Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Noble Task: The Divine Call, Biblical Character, and Ecclesiastical Recognition of the Elder
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back. You are listening to Reformed
- 0:02Thinking. Today we're opening up a topic
- 0:04that feels, well, it feels weighty.
- 0:06And I don't mean that in a boring, academic way.
- 0:08I mean, it feels heavy, like we're looking at the blueprints
- 0:11for something structurally critical.
- 0:13It definitely has that kind of gravity to it.
- 0:14What we're discussing today isn't just a matter of
- 0:17preference or church style. Our sources treat it as a matter
- 0:21of spiritual life and death for the church.
- 0:24The topic is church leadership and.
- 0:26I want to be really clear for you right at the top about what
- 0:29we're not talking about about we're not doing a deep dive into
- 0:32organizational charts or how to run a nonprofit more
- 0:35efficiently. We are digging into the Biblical
- 0:38office of the Elder. It's one of those topics that I
- 0:42think most people in the church think they have a handle on.
- 0:45You know, you see the elders, maybe their names are in the
- 0:46bulletin. But when you really start to
- 0:48examine what the Bible demands for that office, it's often a
- 0:52world away from what we see practiced.
- 0:55You're so right. And the sources we have in front
- 0:57of us, which lean heavily on First Timothy and Titus, they
- 1:01start by calling us out. Really.
- 1:03They point to this modern tendency to run the church like
- 1:07a secular business, like a startup.
- 1:09Or a social club, or in some cases, a political organization.
- 1:13Yes, we look for the CEO pastor. You know the type I'm talking
- 1:17about. He's got the dynamic
- 1:18personality. He's a visionary, commands a
- 1:20room. He looks good on social media,
- 1:22knows how to build a brand. We want the guy who generates
- 1:25buzz. And that's a great model if
- 1:27you're trying to launch a new sneaker line.
- 1:29But the church isn't a company selling a product.
- 1:33The sources are incredibly clear on this.
- 1:35It's the household of God. And because it's his house, he
- 1:38sets the rules. He provides the blueprints.
- 1:40That's our mission today, to look at those divine blueprints
- 1:43for leadership. So we're intentionally setting
- 1:45aside our cultural ideas of what makes a good leader, and we're
- 1:48submitting ourselves to what Scripture actually says.
- 1:51And the stakes couldn't be higher.
- 1:52This is not about choosing your favorite management style.
- 1:55No, not at all. It's a question of covenantal
- 1:57obedience, and it's about protecting the flock.
- 2:01A flock that we have to remember was purchased with the blood of
- 2:04Christ himself. When the leadership is wrong,
- 2:07either corrupt or just biblically unqualified, the
- 2:10sheep are the ones who get hurt. Let's start unpacking that,
- 2:13because before we get into the fine print of the
- 2:15qualifications, the sources make this massive point about the
- 2:19historical context. They draw a sharp line between a
- 2:22priest and a shepherd. This is such a critical starting
- 2:25point. If you get this wrong,
- 2:27everything that follows will be distorted.
- 2:28So think about the Old Covenant. The central leadership figure
- 2:31was the priest. In the Greek, the word is
- 2:34hierius. Hierius OK and his whole
- 2:36function was mediatorial, right? He was the go between.
- 2:39Exactly. He stood between a holy God and
- 2:41a sinful people, and how did he get the job?
- 2:43It wasn't an internal call. It wasn't because he was a good
- 2:46person or a gifted speaker. It was hereditary.
- 2:50You were a priest because you were born into the tribe of
- 2:52Levi. It was all about your bloodline.
- 2:55Your job was sacrifices, ceremonial purity, and you had
- 2:58restricted access to God's presence.
- 3:00But then with Christ, the whole system changes.
- 3:03The sources describe it as a seismic shift.
- 3:05It's a complete revolution. The veil in the temple is torn
- 3:08in two. The shadows are over.
- 3:10Because the reality Christ has come, and because Christ is our
- 3:14great and final High priest, we no longer need an earthly
- 3:17priesthood. That's why the New Testament
- 3:19never ever uses that word Hierius for a church leader that
- 3:23uses a different word presbyteros Elder.
- 3:26Yeah, that's a distinction that gets blurred so often.
