Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Are The Buckeyes Being Overlooked Nationally?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdeman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony.
- 0:12We are almost to June first, which means children are home from school.
- 0:17Memberships are renewing at Ohio state websites all across the land. Tony felt like
- 0:24a great time to remind people that this would be a great time to think
- 0:28about if you want to do join us at Buckeye Huddle dot com because we
- 0:31always do this at the end, I thought, you know what, this
- 0:34is the time of year when you know, it's sort of it's like the
- 0:36end of the fiscal year and sort of the start of the next fiscal year,
- 0:39so you're not necessarily you don't, you know, not everyone's membership for
- 0:43news, like at the first football game. Everyone's kind of interested in what's
- 0:45going on over the summer. So you know, if you've got a membership
- 0:48somewhere else, consider you know, ye adding I'm on at buckeyehutllle dot com,
- 0:52or if you've been members of sites that we've been members of that at
- 0:55the past and you're like, hey, I missed Tom and Tony and Kevin
- 0:58and Alex and Mark and Ross and everyone else missed the whole gang. Well,
- 1:03we're at Buckeye Huddle dot com and you can be too if you,
- 1:07as we always like to say, right for a month, you can sign
- 1:11up for a year, or if you're not sure, just try for a
- 1:14month. But Tony, it is the price of a lousy chain store pizza.
- 1:17The price of everything else seems to be going up these days, not
- 1:19bucke huddle dot com. So you can sign up today. Commercial over now
- 1:23back to you. Well, and you know this month, you know had
- 1:27the Southern swing. Mark has now been covering some seven on seven stuff.
- 1:32We'll do more of that June as Ohio State camp, so we'll be on
- 1:36campus. They're permitted to be there watching the camps and checking out all of
- 1:41the prospects and talking with them afterwards. And they're there are a ton of
- 1:45Ohio right now twenty twenty four, twenty five, twenty six, so there's
- 1:49still plenty of stuff going on this summer. So yes, check out Buckeye
- 1:53Huddle dot com. The big news, Tom and this was a complete shocker.
- 2:00Ohio State Notre Dame game time is set for seven thirty pm on NBC
- 2:07when you got this news, Did you have to stop your car and pull
- 2:09over? I didn't the bridge abutment that I slammed my car into. Yes,
- 2:15total shock, total shock. Uh yeah, this is this is one
- 2:19that I think if you go back, maybe even the last show we were,
- 2:23you know, someone said we had we had a listener question show at
- 2:24one point, then we might people are asking, but you know, when
- 2:27when are we get to know more game times? And you know, there
- 2:30were a couple out. This one was one we were assuming. We got.
- 2:32We got kind of a heads up, Hey, they're going to be
- 2:34announcing the first two game times of the year, and we I think both
- 2:38thought the same thing, which was Michigan at noon and Notre Dame at seven
- 2:40thirty on NBC. And then it was Ohio State Michigan State at seven thirty
- 2:46n NBC. So I was like, Okay, well that was unexpected,
- 2:47but certainly they're going to announce Ohio State, Notre Dame at seven thirty and
- 2:51NBC pretty soon, and then they did. I'm kind of wondering why they
- 2:54waited longer to do that, but it was maybe it took them longer to
- 2:59figure out than it did for US. I don't know, still some wires
- 3:04crossed with the whole NBC Big Ten thing, perhaps, you know. One
- 3:08thing that I did not realize is that this will be obviously, this will
- 3:13be Ohio State's fourth game of the year. I did realize that this will
- 3:15be Notre Dame's fifth game of the year because they opened Week zero in Dublin
- 3:20against Navy, which will be fun. And then their second game is against
- 3:23Eddie George and the Tennessee State Tigers. We know the last time, of
- 3:29course, Eddie George went up against Notre Dame. He vanquished the Irish.
- 3:35The lore has been written about it, there have been songs sung, and
- 3:39then they Notre Dame, then ghost to North Carolina State and then the host
- 3:43Central Michigan before hosting Ohio States. So this is almost a midseason game for
- 3:47them, and they're they're used to that sort of thing, playing you know,
- 3:51big games in mid season. Ohio State, I mean, I think
- 3:55it comes at a very good time for them, their fourth game of the
- 3:59year, like thing will be new at that point. I'm sorry, I
- 4:01don't know that there's an advantage. I'd say there's more of an advantage for
- 4:05Ohio State just because it won't be their first time on the road. It
- 4:10won't be their first time all of these guys are coming out because you saw
- 4:12kind of the nerves and everything last year. So I think this sets up
- 4:15well for Ohio State. Yeah, I think it sets up reasonably well for
- 4:19both teams because you get that Week one game and there's always the uncertainty.
- 4:24You know last year, So they start with Notre Dame and it was you
- 4:28know, it's an exciting start this season, but you never know you've got
- 4:31you know, you have a new coordinator like this Revieer, for example.
- 4:33Notre Dame has a new offensive coordinator. They're gonna have a new quarterback.
