Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / The Making of a Professional Counselor: History, Identity, and Ethics
Transcript
- 0:00Usually, when we talk about a medical diagnosis,
- 0:02there is this, like, comforting expectation of
- 0:04precision. You know, you break your arm, the
- 0:07x -ray shows the jagged line on the bone, and
- 0:09the doctor points right at it and says, yep,
- 0:10there's the problem. Right, exactly. It's very
- 0:12visible. But the moment you step into the world
- 0:15of human psychology and mental health, that x
- 0:19-ray machine is just totally useless. We are
- 0:21suddenly looking at a landscape that is frankly
- 0:24incredibly murky. It is literally the definition
- 0:27of diagnostic muddy waters. I mean, the mind
- 0:29doesn't fracture in a clean line like a bone
- 0:32does. Yeah, unfortunately. And trying to figure
- 0:34out exactly how to navigate those waters, like
- 0:36how to help a human being heal when you can't
- 0:39actually see the wound, that is the entire foundation
- 0:42of the counseling profession. Welcome to the
- 0:45Psychology Undergrad. If you are joining us today,
- 0:48you are right on time for our latest study session.
- 0:50Yes, welcome. Today, we're doing a deep dive
- 0:53into chapters one through three of New Krug's
- 0:55The Counselor's Identity. We are basically going
- 0:58to unpack what it actually means to be a professional
- 1:00counselor. Which is way more complex than just,
- 1:02you know, sitting on a couch and talking about
- 1:04your feelings. Oh, for sure. We're going to explore
- 1:07the field's really fascinating history, define
- 1:10what actually makes a counselor effective in
- 1:12the room, and look at the pretty rigid ethical
- 1:15and multicultural standards that hold this whole
- 1:17profession together. And just to help you remember
- 1:20these super dense concepts for the real world,
- 1:22or let's be real for final exam, we're going
- 1:25to use some memory tricks. Definitely. And we'll
- 1:28also point out how a lot of the field's history
- 1:29is deeply intertwined with concepts of morality
- 1:32and religion. Because it absolutely is. But before
- 1:36we can even trace that history, we have to define
- 1:38our terms. Because if you ask the average person
- 1:40on the street the difference between, like, a
- 1:42counselor, a therapist, and a psychiatrist, you
- 1:44usually just get a blank stare. Yeah. The public
- 1:46is super confused by the terminology. Exactly.
- 1:49So the sources lay out this continuum of mental
- 1:53health care. And on one far end, you have what's
- 1:56historically called guidance. Right. Guidance.
- 1:59Which is essentially short -term, surface -level
- 2:02intervention. OK. So like what? Well, it has
- 2:04a very specific goal, right? Like modifying a
- 2:06behavior or making a concrete decision. Think
- 2:09of a high school guidance counselor helping a
- 2:11student pick a college. Makes sense. But historically,
- 2:14the term carried a lot of heavy baggage. It was
- 2:16deeply moralistic. In the early 20th century,
- 2:19guidance often meant a person in authority telling
- 2:21you the quote unquote moral way to live your
- 2:24life. Oh, yikes. Yeah. So modern practitioners
- 2:27actively avoid the term now because of those
- 2:29judgmental implications. OK, so if guidance is
- 2:31on one end. The complete opposite extreme is
- 2:34psychotherapy, which is the long -term, really
- 2:38intensive work. The heavy stuff. Right. It's
- 2:40focused on deep -seated trauma, exploring the
- 2:43unconscious mind, and sometimes aiming for total
- 2:47personality reconstruction. Which is a massive
- 2:50undertaking. It is. So if we look at this like
- 2:53a journey into the wilderness, I like to think
- 2:55of it this way. Guidance is like asking a park
- 2:58ranger for quick directions at the trailhead.
- 3:00I like that. And psychotherapy is like deep sea
- 3:04diving into this dark abyss where you don't even
- 3:07know what creatures you might find at the bottom.
- 3:09That's a great analogy. Which leaves counseling
- 3:11falling right in the middle of that continuum.