- 3:28I mean, if a church is structured in a way that the
- 3:31pastor is seen as the dispenser of grace, the one you have to go
- 3:34through to get to God, they've effectively hit the rewind
- 3:37button and gone back to the old covenant.
- 3:39They have. That's the core era of
- 3:40Sacredodilism, which you find in its clearest form in Roman
- 3:44Catholicism. The idea that a priest re
- 3:46sacrifices Christ or acts as a necessary channel for grace is
- 3:50something Reformed theology absolutely rejects.
- 3:53There is only one mediator, and it's Jesus.
- 3:55The elder's job isn't to dispense grace, it's to announce
- 3:58the gospel of grace. It's even a change in the
- 4:01primary sense we use in worship, the sources say.
- 4:04We move from a visual spectacle, you know, watching an animal
- 4:07being slaughtered, to an auditory 1.
- 4:10Hearing the word becomes the central act, and This is why the
- 4:13primary metaphor for the elder is an under shepherd, as Peter
- 4:16calls him. He is not the owner of the
- 4:17sheep, he's accountable to the chief shepherd.
- 4:20So his main tool isn't a sacrificial knife, it's the
- 4:23shepherd's staff of Scripture used to guide, comfort and
- 4:26protect the flock. That framing is perfect.
- 4:29So we are not looking for a priest, we are not looking for
- 4:31CEO, we're looking for a shepherd.
- 4:34OK, so let's dive into the text itself.
- 4:36First Timothy 3 verse one. The saying is trustworthy.
- 4:39If anyone aspires to the Office of Overseer, he desires a noble
- 4:43task. Our sources spend a ton of time
- 4:45right here on this idea of the call.
- 4:47As they should, Paul prefaces this by saying the saying is
- 4:50trustworthy. Pistos ho logos.
- 4:52Whenever Paul uses that phrase, he's planting a flag.
- 4:54He's saying pay attention. This is a foundational doctrine,
- 4:57not just my personal advice for your church in Ephesus.
- 5:01And he uses 2 words for this. Desire, aspires and desires.
- 5:07The Greek here is pretty fascinating.
- 5:08The first one is or a Jettai. Or a jettai.
- 5:11The literal picture is to stretch oneself out for
- 5:13something. Imagine reaching for a book on
- 5:16the highest shelf. You're straining, putting an
- 5:19effort to grasp it. It's an active pursuit.
- 5:21And the second word, epithemae, carries the idea of a deep
- 5:25passion, of setting your heart on something.
- 5:27OK, but hold on, let's talk about that for a second.
- 5:28We're in a reformed world here. We believe in God's sovereignty.
- 5:32We're generally pretty wary of human ambition, self promotion,
- 5:35all of that. So how does this idea of a man
- 5:38stretching himself out for an office fit with the idea that
- 5:42God is the one who calls? It sounds a little worldly.
- 5:46It does sound like attention, doesn't it?
- 5:47But the way the sources resolve this is by saying that the
- 5:49desire itself is a work of the Holy Spirit.
- 5:52God's primary way of calling a man is by giving him this holy
- 5:55desire for the work. But, and this is the absolute
- 5:58key, we have to look at what he's desiring.
- 6:00Paul says he desires a noble task.
- 6:03The Greek is Coloss Ergon. And ergon means work.
- 6:06It means work, toil, labor. It implies getting your hands
- 6:10dirty, spending energy, feeling exhausted at the end of the day.
- 6:14So if a man desires the title, if he wants the respect, if he
- 6:17wants the corner office in the church building, but he despises
- 6:21the thought of hours of study, messy counseling and difficult
- 6:24meetings, he is stretching out for the wrong thing.
- 6:27So wanting the platform but not the plow means you're not
- 6:31actually called. That's a great way to put it if
- 6:33you want the microphone but you don't want the towel and basin
- 6:35to wash feet. It isn't a divine calling.
- 6:37It's just human, Edo. The sources use a great term for
- 6:40the biblical model, A pneumatocracy.
- 6:43Rule by the Spirit, yes. Acts 20.28 is so clear.
- 6:46Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock
- 6:49in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers.
- 6:51The Spirit does the appointing. So the church isn't a democracy
- 6:54where we just vote for the most charismatic candidate.
