Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Child Attention Spans, Tarot Ethics, and 988
Transcript
- 0:00So Rebecca Emails and Ethics conversations. What do you say, I'm in upper
- 0:05tier patron Kelsey Hawk. They said, could the need for fast paced content
- 0:11be detrimental to young kids attention spans more so than TV? What do you
- 0:16think? Yeah? I mean you see how I see how my own teen
- 0:20is wired now, cannot have a single screen experience, cannot just watch TV,
- 0:29is constantly on their phone and watching TV. I mean, they're doing
- 0:33fine in their life. At some point it gets turned off. But the
- 0:37amount of stimulation that is normal to them, it's a lot. It's got
- 0:43to impact how our brains are wired. And we know it impacts the pleasure
- 0:46centers, and we also know how much it impacts kids self esteem. I
- 0:51mean, Seattle Public Schools is currently attempting to sue Snapchat or one of those
- 0:57companies to say how detrimental the amount of social media presence is for kids.
- 1:03And part of it is that it's relentless. You know, you see a
- 1:07body type over and over and over again. That's not yours. It's it's
- 1:12not good. Yeah, yeah, yeah, this is a complicated issue,
- 1:17but in a nutshell, their research is such that it's mixed. So on
- 1:23the good side of the current landscape of stimulation to kids, because it's been
- 1:29ever increasing over time. Right before cell phones, you had commercials that were
- 1:34edited very quickly, and before that you had something else. So it's been
- 1:38something that's been research for a long time, and the research has been continuing
- 1:42to see any sort of effect of the current landscape. But so on the
- 1:46good side, what we can say is that kids are smarter today than they
- 1:51ever were before, you know, things involving attention, working memory, cognitive
- 1:56focus. So the idea that the children of today have some sort of cognitive
- 2:00negative effect is not born out in the data. Now, it's hard to
- 2:05know why. On average, kids all over the world are more intelligent,
- 2:08meaning better attention span, better working memory, better cognition. There's a lot
- 2:14of factors. Nutrition, better conditions for children, more education, more access
- 2:19to information, that kind of thing, the Flint effect. But there is
- 2:22some evidence that the sort of things that kids participate in video games included,
- 2:28actually help them in a lot of realms. Like one of the things about
- 2:32social media is there's a lot of reading. You know, you read a
- 2:37lot and you type a lot. And remember when we were kids, Yeah,
- 2:42there was it was hardly class or at the very least when you put
- 2:46pen to paper, it would be rare, especially when you're in the second
- 2:50grade, right, there's not a lot of writing things down. It would
- 2:53be doing homework, you know. I remember maybe you remember this too,
- 2:57Recca, that after summer vacation I would go back to school and I wouldn't
- 3:00know how to write my name because the entire summer I hadn't read or written
- 3:06a single word. And so for kids, you know, that's just one
- 3:10dimension of verbal comprehension, that kind of thing, the ability to process a
- 3:15lot of information. You know, you use it, you don't lose it.
- 3:19That kind of thing. So stimulation, And there's a lot of myths
- 3:23like this idea of attention spans getting shorter. There's a lot of research on
- 3:27this because there have been a lot of claims along these lines. Like a
- 3:30common thing that you will hear is that children today have attention spans that are
- 3:37x amount of seconds shorter. I don't know if you remember when we were
- 3:42teenage in our twenties, there was this notion about the MTV generation, Yes,
- 3:46yeah, and how our attention spans were only seven seconds long or something
- 3:52like this. Do you remember that, no, but I remember the idea
- 3:54that we watched three minute long videos was just going to destroy us. Yeah,
- 3:59right, And the editing of these videos was very quick as well,
- 4:03and the notion was was that it was rotting our brains. And there's just
- 4:08look how intelligent we are now. There's just no evidence that our attention spans
- 4:14are getting shorter. Plus it's hard to know how to measure it an attention
- 4:17span, right, there's a lot of things you can look at, but
- 4:21what does that mean? And when you reduce these to some scary news headline
- 4:27of like kids today have attention spans that are twelve seconds instead of twenty seconds
- 4:30when I was kidding, it just feels right. It sort of slots into
- 4:33this notion that kids are idiots today. That's been something throughout history. Well,
- 4:39I remember when I was in the fourth grade literally looking at second graders
- 4:42and saying, kids today don't know how to respect their elders, because when
- 4:45I was in second grade, I respected the fourth grades anyway. So you
- 4:48know, there's a lot of different myths out there. Now. You mentioned
- 4:51some very obvious things that can be measured, not necessarily cognition, intelligence,
- 4:58attention span, but anxiety depression, Yeah, those are measurable effects as well.
- 5:04They're off the charts right now. Right, we don't know how to
- 5:08know the cause, but you know, it seems pretty obvious that isolation,
- 5:13social comparison, online billing, body dysmorphia, all those lack of social connection.
- 5:20I mean, really, you know, how we defined ourselves as teens
- 5:24were kind of hours on the floor with our peers talking, self regulating,
- 5:30coregulating with someone else. And now the amount of time that and unmonitored.
- 5:36Right, You often tell stories of like wandering in the woods, you know,
- 5:41I mean, how many hours did I spend making ant traps that didn't
- 5:45work out of like soap and yogurt containers? I mean I don't, I
- 5:48literally don't think I was monitored for a single minute of my entire childhood.
- 5:54I mean I might have been around my parents at times, but I don't
- 5:58think they were even monitoring then. And I don't know if I've told this
- 6:00story, but when I was in seventh grade, my mom I was going
- 6:05to Berkeley public schools, but my dad lived in South San Francisco. My
- 6:11high school, my junior high, was Willard Junior High. My mom left
- 6:15and I was staying with my dad, and I had to get from my
- 6:18dad's house to my middle school, and of course I didn't ask any adult
- 6:26what would be the best way to do that, So I just got on
- 6:30Bart at my dad's stop, got off at MacArthur station. You can maps
- 6:35this parts Master Transportation, and then I walked from MacArthur Station to my junior
- 6:46high and like, you know, it never crossed my mind, like maybe
- 6:49there's a bus. And I remember one day I ran into a kid that
- 6:54I went to school with and he was like, what are you doing?
