Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / From Pig Butchering to the Tax Return: Deducting Crypto Scam Losses
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone, my name is Philipp Behring, chair
- 0:06of the BHBA tax section and I welcome you today
- 0:09to tax treatment of pig butchering, work bull
- 0:12-hack, investment scam, losses. The tax section
- 0:16is sponsored by Hochmann Sorge and Torscher Perez.
- 0:18The Hochmann Sorge and Torscher Perez advantage
- 0:21is experience and eye for innovation and generous
- 0:23dedication for clients, the families and the
- 0:25business. In addition to their national practice
- 0:28civil tax and criminal tax controversies and
- 0:32related litigation in federal and state courts.
- 0:35The firm is also active and successful in handling
- 0:37other non -tax white collar investigations and
- 0:40prosecutions. I'm very happy to have Valerie
- 0:44joining me today. She sent me over her bio. She
- 0:48is a shareholder at Carlton Fields in Los Angeles.
- 0:51She is a former federal prosecutor who now focuses
- 0:54her practice on tax controversy, white collar
- 0:57defense, a complex civil litigation, She has,
- 1:00we presented individuals and entities and matters
- 1:03involving CIS, DOJ, state, taxing authorities.
- 1:06She has published on the tax treatment of crypto
- 1:09controversy fraud lawsuits in Bloomberg tax.
- 1:12And what was not included in her bio, but I find
- 1:15very impressive is that she is actually an accomplished
- 1:18trial lawyer and former federal prosecutor with
- 1:20more than 20 years of experience investigating
- 1:23and litigating complex criminal and civil matters
- 1:27in federal and state courts. and she has served
- 1:30as a U .S. Assistant U .S. Attorney in Major
- 1:33Fourth Section of the U .S. Attorney's Office
- 1:35for the Central District of California, where
- 1:38she investigated and prosecuted large -scale
- 1:40financial crimes, sometimes in parallel with
- 1:43civil and regulatory matters that arose in a
- 1:46wide range of industries. So she is uniquely
- 1:48qualified for this presentation today, so I'm
- 1:51very happy, Valerie, that you're joining me today.
- 1:54Thank you for having me, Philip. So we are going
- 1:58to talk about what happens from a tax perspective
- 2:00when someone has actually lost money to a scam,
- 2:04big butchering, a crypto investment scam, a hack,
- 2:06a rock pull, or one of the many variations we
- 2:10are now seeing. We are largely starting at a
- 2:14point where a terrible event has already happened,
- 2:17so the client comes into the office and says,
- 2:19I lost 500 ,000, I lost 2 million, I liquidated
- 2:22my IWA, the money is gone. Is there at least
- 2:25a tax deduction? The answer is there is a definite
- 2:29maybe, and sometimes it's yes, sometimes it's
- 2:32no, and the distinction is not necessarily intuitive.
- 2:35So what we want to do today is give you a framework
- 2:38that you can actually use when that call is coming.
- 2:42So we are going to work with this essentially
- 2:45five steps. Where does the loss fit under 165?
- 2:50Do we actually have a set for text purposes?
- 2:54Whether we will spend some time with that because
- 2:57The answer turns on state criminal law. Third,
- 3:01we will look at 2025 Chief Counsel Advice, which
- 3:04is probably the single most useful piece of recent
- 3:06IRS guidance in this area. Fourth, we will take
- 3:10that framework and apply it to some crypto -specific
- 3:12problems like rock -poles, hacks, failed exchanges,
- 3:16Ponzi -type arrangements. And finally, we will
- 3:20talk about what you actually put in the file
- 3:23and on the return. So if you remember nothing
- 3:26else from today, there are really four questions.
- 3:31Was there theft? Was there a profit motive? What
- 3:35is the year of loss? And finally, can you prove
- 3:38it? So I wanted to start with this slide because
- 3:44it gives you a sense of how rapidly this area
- 3:46has developed. So I'm not going to read through
- 3:52all of these cases. It's simply the collection
- 3:54from the last 12 months of DOJ actions. What
- 3:59is striking to me is the variety. We have traditional
- 4:03Ponzi schemes. We have fake crypto investment
- 4:06platforms. We have account takeovers. We have
- 4:09social engineering. We have market manipulation.
- 4:12We have scam compounds. And we have the entire
- 4:15infrastructure developing along these scams.
- 4:19So the important point is that the scam itself
- 4:23is not new. It's usually confidence fraud, and
- 4:26that's not new. Romans fraud is not new. Impersonating
- 4:30a bank or a police officer is not new. Convincing
- 4:34somebody that you have a special investment of
- 4:36your turn in here is certainly not new. We have
- 4:39that from the beginning of the fax machine to
- 4:41the internet, telephone, etc. What is new is
- 4:46the scale and the industrialization. Historically,
- 4:49think of the confidence man where to find one
- 4:51victim, develop a relationship with that victim
- 4:54and work that person individually. imagine the
- 4:59same fraud being conducted against tens of thousands
- 5:02or hundreds of thousands of people at the same
- 5:05time using standardized scripts, standardized
- 5:08fake websites, standardized payment infrastructure,
- 5:11professional money laundering networks. If you
- 5:14want to see a little bit of that background,
- 5:15there's a front line documentary from a few months
- 5:18ago. And that is not an exit. Yeah. That is,
- 5:25that initialization is new. If you're looking
- 5:27at the latest case, Jimby Guaranteed. I hope
- 5:31I pronounced that name correctly. DJ described
- 5:34Jimby essentially as an illicit marketplace or
- 5:37telegram for the scam industry. A scam operator
- 5:40could obtain services to create a fake investment
- 5:44website. Someone else could then provide money
- 5:47laundering service. Other vendors were involved
- 5:49recruiting people to work in scam compounds.
- 5:53So in other words, you no longer need to build
- 5:56the entire fraud infrastructure. yourself. This
- 5:59effectively is a supply chain for fraud. Fraud
- 6:02as a service. In September, DOJ announced that
- 6:06approximately 52 million of cryptocurrency was
- 6:09restrained in a single day, bringing the strike
- 6:12force total at the time to approximately 938
- 6:15billion. That is what I mean by industrialization.
- 6:19The underlying fraud is centuries old. What technology
- 6:22has done to make it possible to operate it on
- 6:25an enormous scale. AI cryptocurrency is important
- 6:29here, but I would not describe it as a crypto
- 6:31scam. So frequently crypto is simply the payment
- 6:34whale. So the fraud occurs through social engineering,
- 6:38telegram messages, WhatsApp messages. The crypto
- 6:41then lets the proceeds move quickly internationally
- 6:44through multiple wallets. And then finally it
- 6:47gets off ramped somewhere abroad so that the
- 6:52fraudsters can actually use real money because
- 6:54that's what they want. They don't want crypto.
- 6:57And once you initialize something that effectively
- 7:00the loss numbers start looking like this, the
- 7:05numbers are staggering. We have some important
- 7:07materials. That's the FBI Internet Crime Center
- 7:11report from 2025. So reported cybercrime losses
- 7:15are now above 20 billion in the US. More than
- 7:1911 billion of reported losses are cryptocurrency
- 7:21related. And more than 7 billion of that relates
- 7:24to investment fraud. And remember, those are
- 7:28only the reported losses. There's a huge gray
- 7:31number of losses that are probably people who
- 7:33are not reporting it because there's a social
- 7:36hurdle to talk about that. The stories behind
- 7:38these are usually very heartbreaking. And the
- 7:42people calling tax lawyers and accountants about
- 7:44this are often not people who thought of themselves
- 7:47as crypto investors before the scam started.
- 7:51They may be retirees. They may have a brokerage
- 7:54account. They may have an IWA. they may own their
- 7:58own home. You see on the right hand side by age
- 8:03range, while the 60 plus age range is still most
- 8:09of the losses, there's significant amount of
- 8:13losses for younger people, 20 to 25, 30 to 39.