- 6:56And it's not a corporation where you climb the ladder through
- 6:59ambition. It's a pneumatocracy.
- 7:01God sovereignly gives the desire.
- 7:02The Spirit gifts the man, and then the church's job is to
- 7:05recognize what the Spirit has already done.
- 7:08It's a synergy, then the internal call from God and the
- 7:11external confirmation from the church.
- 7:13But before that confirmation happens, there's a list, a
- 7:16checklist. And it's not a list of career
- 7:18accomplishments. It's what our sources call the
- 7:21mirror of the law, the qualifications in First Timothy
- 7:243. And this is where we have to be
- 7:25so careful not to read our own cultural biases into the text.
- 7:29The very first qualification, the one that acts as a sort of
- 7:31canopy over all the rest, is that he must be above reproach.
- 7:35A. Greek word is an epileptos.
- 7:38The definition our sources give is not to be taken hold of or
- 7:41without a handle. That's such a great word
- 7:44picture. It's incredibly vivid.
- 7:46I mean, think of an accuser, whether it's a critic in the
- 7:48community or the accuser, Satan himself, he's looking for a way
- 7:51to grab this man, to get a handle on him and drag his
- 7:54reputation and by extension, the gospel, through the mud.
- 7:57But he can't. There's no glaring sin, no
- 8:00pattern of hypocrisy, no standal to grab onto.
- 8:02So this doesn't mean he's sinless, right?
- 8:05Because if that were the standard, we'd have no elders.
- 8:07No, of course not. Only Christ is sinless.
- 8:09It's about credibility. It means there's no settled,
- 8:12unrepentant pattern of scandalous sin in his life.
- 8:16It means that his life is so consistent that if an accusation
- 8:19were to arise, the natural reaction of those who know Him
- 8:22would be. That just doesn't sound like
- 8:23him. I don't believe it.
- 8:24His character itself becomes his difference.
- 8:27And one of the first places people look for a handle is in a
- 8:30man's home, the text says. He must be the husband of one
- 8:33wife. This line gets a lot of debate.
- 8:36It really does. The literal Greek is MIAs
- 8:38kanikos Andra, which translates to a one woman man.
- 8:42The sources we're using hold to a firm complementarian view here
- 8:46that the office is for qualified man.
- 8:48But this phrase seems to go much deeper than just your marital
- 8:51status or your gender. It's not just a box to check.
- 8:54Not at all. It's a matter of the hearts
- 8:56affections. A man could be married to the
- 8:58same woman for 50 years, but not be a one woman man.
- 9:02If his eyes are constantly wandering, if he's addicted to
- 9:04pornography, if he's nurturing an inappropriate emotional
- 9:08relationship with someone who isn't his wife, he's
- 9:10disqualified. It's a call to singular,
- 9:13faithful devotion in heart, mind and body.
- 9:17And that domestic focus continues with the next
- 9:19qualification managing his own household well.
- 9:23The home is described as the proving ground.
- 9:26The logic Paul lays out is just plain common sense.
- 9:29He basically asks, if a man doesn't know how to manage his
- 9:32own family, how in the world can he take care of God's church?
- 9:35The family is the little church. It's the laboratory where his
- 9:38leadership is tested every single day.
- 9:40Let's make that practical. So you could have a guy who's an
- 9:43amazing project manager at work. He's efficient, he gets results,
- 9:46he's respected in his field. But you go to his house and it's
- 9:49chaos. His kids are out of control,
- 9:51he's emotionally distant from his wife.
- 9:53He's a tyrant. Is he qualified for eldership?
- 9:55Absolutely not. He's disqualified the character
- 9:58traits needed to shepherd a family well.
- 10:00Patience, kindness, consistency, discipline, love are the very
- 10:04same traits needed to shepherd a church.
- 10:06A man who is a bully at home will become a bully in the
- 10:08church. A man who is passive and checked
- 10:11out at home will be a hireling who abandons the flock at the
- 10:14first sign of trouble. That is just such a sobering
- 10:17reality check. It completely flips our modern
- 10:19script for evaluating leaders. We tend to focus almost
- 10:23exclusively on public performance and gifting.
- 10:26Scripture starts with private character and faithfulness.
- 10:28And it gives us both negatives and positives.
