Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Crash That Killed 6: Accident, Medical Emergency… or Murder? | Nicole Linton
Transcript
- Nicholle: Content warning. This episode discusses a fatal car crash involving an infant, a pregnant woman, and multiple deaths. Listener discretion is advised. Please take care while listening. She was about to get gas. Just another afternoon, and then crash. Another and then another. The sound kept coming. Zalle: She was about to be honest. Just another option now. And then crashed. Another. And then another. The sound kept coming. Nicholle: Cars colliding, metal tearing apart, glass flying, and suddenly there was fire in the intersection. People were running, people were screaming. Veronica Esquivel ducked behind a gas pump, trying to get out of the way, and then she looked up. Something had landed near her. It was a baby. An eleven month-old little boy had been thrown from one of the vehicles. For a moment, Veronica wanted to run, but she couldn't leave him there. Zalle: Fires collaboration, tearing apart, glass lines, and suddenly things fired in the intermotion. People were running, people were screaming, Veronica had something dust behind the gas, trying to get out of the weapon. It empty. Something had landed near her. It was a reason. An eleven-month-old board had been flown on one of the vehicles. For a moment, Vernica wanted to run, but she couldn't leave in there. Nicholle: She began screaming for someone to help. A gas station worker rushed over, and another woman would later testify that she tried to perform CPR. But Alonzo couldn't be saved. And when the chaos finally stopped, it became clear just how much had happened in those few seconds. Six people were dead. A mother, a boyfriend, Zalle: She began screaming for someone to help. A gas station worker rushed over, and another woman who later testified that she tried to perform the CPR. But Alonzo didn't be safe. And when the chaos finally stopped, it became clear just how much had each second. Six people were dead. A mother, a boyfriend, Nicholle: Their eleven-month-old son, the baby she was carrying, and two women who Zalle: her 11-month-old son, the baby she was carried, and two women who had Nicholle: had been driving in another car. Six people who had gotten into their cars that afternoon, never knowing they were about to cross paths with something that would change everything. And somewhere in the middle of all that wreckage, a stranger had found herself trying to protect a baby she'd never met. Welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicole, but around here I'm Mom. Zalle: And I'm Zay Lee, but you can call me Zay. Nicholle: Before we get in today's case, make sure you're subscribed or following the podcast wherever you're listening. And if you're watching us, hit that like button, follow the page, turn on those notifications, and share this episode with somebody who needs to hear it. Zalle: Because trust me, you're going to want to stay with us for this one. Nicholle: Four years after that afternoon, what happened in those few seconds is being examined by a jury. the question isn't simply who was driving. We know who was driving. Zalle: Nicole Linton. Nicholle: The question is what was happening to Nicole Linton while she was driving. So we're going back to Zalle: So we're going back to the seconds before that crash. We're gonna walk through what investigators found, what witnesses remember, and what the prosecution and defense say those pieces of evidence actually mean. Nicholle: Because there's a difference between knowing what happened and knowing why it happened. that difference could determine whether what happened at that intersection was a horrific accident, a medical emergency, or murder. Let's get into it. Let's start with something Nicole Linton says she can't remember. Fortunately for investigators, her Mercedes could. Inside the vehicle was an electronic data recorder, and according to prosecutors, five seconds before the crash, Nicole's Mercedes was traveling approximately one hundred and twenty two miles per hour. Five seconds, that's it. And during those final seconds, prosecutors say Nicole wasn't slowing down. She was accelerating. By the time the Mercedes reached the intersection of Slauson and La Brea, approximately 130 miles per hour. The speed limit was 35. Zalle: So she didn't just hit a 103 at some point earlier and then lose control. She was still accelerating as she approached the intersection. Nicholle: According to prosecutors, yes. That's what they say happened. They say the accelerator was fully depressed. They also say there was no breaking or swerving before the collision. And the traffic light, prosecutors say it had already been red for approximately 15 seconds. Zalle: Okay, so people please. Don't get in your feelings when I say what I'm about to say. But this is giving Mackenzie Sharilla. Am I Is it not? That's Nicholle: That's what it's giving me. Zalle: definitely what it's giving. Same details. Okay. So then Nicholle: Is it getting me? Yeah. Mm-hmm. Okay. Zalle: the