Latest / Space Nuts: Astronomy Insights & Cosmic Discoveries / M87’s Black Hole Confirmed & A Missing Exoplanet: Cosmic Mysteries Solved
Transcript
- 0:00Andrew Dunkley: Hi there. Thanks for joining us. This is
- 0:02Space Nuts and we are here to
- 0:04talk astronomy and space science. My name is
- 0:07Andrew Dunkley, your host and, uh, it's good
- 0:09to have your company. Uh, coming up on this
- 0:12episode, we're going to revisit,
- 0:14uh, the event of 2019, where the event
- 0:17Horizon Telescope, uh, caught
- 0:20an image of the black hole at the centre of
- 0:23the M M87 galaxy. So
- 0:26why has it come up again in the news now?
- 0:28Well, it's taken all this time to confirm the
- 0:31image, believe it or not. We'll tell you all
- 0:33about that. That's a big, uh, big story. Uh,
- 0:35and with a very strong Australian connection,
- 0:38we're also going to look at, uh, something
- 0:41a little bit different. Uh, an exoplanet
- 0:44that's been observed for the last, uh,
- 0:46several years, which vanished.
- 0:51So where did it go? What did it do? Maybe it
- 0:53didn't like being watched. We will tell you
- 0:56all about that. And would you like to send
- 0:58your name, uh, on the Dragonfly
- 1:01mission? You can do that. We'll tell you all
- 1:03about it. If you're looking on YouTube, you
- 1:05can see behind me. I've already got my
- 1:07boarding pass. That's all coming up on this
- 1:10episode of space nuts.
- 1:12Generic: 15 seconds. Guidance is internal.
- 1:1410, 9. Ignition
- 1:17sequence start.
- 1:18Generic: Space nuts.
- 1:19Generic: 5, 4, 3. 2. 1, 2, 3, 4,
- 1:225, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. Space
- 1:25nuts. Astronauts report it feels good.
- 1:28Andrew Dunkley: And joining us again is the one and only
- 1:30Professor Fred Watson Watson, astronomer at
- 1:32large. Hello, Fred Watson.
- 1:34Professor Fred Watson: Hi, Andrew. Good to see you again.
- 1:36Andrew Dunkley: See you too.
- 1:36Professor Fred Watson: Good to see you. Good to see your boarding
- 1:39pass. When do you. When do you actually
- 1:40depart?
- 1:41Andrew Dunkley: I can't read the date. It's because
- 1:44on my image it's actually backwards. So, um,
- 1:46that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it. Hang
- 1:48on, let me have a look. July
- 1:512028 is the scheduled departure.
- 1:55Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. Now that's, uh, an interesting date
- 1:58month, uh, because it's the month that we
- 1:59have the Australia wide eclipse, the total
- 2:02eclipse of the sun that will bring
- 2:05pretty well the whole population of the Earth
- 2:07to Australia to watch it.
- 2:09Andrew Dunkley: To Dubbo.
- 2:10Professor Fred Watson: To
- 2:10Andrew Dunkley: Dubbo.
- 2:11Professor Fred Watson: Yes.
- 2:12Andrew Dunkley: We're watching now.
- 2:13Professor Fred Watson: So I hope there'll be
- 2:16somebody left to light the fuse for, um,
- 2:18Dragonfly when, uh, it lifts
- 2:20Andrew Dunkley: off. Yeah, that's right. It is that date.
- 2:22Yeah. Um, now I'm looking
- 2:25forward to that. It's going to be a huge,
- 2:27huge day. Hopefully the weather will be good.
- 2:29It'll be cold that time of year,
- 2:32but, uh, it will be really exciting
- 2:34to have that happen locally. I
- 2:37Think it'll cross the entire continent from
- 2:39the northwest in Western Australia across
- 2:42the Red Centre. Um,
- 2:45excuse the noise, I've got a window open to
- 2:47keep cool and I have
- 2:50no idea what that is.
- 2:53Um, anyway, uh, that'll be a really exciting
- 2:56event in July 2028, um,
- 2:59uh, with the uh, eclipse, uh, crossing
- 3:02Central Australia, then, uh, blacking out the
- 3:04town of Bourke and then Dubbo and then
- 3:06Sydney. Sydney will get it. Which
- 3:09reminds me of the event back in the 70s where
- 3:11Melbourne was blacked out by a total solar
- 3:14eclipse.
- 3:151974. Ish.
- 3:18Six, was it six? Might have been six. Yeah. I
- 3:20remember, uh, we had to, uh, go down and stay
- 3:23with a friend. We um, were only kids, so we
- 3:26were um, put in charge of a friend
- 3:29of the family because Mum and dad had an
- 3:30event to go to and they wouldn't let us
- 3:33outside because
- 3:36Professor Fred Watson: they
- 3:37Andrew Dunkley: just wouldn't let us outside.
- 3:40Professor Fred Watson: It's one of the challenges we have on the
- 3:42eclipse working group for the Astronomical
- 3:44Society of Australia is getting the message
- 3:46across that um, you know, the time when
- 3:49you need the filters and things is
- 3:51most of it, but there's that few minutes
- 3:54in the middle when you can look directly at
- 3:57the sun and um, everybody should see that.