- 3:13Right. It's generally shorter term than classical
- 3:16psychoanalysis, but it's still highly facilitative.
- 3:19The goal isn't just to give advice. It's focused
- 3:22on driving internal change and building problem
- 3:24solving skills. So keeping with the wilderness
- 3:27idea. Counseling is like hiring a guide to walk
- 3:30the trail with you. They aren't going to carry
- 3:32you and they aren't just pointing at a map. Exactly.
- 3:35They're helping you build the skills yourself.
- 3:37But wait, looking at that middle ground, if counseling
- 3:40isn't the deep sea diving of psychotherapy, does
- 3:43that mean counselors aren't equipped to handle
- 3:44really deep trauma? Like, are they stuck in the
- 3:47shallows? That is actually a super common misconception.
- 3:50The lines between these terms have heavily blurred
- 3:53over the last few decades. Oh, really? Yeah.
- 3:55Today, The words counseling and psychotherapy
- 3:58are often used interchangeably in the clinical
- 4:01world. A licensed mental health counselor goes
- 4:03through rigorous training specifically to conduct
- 4:06psychotherapy for, you know, complex PTSD, severe
- 4:09mood disorders, the deep stuff. OK, so the continuum
- 4:12is mostly historical context. Exactly. Modern
- 4:16counselors are frequently swimming in those deep
- 4:18waters. And there are a lot of different professionals
- 4:21in those waters. So just to break it down quickly.
- 4:24Counselors usually have a master's degree and
- 4:26use a broad holistic wellness model. Right. Then
- 4:29you have social workers who approach the client
- 4:32through the lens of their environment, like family
- 4:34systems and societal barriers. And psychologists.
- 4:38Historically, psychology started in experimental
- 4:40labs, right, measuring reaction times and stuff.
- 4:42But today, clinical psychologists focus heavily
- 4:45on providing therapy and doing complex psychological
- 4:48testing. Got it. And then psychiatrists are the
- 4:50medical doctors. They go to med school. So they
- 4:52focus on the biological aspects, which means
- 4:55they are the ones prescribing psychopharmacology.
- 4:58Exactly. So to understand how all these distinct
- 5:00professions even formed, we kind of have to look
- 5:03backward. We have to look at the historical shifts
- 5:05that moved humanity from relying on spiritual
- 5:07leaders to relying on professional mental health
- 5:10workers. The paradigm shifts here are massive.
- 5:13Because for centuries, the people we would like
- 5:15retroactively call the earliest counselors were
- 5:18religious figures, you know, Moses, Buddha, Muhammad,
- 5:21or philosophers like Socrates and Plato. Yeah,
- 5:23when people experienced profound existential
- 5:25dread, they sought out spiritual leaders. There's
- 5:28this really remarkable detail in the textbook
- 5:30regarding Psalm 32 from the Bible. Oh, yeah,
- 5:34the physical symptoms part. Yes. The text describes
- 5:37the physical toll of unconfessed guilt. The author
- 5:40talks about their bones wasting away and their
- 5:43strength being sapped by silence. When you read
- 5:46it today, it sounds exactly like the somatic
- 5:48physical symptoms of trauma. It really does.
- 5:52And the cure described in the text is basically
- 5:55verbalizing the pain, which is therapeutic processing.
- 5:58It just shows that the underlying symptoms of
- 6:01psychological distress haven't changed in thousands
- 6:03of years. Just our frameworks for treating them.
- 6:06Because historically, the soul and the psyche
- 6:08were viewed as the exact same thing. Right. I
- 6:11mean, the word psychotherapy literally comes
- 6:13from Greek words translating to caring for the
- 6:16soul. It wasn't until way later that we tried
- 6:19to cleanly separate the psychological mind from
- 6:21spiritual morality. And before we landed on modern
- 6:25talk therapy, that separation led to some incredibly
- 6:27dark periods, especially in the early asylums.