- 4:36Ohio State's gonna have a new quarterback. They've got some blind changes, so
- 4:41you never know the first game what's it gonna look like. And you know
- 4:44the old adage you never improve more. You know, you improve the most
- 4:46between game one and game two. So okay, you've kind of got that
- 4:48out of the way. I don't think playing in Week four for Ohio State
- 4:55is necessarily an advantage for the Black Eyes, but it also you're far enough
- 4:59end of the season that Ohio State this will be the first real test for
- 5:00Ohio State. Probably. I mean, they've got Indiana before that, Indiana
- 5:04Young Sound State in Western Kentucky, which yeah, okay, but you're far
- 5:11enough into the season that you know, everyone should be kind of syncd up
- 5:15feeling okay. You're probably not playing a four quarter game before that, so
- 5:21you know, the odds are you're not going to have too many serious injuries
- 5:26at that point. But this is a good it's a good point of the
- 5:28year for Ohio State to get that game in. They've got the week off
- 5:32after that to kind of rest up after that first real test, and you
- 5:34know, you adjust to what you saw and you learn from Notre Dame.
- 5:39So it's far enough into the season it's probably feels like you have eliminated some
- 5:44of the uncertainty from the beginning of the season, so then it just becomes
- 5:47more of a true talent battle and a you know, individual positional matchup battle.
- 5:51And to me, that feels like that's good news for Ohio State.
- 5:56Another Saturday night, oh sorry, another Friday day night NBC game was finally
- 6:01announced. We knew that Penn State and Michigan State were going to be meeting
- 6:05on a Friday on NBC Black Friday, we had talked about that, and
- 6:10then I think in the last show, and then it comes out on to
- 6:15Wednesday that the game is being moved to Ford Field, and it's like,
- 6:19yeah, okay, that makes sense. And then it comes out that the
- 6:24game has is not part of the Michigan State season ticket package. They've they've
- 6:28they're going to refund the people who paid for that game because it was a
- 6:31home game for Michigan State. And so now it's essentially a neutral sight game.
- 6:38Because even Michigan State's official tweet says Michigan State versus Penn State and US
- 6:43you know the second team listed as the home team. That like, there,
- 6:46this is completely odd that they've given up a home game. Now they
- 6:53have they have six other home games so and including Michigan and including Washington.
- 6:58So they're justifying it in that way, say hey, look look at these
- 7:01other home games you get. But now I think this moves their Senior Day
- 7:04to like November fourth against Nebraska, and then they have three games after that.
- 7:12I I don't know why they moved to other than weather concerns, I
- 7:19guess is the main reason. But why do you remove it from the ticket
- 7:25package unless you think you can get more money doing it this way. And
- 7:30we know last year the last home game for Michigan State, they had like
- 7:33the they didn't even sell some of the upper seats. They were like twenty
- 7:36thousand under capacity, So it was like in the fifty thousands, four field
- 7:42will seat like sixty five thousand. Maybe they're counting on Penn State to come
- 7:47in and maybe it's cheaper for them. I saw somebody mentioned this on our
- 7:50message board saying maybe it's just cheaper for Michigan State right now to not play
- 7:58that game at home, and somebody else came with the costs of whatever those
- 8:01costs are at Ford Field, and does this time all come back to the
- 8:07melt Tucker contract where they have to pinch every single penny and when they saw
- 8:13this opportunity, like, well, we don't want to play outside because we've
- 8:18seen we've seen daytime games that are really freaking cold and East Lancing, so
- 8:22like, I didn't have a problem with them going inside, but removing it
- 8:26as a home game is odd to me. Yeah, I mean the weather
- 8:31thing, sure, okay, I mean we were up there in what twenty
- 8:35eighteen and that was one of the colder games that I've attended in person,
- 8:41and that was probably the second weekend and maybe in November, and that was
- 8:48mid what mid mid afternoon. I think that I think that might have been
- 8:52That might have even been a new that wasn't new and kick as a matter
- 8:54of fact, because that was the one where it was like the Drew Christman
- 8:56game and Drew Christmas getting interviewed on the field at the end of the game,
- 9:00game on national TV, because that's a normal thing for a punter.
- 9:03But that was that was daytime, so he was that was definitely a nun
- 9:05kick and that was freezing cold there that November tenth. Yeah, so's yeah,
- 9:09second weekend in November, so you know, a couple of weeks later.
- 9:13Yeah, sure, you could have a genuinely unpleasant afternoon in or evening,
- 9:18you know, late night in East Lansing. You know, you get
- 9:20the wind going. It snowed the night before that game in twenty eighteen.
- 9:26So yeah, that's that's all possible that He's sure we can talk about the
- 9:30weather. Okay, Tony, what what drives every possible decision in college football
- 9:33these days? TV and money? So here's the actual answer, TV and
- 9:37money. TV. They're playing it at night because TV wants them to play
- 9:39at night. Money a lot of times when you get those early season non
- 9:45conference games, you know, when Alabama goes to Jerry World to play in
- 9:48Miami or whatever, those teams will make five million bucks from that game.
- 9:52And so the odds are they're probably getting a deal from ford Field that,
- 9:56hey, you know, we'll you know, will give you an X amount
- 10:01of money or you know, you do just don't have the expenses of the
- 10:03day at you know, at the stadium. Whatever it is. I'm sure
- 10:07financially it's working out better for Michigan State. And you know, it's an
- 10:11easier sell to get Michigan to get Penn State fans to drive up there.