- 4:02It's such a, uh, rare sight to be seeing
- 4:05the sun. Exactly. Blacked out with the corona
- 4:07shining around it. It's quite spine tingling.
- 4:09Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. One of the great coincidences,
- 4:12um, in astronomy is that uh, the
- 4:15distance of the moon from Earth
- 4:18versus the distance of sun from
- 4:21the uh, Earth, they're relatively the same
- 4:23size and yeah,
- 4:25Professor Fred Watson: so, yeah, it's 400 times. The moon's
- 4:28400 times smaller and on average 400 times
- 4:31nearer. So that is one
- 4:34doozy of a coincidence. Crazy
- 4:35Andrew Dunkley: science, isn't it? It really is,
- 4:37Professor Fred Watson: yeah. Yeah.
- 4:38Andrew Dunkley: Uh, anyway, we'll get to the boarding pass
- 4:40later, but let's, let's get on,
- 4:43let's get started.
- 4:44Let's get on to this really good story which
- 4:46broke three o' clock this morning, our time.
- 4:49Um, by the time you hear this, that'll be
- 4:52five or six years ago. Uh, no, um,
- 4:54but this involves the uh, first
- 4:57ever image of a black
- 5:00hole. The M M87, um,
- 5:03galaxy's black hole centre, uh,
- 5:06was imaged back in 2019, but
- 5:08here we are talking about it again because
- 5:11it's finally been confirmed through
- 5:14scientific work at the csiro. Is that.
- 5:17What? Am I right about that? Have I got that
- 5:19right?
- 5:20Professor Fred Watson: That's exactly right, Andrew. Okay,
- 5:21Andrew Dunkley: the next
- 5:22Professor Fred Watson: story
- 5:22Andrew Dunkley: we're going to talk about today is. No, I'M
- 5:24Professor Fred Watson: kidding. Well,
- 5:27there's not that much more to say except it
- 5:29is, um, you know, it's a remarkable story
- 5:32of, uh, Australian ingenuity. I think we
- 5:35can say that this is a very small team
- 5:37compared with the cast of thousands that were
- 5:39involved in securing the image. Uh,
- 5:41originally, uh, if I remember rightly, there
- 5:44were nine radio astronomy
- 5:46observatories, uh, are all
- 5:49working together. Um, they were all on one
- 5:52side of the Earth. Sadly, that did not
- 5:53include any of the Australian radio astronomy
- 5:56observatories because we were facing the
- 5:58other way. Um, but, um, I do
- 6:01remember the crucial aspect of it was,
- 6:04uh, to get the timing right. Uh,
- 6:06and I think for that reason, if I remember it
- 6:09kind of dragging up now, memories from
- 6:122019, um, I think there were
- 6:15all these atomic clocks that were taken to
- 6:17each of the observatories so that they were
- 6:19all synchronised. And uh, that meant that the
- 6:22timing was able to be used in order to
- 6:25actually secure these observations.
- 6:28I mean, it is an extraordinary,
- 6:31uh, observation to make. And
- 6:34that's why the Event Horizon Telescope image,
- 6:37and that's Event Horizon Telescope was this
- 6:40configuration of all these different radio
- 6:42observatories. That's where their image is so
- 6:46remarkable. Uh, um, one of the
- 6:48CSIRO team has
- 6:51commented that, um, basically,
- 6:54um, in terms of the sort of
- 6:57scale of what's happening, uh, it's like
- 6:59standing in your backyard. This is a quote.
- 7:02It's like standing in your backyard and
- 7:04trying to take a photo of a doughnut on the
- 7:06moon. That's the same
- 7:10angular resolution.
- 7:11Andrew Dunkley: Orange frosted doughnut.
- 7:14Professor Fred Watson: Orange frosted. That's right. Yes, it was.
- 7:15And a bit thicker on one side than the other.
- 7:18Um, so what's, um,
- 7:21the reason why this is big time and it
- 7:22actually is a headline paper in uh, Nature
- 7:25magazine this morning. Uh, I was very
- 7:27impressed with that to see our, uh, science
- 7:29agency getting the accolades on a global
- 7:32scale. Um,
- 7:36the quote in the press release is that the
- 7:39new approach reduces the effect
- 7:42of calibration errors and
- 7:44subjective image processing decisions which
- 7:47have challenged astronomers for decades. Uh,
- 7:50and I might just continue. The quote from
- 7:52this is from one of the scientists involved
- 7:54at csiro. Our small Australian team
- 7:58developed advanced machine learning and
- 8:00artificial intelligence techniques to capture
- 8:03the information about the black hole
- 8:05structure and, um, filter out atmospheric
- 8:07interference. When we applied it to the
- 8:10original Event Horizon telescope data set,
- 8:13we found a black hole almost identical in
- 8:15size and shape as the historic EHT image.