- 6:59And I described I had my whole journey and they were like, that's insane
- 7:03you're traveling. Was there a bus that went by? Probably somebody can probably
- 7:08map quest this now, and the map quest I'm so old. Whatever,
- 7:11I'm sure there was a bus my middle schools on a major street, but
- 7:15like, no one figured it out for me, right, I just kind
- 7:19of like use the knowledge that I had. And you knew you had enough
- 7:24confidence in yourself that you were like, well, I'll fear something out,
- 7:28all right, walked I don't know three miles. Yeah, And the amount
- 7:30of self esteem that you have, and this is well understood as well that
- 7:35helicopter parenting, which is a different issue, of course than social media,
- 7:40results in children lacking self esteem, lacking self confidence, lacking this sense of
- 7:46themselves as capable human beings you can accomplish things on their own, a bunch
- 7:51more a likelihood that they think of themselves as a failure and dependent on other
- 7:56people. And you know, I'm all for protecting your children from harm,
- 8:01of course, but in the same way that you can't or it's not recommended
- 8:05that you create a sterile environment so that child is never exposed to anything early
- 8:11in life that will help them to not develop allergies to certain things. You
- 8:15also want to have a little bit of real life, you know, getting
- 8:20their hands in the dirt, so to speak, letting them do things on
- 8:24their own. It's scary, but you know, it's not bad parenting the
- 8:28way some people will say anyway. So yeah, I would say that overall
- 8:33social media, at this point, we don't know everything, and we probably
- 8:35never will because the only way we could know more precise effects of social media
- 8:41is if we literally took thousands of children and raise them in a bubble and
- 8:46had a group of children that had social media and a group of kids that
- 8:50didn't and then you would see the differences. So we're left with large scale
- 8:56studies that might be identifying effects of different things in the world. But my
- 9:03take is that it's something that's always been present with raising children. There's always
- 9:09things that are impacting them, both positive and negative, and the key is
- 9:13is to be attuned to your child because children, generally speaking, when they
- 9:18have a good relationship, Sure they like social media, they like the Internet,
- 9:20but they're still human beings. They want to interact with other humans in
- 9:24person. That's what we evolve for. There's a lot of flashing lights,
- 9:28there's a lot of pensity to addiction, and some kids might have a greater
- 9:33disposition of that. But if you're raising kids, or just all of us
- 9:37really, I mean kids, all of us are potentially affected negatively by social
- 9:41media. But the key is that we have in person, attached, secure,
- 9:46connected relationships with people, and then whatever effects that social media might have,
- 9:54it will be mitigated by that foundation. Yeah. Right, And I
- 10:00look at boy like you know, when I look at everybody's having a fun
- 10:05day blah blah blah blah blah, and then I hear everybody's real story of
- 10:09what's really going on in their lives. At least as an adult, I
- 10:11can understand the difference of that. But you know, especially in the year
- 10:18that I've had, I've learned so much about how coregulating with people in the
- 10:24present moment is probably the thing I need most, you know, Like,
- 10:30I really look forward to the times that we get to podcasts together because like
- 10:33I'm sitting with you and looking with you and laughing with you and getting really
- 10:37funny text from you before I arrive. And I won't even say what the
- 10:41last one was, but it was not what I was expecting on my way
- 10:45in the door. And so yeah, I mean, this is what humans
- 10:50are wired for. We are not really wired enough to understand these kind of
- 10:56short snimpets of everyone else's life looks happy in minds feel shitty. Yeah,
- 11:01especially for kids who haven't had a ton of experiences of ups and downs.
- 11:07And yeah, I mean my you know, high school is obviously a complete
- 11:13disaster for everyone. But having watched my kid their first year out of high
- 11:18school and watching like what friends have circle back and said, you know,
- 11:22I've made some mistakes. Do you still like me? Like it's really sweet?
- 11:28Wow? Yeah, yeah, I mean that's another thing to me.
- 11:31Anecdotally, kids today are much more emotionally healthy than we were when we were
- 11:35kids. So there's something that's going right in our society. Well, it's
- 11:41the social emotional learning and the diversity, equity and inclusion education that naturally happens
- 11:46in most schools. Yeah. So you know this notion of like kids today
- 11:52are their brains are being rotted. I just I don't see that now.
- 11:56I mean, if you've spent any time with a jar average high schooler,
- 12:01they are more socially aware. Oh, they're aware of everything. Like it's
- 12:07I am my mind is blown by the conversations that I've had with sixteen,
- 12:11seventeen, eighteen year olds, Like they are the kids, they're too all
- 12:16right, they understand too much of what's happening. Yeah, so, Rebecca,
- 12:20you wanted to talk about ethics. I need your Hell what's the question?
- 12:24Oh it's big? Okay, So let me so. So my one
- 12:30day or that Tarot and Therapy Cascadia has requested a three dayer. So you
- 12:35do classes to therapists, yes, teaching them how to use tarrow cards and
- 12:43to row. I don't know if concepts concepts in therapy with clients yes,
- 12:48and you've already been doing that two years now. You make your own to
- 12:52row cards with I'm yeah, I through collage and ephemera, we make Tarot
- 12:56cards to It's purely our space learning and if people want to sign up for
- 13:01this, this is an in person class or online it's Casscadia trainings. Okay,
- 13:09Cascadia dot com trainings. Yeah, I think it's Casscadia trainings. So
- 13:16you have questions about ethics, right, So they've bumped me up from a
- 13:20one day or I'll continue to do the one days, but I'm going to
- 13:22be doing a three day which is pretty amazing. And in order for them
- 13:28to be able to do the CEUs that they need to do, I need
- 13:31to do four hours of ethics content in my Tarot presentation. So there's a
- 13:37one hour that's really clear, which is what are all people's fears about using
- 13:43tarot in therapy, which really there's no ethical issue. But I've learned as
- 13:48an art therapist, I give myself way more permission to play in the session
- 13:52and try things out with clients. Um, so, like you know,
- 13:56does therapy have to be evidence based? But I've never taught an ethics graduate
- 14:03class or an ethics CU and I think I'm in the minority of my friends
- 14:09who've taught graduate school. No, I would say it's rare that you'll have
- 14:13a professor. I've never taught anything. Really. Yeah, it's not really
- 14:18something I'm super interested in teaching anyway. Well, God, you know,
- 14:22when I think about it now that I review all the people that taught ethics,
- 14:26a lot of them were kind of roped into it because it's not it's
- 14:30not a sexy topic, so very dry. Usually it's foisted on someone and
- 14:35they're like, okay, fine, and as soon as they can they get
- 14:39out of that gig. Yeah, there's there's not a lot of specialists in
- 14:45ethics that you can find. I mean, I suppose you can pull in
- 14:48someone from the outside who's like a lawyer or something. And there's a guy
- 14:52in town that's both a lawyer and a therapist and he has this market locked
- 14:56down. Yeah, I can't remember his name, Eric, Yeah, Eric
- 15:00something. But I also have my lawyer is a social worker and now an
- 15:07attorney, and so she knows all sorts of stuff along these two specializes in
- 15:11therapy, ethics and legal stuff and has been the court a lot that's always
- 15:15the key is like, if you have a teacher in ethics, what you
- 15:20want to ask them is how many times have you actually litigated? How many
- 15:22times have you actually defended someone or prosecuted someone, Because the closer you are
- 15:28to that actual activity, the more you will actually have accurate information because that's
- 15:35where the decisions are made. Right well, and therapists fear that they are
- 15:41being unethical. I don't know if this is true in other professions, but
- 15:46the amount of conversations I have with my peers that they are in the wrong,
- 15:50they must be in the wrong, they must have done it wrong.
- 15:52And so I'm kind of fascinated how we always land that we're doing it badly,
- 15:58yeah, which we're often not. I mean, come on, if
- 16:02you're not sleeping with your client or like embezzling from your client, yeah,
- 16:06you're doing great. Yeah. Yeah, I mean there's there's two things.
- 16:10One is is that people are overly paranoid, like they'll think that they're going
- 16:15to go to jail literally if they accept a five dollar Starbucks card, you
- 16:22know, during the holidays. And yes, it's not something you want to
- 16:26get into a practice of, and you should probably turn it down. If
- 16:30you can. But if for example, someone's crying as they're they're giving you
- 16:36this gift card to it's like this is you know, it means so much
- 16:38if you could just accept this from me, I really want to pay you
- 16:41back. And I know that you're not supposed to accept. You know,
- 16:45they really laid on thick. It would be really, you know, counter
- 16:48to treatment in the relationship for you to just be like, sorry, I
- 16:52am an ethical robot. You will not do that. I have to refuse.
- 16:56You know, the literature and the precedent is such that it totally allows
- 17:02for flexibility. It's not a rule set, it's a set of considerations and
- 17:07decision making practices. And I don't know if I've told you this story,
- 17:11but on my last the last question on my LMHC exam, which was before
- 17:17I was pregnant with Eli, so twenty years ago, but I still remember
- 17:21it crystal clear. The last question is you are working with a Chinese client,
- 17:26they give you a gift? Do you accept it? And I remember
- 17:30thinking at the well, I know what they were getting at, which is
- 17:36it is call literally over a billion people, everyone's the same. But it
- 17:41was also it was do you know your cultural competency and your ethics piece,
- 17:48which is cultural competency at the time, would have been accept the gifts.