- 10:15That's what an hour and a half or so closer to Penn State, so
- 10:18it's a little bit of an easier drive. I'm sure it's easier to get
- 10:20hotels in Detroit than it is in East Lansing. All that, you know,
- 10:24it's in you know, you you can, you know, you buy
- 10:28your tickets. Now you don't have, you know, you're much less likely
- 10:31to have you know, ten thousand students not show up because it's a day
- 10:35after Thanksgiving, because students aren't on campus all that kind of stuff. So
- 10:39yeah, I'm sure it's a lot of that. And yeah, I mean
- 10:41it's kind of crappy to do this after you've presumably sold your season ticket packages.
- 10:46They've got, you know, Washington, You've got Michigan coming, so
- 10:50look those you've got other tent pole kind of games. It's not like you're
- 10:52removing the only game that people would care about, but you're removing a game
- 10:56people would care about. But you know, from Michigan States fans perspective,
- 11:01like you're you're probably gonna buy the season tickets anyway for the Michigan game and
- 11:03for the Washington game, and then you're driving an hour and a half and
- 11:07you know, we've I don't know, have you seen a game in four
- 11:09Field, Like that's a nice it's a nice venue. It's nothing spectacular.
- 11:13If it's a nice venue, it's right downtown Detroit. If you wanted to
- 11:16go and like make that a weekend, you could do that. So I
- 11:20mean that's like it's a it's a perfectly fine decision. But yeah, it's
- 11:24driven by TV and money, just like everything else. I'm looking at Michigan
- 11:28State's schedule now, they their first four games are at home, and that's
- 11:33September one three September twenty third, they are at home. Just two more
- 11:39weeks after that, from like from September twenty fourth until November twenty fourth,
- 11:45they have just two home games, and that's Michigan October twenty first and then
- 11:50Nebraska November fourth, So they just basically have after September one home game a
- 11:54month. That's wild. That's that's because I mean you think about it,
- 12:00like it doesn't really start feeling like football season until about October first. Usually
- 12:03it's you know that September twenty third, that's still sometimes an eighty degree day,
- 12:09and you know, and we've been up there. We were up there
- 12:11last year for a game in what early to mid October, and the leaves
- 12:16are changing and it's fifty degrees and it feels like a football day, and
- 12:20it's like, oh man, this is go back to the photo gallery I
- 12:24put up that day and there's all sorts of pictures from before the game of
- 12:26like bright red leaves on the trees around the Red Cedar River. It's like,
- 12:31man, this is what football should be. It's a great day it
- 12:33was. And then you know, you're going to have like what one of
- 12:37those and then it gets cold in November and then you're done. And you
- 12:41know, I think if you're going to you know, we mentioned TV and
- 12:43money being what drives all the stuff. Senior Day on November fourth, you
- 12:48know, we we can talk all about how much how much our program values
- 12:52it contributions of our seniors and all that kind of stuff, like if you're
- 12:56putting no Senior Day on November fourth or whatever, you it was like,
- 13:00I mean, that's we value your contributions. Thank you for your contributions,
- 13:05but they're not financial contributions in the way that TV is, and so uh,
- 13:13you know, unless you want to up your NF tuck contribute contributions,
- 13:16I don't think we're gonna be able to do anything about that Senior Day.
- 13:18Sorry about that. If you're not pitching in on your nil money back to
- 13:24the university, if you're not giving them a taste, then you can forget
- 13:26your Senior Day college football tithing. Let's let's get it going ten percent back
- 13:31to the university. You know, all of these pardons like no, I'm
- 13:35not going to give any of my nil money, and you got like I'll
- 13:39talk her like it'd be a shame if something happened to your senior day.
- 13:43You know, I would hate to see something happened to it. I don't
- 13:48I don't think he's Italian, but I mean I don't. I don't know.
- 13:50I haven't like checked his ancestry dot com. But yeah, it's a
- 13:54yeah, it is. It's one of those things where you're kind of like,
- 13:58this is this is any things where it's very easy to say the right
- 14:01thing, and you know how how wonderful and how cherished everyone is. But
- 14:05it's like, I mean, we value your contributions, but not not not
- 14:09like that in a different way, in a more intangible way. You don't
- 14:16even get a watch, and there's there's no like here your twenty five,
- 14:18your anniversary thing. It's just like enjoy Detroit Um. Other other news,
- 14:26tom Ohio State offered in state twenty twenty five quarterback Tavia and Saint Clair from
- 14:33Belle Fountain. You may say Bellefontaine, you may say Belle Fountain. Well,
- 14:39bell Fountain is correct, so you should only say bell Fountain. That's
- 14:43uh, it's spelled like Bellfountain, but yes, it has pronounced bell Fountain.