- 8:18Importantly, um, our model had no idea of
- 8:21what a black hole looked like when we applied
- 8:24to the M87 data. This is the first truly
- 8:27independent validation of the EHT
- 8:30image, an important step in the scientific
- 8:31process and that, uh, you know, one has to
- 8:34applaud these scientists for taking that
- 8:36step.
- 8:36Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, and you just said the golden words. Uh,
- 8:40it's a very important step in the
- 8:42scientific process because you can discover
- 8:44something, but it's not really discovered
- 8:47until someone else can
- 8:50ratify your findings.
- 8:53Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's
- 8:53Andrew Dunkley: right.
- 8:54Professor Fred Watson: That's right. In fact, I've been, um,
- 8:57doing, uh, a historical talk
- 9:00not very long ago that's on exactly that. And
- 9:03that's because, uh, with the General Theory
- 9:05of relativity published in 1915, um,
- 9:08we all think that the 1919 eclipse
- 9:11was the one that, uh, demonstrated
- 9:15the movement in the apparent position of
- 9:17stars around the eclipsed sun. That told you
- 9:19that relativity, uh, was correct. But in,
- 9:23um, that was an observation probably very
- 9:26similar in impact and
- 9:28impetus to what we're talking about with the
- 9:30Event Horizon Telescope. But a lot of people
- 9:32didn't believe it, um, and that's partly
- 9:34because some of the data were thrown away
- 9:37because of faulty focus. And it was only in
- 9:391922 and there was an eclipse, uh,
- 9:42in Australia very similar to the one we're
- 9:45gonna see in 2028 that was thoroughly well
- 9:47observed. And sure enough, it
- 9:50independently proved the existence or the
- 9:53correctness of General rel in perhaps
- 9:56a similar way to what this CSIRO work has
- 9:59demonstrated with the M87 black hole,
- 10:02uh, image, uh, which is quite remarkable. I
- 10:05mean, the image itself is dramatic
- 10:08with that ring, um, being a, ah,
- 10:11genuine astrophysical feature, uh,
- 10:13rather than something that's introduced
- 10:15during, you know, during the image
- 10:17processing.
- 10:17Andrew Dunkley: So has the CSIRO released an image?
- 10:22Professor Fred Watson: There are images, yes. I'm sorry, I didn't
- 10:24actually attach, uh, one to the
- 10:27image. But there are images. Yeah, you'll
- 10:29find it very quickly. In fact, there's a
- 10:31movie as well, um, which I haven't
- 10:34really looked at in detail, so I'm not sure
- 10:36exactly what that's depicting. But the main
- 10:38image is very similar. Uh, even though
- 10:41it's completely independently arrived at the
- 10:44main image is very similar to what we were
- 10:46talking about, uh, back in the day in
- 10:492019.
- 10:50Andrew Dunkley: Okay. Uh, yeah, if you do a CSIRO
- 10:53M, uh, M87 black hole image search on Google
- 10:56or any search engine, you will find it.
- 10:59I just found it, uh, then, and it is. Yeah,
- 11:02you can see that it's an exact
- 11:04replica. Really isn't.
- 11:07Professor Fred Watson: Looks a bit sharper to me, but maybe. Yeah,
- 11:09you're right. Yeah,
- 11:12Andrew Dunkley: yeah. Uh, and of course we've since
- 11:15Got an image of the um, of Sagittarius
- 11:18A, haven't we?
- 11:20Professor Fred Watson: We have indeed, that's correct, yes.
- 11:22Andrew Dunkley: Have we taken any others? I don't think it's
- 11:24that easy is it?
- 11:25Professor Fred Watson: That's right because what you're doing is
- 11:28you're seizing half the world's radio
- 11:29telescopes and um, making them look
- 11:32at something and coordinate in a way that I
- 11:35think is quite extraordinary. They don't
- 11:37normally do that sort of coordination with
- 11:39the atomic clocks and things that I was
- 11:41talking about. So yeah, remarkable
- 11:44observations
- 11:45Andrew Dunkley: indeed. And they've published their findings
- 11:48in Nature and it's fresh uh,
- 11:51news. It should be popping up on quite a few
- 11:53science platforms if you want to look for it.
- 11:55But uh, M87
- 11:58black uh, hole image has been confirmed by
- 12:01the CSIRO in Australia.
- 12:03This is Space Nuts, you're with Andrew
- 12:05Dunkley and Professor Fred Watson Watson.
- 12:10Voice Over Guy: 0G and I feel fine. Space
- 12:12Nuts.
- 12:13Andrew Dunkley: Okay Fred Watson, uh, from ah, something
- 12:16at the M. M87 galaxy to an
- 12:18exoplanet designated TOI
- 12:212535b which
- 12:24they've been looking at for quite a while
- 12:26until they couldn't look at it anymore
- 12:28because it disappeared. Uh,
- 12:31what's the story here?