- 17:53It is what you're supposed to be doing. I know your role in your
- 17:56eyes like crazy, But it's just funny that like I don't remember. No,
- 18:00there was also a question about the fourth step in AA, which was
- 18:06also seared in my mind. But yeah, which is about making amends,
- 18:11I think. But yeah, so I just think it was interesting that you
- 18:18know, there are cultural considerations and all that, but that question was like
- 18:22seared into my mind and then in the moment was like all of this back
- 18:27and forth, back and forth, like I know what I would do,
- 18:30and I was working in an all Asian agency at the time, where clients
- 18:33would bring in lavish, four course meals to share with the clinicians. So
- 18:40the idea that like, you know, we're not talking five taller gift card,
- 18:44We're talking an entire roasted pig on a giant piece of cardboard that has
- 18:48come into the office for everyone to enjoy. Like the level of gift giving
- 18:52was insane. Yeah, So it was just so interesting that I'm like doing
- 18:57this peopopoo, you know, I'm like trying to free figured it out in
- 19:00my head, like I know what I would do, I know what my
- 19:03agency has done and will always do. Here, I am in a constricted
- 19:08exam that the sides whether or not I get licensed. But there's literally a
- 19:12right or wrong answer to that question. That the notion of that is ridiculous,
- 19:18and it just highlights, just side note how ridiculous those tests are.
- 19:22Yeah I did pass, by the way, Yeah good so. Yeah.
- 19:27Some of the questions, especially the ethical questions, I will read and I'll
- 19:30just be like, that is just not even the case. I mean,
- 19:33the people who come up with these questions, one they seemingly don't know what
- 19:38they're doing, and two the people who are taking the test really don't know
- 19:42what they're doing, so no one will speak out against it. And there's
- 19:48where do you go to complain about these licensing tests. There's no recourse.
- 19:52It's not you can choose it. No, you can't do anything. You
- 19:55can't choose a different test. There's one test, yeah, and it's this
- 19:59power strip sure that just dominates and it leads to misunderstanding about ethics. The
- 20:03other element that I will see among a lot of clinicians, I would say
- 20:07the vast majority is that when in doubt they will say something's unethical, like
- 20:12what do we do? Is this ethical? Or is that ethical? They'll
- 20:15be like, oh, that's unethical because you can't. I think for them,
- 20:19they're hedging all of their bets. They're like, well, it's easier
- 20:23to restrict myself than to learn actual ethical decision making and consult with people,
- 20:33and it's socially more safe. It's sort of like, I remember when I
- 20:38was in high school. I loved certain things, like I loved depeche Mode
- 20:45and I loved running in the rain, and I remember being exuberant about certain
- 20:52things. And I don't know what was wrong with these peers of mind,
- 20:57but seemingly insecure. I would be exuberant, not bothering anybody, just like
- 21:03hey, I love this thing, and from the side they would put me
- 21:07down. They'd be like, oh, that that thing's stupid. It's so
- 21:11much easier to hate something. So it's the same thing. It's so much
- 21:14easier to call something unethical than to actually look into it. And I would
- 21:18say ninety nine times out of one hundred online when people are saying something's unethical,
- 21:23it's literally not unethical. So that's another thing. But let me ask
- 21:29you about the landscape here. So you're you're wanting, you're tasked with giving
- 21:36them official CEUs Continuing Education units on ethics. So you give them a certificate
- 21:44at the end of this saying you have completed how many hours of ethics three,
- 21:48three or four hours of ethics training. And these are clinicians and you
- 21:53can probably teach anything on ethics as long as it's ethical content. But if
- 21:59it's specific to tarot, so let me let me pulls it to you this
- 22:02way. I've got one hour solid of content of why it's okay to do
- 22:10taro and therapy, okay Ungian, what is evidence based really in a culturally
- 22:15competent world. Blah blah blah. I've got another great exercise at the end
- 22:19for peace well to explore their personal ethics using tarot. I've got two hours.
- 22:26If you could make teaching ethics really fun and interesting and engaging for two
- 22:32hours, what should I do? Well, I gave us something, and
- 22:36I took some notes, so and I am taking notes on your notes.
- 22:40Well, I mean, I'll send you this outlay so you don't have to
- 22:41take notes on all of it. But so I am going off the ACA
- 22:48Code of Ethics, which is I'm guessing at least most of your trainees,
- 22:52the counselors, MHC people. So the first thing and I just read your
- 22:59ethical codes and went through and pulled out what is relevant I think to the
- 23:03training. Number one is informed consent, So all the normal disclosures need to
- 23:08occur, of course, but additionally with clients. So we have this ethical
- 23:14guideline, dear listeners, that is such that as clinicians, we have to
- 23:21give enough information to the potential client before they even engage with us, so
- 23:27that they can consent to treatment with proper information. They are informed as they
- 23:34give consent. So not only do we have to inform them, but we
- 23:37also have to get consent and we have to make sure that they are properly
- 23:45informed the clients of the treatment modality and irrelevant research risks what the treatment can
- 23:52and cannot do. And there's a lot of different practices here, but generally
- 23:56speaking, given what you were saying earlier about evidence base and this sort of
- 24:02thing, there's a lot of forms of therapy that are not technically considered evidence
- 24:08based, but they could be subsumed under what we would call the standard of
- 24:12practice. There is a standard of practice within union psychology and therapy that involves
- 24:19a lot of the things within TORO. So if you were to be sued,
- 24:23for example, and I would even talk about this, like say you
- 24:26use toterrow and someone dies by suicide and you end up getting sued, you
- 24:32know, that's that would be a potential thing that could happen. You know,
- 24:34say you have a client that dies by suicide and the family and it's
- 24:40not your fault, and you're using to row occasionally with that client, but
- 24:42the family is out to get you and they sue you and identify look what
- 24:48they're doing. They're using magical demon cards. And if you have one a
- 24:53written policy about the literature to back up, I mean, is there literally
- 25:00yeah, okay, So having literature that can demonstrate the standard of practice that
- 25:04you have guidelines, that it doesn't involve the devil and that kind of stuff,
- 25:08and also that it could be subsumed under the larger umbrellia of a long
- 25:15tradition called union therapy. And so not only do I have that backing in
- 25:21that foundation that can demonstrate I wasn't acting outside of the industry, I was
- 25:26actually within the standard of practice. And then two I informed the client of
- 25:33this not only in writing, but also as I show you the signed document
- 25:38that the client sign. And two I had a brief conversation with them at
- 25:44the beginning oft therapy of what all this means and where this therapy is considered
- 25:49within the larger realm of therapy, and it was appropriate for the issue at
- 25:53hand. You know, So in form consent that involves a lot of things.
- 25:59It's a lot of homework, some forms understanding of how to communicate about
- 26:03this. The vast majority of therapists, in my anecdotal experience, don't do
- 26:08this. Well. It's hard, you know. Now, the benefit is
- 26:12for you and your students is you can actually do this for yourself and just
- 26:17give them the paragraph and say, if you want to use this paragraph in
- 26:22your disclosure, then go ahead and plagiarize it, you know what I mean.
- 26:26That's a benefit of being in this course. Or if you want to
- 26:30modify it a little bit here and there, of course you can do that.
- 26:33But here's a guideline. Because your students are going to look at you
- 26:36pretty glassy eyed when you tell them about informed consent. There's you know,
- 26:41they'll get anxious, and they'll be like, I don't want to be in
- 26:42this class anymore. So if you just hand them the paragraph because we're doing
- 26:45that day two, okay, day one, everyone will get too focused at
- 26:51and then there should be an intake note that is written sentence of like we
- 26:57went verbally over the evidence and the appropriateness of this model of tarrow. And
- 27:06you know, of course the therapists aren't just using to row. They're using
- 27:07a lot of other different techniques, right, you know, there's a lot
- 27:11of things they're doing. So that's one inform because that's a big area.