- 14:46And if you were not familiar with the Ohio. It is kind of
- 14:48northwest of Dublin, So Dublin is like a northwest suburb of Columbus. If
- 14:54you keep going up Route thirty three, you get to Marysville, which is
- 15:00further from Dublin then you think, and then you go a little ways up
- 15:03and you get up to Bell Fountain, which is again further than you think
- 15:07from Yeah, further than you think. There's a ski area kind of on
- 15:09the way there. Mad River is up there and also Tony. What is
- 15:15Bell Fountain famous for a geographical feature in the state of Ohio? What is
- 15:18Bell Fountain famous for the lowest point or the highest point? It's one of
- 15:22those which one do you think it is? It feels well, you said
- 15:26there's some skiing, so if I use logic, I always thought Chilicothee was
- 15:31are because they've got hills and Chilicothee. But I'll say highest. Bell Fountain
- 15:35is home to Campbell Hill, the highest point in the state of Ohio,
- 15:39located on the campus of a community college of some sort. I believe that's
- 15:43no name. I want to I want that on a hat. It's it's
- 15:46not exactly Summiting Everest. You can drive up to a parking lot in the
- 15:50community college and uh and stand there on the top of the hill if if
- 15:52you so so desire, and why wouldn't you also next door the largest ball
- 15:58of twine. So now they've offered two in state Ohio quarterbacks. That's what
- 16:03in state means, Ryan Ryan Montgomery, who they had previously offered and Uh.
- 16:11And also of course Bryce Underwood, I think is their their main target
- 16:14and he should be like he is a legit national dude. Not that these
- 16:18guys aren't national, because they both have offers from all over the place.
- 16:22Ryan Montgomery recently, UM was either out in Washington or Washington came to see
- 16:27him. But like you see on Twitter every single day, there's a new
- 16:30school at Finley talking to Ryan Montgomery, UM, and I know they were.
- 16:34They were pretty impressed by what they heard from Washington and the way Washington
- 16:37throws the ball around right now, but that's I think that's going to become
- 16:41a place as long as Kalin Dubor is still there, and who knows how
- 16:45long he'll be there at Washington. But UM, with Davian Saint Clair,
- 16:51I'll just give you a little bit of a Rundown right now. The the
- 16:56like he's like in the three hundreds, and like the number twenty four back
- 17:00in the in the in the composit, the number twenty six quarterback in the
- 17:04composite, number ten player in Ohio, number three thirty two. Overall offers,
- 17:11you know, and are these camp offers that sort of thing that come
- 17:15to camp, like offer from Florida, it's like one of those things.
- 17:18Well we'll throw our hat in, I think, um, just because we
- 17:22know you're not going to commit right now, so we'll have some time.
- 17:25Penn State that's alleged offer Tennessee has offered. That's a good place for a
- 17:29Quarterbackowa, Iowa State. You say what you want, but you know Florida,
- 17:33Minnesota, Pitt and obviously the Ohio state now as well. So um,
- 17:40once Ohio State gets in the mix on an in state kid, we
- 17:41know, like, okay, this is legit. Anything can happen. I
- 17:45just think it's cool that you've got now two kids in state that um,
- 17:52you know Ohio State once because this is something we've been saying for a while
- 17:56and it does look like they're trying to take two A is go swing for
- 18:00the fences. But also try to get the best kid in state as well,
- 18:06and you'll have a better chance of keeping kids in state rather than hitting
- 18:10that portal, even though it's not a solution, They're more likely to stay
- 18:15in Columbus if Ohio State is their dream, right, And this is something
- 18:21where you go back a couple of years and they were, you know,
- 18:25Drew Aller was, I believe, committed to Penn State. I don't know
- 18:27if he even never officially had an Ohio State offer. It might have been
- 18:30late, but he was, you know, he was a ended up being
- 18:33a very highly ranked prospect and they went national that class, and then even
- 18:38the current class, Ethan Grunckemeyer is committed to Penn State, and you know
- 18:44that's he's judged. You know, he's viewed as someone who's a pretty significant
- 18:48prospect for twenty twenty four. So it's interesting to me that they have kind
- 18:52of thrown their head in the ring with not one but two in state guys
- 18:55in twenty twenty five. And you know, the interesting question then is is
- 18:57this a change of philosophy? Is them trying to get two quarterbacks for that
- 19:00year because his brainde stated preference is to have four scholarship quarterbacks on the roster
- 19:06at a time with the way things are going where guys are leaving pretty consistently
- 19:11after their third year. That happened with Joyne Haskins, that happened with Justin
- 19:14Fields, that happened with c J. Stroud, That could happen with Kyle
- 19:18McCord after this coming year. If you got guys leaving after your third year,
- 19:22it is it's basically impossible to mathematically impossible to have four scholarship quarterbacks unless
- 19:29you're bringing in guys to the transfer portal like they did with Christian Jeba this
- 19:32year, or you've bringing in two quarterbacks in the class and it's hard to
- 19:36sell national recruits on two quarterbacks in the class. That happened with CJ.