- 12:33Professor Fred Watson: Um, yeah, so toi, uh, target of
- 12:36interest M. It basically
- 12:39was one of the uh, I think it was discovered
- 12:42actually by the Kepler uh, spacecraft
- 12:45and then followed up by NASA's
- 12:48Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite or
- 12:50TESS, which m observed it
- 12:53for well 7um
- 12:56between April 2019 the ELT
- 12:59year if I put it that way, um, not the
- 13:02ELT, I mean the EHT uh year,
- 13:05um that uh, uh between 2019
- 13:08and uh, 2026. And the
- 13:11thing about this planet is it
- 13:14goes round its parent star in eight and
- 13:17a quarter Earth days. So
- 13:20it's whizzing around which means it's a ah,
- 13:22hot Jupiter. It's very close
- 13:24Andrew Dunkley: to the
- 13:25Professor Fred Watson: star. Yeah. And so um,
- 13:28uh the way
- 13:31you observe a planet like this is to
- 13:35watch it transiting uh, in front of
- 13:37its parent star. That means the parent star's
- 13:40light dims very slightly. Uh, it's only
- 13:43a small amount in the case of Jupiter passing
- 13:45in front of the sun. If you were looking at
- 13:47that from outside the solar system, you'd see
- 13:49it dimmed the Sun's light dim by 1%.
- 13:52Uh, it's that sort of level. Um and so
- 13:55um, these are quite difficult observations.
- 13:58But what always clinches it with an
- 14:00exoplanet is when you can determine a
- 14:03period. As I've said, this is eight and a
- 14:05quarter Earth days. Uh, that's how long it
- 14:07takes the thing to go around once. So you get
- 14:09a transit across the planet,
- 14:13across the star. The star's light dims
- 14:15slightly. Eight and a quarter days later, the
- 14:17same thing happens. And that repeatedly
- 14:19happens over seven years. So you pretty sure
- 14:22that this is something stable. But here's the
- 14:24mystery. Then it stops.
- 14:26Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, I mean, eight and a quarter days
- 14:29orbit is a very good candidate for
- 14:31observation because you get to see it quite a
- 14:33lot.
- 14:34Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's right. Um, however,
- 14:37there's a tweak to it and that
- 14:40is, um, that when these. Because
- 14:43it's been observed so thoroughly, it means
- 14:45you can really look at the details. And
- 14:49apparently TOI
- 14:502535b, this planet we're
- 14:53talking about, quite often it would
- 14:56cross, um, its star's disc
- 14:59six hours early or sometimes
- 15:02six hours late. And that
- 15:05means that something else is happening
- 15:08here. Um, and
- 15:11so that, um, change in the time of
- 15:14transit, the occasional changes in the
- 15:17time of transit, suggests that there
- 15:19is another planet in that system
- 15:23that may not be in an
- 15:26orbit that passes in front of the star,
- 15:29which is the key thing here. If that's in an
- 15:32orbit that's slightly tilted, then you don't
- 15:34see it crossing the other star. But if you've
- 15:36got funny effects happening to your target of
- 15:39interest, 23, 53, 25,
- 15:4135B, then, um,
- 15:44that's telling you that there is something
- 15:46else there. And so the
- 15:49fact that perhaps, uh, there is a
- 15:51tilt in the orbit of this, um,
- 15:54invisible or unseen planet, it
- 15:57suggests that maybe the gravitational pull
- 16:00has pulled TOI
- 16:022535B out of
- 16:05its existing orbit. And so,
- 16:08um, it no longer passes in front of its
- 16:11parent star, which is why it is apparently
- 16:13disappeared.
- 16:14Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. Could it have just been bumped out of
- 16:17the way by something? Is that possible?
- 16:19Professor Fred Watson: But yeah, by the other planet, the invisible
- 16:22planet that we don't see. It's been. I mean,
- 16:23I'm
- 16:24Andrew Dunkley: talking collision rather than tug of war.
- 16:26Professor Fred Watson: No, no, I think it's. I, um, think the
- 16:29thinking is it's very much a tug of war
- 16:31rather than a. Rather than a, uh, uh,
- 16:33Andrew Dunkley: collision. It's been yanked out of position
- 16:36and.
- 16:36Professor Fred Watson: Exactly.
- 16:37Andrew Dunkley: Yeah.
- 16:38Professor Fred Watson: Um, there is a nice quote from Samuel, uh,
- 16:40Yee, who's, uh, University of California, one
- 16:43of the, uh, members of the team. Uh, we think
- 16:46of the universe as resembling clockwork.
- 16:47Well, actually, I don't, but most people
- 16:49perhaps do where everything is regular. But
- 16:52that's not true. If there are multiple
- 16:54planets in a system, they can affect each
- 16:56Other's orbits. We know of a few systems that
- 16:58are like this, but this is the most extreme
- 17:00example we've seen. Because the two planets
- 17:03are interacting so strongly, the planet's
- 17:06orbit is tilting so quickly
- 17:09that its transit disappeared while we were
- 17:11watching. Quite remarkable. And it's amazing
- 17:14to think of that whole planet having its
- 17:16orbit shifted by something else that we don't
- 17:19see.
- 17:20Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, it certainly goes to show how much
- 17:23power there is out there in
- 17:26terms of the gravitational forces at play,
- 17:28doesn't it?