- 27:14The other one is personal values, so not imposing our beliefs on our clients.
- 27:21And it could be considered a belief system that could be considered forced on
- 27:27a client if it wasn't done right now. Presumably everyone understands, but you
- 27:33should be explicit as you're teaching the course that you have a brief conversation with
- 27:38clients about that they want this right Well, yeah, I mean, and
- 27:44also in when I present, I say who to not do this with?
- 27:48Right, Like, if a client is the prominent predominant presenting factor is psychosis,
- 27:55I don't do taro with them. It's too overwhelming, And if their
- 28:00clients, if their value system, if their religious value systems says that,
- 28:04you know, an aspect of personal divination like tarot is inappropriate, I don't
- 28:11do it with them. And then finally, if a client believes that it
- 28:17is only the Romani people that should have access to tarot cards, I don't
- 28:22do tarot with them, right, And how do you navigate that? You
- 28:26have a client, for example, and I would go over examples like this
- 28:30that because I'm guessing the trainees are going to have clients that will come into
- 28:34their office not knowing that the clinician, as an aspect of their practice,
- 28:38will use to row. And so how do you broach the topic and navigate
- 28:42that Because a client could feel pressured, especially if you come across as a
- 28:47clinician like this is a particular enjoyable thing for the clinician, you know,
- 28:52So how do you offer it up as an option while not pressuring them?
- 28:57That's you know, it's a very delicate kind of thing. Now, if
- 29:00you advertise yourself as a trurotherapist and they come to you because they want to,
- 29:04then you don't have to have that conversation. Yeah, I mean,
- 29:07what's interesting too. I mean, I'm looking around your office and I know
- 29:10you don't see clients in here, but it says very much who you are.
- 29:14And my office is similar. I have two gigantic dragon puppets. I
- 29:18have a fully articulated owl puppet whose head actually like mostly spins around. I
- 29:25have a gigantic overstuffed octopus. Like. There are things in my office that
- 29:30are like, huh, like we might just not talk here, you know.
- 29:36I have an entire bowl that's sitting there of fidget toys, like you
- 29:40know, there's art supplies right when you sit down, and a lot of
- 29:44my decks are on display. I think I own like forty five decks at
- 29:47this point. I think there are maybe fifteen at the office. But clients
- 29:51will My client base in particular is so hyper vigilant, like they will notice,
- 29:55Oh, you got a new deck. What's that deck? Can I
- 29:57look at that deck with you? Or sometimes a title will pop out,
- 30:00like have this deck. It's not a tarot deck, it's an oracle deck,
- 30:04and it's just famous artists of the last century. And you know,
- 30:10clients will see the squat or you know, they'll see Georgia O'Keefe on the
- 30:15box and they'll say, oh, what's that. That's how you pronounced I
- 30:19thought it was Basquiat. No, this is where Google would come in handy.
- 30:25I probably said it wrong. I don't know. I mean, you're
- 30:27an artist, so I would assume you're right and I'm wrong. It's probably
- 30:32you know, my dyslexia and my hearing loss. I'm not the greatest pronunciator.
- 30:38Yeah, So that is part of the advertising if you will, or
- 30:45invitation into not only to ROW, but also art therapy and hands on therapies
- 30:51that you will utilize at the same time. You know, I hear horror
- 30:56stories of clients that will tell me that they're therapist offered something up and the
- 31:00client felt like they were being impolite by turning it down, and they went
- 31:03along with it and they didn't like anything about it. I mean, this
- 31:07includes all the things we're talking about, but also engaging in like body work
- 31:12and other kinds of invasive things to a client. So it just saying,
- 31:18hey, there's this thing called ROW, would you like to do it?
- 31:22And the client says yes, That is not sufficient in understanding whether or not
- 31:27a client is truly wanting to do something like this. So you know,
- 31:33like one thing that I throw out there is that you would say, hey,
- 31:38you know what you're talking about here lends itself to this other modality of
- 31:44therapy, and I'm going to suggest it, but there are other things we
- 31:48could do to address this, and I don't want to pressure you to do
- 31:52it, but it might be worth exploring. And if you like it,
- 31:56then we can continue, and if you don't, then we won't well.
- 32:00And that's also a brief therapy exercise that art therapy really embraces, which is
- 32:05at the end of any directive, any art based intervention that I'm doing with
- 32:08people, I will always ask what did you think of this exercise? And
- 32:14it gives your client yet another chance to say I liked it or I didn't
- 32:17like it. And one of the biggest ways that clients tell you that they
- 32:22like something is when they want to take it home or they want to take
- 32:24a picture of what happened. And I would say ninety percent of the time
- 32:29that I pull Tarot cards with clients, they want to take a picture because
- 32:34something happens. Yeah, you can usually, hopefully as a therapist, if
- 32:37you're paying attention enough and you're not overly internally pressured to make people do things
- 32:46that you like to do as opposed to attending to the client. You're going
- 32:50to notice when a client is getting into something, you'll into it like,
- 32:54oh, I get energy from them right now that they like this. So
- 33:00that's another thing I might also suggest, like a tech because I've done lots
- 33:05of experimental you know, things that aren't necessarily known to clients, like chair
- 33:09work and this kind of thing. And what I will do with clients is
- 33:14i will do a little taste of it and then I'll say, so,
- 33:17if you ever want to do this again, you tell me, and if
- 33:22you don't bring it up again, then I'm fine. I might throw it
- 33:24out there maybe, but I want clients to be in the driver's seat because
- 33:30even if we do it the way that you know we're talking about earlier,
- 33:35where it's just like you just into it or even ask them, they could
- 33:37still feel like they need to please me, especially with some kind of clients.
- 33:44So anyway, well, and I think you just mentioned the gestall empty
- 33:47chair technique, which I just did yesterday, and it feels like that's a
- 33:52technique I do all the time, but I just had a really interesting experience
- 33:55doing it. With a client yesterday who complicated an amazing family history and their
- 34:02mother is still alive and there's this huge issue going on with their mom,
- 34:07and their mom's in denial of what it all means. And I just said
- 34:10to her, if you could say anything, if you could just let it
- 34:15rip, if you could just you know, this is also remote. So
- 34:17I'm learning, like I had to learn how to introduce the empty chair technique
- 34:22when neither of us are in the same room and there is no empty chair
- 34:27to say, if you could just let it rip and just say what you
- 34:30really wanted to say to your mom, what would you say? And she
- 34:35just let it all out and she was like, oh, that felt really
- 34:38good. Why did that feel good? And I explained the gestalt empty chair
- 34:43technique, right, this is a technique that's been used in therapy now,
- 34:46I don't know, yeah, very probably longer than that, probably like eighty
- 34:52years. And she was like, why did that feel good? And I
- 34:57could say, well, you got to be honest, you know, whether
- 35:00you could ever really say that to your mother, some part of you just
- 35:05really needed to let that go. And we have this special experience in here,
- 35:09not in here, because we're both in separate places, but that you
- 35:14were witnessed in that you I heard you say it, and I will remember
- 35:21what you really wanted to say to your mom. And like that's therapy,
- 35:25right, Like that that truth got told, that that person didn't get rejected,
- 35:30that they got to say the thing without judgment from their family, like
- 35:35you know, I mean, those are those nuggets that we just I as
- 35:37a clinician, I just live for it. Yeah, I mean too.
- 35:39The transformational power of empty chair and parts work is obvious and profound. I
- 35:50mean, some of the biggest moments of my life, let alone as a
- 35:53therapist, have been using empty chair, not only with clients but with students.
