Latest / Chatter that Matters / There is only one Jesse Hirsh
Transcript
- 0:02If we thought about learning independent of control, debating about philosophy, about uncertainty, that's where innovation happens.
- 0:11That's where humanity happens.
- 0:13don't remember when or where I first met Jesse Hirsch, but I remember how I felt excited, saturated, agitated and enlightened.
- 0:23He's one of the smartest people I've ever heard.
- 0:26Everyone has the potential for intellect.
- 0:28Everyone has the potential to take an idea and make it theirs.
- 0:32And that to me is the job of media.
- 0:34And with the delivery, that's one third preacher, one third teacher, and one third wit.
- 0:39You infect people with your ideas, you infect them with your joy, you make everybody smarter, and then they'll give you respect.
- 0:47So I think you're going to really enjoy this episode.
- 0:49But there's more to Jesse that will meet your ear.
- 0:53My belief is that most of us live inside systems we did not design.
- 0:58So we learn how to adapt.
- 1:00Jesse Hirsch has spent his life doing something rare, learning the language of those systems, exposing how they work, and refusing to be shaped or adapted by them.
- 1:09If education is focused around control, it will fail.
- 1:13But if education is focused around discovery, around learning, around exploration, around debate, well then we would get somewhere.
- 1:211995, Jesse's a University of Toronto student, the dawn of the internet age.
- 1:26He gets arrested for hacking.
- 1:28Strips searched by police who were generally afraid of what a curious kid with a modem might become.
- 1:33But that moment didn't shut him down.
- 1:35It lit a fuse.
- 1:37And Jesse exploded onto the scene.
- 1:43studied McLuhan through the programs Marshall McLuhan built and became the moderator for their famous Monday night debates.
- 1:58became a fixture on television, CBC and TVO, advising leaders on digital power.
- 2:04And then Jesse took on Silicon Valley at the highest level, including a warning to Canada's Supreme Court about what happens when private platforms start acting like public
- 2:13infrastructure.
- 2:14This is the consequence of being the court jester.
- 2:16Yes, you get to say important things before anyone else does, but mostly people laugh at you because you're saying it at a time before the threat is visible.
- 2:25And then comes the twists.
- 2:27After years inside media, academia, policy rooms, conference stages, Jesse walks away.
- 2:33He moves to a farm in rural Eastern Ontario and builds the Academy of the Impossible, a where leadership is tested not by titles or talk, but by weather, work, and animals that
- 2:43cannot be managed through charisma.
- 2:45What if as marketers, instead of consumers, we started thinking about herds?
- 2:51But there's one thing that almost took Jesse down, and it wasn't institutions or big tech.
- 2:56It was COVID.
- 2:57In 2023, a near-death experience turned his ideas into urgency and left him even more convinced that algorithms in the hands of those who seek power and control will drive our
- 3:08future unless we push back.
- 3:10Let's stop focusing on control.
- 3:12Let's start focusing on power, how power works, how we can share power, how we can stop evil people from using power.
- 3:20Those are the key policy questions I think we need to be focusing on moving forward.
- 3:28It's Tony Chapman.
- 3:29Thank you for listening to Chata That Matters presented by RBC.
- 3:32If you can, please subscribe to the podcast and ratings reviews while they're always welcome and they're always appreciated.
- 3:46Jesse Hirsch, welcome to Chatter That Matters.
- 3:49Always a pleasure, Tony.
- 3:51Part of the idea of the podcast is human journey.
- 3:53So before the internet, before the hacking, who was Jesse Hirsch?
- 3:58Curious, a really curious hyper kid who loved to get attention and loved to learn.
- 4:04I think the first stage I was on was probably kindergarten.
- 4:08My first media appearance was before that in daycare.
- 4:13I love messing with people.
- 4:14love thinking.
- 4:15I love opening minds.
- 4:17I love talking about great stuff.
- 4:19And I was thinking, Tony, you and I kind of have something in common.
- 4:22We're both kind of jazz musicians when it comes to ideas.
- 4:26And we love nothing more than improvising and riffing.
- 4:30I want you to go back in time to 1995, the arrest, the strip search, this challenge of your identity.
- 4:37What did it do to you?
- 4:38Because a lot of people would have sort of fallen into their back feet.
- 4:40But if anything,
- 4:42You said you're gonna be a warrior against power.
- 4:44That's how I took it.
- 4:45It confirmed all of my childhood ideas before that and it turned me into an adult.
- 4:51But the biggest thing it did is it told me, it's the internet buddy, focus on that.
- 4:56That if they are gonna come and arrest you just because you were using the internet, and don't get me wrong, I was mothin' off on the internet, that was part of it.
- 5:04but it gave me uh a razor sharp focus on the internet as the thing to pay attention to in my lifetime.
- 5:12There've been moments in the last 30 years where I've questioned whether that was the right call, but today, as you and I discuss, I've never felt more uh happy about that
- 5:24decision that I'm just a surfer who wants to get as high up on that internet wave as I can.
- 5:31And that arrest rather sensationally made that very clear.
- 5:36Talk to me about Marshall McLuhan, because to me, and I may be putting you on a pedestal that you feel is undeserved, but in some ways you've carried his sword.
- 5:46I learned two things from him, which are kind of the secret to my success.
- 5:50Number one is be the trickster, right?
- 5:53Have fun, be playful, really enjoy bending ideas.
- 5:58But number two,
- 6:00Don't be an academic in the sense of only talking to a few nerds.
- 6:04Try to talk to everybody.
- 6:06Try to translate what you're saying so that people enjoy it.
- 6:11And I will, as a brag, say that in the 90s when McLuhan was being revisited, he was still treated like a church, like a sacred item that no one could really talk about.
- 6:24And I was the first person to bring back
- 6:26the McLuhan Monday night seminars as a community thing that anyone could show up and pretend to be McLuhan and riff and play.
- 6:35Previous to that, everyone was like, no, no, no, that would be against his spirit.
- 6:40And as a result, now everyone's a media commentator, right?
- 6:44Everyone's got a take on how the media works.
- 6:46So again, no regrets there.
- 6:49So let's talk about media because as you said, you've been chasing microphones since before elementary school.
- 6:56You really made your mark, CBC, TVO, and it was always stretching the audience.