- 8:18So these are people in the middle of their life
- 8:20that should be familiar with most of these technologies.
- 8:24but are still falling for it because these new
- 8:26scams are so convincing. So let me walk you through
- 8:33what one of these scams actually looks like,
- 8:34because it helps explain a lot. The first contact
- 8:39frequency looks completely accident. You receive
- 8:42a text like, hey, is this David? And you say,
- 8:46no, no, wrong number. And the response is something
- 8:48like, I'm sorry. I hope I didn't disturb you.
- 8:51You seem very kind. So that sounds almost comically,
- 8:55obviously, when we describe it in a CLE. But
- 8:59in real life, it is very convincing. And even
- 9:02if you have 100 or a million of these outreach,
- 9:05if you have only two or three of people responding,
- 9:08that's all the scammers need. And that's exactly
- 9:13how these cases begin. So the FBI specifically
- 9:17identifies wrong number of texts, dating sites,
- 9:20social media, and WhatsApp or Telegram groups
- 9:23as common evidence. There is no investment bridge
- 9:28at this beginning. That is important. They talk,
- 9:32they discuss travel, food, hobbies, family, business,
- 9:34sometimes religion. The person on the other end
- 9:37may appear successful, attractive, sophisticated
- 9:39and financially secure. And then fairly early
- 9:43in the interaction, the conversation moves to
- 9:45off the original platform and like, do you have
- 9:48WhatsApp? Let's talk on Telegram. And now the
- 9:51thoughts that controls the direct communication
- 9:53channel. Then comes the trust building phase.
- 9:57They may communicate every morning, every evening.
- 10:01They remember details the victim has told them.
- 10:04There may be photographs, voice messages, sometimes
- 10:06even videos. The point is to make this look like
- 10:11a genuine human relationship rather than a solicitation.
- 10:16Only after that relationship has developed does
- 10:18the investing appear. By the way, I have been
- 10:21doing very well in trading crypto. My uncle is
- 10:23in finance. I have strategies. that have been
- 10:26very successful. It is almost as an aside. And
- 10:30then the victim walks through opening a real
- 10:32account at a legitimate US exchange, or maybe
- 10:35even at a fake exchange, transferring money to
- 10:38some other account. And that is the important
- 10:41part of the psychology. The victim may be interacting
- 10:44with Coinbase or crypto .com, so everything looks
- 10:46legitimate. The scammer then tells the victim
- 10:49to buy cryptocurrency, transfer it to what appears
- 10:51to be an investment platform, and the fake platform
- 10:54is often. very well designed. It's not the typical
- 10:57Nigerian Prince email where you can immediately
- 11:00see that there's something wrong. There's professional
- 11:03interface, there's customer service, there's
- 11:06account statements, charts, trades, and of course
- 11:09accounts start making money. So the victim may
- 11:13put in 5 ,000, maybe 20 ,000, and frequently
- 11:17they are committed to restore a small amount.
- 11:20that may be most effective part of the scan.
- 11:23The victim requests $2 ,000 and actually receives
- 11:26$2 ,000 back. At that point, the victim thinks,
- 11:28I tested it, it works. And then the amount starts
- 11:31increasing. $20 ,000 becomes $100 ,000, $250
- 11:34,000. And then somebody says, we have an extraordinary
- 11:39opportunity. Do you don't want to put another
- 11:41$400 ,000 in? They start liquidating brokerage
- 11:44accounts. I was borrowing against the house,
- 11:47et cetera. And then in the end, the victim tries
- 11:50to restore. That is when good money is swirled
- 11:53after that. There's a withdrawal fee that needs
- 11:56to be paid, a tax withholding that needs to be
- 11:58paid, a service source chart that never can be
- 12:02paid from the account needs to be additional
- 12:04money put in. But it's promised after that you
- 12:08can withdraw. One fee after another until the
- 12:11victim finally realizes it has been scammed.
- 12:14This is not a hypothetical. EOJ described...
- 12:17A woman in Lake County, Ohio, who received an
- 12:20unsolicited text in November 2023. She and the
- 12:23purported new friend bonded over hobbies, religion.
- 12:26The person walked her through opening a crypto
- 12:29.com account. She ultimately transferred more
- 12:31money when she tried to restore. When the money
- 12:35went out, the purported friend began threatening
- 12:38her. Her loss was approximately 663 ,000. Her
- 12:41entire life savings, including both IRA funds.
- 12:44That case was captured almost the entire life
- 12:47cycle of the Ford. So at once the person comes
- 12:51to us, there may actually be multiple tax problems.
- 12:56She has have capital gain from selling investments.
- 12:58She may have a taxable IWA distribution, a penalty
- 13:01from IWA restorers before 95 and a half years
- 13:04old. And then separately, we have to determine
- 13:07whether she has a theft loss deduction. And this,
- 13:15in especially ugly developments that fits right
- 13:17here, It is not over until it's over. Once somebody
- 13:22becomes a scam victim, that person frequently
- 13:24becomes a target again. The second scammer contacts
- 13:27the victim and says, we located your cryptocurrency,
- 13:31we work with law enforcement, we have a blockchain
- 13:33recovery firm, we have law firms specializing
- 13:36in crypto recovery, et cetera, et cetera. And
- 13:40the fee may be described as a tracing fee or
- 13:42legal retainer, tax, insurance bond, release
- 13:45fee, whatever. And once that payment is made,
- 13:48another requirement appears. And again, KCDAJ
- 13:52described in July 2026, in a forfeiture case,
- 13:57the victim had already suffered an unrelated
- 13:59fraud. The second group contacted the victim,
- 14:02claimed that stolen funds had been recovered,
- 14:04and convinced the victim to make a series of
- 14:07additional payments in order to get the original
- 14:08money back. The government was seeking forfeiture
- 14:11of roughly 285 ,000, connected with that second
- 14:15fraud. So when a client tells you, and then I
- 14:19paid a recovery company or the company reached
- 14:21out to me for all I do it be aware of that second
- 14:24scan. So section 165 gives an individual essentially
- 14:37three doors for the tax deduction. Door number
- 14:41one is section 165 C1 trade or business that
- 14:45can matter in what case but it's usually not
- 14:48where the individual investment scan victim falls.
- 14:52Door number two is the most important one. It's
- 14:54165C2, a transaction entered into for -profit.
- 14:58That is the key provision for most of what we
- 15:01are discussing today. And door number three is
- 15:04section 160C3, the personal casualty or theftless.
- 15:09That third category is what's getting you into
- 15:11trouble. A client may tell you quite correctly,
- 15:14someone stole my money, but that tells you that
- 15:17you may have a theft. It does not tell you whether
- 15:20the theft is deducted. You still have to determine
- 15:23which of these three statutory buckets the loss
- 15:26belongs in. So when you first interview the victim,
- 15:31first I'm telling them how common it is that
- 15:34they feel, at least feel somewhat better, they're
- 15:37feeling like elites. They don't want to come
- 15:40forward. So they need some assurances that that's
- 15:44not them. It's a very high profile industry,
- 15:49a lot of money. And one of the first... talks
- 15:53is how did it all happen? Not what kind of scam
- 15:56was this. I would begin with why did you transfer
- 15:59the money? What did you believe you were doing?
- 16:02Because that's the most important part. The reason
- 16:06that characterization matters is that personal
- 16:08theft losses since the TCGA are generally off
- 16:12the table under political, subject to statutory
- 16:14exceptions you see here. So imagine three taxpayers
- 16:17who each lost 500 ,000 to exactly the same criminal.