- 35:59You know, I'll demonstrate to students and half the students will just be
- 36:02having like this mind blowing experience. And so let's take a break. When
- 36:07we get back, let's continue with say, all right, we're back from
- 36:14their break, Okay, So let me just rattle through the less the next
- 36:16bits here pretty obvious things coming up. The next thing in your code of
- 36:22ethics is confidentiality, which I know you are very adamant about this that people
- 36:29don't share online, for example, a client's art or a client's to row
- 36:36card reading, right, so you could see how someone might have an impulse
- 36:39for that, and maybe even a client might even verbally agree to that.
- 36:44But generally speaking, unless there's an absolute necessary reason to do that, which
- 36:50I can imagine why there would be client information, including the tarrot reading,
- 36:53should be kept confidential, and you just probably want to emphasize that as an
- 36:59obvious thing. Then the other thing is documentation. How does one document this?
- 37:04And I don't know the answer that, honestly, because I haven't been
- 37:08in this realm before. I can't imagine it being too complicated, But I
- 37:15would imagine that you would want to have something that you know, we spent
- 37:19half the session today doing to row and here was the purpose and the client
- 37:24said X about it. I mean, and just so people know the way
- 37:29I would document, I would say, you know, we were playing with
- 37:30archetypal imagery. We're playing with union concepts around the dark side of us,
- 37:37and you know, we were playing with the shadows side. So I document
- 37:42completely using union language or using mindfulness, okay, that we were working on,
- 37:50you know, self acceptance, We were working on lessening anxiety symptoms.
- 37:58And there are tons of terror cards that are about kind of really intense,
- 38:02powerful sources of us for personal knowledge, and those are all mindfulness concepts in
- 38:07my idea. That's great, That's that's very great because if someone were to
- 38:15read it, if they were scrutinizing or suing you, the language would look
- 38:22very clinical. It would be buttoned up. You could justify it. It
- 38:27would be related to common therapy tasks and the goal of therapy. Whereas if
- 38:32you said, you know, this happened with the treat and the client said
- 38:37that they now know their future or something, that could open yourself up to
- 38:43a pretty large liability because that's not within the standard of practice. You know,
- 38:49to predict the future, and it's not within the standard of practice.
- 38:52You use mindfulness, self esteem, and union standard of practice to frame what
- 38:59you're doing, which I think is important. I'm guessing a lot of your
- 39:01trainees won't be union. I don't know, but if they're not, you
- 39:07know, giving them other way, maybe even throwing it out there them.
- 39:12It's like, Okay, who who in here is not union? And tell
- 39:15me what modality you're typically using? You know, you might be you know,
- 39:21you could be starting from scratch with some of these people, because like
- 39:23I was saying, earlier. A lot of therapists, what are they doing?
- 39:29Well, what do you mean? Mean? What now? I feel
- 39:32old? I feel so old. Oh well, not just union, but
- 39:37just terrible at documentation. A lot of therapists they don't know how to word
- 39:43things in their notes to be nonliable to themselves, you know, they don't
- 39:49know how to word things like this was you know, the way you laid
- 39:52it out very quickly. I don't know why I'm so good at that.
- 39:54I've always been really good at that, not to do it my own horror
- 40:00or anything, but you know, I mean, clinicians can really get stuck
- 40:04in the weeds of like trying to describe in a paragraph, and I'm just
- 40:07like, oh my god, you are just increasing self esteem, like move
- 40:10on. Yeah. So yeah, I've always been the master of the super
- 40:15brief. So summary use that skill when you're teaching this, because that's a
- 40:21that's a huge part of ethical practice and very helpful to your to your students.
- 40:29I'm sure. So let me just talk this through because you're my this
- 40:32is this is gold. So I could see doing a mock session, doing
- 40:38a fishbowl session and then saying, Okay, how do you word it right?
- 40:43And then asking everybody to come up with a one sentence summary that would
- 40:45be yes, that would be really great, Yeah, exactly. And or
- 40:52what I do with people is think about the last session you have and just
- 40:59tell me in one sentence what you did in a way that won't get you
- 41:02sued. Yeah, one sentence with no semicolons, you know, just just
- 41:08a regular subject verb object. You know, let me just tell me subject
- 41:15and you'll get six out of ten people that will panic and they'll write nothing,
- 41:20and another three will have terrible sentences, and one person will kind of
- 41:22be okay. So it's a skill, just baseline, and then you can
- 41:29go from there and actually how to write a good note intro. And your
- 41:32students will love you because of this, because that's a very useful skill.
- 41:38And also how do you write it quickly? Yeah? You know. The
- 41:42way you're laying it out is the way I do it, which is like
- 41:45you cut to the chase, you get to the foundation, and you write
- 41:47one sentence and you move on with the rest of your day. You're going
- 41:51to be writing thousands of notes and your entire no one will read them.
- 41:55But the one time when someone does read it, it better be buttoned up,
- 42:00you know. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and also I think that
- 42:04I'm burping. Sorry everyone, Um, I was fed cheese on my way
- 42:07in by the host, so it's their fault I'm burping. But I did
- 42:15ask for the cheese, so really that was super passive aggressive in satellite.
- 42:19Yeah, and he had to reach into my pocket together, yeah, which
- 42:21was very odd. And he had slightly opened the cheese stick. It was
- 42:27maybe the most intimate. Oh wait it was open open, yes, Oh
- 42:32that's because so so I she was clothed, it was like resealed. But
- 42:38so Rebecca comes into my house, She's like, I need I need a
- 42:42string cheese. And I'm like okay, and then I'm like, go,
- 42:44wait, I don't know if we have any because we don't eat uh string
- 42:49cheese. It's for the dogs. It's high it's high, high valued treats.
- 42:53They call it, yes, the cheese stacks. So I went into
- 42:57the fridge to look where there might be some string cheese, and there was
- 43:01one that was moldy. Oh well, I'm thankful that you didn't. And
- 43:07I threw that one away. And there's another one and it looked close but
- 43:09it looks like I mean, was there a chunk out of it. It
- 43:14looked like there was it was I thought you were big. So just so
- 43:17everyone knows, like Kirk, I'm sure you would guess this already is like
- 43:21the most unbelievable host. So like you arrive and there's like a water bottle
- 43:24and there's a pillow, and like you know, there's this way in which
- 43:29you I feel very cared for it. Oh good as a cup host and
- 43:32for those of you anyways, So I don't ever have any food. It's
- 43:37the thing, I don't have any snacks. Well, and I asked for
- 43:39the cheese stick and the first thing you hand me is dog treats, and
- 43:43I was like, I asked cheese, so so so to back that up,
- 43:47uh, Rebecca is in the bathroom. I get the cheese and my
- 43:52dog is going right, yeah, well yeah, my dog sees the cheese
- 43:57and it's like, oh, that's that's my high value chee. And I
- 44:00go and I get some kibble to give to the dog knock not only to
- 44:05get them to be like sorry that the cheese is going to the human,
- 44:08but also to calm her down so that she will not be barking the entire
- 44:14time while we're podcasting because her older brothers at daycare and Stacy's at pottery class.
- 44:20So the little dog is just up there by herself. And I gave
- 44:24you a bunch of kibble, and I had a bunch of kibble in my
- 44:28hand, and I said, and I turned around and I said, well,
- 44:30the cheese is in my back pocket. And he reached in there and
- 44:37apparently it was open. Yeah. Wow, huh, but I thought,
- 44:39but in my mind, I'm thinking, oh, that's so nice of Kirk.
- 44:43They pre opened I need to. I'm just a terrible snack person,
- 44:50So I don't know if my wife's a good snack person. I'm terrible with
- 44:53My house is like sacks. I don't really eat meals. I just eat
- 44:58snacks. Okay, I need to stock up on snacks for you because I
- 45:04want to be that kind of host because there's a few times but no,
- 45:07no, no, no, I mean, you know, come in expecting
- 45:10snacks. So the next topic in the Ethical Code are boundaries of competence.