- 19:41Stroud and Jack Miller a couple of years ago. But Miller only stuck around
- 19:45for what two years and then left, So you know, like you said,
- 19:48maybe with it being an instate guy, either it's two instate guys,
- 19:52or it's one national guy and one INSTA guy, maybe that makes an easier
- 19:56sell to get someone to stick around a little longer. I think what you
- 20:00need is a guy like c J. Stroud is like I don't care who
- 20:03else is in this class and he has to be the second guy. Maybe,
- 20:07um, but you you do definitely need that kind of confidence and attitude
- 20:12from one of the guys, and he had it, like, yeah,
- 20:15okay, Jack Miller, congrats, you know, good, good job on
- 20:18committing. I am also, you know, and he was obviously a late
- 20:22at somebody that they they went on that summer and got him hooked up with
- 20:26the high state commits in the seven o sevens and things like that, But
- 20:30he had no concern about who else was in that class. And maybe that's
- 20:37that's one of the that maybe that's the attitude of both of these guys,
- 20:41you know, whichever two they want or or obviously whichever two want them the
- 20:48most. I just the question becomes with Bryce Enderwood being like everybody's essentially everybody's
- 20:56top target in twenty twenty five, if both Briant Memory and Tavian sat Claire
- 21:00come in tomorrow, let's say I commit, do they take both Ohio kids
- 21:06and then call it a day. I think that's a question that I don't
- 21:12I wonder what Ohio State would do at this point. Yeah, And I
- 21:17don't know if I don't know what, you know, are they going to
- 21:19accept both commitments if both guys come in tomorrow and say we want in.
- 21:25You know, I don't get the sense that either of those is. I
- 21:29mean, Ryan Montgomery in particular has been making a lot of visits, so
- 21:33you know, you wonder is that someone in remagomer of course, the younger
- 21:37brother Fluke Montgomery, the current Ohio State freshman offensive lineman. So there's some
- 21:41significant family ties to the to the program. So you know, is he
- 21:45ready to commit? Does he want to walk through the recruiting process a little
- 21:48bit more? What does Tavian Saint Clair's Was Tavian Saint Clair waiting for this
- 21:52Oldhio State offered immediately going to pounce on it? Or is he maybe going
- 21:55to let the process play out because he's someone you know, I'm going to
- 21:59be talking to Mark Giveler for the Friday Morning Show all about these guys,
- 22:03and Mark has gotten to see these guys in person. I have not seen
- 22:06these two guys thrown persons since last summer. And you know, you've kind
- 22:10of heard that Tavian Saint Clair has really improved over the course of the last
- 22:14year. I haven't gotten to see it. I want to kind of hear
- 22:15from Mark, this is this is one of these you know, if we
- 22:18know, we'll tell you. I don't know exactly where you know, where
- 22:22these two guys are in Ohio State's board right now, Mark, I would
- 22:25guess would have a better better sense of the evaluation of those two guys where
- 22:27they are right now after that last season. So I'll be interested. We
- 22:33can all find out together when the Friday morning show drops and U and I
- 22:37get I get to ask Mark about about all those those two guys. But
- 22:40yeah, I mean Bress Underwood. You know, we're talking about him as
- 22:42a national prospect. He' from Belleville, Michigan, which is suburban Detroit,
- 22:45so that's you know, this is not exactly someone who's coming from the dark
- 22:48side of the moon. This is this is someone who's like three hours and
- 22:52some change away from Ohio States campus. So you know, this is that
- 22:56I would be very interested. I wonder if the offer to Tavian Saint Clair
- 23:03is a reflection of what they think their likelihood of getting Bryce Underwood is or
- 23:07is it a you know, is it a reflection of how I improved they've
- 23:12viewed Avan Saint Clair to be or is it something else entirely? Is it
- 23:18a jew holler thing? Like we were late on him and we missed out
- 23:23on that, and maybe if we wouldn't have been late, we've learned our
- 23:26lesson. Let's not be late on the next Ohio kid that we like.
- 23:30And I think they offered Ryan Montgomery very early. And I'm just saying they
- 23:34offered him too early. Clearly they didn't because you know, he is a
- 23:38national guy and he has not committed, so the offer was it was just
- 23:42they offered him early in terms of when they normally offer in state kids.
- 23:48And then this this one to Saint Clair. So it'll be interesting to watch
- 23:51how this plays out. We'll see them both, I'm assuming at os U
- 23:55seven on seven and also Oh's camp. Um. They were both in Obets
- 24:00a few weeks ago at the under Armour next camp growing as was Bryce Underwood.
- 24:07So a lot of quarterbacks and stuff going on. So yes, check
- 24:10out Buckeyes tomorrow morning, later this afternoon. It's confusing, but it's tomorrow,
- 24:19but it's tomorrow morning, but it's because it's my name. Anyway,
- 24:22it doesn't matter. It's fine wherever Pop Fine podcast sold. Just keep refreshing
- 24:27your podcast feed every five minutes until you see it. That's the only way
- 24:32to be safe, and then downloaded on four different devices. That's the way
- 24:34you can make sure you don't miss the episode exactly. So, Tom,
- 24:38this is my favorite time of the year, one of my favorite times of
- 24:41the year. It's college football magazine season and the first one is out.
- 24:45Athlon's national UM magazine is out. And one of my things I love about
- 24:52it is that they're all named after the people that wrote it, Like Phil
- 24:56Steeles Magazine, Street and Smith's you know, written written those two guys,
- 25:00and you know, like Thomas Sporting News. They're all written after the one
- 25:03person who wrote it. Of course, this is no different. I think
- 25:07Mortimer Athlon was the guy. Um. This is one of these times when
- 25:11I have it. Is he completely making this up? Is there are actually
- 25:15a person in Mortimer Athlon? Friends, I'm as baffled. I'm as baffled
- 25:18as you are. I have no idea. Did you not hear me say
- 25:22Thomas Sporting News? Oh no, I did not hear Thomas Sporting News.
