 41:01chavismo and now they are
- 41:03good chavismo.
- 41:05Yesterday they say
- 41:06they removed
- 41:0912,000 of
- 41:11corruption
- 41:13policies?
- 41:18No.
- 41:18Corrupt policies.
- 41:21Or corrupt maybe rules or laws or something?
- 41:23Not rules.
- 41:24the police
- 41:26oh police
- 41:28police
- 41:29the guys
- 41:32the policemen
- 41:33they removed 12,000
- 41:35that's crazy
- 41:37since right now you
- 41:39just realized you have 12,000
- 41:42of policemen
- 41:43corrupt
- 41:45that's crazy
- 41:48so
- 41:48that has no sense to me
- 41:52now they're
- 41:54trying to tell like, oh, now we're doing good stuff because we didn't know all this bad
- 42:01stuff was happening before January 3rd.
- 42:04So now they're trying to sell like the blue chavismo.
- 42:10Wow.
- 42:10Like they want to still be in power.
- 42:14So they're doing all this stuff to make Donald Trump happy.
- 42:19And Donald Trump don't care about democracy in Venezuela.
- 42:21They want to get maybe a lot of money from the United States and to the United States.
- 42:30So if they can get the North American oil companies going back to Venezuela, that would be amazing for the United States.
- 42:43But they don't want it because they say we need to have constitutional rights in Venezuela because we know that Chavismo are going to expropriate us if they want.
- 42:57They know because they get a lot of bad treatment before.
- 43:02so they're trying to
- 43:05put like a balance
- 43:07and convince all these oil
- 43:09companies in the United States to going back
- 43:11to Venezuela and make
- 43:13a lot of money for the United States
- 43:15and everything is good with Trump
- 43:17and they keep the power
- 43:18that is what's happening right now
- 43:21right, that all makes sense
- 43:23but I had not heard about this blue Chavismo
- 43:25wave, I understand it
- 43:27it's like we have two weeks
- 43:29looking blue, blue, blue
- 43:31everywhere and removing jobs. Wow. Okay. Absolutely wild. My last question for you is,
- 43:41you very much believe in open source technology. You obviously believe in Bitcoin,
- 43:47the Lightning Network, all of this technology that you build on and that you build with.
- 43:51Do you think that we will live in a world that, generally speaking, on a major level,
- 43:57gets better because of this technology?
- 43:59Now, I know it's getting better for the people you work with,
- 44:02small pockets of people who understand the technology,
- 44:04but does it end up having a huge global impact
- 44:08that benefits the average human being on planet Earth in your mind?
- 44:13Yes.
- 44:14Yes, definitely.
- 44:15I think I believe in open source everything in the world.
- 44:22To be honest, after Mosul, I have in mind a project
- 44:26that I already started with a friend,
- 44:29but I have it like in POS right now,
- 44:35which is an electronic voting system,
- 44:39open source electronic system,
- 44:40which uses Noster of a passport and authentication
- 44:45and uses blank signature for keeping the secrecy of vote.
- 44:50And we wanted to make, like Monstro,
- 44:53a set of tools for people to make their own elections.
- 44:57So imagine you live in a remote town somewhere in the world,
- 45:09and you can decide, like, okay, we have money right now,
- 45:15but we can decide to wait for the government to send us money
- 45:21or help us or organize election.
- 45:24We can use this open source tool for vote
- 45:29and we can, instead of elect someone for decide for us,
- 45:34a mayor, we can put ideas.
- 45:39So we can use this tool for elect ideas,
- 45:44promote and not promote,
- 45:48like publish ideas.
- 45:50and I like the ideas
- 45:52without removing the
- 45:54politics, the
- 45:56politicians. What I
- 45:59want is remove the politicians
- 46:00and make
- 46:02the ideas where
- 46:04the central of
- 46:06the democracy. So we can
- 46:08have tools for make
- 46:10easy and cheap
- 46:12people organized to organize
- 46:15themselves without having
- 46:16someone to decide
- 46:18and probably you have a mayor in a corrupt small village
- 46:23that they're going to hire their family
- 46:26and they're going to get money from the state
- 46:29and they are not going to work
- 46:32or one day they're going to work
- 46:35but all days they are not working.