- 7:02It always was presented in a way I would say playful in one sense, but you gave a lot more credit to the intelligence of an audience that I would say most journalists do.
- 7:11Yeah.
- 7:12And that's where I personally have a lot of problems with contemporary journalism because they think it's about dumbing down.
- 7:19I think it's about bringing everyone up.
- 7:22Everyone has the potential for intellect.
- 7:24Everyone has the potential to take an idea and make it theirs.
- 7:28And that to me is the job of media.
- 7:30That is the job of anyone who works in the knowledge economy.
- 7:35You infect people with your ideas.
- 7:37You infect them with your joy.
- 7:39You make everybody smarter.
- 7:41And then they'll give you respect.
- 7:42Because to your point, we're living in a world where people just want to make everyone dumber and they try to dumb everything down.
- 7:49And I think that's a mistake.
- 7:50I granted it's harder, but I think it's worth the effort.
- 7:54Now, I was shocked to learn that you actually built a lot of your thinking and a hypothesis around an acronym, CIA.
- 8:02uh
- 8:03The CIA piece looks at our relationship to authority and how we trust people.
- 8:09And it says there's three kinds of authority, the cognitive, the institutional, and the algorithmic, right?
- 8:16The CIA.
- 8:17And it says that when we try to figure out how to make sense of our world, either we turn to an institutional leader, like a president or a prime minister, or return to a cognitive
- 8:29leader.
- 8:29like an influencer, right, or maybe an expert.
- 8:32But of course, the algorithmic authority is maybe the most important because people turn to Google, they turn to chat GPT, they turn to all sorts of machines to make decisions for
- 8:44them.
- 8:45And the question is, who do they believe?
- 8:47Do they believe the influencer?
- 8:48Do they believe the politician?
- 8:51Or do they believe the algorithm?
- 8:53And so in using this framework, I evaluate the different ways that we trust and make these decisions.
- 8:59And how much do you feel our educational system is succeeding or failing, giving the people to have the critical thinking capability versus just snacking into the latest
- 9:10content and digesting it, excreting it, and going, that is the world according to whoever?
- 9:17I am absolutely disgusted by the state of education today, only because it's still in the 20th century.
- 9:24It's still locked in an understanding of cognition and ideas and skills and learning.
- 9:32And here, I'll bring it back to the personal.
- 9:35When I was in high school in Toronto, we had to pick whether you went to a collegiate, whether you went to a technical, or whether you went to a business school.
- 9:43So my parents forced me to go to the collegiate because they wanted me to go to university.
- 9:48And the greatest regret of my life is that I'm not an electrician.
- 9:53Because if I had been able to both A, study political science and become an electrician, not only would I be financially wealthy because of being an electrician, but like that
- 10:05knowledge skill is something I learned anyway, right?
- 10:09And so why do we do the either or?
- 10:11Like, why do we have to pick the trade or the intellectual?
- 10:14Why can't we let people, you know, learn all the things they want?
- 10:18And why do you think we're so scared?
- 10:21to teach people about philosophy and psychology and debate and having a different point of view and meeting in the middle ground and accepting that there's two sides to the coin.
- 10:31It seems like the whole world, we're herding people to the fringes and you belong in this castle where you've got like-minded people and they like your like-minded content and you
- 10:40validate each other.
- 10:41And your only purpose is to actually get up to the top of the turret and throw slingshots at the other guy because they can't possibly be right because you're the absolute right.
- 10:50Why is that?
- 10:51Control is obsolete.
- 10:53And if education is focused entirely about teaching people how to be controlled and controlling what they do during the school day, then people aren't learning, they're
- 11:03rebelling.
- 11:03That's what kids are doing today in class.
- 11:05They're saying, I'll pay attention to them I want to, thank you very much.
- 11:09Whereas if we thought about learning independent of control, to your point about debating, about philosophy, about uncertainty, that's where innovation happens.
- 11:18That's where humanity happens.
- 11:20would love to see a school system in which the students get to decide what they learn and the teachers facilitate that learning.
- 11:28Our current school system fundamentally is about control.
- 11:33Controlling the teachers and what they teach, the teachers controlling the students and what they pay attention in the class.
- 11:40It's a mess.
- 11:41When instead we should realize the internet has kind of subverted our notion of control.
- 11:48I don't discount influence, I don't discount authority, certainly coordination and negotiation are still active, but I couldn't control you Tony if I wanted to, and you
- 11:58couldn't control me.
- 12:00And there's a lot of people who are saying the government can't control me either.
- 12:04I didn't mean to go this whole track down education, but I'm fascinated your thoughts because I have three nieces in the high school system.
- 12:10And I think that part of what we're doing, and it might be intentionally, is also trying to control the parents.
- 12:16I remember when my kids came home and turned off my tap when I was brushing my teeth and taught me about the environment.
- 12:22I really respected that.
- 12:23I said, the school's doing the right thing.
- 12:25But today it's not about turning off the tap.
- 12:27It's about turning off your mind.
- 12:29It is about uncommon sense.
- 12:31They try to teach the kids and therefore the kids teach the parents.
- 12:34Do you think that's a master plan or is it just me questioning so much of what we're filling our minds with?
- 12:40It's not intentional, but you are correctly identifying the problem.
- 12:45Because on the one hand, kids are resilient, right?
- 12:47Every wave of young people is in and of itself a kind of revolution.
- 12:52What's happening now is kids are rebelling against contemporary education in all sorts of ways, but you raised a disturbing trend, which is if you teach kids control, they will act
- 13:04and desire control elsewhere.
- 13:07And I think we are starting to see signs of that throughout the culture, whereas when we grew up,
- 13:11You know, we had lots of freedoms until the school, until the street lights came on.
- 13:16But again, not to pick on education.
- 13:18I think the other reason that I'm so dissatisfied is that I love learning and I've spent my entire life, the secret to my happiness and success is that I wake up every day going,
- 13:29what do get to learn today?
- 13:31And I feel school kills that.
- 13:33Let's move it to the next thing, which I was fascinated about.
- 13:36I actually didn't know this about you, but I can just imagine you in front of the Supreme Court in Canada.
- 13:41warning them about Silicon Valley.
- 13:44Take us back to that time because I have to believe that half the people who couldn't have found Silicon Valley on the map had no idea it was part of Stanford University.