- 25:25No. No, So anyway, Tom, thank you for that. I'm
- 25:30just you have not seen well you've seen some of this because I posted some
- 25:33of on a message board. But I'm always you know, you take a
- 25:37look, You're like, oh what sticks out? What is what is completely
- 25:41wrong? Or what is worth debating? And as we know, Tom,
- 25:44if it's sports, it's worth debating. Um. They do have a final
- 25:49four of Georgiabama, Michigan, and USC. They have Michigan beating Alabama in
- 25:57the in the semi and I do think this is a year where Michigan where
- 26:03Alabama could be gotten. I think that that is clear. However, if
- 26:10Alabama is good enough to get to the playoffs, I don't see Michigan being
- 26:12good enough to beat them. Um. So I'm not gonna say I take
- 26:18umbradge with this. It's just a magazine as we all know. But um,
- 26:23but they then do have Georgia beating Michigan in the National Championship game.
- 26:29I think Georgia right now is the the is. It seems to be the
- 26:33safest, easiest pick. I'm interested to see if any other outlets go a
- 26:38different way. Yeah, I would expect Georgia to sort of be the default
- 26:42answer, because if you pick Georgia, no one's gonna say you idiots,
- 26:48why would you do that now there, I think there's questions. I think
- 26:51the interior of the Georgia defensive line is probably gonna take a step back this
- 26:55year. I think, you know, Stetson Bennett was what he was,
- 26:59but you don't have a returning start at quarterback this year for Georgia. And
- 27:03you've got you know, the skill positions at Georgia, especially the wide receiver
- 27:07units. It's it's okay, but you you know, you went through those
- 27:11games last year and you weren't blown away. This is not They do not
- 27:12have an Ohio State caliber wide receiver corps. So you know, there's there's
- 27:17questions. But also I think the big question would be who has gotten substantially
- 27:22better that they're going to be so much better than Georgia. I think Alabama
- 27:26has questions this year. Michigan, I think, you know, I think
- 27:29Michigan probably has to show that you know, when was the last time Michigan
- 27:32won a major game against like an SEC type team. Well, I mean
- 27:40they beat Florida in one of those bowl you know, was it was it
- 27:45like a New Year's six kind of bowl like ten years ago. Maybe I
- 27:48think maybe maybe it's even a Citrus Bowl. Maybe I'm thinking of a Citrus
- 27:51Bowl against like an urban Meyer team, and before that it was I mean,
- 27:56they beat Alabama in the Orange Bowl when like Tom Brady was still there.
- 28:00But you know, the Michigan versus Georgia game looked a very specific way.
- 28:04And when Michigan played Alabama in one of those season opening games a couple
- 28:07of years ago, looked a very specific way. So you know it,
- 28:12I kind of I kind of have to see it from Michigan before. I
- 28:15wouldn't necessarily expect him to beat Alabama. But yeah, outside of Georgia,
- 28:19I think there's legitimate questions with just about every team towards the top of the
- 28:23sport right now. So you know, Clemson's got question marks, USC has
- 28:27some question marks, and You've got you know there there are plenty of contenders,
- 28:30but I don't think there is anyone who I would clearly pick to beat
- 28:36Georgia. I think it's going to be difficult for anybody to come out of
- 28:40the back twelve without like two losses. USC is obviously going to put up
- 28:45some points. The defense has to be better, he said, questioning Lee,
- 28:51but knowing better, so I I think it's just gonna be tough for
- 28:56them to come out, although they are certainly a dar Some other notes Marvin
- 29:03and A Mecca first Team All Americans, J T T J T two AM
- 29:07a while and Tommy Eickenberg First Team All Americans. Will Johnson third Team All
- 29:11American. I wouldn't be surprised if he's higher than that by the end of
- 29:15the season. I think he is. Legit. My, here's one time
- 29:22Michigan's defensive line, and I don't want to get too far into our tail
- 29:25of the tape because we'll eventually do that Ohio State Michigan, and this will
- 29:29be the most even tail of the tape we've probably ever done when we do
- 29:33it, I think. But this magazine has Michigan's defensive line rated ahead of
- 29:40Ohio States. They have Mason Graham, sophomore Rising sophomore defensive tackle a second
- 29:47team All Big Ten, and Mike Haul a third team All Big Ten.
- 29:52Guy. They've got no Jack Sawyer on any of their three All Big Ten
- 29:59team. It seems to me that I will take umbradge with this. Yeah,
- 30:07I mean, I, you know, as much as I don't pay
- 30:11attention to the postseason All Big Ten teams, the preseason all big ten teams
- 30:15from magazines that come out in June and therefore went to press in correct,
- 30:19you know, I mean, here's here's here's what you need to know.
- 30:22Like about these magazines like this is you know when they say you know that
- 30:26people are talking about gambling, it's like for entertainment purposes only, and it's
- 30:30like, don't don't bet based on this. We're just you know, hey,
- 30:32we're just having fun. Here. Here's the way the magazine business works.