- 45:17So how much training and supervision does one need to be considered competent in this
- 45:22realm? Boundaries of competence? Yeah, so knowing your scope, knowing knowing
- 45:29if you're competent enough to actually do a particular thing in therapy, right,
- 45:34And these are not set in stone, of course, they are you know,
- 45:38decided upon in the standard of practice. And it's not an easy question
- 45:44to answer, and I would pose it to them, maybe even start a
- 45:47discussion briefly for five minutes of what do you think would indicate that you maybe
- 45:54it's something you do at the end of the course or something. Do you
- 45:58feel that you have enough competence to actually do this? And if so,
- 46:04how do you justify that if you were to be asked a question and to
- 46:09if you need more additional training or supervision, what would that what would that
- 46:14look like? And you know, it's an interesting question. I don't know
- 46:16the answer that question. Honestly. I could see someone already having a lot
- 46:21of background like union therapy or other kinds of art therapies are kind of in
- 46:27this area, ish that you could potentially piggyback on that competence. But if
- 46:34you have like a CBT therapist that comes in, which I doubt will happen.
- 46:37But if they did and they're just out of graduate school and they take
- 46:40this, are they competent? I don't know. I mean I'm always fascinated
- 46:45that when I lead this training there are people who are completely frozen, and
- 46:49I think, like, how did you? Especially that training takes some three
- 46:52months, you know, it sells out three months in advance, so like
- 46:54how did you even? Why did you decide to be here? What do
- 46:59you mean they're frozen, like they're terrified. Yeah, I mean they just
- 47:01look like they can't breathe because they're scared of they're just over well, first
- 47:07off, who knows what it is? Are they overwhelmed by the completely art
- 47:09based learning firmament that I've set up? Did they have no idea that,
- 47:14like they were, this was not going to be a dry lecture, but
- 47:16they were going to be playing for six hours straight. So they're like shy
- 47:22and yeah, they're like deer in the headlights, like just like you know,
- 47:23they're clearly not breathing, and I'm like kind of hovering. I don't
- 47:28want to be like, you know, hey, just go for it,
- 47:30but just like you know, this might be new to you or there anything,
- 47:34can we make this any easier for you? Do you need to go?
- 47:37But there's one person, this one person I'm thinking of in particular where
- 47:40I just thought they were going to vomit, and I was like, you
- 47:44know, get up, take a walk, come back. If this isn't
- 47:47the right training for you, I'm sure Cascadi would give you a refund,
- 47:51like they just and they eventually got into it. But yeah, it is
- 47:57the level of permission that I give in my trainings to be you. It's
- 48:04overwhelming for some people because our field can be very didactic. There is one
- 48:08way to do this, there is the right way to do this. I
- 48:10will teach you the right way. You will learn my way, and then
- 48:14you can use my name, you know. And that's not how I teach
- 48:17at all. I mean I teach totally bottom up, like, hey,
- 48:21let's discover your way, let's discover your inherent fo Sure people really appreciate you
- 48:27for that. Yeah. I think that's why these behalf the benefit of going
- 48:30to the class I met. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, I'm just like,
- 48:34hey, let's play. You know, if anybody out there knows the
- 48:37monetary concepts of like, we learn best if we test it out ourselves,
- 48:43right, which can be really overwhelming for some people who like a very didactic
- 48:46style of learning. Yeah, I think that's really great. I'm sure your
- 48:52students really appreciate that. Another part of competence is exactly what is one competent
- 48:59in with this form of therapy? Right? Is it the ability? You
- 49:05know, obviously, the ability to predict the future? No one can claim
- 49:08competence with that. Is it the ability for self exploration for the client?
- 49:15It seems like a pretty easy thing to state as a competence of this,
- 49:21of being good at this sort of form of therapy. You know, I
- 49:23might list out a few things of here is what you could claim to be
- 49:29competent in. Here are things that you cannot claim to be competent in because
- 49:34it's not true, and too you can get sued if you say. Now,
- 49:39if a client chooses to interpret it that way, that's fine. You
- 49:44know, you could have a client that could believe that this predicts the future
- 49:49for them and they make decisions based on that prediction that they are making,
- 49:53and maybe you're even collaborating on that. But that's up to the client,
- 49:58of course, and that's not something that you would propose to them in a
- 50:02strong way. You know, I don't know how, I don't know exactly
- 50:06all the different things. Second up, you could see that people could take
- 50:08the training and really go a lot of different directions with this. Yeah,
- 50:12and I mean really I see most so there's a big fear in the art
- 50:16therapy world. And it's part of why I let my license laps, and
- 50:21I do mention this every time I'm on the podcast, that I let that
- 50:23license laps, that there's a lot of fear in the art therapy world that
- 50:29like someone will take one course from us and steal all our ideas and we
- 50:32will be irrelevant. And I've always really fought very very hard against that in
- 50:38the field, which is no one can take who you are individually. As
- 50:43an art therapist. You bring magic into the environment. And I taught art
- 50:49therapy CEUs for I don't know, fifteen years, and mostly I learned that
- 50:53by teaching it to someone, they got really cautious in seeing how complex their
- 50:59own artistic experience was. And I'm seeing it also with the Tarot work that
- 51:05if someone, if a clinician, takes one of my workshops, it's their
- 51:08first introduction to tarot, they've never done taro before, chances are very slims
- 51:15that they will use it with clients because it's so complex. So mostly it
- 51:22just becomes like an introduction for folks, and that it's really the clinicians who
- 51:27are like, I've been doing this for my own spiritual practice for ten years,
- 51:30twenty five years. I now want to slowly integrate it with clients.
- 51:35Those are the folks who like kind of make the bridge because Tarot is this
- 51:39massive undertaking. It's seventy eight cars. It's like, it's pretty big.
- 51:45And so, you know, I have yet to hear a story if anyone
- 51:50using it unethically obviously, I mean, I'm sure they're out there, but
- 51:54really, you know, we're talking about similar to any projective image I don't
- 52:00want to say test or experience, where we let the clients see an image,
- 52:06hear a couple of words, and see how that relates to their current
- 52:09experience. Yeah, there's dream work is along these lines as well. There's
- 52:15a long traditional union. Okay, it's not that's not the dreamwork that I
- 52:22do. I do, I guess my own version of it. But but
- 52:23also narrative therapy as well. If we were to tell a new story about
- 52:28the same old problem, introducing a new character, introducing a new scenario,
- 52:34how would the story look different? Yeah, that's so I would delineate that
- 52:39and say that whole thing to them, but also get concrete about here is
- 52:45what you what I propose you try to achieve as a competence, and here
- 52:53is what I propose you actually not try to achieve as a competence. And
- 52:59that might be really you're reassuring to people from the beginning on the outset,
- 53:01but you might also piss some people off because they're just like, well,
- 53:05but I believe in this, you know, like this is so good and
- 53:08I was writing the last da year, I got to write it again.