- 13:51And then you're trying to enlighten them in terms of what the danger is that the new superpower in this world was going to be algorithms versus nuclear.
- 14:00And I wish at the time I had, you know, an AI camera or a powerful enough smartphone to have recorded that presentation.
- 14:09because I would love to be able to say that I told the Supreme Court of Canada that Facebook was going to be a problem when people were still like, yeah, it's great.
- 14:18Unfortunately, that didn't matter, right?
- 14:20This is the consequence of being the court jester that yes, you get to say important things before anyone else does, but mostly people laugh at you because you're saying it at
- 14:30a time before the threat is visible, before it's real, right?
- 14:34Before the polarization and the nastiness.
- 14:38that has become social media culture is what it is.
- 14:42And like, what's funny is you and I have been there since the beginning.
- 14:46So we remember when this stuff was filled with hope and optimism, right?
- 14:49When you and I were like preaching to organizations, this is great.
- 14:54This will allow for new things, which it did for a while, but then things went off the
- 15:00And, you know, unfortunately, I was uh raising these concerns a little too prematurely.
- 15:08So people were like, let's not listen to Jesse.
- 15:10He doesn't know what he's talking about.
- 15:12And yet I still get to be Mr.
- 15:14I told you so.
- 15:15As little consolation as that might offer.
- 15:17You know, Jesse, I heard you on stage wearing your hat, futurist.
- 15:21You were almost rabid, manifesting exactly where the future is.
- 15:25You had no notes, no script, unbridled.
- 15:28And yet the audience just leaned in on it.
- 15:31Is that the theater you bring to your speeches or is that the way that you want to convey to people, this reality is unfolding.
- 15:39I can see it.
- 15:40I can feel it.
- 15:41I'm going to open that door and frame it for you, even if it's for 45 minutes.
- 15:45Every single day, I am consuming a high level of research and intelligence on a range of different subjects.
- 15:52And it's pleasurable, right?
- 15:54I'm doing it, you know, the way a lot of people eat.
- 15:56And then it means that my head is just overflowing with ideas and crazy stuff.
- 16:03So to me, the performance is like jazz.
- 16:07It is improv.
- 16:08I never have prepared remarks.
- 16:10I never have a prepared presentation.
- 16:13I have spent time researching the audience, researching the client, researching the subject, but I honestly don't know what I'm about to say until it comes out of my mouth.
- 16:23And I think that's part of the emotional energy that's in the room that people realize.
- 16:29Not only do I know my stuff, but I might say something incendiary at any moment.
- 16:34So you really got to listen.
- 16:36I don't dumb down.
- 16:38I try to raise everybody up.
- 16:40It's almost like transcendental meditation.
- 16:43I'm really trying to raise the vibrational energy in the room so that it is innovation, so that it is intelligent, so that we as a group, the audience and the speaker, and I love
- 16:53when people interrupt and ask questions, that we get to knowledge that no one has encountered before.
- 16:59Because that's what I get out of it.
- 17:01I want to learn stuff.
- 17:02They want to learn stuff.
- 17:04So it's kind of magic.
- 17:07We come back.
- 17:08Jesse and I talk about his move to the farm.
- 17:11why he framed it the Academy of the Impossible, and why it's a place where leadership is tested not by titles or talk, but by whether work and animals that cannot be matters
- 17:21through charisma.
- 17:26Hi, it's Tony Chapman.
- 17:28Food does mean the world to each of us and to all of us.
- 17:33Some of us have the privilege that food can be something we explore, learn about new cultures, test our creativity in the kitchen, dine and enjoy the creativity of a master
- 17:44chef.
- 17:46But for many people in Canada and around the world, each day they're dealing with food insecurity.
- 17:51And Canada can play a role in changing it.
- 17:54we can become a superpower in food.
- 17:57But to do so, we really need to support our farmers.
- 18:01And so I want to give a big shout out to Farm Credit Canada, the University of Guelph, and RBC for putting together the Foundations in Agricultural Management.
- 18:10It's an online course, it's free, but it gives people that work in the agricultural sector the knowledge and confidence to make a lifetime of better informed decisions.
- 18:20to learn about business strategy and planning and farm management, succession planning and financial fundamentals.
- 18:27So here's to the University of Guelph, FCC and RBC.
- 18:31And here's to making Canada a superpower in agriculture.
- 18:35This food means the world to you, to me and to RBC.
- 18:44My current dream would be to have like a guy on bass and a guy on trombone as part of my talk so that like a James Brown thing I could be like, picnic!
- 18:56oh Fuse that element into it.
- 18:59I'm here with someone whose creativity I also admire.
- 19:02So that's why I'm enjoying unriffing on this.
- 19:06Joining me today is Jesse Hirsch.
- 19:07He's an evangelist.
- 19:08He's an activist.
- 19:10He's one of the most enlightening and exciting minds.
- 19:13And I'm honored to have my chapter that matters.
- 19:18You've got influence, you've got attention, you've got everything that you've gone after since you were preschool.
- 19:26And yet you turn your back on most of it to do this green acres thing, to go off to a rural farm.
- 19:33think you call it the Academy, the impossible.
- 19:35Take me back to that decision and let's unpack what you've learned on the farm.
- 19:40Because from what I understand,
- 19:42goats give you more enlightenment than a lot of humans nowadays?
- 19:4511 years ago, I decided I should get a master's degree, right?
- 19:49I'm just this hustler out on stages and I don't have any bona fides.
- 19:53So, all right, I'll go to Van Ryerson now Toronto Metropolitan University.
- 19:59I originally went in thinking I'd study podcasting because I love podcasting.
- 20:04But within the first week, I said, no, AI, AI is what's gonna change the media industry.
- 20:09That's what I gotta study.
- 20:10And when I came out of the degree, I'm like, okay, I've got all this AI knowledge.
- 20:15Where do I wanna apply it?
- 20:17That's when agriculture really struck me as the right place and the right time to take my AI talents.
- 20:23But the other reason, I didn't feel I was turning my back.
- 20:27I felt that the backs had been turned on me.
- 20:30in the sense that like I had a really uh emotional falling out with the CBC because I dared to criticize them and you're not allowed to do that.
- 20:38The moment you do that, you are persona non grata.
