Latest / Her Culture: Books, Film, Music & Women in the Arts / The Courage to Show Your Ugly First Draft | Her Culture
Transcript
- I’m sitting here staring at a half-finished poem that makes my chest ache with embarrassment, wondering if you’ve ever felt the same terrifying urge to delete it all before anyone sees it. That specific panic isn’t just fear of judgment; it’s the violent collision between your exquisite inner vision and the clumsy, awkward hands of your current reality. Let’s unpack that feeling for a moment, because I think we all carry this invisible velvet rope around our creative selves. You know the one. It’s the impulse to keep everything locked behind closed doors until it is flawless, polished, and completely devoid of human error. I used to think that if I waited long enough, the work would eventually match the image in my head. But here is the truth that took me decades to accept: the image in your head will always be more beautiful than what you can physically produce, at least for now. This gap is not a failure. It is the space where the actual work happens. When we refuse to show anything unfinished, we are essentially telling ourselves that our current ability is insufficient, which creates a paralysis so deep it feels like drowning. I remember early in my zine days, I would write entire issues in secret, agonizing over every comma, convinced that if I showed a rough draft to my friends, they would see through the facade of my competence. They wouldn’t. They would see a person trying. And there is something profoundly liberating about being seen as a person trying, rather than a genius performing. There’s a texture to this vulnerability that is quite different from pride. Pride is smooth, hard, and impenetrable. Vulnerability is soft, porous, and alive. When you share an unfinished piece of writing, or a sketch that looks like scribbles, or a melody that hasn’t found its chorus yet, you are inviting people into the messy construction site of your soul. It requires a level of trust that feels risky, especially when you’re a woman who has been socialized to believe that her worth is tied to her likability and her perfection. We worry that if we show the cracks, people will leave. But the opposite is often true. When you show the raw material, you give others permission to show theirs. I’ve had listeners tell me after sharing their own first drafts that it broke a dam in them. Suddenly, the pressure to be perfect evaporated because they realized everyone else was also building on shaky foundations. The community that forms around shared imperfection is far stronger than any community built on curated success. It’s the difference between a museum exhibit and a workshop. In the workshop, you get your hands dirty. You make mistakes. You learn how the tools actually feel in your palm, not just how they look on the shelf.