- 17:30Professor Fred Watson: Uh, yes, that's right, it does. It tells you
- 17:33gravity is pretty strong, um, even though
- 17:35it's the weakest of all the fundamentals,
- 17:37mental forces. But so what
- 17:39happens when scientists find something like
- 17:42this? They build models, as you would.
- 17:45Uh, and so what they've done is they've
- 17:47modelled, um, this
- 17:50change in the tilt of the orbit of the
- 17:53planet, uh, and looked at
- 17:56how that might play out in the future. Ah.
- 17:59And they are saying they think it'll come
- 18:01back maybe something upwards of
- 18:0430 years time. We might start to see it
- 18:06again. But the other possibility, and
- 18:09everybody will be looking out for this, you
- 18:11can be sure that neighbour that
- 18:14pulled it out of its normal
- 18:16orbit might also start crossing
- 18:19the face of the star. So we might eventually
- 18:22be able to see the object that has
- 18:23gravitationally shifted, uh,
- 18:262535 B into its new
- 18:28orbit. We might be able to see them both, not
- 18:30necessarily simultaneously, but, um,
- 18:33know what they are. Guess the way you
- 18:35distinguish one from the other is that if
- 18:38that invisible planet is a different size
- 18:41from uh, 2535 B
- 18:43then uh, it will give you a different
- 18:46signal as it crosses the disc of the star.
- 18:49Because, uh, a bigger planet will give a
- 18:52deeper, uh, um, darkening of the
- 18:55star's brightness.
- 18:57Andrew Dunkley: And just to throw a spanner into the works
- 18:59and confuse people. Cause we get questions
- 19:01about this type of thing. This all happened
- 19:031000 years ago.
- 19:06Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's right. Uh, but I
- 19:08remember it quite well. Andrew, you know,
- 19:11Andrew Dunkley: he beat me to it.
- 19:15Yeah, it's. It's crazy though, isn't it that,
- 19:17um, everything we look at is history, Even,
- 19:19Even the moon.
- 19:20Professor Fred Watson: It is, yes. Um, we might, yes,
- 19:23we might talk about that a bit later on
- 19:26because in our next episode, I think we've
- 19:28got some upcoming questions that. Look at
- 19:30that.
- 19:30Andrew Dunkley: We probably have. Yes, we do get questions
- 19:33about that, that kind of thing a lot. But uh,
- 19:36if you'd like to read about it, it's on the
- 19:37space.com website. I'm sure there's
- 19:40a published paper of some kind somewhere or
- 19:43they've just released a statement at this
- 19:44stage, perhaps, or a media release. But, um,
- 19:47yeah, it's a really fascinating story about
- 19:49TOI, uh,
- 19:522535B. Such, uh,
- 19:55complicated names. I can never remember them
- 19:57either, for some reason.
- 19:58This is Space Nuts. You're with Andrew
- 20:01Dunkley and Professor Fred Watson Watson.
- 20:05Generic: Hey, that's one of the better sims, believe
- 20:07me. We've had a couple of cardiac arrests
- 20:09down here too, Pete. There wasn't any tiny
- 20:11for that up here.
- 20:13Voice Over Guy: Space Nuts.
- 20:15Andrew Dunkley: Our last story, Fred Watson, uh,
- 20:18is a NASA story. It's about an
- 20:20upcoming mission called the Dragonfly
- 20:22mission. Uh, but the difference with this
- 20:25is, uh. It's not,
- 20:28um, a media release
- 20:30that, uh, has been sent out by NASA saying,
- 20:32this is what we're doing, this is how we're
- 20:34doing it, this is why we're doing it. This is
- 20:36all about. This is a different way of
- 20:38publicising an event by getting people
- 20:41involved. And I've fallen
- 20:43for it hook, line and sinker.
- 20:47Professor Fred Watson: That's good.
- 20:49Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. I did have an image. I did have
- 20:52an image behind me of my boarding pass for
- 20:54the Dragonfly mission. But, um,
- 20:57I'd say there was an Internet glitch that's
- 20:59knocked it off. So I'm back to looking
- 21:02at my boring office.
- 21:04Professor Fred Watson: Um, it's not that boring. It's not as
- 21:07boring as mine is. Probably
- 21:09Andrew Dunkley: yours. It's got books. Mine. Mine's just got
- 21:12a fan.
- 21:14Professor Fred Watson: My
- 21:15Andrew Dunkley: only fan.
- 21:16Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. And yes, your only fan. It's got a lot
- 21:18of your microphone in as well.
- 21:20Andrew Dunkley: Yes. If I push it away, you won't be able to
- 21:23hear me. That's the problem.
- 21:24Professor Fred Watson: We've had that conversation before. Anyway,
- 21:27returning to your Dragonfly boarding pass.
- 21:30I'm sorry, I scuppered that. There
- 21:31Andrew Dunkley: it
- 21:32Professor Fred Watson: was. Because I was, um, looking for it in the
- 21:34background and couldn't see it. But you've
- 21:36got. It means that, uh,
- 21:39your name will. As I understand it, I
- 21:42think it'll be inscribed on,
- 21:45um, a chip of some sort. Uh, whether it's
- 21:48a digital chip that'll be
- 21:51put into digitally or whether it's something
- 21:54that it'll be inscribed on the outside of.