- 20:41Even to go back to the public speaking, people don't wanna hire a crazy guy.
- 20:46They wanna hire someone who's gonna give you the deck ahead of time, who's not gonna say anything unpredictable and who is zero risk.
- 20:54I felt marginalized.
- 20:55I felt that even though I've spent my entire life
- 20:59elevating and educating that people were treating me like I was a risk that I was a pariah.
- 21:06And so farming, I believe, is the last frontier of freedom.
- 21:10It's the one part of society where not only can you be an entrepreneur, but the only people watching what you do are just animals.
- 21:19And so I've learned how to weld, I've learned how to do electricity, I've learned carpentry, and none of those things I could do in the city, because someone would have
- 21:27told me you're doing it wrong and you're an idiot.
- 21:29But when I'm doing it out on the farm, there's no where there, and I can make the mistakes, and I can learn from the mistakes.
- 21:35So I wanted to go to the margins, because I felt that that's where innovation happens.
- 21:40But I was also feeling, to your earlier point about how dumb society is becoming, that as a smart guy, I didn't want
- 21:47anymore and it's better to go hang out with the animals than it was to hang out with the people who just want to yell at each other and throw disrespect around.
- 21:55know you think about the times in history where people we now study their words, their meanings, their expressions, their insights into that time in life were often dismissed,
- 22:08marginalized, sent out to pasture, exiled, considered a threat.
- 22:13How do you feel when that happens?
- 22:15I you're talking about, felt that way, but it must have hurt a lot because you have a lot to offer people and yet it's almost like you have glaucoma, that tunnel vision to the
- 22:25point where they didn't see what you had to offer.
- 22:28They just saw what you might offend, where you might offend.
- 22:31I love you, pal.
- 22:32And I wouldn't be having this conversation with anyone else.
- 22:35So I'm going to give you an answer.
- 22:37I haven't really told anyone.
- 22:39In the midst of all this, kind of like, you know, when remote work in the pandemic was normal, I was kind of invited to apply for a really interesting government job.
- 22:49And it was at a point of my depression where I thought, hey, someone actually wants me.
- 22:53I was like, okay, yeah, I'll do it.
- 22:54And they did a kind of first assessment to kind of tell me how the process would go.
- 22:59And then they called me up and said, well, we're rejecting you.
- 23:02Okay, that's your right, but you didn't interview me.
- 23:06And they said,
- 23:07Well, you're Jesse Hirsch, we already know who you are.
- 23:09Well, no, you don't.
- 23:11Like, not until you interview me and talk to me.
- 23:14You may think you know me, because I'm all over the internet.
- 23:17Come on, that's dehumanizing.
- 23:19And that really doubled down that depression, because it made me think, you know, why even bother if they're going to judge me based on who they think I am?
- 23:27Rather than giving me the opportunity, then it feels like...
- 23:31the double whammy, right?
- 23:32That there's really no opportunity there.
- 23:34But again, that's why I kept focusing on agriculture, because the cows don't care, the goats don't care.
- 23:40And it's one of those worlds where you can just keep plotting and doing your own thing.
- 23:44And honestly, that's where my confidence has really returned like a phoenix.
- 23:49And you know, you talk about your welding and electrical skills, but you also brought fiber and AI to the farming.
- 23:55You brought technology as this
- 23:58know, entrepreneurial where freedom still exists, where there's the wild well west mentality.
- 24:03You're not coming in with a six shooter.
- 24:05You're coming in with things that I got to believe conventional farming would go, Jesse, we've been doing this this way for 100 years.
- 24:11Who the hell are you?
- 24:12Funnily enough, uh farming has become remarkably revolutionary.
- 24:17And even though there are a lot of people who are like, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- 24:22There's even more people who see a guy like me from the Internet and from the startup world and are like,
- 24:28We gotta listen to that guy.
- 24:29We want to hear what he's doing.
- 24:31Cause to your point, I didn't learn welding and electricity just to play with, you know, steel and no, I did it to build a robot.
- 24:39So last year I built my first farm robot, you which was ugly and had some issues and might've killed somebody if it wasn't used properly.
- 24:49But this year,
- 24:51the robots I'm able to build thanks to the revolution in AI and vibe coding and agents.
- 24:58Oh my God.
- 25:01And so that's where to your point, I got a lot of confidence that the kind of software I'm building, the kind of automated systems I'm building, the robots I'm doing, all of which I
- 25:11want to make open source so that any other farmer can use these robots.
- 25:15Like rather than have John Deere make billions off Canadian farmers, I...
- 25:20rather have these robots that any farmer could build.
- 25:23I think this is all a simulation.
- 25:25We're a video game of a master race.
- 25:27Ratings were going down.
- 25:28They brought the orange guy back.
- 25:30We repeat mistakes because that narrative worked a century ago.
- 25:33It could work again.
- 25:34I mean, how do we make sense of this world, Jesse?
- 25:37How do you make sense of the lack of common sense, decisions people are making?
- 25:42I think it is hilarious, but also crucially important that quote unquote
- 25:51Hallucinations are a problem with AI.
- 25:54Cause I think that hallucinations are a problem with humans.
- 25:58That we as a society are suffering from a lot of hallucinations.
- 26:03And on an individual level, that's not so bad.
- 26:05Like if I hallucinate certain things, that's not the end of the world.
- 26:09But if our government starts to hallucinate, that's a problem.
- 26:13If our corporations, if our infrastructure starts to hallucinate, that's a problem.
- 26:18So I like that in AI, we're starting to go, hey man, these things hallucinate.
- 26:23Maybe we should be checking the math.
- 26:25Maybe we should be double, good.
- 26:27Let's do that with governments now.
- 26:29Let's do that with organizations now.
- 26:31Cause I think we've been allowing for a lot of hallucination and not enough rigor and not enough conversation and dialogue centered around empathy and respect that allows us to
- 26:43understand each other.
- 26:45Cause
- 26:45That's what social media was back in the day when we were naive and optimistic.
- 26:50But that's why these conversations are so important, because to go to the simulation, yes, there is a simulation.
- 26:57The question is, is that simulation just in our body or does it extend into our collective consciousness?
- 27:05The question as to who else has access to that simulation?
- 27:09That, my friend, is a huge philosophical conversation.
- 27:13You you talked about hallucinations.
- 27:15I love the concept.