- 16:21Victim one senses it because the scammer claims
- 16:24her daughter has been kidnapped. The second one
- 16:27believes she is in a romantic relationship because
- 16:30the person says he needs money. And the third
- 16:34one invests because the scammer tells them he
- 16:37will be invested. And around 20 % recovery of
- 16:43return. Same criminal, same amount, potentially
- 16:47the same underlying states. Well, we will explain
- 16:51that to us. But the federal tax result can be
- 16:58dramatically different. That is because the code
- 17:01is looking at the character of the transaction,
- 17:03not at how apprehensible the criminal conduct
- 17:06is. There is proposed legislation, H .R. 9500,
- 17:14that might offer relief, but today we are talking
- 17:16about the current law. And that takes us to what
- 17:22I call the escape hatch section 165C2. If the
- 17:27taxpayer entered into the transaction for profit,
- 17:29we are no longer dealing with a purely personal
- 17:32theft case. The classic case is straightforward.
- 17:34I transferred 300 ,000 because I believed it
- 17:37was invested and I expected to earn money. That
- 17:40is profit seeking. But not the name of the scam
- 17:44substitutes for the analysis. Suppose the scam
- 17:47begins as a romance. During six months, the taxpayer
- 17:49makes three transactions. The first 20 ,000 because
- 17:54the boyfriend needs emergency medical treatment.
- 17:56The second $300 ,000 because fake investment
- 17:59occurred. The third $75 ,000 described as a tax
- 18:03that must be paid before the $300 ,000 investment
- 18:06can be released. So these are all separate transactions.
- 18:09So just because it's a woman scan doesn't mean
- 18:12you are out. But even if there is a profit motive,
- 18:17Section 165C does no good unless we actually
- 18:21have a theft. And determine whether we have theft
- 18:24is where state criminal law becomes important.
- 18:27So, Valerie, can you take us through that? Thanks,
- 18:33Philip. So, here is where the tax analysis ends
- 18:36and I enter the scene. So, Philip just told you
- 18:39the deduction exists. The hard part is proving
- 18:42you're entitled to it. The problem is the IRS
- 18:45doesn't really care that your client lost money.
- 18:48What they care about is that your client was
- 18:51a victim of a crime. And those are two very different
- 18:54questions. And you have to answer the second
- 18:57one without a prosecution, without an indictment,
- 19:01and without a defendant. So I come at this from
- 19:05a criminal law background. And the thing that
- 19:07stands out to me is that many tax practitioners
- 19:11are perhaps not thinking about the proof burden
- 19:14in the right way. They're treating this as a
- 19:18tax question when really it's an evidentiary
- 19:20one. And in their narratives, they're writing,
- 19:23my client was defrauded. Well, that's a conclusion.
- 19:27It's not proof. Proof means here's the statute,
- 19:31here are the elements, and here is the evidence
- 19:34that satisfies each one. And that's what we're
- 19:37going to build on in the next few slides. So
- 19:40looking at this one, the statute requires four
- 19:43things. The underlying crime must be a violation
- 19:47of state law, not federal, but state law. Second,
- 19:51The scammer must have acted with criminal intent,
- 19:55meaning they set out to steal from your client,
- 19:58not simply fail to deliver on the promised investment.
- 20:03You do not need a conviction, which matters because
- 20:05in these cases, realistically, you're never going
- 20:09to get one. And the loss has to be a theft, not
- 20:13a bad investment. A project that collapsed without
- 20:17fraud is a capital loss. It's not an ordinary
- 20:21deduction. That is a technical distinction, and
- 20:25that six -figure difference, and that is a six
- 20:28-figure difference for your client. Next slide,
- 20:30please. The regulations say that theft means
- 20:36larceny, embezzlement, and robbery. The Fifth
- 20:39Circuit in Edwards versus Brombo said that it
- 20:44also means swindling, false pretenses, and I
- 20:48love this, any other form of guile. So it sounds
- 20:52like we are covered, right? Every pick butchering
- 20:56case involves guile. But the IRS isn't going
- 21:00to argue your client didn't lose money. What
- 21:03they're going to argue is that it wasn't a theft.
- 21:06So you need to prove that what happened satisfies
- 21:09the elements of a criminal theft statute. and
- 21:12the statute that matters is the one in the state
- 21:15where your client was sitting when they sent
- 21:17the money. Not every state defines theft the
- 21:21same way. So let's take a look at how the key
- 21:24states handle it. Florida first because Florida
- 21:28is the standard approach used by a majority of
- 21:31states across the country. Next slide, Phillip,
- 21:33please. A lot of states used to split theft into
- 21:40separate crimes, larceny, embezzlement, fraud,
- 21:44false pretenses, each having its own elements.
- 21:48If you pick the wrong one, your case falls apart
- 21:51on a technicality, even though everyone agrees
- 21:54the money was stolen. Well, Florida and a majority
- 21:58of the states in this country got rid of all
- 22:00of that. They have one statute, one broad definition.
- 22:05If you knowingly obtained someone's property
- 22:08with the intent to deprive them of it, whether
- 22:11by deception, false promise, or abusive trust,
- 22:15it's a theft, period. Pig butchering walks right
- 22:19through those elements without breaking a stride.
- 22:22Now, Florida is also number three in the country
- 22:25for crypto investment fraud losses, documented
- 22:29about 915 million just last year. And Florida,
- 22:35along with many other states, has an elder exploitation
- 22:38enhancement under, in this case, Florida law,
- 22:43which means that prosecutors may actually pay
- 22:46attention to these cases, which can help your
- 22:48client build the record even if no charges are
- 22:52filed. A detective who takes a report seriously
- 22:56generates better documentation than one who doesn't.
- 23:01This Florida statute is what a broad and relatively
- 23:05easily proven criminal statute looks like. Now
- 23:08let me show you what California adds. $2 .1 billion,
- 23:15which is the amount of California's crypto investment
- 23:19fraud losses in 2015. 2 .1 billion, number one
- 23:25in the country. So this is not an academic problem
- 23:28for anyone on this webinar. California Penal
- 23:33Code Section 484A gives you theft by false pretense.
- 23:38Section 487E allows you to aggregate multiple
- 23:43transfers into one single theft. And that matters
- 23:47for pig butchering schemes because they work
- 23:50through escalation. Your client sends money over
- 23:54and over in increasing amounts. Without this
- 23:57aggregation, you would be stuck arguing each
- 24:00individual wire was a separate theft. But with
- 24:04Section 487E, all of those payments are treated
- 24:08as one course of conduct and one loss. Then there's
- 24:13penal code section 532 and 532B has a rule that
- 24:18matters here. You cannot prove a false pretense
- 24:22by the victim's testimony alone. Now 532 was
- 24:28designed for a time long ago in a world where
- 24:31fraud happened in person. There was a verbal
- 24:34promise, there was a handshake deal. This is
- 24:38for matters that had no paper trail. And in those
- 24:41cases, corroboration was genuinely difficult.
- 24:45But pig butchering flips that completely. The
- 24:48scammer handed you the corroboration. And that's
- 24:51every WhatsApp message, every fake account statement
- 24:55showing a balance that didn't exist, every pay
- 24:59the tax to unlock your withdrawal demand. every
- 25:02wire confirmation, and then the blockchain itself,
- 25:05a permanent immutable time stamped record of
- 25:09where the money went and didn't in coming back.
- 25:14So the first phone call that you have with your
- 25:17client should include the words, do not delete
- 25:20anything. Don't reset your phone, don't clear
- 25:23the chat, don't close that browser tab with the
- 25:27fake platform on it. Screenshot it, document
- 25:31it first. because that site can quickly disappear.