- 21:56Um, I don't know. But that means
- 21:59that Andrew Dunkley is going to
- 22:01Saturn. Yes,
- 22:03Andrew Dunkley: M.
- 22:04Professor Fred Watson: Uh, so, uh,
- 22:07if anybody else. I'm
- 22:09Andrew Dunkley: going to drag and drop the boarding pass to
- 22:11our live audience so that they can see it.
- 22:14Professor Fred Watson: You're going to drag and drop it rather than
- 22:15Dragonfly it?
- 22:17Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. Well, I could do both. No, I don't
- 22:19think I can. Don't think I can.
- 22:24Professor Fred Watson: Never Mind.
- 22:24Andrew Dunkley: Sorry, go on. I keep interrupting.
- 22:26Professor Fred Watson: It is quite all right. No, it's an
- 22:28interruptible story is this, uh, I was just
- 22:30going to say if anybody um, in our um, you
- 22:33know, the three people who listen to
- 22:34Spacenuts, if any them want to join
- 22:37Andrew Dunkley on um, the Dragonfly
- 22:40spacecraft, you've got to do it before the
- 22:4115th of January 2027. But you can do it
- 22:44by um, heading to NASA's
- 22:47Dragonfly, uh, website. I haven't got a link
- 22:50directly here but it'll be very easy to find.
- 22:53Andrew Dunkley: NASA.govdragonfly
- 22:56we'll do
- 22:56Professor Fred Watson: it. It's pretty easy. Yeah,
- 22:57Andrew Dunkley: yeah.
- 22:58Professor Fred Watson: Um, so that's the story with the
- 23:01uh, I guess with the boarding pass and the
- 23:04names going on board the spacecraft. And I
- 23:05think you're absolutely right Andrew. That's
- 23:08way for NASA to publicise this mission.
- 23:11Um, but I think what's more, in many ways
- 23:14more heart stopping is the mission itself.
- 23:17Uh, because this is going to be the second
- 23:19helicopter that humankind has
- 23:22ever sent into space. I believe it's an
- 23:24octocopter. It's a drone, very
- 23:27sophisticated looking drone, uh, which
- 23:30will benefit from the fact that Titan has a
- 23:33thick atmosphere. If I remember rightly, it's
- 23:35about 50% higher uh, in pressure than
- 23:38ours is on Earth. It's pretty
- 23:41opaque, um, at least seen from above. You
- 23:43really can't see much of the surface of
- 23:45Titan, which is how we know so
- 23:48much about it because of radar measurements
- 23:50rather than direct imaging. And Titan, just
- 23:53to throw in um, a. Ah, quick backstory.
- 23:56Is the biggest moon of Saturn, second biggest
- 23:58moon in the solar system, bigger than the
- 24:00planet Mercury, and has a frozen
- 24:03solid water surface ice, uh,
- 24:06at minus 200 or so degrees Celsius,
- 24:09um, and that behaves like rock. And in the
- 24:12depressions in that surface there are lakes
- 24:15and seas of liquid natural gas,
- 24:17ethane and methane. What a fantastic place
- 24:20to send um, a drone to,
- 24:24to scout out what there is there, uh, and
- 24:27how things look on the surface of a moon
- 24:30so different from our own planet and yet
- 24:33sharing the one thing that's different about
- 24:35our planet, which is a liquid surface
- 24:38in equilibrium with its atmosphere. These
- 24:40lakes and seas, quite remarkable,
- 24:43Andrew Dunkley: you know when you're getting close to Titan
- 24:45because there's a warning sign that says
- 24:46flammable liquid.
- 24:48Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's right. Do not drop a
- 24:51match.
- 24:52Andrew Dunkley: I don't think you're allowed to take anything
- 24:54like matches or
- 24:55Professor Fred Watson: uh,
- 24:56Andrew Dunkley: fire starters or anything like that.
- 24:58Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, you're probably pretty safe. Cause I
- 25:00don't think there's any oxygen in its
- 25:01atmosphere. So
- 25:03Andrew Dunkley: uh, it's a strange place and it's one of the
- 25:05places in the solar system where they're
- 25:07considering there could be different
- 25:10forms of life that have adapted to such
- 25:14an unusual environment. At least unusual to
- 25:16us.
- 25:17Professor Fred Watson: Yes, uh, you're right. Who knows?
- 25:21But it's one of the places, you know, when we
- 25:23talk about, um, the mantra for astrobiology
- 25:26is follow the water. Uh, and people
- 25:29say, oh, well, are you thinking about the
- 25:31possibility of non water based life forms?
- 25:34And Titan is exactly where people think about
- 25:36that because liquid ethane and methane might
- 25:39well be um, uh, a working
- 25:42fluid for a very unusual form of life.