- 27:16Do you think our government wants that rigor attached to it?
- 27:19I think we're getting less and less open and transparent as a society.
- 27:23I think the problem is control.
- 27:25And I think whether it's our government or whether it's small organizations, their hallucination is they think they can control things that they can't and that everyone
- 27:35recognizes they can't.
- 27:37And the more that they try to control it, the more that their authority and legitimacy and trust disappears.
- 27:44I flip it around.
- 27:45I look at it as they need to be more open.
- 27:49They need to be more humble.
- 27:51They need to be more vulnerable if they want to continue existing.
- 27:55To go back to that Supreme Court presentation I did, I told them point blank, Facebook is competing for your authority.
- 28:04and increasingly more people are gonna trust Facebook than they do the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 28:08That must have gone over really well.
- 28:10Yeah, this is why I say people don't always call me back, right?
- 28:14I think that these crises are being made by governments that are incompetent, not evil.
- 28:20And I think that that incompetence is so entrenched that they don't see it themselves.
- 28:26They still arrogantly think that they are gonna be able to solve the problem, that a good PR, a good...
- 28:33release a good photo op is going to save the day when it goes down to the foundations of government itself to reluctantly compliment our American friends as difficult and as uh
- 28:49violent as the current administration is.
- 28:52I have to give them credit.
- 28:54They are putting in the effort to wrap their head around the Internet.
- 28:57I may not agree with the conclusions that they're making, but at least they're addressing it.
- 29:03versus the Canadians.
- 29:06You know, it's interesting you talk about the states as well.
- 29:08And I admire the fact that they are looking at a three dimensional chessboard, but they never look at it any other way but maintaining global power, world power.
- 29:19I believe that if you focus on something too much, you will never get it.
- 29:24And chances are you'll get the opposite.
- 29:26And I think the mistake that America is making right now is they are focusing so much on their desire for power.
- 29:33they're gonna lose it.
- 29:34They're focusing so much on the rise of China that they're gonna help make it happen, right?
- 29:40And that's my point about incompetence.
- 29:42When you have people that are too arrogant to question illusion, to question people who are different than them, then it's easy to believe the lies you're telling yourself and
- 29:53not have the critical thinking to say, and again, like if the United States government wanted to hire me to help them, I might actually say yes.
- 30:01If they listen to me and the first thing I would tell them is, if you want to challenge China, if you want to have power around the world, stop picking on Canada.
- 30:11Because Canada is the best asset you used to have, and without even needing to, you're tossing it away.
- 30:19When like, again, intellectually, culturally, uh technologically,
- 30:25We've been passing all our best stuff up to America.
- 30:27Here you go, buddy.
- 30:28Take this.
- 30:29Here you go.
- 30:29Here's some talent.
- 30:30Here's some ideas.
- 30:31Here's some whatever.
- 30:33The moment we stop, America's going to notice.
- 30:36It's a great point because I'd also look at saying we have people in power that know they can maintain power by making America the enemy.
- 30:46This is where I go back to when are we going to get to the middle ground and say, as they said in the old Apollo 13, what do we have in the spaceship that's good?
- 30:54Figure it out.
- 30:55understand what you mean by the middle ground.
- 30:58And I think what we used to call the middle ground is gone.
- 31:02Right?
- 31:02Because maybe it was newspapers where we were all looking at the same page, or maybe it was television where we were all watching the same show, but that shared experience is
- 31:12gone.
- 31:13Instead, what I would offer you is a circle.
- 31:16That where before we had the middle ground, now we could all sit in a circle.
- 31:21Or even though we might be on different ends of that circle, we can all look each other in the eye, we can break bread, and we can say together in this circle, we're united, right?
- 31:30Like that's, think, a model for how we could think of our society that works.
- 31:34Because here's where I'm gonna say something really crazy.
- 31:37Liberalism as we know it is dead and has been dead for quite some time.
- 31:42But liberalism as an ideology has been defeated by two primary things amongst many others.
- 31:48Number one,
- 31:50inability to address climate change.
- 31:52Because on the one hand they talk on and on and on about how important it is.
- 32:00And then the flip side, liberalism enabled wealth disparity.
- 32:04Great U of T professor C.
- 32:06B.
- 32:06McPherson decades ago wrote, liberalism and the possessive individual about how liberalism really does not have a way of acknowledging community, of acknowledging we need to take
- 32:17care of everybody.
- 32:18So instead what we have as liberalism has left and we have a vacuum, have conservatism on one side and social democracy on the other.
- 32:28and then behind them, lots of extremists.
- 32:30But what conservatism and social democracy have in common is we all believe in community.
- 32:36We all believe that fundamentally, no one should fall through the cracks.
- 32:41We differ over things like taxation and like other little issues, but that's what's wrong with Canadian politics today, is it's dominated by a dead ideology when there's so many
- 32:53people on the side with lots of ideas on how to do it differently.
- 32:57And there's no way for us to break that first, pass the post system that guarantees everything can be in this hallucinatory policy loop that I call contemporary liberalism.
- 33:10What replaces the liberalism of today?
- 33:12What does this circle look like?
- 33:14it red, blue, orange, green, or is it a brand new concept in terms of how our society is going to move forward?
- 33:20So the most tangible example of that is coming out of Silicon Valley.
- 33:25And there are a range of
- 33:27interesting, provocative ideologies that are neither left nor right, and they really try to reconceive the world with the internet and AI being a part of it.
- 33:40I've written about this stuff, it's kind of a whole other nerdy conversation for us to have, but the short of it is, it reimagines government.
- 33:48Right?
- 33:48It re-imagines the economy.
- 33:50It re-imagines, you know, how we take care of people.
- 33:53Some are proponents of, universal basic income.
- 33:56Others are, you know, looking at what happens to work when AI, right?
- 34:01So, uh the point of ideology is it's there to help us make sense of the world.
- 34:07You know, I actually think that there's much for us to learn from conservatism.
- 34:12There's much for us to learn from social democracy.
- 34:15But I'm also a methods person.
- 34:17So where Silicon Valley is like, yeah, we can make up these ideologies.
- 34:21Yeah, I'll get the AI to make up an ideology.
- 34:24I kind of want to have the conversations first.
- 34:27How do you take those blinders off these biases, this cognitive belief that you're wrong and I'm right?