obvious question is why? Nicholle: Exactly. That's what everybody wants to know. Because nobody disputes that Nicole was driving that Mercedes. The argument is over why she was driving it that way. And the prosecution believes what happened before Nicole ever reached that intersection helps answer that question. Zalle: The exact same situation. Almost. Minus a couple of people in the vehicle and you know the age and the situation. Isn't know, you get it, you get it. Nicholle: Yeah. Minus a couple of people. A couple of people in a building. In the city. Yeah. You understand. We are both on cold medicine, so buckle in everybody. Zalle: yeah. Nicholle: Nicole Linton was a traveling nurse working at Kaiser Permanente West Los Angeles Medical Center. According to prosecutors, Nicole was frustrated with her job and angry with co-workers that day. She was planning to quit, and prosecutors say that anger followed her out of the hospital and into her car. Their allegation is that Nicole channeled that frustration into her driving. Zalle: And the prosecutors say that they don't find it out of the football in incident part. Their allegations that it both channeled that frustration is in her pride. So they're trying to say that this is basically like a road rage theory. Nicholle: yes. That's essentially how prosecutors are framing the driving. But here's where we need to understand why Nicole isn't simply facing charges for causing a fatal crash. She's on trial for six counts of murder, and the prosecution's theory centers on something called implied malice. They're not claiming Nicole left work intending to kill six specific people. They're trying to prove that she knowingly engaged in conduct dangerous to human life. And acted with conscious disregard for that danger. Zalle: Which means the speed alone isn't the whole case. So I'm sorry. Okay, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: go ahead, it'll a you it'll answer it in the next it scrolled up. I had a question, but it answered it. Okay. Nicholle: If you could stop talking I could go, Are you done? They need the jury looking at Nicole's state of mind. And that's where the prosecution and defense take the same day and tell two completely different stories. Because the Zalle: Because the defense says Nicole's co-workers noticed something too, but they don't describe it as anger. They say Nicole wasn't acting like herself. And shortly before the crash, Nicole spoke with her sister. According to her attorney, Nicole talked about possibly marrying Will Smith. She also talked about picking up her niece from school, except her sister lived in Philadelphia, and the niece Nicole was talking about attended college in Hawaii. So what Nicole was describing wasn't actually possible. Nicholle: Now that gives me pause because being angry about your job is one thing. Talking about picking up somebody who is thousands of miles away is something else. Zalle: And that's exactly what the defense wants the jury to consider. They say this wasn't simply an angry woman driving recklessly. They say Nicole was already experiencing some type of altered state. And then she had a seizure. Mm. Nicholle: And there it is, the defense explanation for the 130 per hour. Nicole's attorney says she suffered a sudden medical emergency while driving and lost awareness. Zalle: They've also pointed out what wasn't happening. Nicole wasn't intoxicated. She wasn't racing another car. She wasn't on her phone. And according to the defense, she wasn't rushing somewhere. Nicholle: Their position is that Nicole didn't consciously decide, I'm going to floor the accelerator. something happened to her brain. And if that's true, it creates a serious problem for the prosecution's murder theory. But saying Nicole had a seizure and establishing that she had one are very different things. And that's where the medical evidence starts getting complicated. Zalle: After the collision, first responders described Nicole as confused. She reportedly couldn't remember what had happened. And EMT previously testified that Nicole asked whether she hurt anyone, whether she killed anyone. Nicholle: And I know where somebody's mind immediately goes. Well, there you go. She didn't remember because she'd had a seizure. Not necessarily. She had also just survived a catastrophic collision. So confusion afterward doesn't tell us by itself what caused that confusion. Zalle: And doctors who treated her didn't find clear evidence that she'd suffered a neurological event. Nicholle: Right. A doctor who treated Nicole previously testified that testing didn't show signs of a seizure. prosecutors have also emphasized that Nicole had no previous diagnosis of a seizure disorder. The defense, however, is expected to rely on a neurologist who supports its seizure theory. Zalle: So we're going to have medical experts looking at the same person and potentially giving the jury very different interpretations. Nicholle: Yes. And prosecutors aren't only attacking the seizure theory medically, they're also challenging whether Nicole is telling the truth about it. In opening