- 25:44And um, you know, it might be crawling all
- 25:46over the Dragonfly by the time we uh, get the
- 25:49spacecraft, uh, to have a look around.
- 25:52Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, who knows? But uh, yes, I've sent the
- 25:55links to our live audience so they can have a
- 25:57Professor Fred Watson: look.
- 25:58Andrew Dunkley: Uh, but if you would like to get your name on
- 26:00the Dragonfly mission, you can do it at
- 26:03NASA.gov
- 26:05dragonfly um, Fred Watson, I've got a
- 26:08question without notice from our live
- 26:10audience if you want to tackle it.
- 26:12I think we have raised this issue before so
- 26:14it might be fresh in your mind. Uh, this
- 26:17comes from. I um,
- 26:20think this is his business name. Dmt Guitars.
- 26:23Um, I love guitars. I've got a guitar in the
- 26:25cupboard back there. My son's actually got my
- 26:28real guitar and he's never giving it back
- 26:29because it's um, it's a nice piece. It's
- 26:32a, it's a hummingbird. Anyway, um,
- 26:35the question says, uh, do you think the rate
- 26:38of new discoveries will increase with how
- 26:41good AI is getting?
- 26:44Professor Fred Watson: Um, I think it's already happening. Um, and
- 26:47in fact, uh, the story that we've
- 26:50talked about to kick off this episode
- 26:53of spacenuts used AI,
- 26:55uh, uh, in the
- 26:58reconstruction of the uh, Event Horizon
- 27:01telescope image of M87. Uh,
- 27:03and that's typical of how AI
- 27:06is beginning to be used by scientists to do
- 27:09things that has eluded us,
- 27:12uh, across the whole of science, where
- 27:15I read obviously science news bulletins,
- 27:18start my day off every day doing that. And
- 27:22everywhere you look, biology, geology,
- 27:25space physics, astronomy, physics, AI
- 27:28is playing a part. So I think we are going to
- 27:30see an increase in the rate of discovery.
- 27:33Um, uh, you probably know, uh, Andrew, from
- 27:37recent news media releases
- 27:40that it's more or less, um, put a stop to
- 27:42mathematics, um, because it's.
- 27:45AIs produce the answers to
- 27:48so many theorems that have not, you know,
- 27:50they've not had an answer before.
- 27:51Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, I Saw one the other day and it's a.
- 27:54It's a, uh. It's a mathematical problem that
- 27:57they've been trying to solve for like 52
- 27:59years. And they uploaded
- 28:02it to some AI system and it went
- 28:05like that. Done.
- 28:06Professor Fred Watson: Uh, that might be the one that there was a
- 28:08million dollar prize for as well. That was
- 28:11the one. I see it up.
- 28:12Andrew Dunkley: Yes. That was it. Yeah. I
- 28:14Professor Fred Watson: actually think m. When you. When you look,
- 28:16uh, in detail at it, I think there were seven
- 28:19different attempts with AI
- 28:21before it finally cracked it. But, uh, it did
- 28:24crack it. I
- 28:24Andrew Dunkley: would
- 28:25Professor Fred Watson: have only
- 28:25Andrew Dunkley: read the headline.
- 28:26Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, you read. That's right. But you know
- 28:28that, um, that does suggest that, um,
- 28:33we're in a different regime, particularly
- 28:34with mathematics. Yeah, interesting.
- 28:37Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. I was talking taught in radio
- 28:40journalism that if you're. If you're looking
- 28:42for stories and you're reading newspapers,
- 28:45just read the first two paragraphs because
- 28:47the rest will just be the same story repeated
- 28:49with different words.
- 28:52Professor Fred Watson: That
- 28:53Andrew Dunkley: way you can get through them faster.
- 28:54Professor Fred Watson: It's a bit like space nuts, isn't it? You
- 28:56just listen to the intro and the rest isn't
- 28:59Andrew Dunkley: anything. Then you can go away. But, uh,
- 29:01Professor Fred Watson: yeah,
- 29:03Andrew Dunkley: we don't get paid
- 29:04Professor Fred Watson: if
- 29:04Andrew Dunkley: people cut us off before the end. That's the
- 29:06problem, actually. We don't get paid at all,
- 29:09but.
- 29:10Professor Fred Watson: No, we don't, do we? No.
- 29:13Andrew Dunkley: Oh, well, that's life, you know, that's,
- 29:16uh, that's the way it goes. Thanks for the
- 29:17question. Um, not usually a Q and A episode,
- 29:20but we had a few minutes so we. We threw it
- 29:22in.
- 29:23Professor Fred Watson: Um, sounds
- 29:24Andrew Dunkley: like the gardeners. The gardener's passing
- 29:26by.
- 29:27Professor Fred Watson: Just for the record. Yeah, Mine is a. Mine's
- 29:30a Gibson Blue Ridge custom. It's a
- 29:33Andrew Dunkley: flat top.
- 29:34Professor Fred Watson: Yeah.
- 29:34Andrew Dunkley: From
- 29:34Professor Fred Watson: 1968. And it still plays,
- 29:38uh, with a very angelic voice.