- 25:36Section 532's corroboration requirement sounds
- 25:39like a hurdle until you remember just how much
- 25:42evidence these cases generate. So I'm going to
- 25:45hand it back to Philipp for CCA scenarios and
- 25:48timing rules. Once we established that there
- 25:50was a theft, the next question seems deceptively
- 25:54easy. When do I deduct it? And the answer is
- 25:57not necessarily the year the money left the account.
- 26:01That's the problem. Section 165e directs us to
- 26:04the year in which the theft is discovered. So
- 26:08suppose the taxpayer sends the money in October
- 26:102025, in December 2025 the fake website is still
- 26:14operating, the account still shows a two million
- 26:18dollar balance, the scammer is still communicating,
- 26:22the taxpayer generally believes the investment
- 26:28still exists. And then in April 2026, the taxpayer
- 26:32attempts to withdraw the money. The platform
- 26:34demands another 100 ,000. The taxpayer contacts
- 26:38the supposed exchange and discovers the website
- 26:40is fit. The phone number stopped working. The
- 26:45website starts disappearing. That may point towards
- 26:50discovery in 2026. So not automatically in 2025,
- 26:55simply because that's when the funds were transferred.
- 26:58But there's also a second question, and that's
- 27:01the discovery. Discovery does not automatically
- 27:05mean deduction. You also have to ask whether
- 27:08there is a reasonable prospect of recovery. Is
- 27:12there insurance? Is there law enforcement that
- 27:14throws the wallets? Is there receivership? Is
- 27:17there bankruptcy proceedings? Has perpetrators
- 27:20been identified? Legal proceedings are brought?
- 27:25Is there restitution proceedings? Those facts
- 27:28can... defer and also reduce the loss and conversely
- 27:33if all you have is an anonymous telegram account
- 27:37in offshore fake platform and funds that have
- 27:41moved to dozens of wallets, the recovery analysis
- 27:44made from case to case look very different. There
- 27:47are firms who are tracing it and I can tell you
- 27:50from experience that the first 48 hours of the
- 27:53theft like that are the most important ones.
- 27:56These are the moments where as long as it's still
- 27:58on chain, where you can trace it and have a chance
- 28:01of freezing it. After a week, the chance goes
- 28:05basically to zero, because money moves so fast.
- 28:09But you still have to document it. And the problem
- 28:12is always, if you report it to IC3, if you report
- 28:15it to the FBI, if you report it to police, to
- 28:18prosecution, you will often not hear back, because
- 28:22these scams are common. Success is where it's...
- 28:28How do you prove it without the police confirming?
- 28:33Yeah, we have stopped investigating. They will
- 28:36not confirm that. You have to basically have
- 28:40an objective mind. Is there any reasonable prospect
- 28:44of recovery? And that is, unfortunately, a case
- 28:48-by -case determination based on the facts and
- 28:51circumstances. Once the money is off -chain,
- 28:55you usually don't have any chance. But keep these
- 28:58two. distinct boxes in your file when the discovery
- 29:02occurred and when it's a reasonable expectation
- 29:07of recovery yet. So measure lost by basis. The
- 29:14next sounds obvious to a tax lawyer, but it's
- 29:17often devastating to the victim. The fake dashboard
- 29:19is not so nice. The client may tell you I have
- 29:23six million in the account. No, the website told
- 29:27you that six million. Those are very different
- 29:30things. We generally start with cash actually
- 29:33transferred to the taxpayer spaces or the cash
- 29:38transferred through the account or the taxpayer
- 29:40spaces and properties that was transferred to
- 29:42the account in the case of crypto. Then we look
- 29:45at additional amounts actually paid because of
- 29:48support, things like fake tax with small fees,
- 29:51unlawed payments, et cetera. And we have to subtract
- 29:54amounts that were actually restored or recovered.
- 29:56So if I transfer 500 ,000 to the website, and
- 30:02the website tells me it became three million.
- 30:04I sent another 100 ,000 for supposed tax, and
- 30:09early I successfully withdrew 20 ,000. The numbers
- 30:13are not the three million on the dashboard. It's
- 30:16580 ,000. The 500 ,000 I put in, the 100 ,000
- 30:20I paid in fee, minus the 20 ,000 I recovered.
- 30:24The real case is it shows that very well, it's
- 30:27Fri. Fri case in our later case slide is a good
- 30:30illustration. The taxpayer allegedly transferred
- 30:34approximately 958 ,000 to what they believed
- 30:38was a crypto investment platform. The fake account
- 30:41eventually showed 6 .4 million. That 6 .4 million
- 30:46is psychologically important to the victim, but
- 30:48it's not the tax basis. It's not the loss deduction.
- 30:53And then there's the IWA trap. One more pop.
- 30:57If the taxpayer liquidated the IWA to fund the
- 30:59scam, Do not assume the theft somehow undos this
- 31:02distribution. You may have ordinary income from
- 31:05the Iowa distribution, potentially an additional
- 31:08tax, and then separately a section 165 loss.
- 31:13Those are separate steps, also the penalty for
- 31:17early Iowa restaurants. That might not be the
- 31:21same year. So the Chief Counsel advised 2025
- 31:30-11 -015 it's probably the most useful IIS guides.
- 31:35It was released in 2025, March, and one caveat,
- 31:42it's a CCA, so it's not precedent, but from a
- 31:46practitioner standpoint, this is extraordinarily
- 31:49useful because the Chief Counsel takes five recognizable
- 31:53modern scams and tells us how it is thinking
- 31:56about the 165. And if you step back from the
- 32:00individual examples, See, the writing line becomes
- 32:03fairly clear. Compromised investment accounts,
- 32:08potentially deductible. Pig butchering investment
- 32:10scams, potentially deductible. Phishing, it depends
- 32:14on what kind of properties. Roman scam, emergency
- 32:19or kidnapping scams, not deductible under the
- 32:23facts. Why? It's largely because of the distinction
- 32:28we just discussed. Profit -seeking transaction
- 32:31versus personal transaction. So looking at scenario
- 32:35one, the compromised accounts. It is useful because
- 32:40it eliminates the common misconception. The victim
- 32:44receives a call from someone claiming to be a
- 32:47fraud specialist. The victim is told that the
- 32:50investment account is being compromised. The
- 32:53victim is instructed to move the money to supposedly
- 32:56save the account. And the victim personally initiates
- 33:01the transfer. The safe account is actually controlled
- 33:04by the scammer. The instinct might be that the
- 33:08taxpayer voluntarily transferred the money, so
- 33:10can that be theft? Is there a profit motive?
- 33:15That is not necessarily, I mean, it is a white
- 33:17question under the statute, but it's not necessarily
- 33:19the right way to think about it. A transfer induced
- 33:23through fraud can still be theft, as Valerie
- 33:25explained to us. It might differ from state to
- 33:29state how we argue it, but most likely there
- 33:31is a way. under these facts and circumstances
- 33:35that still is theft. The more interesting question
- 33:40is what the taxpayer was attempting to do with
- 33:43the property. The taxpayer was not giving it
- 33:45away. The taxpayer believed he or she was safeguarding
- 33:49investment assets and those assets could continue
- 33:52to be held for profit. And that is what chief
- 33:55counsel gets to in section 165c and why they
- 33:59allow it. Valerie, do you want to get us to the
- 34:02next one? Certainly. So scenario two is your
- 34:06classic pig setup. So the victim meets somebody
- 34:09online through a dating app, social media, even
- 34:15LinkedIn. Relationship develops. And at some
- 34:19point, the conversation turns to investing. The
- 34:22scammer introduces the victim to a crypto trading
- 34:26platform. I mean, it looks really legitimate,
- 34:30professional interface, real -time charts, even
- 34:33customer support. So the victim deposits funds
- 34:37and the dashboard continuously shows gains. So
- 34:41the victim deposits more and then more. And then
- 34:45comes a time where the victim tries to withdraw
- 34:48and a wall goes up. First, you've got to pay
- 34:51a 15 % tax. to get your withdrawal or pay an
- 34:56insurance deposit, pay a regulatory compliance
- 35:00fee. Every fee is another transfer to the scammer.