statements, prosecutors showed jurors something Nicole purportedly wrote in 2020, two years before this crash, and the title was Bitter Effing Nurse. Zalle: Well. That's certainly a title. Nicholle: That's certainly a it most definitely is. The writing described Nicole's frustrations with her life and career. Prosecutors highlighted a passage in which Nicole reportedly acknowledged sometimes lying to avoid dealing with the consequences of her actions. They're using that material as part of their argument that Nicole fabricated the seizure explanation. Zalle: But she wrote this two years before the crash. Nicholle: Right. And while she was living in North Carolina, and that's the defense's problem with it. They're essentially saying, What does something Nicole wrote in North Carolina in twenty twenty prove about what happened behind the wheel of a Mercedes in Los Angeles in twenty twenty two? Zalle: And I think that's a fair question. Because the title is gonna stick in your head. I mean that that is a off the wall. Nicholle: Yes, definitely. Especially when you think about a nurse. So Zalle: Yeah. So Nicholle: exactly. We'll come back to that in our discussion because I have some thoughts about evidence that tells you something about a defendant's personality versus evidence that proves a crime. But first we need to go back to the Mercedes because the car creates a problem the defense has to explain. Investigators didn't just recover speed and accelerator information. Zalle: investigative speeding and celebrating the company. Prosecutors say that Mercedes also reports steering. even as Nickel traffic reports lost in Brea, the road we curved. According to prosecutors, Mercedes Holly McEr the car stayed center as the approach to the Nicholle: Prosecutors say the Mercedes also recorded steering input. and as Nicole traveled towards Lawson and La Brea, the roadway curved. According to prosecutors, the Mercedes followed that curve. The car stayed center as it approached the intersection. Zalle: intersection. Definitely like this is just Nicholle: Definitely, McKinsey. Like this is just Zalle: Same shit. Same shit. The curve. She just didn't hit a building, she hit a vehicle. Yeah. Correct. Correct. Nicholle: a couple. Correct. Yeah. Zalle: And so obviously now I'm stuck because if Nicole wasn't consciously controlling the car, who was steering? How did you manage to stay in the curve? And you didn't hit anything else until the intersection. Nicholle: Right. Right. And that's exactly the question prosecutors want jurors asking. But there's another question. Does physical movement necessarily prove conscious awareness? Zalle: I mean that's not something you or I can answer. It does not necessarily prove that though I do I do not think. If you've seen so but, but but but but yeah, no. No it's it doesn't I would be done no. No thank you. Because if you're having a seizure you're not gonna be able to just control what you it's gonna be like a jerky motion, you know what I'm saying? Nah. that's not something you or I can answer. No. Nicholle: No, and I'm not gonna pretend we can. That's a medical question. I am gonna say It may not prove it like with black and white hard evidence, but that's sitting nice and snug in the circumstantial evidence column for me. So, could someone experiencing the type of seizure the defense alleges continue pressing an accelerator? Could they make steering movements? Could their body perform those actions without the level of awareness required for conscious disregard? Zalle: So someone experiencing type of seizures that's like just continued presence and acceptance, that they make steering movements, that their body actions without the level of awareness required to actually disregard. Because if the answer is yes, the steering doesn't automatically destroy the defense theory. Nicholle: That's correct. That is true. But if the defense wants this jury to believe Nicole wasn't aware of what she was doing, they have to explain this data. They can't just say seizure and move past it. Zalle: another part of Nicole's history that both sides have had to deal with. Nicole had previously been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. She'd experienced serious mental health episodes and had been hospitalized. She also been prescribed medication and reportedly had not been taking it for years. That's the that's that's the difference. Cause Kinzie wasn't on Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-mm. Zalle: meds. Nicholle: And I want to stop right there because this is where conversations about cases like this go sideways. Bipolar disorder is not proof of a seizure, and having a psychiatric diagnosis doesn't prove that diagnosis caused this crash. Nicole's attorneys aren't pursuing an insanity defense. The argument we're talking about here is a medical event that allegedly affected her awareness while driving. Those are not interchangeable things. Zalle: So her history matters only if the evidence connects that history to what happened on August fourth. Nicholle: Exactly. Otherwise, we're working