- 10:31He must not be a drunkard, not violent, not quarrelsome, not a
- 10:34lover of money. Buddy must be hospitable, A
- 10:36lover of good, self controlled, upright, holy and disciplined.
- 10:40Let's pick up on not violent In the business world, a certain
- 10:44kind of aggressive, domineering leader is sometimes celebrated.
- 10:47They're a hard charger. They take no prisoners.
- 10:50That might get you a promotion in a corporation.
- 10:52But it gets you disqualified in the church, a violent man, and
- 10:57that can mean verbally and emotionally, not just
- 11:00physically, will wound the sheep.
- 11:03The character of an elder must reflect the character of the
- 11:05chief shepherd, who is gentle and lowly in heart.
- 11:09You can't beat the sheep into following you.
- 11:11So after this long list of character traits, we get to the
- 11:14one qualification that is distinctly a skill.
- 11:16It says he must be able to teach the.
- 11:18Tacticos This is the defining gift that separates the office
- 11:22of Elder from the office of Deacon.
- 11:26A Deacon must hold to the faith with a clear conscience, but the
- 11:29elder must be able to explain it, defend it, and apply it.
- 11:32Now, our sources are very specific about what this
- 11:34teaching entails, framing it in what's called the cessationist
- 11:37view. Can you breakdown why that's a
- 11:39relevant distinction here? Yeah, that's a key piece of the
- 11:42theological framework. To be able to teach in the new
- 11:44covenant sense does not mean the elder is receiving new direct
- 11:48revelation from God. He's not a prophet getting
- 11:50downloads from heaven. The conviction here is that the
- 11:53Canon of Scripture is closed, God has spoken fully and finally
- 11:57in His Son, and that word is recorded in the Bible.
- 11:59So if he's not getting new information, what is his
- 12:01teaching job? His job is exposition and
- 12:04preservation. One of the best analogies our
- 12:06sources use was that of a waiter.
- 12:08The elder is not the chef. He didn't create the meal, God
- 12:12did in his word. The elders job is to deliver
- 12:16that meal to the table faithfully.
- 12:18He doesn't add his own spicy opinions because he thinks it's
- 12:20a bit bland. He doesn't remove the hard
- 12:22teachings because he's afraid the diners won't like it.
- 12:25He serves what the chef prepared, pure and
- 12:27unadulterated. I love that analogy, but it's
- 12:30not just about feeding, is it? There's a defensive or polemical
- 12:33aspect to it. Titus 1.9 says he must be able
- 12:37to give instruction and sound doctrine and also to rebuke
- 12:40those who contradict it. Right.
- 12:42The Greek for rebuke is Ellen Shine.
- 12:44It's a strong word. It means to refute, to expose
- 12:46error, to convince the opponent. This is where the shepherd's
- 12:49staff has to become a protective rod.
- 12:52He has to be able to identify and dismantle false teachings
- 12:55that threaten the flock. And the sources give some modern
- 12:57examples, like the prosperity gospel or critical race theory
- 13:00or easy believism, what's called antinomianism.
- 13:03That's right, it's not enough for an elder to be a nice guy
- 13:06who loves Jesus. If he can't open the Bible and
- 13:09clearly, patiently and biblically dismantle the
- 13:12prosperity gospel and shake why it's different gospel, then he
- 13:15is not qualified. He's leaving the sheep
- 13:17vulnerable to wolves. He must have the theological
- 13:20skill and the courage to say that is false, and here's why
- 13:23from Scripture. And the ultimate goal of all
- 13:25this teaching, all this refuting, isn't just to be the
- 13:28smartest guy in the room or win a debate.
- 13:31It has to be Christ centered. Absolutely.
- 13:33It has to be coherent with the whole of Scripture, the analogy
- 13:37of faith, and it must always point to Jesus, like Christ did
- 13:40with the disciples on the road to Emmaus.
- 13:42The elders job is to open up all the scriptures and show how they
- 13:45are about him. If his teaching is just a set of
- 13:47moral rules, be a better person without grounding it in the
- 13:51person and work of Christ. He's not feeding the sheep, he's
- 13:54just giving them a heavier burden to carry.