- 46:37Instead, we can make a good transparency tools.
- 46:43So this project of electronic voting is just something we want to do, but I want to do more tools for transparency that you can use in public institutions, but also in private organizations.
- 47:01so the main idea is to give to the people
- 47:05auditable tools to see what people are doing with your money for example
- 47:12or in the building you're leaving what they are doing
- 47:17so I think it's only with open source we can do all this
- 47:23and I am very positive of all the impact that open source can do for us
- 47:31But now I think with AI, it's way easier to develop all this stuff and make it better.
- 47:44Yeah.
- 47:45The average person, are you a believer in vibe coding that the average person can start contributing to open source through different AI tools, OpenClaw, vibe coding, that kind of stuff?
- 47:56Yes, but we have to reinvent the way we create software.
- 48:05So it's not only like you ask to the computer and just send a patch
- 48:10because you need to test it.
- 48:13Now we're working with specifications.
- 48:15So we're using like specification driving development, SDD.
- 48:21and if we teach this to the average people,
- 48:28average people can be developers.
- 48:30Just create the good specification
- 48:33and test it and check it
- 48:37and see if it works
- 48:39and then that can be accepted.
- 48:42But we're receiving some contributions
- 48:45of people that just put some questions in chat GPD
- 48:49and give us something that doesn't work.
- 48:52But we will get there.
- 48:56We will get to a point where people will know
- 48:59how to do good contributions using AI.
- 49:04Okay.
- 49:04Poco a poco.
- 49:05A little bit, one step at a time.
- 49:07Francisco, this was a real treat.
- 49:11I hope to meet you in person, ideally,
- 49:13sometime maybe this year.
- 49:15I might be at the Oslo Freedom Forum.
- 49:16I don't know if you'll be there this year as well.
- 49:18Yes, I'll be there.
- 49:19Cool. Very cool. I think the work you're doing is amazing.
- 49:23And I appreciate you taking some time to talk with me because I know that you've given some presentations in Spanish.
- 49:29I appreciate you doing this in English because I think you're an amazing Bitcoin or an amazing open source developer.
- 49:35But your story and your name is not well known as it should be, in my very humble opinion.
- 49:39I think that you're incredible at what you do, and I think that it's very clear that what you do is very driven by the need for it and the ideology behind it.
- 49:50The fact that your first experience with Bitcoin was sending money back to your family in Venezuela, and now you help to facilitate things like this for people around the world, especially people who are living in some of the most trying, most difficult areas of planet Earth today.
- 50:06So your humility and your decency, I think, is incredible.
- 50:13You were sort of like a myth in my mind.
- 50:15Like, is Francisco Calderon real?
- 50:16I keep hearing his name.
- 50:17Maybe he's just like, maybe I made him up or something.
- 50:20But you are real, and the work you do is very real.
- 50:23And it's been a pleasure to speak with you.
- 50:26You're really, you're an amazing human being.
- 50:28Where can people follow what you're doing, Faliwan Noster X?
- 50:32Where can they find your work?
- 50:33yes people can find me in master and you can write negrunch and then so i'm gonna i'm gonna spell that
- 50:42for uh for people who are listening that's um yeah at n e g r u n c h negrunch and the same
- 50:52in twitter in x the same thing negrunch perfect yeah um again francisco thank you so much for
- 51:01taking the time to do this.
- 51:03The pleasure is all mine. I look forward to meeting
- 51:05you in person.
- 51:07The pleasure is all mine.
- 51:09Thank you to everyone for listening.
- 51:11We'll talk soon, everybody. Take it easy.
- 51:13Yes. Bye.
- 51:14Thank you. Bye-bye.
- 51:31Thank you.