- 34:33And I'm seeing this time and time again, I decided to make it, to not talk about politics anymore in this country.
- 34:38I was trying to bring people say, here's two points of view.
- 34:41Here's what Carney's trying to say.
- 34:42Here's what Polo Bay is trying to say.
- 34:44Why don't we have a discussion in the middle?
- 34:46The liberals would like, you're such a conservative, the conservatives, you're such a liberal.
- 34:49That lack of civility, that lack of authenticity, is it me that I've just becoming old and angry or is this something you're saying?
- 34:57No, I think you're seeing the problem before other people do.
- 35:00I think you saw.
- 35:01But I think to answer your question, there's two pieces that's missing.
- 35:05On a cultural level, it's just respect, right?
- 35:08We've forgotten how important respect is, how respect works even amongst enemies.
- 35:14and that if a society doesn't have respect, we don't have a society.
- 35:17We can disagree, but let's respect each other.
- 35:21You and I have, uh for lack of a better phrase, dialogic skills, conversation skills that used to be widespread.
- 35:30I'm sure you and I remember people in older generations who had the gift to gab, who knew how to have conversations, who knew how to make a sale, who knew how to really connect
- 35:40with people on an intimate, authentic level.
- 35:43That's gone.
- 35:45I see very rarely see it amongst younger generations.
- 35:48I very rarely see it amongst my own generation.
- 35:51Even people who used to have it have lost it because it's atrophied and they don't practice it anymore.
- 35:56Maybe they're scared, right?
- 35:58They don't want someone telling them that they're wrong or they're an idiot.
- 36:00I've been a media my whole life.
- 36:02People tell me I'm an idiot all the time.
- 36:04I'm okay with that.
- 36:06It goes back to your point about philosophy.
- 36:09Right?
- 36:09We've spent the last 20, 30 years, which everyone was saying, learn programming, go learn the sciences, go learn the hard skills.
- 36:17When no, it's the arts, it's media, it's language, it's humanities.
- 36:22If you want to be a power programmer developer today, it's your language skills that matter when it comes to using the AI.
- 36:29And it's your imagination when it comes to thinking about the applications that are possible.
- 36:34You and I took the road.
- 36:36traveled right we were the one who said we're gonna be passionate and creative when everyone else said I'm gonna be boring and conformist I would love to come in and mediate
- 36:46between groups who hate each other I would love to deal with people in the agriculture sector who absolutely cannot tolerate being in the same room let's get some good food
- 36:55let's get some good music maybe some cannabis maybe some drinks we can all get along again
- 37:01For you and me, that's maybe courage.
- 37:03For everyone else, they don't even think about it because of fear.
- 37:06Let's move to Walden Pond, one of my favorite books.
- 37:09And when I heard you were going off and doing this farm, I said, Jesse's building his Walden Pond.
- 37:14And there's going to be a book that comes out of it.
- 37:17And it's going to be philosophy.
- 37:18It's going to be his version of utopia.
- 37:21Am I fair in saying that?
- 37:22Yes.
- 37:23Maybe it's also George Orwell's Animal Farm that I wanted my own little political drama.
- 37:29happening on my property.
- 37:30You you said something earlier that speaks to my heart, which is I wanted to be with nature, right?
- 37:36I wanted to live with nature.
- 37:38I wanted to wake up every day with nature.
- 37:40I want to talk to the same trees day after day and be like, hey man, how you doing?
- 37:45I didn't really know what I was doing when I did this.
- 37:48I kind of think that I'm still figuring it out as I go.
- 37:51I'm not sure if there'll be maybe the AI will write the book after my death based on all my crazy postings.
- 37:58To go back to the herd thing, what has really transformed my worldview is my relationship with animals.
- 38:06You were using the word herd earlier in the way that pop culture uses it, which is kind of to evoke obedience and conformity and following without thinking.
- 38:17And that's what I thought too, until I became a herdsman.
- 38:21Right?
- 38:21And my favorite activity, spring to fall, is taking my goats for a walk on the back property where there's no fences and they can just graze and whatever.
- 38:30And you quickly realize that herds are not unified, homogeneous entities.
- 38:36In fact, they're very conflicted.
- 38:38They're very diverse.
- 38:40They're groupings of individuals who all have their own agendas.
- 38:45And it's only when we observe the group as a whole
- 38:49that we start projecting meaning, that we start seeing patterns.
- 38:53But to the individual goats, they're all jerks trying to do their own thing.
- 38:58And I, as their leader, have to think of all different types.
- 39:02I can't force them to do anything.
- 39:04I have to align my interests with their interests so what they want is what I want and that's how I get them to do something.
- 39:11And I'm like, hey, wait a minute, isn't that advertising?
- 39:14And that's where I came to this really interesting insight.
- 39:18that maybe one of the mistakes we've been making all along is the word consumer.
- 39:23Because my problem with the word consumer is it doesn't speak to the agency, the dynamism, the uniqueness of every individual human.
- 39:32But what if as marketers, instead of consumers, we started thinking about herds?
- 39:38Because if we accept that herds are comprised of individuals, but individuals seek social identity and belonging for reasons of safety,
- 39:48then we have to understand not just the individual, not just the group, but the complex relationship that comes as a result.
- 39:57Now that's a level of sophistication that I'm not sure the advertising and marketing industry has currently has an appetite for.
- 40:04But that's where my thinking of humanity is evolving that A, we're animals and that animals actually have a lot of things we do, which I think the problem with liberalism
- 40:14is it was an ideology that came when we were all farmers.
- 40:18And in fact, most of our ideologies today, they originate when the founding fathers had farms and spent most of their time watching animals and thinking that's how we should
- 40:29govern society.
- 40:31Versus now we're living on the internet with bots and trolls and agents.
- 40:35And that's what we need to be thinking about when we talk about how we're governing society.
- 40:39I also want to talk about your near death experience.
- 40:43How did it change you?
- 40:44Let's frame it.
- 40:45It was COVID.
- 40:46It wasn't a skip in park.
- 40:48It was pretty serious, wasn't it?
- 40:49So I have chronic immune issues.
- 40:52And one of the impacts COVID has on people is it can really mess up your guts.
- 40:56So there's probably a lot of people listening to this who maybe had about a COVID in which they were pooping a lot.