- 35:05Eventually the platform goes dark and the money
- 35:07is gone and the person they were talking to disappears.
- 35:12Now, the Chief Counsel Advice says that this
- 35:14is a deductible ordinary theft loss under 165C2.
- 35:19Your profit motive has been satisfied. The victim
- 35:22was investing to earn a return. Well, that's
- 35:26the right answer, but the CCA doesn't tell you
- 35:29how to prove it on exam. It doesn't walk you
- 35:32through the state law analysis. It doesn't address
- 35:34what happens when there's no prosecution. It
- 35:37gives you that conclusion and leaves you the
- 35:40practitioner to figure out all of the work. And
- 35:43the work means going back to what I just walked
- 35:45you through, which state, which statute, which
- 35:48element, and which evidence you have to apply
- 35:51to those elements. Now, one thing I think Philip
- 35:55just touched on, but sometimes it gets missed
- 35:58on in the math. Don't forget those backend fees,
- 36:02those taxes and insurance deposits the scammer
- 36:05demanded at the end. Those aren't separate transactions.
- 36:09Those are fraud -induced payments. They're part
- 36:12of the loss. And I've seen practitioners leave
- 36:15six figures on the table by not including them.
- 36:19The Ponzi safe harbor, which we'll go over in
- 36:22a moment, doesn't apply here. There's no charge
- 36:25defendant, no safe harbor. You're going to have
- 36:27to prove this the long and hard way. And scenario
- 36:39three looks even more like what we traditionally
- 36:42think of theft. The taxpayer receives what appears
- 36:45to be an email from a financial institution.
- 36:48The taxpayer clicks the link. the scammer obtains
- 36:51access to more credentials and the scammer drains
- 36:54the account without authorization. The theft
- 36:57element may be easier here, but it still does
- 37:00not answer the deductibility. What was stolen,
- 37:02if someone drains my investment account, that
- 37:05may support 165C. If someone steals funds held
- 37:09in connection with my business, perhaps we are
- 37:11even 165C1. If someone steals purely personal
- 37:15cash, we are back at the personal theft limitations.
- 37:22DOJ has bought forfeiture action involving SIM
- 37:26swap attacks in which criminals took control
- 37:29of victims' authentication and transferred cryptocurrency
- 37:32from victims' wallets. One 2025 action saw forfeiture
- 37:37of more than 5 million in Bitcoin traced to unauthorized
- 37:40transfers from five victims. That is a very clean
- 37:44example of these unauthorized taking side of
- 37:48the spectrum. And we are going for the next Scenario
- 37:57is even more into personal theft. Scenario four
- 38:02was a Roman scam. Chief counsel says no deduction
- 38:05on its facts because the taxpayer transferred
- 38:07some money for personal or emotional reasons.
- 38:10Again, actually we have to look at the transactions
- 38:13and for what transactions they were actually
- 38:15done for. If it starts as a Roman scam, but the
- 38:19transaction was done for investment, it looks
- 38:21different. Again, not look only at the labels.
- 38:24look at the single transactions. Chief counsel
- 38:30advice says the transactions were not entered
- 38:34into for profit. That is true if there was purely
- 38:37a Roman's reason, if they wanted to support that
- 38:40new boyfriend or girlfriend, if they wanted to
- 38:43pay some personal rent payments or car payments
- 38:47or god knows. So do not write Roman scam at the
- 38:54top of the file and stop saying it. The label
- 38:58does not cover it. So suppose somebody meets
- 39:01a purported romantics partner online. The payment
- 39:05is 15 ,000 because the partner needs surgery
- 39:10or back in Columbia and said he needs some money
- 39:15to pay the officers there. That is personal.
- 39:20Three months later, the same person might say,
- 39:22I have been making a lot of money trading crypto.
- 39:25You should invest too. And the taxpayer puts
- 39:28400 ,000 on the fake platform. That's a different
- 39:31transaction. And then the platform says 400 ,000
- 39:34has gone to 900 ,000. We are back in. So that
- 39:41progression is exactly why these cases are difficult.
- 39:43The Ohio case that I mentioned earlier began
- 39:46with a personal relationship. The victim and
- 39:51the stranger bonded over hobbies religion, but
- 39:55it evolved into an arresting scheme. So for tax
- 39:58purposes, we have to look at the character of
- 40:02each transaction. It's a little bit different
- 40:06with the kidnapping emergency scams. It's almost
- 40:11a mirror image. The victim receives an urgent
- 40:14communication saying a child or family member
- 40:16has been kidnapped, arrested, injured, or otherwise
- 40:20in danger. The victim sends money to protect
- 40:23the loved ones. It can unquestionably be a theft.
- 40:27It can involve sophisticated spoofing, voice
- 40:29cloning, or AI. morally far worse than many investment
- 40:35frauds, but no one of that can create a profit
- 40:39motive, the purpose of the transfers person.
- 40:43And that gives us what I think is the simplest
- 40:45way to remember the CCA. The code is not asking
- 40:48how evil the scam was, it's asking why the taxpayer
- 40:52transferred the money. I think that's a great
- 40:57point, Philip, to remember that. the profit motive
- 41:01is the dividing line. So here we have a table.
- 41:05Three scams are deductible, two are not. Again,
- 41:08profit motive is the dividing line every single
- 41:12time. And I've seen pig butchering cases where
- 41:15communications made clear the victim was not
- 41:18investing. Again, they were sending money to
- 41:21keep the relationship alive. So that's a romance
- 41:25scam in a pig butchering package. It's not deductible.
- 41:29But as you've mentioned, I've seen romance scam
- 41:32cases where there was a legitimate investment
- 41:35pitch buried somewhere in the relationship, sort
- 41:38of invest with me, here's the platform. We can
- 41:42all look at our returns together. If you can
- 41:45document that profit motive, you might have a
- 41:47165 C2, even though the scam started on Tinder.
- 41:51The label is irrelevant. The communications are
- 41:54everything. So it's important that you read and
- 41:57read through them with your client. Next here
- 42:05is a look at the litigation, oh, back one, the
- 42:09litigation landscape. And this is moving relatively
- 42:14fast in the courts. So Viya is a case in the
- 42:17Southern District of Ohio. There is an 824 ,000
- 42:21pig butchering loss claimed. It's a straightforward
- 42:24165C2 claim. It's probably the cleanest test
- 42:28case on board, but we don't have a decision yet.
- 42:31So if you're going to follow one case, set an
- 42:34alert for this one. Caputo is pending now in
- 42:38tax court. And this is your nightmare scenario.
- 42:41You have an elderly victim. The fraudsters posed
- 42:44as her bank. She liquidated her IRA and transferred
- 42:48$800 ,000 to the fraudsters. And now she owes
- 42:51tax on the distribution and the IRS. disallowed
- 42:55the theft loss. So you've got about a $268 ,000
- 42:59deficiency plus penalties plus interest. So if
- 43:03this goes to a decision, it could define the
- 43:06intersection of IRA distributions and scam losses
- 43:09for the foreseeable future. Frye and Leedy are
- 43:14matters that have both been resolved, both involved
- 43:17pig butchering, both involved near million dollar
- 43:20losses. And in each time, the IRS conceded. No
- 43:24deficiency, no penalty. They both signed a stipulated
- 43:28decision. The IRS conceding in these matters
- 43:33is a signal, but not a precedent. Its stipulated
- 43:36decision doesn't tell us the government's reasoning.