- 29:41Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. I have not played my guitar for a long
- 29:44time and for so long the tips of my fingers
- 29:47are, uh, soft again. Which means if I ever
- 29:50pull it out and start giving it a bit of a
- 29:52go, uh, it's going to hurt.
- 29:55Professor Fred Watson: It will hurt, but it won't hurt for long.
- 29:57That's the. No, they'll
- 29:58Andrew Dunkley: harden
- 29:58Professor Fred Watson: up. They'll come back. They do harden up.
- 30:04Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. You can always tell if someone's a
- 30:05guitar player because the tips of one hand.
- 30:08Hand are usually, uh, hard. The other hand's.
- 30:10All right.
- 30:12Professor Fred Watson: You can tell more than that. Um, because if
- 30:15you look at my other hand, I've got long
- 30:18fingernails. And that's because I play
- 30:20fingerstyle.
- 30:21Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. Okay.
- 30:23Professor Fred Watson: Don't use a plectrum. That's crass.
- 30:26Well,
- 30:27Andrew Dunkley: I'm a crass player then. I can't
- 30:30do the finger thing. Uh, if you want to hear
- 30:33a good guitarist, listen to my brother.
- 30:34Father. He is amazing. Steve,
- 30:36Professor Fred Watson: congratulations.
- 30:37Andrew Dunkley: He can play anything. He's incredible. Well,
- 30:39he made a career out of it, um, doing the
- 30:42Newcastle pub circuit. So, um,
- 30:44yeah, he was in several very m
- 30:47locally famous bands in Newcastle back in the
- 30:50day. Uh, the world's changed. You don't see
- 30:53that much live music anymore.
- 30:56Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. So I supported myself through
- 30:59my master's degree playing in folk clubs in
- 31:01Scotland and Northern England. And
- 31:05that sort of thing doesn't happen
- 31:07anymore. Just a few places. They were
- 31:10everywhere. This is the late 60s and early
- 31:1270s. Um, it was.
- 31:14So, as you probably know, I used to play
- 31:17alongside some people who became very famous.
- 31:19Like Jerry Rafferty.
- 31:20Andrew Dunkley: Yeah.
- 31:21Professor Fred Watson: And that dude Billy Connolly, whoever he was.
- 31:25Still is good on him.
- 31:27Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. Um, and our, ah, guitar maker,
- 31:30ah, listener has just messaged and said he
- 31:32started making his own guitars because he
- 31:34couldn't afford a new one. And his guitars
- 31:37are made from stainless steel.
- 31:41Okay, that would sound really.
- 31:44I wonder how they would sound. That would be
- 31:46incredible.
- 31:47Professor Fred Watson: Well, ah, a Dobro is made of
- 31:50steel, isn't it? Um,
- 31:52Andrew Dunkley: I don't know.
- 31:54Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, I think a Dobro steel. And ah, what's
- 31:57the other? Um, steel guitar. I can't remember
- 31:59the name of it. It's going back too many
- 32:01years. Anyway, this is not about
- 32:04guitars.
- 32:05Andrew Dunkley: No, it's not. No. My brother's got, I think
- 32:08seven. Seven guitars. Um, a few
- 32:10Fender Stratocasters, a couple of Gibsons.
- 32:13Yeah, he's, he's, he's guitar nut. But,
- 32:16uh, anyway, we got, of course. But, um,
- 32:18thanks for the question. Lovely to hear from
- 32:20you.
- 32:20And I think we're just about done
- 32:24for today. We got there eventually, but,
- 32:27uh, yeah, you can check out all those, um,
- 32:29all those stories in our show notes and thank
- 32:32you, Fred Watson. We'll catch you on the next
- 32:33episode.
- 32:35Professor Fred Watson: We'll sing along together again. Thanks,
- 32:36Andrew.
- 32:37Andrew Dunkley: You can sing. I'll just listen. I
- 32:40couldn't sing to save my life. Thanks,
- 32:42Fred Watson. Professor Fred Watson Watson,
- 32:44astronomer at large between episodes too.
- 32:45Don't forget to visit us on our, uh, social
- 32:47media platforms. Uh,
- 32:49spacenutspodcast.com is our website. If you'd
- 32:52like to go there. You can send us a note or a
- 32:54question or just have a look around. There's
- 32:56a great shop and you can sign up for the
- 32:59astronomy newsletter and so many other
- 33:02things. And thanks to Huw in the studio who
- 33:04couldn't be with us today. Today because he's
- 33:06decided to learn the guitar for the first
- 33:08time in his life and at his age. Um, I
- 33:11wish him luck. And from me, Andrew Dunkley,
- 33:14thanks for your company. We'll catch you on
- 33:15the next episode of Space Nuts. Bye. Bye.
- 33:18You've been listening to the Space
- 33:20Voice Over Guy: Nuts podcast,
- 33:23available at Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 33:26iHeartRadio or your favourite podcast
- 33:28player. You can also stream on demand at
- 33:31bytes. Com M.
- 33:32Voice Over Guy: This has been another quality podcast
- 33:34production from bytes. Com. Um.