- 6:31Oh, it was horrific. The sources highlight Benjamin
- 6:34Rush, who's often called the founder of American
- 6:36psychiatry. His methods were... I mean, they
- 6:40were terrifying. He genuinely believed in this
- 6:43thing he called the dread of the eye. What even
- 6:45is that? He thought the most effective way to
- 6:47treat a mentally ill patient was for the doctor
- 6:50to terrify them by just aggressively staring
- 6:53them down. That is wild. And the medical consensus
- 6:56back then supported treatments like bloodletting,
- 6:59severe blistering of the skin, and plunging patients
- 7:02into freezing water to literally shock the illness
- 7:05out of the body. It's just hard to reconcile
- 7:07that level of cruelty. with the idea of healing.
- 7:12Thankfully, social reform eventually took over.
- 7:15Modern counseling was basically born from the
- 7:17convergence of three distinct paths, social work,
- 7:20psychology, and psychiatry. Right, the three
- 7:22branches. So for my fellow undergrads taking
- 7:25notes, my memory trick for this is SPP, Social
- 7:29Systems, Psychological Science, and Psychiatric
- 7:32Medicine. I love a good acronym. So for the social
- 7:35systems branch, you have pioneers like Jane Addams
- 7:38in the late 1800s. She founded Hull House in
- 7:41the slums of Chicago. Working with impoverished
- 7:44immigrants, right? Exactly. She proved that you
- 7:46cannot treat a person's distress without addressing
- 7:48the systemic poverty and the environment they
- 7:51live in. She basically birthed the social work
- 7:53perspective. Then you have the psychological
- 7:55science branch. Sigmund Freud is the obvious
- 7:58one here, totally revolutionizing the unconscious
- 8:01mind. But it was also early testing, right? Yeah,
- 8:05psychometrics. During World War I, the military
- 8:07developed the Army Alpha Test to rapidly evaluate
- 8:10millions of recruits. Suddenly, the mind was
- 8:13something that could be measured. And the third
- 8:15branch is psychiatric medicine. In France, Philippe
- 8:19Pinel took over an asylum and did something completely
- 8:22radical. He ordered the iron chains to be removed
- 8:25from the patients. A huge paradigm shift. He
- 8:29argued they were human beings suffering from
- 8:31medical ailments, not monsters. So right in the
- 8:35middle of all these shifts, we get Frank Parsons.
- 8:38He's widely recognized as the founder of vocational
- 8:41guidance. Which happened during the Industrial
- 8:43Revolution, right? Yeah. Agrarian workers were
- 8:45flooding into crowded cities to work in factories.
- 8:48And people were just totally lost. Parsons had
- 8:51this deeply moralistic desire to help individuals
- 8:54find a calling that matched their abilities.
- 8:56So they wouldn't just be cogs in a machine. Parsons'
- 9:00work is the direct ancestor of modern counseling.
- 9:02But wait, I have to ask, is it really fair to
- 9:05call early religious figures like Moses or shamans
- 9:08the quote unquote first counselors when their
- 9:11ultimate goal was religious compliance, not necessarily
- 9:14mental health? It's a fair question. But again,
- 9:17historically, caring for the human condition
- 9:19inherently involved moral and spiritual teaching.
- 9:22The split between mental health and spiritual
- 9:24health is a very modern luxury. That makes sense.
- 9:28So moving from ancient spiritual guidance to
- 9:31a modern science, we have to look at what specifically
- 9:34makes a modern healer effective, like in the
- 9:37room with a client. And the research here is
- 9:39super clear. The sources point to Bruce Wampold's
- 9:42work. He analyzed decades of clinical trials
- 9:44and proved that therapy is remarkably effective.
- 9:48Sometimes even more enduring than medication,
- 9:50right? Exactly. Yeah. Because when a patient
- 9:52stops medication, relapse rates can be high.
- 9:55But the coping mechanisms gained in therapy permanently
- 9:58alter how you navigate the world. So what actually
- 10:01makes the counselor effective? The text outlines
- 10:04nine characteristics, but a few really stand
- 10:06out to me. Empathy, obviously. Yeah, empathy
- 10:10is the baseline. Not just feeling sorry for someone,
- 10:13but temporarily stepping into their worldview
- 10:15without judgment. Which totally echoes Carl Rogers.