backwards from a horrific outcome in trying to diagnose the driver, and we're not doing that. So strip away everything that isn't really disputed. Nicole was driving. Her Mercedes entered that intersection at extraordinary speed. Her vehicle triggered a collision that killed six people. Those aren't the questions this trial needs to resolve. The fight is over what was happening inside Nicole Linton before she entered that intersection. Zalle: The prosecution says she was angry, accelerating and consciously controlling the Mercedes. The defense says over. Nicholle: The defense says Nicole was behaving abnormally before the crash and then suffered a seizure that caused her to lose awareness. Same woman, same Mercedes, same five seconds. Two completely different explanations. And now we need to talk. Okay, Zay, first question: timing. That's where I keep landing. Don't just tell me Nicole had a seizure. Tell me when it started. Was it before she started accelerating during? Zalle: That's where I don't just tell me what tell me sorry. Was it before she started your childing rather than It could only have been after the curve. Sorry. My opinion. Nicholle: Right. 'Cause it doesn't Zalle: What's it? Nicholle: make sense that for her to still make that curve, stay in the in her lane and everything. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. Because because it's no way you could be having a seizure and do that. I I mean I don't have lots of seizures and I've only seen a couple, you know. But yeah, you would Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: still have to have awareness to be able to follow a curve and not hit anybody else. So I need somebody qualified to explain, you know, how Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: that can happen. Nicholle: And yeah, I think. Zalle: And if they're saying it's before that if it's before the curve then explain how she was able to have the seizure and be in the lane. I need how both those can be true. Explain it to me 'cause it's not clicking. Nicholle: Yeah, it doesn't make sense outside of that. And then I have a question for the prosecution, those phone calls. If Nicole was simply angry and road raging, what do I do with her talking about marrying Will Smith? What do I do with her talking about picking up a niece who was actually attending college in Hawaii? Zalle: Yeah, something sounds wrong there. Unless she was like one of those people who just talked about Will Smith all the time, like she's just absolutely a fangirl. But the picking up Denise, maybe she had like a secret vacation, like it was just like an impromptu visit, you know, we don't know. We don't know. Nicholle: answers yet but something absolutely sounds wrong but and this is important wrong doesn't automatically mean seizure exactly Zalle: Exactly. It tells me I need an explanation. It doesn't tell me which explanation is correct. Nicholle: And that's important. And then there's bitter effing nurse. I've got a problem with that one. If you're the prosecution and you want me to consider something she wrote two years before this crash, tell me exactly why it matters. Don't give me a title that's going to make me dislike this woman and expect my brain to do the rest. Zalle: Yeah, especially once you hear that title. I mean, you're not gonna forget it, but that was years ago too. Nicholle: Right, right. And that's exactly my point. There's a difference between the evidence that makes me think I don't particularly like this person and evidence that proves this person committed murder. Those are not the same thing. And I don't want to convict Nicole because I don't like her. I don't want to excuse criminal conduct because she has a medical or psychiatric history. Neither one is justice. I want the evidence. Yeah. Zalle: Yeah, and I think the medical experts may end up being at everything here. Because somebody has to connect what was happening in Nicole's brain with what we know the Mercedes was doing. Nicholle: That's what I need. Could Nicole experience the type of seizure the defense alleges? Continue pressing the accelerator, make steering inputs, and still lack conscious awareness? If medically the answer is yes, explain it to me. If medically the answer is no, explain that too. Because that moves me somewhere. Zalle: Medically they can technology. Because bad books is Yeah, and until we hear that, I have questions. I have a Yeah. But Nicholle: I have a list. Yeah. But before we go, I want to bring this back to six people. Asherey Ryan Reynold Lester, Alonzo Quintero, Armani Lester, Nathasia Lewis and Lynette Noble. Whatever this jury ultimately decides, their names belong in this story. Zalle: Nicole Linton has pleaded not guilty and the jury is still hearing the evidence. Nicholle: So now we want to hear from you. And don't just give us guilty or not guilty. We're not there yet. If you were sitting on this jury, what is the one question you absolutely need answered before you could decide? Zalle: Yes, because we really want to know whether everybody gets stuck where we do. Peace now, buttercup.