- 30:36If a magazine is on newsstands before June, it probably needed to be
- 30:40at the publisher sometime before Spring Ball ended in a lot of places. So
- 30:45if you look at the depth chart for your team and you're like, that's
- 30:48not even close to write it's It's like when you watch a you know,
- 30:52like a movie about or a documentary about a subject know a lot about,
- 30:56and you're like, that's that, that's not right. That's but then you
- 30:59watch an or something else and you're like, wow, this is incredible information.
- 31:02I had no idea. It's like if you see something that you know
- 31:04a lot about personally, like you know, I have worked in this industry
- 31:07for a million years. None of this is that's not how any of this
- 31:11works. I think you got to take everything with a grain of salt.
- 31:14And that's not to say don't buy the magazine. That's not to say you
- 31:18know, there's nothing good in there. It's just, you know, hey,
- 31:21just going need to take it for what it's worth. And generally,
- 31:25the later in the summer magazine comes out, the more information from the spring
- 31:30they can sort of incorporate into that magazine, and therefore the more accurate the
- 31:33magazine is going to be. So yeah, I mean, sure you can.
- 31:38You can make an argument for that. I think in terms of Graham
- 31:41being ahead of Hall on the All Big ten team, sure, I think
- 31:45that argument probably involves not necessarily understanding that my Hall was dealing with injuries a
- 31:53bunch last year, and you know, that's that's one of those of you
- 31:56just kind of look at the stats. It's like, oh, well,
- 31:57I mean he was okay, but he wasn't really dominant, and boy that
- 32:00was his second year, and look at Graham and he was he was really
- 32:04good, okay, And that's fine. Sometimes there's a little bit of a
- 32:07story, a little bit of depth behind something that you don't necessarily pick up
- 32:13on a more surface level, you know, surface level examination. Maybe let's
- 32:16say even Graham had like eight more tackles but only like two and a half
- 32:21tackles for loss and sacks. And of course we know, shoot my call
- 32:25had that and against Michigan State. The other thing, the last thing before
- 32:31we go, and this is completely understandable, but it's going to be wrong.
- 32:39They have J. J. McCarthy as the first team All Big Ten
- 32:43quarterback. That is the best, That is the the only, the most
- 32:46sure thing that you can put in a preseason magazine and have KYL McCord third
- 32:53team. However, if you have decided that KYM McCord is your starter and
- 33:00you think he's going to be good enough to be third team, here's a
- 33:04surprise. He's going to be good enough to be your first team quarterback and
- 33:07first team All Big Ten quarterback because of the offense and because of the stats
- 33:10that they'll be putting up. And I know you love JJ McCarthy and people
- 33:15love him, but just statistically, if you think commccord is going to be
- 33:20the guy, then like logically, I completely understand this and it is correct.
- 33:25I'm just telling you, And we did this back in twenty nineteen.
- 33:30Maybe it was between Shay Patterson and Justin Fields, like well, of course
- 33:32you have to side with the the experience of the Michigan quarterback, but just
- 33:37no, by the end of the season, we're gonna have to give the
- 33:40nod to Ohio State. Tom, can you tell me the last non Ohio
- 33:45State quarterback to be All Big Ten First Team? Oh Boys? Sou and
- 33:54a say? CJ. Stroud got it both of his years. Justin Fields
- 33:58got it both of his year. Dwayne Haskins got it his year. Um.
- 34:06JT. Barrett probably got it at least in did J. J.
- 34:10Barrett at then in seventeen? In sixteen? Mm? So was it someone
- 34:17in two thousand and fifteen? Ordn Okay two thousand and fifteen, and only
- 34:22because Ohio State had a quarterback probably quarterback split? Yeah, um two thousand
- 34:28and fifteen. Boy, this is a disturbingly long time ago. Was it
- 34:34who was the Iowa quarterback that transferred to Michigan? Was it Jake Rudoc that
- 34:37year? That would have been good to guess, I think he may have
- 34:39been. Let me see, he wasn't even second team that year. Trying
- 34:46to think of who was good in twenty fifteen, and uh who was good
- 34:51at shoving Archie Griffin out of the way? Oh? Was it Connor Cook?
- 34:57In fact, it was first team by the coaches and media. Second
- 35:00team was CJ. Bethard, which is why Jay Krudoc transferred third team the
- 35:06great Nate Seidfeld. Yeah. So Michigan State, Iowa, and Indiana that
- 35:14is, in terms of quarterbacks in the Big Ten over the last decade or
- 35:17so, that is very much. Who are three people who have never been
- 35:20in my kitchen? That is? Can you imagine Tony and Iowa quarterback being
- 35:23second Team All Big Ten in the year of Our Lord twenty twenty three?
- 35:28Can you imagine such a thing? Do you think Kaid McNamara is destined for
- 35:31second team All Big Ten honors this year? Hey, he's one of the
- 35:35few quarterbacks, maybe the only. He's only one of two quarterbacks in the
- 35:38Big Ten to have led their teams currently in the Big Ten to have led
- 35:42their teams to the playoffs. So I think you better put some respect on
- 35:45his name. So that was twenty fifteen. Do you know that the time
- 35:49previous prior to that, that Aid nine, Ohio State quarterback was first team
- 35:54All Big Ten and no you will not. I'm gonna guess it was twenty
- 36:00eleven. And who was that quarterback? Was that Devin Gardner? No?
- 36:09He wasn't. Was he? Was he the quarterback in twenty eleven? No?