- 43:39It doesn't bind anybody. It doesn't establish
- 43:41a rule. In these events, chief counsel looked
- 43:44at these cases and decided for whatever reason,
- 43:48they did not want to litigate them. And it is
- 43:50meaningful, but it's not the same as winning
- 43:53on the merits. So until VIA or Caputo produces
- 43:57a real opinion, you are filing these deductions
- 44:00without judicial guidance. So the quality of
- 44:03your evidentiary record is the only thing standing
- 44:06between your client and the deficiency notice.
- 44:09Back over to you, Phillips. Oh, wait. Is it me?
- 44:16I don't think so. No, no. Okay. No, that's right.
- 44:18You're rug hacks. But that reminds me, if you
- 44:23guys have questions, just put them in the Q &A
- 44:25box. We will see if we can answer them along
- 44:29the way or at least in the end if we have time.
- 44:33So the Q &A box is there for questions. So applying
- 44:38these frameworks to other crypto hacks. Now we
- 44:43have covered these five CCA scenarios. We have
- 44:46looked at the tax court cases on the one in Ohio.
- 44:51First, let's go to Rockfall. The term Rockfall
- 44:54has no special stature in the IRC, surprisingly,
- 45:00or not. It is a description of conduct. So we
- 45:05still need to ask what actually happens. The
- 45:09strongest, so what happens in a Rockfall, it's
- 45:12usually that you're creating a, for example,
- 45:17an NFT or crypto, you have people invested in
- 45:21it. And in the moment, most people invested in
- 45:25it, you're just pulling the work, meaning that
- 45:27you're actually taking all the money out that
- 45:30people invested and you disappear. And now the
- 45:33crypto is still there as an empty shell, but
- 45:37worthless. The strongest safe case is one. which
- 45:41the fraud exists from the outset. So the promoter
- 45:44solicited investor funds, never intended to build
- 45:47what they promised, took the money, removed the
- 45:50liquidity at his feet. That looks very different
- 45:55from a legitimate project that simply fails.
- 45:59So crypto projects fail. Businesses fail. Poor
- 46:02management is not necessarily safe. So 95 or
- 46:05100 % economic loss does not mean criminal intent.
- 46:10If we're looking at, let's say, One useful real
- 46:13-world example is DOJ's Baller Ape Club prosecution.
- 46:18According to the indictment, the project sold
- 46:21NFTs and then shortly after the first day of
- 46:24public sales, the operators allegedly shut down
- 46:28the project, deleted the website and took approximately
- 46:312 .6 million of investor funds. DOJ alleged that
- 46:36They then moved the proceeds from different blockchains
- 46:40and decentralized swaps to obscure the trail.
- 46:43That's a type of pattern where the argument that
- 46:48fraud existed from inception is here much stronger
- 46:51than simply showing me a token whose price collapsed.
- 46:56Another example we have is heads that are somewhat
- 47:01different. If an outsider attacker exploits a
- 47:04protocol of gains, unauthorized access to a wallet
- 47:08or simply takes a cryptocurrency the unauthorized
- 47:13taking element may be straightforward but we
- 47:16still have to determine the character of the
- 47:18asset and its recovery prospect and one advantage
- 47:22in these cases is the blockchain record so you
- 47:25often can show exactly when the property was
- 47:27moved from which wallet to which wallet and where
- 47:31it moved afterwards but remember blockchain tracing
- 47:35movement does not necessarily by itself every
- 47:37element of the tax deduction. So same as when
- 47:43it went to zero, it's not the same as SEFT. This
- 47:54slide is one of more important crypto -specific
- 47:57points. A client comes in and says the token
- 47:59went to zero, I was what? Maybe. But a price
- 48:03chart is not evidence of SEFT. We have at least
- 48:06three potential different concepts. taxpayer
- 48:10sells an asset for less than basis, that is generally
- 48:14a sales -loss analysis. Two, the asset becomes
- 48:17generally worthless or the taxpayer abandons
- 48:19it. Maybe he sends it to a burnout wallet that
- 48:25no one can access, so that's the way you can
- 48:27abandon your crypto. And that sets its own requirement
- 48:31on the worthlessness of bandwidth deduction.
- 48:36But there's also a third one, and that's somebody
- 48:38fraudulently unlawfully took the taxpayers property
- 48:42and that is the SAFT analysis. We have one IIS
- 48:49guidance, I can't remember if it was CCA or not,
- 48:53that basically says just because crypto is worthless
- 48:55doesn't mean that you can take the deduction,
- 48:59that you need to dispose of it in some way or
- 49:03another before you can take the deduction. So
- 49:06if you have a crypto that became worthless still
- 49:09in your wallet, the value is still close to zero.
- 49:15That doesn't mean that you can take the deduction.
- 49:21So these different types of worthlessness should
- 49:23not be conflated. If a token is still trading
- 49:26even at a tiny fraction of the penny, that can
- 49:30create a separate problem for worthlessness theory.
- 49:34And if the project simply fails, calling the
- 49:37founders Fordster after the fact does not turn
- 49:39the investment loss into an ordinary accept loss
- 49:47problem. Do you want to tell us about the Ponzi
- 49:49schemes? Absolutely. I love Ponzi's. So the RevProc
- 49:552009 -20 is a Ponzi scheme safe harbor shortcut,
- 50:00but it doesn't work here. What this RevProc was
- 50:03built for was Bernie Madoff. It was a named lead
- 50:08figure, pool investment buns, fictitious returns,
- 50:12investors paid with other investors' money, criminal
- 50:16charges ensuing. It was elegant. It was efficient.
- 50:19and had almost nothing to do with pig butchering.
- 50:23Pig butchering is not a Ponzi scheme. It's a
- 50:25one -to -one fraud fund. There is no pool of
- 50:29investors. And as we've spoken about, there's
- 50:34probably no charged defendant, which is the requirement
- 50:37that kills the safe harbor. That fourth element
- 50:41requiring a triggering action it's meaning to
- 50:45be a qualifying criminal charge against the lead
- 50:48figure. So for Madoff, that existed the day he
- 50:51was arrested. For a pig butchering victim whose
- 50:54scammer is operating under a fake name, most
- 50:58likely from a compound in southeastern Asia,
- 51:00it will never exist. To note, the fry taxpayers
- 51:05that we discussed a few slides ago, they initially
- 51:07claimed a deduction under this ref rock, and
- 51:10then they abandoned it because without a charge
- 51:13defendant, you can't satisfy the triggering action
- 51:17requirement, and that's not a gap you can paper
- 51:20over. So this shortcut's closed. Now what do
- 51:23we do? Next slide, Phillip. So here, just like
- 51:32the slide says, there's a prosecution gap. The
- 51:36problem is you've got no name defendant. And
- 51:42the DOJ is trying to do more than it used to.
- 51:44The Scam Center Strike Force has brought real
- 51:47cases with real indictments and asset seizures.
- 51:52But that only helps the victims in those specific
- 51:55cases. If your client's scammer isn't on a charging
- 51:59document, it doesn't change anything about the
- 52:01tax analysis. So your client now has to prove
- 52:05theft. the way a prosecutor would, except without
- 52:08subpoena power, without a grand jury, and without
- 52:11law enforcement running this investigation. Now
- 52:15the good news is that evidence in a pig butchering
- 52:17case is way better than evidence in most white
- 52:20collar cases that I prosecuted. Scammer communicated
- 52:24in writing, the money moved through traceable
- 52:26channels, the platform generated its own proof
- 52:30of fraud every time it displayed a fake balance.
- 52:34And these cases generate enormous amounts of
- 52:37evidence, chat logs, blockchain records, screenshots,
- 52:40platform data. The hard part is structuring it,
- 52:44matching the right evidence to the right elements
- 52:46of the statute. Back to you, Philip. Yes, it
- 52:55is generating an enormous amount of evidence,
- 52:58but that evidence is quickly to disappear. So
- 53:01once the client comes to you, make sure that
- 53:03they are securing all these text messages, especially
- 53:06a telegram. Telegram can be deleted from both
- 53:09sides. And signal? Signal to? Signal state. Yeah.