- 13:56OK, so we've covered the internal call that spear given
- 13:59desire. We've walked through the mirror
- 14:01of the qualifications, that high bar of character, and we've
- 14:04looked at the specific gift of teaching.
- 14:06But a man can't just look at that list, check all the boxes
- 14:09himself, and then declare that he's an elder.
- 14:12No, that would be a disaster. That brings us to the final
- 14:15crucial piece, ecclesiastical recognition, the external call
- 14:20from the church. This is the objective check and
- 14:23balance on a man's subjective, internal sense of calling.
- 14:27There are no lone wolf elders in the New Testament.
- 14:30Authority has to be given by the body.
- 14:31It can't just be taken by an individual.
- 14:33The Bible talks about a period of testing.
- 14:35Let them also be tested first. The Greek word here is dokimazu.
- 14:40Dokimazu. It's a term from metallurgy.
- 14:44It's what you would do to a piece of gold or silver.
- 14:46You'd heat it up. You'd scrutinize it to see if it
- 14:48was pure or if it was full of dross, worthless impurities.
- 14:52So that implies a process that involves some heat, some
- 14:55pressure, some serious examination.
- 14:57And it implies time. This is not something you can do
- 15:01in a couple of interviews over a weekend.
- 15:02You can't dokimazu a man's character by reading his resume.
- 15:06You have to watch him over time. How does he react when he's
- 15:09wrong? How does he handle criticism?
- 15:11How does he serve when no one is watching?
- 15:14It is a prolonged season of observation by the Church.
- 15:17Which leads directly to that very stark warning Paul gives in
- 15:20First Timothy 5.22. Do not be hasty in the laying on
- 15:24of hands. This is one of the most
- 15:25frightening verses for a church leadership team.
- 15:27The prohibition of haste. And Paul gives the reason right
- 15:30after. Nor take part in the sins of
- 15:32others. He's teaching a principle of
- 15:34corporate solidarity. If a church is in a hurry,
- 15:37they're desperate to fill a vacant pulpit, and they rush to
- 15:39ordain an unqualified man. They become partners in his
- 15:42future sins. When he damages the flock, they
- 15:45share in the guilt. They are coinies, partners or
- 15:48sharers in his sin. Wow, that really puts the brakes
- 15:51on the pragmatic temptation to just, you know, get a body in
- 15:54the role. It should.
- 15:55A vacancy in the pulpit is a real problem, but a wolf in the
- 15:58pulpit is the catastrophe. It's always better to wait
- 16:02patiently on the Lord than to hastily install a man who will
- 16:05tear the church apart. So on a practical level, how
- 16:08does this recognition happen? The congregation has a role to
- 16:11play. Yes, the principle is laid out
- 16:13in Acts chapter 6. The apostles tell the people,
- 16:16pick out from among you men of good repute.
- 16:19The congregation, being filled with the Spirit, is given the
- 16:21wisdom to identify men in whom the Spirit is already at work.
- 16:25And this process leads to ordination, the laying on of
- 16:28hands. Right.
- 16:29An ordination is not just a nice ceremony, it's a solemn act of
- 16:32worship. It's the church publicly putting
- 16:34its seal of approval on a man. It's the elder saying on behalf
- 16:38of the whole church, we have tested this man, We recognize
- 16:41God's call on his life. We affirm his character and
- 16:44gifting, and we are now setting him apart and authorizing him to
- 16:47preach the Word and administer the sacraments.
- 16:50It's a weighty covenantal act. When you lay it all out like
- 16:53this, the incredibly high character standard, the
- 16:56necessity of deep biblical knowledge, the long testing
- 17:00period, it just throws into sharp relief how distorted our
- 17:04modern models of leadership can be.
- 17:06Our sources actually identified 4 specific modern distortions
- 17:11that are counterfeits of the biblical model.
- 17:13Yes, and it's good for us to be aware of these.
- 17:15The first one is pragmatism. This is the results oriented
- 17:18approach. The world says if it works it
- 17:21must be right. Growth validates the leader.
- 17:24And Scripture says do not be hasty.
- 17:27It says fruitfulness takes time. You can have a church that is
- 17:29growing numerically with a big budget and lots of programs, but
- 17:32be spiritually toxic. Administrative success is not
- 17:35the same thing as spiritual maturity.