- 10:20He built his humanistic theory on unconditional
- 10:23positive regard. and deep acceptance. Right.
- 10:27And if you strip away the clinical terminology,
- 10:29Rogers essentially took the ancient religious
- 10:31concepts of unconditional love and grace and
- 10:34repurposed them as clinical skills. He proved
- 10:36that just being deeply accepted by another human
- 10:39facilitates actual biological healing. It's amazing.
- 10:43And that acceptance ties directly into this elusive
- 10:46trait they call the it factor. The it factor.
- 10:49Yeah. Salvador Mnuchin called it joining. It's
- 10:52a counselor's unique, highly personal way of
- 10:54bonding with a client. The textbook gives an
- 10:57unbelievable example of this. There was a counselor
- 10:59at a suicide crisis center who naturally used
- 11:02humor to connect with callers, like he would
- 11:04literally joke with suicidal clients. Which sounds
- 11:06like a terrible idea on paper. It sounds so risky.
- 11:10But through sheer charisma and his specific personality,
- 11:13he could disarm their despair and make them laugh,
- 11:16snapping them out of the crisis. Because it was
- 11:18authentic to him. If someone else read those
- 11:21same jokes off a script, it would be a disaster.
- 11:23Right. But pulling that off requires another
- 11:26trait, cognitive complexity. And I have to push
- 11:30back on this one. Oh. Why? Doesn't cognitive
- 11:34complexity sound like an oxymoron for a counselor?
- 11:37Like, if a client comes in with a chaotic, overwhelmed
- 11:40mind, isn't the counselor's job to help simplify
- 11:43things? For the client, maybe. But for the counselor,
- 11:47cognitive complexity means the ability to hold
- 11:49multiple perspectives at once. It's the willingness
- 11:52to question your own truths and not be dogmatic.
- 11:55Oh, so it keeps them from being rigid. Exactly.
- 11:58If a counselor's thinking is black and white,
- 12:00they'll force the client's messy reality into
- 12:02a neat, judgmental box. Complexity allows them
- 12:06to truly see the client without jumping to shallow
- 12:08solutions. Okay, I get that. But having that
- 12:12it factor and being deeply empathetic is great.
- 12:15Until it's not. Without strict boundaries, the
- 12:18therapeutic relationship can become super dangerous.
- 12:21Oh, totally. The power dynamic is huge. Which
- 12:24brings us to the rules of the game. The ethical
- 12:27standards. And we have to clearly define three
- 12:30concepts that people normally mix up. Values,
- 12:33morality, and ethics. Okay, break it down. Let's
- 12:37use a sports analogy. Values are how you personally
- 12:41prefer to play the game. Like maybe you prioritize
- 12:44defense. That's your personal value. Got it.
- 12:47Morals are the traditions of your home team,
- 12:50the beliefs handed down by your family, your
- 12:52culture, or your religion. Right. But ethics,
- 12:57ethics are the referee's official rule book.
- 12:59It doesn't matter how you prefer to play or what
- 13:02your hometown traditions are. If you step out
- 13:04of bounds, the referee blows the whistle. They
- 13:07are the collectively agreed on professional behaviors.
- 13:10That is a perfect way to remember it. And the
- 13:13official rule book for this field is the ACA
- 13:15Code of Ethics, which relies on moral models
- 13:17like principle ethics. Right, the core principles.
- 13:19Autonomy, protecting the client's right to choose,
- 13:22non -maleficence, doing no harm, beneficence,
- 13:26doing good, justice, fidelity, and veracity,
- 13:30which is basically dealing truthfully. But the
- 13:32textbook raises a really provocative conflict.
- 13:35What happens when a counselor's religious morality
- 13:38directly clashes with professional ethics. Yeah,
- 13:41the real -world dilemmas. Like, say a counselor
- 13:44views abortion as a profound moral sin, but their
- 13:48client wants to explore that option. Ethics say
- 13:51the counselor must respect client autonomy and
- 13:54do no harm. How do they navigate that clash?