- 53:14So first step is instruct your client to secure
- 53:18all these text messages, all the evidence that
- 53:21you need. FTX is a very good example. I will
- 53:28not go into all these details what FTX is. I
- 53:32just presume that the case went through the media
- 53:34so much that most people are familiar with it.
- 53:39The lesson taken from FTX is much narrower. Do
- 53:42not ignore recovery prospects. In November 2022,
- 53:47the exchange collapsed. The bankruptcy follows.
- 53:50Then we have criminal proceedings. The assets
- 53:52are recovered. The cryptocurrency prices change
- 53:55materially. then there's claims processes. There
- 53:59was an AI investment that they did that went
- 54:03through the roof. And all of a sudden, what didn't
- 54:08look like it in November 2022, all of a sudden,
- 54:12FTX was able to make all the investments whole
- 54:18with an asterisk because what they were able
- 54:22to do is they were repaying what it was worth
- 54:26on November 22. 2022 when they filed bankruptcy,
- 54:31they were not necessarily able to pay everything
- 54:33back that it was worth in 2024 -2025. As mentioned,
- 54:38the Bitcoin price went smooth also. So people
- 54:42often would have been better off if they would
- 54:46have kept their Bitcoin instead of losing it
- 54:48to the FTX bankruptcy. So, well, indeed, years
- 54:55later, the FTX Recovery Trust was still administering
- 54:58allowed disputed claims and distribution. So
- 55:02if the clients say my FTX account became inaccessible
- 55:05in November 2022, therefore I had a complete
- 55:08theft loss in 2022, that might be too much and
- 55:13too fast. We have to look at what recovery rights
- 55:17objectively existed at the end of the relevant
- 55:19year. And the point is not bankruptcy was always
- 55:23precluded a loss. The point is that you cannot
- 55:27analyze the loss while pretending the bankruptcy
- 55:30does not exist. Right. So here we are almost
- 55:37at the bottom of the hour. And I want to talk
- 55:40to you about building the record as best as you
- 55:43can. And here's the framework that I use is one
- 55:46of these cases. Every piece of evidence maps
- 55:49to a specific element of the criminal statute,
- 55:52not to a general story about fraud, to a specific
- 55:56element. But before I walk through the evidence,
- 55:59I want to say something that we talked about
- 56:03at the top of the hour about the clients sitting
- 56:05in front of you. These cases involve an enormous
- 56:10amount of personal shame. Your client just didn't
- 56:14lose a lot of money. They lost confidence in
- 56:17their own judgment. And many of them are embarrassed
- 56:21to tell their spouse, let alone a lawyer. Most
- 56:26people that you will see were substantially,
- 56:29if not completely, financially wiped out. Some
- 56:34of them are even suicidal, and this is not an
- 56:37exaggeration. The FBI data tracks this. So when
- 56:41you ask them to walk you through every message,
- 56:45every transfer, Every moment they believed the
- 56:49lie, you are asking them to relive what may be
- 56:53the worst experience of their life. And we need,
- 56:56as practitioners, to be aware of that. You can
- 57:00build the evidentiary record, but also simultaneously
- 57:03be sensitive to what it costs the client to help
- 57:07you build it. Those aren't in conflict, but it
- 57:11requires some intention. And I do want to highlight
- 57:14one resource worth knowing about is AARP's Fraud
- 57:18Watch Network. And it's not just for people over
- 57:2155. They provide fraud reporting assistance,
- 57:25but also emotional support, counseling, peer
- 57:29support groups, resources to help victims rebuild
- 57:32their financial lives and their confidence. So
- 57:36if your client is struggling beyond the tax issue,
- 57:39please point them to these types of resources.
- 57:43They're free, they're well run, and they fill
- 57:46a gap that lawyers maybe not are the best equipped
- 57:50to fill. Now back to the evidence. Every piece
- 57:55maps to a specific element of the criminal statute.
- 57:58So we're looking at messages like WhatsApp, Telegram,
- 58:02dating apps. These aren't just for context. These
- 58:05are your proof of false representations. The
- 58:08scammer claimed to be someone they weren't. They
- 58:11claimed expertise they didn't have. They directed
- 58:15the victim to a platform that didn't exist. And
- 58:18under Florida law that we reviewed, that's false
- 58:21representation. Under California, that's the
- 58:24pretense. And the messages are their own corroboration
- 58:28under Penal Code Section 1532. So start by organizing
- 58:32everything chronologically. Build a timeline
- 58:35that tracks the full arc of the scheme, from
- 58:38first contact through relationship development
- 58:41to the first mention of investing, the first
- 58:44transfer of funds, the escalation, the denial
- 58:48of withdrawals, and then the disappearance. When
- 58:50you lay it all out that way, you're not just
- 58:53proving fraud, you're proving fraud from inception.
- 58:57You've got wire confirmations and blockchain
- 59:00records, fees. This evidence proves the taking.
- 59:04The money left in your client's account and went
- 59:07somewhere that was not a legitimate trading platform.
- 59:11Blockchain forensics can trace the flow with
- 59:14wallets and layering and conversion. And this
- 59:18evidence shows it wasn't just a bad investment.
- 59:20That's money disappearing into an infrastructure
- 59:23designed to steal it. Now, the platform screenshots
- 59:27are your best evidence of intent. They show fabricated
- 59:30balances, fake transaction histories, and withdrawal
- 59:33denials that demand more money before any funds
- 59:36could be released. Every one of those screens
- 59:39is proof that the platform existed to extract
- 59:42funds, not to invest them. And in California,
- 59:46they serve as corroboration. And then finally,
- 59:50IC3 complaints and police reports serve as a
- 59:53timeline anchor. They prove that your client
- 59:55reported this fraud contemporaneously, not as
- 59:59a failed investment being re -characterized at
- 1:00:02tax time. And that distinction matters when the
- 1:00:05IRS asks why this should be treated as a theft,
- 1:00:08loss, and not a capital loss. So again, build
- 1:00:12the file, you would build your case file, organize
- 1:00:14it chronologically, work through it element by
- 1:00:17element, and map the evidence to each element
- 1:00:19as you go. And that's the file that survives
- 1:00:23exam and what might win if this goes to litigation.
- 1:00:34And you basically wins for most of it. Here we
- 1:00:36have a supporting - Sorry, Philip. Nope, nope,
- 1:00:40nope. That was perfectly. And here we have some
- 1:00:46lists that you might want. I want to, before
- 1:00:49we went off, I promised that we have some questions,
- 1:00:51so I want to turn to the questions. Andrew asked,
- 1:00:54what about inheritance scams? Taxpayers received
- 1:00:58some communications and taxpayers the error before
- 1:01:00and descend in the state, but that there are
- 1:01:02fees, taxes, insurance, clearance, et cetera,
- 1:01:05that must be paid before. Should the payment
- 1:01:08incurred to secure the claimed inheritance satisfies
- 1:01:12the profit requirement for a loss claim? Valerie,
- 1:01:16I'm not sure if you have an opinion on that.