- 53:10What did you just say? So you tell them maybe at the very beginning,
- 53:15maybe even advertise as such, and then really go over this of here's
- 53:20what I propose you attempt to achieve as a competence within tarrow forms of therapy,
- 53:30and here is here are a set of things that I propose that you
- 53:32do not attempt to become competent in because of the following reasons, Like if
- 53:39someone were to use Christianity in there, because people will do that. Obviously
- 53:46tarot is not in that realm exactly, but it could be considered that in
- 53:52a certain someone wanting to do taro and someone that's doing taro and as a
- 53:58therapy similar to a Christian who wants a Christian therapist, and a Christian therapist
- 54:01says, I do Christian therapist. There might be prayer, for example,
- 54:07in the session, there might be talks of the Bible. There might be
- 54:10talks of what God might want from you, and spiritual practices and navigating life
- 54:20through a Christian lens, and that in those conversations, the ethics are such
- 54:25that you you know, in terms of all we're talking about earlier, about
- 54:30not imposing your values, about informed consent, all that kind of stuff,
- 54:34proper advertising, But you can't claim as a therapist that you are saving someone's
- 54:40soul, for example. You can't claim as a therapist that you know what
- 54:45God wants for them, right, And you could absolutely imagine a therapist crossing
- 54:51those lines. You can talk about even your own interpretation of the Bible,
- 54:58but you have to couch it in that just mine. You're free to have
- 55:00yours. You know, there's just a way of talking about these topics in
- 55:07therapy that can be within the realms of competence and ethics, and there's a
- 55:13way to have it not be that way. And that's a weird line,
- 55:16right, like where do you where do you draw that line. But you
- 55:21know, I'm sure that you do this really well given my impression of your
- 55:24practice is that you're certainly allowed to be yourself and to have your own beliefs,
- 55:30but you work collaboratively with the client, right like you you extract from
- 55:34the client where they want to go with it, and then you might suggest
- 55:37or add a little bit, but you're not going to impose. You're not
- 55:40going to bulldoze them. If they want to go in a certain direction with
- 55:45their art or taro, then you you go with them on that. And
- 55:52you know that's a that's a weird zone to be in, but when you
- 55:57do it well enough and maybe even working in like proper consultation and supervision measures
- 56:04to make sure that you're not going over the edge along those lines anyway.
- 56:09And then the next three topics are accurate advertising, which is self explanatory,
- 56:15making sure that you state that there's limited evidence of this mode actually working,
- 56:21making sure that you state what you act, what it means, and all
- 56:24that kind of stuff. Also accurate representation, so if you are talking about
- 56:31this at a conference or you are putting something in your sculture statement, that
- 56:36you don't say something that is considered to be dubious in terms of its statement.
- 56:43This will solve all problems for all clients, right or I can tell
- 56:45your future yea. And the last is scientific basis for treatment. We've kind
- 56:50of already been over this, but that when providing services, counselors and really
- 56:55all clinicians in the mental health field, are you supposed to use modalities that
- 57:02are grounded in theory and have a scientific foundation. There is evidence of union
- 57:08therapy working, of course, you just have to not be within the tight
- 57:15realm of CBT, you know, randomized controlled trials. There's tons of studies
- 57:21demonstrating that union therapy can be beneficial. So having those on hand and relating
- 57:25that can be a way to stave off liability if you're ever sued along those
- 57:31lines. So yeah, those are all the topics that I came up with.
- 57:38This has been a masterclass. Thank you so much. I have several
- 57:44pages of notes, and just so everyone knows who's writing so much. My
- 57:46pen ran out of incoh it did No, I'm good, Oh I got
- 57:50it back. But yeah, yeah, those are my favorite pens. What
- 57:53kind of pen is this? What is it? It's a pilot precise V
- 58:00five RT if you want to write like Kirk does, it's it's like,
- 58:05um, it's from Japan. It is. It's a very smoothball, pointy
- 58:08pen. Well, and as a left hander, I can often smear if
- 58:14with the wrong pen. Does that smear? No? This, I could
- 58:16see it's smearing. This. This does not smear. It makes me like
- 58:22the pilot precise five. All right, second break and then we get back.
- 58:27Just one more email. What do you say? I'm in all right?
- 58:32This next email is from Patron Angel from Tucson. They say, have
- 58:37you seen about the new nine eight eight suicide and crisis line number in the
- 58:43United States dialing nine eight eight instead of nine on one. There's been a
- 58:45lot of mixed messages and possible misinformation going around social media about how calling this
- 58:51number will result in the use of your geolocation, which will lead to inviting
- 58:54the police into your life, oh unknowingly or involuntary hospitalizations. I've read other
- 59:01numbers like this trans Lifeline. I sorry, I've read other numbers like this.
- 59:08The trans Lifeline won't result in this as they don't use your geolocation and
- 59:15don't work with the police. What have you gathered about the risks and benefits
- 59:20of using nine eight eight number. Rebecca, What do you think? So,
- 59:24I've heard a lot about it. It's from what i've heard, it's
- 59:29great. I haven't heard any stories of police being involved. It's a I
- 59:35would think the only way, the only reason they're using geolocation is to get
- 59:40someone in your state so that that person knows the state ethics if at all
- 59:45possible. Yeah, So yeah, I would say it's very safe and it's
- 59:50a really cool service because unlike your normal nine on one operator who's trained for
- 59:55any multitude of issues, this person is specifically ran on suicidality. So I
- 1:00:01just want to give a big two thumbs up for this service. And I'm
- 1:00:06sorry there's so much misinformation going on. Yeah, it doesn't surprise me,
- 1:00:10but yeah, I looked into it, and you're right that the only geolocation
- 1:00:15that they use is to determine your local crisis line number. Because this isn't
- 1:00:21a national office. They want to connect you with your local suicide prevention professionals
- 1:00:28on the phone. So they do that, but they don't use your GPS
- 1:00:32to figure out where you're at. It's just a I don't even know exactly
- 1:00:36how they do. It might even be based on your telephone number or the
- 1:00:38cell phone tower or something. I don't know, but they figure out what
- 1:00:44office to route you too, and the person that answers the phone. They
- 1:00:45don't know where you are. You you could be anywhere. Also, they
- 1:00:51don't call the police on you unless well so, and I'll get into that
- 1:00:55in a second. And they certainly don't run out and detain you and to
- 1:01:00put you in the hospital. Now, if you call this number and you
- 1:01:05indicate to the individual that you are imminently at risk of dying, then they
- 1:01:10will call nine one one one themselves. They will probably suggest to you that
- 1:01:15you call nine one one yourself. But if you don't do that, they
- 1:01:19do have potentially a moral responsibility, and it's certainly a legal and ethical responsibility
- 1:01:24to do what they can to help you get through this, which might involve
- 1:01:30calling nine one one. Now, presumably the suicide hotline professionals understand how to
- 1:01:36communicate to nine one one such that the police are less likely to roll up
- 1:01:40with their guns out right, So there's that. The other thing is,
- 1:01:45you know, it's hard to know exactly the research on this because it's it's
- 1:01:50fairly newish. But but we have a lot of data on this because this
- 1:01:54is just a new telephone number. It's not a new service. The service
- 1:01:59has been around for decades. The same people are working in these places.
- 1:02:04The number is just an easier way to get in touch with these people.
- 1:02:07So we do have a lot of data along these lines, and very few
- 1:02:13people, like one or two percent of the callers will cause the you know,
- 1:02:17the professional answering the phone to call nine one one, and a lot
- 1:02:22of times those are good for those individuals. It gets you know, gets
- 1:02:28them the help that they need, gets them through that difficult time so that
- 1:02:30they can live and they can get the treatment and they can live a regular
- 1:02:34life. So now, why do you this did not surprise me that these
- 1:02:38rumors are out there, because this happens all the time. Why do you
- 1:02:43think these rumors are so quickly spread and so often spread along these lines?
- 1:02:47I mean, I think people fear the worst, and that's obviously because the
- 1:02:52system has failed lots and lots of people. So when something good actually does
- 1:02:55show up, it's hard to believe that it's actually good. And I don't
- 1:03:01know quite how. I know someone who's very involved in ninety eight, So
- 1:03:07I'm really talking from personal experience, So I just it's like heartbreaking for me
- 1:03:15to hear that things have landed, that this could be such a bad thing,
- 1:03:17when really it's such a great thing. But I think, you know,
- 1:03:22the system has failed lots and lots of people, and we just expect
- 1:03:25that it's going to fail us, which you know speaks to our experience.