- 13:57That is where the developmental models of ethical
- 13:59decision -making come in. Counselors have to
- 14:02evolve how they think. What do you mean? Well,
- 14:04novice counselors often use dualistic thinking.
- 14:07It's very binary, black and white, right or wrong.
- 14:10When they face a moral clash, they just want
- 14:11someone to hand them the quote unquote correct
- 14:13answer. But there isn't always one. Right. So
- 14:16they have to evolve into relativistic thinking.
- 14:19A relativistic thinker can hold their own moral
- 14:21beliefs, but they are flexible enough to realize
- 14:24that imposing those beliefs on a client violates
- 14:27the ethics of the profession. So they process
- 14:29their own discomfort outside the session. Exactly.
- 14:32But to ensure these ethical standards are actually
- 14:35upheld on a large scale, the profession had to
- 14:37build systemic structures, which leads us to
- 14:41accreditation, credentialing, and the modern
- 14:43push for social justice. Yes, the structural
- 14:46oversight. I use the ABCs of standards to remember
- 14:49this. Let's hear it. Accreditation is for the
- 14:52school, so KCREP evaluating the university programs.
- 14:56Board certification is for the resume, like the
- 14:59NCC denoting national mastery. And licensure
- 15:02is for the law. It's the state defining your
- 15:05legal practice. Perfect mnemonic. And all this
- 15:08infrastructure enforces the newer paradigms,
- 15:11what the field calls the fourth and fifth forces
- 15:13of counseling. Multiculturalism and social justice.
- 15:17Which brings us to the MSJCC. The Multicultural
- 15:21and Social Justice Counseling Competencies. It
- 15:24has four main domains. Right. Counselor self
- 15:27-awareness, understanding the client's worldview,
- 15:30the counseling relationship itself, and advocacy
- 15:33interventions outside the office. And a big part
- 15:36of that is the MSJCC praxis matrix. It forces
- 15:39counselors to examine whether they and their
- 15:41clients hold marginalized or privileged identities.
- 15:44And how those power dynamics influence the therapy.
- 15:47But wait, I have another pushback here. Go for
- 15:50it. Does categorizing the counselor and client
- 15:52and district privileged or marginalized quadrants
- 15:56risk putting people into rigid boxes? Doesn't
- 15:59that defeat the whole humanistic goal of treating
- 16:02the individual? It's a valid concern, but The
- 16:05Matrix is meant as a developmental lens, starting
- 16:08with self -awareness. It ensures the counselor
- 16:10recognizes invisible power dynamics in the room,
- 16:13rather than just relying on stereotypes. Oh,
- 16:15so it's about acknowledging the reality of society,
- 16:18so it doesn't secretly poison the therapy. Exactly.
- 16:21You have to see the barriers to dismantle them.
- 16:24Wow. OK, so... Summarizing our deep dive today,
- 16:28we've defined counseling against guidance in
- 16:30psychotherapy. We traced its roots from religious
- 16:33philosophy to scientific practice. We identified
- 16:36the traits of an effective helper, like empathy
- 16:39and the it factor. And unpacked the ethical rule
- 16:42books and multicultural standards that keep the
- 16:45profession safe. That's a lot. And the sources
- 16:48explicitly note that counseling history is defined
- 16:50by paradigm shifts. from moral guidance to psychoanalysis
- 16:54to humanism and now to multiculturalism and telemental
- 16:58health. Always adapting. Which leaves us with
- 17:00a final forward -looking question. If we are
- 17:03currently in the technology and social justice
- 17:06paradigm, what is the next shift? Good question.
- 17:10As algorithms and AI become incredibly sophisticated,
- 17:13could a machine ever possess the it factor or
- 17:16the cognitive complexity required to be an ethical
- 17:19counselor? Or is the healing power of the counseling
- 17:22relationship inherently, fundamentally human?
- 17:25Oh man. That is the ultimate question for the
- 17:28future of the field. Something to mull over.
- 17:30Thank you for joining this study session on the
- 17:32psychology undergrad. Keep questioning the mind
- 17:35and the systems we build to heal it. And we will
- 17:37see you next time.