- 17:37We have to remember that cancer also grows quickly.
- 17:40The. 2nd distortion is celebrity culture.
- 17:42This one is everywhere in our time.
- 17:44The world equates fitness for leadership with platform size,
- 17:47social media followers and brand recognition.
- 17:50If a guy is famous, he must be qualified.
- 17:52But Scripture points us in the opposite direction.
- 17:55It says leadership is demonstrated in quiet holiness
- 17:58and faithfulness in the home. That's right, the elder is
- 18:01called to be a local example, not a global performer.
- 18:05And celebrity culture is so dangerous because it often
- 18:08insulates a leader from real accountability.
- 18:10He becomes too big to fail. But in God's economy, the leader
- 18:14is the one who should be under the most scrutiny, not the
- 18:17least. OK, the third distortion is
- 18:19mysticism. This is the person who plays the
- 18:21God told Me card. They say God has called me to be
- 18:24the pastor here, so who are you to question it?
- 18:26It's a way of short circuiting the whole testing process.
- 18:29It is. It tries to substitute a private
- 18:32subjective experience for the objective public standards of
- 18:36Scripture and the confirmation of the church.
- 18:39But the Bible tells us to test the spirits.
- 18:42A true call from God will always humble itself and submit to the
- 18:45testing process. A man who refuses to be tested
- 18:48because he claims a special word from God has already revealed A
- 18:51disqualifying level of pride. And the final one, moral
- 18:55minimalism. This is the mindset that says,
- 18:58well, as long as he hasn't committed a felony or had a
- 19:00major public scandal, he's good to go.
- 19:03It prioritizes talent over character.
- 19:05You hear it all the time. Yeah, he can be a bit arrogant
- 19:08or he's not great with people, but man, can he preach.
- 19:12That's moral minimalism in a nutshell.
- 19:14But the biblical standard isn't not a criminal.
- 19:16The standard is above reproach. Character is the non negotiable
- 19:21foundation. If that foundation has cracks,
- 19:24it doesn't matter how beautiful the rest of the building looks,
- 19:27it will eventually collapse. This is all incredibly
- 19:30challenging. It really forces you to take a
- 19:32hard look at what we value and prioritize in our churches.
- 19:35It should. It should change everything, how
- 19:38we pray for potential leaders, how we identify them and how we
- 19:41train them up over the long haul.
- 19:43So let's bring this all home. What's the application for you
- 19:45listening today? Well, if you're a man who feels
- 19:48that desire that aregitai to be an elder, the message is this.
- 19:53Pursue the qualifications, not the office.
- 19:56Focus on becoming the man the Bible describes.
- 19:58Work on your character, your marriage, your family, your
- 20:01knowledge of the Word. Serve faithfully where you are
- 20:04and trust God to open the door in His time and trust His Church
- 20:07to recognize His work in you. And for those already in church
- 20:10leadership? The application is to build
- 20:13slow, patient pathways for developing leaders.
- 20:16Resist the urge to be hasty. Take the time to Dokimasu to
- 20:20really test men and value holiness more than you value
- 20:24charisma. And for everyone else, the
- 20:26person in the Pew. Pray.
- 20:28Pray for the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers and learn
- 20:31to value the right things. Don't be drawn to the flashy
- 20:34celebrity pastor. Instead, learn to cherish the
- 20:37faithful, perhaps even boring shepherd who week after week
- 20:41simply opens the Word and feeds your soul.
- 20:43That is how a church stays healthy.
- 20:45The process God designed is benevolent, not bureaucratic.
- 20:49It's Christ who calls. It's Scripture that qualifies,
- 20:51and it's the church that recognizes.
- 20:53And the final thought from the sources is the ultimate
- 20:55motivation is from first Peter 5.
- 20:58The reward for this difficult work isn't a bigger church or a
- 21:01book deal. The reward is that when the
- 21:03chief shepherd appears, the faithful under shepherd will
- 21:05receive the unfading crown of glory.
- 21:08And that's the only approval we're having a.
- 21:10Perfect place to end. Thanks for joining us for this
- 21:12deep dive into the Shepherd's mandate.
- 21:14A high calling indeed. It certainly is.
- 21:16We'll see you next time on reformed thinking.