- 41:01I had that, but then my system just went into arrest.
- 41:05And you know what, Tony?
- 41:07Not to make a point, but we're having fun today.
- 41:11None of that would have happened in the United States.
- 41:14Right?
- 41:14In the United States, I would have had access to medicine immediately.
- 41:17They would have looked at my condition and they would have given me the steroids that initially would have got my body back and then the other medicine that fixed it.
- 41:25But here in Canada, where, you know, not only will they not treat you until all the tests are done, but it takes you forever to get all the tests.
- 41:33And of course, back then there was lots of backlogs of tests.
- 41:36Had I just got the steroids, which I knew I needed, I would have been fine.
- 41:41but it took four months just to get the steroids, at which point I think I was down to 118 pounds and, you know, internal bleeding and all that stuff.
- 41:51So totally unnecessary, but traumatic because I came out of that going, well, life's short.
- 41:58I guess I better make the most of every moment.
- 42:01So that was the other fuel beneath the Phoenix that...
- 42:06be not taking any punches, not holding any quarter, and not hesitating to say things like maybe we should abolish our education systems, maybe liberalism as a concept is dead, and
- 42:16then for good measure, if we want to save public broadcasting, let's get rid of the CBC.
- 42:21Is that your greatest gift, the fact that you realize now that that fuse that was lit years ago when you were arrested, mortality is attached to it, and then the next 10, 20,
- 42:32or 30 years, you've got a lot to say and a lot to offer.
- 42:36That was the wake-up call that said, I can't just spend every minute walking that back pasture with my goats.
- 42:43I have a duty.
- 42:44I have a calling and I got to answer it.
- 42:46Yes and no.
- 42:48Yes, you are right.
- 42:48That sense of mortality, that sense of live every day as if it's your last, that is central to my operating philosophy, 100%.
- 42:58I'm not convinced I'm going to live another five years, let alone several decades.
- 43:02I'm happy to take those decades, but I think...
- 43:05To answer your question, it's actually the love of life, the love of learning.
- 43:10My whole life I felt I could die tomorrow, because what I learned today was so intoxicating, so illuminating, filled with such joy.
- 43:20And that's why I wake up.
- 43:23Like these days, I'm literally waking up at 2.33 in the morning, because I want to go play with AI.
- 43:28Cause I wanna go learn, I wanna go do these tools.
- 43:32So that's really is my secret.
- 43:33And that's the thing that I try to infect other people with.
- 43:36That if learning is your through line, aging will be easy, right?
- 43:42Because you're always gonna learn new stuff.
- 43:44Your mind is gonna stay fresh.
- 43:45Your body's gonna stay fresh.
- 43:47No matter how crazy or violent the world becomes, if you're learning, not only are you gonna survive, you're gonna thrive.
- 43:55It seems obvious to me.
- 43:57It's not something that costs any money.
- 43:59It's not some cult.
- 44:01But learning, I think, is one of those things that as a society we've given a bad rep to.
- 44:07And it's one of the secrets, I think, to joy and happiness.
- 44:10know, Jesse, I always wrap up with my three takeaways.
- 44:14I'm not going to worry about the number three.
- 44:16There's two words that really stood tall in this conversation.
- 44:20One is curiosity.
- 44:21And you began the interview saying you were a curious kid.
- 44:25Your curiosity is intoxicating because every time you open that window, you get even more excited.
- 44:32There's no diminishing, there's no fuse that's ending.
- 44:34You're excited about it.
- 44:35But the other side is control.
- 44:37And the control is the less curious we make people, the more we control them.
- 44:42How do we get people hungry for curiosity, which takes more work, which takes collaboration and debate and critical thinking versus that stackable content that society
- 44:54is controlled by?
- 44:55Let me end up with that question to you is what do we need to do as a human race to regain our appetite as opposed to being subdued, I guess, to the control of algorithms and all
- 45:07they bring?
- 45:08We have to reward learning, right?
- 45:10It's one thing for me to say, hey, yeah, learning is the answer.
- 45:14Our workplaces, our associations, our governments need to reward their members, their employees when they learn and reward them in a way that creates envy.
- 45:24that creates FOMO that makes other people go, hey, why is he getting recognition?
- 45:28Why is he getting a pay bump?
- 45:29know, why is he getting an extra week of vacation?
- 45:32It's because he took the time to learn and he applied that learning to the company and it helped our bottom line.
- 45:37And governments, they're scared of learning, right?
- 45:41They're scared of having civil servants learn stuff and then challenge what the minister might say.
- 45:46So I think we got to reward learning.
- 45:48We have to incentivize learning.
- 45:49have to, you know, the same way that we reward victory and success.
- 45:53Let's reward learning as a form of victory and success.
- 45:56And I think the catalytic change from that has infinite potential.
- 46:01Is that something that could happen over a generation if we arm this next generation with this incredible appetite to challenge, to learn, to question, to demand change?
- 46:12I think it could happen faster.
- 46:13On the one hand, I think that we, and this isn't radical or provocative, a lot of people say this, I think we've let our kids down.
- 46:21I think we've really, you know, haven't been there for our kids.
- 46:24We haven't given them the tools we need.
- 46:26So therefore I think it's wrong that we ask them to save us.
- 46:30I think if we're going to accomplish the mission you and I are describing, it's intergenerational, right?
- 46:36It's not just young people, it's old people, it's middle-aged people, it's everybody.
- 46:41And this is where one of the dangerous things I hear people say is, I'm too old to learn.
- 46:47And I think there's a lot of really smart, really experienced people who, when they retire, we as a society lose a lot.
- 46:54I think it's all hands on deck.
- 46:56I think we are experiencing, whether it's as a country or as a society, an existential moment, and we should all come together in a circle.
- 47:04We can acknowledge our differences, but we got to help each other.
- 47:08And I think to go to your point, we can make that change faster than a generation.
- 47:14if we had the humility to be open to new ideas and new people.
- 47:18I wonder now with today's society where these kids, you know, they have a magic wand in their pocket.
- 47:24They can escape a boring history class.
- 47:26They can find pursuit in a video game.
- 47:28They can find competition online.
- 47:31I wonder is that generation divide, much like our wealth divide, becoming so to the point where we are going to have a breakup in society.