- 36:12No, that was Denard Robinson? Was it Denard Robinson in twenty eleven?
- 36:15It was not former baseball player from North Carolina State? Oh, Russell
- 36:22Wilson, you said, you said former baseball player who's a quarterback in twenty
- 36:27and eleven? And I'm like, I'm sure it was not Joe Bouserman.
- 36:29I'm extremely sure it was not Joe Bouserman. Wilson, Yeah, that's right,
- 36:34but in fact he is not the correct answer. You have to go
- 36:37back one year later, twenty twelve, okay, because he shared it and
- 36:43this person shared it with Braxton Miller, Braxton who his first team media This
- 36:46quarterback was first team coaches? Who was it? Two thousand and twelve?
- 36:54So it wouldn't have been anyone from Penn State. I don't think it would
- 37:00have been anyone from Michigan. Is that would have been Devin Gardner's first year?
- 37:05Right? Was that Devin Gardner's first year starting? Um? Was this?
- 37:13Was this like a This is one of these things where Mitch Leitner has
- 37:16no object permanence in my brain and like he might have played in two thousand
- 37:21and five, he might have played in two thousand and fifteen, Like was
- 37:22it was it one of these stupid like Minnesota quarterbacks who was like a thing
- 37:27for just like six months. No, but I will give you his stats.
- 37:31He threw for twenty one hundred and seventy one yards with twenty three touchdowns
- 37:35and twelve interceptions and ran the ball one hundred ninety five times for one thousand
- 37:39nineteen yards and ten touchdowns. Taylor Martinez, Yes, wow, that's uh
- 37:46oh yeah, because that was the year, right, that was the year
- 37:50that Nebraska went to the Big Ten Championship game? Right or was that twenty
- 37:54eleven? I think it's eleven. That was eleven, Okay, yeah,
- 37:58Well Taylor Martinez was there for sixteen years, so he's a good He's a
- 38:00good guest almost no matter what. So yeah, Taylor Martinez, boy,
- 38:04twenty three touchdowns and twelve picks for the first team All Conference quarterback is that
- 38:12is quite a time and a place that is different from the present day.
- 38:15That's a good that's a good way to peg things in in you know,
- 38:20the medium too distant past your right time. That was Nebraska in the Big
- 38:23Ten Championship game. Of course they struggled a little bit against Wisconsin. Yeah,
- 38:29well that was that was largely a defensive issue. I believe they put
- 38:31up thirty one points in that game, correctly did they get doubled up?
- 38:36Listen, it's fine. Nebraska made the Big Ten championship game. That makes
- 38:40them legends and or leaders. So yeah, that was. That was the
- 38:44year that it was like an eight and five Wisconsin team because that was your
- 38:47the Ohio State wasn't eligible, Penn State wasn't eligible, Michigan wasn't any good
- 38:52and uh yeah that was oh well Michigan was in the other decision, right,
- 38:58yeah, man, speaking of speaking of a very specific time in place.
- 39:01But yeah, Ohio State in Penn State, I think both finished and
- 39:04they finished like one two in the division that year and third place Wisconsin at
- 39:07whatever eight and five or four and four in the conference just annihilates was annihilates
- 39:15Nebraska in the in the Big Ten Championship game and gets to go to the
- 39:20Rose Bowl because with no no one does anything better than Wisconsin. Just falling
- 39:25ass backwards into Rose Bowl somehow. It's just like the universe just aligns for
- 39:30Wisconsin and then prior to them, it just did that for Northwestern for a
- 39:35couple of years. Just everything everything falls into place, so they get to
- 39:37go to the Rose Bowl. Yeah, Nebraska went seven and one into Big
- 39:40Ten that year. Their lone loss of course at Ohio State sixty three eight
- 39:45to thirty eight. So that will go ahead time meant anything else that you
- 39:50want to throw in there. Famous defensive coordinator bowl put Po Polini giving up
- 39:53sixty three and seventy points in the same season in conference play in a year
- 39:58when he only lost two games. Sit conscience play. That is that is
- 40:02a that is an entire mood. How did how did he end up?
- 40:05How did nine four end up being Bocale day? Well, defense was involved,
- 40:09we can we can say that for sure. Yeah. They also lost
- 40:13at UCLA the second game of the season, thirty six to thirty and then
- 40:15they lost their bowl game the Citrus Ball forty five to thirty one against number
- 40:21six Georgia. That was a long time ago, back when like six coaches
- 40:28ago, I think for Nebraska in fact. But anyway, Matt Rules got
- 40:31them on the right path. Now. I'm sure we haven't seen any evidence
- 40:35of it, but we know Matt Rule has done things before and I'm sure
- 40:39he will do things again. So thank you all for joining us today as
- 40:44I always find us at bucke huddle dot com. As Tom said at the
- 40:45start of the show, and then I also echoed us at those sentiments,
- 40:50join, be come, remember, say hello to us there on the message
- 40:52board. Checkout all the premium content that we have for you as well.
- 40:55Want us at YouTube dot com slash bucke Huddle. Find us at Facebook dot
- 40:59com look for buckeye Huddled there as well. Go ahead and like and subscribe
- 41:02to that page as well, if you would, would character you So thank
- 41:06you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later