- 1:03:30So I'm really glad this person wrote in so that you know, if there's
- 1:03:35anybody out there listening who had negative thoughts about this but hadn't tried it,
- 1:03:39I hope you will suggest this number to people. Yeah, it's really there
- 1:03:43to help. Yeah, and even if you're not the one having the suicidal
- 1:03:47thoughts, it's a friend or someone else, you can call it yourself as
- 1:03:52well. They are there to answer your questions, connect you with resources,
- 1:03:59give you suggestions, talk you through it. They're there for a lot of
- 1:04:03different people who might need help. Yeah. Absolutely, So that would be
- 1:04:09my guests as well about why these rumors are so often spread about services like
- 1:04:14this, that there have been people who have been harmed and murdered because of
- 1:04:19reaching out for help in these situations, and that does happen, and it's
- 1:04:25atrocious and criminal. And it needs to stop, and we need to train
- 1:04:30people and have systems in place like nine to eight eight by the way,
- 1:04:33to help with that. And because wouldn't you want to talk to somebody who
- 1:04:38is specifically trained right to address what's happening. Yeah, and if anyone understands
- 1:04:44the landscape of that whole thing, the police, it's going to be these
- 1:04:47nine eight eight people. Now. The other thing here is that what's highlighted
- 1:04:53in the media and online are the bad cases, and so you'll find people
- 1:04:59that just believe, well, if you are suicidal, you should never call
- 1:05:02anybody because the police are going to show up and shoot you. There are
- 1:05:08many, many examples of that happening. We understand that, but the vast
- 1:05:12vast majority of the time that doesn't happen, and those stories are never told.
- 1:05:15Apparently, no one ever tells those stories. It's like the same thing
- 1:05:18when you hear about CPS child protective services never called child protective service because they'll
- 1:05:25just come in and take your kids. Does that happen? Yes, certainly
- 1:05:29those cases are horrible, you know, meaning that it was not justified.
- 1:05:33But the vast vast majority of the time child protective services dshs are doing a
- 1:05:39good job. I worked side by side with them many many times. Are
- 1:05:43their mistakes made? Are Is it a difficult situation, like kind of a
- 1:05:46no win situation for a lot of these social workers. Yes, But I
- 1:05:51just want to put that out there. The other thing that I think is
- 1:05:56out there is the stigma of just about anything mental health. And I don't
- 1:06:01really have a well articulated thought on this, but I'm going to briefly,
- 1:06:06in two or three sentences, summarize it. I think that we obviously know
- 1:06:12that there's stigma around mental health, and there's stigma around emotions, and stigma
- 1:06:15around vulnerability and all that, right, and so that's always been the case.
- 1:06:23But as we have more awareness in our society that that stigma is ridiculous,
- 1:06:29we don't actually shed the foundation of the stigma that anything mental health is
- 1:06:34disgusting or evil or scary or dangerous or dangerous it's going to get out of
- 1:06:40control. Right. So, cognitively, you have a lot of people walking
- 1:06:42around knowing that that's not true, but their feelings are still there, and
- 1:06:47so they will have things like this that will come along, and so cognitively
- 1:06:53they're like, Okay, that's a good idea, but their heart is like,
- 1:06:56something is scary about that, and so they will either highlight things that
- 1:07:01are in agreement with that fear and or when they're fed that information they eat
- 1:07:06it up. They just they're like, yes, that feels right to me.
- 1:07:10I'm going to retweet that. I'm going to repost that because that's how
- 1:07:15it feels to me. And this happens a lot online. There are so
- 1:07:20many examples of this, and I think that is a better thing than we
- 1:07:28were before, where heart and mind were in agreement that all things mental health
- 1:07:31were bad. But we're not where we should be, where people have positive
- 1:07:39associations with mental health mental wellness professionals and that someone there could be this idea
- 1:07:45that there could be a professional out there who could a help you. So
- 1:07:50this happens to me all the time. I am somebody's first contact with the
- 1:07:55mental health system. This idea that like I am gentle, kind and funny
- 1:08:00and I have some things that could help you instead of you know, I'm
- 1:08:03going to make you feel worse or ashamed, or you know all these things
- 1:08:08that I'm gonna pick your brain, I'm gonna invade your brain right or I'm
- 1:08:13only here to make you feel bad about yourself when actually I'm here to build
- 1:08:16you up. Yeah, and TV shows and movies. Side note, have
- 1:08:20you seen Shrinking Is? The first episode made me so angry. I think
- 1:08:27I watched another couple episodes, but it was so stigmatizing to clients. It
- 1:08:32had that typical montage where you have twelve clients that are rotating through really quick
- 1:08:39yeah whiny about like ridiculous presenting problems, annoying presentations, and I just thought,
- 1:08:48you've lost me you obviously. I don't know like whoever wrote that thing.
- 1:08:54I just I feel like they had a few toes within the realm of
- 1:08:59realism, you know, realistic depictions of therapy and positive associations of therapy,
- 1:09:05but they still had it. Whoever wrote it and made this thing had a
- 1:09:09lot of toes in that old school anti therapy realm. It was. It
- 1:09:13was trying to do both. It was like trying to say we're pro therapy,
- 1:09:17but we also are anti clients or something. I don't know, like
- 1:09:21it was Yeah, it's like as an Asian being asked, where are you
- 1:09:27from? Like if I just heard that one time in my life, I
- 1:09:30would say, oh, huh, well I'm I'm from Isa, Washington.
- 1:09:35Where are your parents from Spokane, Washington? Where are your grandparents from eastern
- 1:09:41Washington? You know, like, what are you getting at? You get
- 1:09:44asked that thousands of times. It gets on your fucking nerves. And the
- 1:09:47amount of fucking times that I see depictions of therapy and a TV show or
- 1:09:51a movie that are denigrating to clients and therapists. It's fucking aggravating, man.
- 1:09:58And the offices are always too big and too fancy, way too expensive.
- 1:10:01I know, I'm like, fucking give that person an eighth of a
- 1:10:05space, a super tiny window and no one's sitting in a comfortable chair,
- 1:10:09and then this show will be realistic. Yeah, they always have a giant
- 1:10:12desk, oh yeah, and a giant lavish couch and like a huge bay
- 1:10:15window. I mean, I have one of probably the biggest offices in your
- 1:10:18offices, big yeah, yeah, But it's not glamorous. I mean,
- 1:10:23but it's sort of a catch off for everything because it's also your office with
- 1:10:26your desk, but it's against the wall, right. But like most therapists
- 1:10:30are providing therapy basically in window list closets, So unless it's portrayed like that,
- 1:10:33on TV. It's not realistic, right yeah, all right, Rebecca,
- 1:10:40that doesn't for that episode. So so, oh yeah, I'm continuing
- 1:10:44on my Instagram challenge. We made it two one thousand followers are text.
- 1:10:49But the more you follow me, the better. So our next goal is
- 1:10:56to get to twelve hundred. Okay, the magic of twelve a right,
- 1:11:00I think the archetype of I'm sure Young had something about the archetype of twelve
- 1:11:05tribes. There's twelve tribes of Israel. Yeah, yeah, twelve signs in
- 1:11:10the zodiac. So become part of that movement. Just to lock in.
- 1:11:15We used to count by twelves. There were societies that we're base twelve,
- 1:11:19not based ten. We still have twelve hours in a day, which is
- 1:11:23strange exactly, and we have dozens. You know, we go by dozens
- 1:11:27because you can divide twelve by two, three and four, and you can
- 1:11:30only divide ten by two and five. Clearly, it's harder to break things
- 1:11:36up if you're trying to, you know, do fourths and eighths and all
- 1:11:40that kind of stuff, and even a lot today, and everyone out there,
- 1:11:44please take care of yourself because you're so worth it. And we like knowing you