- 47:40Maybe that's where we're heading.
- 47:41We've been talking about control a lot today.
- 47:44Let's take a moment to talk about power, because power and control are not the same thing.
- 47:49But I think we need to be giving more power to young people.
- 47:53We're trying to control them and it's not working and they don't have any power.
- 47:57They don't have a lot of economic avenues.
- 47:59They can't buy a house.
- 48:00You know, it's difficult to do a lot of stuff.
- 48:03We should be thinking about how we can share our power with them, because that's what they want.
- 48:08They want power.
- 48:10That's why hip hop continues to be a source within pop culture, because it promises people power.
- 48:16So again, let's stop focusing on control.
- 48:19Let's start focusing on power, how power works, how we can share power, how we can stop evil people from using power.
- 48:27Those are the key policy questions I think we need to be focusing on moving forward.
- 48:31Jesse Hersh, you never disappoint.
- 48:33I enjoy it.
- 48:34I smile, I laugh.
- 48:35I think I get distracted wondering.
- 48:37Where this is going and all of that has been incredible and I appreciate you brother, you know that.
- 48:42My pleasure.
- 48:50Many of know that I often end my show by bringing on somebody from RBC and more often than not, it extends beyond banking to the role organizations can play and helping individuals,
- 49:02corporations, communities, even Canada get to where it needs, wants and deserves to go.
- 49:08Joining me today is Lisa Ashton.
- 49:09She's the Agricultural Policy Lead at RBC Thought Leadership.
- 49:13And Lisa, it's fantastic to have you on the show.
- 49:15Yes.
- 49:16Thank you for having me, Tony.
- 49:17Tell me a little bit about what you're doing as the agricultural policy lead and why is agriculture something that really RBC is focusing a lot of attention on?
- 49:27My role provides the opportunity to spearhead our agricultural research from most topical issues like trade and tariffs, but also important issues including uh climate and policy
- 49:41as well.
- 49:42So complimentary to that.
- 49:44engage with stakeholders across Canada to understand what issues are most important to them and work together to drive action because we're not only a think tank, but we're also
- 49:55a do tank.
- 49:56I want to talk to you a little bit about Canada can become a superpower in agriculture, the quality of our food, the efficacy, moving up from a commodity to value added.
- 50:07All of these things can play into this North Star.
- 50:11Is it possible that as a country we can play that role in terms of providing the food that the world so desperately needs?
- 50:18I would actually argue that Canada is already a powerhouse superpower in agricultural and agri-food production, but also export.
- 50:28And believe under a high-growth scenario, Canada could actually add $44 billion.
- 50:34within the next 10 years.
- 50:36So there is certainly a north star to move towards.
- 50:40I think there's a lot that needs to happen domestically, a lot that needs to happen in terms of our trade growth and diversification approach.
- 50:47Emerging economies such as Brazil and Argentina are biting up some key categories that traditionally are very important to Canada.
- 50:56So oil seeds, grains and meats, that's one key challenge that Canada faces.
- 51:02It is somewhat in a way kind of dulling its competitive edge relative to some of our traditional competitors like Australia, for example, who is really taking an aggressive
- 51:13leadership approach in terms of accessing what we're calling the growth market.
- 51:18So markets that you would expect to see high GDP and high population growth.
- 51:23Part of the issue is not so much our ability to grow, it's our ability to be a reliable exporter.
- 51:29Transportation infrastructure is key, I guess, linchpin in terms of our growth.
- 51:36When we compared ourselves to other key agri-food exporters, including Brazil, Australia, and the US, we're behind all of them in terms of our turnaround time.
- 51:45And there's key challenges that slow that down for us in terms of getting product to market fast, such as rules around loading grain onto ships when it rains.
- 51:57I think the other element is also being a little bit more aggressive in how we are exploring and um delivering on trade diversification.
- 52:07Canada has roughly 15 free trade agreements that gives us access to more than two thirds of the global economy.
- 52:14So that's a lot of opportunity that's already on Canada's plate that it can be taking more advantage of, including within the European Union, through the Trans-Pacific Partnership.
- 52:27And even some of our bilateral agreements with uh Ukraine, Chile, Colombia, we have access to all those markets.
- 52:33So taking a more aggressive approach to enter those markets and deliver our products to them is a key opportunity.
- 52:40Talk to me about technology, regenerative farming, some of the moves that are being made on the chessboard to not only maybe drive efficiency, but the efficacy of food.
- 52:51And how does that play into Canada in terms of our position globally?
- 52:55We are very fortunate to have a significant amount of natural resources from water to land.
- 53:01A very efficient production system.
- 53:03So when we looked at uh Canada's agricultural total factor productivity, basically how efficient are you using your inputs relative to your outputs, we exceed the OECD average.
- 53:16I think it's important to note that we can't be productive if we don't have healthy soils and we don't have resilient ecosystems.
- 53:24So RBC works very closely with some of our corporate partners to help scale the adoption and access to climate smart practices and we do that through one of our climate action
- 53:35alliances.
- 53:36spending a lot of time helping youths find their path in life.
- 53:40A lot of them seem to dismiss agriculture as a career.
- 53:44I have to believe that a career in agriculture has got to be something that's incredibly rewarding, purposeful.
- 53:51has nothing but creativity and innovation as part of it.
- 53:53That is a missed opportunity that agriculture is not kind of top of mind for many uh young people that are determining kind of what they want to do for their career because it is
- 54:04such an evolving and growing space.
- 54:07There's lots of exciting technology applications.
- 54:10So generative AI has a role from on-farm efficiency all the way through the value chain.
- 54:16There's a lot of diverse
- 54:18opportunities.
- 54:19So for example, I'm technically a researcher, but I say I work in the agricultural sector.
- 54:24There's opportunities in marketing, communication, engineering, and it is really an exciting field and also a leading sector for Canada.
- 54:32So a place for you to really grow your career with the number of different avenues that can be taken.
- 54:39I really want to do more shows on why food means the world to all of us.
- 54:45and why Canadian food means the world to the world.
- 54:47So I really appreciate you joining me in Chatter That Matters.
- 54:50Thank you, Tony.
- 54:51Happy to join anytime.
- 54:54Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chata That Matters.
- 54:57It's Tony Chapman.
- 54:59Thanks for listening and let's chat soon.