- 1:01:19I find that a very interesting question, but
- 1:01:22I can see both sides of the argument. Yes, which
- 1:01:26one here? The upper one, Andrew. So whether or
- 1:01:32not an inheritance game that you have the inheritance
- 1:01:35and you have to pay before you can get the inheritance,
- 1:01:39whether or not that satisfies the for -profit
- 1:01:42motive. Well, I don't I don't I think for profit
- 1:01:46is you Philip But it does ring a little bit true
- 1:01:51of the pig butchering That each time you make
- 1:01:56a series of payments To try to clear another
- 1:02:01legal obstacle and receive the inheritance I
- 1:02:05would probably want to see like the representations
- 1:02:08made the building of the confidence between yourself
- 1:02:12and this person in the inheritance schemer to
- 1:02:18see if that tracks very similar ideas of pig
- 1:02:24butchering. It can take many forms. It doesn't
- 1:02:28necessarily need to be in the digital crypto
- 1:02:32world, but I would want to see the building of
- 1:02:35that scam and to see if those fees are just fraud
- 1:02:44-induced payments. To get to the core of your
- 1:02:51question, is there a for -profit motive? I don't
- 1:02:54know. I can see both sides of the argument at
- 1:02:58that point. I would have to see if there's any
- 1:03:02case law on that. I'm sorry for that. Then you
- 1:03:07ask, how does evident recovery gathered in civil
- 1:03:11probate financial elder abuse matter fit into
- 1:03:14supporting evidence framework. It depends on
- 1:03:19the evidence. If it supports one of the elements
- 1:03:22we are discussing, yeah, it fits. It helps. Valerie,
- 1:03:28I'm not sure if you have a different opinion
- 1:03:30here. Yeah, I mean, every matter that you are,
- 1:03:39every piece of evidence that you're gathering
- 1:03:41together to prove up the elder abuse, I would
- 1:03:49want to take a look at whether that fits into
- 1:03:53a California theft statute and looking at what
- 1:03:57the false pretenses were and looking at that.
- 1:04:03But that, again, that could be a different manner
- 1:04:05of a scheme. I'm not certain I have too much
- 1:04:09experience in a financial elder abuse matter,
- 1:04:12but I welcome anyone who wants to reach out to
- 1:04:18either of us to see if we can assist in that
- 1:04:21manner. And then Mark here made a comment about
- 1:04:27my old -fashioned false pretense corroboration.
- 1:04:34You're right, Mark, that two witnesses can be
- 1:04:38sufficient to establish a false pretense. I would
- 1:04:45say yes, that victims sharing their experience
- 1:04:49with other corroborating people is definitely
- 1:04:54can fit into that corroboration requirement.
- 1:05:00And definitely they can serve as witnesses. Those
- 1:05:05are great people to corroborate the fact that
- 1:05:08this is happening contemporaneously. So that
- 1:05:13evidence is really priceless. What, and then
- 1:05:18Ian writes here, what, if anything, can you do
- 1:05:22to track down the scammers? The picture is bleak,
- 1:05:27isn't it, Philipp? Things go off chain to different
- 1:05:33unattended wallets almost as quickly as they
- 1:05:37left your bank account. So what you can do when
- 1:05:41you discover the scam is almost its own. presentation.
- 1:05:46So if you want to reach out after so that if
- 1:05:48you want to have a detailed discussion about
- 1:05:49that, we can do that. But just as a quick step,
- 1:05:55reach out to people, for example, California
- 1:05:59DOJ has a cyber crime. They have a prosecutor
- 1:06:02sitting in LA. That would be one of my if if
- 1:06:05it's a California victim, that would be one of
- 1:06:08my first call to go to him and say, Hey, do you
- 1:06:12want to take that matter? Because the most difficult
- 1:06:15part, once you get one of these cases, and it's
- 1:06:19still fresh, still within the first 48 hours,
- 1:06:23is getting people interested in taking these
- 1:06:25cases on. You have firms like Chainalysis, TRM,
- 1:06:31which are crypto tracking firms, and you can
- 1:06:34hire. You have financial investigators who handle
- 1:06:41these kinds of cases. So these are people you
- 1:06:45can reach out to to track down where your crypto
- 1:06:49went, as long as it's still on chain. Sometimes
- 1:06:52it just goes to a bank account somewhere offshore.
- 1:06:55It's just a fake crypto. It's not really a crypto
- 1:06:57account. But as long as it's really on chain,
- 1:07:00you can trace it and it should involve people
- 1:07:02who can trace it. Because the scammer has only
- 1:07:05so much time to really put in the next number
- 1:07:09and to trace to get it to the next wallet. That
- 1:07:12takes time, not long. but time. If you have someone
- 1:07:17who can trace it faster than the scammer can
- 1:07:19move it, you have a chance to still freeze it
- 1:07:23as long as it's on an exchange that collaborates
- 1:07:26with the US. So that you really can track down
- 1:07:32the scammer, him or herself, that will be, I
- 1:07:38would say, very limited expectation of success.
- 1:07:43Often these scammers are victims themselves.
- 1:07:46So the person who is really on the other side
- 1:07:48of the phone, it's not the scammer who's financially
- 1:07:53benefiting from it. It's often a victim of human
- 1:07:57trafficking themselves. We mentioned these compounds
- 1:08:01and we have, let's go to the beginning of the
- 1:08:09first slide, these are hundreds and hundreds
- 1:08:12of people sitting in a room, not as highly sophisticated
- 1:08:17as here, usually in very small rooms without
- 1:08:19air conditioning. And they are getting brutalized,
- 1:08:23they're getting human traffic. So the scammer
- 1:08:29who is on the other side of the phone is not
- 1:08:31the person who financially benefits. It's an
- 1:08:33entire industry in different parts of this world.
- 1:08:39Again, the frontline documentation might help
- 1:08:41there, but limited expectations, getting down
- 1:08:44to the scammer, him or herself. Your expectation
- 1:08:49should be, if you are within the first 48 hours,
- 1:08:52maybe a week, but it gets a little less, is you
- 1:08:58might have a chance of getting these funds frozen
- 1:09:00at some point. That is the highest you want to
- 1:09:05get to. And then from there on, you can think
- 1:09:08about recovery. Right. I just meant, I know we're
- 1:09:11running long. I just met with Chainalysis last
- 1:09:15week about this. And if you're quick to move,
- 1:09:18you're right. There is some effort. It's not
- 1:09:21cheap, though, to trace these things. So if you're
- 1:09:25with a client that has wiped out their entire
- 1:09:28life savings, you're in a different situation
- 1:09:32than perhaps somebody who has a little bit more
- 1:09:35financial means and was also caught in the same
- 1:09:38scheme. Yes, all of this is mostly human trafficking.
- 1:09:45You're right, the person who is on the other
- 1:09:48end isn't the person who's cashing out that wallet.
- 1:09:52Although I did meet with somebody also last week,
- 1:09:55just as a quick aside, there are companies now
- 1:09:58using bots to converse with the schemers' bots.
- 1:10:05and establish a relationship. There's a great
- 1:10:08company that will engage with your text messaging
- 1:10:14person who might be a bot, might be a real person,
- 1:10:17undetermined, and then develop that relationship.
- 1:10:20And once the scammer gives the bank account or
- 1:10:25chain that you want or the crypto wallet that
- 1:10:28they want this person, this potential victim,
- 1:10:32but in disguise, it's a bot for the good good
- 1:10:35guys, they will aggregate that data and send
- 1:10:39it to banks to close their accounts and to make
- 1:10:43sure that those accounts aren't being used to
- 1:10:46perpetrate fraud. So there are very clever people
- 1:10:48in this world who are working to, and not just
- 1:10:52law enforcement, who are working to combat this
- 1:10:54crime. I just like a job to sit there and speak
- 1:10:59with all of these people all day long. That sounds
- 1:11:01to me like an interesting endeavor. One of your
- 1:11:06former colleagues does an air invest. She has
- 1:11:09the operation. Oh, yeah Yeah, well, thanks everybody
- 1:11:14Yeah, thanks to everybody who? Participated and
- 1:11:19listened to our program. I think our matters
- 1:11:22our contact information is in this slides We're
- 1:11:26happy to speak with everyone afterwards and thanks
- 1:11:29for your time